Latest / Culture Room: Books, film, music & culture / Listening to the Deep: Whales, Silence, and Our Noisy Lives | Culture Room
Transcript
- Imagine a sound so vast it could swallow your entire day whole, yet no one in the room even noticed it happened. I want you to close your eyes for just a second and try to hold that silence. Let’s sit with that for a moment. We spend so much of our lives curating noise. We fill our commutes with podcasts that demand our attention, we scroll through feeds that scream for our outrage, and we surround ourselves with background music because the quiet feels too heavy, too exposing. But there is a different kind of listening happening right now, miles beneath the surface of our oceans, where the air is thin and the pressure is immense. Researchers have been recording ambient noise from inside migrating whale pods, and what they found wasn’t just data. It was a revelation about how we connect, how we move through the world, and perhaps, how we’ve forgotten how to simply be together without trying to fix everything. When you hear these recordings, the first thing that strikes you isn’t the song. It’s the texture. The clicks, the whistles, the low-frequency hums that travel for hundreds of miles through water. These aren’t isolated notes played by soloists on a stage. They are woven together, overlapping, supporting one another in a complex web of communication. It’s not just about the plot of their migration, is it? It’s about the infrastructure of their care. If one voice falters, others step in. If one path becomes unclear, the group adjusts as a single, breathing entity. There is no ego in that chorus. There is only function, beauty, and survival. I’ve been thinking a lot about this lately because my own life has felt incredibly fragmented. You know that feeling when you’re physically alone but mentally surrounded by a hundred different conversations? I feel like we’ve built a culture that glorifies the solitary genius, the lone wolf, the individual who conquers the mountain by themselves. But watching the whales, or rather, listening to them, makes me question that narrative entirely. Even in their vastness, they are never truly alone. The pod moves as one. The calf stays close to the mother not just for protection, but for learning. The elders guide the young not out of obligation, but out of a deep, ancestral knowledge passed down through sound. It makes me wonder why we treat human connection as optional or secondary to our personal goals. We celebrate independence above all else, yet independence without interdependence is just isolation dressed up as strength. When I listen to the whale songs, I don’t hear individuals shouting over each other to be heard. I hear a conversation. I hear a rhythm. And it’s gentle. It doesn’t demand you run faster or work harder. It asks you to tune in. To notice the frequency of the person next to you. To recognize that your voice is part of a larger harmony, not a competition against it. Tell me more about how that landed. Does your daily routine feel like a solo performance or a duet? There is a scientific term called ‘vocal learning,’ which allows whales to adapt their songs over time, passing new phrases down through generations. It’s cultural evolution, but it happens at the speed of trust. You can’t rush a song into existence if no one is listening closely enough to catch the nuance. In our digital age, we have lost the patience for slow transmission. We want the highlight reel, the summary, the takeaways. We skim articles instead of reading them. We send emojis instead of letters. We assume that because we can transmit information instantly, we are communicating effectively. But communication requires reception. It requires someone on the other end who is willing to slow down enough to receive the signal. The whales understand this intuitively. Their songs can last for hours, sometimes days. They repeat patterns. They vary them slightly. They invite response. This isn’t inefficient; it’s intentional. It’s the opposite of the frantic energy we bring to our relationships. We often approach our friends, our partners, our colleagues with a checklist mindset. What do we need to discuss? What needs to be resolved? How quickly can we move to the next item? But real connection, the kind that sustains us through long migrations of grief or joy, requires repetition. It requires hearing the same story twice to understand the fear behind it. It requires sitting in the discomfort of silence until the truth bubbles up on its own. One of the most troubling findings in oceanography is how human-made noise interferes with these ancient communications. Ship engines, sonar, construction—all of it creates a blanket of static that drowns out the subtle frequencies whales rely on. It’s a metaphor I can’t stop turning over in my head. We are drowning each other in noise. Not just physical noise, but emotional noise. The constant updates, the notifications, the curated images of perfect lives, the opinions we share before we’ve even formed our own thoughts. It’s a cacophony that makes it hard to hear the distinct voice of another human being standing right in front of you. When researchers recorded the whales, they had to use specialized equipment to filter out the background hiss of the ocean itself. They had to learn to distinguish between the wind, the currents, and the call of a friend. We need to do the same with our inner lives. We need to learn how to filter out the external demands so we can hear our own intuition. And once we can hear ourselves, we can begin to hear others. This isn’t about building walls or withdrawing from the world. It’s about creating pockets of clarity. Small spaces where the signal is strong and the noise is low. Where we can say what we mean without worrying if anyone is actually listening. Where we can let our voices ripple out and trust that they will find their way back to us. I remember a conversation I had years ago, back when I was still editing books, with an author who was terrified her work wouldn’t matter. She said, ‘If no one reads it, did I really write it?’ And I told her then, and I’ll tell you now, that writing is an act of faith, but speaking is an act of courage. The whales sing not because they know everyone will hear them, but because singing is who they are. It is their way of existing in the world. To withhold your voice, to mute yourself to avoid conflict or judgment, is to deny a fundamental part of your nature. You were designed to resonate. To vibrate with the people around you. But resonance requires vulnerability. You have to be open to being affected by others. You have to allow their songs to change yours. This is terrifying in a world that prizes invulnerability. We build armor. We develop thick skins. But armor keeps the music out. It also keeps the warmth out. When we lower our defenses, when we admit we are confused, or scared, or happy, or tired, we create space for others to do the same. We become part of the pod again. We remember that we are not floating adrift in a cold void. We are surrounded by voices, waiting for us to join the chorus. Let’s sit with that for a moment. Who are you singing for today? And who is singing for you? So, what do we do with this knowledge? How do we carry the image of the whale pod into our busy, noisy, chaotic Tuesday mornings? I think it starts with small acts of rebellion against the noise. It means putting the phone face down during dinner. It means asking a question and actually waiting for the answer, even if it takes longer than you’d like. It means noticing the quiet details others miss in art and life. Maybe it’s the way your partner sighs when they walk through the door, not because they’re angry, but because they’re releasing the weight of the day. Maybe it’s the specific tone of a friend’s laugh that tells you everything you need to know about their mood. We can choose to listen deeply. We can choose to be the ones who filter out the static. It’s a radical act in a culture that rewards distraction. But it’s also the most natural thing in the world. We are social creatures. We are wired for connection. The whales remind us that connection isn’t about volume. It’s about frequency. It’s about finding the right wavelength and staying there. So tonight, before you sleep, try to turn off the noise. Turn off the screen. Listen to the house settle. Listen to your own breath. And imagine you are drifting in deep water, surrounded by friends, safe in the knowledge that you are heard. That you belong. That you are part of something vast and beautiful and enduring. Thank you for listening, for sharing this space, and for being such a wonderful part of my own podcasting pod. Until next time, keep listening closely. I’m Karyn Gillen, and I’ll see you in the next episode.