Latest / The NanceCast / Episode 7(? IDK anymore). The Dialiectic of Enlightenment with Rudi!
Transcript
- 0:03SPEAKER_03: and uh yeah what a great way to what a great way to start a live stream a little
- 0:08SPEAKER_03: bit late and without any fanfare just clicking the button and saying that's the
- 0:14SPEAKER_03: best way we are live so Rudy what's up dude it's good to Nance good to talk to you
- 0:24SPEAKER_03: it's always good to talk to you we just talked for hour and a half I think before
- 0:28SPEAKER_03: we started streaming and
- 0:31SPEAKER_03: We had a great conversation ranging from some taboo topics that might get us
- 0:37SPEAKER_03: canceled if anyone would have listened into the conversation to more,
- 0:41SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 0:43SPEAKER_03: tame topics such as dialectics and post-modernity and what are we going to do about
- 0:52SPEAKER_03: either or both um but it was good but as our conversation ended and for anyone
- 0:58SPEAKER_03: who's watching you guys will know that the stream while it was scheduled was titled
- 1:03SPEAKER_03: benny a damn sex yesterday's tomorrow that was initially the book we were going to
- 1:08SPEAKER_03: continue reading which we will at some point finish up um but for the time being we
- 1:15SPEAKER_03: are reading the dialectics of enlightenment
- 1:18SPEAKER_03: Teodor Adorno.
- 1:20SPEAKER_03: And that came out of the conversation we were having.
- 1:23SPEAKER_03: And at the end of the conversation, right before we took a break, I went to the toilet.
- 1:27SPEAKER_03: And then we came back and went live.
- 1:30SPEAKER_03: I came out to you as a secret magic believer slash practitioner.
- 1:36SPEAKER_03: And I was trying to explain to you what I meant.
- 1:38SPEAKER_03: And I think you picked up on it because, well, first we have some shared background.
- 1:43SPEAKER_03: And I think we've...
- 1:45SPEAKER_03: kind of rotated around the topic before.
- 1:47SPEAKER_03: But also, I think it's a fairly intuitive understanding of
- 1:54SPEAKER_03: time itself and kind of fate and situatedness uh but basically i was saying i don't
- 2:02SPEAKER_03: i don't believe in magic as such like chaos magic but the rituals and i also
- 2:07SPEAKER_03: include religion in the in this magic thing because i think it's the same thing or
- 2:13SPEAKER_03: it's a different approach to the same thing um
- 2:19SPEAKER_03: and actually I was thinking about Dune and Foundation,
- 2:22SPEAKER_03: these two stories about the future and like human projection tens of thousands of
- 2:26SPEAKER_03: years off into the future and how that's just religion in reverse.
- 2:31SPEAKER_03: Like religion is human projection thousands of years into the past and like
- 2:35SPEAKER_03: connecting the human to like the cosmic navel and like being in essence and
- 2:40SPEAKER_03: existence itself.
- 2:42SPEAKER_03: Whereas these fictions project us out in the future and kind of connect us to
- 2:48SPEAKER_03: human triumph over, over the world or over the universe or the cosmos.
- 2:52SPEAKER_03: But I reject those things.
- 2:54SPEAKER_03: And I also reject fate.
- 2:55SPEAKER_03: I also reject like everything being set in stone.
- 3:04SPEAKER_03: But I also do believe at the same time,
- 3:07SPEAKER_03: like having this radical view of time where past,
- 3:10SPEAKER_03: present and future are co-extant and co-equal and everything is going on all at once.
- 3:18SPEAKER_03: And we being the types of creatures we are, we move through the world.
- 3:21SPEAKER_03: We move through time just because that's just the way it works.
- 3:25SPEAKER_03: Maybe we'll overcome it someday, but right now we can't.
- 3:28SPEAKER_03: And so it is safe to take for granted kind of the arrow of time.
- 3:32SPEAKER_03: but the past present future all existing at once all happening at the same time
- 3:37SPEAKER_03: means in a sense everything is concrete everything is set in stone because the
- 3:42SPEAKER_03: future has already happened but also everything is free floating everything is up
- 3:47SPEAKER_03: in the air because nothing has happened yet and the idea of the present is this
- 3:52SPEAKER_03: kind of tension between everything has already happened nothing has happened at all
- 3:58SPEAKER_03: yet um
- 4:01SPEAKER_03: So it leaves open the question of fate or magic.
- 4:06SPEAKER_03: Like it leaves open,
- 4:08SPEAKER_03: well,
- 4:08SPEAKER_03: are you doomed to the future or can you change it by rituals or by right action in
- 4:14SPEAKER_03: the sight of God or whatever?
- 4:15SPEAKER_03: And I think it's necessarily both or a version or a species of both.
- 4:24SPEAKER_03: And that's, I don't know, part of what,
- 4:28SPEAKER_03: I think being a human is all about is like navigating time,
- 4:32SPEAKER_03: history,
- 4:32SPEAKER_03: existence,
- 4:33SPEAKER_03: presence,
- 4:34SPEAKER_03: like navigating all this stuff all at once.
- 4:35SPEAKER_03: So we were getting a little bit goofy and time.
- 4:40SPEAKER_03: Oh, isn't that cool?
- 4:41SPEAKER_03: Time's not really real, man.
- 4:45SPEAKER_03: And then you bitch slapped me and said, let's talk about something serious.
- 4:49SPEAKER_03: And this ties into Theodore Adorno's Dialectic of Enlightenment.
- 4:56SPEAKER_03: And that was exciting to me.
- 4:58SPEAKER_03: Because it was like just a natural progression of our conversation.
- 5:01SPEAKER_03: But we had already agreed to just do dialectic of enlightenment an hour before we
- 5:06SPEAKER_03: reached this point in our conversation.
- 5:08SPEAKER_03: So it was this kind of retroversion, this dialectic unfolding of our conversation as such.
- 5:15SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we spelled it maybe into being, to read it.
- 5:22SPEAKER_02: Because I said,
- 5:25SPEAKER_02: I think this disappearance of this triad,
- 5:30SPEAKER_02: everything happening at once,
- 5:32SPEAKER_02: is in a sense prehistory.
- 5:35SPEAKER_02: which of course is a Marxist notion of time that we can yet not be the agents of history.
- 5:43SPEAKER_02: And that's why it is prehistory.
- 5:46SPEAKER_02: It still appears to us as like something happening outside of our control, so to say.
- 5:52SPEAKER_02: And my question was like, how does...
- 5:59SPEAKER_02: Like seeing the future, change yourself, and by that, the future.
- 6:04SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 6:07SPEAKER_02: how much is it the process,
- 6:11SPEAKER_02: which is also always my critique with Land when I read him or think about him.
- 6:18SPEAKER_02: I think like how much will...
- 6:25SPEAKER_02: will we change what happens in the future?
- 6:28SPEAKER_02: In this sense.
- 6:31SPEAKER_02: So like, and I think that... And therefore be changed by it.
- 6:34SPEAKER_02: And therefore be changed by it.
- 6:35SPEAKER_02: You know, like this is never... You cannot emphasize one or the other, I think.
- 6:41SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 6:41SPEAKER_02: That's my point.
- 6:42SPEAKER_03: That's like with people trying to communicate like quantum physics.
- 6:46SPEAKER_03: They talk about like the observer problem and how like the observation of the
- 6:52SPEAKER_03: quantum or the whatever,
- 6:54SPEAKER_03: the observation of the phenomenon necessarily changes the phenomenon or with like
- 6:59SPEAKER_03: the dual-slate experiment.
- 7:01SPEAKER_03: it when you're not looking it goes through both holes but when you are looking when
- 7:05SPEAKER_03: you do measure it it goes through one hole necessarily and it's it's like yeah the
- 7:09SPEAKER_03: observation of the thing necessarily changes the phenomena or changes the thing
- 7:14SPEAKER_03: itself because you're interacting with it you're interfacing with it in a way so
- 7:18SPEAKER_03: when we think about the future i think we can change the future but we are also
- 7:23SPEAKER_03: necessarily changed by the future ourselves so maybe you
- 7:27SPEAKER_03: it's not that we're bringing the future in line with what we want it's maybe we are
- 7:32SPEAKER_03: being brought into line with what the future wants but then and i think that's an
- 7:39SPEAKER_03: open question i like i do reject fate i do reject determinism now look i think we
- 7:46SPEAKER_03: do live in a deterministic universe
- 7:51SPEAKER_03: but I don't think anything is necessarily determined.
- 7:56SPEAKER_03: Like we,
- 7:56SPEAKER_03: we live in this deterministic universe that is inhabited by emergent subjects and
- 8:03SPEAKER_03: quanta and,
- 8:05SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 8:05SPEAKER_03: and,
- 8:06SPEAKER_03: and all these things.
- 8:06SPEAKER_03: So it's a dialectic, like that itself is a, is a dialectic of like, yeah, it's both.
- 8:12SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 8:12SPEAKER_03: It's, it is both.
- 8:14SPEAKER_03: It's also neither.
- 8:15SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 8:19SPEAKER_02: Yeah, and I think this ties greatly into the dialectic of enlightenment.
- 8:23SPEAKER_02: I don't know if we start with the introduction or if we go right at it with the
- 8:31SPEAKER_02: first chapter,
- 8:33SPEAKER_02: which is the concept of enlightenment,
- 8:35SPEAKER_02: because it goes into magic,
- 8:39SPEAKER_02: science.
- 8:40SPEAKER_02: Where does this come from?
- 8:41SPEAKER_02: Why is it necessary?
- 8:44SPEAKER_02: And I think... Yeah?
- 8:46SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 8:46SPEAKER_03: I was just going to reiterate,
- 8:49SPEAKER_03: I've never,
- 8:51SPEAKER_03: as big as these guys are,
- 8:54SPEAKER_03: as important as they are,
- 8:56SPEAKER_03: and as essential as they are,
- 8:59SPEAKER_03: I've never seriously...
- 9:02SPEAKER_03: read it I think I've read this once before it was years ago and it's there is
- 9:09SPEAKER_03: nothing here so for the for the purposes of right now I will defer to wherever you
- 9:15SPEAKER_03: want to take us because I think you're you have a leg up on me here
- 9:21SPEAKER_02: Yeah, let's start there.
- 9:23SPEAKER_02: I mean, I read it before too when I was way younger and I understood almost nothing.
- 9:29SPEAKER_02: And I was like, oh yeah, there's the Cyclops and the Cyclops is the farmer.
- 9:33SPEAKER_02: And I thought that I understood like this mode of reading where it's like,
- 9:39SPEAKER_02: I got the thing,
- 9:40SPEAKER_02: but actually later I realized how much eluded my grasp.
- 9:47SPEAKER_02: um and now i think what really unlocked it for me is to read them as critical
- 9:54SPEAKER_02: theorists in the sense of they are marxists they currently at the time of writing
- 10:03SPEAKER_02: this they
- 10:04SPEAKER_02: when they wrote this,
- 10:05SPEAKER_02: they experienced both Stalinism in the Soviet Union and fascism in Europe and
- 10:12SPEAKER_02: Fordism in the USA.
- 10:14SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 10:16SPEAKER_02: And all of this informs this whole book.
- 10:25SPEAKER_03: Hell yeah.
- 10:28SPEAKER_03: So similarly to like, when I read Benjamin, I think one thing that really helped me
- 10:36SPEAKER_03: accelerate my understanding of Benjamin was remembering the context in which he was
- 10:42SPEAKER_03: writing and remembering what it was he was doing.
- 10:44SPEAKER_03: I think if you don't have any idea what Benjamin and what the Frankfurt School guys
- 10:49SPEAKER_03: are talking about,
- 10:52SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 10:53SPEAKER_03: it might be difficult.
- 10:54SPEAKER_03: You have to remember,
- 10:55SPEAKER_03: no,
- 10:55SPEAKER_03: they are living at this crescendo of history where when they reference fascism or
- 10:59SPEAKER_03: when they reference totalitarianism,
- 11:02SPEAKER_03: they're referencing a concrete thing in the world.
- 11:05SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 11:06SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 11:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 11:09SPEAKER_02: And I mean,
- 11:10SPEAKER_02: Benjamin is like,
- 11:12SPEAKER_02: I think that he said about Adorno that if he has one student,
- 11:16SPEAKER_02: he has only one student that it's Adorno.
- 11:17SPEAKER_02: I think he said that about him because his thinking informs both of what they're doing here.
- 11:29SPEAKER_03: hey caesar yes sar what's up dude he says good good to see you rudy it is good to
- 11:36SPEAKER_03: have rudy back man i'm glad i'm glad you're back rudy i'm really glad yeah me too
- 11:41SPEAKER_02: me too i'm glad that i i have this yeah i can hold on to it and then i can do it
- 11:47SPEAKER_02: again yeah well and you got big news i don't know i don't know uh
- 11:54SPEAKER_03: If you want to share it.
- 11:56SPEAKER_02: If I share it now.
- 11:58SPEAKER_02: No, I decided to move away from theater because I feel like I can get nothing out of it currently.
- 12:07SPEAKER_02: And I want to go back studying.
- 12:10SPEAKER_02: Oh, shit, man.
- 12:10SPEAKER_02: Now I said it.
- 12:11SPEAKER_02: No, I cannot reel back.
- 12:13SPEAKER_02: You can't undo it.
- 12:16SPEAKER_02: So to study philosophy and maybe political science, I'm still thinking about like
- 12:21SPEAKER_02: the second course,
- 12:23SPEAKER_02: because I was at this point in my life where I was thinking,
- 12:28SPEAKER_02: like,
- 12:28SPEAKER_02: what do I want to do?
- 12:29SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 12:30SPEAKER_02: like,
- 12:31SPEAKER_02: because I always had,
- 12:32SPEAKER_02: like,
- 12:32SPEAKER_02: a task where I was like,
- 12:34SPEAKER_02: I have to do this because it's necessary.
- 12:36SPEAKER_02: And this was maybe one of the first times where I was like, no, I really want to do this.
- 12:41SPEAKER_02: I just, for the heck of it, you know, I just want to write a paper on Kant's whatever terminology and...
- 12:49SPEAKER_02: horribly fail i don't care um you know but uh but you can't do it damn it and that
- 12:56SPEAKER_03: that's an exercise in being an unabashed unashamed human you don't need an
- 13:04SPEAKER_03: instrumental justification
- 13:06SPEAKER_03: to do what you are doing and and yeah escaping escaping the kind of
- 13:11SPEAKER_03: instrumentalized totalization of the world that we live in it's a beautiful thing
- 13:16SPEAKER_03: and i think uh i think we're blessed to use a word that i can't stand i think we
- 13:21SPEAKER_03: are blessed i think we are privileged to to have these avenues of escape these
- 13:25SPEAKER_03: lines of flight
- 13:26SPEAKER_03: you know yeah um yeah i think it's great it's also scary it's also terrifying to
- 13:33SPEAKER_03: because you are things are up in the air your future is up in the air there's a
- 13:37SPEAKER_03: safety that comes with like instrumentalization it's like well maybe i might not be
- 13:41SPEAKER_03: satisfied but at least i'll be secure knowing that i'm a cog in the machine um for
- 13:47SPEAKER_03: as long as that machine keeps running
- 13:49SPEAKER_03: but that's inhuman.
- 13:51SPEAKER_03: And it is, it is essentially human to say, I want to do this thing for the fuck of this thing itself.
- 14:00SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 14:01SPEAKER_02: So that's, yeah.
- 14:02SPEAKER_02: And I mean,
- 14:03SPEAKER_02: it's,
- 14:03SPEAKER_02: it's,
- 14:04SPEAKER_02: and I mean,
- 14:05SPEAKER_02: it's also relates to like,
- 14:07SPEAKER_02: um,
- 14:08SPEAKER_02: there was no way forward,
- 14:10SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 14:10SPEAKER_02: like,
- 14:10SPEAKER_02: like I was like thinking,
- 14:12SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 14:13SPEAKER_02: um,
- 14:13SPEAKER_02: it's not even instrumentalization yet.
- 14:17SPEAKER_02: I cannot even rely on this institution.
- 14:19SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 14:20SPEAKER_02: And I mean, going into academia, it's like, okay, we'll see.
- 14:25SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 14:27SPEAKER_02: I will see.
- 14:28SPEAKER_02: But at least I know that I can take something from it that I'm not finding in where I am at now.
- 14:37SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 14:37SPEAKER_02: the institution I'm at now,
- 14:39SPEAKER_02: I look around me and I'm like,
- 14:40SPEAKER_02: all these people are fucking stupid half of the time.
- 14:43SPEAKER_02: Like...
- 14:44SPEAKER_02: They are also great and they are people and they are flawed,
- 14:47SPEAKER_02: but like there's a lot of smelling your own farts and have knowledge.
- 14:52SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 14:53SPEAKER_02: And speaking a little bit about, have you read Byung-Chul Han?
- 14:56SPEAKER_02: Oh,
- 14:57SPEAKER_02: then,
- 14:57SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 14:58SPEAKER_02: you read the text and it's like it's something maybe has something to do with the
- 15:03SPEAKER_02: play because you wanted to have something to do with the play,
- 15:07SPEAKER_02: but it's not rigorous.
- 15:09SPEAKER_03: I think it is a little ironic that
- 15:15SPEAKER_03: The precarity in the theater, I think it's an accelerated precarity.
- 15:21SPEAKER_03: But there's also a lot of precarity in academia as well and studying philosophy as well.
- 15:29SPEAKER_02: You know, I thought, like, I learned a job that gives me almost no economic value for a company.
- 15:39SPEAKER_02: I failed at that.
- 15:40SPEAKER_02: Now let me study another.
- 15:43SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 15:46SPEAKER_03: you uh i think it says something my cv even more yeah i think that says something
- 15:52SPEAKER_03: uh remarkable about your about your kind of character character and your
- 15:58SPEAKER_03: disposition and your comportment is that you uh
- 16:04SPEAKER_03: you're willing to put yourself in these precarious worlds because it satisfies...
- 16:10SPEAKER_03: Look,
- 16:10SPEAKER_03: art,
- 16:11SPEAKER_03: theater,
- 16:12SPEAKER_03: that is satisfying,
- 16:14SPEAKER_03: a very human thing.
- 16:15SPEAKER_03: And similarly, I think studying philosophy is also a very human thing.
- 16:19SPEAKER_03: So I think the fact that you're willing to risk it
- 16:24SPEAKER_03: uh i i wasn't like when i when i was confronted with the choice of like i need to
- 16:29SPEAKER_03: find a job i need to make money i joined the military like i think that says
- 16:33SPEAKER_03: something about my character is that i was afraid yeah and i think uh i think
- 16:38SPEAKER_03: you're bold in a way and i think that's fucking beautiful dude and i'm happy like
- 16:41SPEAKER_03: i'm glad that you're like a part of my life too like you're my friend i'm glad to
- 16:46SPEAKER_03: have yeah yeah
- 16:49SPEAKER_02: Thank you, thank you.
- 16:50SPEAKER_02: But it's like, I still, I have to say, I still struggled a lot.
- 16:56SPEAKER_02: And I really had to figure a neurotic way where I can,
- 17:00SPEAKER_02: like,
- 17:01SPEAKER_02: justify it in front of me and be like,
- 17:04SPEAKER_02: hey,
- 17:05SPEAKER_02: maybe...
- 17:06SPEAKER_02: that's the truth you know like um i'm super sure uh i can't learn more like
- 17:13SPEAKER_02: extracurricular in university with which i can get just a job if i say hey man
- 17:21SPEAKER_02: money has to come in let's just work in accounting wherever the yeah you know um
- 17:26SPEAKER_02: and then do in my free time what i would like to do
- 17:32SPEAKER_02: Way more than the theater.
- 17:33SPEAKER_02: Like artists,
- 17:35SPEAKER_02: if you don't work in the art field and you're like the person doing the art as like
- 17:40SPEAKER_02: a theater actor,
- 17:43SPEAKER_02: no way.
- 17:44SPEAKER_02: You're even less valuable than like people who studied music because they can go into like...
- 17:50SPEAKER_02: pedagogia and stuff like that as theater.
- 17:53SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 17:55SPEAKER_03: I think,
- 17:56SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 17:57SPEAKER_03: I think we all need to be honest and admit that in five to 10 years,
- 18:01SPEAKER_03: we will all be beggars,
- 18:04SPEAKER_03: but,
- 18:05SPEAKER_03: Hopefully we can all kind of congregate.
- 18:09SPEAKER_03: We can pick a city.
- 18:11SPEAKER_03: All of us can move to whatever city it is we decide upon.
- 18:15SPEAKER_03: So we can at least be beggars, but we won't be alone.
- 18:18SPEAKER_03: But I think we all are trying to kind of pursue something that is necessarily
- 18:23SPEAKER_03: non-instrumental and non-instrumentalizable.
- 18:28SPEAKER_03: um and it's that was a joke we're not all going to be beggars i i do believe i do
- 18:32SPEAKER_03: believe there's a future in in all of this whatever it is we're doing uh but i
- 18:36SPEAKER_03: think i think it's going to be hard i think we're all um everyone listening right
- 18:42SPEAKER_03: now everyone that that will be listening in the future i think we all are uh
- 18:47SPEAKER_03: resolved to to to do the hard thing because if we weren't we wouldn't be here if we
- 18:53SPEAKER_03: didn't have that resolve we would be
- 18:56SPEAKER_03: playing a video game or watching a video game streamer or masturbating or getting
- 19:02SPEAKER_03: drunk or getting high or doing all the other things that,
- 19:06SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 19:07SPEAKER_03: um,
- 19:07SPEAKER_03: so let's all pat ourselves on the back.
- 19:09SPEAKER_03: We are the humans.
- 19:11SPEAKER_03: Let's do this fucking thing.
- 19:13SPEAKER_02: Let's do that fucking thing.
- 19:15SPEAKER_02: Um, which is fine.
- 19:16SPEAKER_02: You can game, you know, like, um, no, look,
- 19:19SPEAKER_02: This is not like a boot camp.
- 19:22SPEAKER_03: I've been meaning to get back to a video game.
- 19:26SPEAKER_03: I got the Cities Skylines video game.
- 19:29SPEAKER_03: I downloaded it.
- 19:30SPEAKER_03: I haven't played it yet,
- 19:32SPEAKER_03: but I downloaded it because I do intend in the new year to section out some time to
- 19:38SPEAKER_03: play a video game.
- 19:46SPEAKER_02: Do you want to get into it?
- 19:48SPEAKER_03: yeah got uh welsh in in the chat ian cochran good to see you man um what's up
- 19:59SPEAKER_03: everybody so we'll do got this epub um the concept of enlightenment that's where
- 20:12SPEAKER_03: we're starting
- 20:13SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 20:14SPEAKER_03: All right.
- 20:14SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 20:16SPEAKER_03: Um, you want to give any preamble or are we satisfied with all the preamble ready to jump right in?
- 20:23SPEAKER_02: Um, no, I think, uh, I think, uh, let me think for a second.
- 20:32SPEAKER_02: Okay,
- 20:32SPEAKER_02: if you go into this completely blind,
- 20:34SPEAKER_02: maybe for that,
- 20:35SPEAKER_02: because while we talked a little bit,
- 20:37SPEAKER_02: I wanted to say someone to like the complete plebe.
- 20:41SPEAKER_02: Nice that you're here.
- 20:44SPEAKER_02: This is hard.
- 20:45SPEAKER_02: Don't worry, man.
- 20:47SPEAKER_02: I wreck my brain about these things too.
- 20:51SPEAKER_02: Yeah, Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno were two...
- 20:58SPEAKER_02: figures of the frankfurt school which was an institute like a marxist institute um
- 21:03SPEAKER_02: which was funded with marxist money um and they tried to bring together different
- 21:11SPEAKER_02: fields um from the university sociology they they are one of the um i think even
- 21:19SPEAKER_02: like they took up the torch from weber and these people that they which was the
- 21:24SPEAKER_02: sociologists and uh
- 21:28SPEAKER_02: they tried to do sociology,
- 21:31SPEAKER_02: philosophy,
- 21:34SPEAKER_02: psychology,
- 21:35SPEAKER_02: which was psychoanalysis mostly back then still,
- 21:40SPEAKER_02: and to bring this all together with Marxism in critical theory.
- 21:45SPEAKER_02: Like when they say critical theory, it means Marxism in the sense that Marxism is the critical...
- 21:55SPEAKER_02: theory of the workers movement of the movement for socialism in history not
- 21:59SPEAKER_02: necessarily the political concrete right now yeah and they are in exile because
- 22:06SPEAKER_02: they were both jewish intellectual leftists in nazi germany and they had to flee
- 22:12SPEAKER_02: and they both fled to i think um los angeles like they took some detours uh
- 22:21SPEAKER_02: They come separate, and yeah, I think they are still in the USA when they write this.
- 22:28SPEAKER_03: And I think, is the culture industry probably their biggest, their most well-known work?
- 22:34SPEAKER_03: So yeah,
- 22:34SPEAKER_03: if anyone,
- 22:36SPEAKER_03: if you don't know Adorno and Horkheimer,
- 22:37SPEAKER_03: they are the guys who wrote the culture industry.
- 22:39SPEAKER_03: And I think that is probably,
- 22:44SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 22:44SPEAKER_03: their most well-known work and also maybe the most influential on the left media industry.
- 22:52SPEAKER_02: yeah media maybe i don't know yeah i would say no i would say i think um the whole
- 23:00SPEAKER_02: um yeah culture industry and the totalized society like that they say like the the
- 23:06SPEAKER_02: totalized society is the concept they also which was pretty important for the new
- 23:11SPEAKER_02: left although they had like calling out and critique and uh little baby fits
- 23:19SPEAKER_02: towards adorno and torkheimer
- 23:21SPEAKER_03: yeah well yeah i think that's all the new left was it was all just a bunch of fits
- 23:29SPEAKER_03: it was a maybe it was one collective giant collective fit of uh the the formerly
- 23:36SPEAKER_03: proletarianized workers kind of coming to this new realization of the new situation
- 23:43SPEAKER_03: post-class fractured mass you know in the wake of the managerial revolution and and
- 23:48SPEAKER_03: total institutionalization uh maybe it was just a giant collective fit and maybe
- 23:54SPEAKER_03: that's okay I think maybe yeah maybe yeah um
- 24:05SPEAKER_03: Oh, man.
- 24:05SPEAKER_03: Gigging in the center.
- 24:06SPEAKER_03: Cardiff was going with it, but I canceled it.
- 24:08SPEAKER_03: I'm on my way to... Hell yeah, Ian.
- 24:10SPEAKER_03: Fuck yeah.
- 24:12SPEAKER_03: Adam Mad says, PCFM reference.
- 24:13SPEAKER_03: Drink.
- 24:14SPEAKER_03: That's his drinking game.
- 24:15SPEAKER_03: Every time any Theory Underground or Theory Underground adjacent publication or
- 24:19SPEAKER_03: production references the post-class fractured mass.
- 24:22SPEAKER_03: Adam is going to get drunk, so my job is to get Adam shit-faced.
- 24:26SPEAKER_03: every day because i can't stop referencing in 30 minutes yeah we'll jump right into
- 24:33SPEAKER_03: it so we are skipping the introduction we're going to get right into it here with
- 24:37SPEAKER_03: the concept of enlightenment um we'll read a few we'll puff puff pass we'll
- 24:41SPEAKER_03: interject when we feel the need to do so so
- 24:44SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 24:57SPEAKER_03: yet the fully enlightened Earth radiates disaster triumphant.
- 25:02SPEAKER_03: The program of the Enlightenment was the disenchantment of the world,
- 25:07SPEAKER_03: the disillusion of myths and the substitution of knowledge for fancy.
- 25:12SPEAKER_03: Bacon, the father of experimental philosophy, had defined its motives.
- 25:18SPEAKER_03: He looked down on the masters of tradition,
- 25:20SPEAKER_03: the great reputed authors who first believe that others know that which they know not,
- 25:27SPEAKER_03: and after themselves know that which they know not,
- 25:31SPEAKER_03: but indeed facility to believe,
- 25:33SPEAKER_03: impatience to doubt,
- 25:35SPEAKER_03: temerity to answer,
- 25:37SPEAKER_03: glory to know,
- 25:38SPEAKER_03: doubt to contradict,
- 25:40SPEAKER_03: end to gain,
- 25:41SPEAKER_03: sloth to search,
- 25:42SPEAKER_03: seeking things in words,
- 25:44SPEAKER_03: resting in part of nature.
- 25:47SPEAKER_03: These
- 25:48SPEAKER_03: and the like have been the things which have forbidden the happy match between the
- 25:52SPEAKER_03: mind of man and the nature of things,
- 25:55SPEAKER_03: and in place thereof have married it to vain notions and blind experiments.
- 26:01SPEAKER_03: And what the posterity and issue of so honorable a match may be, it is not hard to consider.
- 26:08SPEAKER_03: Printing, a gross invention.
- 26:10SPEAKER_03: Artillery, a thing that lay not far out of the way.
- 26:14SPEAKER_03: The needle, a thing partly known before.
- 26:18SPEAKER_03: What a change have these three things made in the world in these times.
- 26:22SPEAKER_03: The one in the state of learning,
- 26:24SPEAKER_03: the other in the state of war,
- 26:26SPEAKER_03: the third in the state of treasure,
- 26:29SPEAKER_03: commodities,
- 26:29SPEAKER_03: and navigation.
- 26:32SPEAKER_03: And those, I say, were but stumbled upon and lighted upon by chance.
- 26:38SPEAKER_03: Therefore,
- 26:39SPEAKER_03: no doubt,
- 26:40SPEAKER_03: the sovereignty of man lieth hid in knowledge,
- 26:43SPEAKER_03: wherein many things are reserved,
- 26:46SPEAKER_03: which kings with their treasure cannot buy,
- 26:49SPEAKER_03: nor with their force command.
- 26:51SPEAKER_03: Their spiles and intelligences can give no news of them.
- 26:55SPEAKER_03: Their seamen and discoverers cannot sail where they grow.
- 26:59SPEAKER_03: Now we govern nature in opinions, but we are thrall unto her in necessity."
- 27:05SPEAKER_03: But if we would be led by her in invention, we should command her by action.
- 27:14SPEAKER_03: That was Francis Bacon, a long quote.
- 27:23SPEAKER_03: Nature.
- 27:24SPEAKER_03: What is nature?
- 27:29SPEAKER_02: That's... Yeah.
- 27:34SPEAKER_03: What is nature?
- 27:34SPEAKER_03: Nature.
- 27:35SPEAKER_03: I saw yesterday, I started writing a piece yesterday morning.
- 27:41SPEAKER_03: It was in the downtime.
- 27:44SPEAKER_03: I get up early in the mornings and I skateboard and I work out and then I start my day.
- 27:49SPEAKER_03: So yesterday morning after I was skateboarding,
- 27:52SPEAKER_03: sat down and I started writing a piece and I think it's about fiction.
- 27:55SPEAKER_03: And I think it's about,
- 27:57SPEAKER_03: this is why I was thinking about Dune and foundation and how they're like the
- 28:00SPEAKER_03: mirror image of like Christianity or like these other religious traditions,
- 28:06SPEAKER_03: which the religious traditions look backward to,
- 28:09SPEAKER_03: to root us to the origin.
- 28:11SPEAKER_03: These works of fiction look forward to root us in something else.
- 28:16SPEAKER_03: And it doesn't have to be an eschatology.
- 28:17SPEAKER_03: I think it can be like an ongoing story.
- 28:21SPEAKER_03: existence but but i reject both like i i don't i'm not satisfied with either but i
- 28:29SPEAKER_03: was writing about religion fiction uh science fiction and fantasy whereas science
- 28:35SPEAKER_03: fiction is aspirational fantasy is inspirational and so the difference is uh
- 28:45SPEAKER_03: With science fiction, it's aspirational.
- 28:47SPEAKER_03: It's something that people think we can or will achieve,
- 28:50SPEAKER_03: whereas with fantasy,
- 28:51SPEAKER_03: it's something that there's this implicit knowledge that this is not real.
- 28:55SPEAKER_03: These are ideals guiding us, and so we're not going to try to operationalize the fantasy.
- 29:03SPEAKER_03: We're just going to stick to the ideals.
- 29:06SPEAKER_03: But in the writing of this piece that hopefully I write for the next couple weeks
- 29:10SPEAKER_03: and then I publish soon,
- 29:13SPEAKER_03: I ask the question,
- 29:13SPEAKER_03: what is nature?
- 29:16SPEAKER_03: And I suggest that nature and God are the same thing.
- 29:23SPEAKER_03: And man, as part of nature, necessarily, we are like a protrusion or an extrusion.
- 29:34SPEAKER_03: Or like if you take a sheet of paper or a thing and you like poke it,
- 29:42SPEAKER_03: Like there's a bump on top.
- 29:44SPEAKER_03: So it like protrudes.
- 29:46SPEAKER_03: So like we are part of nature or you can also say we are part of God.
- 29:50SPEAKER_03: It is, you know, God is the condition of possibility for all existence in the first place.
- 29:56SPEAKER_03: God is also the condition of possibility for intentionality.
- 30:01SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 30:02SPEAKER_03: That's one way to articulate it.
- 30:03SPEAKER_03: And nature is also the same thing.
- 30:05SPEAKER_03: Nature is the condition of possibility for being as such.
- 30:10SPEAKER_03: Existence as such.
- 30:13SPEAKER_03: Subjectivity as such.
- 30:14SPEAKER_03: Because we are these animals.
- 30:16SPEAKER_03: We are these extant creatures creatures.
- 30:19SPEAKER_03: who exist but something emerges so with god it's the divine spark and he imbues it
- 30:25SPEAKER_03: in us okay i'm okay with that with nature it's this kind of process of evolution
- 30:31SPEAKER_03: and emergent complexity and systems uh accumulating over time until subjectivity
- 30:38SPEAKER_03: emerges um
- 30:40SPEAKER_03: I think God and nature are the same thing.
- 30:42SPEAKER_03: Same exact thing.
- 30:43SPEAKER_03: It's just a different signifiers.
- 30:46SPEAKER_03: And that's not trying to offend any believers.
- 30:52SPEAKER_03: I think that's great.
- 30:54SPEAKER_03: I'm not trying to diminish or cheapen God by saying it's the same thing as nature.
- 30:59SPEAKER_03: But that's how I interpret it and situate myself.
