Latest / Property Investment & Wealth Creation Australia | The Michael Yardney Podcast / Property Investors: Why Australia's Growth Engine Is About To Stall
Transcript
- 0:00For 20 years Australia's economy has been growing.
- 0:02Company profits have gone up, dividends have gone up,
- 0:05property values have gone up. But what if I told you that most of that growth
- 0:09had almost nothing to do with us getting smarter,
- 0:11more efficient or more productive?
- 0:13What if it was really just that we had more people?
- 0:16More immigration, more houses needed,
- 0:18more traffic, more schools, more everything.
- 0:20Not one dollar per person any richer for it.
- 0:23That's exactly what my guest today has uncovered in a piece of research that should
- 0:27Make every property investor sit up.
- 0:29Because if the population growth tap gets turned off,
- 0:32and right now every side of politics is racing to turn it off,
- 0:36the growth story that underpinned property values,
- 0:38company profits and rental demand for two decades could look very different.
- 0:43So by the end of this episode,
- 0:45you're going to understand the real difference between population driven growth
- 0:49and productivity driven growth.
- 0:51Why Australia's been taking the lazy option for 20 years.
- 0:55and more importantly what it means for your property portfolio
- 0:58if immigration numbers keep getting cut.
- 1:00My guest today is my regular monthly guest now,
- 1:03Ashley Owen, Director of Owen Analytics and co-founder of Firstlinks.
- 1:07He's one of Australia's most respected sources of independent investment research.
- 1:12Ashley spent decades analysing long-term economic and market data and he's built
- 1:17a brilliant reputation for cutting through the noise with hard numbers rather than the headlines.
- 1:22Interestingly, former Reserve Bank Governor,
- 1:24Ian Macfarlane, has called his research in a class of its own.
- 1:28Hi, I'm Michael Yardney I don't have a record like that,
- 1:31but welcome to the Michael Yardney podcast because for 50 years I've been investing
- 1:35in property and I've seen the cycles come and go,
- 1:38the booms and busts. And that's why twice a week I like to cut through
- 1:41the clutter to share proven experts,
- 1:43theories, strategies that have worked,
- 1:46but insights, I said, from the experts.
- 1:48And that's what we're doing today.
- 1:50So let's get into it.
- 1:56Hi, Ashley. Welcome back to the podcast.
- 1:59Hello Michael, how are you going over there?
- 2:00Good, thank you. Well Ashley, the last couple of podcasts we've done together have
- 2:04had great response from our viewers and our listeners because
- 2:07of the detailed information you give.
- 2:09And today I want to discuss an article you've recently written,
- 2:12I'll leave a link in the show notes,
- 2:14about how Australia has been growing because of population growth.
- 2:19In other words, not because we're more productive,
- 2:22but just because there have been more of us.
- 2:23I'd like to go into detail about that.
- 2:25Because currently all sides of government are talking about
- 2:28decreasing population growth, decreasing migration,
- 2:31and that could well have effects on not just the economy,
- 2:35but our housing markets.
- 2:37Yes, the thanks Michael. The point I was making was something that's it's
- 2:41something that's it's one of those things that creep up over time and it's
- 2:45not a sudden change like a sudden recession or a sudden crash.
- 2:49It's something that just gradually creeps up and you only really know you're
- 2:52in it when you when you hit the crisis point.
- 2:54And the problem is this Australia has had decent
- 2:57economic growth and we me we measure economic growth in the total pie which
- 3:01is GDP gross domestic product or gross domestic income
- 3:04or gross domestic expenditure,
- 3:06basically output and incomes for the whole twenty eight million people combined.
- 3:10That's the whole pie. That pie has been growing and then
- 3:13you deduct inflation because inflation distorts prices.
- 3:16So the real economic pie is what counts.
- 3:19That's been growing by about two or three percent for many, many, many decades.
- 3:24the problem is that the components of that,
- 3:26what produces that growth in the pie,
- 3:29has been changing gradually but steadily into crisis levels,
- 3:34which we haven't seen for many, many, many decades.
- 3:36Crisis level, that's a very strong word.
- 3:39What do mean by that?
- 3:40Well, crisis it's a point you get to where policymakers have to change direction,
- 3:44otherwise before you know you get into difficult situations where you cannot
- 3:47get out of. It's much tougher to get out of once you take delayed action.
- 3:51So for example, the total economic pie in Australia for you know since federation
- 3:56has been growing by the real economic growth,
- 3:58the real national output of all the people in Australia,
- 4:01has been growing by about three percent per annum.
- 4:04compound through all the booms and busts for century and a half.
- 4:07So three percent per annum real economic growth is actually very good
- 4:10in global terms. Yes. The US, exactly the same period,
- 4:14same sort of economy, Western based democracy,
- 4:17with industrial based rule of law,
- 4:19the US economy has been growing by the same three percent per annum over
- 4:23the same period. So like for like, they've been very similar.
- 4:26The difference is this
- 4:28The 3% growth in America, annual growth in the real economic pie,
- 4:32the total pie growth, 3% per annum forever for 150 years.
- 4:36Two-thirds of that have come from productivity growth,
- 4:39and one third has come from more people,
- 4:42population growth. So, for example,
- 4:43there's two ways to grow a pie.
- 4:45You can simply add more people doing the same old things,
- 4:48and the output will increase, total output will increase.
- 4:51People is the same, they're just producing the same number of widgets
- 4:53in the same factory, they're just more people in more factories.
- 4:56So that increases the pie,
- 4:57but doesn't increase the income of individual people.
- 5:00The second way of increasing the total pie is to have the same number of people,
- 5:05but the same number of people producing more per person,
- 5:08more per hour. Productivity growth.
- 5:10So the US has been growing by three percent ish per annum forever.
- 5:14Hundred years, fifty years, hundred and fifty years.
- 5:16And I've got long-term charts to talk about in a second.
