Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why High Dividends Are a Mathematical Trap
Transcript
- 0:00You know, there is this like very specific, almost
- 0:03intoxicating feeling you get when you're just scrolling
- 0:06through a stock Screener late at night.
- 0:08Oh yeah, I know that feeling. Right.
- 0:10And you stumble across a company offering, I don't know, an A10
- 0:14or maybe even a 12% dividend yield.
- 0:16Yeah, it feels like you have just found a literal cheat code
- 0:20for the financial matrix. It really does.
- 0:22It genuinely triggers this immediate sense of relief in
- 0:25your brain. You know, you see that high
- 0:27number and it feels like you've suddenly found a safe harbor in
- 0:31this totally chaotic market. Yeah.
- 0:33And I mean, it's really hard not to fall for it.
- 0:35You look at a Standard Bank deposit and maybe you're getting
- 0:38a couple of percent if you're lucky.
- 0:39Exactly. And then you see the stock
- 0:41offering 10% year in, year out. It feels like a totally
- 0:45foolproof steady income stream. The psychological framing is
- 0:49basically that the market is just handing you free money just
- 0:52for showing up. Right.
- 0:53But as we are exploring today, that warm fuzzy feeling might
- 0:57actually just be the bait in a very, very sophisticated trap.
- 1:01So welcome to the deep dive. Yes, welcome.
- 1:04Today we are taking a hard look at a concept that has burned
- 1:07incredibly smart investors time and time again.
- 1:10We're drawing on this fascinating breakdown by a
- 1:12financial creator named Ammu, who calls this phenomenon the
- 1:16sweet trap of high dividend and investing.
- 1:18The sweet trap. I love that phrase.
- 1:21It's perfect, right? So our mission today is to
- 1:25basically systematically dismantle and reframe how you
- 1:28look at stock market returns because chasing that high
- 1:31dividend rate without looking under the hood isn't just some
- 1:34suboptimal strategy. No, much worse.
- 1:37It is a mathematical mechanism that can actively erode your
- 1:40wealth over time. I mean, I will be the absolute
- 1:43first to admit I am definitely the target audience for this
- 1:46trap. I see a high yield and my brain
- 1:49instantly translates that to like safety gas of income, right
- 1:52A. 100% the dream. Right.
- 1:54I imagine waking up, opening my brokerage app, and just seeing
- 1:57$5000 of fresh cash sitting there from a quarterly payout
- 2:02meet. It feels like pure profit.
- 2:03It feels exactly like getting an end of your bonus from my boss
- 2:07at work. If I did nothing to earn it
- 2:09other than just hold the stock, why shouldn't I treat it like a
- 2:13bonus? Well because a publicly traded
- 2:15company is a not your employer and they definitely aren't
- 2:21handing you extra cash from some secret separate vault they have
- 2:24Outback. OK, so let's unpack this then.
- 2:26What is actually happening? To understand the mechanics of
- 2:30what's going down in your brokerage account, we really
- 2:32need to look at Amuse Pizza analogy, OK?
- 2:34I am always here for a food analogy.
- 2:36Right, so I want you to imagine the company you've invested in,
- 2:38the total enterprise value, is a giant fully baked pizza.
- 2:42OK. So my initial say $10,000
- 2:45investment is essentially buying me a certain number of slices of
- 2:48that whole pie. Correct.
- 2:50Now, when that company pays a dividend, they are not baking a
- 2:53free extra side dish that magically appears next to your
- 2:56pizza. They aren't, you know, handing
- 2:58you garlic knots on the House. Man, I wish they were.
- 3:00We all do. But no, that dividend is a slice
- 3:03cut directly out of your existing pizza.
- 3:06They put it onto a different plate and they hand it right
- 3:08back to you. Wait, meaning the original
- 3:10pizza, like my underlying investment, physically shrinks
- 3:14by the exact size of the slice they just handed me?
- 3:16It has to. And this isn't just like a cute
- 3:19metaphor, it is a literal mechanism hard coded into the
- 3:23Stock Exchange. Wait, really?
- 3:25How does that work? It's called the ex dividend
- 3:27adjustment. So on the day a stock goes ex
- 3:30dividend. It means it begins trading
- 3:31without the value of its next dividend payment attached to it,
- 3:34right? Exactly on that morning, the
- 3:37Stock Exchange actually adjust the opening price of the stock
- 3:40downward by the exact mathematical amount of the
- 3:43dividend. So OK, let me get this straight.
