Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Overview of Permanent Disability Ratings in California Workers Compensation
Transcript
- 0:03Hello and welcome to Overview of Permanent Disability
- 0:06Ratings in California Workers' Compensation.
- 0:09I'm Michael Falati, Chair of the Workers' Compensation
- 0:11Law Section and a Certified Specialist in Workers'
- 0:14Compensation Law. I'd like to take a moment to
- 0:16plug the Workers' Compensation Section, a new
- 0:19and fast -growing section of the Beverly Hills
- 0:21Bar Association. I encourage all work comp practitioners
- 0:24as well as practitioners in overlapping practice
- 0:27areas like personal injury, labor and employment,
- 0:30and social security disability to join the section
- 0:33and perhaps get more involved as a section leader.
- 0:36We'll throw my email address and the BHBA help
- 0:39desk email address in the chat so you can follow
- 0:41us and contact us about the section. And now
- 0:44I'm delighted to introduce our speaker for today,
- 0:47Eric Wachna. Eric is a senior managing partner
- 0:50at Alberta McKinsey's Inland Empire office. where
- 0:53he specializes in defending workers' compensation
- 0:55claims, conducting exposure analyses, and overseeing
- 0:59the firm's medical rating program based on AMA
- 1:01guides and permanent disability schedules. Throughout
- 1:04his career, he has secured numerous take -nothing
- 1:06decisions across a wide range of affirmative
- 1:08defenses, partnered with the District Attorney
- 1:11and Department of Insurance to obtain restitution
- 1:13orders in fraud cases, and successfully reduced
- 1:16client exposure through skilled doctors' cross
- 1:19-examinations. And now, let's get started. Thank
- 1:24you so much, Michael. Appreciate it. All right,
- 1:37thank you again for the introduction, Michael.
- 1:39Welcome, everyone. Good afternoon. It really
- 1:41is a pleasure to be speaking in front of you
- 1:44all today. Again, I'm gonna go over permit disability
- 1:48ratings. It is my understanding that we have
- 1:53combination of or comp practitioners as well
- 1:57as perhaps other practitioners that are looking
- 2:00at this concept. So I'm going to just briefly
- 2:04provide a real over level discussion of permanent
- 2:10disability ratings specifically in workers compensation
- 2:13today. Really the goal of the presentation today
- 2:22is hopefully you'll come away with an understanding
- 2:24of the relationship between impairment and disability
- 2:27to very different things in the world of workers'
- 2:31compensation. You'll get a little bit of an understanding
- 2:34in terms of how to apply the AMA Guides Fifth
- 2:36Edition in California, calculate a permanent
- 2:40disability rating. I've got a real brief section
- 2:45on identifying some common rating disputes. issues
- 2:48with medical reports that we do see as practitioners
- 2:52quite commonly evaluate those reports for substantial
- 2:57medical evidence. Of course, recognizing opportunities
- 3:02where you may perhaps have an ability to challenge
- 3:06a defective rating. So, permit disability, why
- 3:14does it matter? It is a big part of every worker's
- 3:19compensation claims, specifically as a cost driver.
- 3:23Obviously, it impacts settlement value of cases,
- 3:27value of the settlement that we do reach. It
- 3:30can affect future earning capacity, life pension
- 3:34eligibility, just an additional payment of compensation
- 3:38to injured workers that have a certain level
- 3:40of disability, plus permanent total disability
- 3:43exposure where you have an injury worker or an
- 3:46applicant that is unable to return to the workforce.
- 3:51Oftentimes drive litigation strategy in terms
- 3:54of the discovery that would make repound and
- 3:57in many cases the permanent disability evaluation
- 4:00may be the single largest driver of indemnity
- 4:04exposure itself. A little background about how
- 4:09we get to the end result of permanent disability
- 4:14here in California. California ULOT is something
- 4:18called the Permanent Disability Rating Schedule.
- 4:21It is a document that has been around for decades,
- 4:28was most recently revised in 2005. Interesting
- 4:32that part of the labor code, we actually are,
- 4:37the legislature is supposed to update the Permanent
- 4:39Disability Rating Schedule every five years.
- 4:41It's not been done since B899 in 2005, so we
- 4:46are 20 years and ongoing. There does not appear
- 4:50to be anything in the pipeline that we're aware
- 4:53of up in Sacramento in regards to amendments
- 4:56in that regard, but we've had the same system
- 4:58for the last 20 years essentially that we're
- 5:01operating under. So as I mentioned, California
- 5:05does not award direct disability directly from
- 5:08the A &E guides. It's a big conversation or topic
- 5:11that we'll be talking about today in terms of
- 5:14there being apples and oranges. We speak in terms
- 5:20of impairment when we are discussing the case
- 5:25with the medical evaluator who is looking at
- 5:31the applicant or a worker. and evaluating their
- 5:34disability. Term disability, on the other hand,
- 5:38comes from whole person impairment being placed
- 5:41through the permanent disability rating schedule
- 5:43to ultimately get to that permanent disability
- 5:45factor. So it is apples and oranges, though the
- 5:49two are codependent of one another. So again,
- 5:55as I've mentioned, really, we've had the same
- 5:57rating schedule since 2005. Before 2005, we really
- 6:01had this work schedule that was a combination
- 6:03of objective findings, activities of daily living,
- 6:09perhaps a specific medical condition or restriction.
- 6:13It really gave pretty large disparate ratings.
- 6:19In addition to that, we had a situation where
- 6:22each party would bring their own expert in and
- 6:26you would get some very wonky results in the
- 6:30sense of how much disability there was for our
- 6:33claim, depending on the expert report that you
- 6:36had. And so California really attempted to simplify
- 6:40that through SB 899 in 2005 and said, okay, folks,
- 6:44we are going to now use the A &A Guide's fifth
- 6:47edition, which at that time was already several
- 6:49years old. We're gonna go to objective scientific
- 6:53medicine -based assessments to where we're looking
- 6:58at the objective condition of the applicant or
- 7:02injured worker and I'm going to be using that
- 7:06as the framework for determining impairments.
- 7:09So the idea being there's greater consistency
- 7:11and uniformity and the courts would not have
- 7:16to rely on medicals that were so disparate and
- 7:20utilizing so many different parts of the old
- 7:23ratings schedule. So long story short. California's
- 7:27attempted trying to simplify and standardize
- 7:31some basis for it to award a parent for a medical
- 7:34condition. So again, the basic process is you
- 7:38have an injury. If that injury is admitted, some
- 7:41speed over nature extent of the body part or
- 7:45system that was injured, the applicant's gonna
- 7:48see an evaluator. It's gonna utilize the AMA
- 7:51guides, going to go through the guides and determine
- 7:54the amount of whole person impairments to the
- 7:57body part or systems affected. It's then going
- 8:00to be adjusted under the California PDRS or disability
- 8:04rating schedule, which we'll look at each part
- 8:08of those adjustments in the string rating and
- 8:10greater detail and essentially adjusted for occupation,
- 8:13adjusted for age. And then we're going to get
- 8:16a permanent disability number that comes out
- 8:20of that, which may be subject to a legal concept
- 8:23called apportionment. potentially reduced. I'll
- 8:27touch on that throughout the presentation as
- 8:29well. So again, impairment versus disability
- 8:33are two very different things. The AMA guides,
- 8:36they're there for an evaluator to objectively
- 8:39measure impairment, loss of function. It's purely
- 8:42a medical determination. The AMA guides book
- 8:46itself is a 500 -page book written by a whole
- 8:49bunch of doctors with the idea of putting doctors
- 8:53and lawyers on the same playing field when they
- 8:55are discussing the extent of an injury to a particular
- 9:01body part or system. So in terms of permanent
- 9:05disability, that is a legal mechanism where we
- 9:08take that whole person's impairment number and
- 9:11we're now looking to measure the extent of disability.
- 9:14So it is a quasi -economic legal determination
- 9:17and of course, adjusted by statutes. you'll see
- 9:21that if you're looking at a medical report, you
- 9:22have a doctor that says, well, this particular
- 9:25individual might have 10 % whole person impairment
- 9:28to a particular body part or system. And that
- 9:31would be very different than that body part rates
- 9:34to 16 % of disability. So we're looking at using
- 9:39both methodologies to arrive at disability. what
- 9:47doctors must do their role in terms of utilizing
- 9:51the A &A guides and creating a medical framework
- 9:53for both parties to use is one, they're gonna
- 9:58conduct a thorough evaluation on the applicant
- 10:02or injured worker and assess for what we call
- 10:06MMI status or maximum medical improvements. That
- 10:10is a legal term of art. It's defined in the A
- 10:15&A guides as the point in which an injured worker
- 10:18has reached a plateau and their condition is
- 10:20not likely to get any better over the next year
- 10:25with additional medical treatments. So really
- 10:27what we're looking to see as practitioners or
- 10:29the doctor, excuse me, is looking to see, has
- 10:33this individual changed? Is there additional
- 10:34treatment necessary? And if so, is that treatment
- 10:38going to change their condition? Sort of want
- 10:41to evaluate that capacity and make a call on
- 10:43termination on MMI status. Once that's the case
- 10:47and the applicant or injured workers reached
- 10:49maximum medical improvement, then they're ready
- 10:51to be rated and provided a whole person impairment
- 10:55so that permanent disability can be calculated.
