Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1069: Data, People, and the Future of Public Health Response
Transcript
- 0:00This is Public Health Review Morning Edition for Friday,
- 0:03February 13th, 2026. I'm John Sheehan with news from
- 0:07the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.
- 0:10Today is all about sharing data across the public health system
- 0:14and within a single state. First, Shirley Orr, executive
- 0:18director of the Association of Public Health Nurses, discusses
- 0:21the Public Health Nursing Workforce Learning Lab Series,
- 0:25Session 5, with insights from pH WINS, the nation's only survey
- 0:29of the state and local public health workforce, which reaches
- 0:32nearly 50,000 professionals. A little later, Doctor Lisa
- 0:37Villarreal, chief Medical officer for Public Health of the
- 0:40Arizona Department of Health Services, shows us what happens
- 0:43when that workforce is connected in real time.
- 0:47Arizona's statewide Healthcare Collaborative Forum, A simple
- 0:50monthly virtual call during respiratory season, brings EMS,
- 0:55hospitals, post acute care and public health leaders together
- 0:59to review virus trends, hospital capacity, Ed diversion.
- 1:03And emerging challenges. But let's start with Shirley Orr
- 1:07with what the upcoming Public Health Nursing Workforce
- 1:09Learning Lab series session will cover.
- 1:12To give a little bit of background, pH Winds is the only
- 1:17survey that looks at the educational needs as well as the
- 1:21demographics and trends in the public health workforce.
- 1:25The Winds survey, the most recent one, reached about 50,000
- 1:29workers in local and state health departments.
- 1:32And it gives a good set of comprehensive data for us to use
- 1:36as we think about the needs of our workforce, in our case,
- 1:39public health nurses specifically.
- 1:41The data includes areas like age.
- 1:44It's important for us to be aware of the age of our
- 1:46workforce. Obviously to look at are we
- 1:49bringing in enough younger, newer professionals as well as
- 1:52are we preparing for those leaving the field due to
- 1:55retirement. It looks at gender distribution.
- 1:59We know of course, that within nursing it's largely female
- 2:02dominated. And also we certainly want to
- 2:05try to diversify the field. So it gives us some good
- 2:07guidance to base that action on. It also looks at some really
- 2:11important things like what is staff engagement look like?
- 2:15What about morale? What about burnout in the
- 2:19workforce? You know, we saw a lot of exodus
- 2:22during COVID and after that time period I think things have
- 2:26become better. But I think it's really
- 2:28important for us to continue to be conscious of burnout in the
- 2:31workforce and look at strategies that we can implement to help to
- 2:36promote recruitment and retention.
- 2:39We know that nurses that come to public health come here not for
- 2:42the salary. You can certainly earn a higher
- 2:44salary in a clinical care setting, but they come because
- 2:48they're really committed to the mission and we want to try to do
- 2:51everything we can to encourage them to continue to stay and
- 2:55practice in the field. Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:58And it sounds like the survey is pretty comprehensive.
- 3:00It has both qualitative and quantitative, you know,
- 3:03demographic information as well as that drill down information
- 3:06on what is the workforce looking for, what are they experiencing?
- 3:10Are they burned out? Yeah, that's true.
- 3:13Hopefully people will keep in mind that it is indeed a survey,
- 3:16therefore it's based on a representative sample of
- 3:20probably also a very good idea for individual organizations to
- 3:24do a little bit of a deeper dive on their own workforce and
- 3:26perhaps do some qualitative follow up, maybe some focus
- 3:29groups with individuals who are staff in their agencies to help
- 3:33them understand a little bit more about the uniquenesses.
- 3:37We know that there's a lot of commonality across the
- 3:39workforce, but there are also some uniquenesses.
- 3:41So there is the opportunity to do that at the individual
- 3:45organizational level. Sure.
- 3:48And you touched on this a little bit, noting that by and large
- 3:52the workforce skews female. Can you talk a little bit more
- 3:55about sort of the demographic makeup of the current?
- 3:57Workforce. Yeah, sure.
- 4:00Some of the things that we know about the workforce, we're
- 4:02getting better in terms of younger people coming into the
- 4:06field. I think right now around 25% of
- 4:09the workforce is underage, 35. The majority of them are new in
- 4:14the past five years, which that does represent a change from
- 4:17what we've seen in previous years.