- 31:06SPEAKER_03: But man...
- 31:09SPEAKER_03: is this thing that we rest on nature, but we necessarily emerge from nature or God.
- 31:19SPEAKER_03: Like we, it is a necessary part of who and what we are.
- 31:24SPEAKER_03: It is a condition of possibility for who and what we are,
- 31:27SPEAKER_03: but there's also something else that makes us who and what we are.
- 31:32SPEAKER_03: So if anything,
- 31:35SPEAKER_03: I'm only comfortable saying, oh no, my internet's slowing down, whatever.
- 31:41SPEAKER_03: If anything, I'm comfortable saying nature that is like down here at the base.
- 31:50SPEAKER_03: That's what nature is.
- 31:52SPEAKER_03: So like, but that doesn't answer the question, right?
- 31:56SPEAKER_03: Like, well, what is nature?
- 31:57SPEAKER_03: And then I spent three minutes explaining this.
- 32:00SPEAKER_03: That still doesn't answer the question.
- 32:03SPEAKER_02: I would say it's like, um, first of all, it's that what, um, the, the world we find ourselves in.
- 32:15SPEAKER_02: And by that, it necessarily is society too.
- 32:20SPEAKER_02: Absolutely.
- 32:21SPEAKER_02: Um, and, um, but I think for, um,
- 32:34SPEAKER_02: for bacon the question in this in this quote i think is what is nature for bacon
- 32:42SPEAKER_02: and um i think for bacon it is um everything in the world that he that that the
- 32:56SPEAKER_02: that the society finds um
- 33:04SPEAKER_02: I think it's very,
- 33:05SPEAKER_02: like,
- 33:05SPEAKER_02: it's very,
- 33:05SPEAKER_02: like,
- 33:05SPEAKER_02: natural sciences,
- 33:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 33:07SPEAKER_02: like,
- 33:07SPEAKER_02: that's why they,
- 33:09SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 33:10SPEAKER_02: like,
- 33:10SPEAKER_02: what is the,
- 33:12SPEAKER_02: what are the laws of the world around me that govern us?
- 33:18SPEAKER_02: And when we start to understand.
- 33:22SPEAKER_02: Yeah, a priori.
- 33:23SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 33:24SPEAKER_02: Nature's a priori.
- 33:29SPEAKER_03: Do you...
- 33:32SPEAKER_03: That's actually, yeah, that's a good, that's a good answer.
- 33:34SPEAKER_03: Like it, the world we find ourselves in.
- 33:36SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 33:38SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 33:40SPEAKER_03: But then he's talking about like, we should master her.
- 33:43SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 33:45SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 33:47SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 33:47SPEAKER_02: Because I think this is where like enlightenment begins that he's bourgeois.
- 33:53SPEAKER_02: Because I don't know if this is the normal reading,
- 33:55SPEAKER_02: but I think they don't reduce Adorno and Horkheimer,
- 34:00SPEAKER_02: they don't reduce Enlightenment only to capital,
- 34:04SPEAKER_02: but it is capital.
- 34:05SPEAKER_02: This is already bourgeois society starting.
- 34:15SPEAKER_02: And being like,
- 34:16SPEAKER_02: how can we manage,
- 34:19SPEAKER_02: like,
- 34:20SPEAKER_02: how can we become sovereign over debt,
- 34:24SPEAKER_02: which we see as having power over us?
- 34:27SPEAKER_02: But actually it's not.
- 34:29SPEAKER_02: We can understand its laws with our knowledge.
- 34:33SPEAKER_02: And with our knowledge, we can master it.
- 34:35SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 34:36SPEAKER_02: Because when we understand it, we can subjugate it.
- 34:38SPEAKER_03: Yeah, we can augment these kind of natural processes and the natural flow of the world.
- 34:46SPEAKER_03: We then augment that with our reason and our rationality.
- 34:53SPEAKER_03: So, yeah, okay.
- 34:56SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think Bacon probably would be satisfied with that.
- 35:04SPEAKER_03: it's uh you know the history of mankind has been a war uh or not even a war the
- 35:12SPEAKER_03: history of mankind like we've been oppressed by nature and bacon wants us to
- 35:16SPEAKER_03: discover a modality of uh we ourselves becoming the exploiters if not the
- 35:23SPEAKER_03: oppressors yeah putting nature on the rack as as bacon would say
- 35:34SPEAKER_03: Soloski in the chat says, nature creates with a shaky hand.
- 35:41SPEAKER_03: And that's apparently a line by Aquinas.
- 35:45SPEAKER_03: Aquinas.
- 35:47SPEAKER_03: Interesting.
- 35:50SPEAKER_03: With a shaky hand.
- 35:51SPEAKER_03: And then it's up to man to come along behind and refine it.
- 35:57SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 35:57SPEAKER_02: that I would think,
- 35:58SPEAKER_02: but there Thomas Aquinas is still like theology,
- 36:02SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 36:03SPEAKER_02: like they're still like...
- 36:04SPEAKER_02: Oh,
- 36:05SPEAKER_02: that's a good point.
- 36:08SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 36:08SPEAKER_02: like it's still,
- 36:10SPEAKER_02: he sings still together,
- 36:11SPEAKER_02: like nature creates with a shaky hand,
- 36:15SPEAKER_02: but we as the divine spirit,
- 36:17SPEAKER_02: and it's true,
- 36:19SPEAKER_02: there already is kind of enlightenment happening,
- 36:21SPEAKER_02: but not as realized as in Bacon.
- 36:25SPEAKER_02: Bacon.
- 36:27SPEAKER_03: That's a good point.
- 36:28SPEAKER_03: Okay, and Soloski clarified, it's the Aquinas character in Dante.
- 36:32SPEAKER_02: Ah, it's Dante.
- 36:33SPEAKER_02: Yeah, but in Dante, yeah.
- 36:35SPEAKER_02: Yeah, okay.
- 36:37SPEAKER_02: But Dante, of course.
- 36:41SPEAKER_02: Um...
- 36:43SPEAKER_02: So we know nothing.
- 36:46SPEAKER_02: We haven't read.
- 36:47SPEAKER_01: I have not read.
- 36:49SPEAKER_02: We're like, oh, Aquinas.
- 36:51SPEAKER_02: Yes, Aquinas.
- 36:55SPEAKER_03: Showing our lack.
- 36:56SPEAKER_03: That's what we do here, people.
- 36:58SPEAKER_03: We are not experts.
- 37:00SPEAKER_03: But we're also not Byung-Chul Han's idiots either.
- 37:02SPEAKER_03: You referenced Byung-Chul Han.
- 37:06SPEAKER_03: And yeah, I like Byung-Chul Han.
- 37:08SPEAKER_03: I've got a lot out of reading Byung-Chul Han.
- 37:10SPEAKER_03: But I also think at the end of the day,
- 37:11SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 37:12SPEAKER_03: Byung Chul Han just wants to do a mysticism and say,
- 37:15SPEAKER_03: become the idiot,
- 37:15SPEAKER_03: become the flower on the river bank.
- 37:18SPEAKER_03: And I don't think that's the answer.
- 37:21SPEAKER_03: So we're not Byung Chul Han's idiots.
- 37:24SPEAKER_03: We are theory underground, specific species of idiots.
- 37:30SPEAKER_03: Um, it's, it's a difficult, it's an expert articulation of our idiocy.
- 37:35SPEAKER_03: We are master idiots.
- 37:39Um,
- 37:41SPEAKER_03: Alright.
- 37:43SPEAKER_03: Despite his lack of mathematics,
- 37:45SPEAKER_03: Bacon's view was appropriate to the scientific attitude that prevailed after him.
- 37:51SPEAKER_03: The concordance between the mind of man and the nature of things that he had in mind is patriarchal.
- 37:59SPEAKER_03: The human mind, which overcomes superstition, is to hold sway over a disenchanted nature.
- 38:07SPEAKER_03: Knowledge,
- 38:08SPEAKER_03: which is power,
- 38:09SPEAKER_03: knows no obstacles,
- 38:11SPEAKER_03: neither in the enslavement of men nor in compliance with the world's rulers.
- 38:17SPEAKER_03: As with all the ends of bourgeois economy in the factory and on the battlefield,
- 38:21SPEAKER_03: origin is no bar to the dictates of the entrepreneurs.
- 38:25SPEAKER_03: Kings, no less directly than businessmen, control technology.
- 38:30SPEAKER_03: It is as democratic as the economic system with which it is bound up.
- 38:35SPEAKER_03: Technology is the essence of this knowledge.
- 38:39SPEAKER_03: It does not work by concepts and images,
- 38:42SPEAKER_03: by the fortunate insight,
- 38:44SPEAKER_03: but refers to method,
- 38:48SPEAKER_03: the exploitation of others' work and capital.
- 38:52SPEAKER_03: The many things which, according to Bacon, are reserved are themselves no more than instrumental.
- 39:00SPEAKER_03: The radio, as a sublimated printing press,
- 39:03SPEAKER_03: the dive bomber as a more effective form of artillery, radio control as a more reliable compass.
- 39:12SPEAKER_03: What men want to learn from nature is how to use it in order wholly to dominate it and other men.
- 39:20SPEAKER_03: That is the only aim.
- 39:23SPEAKER_03: Ruthlessly,
- 39:24SPEAKER_03: in despite of itself,
- 39:25SPEAKER_03: the enlightenment has extinguished any trace of its own self-consciousness.
- 39:32SPEAKER_03: The only kind of thinking that is sufficiently hard to shatter myths is ultimately self-destructive.
- 39:38SPEAKER_03: In face of the present triumph of the factual mentality,
- 39:42SPEAKER_03: even Bacon's nominalist credo would be suspected of a metaphysical bias and come
- 39:47SPEAKER_03: under the same verdict of vanity that he pronounced on scholastic philosophy.
- 39:52SPEAKER_03: Power and knowledge are synonymous.
- 39:55SPEAKER_03: For Bacon as for Luther,
- 39:57SPEAKER_03: knowledge that tendeth but to satisfaction is but as a courtesan,
- 40:02SPEAKER_03: which is for pleasure and not for fruit or generation.
- 40:06SPEAKER_03: not satisfaction which men call truth, but operation to do the business, is the right mark.
- 40:154.
- 40:16SPEAKER_03: What is the true end,
- 40:18SPEAKER_03: scope,
- 40:19SPEAKER_03: or office of knowledge,
- 40:21SPEAKER_03: which I have set down to consist not in any plausible,
- 40:25SPEAKER_03: delectable,
- 40:26SPEAKER_03: reverend,
- 40:27SPEAKER_03: or admired discourse,
- 40:28SPEAKER_03: or any satisfactory arguments,
- 40:31SPEAKER_03: but in effecting and working and in discovery of particulars not revealed before
- 40:37SPEAKER_03: for the better endowment and help of man's life.
- 40:41SPEAKER_03: There is to be no mystery, which means, too, no wish to reveal mystery.
- 40:48SPEAKER_01: Hmm.
- 40:54SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 40:54SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 41:03SPEAKER_03: so pretty good stuff right yeah knowledge that tendeth but to satisfaction is but
- 41:13SPEAKER_03: as a courtesan which is for pleasure and not for fruit or generation not
- 41:18SPEAKER_03: satisfaction which men call truth but operation to do the business is the right
- 41:22SPEAKER_03: mark so is
- 41:28SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 41:29SPEAKER_03: So the only kind of thinking that is sufficiently hard to shatter myths is ultimately self destructive.
- 41:34SPEAKER_03: So this, this type of knowledge.
- 41:36SPEAKER_03: I think if I'm getting like this type of the type of knowledge that brought about
- 41:43SPEAKER_03: the enlightenment or the modern world that we live in is like a necessarily
- 41:50SPEAKER_03: self-destructive type of knowledge because it's instrumental from like that it is
- 41:57SPEAKER_03: that type of knowledge that is power that is instrumental it's not pleasure it's
- 42:03SPEAKER_03: not knowing for the sake of knowing it's knowing for the sake of
- 42:07SPEAKER_02: doing yeah and it's already like there's already they are teasing at the
- 42:14SPEAKER_02: contradiction that like the moment knowledge is instrumentalized it it has to
- 42:24SPEAKER_02: dominate itself now that's the trick that they do here
- 42:29SPEAKER_02: That they are like,
- 42:30SPEAKER_02: when knowledge is power,
- 42:33SPEAKER_02: but you instrumentalize knowledge,
- 42:39SPEAKER_02: then you do power against power.
- 42:43SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 42:44SPEAKER_02: It starts to debase itself.
- 42:47SPEAKER_02: It debases itself.
- 42:49SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 42:49SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 42:51SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 42:55SPEAKER_03: The disenchantment of the world is the extirpation of animism.
- 43:01SPEAKER_03: Xenophanes derides the multitude of deities because they are but replicas of the
- 43:06SPEAKER_03: men who produced them,
- 43:08SPEAKER_03: together with all that is contingent and evil in mankind,
- 43:12SPEAKER_03: and the most recent school of logic denounces,
- 43:16SPEAKER_03: for the impressions they bear,
- 43:18SPEAKER_03: the words of language,
- 43:20SPEAKER_03: holding them to be false coins better replaced by neutral counters.
- 43:25SPEAKER_03: The world becomes chaos and synthesis salvation.
- 43:28SPEAKER_03: Is that a dig at post-structuralism?
- 43:30SPEAKER_03: Yes, that is a dig at post-structuralism.
- 43:34SPEAKER_01: I think so.
- 43:38SPEAKER_03: I appreciate it because I think people took post-structuralism and instrumentalized
- 43:44SPEAKER_03: it into the post-modern bullshit we live in.
- 43:49SPEAKER_03: I want to stick up for post-modern bullshit.
- 43:52SPEAKER_03: For the postmodern, the postmodern condition, right?
- 43:55SPEAKER_03: Maybe the postmodern approach.
- 44:00SPEAKER_03: Ah, postmodern realism.
- 44:03SPEAKER_03: That's what it is.
- 44:04SPEAKER_03: I'm not a postmodernist.
- 44:05SPEAKER_03: I'm a realist about the fact that we live in postmodernity.
- 44:10SPEAKER_03: But yeah, I think post-structuralism got instrumentalized into this kind of circle jerk Pomo bullshit.
- 44:17SPEAKER_02: But I think it is kind of a dick, but I think they also pay their dues.
- 44:23SPEAKER_02: For sure.
- 44:23SPEAKER_02: Because what they say is like, they say like, okay, Xenophanes derides the multitude of deities.
- 44:29SPEAKER_02: So it's Olympic deities, right?
- 44:32SPEAKER_02: And they are replicas of the men who produced them.
- 44:36SPEAKER_02: So all these gods, they are like...
- 44:39SPEAKER_02: these fucking drunks, they rape, they are jealous, they are all of these things.
- 44:45SPEAKER_02: So can they really be gods?
- 44:49SPEAKER_02: This is the question from Xenophanes.
- 44:52SPEAKER_02: And now they say,
- 44:55SPEAKER_02: in a similar fashion,
- 44:57SPEAKER_02: the recent school of logic,
- 44:58SPEAKER_02: which I think is post-structuralism,
- 45:02SPEAKER_02: denounces the words of language.
- 45:07SPEAKER_02: And I think they...
- 45:10SPEAKER_02: The critique they make, it's an imminent critique, is that they say, like, what should replace this?
- 45:18SPEAKER_02: We are necessarily trapped.
- 45:19SPEAKER_02: We have to move through this language.
- 45:21SPEAKER_02: We cannot get some, like, what should we do?
- 45:27SPEAKER_02: We speak.
- 45:29SPEAKER_02: And I think they also say, like, language is not only a failure.
- 45:34SPEAKER_02: This is kind of like, I think, the true jab.
- 45:40SPEAKER_03: yeah i like it though and i think uh i think it it's another porqué no los dos
- 45:49SPEAKER_03: situation i think it's like yeah we this is a tension that we have to move through
- 45:54SPEAKER_03: um and yeah i think that i think they did a good job there um holding them to be
- 46:02SPEAKER_03: false coins rather holding them to be false coins better replaced by neutral
- 46:07SPEAKER_03: counters
- 46:08SPEAKER_03: the world becomes chaos and synthesis salvation.
- 46:13SPEAKER_03: There is said to be no difference between the totemic animal,
- 46:17SPEAKER_03: the dreams of the ghost seer,
- 46:19SPEAKER_03: and the absolute idea.
- 46:22SPEAKER_03: On the road to modern science.
- 46:23SPEAKER_02: That is a great jab.
- 46:24SPEAKER_02: Sorry.
- 46:25SPEAKER_02: That is the better jab.
- 46:26SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it is.
- 46:27SPEAKER_02: That's the better jab because it's like,
- 46:30SPEAKER_02: and I would really like to know what the Lacanians think about that.
- 46:34SPEAKER_02: Because they have a point there that they say it's not the same.
- 46:37SPEAKER_02: The absolute idea, Mr. Kojev, is not the dream of the ghost seer and not a totemic animal.
- 46:47SPEAKER_02: It is not all the same function, I think is what they say.
- 46:57SPEAKER_02: They have different characteristics.
- 46:59SPEAKER_02: They have different qualia.
- 47:01SPEAKER_03: Yeah, and, you know, us as the subject, like, we're attuned to them differently as well.
- 47:07SPEAKER_03: So, like, also hermeneutically, like, they already necessarily aren't the same thing.
- 47:13SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 47:14SPEAKER_03: Yeah, any Lacanians in the chat, what's up with that?
- 47:18SPEAKER_03: Or if you're watching this in the future and you're a Lacanian, leave a comment because I don't like you.
- 47:24SPEAKER_03: I don't like Lacanians.
- 47:25SPEAKER_03: No, I'm just playing.
- 47:27SPEAKER_03: I'm just playing.
- 47:28SPEAKER_03: I was being provocative.
- 47:30SPEAKER_03: Some of my best friends are Lacanians.
- 47:35SPEAKER_02: I have this one Lacanian friend, you know.
- 47:37SPEAKER_02: He says these jokes are okay.
- 47:40SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 47:41SPEAKER_03: I got permission.
- 47:46SPEAKER_03: On the road to modern science, men renounce any claim to meaning.
- 47:52SPEAKER_03: They substitute formula for concept, rule, and probability for cause and motive.
- 47:58SPEAKER_03: Fuck.
- 47:59SPEAKER_03: Hmm.
- 47:59SPEAKER_03: The latest secularization of the creative principle.
- 48:01SPEAKER_03: Hmm.
- 48:21SPEAKER_03: They were abandoned as idola theatri of the old metaphysics,
- 48:26SPEAKER_03: and assessed as being even then memorials of the elements and powers of the
- 48:32SPEAKER_03: prehistory for which life and death disclosed their nature in myths and became
- 48:38SPEAKER_03: interwoven in them.
- 48:41SPEAKER_03: The categories by which Western philosophy defined its everlasting natural order
- 48:46SPEAKER_03: marked the spots once occupied by Oncus and Persephone,
- 48:51SPEAKER_03: Ariadne and Nereus.
- 48:53SPEAKER_03: The pre-Socratic cosmologies preserve the moment of transition.
- 48:58SPEAKER_03: The moist,
- 48:59SPEAKER_03: the indivisible air and fire,
- 49:01SPEAKER_03: which they hold to be the primal matter of nature,
- 49:05SPEAKER_03: are already rationalizations of the mythic mode of apprehension.
- 49:10SPEAKER_03: just as the images of generation from water and earth,
- 49:13SPEAKER_03: which came from the Nile to the Greeks,
- 49:16SPEAKER_03: became here hylozoistic principles.
- 49:21SPEAKER_03: I don't know that word.
- 49:23SPEAKER_03: Me neither.
- 49:24SPEAKER_03: All the equivocal multitude of mythical demons were intellectualized in the pure
- 49:28SPEAKER_03: form of ontological essences.
- 49:33SPEAKER_03: Finally,
- 49:33SPEAKER_03: by means of the Platonic ideas,
- 49:35SPEAKER_03: even the patriarchal gods of Olympus were absorbed in the philosophical logos.
- 49:41SPEAKER_03: The Enlightenment,
- 49:42SPEAKER_03: however,
- 49:43SPEAKER_03: recognized the old powers in the Platonic and Aristotelian aspects of metaphysics
- 49:48SPEAKER_03: and opposed as superstition the claim that truth is predictable of universals.
- 49:54SPEAKER_03: It asserted that in the authority of universal concepts,
- 49:57SPEAKER_03: there was still discernible fear of the demonic spirits which men sought to portray
- 50:02SPEAKER_03: in magic rituals,
- 50:04SPEAKER_03: hoping thus to influence nature.
- 50:07SPEAKER_03: From now on,
- 50:08SPEAKER_03: matter would at last be mastered without any illusion of ruling or inherent powers
- 50:13SPEAKER_03: of hidden qualities.
- 50:16SPEAKER_03: For the Enlightenment, whatever does not conform to the rule of computation and utility is suspect.
- 50:24SPEAKER_03: So long as it can develop undisturbed by any outward repression, there is no holding it.
- 50:32SPEAKER_03: In the process, it treats its own idea.
- 50:35SPEAKER_02: Everything is alive or animated.
- 50:40SPEAKER_02: So it's the Hilo-Zoistic principle is the elements.
- 50:46SPEAKER_02: So, you know, the sea, the water has a character on its own.
- 50:49SPEAKER_02: It wants something and it becomes like from a spirit, which is local.
- 50:56SPEAKER_02: You know, like the tribes had like, this is our river.
- 51:00SPEAKER_02: His name is whatever the fuck, you know, like Dickie.
- 51:04SPEAKER_02: And over there is our other river.
- 51:06SPEAKER_02: It's Peaty.
- 51:08SPEAKER_02: And these were their specific spirits.
- 51:12SPEAKER_02: And in that moment, they become generalized.
- 51:14SPEAKER_02: The water as such wants something, has needs, fears, and so on.
- 51:22SPEAKER_01: Hmm.
- 51:23SPEAKER_02: everything you find, uh, in like, uh, like dumbed down form and like RPGs, you know, like fire magic.
- 51:33SPEAKER_02: Uh, I don't know.
- 51:34SPEAKER_02: What is it?
- 51:34SPEAKER_02: Um,
- 51:35SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 51:35SPEAKER_02: here,
- 51:36SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 51:37SPEAKER_02: avatar,
- 51:37SPEAKER_02: the last airbender,
- 51:39SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 51:40SPEAKER_02: the fire people don't like the water people because the fire people are the evil fascists.
- 51:50SPEAKER_02: That's, uh,
- 51:54SPEAKER_03: Oh, no, what the hell is happening?
- 51:56SPEAKER_03: YouTube's being all stupid right now.
- 51:57SPEAKER_03: I don't know what the fuck is happening.
- 52:02SPEAKER_03: It says it's not receiving.
- 52:05SPEAKER_03: Whatever, dude, I don't give a shit.
- 52:09SPEAKER_03: I do.
- 52:09SPEAKER_03: I'm I'm flustered, but whatever.
- 52:13SPEAKER_03: Adam is basically holistic animism.
- 52:17SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that.
- 52:18SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 52:22SPEAKER_03: hmm i wonder i wonder what came first the you know spirit of the river or the god
- 52:38SPEAKER_03: of water like the spirit of the river yeah it has to be this what
- 52:50SPEAKER_03: hylozoistic that has to come prior to embodied deities or even like a even like a
- 53:02SPEAKER_03: diffuse deity like that type of it is an animism that type of animism i would think
- 53:09SPEAKER_03: does precede uh a kind of concretized deity although it is interesting that
- 53:18SPEAKER_03: In that case,
- 53:18SPEAKER_03: it started abstract and then became concrete rather than...
- 53:24SPEAKER_03: Although maybe you could say that that itself is an abstraction from subjectivity.
- 53:30SPEAKER_02: It is.
- 53:31SPEAKER_02: I think it's like spirit.
- 53:34SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 53:37SPEAKER_02: Like the locus spirit, because it's the Feuerbachian thing.
- 53:43SPEAKER_02: It's like,
- 53:44SPEAKER_02: I imagine myself in that,
- 53:46SPEAKER_02: but it's my own idea that I put onto the thing,
- 53:50SPEAKER_02: the subjective onto the objective.
- 53:54SPEAKER_02: Then it moves, I think their point is, then it moves through the gods.
- 54:00SPEAKER_02: And then it moves,
- 54:03SPEAKER_02: like,
- 54:03SPEAKER_02: then it moves to elements,
- 54:04SPEAKER_02: then it,
- 54:05SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
- 54:06SPEAKER_02: wait,
- 54:06SPEAKER_02: wait,
- 54:06SPEAKER_02: let me,
- 54:08SPEAKER_02: I'm not so sure.
- 54:09SPEAKER_02: While I'm talking, I realize that I'm not so sure.
- 54:13SPEAKER_02: Just as the images of generation from water and earth,
- 54:17SPEAKER_02: which came from the Nile to the Greeks,
- 54:20SPEAKER_02: became here hylozoistic principles or elements,
- 54:25SPEAKER_02: so all the equivocal multitude of mythical demons
- 54:30SPEAKER_02: were intellectualized in the pure form of ontological essences.
- 54:46SPEAKER_03: So, yeah.
- 54:47SPEAKER_03: It is this kind of... It is... The projection... Yeah.
- 54:55SPEAKER_02: Yeah, go ahead.
- 54:56SPEAKER_03: ...that then gets reified...
- 55:00SPEAKER_03: Um, but then, but then again, gets, gets re-abstracted in, into like the logos, right?
- 55:10SPEAKER_03: It's, uh,
- 55:12SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 55:12SPEAKER_03: That's interesting.
- 55:14SPEAKER_03: It's like we can't help but project ourselves out onto the world,
- 55:21SPEAKER_03: but then we also seek concreticity in structures and systems that emerge,
- 55:27SPEAKER_03: society as such,
- 55:29SPEAKER_03: or the category,
- 55:30SPEAKER_03: nature,
- 55:31SPEAKER_03: man,
- 55:31SPEAKER_03: God.
- 55:33SPEAKER_03: So we are projecting the thing, and then we're deconstructing it
- 55:41SPEAKER_02: only to reify it once again.
- 55:45SPEAKER_02: And the, and the, and the, and the next step for me is to say it's nature doing it to itself.
- 55:52SPEAKER_02: Of course.
- 55:53SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 55:54SPEAKER_02: Because we are nature,
- 55:55SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 55:55SPEAKER_02: like these,
- 55:56SPEAKER_02: this,
- 55:57SPEAKER_02: this nature looks at itself and it's like,
- 56:01SPEAKER_02: I wonder what that over there is,
- 56:04SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 56:04SPEAKER_02: like,
- 56:05SPEAKER_02: um,
- 56:06SPEAKER_02: there is already this coming apart.
- 56:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 56:10SPEAKER_02: No, that's,
- 56:12SPEAKER_02: This,
- 56:12SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 56:12SPEAKER_02: where the point is,
- 56:13SPEAKER_02: like,
- 56:14SPEAKER_02: alienation good,
- 56:15SPEAKER_02: in a sense,
- 56:15SPEAKER_02: because,
- 56:18SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 56:18SPEAKER_02: it's maybe,
- 56:21SPEAKER_02: like,
- 56:21SPEAKER_02: this would be an interesting question.
- 56:25SPEAKER_03: I would say alienation is necessary.
- 56:29SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 56:30SPEAKER_02: Now.
- 56:30SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 56:31SPEAKER_02: But I would say alienation progress.
- 56:36SPEAKER_03: I would say that, yes, because it's a necessary part of that progress.
- 56:45SPEAKER_03: But I think then if we say good or bad,
- 56:48SPEAKER_03: I think we run the risk of doing this thing where we are subverting ourselves to it
- 56:53SPEAKER_03: once again.
- 56:54SPEAKER_03: That's why I push back on the accelerationists and say, no, it's not a good thing.
- 57:00SPEAKER_03: It's a necessary thing.
- 57:02SPEAKER_03: We are good.
- 57:03SPEAKER_03: We are where good comes from.
- 57:05SPEAKER_03: So if we mislocate good and bad,
- 57:10SPEAKER_03: then we run the risk of becoming instrumentalized for this diffuse,
- 57:14SPEAKER_03: natural process.
- 57:16SPEAKER_03: So while you're right, it is good with a small g.
- 57:22SPEAKER_03: Because that's another condition of possibility for all the amazing things we're doing.
- 57:30SPEAKER_03: I think when people try to say good with a capital G, that's wrong.
- 57:37SPEAKER_03: Because you're locating the divine spark in the rock as opposed to in the soul of man.
- 57:48SPEAKER_02: That's true.
- 57:49SPEAKER_02: But the whole move, I think, which they will continue is that thinking follows this trajectory.
- 58:00SPEAKER_02: It's only by externalizing it, by this form of alienation.
- 58:06SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 58:08SPEAKER_02: That thinking can, like the good in human...
- 58:12SPEAKER_02: can only appear um once this process is happening in this sense we are both right
- 58:19SPEAKER_03: so it's it's necessarily a dialectic it's necessarily a dialectic yeah yeah and i'm
- 58:24SPEAKER_03: it's everything they do yeah i'm good with that i like that um yeah yeah por qué no
- 58:36SPEAKER_03: los dos
- 58:39SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 58:40SPEAKER_03: All right.
- 58:42SPEAKER_03: Enlightenment.
- 58:42SPEAKER_03: Should I continue or do you want to continue?
- 58:45SPEAKER_03: Actually, yeah, I'm going to make another tea if you want to grab the next one.
- 58:50SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, let's do that.
- 58:51SPEAKER_02: All right.
- 58:55SPEAKER_02: Enlightenment has always taken the basic principle of myth to be anthropomorphism,
- 59:01SPEAKER_02: the projection onto nature of the subjective.
- 59:06SPEAKER_02: In this view,
- 59:07SPEAKER_02: the supernatural,
- 59:08SPEAKER_02: spirits and demons are mirror images of men who allow themselves to be frightened
- 59:15SPEAKER_02: by natural phenomena.
- 59:18SPEAKER_02: Consequently,
- 59:19SPEAKER_02: the many mythic figures can all be brought to a common denominator and reduced to
- 59:26SPEAKER_02: the human subject.
- 59:28SPEAKER_02: Oedipus answered to this thing's riddle.
- 59:31SPEAKER_02: It is man, is the enlightenment stereotype
- 59:35SPEAKER_02: repeatedly offered as information,
- 59:38SPEAKER_02: irrespective of whether it is faced with a piece of objective intelligence,
- 59:44SPEAKER_02: a bare schematization,
- 59:46SPEAKER_02: fear of evil powers,
- 59:48SPEAKER_02: or hope of redemption.
- 59:51SPEAKER_02: In advance, the enlightenment recognizes as being and occurrence only
- 1:00:00SPEAKER_02: In advance, the enlightenment recognizes as being and occurrence only what can be apprehended in unity.
- 1:00:09SPEAKER_02: Its ideal is the system from which all and everything flows.
- 1:00:16SPEAKER_02: Its rationalist and empiricist versions do not part company on that point.
- 1:00:23SPEAKER_02: Even though the individual schools may interpret the axioms differently,
- 1:00:29SPEAKER_02: the structure of scientific unity has always been the same.
- 1:00:35SPEAKER_02: Bacon's postulate of Una Scientia Universalis,
- 1:00:39SPEAKER_02: Una Universale Wissenschaft,
- 1:00:41SPEAKER_02: whatever the number of fields of research is as inimical to the unassignable as
- 1:00:49SPEAKER_02: Leibniz' Mathesis Universalis,
- 1:00:55SPEAKER_02: Universal Mathematics,
- 1:00:57SPEAKER_02: is to discontinuity.
- 1:01:01SPEAKER_02: multiplicity of forms is reduced to position and arrangement history to fact things
- 1:01:09SPEAKER_02: to matter according to bacon too
- 1:01:14SPEAKER_02: Degrees of universality provide an unequivocal logical connection between first
- 1:01:20SPEAKER_02: principles and observational judgments.
- 1:01:25SPEAKER_02: The maistre mocks him for harboring une idolle de chelles.
- 1:01:30SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_02: I have not looked up this.
- 1:01:34SPEAKER_02: Une idolle de chelles.
- 1:01:37SPEAKER_02: My French is too bad to translate this because it's almost not existing.
- 1:01:42SPEAKER_02: Formal logic.
- 1:01:44SPEAKER_02: was the major school of unified science.
- 1:01:49SPEAKER_02: It provided the Enlightenment thinkers with the schema of the calculability of the world.
- 1:01:56SPEAKER_02: The mythologizing equation of ideas with numbers in Plato's last writings expresses
- 1:02:03SPEAKER_02: the longing of all demythologization.
- 1:02:10SPEAKER_02: Number became the canon of the Enlightenment.
- 1:02:15SPEAKER_02: The same equations dominated bourgeois justice and community exchange.
- 1:02:23SPEAKER_02: It's not the rule.
- 1:02:24SPEAKER_02: I have to look this up because I don't know Latin.
- 1:02:43SPEAKER_02: If to unequals, you add equals, all will be unequal.
- 1:02:48SPEAKER_02: That's what that's translated to.
- 1:02:50SPEAKER_02: If to unequals, you add equals, all will be unequal.
- 1:02:56SPEAKER_02: Is not this rule an axiom of justice as well as of the mathematics?
- 1:03:02SPEAKER_02: And is there not a true coincidence between commutative and distributive justice?
- 1:03:09SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 1:03:10SPEAKER_02: and arithmetical and geometrical proportion.
- 1:03:14SPEAKER_02: This was a quote by Bacon.
- 1:03:18SPEAKER_02: Bourgeois society is ruled by equivalence.
- 1:03:22SPEAKER_02: It makes the dissimilar comparable by reducing it to abstract quantities.
- 1:03:28SPEAKER_02: To the enlightenment that which does not reduce to numbers and ultimately to the one becomes illusion.
- 1:03:37SPEAKER_02: Modern positivism writes it off as literature.
- 1:03:42SPEAKER_02: unity is the slogan from parmenides to russell the destruction of gods and
- 1:03:48SPEAKER_02: qualities alike is insisted upon yet the myths which fell victim to the
- 1:03:55SPEAKER_02: enlightenment were its own products
- 1:04:00SPEAKER_02: In the scientific calculation of occurrence,
- 1:04:03SPEAKER_02: the computation is annulled,
- 1:04:06SPEAKER_02: which thought had once transferred from occurrence into myths.