- 10:58Doctors, of course, do have to identify body
- 11:00parts and systems that were determined to be
- 11:03injured in the course and scope of employment.
- 11:06They are expected to identify the proctor AMA
- 11:11chapter or table in the AMA guides. calculate
- 11:15full person impairments and really an overarching
- 11:17discussion or theme of today's conversation really
- 11:20explaining the methodology or the rationale on
- 11:23how they got there. Any discussion that's really
- 11:27unsupported by that analysis is potentially going
- 11:31to run the risk of not being substantial medical
- 11:34evidence by the court, which means that the court
- 11:37can either order that the medicals be reformed
- 11:41or Alternatively, that they are just disallowed
- 11:47or not followed by the court as a basis for an
- 11:49award of benefits. A couple of common chapters
- 11:56in the AMA guides. The AMA guides itself is an
- 11:5818 -chapter book. Chapter 1 gives the framework
- 12:03on the guides, the basic nuts and bolts of how
- 12:07to use it. As does chapter two, provide specific
- 12:11guidance in terms of practitioners and how they
- 12:13are to utilize the AMA guides. And then chapters
- 12:16three through 18 really identify all consortium
- 12:20of body parts and systems. Most commonly, I've
- 12:25provided six of the most common chapters that
- 12:28we do tend to see in most workers' compensation
- 12:30planners from day to day. I'll discuss a little
- 12:34bit about each chapter in some detail. So you
- 12:39have a little working knowledge in terms of framework
- 12:42of those chapters. These are the most common
- 12:44ones we see. Discussing, moving on to really
- 12:51how we're going to formulate a rating, before
- 12:54we were to rate any sort of reports, there is
- 12:59some information that everyone needs. Why? Because
- 13:02this information is going to come up when you
- 13:04plug it in to your rating itself. So we need
- 13:10definitely the first five things here on this
- 13:12slide. Date of injury, why? Because that controls
- 13:15the permanent disability rate and monetary value
- 13:18that's assigned to the disability. Second, the
- 13:21applicant's age at the time of injury. Why? Because
- 13:25date also is a controlling factor when you are
- 13:29calculating the rating. As is the applicant's
- 13:32occupation, you'll need a permanent disability
- 13:35money chart. There are tons of those money charts
- 13:39online. I do not believe the state of California,
- 13:42the DIR, has one within the labor code. If anyone
- 13:46ever needs one, feel free to email me after the
- 13:49presentation. I'll be happy to have my phone
- 13:52provide you with a money chart. And finally,
- 13:55of course, the program disability rating schedule.
- 13:58I do have the link to the DIR that is posted.
- 14:03So you need those five bits of information to
- 14:05get going. And if anyone has not seen a rating
- 14:10formula or seen a rating, and it's this mishmash
- 14:14of different numbers, parentheses, this is essentially
- 14:19what it looks like. I'm going to discuss how
- 14:22we get there in its basic individual pieces.
- 14:26It's a combination of one, an impairment number,
- 14:28it's the body part or system that's being affected.
- 14:32Two, it's the impairment standard, whole person
- 14:35impairment that's given by the doctor from medical
- 14:38reports. This third little adjustment here is
- 14:42diminished future earning capacity rank. And
- 14:47then we've got a occupational code and adjustments,
- 14:53the adjusted impairment for impact factoring
- 14:59and occupation, and then finally adjusted for
- 15:02age. So that's the reason why we need all those
- 15:04bits and pieces of information for our slide.
- 15:08So I'll give you an example. I'll try and go
- 15:11through how a string rating itself is generated.
- 15:17Example, I've got an applicant, 60 -year -old
- 15:19truck driver, multiple orthopedic injuries for
- 15:21a specific injury on September 15th, 2020, neck,
- 15:25back, and right shoulder as body parts injured.
- 15:28And we'll say that calculation AWW, that's short
- 15:32for average weekly wage, thousand dollars a week.
- 15:35We're gonna calculate permanent disability at
- 15:38a rate of two thirds the average weekly wage
- 15:42subject to a statutory cap of $290 per week.
- 15:47That's why the date of injury is important because
- 15:50if let's say this is an earlier date of injury
- 15:53pre -2013, the statutory cap for permanent disability
- 15:57is $230 per week. And then historically, as the
- 16:01date of injury has gotten longer, that permanent
- 16:03disability standard cap has gotten lower in terms
- 16:07of the weekly rate. So we've got our basic facts
- 16:13here, and I'll walk through and call the five
- 16:19-step process in terms of getting that number.
- 16:22Getting to the impairment number, first off,
- 16:25a little piece of a medical report that we're
- 16:28using as an example out highlighted in yellow.
- 16:31We've got a cervical spine or a neck injury.
- 16:35We've got a doctor saying, okay, I'm going to
- 16:37use the DRE method, diagnosis related method,
- 16:41category two. It's in page three for the AMA
- 16:44guides. You can give a 5 % whole person and parents.
- 16:48Now, I do recognize that this particular medical
- 16:53The very first thing this doctor does say is
- 16:55DRE category one zero percent impairment. What
- 16:58this doctor is actually also doing is saying
- 17:01that I'm going to use the AMA guides in a manner
- 17:08that is not strict per se based on what I see
- 17:12or have evaluated during my examination, but
- 17:15I'm going to take in consideration the nature
- 17:17and extent of the injury, the extraordinary circumstances
- 17:21around the case, and 0 % here isn't good enough,
- 17:25I believe that instead, we should use a different
- 17:28part of this table to get 5 % whole person impairment.
- 17:31Something called Numerized Guzman Analysis, and
- 17:34I will touch base on that for purposes of determining
- 17:37our rating, we'll go with the 5 % whole person
- 17:39impairment, just for our example. So how does
- 17:43this all work? Again, I've cut a little bits
- 17:47and pieces of the permanent disability rating
- 17:49schedule out on each slide. Ordinarily, you would
- 17:52have the schedule and you'd be going page by
- 17:54page to get to the appropriate section, to run
- 17:58the numbers. I've got a shortcut of this and
- 18:02cut and pasted different parts out of it. I'm
- 18:04sorry. Excuse me, the PRS as we're going through.
- 18:09So obviously, step one is your impairment number,
- 18:13page two, three of the PRS. We're talking about
- 18:15cervical spine diagnosis for diagnosis -related
- 18:19asthma. Maybe a little code, 15101 .0100. What
- 18:28we do first and foremost is we start our rating
- 18:31by assigning that code. Then we use a dash and
- 18:35then we add the 5 % whole person impairment,
- 18:37which was, again, if I back up, the 5 % impairment
- 18:41given by the doctor. Our next step is to determine
- 18:47the future earning capacity. There's another
- 18:51adjustment. I'll go back to the initial page
- 18:57impairment rank, and you'll see a note regarding
- 19:00rank. What that is, is that's your diminished
- 19:04future earning capacity rank. It's on a scale
- 19:07of one through eight, and based on a bunch of
- 19:10evidence that was put together, paired for the
- 19:12state of California, they assigned a specific
- 19:14rank to each particular body part or condition.
- 19:19the theory that the amount of impairment should
- 19:22be adjusted due to loss of future earning capacity
- 19:26relative to that body part. What you would normally
- 19:33do in this particular case is you would first
- 19:36take the go to section two of the permanent disability
- 19:41rating schedule, find the appropriate FEC rank,
- 19:45which our case was five, and then go down with
- 19:49the AMA 5 % impairment that was given. And you'll
- 19:53see that that, in this particular case, combines
- 19:56to six. That was the way you did it for dates
- 20:01of injury before January 1st, 2013. After 2013,
- 20:08as part of SB 863, the legislature just said,
- 20:13we're gonna simplify this process a little bit.