- 4:20People tended to come in and stay quite a long time.
- 4:22Therefore, the workforce skewed a lot.
- 4:24Older. We do still have a number of
- 4:27individuals in that, that older segment of the workforce that
- 4:31we're pleased to see that we're bringing in new people to the
- 4:34field. Another major issue that we
- 4:37continue to face, and this has been an issue for many years, is
- 4:42to work toward a workforce that better represents our
- 4:45population, the workforce that looks like the people we serve.
- 4:49So that we have public health nurses along with other public
- 4:52health workers who come from diverse backgrounds.
- 4:55And I mean diverse in every way, both racially and ethnically, in
- 4:59terms of age, geographically representative.
- 5:02So really working on that is important.
- 5:05One thing that I might point out is that historically, nurses
- 5:08that rise to leadership roles in and that group underrepresented
- 5:13minorities are even more underrepresented.
- 5:16So creating career pathways to provide a means for those people
- 5:21to move forward in their public health careers and assume
- 5:25leadership roles is a really important focus for the future.
- 5:30And another goal of the survey is to provide direction and data
- 5:35towards training, what the workforce needs in terms of
- 5:37training and. How?
- 5:38How? Agencies can improve.
- 5:40Can you talk a little bit more about how the survey can be used
- 5:43in that capacity? Yeah, sure.
- 5:45So understanding education and training needs of the workforce
- 5:50helps us in a number of ways. For one thing, in recent years,
- 5:54we have a relatively new process for public health agency
- 5:58accreditation. And one of the important
- 6:00components of that accreditation is does the organization have a
- 6:05clearly defined process for recruitment, retention and
- 6:08education of the workforce. So having some data that enables
- 6:13agencies to look at that, to plan quality improvement
- 6:16efforts, look at how they allocate their budgets for
- 6:19training, that's really important to to that.
- 6:22Certainly another important aspect, along with
- 6:26accreditation, we've seen new frameworks for public health
- 6:30practice come online, including foundational public health
- 6:34services. So it's really important for us
- 6:36to look at our workforce, their educational needs particularly
- 6:41to assure that we have the ability to meet those
- 6:45foundational services and to provide those for our
- 6:47populations. And hand in hand with that, can
- 6:50you talk a little bit about how leadership could use the survey
- 6:55in tandem with or as opposed to sort of an annual review process
- 7:00that looks only at their own agency?
- 7:02The survey can bring in sort of a whole picture look.
- 7:05Yeah, WINS gives us the ability to have a broader database so we
- 7:10can benchmark our workforce at local and state levels to the
- 7:15national workforce. And I believe very importantly,
- 7:18it gives leaders the knowledge and data to be able to advocate
- 7:24to policy makers for investments in public health, particularly
- 7:28in terms of the workforce. What are the needs?
- 7:31How can we be prepared for emerging issues and trends in
- 7:34public health? Do we have enough individuals
- 7:37who serve in various roles? And if not, how can we begin to
- 7:40plan strategies to help both improve the workforce we have
- 7:44through targeted training and education, but also recruitment
- 7:47efforts? And lastly, Shirley.
- 7:51You've you've. Already sort of made some great
- 7:53cases for how the survey can be used as a tool for advancing
- 7:57training recommendations for setting benchmarks as you
- 8:00mentioned. Can you make the case why
- 8:02someone should tune into this webinar and listen to sort of
- 8:06the the pH Twins overview? Yeah, sure.
- 8:08So as I mentioned, this is one of the PHN recruitment and
- 8:14retention focused sessions in the Public Health Nursing
- 8:18learning lab. We know recruitment and
- 8:20retention is a very major issue and certainly this is an
- 8:23important part of that. Public Health Wins is a great
- 8:27tool and resource and sometimes I think it may be not well
- 8:31enough understood across our workforce widely.
- 8:35There have been many changes in pH wins over the years.
- 8:38It has a lot more functionality than it did even just a few
- 8:42years ago. One of the new additions this
- 8:44year is something called Insights to Action that contains
- 8:48somewhere around 40 practical tools and resources for
- 8:53workforce development that can be used within local agencies.
- 8:57And then importantly, we'll have Maddie Papalis, who is with the
- 9:01de Beaumont Foundation, with us to talk about WINS.
- 9:05She is the WINS expert. Her professional role is 100%
- 9:09dedicated to WINS, so leaders can certainly find out current
- 9:14information from the national expert in Public health WINS.
