Latest / The Witness Files / James Brogan – Life on the Frontline and Behind the Expert Witness Report
Transcript
- James Brogan: If we're thinking in terms of 999 calls, people who dial 999 are having one of, if not the worst day of their life, from their viewpoint. And I say, look, I'll make you a deal. When I start looking worried, that's when you need to start worrying. Until that time, we've got you. I describe the Ambulance Service as effectively the feral love child of the National Health Service and some sort of like home office funded police fire sort of quasi militaristic organisation. markjnicol: So I'm here today with James Brogan. So James, can you tell me a little about yourself? James Brogan: Yeah, thanks Mark, it's great to be here. So I'm James, I'm a registered paramedic and I am an expert witness as a paramedic. I am the principal lecturer of paramedicine at Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen. I'm also the geographical education lead for Scotland for the Royal College of Paramedics and I'm consultant editor for the Journal of Paramedic Practice. One of the things, one of the hallmarks about harmonics being of quite a small profession is that I've got lots of little roles and jobs and things. We're a very small profession, which means we all have to cover lots of different bases. So that's a little bit about me. markjnicol: that's great. So you've had quite a varied career, obviously, you know, doing a bit of research on that. you've obviously, you know, worked in ambulances, you've taught, you know, the next generation of paramedics studied law. And now you've, you know, you've also been involved in the expert witness world. But one kind of start before all of that, really. So you can tell me what you were like, kind of growing up. James Brogan: Sure, yeah. mischievous I think is probably the is the word that's cheeky, cheeky chap. Yeah I think I was fairly precocious as a young lad. I didn't seem to realise at the time the environment in which I was living in. you know, family and you know, all of that sort of schooling and what have you, how much of an impact that would likely have on my future career. But yeah, definitely cheeky chappy. Always up for making mischief and actually that's something that has followed me into my professional career in terms of, but now I try and use it for the positive in terms of looking for innovative ways to look for improvements, know, better ways of getting care to patients by actually just going let's just let's think really off the wall here let's just let's just really let's be really playful with some of this so yeah I think that's probably hard to score. markjnicol: How did you go from that precocious child to getting involved with the St John's ambulance? James Brogan: So when I was at school, one of the teachers started a first aid club and it was with the Royal Life Saving Society and we did some sort of basic life support type qualification. And I remember, that's one of those core memories. I can close my eyes and can vividly remember going in for the test and thinking, you know, this is great. It's intellectually stimulating. mean, this is how I describe it now. I don't think I did that when I was 10 or whatever. But, you know, it was intellectually stimulating. It was exciting. It was something new. And actually it was a useful skill. And I was able to help people. And I'd been brought up on the notion that, life was about service, you know, actually a life of service was a life well led. And that was something that was... drilled into me by my parents. You know, in terms of that, you know, need to work hard, which means you can play even harder. You know, do stuff for the community and the community will look after you. And that's where it started. So I did that and sort of got the bug for it. And my mum actually used to be in the British Red Cross. So I was like, well, you used to do this sort of thing. That sounds interesting, what's going on. Anyway, because of my age and because of where I lived and what have you, the Red Cross wasn't an option. St John did, there was a St John unit in my division in the town I lived in and they had a cadet division. So I went along and I took a friend of mine with me and I think he lasted one week, possibly two weeks and I stayed and yeah, the rest is history. markjnicol: What was next for you after that then? You got the bug for the service at James Brogan: yeah. markjnicol: that point. So what came after? James Brogan: Yeah, so I was a cadet, I did loads of stuff within that. I did a cadet trainer course, which is where the of the educational thing starts. I did the cadet trainer course so I could train cadets in first aid. I then took on a leadership role within the cadet unit. I then matured into an adult and moved into the adult division. But as a... As one of the cadet leadership team, as a member of cadet leadership team, I've already got some really strong links with the divisional leadership team. So when I transitioned, and the adults, when I transitioned into the adult... part of the division, very quickly I was taking on responsibilities for, first of all I started off with responsibilities for the training plan for the unit and then I was eventually, after maybe a year or two I was then promoted in the adult division into a leadership role where I took on responsibility for... operations, so event, clinical stuff and the training. And yeah, and it just sort of became a bigger and bigger and bigger and bigger part of my life. I then there were lots of other opportunities and there was some changes within the organisation, which meant that I happened to be in the right place at the right time. I did my adult training qualification and yeah, went around the county as it was and then became the region when we were when we regionalised training, assessing. I joined the training standards team as a training standards assessor so I could train and assess trainers and assessors. I was still doing clinical event work as well as leading my division to which I ended up as the divisional superintendent. So I ran the division, was responsible for everything that happened within that. And then from there I was promoted to, there was a restructure and I was promoted to area manager. So I looked after North Worcestershire. and then within 12 months I was then promoted to district manager what was formerly county commander so district manager for Herefordshire and Worcestershire so I was the senior volunteer for Herefordshire and Worcestershire so I was responsible for everything that happened within the two counties. When it went right my team did a great job when it all went wrong it was my fault and I had to sort it out but markjnicol: Yeah James Brogan: that was you know that was our youth wing training operations everything logistics fleet buildings, everything, everything. And I was a volunteer and by this time had a full-time job in the ambulance service. And it was, I'd be working with the ambulance service but I had a St John issue Blackberry, that's how long ago it was, a St John issue Blackberry, was on the the Gold Onkel rotor, you know, we were having to pass budgets of X millions in terms of having to it was from... From a young child that started off thinking, Royal Life Saving Society First Aid certificate is quite interesting, it was quite a journey over quite a short period of time. markjnicol: Yeah. So how did you, but you just mentioned that all