- 3:45If a stock closes at $100 on Tuesday and it's set to pay a $5
- 3:50dividend, the exchange will forcibly open the stock at $95
- 3:54on on Wednesday morning. They mandate it, Yeah.
- 3:57If they didn't do that, the market would be completely
- 3:59broken. Just think about it.
- 4:00If the price didn't drop, algorithmic traders would just
- 4:03buy millions of shares at 3.59 PM on Tuesday.
- 4:07Collect the $5 dividend overnight.
- 4:09And then sell at 9:30 AM on Wednesday for a massive,
- 4:13completely risk free profit. Yeah, the market doesn't allow
- 4:17free lunches. Never.
- 4:19The exchange mechanically drops the price to prevent that exact
- 4:23arbitrage. That makes total sense when you
- 4:25actually walk through the mechanics of it.
- 4:27So for you listening right now, I want you to visualize your
- 4:31portfolio. Think about the last time you
- 4:34got a big dividend payout. Yeah.
- 4:36Think about that. Feeling You saw the cash balance
- 4:38go up and you felt that little dopamine thrill, right?
- 4:42But if you look really closely at the total net worth of your
- 4:45account in that exact millisecond, it hasn't increased
- 4:48by a single penny. Not one cent.
- 4:50The value has simply shifted from column A, your stock
- 4:54holdings, over to column B, your cash.
- 4:56The absolute total value of your assets remains identical minus
- 5:00whatever normal market fluctuations happened that day,
- 5:03of course, but it's an illusion of new wealth.
- 5:06You are simply holding the exact same amount of value in a
- 5:09different state of matter. A different state of matter.
- 5:11I like that. Yeah, it's like yesterday you
- 5:13had a block of ice and today you have a little less ice and a
- 5:15puddle of water. But wait, let me play devil's
- 5:18advocate here for a second, because I know exactly what the
- 5:20skeptical listeners thinking right now.
- 5:22Bring it on. Let's say I find a stock
- 5:24yielding 10% right? And I hold that stock for 10
- 5:27years. I've collected 100 of my initial
- 5:31investment in pure cash. OK.
- 5:34At that point, who cares if the stock price drops or even goes
- 5:37to zero? I'm laying with house money.
- 5:40I'll take the shrinking pizza if it means I get a guaranteed
- 5:43slice of cash every single quarter for a decade.
- 5:47Well see, that assumes the company can physically sustain a
- 5:5010% cash payout for a decade while its underlying business is
- 5:54actively declining. Right, which is a big
- 5:56assumption. Huge assumption.
- 5:58And that brings us to the math behind how a yield actually gets
- 6:01that high in the 1st place. You have to look at the dividend
- 6:04yield formula. It's just a simple fraction.
- 6:07The annual dividend divided by the stock.
- 6:08Price exactly. It has a numerator and a
- 6:11denominator. So if a company pays $1.00 a
- 6:13year in dividends and the stock price is $10, my yield is 10%.
- 6:18Yes, Now if you are scanning a stock Screener and you see a sky
- 6:23high yield, say 15 or 20%, it is almost never because of the
- 6:28company's underlying business is booming and they're just
- 6:31swimming in excess cash to share with you so.
- 6:34What is it? It is almost always because the
- 6:36denominator, the stock price, has plummeted.
- 6:39Oh, OK, so let's run that scenario.
- 6:41The company is paying a $1.00 dividend on a $10 stock, but
- 6:44then they have like a terrible earnings report.
- 6:47Right, bad news comes out. The market panics, institutional
- 6:51investors start fleeing, and the stock price gets cut in half to
- 6:54$5. And this is exactly where
- 6:56boardroom psychology kicks in. The executives are sitting there
- 7:00watching their stock crash, sweating profusely, and they
- 7:03know that if they cut that $1.00 dividend, the dividend focused
- 7:07mutual funds and ETFs which have super strict mandates will be
- 7:11mathematically forced to dump the stock.
- 7:13Which causes to crash even harder.
- 7:15Exactly. So they stubbornly decide to
- 7:17maintain the $1.00 payout. Which means the math
- 7:20automatically updates $1.00 divided by a new stock price of
- 7:24$5, the yield just artificially doubled to 20% without the
- 7:29company actually becoming any more profitable.
- 7:31In fact, it became less profitable, but to a novice
- 7:34investor casually looking at a Screener.
- 7:36That 20% yield looks like the absolute opportunity of a
- 7:39lifetime. Right.
- 7:40But in institutional finance, analysts view an abnormally high
- 7:44yield not as an opportunity, but as a death signal.
- 7:47A death signal? Wow.