- 9:19Shirley Orr is executive director of the Association of
- 9:22Public Health Nurses. You can learn.
- 9:24More about the upcoming Public Health Nursing Workforce
- 9:27Learning Labs Series, Session 5 at the link in the show notes.
- 9:33Now let's hear from Doctor Lisa Villarroel, chief medical
- 9:36officer for Public health of the Arizona Department of Health
- 9:39Services, about Arizona's statewide Healthcare
- 9:42Collaborative forum. So for the past four years, the
- 9:47Arizona Department of Health Services has hosted this
- 9:50statewide healthcare collaborative forum, and it's a
- 9:54virtual statewide meeting that invites everyone along the
- 9:57spectrum of healthcare. So we're thinking, you know, EMS
- 10:01hospital post acute care setting brings everyone together once a
- 10:05month for an hour during the respiratory season.
- 10:09This season we started in November and we're going to end
- 10:12either in February or March. The way these meetings usually
- 10:16work is we start with a data review from public health on
- 10:20circulating respiratory viruses, on any new regulatory updates,
- 10:23any new EPI updates. And then we move into a
- 10:26presentation from a local partner on a particular topic
- 10:30around surge, around infection control.
- 10:32And then we end with a full partner report out and sometimes
- 10:37we're done in 35 minutes and sometimes we're racing the clock
- 10:39at 59 minutes. Yeah, that makes sense because
- 10:42you've got everyone in in the virtual room from the on the
- 10:46ground practitioners to the folks up making the policy and
- 10:49seeing where all of it sort of shakes.
- 10:51Out. Yeah, that's right.
- 10:52It's, it's like the one place where you have on one call EMS,
- 10:57we have AZ REACH which is our statewide inter hospital
- 11:00transfer system. We have all, almost every acute
- 11:03care hospital represented and the post acute care agencies and
- 11:07entities represented. It's like the one place where
- 11:09the full spectrum is all there at once.
- 11:13What was the sort of impetus for it and why?
- 11:15Why was was the seasonal strain just hitting so much that you
- 11:20were like, we, we need to figure this out?
- 11:22Honestly, I think this came out of COVID.
- 11:23You know, we were used at that point for everyone coming
- 11:26together and meeting in one place.
- 11:28And I think one of the lessons we learned from the pandemic was
- 11:30the disproportionate impact just bringing everyone together can
- 11:35have. So it's a very simple concept to
- 11:37have one virtual phone call with everyone.
- 11:40We all hear the same information.
- 11:41If people have a particular concern, it comes up.
- 11:44But we've been doing it for four years now and we have incredible
- 11:47attendance still. What sorts of things have come
- 11:50up during these meetings that you're like, oh, this is?
- 11:52Incredible. We would have never otherwise
- 11:53seen this. Yeah.
- 11:54So there's 4 main objectives of this work group. 1 is to share
- 11:58situational awareness, 1 is to share, you know, EPI or
- 12:02regulatory updates. One is to present any kind of
- 12:05regional best practices going on.
- 12:06And the last one is for the health department to support any
- 12:09collaborative effort that all the entities, you know, want to
- 12:11embark upon. And so in the course of, you
- 12:15know, working with those 4 objectives, interesting things
- 12:18come up. Recently, one of our healthcare
- 12:20systems presented on their universal masking policy.
- 12:24One time an Arizona hospital presented on a regional alliance
- 12:28they have with other hospitals, where the smaller hospitals
- 12:31support each other with consultations and diversion.
- 12:34One time a hospital leader brought up the low flu
- 12:38vaccination rates that they were seeing in their staff.
- 12:41So all these little pings really inspire further conversations.
- 12:44And so, you know, a hospital will think we'll do.
- 12:47Does our hospital need a universal masking policy?
- 12:49Like should our hospital be part of an alliance?
- 12:52Like, what is our staff vaccination rate?
- 12:55I can tell you on the vaccination rate part, when that
- 12:57hospital brought it up, it prompted the health department
- 12:59to go back and look at our own annual flu vaccination rate data
- 13:02year over year to see if we were tracking with what that
- 13:05particular hospital had been seeing.
- 13:07Oh wow, so already getting these tangible results from just
- 13:11sharing stories. Yeah.