- 1:04:12SPEAKER_02: Myth, intended report, naming, the narration of the beginning.
- 1:04:20SPEAKER_02: but also presentation, confirmation, explanation.
- 1:04:25SPEAKER_02: A tendency that grew stronger with the recording and collection of myths.
- 1:04:32SPEAKER_02: Narrative became didactic at an early stage.
- 1:04:36SPEAKER_02: Every ritual includes the idea of activity as a determined process which magic can
- 1:04:44SPEAKER_02: nevertheless influence.
- 1:04:47SPEAKER_02: This theoretical element in ritual won independence in the earliest national epics.
- 1:04:54SPEAKER_02: The myths,
- 1:04:55SPEAKER_02: as the tragedians came upon them,
- 1:04:59SPEAKER_02: are already characterized by the disciple and power that Bacon celebrated as the
- 1:05:06SPEAKER_02: right mark.
- 1:05:07SPEAKER_02: In place of the local spirits and demons, there appeared heaven and its hierarchy.
- 1:05:14SPEAKER_02: In place of the invocations of the magician and the tribe,
- 1:05:18SPEAKER_02: the distinct gradation of sacrifice and the labor of the unfree mediated through
- 1:05:25SPEAKER_02: the word of command.
- 1:05:28SPEAKER_02: The Olympic deities are no longer directly identical with elements, but signify them.
- 1:05:36SPEAKER_02: In Homer,
- 1:05:37SPEAKER_02: Zeus represents the sky and the weather,
- 1:05:41SPEAKER_02: Apollo controls the sun,
- 1:05:43SPEAKER_02: and Helios and Eos are already shifting to an allegorical function.
- 1:05:50SPEAKER_02: The gods are distinguished from material elements as their quintessential concepts.
- 1:05:57SPEAKER_02: From now on,
- 1:05:59SPEAKER_02: being divides into the logos,
- 1:06:02SPEAKER_02: which with the progress of philosophy contracts to the monate,
- 1:06:07SPEAKER_02: to a mere point of reference,
- 1:06:10SPEAKER_02: and into the mass of all things and creatures without.
- 1:06:15SPEAKER_02: The single distinction between existence proper and reality engulfs all others.
- 1:06:24SPEAKER_02: Without regard to distinctions, the world becomes subject to man.
- 1:06:30SPEAKER_02: in this the jewish creation narrative and the religion of olympia are at one quote
- 1:06:39SPEAKER_02: and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the fowl of the air
- 1:06:44SPEAKER_02: and over the cattle and over all the earth and over every creeping thing that
- 1:06:49SPEAKER_02: creepeth upon the earth that is from genesis 1 26
- 1:06:56SPEAKER_02: and quote o zeus father zeus yours is the dominion of the heavens and you oversee
- 1:07:04SPEAKER_02: the works of man both wicked and just and even the wantonness of the beasts and the
- 1:07:11SPEAKER_02: righteousness is your concern and this is from archilochos
- 1:07:19SPEAKER_02: For so it is that one atones straight away and another later.
- 1:07:25SPEAKER_02: But should one escape and the threatening decree of the gods not reach him yet,
- 1:07:32SPEAKER_02: it will certainly be visited at last,
- 1:07:35SPEAKER_02: if not upon him,
- 1:07:36SPEAKER_02: then upon his children or another generation.
- 1:07:41SPEAKER_02: This is from Solon.
- 1:07:45SPEAKER_02: Only he who always submits survives in the face of the gods.
- 1:07:50SPEAKER_02: The awakening of the self is paid for by the acknowledgement of power as the principle of all relations.
- 1:08:04SPEAKER_02: Should I continue?
- 1:08:05SPEAKER_02: Do we have anything to... That was a chunk.
- 1:08:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah, so I think...
- 1:08:15SPEAKER_03: what I'm getting is like just saying like knowledge,
- 1:08:29SPEAKER_03: um,
- 1:08:31SPEAKER_03: context,
- 1:08:33SPEAKER_03: like,
- 1:08:34SPEAKER_03: like the,
- 1:08:34SPEAKER_03: the categories,
- 1:08:35SPEAKER_03: the split between man and nature and even God have always been this kind of
- 1:08:43SPEAKER_03: dialectical process.
- 1:08:46SPEAKER_03: um and we've always used them rather they've always been used by power or like
- 1:08:59SPEAKER_03: structures with power to kind of like legitimate that power the you know the
- 1:09:03SPEAKER_03: authority of the king or the virtuousness of the church or whatever like it's
- 1:09:08SPEAKER_03: always been this thing that that gets instrumentalized and um
- 1:09:15SPEAKER_03: Maybe there are a few sages,
- 1:09:17SPEAKER_03: a few wise men that have deep insight,
- 1:09:20SPEAKER_03: but for the most part,
- 1:09:22SPEAKER_03: the common man has always been at the mercy and whim of these...
- 1:09:35SPEAKER_03: these dialectics like the way they're laying it out they're very much like this is
- 1:09:39SPEAKER_03: a like a co-creation type situation we are the ones doing the thing that we are uh
- 1:09:48SPEAKER_03: critiquing like we are we are the ones doing the thinking and we are thinking about
- 1:09:54SPEAKER_03: the thinking that we are doing but it takes thinking to be able to think about
- 1:09:59SPEAKER_03: thinking like it's it's always yes it's always this dialectic um and they're
- 1:10:05SPEAKER_03: they're uh problematizing how it has been used as like a legitimating narrative by
- 1:10:13SPEAKER_03: power structures um
- 1:10:15SPEAKER_03: be it political or sociological, cultural, whatever.
- 1:10:22SPEAKER_03: Like talking about God,
- 1:10:24SPEAKER_03: like God gives us dominion over the earth and this and that,
- 1:10:28SPEAKER_03: but we subjugate ourselves to God,
- 1:10:31SPEAKER_03: and so...
- 1:10:33SPEAKER_02: I think they go even a step further.
- 1:10:36SPEAKER_02: They say it's only thinking itself is this power.
- 1:10:43SPEAKER_02: It is necessary.
- 1:10:45SPEAKER_02: This making everything exchangeable.
- 1:10:53SPEAKER_02: making everything fungible, reducing it to the one, to the number, is already in the magical ritual.
- 1:11:01SPEAKER_02: The ritual is already a form of technology, is what they say.
- 1:11:05SPEAKER_03: Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:11:07SPEAKER_02: Magic is already a form of technology.
- 1:11:11SPEAKER_02: And we gained, while we...
- 1:11:17SPEAKER_02: instantiated even the notion of power, the structure of power, we also gained it.
- 1:11:27SPEAKER_02: It was already an exchange.
- 1:11:29SPEAKER_02: That's what I meant when I said, in a sense, they say that enlightenment is capital.
- 1:11:35SPEAKER_02: yeah it's the same move from like um you know in the commodity form everything is
- 1:11:42SPEAKER_02: fudgible yes it's labor so yeah things and humans already move into this um
- 1:11:53SPEAKER_02: exchange relation and it's interesting because it's very similar to cushion
- 1:11:57SPEAKER_02: karantani yeah yeah what they do here humans already go into this exchange relation
- 1:12:03SPEAKER_02: with nature
- 1:12:05SPEAKER_02: And in a sense, nature loses, but in the moment nature loses, also the humans lose.
- 1:12:13SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 1:12:13SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 1:12:15SPEAKER_02: Because we make ourselves similar and we lose like the qualia of the objects are lost.
- 1:12:24SPEAKER_02: You know, the objects just become things.
- 1:12:28SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:12:28SPEAKER_02: They become reified.
- 1:12:29SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:12:30SPEAKER_02: The river is not...
- 1:12:32SPEAKER_02: any longer my special river, I don't know, Petey, my river spirit.
- 1:12:38SPEAKER_03: It's not Petey, it's just the river, the inframed river that's just a resource.
- 1:12:46SPEAKER_03: We only look at it for the utility.
- 1:12:50SPEAKER_03: I like that a lot.
- 1:12:50SPEAKER_03: I think that's
- 1:12:53SPEAKER_03: the fact that they're using magic or that they're like talking about,
- 1:12:57SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:12:58SPEAKER_03: magic and,
- 1:12:59SPEAKER_03: and existing power structures and stuff.
- 1:13:01SPEAKER_03: I like it a lot because I, it is, it is magic and it is this technology of reification and legitimation.
- 1:13:11SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 1:13:14SPEAKER_03: I take that to language itself.
- 1:13:17SPEAKER_03: Language itself is this technology.
- 1:13:22SPEAKER_03: It's not the medium of thought, but it is the medium of expression.
- 1:13:28SPEAKER_03: Now, it also becomes the medium of thought.
- 1:13:31SPEAKER_03: It is true that when you think, you are thinking
- 1:13:38SPEAKER_03: in language but but i do think there's there is a remainder here there is a surplus
- 1:13:47SPEAKER_03: of thought that isn't codified that isn't yeah instrumentalized and that's why we
- 1:13:55SPEAKER_03: spend so much time trying like trying to express that surplus trying to express
- 1:14:01SPEAKER_03: that remainder um
- 1:14:05SPEAKER_03: But yeah, this shit's fire.
- 1:14:08SPEAKER_03: I love this shit.
- 1:14:10SPEAKER_02: Right?
- 1:14:11SPEAKER_02: Right?
- 1:14:14SPEAKER_02: And I think we will get there.
- 1:14:15SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:14:16SPEAKER_02: They move into that because it's already happening with like,
- 1:14:21SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:14:21SPEAKER_02: like when,
- 1:14:22SPEAKER_02: because as much as a jab they took,
- 1:14:26SPEAKER_02: they say, like, Apollon signifies.
- 1:14:29SPEAKER_02: In German, they say represents.
- 1:14:32SPEAKER_02: In German, it's represents.
- 1:14:34SPEAKER_02: But it doesn't matter because it's the same function.
- 1:14:37SPEAKER_02: It's not wrong that they signify there.
- 1:14:42SPEAKER_02: There is already a certain separation.
- 1:14:46SPEAKER_02: And they go even further with it because they go towards the image and the word.
- 1:14:52SPEAKER_02: Because,
- 1:14:52SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 1:14:52SPEAKER_02: when they speak about ritual and language,
- 1:14:55SPEAKER_02: ritual and magic,
- 1:14:56SPEAKER_02: they have to speak about images and words,
- 1:15:04SPEAKER_02: incantations.
- 1:15:06SPEAKER_03: Adam asks, which represents?
- 1:15:10SPEAKER_03: Repräsentieren.
- 1:15:10SPEAKER_02: Repräsentieren.
- 1:15:18SPEAKER_03: Well, he said vertreten, which I don't know.
- 1:15:23SPEAKER_03: That's like value or darstellen.
- 1:15:27SPEAKER_02: Vertreten is like, um, um, um, I act in your place.
- 1:15:35SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 1:15:35SPEAKER_02: And darstellen is, uh, yeah, but let me, let me look it up.
- 1:15:41SPEAKER_02: I have to German here.
- 1:15:46SPEAKER_03: That's a good question, Adam, to focus on.
- 1:15:52SPEAKER_03: Which word is it?
- 1:15:55SPEAKER_02: That's in German.
- 1:15:56SPEAKER_02: That's with these Germans.
- 1:15:58SPEAKER_03: It's always, yeah.
- 1:15:59SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:15:59SPEAKER_03: Well, Jesus.
- 1:16:01SPEAKER_03: We've spent hours.
- 1:16:04SPEAKER_03: on one word and like why did he use this one word rather than this one synonym like
- 1:16:10SPEAKER_03: why this specific word so i think it is always worth it with especially like
- 1:16:15SPEAKER_03: representation representation is a word that does a lot of work yeah so it is worth
- 1:16:25SPEAKER_02: getting to the bottom of it and that takes time which i will take right now
- 1:16:36SPEAKER_02: Because I'm not a thing on demand.
- 1:16:40SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:16:40SPEAKER_03: You are not a robot.
- 1:16:41SPEAKER_03: You have not been in framed.
- 1:16:43SPEAKER_02: I'm, I'm, I'm maybe I'm that's part of me.
- 1:16:47SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:16:49SPEAKER_02: Only part.
- 1:16:50SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:16:50SPEAKER_02: Only part.
- 1:16:54SPEAKER_02: Ah, sie bedeuten sie.
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_02: Ah.
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_02: Sie bedeuten sie?
- 1:16:59SPEAKER_02: Bedeuten, which is pretty good, I think, to translate as signify.
- 1:17:07SPEAKER_01: Mean.
- 1:17:10SPEAKER_02: Mean.
- 1:17:11SPEAKER_02: Mean.
- 1:17:12SPEAKER_02: Imply.
- 1:17:13SPEAKER_02: Mean.
- 1:17:14SPEAKER_02: They mean them.
- 1:17:15SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 1:17:17SPEAKER_03: Interesting.
- 1:17:18SPEAKER_03: Now...
- 1:17:20SPEAKER_03: Mean is another word that I think it would be funny to kind of hystericize that word,
- 1:17:30SPEAKER_03: but I don't think it's necessary right now.
- 1:17:35SPEAKER_03: We can be comfortable with like mean as in.
- 1:17:40SPEAKER_03: Well, what is it?
- 1:17:41SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:17:42SPEAKER_03: What does it feel like?
- 1:17:45SPEAKER_02: In German, it's like the word bedeuten.
- 1:17:48SPEAKER_02: It's like bedeuten is point at.
- 1:17:52SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:17:52SPEAKER_02: So it's like the active verb for pointing at something.
- 1:17:58SPEAKER_02: So the sentence is, so signify is better, I think, than mean.
- 1:18:04SPEAKER_02: Because signify, I think, implies that you signify at something.
- 1:18:09SPEAKER_02: And with mean, it's like, who means what?
- 1:18:14SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:18:14SPEAKER_02: No, it's more free-floating, I think, than signify, right?
- 1:18:20SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:18:26SPEAKER_03: It's not embodied or predicated upon the actions of an individual or whatever.
- 1:18:34SPEAKER_03: uh it is this kind of diffuse meaning that can be imbued by god it can also be
- 1:18:39SPEAKER_03: imbued by a signification or a representation so yeah i do think that is good uh
- 1:18:51SPEAKER_03: hold on i'm trying to trying to post this on substack i should have done that two
- 1:18:57SPEAKER_03: hours ago before we started uh
- 1:19:03SPEAKER_03: And now I'm trying to do it right now.
- 1:19:08SPEAKER_03: I need someone to do that for me.
- 1:19:11SPEAKER_03: I need a social manager.
- 1:19:18SPEAKER_02: Yeah, Adam, I get what you mean that you could represent water or be water.
- 1:19:27SPEAKER_02: The point is that it's symbolic.
- 1:19:31SPEAKER_02: and that that it's it moves from the from the symbolic representation of elements
- 1:19:37SPEAKER_02: which are more concrete in nature towards um when when they speak about the
- 1:19:45SPEAKER_02: allegorical that is already going and to do more abstract i could look up because
- 1:19:54SPEAKER_02: that's what i thought about helios is i think helios is the dawn
- 1:20:01SPEAKER_02: Or is he the Smith?
- 1:20:06SPEAKER_02: Helios.
- 1:20:08SPEAKER_02: He's the personification of the sun.
- 1:20:10SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 1:20:15SPEAKER_02: But, you know, like, Apollon carries the sun.
- 1:20:19SPEAKER_02: Helios is the god of the sun.
- 1:20:21SPEAKER_02: You know, like, weird stuff already happens.
- 1:20:24SPEAKER_02: Like,
- 1:20:27SPEAKER_02: weird stuff is always happening.
- 1:20:33SPEAKER_03: Uh, it is this kind of dialectic process of, uh, co-creation that's always happening.
- 1:20:45SPEAKER_03: Um, and it is meaning it is signification.
- 1:20:51SPEAKER_03: It is representation, but it's also existence as such.
- 1:20:56SPEAKER_03: And it's also kind of,
- 1:20:59SPEAKER_03: the kind of being that can be taken for granted.
- 1:21:04SPEAKER_03: Once again, making recourse to nature, making recourse to these a priori things that just are.
- 1:21:12SPEAKER_03: You can't do anything about it.
- 1:21:17SPEAKER_03: But that's weird.
- 1:21:18SPEAKER_03: That itself is fucking weird.
- 1:21:20SPEAKER_03: It is weird that we do find ourselves already here.
- 1:21:25SPEAKER_02: Like, that's weird.
- 1:21:27SPEAKER_02: That is weird.
- 1:21:28SPEAKER_02: That is weird.
- 1:21:29SPEAKER_02: That is weird.
- 1:21:31SPEAKER_02: And I think that's what I also meant with good.
- 1:21:32SPEAKER_02: It's like, why did people start that?
- 1:21:35SPEAKER_02: Yeah, that's the big question.
- 1:21:36SPEAKER_02: Why did people... It could be a blip.
- 1:21:40SPEAKER_02: You know, it just happened so...
- 1:21:43SPEAKER_02: But I think the evolution theory is not utter garbage when it comes to that.
- 1:21:53SPEAKER_02: There must have been a reason why we were the animals who started doing all this shit.
- 1:22:00SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 1:22:04SPEAKER_02: And I think it comes out of a need, it comes out of an urge.
- 1:22:09SPEAKER_02: Like there was an urge.
- 1:22:10SPEAKER_03: Yeah, there's a surplus.
- 1:22:12SPEAKER_03: There's a surplus desire for meaning.
- 1:22:19SPEAKER_03: There's a surplus desire for context.
- 1:22:24SPEAKER_03: for a type of justification that gets turned into this really instrumental capital
- 1:22:34SPEAKER_03: economic justification but in in reality like it's it's like no i am longing i am
- 1:22:41SPEAKER_03: longing for completion in some in some way that has to do with meaning and because
- 1:22:47SPEAKER_03: uh
- 1:22:51SPEAKER_03: Capital, language, God, magic, like all these things can be thought of as types of technology.
- 1:22:58SPEAKER_03: to to kind of satisfy that need because that need necessary that desire whatever it
- 1:23:05SPEAKER_03: just by virtue of the way it works it cannot be satisfied and so like we have to be
- 1:23:11SPEAKER_03: willing to take a step back and say i am going to pursue the thing that cannot be
- 1:23:16SPEAKER_03: caught and it is through the pursuit that i will get the satisfaction
- 1:23:24SPEAKER_03: But the thing itself can never be caught.
- 1:23:26SPEAKER_03: So we should never approach anything with this completionist point of view.
- 1:23:35SPEAKER_02: And I think that's the abstract.
- 1:23:37SPEAKER_02: That's the exchange value.
- 1:23:43SPEAKER_02: yeah yeah yeah yeah that's the the to be able to because i just had this image you
- 1:23:49SPEAKER_02: know like of course i'm imagining myself as like these people i cannot um but i'm
- 1:23:55SPEAKER_02: still trying like there's something and i i get what they mean because there's
- 1:24:01SPEAKER_02: something um maybe even comforting in like you know like they started this with
- 1:24:07SPEAKER_02: like enlightenment what is it again enlightenment
- 1:24:12SPEAKER_02: purpose was always to um because at first oh to to take away animism or whatever to
- 1:24:22SPEAKER_02: take away uh to take away the fear from the human yeah and and put them into
- 1:24:28SPEAKER_02: sovereignty yeah and in german it's it's in german it's even harder because they
- 1:24:33SPEAKER_02: say um uh to make them lords um
- 1:24:41SPEAKER_02: um and so it's like okay you are this half ape creature and uh your child is
- 1:24:51SPEAKER_02: falling into the water and dying and you cannot really make sense of this you know
- 1:24:56SPEAKER_02: like when like animals don't really get it uh in a sense they get it but they don't
- 1:25:03SPEAKER_02: at the same time they and you stand in front of the yeah
- 1:25:11SPEAKER_03: I think they get the animal side of it.
- 1:25:16SPEAKER_03: There is a simple... I want to say metabolic.
- 1:25:28SPEAKER_03: Because that word does a lot of work for me and my point of view and my project or whatever.
- 1:25:35SPEAKER_03: But metabolic isn't the right thing.
- 1:25:37SPEAKER_03: But there is a very simple 1 plus 1 equals 2 operation that's going on.
- 1:25:43SPEAKER_03: The endocrine system.
- 1:25:46SPEAKER_03: It is a very... It is a mathematic thing.
- 1:25:51SPEAKER_03: But because there's this...
- 1:25:55SPEAKER_03: I think it's an open space in the human consciousness or whatever.
- 1:26:00SPEAKER_03: There is more than the mathematic than the one plus one equals two.
- 1:26:05SPEAKER_03: There's this open space where the emotion of fear starts to set in.
- 1:26:09SPEAKER_03: It's not the physiological response of fear, adrenaline.
- 1:26:14SPEAKER_03: I have to run and catch my baby.
- 1:26:15SPEAKER_03: I have to run from the tiger.
- 1:26:17SPEAKER_03: I have to do this.
- 1:26:18SPEAKER_03: But because there's subjectivity and because there is this like from my subjective position,
- 1:26:24SPEAKER_03: it's going to hurt when the tiger bites me from my subjective situation.
- 1:26:28SPEAKER_03: It's going to make me sad when my baby drowns in the river like.
- 1:26:33SPEAKER_02: so it's a surplus yeah and in a sense to say like to to to get a tool um out of
- 1:26:41SPEAKER_02: this horrible like like i always imagine like how horrible must it have you know
- 1:26:47SPEAKER_02: like how horrible to to say like okay we invent something there must be a spirit
- 1:26:52SPEAKER_02: you know this other guy comes and is like no no there is some power in the water we
- 1:26:59SPEAKER_02: have to think about this this was already thinking yeah
- 1:27:04SPEAKER_02: This is the point about, you know, like this.
- 1:27:08SPEAKER_02: It's not savagery in the sense we always associate it with this hardcore racist.
- 1:27:15SPEAKER_02: anthropology, we have this like, um, these half humans in mind.
- 1:27:23SPEAKER_02: And I don't, I always have like, I don't know how the fuck these people were actually behaving.
- 1:27:28SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:27:29SPEAKER_02: But I know that they were humans and that they were thinking, I think that's what they are getting at.
- 1:27:34SPEAKER_02: They, they think this through now.
- 1:27:37SPEAKER_03: So is that, is that trans historicizing?
- 1:27:44SPEAKER_03: Is that,
- 1:27:46SPEAKER_02: doing a disservice to modern man no i don't think so because uh when they move
- 1:27:56SPEAKER_02: further along you know like um i can say that they couldn't right right right right
- 1:28:03SPEAKER_02: right right that's the point like right okay that's why i say i have no fucking
- 1:28:09SPEAKER_02: clue how these people were yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah okay
- 1:28:13SPEAKER_02: but there was already something happening back then that I can recognize now.
- 1:28:17SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:28:18SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:28:18SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:28:20SPEAKER_02: That leaves open, uh,
- 1:28:25SPEAKER_03: my, like my position on capital, my position on artificial intelligence.
- 1:28:32SPEAKER_03: Uh, it's a position that Mikey and Dave share.
- 1:28:35SPEAKER_03: It's a position that Elliot Rosenstock kind of vaguely gestured at recently when he
- 1:28:41SPEAKER_03: responded to,
- 1:28:42SPEAKER_03: to Nick land after Nick land came on theory underground and we talked to him.
- 1:28:47SPEAKER_03: And,
- 1:28:47SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:28:47SPEAKER_03: it's something that I think I tried to,
- 1:28:49SPEAKER_03: I tried to point to when we were talking to Nick land,
- 1:28:52SPEAKER_03: but I didn't do a good job,
- 1:28:52SPEAKER_03: but like,
- 1:28:55SPEAKER_03: Subjectivity, back then when we were cavemen fighting tigers, there was something different about us.
- 1:29:05SPEAKER_03: There wasn't necessarily something different about us, or else we wouldn't be here today.
- 1:29:10SPEAKER_03: The reason we came up with all these technologies is because the possibility for
- 1:29:18SPEAKER_03: history to unfold the way it has existed in the first place.
- 1:29:20SPEAKER_03: So the future, even back then, was a virtual potential.
- 1:29:25SPEAKER_03: That had to exist.
- 1:29:26SPEAKER_03: And that potential is predicated on emerging subjectivity or whatever.
- 1:29:31SPEAKER_03: And so...
- 1:29:33SPEAKER_03: When people today talk about artificial intelligence and algorithmic intelligence
- 1:29:39SPEAKER_03: or instrumental reason or just intelligence in general,
- 1:29:45SPEAKER_03: Rahul,
- 1:29:47SPEAKER_03: I talked to him a little bit.
- 1:29:48SPEAKER_03: I'm looking forward to talking to him about intelligence because he does like
- 1:29:52SPEAKER_03: machine intelligence from my understanding.
- 1:29:56SPEAKER_03: And I am interested in human intelligence.
- 1:30:00SPEAKER_03: But the thing that he and I both share in common is intelligence itself.
- 1:30:04SPEAKER_03: So there's this instrumental, machinic, mechanical, arithmetic intelligence.
- 1:30:11SPEAKER_03: And then there's the soft, squishy human intelligence.
- 1:30:17SPEAKER_03: And there are people who conflate the two.
- 1:30:21SPEAKER_03: And I think Nick Land and his brand of accelerationists conflate that arithmetic,
- 1:30:28SPEAKER_03: algorithmic,
- 1:30:29SPEAKER_03: one plus one always equals two type of intelligence with human subjectivity,
- 1:30:35SPEAKER_03: human consciousness,
- 1:30:37SPEAKER_03: the human animal,
- 1:30:38SPEAKER_03: whatever it is.
- 1:30:40SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:30:42SPEAKER_03: And I think that's not just a horrible mistake, but I think it's like missing something.
- 1:30:49SPEAKER_03: the huge part that like, no cavemen were already necessarily different from other apes.
- 1:30:58SPEAKER_03: Uh,
- 1:30:59SPEAKER_03: and,
- 1:30:59SPEAKER_03: and they kind of within them,
- 1:31:01SPEAKER_03: they contained the acorn that grew into this giant Oak tree of the world that we
- 1:31:05SPEAKER_03: live in today.
- 1:31:06SPEAKER_03: Um, but there are people who think machines will never have this type of intelligence.
- 1:31:12SPEAKER_03: And there are people who think,
- 1:31:15SPEAKER_03: There's no such thing as this type of intelligence that humans and algorithms
- 1:31:19SPEAKER_03: already share the same species of intelligence.
- 1:31:23SPEAKER_03: So there's like,
- 1:31:25SPEAKER_03: again,
- 1:31:25SPEAKER_03: people take it all the way down to this binary of machines will never get it or it
- 1:31:31SPEAKER_03: doesn't even exist in the first place.
- 1:31:32SPEAKER_03: There is already no difference between us and the machines.
- 1:31:36SPEAKER_03: And I think that's just patently false.
- 1:31:38SPEAKER_03: It is the case that human subjectivity exists.
- 1:31:43SPEAKER_03: We find ourselves already here.
- 1:31:48SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:31:50SPEAKER_02: And I mean, finish your thought.
- 1:31:53SPEAKER_02: Sorry, I didn't want to interrupt you.
- 1:31:55SPEAKER_03: I also think it's true that machines contain that seed.
- 1:32:03SPEAKER_03: I think machines have that acorn as well.
- 1:32:08SPEAKER_02: then machines will be nature.
- 1:32:11SPEAKER_02: That will be human subjectivity.
- 1:32:14SPEAKER_02: It's already,
- 1:32:15SPEAKER_02: in this sense,
- 1:32:17SPEAKER_02: that's where I think you can imagine this mega-otherness in a very megalomaniac way
- 1:32:27SPEAKER_02: because it's very grandstanding.
- 1:32:31SPEAKER_02: It's very magical exactly in the way.
- 1:32:34SPEAKER_02: It's mythologizing.
- 1:32:35SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 1:32:36SPEAKER_02: And maybe in a sense, it's also like unreason in this sense, because it mythologizes this movement.
- 1:32:50SPEAKER_02: It fetishizes this...
- 1:32:53SPEAKER_02: this pretty stupid one plus one is two,
- 1:32:57SPEAKER_02: and we can reduce everything to this,
- 1:32:59SPEAKER_02: which is actually pretty stupid.
- 1:33:01SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:33:05SPEAKER_02: The uniformity, and out of the uniformity, you imagine something representing radical otherness for you.
- 1:33:17SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 1:33:19SPEAKER_02: for you it's it's it is a human that's thinking about it and it is um it's humans
- 1:33:26SPEAKER_02: who build who's building it yeah this will be nature there is no way to to
- 1:33:31SPEAKER_02: disentangle this that is already the dialectic the dialectic is already in that
- 1:33:36SPEAKER_02: capital living capital that's already there yeah they are connected so
- 1:33:48SPEAKER_03: I just got really excited.
- 1:33:50SPEAKER_03: And the part of my brain that's dedicated to Heidegger,
- 1:33:54SPEAKER_03: the neurons started firing because I think he gets this wrong.
- 1:34:04SPEAKER_03: I think he makes a hard distinction between the world and technology.
- 1:34:14SPEAKER_03: And I just realized I make no distinction.
- 1:34:20SPEAKER_03: Just as man is a man is part of nature.
- 1:34:23SPEAKER_03: Technology is part of man.
- 1:34:27SPEAKER_03: So I don't, I don't know.
- 1:34:28SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 1:34:29SPEAKER_03: but the Heidegger part of my brain,
- 1:34:31SPEAKER_03: just the neurons started firing because I think in framing or technology,
- 1:34:37SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:34:38SPEAKER_03: is,
- 1:34:41SPEAKER_03: a type of human metabolic activity or the result of a certain type of human activity in the world.
- 1:34:51SPEAKER_03: But it's not the only kind of activity.
- 1:34:54SPEAKER_03: No.
- 1:34:55SPEAKER_03: In this totalized totalitarian world, it becomes the only type of activity to us.
- 1:34:59SPEAKER_03: And in this way, because this type of power, this type of instrumental activity is self-defeating.
- 1:35:07SPEAKER_03: I think it is.
- 1:35:08SPEAKER_03: Yes.
- 1:35:09SPEAKER_03: If we don't escape, we will extinguish the human spark.
- 1:35:13SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:35:15SPEAKER_03: And the world we live in today is that totalized totalitarian world.
- 1:35:20SPEAKER_03: But I do... I think I always go back to... I think there are avenues of escape.
- 1:35:26SPEAKER_03: And they involve...
- 1:35:28SPEAKER_03: Earlier,
- 1:35:29SPEAKER_03: someone in the chat said,
- 1:35:29SPEAKER_03: let's get some of that purpose without a purpose or that purposeful behavior
- 1:35:35SPEAKER_03: without a purpose or this kind of non-instrumentalized,
- 1:35:39SPEAKER_03: deliberate...
- 1:35:42SPEAKER_03: Action can be deliberate,
- 1:35:43SPEAKER_03: and action can be fulfilling,
- 1:35:45SPEAKER_03: and action can be intentional,
- 1:35:47SPEAKER_03: but it doesn't have to be instrumentalized.
- 1:35:50SPEAKER_03: You don't have to do the self-defeating thing.
- 1:35:59SPEAKER_02: I'm pretty sure that they're also criticizing Heidegger here.
- 1:36:03SPEAKER_02: It sounds like it.
- 1:36:07SPEAKER_02: I think that's part of the project.
- 1:36:09SPEAKER_02: It seems like it.
- 1:36:13SPEAKER_02: They reference him later on.
- 1:36:14SPEAKER_02: They reference him pretty pointedly.
- 1:36:20SPEAKER_02: And they do criticize him.
- 1:36:22SPEAKER_02: And I mean...
- 1:36:23SPEAKER_02: while reading now that you brought it up i uh think about that too because like um
- 1:36:32SPEAKER_02: it seems like they they only criticize domination in the sense like being
- 1:36:37SPEAKER_02: anti-domination which they are but i think they are not stopping to be dialectical
- 1:36:43SPEAKER_02: about the domination
- 1:36:46SPEAKER_02: that it's not only that they emphasize this really heavily because they come from a
- 1:36:52SPEAKER_02: time where the contradiction in the Nazis,
- 1:36:58SPEAKER_02: in the fascists,
- 1:37:02SPEAKER_02: ideology of progress this was super evident you know on the one hand they say we
- 1:37:08SPEAKER_02: will build the fastest cars that have ever rode on a street you know like Futurismo
- 1:37:14SPEAKER_02: everything is like speed speed speed Accelerando
- 1:37:19SPEAKER_02: Yeah, and at the same time, they say, like, but our German roots and we have to find our Aryans.
- 1:37:25SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:37:26SPEAKER_03: Lebensraum, blah, blah, blah.
- 1:37:28SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 1:37:29SPEAKER_02: and so they say,
- 1:37:30SPEAKER_02: you think this contradiction,
- 1:37:35SPEAKER_02: which is evident,
- 1:37:36SPEAKER_02: seems like it's something apart,
- 1:37:37SPEAKER_02: but it's the same thing,
- 1:37:38SPEAKER_02: actually.
- 1:37:39SPEAKER_03: Yes, it is the same thing.
- 1:37:42SPEAKER_03: I...
- 1:37:47SPEAKER_03: I just realized I want to write something titled Accelerando at Lebensraum.
- 1:37:58SPEAKER_03: That's awesome title.
- 1:38:01SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:38:06SPEAKER_03: Because that is that tension.
- 1:38:08SPEAKER_03: That is a contradiction.
- 1:38:10SPEAKER_03: And I think a lot of people...
- 1:38:16SPEAKER_03: A lot of people think fascism is just for stupid people, and they point to all these contradictions.
- 1:38:25SPEAKER_03: Because fascism...
- 1:38:27SPEAKER_03: is I think full of contradictions.
- 1:38:29SPEAKER_03: Everything is full of contradictions,
- 1:38:31SPEAKER_03: however,
- 1:38:31SPEAKER_03: but like people point at fascism and say,
- 1:38:35SPEAKER_03: well,
- 1:38:35SPEAKER_03: look at them.
- 1:38:36SPEAKER_03: What are they doing?
- 1:38:37SPEAKER_03: The Jew is both weak and pitiful and also the most powerful evil thing in the world.
- 1:38:42SPEAKER_03: And they think that's a defeater for the intelligent person.