- 7:49It's a massive red flashing light indicating the company is
- 7:52struggling so badly that the broader market has just totally
- 7:56abandoned its stock. I see the trap now, I really do.
- 7:59You buy it thinking you're locking in a 20% return, but you
- 8:04were actually just buying a sinking ship.
- 8:06And to go back to my 10 year house money argument.
- 8:08Yeah, let's revisit that they. Aren't going to be able to pay
- 8:10me that 20% for 10 years are they?
- 8:12They physically can't. When the underlying business is
- 8:15shrinking, that high dividend isn't being paid out of new
- 8:18recurring profits, it's being paid out of the company's
- 8:20savings. Oh, that's bad.
- 8:22They are literally draining their cash reserves to keep the
- 8:25yield up and delay a total stock collapse.
- 8:28And when the savings run dry, and they always do, they are
- 8:32forced to cut the dividend to 0, which.
- 8:34Triggers the exact mass sell off they were trying to avoid in the
- 8:37first place. Leading to what Ammu describes
- 8:40as the double whammy. Think about it.
- 8:42You bought a $10,000 position for a 10% yield.
- 8:46You get your $1000 in cash, but over the year, because the
- 8:50business is failing, the stock drops 20%.
- 8:54Ouch. So my $10,000 of stock is now
- 8:56only worth 8000 plus my thousand in cash.
- 9:00So my total net worth is $9000. I lost 20% of my principal just
- 9:05to get 10% in cash. My real return is -10%.
- 9:08No, we haven't even factored in the most guaranteed drag on this
- 9:11entire strategy. Oh, I know what you're going to
- 9:13say. Taxes.
- 9:14The silent killer of compounding wealth.
- 9:16This is where it goes from a bad strategy to actively punishing
- 9:20yourself, because in many countries dividends are treated
- 9:23as taxable income the moment they hit your account.
- 9:26The exact second. So the company cuts a slice of
- 9:29your own pizza, hands it back to you, and the government
- 9:32immediately steps in and takes a bite out of that slice.
- 9:35It creates a massive drag on your long term returns.
- 9:39You are triggering a taxable event on value you literally
- 9:42already owned. It's like taking out a home
- 9:45equity loan to pay yourself a monthly cash allowance, all
- 9:49while the foundation of your house is actively sinking.
- 9:52That is a great way to put it. You feel rich because you have
- 9:55cash in your pocket to spend, but your actual net worth is
- 9:58plummeting and on top of that the government is charging you
- 10:01an info tax on every allowance payment.
- 10:04That is the perfect encapsulation of the mechanism.
- 10:07You are paying for the privilege of liquidating your own
- 10:09shrinking assets. That's insane.
- 10:12But this brings up a crucial question about corporate
- 10:14behavior, right? If a company is dying.
- 10:17If the stock price is plummeting and cash reserves are dwindling.
- 10:20Why on earth are the executives taking their remaining cash and
- 10:24handing it out as taxable dividends?
- 10:26That's what I don't understand. If I am the CEO and my stock is
- 10:30down 20% because our products are losing to competitors, I
- 10:34wouldn't pay a dividend. What would you do?
- 10:36I would take every single cent of cash we have and pour it
- 10:39straight into research and development.
- 10:41I'd hire new engineers, pivot the business model, do whatever
- 10:45it takes to fix the core problem.
- 10:46Well, that assumes the company operates in an industry where a
- 10:49pivot is still actually possible.
- 10:52But our source material highlights that this high
- 10:55dividend behavior is extremely characteristic of what they call
- 10:58Sunset industries. Sunset industries?
- 11:01You mean like traditional declining sectors that are being
- 11:03totally aged out of the economy? Think of legacy print media, or
- 11:07obsolete forms of retail, or maybe traditional hardware
- 11:11manufacturing being eaten by software.
- 11:14The executives in these sunset industries aren't stupid.
- 11:17Do you see the writing on the wall?
- 11:18They look at the macroeconomic landscape and realize a very
- 11:21harsh truth. They have no high growth future
- 11:24to invest in. So if a legacy traditional
- 11:26hardware company took $500 million and tried to pivot into,
- 11:31I don't know, building AI chips, the executives know they would
- 11:34basically just be setting that money on fire.
- 11:36Yep. They can't compete with the
- 11:38entrenched tech giants. They're too far behind.
- 11:41Exactly. The probability of a successful
- 11:43turn around is near 0, so their fiduciary duty to their
- 11:48shareholders completely changes. It's no longer about growth.