of that was voluntary. So how did you balance your full-time job in the ambulance service with all of this volunteer work? James Brogan: Yeah, balance is an interesting word. I think when I wasn't at work, I was doing St John stuff and when I wasn't doing St John stuff, I was at work. know, a couple of hours for sleep or something like that. markjnicol: Yeah James Brogan: There's a famous line in a Bond film where one of the villains turns around and says, you know, you only get so many hours in this life, why waste it on sleep? And for a time that was my mantra. which on reflection now was a horrendous thing to think at the time, but hey, I'm still, I'm in my early twenties at this point. I'm still, I've got all the energy and I'm going out with my friends and we're doing all this. So it was just, it just happened. It was just, I was just able to do it. It was great. I couldn't do it now. There's no way I could do it now. markjnicol: So what did obviously that experience, you know, kind of working in, you know, within the, you St. John's and with your day job, what does that teach you about dealing with people? James Brogan: I famously have always said, you know, I used to think I was normal and then I started working with the public and I realised I was really abnormal in that people's perception of normal is extremely varied and will be personal to that particular individual. What I learnt in particular, I the thing that I've taken, I've taken loads from St John and St John, you know, I wouldn't be in the position I was in today without St John. I learnt that people come in all shapes and sizes and have their own motivators and their own foibles and vices and all of that. And one of the things that I think was really interesting, particularly as a volunteer leader and dealing with volunteers, know, and working with other volunteers was that, that I've taken certainly into paid employment, is that I had to really think about, okay, I want... these people to go and cover an event or want to go and do something, I have no other currency than their goodwill. So actually working with them, getting to know them, understanding what makes them tick, what's their motivator, know, what can I do to try and make a situation more appealing? Managing volunteers, I think, is one of the hardest things that you can do. Because unlike in a paid employment role, I can't say, well, you contractually obliged to do this, I'm telling you that you need to do this, off you go you need to do it. It's a very different approach and I think that's something that I learned. The other thing as well is that the variety of people, whether that be at training events, whether that be at medical events, we used to also do voluntary patient transports and so we had a relationship that St John had a relationship with the local hospital, that three nights a week we would put out a voluntary emergency patient transport crew and we had three other divisions within the county that did that. We did Mondays then another division did Wednesdays, division did Fridays. After a couple of years one of the other divisions said actually we can't we don't want to do this anymore so obviously we went well we'll have that we'll do two nights instead. So actually what you found was that we were doing non-emergency work twice a week on top of the weekend activities and the training nights on a Thursday. and what have you. really the camaraderie of a group of willing volunteers who are doing things that they believe in, that are passionate about, think exposed me to far more people than any of my contemporaries. So when I applied to go to university to become a paramedic, I had all of that experience, which I think... I think it helped me, I don't think it was a disadvantage. And actually I was able to quite quickly focus on that because I'd sort of nailed down over a long period of time, event medical work, talking to people, dealing with things, non-immunity transport, the fundamental ambulance skills. I was able to very quickly start thinking about that, okay, so now the transition into being a registered clinician, I found markjnicol: Yeah James Brogan: that invaluable. markjnicol: So you spoke then about the the volunteers and you know managing volunteers is very different to managing contracted staff Obviously with all of your training background as well when you were coming up through st. John's You must have had some volunteers that you had to have difficult conversations with them to say This isn't for you How did you approach? that conversation because you've got somebody who is willing to give up their free time and you're telling them actually, maybe this isn't for you. How do you approach that? James Brogan: Yeah, well one of the great things about having a volunteer workforce or in a voluntary organisation and certainly at the time, you know, I was able to... because... I wasn't reliant on I have a budget for full-time equivalent of X number of staff, I was able to often have a coaching conversation with the individual and go, okay, so what is it you're trying to get out of it? What is it you want to do? And often the motivator could be, okay, so you're trying to get out of this route, whatever that But actually we've got these other options that you could do which might be a county level role, might be a unit level role, it might be a fundraising role, it might be in education, it might be in the safeguarding team. There were lots of opportunities for us to funnel people off and I didn't have to get a budgetary sign off for that because the overhead was actually we have somebody that's willing to give their time provided we have a role that they are suitable for. It was much more fluid. because we didn't have to worry about the of the contractual obligations that you would if you were an employee and I was going, actually I'm going to redeploy you into this team instead. And that was done through a coaching conversation and actually for the most part was done really amicably. markjnicol: For the most part, was there occasions where people were just disappointed that actually what they wanted didn't quite match their skills? James Brogan: Yeah absolutely and I think it's difficult isn't it in terms of that. Often people would probably have privately come to that conclusion themselves. know there are lots of things that know I'm really fortunate that I have you know. with a good dose of luck, found a career that I absolutely love. I am motivated every morning to get out of bed and to be involved in the profession again. Right, okay, this is where I left it last night and this is what we're going to do today and what have you. I'm really fortunate. I know lots of people don't have that level of intrinsic motivation. There are a million and one other roles that I think and I'm like, gosh, I just wouldn't be, I'd just be awful at doing that and I'd hate it and I couldn't. So I know I'm really, really fortunate in that. But oftentimes, and there have been times in my career where I've gone, do you know what, I've taken maybe a role or I've done some stuff and I've gone, yeah, this is all right, but it just doesn't quite feel, yeah, it doesn't quite feel right. And often you've admitted that to yourself before you've admitted it publicly to anybody else. so yeah, so like I said, most of the time, I can probably count on one hand the amount of times I've had to have. Certainly from a St John point of view, we're talking St John