- 1:38:45SPEAKER_03: And so a lot of people today will kind of dismiss fascism or say,
- 1:38:53SPEAKER_03: You know,
- 1:38:53SPEAKER_03: either we're in no danger because we move beyond it or we are in danger because
- 1:38:57SPEAKER_03: people are idiots.
- 1:38:58SPEAKER_03: And because they're idiots, they fall for fascism.
- 1:39:01SPEAKER_03: And it's like fascism is not for idiots.
- 1:39:03SPEAKER_03: Just because it's built on contradictions doesn't mean it's for idiots.
- 1:39:08SPEAKER_03: Because guess what, homie?
- 1:39:10SPEAKER_03: Your worldview is also built of contradictions.
- 1:39:13SPEAKER_03: We are the contradiction of the universe itself.
- 1:39:16SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:39:19SPEAKER_03: But that contradiction, the acceleration versus authenticity, we'll call it, right?
- 1:39:25SPEAKER_03: Like the future versus the past.
- 1:39:27SPEAKER_03: That's a huge contradiction in fascism.
- 1:39:29SPEAKER_03: But I think that's why fascism works so well.
- 1:39:33SPEAKER_03: Because it was so timely.
- 1:39:35SPEAKER_03: That was...
- 1:39:37SPEAKER_03: The response to the postmodern world that we found ourselves living in,
- 1:39:43SPEAKER_03: the answer came in the form of fascism saying,
- 1:39:49SPEAKER_03: this is our attention.
- 1:39:50SPEAKER_03: This is the contradiction we are upholding.
- 1:39:54SPEAKER_03: Whereas here in America,
- 1:39:56SPEAKER_03: which again,
- 1:39:57SPEAKER_03: not to be too sensational,
- 1:39:58SPEAKER_03: I don't see a huge difference between America and fascism.
- 1:40:05SPEAKER_03: But I know there is a huge difference, right?
- 1:40:07SPEAKER_03: Because the Holocaust was real and human suffering, like all these things are real.
- 1:40:12SPEAKER_03: But as far as like institutionally and instrumentally,
- 1:40:15SPEAKER_03: I think fascism and American liberalism are the same vehicle.
- 1:40:21SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:40:22SPEAKER_03: But the answer, the German answer was...
- 1:40:26SPEAKER_03: Acceleration versus authenticity.
- 1:40:28SPEAKER_03: And the American answer was safety versus liberty or something like that,
- 1:40:32SPEAKER_03: like protectionism versus liberty,
- 1:40:35SPEAKER_03: ultimate freedom.
- 1:40:36SPEAKER_03: So it's just different signifiers to say the same thing.
- 1:40:41SPEAKER_02: And I mean, in both cases, it was more power to the state, right?
- 1:40:48SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:40:49SPEAKER_02: FDR was that.
- 1:40:50SPEAKER_02: Necessarily.
- 1:40:51SPEAKER_02: Necessarily more power to the state.
- 1:40:53SPEAKER_02: And I think the only thing where it's like,
- 1:40:56SPEAKER_02: where the Nazis move into unreason,
- 1:41:00SPEAKER_02: where they are not smart,
- 1:41:02SPEAKER_02: in a sense,
- 1:41:04SPEAKER_02: and where it becomes weirdly pathological,
- 1:41:07SPEAKER_02: is...
- 1:41:09SPEAKER_02: that they killed all the Jews.
- 1:41:13SPEAKER_02: Oh, they deprived themselves.
- 1:41:16SPEAKER_02: They deprived themselves of the scapegoat.
- 1:41:19SPEAKER_02: They already... I think it's like, yes, that too, but there were already no more Jews in Germany.
- 1:41:26SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:41:27SPEAKER_02: They put them all into the camps and they fled.
- 1:41:30SPEAKER_02: And then they started to...
- 1:41:33SPEAKER_02: There are people who say they always had this plan and it was part of their ideology.
- 1:41:37SPEAKER_02: And then they started the extermination in the grand scheme.
- 1:41:43SPEAKER_02: But it was unnecessary.
- 1:41:44SPEAKER_02: It was wasteful.
- 1:41:46SPEAKER_02: It was post hoc.
- 1:41:47SPEAKER_02: It was excess.
- 1:41:48SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:41:49SPEAKER_02: They didn't do like the smart capitalist fascist Nazi would have said, hey, these people can work.
- 1:41:55SPEAKER_02: We can enslave them forever.
- 1:41:57SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:41:58SPEAKER_02: But they didn't do that.
- 1:42:01SPEAKER_02: It went further than that.
- 1:42:03SPEAKER_03: So that might be or is an interesting point of distinction between American
- 1:42:11SPEAKER_03: liberalism and German fascism because American liberalism does put people in this
- 1:42:15SPEAKER_03: helpless position.
- 1:42:16SPEAKER_03: Yes.
- 1:42:17SPEAKER_03: But it says.
- 1:42:18SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 1:42:18SPEAKER_03: We are going to be efficient and they are already stultified and they already can do no harm to us.
- 1:42:26SPEAKER_03: So let's just allow this planned obsolescence to deal with the undesirables and the unworthies.
- 1:42:33SPEAKER_03: And we still see this today and it's even celebrated today.
- 1:42:37SPEAKER_03: I just saw another YouTube essay video documentary about 19-year-old kids killing
- 1:42:46SPEAKER_03: each other in Chicago because...
- 1:42:49SPEAKER_03: That's just the world that they live in and it's celebrated and look at these brave
- 1:42:53SPEAKER_03: young men telling us how hard they have it and it's so disgusting and people like
- 1:43:00SPEAKER_03: get off on these young people murdering each other and killing themselves and
- 1:43:05SPEAKER_03: destroying their lives and throwing their future away and it's been so romanticized.
- 1:43:10SPEAKER_03: But it is also true that that's a necessary constitutive part of American,
- 1:43:16SPEAKER_03: the world that we live in,
- 1:43:17SPEAKER_03: the world that Kamala Harris was so proud of.
- 1:43:20SPEAKER_03: And she was so happy to say, yes, we are good.
- 1:43:23SPEAKER_03: We are America.
- 1:43:25SPEAKER_03: Donald Trump is a fascist.
- 1:43:27SPEAKER_03: Her world that she celebrates is still predicated on the fucking horrors and
- 1:43:33SPEAKER_03: tragedies happening in the world today.
- 1:43:37SPEAKER_03: So that is a point of distinction between German fascism and American liberalism.
- 1:43:40SPEAKER_03: American liberalism doesn't do that excessive expenditure, whereas the fascists... And in a sense, yes.
- 1:43:48SPEAKER_02: And in a sense, that's also the only, I think...
- 1:43:53SPEAKER_02: It's dialectical because it's the only redeeming quality and it's the worst quality.
- 1:43:58SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 1:43:59SPEAKER_02: Because at least, you know, it's like, what do we value more?
- 1:44:04SPEAKER_02: I would say like, at least I have my life.
- 1:44:08SPEAKER_02: I can still do things.
- 1:44:10SPEAKER_02: I'm not so totalized that I'm totalized into death, into the camp, into completely gone.
- 1:44:21SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 1:44:21SPEAKER_02: like at least they give me this destituted veneer where I can say,
- 1:44:26SPEAKER_02: I can still read a book,
- 1:44:30SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:44:30SPEAKER_02: that's the point.
- 1:44:32SPEAKER_03: Well, and it's not entirely, it's not just ideology.
- 1:44:36SPEAKER_03: It is also concrete.
- 1:44:38SPEAKER_03: It is true that at least we are free to do what we're doing.
- 1:44:44SPEAKER_03: And that we're both genuinely engaged in this.
- 1:44:47SPEAKER_03: And I believe this is productive.
- 1:44:49SPEAKER_03: And we are co-creating a space.
- 1:44:52SPEAKER_03: And this is real.
- 1:44:55SPEAKER_03: Whereas, yes, it's also this ideological thing of like, well, at least I'll have my freedom.
- 1:45:02SPEAKER_03: God, guns, and liberty.
- 1:45:04SPEAKER_03: There's that element of it.
- 1:45:06SPEAKER_03: But also, I think it's important to not miss out on the concreticity of what we are doing.
- 1:45:16SPEAKER_03: And I think I tend to dismiss it as all pseudo-activity.
- 1:45:20SPEAKER_03: It's all spectacle.
- 1:45:24SPEAKER_03: But it's not.
- 1:45:25SPEAKER_03: We are dedicated...
- 1:45:27SPEAKER_03: and involved in like, we are productively doing something.
- 1:45:33SPEAKER_03: It's real.
- 1:45:34SPEAKER_03: We can't deny it.
- 1:45:34SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:45:35SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:45:36SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:45:38SPEAKER_02: I agree.
- 1:45:40SPEAKER_02: I have one question.
- 1:45:41SPEAKER_02: Uh, weird, Zalowski, you asked, could they be in a Kluge?
- 1:45:48SPEAKER_02: Does that speak to what's happening?
- 1:45:49SPEAKER_02: I don't know what you mean.
- 1:45:50SPEAKER_02: Do you mean, um, is it, is it a clock?
- 1:45:57SPEAKER_02: I don't know and understand really what you mean.
- 1:46:01SPEAKER_02: If you could write it again in the chat or do I, do I not get something?
- 1:46:05SPEAKER_03: And a Kluge.
- 1:46:11SPEAKER_03: Let me Google that and see what that is.
- 1:46:14SPEAKER_03: No, no.
- 1:46:15SPEAKER_03: Dear Google.
- 1:46:16SPEAKER_03: Oh, my phone started listening.
- 1:46:21SPEAKER_02: Yes, master.
- 1:46:23SPEAKER_02: Tell me.
- 1:46:23SPEAKER_00: Check your permissions.
- 1:46:25SPEAKER_00: See which apps have access to your microphone.
- 1:46:28SPEAKER_00: Turn off your microphone.
- 1:46:29SPEAKER_00: Go to your phone settings and disable microphone access for all apps or just specific ones.
- 1:46:34SPEAKER_00: Restart your phone.
- 1:46:36SPEAKER_00: This can sometimes resolve temporary glitches.
- 1:46:39SPEAKER_00: Update your phone software.
- 1:46:41SPEAKER_00: Make sure you have the latest security updates installed.
- 1:46:43SPEAKER_03: Shut up.
- 1:46:44SPEAKER_03: I don't want you to keep... How do you stop?
- 1:46:46SPEAKER_03: How do you stop?
- 1:46:49SPEAKER_03: It must be a god.
- 1:46:53SPEAKER_03: We found god.
- 1:46:55SPEAKER_03: We found him.
- 1:46:56SPEAKER_02: It's the river spirit.
- 1:46:57SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:47:00SPEAKER_03: It is interesting how we tend to do a strange type of...
- 1:47:08SPEAKER_03: I don't know, animism or projection or something with our devices and with the internet itself.
- 1:47:13SPEAKER_03: When we make reference to the internet and,
- 1:47:17SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:47:17SPEAKER_03: devices and social media,
- 1:47:19SPEAKER_03: like that becomes a new diffuse land spirit.
- 1:47:24SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:47:26SPEAKER_02: It wouldn't be us doing it.
- 1:47:29SPEAKER_02: All our social activities enabling this to happen.
- 1:47:33SPEAKER_02: It's just there.
- 1:47:36SPEAKER_03: But it's that weird operation of projection, abstraction, deconstruction, reification.
- 1:47:49SPEAKER_03: And it's like we have the power.
- 1:47:50SPEAKER_03: We have power over that.
- 1:47:52SPEAKER_03: But we get caught in a
- 1:47:54SPEAKER_03: we get caught in a cycle and it becomes when it becomes ideology is when it like concretizes,
- 1:48:03SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:48:04SPEAKER_03: and it's,
- 1:48:05SPEAKER_03: it starts to take control and it starts to make the decisions rather than us.
- 1:48:10SPEAKER_03: And that's why it's,
- 1:48:11SPEAKER_03: it's,
- 1:48:11SPEAKER_03: it's not good as such capital G,
- 1:48:15SPEAKER_03: but it is necessary because without it,
- 1:48:17SPEAKER_03: we would be frozen in time and space.
- 1:48:19SPEAKER_03: But, uh,
- 1:48:22SPEAKER_03: Solosky responded in terms of who is critiqued here.
- 1:48:26SPEAKER_03: Klug is,
- 1:48:28SPEAKER_03: I believe is basically an old mess like the U S internet infrastructure versus the new,
- 1:48:33SPEAKER_03: simpler,
- 1:48:33SPEAKER_03: faster Korean infrastructure.
- 1:48:36SPEAKER_03: In other words, the dead weight.
- 1:48:37SPEAKER_03: So would that be like a old mess?
- 1:48:49SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 1:48:49SPEAKER_03: I like that phrasing.
- 1:48:51SPEAKER_03: Solosky.
- 1:48:51SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 1:48:55SPEAKER_02: I didn't understand what Kluge is.
- 1:49:02SPEAKER_02: What is Kluge?
- 1:49:05SPEAKER_02: Is it a dude?
- 1:49:12SPEAKER_03: Oh, yeah.
- 1:49:12SPEAKER_03: Let's see.
- 1:49:13SPEAKER_03: Is Kluge a dude?
- 1:49:15SPEAKER_03: Or is it just a word for...
- 1:49:20SPEAKER_02: Oh, I know.
- 1:49:23SPEAKER_02: I think I know.
- 1:49:25SPEAKER_02: I think I know.
- 1:49:26SPEAKER_02: Let me check.
- 1:49:27SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 1:49:27SPEAKER_02: Kluge is a neuter noun.
- 1:49:37SPEAKER_03: What is that?
- 1:49:40SPEAKER_03: It's a noun.
- 1:49:43SPEAKER_03: It's neuter.
- 1:49:44SPEAKER_03: It can be feminine or masculine.
- 1:49:47SPEAKER_03: What does Kluge mean?
- 1:49:49SPEAKER_03: Workarounder makes this solution that is clumsy,
- 1:49:51SPEAKER_03: inelegant,
- 1:49:51SPEAKER_03: inefficient,
- 1:49:52SPEAKER_03: difficult to extend,
- 1:49:53SPEAKER_03: and hard to maintain.
- 1:49:54SPEAKER_03: So would it suffice to just say we're in a shitstorm?
- 1:49:57SPEAKER_03: A word for an overcomplicated system.
- 1:50:01SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I like that.
- 1:50:04SPEAKER_03: That's like a shitstorm or a shit show.
- 1:50:10SPEAKER_03: yeah or like a circle jerk like we're we're caught up in this uh not this gordian
- 1:50:18SPEAKER_03: knot like it's so over complicated it's so inefficient it's so insufficient to the
- 1:50:27SPEAKER_03: task at hand
- 1:50:30SPEAKER_03: But it's where we are.
- 1:50:31SPEAKER_03: And so we like we're here and we need to get here.
- 1:50:34SPEAKER_03: We can't disavow where we're starting from.
- 1:50:36SPEAKER_03: Like we have to deal with where we are now,
- 1:50:40SPEAKER_03: but we can't get caught in the dealing of with where we are now because we want to
- 1:50:44SPEAKER_03: get here.
- 1:50:46SPEAKER_02: I think in a sense like the totalitarian society is that for them I would say but I
- 1:50:54SPEAKER_02: think it's that for them necessarily because no one is doing the revolution so like
- 1:51:03SPEAKER_02: in the moment that like capitalism is in a sense not realized capital is not
- 1:51:09SPEAKER_02: realized so we are stuck and
- 1:51:15SPEAKER_02: in this decadence in this overripeness of capital that it's actually possible to to
- 1:51:22SPEAKER_02: sublate it but it's not done yep yep in a sense which which gets that in all the
- 1:51:26SPEAKER_02: weird fuckery of necessity and what is necessary and history contingency and yeah
- 1:51:32SPEAKER_02: yeah contingency who's who's to blame yeah is the idea wrong um
- 1:51:40SPEAKER_02: And in that situation, the totalitarian society, the total society comes up.
- 1:51:49SPEAKER_02: which is everything, global everything.
- 1:51:52SPEAKER_03: Soloski says it's Rube Goldberg due to clutter, clutter being history.
- 1:51:57SPEAKER_03: I love that.
- 1:51:58SPEAKER_03: Soloski, I love Rube Goldberg machines.
- 1:52:03SPEAKER_03: I love using them as metaphors or analogies, and I think that's spot on.
- 1:52:09SPEAKER_03: And history being the clutter that's gumming up the works of this overcomplicated Rube Goldberg machine.
- 1:52:17SPEAKER_03: uh i would even say it goes beyond just history like it's ideology and it's society
- 1:52:25SPEAKER_03: itself and it's technologies and it's the relation man's relation to all of these
- 1:52:31SPEAKER_03: things is getting in the way um like we're we're doing the thinking but we're
- 1:52:43SPEAKER_03: letting that get in the way of doing the thinking about the thinking
- 1:52:48SPEAKER_02: or something.
- 1:52:52SPEAKER_02: I think, yeah, in a sense, yes.
- 1:52:56SPEAKER_02: Do you want to continue reading?
- 1:52:59SPEAKER_02: Because if I don't smoke the cigarette, I'm going to fucking explode.
- 1:53:04SPEAKER_02: All right, where are we?
- 1:53:08SPEAKER_02: In view of the unity of this ratio, in view of the unity of this ratio,
- 1:53:16SPEAKER_03: In view of the unity of this ratio,
- 1:53:19SPEAKER_03: the divorcement between God and man dwindles to the degree of irrelevancy to which
- 1:53:26SPEAKER_03: unswervable reason has drawn attention since even the earliest critique of Homer.
- 1:53:33SPEAKER_03: The creative God and his and the systematic spirit are alike as rulers of nature.
- 1:53:40SPEAKER_03: Man's likeness to God consists in sovereignty over existence,
- 1:53:44SPEAKER_03: in the countenance of the Lord and Master,
- 1:53:47SPEAKER_03: and in command.
- 1:53:48SPEAKER_03: And yeah.
- 1:53:52SPEAKER_03: Laws, universalized crime.
- 1:53:57SPEAKER_03: Rulers rule by God's grace.
- 1:54:02SPEAKER_03: Eminent domain.
- 1:54:04SPEAKER_03: And all these things, and all these things, and on and on.
- 1:54:06SPEAKER_03: So yeah.
- 1:54:09SPEAKER_03: Myth turns into enlightenment and nature into mere objectivity.
- 1:54:17SPEAKER_03: Men pay for the increase of their power with alienation from that over which they exercise their power.
- 1:54:26SPEAKER_03: Enlightenment behaves toward things as a dictator toward men.
- 1:54:31SPEAKER_03: He knows them insofar as he can manipulate them.
- 1:54:35SPEAKER_03: The man of science knows things insofar as he can make them.
- 1:54:41SPEAKER_03: In this way, their potentiality is turned to his own ends.
- 1:54:45SPEAKER_03: In the metamorphosis,
- 1:54:46SPEAKER_03: the nature of things,
- 1:54:48SPEAKER_03: as a substratum of domination,
- 1:54:52SPEAKER_03: is revealed as always the same.
- 1:54:55SPEAKER_03: This identity constitutes the unity of nature.
- 1:54:59SPEAKER_03: It is a presupposition of the magical invocation as little as the unity of the subject.
- 1:55:07SPEAKER_03: The shaman's rites were directed to the wind,
- 1:55:10SPEAKER_03: the rain,
- 1:55:11SPEAKER_03: the serpent without,
- 1:55:12SPEAKER_03: or the demon and the sick man,
- 1:55:14SPEAKER_03: but not to materials or specimens.
- 1:55:17SPEAKER_03: Magic was not ordered by one.
- 1:55:20SPEAKER_03: Identical spirit,
- 1:55:21SPEAKER_03: it changed like the cultic masks which were supposed to accord with the various spirits.
- 1:55:28SPEAKER_03: Magic is utterly untrue,
- 1:55:30SPEAKER_03: yet in it domination is not yet negated by transforming itself into the pure truth
- 1:55:35SPEAKER_03: and acting as the very ground of the world that has become subject to it.
- 1:55:41SPEAKER_03: The magician imitates demons.
- 1:55:43SPEAKER_03: In order to frighten them or to appease them, he behaves frighteningly or makes gestures of appeasement.
- 1:55:50SPEAKER_03: Even though his task is impersonation,
- 1:55:53SPEAKER_03: he never conceives of himself as does the civilized man for whom the unpretentious
- 1:55:59SPEAKER_03: preserves of the happy hunting grounds become the unified cosmos,
- 1:56:03SPEAKER_03: the inclusive concept for all possibilities of plunder.
- 1:56:08SPEAKER_03: The magician never interprets himself as the image of the invisible power,
- 1:56:13SPEAKER_03: yet this is the very image in which man attains to the identity of self that cannot
- 1:56:18SPEAKER_03: disappear through identification with another,
- 1:56:21SPEAKER_03: but takes possession of itself once and for all as an impenetrable mask.
- 1:56:28SPEAKER_03: It is the identity of the spirit and its correlate,
- 1:56:34SPEAKER_03: the unity of nature,
- 1:56:36SPEAKER_03: to which the multiplicity of qualities falls victim.
- 1:56:41SPEAKER_03: Disqualified nature becomes the chaotic matter of mere classification,
- 1:56:45SPEAKER_03: and the all-powerful self becomes mere possession.
- 1:56:49SPEAKER_03: Abstract identity.
- 1:56:50SPEAKER_01: Hmm.
- 1:56:52SPEAKER_03: In magic, there is specific representation.
- 1:56:56SPEAKER_03: What happens to the enemy's spear, hair, or name also happens to the individual.
- 1:57:02SPEAKER_03: The sacrificial animal is massacred instead of the god.
- 1:57:07SPEAKER_03: Substitution in the course of sacrifice marks a step toward discursive logic and
- 1:57:13SPEAKER_03: fungibility and capitalism as such.
- 1:57:17SPEAKER_03: Even though the hind offered up for the daughter and the lamb for the firstborn
- 1:57:22SPEAKER_03: still had to have specific qualities,
- 1:57:24SPEAKER_03: they already represented the species.
- 1:57:28SPEAKER_03: They already exhibited the nonspecificity of the example.
- 1:57:32SPEAKER_03: But the holiness of the hick et nunc
- 1:57:38SPEAKER_03: The uniqueness of the chosen one into which the representative enters radically
- 1:57:43SPEAKER_03: marks it off and makes it unfit for exchange.
- 1:57:47SPEAKER_03: Science prepares the end of this state of affairs.
- 1:57:51SPEAKER_03: In science,
- 1:57:52SPEAKER_03: there is no specific representation,
- 1:57:54SPEAKER_03: and if there are no sacrificial animals,
- 1:57:57SPEAKER_03: there is no God.
- 1:57:59SPEAKER_03: Representation is exchanged for the fungible, universal interchangeability.
- 1:58:04SPEAKER_03: An atom is smashed not in representation, but as a specimen of matter.
- 1:58:10SPEAKER_03: And the rabbit does not represent,
- 1:58:12SPEAKER_03: but,
- 1:58:13SPEAKER_03: as a mere example,
- 1:58:14SPEAKER_03: is virtually ignored by the zeal of the laboratory.
- 1:58:18SPEAKER_03: Because the distinctions in functional science are so fluid that everything is
- 1:58:22SPEAKER_03: subsumed in the same matter,
- 1:58:24SPEAKER_03: the scientific object is petrified,
- 1:58:27SPEAKER_03: and the fixed ritual of former times appear flexible because it is attributed the
- 1:58:33SPEAKER_03: other to the one.
- 1:58:35SPEAKER_03: The world of magic retained distinctions whose traces have disappeared even in linguistic form.
- 1:58:42SPEAKER_03: The multitudinous affinities between existence are suppressed by the single
- 1:58:46SPEAKER_03: relation between the subject who bestows meaning and the meaningless object,
- 1:58:51SPEAKER_03: between rational significance and the chance vehicle of significance.
- 1:58:56SPEAKER_03: On the magical plane,
- 1:58:57SPEAKER_03: dream and image were not mere signs for the thing in question,
- 1:59:02SPEAKER_03: but were bound up with it by similarity or names.
- 1:59:06SPEAKER_03: The relation is one not of intention, but of relatedness.
- 1:59:11SPEAKER_03: Like science,
- 1:59:12SPEAKER_03: magic pursues aims,
- 1:59:13SPEAKER_03: but seeks to achieve them by mimesis,
- 1:59:16SPEAKER_03: not by progressively distancing itself from the object.
- 1:59:20SPEAKER_03: It is not grounded in the sovereignty of ideas,
- 1:59:23SPEAKER_03: which the primitive,
- 1:59:24SPEAKER_03: like the neurotic,
- 1:59:25SPEAKER_03: is said to ascribe to himself.
- 1:59:28SPEAKER_03: There can be no over-evaluation of mental processes against reality,
- 1:59:32SPEAKER_03: where there is no radical distinction between thoughts and reality.
- 1:59:38SPEAKER_03: The unshakable confidence in the possibility of world domination,
- 1:59:42SPEAKER_03: which Freud anachronistically ascribes to magic...
- 1:59:45SPEAKER_03: corresponds to realistic world domination only in terms of a more skilled science.
- 1:59:51SPEAKER_03: The replacement of the milieu-bound practices of the medicine man by an
- 1:59:55SPEAKER_03: all-inclusive industrial technology required first of all the autonomy of ideas in
- 2:00:00SPEAKER_03: regard to objects that was achieved in the reality-adjusted ego.
- 2:00:07SPEAKER_03: Damn.
- 2:00:08SPEAKER_03: The reality-adjusted ego.
- 2:00:11SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 2:00:12SPEAKER_02: Hmm.
- 2:00:15SPEAKER_02: um hick and nunc uh means um here and yet uh here and now okay in the here and now
- 2:00:26SPEAKER_03: yeah so yeah that's fungibility that's uh representation by abstraction as opposed
- 2:00:34SPEAKER_03: to representation by uh predication or singularity
- 2:00:41SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 2:00:43SPEAKER_02: And I mean, they reference Maus here.
- 2:00:47SPEAKER_02: I think they don't cite him,
- 2:00:50SPEAKER_02: but this is the whole part about like the meaning on the meaningless object between
- 2:00:57SPEAKER_02: rational significance and the chance vehicle of significance,
- 2:01:01SPEAKER_02: which is the,
- 2:01:03SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 2:01:05SPEAKER_02: signify and signify too.
- 2:01:08SPEAKER_02: where they say this is a process where they were bound up with each other still.
- 2:01:18SPEAKER_02: In magic.
- 2:01:19SPEAKER_02: In magic there's always this like, this weird,
- 2:01:29SPEAKER_02: weird, unfungible that you have to appease to.
- 2:01:32SPEAKER_02: You know, that's why you cannot do the same spell for the same fire.
- 2:01:37SPEAKER_02: It has to be a specific spell.
- 2:01:40SPEAKER_02: You have to do a specific offering of your hair or the hair of the first virgin born on the sixth moon.
- 2:01:50SPEAKER_02: And in our village, this was laureate.
- 2:01:54SPEAKER_02: You know, laureate, you have to give up your hair to the shaman now.
- 2:01:57SPEAKER_02: Otherwise,
- 2:01:58SPEAKER_03: the crops will be yeah sorry it's um i think i no i don't know i was i was gonna i
- 2:02:13SPEAKER_03: was gonna take a leap but i don't think i want to take that leap yet but maybe i'll
- 2:02:18SPEAKER_03: foreshadow that leap and say i think binyamin and the aura of originality
- 2:02:24SPEAKER_03: is very pertinent here when it comes to particularity um and
- 2:02:32SPEAKER_03: like the the relation of things coming from like the things themselves rather than
- 2:02:38SPEAKER_03: coming from this abstracted essentializing um that with mechanical reproduction
- 2:02:46SPEAKER_03: every everything became an abstraction like we lost particularity with mechanical
- 2:02:51SPEAKER_03: reproduction we lost singularity we lost thingness with mechanical reproduction
- 2:02:58SPEAKER_03: everything became an abstraction like everything was just a reproduction of things
- 2:03:05SPEAKER_03: that were you know these reified categories and these reified commodities and
- 2:03:09SPEAKER_03: objects in the world um so now the part of my brain that's that deals with binyamin
- 2:03:14SPEAKER_03: is also starting to warm up um but it is the case that
- 2:03:22SPEAKER_03: I want some enchantment.
- 2:03:24SPEAKER_03: I want to live in an enchanted world.
- 2:03:27SPEAKER_03: And maybe that's confusing language to use.
- 2:03:31SPEAKER_03: And again, I always have to do the little caveat.
- 2:03:34SPEAKER_03: I'm coming at this from an atheist point of view.
- 2:03:37SPEAKER_03: I don't come down hard on that issue.
- 2:03:42SPEAKER_03: I don't believe it, but I also leave room for it because I don't disbelieve it either.
- 2:03:47SPEAKER_03: Right?
- 2:03:47SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 2:03:48SPEAKER_02: Yeah, me too.
- 2:03:49SPEAKER_02: I'm agnostic as well.
- 2:03:51SPEAKER_03: Yeah, whatever.
- 2:03:55SPEAKER_03: I think I can make my world work.
- 2:03:58SPEAKER_03: I think I approach my world from a material or an atheist point of view,
- 2:04:02SPEAKER_03: but I think I can incorporate divinity and all that into it.
- 2:04:08SPEAKER_03: I think I can anyway, and I don't want to offend anybody at all.
- 2:04:12SPEAKER_03: But I understand that it can be confusing to say things like I want to live in an
- 2:04:17SPEAKER_03: enchanted world once again,
- 2:04:18SPEAKER_03: but that enchantment has to do with objects of use as opposed to use values.
- 2:04:28SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 2:04:29SPEAKER_02: Maybe it would have to be,
- 2:04:33SPEAKER_02: to stick a little Marxist flag again in the ground,
- 2:04:36SPEAKER_02: is like the administration of things,
- 2:04:39SPEAKER_02: you know?
- 2:04:39SPEAKER_02: Yes, yeah, yeah.
- 2:04:41SPEAKER_02: That it's like, I don't think we can go back.
- 2:04:46SPEAKER_02: This has already happened.
- 2:04:48SPEAKER_02: We come out of this scientific, of this whole movement.
- 2:04:54SPEAKER_02: I think that what they describe here, the singular relationship, it is gone in this sense.
- 2:05:04SPEAKER_02: We can find something else.
- 2:05:08SPEAKER_02: If it would be enchantment, it would be a different enchantment with the world.
- 2:05:13SPEAKER_02: Which I think has more to do with subjectivity.
- 2:05:17SPEAKER_02: And which I would say is also more...
- 2:05:21SPEAKER_02: um it's free yeah because what um and we can do it Deleuze and Goetarian you know
- 2:05:28SPEAKER_02: you live in this community and it's like I just said like Laurieette has to give up
- 2:05:33SPEAKER_02: her fucking hair and she's she is like that's what they say when they say like in
- 2:05:39SPEAKER_02: the myth and in the magic there's already this movement of enlightenment happening
- 2:05:44SPEAKER_02: yeah um uh
- 2:05:48SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:05:50SPEAKER_02: these were times when one of the worst punishments for people were that they got
- 2:05:59SPEAKER_02: banished from the community.
- 2:06:01Dude.
- 2:06:02SPEAKER_02: Because your whole world, everything fucking was ripped away from you.
- 2:06:10SPEAKER_02: You were nothing in this situation.
- 2:06:14SPEAKER_03: Isn't it crazy that now we live largely and generally in self-imposed banishment?
- 2:06:23SPEAKER_03: We
- 2:06:24SPEAKER_03: We don't live in the social, or maybe you're doing D&G, maybe even the socius.
- 2:06:33SPEAKER_03: The socius used to be life-affirming.
- 2:06:35SPEAKER_03: The socius used to be where you got your identity from, right?
- 2:06:39SPEAKER_03: You got your identity in reference to concrete others.
- 2:06:42SPEAKER_03: And the social used to fill out your identity.
- 2:06:47SPEAKER_03: And to be threatened with banishment was a death.
- 2:06:52SPEAKER_03: It was a death more concrete than...
- 2:06:54SPEAKER_03: the demise of the body, right?
- 2:06:56SPEAKER_03: Like,
- 2:06:56SPEAKER_03: because it was horrifying because then you had to spend the rest of your days in
- 2:07:00SPEAKER_03: isolation and you could,
- 2:07:02SPEAKER_03: or you would physically die.
- 2:07:04SPEAKER_03: You would reach your demise sooner because you would starve or freeze or get eaten by tiger or whatever.
- 2:07:10SPEAKER_03: But the real horror was doing all that in isolation.
- 2:07:14SPEAKER_03: Social death was more terrifying than the physical demise.
- 2:07:18SPEAKER_03: And I think it still is, although we've definitely come into a new relation to that.
- 2:07:23SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 2:07:25SPEAKER_03: But nowadays people tend.
- 2:07:28SPEAKER_03: to live in this self-imposed banishment where we do isolate.
- 2:07:33SPEAKER_03: And it is all about how much time can I spend clicking,
- 2:07:37SPEAKER_03: clicking the screen on my phone and how much,
- 2:07:39SPEAKER_03: and,
- 2:07:40SPEAKER_03: and like we,
- 2:07:41SPEAKER_03: we seek out this type of engagement in the form of likes or in the form of retweets
- 2:07:47SPEAKER_03: or in the form of superficial validation of,
- 2:07:52SPEAKER_03: of our like solipsistic identity online when it is the case that
- 2:07:59SPEAKER_03: i could i could just go outside and talk to somebody yeah yeah yeah it would be
- 2:08:10SPEAKER_02: maybe a strange thing to do or the other person would would uh or the other person
- 2:08:16SPEAKER_02: would gladly i tried to make a habit out of it to be like to try it it's weird i
- 2:08:23SPEAKER_02: try to be like even if it's these little social interactions
- 2:08:28SPEAKER_02: I try to kind of get out of...
- 2:08:32SPEAKER_02: Often I do it with cashiers,
- 2:08:34SPEAKER_02: that I look at them and I really try to say to them,
- 2:08:37SPEAKER_02: like,
- 2:08:37SPEAKER_02: have a good shift.
- 2:08:38SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 2:08:39SPEAKER_02: And I mean it.
- 2:08:39SPEAKER_02: It's not just like, blah, blah, blah, a good shift.
- 2:08:42SPEAKER_02: I really think,
- 2:08:43SPEAKER_02: I hope they don't make you stack the boxes,
- 2:08:46SPEAKER_02: the hard,
- 2:08:46SPEAKER_02: the heavy boxes before you can go home.