- 11:51It is about managed decline. They stop funding R&D, they halt
- 11:55all expansion, They just take whatever cash the existing,
- 11:59slowly dying business is still managing to generate.
- 12:02And they systematically pay it all out to the shareholders.
- 12:05The source material calls this a suicide dividend or a
- 12:08liquidation dividend. It's.
- 12:09Suicide dividend? That sounds brutal.
- 12:11It is, but when you walk through the logic of a sunset industry,
- 12:15it isn't just corporate mismanagement, it is literally a
- 12:18slow motion liquidation of the company.
- 12:20They are returning the capital because the enterprise itself
- 12:23has absolutely no functional use for it anymore.
- 12:25Which fundamentally changes what you are buying when you invest
- 12:29in them. Right.
- 12:30And here's where it gets really interesting.
- 12:32When you buy into one of these sunset companies chasing that
- 12:35massive yield, you aren't actually buying a living,
- 12:39breathing company's assets. No, you're not.
- 12:41You aren't buying a stake in future innovation at all.
- 12:44You are buying a company's legacy.
- 12:47You're basically just picking the meat off the bones of a
- 12:50dying entity. You are an inheritor of a fading
- 12:52estate, not a partner in a growing enterprise.
- 12:56Man, that reframing is incredibly stark.
- 12:58Once the meat is picked clean, the dividends dry up, the stock
- 13:01goes to 0, and the trap snaps shut.
- 13:04It snaps shut hard. So, OK, if chasing these
- 13:07artificially high yields in sunset industries is a toxic
- 13:11trap, what is the alternative? How do the truly successful
- 13:15investors measure their wealth? They ignore the noise of the
- 13:18immediate cash payout entirely. They focus on the ultimate
- 13:21metric of investing. Which is total return.
- 13:23Total return. OK, so I assume total return
- 13:25means zooming out, right? Ignoring that quarterly dopamine
- 13:28hit of the cash hitting the account and tracking the actual
- 13:32long term trajectory of the stock price alongside any
- 13:34dividends that are paid. Exactly.
- 13:36It is the a complete holistic picture of how your purchasing
- 13:39power has grown. True wealth building isn't about
- 13:43how much cash a company throws at you today just to make you
- 13:46feel good. It is about how the overall
- 13:48value of your underlying investment compounds over a
- 13:52decade or two. And to understand this, we
- 13:54really just have to look at the math behind some of the greatest
- 13:57wealth creating companies in history.
- 14:00The source material points straight to Berkshire Hathaway
- 14:03and the early decades of Amazon for this.
- 14:05Perfect examples. If you look at Warren Buffett,
- 14:07who is widely considered the greatest investor of all time,
- 14:10his own company, Berkshire Hathaway pays 0 dividends, not a
- 14:14single cent. And it isn't because Buffett is
- 14:17just hoarding the cash in a mattress.
- 14:19It's because of the concept called reinvestment efficiency.
- 14:22Walk me through the mechanics of that.
- 14:23Why is 0 dividends actually better for the investor in that
- 14:26scenario? Let's run the math.
- 14:28If Berkshire Hathaway decides to pay you a $1.00 dividend, you
- 14:31immediately lose, say, $0.20 to taxes, right?
- 14:34Right, the government takes their bite.
- 14:36So you are left with $0.80. Now you have to take that $0.80,
- 14:39go out into the market yourself and try to find a new stock that
- 14:42gives you a solid return. Which requires my time, my
- 14:45research and obviously taking on new risk.
- 14:48Exactly. But Warren Buffett looks at that
- 14:51exact same dollar of profit and says, well, if I keep this
- 14:54dollar inside the company, it doesn't trigger a tax event for
- 14:58the shareholder. No taxes.
- 15:00Zero. And because I have access to
- 15:03private deals, whole company acquisitions and these massive
- 15:07economies of scale, I can take that fully untaxed dollar and
- 15:11earn a 15 or 20% return on it internally.
- 15:13He's basically saying leave your money in our pizza.
- 15:16We have the recipe to make the pizza 10 times larger much
- 15:19faster than you ever could on your own.
- 15:21Jeff Bezos did the exact same thing in the early days of
- 15:24Amazon. In his early shareholder
- 15:26letters, he had to constantly defend his zero dividend, 0
- 15:30profit strategy to a very, very skeptical Wall Street.
- 15:33Because the analysts just wanted the cash payouts.
- 15:35Right. They wanted the dopamine hit,
- 15:37but Bezos insisted that every single dollar the company
- 15:40generated needed to be poured aggressively back into building
- 15:43fulfillment centers, expanding AWS, and just capturing market
- 15:47share. He totally understood that
- 15:49giving cash back to investors was basically an admission that
- 15:52Amazon had run out of good ideas to invest in.
