Latest / The Long for Truth Show / Women Pastors Vs The Bible
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to the Lung for Truth podcast. I'm Robin Long. Join my husband
- 0:06Dan and I as we explore the roots of the early Pentecostal and Charismatic movements
- 0:11and we shine a light on false doctrines and false teachers in the modern church.
- 0:16Let's get started. I'm concerned about now, convinced we'll never fulfill the
- 0:23Great Commission with half of the church sitting on the bench. Okay, somebody's
- 0:27asked, can a woman pastor? Can a woman be a pastor or an
- 0:32elder? I would love to hear your thoughts. Yeah, absolutely, does
- 0:36the church need women shepherds? Yes, I am a woman pastor. Listen,
- 0:43I am a woman pastor that loves the hell out of people. That's
- 0:47what I do, and I mean that in a spiritual manner. I'm going
- 0:50to do two things, and we're going to ask that the Lord help me
- 0:54to do two things to communicate this very important message clearly. And second of
- 1:00all, I'm going to ask that the Lord start to open the eyes of
- 1:04some of the people who have treated me and God lack a second class citizen.
- 1:10And I think I need to stand up for the millions of godly Southern
- 1:14Babbist women whose gifts and leadership skills are being stymied. The only places where
- 1:22Paul writes any corrections about women are to Greek cities. He wrote to Creed,
- 1:26Corinth, and Ephesus. Those were all Greek cities. Why is that
- 1:32important? Because they all had Greek gods. The god, the god of
- 1:37those cities, of each of those cities were a woman. And that's why
- 1:42Paul addresses in first Crimson's eleven. For example, he says it was first,
- 1:48you know. He says, first there was God in Christ, than
- 1:51man, then women. And the reason why he addresses creation order is because
- 1:56he's talking to Greeks who who believed that women should dominate men because of their
- 2:02commission order. Wow, I'm absolutely blocking the haters. Ain't got time for
- 2:07it. I'm blocking the debaters and the haters. Hello everyone, welcome along
- 2:13for truth. My name is Daniel Long, sitting next to me as my
- 2:15lovely wife Robin. Hi. Everyone, So today we're going to be revisiting
- 2:20an old topic. A couple of years ago, Robin and I did a
- 2:23video called women can be Pastors to what does the Bible say? We are
- 2:28going to be addressing that issue again because some concerns have come up about it.
- 2:34We're going to be looking at the role of women in the church.
- 2:37We're going to be asking the question from a biblical perspective, looking at what
- 2:43the Bible says, Can women be pastors, can they be church leaders?
- 2:47And can they lead men? And we will put the link to the old
- 2:52video we did over in the comments, because it's a we're using totally different
- 2:58examples, different people talking about it in different passages. Yeah, so we
- 3:02did want to share with you a few of the comments that we got.
- 3:06And one of the comments that we got on our last video, and we
- 3:08got it numerous times, was it said, no disrespect, but Robin is
- 3:15here teaching men in the internet audience. So isn't this the same thing someone
- 3:20else? Right, what's the difference between what you the women are doing here.
- 3:23You're teaching alongside the man, and I'm sure there are men listening.
- 3:28I'm not disputing what you're saying. I'm just curious as how you would explain
- 3:31this. Yeah, so here's how we would explain it. No, Robin,
- 3:37it is Robin is not doing the same thing as what we had talked
- 3:40about in that video. Because the Bible doesn't forbid this. The Bible forbids
- 3:45women being pastors of a church in a church setting and leading men and a
- 3:53church, and in our opinion that would even include adults Sunday school classes where
- 3:58men are present. And so what Robin is doing here, what Paul Ett
- 4:03does with Steve on the messed up Church is not the same thing. This
- 4:10is not what Paul is talking about. Otherwise you would have to eliminate passages
- 4:16that discuss women, prophetesses, Priscilla and Aquila, all of that, all
- 4:24of those other passages. Paul is specifically speaking of a church gathering, an
- 4:30ecclesia, a congregation where the church is operating at that particular point in time.
- 4:40So if Danny were standing at the podium in a church and I got
- 4:44up to help him, that would be inappropriate. Yes, that would be
- 4:48inappropriate. So know what Robin is doing is not the same thing as what
- 4:55Paul is talking about in those passages. Okay, so hopefully that helps.
- 5:00Another question. Please, can you show me anywhere at all in the Bible
- 5:04using the word pastor in reference to your topic? Yes, we can.
- 5:10So in order to do that, I'm going to have to share the screen,
- 5:13and I want I'm going to have to go over to Ephesians chapter four,
- 5:15So let's do that, all right. So here we are over in
- 5:18Ephesians chapter four. Let me get the Greek up here. We're in Ephesians
- 5:23chapter four, and this is what it says. And he Christ gave the
- 5:29apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds, and the teachers.
- 5:34Now the ESV translates this word shepherd this Greek word which is right over here,
- 5:42and that is the Greek word poimna poimenos, and it is translate if
- 5:48you look down there at the very bottom of the screen. I wish I
- 5:51could hold my cursor there, But if you look down on the Greek you
- 5:56can see at the very bottom of the screen it is translated pastor. But
- 5:59let me click on on it and we'll open up B DAG and we'll see
- 6:03what this actually means. So the first definition one who heard sheep, shepherd,
- 6:09sheep, herder, okay, And then we come down here to the
- 6:13second one who serves as guardian or leader shepherd. And then we come down
- 6:17here of those who lead Christian communities. And then we can come all the
- 6:23way down human leaders. Okay, and we see our passages right there.
- 6:28He gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds, and
- 6:32the teachers. Now what we wouldn't to do is we want to look at
- 6:35how other Bible translations translate this Greek word. So the SV, of course
- 6:45translates it shepherd. This is the text comparison tool. I use this a
- 6:47lot because this is just so helpful, and it says there, it translates
- 6:54that word is. You can see where my cursor is shepherds. The NSP
- 6:57he translates it pastors. He gave some to be prophets, and some evangelists,
- 7:02and some as pastors. The new King James version translates that word pastors.