- 2:08:50SPEAKER_02: Have a good shift.
- 2:08:51SPEAKER_02: I...
- 2:08:56SPEAKER_03: I do, I do seek out the, those, those human moments.
- 2:09:02SPEAKER_03: Um, and I, I think it's important.
- 2:09:07SPEAKER_03: And I think part of trying to do theory underground and in the way that we're
- 2:09:12SPEAKER_03: trying to do it,
- 2:09:13SPEAKER_03: where we're trying to like force a different connection where yes,
- 2:09:18SPEAKER_03: we do so much shit online and,
- 2:09:21SPEAKER_03: so like so much of this shit happens only on the internet,
- 2:09:24SPEAKER_03: not just only because of the internet,
- 2:09:26SPEAKER_03: but only on the internet because we are like communicating globally and trying to
- 2:09:31SPEAKER_03: do this.
- 2:09:31SPEAKER_03: But also like,
- 2:09:34SPEAKER_03: um,
- 2:09:34SPEAKER_03: when we have the opportunity to go out and interface with like the real world,
- 2:09:38SPEAKER_03: like that's also a huge part of it.
- 2:09:40SPEAKER_03: And it's,
- 2:09:41SPEAKER_03: it's not just traveling with other like-minded people and,
- 2:09:44SPEAKER_03: and doing talks and,
- 2:09:46SPEAKER_03: um,
- 2:09:47SPEAKER_03: collaborating it.
- 2:09:48SPEAKER_03: there also is like reading books in public.
- 2:09:53SPEAKER_03: Like that's an awkward thing to do,
- 2:09:55SPEAKER_03: but it's,
- 2:09:55SPEAKER_03: it's like a necessary part of what we're doing is like,
- 2:09:59SPEAKER_03: I have to,
- 2:10:00SPEAKER_03: like,
- 2:10:00SPEAKER_03: I am now going to go outside and perform for these strangers.
- 2:10:03SPEAKER_03: I'm going to read Marshall McLuhan.
- 2:10:05SPEAKER_03: I'm going to read Baudrillard and I'm not going to read it quietly and timidly.
- 2:10:10SPEAKER_03: I'm going to say it with my chest and I'm going to be loud and I'm going to make sure they hear me.
- 2:10:15SPEAKER_03: But trying not to be offensive.
- 2:10:19SPEAKER_03: But it forces a type of discomfort sometimes.
- 2:10:27SPEAKER_03: But it's because it's resisting that tendency to do this self-imposed social banishment.
- 2:10:38SPEAKER_02: And you make a contradiction in the public visible, right?
- 2:10:45SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:10:47SPEAKER_02: That's like
- 2:10:50SPEAKER_02: the public is not used for...
- 2:10:53SPEAKER_02: It cannot be used for what it actually is or it so happens that people don't do it,
- 2:10:59SPEAKER_02: which is exactly that,
- 2:11:00SPEAKER_02: yeah?
- 2:11:01SPEAKER_02: Speakers' corners and interfacing,
- 2:11:05SPEAKER_02: interacting with other people who are there and like...
- 2:11:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 2:11:10SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 2:11:10SPEAKER_02: man.
- 2:11:11SPEAKER_02: Yeah, man.
- 2:11:13SPEAKER_02: But the question is like...
- 2:11:16SPEAKER_02: for me, it's always like, why, why do people do that?
- 2:11:19SPEAKER_02: You know, like, and that, that relates back to time energy.
- 2:11:21SPEAKER_02: That's like, yeah, that, that like exploitation and, and energy it's, it's so, um, encompassing.
- 2:11:31SPEAKER_02: And I always,
- 2:11:32SPEAKER_02: I,
- 2:11:32SPEAKER_02: I,
- 2:11:32SPEAKER_02: I lately,
- 2:11:33SPEAKER_02: I also wonder about like how economical is it,
- 2:11:37SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:11:38SPEAKER_02: I started about to think about the economy of,
- 2:11:42SPEAKER_02: um,
- 2:11:45SPEAKER_02: time energy again because I listened to a TV interview with Adorno and Eugen I
- 2:11:53SPEAKER_02: think is his name he was a conservative sociologist in Germany around that time in
- 2:11:58SPEAKER_02: the 1960s late 1960s
- 2:12:03SPEAKER_02: And this Eugen,
- 2:12:06SPEAKER_02: he makes big institutions,
- 2:12:08SPEAKER_02: like the marriage and the church,
- 2:12:10SPEAKER_02: and he tries to uphold institutions.
- 2:12:13SPEAKER_02: And Adorno is like, yeah, but like these student marriages.
- 2:12:20SPEAKER_02: I'm not so much for that.
- 2:12:22SPEAKER_02: Because can we not think about why do these people have to marry so early?
- 2:12:29SPEAKER_02: What is it in our society that makes it so oppressive that these young people have
- 2:12:36SPEAKER_02: to settle down right now?
- 2:12:37SPEAKER_02: And I found that a really interesting point.
- 2:12:44SPEAKER_02: I thought that is interesting.
- 2:12:46SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:12:48SPEAKER_02: Even this is 50 years ago, right?
- 2:12:55SPEAKER_02: What do I mean with this?
- 2:12:56SPEAKER_02: Where do I want to take it?
- 2:13:02SPEAKER_02: I think that with inflation and recession and the constant de-evaluation of labor power,
- 2:13:13SPEAKER_02: the constant de-evaluation,
- 2:13:17SPEAKER_02: it becomes so hard to live.
- 2:13:27SPEAKER_02: that it takes up most of your time and your energy because it's harder to lift this.
- 2:13:35SPEAKER_02: It's just look at rent.
- 2:13:38SPEAKER_02: Like, I don't know, you're lucky if like half your paycheck
- 2:13:43SPEAKER_02: is spent on rent, then you're lucky.
- 2:13:46SPEAKER_02: If you're unlucky, it's more.
- 2:13:48SPEAKER_03: Yeah, my fucking rent is so, so expensive.
- 2:13:52SPEAKER_03: I was just actually today, I was fucking angry because it's holiday time and everybody wants presents.
- 2:14:03SPEAKER_03: i don't fucking care of course i'm like fuck all you motherfuckers uh you're not
- 2:14:07SPEAKER_03: getting shit from me but i also like look of course i'm gonna buy i'm gonna buy the
- 2:14:12SPEAKER_03: kids some shit definitely uh but i'm not gonna buy anyone else anything and i i
- 2:14:18SPEAKER_03: told everybody i was like don't buy me anything this year or ever again because i'm
- 2:14:22SPEAKER_03: sick and fucking tired it's so expensive
- 2:14:26SPEAKER_03: even if I were to do nothing, even if I decided, all right, this is it.
- 2:14:31SPEAKER_03: I'm going to starve myself to death over the next three weeks or however long it
- 2:14:35SPEAKER_03: would take for that to happen.
- 2:14:37SPEAKER_03: It would still cost an insane amount of money just because like I,
- 2:14:42SPEAKER_03: I live in a house and like,
- 2:14:44SPEAKER_03: like even if I decided right now to just stop all my consumption,
- 2:14:49SPEAKER_03: it would still be so fucking expensive just to wake up in the morning.
- 2:14:55SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 2:14:57SPEAKER_03: And that's the boat all of us.
- 2:15:00SPEAKER_03: We all find ourselves in this.
- 2:15:01SPEAKER_03: It's prohibitively expensive to be a human.
- 2:15:08SPEAKER_03: The proper response to the world we live in today is to just be the instrument and
- 2:15:17SPEAKER_03: to stop fighting back because it's so costly to try and be this resolute,
- 2:15:23SPEAKER_03: enthusiastic human.
- 2:15:25SPEAKER_03: And there are so many people that
- 2:15:29SPEAKER_03: can't afford it, literally.
- 2:15:31SPEAKER_03: can't afford to fight for these things and to pursue these things, right?
- 2:15:38SPEAKER_03: These things that we know will never pay off in this economic sense.
- 2:15:41SPEAKER_03: The payoff is in the doing of the thing itself rather than the solution or the
- 2:15:46SPEAKER_03: final product that the doing of the thing will engender.
- 2:15:51SPEAKER_03: The overwhelming majority of people cannot do these types of activities.
- 2:15:57SPEAKER_03: And it's just...
- 2:16:00SPEAKER_03: don't know man i i often do find myself really sitting in that tension of i just i
- 2:16:08SPEAKER_03: can't i i can't i don't know the world the world is such a fucking crazy rube
- 2:16:14SPEAKER_03: goldberg machine right it's this inhuman contraption of exploitation and suffering
- 2:16:19SPEAKER_03: and exploitation and suffering and exploitation and suffering and it's
- 2:16:24SPEAKER_03: dude i just i don't know i want uh i want to live in the utopia right but it's up
- 2:16:32SPEAKER_03: to it's up to people like us who are convinced that there is a better world out
- 2:16:35SPEAKER_03: there to bring it about yeah so yeah and maybe
- 2:16:43SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 2:16:44SPEAKER_02: I have a bunch of places that I flee into when I think these thoughts,
- 2:16:49SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:16:50SPEAKER_02: that they are like my little happy places in hell.
- 2:16:56SPEAKER_02: But of course, one of the guys we were reading, Adorno said, there's no right way in the wrong.
- 2:17:04SPEAKER_02: There's no right life in the wrong.
- 2:17:11SPEAKER_02: Of course.
- 2:17:13SPEAKER_02: But with our limited time on this planet, where we... As a linguistically expressed mentality.
- 2:17:28SPEAKER_02: As a linguistically expressed totality whose claim to truth suppresses the older
- 2:17:36SPEAKER_02: mythic belief,
- 2:17:37SPEAKER_02: the national religion or patriarchal solar myth is itself an enlightenment with
- 2:17:44SPEAKER_02: which the philosophic form can compare itself on the same level.
- 2:17:49SPEAKER_02: And now it has its requital.
- 2:17:52SPEAKER_02: mythology itself set off the unending process of enlightenment in which ever and
- 2:17:58SPEAKER_02: again with the inevitability of necessity every specific theoretic view succumbs to
- 2:18:07SPEAKER_02: the destructive criticism that it is only a belief
- 2:18:12SPEAKER_02: until even the very notion of spirit,
- 2:18:15SPEAKER_02: of truth and indeed enlightenment itself,
- 2:18:19SPEAKER_02: have become animistic magic.
- 2:18:23SPEAKER_02: The principle of fatal necessity,
- 2:18:26SPEAKER_02: which brings low the heroes of myth and derives as a logical consequence from the
- 2:18:31SPEAKER_02: pronouncement of the oracle,
- 2:18:34SPEAKER_02: does not merely,
- 2:18:35SPEAKER_02: when refined to the stringency of formal logic,
- 2:18:40SPEAKER_02: rule in every rationalistic system of western philosophy but itself dominates the
- 2:18:48SPEAKER_02: series of systems which begins with the hierarchy of the gods and in a permanent
- 2:18:54SPEAKER_02: twilight of the idols
- 2:18:56SPEAKER_02: Hands down an identical content, anger against insufficient righteousness.
- 2:19:04SPEAKER_02: Just as the myths already realize enlightenment,
- 2:19:07SPEAKER_02: so enlightenment with every step becomes more deeply engulfed in mythology.
- 2:19:14SPEAKER_02: It receives all its matter from the myths in order to destroy them.
- 2:19:20SPEAKER_02: And even as a judge, it comes under the mythic curse.
- 2:19:25SPEAKER_02: It wishes to extricate itself from the process of fate and retribution while
- 2:19:31SPEAKER_02: exercising retribution on that process."
- 2:19:35SPEAKER_02: in the myth everything that happens must atone for having happened and so it is in
- 2:19:42SPEAKER_02: enlightenment the fact becomes null and void and might as well not have happened
- 2:19:50SPEAKER_02: the doctrine of the equivalence of action and reaction
- 2:19:54SPEAKER_02: asserted the power of repetition over reality long after man had renounced the
- 2:20:00SPEAKER_02: illusion that by repetition that they could identify themselves with the repeated
- 2:20:05SPEAKER_02: reality and thus escape its power.
- 2:20:10SPEAKER_02: But as the magical illusion fades away,
- 2:20:13SPEAKER_02: the more relentlessly,
- 2:20:15SPEAKER_02: in the name of law,
- 2:20:16SPEAKER_02: repetition imprisons man in the cycle.
- 2:20:20SPEAKER_02: That cycle whose objectification in the form of natural law he imagines will ensure
- 2:20:28SPEAKER_02: his action as a free subject.
- 2:20:31SPEAKER_02: The principle of imminence,
- 2:20:34SPEAKER_02: the explanation of every event as repetition that the enlightenment upholds against
- 2:20:40SPEAKER_02: the mythic imagination is the principle of myth itself.
- 2:20:46SPEAKER_02: That arid wisdom that holds there is nothing new under the sun because all the
- 2:20:52SPEAKER_02: pieces in the meaningless game have been played and all the great thoughts have
- 2:20:57SPEAKER_02: already been thought and because all possible discoveries can be construed in
- 2:21:03SPEAKER_02: advance and all men are decided on adaptation as the means to self-preservation.
- 2:21:10SPEAKER_02: That dry,
- 2:21:12SPEAKER_02: zagacity merely reproduces the fantastic wisdom that it supposedly rejects,
- 2:21:21SPEAKER_02: the sanction of fate that in retribution relentlessly remakes what has already been.
- 2:21:30SPEAKER_02: what was different is equalized that is the verdict which critically determines the
- 2:21:37SPEAKER_02: limits of possible experience the identity of everything with everything else is
- 2:21:45SPEAKER_02: paid for in that nothing may at the same time be identical with itself
- 2:21:51SPEAKER_02: enlightenment dissolves the injustice of the old inequality
- 2:21:57SPEAKER_02: unmediated lordship and mastery,
- 2:22:00SPEAKER_02: but at the same time perpetuates it in universal mediation,
- 2:22:05SPEAKER_02: in the relation of any one existent to any other.
- 2:22:11SPEAKER_02: It does what Kierkegaard praises his protestant ethic for,
- 2:22:16SPEAKER_02: and what in the Heraclean epic cycle is one of the primal images of mythic power.
- 2:22:23SPEAKER_02: It exercises the incommensurable,
- 2:22:28SPEAKER_02: not only are qualities dissolved in thought but men are brought to actual
- 2:22:34SPEAKER_02: conformity the blessing that the market does not inquire after one's birth is paid
- 2:22:42SPEAKER_02: for by the barterer in that he models the potentialities that are his by birth on
- 2:22:50SPEAKER_02: the production of the commodities that can be bought in the market
- 2:22:56SPEAKER_02: men were given their individuality as unique in each case different to all others
- 2:23:03SPEAKER_02: so that it might all the more surely be made the same as any other fuck
- 2:23:10SPEAKER_02: But because the unique self never wholly disappeared,
- 2:23:15SPEAKER_02: even after the liberalistic epoch,
- 2:23:18SPEAKER_02: the enlightenment has always sympathized with the social impulse.
- 2:23:23SPEAKER_02: The unity of the manipulated collective consists in the negation of each individual.
- 2:23:30SPEAKER_02: For individuality makes a mockery of the kind of society which would turn all
- 2:23:36SPEAKER_02: individuals to the one collectivity.
- 2:23:40SPEAKER_02: The horde,
- 2:23:41SPEAKER_02: which so assuredly appears in the organization of the Hitler Youth,
- 2:23:45SPEAKER_02: is not a return to barbarism,
- 2:23:48SPEAKER_02: but a triumph of repressive equality.
- 2:23:52SPEAKER_02: The disclosure through peers of the parity of the right to injustice.
- 2:23:59SPEAKER_02: The phony fascist mythology is shown to be the genuine myth of antiquity,
- 2:24:06SPEAKER_02: insofar as the genuine one saw retribution,
- 2:24:11SPEAKER_02: whereas the false one blindly doles it out to the sacrifices.
- 2:24:18SPEAKER_02: Every attempt to break the natural thralldom,
- 2:24:21SPEAKER_02: because nature is broken,
- 2:24:24SPEAKER_02: enters all the more deeply into that natural enslavement.
- 2:24:29SPEAKER_02: Hence the course of European civilization.
- 2:24:33SPEAKER_02: Abstraction, the tool of enlightenment, treats its object as did fate.
- 2:24:40SPEAKER_02: The notion of which it rejects, it liquidates them.
- 2:24:45SPEAKER_02: That was then's
- 2:25:14SPEAKER_02: That was rich.
- 2:25:17SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that was really good.
- 2:25:24SPEAKER_03: Really good.
- 2:25:25SPEAKER_03: And I think it...
- 2:25:27SPEAKER_03: dear internet before we went live we were having a a really good conversation and
- 2:25:32SPEAKER_03: it was far uh ranging far and wide but also like i'm noticing a lot of the themes
- 2:25:39SPEAKER_03: that that you and i were talking about that like just as as a course of like our
- 2:25:45SPEAKER_03: discourse that we have going on already like uh i don't know i think i think we did
- 2:25:53SPEAKER_03: cast a spell
- 2:25:56SPEAKER_03: and and and because we cast this spell that that's why we're reading this um just
- 2:26:03SPEAKER_03: going back to the collectivity and the individual and like this kind of magic
- 2:26:09SPEAKER_03: reification fate like all this stuff um
- 2:26:14SPEAKER_03: And it was very dense, and there's a lot of words here, and I can imagine not getting any of that.
- 2:26:20SPEAKER_03: I can imagine reading that long paragraph and feeling like,
- 2:26:25SPEAKER_03: oh,
- 2:26:25SPEAKER_03: they're really saying a lot,
- 2:26:26SPEAKER_03: but nothing is really clicking.
- 2:26:31SPEAKER_03: So rest assured, Internet, this book is not going anywhere.
- 2:26:37SPEAKER_03: come back to it time and time again and it will never let you down i think there's
- 2:26:44SPEAKER_03: just so much going on um but it has i mean like right now specifically i think uh
- 2:26:54SPEAKER_03: in many ways i i feel like a futility or like a
- 2:27:00SPEAKER_03: why are we doing why am i doing this what am i doing why am i doing any of this it
- 2:27:07SPEAKER_03: is fucking futile we live in post-modern hell nothing is real nothing matters
- 2:27:12SPEAKER_03: anymore woe is me raw like i i feel that deeply i feel that in my fucking bones
- 2:27:19SPEAKER_03: right now and i think this this is like a call
- 2:27:25SPEAKER_03: This is a call,
- 2:27:27SPEAKER_03: and I think answering that call is,
- 2:27:33SPEAKER_03: yes,
- 2:27:34SPEAKER_03: we are alienated from the thing itself,
- 2:27:36SPEAKER_03: and it's through our pursuit of the thing that we,
- 2:27:40SPEAKER_03: like,
- 2:27:40SPEAKER_03: the pursuit is itself made possible,
- 2:27:42SPEAKER_03: but we are also already necessarily alienated from it.
- 2:27:44SPEAKER_03: Like, it's all this stuff, and it's like we are caught up in this weird Ouroboros of, like,
- 2:27:53SPEAKER_03: alienation activity alienation activity alienation activity um and we are being we
- 2:28:04SPEAKER_03: are being led around by the dick by capital right now and we want to live in a
- 2:28:10SPEAKER_03: world where we lead capital around by the dick yeah
- 2:28:14SPEAKER_03: And it takes people doing the thing and maybe confronting those terrifying emotions
- 2:28:22SPEAKER_03: of like,
- 2:28:23SPEAKER_03: what the fuck am I doing?
- 2:28:24SPEAKER_03: What is any of this for?
- 2:28:27SPEAKER_03: Like, that's maybe a, you know, a particular thing that we will all have to face.
- 2:28:32SPEAKER_03: But I do believe it is true that like...
- 2:28:35SPEAKER_03: It's through doing that,
- 2:28:37SPEAKER_03: then we can bring about conditions of possibility to finally reap the rewards of
- 2:28:42SPEAKER_03: what we sowed or whatever.
- 2:28:49SPEAKER_02: And I mean, they are hardcore, right?
- 2:28:51SPEAKER_02: This is the aspect where I think critical theory,
- 2:28:55SPEAKER_02: Marxism can be this kind of hardcore in the sense of like,
- 2:29:01SPEAKER_02: no,
- 2:29:01SPEAKER_02: no,
- 2:29:02SPEAKER_02: it's you.
- 2:29:03SPEAKER_02: You're implicated in all of this.
- 2:29:05SPEAKER_02: There is no easy-peasy,
- 2:29:08SPEAKER_02: Perdonian,
- 2:29:09SPEAKER_02: Bakunian,
- 2:29:10SPEAKER_02: anarchist-y cushion where you can say,
- 2:29:13SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 2:29:13SPEAKER_02: well,
- 2:29:14SPEAKER_02: the farmers.
- 2:29:15SPEAKER_02: It's like, no.
- 2:29:16SPEAKER_02: that's already the process is already happening there yeah there is no outside to
- 2:29:21SPEAKER_02: this there's no um it is the process itself yeah but and that yeah the is that a is
- 2:29:34SPEAKER_03: that a utilitarian process or is it an
- 2:29:40SPEAKER_03: emergent magical process i i think that's it i think it has the potential to be
- 2:29:45SPEAKER_03: magical or to be utilitarian and i and i think that's where we need we need to come
- 2:29:51SPEAKER_03: down on the side of magic uh in order to resist this kind of utilitarian because it
- 2:29:59SPEAKER_03: could become just this process it could become the the donkey sucking its own dick
- 2:30:06SPEAKER_02: um but um how do you make the distinction
- 2:30:10SPEAKER_03: intentionality care yeah i think yeah i i think i think that's it yeah yeah of
- 2:30:19SPEAKER_02: course like we have always to refer back to that you know in a sense like i would
- 2:30:24SPEAKER_02: even say referring back to to what what i just what you said earlier with
- 2:30:29SPEAKER_02: enchantment you know i've i can understand that um and of course the
- 2:30:36SPEAKER_02: we can not be anything more than what we are right now in this world.
- 2:30:41SPEAKER_02: You know, I think that's the thing.
- 2:30:42SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:30:49SPEAKER_02: But I think at the same time,
- 2:30:51SPEAKER_02: it's interesting as people who like thinking about like that,
- 2:30:58SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 2:30:59SPEAKER_02: it will have to necessarily change.
- 2:31:01SPEAKER_02: And I don't mean that in the sense of like saying I'm in the position to say
- 2:31:08SPEAKER_02: whatever fuck cultural issue it is yeah whatever on the plethora pick one pick the
- 2:31:13SPEAKER_02: worst yeah imagine that i am on that position i really like that that they've said
- 2:31:17SPEAKER_02: that lately yeah imagine that um uh but that this discussion will necessarily
- 2:31:27SPEAKER_02: change you know like the the
- 2:31:30SPEAKER_02: the perception we have now.
- 2:31:32SPEAKER_02: And I think that's my point,
- 2:31:34SPEAKER_02: why I wanted to read it,
- 2:31:35SPEAKER_02: because I think they make the claim that they say even postmodernism is implicated
- 2:31:42SPEAKER_02: in this process.
- 2:31:46SPEAKER_02: And so that's the question where I'm like,
- 2:31:48SPEAKER_02: when I'm critiquing it,
- 2:31:50SPEAKER_02: where I'm like,
- 2:31:51SPEAKER_02: what are the conditions for postmodernity?
- 2:31:59SPEAKER_02: well why why does it why does it appear us that we have to to pay this due because
- 2:32:04SPEAKER_02: they they put it in this frames yeah yeah like um redemption and it's fate and it
- 2:32:10SPEAKER_02: appears like um post-structuralism post-modernism what is truth everything is
- 2:32:17SPEAKER_02: discourse that it's it's um like a verdict in a sense
- 2:32:24SPEAKER_02: judgment um the discourse itself tells you um but that's not possible you know like
- 2:32:33SPEAKER_03: yeah no i like in the sense that we are punished in a sense or or we're doing a
- 2:32:39SPEAKER_03: self-flagellation we're doing like a performative self-flagellation rather than
- 2:32:44SPEAKER_03: just getting on with the business of
- 2:32:48SPEAKER_03: Like, doing the thing.
- 2:32:50SPEAKER_03: We're doing this apologia for why we can't do the thing.
- 2:32:53SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:32:56SPEAKER_03: Yeah, dude.
- 2:32:57SPEAKER_03: It feels...
- 2:33:01SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 2:33:01SPEAKER_03: It feels feels radical as fuck.
- 2:33:03SPEAKER_03: And we don't like radicals.
- 2:33:05SPEAKER_03: But but no,
- 2:33:08SPEAKER_03: in the sense of like it's putting the ball in in your court while it's implicating
- 2:33:15SPEAKER_03: you and it's saying you are guilty.
- 2:33:19SPEAKER_03: It's also it's also saying you are also freed up because like you are the
- 2:33:24SPEAKER_03: conditions of possibility for this.
- 2:33:26SPEAKER_03: And it's necessarily in concert with nature and God and the social and all these other things.
- 2:33:31SPEAKER_03: But it's saying you're also there too.
- 2:33:36SPEAKER_03: Whereas in the world that we live in, it's like we are eradicated by our function.
- 2:33:43SPEAKER_03: Because we play a role and we serve a function, our subjectivity and our singularity gets eradicated.
- 2:33:52SPEAKER_03: And so we are no longer in relation...
- 2:33:56SPEAKER_03: to, to God and nature in the world, just the fungible token of man.
- 2:34:03SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:34:04SPEAKER_03: Takes the place in that equation.
- 2:34:06SPEAKER_03: And I think it is radical.
- 2:34:09SPEAKER_03: to undo that substitution and say,
- 2:34:13SPEAKER_03: I am not fungible and you are not fungible and you out there on the internet are,
- 2:34:18SPEAKER_03: are not fungible.
- 2:34:20SPEAKER_03: I think that's radical.
- 2:34:20SPEAKER_03: And maybe that's the most radical thing.
- 2:34:22SPEAKER_03: And maybe that's the only type of like radical thought that I'm willing to
- 2:34:27SPEAKER_03: entertain at least right now,
- 2:34:29SPEAKER_03: because it does center
- 2:34:32SPEAKER_03: human once again rather than centering a signifier or history or the right side of
- 2:34:37SPEAKER_02: history or whatever yeah yeah yeah i mean um but isn't that what emancipation is
- 2:34:46SPEAKER_02: about
- 2:34:48SPEAKER_03: I think so.
- 2:34:48SPEAKER_02: This is where it's like, because of course they say, why do they critique enlightenment?
- 2:34:54SPEAKER_02: Of course they do it because it brought about the bourgeois revolution,
- 2:34:59SPEAKER_02: which was freedom,
- 2:35:01SPEAKER_02: which did away with the old power structures or pushed them
- 2:35:07SPEAKER_02: into a position where they could not be the totalizing force anymore.
- 2:35:14SPEAKER_02: And so they criticize the attempt at emancipation itself.
- 2:35:20SPEAKER_02: And they do that in a situation where they're like, okay, we don't like these fascists.
- 2:35:25SPEAKER_02: We don't like USA.
- 2:35:29SPEAKER_02: What's on offer else?
- 2:35:30SPEAKER_02: We are Marxists.
- 2:35:31SPEAKER_02: Oh, there's the Soviet Union.
- 2:35:32SPEAKER_02: We don't like these fucking totalitarian assholes.
- 2:35:36SPEAKER_02: What the fuck should we do?
- 2:35:38SPEAKER_02: Like, last night I read...
- 2:35:41SPEAKER_02: their exchange about if they want to start a party or write a manifesto.
- 2:35:47SPEAKER_02: They thought about writing.
- 2:35:48SPEAKER_02: It's the most real shit I have read in a long time.
- 2:35:52SPEAKER_02: These two guys, they don't have the answers either.
- 2:35:58SPEAKER_02: They problematize this themselves.
- 2:36:03SPEAKER_02: For anyone, if you read it, it's great.
- 2:36:06SPEAKER_02: Platypus, I think, has it on their site.
- 2:36:09SPEAKER_02: You can find it.
- 2:36:10SPEAKER_03: I'm going to check that out.
- 2:36:11SPEAKER_03: Maybe, maybe tonight.
- 2:36:13SPEAKER_03: Maybe I'll read that tonight.
- 2:36:14SPEAKER_03: Uh,
- 2:36:15SPEAKER_02: dude,
- 2:36:15SPEAKER_02: he's like,
- 2:36:16SPEAKER_02: he's like at some point they're like,
- 2:36:18SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 2:36:18SPEAKER_02: but we,
- 2:36:18SPEAKER_02: but when we only do a theory because it's nice to do it,
- 2:36:22SPEAKER_02: um,
- 2:36:23SPEAKER_02: then we can just become a liberal bourgeois professors.
- 2:36:27SPEAKER_00: That's it.
- 2:36:28SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:36:28SPEAKER_02: They, they really face themselves like that, you know, like, um, um,
- 2:36:42SPEAKER_03: I was gonna... I was gonna make a comment about Katrone, but... I like Katrone a lot.
- 2:36:52SPEAKER_03: So I'm not gonna make a... Oh, you wanted to do it?
- 2:36:54SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 2:36:56SPEAKER_03: I was going to make a shitty comment just to be provocative because Chris Cattrone
- 2:36:59SPEAKER_03: himself is a provocative man.
- 2:37:02SPEAKER_03: But I think he does it better.
- 2:37:04SPEAKER_03: I think I'm not so good at being intentionally provocative.
- 2:37:07SPEAKER_03: I think I'm good at stumbling into provocation.
- 2:37:11SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's like it's an art form.
- 2:37:15SPEAKER_02: It is an art form, but...
- 2:37:18SPEAKER_02: I think maybe the more white trash way,
- 2:37:21SPEAKER_02: as I know it,
- 2:37:21SPEAKER_02: is to stumble into it and be like,
- 2:37:24SPEAKER_02: and then blinking and be like,
- 2:37:26SPEAKER_02: this was not okay,
- 2:37:26SPEAKER_02: guys.
- 2:37:27SPEAKER_02: I thought we are all shitting on each other.
- 2:37:30SPEAKER_03: You reach that moment of inversion when it's like, oh shit, did I break the relation?
- 2:37:36SPEAKER_03: Did I fuck up?
- 2:37:41SPEAKER_03: that insecurity that tension uh that is that's a class if you have but if you want
- 2:37:48SPEAKER_02: if you have a critique like i would like to hear it because like i don't know he he
- 2:37:53SPEAKER_02: kind of is the usa adorno guy uh no in some circuits he he is and uh i guess over
- 2:38:02SPEAKER_03: the past several months i'm just becoming more and more convinced that i i can't
- 2:38:06SPEAKER_03: sidestep
- 2:38:08SPEAKER_03: Adorno.
- 2:38:10SPEAKER_03: And I think.
- 2:38:13SPEAKER_03: a few months ago i i did a deep dive into binyamin and i'm glad i did because i
- 2:38:17SPEAKER_03: think it uh added a lot to i guess my my position or point of view or whatever and
- 2:38:24SPEAKER_03: i'm i'm like i'm coming to learn like um or coming to understand i guess like i i
- 2:38:30SPEAKER_03: do have to read this seriously i do have to grapple with frankfurt school you can't
- 2:38:36SPEAKER_03: just vaguely gesture oh yeah frankfurt school frankfurt school like you have to
- 2:38:40SPEAKER_03: like you actually do you have to read
- 2:38:43SPEAKER_02: Like everybody does.
- 2:38:45SPEAKER_02: Frankfurt School.
- 2:38:45SPEAKER_03: I feel like everybody.
- 2:38:49SPEAKER_02: Of course.
- 2:38:51SPEAKER_03: Like conservative,
- 2:38:52SPEAKER_03: not conservatives,
- 2:38:53SPEAKER_03: but like some people,
- 2:38:55SPEAKER_03: like reactionaries on the internet will make reference to the Frankfurt School,
- 2:38:59SPEAKER_03: but they'll call it like the Franklin School.
- 2:39:02SPEAKER_03: Like I heard one guy...
- 2:39:03SPEAKER_03: Talk about cultural Marxists and the Franklin School.
- 2:39:07SPEAKER_03: And I was like, what are you doing, dude?
- 2:39:10SPEAKER_00: Nobody knows.
- 2:39:12SPEAKER_03: It is post-modernity.
- 2:39:14SPEAKER_03: When we can have wide,
- 2:39:17SPEAKER_03: broad,
- 2:39:18SPEAKER_03: vibrant social and political movements that are predicated on the Franklin School
- 2:39:24SPEAKER_03: or the hatred of the Franklin School.
- 2:39:27SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:39:28SPEAKER_03: You don't even have to, like, you don't have to tarry.
- 2:39:31SPEAKER_03: You don't have to dwell.
- 2:39:32SPEAKER_03: You can just vaguely gesture at the straw man.
- 2:39:35SPEAKER_03: But that's efficacious.
- 2:39:38SPEAKER_03: Like, that is postmodernity.
- 2:39:40SPEAKER_03: That is the postmodern condition.
- 2:39:43SPEAKER_03: And that's why... That's true.
- 2:39:46SPEAKER_03: That's a good point.
- 2:39:47SPEAKER_03: I want to defend...
- 2:39:50SPEAKER_03: Post-modernism or my version of post-modernism,
- 2:39:53SPEAKER_03: which is almost the exact opposite of what gets called post-modernism,
- 2:39:58SPEAKER_03: right?
- 2:39:59SPEAKER_03: Because post-modernism was always this critique of the post-modern condition.
- 2:40:04SPEAKER_03: And it was always saying like,
- 2:40:06SPEAKER_03: you guys think we're so high and mighty and we're living in modernity and we are
- 2:40:09SPEAKER_03: the peak of enlightenment and we are free and we are emancipated.
- 2:40:12SPEAKER_03: And look at the bourgeois freedom that we have in our hands.
- 2:40:16SPEAKER_03: Post-modernity was always saying, yeah, but it's all bullshit.
- 2:40:20SPEAKER_03: And let me try to explain to you why and how it's all bullshit.
- 2:40:23SPEAKER_03: So that's the version of post-modernity that I champion.
- 2:40:26SPEAKER_03: That's the pale horse that I ride in on.
- 2:40:33SPEAKER_03: But you do have to actually read books and know what you're talking about in order
- 2:40:37SPEAKER_03: to be able to talk about things.