- 15:54Exactly. And by keeping the cash, they
- 15:57built an insurmountable Moat. And the total return really
- 16:01reflects that. I mean, the investors who held
- 16:02those stocks didn't get a quarterly cash payout to make
- 16:05them feel warm and fuzzy, but their net worth absolutely
- 16:09exploded because the underlying asset became a global
- 16:12juggernaut. They allowed their wealth to
- 16:14compound uninterrupted by the tax drag or those ex dividend
- 16:18price drops we talked about. So we really need to completely
- 16:22reprogram our stock screeners and our brains.
- 16:24We really do. The next time you're looking at
- 16:26your portfolio, where you read an article hyping up a stock
- 16:29with an 810 or 12% dividend yield, you need to stop and ask
- 16:33yourself 2 crucial questions before you hit by.
- 16:36First, you have to ask, is the company's underlying performance
- 16:38actually growing? Are they innovating?
- 16:41Capturing market share? Building for the future?
- 16:44Or is this a sunset industry slowly liquidating its legacy?
- 16:48Exactly. And the second question, is this
- 16:51dividend mathematically sustainable?
- 16:54Because if the yield is artificially high simply because
- 16:57the denominator, the stock price, is falling off a Cliff,
- 17:00that payout is a mirage. A total mirage.
- 17:03They are draining their savings. It will be cut, the stock will
- 17:06fall further and you will be left holding an empty bag.
- 17:09It really requires A profound shift in perspective.
- 17:12We've moved from viewing A dividend as this magical
- 17:15guaranteed bank deposit to understanding the mechanical
- 17:18reality of the shrinking pizza. Yep, we've walked through how
- 17:21the stock exchange's ex dividend adjustment literally forces a
- 17:24shift in value rather than creating it.
- 17:27And how the tax drag relentlessly punishes you for
- 17:30essentially liquidating your own money.
- 17:32We've learned to spot the death signal of a plummeting stock
- 17:35price, inflating the yield. And we've recognized the pre
- 17:38grim reality of Sunset Industries paying out suicide
- 17:41dividends. It all points us away from the
- 17:43illusion of free money and straight toward the true North
- 17:46star of investing, which is total return.
- 17:49Focusing on companies that compound wealth efficiently
- 17:52rather than those just throwing off taxable cash to mask a dying
- 17:56underlying business. It's a heavy shift in how we
- 17:58process financial data and it really requires an audit of how
- 18:02we make decisions, which actually brings me to a final
- 18:05thought I want to leave you with today.
- 18:07Oh, lay it on me. Something to really chew on long
- 18:11after this deep dive is over. We've talked entirely about the
- 18:14math today, right? Mechanics, yeah.
- 18:15The ex dividend formulas, the tax inefficiencies, the
- 18:18corporate strategy. But underlying every single one
- 18:21of those mistakes is something much more primal.
- 18:24Human nature. Exactly.
- 18:25Human psychology is biologically wired to crave instant
- 18:29gratification. When you see a cash dividend hit
- 18:32your account, it physically feels rewarding.
- 18:35It feels safe. It gives your brain a literal,
- 18:38measurable dopamine hit. You can see it.
- 18:41You can transfer to your checking account.
- 18:43You can spend it. It's real.
- 18:45On the other hand, total return, the kind of immense generational
- 18:51wealth built by companies that relentlessly reinvest their
- 18:55profits to grow over decades, that is entirely abstract.
- 18:59It is. It's just a number on a screen,
- 19:01right? Doesn't give you a dopamine hit
- 19:02today. It requires patience, immense
- 19:06delayed gratification, and real trust in a long term vision.
- 19:11Oi want you to ask yourself, yeah.
- 19:12Is our biological evolutionary desire for immediate visible
- 19:17rewards actually the biggest blind spot in our modern
- 19:20financial decision making? Wow, are we sacrificing our
- 19:24ultimate future wealth simply because we are biologically
- 19:27addicted to the comfort of the present moment?
- 19:29That is a fascinating question. It strongly suggests that the
- 19:33hardest part of being a successful investor isn't
- 19:35actually mastering the math. No, it's managing the impulses
- 19:38of our own minds. That is the real deep dive right
- 19:40there. Thank you so much for joining us
- 19:42on this one. It's been great.
- 19:43Take a fresh look at your portfolio this week through this
- 19:45new lens, Check your yield traps and we will see you next time.