Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Were Promoted Without One
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, here's a situation I hear about all the time, and I bet some of our listeners are nodding right now. You get promoted — new title, bigger scope, more responsibility — but your paycheck doesn't move. Not a cent. Luna: Oh, that's the worst. It's like a participation trophy that doesn't even cover your rent increase. Lucas: Exactly. And it's actually more common than you'd think. A recent survey from a big HR association found that nearly thirty percent of employees who were promoted in the past two years didn't receive a raise with the new title. That's a lot of people sitting in meetings thinking, 'Wait, I'm doing more work, but my bank account didn't get the memo.' Luna: So why does it happen? Is it just companies being cheap, or is there something else going on? Lucas: It's rarely just stinginess, though that's part of it. Sometimes it's a timing issue — the promotion is tied to the annual review cycle, so the raise comes a few months later. Other times, the company genuinely views the promotion as a 'development opportunity' or a 'lateral move' in terms of pay band. But I think the biggest factor is just that they think they can get away with it. Luna: Yeah, because what are you going to do, turn down the promotion? That feels like career suicide. Lucas: Right, and that's the leverage they have. They know you want the title, the experience, the resume line. So they dangle that 'senior' or 'lead' in front of you, and hope you won't quibble over the paycheck. Luna: But here's the thing — if you don't push back, you're setting a precedent. Your next raise will be calculated off that lower base, and you'll be playing catch-up for years. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why it's worth having the conversation, even if it feels awkward. The key is how you frame it. You're not asking for a favor; you're pointing out a mismatch between your responsibilities and your compensation. Luna: So what's the script? I need something I can use in my next one-on-one. Lucas: Well, first, do your homework. Before you even book the meeting, look at salary benchmarks for your new title — sites like Glassdoor, Payscale, or even LinkedIn's salary tool. Find the median for your industry and location. That gives you a number to anchor to, not just a vague 'I want more money.' Luna: Right, and also think about your own numbers. What have you accomplished since the promotion? Did you hit any big goals, take on extra projects, improve a process? You want to show that you're already delivering at the new level, not just hoping to grow into it. Lucas: That's a great point. And when you sit down, you want to be direct but not confrontational. Something like, 'I really appreciate the promotion and the trust you've shown in me. I'm excited about the new responsibilities. But I've noticed my compensation hasn't changed, and I was hoping we could talk about that.' Luna: That's good. It's respectful, but it doesn't let them off the hook. And then you bring in your market data. Lucas: Exactly. 'Based on my research, the market range for this role is between X and Y. Given my experience and the results I've delivered, I think a fair adjustment would be Z.' And you name a specific number, or at least a range with a floor you're comfortable with. Luna: But what if they say, 'We don't have budget right now'? That's the classic brush-off. Lucas: So you don't just accept that. You ask, 'Can we set a specific date to revisit this, say in three months, and what would I need to have accomplished by then to make the case?' That turns a vague 'no' into a concrete plan with measurable goals. Luna: And if they still say no, you have to seriously consider whether this company values your growth. Maybe it's time to update your resume and see what else is out there. Lucas: Right, and having that alternative gives you leverage in the conversation itself. You're not desperate; you're negotiating from a position of worth. Luna: Let's talk about the timing. Should you wait a few months after the promotion to bring it up, or do it right away? Lucas: I'd say don't wait too long. If you let it slide for six months, it's easier for them to say, 'Well, we've been paying you this for months and you didn't object.' But you also don't want to bring it up in the same meeting where they announce the promotion, because they might still be figuring out the details. A couple of weeks in, once you're settled into the role, is perfect. Luna: That makes sense. And what about the 'we'll evaluate it at your annual review' line? Is that a trap? Lucas: It can be, but it doesn't have to be. You can say, 'I'm happy to be evaluated at my annual review, but if that's the case, I'd like to make sure my performance is assessed against the new role's expectations, and I want to be sure there's a clear plan for how a raise would be determined.' That way, you're not just passively waiting; you're shaping the criteria. Luna: I like that. And you know, a lot of people worry about souring the relationship. But if you approach it with respect and data, you're actually showing that you're a professional who knows your worth. That can be a good thing. Lucas: Absolutely. And look, on a personal note — and I think this resonates with what we do here on Office Hours — we spend a huge chunk of our waking hours at work. It's not just about the money; it's about feeling valued. That's why we do this show, and it's why listener support matters so much. Luna: Yeah, absolutely. And if these conversations have helped you navigate a career move or a tough workplace situation, you can keep us going by buying us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Every little bit helps us stay ad-free and keep putting out episodes like this one. Lucas: Exactly. So back to the raise. One more tactic that a lot of people overlook: don't just focus on the base salary. If they really can't budge on the number, ask about other forms of compensation — a signing bonus, extra vacation days, remote work flexibility, or a clear commitment to a review in six months with a target increase. Luna: That's a smart fallback. It's like saying, 'I'm flexible, but I need something that shows you're investing in me.' Lucas: Exactly. And remember, the conversation isn't just about the immediate raise. It's about setting the stage for your future earnings. The base salary you negotiate now is the base for all future raises and bonuses. So even a small adjustment now can compound significantly over your career. Luna: That's a great point. I remember reading that a one-time bump of five thousand dollars early in your career can be worth over fifty thousand dollars by retirement, just from the compounding effect on raises and investment contributions. Lucas: That's a powerful number. So don't undervalue yourself. You're not being greedy; you're being smart. Luna: So what's the one takeaway you want listeners to have from this episode? Lucas: That getting a promotion without a raise is not something you have to accept silently. You deserve to be compensated for the work you're doing, and it's okay to ask for it. Do your research, bring the data, and have the conversation. Worst case, you're no worse off than you are now. Best case, you're earning what you're worth. Luna: And if you're still unsure, just remember: the worst they can say is no. And even then, you've learned something about where you stand. Lucas: That's a perfect place to leave it. Thanks for listening, everyone. We'll see you next time.