- 5:18The 3% is primarily in America has been people doing things smarter,
- 5:23not simply more people doing things.
- 5:25So two-thirds of total economic pie growth in America has been productivity growth,
- 5:30give or take. And only one-third has been population growth.
- 5:33In Australia, it's the reverse.
- 5:34It has been for 50, 100, 150 years,
- 5:37two-thirds of our same three percent has come from population growth,
- 5:40which just means busier cities.
- 5:42Busier roads, busier ports, busier schools,
- 5:46busier hospitals, just more people,
- 5:48and only one third of it has come from productivity growth,
- 5:51actually doing things smarter per person.
- 5:54Now that's the long term picture,
- 5:56but that has not been a straight line.
- 5:57The last ten years in Australia,
- 5:59there's been zero productivity growth.
- 6:01The entire growth of the Australian economy in the last ten years since
- 6:05the middle of two thousand and ten,
- 6:07since the end of the China boom.
- 6:08Has been simply adding more people and adding more traffic and adding more people
- 6:12in schools, competing for hospital beds and competing for traffic space
- 6:16on the roads, without anybody doing anything smarter or producing more per hour.
- 6:20Now that zero productivity growth means that the living standards
- 6:25of Australians have gone zero,
- 6:26gone absolutely nowhere. All we've done to increase the pie,
- 6:30the pie look good from a distance,
- 6:31the pie's getting better, but it's purely on the basis of adding more people.
- 6:34So that's the lazy way of doing it,
- 6:36I guess, actually. And if we look at it in reality,
- 6:39it's not natural population growth.
- 6:41It's really been immigration over the last decades.
- 6:44It has. So the point of the chart,
- 6:46which we'll get to in a second,
- 6:47shows that this not only has the reliance on population growth for total
- 6:52pie growth increased over the last twenty,
- 6:54thirty, forty, fifty years, but therefore the overall
- 6:58and the productivity growth has declined.
- 7:00and again, the point of the story was to say that you can't blame Labour or Liberal.
- 7:05This has been going on for many,
- 7:07many, many generations post Second World War.
- 7:09In pretty much a straight line down in total economic growth,
- 7:13which is largely because the productivity growth has declined as
- 7:17but while population growth has kept up.
- 7:20So if you look at the last the economic growth pie,
- 7:23the two percent real economic growth in the last year,
- 7:26last 12 months, which is announced the other day,
- 7:28of that, all of that, almost all of that came from simply adding more people,
- 7:32and none of it came from working smarter.
- 7:34It's just more people doing the same stuff.
- 7:36Nobody's working smarter on average across 28 million people.
- 7:39That's the crisis. That means in order to get more money,
- 7:41now, as shareholders, we have shares in Woolworths and Coles and
- 7:45all sorts of companies, but they don't really care about productivity growth.
- 7:49All they want is more people at the turnstiles.
- 7:51So business loves more population.
- 7:54They don't care about traffic on the roads or getting into schools.
- 7:56They just like revenue top line growth.
- 7:58And more people at the turnstile,
- 8:00more people walking through buying stuff.
- 8:01So their agenda is population growth, population, population growth.
- 8:05The problem with that is we're gonna try and get our kids in schools,
- 8:07we're gonna try and get into hospital,
- 8:08we're gonna get across the road,
- 8:10and everything's more busy, more noise,
- 8:11more pollution, more sound. That's the problem with population growth.
- 8:15We'd like we're much better off doing things smarter as we have been in the past,
- 8:18rather than relying on simply importing more people.
- 8:22Well, Ashley, you've got a chart that goes back to 1950,
- 8:25just after the Second World War.
- 8:27Can we have a look at that and see what actually has been going on?
- 8:31Well, actually, this analysis goes back to 1950 and your data shows Australia's
- 8:36growth has steadily declined for 70 years,
- 8:40you know, from about 4 percent in the 1950s and 60s down to two and
- 8:45a half percent this century. What's driving this long decline?
- 8:49Well, it's it's important not I try and do everything very fact based,
- 8:54very evidence based. I try and ignore politics,
- 8:56and try and it's very hard to get people to try and get away from blaming
- 9:00one side or the other. So the point of this chart is to show that if you look
- 9:04at all these governments, I've got Labour governments in pink and
- 9:06and Liberal National Party governments in blue.
- 9:09you can see overall through a bunch of different you know,
- 9:12a dozen different governments over the last seventy years since the war
- 9:15You've got the steady decline of overall growth rates through all of them.
- 9:19And I can talk about each cycle and who did what when and what the impact
- 9:22was and the reforms of the eighties and the deregulation and
- 9:25the privatization and the outsourcing,
- 9:27all of those sorts of things. We can talk about and the problems
- 9:30in the seventies and the problems in the two thousands and the and the GFC.
- 9:33We can talk about all but
- 9:34Step back and ignore all those ups and down inevitable cycles and look
- 9:37at the big picture. The big picture shows that regardless of the government,
- 9:40the w regardless of the world conditions,
- 9:42regardless of the makeup of the economy and the booms and busts
- 9:47and the cycles and the crashes that we get inevitably,
- 9:49through all of those you get this steady long term downward trend
- 9:53in the overall growth of the pie.
- 9:55That's the first message. You can't blame one side or the other.
- 9:58Now you can you can always point to some politician who did something,
- 10:01but step back, it's been a
- 10:03continuous decline through all governments.
- 10:06It's very obvious.
- 10:07We have to wake up as a nation and stop blaming each other and say,
- 10:10look, forget politics. What do we have to do to reset the settings to
- 10:13get on the path to growth again?
- 10:15That's very hard to do when you've got Pauline Hanson in the corner arguing this
- 10:18and you've got change of leadership in the in the coalition and you've
- 10:22got Labour going back and forth on a whole bunch of stuff.
- 10:24You've got to step back and say,
- 10:25Well, stop this silly debate. Let's talk about the real issues in the long term.