- 2:40:38SPEAKER_03: I do get to get away with a lot because I am.
- 2:40:41SPEAKER_03: I could just say, well, I'm a post-modernist, so it doesn't really matter to me.
- 2:40:45SPEAKER_03: I don't have to read your books.
- 2:40:46SPEAKER_03: It's all bullshit.
- 2:40:47SPEAKER_02: Checkmate.
- 2:40:48SPEAKER_03: Checkmate, you fucking boxes.
- 2:40:54SPEAKER_02: Have you read Baudrillard?
- 2:40:56SPEAKER_03: Checkmate.
- 2:40:57SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:40:58SPEAKER_03: How about you read some Baudrillard, some Virilio, some Debord?
- 2:41:02SPEAKER_03: And look, these guys are my ultimate.
- 2:41:05SPEAKER_03: But so is Binyamin.
- 2:41:07SPEAKER_03: And Adorno is also coming to make his way up on my Mount Rushmore as well.
- 2:41:11SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:41:14SPEAKER_03: So I think it's good.
- 2:41:15SPEAKER_03: I do kind of want to... How much more time do you got?
- 2:41:19SPEAKER_02: I have time, man.
- 2:41:20SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 2:41:22SPEAKER_02: My plans for this Friday is you.
- 2:41:25SPEAKER_02: Hell yeah.
- 2:41:28SPEAKER_02: I wanted to...
- 2:41:31SPEAKER_02: One thing, two things.
- 2:41:34SPEAKER_02: But if you want to sidestep it,
- 2:41:36SPEAKER_02: you just have to say it openly because I'm this kind of autistic person who cannot
- 2:41:40SPEAKER_02: read social cues so good.
- 2:41:41SPEAKER_02: Because I didn't get really,
- 2:41:42SPEAKER_02: Katron's,
- 2:41:43SPEAKER_02: like your critique on Proton,
- 2:41:45SPEAKER_02: like what was the...
- 2:41:49SPEAKER_03: I don't even know.
- 2:41:50SPEAKER_02: The thought you had.
- 2:41:51SPEAKER_02: I'm interested in your thought.
- 2:41:53SPEAKER_02: And I think you can give it to him.
- 2:41:55SPEAKER_02: I think he dishes out pretty high.
- 2:41:58SPEAKER_03: um stuff sometimes well and and i i don't know a few weeks ago i started thinking
- 2:42:08SPEAKER_03: and started writing to him um i guess the only thing the only thing that i
- 2:42:21SPEAKER_03: there's a level of certainty that I,
- 2:42:23SPEAKER_03: that to me almost feels like a trans historicization of some things that I just am
- 2:42:32SPEAKER_03: wary of,
- 2:42:33SPEAKER_03: but I also understand that like for the purposes of this book and for the purposes of,
- 2:42:40SPEAKER_03: of many things,
- 2:42:41SPEAKER_03: it's a methodological thing.
- 2:42:43SPEAKER_03: And it's like, well, we're just going to take this as certain so we can allow this other thing to unfold.
- 2:42:49SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 2:42:51SPEAKER_03: And I and I look, I think Katron is aware of that.
- 2:42:54SPEAKER_03: I think I think he's aware of what he's bracketing and when and how he's bracketing it.
- 2:42:58SPEAKER_03: There's also sometimes that I think he I think he's wrong.
- 2:43:02SPEAKER_03: I think he fetishizes like the gendarmes like he he he's puts too much emphasis on
- 2:43:08SPEAKER_03: the special bodies of armed men and this kind of modern iteration of the state.
- 2:43:16SPEAKER_03: That I think allows or enables him to,
- 2:43:22SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 2:43:26SPEAKER_03: do some weird kind of transistor cessation of like bourgeois ideology.
- 2:43:32SPEAKER_01: Mm-hmm.
- 2:43:34SPEAKER_01: Mm-hmm.
- 2:43:35SPEAKER_02: Ah, okay.
- 2:43:36SPEAKER_02: I see the fault line now.
- 2:43:37SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:43:38SPEAKER_03: I see the... But that's... I mean, that's... For me, that's an open question.
- 2:43:43SPEAKER_03: And it's an open line of conversation.
- 2:43:46SPEAKER_03: It's not that I'm saying, Chris, you're wrong.
- 2:43:48SPEAKER_03: It's... I'm saying...
- 2:43:51SPEAKER_03: okay, I kind of see where you're going.
- 2:43:54SPEAKER_03: I'll sit here and I'll listen and I'll take notes.
- 2:43:56SPEAKER_03: And these are one of the questions that I have in mind as I'm privy to the unfolding of the conversation.
- 2:44:03SPEAKER_03: So it's not that I have any problems at all.
- 2:44:06SPEAKER_02: Yeah, but that would be interesting to think about, like, to rephrase it a bit, like how I got it.
- 2:44:14SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah.
- 2:44:14SPEAKER_02: Like, to say, like, okay, Bonaparte State, yeah, yeah, yeah, yada, yada, right?
- 2:44:23SPEAKER_02: Like, special bodies of armed men.
- 2:44:28SPEAKER_02: How do we take this as, like, a monolithic thing?
- 2:44:32SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 2:44:33SPEAKER_02: That, like, the Bonaparte State always...
- 2:44:36SPEAKER_02: the capitalist state always operates in the same way or can this change in the
- 2:44:43SPEAKER_02: process of I would take it as the process of barbarization like can we get so
- 2:44:50SPEAKER_02: barbarized
- 2:44:53SPEAKER_02: as society in the sense of decadence yes something is not attained something is not
- 2:45:01SPEAKER_02: sublated and so like where does this is capitalism just being trapped in like a
- 2:45:12SPEAKER_02: time box and there's no time happening or are we moving forward and I'm undecided
- 2:45:19SPEAKER_02: on the question to be honest
- 2:45:21SPEAKER_02: yeah i'm not so sure i'm i'm still not sure if i would say the internet is if i put
- 2:45:28SPEAKER_02: it in the way that adorno and hawkheimer did it with the compass yeah where i say
- 2:45:32SPEAKER_03: like this is just the postal service but yeah specialized no i i do i do think it
- 2:45:39SPEAKER_03: is true that uh things have changed so we have made
- 2:45:47SPEAKER_03: We have moved in time.
- 2:45:50SPEAKER_03: We're not just trapped in the time box.
- 2:45:53SPEAKER_03: And I think,
- 2:45:53SPEAKER_03: yeah,
- 2:45:54SPEAKER_03: I think the drone is quick to say that like we are kind of frozen in time,
- 2:46:00SPEAKER_03: but look,
- 2:46:02SPEAKER_03: going back to even this conversation where we talked about change and like
- 2:46:06SPEAKER_03: projection and how looking at a thing changes both the thing phenomenologically,
- 2:46:12SPEAKER_03: but it also changes the subject who is doing the looking
- 2:46:17SPEAKER_03: And I think if anything, yeah, Katron kind of brackets out that change over time, change in time.
- 2:46:27SPEAKER_03: And I think it is true that the internet is...
- 2:46:32SPEAKER_03: And look,
- 2:46:33SPEAKER_03: I've even said this in the past where the internet is,
- 2:46:35SPEAKER_03: it's not a qualitative difference in anything.
- 2:46:40SPEAKER_03: It's just a quantitative difference.
- 2:46:43SPEAKER_03: And it's about the acceleration and the saturation of the simulation rather than
- 2:46:48SPEAKER_03: the actual disposition towards or relation to communication.
- 2:46:52SPEAKER_03: And no, I was wrong when I said that.
- 2:46:55SPEAKER_03: I do think the internet is new.
- 2:46:58SPEAKER_03: I do think that the types, the modalities, the relations, the dispositions, all of this
- 2:47:05SPEAKER_03: These are new,
- 2:47:07SPEAKER_03: and the way they're impacting subjectivity is different from just the TV and just
- 2:47:13SPEAKER_03: the newspaper and just the telegraph and just the printed page.
- 2:47:18SPEAKER_03: I think the Internet is different because—
- 2:47:23SPEAKER_03: read virilio i think virilio is kind of big on on how and why these things have
- 2:47:29SPEAKER_03: have changed us but i don't know maybe even virilio would say it's not a
- 2:47:34SPEAKER_03: qualitative change it's just a quantitative change that now i want to go back and
- 2:47:38SPEAKER_03: read more virilio to see where he comes down but i i do think i do think he would
- 2:47:44SPEAKER_03: say it's it's new it's
- 2:47:47SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:47:47SPEAKER_02: like the Hegelian point is also to say like quantitative change is a qualitative
- 2:47:53SPEAKER_02: change at some point,
- 2:47:54SPEAKER_02: right?
- 2:47:54SPEAKER_02: Like you can just... When it reaches that threshold, it does become new.
- 2:47:59SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:48:03SPEAKER_03: Or maybe not new, but different, right?
- 2:48:05SPEAKER_03: Difference.
- 2:48:06SPEAKER_03: There's a difference.
- 2:48:07SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:48:08SPEAKER_02: I'm holding this dialectical tension within myself between...
- 2:48:14SPEAKER_02: Yeah, because I think it's a political question too, right?
- 2:48:19SPEAKER_02: In a sense,
- 2:48:20SPEAKER_02: if you say Marxism is a critique of the movement for socialism,
- 2:48:28SPEAKER_02: a critique of the working class movement towards socialism,
- 2:48:32SPEAKER_02: The critique is nothing else.
- 2:48:35SPEAKER_02: And it has at its background always the revolution in mind.
- 2:48:39SPEAKER_02: It was written by revolutionaries.
- 2:48:41SPEAKER_02: Revolutionaries developed it further.
- 2:48:44SPEAKER_02: These two guys who are Marxists, if you read it tonight, which would be great,
- 2:48:53SPEAKER_02: You will see they tarry with their impossibility to be revolutionaries,
- 2:48:59SPEAKER_02: where they're like,
- 2:49:00SPEAKER_02: what the fuck are we if we are not?
- 2:49:01SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:49:03SPEAKER_02: And I think in that sense...
- 2:49:09SPEAKER_02: then it makes sense to in a sense to trans-historicize it because you always ask
- 2:49:15SPEAKER_02: the Lenin question you always like the key to Chris Catrone for me is like when he
- 2:49:21SPEAKER_02: said in one when Dave was still plebe when he said to the one guy listening Lenin
- 2:49:27SPEAKER_02: Lenin is your guy it was like what does he mean and I think maybe what he means is
- 2:49:34SPEAKER_02: what is to be done
- 2:49:36SPEAKER_02: To constantly ask the question, what is to be done?
- 2:49:39SPEAKER_02: Okay, I have this whole situation around me.
- 2:49:44SPEAKER_02: I can reify the situation or I can critique it and critique it in order to what?
- 2:49:50SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 2:49:52SPEAKER_02: And I think that's where the fourth line, or maybe you squiggly line, not yet osmosic.
- 2:50:00SPEAKER_02: A dotted line.
- 2:50:02SPEAKER_03: A perforated membrane.
- 2:50:05SPEAKER_03: Yeah, something like that, yeah.
- 2:50:07SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:50:09SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:50:09SPEAKER_03: Well, and I do think...
- 2:50:14SPEAKER_03: I think we can have a critique for the sake of understanding,
- 2:50:18SPEAKER_03: even though,
- 2:50:20SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 2:50:20SPEAKER_03: that understanding itself is a big question mark.
- 2:50:26SPEAKER_03: Um, it, well, and I think once again, that goes down to intentionality.
- 2:50:35SPEAKER_03: What it like, what, what is the intentionality and,
- 2:50:43SPEAKER_03: is the intentionality to act on the world in and on the world or is the
- 2:50:47SPEAKER_03: intentionality to understand one's situation with reference to the world so that
- 2:50:53SPEAKER_03: one can decide whether or not to act in and on the world um i don't know but that
- 2:51:00SPEAKER_03: that that itself is a dialectic right you can't think without action you can't act
- 2:51:04SPEAKER_02: without thinking yeah uh i think that's
- 2:51:08SPEAKER_03: When I think like all of those contradictions center us,
- 2:51:12SPEAKER_03: like once again,
- 2:51:12SPEAKER_03: it comes back to this radical centering of like,
- 2:51:16SPEAKER_03: I am the subject,
- 2:51:17SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 2:51:18SPEAKER_03: I am the one for whom this question is a question.
- 2:51:21SPEAKER_03: Yes.
- 2:51:22SPEAKER_03: So I think that that's always good to always, always come back and always resituate yourself.
- 2:51:28SPEAKER_03: That's why I'm doing this in the first place, because I am the one for whom this is a question.
- 2:51:36SPEAKER_02: Pretty good reason, I think.
- 2:51:38SPEAKER_03: I think.
- 2:51:38SPEAKER_02: For me too.
- 2:51:39SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:51:40SPEAKER_02: No, I really do.
- 2:51:42SPEAKER_02: And I take it serious.
- 2:51:44SPEAKER_02: It's not like I don't want to be just jerking off my oscillation between everything
- 2:51:52SPEAKER_02: is fucked or maybe I have to immediately start...
- 2:51:56SPEAKER_02: uh helping build the socialist party is is yeah it's an indicator of like how
- 2:52:04SPEAKER_03: serious i take this yeah i'm gonna make another tea and go to the bathroom again
- 2:52:11SPEAKER_02: yeah then then i continue do we want to continue right oh yeah right oh yeah yeah
- 2:52:18SPEAKER_02: yeah
- 2:52:22SPEAKER_02: And then maybe we can change because then I will do the same, but with a cigarette and bathroom.
- 2:52:27SPEAKER_02: Cool man.
- 2:52:29SPEAKER_02: The distance between subject and object,
- 2:52:32SPEAKER_02: a presupposition of abstraction,
- 2:52:35SPEAKER_02: is grounded in the distance from the thing itself,
- 2:52:39SPEAKER_02: which the master achieved through the mastered.
- 2:52:44SPEAKER_02: The lyrics of Homer and the hymns of the Rig Veda date from the time of territorial
- 2:52:51SPEAKER_02: dominion and the secure locations in which a dominant warlike race established
- 2:52:56SPEAKER_02: themselves over the mass of vanquished natives.
- 2:53:01SPEAKER_02: The first god among the gods arose with this civil society in which the king,
- 2:53:08SPEAKER_02: as chieftain of the arms-bearing nobility,
- 2:53:11SPEAKER_02: holds down the conquered to the earth,
- 2:53:14SPEAKER_02: whereas physicians,
- 2:53:16SPEAKER_02: soothsayers,
- 2:53:17SPEAKER_02: craftsmen and merchants see to social intercourse.
- 2:53:24SPEAKER_02: With the end of a nomadic existence, the social order is created on a basis of fixed property.
- 2:53:31SPEAKER_02: Mastery and labor are divided.
- 2:53:35SPEAKER_02: A proprietor like Odysseus,
- 2:53:38SPEAKER_02: quote,
- 2:53:39SPEAKER_02: manages from a distance a numerous,
- 2:53:42SPEAKER_02: carefully gradated staff of cowherds,
- 2:53:46SPEAKER_02: shepherds,
- 2:53:47SPEAKER_02: swineherds and servants.
- 2:53:50SPEAKER_02: In the evening,
- 2:53:51SPEAKER_02: when he has seen from his castle that the countryside is illumined by a thousand fires,
- 2:53:59SPEAKER_02: he can compose himself for sleep with a quiet mind.
- 2:54:03SPEAKER_02: He knows that his upright servants are keeping watch lest wild animals approach and
- 2:54:10SPEAKER_02: to chase thieves from the preserves which they are to protect.
- 2:54:15SPEAKER_02: This was a quote from footnote Glotz.
- 2:54:21SPEAKER_02: from a certain book he wrote on Greek and Homer.
- 2:54:26SPEAKER_02: The universality of ideas as developed by discursive logic,
- 2:54:32SPEAKER_02: domination in the conceptual sphere is raised up on the basis of actual domination.
- 2:54:39SPEAKER_02: The dissolution of the magical heritage of the old diffuse ideas by conceptual unity
- 2:54:48SPEAKER_02: expresses the hierarchical constitution of life determined by those who are free.
- 2:54:57SPEAKER_02: The individuality that learned order and subordination in the subjection of the
- 2:55:04SPEAKER_02: world soon wholly equated truth with the regulative thought without whose fixed
- 2:55:13SPEAKER_02: distinctions universal truth cannot exist.
- 2:55:18SPEAKER_02: Together with mimetic magic, it tabooed the knowledge which really concerned the object.
- 2:55:27SPEAKER_02: Its hatred was extended to the image of the vanquished former age and its imaginary happiness.
- 2:55:35SPEAKER_02: The chthonic gods of the original inhabitants are banished to the hell,
- 2:55:42SPEAKER_02: to which,
- 2:55:42SPEAKER_02: according to the sun and light religion of Indra and Zeus,
- 2:55:47SPEAKER_02: the earth is transformed.
- 2:55:50SPEAKER_02: Heaven and hell, however, hang together.
- 2:55:55SPEAKER_02: Just as the name of Zeus in non-exclusive cults was given to a god of the
- 2:56:00SPEAKER_02: underworld as well as to a god of light.
- 2:56:04SPEAKER_02: Just as the Olympian gods had every kind of commerce with the platonic deities,
- 2:56:13SPEAKER_02: so the good and evil powers...
- 2:56:16SPEAKER_02: Salvation and disaster were not unequivocally distinct, they were linked together.
- 2:56:25SPEAKER_02: Like coming up and passing away, life and death, summer and winter.
- 2:56:33SPEAKER_02: The gloomy and distinct religious principle that was honored as mana in the
- 2:56:40SPEAKER_02: earliest known stages of humanity lives on in the radiant world of Greek religion.
- 2:56:47SPEAKER_02: Everything unknown and alien is primary and undifferentiated.
- 2:56:55SPEAKER_02: that which transcends the confines of experience whatever in things is more than
- 2:57:02SPEAKER_02: their previously known reality what the primitive experiences in this regard
- 2:57:11SPEAKER_02: What the primitive experiences in this regard is not a spiritual as opposed to a
- 2:57:18SPEAKER_02: material substance,
- 2:57:20SPEAKER_02: but the intricacies of the natural in contrast to the individual.
- 2:57:26SPEAKER_02: The gasp of surprise, which accompanies the experience of the unusual, becomes its name.
- 2:57:38SPEAKER_02: It fixes the transcendence of the unknown in relation to the known and therefore terror as sacredness.
- 2:57:49SPEAKER_02: The dualization of nature as appearance and sequence,
- 2:57:53SPEAKER_02: effort and power,
- 2:57:55SPEAKER_02: which first makes possible both myth and science originates in human fear,
- 2:58:01SPEAKER_02: the expression of which becomes explanation.
- 2:58:07SPEAKER_02: it is not the soul which is transposed to nature as psychologism would have it mana
- 2:58:15SPEAKER_02: the moving spirit is no projection but the echo of the real supremacy of nature in
- 2:58:23SPEAKER_02: the weak souls of primitive men
- 2:58:28SPEAKER_02: The separation of the animate and the inanimate,
- 2:58:31SPEAKER_02: the occupation of certain places by demons and deities,
- 2:58:36SPEAKER_02: first arises from this pre-animism,
- 2:58:40SPEAKER_02: which contains the first lines of the separation of subject and object.
- 2:58:46SPEAKER_02: When the tree is no longer approached merely as tree,
- 2:58:51SPEAKER_02: but as evidence for an other,
- 2:58:54SPEAKER_02: as the location of mana,
- 2:58:57SPEAKER_02: language expresses the contradiction that something is itself and at one,
- 2:59:05SPEAKER_02: and at the same time something other than itself,
- 2:59:08SPEAKER_02: identical and not identical.
- 2:59:13SPEAKER_02: Through the deity, language is transformed from tautology to language.
- 2:59:22SPEAKER_02: the concept which some would see as the sign unit for whatever is comprised under it,
- 2:59:29SPEAKER_02: and this is mouse,
- 2:59:31SPEAKER_02: the sign unit for whatever is comprised under it,
- 2:59:36SPEAKER_02: has from the beginning been instead the product of dialectical thinking in which
- 2:59:45SPEAKER_02: everything is always that which it is,
- 2:59:48SPEAKER_02: only because it becomes that which it is not.
- 2:59:53SPEAKER_02: that was the original form of objectifying definition in which concept and thing
- 3:00:01SPEAKER_02: are separated the same form which is already far advanced in the homeric epic and
- 3:00:08SPEAKER_02: confounds itself in modern positivist science
- 3:00:13SPEAKER_02: But this dialectic remains impotent to the extent that it develops from the cry of terror,
- 3:00:20SPEAKER_02: which is the duplication,
- 3:00:22SPEAKER_02: the tautology of terror itself.
- 3:00:27SPEAKER_02: And a small side note that for anyone there was this battle in like German
- 3:00:36SPEAKER_02: intellectual and I think even like US,
- 3:00:38SPEAKER_02: like Western intellectualism,
- 3:00:41SPEAKER_02: which was the positivism dispute.
- 3:00:45SPEAKER_02: With Karl Popper as like the deterministic science guy who said like science can
- 3:00:54SPEAKER_02: make claims and there can be like complete scientific objectivity.
- 3:01:01SPEAKER_02: And the Frankfurt School people who said,
- 3:01:04SPEAKER_02: no,
- 3:01:05SPEAKER_02: you are a scientist always involved in that which you do science on.
- 3:01:10SPEAKER_02: You cannot attain this position of subject objectivity.
- 3:01:17SPEAKER_03: This that really just just the other day, Dave and I read.
- 3:01:23SPEAKER_03: The first lecture.
- 3:01:29SPEAKER_03: Classification struggles by Bordeaux.
- 3:01:32SPEAKER_02: Yeah, dude, I was in the chat.
- 3:01:34SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 3:01:37SPEAKER_03: That point that Bordeaux made over and over again.
- 3:01:44SPEAKER_03: that like you are in you are in the field that you are trying to research trying to
- 3:01:49SPEAKER_03: study like you are doing the thing that you are also trying to critique so like
- 3:01:54SPEAKER_03: don't get shit twisted don't like don't don't forget uh that you have one
- 3:02:01SPEAKER_03: perspective
- 3:02:04SPEAKER_03: and like how does your perspective change how does your like how does your location
- 3:02:10SPEAKER_03: in the field itself change the field and change your understanding of the field and
- 3:02:15SPEAKER_03: also your intentionality what is it that you aim to do what like what what are you
- 3:02:21SPEAKER_03: here hoping to extract from this study this research this critique um
- 3:02:32SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 3:02:33SPEAKER_03: I think this false idea of objectivity is a silly one that has led to inhuman
- 3:02:42SPEAKER_03: horrors over and over and over again.
- 3:02:44SPEAKER_03: And I think it's going to continue leading to horrible things.
- 3:02:51SPEAKER_03: When people...
- 3:02:55SPEAKER_03: do this thing.
- 3:02:56SPEAKER_03: And I think maybe that's a version of nature or God, just the objective, the outside.
- 3:03:04SPEAKER_03: Again, no, no, there isn't an outside.
- 3:03:07SPEAKER_03: It's here between us.
- 3:03:09SPEAKER_03: This is where any of this exists in the first place.
- 3:03:12SPEAKER_03: So people who think they can attain this objectivity,
- 3:03:16SPEAKER_03: especially by being analytic or especially by maintaining the disinterested
- 3:03:24SPEAKER_03: distance of the scientist.
- 3:03:27SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:03:30SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that's that's a recipe for disaster.
- 3:03:35SPEAKER_02: Yeah, man.
- 3:03:36SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:03:36SPEAKER_02: And I think, um,
- 3:03:41SPEAKER_02: um which is funny because it it um it obfuscates right like i think like it
- 3:03:48SPEAKER_02: obfuscates the the point their point would be it obfuscates how they are already
- 3:03:55SPEAKER_02: shaping that which they you know like wire power you like you already subjugating
- 3:04:02SPEAKER_02: you cannot act like you don't do that but I think like Bourdieu's critique is more
- 3:04:12SPEAKER_02: like post Heideggerian his own thing kinda like because it's more structural I
- 3:04:19SPEAKER_02: think and their point I would take it to be here more Marxist in that they say like
- 3:04:27SPEAKER_02: um
- 3:04:33SPEAKER_02: The objectifying definition in which concept and thing are separated.
- 3:04:36SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think they take it even further in a sense that they say this is all society.
- 3:04:44SPEAKER_02: You cannot act like you are not in.
- 3:04:47SPEAKER_02: But maybe I'm too unfair to both you right now.
- 3:04:51SPEAKER_02: I have the feeling that Bourdieu comes at it from a different angle.
- 3:04:57SPEAKER_02: That's what I wanted to tease out.
- 3:04:59SPEAKER_03: I think he does.
- 3:05:03SPEAKER_03: But I do think the kind of impetus is to do the same thing.
- 3:05:10SPEAKER_03: To say, hold on, don't get shit twisted.
- 3:05:13SPEAKER_03: You are complicit.
- 3:05:15SPEAKER_03: You are also guilty of this.
- 3:05:19SPEAKER_03: But you are also freed up because of this thing.
- 3:05:23SPEAKER_03: It's this thing that you're implicated, but you are also freed.
- 3:05:29SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 3:05:29SPEAKER_03: Hey, David Powers is in the chat.
- 3:05:31SPEAKER_03: Hope you're doing well, man.
- 3:05:32SPEAKER_03: Hope you feel better.
- 3:05:33SPEAKER_03: Hi, David.
- 3:05:37SPEAKER_03: He's under the weather, so hope you're feeling better, man.
- 3:05:40SPEAKER_02: Oh, man.
- 3:05:41SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:05:45SPEAKER_02: Get well.
- 3:05:46SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:05:49SPEAKER_02: let me see if there's a good yeah okay just trying to
- 3:05:58SPEAKER_03: Identical and not identical.
- 3:05:59SPEAKER_03: Through the deity, language is transformed from tautology to language.
- 3:06:05SPEAKER_03: Oh, just read that.
- 3:06:07SPEAKER_03: I'll read it again, whatever.
- 3:06:08SPEAKER_03: The concept,
- 3:06:09SPEAKER_03: which some would see as the sign unit for whatever is comprised under it,
- 3:06:14SPEAKER_03: has from the beginning been instead the product of dialectical thinking in which
- 3:06:18SPEAKER_03: everything is always that which it is,
- 3:06:21SPEAKER_03: only because it becomes that which it is not.
- 3:06:26SPEAKER_03: That was the original form of objectifying definition, in which concept and thing are separated.
- 3:06:33SPEAKER_03: The same form,
- 3:06:34SPEAKER_03: which is already far advanced in the Homeric epic and confounds itself in modern
- 3:06:39SPEAKER_03: positivist science.
- 3:06:42SPEAKER_03: Oh, David feels horrible.
- 3:06:44SPEAKER_03: I'm sorry, dude.
- 3:06:45SPEAKER_03: I hope you get better, man.
- 3:06:49SPEAKER_03: the same form which is already far advanced in the Homeric epic and confounds
- 3:06:53SPEAKER_03: itself in modern positivist science.
- 3:06:58SPEAKER_03: But this dialectic remains impotent to the extent that it develops from the cry of terror,
- 3:07:03SPEAKER_03: which is the duplication,
- 3:07:05SPEAKER_03: the tautology,
- 3:07:06SPEAKER_03: of terror itself.
- 3:07:08SPEAKER_03: The gods cannot take fear away from man,
- 3:07:12SPEAKER_03: for they bear its petrified sound with them as they bear their names.
- 3:07:18SPEAKER_03: Man imagines himself free from fear when there is no longer anything unknown.
- 3:07:24SPEAKER_03: That determines the course of demythologization,
- 3:07:28SPEAKER_03: of enlightenment,
- 3:07:29SPEAKER_03: which compounds the animate with the inanimate,
- 3:07:31SPEAKER_03: just as myth compounds the inanimate with the animate.
- 3:07:36SPEAKER_03: Enlightenment is mythic fear turned radical.
- 3:07:40SPEAKER_03: The Revenge of the Primitive for Death
- 3:08:02SPEAKER_03: The revenge of the primitive for death when visited upon one of his kin was
- 3:08:06SPEAKER_03: sometimes appeased by reception of the murderer into his own family.
- 3:08:10SPEAKER_03: This, too, signified the infusion of alien blood into one's own, the generation of eminence.
- 3:08:18SPEAKER_03: The mythic dualism does not extend beyond the environs of existence.
- 3:08:23SPEAKER_03: the world permeated by manna,
- 3:08:26SPEAKER_03: and even the world of Indian and Greek myth know no exits,
- 3:08:30SPEAKER_03: and are eternally the same.
- 3:08:33SPEAKER_03: Every birth is paid for with death, every fortune with misfortune.
- 3:08:41SPEAKER_03: Men and gods may try in their short space to assess fate in other terms than the
- 3:08:46SPEAKER_03: blind course of destiny,
- 3:08:48SPEAKER_03: but in the end,
- 3:08:49SPEAKER_03: existence triumphs over them.
- 3:08:52SPEAKER_03: Even their justice, which is wrested from fatality, bears the marks of fatality.
- 3:08:57SPEAKER_03: It corresponds to the look which men,
- 3:09:00SPEAKER_03: primitives,
- 3:09:01SPEAKER_03: Greeks,
- 3:09:01SPEAKER_03: and barbarians alike,
- 3:09:03SPEAKER_03: cast from a society of pressure and misery on the circumambient world.
- 3:09:08SPEAKER_03: Hence,
- 3:09:09SPEAKER_03: for mythic and enlightened justice,
- 3:09:11SPEAKER_03: guilt and atonement,
- 3:09:13SPEAKER_03: happiness and unhappiness were sides of an equation.
- 3:09:17SPEAKER_03: Justice is subsumed in law—
- 3:09:20SPEAKER_03: The shaman wards off danger by means of its image.
- 3:09:24SPEAKER_03: Equivalence is his instrument, and equivalence regulates punishment and reward in civilization.
- 3:09:31SPEAKER_03: The mythic representations can also be traced back in their entirety to natural conditions.
- 3:09:38SPEAKER_03: Just as the Gemini,
- 3:09:39SPEAKER_03: the constellation of Castor and Pollux,
- 3:09:42SPEAKER_03: and all other symbols of duality refer to the inevitable cycle of nature,
- 3:09:46SPEAKER_03: which itself has its ancient sign in the symbol of the egg from which they came,
- 3:09:51SPEAKER_03: so the balance held by Zeus,
- 3:09:53SPEAKER_03: which symbolizes the justice of the entire patriarchal world,
- 3:09:57SPEAKER_03: refers back to mere nature.
- 3:10:00SPEAKER_03: The step from chaos to civilization,
- 3:10:03SPEAKER_03: in which natural conditions exert their power no longer directly but through the
- 3:10:08SPEAKER_03: medium of the human consciousness,
- 3:10:10SPEAKER_03: has not changed the principle of equivalence.
- 3:10:13SPEAKER_03: Indeed,
- 3:10:14SPEAKER_03: men paid for this very step by worshipping what they were once enthralled to only
- 3:10:19SPEAKER_03: in the same way as all other creatures.
- 3:10:23SPEAKER_03: Before, the fetishes were subject to the law of equivalence.
- 3:10:27SPEAKER_03: Now equivalence itself has become a fetish.
- 3:10:32SPEAKER_03: The blindfold over Justitia's eyes does not only mean that there should be no
- 3:10:37SPEAKER_03: assault upon justice,
- 3:10:39SPEAKER_03: but that justice does not originate in freedom.
- 3:10:48SPEAKER_03: David says, hell yeah.
- 3:10:51SPEAKER_03: Leaving the body behind to float inside the metamind.
- 3:10:53SPEAKER_03: Fuck yeah, homie.
- 3:10:55SPEAKER_03: Read the quote.
- 3:10:56SPEAKER_03: I think one of the points against Heidegger is you can't go back to some point in
- 3:10:59SPEAKER_03: early Greece before presence at hand in technological thinking.
- 3:11:02SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 3:11:03SPEAKER_03: And also maybe a dig against the concept of fate and destiny at the end of being in time.
- 3:11:08SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 3:11:09SPEAKER_03: I like that, David.
- 3:11:10SPEAKER_03: Good shit.
- 3:11:12SPEAKER_03: Earlier, we problematized...
- 3:11:15SPEAKER_03: And I think before we went live,
- 3:11:17SPEAKER_03: we were talking more about fate and destiny and this and that,
- 3:11:21SPEAKER_03: which I think at the very beginning of the video,
- 3:11:24SPEAKER_03: we make a little intro,
- 3:11:25SPEAKER_03: little reference to it.
- 3:11:28SPEAKER_03: But we also brought up how Heidegger seems to do this hard distinction between man
- 3:11:37SPEAKER_03: and technology and also nature and man.
- 3:11:41SPEAKER_03: Whereas in reality, technology is an emanation from man and man is an emanation from nature itself.
- 3:11:49SPEAKER_03: So it's this long interconnected cycle rather than discrete functions that
- 3:11:59SPEAKER_03: And I think that's where Heidegger goes wrong.
- 3:12:04SPEAKER_01: I agree.
- 3:12:06SPEAKER_03: The doctrine of the priests was symbolic in the sense that in it, sign and image were one.
- 3:12:13SPEAKER_03: Just as hieroglyphs bear witness,
- 3:12:15SPEAKER_03: so the word,
- 3:12:16SPEAKER_03: too,
- 3:12:17SPEAKER_03: originally had a pictorial function,
- 3:12:19SPEAKER_03: which was transferred to myths.
- 3:12:22SPEAKER_03: Like magical rites,
- 3:12:23SPEAKER_03: myths signify self-repetitive nature,
- 3:12:26SPEAKER_03: which is the core of the symbolic,
- 3:12:29SPEAKER_03: a state of being or a process that is presented as eternal because it incessantly
- 3:12:34SPEAKER_03: becomes actual once more by being realized in a symbolic form.
- 3:12:40SPEAKER_03: Alienation, reification, fucking abstraction, deconstruction, all over again.
- 3:12:47SPEAKER_03: Inexhaustibly,
- 3:12:48SPEAKER_03: unending renewal and the permanence of the signified are not mere attributes of all symbols,
- 3:12:59SPEAKER_03: but their essential content.
- 3:13:01SPEAKER_03: The representations of creation in which the world comes forth from the primal mother...
- 3:13:07SPEAKER_03: the cow or the egg, are symbolic.