specifically, difficult conversations with people and going, it's just not working and they haven't seen that or at least they haven't gone, yeah, I'm not really enjoying it as well. Yeah. markjnicol: Okay. So, but one of the things, obviously, that's fascinating about, you know, the ambulance service is you're, you're kind of walking into people's lives at their worst possible moment. You know, that they're going through something absolutely, you know, devastating for them. What goes through your mind when you arrive on a scene like that and you've got to make, you know, decisions, you know, for something that's going on? James Brogan: Yeah, I mean I think it depends on the role in which or how you come to that work. One of my biggest sort of things is that, know, paramedic doesn't equal ambulance, ambulance doesn't equal paramedics. There are lots of people that work in ambulances that aren't paramedics, there are a lot of paramedics that don't work on ambulances. So the profession and the ambulance services are two very different things, but often a significant proportion of paramedics do still work in ambulance services, particularly in the UK, and often that can be something that's quite challenging to sort of decouple in people's minds, including a lot of registrants. Actually, you're not defined by the sector which you work you're defined because you are on the professional register for this profession. But speaking about the Ambulance Service specifically or in that sort of emergency response I think it depends. So I was really fortunate before I was a paramedic, like I say, with St John we used to do 999 support work as well for the local ambulance service. And normally you know in times of bad weather so we had flood, we had flooding, we had a lot of flooding in the Midlands, in the in the noughties and snow and know St John we had we had Land Rover ambulances we you know so we were able to go and respond where the the Renault Master converted vans of the ambulance service perhaps weren't as adept with the conditions you know I was there in my Land Rover 110 converted ambulance going yeah come on jump in let's go and so so actually I can see it through the lens of being not going to emergency calls not as a registrant and then as a registrant and actually there is a nuance between that. But actually, fundamentals stay the same for whoever is responding in terms of... If we're thinking in terms of 999 calls, people who dial 999 are having one of, if not the worst day of their life, from their viewpoint. 999 is not a number that most of us call on a regular basis. unless you work around the system, you're incredibly unlucky and keep coming across things, or if you're a frequent flyer, right? Most people, dialling 999 is a big life event, and it's something that they, that's a sort of a light bulb is a large event. For ambulance staff, this is... everyday, rid of the mill stuff, you You dial 999 maybe once every five or ten years, I go to five or ten 999 calls every twelve hours. Like, you know, in terms of the frequency, and it's probably even more now, again, depending on where you work and what have you, in terms of call volume, but... It's about going in and recognising that the people who are there perceive that they are having an emergency, that there is some emergency. The vast majority of the time, and we can see from the statistics, know, the vast majority of 999 calls are not life-threatening emergencies. Is there somebody that needs unscheduled undifferentiated care? Yes. Is there somebody that needs some sort of assistance? Yes. Is there somebody in front of me that is rapidly deteriorating, has a life threatening, whether it's acute, know, chronic exacerbation or acute injury, trauma, illness, medical event, whatever. No. You know, that is not the... Unlike what the TV programs tell you, it's not all driving from death and destruction one to the next, to the next, to the next. Often it is driving to lots of social problems, lots of things that actually could have been and potentially could have been dealt with earlier but haven't, either because of a failure of the system, because of a deterioration, because of social factors, because of lots of other things. So it's about recognising that thing, isn't it? It's about recognising. that the people that you are going to are having, they think they're having the worst day of their life possibly so far or at least a very bad day, at the very least a very bad day and the first job I need to do is to bring order to chaos yeah and sometimes that could be as simple as hi there what's going on yeah okay great who are you brilliant okay do us a favor right we're gonna do you want to stick the kettle on for us that'd be great yeah sit on the sofa if we're in somebody's house and go right before I do anything else, tell me what's going on. just giving that calmness, know, of like spreading that sort of voice kind. And, you know, I had a phrase that I used to use when I was in full time clinical practice, often, you know, particularly with people who you can see are physically scared. And I say, look, I'll make you a deal. When I start looking worried, that's when you need to start worrying. Until that time, we've got you. It's fine. Don't worry about it. Like as in... you know, whatever's happening, this is happening, we're here, we're going to help you, it's not a problem, just let me do the worrying for you. And often the amount of, you know, when you'd say something like that, a little bit humorous perhaps, but again going back to what I said earlier about, you know, being the cheeky chap or whatever, but actually saying, you know, when I start looking worried, you look worried, people go, all right, yeah, okay, yeah, all right. And you can, you could sometimes visibly see people go. just take exhale slightly okay yeah we can do that so yeah markjnicol: So with, obviously, like you said, you're going from event to event, situation to situation. When in your career, when did that start becoming the other kind of day to day in the norm? And you were able to kind of let go of each those incidents and move on to the next one. James Brogan: Honestly, I don't remember a time where that happened. I remember vividly as a student, I remember vividly as a student going through the cycle of incompetence in terms of, in the beginning, I knew I didn't know very much, but I didn't know how much I didn't know. Then I suddenly became very acutely aware that there was a lot I didn't know and I knew exactly what I didn't know markjnicol: Ha James Brogan: and I didn't know anything. I then moved into a phase where I actually knew what I was doing but I didn't realise I knew what I was doing and I was like, gosh, no, this is just, I'm just awful and I'm never gonna do this and I'll get... And then one day it just went, there was a click and I was like, I just did that, I can do this. And you just suddenly, you just... Most people describe what I would describe as a a damascus moment. You know, have that sort of, it's not quite a sort of light coming out of the clouds, but you have that sort of moment where go, okay, maybe all of this stuff is starting to click into place. In terms of the coping, I think because of the culture that is... that you find in the ambulance sector in that this is just normal, we just get on with it. There's a lot of humour, there's a lot of camaraderie, know camaraderie. The people you work with is really important, particularly