- 10:30hard to do in an election cycle like this,
- 10:32in a media cycle. So that's the first message.
- 10:35Overall steady decline through all governments,
- 10:38because all governments are getting it wrong across the political spectrum,
- 10:42across various cycles, countless cycles since the war.
- 10:46If I could just interrupt for a sec,
- 10:47we're showing a chart on the screen for those of you who are just listening,
- 10:50but wherever you're watching or listening to this,
- 10:53whether it's Apple Podcasts or Spotify,
- 10:55we do have a video version as well of this,
- 10:58but Ashley's going to try and talk through some of the charts that he's going
- 11:02to be talking about. But we really do recommend if you can just stop for a second,
- 11:06look at the video so you can see it's very obvious,
- 11:09it's very clear. So you've broken things up to what's actually been happening to
- 11:14productivity, population growth and the gradual decline.
- 11:19But how is productivity measured?
- 11:22Okay. There's lots of problems with any sort
- 11:26of economic measure because you've got problems in measuring things.
- 11:29There's there's a black economy,
- 11:30there's a black market, there's things below the radar.
- 11:33most Australian Bureau of Statistics data is based on surveys of,
- 11:37you know, thirty thousand people every year,
- 11:40and so on. So there's always people that don't get captured and
- 11:43an activity that doesn't get captured.
- 11:45So you gotta pick
- 11:46measures and understand the problems of the measures,
- 11:48but at least you need something to talk about to drive policy.
- 11:51The productivity here of just which is which is good for long term across countries
- 11:57and across different sort of economic systems is the total pie divided
- 12:01by the number of people, which is GDP or the total income
- 12:05or total output per person. Total income and total output are measured similar ways.
- 12:09The GDP gross domestic product is output,
- 12:12gross domestic income is income is total income of all people added
- 12:15up and all companies added up.
- 12:17They more or less balance over time.
- 12:18So the GDP, gross domestic output,
- 12:21or gross domestic income, total 28 million people's income and output,
- 12:25divided by 28 million people, so it's a per person.
- 12:28Now, beyond that, you've got things like the fact that you know a third
- 12:31of the people don't work. They're either students or retirees.
- 12:34So, how do you account for the fact that not all those people are producing output?
- 12:37A better measure is GDP or output per worker.
- 12:41Or even better is the output per hour's work because what you want to do
- 12:44is you want to work fewer hours with the same output or more output so
- 12:48we have more leisure time and more income to spend and more time
- 12:52to spend that in. So there's lots of different measures.
- 12:54This particular measure is based on total pie divided by the number of people.
- 12:59Okay, that makes sense. So what you're saying though,
- 13:02it's been growing mainly because of population growth
- 13:06as opposed to productivity.
- 13:09Now, is that because the government hasn't taken the hard steps and reformed
- 13:16before I get to that question,
- 13:17which is which is a dynamite question,
- 13:19the bottom half of that chart just breaks it rather than looking at annual bars,
- 13:23and each bar has got a green bar and a and a brown bar.
- 13:26The green bar represents the population growth contribution to total pie growth,
- 13:31and the br the brown bar represents productivity growth.
- 13:35sorry, other way around, population growth is a brown bar.
- 13:36Green bar is productivity growth.
- 13:39So you But those who are not able to see this because they're in the gym or driving
- 13:44as we talk, can you just quickly explain what's happened over those decades
- 13:48in that second chart?
- 13:49Okay, so the lower chart just summarizes the annual by which it's
- 13:53got booms and busts in it into three chunks of periods.
- 13:56So the third the there are three sections.
- 13:58One is nineteen fifty to nineteen seventy nine,
- 14:00and I've picked that for a reason.
- 14:02The second one is nineteen eighty to nineteen ninety nine,
- 14:05and the third era is year two thousand to today,
- 14:08twenty twenty six. Now, the first message in here is that the overall pie growth, the total economic
- 14:14income, total economic output of all Australians has decreased from 4.2ish
- 14:20percent per annum for the first period,
- 14:221950 to 1979, down to 3.3%,
- 14:25which is more of our long-term average in the 80s to 90s,
- 14:29and then down again to 2.5% this century.
- 14:33So this century's been a low growth in our in our economic history.
- 14:38So that's the first message. We have steadily declining total growth
- 14:41Pie growth. The second element, which represents the total line on
- 14:45the top panel going through all governments downhill.
- 14:47The second part of the bottom chart is that these pie charts,
- 14:50these circles above the bars, indicate where that growth has come from,
- 14:54what's contributed to that total pie growth.
- 14:56In the th first period, nineteen fifties,
- 14:59sixties and seventies, most of the economic growth came from doing things smarter.
- 15:04which is productivity growth. And less than half of it came from,
- 15:06which is like America, two thirds of it comes from doing things smarter.
- 15:09And only a third comes from in America,
- 15:11comes has come from more people doing stuff.
- 15:14That was the case in our in Australia in the 50s,
- 15:1660s, and 70s. In the eighties and 90s,
- 15:19which is this middle section, you can see what's happened here,
- 15:21same thing. The total growth has gone down to only three percent per annum. but
- 15:26Still, most of it's come from doing things smarter,
- 15:29and most of that was to do with the reforms of Hawke,
- 15:31Keating and Kelty, followed by the early years of Howard and Costello.
- 15:36that accounts for the very strong productivity growth during
- 15:40the eighties and nineties, supplemented by lower population growth.
- 15:43Now, you look at this last century,
- 15:44the last twenty five years, a couple of things have happened.
- 15:47We've got a total growth, pie growth reducing dramatically down to only
- 15:51two and a half percent.
- 15:52Which is very poor for Australia,
- 15:54historically, l much less than what we're used to.
- 15:56And secondly, we have the fifty-five percent of that total pie growth,
- 16:02albeit smaller, fifty-five percent,
- 16:04more than half of it's come from simply adding more people.