- 20:16We're instead gonna give the max FEC rank to
- 20:21every body part and system in the Permanent Disability
- 20:25Rating Schedule. Long story short, you take the
- 20:28whole person impairment number and now you multiply
- 20:32it by 1 .4, which is actually the maximum number
- 20:36in the FEC rank in the Permanent Disability Rating
- 20:41Schedule. So 5 times 1 .4 equals exactly 7. and
- 20:47that's how I have my string there that it's set
- 20:50up. So just know that if you're dealing with
- 20:56a date of injury that just so happens to be pre
- 20:58-2013, pretty old, late in the game now to be
- 21:02getting medical reports on dates of injury that
- 21:05are that old, but they still do exist, just know
- 21:08that you will have to take an additional step
- 21:10in terms of identifying the specific FEC rank
- 21:13on impairment ranking, and then also under the
- 21:20FEC rank under page 2 -3. That takes us to group
- 21:26occupation number. This is the meat and potatoes
- 21:30of the permanent disability rating schedule in
- 21:36terms of contents. There's 35 pages dedicated
- 21:40to different occupations, industries, and what
- 21:46really what we're trying to do is trying to identify
- 21:51a group number based on occupation. And the permanent
- 21:56disability rating schedule is very detailed in
- 22:00that respect. It's got every single rank and
- 22:04body part that's aligned with chapters three
- 22:09and 318 of the AMA guides. And depending on your
- 22:15group number, run from 120 to 590 for different
- 22:18occupations. They're going to have an adjustment.
- 22:22In the last few pages of this particular section
- 22:26of the rating schedule, there's a bunch of entries
- 22:31that look very similar to the one I have at the
- 22:33bottom of the slide here. You can see it says
- 22:35Group 350, Truck Drivers. And it's got one for
- 22:40every single group number that the part disability
- 22:45rating central contemplates, along with a better
- 22:49description or a detailed description as to some
- 22:51of the physical expectations of the job or requirements
- 22:57of the job itself. So a practitioner could look
- 23:00at this and say, okay, well, I have no idea what
- 23:03a 120 or 130 group might be, but I can look at
- 23:10this and it will give me a list of typical occupations,
- 23:14as well as some of the expectations in terms
- 23:16of what somebody would be expected to do as part
- 23:20of their job. And then finally over to the right
- 23:23here, there's a bunch of different body parts
- 23:25and systems along with a particular letter. As
- 23:31with all things in workers compensation, certainly,
- 23:37this is all subject to interpretation. You may
- 23:39have a truck driver that may have entirely different
- 23:43expectations or what it is they do that may be
- 23:47able to tee up an argument for against a higher
- 23:51or lower group number. So it's all subject to
- 23:54interpretation. This is all to provide the party's
- 23:57guidance with or the court guidance with preparing
- 24:00rating instructions as well as of course for
- 24:03practitioners to assist in settlement or arguments
- 24:06in support of whatever occupation numbers being
- 24:10sought. The way the group numbers are adjusted
- 24:14is such that the lower group numbers tend to
- 24:18be occupations that are physically less intensive.
- 24:25Think admin, desk jobs, those types of jobs where
- 24:31you've got less of a heavy physical demand, but
- 24:35of course you've got more perhaps in terms of
- 24:38a skill set or analysis. demand, which would
- 24:43result in less adjustment for physical injuries,
- 24:46but of course more of an adjustment for psychological
- 24:50mental injuries. Conversely, you've got higher
- 24:53group numbers, somebody that's a weightlifter
- 24:56or bricklayer, a more intensive, physically intensive
- 25:00occupation, you're going to have less of an adjustment
- 25:03for a psych injury, but a much higher adjustment
- 25:06for a physical injury. So again, it's the state's
- 25:11best attempt at trying to create a fair representative
- 25:15for somebody that's in a particular occupation
- 25:19and is losing a potentially a right to participate
- 25:25in the labor market in that capacity. So I've
- 25:28got, here I've got, we've got a neck injury,
- 25:32so spine G. What I would do then at that point
- 25:37is I would go ahead and then add the group number.
- 25:40My truck driver based on our example as well
- 25:42as our occupational variant G to the string and
- 25:45say I have 350G at this point. Next step is going
- 25:50to be to adjust for that occupational variant,
- 25:53that 350G. And that's where pages 5253 in the
- 26:00rating schedule provide tables for adjustments.
- 26:03Cut and pasted a part, a portion of that particular
- 26:06page. to show you how you would do it. Essentially,
- 26:11we've got a rating standard, a percent, and that's
- 26:13our seven here. When we go down to seven, and
- 26:16when we just carry that over to G, what you give
- 26:19us are H. And so we're adjusted for occupational
- 26:22variance, A percent at this point. We're almost
- 26:28there. And the last thing we're gonna do with
- 26:30the string rating itself is adjust for H. You'll
- 26:35recall that my example of a 60 -year -old applicant
- 26:40at the time of injury. And so we'll go under
- 26:43page 6, this particular case, it's 6 -2 of the
- 26:47rating schedule. And I'm going to go ahead and,
- 26:52as with the previous schedule, find the amount
- 26:56of percentage in terms of our rating. And I'm
- 27:00going to go over to the age of the applicant
- 27:02at the time of injury, which was 60. and that
- 27:06gets me my 10. So I'm going to put 10 in right
- 27:09at the end of the string there which gives me
- 27:12the whole string and the monetary value in this
- 27:16particular case would be $8 ,700 and change based
- 27:19on a permanent disability, a rate of $290 per
- 27:23week. How did I get that monetary value? Fast
- 27:29forward just a little bit and we'll go through
- 27:31our money charts and you will see 10 % would
- 27:37be $290 per week, payable at 30 and a quarter
- 27:41weeks, having a monetary value of 8772 .50 for
- 27:46a date of injury in 2002. Well, that's how I
- 27:51came up with a string rating. That is, of course,
- 27:55one string or one body part on one date of injury.
- 27:59So we're really looking at this in a vacuum.
- 28:03Before I go on to what happens when you have
- 28:06multiple body parts in what you do, the last
- 28:09step, if applicable, would be to adjust for apportionments.
- 28:13And again, apportionment is a concept where we're
- 28:16allocuting permanent disability to industrial
- 28:20and non -industrial factors. It's codified under
- 28:26Labor Code Section 4663. 4664 is... one of the
- 28:31few conclusive presumptions in the labor code
- 28:34that allows for a credit of permanent disability
- 28:40from a prior award toward permanent disability
- 28:43of a new award. So the best example I can think
- 28:47of is if we're talking about a neck of 10%, if
- 28:50we've got an applicant that injured himself five
- 28:53years before this time had an award of 9 % permanent
- 28:59disability, then obviously the practitioner could
- 29:04argue that 90 percent of the disability that
- 29:11was given in this rating is all the result of
- 29:15a prior injury from five years ago, leaving a
- 29:18one percent permanent disability attributable
- 29:21to the current injury. That's 4664. It's got
- 29:26to be apples to apples in terms of how an examiner
- 29:30from the prior injury, how they utilized the
- 29:34AMA guides. Did they utilize the AMA guides?
- 29:37There's legal authority out there saying that
- 29:39if you're using a prior award that's based on
- 29:44a rating schedule that pre -existed in the AMA
- 29:46guides, then you're not gonna be able to apply
- 29:484664 apportionment. So, not a worry. You just
- 29:53default to 4663 and... and make your argument
- 29:57based on the facts and circumstances on that.
- 30:01So I'll cover that in just a little bit, but
- 30:05in terms of the immediate case, you'll see I
- 30:09also pulled a portion of the same medical that
- 30:11we looked at originally for the discussion regarding
- 30:15impairment for that neck. And there's a little
- 30:18blurb here that I've highlighted in yellow about
- 30:21the discussion regarding abortion. Essentially,
- 30:24the doctor evaluated the applicant in the case
- 30:26saying that 60 % of this particular disability
- 30:31is related to the injury, 40 % of pre -existing
- 30:35factors based on the discussion above. What happens
- 30:43with that is assuming there is valid legal apportionment,
- 30:49meaning that a court reviewing this has determined
- 30:53that the discussion itself is substantive enough
- 30:57to where it does make sense and it's based on
- 31:00the evidence. For the parties to simply agree,
- 31:03solve the case based on the valuation. Then what
- 31:06would happen is that same rating that we did
- 31:10would be reduced. So you would take a 0 .6, the
- 31:130 .6 reflecting 60 % being allocated to the industrial
- 31:18injury and then. that being multiplied by the
- 31:23existing permanent disability strength. You arrive
- 31:26at 6 % permanent disability at all after apportionment.
- 31:35Once we've ran a string for the body parts, identified
- 31:41whether apportionment is a discussion and applying
- 31:43that, the next thing we would do is run that
- 31:46very same string for any other body parts and
- 31:49systems that were determined to be injured through
- 31:55the course of scope of employment as a result
- 31:57of this particular injury. I've saved you the
- 32:01trouble in the time rather than going back through
- 32:03the schedule and individually doing the back,
- 32:06individually doing the right shoulder. You can
- 32:08see I've gone ahead and done those. So just note
- 32:11that you'll see the impairment Group number is
- 32:16different here. Again, that's just based on me
- 32:19utilizing the DRE method for the lumbar spine
- 32:23or the back, which has a impairment code of 15
- 32:27.03, and also the right shoulder for loss of
- 32:31motion in this particular case. And it's a little
- 32:35different group number. But everything is calculated
- 32:37exactly the same. And then... because the doctor
- 32:40did opine that the unfortunate applied to all
- 32:43three body parts and systems, then I've got that
- 32:46all reduced by 40%. Once you've got your individual
- 32:54strings for each body part, then the next thing
- 32:57you're going to go ahead and do is combine all
- 33:00of those different body parts into one total
- 33:04permanent disability. And to do so, you would
- 33:10go to pages 8 -2 and onward of the permanent
- 33:14disability rating schedule. It's the very end,
- 33:17giant chart that's descending pyramid of numbers.