if you're working in the ambulance service, you know, often, you will work with people, you will, I would work with my crew mates. I would see my crewmate for more hours in a week than I would see my partner, children, what have you. I'm spending a lot of time with them. So you get to know people really, really well. And all their foibles as well. What makes them tick, what also sends them into a spin. And that's a really privileged position to be in. But actually, a lot of it is about the camaraderie. there is a lot of stuff, there was some stuff years ago about comparing sort of emergency service workers and the military in terms of that levels of camaraderie. And actually, you know, some of the interesting statistics say statistics saying that ambulance staff were much more likely, even during the sort of the height the the conflicts in the Middle East that the British troops were deployed into, that PTSD was actually more prevalent in UK ambulance services than it was in soldiers returning from Helmand, which I think probably tells you something. However, a lot of it is about the people. The people get you through. The camaraderie. you, historically, before everybody was queuing outside emergency departments for hours on end, you would do something difficult, you would finish up, you'd tidy it up, you'd go back to the ambulance station, you'd put the kettle on and you'd sit around and you'd have a chat about it. and you chat about the clinical stuff, but you'd also chat about the personal stuff as well. And that was a debriefing, unofficial coping strategy. markjnicol: Yeah, okay. So you moved on obviously later on into the more kind of academic side of paramedicine. But one of the things I found interesting was your paper you done on informed consent, which it's something obviously, you know, I'd never kind of considered. But first off, you know, what is informed consent? And secondly, How do you approach a situation where what somebody wants isn't something that you think is in their best interests? James Brogan: So, yeah, I went back to university to do my topical degree. So when I became a paramedic, was on one of the first pilot university programmes within the West Midlands for direct attendery students. I think I was on the second, possibly third cohort. And so I came up with a foundation degree. So I went back and there was a little bit of funding, some part funding from the ambulance service, I don't know whether it was the Strategic Health Authority or whatever. I've been through that in many NHS reorganisations. Whoever it was, the regional health people, there was some budget for, you know, we'll give you a little bit of money to go and assist you to go and do your top-up degree. So I did my top-up degree and one of the modules I did... was in law and ethics for health practitioners and it was taught by an absolute diamond. It was taught by a lady who was a nurse and also a non-practicing barrister. was an academic staff at the University of Worcester. She taught me, attempted to teach me I think she'd probably say, she taught our research methods module on the paramedic foundation degree which I was just like... Nah, what do need to know this for? Like, cos I was in that sort of, nah, it's just all about the job, I wanna do some stuff, I don't need to know about evidence and research and stuff. I've now revised my view on that. However, at the time, was just like, is very, whatever, anyway, she was really in that. We had a really good... The scales dropped from my eyes. I did this module in law and ethics. In parks I knew the lecturer was like, yeah, we'll have a bit of a laugh here, know, it'll be good. And it was just revolutionary. Before that I was like, gosh, know, practising really defensively, thinking, God, if I make any slip ups, is that, I'm going to be in trouble and there's going to be all these issues. And I started learning a little bit about the law and thought... Actually, providing I go in there and I can go, well, I'm going in with the best of intentions. I'm not going in to actively try and harm someone or cause problems. I'm going in with the best of intentions. And based on the information that's in front of me, I've made some decisions that, you know, a body of people, you know, my colleagues would probably go, yeah, that's probably reasonable. Yeah, it's probably okay. Then even if it was wrong, I'm not going to be carted off to the nick, you know. And this was so revolutionary because historically the Ambulance Service has very much like any sort of quasi-militaristic sort of organisation, works on hierarchy, fear of reprisal, fear of discipline. And this was revolutionary. was like, actually, I don't have to, you know, the mantra of, I've got to take the patient to the hospital to cover my own back. It's like... actually that's wrong and actually if I take them to the hospital they then contract at the time MRSA, C. diff all that sort of stuff was you know really big headline news and stuff it's like and they then become ill or die from that actually me doing that has actively potential, there's potentially a linkage there. And was like, gosh, and what that did was having a little bit of knowledge allowed me to be a little bit more confident, well, it allowed me to, me more confidence in my practice, which then allowed me to then, I felt myself going, okay, well, I'm gonna try something different here. I'm gonna try a community referral pathway instead. And when the community referral pathway started working and patients started getting benefits, from that and I could see that I did it more often. So actually, going and studying the law, well, I say going and studying the law, no. Going into this one little module, because the law degree came later, going into this one little module on law and ethics was absolutely revolutionary for my clinical practice, because it gave me the confidence in knowing that I'm not going to at any minute, the old bill's not going to turn up and cut me off to the nick because of something that I've accidentally done or because somebody has come to harm as a result of something that I've unintentionally done. know or not done. Yeah what was the second part of question? Sorry. markjnicol: So where did the paper from the informed consent, how did that come about? James Brogan: So that came about, it was published with the tutor, so Helen, it was her paper and I'm the second author on it and she was very, very fabulous in supporting me to take my first step into writing an academic paper but I was really frustrated at, particularly in terms of capacity, consent, that... And even to this day, I still think a lot of healthcare professionals think they understand the law, but actually the nuances and the complexities of it. In a three, four, five year degree programme, whatever, you know, whatever you're doing, for whatever profession, there's so much stuff you have to cover. Law and ethics tends to be a very, very small part of it, but actually it is fundamental and so consequential to everything else that you do. And I was really frustrated because I would be out in practice and I'd go, hmm, you know, and people would say, well, they don't have capacity, full stop, and I'd go, but they don't have capacity for what? What do mean? Well. Capacity is about having the capacity to make a decision about a specific decision, a specific thing at a material time. So we're saying that this patient at this time cannot, can or cannot