- 16:07And the last ten years it's been zero growth from doing things smarter,
- 16:10and it's just adding more people.
- 16:12So you wonder why people are worried about immigration,
- 16:14because immigration is the core of that.
- 16:16because that has been the policymaker's answer to raising Woolworth's revenues
- 16:20and dividends is simply add more people on the turnstile.
- 16:22That's not the answer. That just means we'd be busier and noisier
- 16:26and crowdier in Australia. So that's the problem in that last tw this is not
- 16:30one government or another,
- 16:31this is twenty-five years through lots of governments doing things very poorly.
- 16:36Now, you get to your question,
- 16:37why? fundamentally, if you look at the
- 16:40You had the Great Depression and you had unemployment of thirty percent across
- 16:44the world and in Australia. We had a lot of reforms,
- 16:46a lot of social reforms. We had a lot of we had the building of the welfare state
- 16:49in the fifties and sixties, supported by protected manufacturing.
- 16:53So you had manufacturing cities all over Australia which churned
- 16:55out cars and computers and phones and all sorts of things were made in Australia,
- 16:59all very inefficiently, all very high cost and increasingly poor quality
- 17:03and less choice behind massive protection barriers,
- 17:06which were paid for by agriculture and mining.
- 17:09That welfare state and high protection barriers produced
- 17:12in Australia and around the world,
- 17:14high inflation and unemployment and stagflation in the 70s for a whole
- 17:18lot of reasons. Plus wartime spending in Vietnam,
- 17:20etc. At the end of the 70s, in the early eighties,
- 17:23governments around the world woke up and said,
- 17:25We gotta change. So you look at Thatcher in the UK,
- 17:28Reagan in the US, Hawke, Keating and Bill Kelty at the ACTU in Australia created a
- 17:33Massive number of economic reforms which opened up the economy,
- 17:36they floated the dollar, they allowed in foreign banks,
- 17:39they deregulated bank lending.
- 17:40I had an eighteen percent mortgage in the eighties and paid it off ASAP.
- 17:44Nowadays kids have got a seven percent they think it's high because
- 17:47it was higher than three percent five years ago.
- 17:49It's a different world now.
- 17:51In the early eighties, a whole lot of reforms they introduced the award system,
- 17:54the accord system, the compulsory superannuation system.
- 17:57They privatized all the Telstras and the bad businesses of the world that were
- 18:01run by governments badly. All the power stations and the electricity
- 18:05and the insurance companies,
- 18:07they're all sold off. Qantas was sold off.
- 18:09So that privatization of great government enterprises was done.
- 18:13The reduction of the tariff barriers,
- 18:15reduced the cost of everything because we now started to import cheap stuff
- 18:19from China, so inflation went down.
- 18:21So all of a now some of those things I've deliberately put a negative skew
- 18:25on to demonstrate that, not all reforms work well for all people all the time.
- 18:29There's a lot of pain in reforms.
- 18:31And if you look at those sorts of conditions now,
- 18:34we've got high inflation.
- 18:36You haven't got high unemployment only because the government keeps
- 18:39unemployment down by hiring people.
- 18:40Almost all now, 80% of all jobs created in the last 10 years
- 18:43in Australia have been government jobs,
- 18:45very inefficient, low productivity growth jobs what they call the care economy,
- 18:49which is nothing wrong with the care economy,
- 18:51but it is not where you're going to get productivity gains.
- 18:53A teacher can teach 20 kids, they can't suddenly teach 50 kids
- 18:57to get productivity gains. So the care economy is where you
- 19:00get low productivity growth.
- 19:02But that's where the jobs have been added in Australia.
- 19:04So the answer to your question is reform is difficult.
- 19:08And if you look at the last five years,
- 19:10what they've done primarily is reverse the reform.
- 19:13A lot of the reforms of the 1980s and 90s have been reversed.
- 19:17You look at industrial relations,
- 19:18that's gone backwards. The rise of union power rights has gone backwards.
- 19:23The idea of small government has completely gone backwards.
- 19:26We've got a massive government which is interfering everywhere.
- 19:29We've got a trillion dollars of federal government debt and eight hundred billion
- 19:32dollars of state government debt,
- 19:33which didn't exist. We had zero debt fifteen years ago.
- 19:37All of a sudden we've got a trillion dollars of debt,
- 19:39which are paid for by you and I and our kids and grandkids for
- 19:42the next thirty years. It's much easier to grow the pie,
- 19:45to increase total revenues, to make companies happy,
- 19:49to make woolies happy, coals happy,
- 19:51by just importing more people.
- 19:52Without anybody getting richer because they're not working smarter.
- 19:56Now that sounds good in theory,
- 19:57but in practice you get people complaining about
- 20:00the immigration and that become becomes an immigration debate which you're
- 20:04not allowed to say this, but it very quickly becomes a racist debate,
- 20:07but you're not allowed say that.
- 20:08I can say things because I'm a I'm a I'm a boat person from Asia,
- 20:11so I'm not a Whitey. But it's very hard to get sensible debate about immigration
- 20:15without getting into racism and religious issues.
- 20:17So much easier to import more people.
- 20:20Are you criticising immigration itself or just the government using population
- 20:25growth as a substitute for reform?
- 20:27I'm not blaming immigration. Australia has, this is one
- 20:31of the not hidden things but one of the things
- 20:34the characteristics of Australia which we take for granted but when
- 20:37you scratch the surface it raises issues which we need to talk about.
- 20:40Australia, since seventeen eighty eight,
- 20:42the last two hundred and odd years,
- 20:44in the world, Australia has had the highest population growth rate in the world,
- 20:50bar none outside of Africa.
- 20:51That includes the Brazils and the Indians and the high growth economies.
- 20:55Australia has had and numbers New Zealand is number two,
- 20:58but Australia leads the world,
- 20:59it has had the highest population growth in the world outside of Africa
- 21:04for the last 200 plus years. Very unusual.