- 7:09The Lexim English Bible translates the word pastors, The NIV translates it pastors.
- 7:15Young's literal translation does what the EESV does and translates it as shepherds,
- 7:20and even the King James translates it pastors, the n ET pastors, and
- 7:26the Home and Christian Standard version pastors. So you can see the majority of
- 7:30those translations translate that verse as pastors. So a shepherd is a pastor.
- 7:39So Danny I think the issue was that we're talking about women being pastors,
- 7:44and a number of people said, well, pastors isn't even in the Bible.
- 7:47So maybe the translation you are reading uses another form of the words.
- 7:53So if you see elder, overseer, shepherd, that would be the same
- 7:59thing as a pastor. So we could say women should not be elders,
- 8:03they shouldn't be shepherds, they shouldn't lead the church, and that overseers exactly
- 8:09now, so that I hope that that's clear. And also please remember that's
- 8:13in the context of Christ giving these gifts to the church. The evangelists,
- 8:20the apostles, the teachers, the pastors, all of those gifts are given
- 8:24to the church, and shepherd or pastor is one of those gifts. Okay,
- 8:30right, So our first clip today is by Beth Moore. Women are
- 8:37spiritually gifted the same as men, even if our roles may differ. We
- 8:43may have distinctions, but we better figure out how is it we are going
- 8:48to serve, not just consume. How is it we're going to serve and
- 8:52is there any place to do that. One of the things that has concerned
- 8:56me most with believing that there was an extremely hard pull to the far right,
- 9:01where there was going to be less and less for women to do,
- 9:05and where it was getting more and more the norm that the only thing a
- 9:11woman really was called to do that was blessed by God in the church was
- 9:16in the context of the traditional family. I love the family, I love
- 9:22my role as wife, I love my role as mother. But I'm going
- 9:26to ask you, what the world are you going to do with ten thousands
- 9:31single men and women. This just does not make sense. This is a
- 9:35very strong context. It's not the only one we have calling whether inside or
- 9:41outside at home, whether men or women, you don't wipe out half the
- 9:48Gospel force. And so I'm gonna let Robin start on that first qu comment
- 10:00that she made about women and the family. So Beth Moore is exaggerating greatly
- 10:09the issue that she is having with women in the church. And yes,
- 10:13obviously this happens because of what was going on with the Southern Baptist Convention.
- 10:20And she said in this clip her concern is about a hard pull to the
- 10:24far right in which the only thing that women can do and be blessed by
- 10:33God is to have a role in the family as a wife and mother.
- 10:37And number one that's just so not true, Danny. I know. And
- 10:43when she makes that comment at the end there where it says something to the
- 10:46she said something to the fact I might have to look at the clip again,
- 10:50but something to the effect of wiping out half of the gospel. Force
- 10:54there you go. You don't wipe out half the gospel. For so she's
- 11:03talking about women not being able to serve no one. It's saying women can't
- 11:07serve in the church. There are places in scripture where Paul talks about women
- 11:13teaching but not men and not pastoring. Women can teach women, what's wrong
- 11:20with that. Women can teach children, and women can teach outside the church.
- 11:24Women can share the gospel on the street, women can sit at their
- 11:30workplace and talk to men about the Gospel. And so, I mean,
- 11:35it's just, you know, it's just not a good argument, not at
- 11:39all. I have not heard of a church in which a woman did not
- 11:45hold a teaching position over children or or other women, and she was relegated
- 11:50to be and saying only to the family, as if that is not as
- 11:58if being a mother and a wife is not a high calling, especially a
- 12:01mother who is training these little ones to grow up to be godly men and
- 12:09women. I mean, how is that a small calling? That's one of
- 12:15the highest callings a person can have. Exactly, that is not less than
- 12:20any other calling, is not it is greater than Yes Matthew sixteen seventeen through
- 12:28eighteen states and Jesus answered him, blessed are you, Simon Barjonah, for
- 12:33flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, But my Father, who
- 12:37is in heaven, And I tell you you are Peter, and on this
- 12:41rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell she and that
- 12:45shall not prevail against it. So, according to Beth, more than not,
- 12:50women not being leaders in the church, and especially over men, you
- 12:56are wiping out half the gospel force. Jesus says that he is building a
- 13:03church and the gates of hell will not prevail against it. So there's no
- 13:07way that we are wiping out half the gospel force. Christ is going to
- 13:13build his church and it will stand and it will last. In recent church
- 13:18news, and I'm sure you've heard this, the Southern Baptist Convention expelled Saddleback
- 13:22Church for having female pastors. Rick Warren had been on the Russell Moore Show
- 13:30explaining the scriptures that he used to justify his change of mind, and we're
- 13:35going to share those scriptures with you and talk about them. The first passage
- 13:41is the Great Commission. In that study caused me to change my view about
- 13:46women. Nothing else could have studied it, as I came upon three different
- 13:52scriptures. First the Great Commission. Now Baptist Southern Baptists like to call ourselves
- 13:58Great Commission Baptists, and we claim that we believe the Great Commission is for
- 14:03everybody. Both men and women are to fulfill the Great Commission. Well not
- 14:07really, you don't believe that because it says there are four verbs in the
- 14:11Great Commission, go make disciples, baptize, and teach. Women are to
- 14:22go, women are to make disciples, women are to baptize, and women
- 14:28are to teach, not just men. Now, this is one of the
- 14:33reasons why Saddleback is baptized more people than any church in American history, fifty
- 14:37seven thousand adult baptisms in forty three years. Why because in our church,
- 14:43if you and him to Christ, you get to baptize them. So if
- 14:48a mom wants to baptize her child, or a wife wants to baptize her
- 14:50husband, that she led to Christ. Anybody can baptize anybody. They led
- 14:56to Christ fifty seven thousand bats. It's the reliberation, the emancipation of every
- 15:01member as a minister, that truly we believe in the priesthood of the priest
- 15:05most of the time instead of the priest of the believer. Now, Great
- 15:07Commission, go make disciples, baptist teach. You can't say, well,
- 15:11the first two or for men and women. The last two are only for
- 15:13men, or maybe just ordained men. That's I said, Jesus, you
- 15:20got a problem. Who authorized women to teach? Jesus, all authority is
- 15:24given to me. Therefore teach all authorities given to me. Therefore baptize.