decide that they want to have the treatment or not, or they want to go to hospital or not. And people have looked at me as if I've grown a second head and like, what are you talking about? You you look on the ambulance service report form and it just says capacity and it's yes. No, it's like if you don't have you don't have capacity for anything. know and I would say well you know and you'd go out to perhaps some you know people who maybe were in specialist dementia facilities you know and be like well they don't have capacity. So well they might not have the capacity to refuse treatment for a urine infection that they've got or that you know they might have the ability to understand and comprehend that they need to go to the hospital because they're having some sort of acute event they may not be able to do. you're right, they might not have the capacity to consent or refuse to that. They probably know if they want a cup of tea. Or they might know, well, do you want a blanket? Because it's snowing outside, you yeah, actually, I'm quite warm actually, I don't want a blanket. So there are some sort of fundamental and foundational things that even people with advanced progressive, potentially permanent disturbances of the mind or brain can still make decisions about. And that was the thing for me. was the passion of going, my goodness, like, hang on a minute lads, like, we're doing the population a big disservice here. And I say we in terms of not just paramedics, but healthcare professionals more generally in terms of that, yeah, they don't have capacity. It's a throw away comment from a healthcare professional. And not all healthcare professionals, that's a gross generalisation, but. actually when you dig into it, when you scratch more of the surface, it becomes much more complex. The other thing that I found really interesting as well, obviously, thinking in a UK context, there are four constituent nations of the United Kingdom that operate in three different legal jurisdictions. Consent. Health, education, certainly Scotland is devolved, but the consent capacity legislation, should say the capacity legislation, you have the Mental Capacity Act 2005 in England and Wales, you have the Mental Capacity Northern Ireland Act in Northern Ireland, and you have the Adults Within Capacity Scotland Act 2000. And lots of their provisions are quite similar, but some bits of it are extremely different. We don't talk about it. It's not a... The Ambulance Service Clinical Practice Guidelines, if you look in the JOWCOUT guidelines, the Ambulance Service Clinical Practice Guidelines, which are designed for any ambulance practitioner across the land, their section on capacity to consent and the little flow chart, it's lovely, it's amazing, it's beautiful, but it only makes reference to the mental capacity at 2005, which only applies in England and Wales. And I've sort of flagged this and I have been flagging it for years but nothing's been done about it. that was my, it came from a passion and a frustration of going, I did this module and went, my goodness, like the scales have dropped from my eyes and I wanted to go, guys, like, you know, we probably need to know a bit more about this subject. markjnicol: Yeah, this kind of ties in with a parliamentary paper you wrote about the service and the changes that are needed. So what was happening within our paramedicine that made you feel that these questions needed answering? James Brogan: Yeah, well I was really fortunate, so I was asked if I'd submit some of my, as I like to refer to it, some of my preposterous ideas. I'm like, yeah, okay, great. Again, that's the mischievous comedian in me coming out. You know, I was really fortunate to be invited to submit evidence to the select committee. So my current research, my current study is looking at the professionalisation of the parametric profession and the question of what is the strategy of professionalisation? What is the profession? Where is it going? And how does it then interface with the system at the state, regional, country, local level? And I can boil it really down to go really simply to go, it doesn't. There isn't really a plan. There are plans, but there isn't one overarching sort of... That's the way we're going. Because nobody really knows what they want from us. Least of all us as a profession. Which, mean, hey, that's great because I've now charted the rest of my career in terms of research. I've got a whole lifetime's worth of research now that I can do and I'm never going to answer the question fully. So thanks for that. But in terms of the parliamentary stuff, it's about asking the question of what is it we want? what is it that we want out of our paramedic profession or as it was in the case of the Lords, it was looking at the enquiries looking at emergency departments and ambulance services and supporting emergency departments. So I was thinking about it from an ambulance service point of view and it was looking because it was the Lords and because health is developed, this was looking at England only. Fine, whatever. Yeah, great. And just about identifying some of those really key questions about what is it that you want. The ambulance services suffer from this trying to be everything to everybody. And often the ambulance service is the... the glue that's sort of the sticky tape that holds other parts of the NHS together because it's the interlocutor. Yeah, it's the bit that, it's the bit that links the different hospitals and community settings and what have you. And ultimately at three o'clock in the morning when everybody else who works Monday to Friday, nine till five isn't available, who are you going to call? It's not Ghostbusters. Yeah. We have a three digit free phone number that if I can, well actually we have two three-digit phone numbers, but if I ring 111 or 999 I'm going to either speak to somebody or in a large part of the time I'm going to get somebody physically attending wherever I am to come and assess me. Okay that's great but going back to what I was saying earlier in terms of actually the vast majority of ambulance practice or the ambulance workload is non-life-threatening emergencies. They might be classified as emergencies that are non-life-threatening which I mean... We could talk about that for quite a while, but there's lots of unscheduled care need. But what is it we want our ambulance services to do? Peter Bradley did a report for the Department of Health, as it was then, called Taking Healthcare to the Patient in 2005. Now, to me, and probably to yourself, Mark, 2005 seems like yesterday, right? But it wasn't, it was 21 years ago. it, it, yeah, like that's a... That's a, I mean, it's a scary concept, right? But was, you know, that was 21 years ago, a report came out from the Department of Health Care and Peter Bradley, was then Chief Executive of London Ambulance Service, we need to become a mobile, the ambulance services will become, needs to become a mobile health resource for the NHS. We need to take care to the patient. It's about bringing the hospital to the patient in terms of primary care, referrals, see and treat in the community, refer on, all of these sort of things. That was 21 years ago. And we're still having these conversations. And you've got this thing whereby ambulance services are trying to do all these great things and referral pathways and do all of this unscheduled non-emergency caseload, but at the same time they're measured on performance