- 21:07Now Australia's got used to, we had a White Australia policy for most of that time.
- 21:11It was White Australia from day one until nineteen sixty-eight,
- 21:14when it was finally disbanded.
- 21:16So all the immigrants came from
- 21:17From England and Scotland. And then we had the post war immigration,
- 21:21ran out of Brits with a ten pound POM,
- 21:23so we started to import the Balts from Northern Europe,
- 21:25ran out of them, we started to import the southern Europeans,
- 21:28the Italians and the Greeks,
- 21:30et cetera. and we all grew up through all of that.
- 21:32Then we had Vietnam after the war,
- 21:34we had the Middle East, and now we've got Africa.
- 21:36So they all so Australia has had the highest population growth in the world.
- 21:40Yep.
- 21:41Percentage wise, you're talking about,
- 21:43opposed to numbers, yes.
- 21:45No the growth percentage wise in the world,
- 21:47bar none, outside of Africa. Most of that has been immigration.
- 21:51so what the first set of charts we went through in the last
- 21:54ten minutes has showed us that our total pie growth,
- 21:57the economic pie growth, that the ability for us to rent more houses
- 22:01and find more tenants, literally more tenants,
- 22:03has depended totally not on people doing things smarter for more income per hour,
- 22:07more income per person, but it's relied totally on just getting more people in.
- 22:11Which is great for landlords, they get more people knocking on the door, which is great.
- 22:15But it means everything is busier and noisier and more waste,
- 22:18et cetera, in the economy, which is not the answer.
- 22:20The answer is to work smarter,
- 22:21not have more people doing the same old stuff.
- 22:24But now all sides of politics are moving to cut immigration.
- 22:28What does that mean for the growth assumptions that we've been counting
- 22:31on over the last little while?
- 22:33Well, the intergenerational report,
- 22:35which was released a couple of days ago by the Labour government,
- 22:39and the governments have been doing this since I think Peter Costello
- 22:42did this in two thousand and two,
- 22:44the first one, which is basically a look ahead at what they see of
- 22:47the economy and how the shape of the economy growing and how over
- 22:50the next thirty forty years. Given that productivity growth has been zero
- 22:55for ten years and it's all just more people.
- 22:57The intergenerational report says for the next 40 years we're going
- 23:00to suddenly magically have a return to 1.2% productivity growth,
- 23:06working smarter, more output,
- 23:071.2% more output per person or per hour for the next 40 years.
- 23:11Now, that is just a magical fairyland stuff for how.
- 23:15There's no concept, there's only one two letter word used to explain
- 23:20how that's going to come about.
- 23:21It's called AI. They can't even spell AI.
- 23:23There's no description about how that will increase my productivity.
- 23:26There's no description about how that will increase the productivity
- 23:28of 28 million people. It is just this magical thing called AI,
- 23:31which will suddenly make us revert to our normal 1.2% ish productivity growth
- 23:36per annum, per worker, every single day of the week.
- 23:39It's nonsense stuff. So that's their entire plan.
- 23:42And even then, with this magical 1.2% productivity growth,
- 23:46which will come from nowhere except AI.
- 23:47Michelle Bullock, by the way, yesterday said that.
- 23:50We've seen none of that in Australia yet.
- 23:51It could be years or decades before we get any productivity growth across
- 23:54the whole economy. Therefore, it's all gonna come from population growth.
- 23:58And they're cutting immigration.
- 23:59so if you have no productivity growth and no end in sight,
- 24:03and this it's been a downward trend for decades and decades,
- 24:06there's no sudden magical wand we're gonna we're gonna suddenly find.
- 24:09Therefore The only thing growing the pie for shareholders and landlords,
- 24:14et cetera, is population growth.
- 24:16If you cut population growth to zero,
- 24:19which is, or negative actually, with One Nation's plan,
- 24:22or to very low, a hundred thousand, which is the Liberal Nationals' plan,
- 24:26you're going to do a few things.
- 24:27The po first of all, the pie is going to stop growing and they're much more likely
- 24:30to have recessions because it only takes a negative quarter or two,
- 24:33which is easy to do when you've got no population growth,
- 24:36and that's the only driver of growth.
- 24:38You cut population, that'll create an instant technical recession because
- 24:41the economy won't grow. And the natural ups and downs will make
- 24:43it go backwards every now and again,
- 24:45which it always does. the other that's the macro impact.
- 24:48The smaller imp the more targeted impact is things like remember COVID,
- 24:52when there was no immigration because the borders were closed,
- 24:54the price of fruit went up because we had no fruit pickers.
- 24:57Because they're backpackers. If you cut backpackers out and
- 24:59the temporary migrants out, you're gonna get nobody picking the fruit.
- 25:02So you're gonna get price inflation all over again.
- 25:04Duh, where were you five years ago?
- 25:06so nobody's thought through those implications of industry by industry,
- 25:10how are we going to get through without avoiding a recession,
- 25:13which it sounds scary, but it just means that the pie contracts.
- 25:16And if we've got no population growth, it will contract.
- 25:18Now in your article you make a point that we needed some reforms,
- 25:23historically to get major government reforms we actually needed to fall into crisis
- 25:29for that to happen. Is that still your feeling?
- 25:31The answer is yes. Ross Garnaut,
- 25:34who's a friend of mine and a very well known economist in Australia,
- 25:37he didn't coin the phrase, but he used the phrase quite often in
- 25:41the eighties and nineties. He said it's the boiling frog.
- 25:43If you put a frog into a pot of cold water,
- 25:45put it on the stove, and you put the heat on,
- 25:48the frog won't realize that it's gradually getting hotter and he'll boil to death.
- 25:51If you take a frog and throw him into a pot of boiling water already boiling,
- 25:55he'll suddenly realize it and jump out.