- 13:13Another big example was when an EMS agency brought up the fact
- 13:19that a new prior authorization protocol was holding up their
- 13:22transport. We had not heard of this at the
- 13:24health department and so we ended up helping connect those
- 13:27EMS agencies with the right person at the pair.
- 13:30It felt tangible. It felt like there were there
- 13:33was a result. And I guess the question is
- 13:35where else should this have been brought up?
- 13:37Like where else do you have everyone along the process of
- 13:40healthcare and patient throughput all together on one
- 13:43call? I mean, in this particular
- 13:45circumstance, you have two of the three components of the
- 13:48healthcare system involved. You have the facilities and you
- 13:52have EMS, and in this call they're all together.
- 13:55One of the big goals of the of the program is collaboration
- 13:59through data. Can you talk a little bit more
- 14:01about the kinds of data that you're getting that you're
- 14:04collecting, maybe that you didn't know that you needed?
- 14:07Yeah, Data is always how we open.
- 14:10Every meeting is to talk about the data that that we have.
- 14:13And I think it is critical for the state health department to
- 14:16be able to trust its own data. And so every meeting we show the
- 14:21data that we have. Yes, we show the EPI data on the
- 14:24respiratory viruses that are circulating, but we will always
- 14:26show the bed capacity data that we have.
- 14:28We will show the Ede, you know, diversion that we have and so
- 14:32on. And we asked specifically, does
- 14:34this match with what you all are seeing on the ground?
- 14:39Before we started, you made clear that you want this to be
- 14:42known. At it's heart, it's a phone
- 14:44call. It's getting everyone to talk to
- 14:46each other. Is that?
- 14:47How you would approach? Other systems that are trying to
- 14:51think about like, well, how? Do we just get everyone in a
- 14:53room to understand? Make a phone call.
- 14:57No thanks. That's, that's exactly the point
- 14:59that I'd like to make about the Statewide Healthcare
- 15:01Collaborative forum is that health departments could
- 15:04implement this next week if they wanted.
- 15:06You don't need tech. You don't need slides.
- 15:09We'll send you our slides if that would be helpful, but you
- 15:11don't need a room. You don't need written
- 15:13materials. You need an hour once a month
- 15:16during the respiratory season for a virtual meeting.
- 15:19And I think, you know, we keep our program really standard.
- 15:22We tweak it a little bit, you know, year over year.
- 15:24One year, I remember we tried to highlight the major published
- 15:27articles on surge that were coming out this year.
- 15:30For example, we had to add a section on measles because
- 15:34that's something that we're experiencing here in Arizona.
- 15:36Honestly, the opening content can change, but the invitees and
- 15:41the concept of inviting everyone to the table for folks to come,
- 15:45you know that is what doesn't change.
- 15:47And this is our fourth year running this and attendance
- 15:51remains high. Nearly every acute care hospital
- 15:54is represented, all EMS agencies, several local health
- 15:58departments and then the agencies representing post acute
- 16:01care as well. And I just think it's a
- 16:03wonderful baseline structure to have.
- 16:06And I remember one year there were conversations internally
- 16:09like, should we reconvene this group before our next meeting
- 16:13because things are escalating with with hospital surges and we
- 16:18didn't at the time, but that's a lever that can be pulled at any
- 16:23time. This is a known entity.
- 16:25This is a known work group. And it's so nice to have that.
- 16:32Doctor Lisa Villarroel is chief medical officer for public
- 16:35health of the Arizona Department of Health Services.
- 16:38Earlier we heard from Shirley Orr, executive director of the
- 16:41Association of Public Health Nurses.
- 16:44Leading Change is a new ASTA workshop designed for
- 16:47professionals and clinical and non clinical public health
- 16:50roles. The workshop equips participants
- 16:53with strategies and skills to navigate change and uncertainty
- 16:56as individuals, team members and organization wide leaders,
- 17:00emphasizing actionable instruction and resources.
- 17:03It enables leaders to create and implement real world initiatives
- 17:06in their agencies for 2026 and beyond.
- 17:10Participants will gain tools to design targeted initiatives and
- 17:13foster tangible organizational change.
- 17:16This experience prepares them to drive meaningful impact in their
- 17:19workplaces. Find more at the link in the
- 17:22show notes. This has been public health
- 17:24review morning edition. I'm John Sheehan for the
- 17:27Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.