targets around if you don't get to this type of category within this amount of call, this category of call within this amount of time, you will be castigated for failing that. And actually that has got better. The Ambulance Response Project in England has improved that somewhat, but there is still a large that measures time and it comes to something it's like I can get to somebody in eight minutes let's say if the if it's an eight minute response time if I get to them within eight minutes and one second and I do exquisite exquisite clinical care and I save that person's life that goes down as a failure I can get there in seven minutes and 59 seconds can be absolutely useless and they die but that chalks off as a win because we hit the time yeah now the time has been de-emphasized in ARP and I should say that again lots of things the different nations of the United Kingdom have different response time targets and I mean this is a whole new conversation yeah we can have a whole other conversation around that but the fundamental question was what can we do? And so what I tried, what I put into the Lords Committee, and I was really humbled that they used my evidence and sort of cited it through their interim report and the letter they sent off to the Minister at the Department of Health and Social Care, was just about going, we just need to take stock a little bit here and go. What is it that we want? And actually, the thing I was arguing for was about we need to just agree a universal standard, baseline minimum. So, you know, in some areas there are specific mental health practitioners, mental health paramedics or mental health practitioner responses that ambulance services have, whereas in other postcodes they're not because the local CCG, insert whatever other three-letter acronym is now the local commissioning arrangement, certainly in England, you know, well, we fund it in, I don't know, this county but we don't fund it in that county and you happen to live 200 yards over the border so unfortunately we can't send this resource to you because your commissioning group doesn't pay for that. I mean it's just it's just crackers. But that was part of it in terms of you know now looking at that going okay so what is it what is the universal minimum that if I pick up 999 wherever I am in the country in that report we were talking about England But wherever I am, this is the minimum I should be able to expect, was my suggestion. markjnicol: Yeah, kind of one of the things that I kind of picked up on was a phrase which I absolutely loved. So I wrote it down was the tyranny of tradition. James Brogan: You markjnicol: Which, yeah, I think anyone who's ever worked in any kind of long established company or civil service role is kind of very familiar with with that concept. You know, it's as a youngster myself, of, you working, I'd often ask the question, well, why are we doing it that way? You get the response, we've always done it that way. That's just the way it is. So how much of that kind of attitude kind of plays into the kind of what you were trying to obviously achieve with, you know, with the parliamentary paper? James Brogan: lots of it and actually identity and sort of symbolism and heraldry and all of that sort of I get I'm I'm really interested in all of that and that's on James's list of things to do once he's finished his current study on professionalization strategy although part of it is actually sort of does does does sit with that so ambulance services I'm just gonna just wind back a little bit. Ambulance services are very strange organisations. In that, I describe the Ambulance Service as effectively the feral love child of the National Health Service and some sort of like home office funded police fire sort of quasi militaristic organisation. In that, is an NHS organisation the NHS organisations, the ambulance services. And so all this stuff about, yeah, we need to flatten hierarchies and NHS 6Cs and all of the values and all of that and autonomy and all that. And that's all great and amazing. And yet at the same time, we all have to wear uniforms. We have hierarchical rank structures. We give out medals for people for service. and also for doing good stuff, so the King's Ambulance Medal for faithful ambulance service. And I'm not belittling any of this, please don't think I am, but we just have to go, that's a little bit strange because nowhere else in the NHS does that happen. We had the coronation a few years ago. If you had been serving in an ambulance service, if I was working in an ambulance service I'd have been awarded a coronation medal for, yeah I think you had to do five years of service on the date of the coronation. It was the same for things like the platinum jubilee, the gold jubilee, the double jubilee, that sort of stuff. Right, I got a medal. So I'm in uniform service. Nurses didn't get that, who worked in hospitals, doctors didn't get No other health worker got that. That's the bit where we go, we're in the emergency services, so we're in this camp over here. And yeah, this whole hierarchical thing of medals and, mean, you see people get, particularly on remembrance events, it's prolific. You see people dressed up in number one uniforms and they have standards and... Gillettes and they look like I am I have a bit of a of a soft spot for David Croft sitcoms Yeah, but you know that you know some of these some people turn up looking like Captain Bertorelli from a low low you know in terms of like all of these Medals and you know I'm expecting somebody to come out with a hat with like ostrich feathers at some point. It's just it's just crazy And I can say that Going back to my roots with St. John St John is, or historically was, exactly the same. The Knights of St John was a military crusading order, right, and the history has come through that. The paramedic profession was born in the battlefield, right. It's not a coincidence that we celebrate International Paramedics Day on the birthday of Jean Dominique Lary, the guy who was Napoleon's Surgeon General who invented battlefield triage and the battlefield ambulance. So we have very strong military routes, both ambulance services and also the paramedic profession. it's not uncommon that we shouldn't have... Ambulance services have royal crest badges nobody else has that yeah There's this whole level of heraldry and tradition and I'm not saying that that's a bad thing because having come up, having been sort of volunteer at Three St John for a number of years, I know what it's like to get dressed up in a number one dress uniform with all my medals and my peak hat with all my little scrambled egg on top and what have you, and parading around like a Ploughman's lunch. It feels fabulous. It's amazing. Yeah, it's, you know, it's that little bit of the theatrics. I love it. But because I know how amazing that feels when you are dressed really smartly and you've got polished shoes and you look the epitome of a uniformed emergency services personnel, I can also go, it's completely mad because most normal people just don't get it. So I think there's a really interesting, mean, there's a whole thing about culture. Yeah, ambulance culture. But like I say, we've got this really weird thing whereby police and fire, funded by the Home Office, police and fire are very hierarchical, quasi-militaristic. The Ambulance Service sort of sits one step removed from that because it is an NHS organisation, but still has a lot of, has one