- 25:57So in Australia we've got this problem is
- 26:00It's a boiling frog. We're we're getting we've got worse over the last,
- 26:03three or four decades, progressively worse w worse without anybody saying,
- 26:08Aha, we gotta get out, because it's been so gradual.
- 26:10Ask yourself this. Why did Hawke Keating and Kelty suddenly wake up
- 26:15in eighty three and say, We need to make change and it's gotta be big change,
- 26:19radical change, painful change,
- 26:21and we have to do it now? The answer was they had just lived through a
- 26:25few years ago the seventies.
- 26:26In the 70s, we had we had double digit unemployment.
- 26:29We had double digit inflation.
- 26:31Inflation was peaking at 13, 14,
- 26:3315% in the mid 70s. We had a political crisis.
- 26:35We had the King, the Queen of England sacking the national government here.
- 26:39We had Vietnam. We had all sorts of problems.
- 26:42You read the paper every day in the paper in the 70s.
- 26:44I know, I was there. Every day in the paper in the 70s,
- 26:46you'd read the paper, and there'd be a strike somewhere,
- 26:48a national strike somewhere. Countless industries were on strike, constantly striking with
- 26:53Days lost and productivity lost because of massive power of unions.
- 26:57Plus, you had, power of unions is good in some ways,
- 27:00but you had massive stoppages and massive national outages every
- 27:04day across Australia. So we had that in the 70s,
- 27:07and in the early 80s, everyone said,
- 27:09We're not, we're we've just been through this,
- 27:11and we know when that's like we want,
- 27:12we need to change. We have to,
- 27:14we can't return to the 70s.
- 27:15So they had a
- 27:16What they call the burning bridge.
- 27:18They had to get off the bridge.
- 27:19There was something burning chasing them.
- 27:20There was a, they were thrown into a boiling vat.
- 27:22so they jumped out. Now, it's been we're we're too fat and lazy.
- 27:26It's just there's no, there's no urgency,
- 27:28just import more people. crisis after crisis.
- 27:31It's it's now, to give you an example of one reform,
- 27:34what Hawke, Keating and Kelty said in the early 80s was.
- 27:37The idea, and given that we we've just been through double-digit inflation,
- 27:40and we still had six, eight percent average inflation through the eighties decade,
- 27:44even despite the reforms, what they said was we're not going to allow
- 27:48any wage raises without a corresponding productivity gain.
- 27:53So they ruled out productivity-free wage gains.
- 27:56So the whole accord system, and there's about seven different mark accords over
- 27:59the la over the next 15 years,
- 28:01they were designed to replace
- 28:03cost of living type wage rises just because inflation's going up,
- 28:07which is spiraling inflation. And they said,
- 28:09well, no more of that. We're going to have a productivity-based wage structure,
- 28:12which they did. So if you look at the last five years in Australia,
- 28:15post-COVID, it's all about cost of living,
- 28:18give us more money. And they just give them more money.
- 28:19You get 28% pay rises over four years.
- 28:22Every industry has gone through this.
- 28:23And they give them the right for enterprise bargaining to
- 28:25to become national industry-wide bargaining.
- 28:28So they've broadened the
- 28:29the scope of these silly wage claims.
- 28:31And they're c they're dressed up as they're cost of living wage gains because
- 28:35everything costs more the supermarket.
- 28:36That simply enforces the spiral.
- 28:38Yes. Because supermarkets then put prices up.
- 28:40So it's a s it's a wage spiral we had in the seventies in America,
- 28:43and we had in the US and we had in the UK.
- 28:45It's called wage spiral, wage price spiral.
- 28:47On the left of policy politics is called a prices wage spiral.
- 28:50On the right of politics is called a wages price spiral as to who was first.
- 28:55Doesn't matter. If you give wage rises for cost of living pressures just to compensate
- 29:00for higher prices, you're guaranteeing an entrenchment of the inflation.
- 29:04What Hawke, Keating and Kelty said was, none of that.
- 29:06You've got to prove you produce more per hour to get one dollar of wage rises.
- 29:11Now that's horribly painful to do,
- 29:14but because they control the union movement,
- 29:16Bob Hawke was ACTU president just prior, in eighty-three.
- 29:20And Bill Kelty ran the thing for the next 15 years,
- 29:23and he was on board. He was the driver.
- 29:25So I can't see the climate inside either side of politics making that simple
- 29:31one statement that says no more wage rises without producing more per hour.
- 29:36Sounds logical. It was done in the eighties very,
- 29:38very painfully, but the trade off is in the chart.
- 29:41The trade off was productivity growth through the eighties and nineties.
- 29:44Now that's one simple example of a reform which is a no brainer,
- 29:47which I can see politically impossible on either side of politics.
- 29:51What reforms do you think could work,
- 29:53to improve productivity? Because clearly we have to.
- 29:57But I would like to see open the paper or read the news and says we're going
- 30:02to have a genuine summit to discuss. The first thing Paul Keating
- 30:05and Kelty did was they announced it several times, that the tax reform
- 30:08was the same thing. They announced a tax summit,
- 30:10and you remember Paul Keating was dead against the GST and he went to an election
- 30:14on a GST and John Hewson went to an election on a GST and lost.
- 30:18All of a sudden, ten years later,
- 30:19Bob John Howard got in and guess what?
- 30:21We had a GST. And then Keating has been praising that ever since.
- 30:24So those sorts of tax reforms are very painful and they've destroyed governments
- 30:29and they've destroyed campaigns,
- 30:31but they've got to be done. there's lots of what I mean you look at
- 30:33the income tax take in Australia.
- 30:35What you want to be doing is you want if you want to tax somebody,
- 30:38you want to be taxing the spending rather than the saving.
- 30:41You don't want to be taxing the earning of the income.
- 30:42You don't you don't want to disincentivize people to earn more only because they
- 30:45lose almost all of it in tax.
- 30:47You want to skew the taxes away from individual income taxes towards taxes
- 30:53on spending. And you want to reduce the taxes on capital expenditure and
- 30:57r and R and D research and development.