- 33:22And really what you do is you start with the
- 33:26body parter system that is the highest in terms
- 33:30of permanent disability after apportionment.
- 33:33And then you combine it with the next highest
- 33:35one. So in this particular case, you have six.
- 33:37and then you combine with 6. Again at the bottom
- 33:41of this chart it is cut off because I pulled
- 33:43a small portion of it. At the bottom of the chart
- 33:47itself the numbers 1 through 50 go from left
- 33:53to right as well. So when you're combining you
- 33:56just simply go down take the existing permanent
- 33:57visibility from the highest first highest one
- 34:00and move it over by 6. That would get us 12.
- 34:04The next thing you would then do is go further
- 34:06down the chart. I'm going to combine the right
- 34:08shoulder with the sum of the neck and the back,
- 34:11the two we've done already. So we're going to
- 34:13go 12, and then we go over 2, and that gives
- 34:16us 14. It may look, in this particular instance,
- 34:25it looks like everything is just being added.
- 34:28The sum of 6 and 6 is 12, 12 and 2 is 14. When
- 34:32you're high enough in the combined values chart
- 34:36where the permanent disability is low that you're
- 34:40combining, the chart does frequently add. The
- 34:46result will be the sum of those two body parts
- 34:50of systems. However, when you get further down
- 34:53and your permanent disability rating gets much
- 34:57higher, the amount of impairments from another
- 35:03body part or system is going to be greater to
- 35:07move that needle. You'll see from the bottom
- 35:11of the chart I even have here, if you go 12 and
- 35:15combine with 12, you don't have 24, you have
- 35:1923. And to take this all the way down to the
- 35:23very bottom of the permanent disability chart,
- 35:27let's just say you have an applicant with a 99
- 35:30% permanent disability. high as you can get in
- 35:33our system. If all the medicals you have rate
- 35:39to a total of 99%, the next body partner system
- 35:46that you add has to exceed 49 % permanent disability.
- 35:51In other words, that particular one body partner
- 35:54system has to have more than 49 % permanent disability
- 35:57for it to even take over to 100 % on the medicals.
- 36:01So it becomes much harder to increase permanent
- 36:03disability as you go further down and relative
- 36:06permanent disability for the applicant gets greater.
- 36:14Again, as I was showing you in my first example,
- 36:16just assuming one body part, one monetary value,
- 36:19what we would do after we've combined those body
- 36:22parts is we would go ahead and then run the whole
- 36:26thing through, again, the money chart. you'll
- 36:29see in this particular case because we had 14
- 36:31percent permanent disability, some of the neck,
- 36:34the right shoulder, and the back. It would be
- 36:38payable at $290 per week for 46 and a quarter
- 36:41weeks, totaling $13 ,400 and change. What happens
- 36:48if your applicant does not have permanent disability
- 36:58or it's not eligible for a permanent disability
- 37:00rate at the statutory max. Again, permanent disability
- 37:04is calculated at two thirds of an applicant's
- 37:07average weekly wage subject to a statutory cap.
- 37:14So if for whatever reason the applicant tends
- 37:16to be making less money and two thirds of that's
- 37:18less than $290 per week, the statutory cap, how
- 37:22do you get to that number? You're going to simply
- 37:24multiply whatever the permanent disability rate
- 37:26you came to is by the number of weeks that you
- 37:30have for the permanent disability percentage
- 37:33that you've identified. Again, if I'm using,
- 37:36let's assume $200 per week, I wouldn't use 219
- 37:40to come up with this number. I would simply use
- 37:42200 times 46 and a quarter weeks. The number
- 37:46of weeks PD is payable for the same 14 % permanent
- 37:49disability, which would then result in a permanent
- 37:51disability total of $9 ,200. So always be sure
- 37:56to calculate your permanent disability rate.
- 37:59If it's under $2 .90 a week for whatever reason,
- 38:01you are going to have to independently calculate
- 38:07what the amount of the permanent disability benefit
- 38:10is. Now I'm just going to discuss with generating.
- 38:20I'm just going to discuss a couple of, again,
- 38:23sections of the AMA guides that we did. I brought
- 38:26up a little bit earlier. Part of what we discussed
- 38:30in just our rating and went over involved a spinal
- 38:33rating, in this particular case, a neck and a
- 38:35back. Chapter 15 is the section of the AMA guides
- 38:40that deals with spinal injuries. I have this
- 38:44slide here, the DRE method, because it's one
- 38:46of the most common injuries and common methodologies
- 38:50for rating that practitioners see. And there's
- 38:55a couple different ways you can rate back injuries
- 38:58under Chapter 15. Essentially, there's a DRE
- 39:02or diagnosis related estimate. The other one
- 39:05is a range of motion method. There's a whole
- 39:08checklist and a subset of criteria that an evaluator
- 39:11has to consider when moving someone over from
- 39:15a diagnosis related estimate to a range of motion
- 39:19when it's appropriate. But the DRE, as we call
- 39:24it, is the preferred method for writing spinal
- 39:29injuries. And this particular example is on page
- 39:333 -4 of the AMA guides. It's got a table and
- 39:37a bunch of criteria in it for an evaluator to
- 39:42assess how much impairments they believe is clinically
- 39:45warranted. This is a common theme that you see
- 39:49throughout the AMA guides with charts and tables
- 39:52where they attempt to put the injured worker
- 39:55or applicant into some category based on either
- 39:59a combination of what they see in terms of the
- 40:03physical examination, diagnosis rendered on that.
- 40:07Perhaps there could be some diagnostic studies
- 40:09supporting a particular condition. But in this
- 40:12particular case, our spinal chapter, this particular
- 40:18chapter or table of the guys. DRE1 is essentially
- 40:23somebody has hurt their back, they do have an
- 40:26injury, but there's no real objective findings
- 40:29on clinical examination. Everything appears to
- 40:32be normal for that individual's age. We'll see
- 40:36a DRE2, and appropriately of course, the DRE1
- 40:39has no impairment. A DRE2, for example, might
- 40:43contain some objective findings that that evaluator
- 40:46had on their clinical examination. Could have
- 40:49been some tenderness that could have palpated
- 40:51the injured worker at the time of the examination,
- 40:54that positive sign in that regard. There could
- 40:59be some unverified complaints of neurological
- 41:02problems that are not supported by diagnostic
- 41:06study. Those are all criteria that an evaluator
- 41:08can look at and place an applicant in the SIGNA
- 41:11-DRE category too. You'll see there's a range
- 41:14of between five and eight percent. the AMA guides
- 41:17to allow the evaluator to use their clinical
- 41:19judgment. DRE3, again, typically you'll find
- 41:27we're talking about neurological issues verified.
- 41:31Sometimes you'll have a reference to a lumbar
- 41:33disectomy. That's really a procedure where we're
- 41:36going in, we're cleaning up the anatomy and discs
- 41:38of certain levels that are affected at the spine
- 41:42to minimize the amount of neurological impact.
- 41:45on the spine itself. So that unsurprisingly would
- 41:49have a higher level of impairment. And then DRE4
- 41:55and higher, there's actually a DRE5 category
- 41:57that may go all the way up high to where you
- 42:00have an instance where somebody injured their
- 42:02back, they may have had a fusion. They've got
- 42:04anatomical changes and problems that are just
- 42:08not going to subside having already performed
- 42:11a surgery. So long lingering pain, anatomical
- 42:14defects, things of that nature. So that's just
- 42:18an example of what you may see when you're medical
- 42:24reports from a doctor discussing a DRE method
- 42:27for a spinal injury. It could be, again, a lumbar
- 42:31spine. could be the thoracic spine, just the
- 42:34middle, it could be the cervical spine. Those
- 42:37impairment numbers do change depending on that
- 42:39level of the spine impacted, but that's generally
- 42:43the framework on how doctors will discuss impairment
- 42:48utilizing the DRE. So again, just another example
- 42:53here I have of an injured worker that's undergone
- 42:57a microdystectomy, persistent radiculopathy,
- 43:00again, a condition where you've got discomfort,
- 43:05perhaps loss of sensation, motor neurological
- 43:08fudge functioning in the lower extremities. Physician
- 43:12gives a DRE3, category 3, 13 % whole person impairment,
- 43:16higher end of the range there, 13 % the permanent
- 43:20disability rating. It's not. We got to take that
- 43:2313%. We got to run through our string, just as
- 43:26we did in my example there, and come up with
- 43:29the resulting permanent disability. subject to,
- 43:32of course, the date of injury, the applicant's
- 43:35occupation, age of time of injury, and of course,
- 43:38their earnings. Chapter 16 deals with upper extremity
- 43:46ratings in the DMA guides, common injuries in
- 43:49boot rotator cuff repairs, labral tears, elbow
- 43:52injuries, carpal tunnel syndrome is a big one.