hand sort of held onto that. And that causes tension. markjnicol: Yeah, so with this paper, I how well was it received within the ambulance service, with the parliamentary review that you've done, where you were quite critical of the organisation and its kind of lack of plan, how was it received amongst your peers? James Brogan: Yeah, I think Yeah, let's say exactly what I said. So I basically said that, ambulance services in England, because they work on a regional model, they're too small an organisation for Westminster and the Department of Health and Social Care to really, I'm not saying to worry about, but when you think that, you know, a regional ambulance service possibly has what, 6,000 members of staff, they're tiny organisations by comparison to maybe like a large university hospital trust or something. So they're too small. really for the state, know, the Westminster government to think about if we think about in England. But equally, they're too big because they cover multiple commissioning areas for the local people to do. So they sit in this sort of middle layer. They sort of this, you've got sort of this middle layer of of of organisation. And so as a result of that, and because there's no, apart from the time targets in England, which is, you know, sort of standardised, apart from that, providing you hit those targets, how you do that, it's up to the individual service. And so what you find is that actually some of them run as their own little, using the words I use in the paper, they run as their own little fiefdoms, right? They are, you know, it's chalk and cheese between, can cross a border with a regional ambulance service and the service you get will be completely different. that might be good different or not so good different, it depends which way you're travelling. And that was the bit that I was really trying to sort of call out and go, actually we need to just be taking a look at this because it's such a small sector if you think about. you know, the number of people employed in ambulance services is minute by comparison to the wider NHS. So naturally it doesn't get that much air time. But actually, ultimately it's the fundamental bit that everybody, every one of us relies on every single day. We're having this conversation now. I'm reliant upon the fact if suddenly I have some sort of acute event, somebody outside will be able to hit the three nines and somebody will come and turn up and help me. I rely on it 24 hours a day, 365 days of the year, without even thinking about it. So we probably need to spend a little bit more time, thinking about how it works or doesn't. markjnicol: So how did you get something? I'm going to kind of shift the focus a little bit here. James Brogan: Shoo. markjnicol: How did you first start getting involved in expert witness work? James Brogan: right, so when I took up my first part-time academic appointment, by sheer chance, I happened to start sharing an office with an absolutely fabulous chap who did expert witness work, and at the time was, I think, one of three paramedics in the UK that did, and he was just so fab. and I'd done the, this was about the time I was doing, I'd done the half law module and I was like, gosh, I'm really interested in this, I really like to do some of this. And he was like, why don't you, I mean, like, just, he was like, there's so much work, I just have to, I say no to most of it, because I just, I don't have time to do it, you know, I've got, I just don't have the capacity to sort of, to do that. And I was like, that might be quite interesting. And. I umb'd and ah'd around it for a number of years actually. was like, yeah, that sounds really interesting, but I don't really understand it. Because I'd only ever worked, know, and because I'd been bought up with that view of, you you must get a proper job, be employed, be on the PAYE sort of side of life, the idea of then going, I've got to set this up for myself and I've got to think about like my own insurances and how do I market myself? And I've got to, like, how do I didn't understand how to do any of that. And yeah, was just after several years of just sort of prevaricating it, I just thought, right, I'm going to do this. And I went and did a course with... with one of the expert witness training providers about report writing. I found it absolutely fabulous, really enjoyed it, felt very out of my depth. I had to travel to London to go down and do this report writing course and I turned up at this place and there were smoked salmon and cream cheese bagels and I was sort of coffee do you want? And I'm thinking... just coffee and markjnicol: You James Brogan: this comes back to I didn't realize and there was a view and there still is a view my parents whilst they're very supportive certainly one of them is just still doesn't understand what I do still at the time when I I want to go to university I was first person to go to university my family was like why just need to go and get a proper job like you don't need to what are you doing why would you want it All right. And the only reason they actually supported me in terms of emotionally to go to university was because it was like, well, you're going to, it's a foundation degree, it's only two years and you're going to come out, become a paramedic and then you're going to get a proper job because you work for an ambulance service and that's a proper job. You know, if I'd said I wanted to go and do history of fine art or something or, you know, media studies with football or something, I don't know. I mean, I wouldn't have done that. like, they'd have just been yeah, no. Or a degree in history or something or law. No. because people like me from my background didn't go to university. We didn't go and do medicine or law or anything like that. So I think it's, yeah, was, it's just really, yeah, very interesting that, yeah. markjnicol: So what surprised you most then when you started working with solicitors and barristers in the courts? James Brogan: One of my first engagements, I was asked to do a few reports and that was all great and fine and wonderful and amazing and all of that. I had a call going, could you write us a report at Shortnet? We need an expert, we need an expert now. And this was when I was just starting up, so was like, yeah, okay, I'll do that. And at the time I was a clinical supervisor, I'd been in the profession for a number of years, I'd done extra training, I was teaching on lots of other, so this is not me straight out of university going, yeah, I'm gonna be an expert. I'd been in the profession for a number of years and got lots of experience at this point. And they were like, yeah, we need somebody to do it. I can do that. Wrote the report, very nice, submitted it and then got a phone call, I think it was at about three o'clock in the afternoon and goes, yeah, council wonders if you can be in central London tomorrow morning at eight o'clock. I was like, Yeah, okay. Just, yeah, and I remember having to ask for an advance from the expert witness organization that had instructed me to go, look, I need an advance because I don't have enough money in my account to pay for a train ticket. That's how shoestring it was in the start and you know being totally honest, know and actually not really understand You know when I said earlier about not understanding the business and how to set it up and how to market myself I paid for the insurances I paid for all this stuff, but it was like I