- 15:30You've got a problem with the Great Commission. I had to repent when I
- 15:33actually looked at the Great Commission. I had to say, it's not just
- 15:37for ordained men. Is for everybody, and the Great Commission is for everybody.
- 15:43But it does not say, there and the Great Commission that women are
- 15:48to be pastors. The Great Commission is for men and women. Women can
- 15:52teach other women and children, and they can teach outside the church. Is
- 16:00Rick Warren actually saying that he read the Great commission and thought it had to
- 16:03do with female leadership in the church. That's what he's saying, what he's
- 16:07repenting over. Yeah, such a week week week argument. It's unbelievable.
- 16:12So, yes, women are to be doing what Jesus commanded men to do
- 16:19the same and the great commission. And I hear this, and I think
- 16:22of all of these single female missionaries through the ages, yea, who have
- 16:27shared the Gospel around the world. Yes, but they weren't pastors. And
- 16:32you know so, I mean, and that's that's our point. You can
- 16:36look at plenty of examples in scripture where women were prophetesses, and you can
- 16:42look at Aquila and Priscilla who schooled a Polish and those are all facts or
- 16:48biblical facts. But that does not nullify Paul's command. And it doesn't mean
- 16:55that Paul was kind of beating around the bush or he had something else on,
- 17:00you know, in mind when he said that women are not to teach
- 17:03men. That is just not how it worked. It's not our Next clip
- 17:11is by doctor Sandra Richter. Doctor Richter is a professor at Westmont College in
- 17:17California, where she studies, where she teaches primarily environmental theology and Old Testament,
- 17:26and in this clip she is going to be talking about the passage in
- 17:30First Timothy. In other words, the focus of this problem is not women.
- 17:34The focus of this problem are people who are propagating false doctrine because they
- 17:41are too uneducated or under educated to know the difference. Why does he tie
- 17:45it back to even Adam? I think he ties it back to even Adam
- 17:49in the way that he does. I think he's actually quoting the wisdom of
- 17:52Sirac. There's an illusion here. It's a acryphal book, an intertestamental piece.
- 18:00But in the situation in the garden, Eve was the one who was
- 18:04deceived. And the theory here is that it was Adam who was actually taught
- 18:10the word by God. Eve was operating on hearsay. Eve got deceived.
- 18:15Therefore she was vulnerable. She was vulnerable. That's why she got deceived.
- 18:18And Paul is using this as an illustration. Does he tie this back to
- 18:22the Creation Ordinance? Well, folks, most of the commentators, you know
- 18:26what they have to say this little paragraph. I have no idea what Paul
- 18:30is doing. That's the general consensus on this piece. I have no idea
- 18:36what Paul is doing so, if we have no idea what Paul is doing,
- 18:38it's probably not a good idea to hang major policies and doctrines on this
- 18:45business about the Eve and Adam piece. But the kicker of all this,
- 18:49for me, the kicker about this particular passage is it occasional? Is it
- 18:56normative? Is going back to that story about Priscilla and Aquila in Acts eighteen,
- 19:02did you notice where Apolos was preaching. Now, a certain Jew named
- 19:07Apollos and Alexandrian by birth, an eloquent man, came to ephesis and he
- 19:14was mighty in the scriptures. Where does Priscilla call him down and instruct him
- 19:19in the full Gospel and Timothy's church? And she is commended for doing it.
- 19:26So, if Priscilla is operating in her teaching gifts even in ephesis,
- 19:33apparently the problem in Timothy was very particular to this time, this moment,
- 19:41and I would say this is an occasional command as opposed to a normative.
- 19:45All right, So doctor Richter says that most commentators do not know why Paul
- 19:52makes the connection the creation connection there in First Timothy chapter two. So why
- 20:00don't we go ahead and read the Passage for Timothy two eight through fifteen.
- 20:04I desire them that in every place the men should pray, lifting holy hands,
- 20:08without anger or quarreling. Likewise, also that women should adorn themselves in
- 20:15respectable apparel with modesty and self control, not with braided hair and gold or
- 20:19pearls or costly attire, but with what is proper for women who profess godliness,
- 20:26with good works. Let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. I
- 20:30do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man.
- 20:34Rather, she is to remain quiet. For Adam was formed first, then
- 20:40Eve, and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became
- 20:45a transgressor. Yet she will be saved through childbearing if they continue in faith
- 20:49and love and holiness with self control. All right, and as we move
- 20:56forward, we see right after that at section the qualifications for the pastors and
- 21:04deacons or the overseers and the deacons. Same thing. So this is very
- 21:10important to show that this is how Paul lays out the structure for leadership and
- 21:19the church. This is not some kind of you know, situation just for
- 21:26that specific church, and it's not Danny it's not parenthetical like by the way
- 21:33Adam was formed first. And it was a surprise, I think to both
- 21:37of us that she said. Most commentators said they didn't understand why it was
- 21:41there. So of course we look in commentary, of course, and we
- 21:45have lots and lots of commentaries between the both of us. So, first
- 21:49of all, even not in his New Testament commentary, but in his in
- 21:55the Study Bible. In his notes, John MacArthur states the following about that
- 22:00passage. A woman's subordinate role did not result after the fall as a cultural
- 22:07chauvinistic corruption of God's perfect design. Rather, God established her role as part
- 22:12of his original creation. God made woman after man to be his suitable helper.