- 43:56I bring this up because The most common thing
- 44:03that we see as practitioners with doctors assigning
- 44:07or giving impairments when using the upper extremity
- 44:11section is not using the correct impairments
- 44:15itself. Chapter 16 is a bit unique in the sense
- 44:19that because we're dealing with hands, wrists,
- 44:22elbows, shoulders, the authors of the AMA guides
- 44:27thought it necessary to provide an independent
- 44:34upper extremity impairment for that particular
- 44:38body part. So for instance, chapter 16 speaks
- 44:41in terms of hand impairment for hand injuries.
- 44:44It then gets converted, or finger impairment,
- 44:46excuse me, just then gets converted into hand
- 44:48impairments, which could be converted into upper
- 44:52extremity impairments and then ultimately whole
- 44:54person impairments. So if you're dealing with
- 44:57perhaps a finger injury, somebody lost a finger
- 45:00at work, you may see a medical report that's
- 45:03discussing impairment in the context of the finger
- 45:09itself. And that still has to be run through
- 45:12the hand and then adjusted for upper extremity
- 45:15and then adjusted for ultimately whole person
- 45:18impairment. So it's just important to point out
- 45:21and to know that when you're reviewing medicals
- 45:24in in a particular medical legal examination
- 45:27that pertains to uproar extremity ratings, just
- 45:30double -check to confirm that the doctor is using
- 45:33the correct impairment standard based on the
- 45:35body part or system of the uproar extremity they're
- 45:37talking about. Shoulder surgery is another one
- 45:42that commonly comes up. Shoulder surgery itself
- 45:46may not necessarily be a rating. It depends on
- 45:49the procedure. Rotator cuff repairs oftentimes
- 45:52don't carry with their own. their own level of
- 45:57impairments. Instead, you're going to look anatomically
- 46:00at perhaps loss of strength, range of motion,
- 46:05objective findings of that nature to determine
- 46:08the impairments. However, in the instances of
- 46:10a distal clavicle resection, someone's going
- 46:13through and again changing the anatomy of the
- 46:15shoulder itself, there is a estimate of 15%.
- 46:24that can be provided. So I've given just an example,
- 46:29again, where a combination of those particular
- 46:33impairments, findings, and if a physician determines
- 46:38that you've got 12 % upper extremity impairment
- 46:41based on a combination of that residual weakness,
- 46:44loss of motion from that rotator -recover pair,
- 46:47then we're going to want to make sure that we
- 46:48do converts. 12 % upper extremity impairment
- 46:52to 7 % whole person impairment. At that point
- 46:56then we run that through the permanent dissimilar
- 46:59scheduling. Carpal tunnel ratings, another injury
- 47:06that we see quite often on the world of workers'
- 47:10compensation. Again, could be a combination of
- 47:14a sensory and motor deficit. Grip strength is
- 47:18another one. With carpal tunnel, it's important
- 47:22to note that the AMA guides provide for impairments,
- 47:29evaluate to give impairment for carpal tunnel
- 47:31syndrome. However, it's rather specific. It does
- 47:35require first that a carpal tunnel surgery be
- 47:38performed. And once that carpal tunnel surgery
- 47:41is performed and the applicant still has residual
- 47:48carpal tumble, carpal tumble syndromes that is
- 47:52verified by electrodiagnostic evidence after
- 47:55they've had the procedure for some time, then,
- 47:58and at that point, the evaluator can award anywhere
- 48:01between one and three percent whole person impairment
- 48:03for that particular condition. Of course, independent
- 48:07of that, you might have some loss of motion.
- 48:10You could have, again, sensory or motor deficits.
- 48:15Chapter 16 allows for impairments in that regard.
- 48:19So I just know there are a number of ways that
- 48:22doctors can assign impairment for neurological
- 48:27conditions in the upper extremities, including
- 48:29benign carpal tunnel. I mentioned grip strength
- 48:33comes up so much because grip strength is one
- 48:35of those areas where you may see a doctor defer
- 48:38to utilizing that particular table. when given
- 48:45an impairment. And really, the AMA guides do
- 48:50allow for that in certain circumstances. There's
- 48:53a blurb in the guides that say rating by grip
- 48:57strength is not appropriate in the presence of
- 48:59loss of motion or any other anatomical condition
- 49:03that would prevent the maximum application of
- 49:05force. Essentially, what they're saying is that
- 49:08if you've got limited range of motion in some
- 49:10other body part that's preventing you from being
- 49:11able to squeeze, the JMR dynamometer, which doctors
- 49:15use, then that's going to be probably the most
- 49:18accurate and the better rating to use of grip
- 49:21strength. A lot of times what'll happen is when
- 49:27you see medical reports where grip strength is
- 49:30used in combination with loss of motion for perhaps
- 49:33another elbow or wrist, fingers, and those obviously
- 49:40become the basis of some sort of supplemental
- 49:44report or perhaps an interrogatory to the doctor
- 49:47asking them to explain the decision to utilize
- 49:52grip strength in the presence of the other objective
- 49:55range of option. Again now moving on to chapter
- 50:0117 we've got lower extremity ratings and same
- 50:05type of similar framework that the authors have
- 50:10with the upper extremity section. Again, typically
- 50:13we see meniscal surgeries, ACL reconstructions,
- 50:17knee and hip replacements. Chapter 17 is a bit
- 50:21unique in the sense that it does lead off with
- 50:25a table that allows an evaluator to use particular
- 50:29methodologies for rating, but a lot of methodologies
- 50:35cannot be combined with each other. So what we'd
- 50:43want to obviously be cognizant of when you're
- 50:45reviewing is identifying the specific methodology
- 50:48the doctor's using and then cross -referencing
- 50:50that with the combination table in the lower
- 50:54extremity section of the guides to identify whether
- 50:57that is an impairment that can be combined with
- 51:00another lower extremity impairment. The idea
- 51:02being is that because the hip bone is connected
- 51:07to the knee bone, the ankle, and so on and so
- 51:10forth, a lot of these impairments themselves
- 51:13could be residual and have duplicates impacts
- 51:16on the lower extremum. So that's the AMA author's
- 51:21attempt at trying to eliminate overlap as best
- 51:24as they possibly can. Pain add -on, chapter 18
- 51:30of the AMA Guides. Really, there's two flavors
- 51:37that you see the pain add on. The most common
- 51:40one by far and large is the pain add on itself
- 51:45that's discretionary to the evaluator. H73 of
- 51:50the, 573, excuse me, of the AMA guides. It allows
- 51:55you to, an evaluator to increase a impairment
- 51:59on a body part or system. and by one to three
- 52:02percent if the burden of that condition is increased
- 52:07in excess of what would normally be expected
- 52:13from somebody presenting with that type of injury.
- 52:17It is a subjective analysis by the doctor and
- 52:20the doctor is given the discretion to subjectively
- 52:22increase impairment to that amount. That said,
- 52:30we do see occasionally medical reports where
- 52:33you'll have a doctor that finds no impairment
- 52:35to a body part system, but then says, well, in
- 52:38light of all the facts and circumstances of the
- 52:40case, I'm going to go ahead and I'm going to
- 52:43give the applicant 3 % based on the pain add
- 52:45on chapter 18. WCAV has said you can't do that.
- 52:53If your impairment is zero, you can't increase
- 52:56zero by one third at that point. because there's
- 53:00nothing to increase. There's no impairment in
- 53:02that regard. So, just know that that is something
- 53:07that is challenged in sports and there's case
- 53:10law supporting that. Again, whenever you see
- 53:13a 1 -3 % increase, you've got to verify the what,
- 53:15the why, the how. It doesn't make sense to untie.
- 53:19The other way to beyond the 3 % paid add -on
- 53:23discretion in Chapter 18 is to do a formal pain
- 53:27analysis. and to go through a 10 -step process
- 53:30that few, if any, doctors ever do. And then you're
- 53:35left with something at the end of the day. The
- 53:37AMA guides say you can't use if you've got objective
- 53:40findings in a condition already that's contemplated
- 53:46for the body part or system impacted. Again,
- 53:49really trying to use the most accurate methodology
- 53:52in strict sense. Psych injuries. We use a GAF
- 54:01global assessment function methodology in conjunction
- 54:05with the AMA guides, as well as the DSM -5 statistical
- 54:10manual. Those all provide the framework for an
- 54:14evaluator to make a formal psych diagnosis and
- 54:19how to do so. Again, that diagnosis is expressed
- 54:22in the terms, or at least impairment, starts
- 54:25in the terms of a global assessment of function.