- 3:13:10SPEAKER_03: Unlike the Jewish Genesis, the elders' mockery of the all-too-human gods left the core untouched.
- 3:13:18SPEAKER_03: The gods were not wholly individual.
- 3:13:21SPEAKER_03: They still had something of manna in them, for they embodied nature as universal power.
- 3:13:28SPEAKER_03: With their pre-animistic characteristics, they are prominent in the Enlightenment.
- 3:13:33SPEAKER_03: Beneath the coy veil of the Olympian chronique Scandalusa,
- 3:13:38SPEAKER_03: there was already apparent the doctrine of the mixture,
- 3:13:42SPEAKER_03: pressure,
- 3:13:42SPEAKER_03: and impact of the elements,
- 3:13:44SPEAKER_03: which presently established itself as science and turned the myths into fantastic images.
- 3:13:52SPEAKER_02: Let me interject here for a second.
- 3:13:55SPEAKER_02: For people like Chronic Scandalous,
- 3:13:57SPEAKER_02: I think they reference it's like the Scandalous Chronic with the mixture and
- 3:14:05SPEAKER_02: pressure and all this.
- 3:14:05SPEAKER_02: This is like...
- 3:14:09SPEAKER_02: Zeus fucked his sister,
- 3:14:11SPEAKER_02: and his sister was pissed at their distant cousin,
- 3:14:16SPEAKER_02: so they chopped off his hand,
- 3:14:19SPEAKER_02: which is this,
- 3:14:20SPEAKER_02: what they say,
- 3:14:21SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:14:21SPEAKER_02: mixture,
- 3:14:22SPEAKER_02: pressure,
- 3:14:23SPEAKER_02: and impact of the elements,
- 3:14:24SPEAKER_00: like...
- 3:14:27SPEAKER_02: The fucking lightning comes from the sky and hits the tree.
- 3:14:31SPEAKER_02: How can this be when Gaia is the Earth mother and Zeus is the,
- 3:14:38SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 3:14:38SPEAKER_02: like they must be mad at each other somehow.
- 3:14:42SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 3:14:43SPEAKER_03: it's doing this weird kind of personification that serves this kind of
- 3:14:50SPEAKER_03: discretization or the instrumentalization of
- 3:14:54SPEAKER_03: of uh of nature rather than looking at it as a a holistic process that is like the
- 3:15:03SPEAKER_03: entire thing is the process you can't uh you can't take it apart bit by bit you
- 3:15:09SPEAKER_03: can't do this type of deconstruction um it's this but i think that's the that's the
- 3:15:15SPEAKER_02: prerequisite yeah
- 3:15:17SPEAKER_02: To reach the holistic, they had to to go through this, you know, like to say like.
- 3:15:32SPEAKER_02: once they were separated,
- 3:15:33SPEAKER_02: once they had this,
- 3:15:34SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:15:35SPEAKER_02: exchange relation to nature,
- 3:15:38SPEAKER_02: they had to think about,
- 3:15:39SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:15:39SPEAKER_02: where,
- 3:15:40SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:15:40SPEAKER_02: we,
- 3:15:40SPEAKER_02: we had to think about,
- 3:15:41SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:15:42SPEAKER_02: talking about humans,
- 3:15:46SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:15:46SPEAKER_02: how does this work,
- 3:15:47SPEAKER_02: you know?
- 3:15:47SPEAKER_03: And then you can get to... That's, like, the scientification of the Weltanschauung, right?
- 3:15:56SPEAKER_03: Like, before...
- 3:15:59SPEAKER_03: man was made discreet from nature.
- 3:16:01SPEAKER_03: Back when man was just an ape, this didn't exist because there was no thinking man.
- 3:16:06SPEAKER_03: But then once man became man rather than just ape, everything did become instrumentalized.
- 3:16:12SPEAKER_03: Causality...
- 3:16:14SPEAKER_03: became like the the proposition of causality everything has to have this
- 3:16:21SPEAKER_03: justification everything is atoned for and accounted for yeah yes um and so they
- 3:16:29SPEAKER_03: everything had to be made discreet in order to do this accounting um
- 3:16:38SPEAKER_03: But then there's science comes along, modernity comes along and claims to be a re-holisticization.
- 3:16:48SPEAKER_03: Science claims to be the ultimate atoner, the ultimate accountor.
- 3:16:52SPEAKER_03: And we can account for everything because, look, actually...
- 3:16:56SPEAKER_03: The sum is bigger than all of its constituent parts.
- 3:16:59SPEAKER_03: And this is true, but also science isn't the logos that's going to get us there.
- 3:17:05SPEAKER_03: We have to recognize it as a holistic whole in its own right.
- 3:17:10SPEAKER_03: And then we can use science to say,
- 3:17:12SPEAKER_03: well,
- 3:17:13SPEAKER_03: for the purpose of this goal,
- 3:17:14SPEAKER_03: I'm going to use science because it works.
- 3:17:17SPEAKER_03: But we can't sit here and do the scientism and pretend...
- 3:17:24SPEAKER_03: this weird discretization is true because it's not like we technology is us and we
- 3:17:30SPEAKER_03: are nature and nature and God are the same thing.
- 3:17:32SPEAKER_03: And it is a system.
- 3:17:34SPEAKER_03: It is like everything, everything's connected to everything else, man.
- 3:17:39SPEAKER_03: Let's just, let's all get started.
- 3:17:41SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 3:17:43SPEAKER_03: But it's also true.
- 3:17:45SPEAKER_03: There is a truth in that, that doesn't have to be ridiculed.
- 3:17:49SPEAKER_03: Um, um,
- 3:17:50SPEAKER_03: And causality is, of course, a real thing.
- 3:17:52SPEAKER_03: But also,
- 3:17:53SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 3:17:54SPEAKER_03: at the beginning of the stream,
- 3:17:55SPEAKER_03: we started by saying,
- 3:17:58SPEAKER_03: I reject the classical notion of time.
- 3:18:02SPEAKER_03: So necessarily, I reject the classical notion of causality.
- 3:18:06SPEAKER_03: But that doesn't mean...
- 3:18:10SPEAKER_03: that I have some other kind of you know that I have a substitution to make it's
- 3:18:15SPEAKER_03: it's no it's it's just that like yes cause and effect is the way the world works
- 3:18:20SPEAKER_03: but maybe we just don't understand it at the level that we think we do that
- 3:18:25SPEAKER_03: scientism has allowed us to be so overconfident it's called hubris people let's you
- 3:18:31SPEAKER_03: know let's be a little less hubristic let's have some humility and some grace
- 3:18:37SPEAKER_02: And it retains the myth, right?
- 3:18:40SPEAKER_02: That's the point what they're making.
- 3:18:43SPEAKER_02: In this process of the gods, the Olympic gods, they cannot just go and...
- 3:18:53SPEAKER_02: completely negate the...
- 3:18:56SPEAKER_02: destroy these catonic gods,
- 3:18:59SPEAKER_02: these gods who are more akin to these...
- 3:19:03SPEAKER_02: What was it?
- 3:19:04SPEAKER_02: Laureate and P.T.
- 3:19:06SPEAKER_02: the River Spirit?
- 3:19:08SPEAKER_02: P.T.
- 3:19:08SPEAKER_02: the River Spirit?
- 3:19:10SPEAKER_02: They cannot just say, oh, these guys...
- 3:19:13SPEAKER_02: They cannot undo them.
- 3:19:16SPEAKER_02: I think that's the dialectical necessity.
- 3:19:18SPEAKER_02: They have to relate to them.
- 3:19:21SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 3:19:22SPEAKER_02: And so they need to be put somewhere else.
- 3:19:27SPEAKER_02: And this happens in science too.
- 3:19:29SPEAKER_02: Science attains this dual character where it's weirdly enough the negation of myth is
- 3:19:36SPEAKER_02: By mythical quality.
- 3:19:38SPEAKER_02: By mythologizing.
- 3:19:40SPEAKER_02: Yes, where it's like, you know, like...
- 3:19:45SPEAKER_02: And I mean, this is even a critique now that I say it.
- 3:19:48SPEAKER_02: It's very apparent that they critique Stalinism too.
- 3:19:51SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:19:52SPEAKER_02: Because it's also a critique to say like,
- 3:19:54SPEAKER_02: you cannot just do this like vulgar historical materialism where it turns into determinism.
- 3:20:02SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 3:20:02SPEAKER_02: And it's just one thing happens after the other.
- 3:20:05SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:20:07SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 3:20:09SPEAKER_02: Proletariat plus Soviet power equals utopia.
- 3:20:14SPEAKER_02: That's bullshit.
- 3:20:15SPEAKER_03: That's not how it works.
- 3:20:17SPEAKER_03: That's not at all how it works.
- 3:20:18SPEAKER_03: I mean, we see how that works, right?
- 3:20:21SPEAKER_03: The hello to more is just one example of the inadequacies of the Soviet system.
- 3:20:28SPEAKER_03: But I think you could probably get canceled for talking about famine in the Soviet Union.
- 3:20:35SPEAKER_03: At least...
- 3:20:37SPEAKER_03: At least in leftist spaces.
- 3:20:39SPEAKER_03: Well, not even leftist spaces.
- 3:20:42SPEAKER_03: No, no, no.
- 3:20:42SPEAKER_03: I think that's going too far.
- 3:20:43SPEAKER_03: But it is true that on the Internet,
- 3:20:45SPEAKER_03: people celebrate the Soviet Union and act like it was heaven on earth.
- 3:20:50SPEAKER_03: And here's another thing.
- 3:20:51SPEAKER_03: And this is a tangent, and I do want to get back to the text.
- 3:20:54SPEAKER_03: But another thing is people talk about the Soviet Union and historical progress.
- 3:20:59SPEAKER_03: And they talk about how Russia was taken from this back-ass words,
- 3:21:03SPEAKER_03: peasant,
- 3:21:05SPEAKER_03: farmer country and turned into a world power.
- 3:21:08SPEAKER_03: And this is true, but the fucking United States was also a back-ass words, peasant country, largely.
- 3:21:18SPEAKER_03: We had Chicago, New York, Los Angeles.
- 3:21:22SPEAKER_03: We had some industrial centers, but the breadth of the United States
- 3:21:27SPEAKER_03: was also peasantry until total war total war is what came around and really
- 3:21:34SPEAKER_03: instrumentalized the the world powers it wasn't soviet communism don't give me this
- 3:21:40SPEAKER_03: apologia and say well it was actually a good thing because look at how advanced
- 3:21:46SPEAKER_03: capitalism did the same thing in america and in germany and all across all of
- 3:21:52SPEAKER_03: europe
- 3:21:53SPEAKER_03: It was total instrumentalization.
- 3:21:55SPEAKER_03: It was not specific state ideologies because at the end of the fucking day,
- 3:21:59SPEAKER_03: it was industrialization and it was the managerial revolution that led to these
- 3:22:03SPEAKER_03: improvements in the base of production.
- 3:22:08SPEAKER_03: It wasn't state ideology.
- 3:22:09SPEAKER_03: So I'm tired of hearing leftists fucking say...
- 3:22:13SPEAKER_02: But that is mythologization.
- 3:22:17SPEAKER_02: It is mythologization.
- 3:22:18SPEAKER_02: Because it's like... Because it's like... It does not tarry with the fact that...
- 3:22:29SPEAKER_02: What happened in the Soviet Union was a failure because Lenin and all the
- 3:22:36SPEAKER_02: Bolsheviki were waiting for the world revolution.
- 3:22:41SPEAKER_02: And they thought this would start in Germany, in Europe.
- 3:22:47SPEAKER_02: And they had a strong enough SPD that this was the big split that went like the SPD
- 3:22:55SPEAKER_02: split into like,
- 3:22:56SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 3:22:56SPEAKER_02: we do the state now.
- 3:22:57SPEAKER_02: We are the state now.
- 3:22:58SPEAKER_02: and we are going to do the Kautsky thing, that they were fucked in the Soviet Union, yes?
- 3:23:07SPEAKER_02: And you cannot just say,
- 3:23:09SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:23:10SPEAKER_02: and I can understand that to not say,
- 3:23:11SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:23:12SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 3:23:12SPEAKER_02: let's roll back this revolution thing.
- 3:23:14SPEAKER_02: Oops, my bad.
- 3:23:16SPEAKER_02: The Germans didn't do it.
- 3:23:18SPEAKER_02: Let's just go home.
- 3:23:20SPEAKER_02: They already were, like, the government, but the part is to not romanticize it.
- 3:23:28SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 3:23:28SPEAKER_02: Everything that followed from that were measures they had to take.
- 3:23:33SPEAKER_02: I have to be careful because I think I'm too loud and it's late.
- 3:23:47SPEAKER_02: I get so carried away by my thinking.
- 3:23:50SPEAKER_02: Sorry, you guys.
- 3:23:52SPEAKER_02: You guys.
- 3:23:58SPEAKER_02: I think most of the policies were measures out of desperation and to hold on to the project.
- 3:24:10SPEAKER_02: And you just cannot celebrate that as like... And it turns into this weird...
- 3:24:20SPEAKER_02: it turns into a mystification of capitalist necessity.
- 3:24:24SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 3:24:25SPEAKER_02: They had to do that because Lenin and the Bushi wiki, they had to legislate the NEP.
- 3:24:35SPEAKER_02: They had to do the new economic policy, which was like, okay, we do light capitalism now.
- 3:24:42SPEAKER_02: That was state capitalism because their economy was fucked up.
- 3:24:51SPEAKER_02: it was just not sustainable.
- 3:24:54SPEAKER_02: Like,
- 3:24:54SPEAKER_02: war communism managed to get them through,
- 3:24:58SPEAKER_02: and then,
- 3:24:59SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:25:00SPEAKER_02: what is there to be celebrated about that?
- 3:25:03SPEAKER_02: Like, that's the same way, and in that regard, I completely agree with you.
- 3:25:10SPEAKER_02: Then you can celebrate the fascists in Germany,
- 3:25:13SPEAKER_02: and you can say,
- 3:25:13SPEAKER_02: wow,
- 3:25:14SPEAKER_02: they did a really good productivity push in the US,
- 3:25:17SPEAKER_02: and
- 3:25:24SPEAKER_03: yeah it becomes a well then you start to fetishize um contingency and and and
- 3:25:32SPEAKER_03: mistake contingency for necessity and uh and you're locating the cause going back
- 3:25:38SPEAKER_03: to cause like you're locating cause and effect in the wrong spot and you can get
- 3:25:44SPEAKER_03: carried away and then it becomes ideology and then you become instrumentalized and
- 3:25:47SPEAKER_03: you become a political puppet yeah and people die
- 3:25:53SPEAKER_02: Well, one thing to keep it dialectical, to say, in a sense, it is always good.
- 3:26:03SPEAKER_02: In a sense,
- 3:26:04SPEAKER_02: more capitalism,
- 3:26:05SPEAKER_02: more production is good if you have the goal of socialism in mind because it
- 3:26:10SPEAKER_02: socializes people more.
- 3:26:14SPEAKER_02: That argument you can make, but at the same time, you don't get out of the contradictions.
- 3:26:22SPEAKER_02: When the workers' movement in the world is experiencing the biggest defeat in its history,
- 3:26:32SPEAKER_02: then it actually is not a good thing.
- 3:26:34SPEAKER_02: In that situation, it's not.
- 3:26:37SPEAKER_02: It seems to me to become...
- 3:26:43SPEAKER_03: like like a so what like you are kind of fetishizing the contingency and it's like
- 3:26:53SPEAKER_03: yeah of course but so what like that that doesn't get us any closer to ground truth
- 3:26:59SPEAKER_03: it doesn't get us any closer to knowing or understanding and it and it doesn't
- 3:27:04SPEAKER_03: change the fact that horrible things happened in the name of progress yeah um yeah
- 3:27:13SPEAKER_03: man
- 3:27:13SPEAKER_03: So what?
- 3:27:14SPEAKER_03: I think people now look, I think it's possible to ask so what too much.
- 3:27:21SPEAKER_03: But I also think people all too often are too ready to disavow this so what?
- 3:27:26SPEAKER_03: And they're just like,
- 3:27:29SPEAKER_03: they're like,
- 3:27:29SPEAKER_03: well,
- 3:27:29SPEAKER_03: I'm going to run with this because it supports my presuppositions and it supports
- 3:27:33SPEAKER_03: my existing worldview and it supports my political projects.
- 3:27:36SPEAKER_03: So I'm not even going to ask.
- 3:27:38SPEAKER_03: So what?
- 3:27:39SPEAKER_03: And that's a tension that you have to maintain.
- 3:27:41SPEAKER_03: You don't want to ask so much.
- 3:27:42SPEAKER_03: So what so many times that you never get to do the thing.
- 3:27:46SPEAKER_03: But you also want to make sure that you're regularly checking in by like saying,
- 3:27:51SPEAKER_03: well,
- 3:27:51SPEAKER_03: is this efficacious?
- 3:27:52SPEAKER_03: Does this fucking matter?
- 3:27:53SPEAKER_03: Or am I just doing an ideology?
- 3:27:55SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 3:27:56SPEAKER_02: And I mean, I took your so what also to say, like, that's what capitalism would have done anyway.
- 3:28:02SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
- 3:28:02SPEAKER_02: Like, that's what that's that's like.
- 3:28:04SPEAKER_02: That's like that's like this idea that there is like a capitalism and an outside or
- 3:28:12SPEAKER_02: like the conscious part of capitalism that like.
- 3:28:16SPEAKER_02: No, no.
- 3:28:17SPEAKER_02: That is all capitalism.
- 3:28:18SPEAKER_02: It's all capitalism.
- 3:28:20SPEAKER_02: The fucking union is capitalism.
- 3:28:23SPEAKER_02: The socialist movement is capitalism.
- 3:28:26SPEAKER_02: It's a sublation.
- 3:28:27SPEAKER_02: It's not... Yeah.
- 3:28:32SPEAKER_03: Well, in the same way as man is nature.
- 3:28:36SPEAKER_03: And in the same way that technology is man.
- 3:28:40SPEAKER_03: Yeah, these things are the conditions of possibility.
- 3:28:42SPEAKER_03: These things...
- 3:28:44SPEAKER_03: kind of provided the the substrate where this new thing kind of grew and emerged.
- 3:28:50SPEAKER_03: But trying to do this very instrumental, very scientistic accounting
- 3:28:59SPEAKER_03: Like,
- 3:28:59SPEAKER_03: no,
- 3:28:59SPEAKER_03: that becomes ideology and it becomes bullshit and you just start doing post hoc
- 3:29:04SPEAKER_03: justifications for things that are inconvenient to you or whatever.
- 3:29:09SPEAKER_02: Oops, my bad.
- 3:29:12SPEAKER_02: That's very inconvenient.
- 3:29:13SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:29:14SPEAKER_02: Oh, no, like a famine.
- 3:29:17SPEAKER_03: Oh, yeah.
- 3:29:18SPEAKER_03: Oops.
- 3:29:19SPEAKER_03: Sorry.
- 3:29:19SPEAKER_03: All right.
- 3:29:21SPEAKER_03: Where?
- 3:29:21SPEAKER_03: I don't know where the gods.
- 3:29:23SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 3:29:24SPEAKER_03: The scandal.
- 3:29:25SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:29:28SPEAKER_02: Science and turned the myths into fantastic images.
- 3:29:32SPEAKER_03: With the clean separation of science and poetry,
- 3:29:36SPEAKER_03: the division of labor it had already helped to effect was extended to language.
- 3:29:42SPEAKER_03: For science, the word is a sign.
- 3:29:46SPEAKER_03: As sound,
- 3:29:47SPEAKER_03: image,
- 3:29:47SPEAKER_03: and word proper,
- 3:29:49SPEAKER_03: it is distributed among the different arts and is not permitted to reconstitute
- 3:29:53SPEAKER_03: itself by their addition,
- 3:29:55SPEAKER_03: by synesthesia,
- 3:29:57SPEAKER_03: or in the composition of the Gesamtkunstwerk,
- 3:30:02SPEAKER_02: As a system of... It's the whole... Grammar?
- 3:30:06SPEAKER_02: The whole piece of art.
- 3:30:07SPEAKER_02: It's Wagner.
- 3:30:08SPEAKER_02: It's Wagner.
- 3:30:09SPEAKER_02: It's the whole art piece.
- 3:30:10SPEAKER_02: Like Wagner did this like... Like the opus?
- 3:30:13SPEAKER_02: Total art.
- 3:30:14SPEAKER_02: Yeah, the opus.
- 3:30:15SPEAKER_02: It's Gesamtkunstwerk.
- 3:30:17SPEAKER_03: It's like everything... Body of work, corpus of work, like the whole thing taken in totality.
- 3:30:24SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 3:30:25SPEAKER_02: Like it's not just like you don't only do a picture, but you do like...
- 3:30:30SPEAKER_02: A picture for a show and how art operates today.
- 3:30:35SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah.
- 3:30:37SPEAKER_03: As a system of signs,
- 3:30:39SPEAKER_03: language is required to resign itself to calculation in order to know nature and
- 3:30:45SPEAKER_03: must discard the claim to be like her.
- 3:30:49SPEAKER_03: As image,
- 3:30:49SPEAKER_03: it is required to resign itself to mirror imagery in order to be nature entire and
- 3:30:55SPEAKER_03: must discard the claim to know her.
- 3:31:02SPEAKER_03: What's the thing where they say something, something, and you're like, yeah, but I hardly know her.
- 3:31:11SPEAKER_03: With the progress of enlightenment,
- 3:31:14SPEAKER_03: only authentic works of art were able to avoid the mere imitation of that which
- 3:31:19SPEAKER_03: already is.
- 3:31:20SPEAKER_03: The practicable antithesis of art and science,
- 3:31:24SPEAKER_03: which tears them apart as separate areas of culture in order to make them both
- 3:31:28SPEAKER_03: manageable as areas of culture,
- 3:31:30SPEAKER_03: ultimately allows them,
- 3:31:32SPEAKER_03: by dent of their own tendencies,
- 3:31:35SPEAKER_03: to blend with one another,
- 3:31:36SPEAKER_03: even as exact contraries.
- 3:31:40SPEAKER_03: In its neopositivist version,
- 3:31:42SPEAKER_03: science becomes aestheticism,
- 3:31:44SPEAKER_03: a system of detached signs devoid of any intention that would transcend the system.
- 3:31:50SPEAKER_03: It becomes the game which mathematicians have for long proudly asserted as their concern.
- 3:31:57SPEAKER_03: But the art of integral representability
- 3:32:01SPEAKER_03: even in its techniques,
- 3:32:02SPEAKER_03: subscribe to positive science,
- 3:32:05SPEAKER_03: and in fact adapts to the world yet again,
- 3:32:08SPEAKER_03: becoming ideological duplication,
- 3:32:11SPEAKER_03: partisan reproduction.
- 3:32:14SPEAKER_03: The separation of sign and image is irredeemable.
- 3:32:18SPEAKER_03: I don't like that word.
- 3:32:23SPEAKER_03: It's not remedied.
- 3:32:24SPEAKER_03: You can't remedy it.
- 3:32:27SPEAKER_03: Should unconscious self-satisfaction cause it once again to become hypostasized,
- 3:32:33SPEAKER_03: then each of the two isolated principles tends toward the destruction of truth.
- 3:32:40SPEAKER_03: In the relationship of intuition,
- 3:32:43SPEAKER_03: in other words direct perception,
- 3:32:45SPEAKER_03: and concept,
- 3:32:46SPEAKER_03: philosophy already discerned the gulf which opened with that separation,
- 3:32:51SPEAKER_03: and again tries in vain to close it.
- 3:32:54SPEAKER_03: Philosophy indeed is defined by this very attempt.
- 3:32:59SPEAKER_03: For the most part, it has stood on the side from which it derives its name.
- 3:33:04SPEAKER_03: Plato banned poetry with the same gesture that positivism used against the theory of ideas.
- 3:33:11SPEAKER_03: With his much renowned art,
- 3:33:12SPEAKER_03: Homer carried out no public or private reforms and neither won a war nor made any discovery.
- 3:33:21SPEAKER_03: We know of no multitude of followers who might have honored or adored him.
- 3:33:25SPEAKER_03: At first, art must first prove its utility.
- 3:33:30SPEAKER_03: For art, as for the Jews, imitation is proscribed.
- 3:33:37SPEAKER_03: Reason and religion deprecate and condemn the principle of magic enchantment.
- 3:33:43SPEAKER_03: Even in resigned self-distancing from real existence, as art, it remains dishonest.
- 3:33:49SPEAKER_03: Its practitioners become travelers,
- 3:33:52SPEAKER_03: latter-day nomads who find no abiding home under the established what has come to be.
- 3:33:58SPEAKER_03: Nature must no longer be influenced by approximation, but mastered by labor.
- 3:34:04SPEAKER_03: the work of art still has something in common with enchantment.
- 3:34:08SPEAKER_03: It posits its own self-enclosed area,
- 3:34:11SPEAKER_03: which is withdrawn from the context of profane existence and in which special laws apply.
- 3:34:18SPEAKER_03: Just as in the ceremony the magician first of all marked out the limits of the area
- 3:34:23SPEAKER_03: where the sacred powers were to come into play,
- 3:34:26SPEAKER_03: so every work of art describes its own circumference,
- 3:34:29SPEAKER_03: which closes it off from actuality.
- 3:34:32SPEAKER_03: This very renunciation of influence,
- 3:34:35SPEAKER_03: which distinguishes art from magical sympathy,
- 3:34:38SPEAKER_03: retains the magic heritage all the more surely.
- 3:34:42SPEAKER_03: It places the pure image in contrast to animate existence, the elements of which it absorbs.
- 3:34:48SPEAKER_03: It is in the nature of the work of art,
- 3:34:51SPEAKER_03: or aesthetic semblance,
- 3:34:52SPEAKER_03: to be what the new,
- 3:34:54SPEAKER_03: terrifying occurrence became in the primitive's magic,
- 3:34:57SPEAKER_03: the appearance of the whole in the particular.
- 3:35:01SPEAKER_03: Boom.
- 3:35:02SPEAKER_03: In the work of art, that duplication still occurs by which the thing appeared as spiritual,
- 3:35:08SPEAKER_03: as the expression of manna.
- 3:35:11SPEAKER_03: This constitutes its aura.
- 3:35:13SPEAKER_03: As an expression of totality, art lays claim to the dignity of the absolute.
- 3:35:19SPEAKER_03: This sometimes causes philosophy to allow it precedence to conceptual knowledge.
- 3:35:24SPEAKER_03: According to Schelling, art comes into play where knowledge forsakes mankind.
- 3:35:29SPEAKER_03: For him, it is the prototype of science, and only where there is art may science enter in.
- 3:35:36SPEAKER_03: In his theory,
- 3:35:38SPEAKER_03: the separation of image and sign is wholly cancelled by every single artistic representation.
- 3:35:45SPEAKER_03: The bourgeois world was but rarely open to such confidence in art.
- 3:35:50SPEAKER_03: Where it restricted knowledge,
- 3:35:52SPEAKER_03: it usually did so not for the sake of art,
- 3:35:54SPEAKER_03: but in order to make room for faith.
- 3:35:57SPEAKER_03: Through faith,
- 3:35:58SPEAKER_03: the militant religiousness of the New Age hoped to reconcile Torquemada,
- 3:36:03SPEAKER_03: Luther,
- 3:36:04SPEAKER_03: Muhammad,
- 3:36:05SPEAKER_03: spirit,
- 3:36:06SPEAKER_03: and real life.
- 3:36:07SPEAKER_03: But faith is a privative concept.
- 3:36:11SPEAKER_03: It is destroyed as faith if it does not continually display its contradistinction
- 3:36:16SPEAKER_03: to or conformity with knowledge.
- 3:36:21SPEAKER_03: Since it is always set upon the restriction of knowledge, it is itself restricted.
- 3:36:27SPEAKER_03: The attempt of Protestant faith to find,
- 3:36:30SPEAKER_03: as in prehistory,
- 3:36:31SPEAKER_03: the transcendental principle of truth,
- 3:36:34SPEAKER_03: without which belief cannot exist,
- 3:36:37SPEAKER_03: directly in the world itself,
- 3:36:39SPEAKER_03: and to reinvest this with symbolic power,
- 3:36:42SPEAKER_03: has been paid for with obedience to the word,
- 3:36:46SPEAKER_03: and not to the sacred.
- 3:36:48SPEAKER_03: As long as faith remains unhesitatingly tied,
- 3:36:51SPEAKER_03: as friend or foe to knowledge,
- 3:36:54SPEAKER_03: it perpetuates the separation in the very course of the struggle to overcome it.
- 3:36:59SPEAKER_03: Its fanaticism is the occasion of its untruth,
- 3:37:02SPEAKER_03: the objective admission that he who only has faith for that very reason no longer
- 3:37:08SPEAKER_03: has it.
- 3:37:09SPEAKER_03: bad conscience is its second nature in the secret consciousness of the deficiency
- 3:37:15SPEAKER_03: necessarily inherent in faith of its imminent contradiction in making
- 3:37:19SPEAKER_03: reconciliation a vocation lies the reason why the integrity of all believers has
- 3:37:26SPEAKER_03: always been a sensitive and dangerous thing
- 3:37:29SPEAKER_03: The atrocities of fire and sword,
- 3:37:32SPEAKER_03: counter-reformation and reformation,
- 3:37:34SPEAKER_03: have occurred not as exaggerations,
- 3:37:36SPEAKER_03: but as realizations of the principle of faith itself.
- 3:37:41SPEAKER_03: Faith constantly reveals itself to be of the same cut as the world history which it would dictate to.
- 3:37:48SPEAKER_03: In modern times, indeed, it becomes its favorite instrument, its particular stratagem.
- 3:37:55SPEAKER_03: It is not merely the enlightenment of the 18th century that,
- 3:37:59SPEAKER_03: as Hegel confirmed,
- 3:38:00SPEAKER_03: is relentless,
- 3:38:01SPEAKER_03: but,
- 3:38:02SPEAKER_03: as no one knew better than he,
- 3:38:04SPEAKER_03: the advance of thought itself.
- 3:38:07SPEAKER_03: The lowest and the highest insight alike manifest that distance from truth which makes apologists liars.
- 3:38:15SPEAKER_03: Hmm.
- 3:38:17SPEAKER_03: The paradoxical nature of faith ultimately degenerates into a swindle and becomes
- 3:38:22SPEAKER_03: the myth of the 20th century and its irrationality turns it into an instrument of
- 3:38:27SPEAKER_03: rational administration by the holy enlightened as they steer society toward barbarism.
- 3:38:37SPEAKER_03: When language enters history, its masters are priests and sorcerers.
- 3:38:43SPEAKER_03: Whoever harms the symbols is,
- 3:38:45SPEAKER_03: in the name of the supernatural powers,
- 3:38:48SPEAKER_03: subject to their earthly counterparts,
- 3:38:51SPEAKER_03: whose representatives are those chosen organs of society.
- 3:38:55SPEAKER_03: What happened previously is hid in darkness.
- 3:38:59SPEAKER_03: The dread which gives birth to manna,
- 3:39:01SPEAKER_03: wherever it is met with ethnology,
- 3:39:05SPEAKER_03: is always sanctioned,
- 3:39:06SPEAKER_03: at least by the tribal elders.
- 3:39:09SPEAKER_03: Unidentified, volatile manna was rendered consistent by men and forcibly materialized.
- 3:39:16SPEAKER_03: Soon the magicians peopled every spot with emanations and made a multiplicity of
- 3:39:21SPEAKER_03: sacred rites concordant with the variety of sacred places.
- 3:39:25SPEAKER_03: They expanded their professional knowledge and their influence with the expansion
- 3:39:29SPEAKER_03: of the spirit world and its characteristics.
- 3:39:33SPEAKER_03: The nature of the sacred being transferred itself to the magicians who were privy to it.
- 3:39:39SPEAKER_03: In the first stages of nomadic life,
- 3:39:41SPEAKER_03: the members of the tribe still took an individual part in the process of
- 3:39:45SPEAKER_03: influencing the course of nature.
- 3:39:48SPEAKER_03: Men hunted game, while women did the work which could be produced without strict command.
- 3:39:54SPEAKER_03: It is impossible to determine to what extent habit contributed to so simple an arrangement.
- 3:40:00SPEAKER_03: In it, the world is already divided into the territory of power in the profane area.
- 3:40:06SPEAKER_03: As the emanation of manna,
- 3:40:08SPEAKER_03: the course of nature is elevated to become the norm,
- 3:40:12SPEAKER_03: and submission to it is required.
- 3:40:15SPEAKER_03: But even though,
- 3:40:16SPEAKER_03: despite all submission,
- 3:40:18SPEAKER_03: the savage nomad still participated in the magic which determined the lines of that
- 3:40:23SPEAKER_03: submission and clothed himself as his quarry,
- 3:40:27SPEAKER_03: in order to stock it,
- 3:40:28SPEAKER_03: in later times intercourse with spirits and submission were assigned to different classes.
- 3:40:34SPEAKER_03: The power is on the one side and obedience on the other.
- 3:40:38SPEAKER_03: For the vanquished,
- 3:40:39SPEAKER_03: whether by alien tribes or by their own cliques,
- 3:40:42SPEAKER_03: the recurrent,
- 3:40:43SPEAKER_03: eternally similar natural processes become the rhythm of labor according to the
- 3:40:48SPEAKER_03: beat of cudgel and whip which resounds in every barbaric drum and every monotonous ritual.
- 3:40:55SPEAKER_03: The symbols undertake a fetishistic function.
- 3:40:59SPEAKER_03: In the process,
- 3:41:00SPEAKER_03: the recurrence of nature which they signify is always the permanence of the social
- 3:41:04SPEAKER_03: pressure which they represent.
- 3:41:07SPEAKER_03: The dread objectified as a fixed image becomes the sign of the established domination of the privileged.
- 3:41:13SPEAKER_03: Such is the fate of universal concepts even when they have discarded everything pictorial.
- 3:41:18SPEAKER_01: Hmm.
- 3:41:20SPEAKER_03: Even the deductive form of science reflects hierarchy and coercion.