- 22:19The fall actually corroborates God's divine plan of creation. By nature, Eve
- 22:26was not suited to assume the position of ultimate responsibility. By leaving Adam's protection
- 22:33and usurping his headship, she was vulnerable and fell, thus confirming how important
- 22:38it was for her to stay under the protection and leadership of her husband.
- 22:42Adam then violated his leadership role, followed Eve in her sin, and plunged
- 22:48the human race into sinfulness, all connected with violating God's planned role for the
- 22:55sexes. Ultimately, the responsibility for the fall still rests with Adam, since
- 23:00he chose to disobey God, apart from being deceived. So there were two
- 23:03reasons Paul makes their in Timothy. The first one is and the most important
- 23:10one is that Adam was formed first, and then the second one is that
- 23:15the woman was deceived. So I think we have another commentator we do in
- 23:22Lensky. He says the following. There are two facts, and the greater
- 23:29is stated first, although the second two is very decisive. Adam and Eve
- 23:33were not created at the same time. Paul's brief statement is to the point
- 23:38Adam was created as the first. He existed for some time before Eve was
- 23:44formed. That certainly reveals God's intention that Eve was not to direct rule supervise
- 23:51him, that she was not to be the head, but he. It
- 23:55is said truly that priority in creation includes dignity. God could have created both
- 24:00at the same time. He did not do this, and so just the
- 24:06very fact that Adam was created first. That's the first argument that Paul makes,
- 24:11and he is connecting the Genesis account with the leadership and role of a
- 24:18woman in the church. Right, So doctor rictor doesn't want to hang any
- 24:23major policies on this scripture because her argument is it's occasional not normative, meaning
- 24:32it's for that church in that specific time, which was having very particular issues,
- 24:38so it shouldn't be something that we carry down and build doctrines on.
- 24:44She also talks about the whole Priscilla and Aquila schooling Apollos in that clip,
- 24:52and she makes the argument that, you know, it was in Timothy's church,
- 24:57and so Priscilla must have been a lead there and she was schooling Apolos.
- 25:02Well, we do know that Priscilla and Aquila both school Apollos. We
- 25:07know that we you know, and it wasn't that Apollos was teaching inaccurate things
- 25:12about Christ, but he was teaching the doctrine that he learned from John the
- 25:18Baptist. Yeah, And I think her point is it was in Timothy's church,
- 25:22which was really messed up at that time and needed all of this help,
- 25:26and when we don't even know if Priscilla and Quilla were helping Apolos during
- 25:30the time that Timothy was a pastor, right, Like, she's really making
- 25:33a lot of connections there that she's not clarifying, not at all. And
- 25:38so so let me ask you this, if and we were talking about this
- 25:44earlier, if we were sitting in church and a man, this is after
- 25:48church is over and we're just hanging out with people, were fellowshipping with people,
- 25:53and a man pulls us aside and asks us or you know, together,
- 25:59Hey, listen, my wife is really starting to get into Jesus calling
- 26:04you know, what do you guys think of that? And if Robin began
- 26:07to talk about Jesus calling him, why it's wrong and why it's unbiblical,
- 26:11is she's schooling that guy? Well, in a sense she is, but
- 26:15she's not holding a leadership position there in the church. She's not a pastor.
- 26:18So she's doing something that she is fine to do. Authority over yeah,
- 26:26And Priscilla did not have any authority. No over Apaula, No,
- 26:30no, not at all. And speaking of Priscilla, our next clip is
- 26:34doctor Rictor talking about Priscilla. He says, great Prisca, which is short
- 26:40for Priscilla and Aquila. My fellow workers in Christ, Jesus, fellow workers,
- 26:47fellow yoke bearers. These two apparently have shared Paul's tasks. They have
- 26:52done what Paul does with him. And Priscilla is the female member of this
- 27:00couple. We go on and read who for my life risked their own necks
- 27:04to whom not only do I give thanks, but also all the churches of
- 27:07the Gentiles, and also greet the church that is in their house. Oh,
- 27:11they're pastoring a church. Greet Epenetus, my beloved, who is the
- 27:17convert to Christ from Asia. Now, not only is Priscilla listed and listed
- 27:23as a fellow labor and as someone who's apparently pastoring a church. If we
- 27:26flip back to chapter eighteen of the Book of Acts, we read a little
- 27:32bit of the biography of Priscilla and Aquila and their ministry. And in Acts
- 27:38chapter eighteen, verse twenty six, we read about a man named Apollos,
- 27:42who, at least back when I was doing my undergraduate degree, was a
- 27:45major possibility for the author of the Book of Hebrews. And Apollos, although
- 27:51a good man, was apparently a little shortsighted in his theology and his biblical
- 27:56education. And so it will start it verse twenty four. Now, a
- 28:00certain man named Apollos, and Alexandrian by birth, an eloquent man, came
- 28:03to Ephesus, and he was mighty in the scriptures. This man had been
- 28:07instructed in the way of the Lord, and being fervent in spirit, he
- 28:11was speaking and teaching accurately the things concerning Jesus, being acquainted only with the
- 28:18baptism of John, and he began to speak out boldly in the synagogues.