- 54:27it's in the PDRS, pages 112 through 115, and
- 54:32you'll see the range goes from 0 to 99. 99, 100
- 54:36being that there's absolutely no residual effects,
- 54:390 being absolutely severe psychiatric effects.
- 54:45And depending on which scale you fall within
- 54:47there, there is a certain gaff score that's given
- 54:51that correlates to a certain whole person and
- 54:53parent. And then you run your string based on
- 54:56that and say an exact With psych injuries, there
- 55:02is for injuries after 1113, there are some restrictions
- 55:07in terms of how you can get impairments. Generally
- 55:11speaking, there's no permanent disability impairment
- 55:13for psychiatric sequelae. That's secondary to
- 55:17a physical injury, really meaning a doctor is
- 55:21saying the root cause of whatever the psychological
- 55:25diagnosis is is secondary to pain and discomfort
- 55:30from undocumented physical injury and trying
- 55:33to prevent overlap. Same thing with sleep and
- 55:36sexual dysfunction. Again, like everything else,
- 55:39there are exceptions. Violent acts, catastrophic
- 55:43injuries, both legal terms of art that are presented
- 55:47if you're making an argument that this fits or
- 55:51does not fit within one of the exceptions for
- 55:54a psych -forming disability to be compensable.
- 55:59Again, apportionment, I know I talked real briefly
- 56:01about apportionment. Again, very important in
- 56:04the sense that really we're looking at a tool
- 56:07that can be used to perhaps minimize exposure,
- 56:13allocate permanent disability to different causes.
- 56:18And really what we're looking at with apportionment
- 56:20is which portion of the injury is industrial.
- 56:22Think of it as a pie. If a pie is the entirety
- 56:26of 10 % permanent disability to a body part,
- 56:29we're just looking at, okay, which portion of
- 56:31that pie is a result of the industrial injury?
- 56:33Which portion of that pie is not? Things that
- 56:38may be effective in terms of back injuries we
- 56:41were talking about. You may see in the medical
- 56:44evidence, evidence of degenerative spine disease,
- 56:47prior surgeries, prior injuries, all things that
- 56:50may help establish a baseline of impairments
- 56:55that pre -existed the industrial injury for the
- 56:58argue that proportioning applies. I included
- 57:06a slide here about Escobedo. Escobedo is really
- 57:09the genesis case outlining what constitutes valid
- 57:12medical apportionments. Really, we're talking
- 57:15about, again, 4663 apportionment, not necessarily
- 57:18conclusive presumption that a prior award of
- 57:23permanent disability applies toward the current
- 57:24injury, but we're looking at just all things
- 57:27medical and really what Escobedo does, and it's
- 57:31the gold standard for today, really requires
- 57:37the evaluator to identify all pathologies, conditions,
- 57:44perhaps work preclusions, any real specific evidence
- 57:48that you have. and bring that in as the context,
- 57:55in the context of how that is impacting the current
- 57:59disability. So you require first show and do
- 58:02explain why, how, what, but then also to identify
- 58:08a specific percentage. As you might have seen
- 58:10in my sample that we went through a little bit
- 58:13earlier, Dr. gave 40 % to non -industrial causes.
- 58:19and of course provide, the doctor needs to provide
- 58:21evidentiary supports. More often times than not,
- 58:25unfortunately doctors tend to lean a little light
- 58:28in terms of the discussion regarding apportionment.
- 58:30It could just be because they are seeing it as
- 58:32a practitioner and years of experience in that
- 58:35field. It is obvious to them that there's obviously
- 58:39something else at play causing the disability,
- 58:42but perhaps they might not have any medical evidence.
- 58:45What we really as practitioners need is a real
- 58:50detailed explanation as to why and how that court
- 58:54could use to follow. Portion Minutes, the defense
- 58:57burden of proof to prove up, because obviously
- 59:01it was a tool that could limit the payments of
- 59:06compensation to the applicant. So we've got the
- 59:13Almaraz -Guzman line of decisions. Now what Almaraz
- 59:18-Guzman was, a couple of different it was an
- 59:21unbound decision combining a couple different
- 59:23cases that were really up in 2009 up on the same
- 59:27issue and really what it involves is doctors
- 59:32using a different section of or table of the
- 59:37May Guides other than what is contemplated for
- 59:40a body part because they think that that is really
- 59:45the most accurate reflection of the applicant's
- 59:49disability, given the certain facts, given the
- 59:52circumstances and facts of the case. Long story
- 59:56short, the WCAB held that really a physician
- 1:00:01can depart from a strict rating of the AMA guides.
- 1:00:05In other words, using the table that is directly
- 1:00:08on point to the body part or system that's injured.
- 1:00:12But they really have to explain in great detail
- 1:00:15as to why. Additionally, they have to first provide
- 1:00:19the strict rating. You may have seen in my sample
- 1:00:22that we went on earlier, the doctor said, clinically,
- 1:00:25I find zero percent whole person impairment.
- 1:00:28This particular applicant belongs in a DRE category
- 1:00:31one. But because of XYZ degenerative changes,
- 1:00:36medical evidence, and the doctor really, in my
- 1:00:40opinion, probably leaned very light in terms
- 1:00:42of the discussion regarding the basis for he
- 1:00:45believed that the applicant should instead warrant
- 1:00:48a 5 % whole person impairment and should be instead
- 1:00:51in a class two with 5 % impairments. So that's
- 1:00:55really this quasi Alvarez -Guzman analysis. Again,
- 1:01:00it's not a license to create ratings out of thin
- 1:01:03air. It's also not a license to use the AMA guides
- 1:01:06incorrectly to obtain some sort of specific results.
- 1:01:12Every bit of experience I have has seen ports
- 1:01:14that do encourage a robust and thorough discussion
- 1:01:17using strict rating. And when you get, of course,
- 1:01:20it is appropriate and medically justified, then
- 1:01:25doctors shouldn't use an Amaranth's -Guzman rating,
- 1:01:30explaining the what and the why of how they came
- 1:01:32to the conclusions that they did. So they got
- 1:01:36to stay within the four corners of the AMA guides.
- 1:01:39We are currently on, I believe, the fifth or
- 1:01:42sixth revision of the sixth edition of the guides.
- 1:01:47Again, the book we're using is several decades
- 1:01:51old at this point, and AMA has since brought
- 1:01:56up additional chapter additions of the guides
- 1:01:59that provide additional body parts and systems.
- 1:02:04That has been argued over the last decade. that
- 1:02:08Alvarez -Guzman should extend to other editions
- 1:02:10of the AMA guides. Last time I saw, WCAB had
- 1:02:15come back and rejected that argument. So for
- 1:02:19all intents and purposes, the fifth edition remains
- 1:02:21the confines of what an evaluator can do to address
- 1:02:28impairments, at least from a strict mathematical
- 1:02:30sense. Then we've got Kite and Vigil. What we're
- 1:02:33talking about now is we've got a rating. for
- 1:02:37multiple body parts, say a neck and a back, that
- 1:02:40rating is all done and instead of using the CVC
- 1:02:43or combined value chart that I have alluded to
- 1:02:46earlier and walked you through, we are, because
- 1:02:49of the facts and circumstances of the case, we're
- 1:02:52instead going to add them. So that started with
- 1:02:56Kite about a decade before this vigil case involved
- 1:03:01the truck driver with knee injury and argument
- 1:03:04was that there was because of some synergistic
- 1:03:07effects between the bilateral knees that combining
- 1:03:11made no sense. It made more sense given the facts
- 1:03:17and circumstances of the case, the outcome of
- 1:03:19the applicant's procedure to instead add those
- 1:03:21disabilities. That has come and gone over the
- 1:03:27years in terms of courts trying to interpret
- 1:03:31CITE, what synergy means. And in 2024, they got
- 1:03:37involved, dropped vigil, really, which was the
- 1:03:43appeals board attempt at trying to clarify what
- 1:03:45is exactly needed. So court came back and said,
- 1:03:51well, we're going to look at ADLs very specifically
- 1:03:54here. And with ADLs, we first obviously identified
- 1:04:00those specific ADLs. that first, there's no overlap
- 1:04:06between the two ADLs of the body parts and systems
- 1:04:09affected. Or again, going back to that synergistic
- 1:04:13effect, yeah, there's overlap, but that overlap
- 1:04:15increases or they use the term amplifies the
- 1:04:20impact of the ADLs itself. The holding itself
- 1:04:23suggests the applicant has the burden of proof,
- 1:04:25establishing all the elements. Why? Because this
- 1:04:28is a rebuttal of the permanent disability review
- 1:04:30schedule, which is allowed. But, of course, as
- 1:04:35with Almaraz Guzman and Cai, you've got to explain
- 1:04:42the what, the why, the how, and provide a detailed
- 1:04:44analysis. In Vigil, when the court actually authored
- 1:04:48the opinion, Nate concluded the doctor didn't
- 1:04:51do a good enough job, gave him some framework
- 1:04:53to go by, and sent that back to him for further
- 1:04:57clarification. Things before we wrap up here,
- 1:05:04I mentioned the concept and terms of substantial
- 1:05:06evidence. Throw that term around a lot as practitioners,
- 1:05:10the courts throw that a lot around a lot. It's
- 1:05:13really codified or broken down in library code
- 1:05:15section 4628. It's really got your guideposts
- 1:05:19for what constitutes substantial medical evidence.