- 30:59You look at one of these May twenty twenty six reforms, one was capping
- 31:04the R and D grant. Why would you want to cap the R and D?
- 31:06The idea of productivity comes from innovation,
- 31:09which is come which comes from companies investing in technology.
- 31:13Why would you then tax companies more and then cap the R and D grant?
- 31:17It's just it's not only stupid, it's actually counterproductive.
- 31:20The way to create productivity growth is to encourage companies
- 31:24to invest in technology so workers can do more with the same hours.
- 31:28You don't want to tax them, you don't you don't want to create taxes
- 31:31and more taxes and make that disincentive for companies to invest.
- 31:35So it's simple stuff, but they've gone they've gone the opposite direction in several cases.
- 31:39Well, we've discussed a lot today and clearly nothing's going to change quickly.
- 31:44But over the next decade, what evidence would show you,
- 31:49convince you that Australia has finally turned the corner
- 31:52and become more productive?
- 31:54Well, you'd like to see the output per hour increase and you'd like to
- 31:58see the out the total pie per person increase.
- 32:01and that will have to run against seven decades of downward cycle.
- 32:05the good thing I mean, Australia's prosperity in the first hundred years
- 32:10was created primarily off the sheep's back,
- 32:13wool, the great expansion of agriculture across Australia.
- 32:16at the expense of aboriginal cultures and towns and population.
- 32:19the second century was basically primarily again wool as it
- 32:24deteriorated, particularly post war.
- 32:27We had great mining boom. We had a mining boom in the in Adelaide
- 32:30in the eighteen forties. We had the great base metals booms
- 32:33in the eighteen seventies and eighties.
- 32:34We had the silver lead boom with BHP in the eighteen eighties and nineties.
- 32:37We had the gold rush in the eighteen fifties,
- 32:40which literally made Australia the richest country in the world.
- 32:43per capita, which it's in median terms,
- 32:46which it's had ever since. We had the eighteen nineties gold rush,
- 32:49we had the nineteen thirties gold,
- 32:50we had the great China boom. So each of the great step ups
- 32:54in productivity were either wool or mining.
- 32:57Most of those in the last hundred and fifty years have been mining.
- 33:00Now so you say, well we're going to get a next boost with a mining boom.
- 33:04Well guess what? We've been in a mining boom. We're in a mining boom.
- 33:06You got you look at the dividends sheet,
- 33:08I got the dividends from mining companies literally the other day,
- 33:11and they're they're double what they were last year.
- 33:13So we're already in a mining boom.
- 33:15So how do we, in a mining boom where you've got record revenues
- 33:19for WA and Queensland and national governments,
- 33:22record revenues from mining royalties,
- 33:24why do we have a suddenly racked up a trillion dollars in debt?
- 33:27Stupid stuff. So mining boom is not the answer.
- 33:29We're in a mining boom and we still found ways to spend and
- 33:33and borrow a trillion dollars.
- 33:34So until until somebody wakes up and said,
- 33:36Hey, something's wrong here. If mining is our saviour,
- 33:39we're already in a mining boom and we've still got
- 33:42a trillion dollars of debt. Something's gotta give.
- 33:44It's not labor, they're doing the spending.
- 33:46It's not liberals because they're they're part of that whole downward trend as well.
- 33:50So people are saying, Well, I don't trust either of those 'cause they haven't
- 33:53got it right, and I'm still doing it tough.
- 33:54So What the heck, let's try something else.
- 33:56A vote for one nation is not a vote for anything,
- 33:58it's a vote against people. And good on them, the two sides
- 34:03are not producing policies which are credible and rational and will make
- 34:06a difference. So let's just vote for somebody else.
- 34:08I can understand that.
- 34:10Well I guess some people have been listening to us watching us for
- 34:12the last 45 minutes or so and thinking,
- 34:15hey, this isn't sounding good for the future,
- 34:18maybe I shouldn't invest in property,
- 34:20maybe I shouldn't invest in shares.
- 34:22Are you still optimistic Ashley?
- 34:24I I've made half my money in forty years,
- 34:27half my money, pretty much half from investment properties or properties,
- 34:30owner occupied in investment in about twenty properties across three states,
- 34:33and about the other half in shares.
- 34:35so I've got a foot in both camps.
- 34:36Both of those rely pretty much on population growth.
- 34:40you know, we don't care about the rest,
- 34:41you just want more tenants knocking on the door,
- 34:43you just want more revenues and woolies so they pay more dividends.
- 34:46So so population growth is not a bad answer.
- 34:48The other thing with housing in particular is supply.
- 34:52Yeah, you got you've got a whole lot of problems.
- 34:55Now, the problem with the moment is you've got the downturn in housing,
- 34:58which everyone's talking about,
- 34:59you know, ten, fifteen percent.
- 35:00That's across the board. There are got there are pockets that are dropping forty,
- 35:04fifty percent, and there are pockets that'll do well,
- 35:06but over the ten million households in Australia,
- 35:08you've got a reduction in prices
- 35:10Which is really meaningful. Now the problem with that is that's meaning that that's
- 35:14making construction companies in the meantime are going broke and every
- 35:18day in the in the paper we need another builder going broke.
- 35:20So supply is tight, you've got NIMBY's,
- 35:23you've got massive property taxes at state level that stop property developments
- 35:27and cost property developments.
- 35:28So I can see that under supply not being solved anytime soon.
- 35:32So as a as a landlord, I'm saying that's fine,
- 35:35rents are going up, property prices are going up.
- 35:37Sweet. Happy days. Well, interesting times ahead,
- 35:40but I think this has been a useful reminder,
- 35:42Ashley, that a bigger economy and a wealthier population are actually two very,
- 35:46very different things. We've clearly shown that migration
- 35:49has brought Australia enormous benefits,
- 35:51although population growth can't carry the full burden for improving
- 35:56our living standards. And look,
- 35:58I think the message, you correctly say,
- 36:00for property investors is all this isn't a reason to panic.