- 28:22But when Priscilla and Aquila heard him, they took him aside and explained,
- 28:29exegted, narrated, taught him the way of God more accurately. So now
- 28:36Paul is busy greeting Priscilla, who was not only a fellow laborer, but
- 28:41she also specifically in the book is identified as someone who instructed a man,
- 28:47an educated man, in the scriptures, and taught him how to preach more
- 28:52accurately. Now that enough gives me pause. But then I've noticed the order
- 28:56of the names, all right. She says that because the church met in
- 29:00Aquila and Priscilla's home, that that meant that Priscilla was the one of the
- 29:07pastors that her and both Aquilla pastored together. Did get a kick out of
- 29:11that, how she jumped from greeting them and their their church at their house
- 29:17too. Oh, they're pastoring a church that's that's a hugely elite. I'm
- 29:22telling you so. And there's nothing, nothing in scripture other than what Paul
- 29:27says there in Roman's chapter sixteen, greet the greet the church that meets in
- 29:33their house. So so you found something in a commentary about the church churches
- 29:40that met in homes. Yes, this is from Michael Middendorff's Romans commentary from
- 29:45the Concordia Commentary series. Okay, and he states finally, Paul references the
- 29:49congregation which meets in their home as an emphasis. Prisca and Aquilla hosted a
- 29:56congregation of believers in Rome. The fact that they could have ford such a
- 30:00sizeable residence corroborates the presumption that they had financial means. It further illustrates the
- 30:07often overlooked point that there were no buildings specifically appropriated to church purposes at this
- 30:15time. Instead, Meets points out the local church structure of the early church
- 30:21groups was linked with what was commonly regarded as the basic unit of society,
- 30:27the home. If there were no church buildings now, and Danny and I
- 30:33had a church in our home, it would be quite a leap to say
- 30:37I was co pastoring that church. Just because a church met in our home.
- 30:41Yeah, just because a church meets in a home and the scriptures mentioned,
- 30:45that does not mean that the person who is hosting the church in their
- 30:51home is a pastor. I mean again, that's just a huge jump,
- 30:55right. One other thing Richter mentions in this clip is right at the end,
- 31:00she says, well, let's look at the order of the names now.
- 31:03I think on Priscilla and Aquila are mentioned six times in the New Testament,
- 31:07and four of those times, Priscilla's name comes first. She makes the
- 31:15argument that Priscilla's name came first because number one, she was more important in
- 31:22the church. Number two, that she probably was a better speaker, and
- 31:27that she was more widely wanted on whatever speaking circuit there was in the church
- 31:37at that time. Yeah, that's again, that's just making assumptions that aren't
- 31:42you know that that aren't there. One of the big reasons her name could
- 31:48have been first was that she had a higher social stature than Aquilla. And
- 31:52that's one main reason that a woman's name would be put first. But we
- 31:57don't know so exactly. We have one more Richter clip before we move on
- 32:05to other arguments. And in this one she's talking about Ephesians. For let
- 32:09me say another way, don't allow the kingdom to be hindered by failing to
- 32:15use your gift. And what about Ephesians. For there is one body in
- 32:19one spirit, same emphasis, Paul, Just as also you were called in
- 32:22one hope of your calling, one Lord, one baptism, one God and
- 32:27Father who's overall, through all and in all. Paul's got a point.
- 32:30But to each one of us grace was given according to the measure of Christ's
- 32:35gift. And he gave some as apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors,
- 32:42teachers, for what purpose the equipping of the saints, for the work of
- 32:45service, to the building up of the body of Christ, until we all
- 32:50attain to the unity of the faith and the knowledge of the Son of God
- 32:53to a mature man, to the measure of the stature which belongs to the
- 32:58fullness of Christ. Your gifting, my gifting, is a matter of God's
- 33:06administration, his management of his body. He has entrusted gifts to each one
- 33:13of us so that we can serve each other and serve the church. He's
- 33:16done the choosing. Your job is to do the faithful serving in order that
- 33:22the kingdom may be built. So with those normative texts in mine, it
- 33:30would seem that if God has chosen to gift a woman with the gift of
- 33:37preaching, it is my job to support her in that gifting. I don't
- 33:42have the authority to give her a different gift or to call her gift into
- 33:49question, not by those texts that we've just reviewed. Rather, my task
- 33:53would be to support her in that gifting and to facilitate that gifting. That's
- 34:00what I would see. So she has kind of the same argument there,
- 34:05Robin, that Melissa Scott had in her argument in our first video. God
- 34:12is sovereign. This is if I remember correctly what Melissa Scott said. God
- 34:16is sovereign. He chose me. Therefore, if you have a problem,
- 34:20take it up with God. It's it. So it's your job to support
- 34:25these women who say God has called them to be pastors. And of course
- 34:30one issue with her argument is, of course God is sovereign and he does
- 34:35the choosing, but he's he going to choose against what he's written in the
- 34:39scripts. He's not. But see their argument is you can't use those very
- 34:45clear passages of scripture that say a women are not women isn't to teach because
- 34:51that's not what Paul meant. He meant something else. He meant something else,
- 34:54and that is just they have to do. It's so much easier to
- 35:00look at plain text like this and let them speak for themselves rather than trying
- 35:06to jump through hoops to make the text fit your own theology. And if
- 35:12you are a woman who wants to be a pastor, but you want to
- 35:15obey God, you know, swallow that pill. It's not easy sometimes obeying
- 35:22what God is telling us in scripture, but it is always much more spiritually
- 35:27fulfilling obeying him rather than trying to find a way around it and coming up
- 35:34with your own interpretation of these scriptures. Right, we're moving on to a
- 35:38man named Matt O'Reilly who has a video called Theology Project, and in this
- 35:45one he talks about theology teachers. You might imagine Adam saying something like this
- 35:49to Eve. You know what, Eve, God said, don't eat that
- 35:52fruit, you know what, don't even touch it, or else will dot
- 35:57And so you can see Adam adding to God's commandment by adding to the word
- 36:02of God, did not faithfully execute his responsibility to teach and instruct. Therefore,
- 36:08Eve was in a position to be more easily deceived. That makes great
- 36:14sense in the context of First Timothy chapter two, eleven through fifteen, where
- 36:20we are dealing with the question of learning and proper instruction before you become a
- 36:28teacher. If you don't get the proper instruction, you are more liable to
- 36:32deception. If you aren't properly taught, then you are not ready to teach.