- 1:05:23As a practitioner, when you're reviewing a report,
- 1:05:27basically the threshold questions you want to
- 1:05:30ask is, Were you in the correct chapter of the
- 1:05:33AMA guides? Were you in the correct table? Did
- 1:05:37the doctor give an impairment? Did they explain
- 1:05:40what it is that impairment was based on? Did
- 1:05:44they explain causation of the body parts and
- 1:05:47systems that are alleged to be injured and provided
- 1:05:50the what, the why, and how they were injured
- 1:05:52as a result of the employment? And of course,
- 1:05:55if we've got our apportionment analysis. what
- 1:05:58are we relying on in terms of medical evidence,
- 1:06:02the clinical evaluation, scientific and medical
- 1:06:05evidence that may not be within the medical record
- 1:06:11itself? Perhaps just experiencing clinical judgment
- 1:06:15as an evaluator who's seen the type of diagnosis
- 1:06:19that the applicants had many times in their career.
- 1:06:23So really, it's not enough to multiply and say
- 1:06:2912 times 12 equals 144. No, you got to take the
- 1:06:3312, multiply by the 12, carry it to 12, the 1,
- 1:06:35the down, come up with 144, and really show your
- 1:06:38work. That's the best analogy I can think of.
- 1:06:45Again, if medical reporting is not determined
- 1:06:50to be substantial, a judge that has the case
- 1:06:56and is hearing the issue of permanent disability
- 1:06:59can subject the report to development. It's a
- 1:07:03case called McDuffie. It came out in 2014 and
- 1:07:06essentially requires judge to take the evidence
- 1:07:09into hearing and determine if that evidence needs
- 1:07:13to be, the record needs to be developed in that
- 1:07:17capacity. Or, of course, a judge could elect
- 1:07:21to simply disallow for ignoring the evidence
- 1:07:25as the basis for an award of benefits. So again,
- 1:07:30speaking to a lot of different judges over the
- 1:07:33years, generally what they want presented in
- 1:07:35front of them is medical with a real clear reason
- 1:07:38why how, real objective analysis, and something
- 1:07:44more than a conclusory opinion at the end of
- 1:07:47the day. So here's a little checklist I've attached
- 1:07:51just to keep going through. some of the components
- 1:07:55of a medical report. Does it have all of this?
- 1:07:58If it's got all of this and explains the what,
- 1:08:00the why, the how, you can feel a lot better about
- 1:08:05making your argument that the medical itself
- 1:08:06should be followed by the court. So, again, common
- 1:08:10QME reporting errors, QMEs being panel QMEs,
- 1:08:14agreed medical evaluators, any one that compounds
- 1:08:17medical legal exam that the court has used for
- 1:08:20an award of benefits. You'll have doctors fail
- 1:08:24to convert again in the upper extremity section.
- 1:08:27You got the wrong level of impairment to the
- 1:08:31upper extremity, being confused with WPI. Oftentimes
- 1:08:36they will not use the combined values charts.
- 1:08:41That may be missing from the discussion. There
- 1:08:44may be no discussion of the chapter that they're
- 1:08:46using or the table that they're using. I am just
- 1:08:49giving 18 % whole person impairment for the spinal
- 1:08:51injury. not really explaining how, based on the
- 1:08:54diagnosis, what the clinical evaluation, how
- 1:08:59that supported that 18%. Causations, one that
- 1:09:05comes up, failing to really just identify specific
- 1:09:08medical causation, how that body part of the
- 1:09:11system was injured, AOE, CUE, rousing, and of
- 1:09:14course, forcing scope of employment. And then
- 1:09:17lastly, of course, again, apportionment, not
- 1:09:20explaining. medical history and evidence justifying
- 1:09:25unfortunate discussion. Permanent total disability.
- 1:09:31Permanent total disability, in other words, the
- 1:09:33applicant is 100 % permanently and totally disabled,
- 1:09:37unable to return or participate in the workforce
- 1:09:41going forward. You can get there a couple different
- 1:09:45ways. One is just through a schedule rating,
- 1:09:47WPI for one body part that's so high that once
- 1:09:51you rate it, it comes out to 100 % permanent
- 1:09:53disability. You can get there by combination
- 1:09:57of different impairments. Again, very, very difficult
- 1:10:02to do so unless you've got really significant
- 1:10:05WPI for every body part and system affected.
- 1:10:09Last but not least, you have vocational evidence.
- 1:10:11So this is parties listing the services of the
- 1:10:15vocational experts that takes into consideration
- 1:10:19medical diagnosis, the work restrictions that
- 1:10:23are given by the doctor itself, and then running
- 1:10:26that through their bank knowledge of potential
- 1:10:33occupations that that applicant could continue
- 1:10:37to work in going forward, or perhaps given some
- 1:10:40extra injuries that are included from being able
- 1:10:42to return to the workforce. So that is something
- 1:10:45that you can also get 100 % permanent disability
- 1:10:49in accordance with the fact, fact being extra
- 1:10:52extraneous locational evidence. That is of course
- 1:10:56substantial evidence follows a well reasoned
- 1:10:59decision in all the medical evidence and findings
- 1:11:01of the doctors. So life pension is another thing
- 1:11:05that impacts permanent disability. It is a benefit
- 1:11:10that is made available to applicants who have
- 1:11:17a permanent disability in excess of 70%. Once
- 1:11:22all permanent disability has been paid out, that
- 1:11:24applicant is eligible for a weekly life pension
- 1:11:29at a specific rate. Again, depends on the extent
- 1:11:32of the permanent disability. And that will continue
- 1:11:37indefinitely and is subject to adjustment on
- 1:11:40a regular basis as well. Some key takeaways,
- 1:11:45of course, from today's discussion. AMA guides,
- 1:11:50really, they're there to measure impairment.
- 1:11:52We've got the PDRS to give us the extent of disability.
- 1:12:00Age, occupation, date of injury, all matter,
- 1:12:05as does wage, because that factors into your
- 1:12:08rating. Apportionment is a legal tool that can
- 1:12:13dramatically affect exposure. Of course, again,
- 1:12:15key takeaways, it's really got to be well -reasoned
- 1:12:18and experienced. We've got cases like Almera's
- 1:12:23Guzman vigil that may impact how ratings, how
- 1:12:30permanent disability is combined, added, or even
- 1:12:34how impairment is calculated. So just know that
- 1:12:37those are. Issues are out there with evaluators,
- 1:12:42practitioners raising those issues with evaluators
- 1:12:45to potentially increase impairment. And really,
- 1:12:51at the end of the day, permanent disability rating
- 1:12:54itself is really the only thing that has the
- 1:12:55medical evidence supporting it. Got to be based
- 1:12:57on substantial evidence, got to be based on record,
- 1:13:00got to be based on scientific judgment. That
- 1:13:07said, thank you for your time. Really any questions
- 1:13:11at all? I think we have a chat section. I will
- 1:13:18look in the chat to see if there's any particular
- 1:13:22questions. So it looks like we have about seven
- 1:13:27questions so far in the Q &A box. We have quite
- 1:13:33a few questions. Let's see. It seems as though
- 1:13:37most, if not all, of this can be automated by
- 1:13:39AI, right, compared with what happened in family
- 1:13:41court on child support. Does play any role? Yeah,
- 1:13:48really, to that question, that's a good question.
- 1:13:51And AI is obviously huge in the legal industry
- 1:13:56in terms of how practitioners are utilizing it.
- 1:14:05Rating itself, just the raw data, I suppose you
- 1:14:09could throw it into ChatGBT or Claude or Gemini,
- 1:14:15any one of those tools, and have it propound
- 1:14:18a rating for you. Again, the devils of the details,
- 1:14:21really, we're more concerned with why it is the
- 1:14:25WPI is the number that it is. As practitioners,
- 1:14:28we're looking at evaluating the basis for what
- 1:14:32that opinion was for the whole person impairments.