- 36:03It's a reason to be more selective than ever in a lower
- 36:06growth environment, maybe the gap between investment grade properties
- 36:10and the average property is going to only widen.
- 36:13We've got still a growing population,
- 36:15no matter what government we're going to have,
- 36:17we're going to still have an under supply that's taken decades to build
- 36:23up and therefore isn't going to go away quickly.
- 36:25We've got the value of properties being underpinned by the cost that
- 36:29new properties are going to be so much more expensive.
- 36:32than lower-priced property. That's going to underpin the value
- 36:35of current established properties.
- 36:37So challenging times, but interesting times ahead.
- 36:40Thank you for explaining all that.
- 36:42So the bottom line is population growth isn't enough.
- 36:46We are going to have to become more productive.
- 36:49And the government's comment in the latest intergenerational report saying
- 36:54AI is going to fix it. Hey, come on.
- 36:56They don't fully even understand how, they Ashley?
- 36:59No idea. And it's interesting that I think Medibank was hacked by
- 37:01an independent non-human AI.
- 37:04And they did it back a month and a half ago.
- 37:06And Medibank doesn't know about it.
- 37:08They didn't know. OpenAI came clean overnight and said,
- 37:12by the way, we hacked into one of our humanless bots hacked into Medicare
- 37:17and took a lot of data.
- 37:18so they've got no idea. They wouldn't know if it jumped up and bit
- 37:21them on the forehead.
- 37:22So it's just silly stuff. So we gotta we've gotta get sensible and work
- 37:25out how to create real reforms that will make a difference,
- 37:28which is tough politically. Will the political cycle handle that toughness?
- 37:33Don't know. Interesting that's hard when the election cycles are shortened with another election
- 37:38coming up not too long away. You wonder whether they want to take the risk
- 37:42of making those decisions. Look forward to catching up with you again next month
- 37:45Ashley. Fantastic. It's been a pleasure.
- 37:52More than 20 years ago, I wrote the first edition of my bestselling book,
- 37:56How to Grow a Multi-Million Dollar Property Portfolio in Your Spare Time.
- 37:59Since then, I've updated it several times as our property markets,
- 38:03our finance systems, and the tax rules evolved.
- 38:05But this time, I had no choice but to bring out a new edition because 2026's federal
- 38:11budget changed some of the fundamentals that serious property investors have relied
- 38:15on for years. So this new edition has got new chapters,
- 38:18updated numbers, a straight assessment of
- 38:21what's changed and what it means if you're thinking about buying,
- 38:24selling or holding real estate as an investment.
- 38:27And to explain it all, I'm holding a series of seminars in Brisbane,
- 38:30Sydney and Melbourne with Brett Warren where I'm going to unpack the changes,
- 38:34discuss the opportunities that still exist and answer your questions.
- 38:38So when you purchase a copy of the new book,
- 38:40your seminar admission is included for free.
- 38:42Now, I haven't done anything like this for years and I don't plan to again.
- 38:45And we're deliberately keeping the room small
- 38:48I want these events to be a conversation.
- 38:50I want to be able to look you in the eyes,
- 38:51hear your questions and talk openly about what's really happening
- 38:54in property and what the new rules mean for you.
- 38:57Of course a small room means limited seats,
- 38:59but I'm going to leave a link to this at the top of the show notes for
- 39:04you to secure your place. A lot's changing in property.
- 39:07I'd love to discuss it with you in the room at the end of October, early November.
- 39:17Each show I like to leave you a trivia question,
- 39:19a chance to win one of three books I give away each week.
- 39:22Today's trivia question is based on my discussion with Ashley just
- 39:26a short while ago. Which Australian Prime Minister's government made
- 39:30all those large changes in the 1980s?
- 39:34Who was the Prime Minister at the time?
- 39:37Was it Bob Hawke or Paul Keating?
- 39:39Leave your answer at propertytrivia.com.au
- 39:43Bob Hawke or Paul Keating who was the Prime Minister who made
- 39:47all those significant reforms that Ashley Owen spoke about and you'll have
- 39:52a chance to win one of three books but everyone gets a property report.
- 39:56Doesn't matter if you listen to the show a bit late.
- 39:58PropertyTrivia.com.au I'd like to share a message with you today that life is a zero-sum game.
- 40:16You see, when the time finally comes,
- 40:19you're going to leave everything behind.
- 40:20The wealth you've created, the grudges you hold,
- 40:23and even the people you love. They're not things you can take with you.
- 40:27So then why do we spend so much of our time controlling these things when
- 40:32in the end, it's all going to be gone?
- 40:34If you know that you're going to leave all your money behind,
- 40:37Why are you so absorbed and stressed about gaining more than you need?
- 40:40When you can spend more time being happy instead.
- 40:44So in my mind, life is a zero sum game.
- 40:46We came here with nothing and we're going to leave with nothing.
- 40:49Your life and everything that you own,
- 40:52including your body, is essentially a rental.
- 40:54It's up to you to fully appreciate it while you're the tenant.
- 40:58I found this freedom in thinking that if nothing is yours,
- 41:02there's nothing that can be lost.
- 41:04Experience things while they last.
- 41:06Love them. And then let them get on with their own life.
- 41:10Letting go of attachments makes your life richer as you create space
- 41:14for new experiences to come in.
- 41:15This also means that when you encounter times of illness or hardship or loss,
- 41:21you realize that these moments of darkness
- 41:23are always temporary. Nothing is here to stay.
- 41:26When you choose to live every experience that comes your way as a rental,
- 41:30you appreciate that these moments are here for you to embrace and to learn from,
- 41:34but not to keep. So my message to you is your focus should shift from living
- 41:39in fear of not having enough to living in abundance as you realise that everything
- 41:44you need is already within you.