- 36:39It was true for Adam, it was true for Eve. It's true
- 36:45in First Timothy with the women who are learning and not get ready to teach.
- 36:49And it's true in First Timothy chapter three, chapter one, verses three
- 36:52through seven, where Paul says, the big thing I'm trying to deal with
- 36:55here is making sure people are prepped properly before we let them go teach.
- 37:01So in First Timothy, a coherent reading of this text that takes into account
- 37:07Paul's use of genesis, the situation as he describes it in First Timothy,
- 37:12and the language the specific language, the negative language for authority that he uses.
- 37:16Paul is not forbidding women from having authority when it is properly exercised.
- 37:24He's not forbidding women from having authority in teaching in every instance, all the
- 37:30time he's saying women should not become teachers until they have properly been trained.
- 37:38I think we can see the sense in that, whether it's men or women.
- 37:44A couple of things Danny that he comments out, So Adam in telling
- 37:50Eve, God said don't eat the fruit, and then he says, Adam
- 37:54must have told her also, don't touch it, because that's what she tells
- 37:59the serpent. And Adam was an error because he gave her more than God
- 38:04had told him, and that made her more vulnerable when what he told her
- 38:09would have made her more cautious. If you're not supposed to eat the fruit
- 38:15and don't even pick it up, don't touch it, you know, be
- 38:19like mom saying don't even look at it, get away from it, that
- 38:22should have made her more cautious, not more vulnerable. So I don't think
- 38:27she fell because of Adam's poor teaching. And just you know, like I
- 38:34said, it is a huge stretch. It's like looking at a clear passage,
- 38:43something that is so clear and just saying to yourself, well, it
- 38:46can't mean that. There's no way. So we have to come up with
- 38:52something outside of what the Bible says to try to connect this with the ability
- 39:00to have women leaders and women pastors in the church. So we did read
- 39:05the passage in First Timothy that he's talking about that he says, it really
- 39:08means that women just need to be taught before they teach men. And I
- 39:12just wanted to read a couple of those verses over again. Yes, starting
- 39:16verse eleven and twelve, let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. I
- 39:22do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man.
- 39:25Rather is she is to remain quiet. Now, how easy would it have
- 39:30been for Paul to add a phrase right there that said until she is trained
- 39:37properly. And like Danny you pointed out, right after that passage about women,
- 39:43Paul starts talking about the qualifications of an overseer and the main qualifications.
- 39:50One of the first ones is to be the husband of one wife. And
- 39:53if he really intended on women being overseers in the church, that would have
- 40:00come through very clearly in one of the passages where he talks about overseers.
- 40:05All is clear. There's just not much more you can say about it.
- 40:09Matt O'Reilly goes on to talk it now a little bit more about women preachers.
- 40:15Does the Bible forbid women from preaching or teaching or holding pastoral offices?
- 40:22We have to answer that it is wildly irresponsible to say that the Bible clearly
- 40:29forbids women from having pastoral, preaching or teaching responsibilities. There are a multitude
- 40:36of questions that come before us when we look carefully at the texts of scripture
- 40:42in question in context. At the very least, the text doesn't clearly forbid
- 40:49women from speaking or teaching in every instance, and it likely, as best
- 40:54we can tell, only forbids women from speaking and teaching when they haven't yet
- 41:00been properly trained. Once a woman has been trained and prepared to lead the
- 41:07church in a teaching role, by all means, that's an appropriate thing.
- 41:12He says, it's wildly irresponsible to say the Bible forbids women from having preaching
- 41:19or teaching responsibilities. I would say it's widely irresponsible to take clear biblical texts
- 41:28and make them say something that they don't say by stretching and trying to find
- 41:36something that you can use in order to build your own interpretation. Just very
- 41:44dangerous. So he's the one that is actually being wildly irresponsible there right,
- 41:49And did you want to share that verse in Titus Yes, I do about
- 41:53women teaching, and how many opportunities and rules we do have Titus two three
- 42:00through five. Older women likewise are to be reverent and behavior, not slanders
- 42:05or slaves too much wine. There to teach what is good, and so
- 42:08train the young women to love their husbands and children, to be self controlled,
- 42:13pure, working at home, kind, and submissive to their own husbands,
- 42:16that the word of God may not be reviled. So let me ask
- 42:21a question, Robin. In that passage right there, does Paul call women
- 42:25teachers? Yes, he does, and teach what is good? They teach
- 42:30what is good. They're teaching the younger women. So there is not that
- 42:36this is a false argument to make. That another false argument, another false
- 42:42argument to make that women cannot be teachers in the church. We are not
- 42:45saying, and Paul is not saying, and none of the authors of Scripture
- 42:50are saying that women cannot be teachers in the church. They can, They
- 42:54can't teach men. The older women are to teach the younger women. The
- 43:00younger women are to teach their children. And it goes on and on.
- 43:05We're going to get back to Rick Warren now, who had his three scriptures
- 43:08that he claims changed his mind, And we're going to Acts two. Mine
- 43:15was the day of Pentecost. Two things. The second thing that changed my
- 43:23mind was the day of Pentecost. Two things happen on that day. We
- 43:28know the first day of the church. The church is its birth as the
- 43:32church at its best on that day at Pentecost. We know women were in
- 43:37the upper room. We know women were filled with the Holy Spirit. We
- 43:43know that women were preaching in languages that other people couldn't hear, to a
- 43:49mixed audience. We know women. It wasn't just men. Women were preaching
- 43:53on the day of Pentecost. How do we know that? Because Peter felt
- 43:58obligated to explain it, and so in Acts Chapter two, Versus seventeen and
- 44:06eighteen, he goes, hey, guys, these people aren't drunk. What
- 44:09you're seeing was foretold by Joel. It was going to happen, and he
- 44:15said, so he explains why you're now seeing women preaching on the very first
- 44:22day of the church. He explains it, and he says, this is
- 44:24that that Joel predicted and here's what he says, in the last days,
- 44:30and clearly that means Peter thought the last days began with the birth of the
- 44:36church. We're in the latter of the last days now. We don't know
- 44:38how many more there will be, but the last days began with the birth
- 44:43of church. Peter says, in the last days, I will pour out
- 44:46my spirit on all flesh, all flesh, your sons and daughters will prophesy.