- 1:14:34Yes, AI can calculate a rating. I think I could
- 1:14:37probably put one in pretty quickly. But I don't
- 1:14:41know to what extent AI can run through the objective
- 1:14:47evidence, the results of the clinical evaluation
- 1:14:50the doctors had during their exam on how they
- 1:14:53came up with that WPI based on specific evidence.
- 1:14:57Nor as a practitioner, I don't know that we would
- 1:15:01be wanting to put the results of medical legal
- 1:15:06examinations into some sort of open AI type of
- 1:15:10environment. So, good question. There's a couple
- 1:15:15of them. Range of motion, really a proxy for
- 1:15:17pain. Pain itself is really supposed to be subsumed
- 1:15:22in the A &A guides. Chapter 18 is, again, it
- 1:15:30is a tool that evaluators could use to assign
- 1:15:35impairment for pain if there's otherwise no other
- 1:15:38objective basis, no better basis to do so. Another
- 1:15:50question here, is there anyone without some back
- 1:15:53pain, carpal tunnel disability in done form?
- 1:15:56How about obesity, BMI, exercise, bad nutrition?
- 1:15:59Yes, all factors. that's maybe contributing to
- 1:16:05go to apportionment. 100 % agree, those are questions
- 1:16:09you raise with the doctor. We are constantly
- 1:16:11looking at medicals, not only prior to the medical
- 1:16:14legal examination, but we're getting doctor's
- 1:16:16reports from, say, primary treating physicians
- 1:16:19or gatekeepers in the workers' compensation arena.
- 1:16:22They're the ones who evaluate the applicant,
- 1:16:24make recommendations on treatments, and they
- 1:16:27are providing a lot of things in addition to
- 1:16:32the clinical examination that we'll be looking
- 1:16:35at. You know, weight, BMI, huge things that come
- 1:16:38there. You'll recall that I had mentioned that
- 1:16:42in California, at least as a jurisdiction, we
- 1:16:44use the AMA guide's fifth edition. Part of the
- 1:16:47reason why there was an argument that went up
- 1:16:49a few years ago to use the sixth edition was
- 1:16:52an Almaraz Guzman argument that the sixth edition
- 1:16:56should be used because there's a section for
- 1:16:58weight gain. in the sixth edition. So the court,
- 1:17:03again, did not allow that in our case. But certainly,
- 1:17:08yeah, holistically, you're looking at the body
- 1:17:12in the medical evidence, the records that you
- 1:17:16get that can all be presented to a doctor in
- 1:17:19support that you might have another comorbidity
- 1:17:22that we call it that has a factor on the the
- 1:17:29extent of impairments. Those are all tools that
- 1:17:32we raise, things that we raise with the doctors
- 1:17:34in support of the fortunate. So, great question.
- 1:17:43What specific documents can a family law litigant
- 1:17:46divorce or support proceeding request to determine
- 1:17:49community property interest in disability award?
- 1:17:53You know, it's interesting. So, I practice workers'
- 1:17:57compensation. exclusively. And that is our firm's
- 1:18:03gig. We're a one -trick pony in that regard.
- 1:18:06The extent that I know about workers' compensation
- 1:18:09benefits is that they're not taxable. I do not
- 1:18:12know if there's a specific exclusion for permanent
- 1:18:15disability or whether that is, in fact, community
- 1:18:19property itself. That would be an overlap into
- 1:18:23community property, I suppose. one of our practitioners
- 1:18:27in the Bar Association could advise on? Certainly
- 1:18:31an interesting question. But as far as I know,
- 1:18:34disability benefits tend to be non -taxable.
- 1:18:39And I do not know about whether they are part
- 1:18:41of community benefits or the individual benefit
- 1:18:49itself. So, good question. Is there ever actual
- 1:18:52malpractice cases filed in this area? So in this
- 1:18:56area, I presume you mean workers compensation
- 1:18:58cases. Workers compensation is, you know, that's
- 1:19:02a question that I would defer more to my friends
- 1:19:07over, represent injured workers from time to
- 1:19:11time. There are very few things that an attorney
- 1:19:14could do to fall below the standard of care and
- 1:19:17workers compensation. There's a couple of different
- 1:19:20things procedurally. on the outset of the claim
- 1:19:22that deal with the timeframes in which you absolutely
- 1:19:27have to make decisions on whether a claim is
- 1:19:34compensable, meaning that we've accepted it,
- 1:19:36we can pay benefits as the dispute's nature extends,
- 1:19:40or we're denying that claim and its compensability
- 1:19:43on either a medical, a factual, or a legal basis
- 1:19:47to do so. I've never seen a practitioner involved
- 1:19:55in a malpractice case. I'm sure they exist. I
- 1:19:59guess an argument can be made that any practitioner
- 1:20:00can fall below the standard of care. In terms
- 1:20:03of settlements, I know that unlike, I believe,
- 1:20:09most other practice areas with workers' compensation
- 1:20:13settlements, they are subject to adequacy by
- 1:20:18the courts. In other words, the court is acting
- 1:20:21as a gatekeeper, making a determination that
- 1:20:26any settlement we present to them, whether it
- 1:20:28is what we call a compromise and release, buyout
- 1:20:31of all issues raised in the application, or what
- 1:20:35we call stipulation of request for award, stipulated
- 1:20:37award, where the parties have stipulated to the
- 1:20:40extent of, say, the permanent disability of a
- 1:20:46case, the dates of injury, body parts and systems
- 1:20:49injured, that sort of thing. And the judge has
- 1:20:53ultimately the decision to make that call, and
- 1:20:56they're the ones who determine. So it would be
- 1:20:59very hard, I could see, imagine, unlike other
- 1:21:02areas, securities comes to mind where you make
- 1:21:06a settlement into something and perhaps... because
- 1:21:08of something that was left out or not contemplated,
- 1:21:11that becomes a big problem for that practitioner
- 1:21:13in the area later on down the road. In comp,
- 1:21:17all we do is we present the medicals and anything
- 1:21:21that the judge requests and the judge makes the
- 1:21:24call 100 % on whether the settlement itself is
- 1:21:27adequate. So it's a little different in that
- 1:21:30regard because the court not only has the ultimate
- 1:21:34authority and say on the settlement, but they're
- 1:21:36the ones who actually legally make the call.
- 1:21:39So great question. What if you disagree with
- 1:21:42an impairment rating? Can a petitioner challenge
- 1:21:45those findings? Absolutely. If somebody disagrees
- 1:21:49with an impairment rating, typically practitioners
- 1:21:52will have the opportunity to either correct or
- 1:21:56argue for a different rating based on a couple
- 1:22:00different ways. We have a lot of practitioners
- 1:22:03who will first propound supplemental reports
- 1:22:05and interrogatory to that doctor stating to the
- 1:22:10effect of, hey, we've got your clinic, we've
- 1:22:12got your examination in light of what was discussed
- 1:22:16in your examination and based on this additional
- 1:22:19medical evidence, the evidence that we have.
- 1:22:24Did you intend to do this or don't you feel that
- 1:22:28Perhaps the applicant belongs in a lower class
- 1:22:30and has lower impairment given the lack of objective
- 1:22:33findings. So you can introduce evidence through
- 1:22:36a supplemental report. And a doctor, my statute
- 1:22:40has 60 days to do so. Again, we're talking in
- 1:22:42the context of a medical legal exam, some exam
- 1:22:45that the court can use as the basis to fix an
- 1:22:48award of compensation. There is nothing that
- 1:22:51can prevent a primary treating physician or a
- 1:22:54gatekeeper. to make a comment on permanent disability.
- 1:22:59So parties are free to communicate with the doctors
- 1:23:02in that regard. Of course, you've got to copy
- 1:23:04opposing counsel, let them know you're doing
- 1:23:05it. And if all else fails, then you're not getting
- 1:23:12what you want by interrogatory. The courts will
- 1:23:15frequently allow depositions of the doctor. It's
- 1:23:19a good opportunity to get them front and center.
- 1:23:21to have them walk through their analysis. That's
- 1:23:24really helpful if you find that they already
- 1:23:27have in the context of the report the correct
- 1:23:29analysis, but they're just not coming to the
- 1:23:31right decision using the correct table or section
- 1:23:34of the guides. So depending on what the error
- 1:23:39is or whether I need to introduce additional
- 1:23:42evidence, that may dictate whether I choose to
- 1:23:47request a supplemental report from the doctor
- 1:23:48or I choose to depose that. So great question
- 1:23:53that comes up all the time with practitioners.
- 1:23:56Any other questions at all? All right, well,
- 1:24:05I think we can go ahead and, yeah, thank you
- 1:24:08for your time. Really do appreciate the opportunity
- 1:24:11to speak this afternoon and hope you all enjoy
- 1:24:15the presentation. Informative.