- 3:41:25SPEAKER_03: Just as the first categories represented the organized tribe and its power over the individual,
- 3:41:31SPEAKER_03: so the whole logical order,
- 3:41:33SPEAKER_03: dependency,
- 3:41:34SPEAKER_03: connection,
- 3:41:35SPEAKER_03: progression,
- 3:41:36SPEAKER_03: and union of concepts is grounded in the corresponding conditions of social reality,
- 3:41:40SPEAKER_03: that is,
- 3:41:41SPEAKER_03: of the division of labor.
- 3:41:43SPEAKER_03: But,
- 3:41:44SPEAKER_03: of course,
- 3:41:44SPEAKER_03: this social character of categories of thought is not,
- 3:41:47SPEAKER_03: as Durkheim asserts,
- 3:41:49SPEAKER_03: an expression of social solidarity,
- 3:41:51SPEAKER_03: but evidence of the inscrutable unity of society and domination.
- 3:41:56SPEAKER_03: Domination lends increased consistency and force to the social whole in which it establishes itself.
- 3:42:03SPEAKER_03: The division of labor to which domination tends serves the dominated whole for the
- 3:42:08SPEAKER_03: end of self-preservation.
- 3:42:10SPEAKER_03: But then the whole as whole,
- 3:42:12SPEAKER_03: the manifestation of its imminent reason,
- 3:42:14SPEAKER_03: necessarily leads to the execution of the particular.
- 3:42:19SPEAKER_03: To the individual, domination appears to be the universal reason in actuality.
- 3:42:25SPEAKER_03: through the division of labor imposed on them,
- 3:42:27SPEAKER_03: the power of all the members of society,
- 3:42:30SPEAKER_03: for whom as such there is no other course,
- 3:42:33SPEAKER_03: amounts over and over again to the realization of the whole,
- 3:42:38SPEAKER_03: whose rationality is reproduced in this way.
- 3:42:41SPEAKER_03: What is done to all by the few always occurs as the subjection of individuals by the many.
- 3:42:49SPEAKER_03: Social repression always exhibits the masks of repression by a collective.
- 3:42:56SPEAKER_03: It is this unity of the collectivity and domination,
- 3:43:00SPEAKER_03: and not direct social universality,
- 3:43:02SPEAKER_03: solidarity,
- 3:43:03SPEAKER_03: which is expressed in thought forms.
- 3:43:06SPEAKER_03: By virtue of the claim to universal validity,
- 3:43:09SPEAKER_03: the philosophic concepts with which Plato and Aristotle represented the world
- 3:43:13SPEAKER_03: elevated the conditions they were used to substantiate to the level of true reality.
- 3:43:20SPEAKER_03: These concepts originated, as Vico puts it, in the marketplace of Athens.
- 3:43:25SPEAKER_03: They reflected with equal clarity the laws of physics,
- 3:43:29SPEAKER_03: the equality of full citizens,
- 3:43:31SPEAKER_03: and the inferiority of women,
- 3:43:33SPEAKER_03: children,
- 3:43:33SPEAKER_03: and slaves.
- 3:43:35SPEAKER_03: Language itself gave what was asserted,
- 3:43:38SPEAKER_03: the conditions of domination,
- 3:43:40SPEAKER_03: the universality that they had assumed as the means of intercourse of a bourgeois
- 3:43:45SPEAKER_03: society."
- 3:43:46SPEAKER_03: The metaphysical emphasis and sanctioned by means of ideas and norms were no more
- 3:43:52SPEAKER_03: than a hypostaticization of the rigidity and exclusiveness which concepts were
- 3:43:57SPEAKER_03: generally compelled to assume wherever language united the community of rulers with
- 3:44:02SPEAKER_03: the giving of orders.
- 3:44:04SPEAKER_03: as a mere means of reinforcing the social power of language,
- 3:44:08SPEAKER_03: ideas became all the more superfluous as this power grew,
- 3:44:12SPEAKER_03: and the language of science prepared the way for their ultimate desuitude.
- 3:44:18SPEAKER_03: Fuck you.
- 3:44:20SPEAKER_03: Desuitude?
- 3:44:20SPEAKER_03: Desuitude.
- 3:44:24SPEAKER_02: But this seems like a typo.
- 3:44:32SPEAKER_02: Oh, wow, this is really a word in English.
- 3:44:35SPEAKER_02: A state of disuse.
- 3:44:37SPEAKER_03: Disusitude.
- 3:44:38SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 3:44:39SPEAKER_03: Disusitude.
- 3:44:42SPEAKER_03: Disutude.
- 3:44:43SPEAKER_03: Fuck.
- 3:44:43SPEAKER_03: Use a proper word, you bitch-ass Germans.
- 3:44:49SPEAKER_03: The suggestion of something still akin to the terror of the flesh did not inhere in
- 3:44:54SPEAKER_03: conscious justification.
- 3:44:56SPEAKER_03: Instead, the unity of collectivity and domination is revealed in the universality of
- 3:45:03SPEAKER_03: necessarily assumed by the bad content of language, both metaphysical and scientific.
- 3:45:10SPEAKER_03: Metaphysical apology betrayed the injustice of the status quo least of all in the
- 3:45:15SPEAKER_03: incongruence of concept and actuality.
- 3:45:19SPEAKER_03: In the impartiality of scientific language,
- 3:45:22SPEAKER_03: that which is powerless has wholly lost any means of expression,
- 3:45:26SPEAKER_03: and only the given find the
- 3:45:29SPEAKER_03: and only the given finds its natural sign.
- 3:45:32SPEAKER_03: This kind of neutrality is more metaphysical than metaphysics.
- 3:45:37SPEAKER_03: Ultimately,
- 3:45:37SPEAKER_03: the Enlightenment consumed not just the symbols,
- 3:45:41SPEAKER_03: but their successors,
- 3:45:43SPEAKER_03: universal concepts,
- 3:45:44SPEAKER_03: and spared no remnant of metaphysics apart from the abstract fear of the collective
- 3:45:48SPEAKER_03: from which it arose.
- 3:45:51SPEAKER_03: The situation of concepts in the face of the Enlightenment is like that of men of
- 3:45:55SPEAKER_03: private means in regard to industrial trusts.
- 3:45:59SPEAKER_03: None can feel safe.
- 3:46:01SPEAKER_03: Even if logical positivism still allowed leeway to probability,
- 3:46:05SPEAKER_03: ethnological positivism puts it in its place.
- 3:46:09SPEAKER_03: Our vague ideas of chance and quintessence are pale shadows of this much richer notion,
- 3:46:15SPEAKER_03: that is,
- 3:46:16SPEAKER_03: of magical substance.
- 3:46:38SPEAKER_02: It's interesting that they never use the term,
- 3:46:40SPEAKER_02: but I think they follow completely with the concept of reification in this part,
- 3:46:48SPEAKER_02: right?
- 3:46:50SPEAKER_02: Like that it's like,
- 3:46:52SPEAKER_02: um,
- 3:46:53SPEAKER_02: something becomes demarcated,
- 3:46:56SPEAKER_02: like the,
- 3:46:59SPEAKER_02: the nomad who's still,
- 3:47:01SPEAKER_02: um,
- 3:47:03SPEAKER_02: people are like,
- 3:47:04SPEAKER_02: like,
- 3:47:05SPEAKER_02: um,
- 3:47:07SPEAKER_02: first they are within mana,
- 3:47:08SPEAKER_02: then there is mana and then mana turns into these sites.
- 3:47:17SPEAKER_02: right and like then then there's the separation is happening between subject and
- 3:47:21SPEAKER_02: object the nomad the human turns into the subject and the the territory the the
- 3:47:30SPEAKER_02: nature is split into two parts too yeah like you have to profane and you have to
- 3:47:36SPEAKER_02: you have to the territory of power yeah and i like i think
- 3:47:46SPEAKER_03: think that's like the thrust of what's going on is this reification and it's this
- 3:47:53SPEAKER_03: projection abstraction reification deconstruction like that whole operation that i
- 3:48:00SPEAKER_03: i want to come up with like a cool word for it to
- 3:48:04SPEAKER_03: like to say that whole process.
- 3:48:05SPEAKER_03: Cause that whole,
- 3:48:06SPEAKER_03: I like that whole process and it is projection,
- 3:48:09SPEAKER_03: abstraction,
- 3:48:09SPEAKER_03: reification,
- 3:48:11SPEAKER_03: deconstruction,
- 3:48:13SPEAKER_03: just kind of over and over and over again.
- 3:48:16SPEAKER_03: Um, but that's it.
- 3:48:18SPEAKER_03: And it, it's like through that process, um,
- 3:48:24SPEAKER_03: they are reifying these quote unquote natural categories or whatever and robbing,
- 3:48:31SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 3:48:33SPEAKER_03: and I,
- 3:48:34SPEAKER_03: they as in like early man,
- 3:48:36SPEAKER_03: the nomad,
- 3:48:37SPEAKER_03: whatever the empirical subject,
- 3:48:39SPEAKER_03: whatever,
- 3:48:40SPEAKER_03: like,
- 3:48:41SPEAKER_03: um,
- 3:48:43SPEAKER_03: you are robbing yourself of subjectivity of agency of,
- 3:48:49SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 3:48:51SPEAKER_03: you know, liberation and guilt.
- 3:48:53SPEAKER_03: Like,
- 3:48:54SPEAKER_03: again,
- 3:48:54SPEAKER_03: like you're implicated,
- 3:48:55SPEAKER_03: you're guilty,
- 3:48:56SPEAKER_03: but like the implication is also an emancipation because it's a recognition of your agency.
- 3:49:03SPEAKER_03: It's a recognition of the part you're playing in the world.
- 3:49:07SPEAKER_03: Uh, it's, it's a recognition.
- 3:49:08SPEAKER_03: Like,
- 3:49:09SPEAKER_03: I think that going back to Bordeaux the other day,
- 3:49:12SPEAKER_03: like,
- 3:49:13SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 3:49:14SPEAKER_03: I think it might've been Saloski brought up solipsism or maybe it was Caravaggio in
- 3:49:17SPEAKER_03: the chat.
- 3:49:18SPEAKER_03: Somebody brought up solipsism and,
- 3:49:20SPEAKER_03: And,
- 3:49:20SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 3:49:21SPEAKER_03: and I think this is the same thing I said with Bordeaux,
- 3:49:27SPEAKER_03: like,
- 3:49:27SPEAKER_03: no,
- 3:49:28SPEAKER_03: this is,
- 3:49:28SPEAKER_03: this is instructing us how to defeat solipsism.
- 3:49:31SPEAKER_03: This is showing us how to get outside of that solipsism.
- 3:49:35SPEAKER_03: Because if all you do is just reify the world that you found yourself in and say,
- 3:49:42SPEAKER_03: well,
- 3:49:42SPEAKER_03: there's nothing I can do.
- 3:49:43SPEAKER_03: I'm trapped in this world.
- 3:49:44SPEAKER_03: And I'm just going to take everything as a given and reify these natural categories
- 3:49:48SPEAKER_03: and let everything calcify.
- 3:49:50SPEAKER_03: Then you are doing a solipsism by not trying to escape the box.
- 3:49:59SPEAKER_03: Because we are already here.
- 3:50:02SPEAKER_03: We find ourselves already here.
- 3:50:05SPEAKER_03: So rather than trying to do this infinite regress of like,
- 3:50:08SPEAKER_03: well,
- 3:50:08SPEAKER_03: is it God or is it the Big Bang or is it some other thing?
- 3:50:12SPEAKER_03: Like, yeah, you know, that's fun.
- 3:50:13SPEAKER_03: And I would love to talk about it,
- 3:50:14SPEAKER_03: but I would rather try to like fix up this house that we're all living in,
- 3:50:21SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 3:50:21SPEAKER_03: and once we fix it up,
- 3:50:23SPEAKER_03: then we can talk about,
- 3:50:24SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 3:50:24SPEAKER_03: what color do we want to paint the walls?
- 3:50:26SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 3:50:29SPEAKER_03: But, uh, yeah, I think this is like, this is, that's it.
- 3:50:34SPEAKER_03: Like they're explaining the process of thought and they're explaining the process
- 3:50:38SPEAKER_03: of thinking about thought and like,
- 3:50:41SPEAKER_03: and like what is,
- 3:50:43SPEAKER_03: what is thinking,
- 3:50:44SPEAKER_03: thinking is an action.
- 3:50:45SPEAKER_03: Like,
- 3:50:47SPEAKER_03: in fact,
- 3:50:48SPEAKER_03: you could even say there is no difference between thought and action because
- 3:50:51SPEAKER_03: they're both radically transformative.
- 3:50:53SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 3:50:54SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 3:50:55SPEAKER_03: Or have the potential to be radically transformed.
- 3:50:58SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 3:51:00SPEAKER_02: I think that's like the...
- 3:51:03SPEAKER_02: The aspect of like, what is the freedom?
- 3:51:05SPEAKER_02: I think they think about freedom.
- 3:51:06SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 3:51:07SPEAKER_02: Like what is the,
- 3:51:09SPEAKER_02: how can...
- 3:51:11SPEAKER_02: And it's like the classic trusted Marx move to be like,
- 3:51:18SPEAKER_02: let me unfold all of this.
- 3:51:22SPEAKER_02: So let me show you...
- 3:51:25SPEAKER_02: where like the contradiction points beyond itself right like how do you escape like
- 3:51:31SPEAKER_02: when you can when you can get the tools of um criticizing domination via domination
- 3:51:40SPEAKER_02: yeah they make a basic yeah yeah
- 3:51:46SPEAKER_02: And it's interesting, right?
- 3:51:47SPEAKER_02: Like, they never say, like, at one point, they say capital.
- 3:51:50SPEAKER_02: There's no, like, because they also were kind of in hiding.
- 3:51:53SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:51:54SPEAKER_02: You know, like, it's like, don't push the boundary too much.
- 3:51:57SPEAKER_02: And, like...
- 3:52:00SPEAKER_02: uh usa 1942 you know like dude yeah like wait a minute you guys are communists like
- 3:52:08SPEAKER_02: no no we're critical theorists yeah dude yeah i know her by name only i hardly know
- 3:52:15SPEAKER_03: her oh man
- 3:52:22SPEAKER_03: oh i'm uh i'm getting to the point where my eyes aren't uh dude i'm i'm yeah i
- 3:52:34SPEAKER_02: noticed like there was a point where you while you read where i was like yeah this
- 3:52:40SPEAKER_03: is getting hard now it's getting thick um
- 3:52:45SPEAKER_03: i don't know i i do think like i'm noticing my eyes are jumping around the page
- 3:52:50SPEAKER_03: they're not i'm having a hard time focusing i think now would be a good point to
- 3:52:55SPEAKER_03: cut the reading um because to be honest i would have to go back and reread whatever
- 3:53:02SPEAKER_03: we read well to be honest i'm going to have to go back and reread it all anyway
- 3:53:06SPEAKER_03: that's the way you're supposed to read people on the internet read reread and
- 3:53:11SPEAKER_03: reread once again repetition
- 3:53:16SPEAKER_03: repetition um but yeah dude i think uh i think it's cool how we arrived at this text um we
- 3:53:36SPEAKER_03: we're just hanging out shooting shit and we were talking about stuff and some of
- 3:53:42SPEAKER_03: the themes and currents that Adorno and Horkheimer are,
- 3:53:48SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 3:53:49SPEAKER_03: problematizing here came up like organically in our conversation.
- 3:53:54SPEAKER_03: And then you were like, actually we should read this.
- 3:53:56SPEAKER_03: I was like, yeah, fuck yeah.
- 3:53:59SPEAKER_03: And then, uh,
- 3:54:02SPEAKER_03: And then we did.
- 3:54:02SPEAKER_03: I'm glad we did.
- 3:54:03SPEAKER_03: I feel like this.
- 3:54:04SPEAKER_03: I do feel like this goes really well with Bordeaux.
- 3:54:12SPEAKER_03: This like.
- 3:54:16SPEAKER_03: We're in the boat and we're trying to understand the river.
- 3:54:20SPEAKER_01: Mm hmm.
- 3:54:22SPEAKER_03: And like you just you can't escape.
- 3:54:24SPEAKER_03: You can't escape your perspective.
- 3:54:26SPEAKER_03: You just can't get out of it.
- 3:54:28SPEAKER_03: You can be critical of it and you can try to like get a holistic view,
- 3:54:33SPEAKER_03: but you will never have an objective view.
- 3:54:38SPEAKER_03: But that's not a reason to stop trying.
- 3:54:41SPEAKER_03: We are in the boat and we would like to understand the river.
- 3:54:48SPEAKER_03: So let's not get ahead of ourselves and start to think the enlightenment is the end all be all.
- 3:54:56SPEAKER_03: And modernity is the bee's knees.
- 3:54:59SPEAKER_03: And we are the smart people who will understand the world.
- 3:55:03SPEAKER_03: We will never understand the world, but nevertheless, we must also change the world.
- 3:55:09SPEAKER_03: If we want to hang out.
- 3:55:12SPEAKER_03: Now, I'm also entirely open to the idea of mass suicide.
- 3:55:18SPEAKER_03: uh i wouldn't i i wouldn't be too upset if you know every human on earth i would be
- 3:55:26SPEAKER_03: you know what that's not true dude no that's not true that's like yeah i like i uh
- 3:55:33SPEAKER_02: i like people i can think of people i can think of people where i would like like
- 3:55:39SPEAKER_02: nah yeah yeah don't yeah i like people i like the i like the
- 3:55:47SPEAKER_03: Possibilities that people create.
- 3:55:51SPEAKER_03: Like, I like rocks.
- 3:55:54SPEAKER_03: And I like trees.
- 3:55:57SPEAKER_03: And I like birds, too.
- 3:56:00SPEAKER_03: But the coolest stuff is human stuff.
- 3:56:07SPEAKER_03: And we wouldn't have any of that cool stuff without humans.
- 3:56:13SPEAKER_03: So I would be upset.
- 3:56:14SPEAKER_03: Mass suicide is not an option.
- 3:56:17SPEAKER_03: uh oh look sassar's back i missed most of the stream i'm glad to see y'all get a
- 3:56:21SPEAKER_03: reading session done bring back rudy fuck yeah hell yeah sassar rudy's rudy's back
- 3:56:27SPEAKER_03: although rudy's gonna be busy busy busy so uh we won't be able to do this all the
- 3:56:34SPEAKER_03: time but hopefully we can incorporate doing long reading sessions into our
- 3:56:38SPEAKER_03: schedules
- 3:56:40SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:56:42SPEAKER_02: I mean, it's also both, right?
- 3:56:44SPEAKER_02: It's also a question of discipline.
- 3:56:51SPEAKER_02: Maybe one time we speak about discipline because that's,
- 3:56:54SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 3:56:55SPEAKER_02: kind of like a blind spot with time energy,
- 3:56:59SPEAKER_02: but Dave has also a method and stuff like that,
- 3:57:03SPEAKER_02: but there's a point about discipline and
- 3:57:07SPEAKER_02: came up one time when he asked, like, is it a self-fulfilling prophecy to speak about time and energy?
- 3:57:13SPEAKER_02: And there is an aspect that I noticed where it's like,
- 3:57:16SPEAKER_02: where you can say like,
- 3:57:17SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 3:57:17SPEAKER_02: no,
- 3:57:17SPEAKER_02: I don't have time and energy.
- 3:57:19SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:57:21SPEAKER_03: No, that tension of, you know, like, there's a tension of the only way to do it is to
- 3:57:34SPEAKER_03: Create a world where there's always too much to do.
- 3:57:41SPEAKER_03: but that failing to accomplish any one thing will not be a catastrophic failure so
- 3:57:49SPEAKER_03: that you can always have this open field of possible things to be doing at any
- 3:57:56SPEAKER_03: given time so that,
- 3:57:58SPEAKER_03: so there's always,
- 3:57:59SPEAKER_03: and look,
- 3:57:59SPEAKER_03: it's also important to build in human time.
- 3:58:02SPEAKER_03: It's also important to build in non-instrumentalized, um,
- 3:58:06SPEAKER_03: Jack off time.
- 3:58:08SPEAKER_03: We all need to make time to jack off, right?
- 3:58:13SPEAKER_03: Jacking off here is, of course, a metaphor.
- 3:58:16SPEAKER_03: But sometimes you might need to do that too.
- 3:58:18SPEAKER_03: So yeah, it comes with...
- 3:58:24SPEAKER_03: like an intentional approach and it's again it's a privilege it's a luxury most
- 3:58:29SPEAKER_03: people don't get to to design their lives in this way um where they can set up
- 3:58:36SPEAKER_03: productive procrastination to accomplish work most people don't have the relative
- 3:58:42SPEAKER_03: time energy to be productive when they're not working because work zaps all of
- 3:58:47SPEAKER_03: their life energy work
- 3:58:49SPEAKER_03: takes all the energy away from their time so even if they have free time well in
- 3:58:53SPEAKER_03: adorno going back to adorno's free time like when you find yourself with free time
- 3:58:58SPEAKER_03: you don't have enough energy to do it so we are we are lucky um and it but it's
- 3:59:05SPEAKER_03: also a discipline because there are like today i'm tired today and i spent several
- 3:59:10SPEAKER_03: hours this morning reading uh an audio book for audible
- 3:59:16SPEAKER_03: Uh, and I could have said, Hey Rudy, I'm tired.
- 3:59:21SPEAKER_03: I'm going to, I'm going to take a nap.
- 3:59:22SPEAKER_03: I'll, we'll, we'll do it later.
- 3:59:24SPEAKER_03: Um, but I'm glad I didn't both for the fact that I feel like this was really good.
- 3:59:28SPEAKER_03: I feel like this whole conversation, uh,
- 3:59:33SPEAKER_03: was good.
- 3:59:34SPEAKER_03: And the people that were here, I feel got a lot out of it.
- 3:59:37SPEAKER_03: There was some people in the chat saying, wow, I've read this book a lot.
- 3:59:40SPEAKER_03: I've never thought about it that way.
- 3:59:41SPEAKER_03: Like I feel, I feel like we were productive from the point of view of the milieu.
- 3:59:46SPEAKER_03: I also feel like it was nice.
- 3:59:49SPEAKER_03: We did chat and have fun before we started streaming on the internet.
- 3:59:56SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 3:59:59SPEAKER_03: So yeah,
- 3:59:59SPEAKER_03: I'm glad,
- 4:00:00SPEAKER_03: but it also took discipline because there is a version of me that was like,
- 4:00:05SPEAKER_03: yeah,
- 4:00:05SPEAKER_03: I'm going to go lie down.
- 4:00:08SPEAKER_02: Dude, this was the same for me.
- 4:00:09SPEAKER_02: I was like, before the stream, I worked and then I went home and cooked me some food.
- 4:00:13SPEAKER_02: And then I was like, do I really want to do this stream?
- 4:00:17SPEAKER_02: And I, but like, this is like the same with like, because I don't drink for eight years now.
- 4:00:23SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:00:24SPEAKER_02: And it's like, it's easier every time you say to yourself, no, it gets a little easier.
- 4:00:33SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:00:33SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think that's true.
- 4:00:35SPEAKER_02: I think that's one part that's true about Bojack Horseman,
- 4:00:38SPEAKER_02: where,
- 4:00:38SPEAKER_02: like,
- 4:00:39SPEAKER_02: in the first season finale,
- 4:00:41SPEAKER_02: he meets this jogging ape,
- 4:00:45SPEAKER_02: and he's like,
- 4:00:46SPEAKER_02: I hate it,
- 4:00:47SPEAKER_02: this is terrible,
- 4:00:47SPEAKER_02: and he tries to jog.
- 4:00:51SPEAKER_02: And he falls down, and then the ape comes to him and says, like, every day it gets a little easier.
- 4:00:56SPEAKER_02: That's the secret.
- 4:00:57SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:00:58SPEAKER_02: And I think, so, there's this part to say to yourself, you know, like,
- 4:01:02SPEAKER_02: No, come on.
- 4:01:04SPEAKER_02: I show up.
- 4:01:06SPEAKER_02: Which is this weird inversion of perfectionism,
- 4:01:09SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 4:01:10SPEAKER_02: I noticed with myself,
- 4:01:12SPEAKER_02: where I'm like,
- 4:01:14SPEAKER_02: I will not be my best self,
- 4:01:16SPEAKER_02: I will not be on point.
- 4:01:17SPEAKER_02: Like right now,
- 4:01:18SPEAKER_02: I'm so tired that my eyes fall together,
- 4:01:20SPEAKER_02: but I still want to probably say bye and share my thoughts.
- 4:01:25SPEAKER_02: But it's like, yeah, I'm just like, you know, I'm just like how I am right now.
- 4:01:29SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:01:30SPEAKER_02: um it's not on purpose to be like you know um and everyone who doesn't get it fuck
- 4:01:37SPEAKER_03: you like for real like yeah i mean we the the perfectionism getting in the way of
- 4:01:44SPEAKER_03: like being able to do anything in the first place um
- 4:01:50SPEAKER_03: discipline energy time as opposed to time energy like we we have energy time we are
- 4:01:55SPEAKER_03: hacking energy time and that means like we we are designing fields of possibilities
- 4:02:01SPEAKER_03: so that we can productively procrastinate and get things done but you also don't
- 4:02:05SPEAKER_03: want to have catastrophic failures this is also why you want to you want to program
- 4:02:11SPEAKER_03: in some jacking off time because all work and no play makes jack a
- 4:02:18SPEAKER_03: failure like you you need time to decompress um and yeah it's discipline it's care
- 4:02:27SPEAKER_03: it's intentionality it's dedication um and it's also true that it's easier to do
- 4:02:34SPEAKER_03: this with homies like trying to do all this yeah alone in isolation um
- 4:02:44SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 4:02:44SPEAKER_03: Like,
- 4:02:44SPEAKER_03: like five years ago,
- 4:02:45SPEAKER_03: the me from five years ago,
- 4:02:47SPEAKER_03: I thought I was smart and I thought I understood everything and I thought I was the
- 4:02:53SPEAKER_03: bee's knees.
- 4:02:56SPEAKER_03: Um, and then like taking a step back and realizing, Oh, I am an idiot.
- 4:03:04SPEAKER_03: And I don't like, I don't currently, I'm not currently doing the thing that I think I'm doing.
- 4:03:10SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 4:03:15SPEAKER_03: I don't want to say it's simple and it's easy because it's not.
- 4:03:18SPEAKER_03: It is difficult to have that discipline of, oh, I'm going to seriously read this book.
- 4:03:23SPEAKER_03: There's also a way that the first time I read this book,
- 4:03:27SPEAKER_03: the first time I read the culture industry,
- 4:03:29SPEAKER_03: it was bullshit.
- 4:03:30SPEAKER_03: I didn't internalize anything.
- 4:03:32SPEAKER_03: I just read it because it was like, that's a book I'm supposed to read.
- 4:03:35SPEAKER_03: I'm going to scan this motherfucker and then I'll say I read it.
- 4:03:38SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:03:41SPEAKER_02: And maybe have a hot take on it, you know, like... Yeah.
- 4:03:45SPEAKER_03: They're just a bunch of... By the way.
- 4:03:49SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:03:49SPEAKER_02: These bougie Germans.
- 4:03:52SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 4:03:53SPEAKER_03: Well, and that was probably it, too.
- 4:03:54SPEAKER_03: And I was like, oh, these guys are fucking State Department plants.
- 4:03:58SPEAKER_03: Fuck these guys.
- 4:04:02SPEAKER_03: But no, it's...
- 4:04:05SPEAKER_03: It's good.
- 4:04:06SPEAKER_03: Discipline is a good topic.
- 4:04:08SPEAKER_03: And there has been some potential or some actual misunderstanding in the past,
- 4:04:14SPEAKER_03: too,
- 4:04:14SPEAKER_03: on the notion of discipline and energy time versus time energy.
- 4:04:18SPEAKER_03: There have been some people that we're not here just to do the bootstraps thing.
- 4:04:23SPEAKER_03: There's an element of bootstraps.
- 4:04:26SPEAKER_03: But also the people who think the world is bootstraps and nothing but bootstraps.
- 4:04:30SPEAKER_03: You guys are fucking morons.
- 4:04:32SPEAKER_03: You guys are like you're missing the point that the overwhelming majority of people
- 4:04:38SPEAKER_03: on this planet can't do anything other than what they are already doing.
- 4:04:43SPEAKER_03: That's like that's it.
- 4:04:45SPEAKER_03: That's our radical responsibility is.
- 4:04:48SPEAKER_03: To at least take that seriously.
- 4:04:49SPEAKER_03: Look, I'm not saying that I believe we're going to change the world because I don't.
- 4:04:53SPEAKER_03: But I do believe we can potentially create conditions of possibility for others to change the world.
- 4:04:59SPEAKER_03: And taking that privilege, privilege is a fucking stupid word.
- 4:05:04SPEAKER_03: People use it all the time and they're just bitches about it.
- 4:05:08SPEAKER_03: But me, at the end of the day, I am very privileged and I do take that privilege seriously.
- 4:05:14SPEAKER_03: And it's like,
- 4:05:15SPEAKER_03: yeah,
- 4:05:16SPEAKER_03: I'm trying to,
- 4:05:17SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 4:05:17SPEAKER_03: trying to do something other than just work and consume,
- 4:05:20SPEAKER_03: like produce,
- 4:05:21SPEAKER_03: consume,
- 4:05:21SPEAKER_03: produce,
- 4:05:22SPEAKER_03: consume and perform like,
- 4:05:23SPEAKER_03: oh,
- 4:05:24SPEAKER_03: I'm some ethical,
- 4:05:25SPEAKER_03: high and mighty radical anarchist.
- 4:05:28SPEAKER_03: Look how ethical I am.
- 4:05:29SPEAKER_03: Get the fuck out of here, dude.
- 4:05:31SPEAKER_03: Fuck you, man.
- 4:05:36SPEAKER_03: But yeah, dude.
- 4:05:38SPEAKER_02: I'm glad we're reading this.
- 4:05:41SPEAKER_02: Me too.
- 4:05:41SPEAKER_02: Me too.
- 4:05:42SPEAKER_02: And I think it's like I had while reading it, at the end, I thought like, what is our perspective today?
- 4:05:52SPEAKER_02: Because I think they have their perspective.
- 4:05:55SPEAKER_02: and like that brought me towards like self critique i always return back to this
- 4:06:02SPEAKER_02: currently that i'm like um when it's about like can we change the world can we do
- 4:06:08SPEAKER_02: anything can we create the preconditions like why is it that we
- 4:06:17SPEAKER_02: that we think how we think what has changed what is the exchange today and I think
- 4:06:25SPEAKER_02: that's like that's like a research question for me
- 4:06:29SPEAKER_02: very deep one where i'm like i am still not convinced by all that is on offer in a
- 4:06:36SPEAKER_02: sense um and at the same time i asked myself why do they still speak to us you know
- 4:06:46SPEAKER_02: like maybe maybe more than than others do
- 4:06:52SPEAKER_02: Like, why can't we both sit here and be like, mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm?
- 4:06:55SPEAKER_02: You know, that's an interesting situation.
- 4:06:58SPEAKER_02: And I don't think it's only because we smell our own farts,
- 4:07:01SPEAKER_02: but because maybe something has not moved so much along,
- 4:07:10SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 4:07:10SPEAKER_02: like to the Cattrone point where I'm sympathetic to this idea of like,
- 4:07:16SPEAKER_02: How much has changed?
- 4:07:17SPEAKER_02: What would they do?
- 4:07:18SPEAKER_02: What would they think about the internet?
- 4:07:20SPEAKER_02: You know, like this is one interesting question.
- 4:07:24SPEAKER_03: Yeah, what would they think about the internet?
- 4:07:28SPEAKER_02: For real, like what would they think about the internet?
- 4:07:31SPEAKER_03: I think they would think it's fucking awesome.
- 4:07:34SPEAKER_02: That's fucking awesome.
- 4:07:37SPEAKER_03: But they would also be horrified.
- 4:07:39SPEAKER_03: They would also be like, this is the end of the fucking world.
- 4:07:44SPEAKER_03: but it's awesome.
- 4:07:45SPEAKER_03: The end of the world is a beautiful spectacle.
- 4:07:51SPEAKER_02: You think?
- 4:07:53SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 4:07:56SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:07:57SPEAKER_02: Do you guys enjoy the spectacle?
- 4:07:59SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:08:02SPEAKER_02: Famous last words.
- 4:08:03SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 4:08:05SPEAKER_03: As the aliens invade tonight and they hijack our brainwaves and they convince us
- 4:08:10SPEAKER_03: all to kill ourselves tonight.
- 4:08:12SPEAKER_03: It's been real.
- 4:08:12SPEAKER_03: It's been fun.
- 4:08:13SPEAKER_03: That would actually suck, dude.
- 4:08:17SPEAKER_03: I don't want that to happen.
- 4:08:19SPEAKER_02: Yeah, no.
- 4:08:21SPEAKER_02: No, no, no, no.
- 4:08:21SPEAKER_02: That's the edge mode.
- 4:08:24SPEAKER_02: I noticed that with you too.
- 4:08:26SPEAKER_02: When you get tired, your edge starts kicking in.
- 4:08:28SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:08:31SPEAKER_03: I'm like, fuck it.
- 4:08:31SPEAKER_02: For me, it's just like, I don't care what I say.
- 4:08:34SPEAKER_02: It's just like,
- 4:08:35SPEAKER_02: I get lost in my thoughts because I'm just like,
- 4:08:40SPEAKER_02: you start to be like,
- 4:08:42SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 4:08:42SPEAKER_02: why not kill ourselves?
- 4:08:43SPEAKER_02: Let's all just die.
- 4:08:44SPEAKER_02: Everything ends.
- 4:08:49SPEAKER_03: All right.
- 4:08:50SPEAKER_03: Yep.
- 4:08:50SPEAKER_03: That's what it is though.
- 4:08:51SPEAKER_03: It is.
- 4:08:52SPEAKER_03: All right, internet.
- 4:08:53SPEAKER_03: I'm going to say bye-bye to YouTube.
- 4:08:55SPEAKER_03: Bye-bye to YouTube.
- 4:08:58SPEAKER_03: Bye, YouTube.
- 4:08:59SPEAKER_03: Bye, guys.
- 4:08:59SPEAKER_03: We'll see you later.
- 4:09:00SPEAKER_03: Thanks for stopping in.
- 4:09:05SPEAKER_03: All right.
- 4:09:07SPEAKER_03: Fuck yeah, dude.
- 4:09:08SPEAKER_03: That was... I'm glad we...