- 44:53That's different than the Old Testament. Russell. I've looked at over three
- 44:58hundred commentaries on those verses, and it's interesting to me that almost thereby goes
- 45:01yep in the In the church, everybody gets to play, everybody gets to
- 45:06preach, everybody gets to prophesy. And the people who don't like that ignore
- 45:12that verse. John MacArthur doesn't even cover that verse. He just skips over
- 45:16lots and lots and lots of stuff to talk about in that clip. First
- 45:21of all, Robin, it is not clear, and we're going to look
- 45:24at this passage of scripture that Rick Warren mentions in Acts chapter two, it
- 45:31is not clear that women were speaking in tongues and that women were doing uh.
- 45:38First of all, he called it preaching. It wouldn't have been preaching
- 45:42because the church wasn't even formed yet. I mean there had been no there's
- 45:45no structure. They were still using the synagogue model. There was no it
- 45:49was just the very beginning here. But secondly, there's just no it's not
- 45:54clear whether there were women that were speaking in tongues. It's could have just
- 46:00been the apostles themselves. It could have been and I think, like Judish
- 46:06says that it was probably just the apostles. But you can read it either
- 46:08way. I think the point is it is not it is not clear right,
- 46:14and really quickly before we get into the passage. At the end of
- 46:17that clip, he says John MacArthur does not approach these verses at all.
- 46:22If you go on YouTube and type in Rick Warren says something about John MacArthur.
- 46:29I know, Polite Leader has done a video refuting Warren's comments and doing
- 46:34exactly what John MacArthur says about this passage. Yeah. I've never been ever
- 46:42thought that John MacArthur would be one to ignore any biblical ten No, nope,
- 46:47nope. Let's look at the passage. Okay, so we're going to
- 46:51read acts too, starting in verse one, when the day of Pentecost arrived.
- 46:54They were all together in one place, and suddenly there came from heaven
- 46:59a sound like a mighty rushing wind, and it filled the entire house where
- 47:02they were sitting, and divided tongues as a fire appeared to them and rested
- 47:07on each one of them. And they were all filled with the Holy Spirit
- 47:10and began to speak in other tongues as the Spirit gave them utterance. Now
- 47:15they were dwelling in Jerusalem, Jews, devout men from every nation under heaven.
- 47:21And at this sound, the multitude came together, and they were bewildered
- 47:24because each one was hearing them speak in his own language. And they were
- 47:29amazed and astonished, saying, are not all these who are speaking Galileans?
- 47:34And how is it that we hear each one of us in his own native
- 47:37language. Parthians and Medes and Elamites, and residents of Mesopotamia, Judea and
- 47:43Cappadocia, Pontius and Asia, Rhigea and Pamphila, Egypt and parts of Libya
- 47:49belonging to Cyrene, and visitors from Rome, both jew Jews and proselytes,
- 47:54Cretans and Arabians, we hear them, telling in our own tongues the mighty
- 47:59works of God. And all were amazed and perplexed, saying to one another,
- 48:05what does this mean? But others mocking, said, they're filled with
- 48:07new wine. But Peter, standing with the eleven, lifted up his voice
- 48:13and addressed them, men of Judea and all who dwell in Jerusalem, let
- 48:17this be known to you, and give ear to my words. For these
- 48:21people are not drunk, as you suppose, since it is only the third
- 48:24hour of the day. But this is what was uttered through the prophet Joel.
- 48:30And in the last days it shall be. God declares that I will
- 48:32pour out my spirit on all flesh, and your sons and your daughters shall
- 48:37prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall
- 48:42dream dreams. Even on my male servants and female servants. In those days,
- 48:46I will pour out my spirit, and they shall prophesy, and I
- 48:51will show wonders in the heavens above, and signs on the earth below,
- 48:54blood and fire and vapor of smoke. The sun shall be turned to dark
- 49:00and the moon to blood. Before the day of the Lord comes, the
- 49:02great and magnificent day, and it shall come to pass that everyone who calls
- 49:07upon the name of the Lord shall be saved. All right, very long
- 49:12passage to read, But there's a couple of things that we need to point
- 49:15out here. Again, we are not saying that women were not speaking in
- 49:19tongues there, but when you look closely at Acts chapter two, it's very
- 49:23possible that they weren't, especially if you look at verse seven and they were
- 49:30amazed and astonished. Thing, are not all these who were speaking Galileans?
- 49:36Who are the Galileans? Well, that was the Apostles. Now it's possible
- 49:40that women were there, and women were Galileans as well, But when you
- 49:45think of the Galileans, you're really especially thinking of the Disciples of Christ.
- 49:52And would they not have mentioned that that? That was also very strange.
- 49:57Not only are there Galileans speaking, but a bunch of women women doing this?
- 50:01Yeah? Yeah, And then you pointed something out or earlier as we
- 50:06were going over this, Robin verse fourteen. So after he taught me this,
- 50:10she taught me them. She schooled me verse fourteen. After the speaking
- 50:17in tongues and they were commenting on it, Peter Or, standing with the
- 50:22eleven, lifted up his voice and addressed them. So where did the women
- 50:28go, and why at this point if women were being given the authority to
- 50:32preach at that point, why weren't some of the women standing with Peter exactly?
- 50:38And to call this, even even if the women were there speaking in
- 50:43tongues, to call this preaching and to say this passage changed my mind about
- 50:50women pastors and leaders doesn't make any sense either, because the church hadn't even
- 50:54this is the birth of the church. There was no structure formed or anything
- 51:00yet before that, the God Fears, the Gentiles and the Jews, they
- 51:05were all meeting in synagogues, and in the very beginning of Acts, that's
- 51:08where the apostle. The apostles went to teach and preach their message of Christ
- 51:15resurrection, were the synagogues. So this was not there was a structure in
- 51:21the church at this time. And Rick Warren points out the prophecy of Joel
- 51:27that your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and so he's saying, yes,
- 51:31all can prophesy. Well, is prophesying the same as being an overseer
- 51:37or a leader? No, And we do know that Philip's daughters and Acts
- 51:42his daughters were prophets or prophetesses or whatever you want to call them, but
- 51:45they were not leaders in the church because when Paul set the order up,
- 51:53he made sure that the structure was the way it was, that the men
- 52:00were the head, the men were of the leaders. And I think we've
- 52:01talked about this in the other video, Robin, that you can also go
- 52:07back to the Old Testament. A lot of people like to bring up Debra
- 52:10and like to bring up Miriam and others who prophesied. That's fine, But
- 52:16if you look at the temple structure or the tabernacle when the children of Israel
- 52:23were in the wandering in the desert, or when they first took over in
- 52:28it, before the temple was built, and even at the temple there were
- 52:31no women priests. Those who were leading the children of Israel were men in
- 52:38the worship structure of Israel. Yes, so I think this is a really
- 52:45interesting passage that Rick Warrens was to use as interesting as a good word.
- 52:52Yes, okay. Rick Warren's third scripture, jerrem role please third scripture for
- 52:59why he believes women can be pastors. And then the third thing that changed
- 53:02my mind. See, none of us had to do with culture, had
- 53:06to do with Scripture. And then all of a sudden, I noticed that
- 53:09the very first sermon, the very first Christian sermon, the message of the
- 53:16Gospel of good News of the Resurrection, Jesus chose a woman to deliver it
- 53:22to men. He had Mary Magdalene go and tell the disciples. Now that
- 53:30clearly wasn't an accident. It was unintentional. It's a whole new world baby.
- 53:36Now he has a woman, go tell the apostles. You got kind
- 53:40of woman teach an apostle evidently did it on the first day. He chose
- 53:45her to be the first preacher of the gospel. So you would, after
- 53:50the last three years, you would support men and women as elders, a
- 53:57senior pastor, as everything within the church. I would, I would,
- 54:02I would. But here's what I say, because I have to say this
- 54:07is my interpretation. I have to stay with humility. It doesn't bother me
- 54:12if you disagree with me. For two thousand years the church has debated the
- 54:17role of women in culture. But to make it a litmus test for are
- 54:22you a Baptist or not? Is nonsense. Okay, Robin. He calls
- 54:29the good news that Jesus has risen from the dead a Christian sermon, the
- 54:35first Christian sermon. So, if you're a lady and you're sitting at work
- 54:39and you're sharing the Gospel with someone, is that a sermon because you're sharing
- 54:47good news and that's what he's trying to do. He's trying to he's trying
- 54:52to which I just don't understand. Take this passage that you're getting ready to
- 54:59read and make this about women preachers. Doesn't make any sense. John twenty
- 55:05seventeen. Starting in verse seventeen, Jesus said to her, do not cling
- 55:08to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father. But go
- 55:13to my brothers and say to them, I am ascending to my Father and
- 55:15your father, to my God and your God. Mary Magdalene went and announced
- 55:21to the disciples, I have seen the Lord, and that he had said
- 55:24these things to her. Okay, there you go. First Christian sermon.
- 55:30That's a female pastor. Yeah, well yeah, first female pastor, first
- 55:34Christian sermon. She's announcing to the apostles that she saw the Lord. That's
- 55:40not her preaching a sermon. And that's not in a church setting, because
- 55:44again, the church had not even like the Holy Spirit hadn't even fallen yet
- 55:52Pentecost had not even happened yet, the church was not birthed yet. This
- 55:58is pre cost so there's just no way. And what passage did you say?
- 56:04If you were picking a passage to use for a woman, it was
- 56:07the woman at the Yes, I would have used probably if I was rick
- 56:10warm, I might have used John chapter four and the woman at the Well
- 56:15because she went to the city after Jesus, after she realized Christ was the
- 56:20Messiah, and she went into Samaria and grabbed all the guys that come with
- 56:23me and see who see, you know, I found the Messiah. That
- 56:27I would have probably gone there, I mean, because he's doing that's pre
- 56:32church as well, and he's doing the same thing with the resurrection. So
- 56:36it just doesn't I don't know. Yeah, another very weak reason for believing
- 56:42that women should be pastors and Danny, when you look at how Jesus treated
- 56:47women in general, it was so far removed from how they were treated in
- 56:53society. Even that example you used of the woman at the well, Yep,
- 56:58what did the disciples come back? And they said in verse twenty seven.
- 57:01I believe it was yes, just then his disciples came back. They
- 57:05marveled that he was talking with a woman. He taught women, women sat
- 57:10at his feet and were taught they were considered to be part of his larger
- 57:15disciple group. Yes, absolutely so, folks. These are just some examples
- 57:24of what you're gonna hear when people are trying to promote women pastors and women
- 57:31teachers within the church. And again, we don't have a problem with women
- 57:34teachers. The Bible doesn't have a problem with women teachers. It just directs
- 57:37women to teach other women. And so I hope this video has been helpful.
- 57:43I hope that if you know someone who's struggling with this topic that this
- 57:49will be helpful to them as well. Thanks for watching, and Lord Willen
- 57:52will see you next week. Four and the name