actually physically don't have enough money to get myself there And to be fair they did and they sorted it it was and it was fab and to be fair because I was doing them a favor I think because I turned up the next day and I turned up the next day and for this hearing and the barrister that was conducting the case for the side that had instructed me was somebody who I was like, my goodness, you know, I felt like I'd met sort of, I'm not going to name names, but I felt like I'd met a cross between Kavanaugh QC and Rumpole of the Bailey. I was like, wow, like I felt so out of my depth. At the coffee break said individual then identified that actually they were originally not from a million miles away from where I was from and actually had a very similar upbringing and we had a really nice conversation about how fabulous it was that people like us markjnicol: Yeah. James Brogan: were now able to do the things that we were doing. mean, this guy was like a bencher at his inn, Like, you know, this was a senior silk that I was talking to and I was like, I was like, my goodness, what am I doing here? And I was just so well supported. I was so well supported by the instructors, I was so well supported by the barrister and their team. And... Yeah, I just went from there. The rest, they say, is history, I guess. But it was that initial... I just remember sitting, sitting, waiting to be called to give evidence, thinking... why am I here? Why did you think that you could do this? And actually when I got up on the stand and I was asked questions I was able to have a really great, I really enjoyed it because I had a really intellectually stimulating discussion about my opinion, what could have happened, what might not have happened and ultimately I felt and that was relatively supportive, know the cross-examination wasn't too personal. that time at least, was, you was about, look, everybody here is just trying to get to the truth and to, what was, what could have happened. So I had a good, I had a good first experience, which, which I think, if I'd had a bad first experience, I probably would never have carried on with it, but I was very fortunate. markjnicol: I think there comes a time in everyone's lives when somebody asks for the parent in the room and you're looking around looking for the parent in the room and you realize that they mean you. James Brogan: yes, and this is the thing right, and this is something that I've come to more and more recently. I have, one of the hallmarks of my career is that I've always defied barriers. People like me don't go to university, I went to university. Once you've qualified you have to be in for X number of years before you can possibly be promoted or be a clinical supervisor or be a tutor or do whatever. I didn't. had a very swift acceleration and I don't think that was for any sort of other reason than hopefully people looked at me and went, actually this guy, you know, and his preposterous ideas, this guy might be able to bring some value. You know, I don't think I was ticking any sort of, any other sort of like boxes of, well actually we need somebody him to do this. I think I just, I was very fortunate to be able to be, for people to say. actually we're going to give you an opportunity here. markjnicol: Yeah. So what was it like for you then, you know, giving evidence because most people in the country, in the world, would have no idea what it's like to kind of be cross examined. What was it like for you that first experience when you're like, James Brogan: Yeah, so I mean, yeah, the first time was interesting. And actually, think what helped was because I'd done the module in Law and Health, sorry, Law and Ethics for Healthcare. practitioners and because I had a number of years of experience and because I'd also got I was transitioning from I'd started off doing one day a week at the university and and then it became two and then it became 50 % of my time so I transitioned from full-time clinical practice over a number of years I was really fortunate that my all the employers allowed me to do that but actually the conversation I was having was not unlike some of the conversations I would have with students in terms of going, well, here's a scenario, let's war game effectively all of the scenarios, you know? And I find and actually, I think one of things my, you know. having been fortunate enough to do lots of psychometric stuff with you, know, believing that stuff or not, on anything that I've ever done, it always comes up, mm-hmm, yeah, yeah, you are a debater. You like to just, you know, you like to sort of tease out things and, but what about this? And, you know, just for the sheer, the mental pleasure of doing that. So actually, I really enjoyed it. I enjoyed it until it started becoming personal. And even then, I recognise that, and there has been times, and actually it's only been a handful of times, you know, lawyers for the other, I say the other side obviously, you and as I'm required to, but I also say, you my duty here is to the core, so I'm just going to tell you exactly what I think, whether it helps, you know, it doesn't matter who originally approached me. my duties to the court or to the tribunal or whatever the setting is. But actually when you then get into people into questioning going well actually do you know what you're talking about? know, what right do you have to be an expert, to claim to be an expert? And you go well and then you have to go through the whole rigmarole and sometimes it's going... actually I understand and I understand why they're doing that I understand it that's the bit that's really not very nice and and still isn't very nice even today and I mean like today I'm I'm very much more because I've been doing this now for longer than I care to remember but even today like today I'm much more able to be like they're just they're just doing their bit because they're trying to their point and they're trying I get that it still isn't nice you know debate me on the substance, that's absolutely fine, but the personal stuff can be... Although you know that it's gone a bit too far when the judge sort of intervenes and goes, come on, let's be fair. Anyway, yeah. markjnicol: So with all your kind of experience in hindsight of your career and your experience as an expert awareness, if you were to take an objective view of your own career and think about obviously some of the incidents that you've had to deal with, how confident would you be that you could pass Master? James Brogan: I think, yeah, I'm hoping that there is some sort of like statutory time bar to some of my earlier practice. No, and I say, you know, but, you know, we know that a novice practitioner cannot claim to be a novice practitioner. You're a registrant, you're a registrant. I think back to certainly my earlier practice and I think, I don't think there's anything that I think, ooh, I hope that... I would never ever do that again, but there's lots of things where I think, well, actually, probably my approach might be different now, but... going back to what I said earlier, particularly when you were talking about capacity and actually, and and the whole thing I learned about the law, was like, well, at the time, I went in there with the best of intentions and on the information I had in front of me, and based on my qualifications, my knowledge, my experience, these are the decisions I made and this is why, whilst now I would probably go, hmm, I probably wouldn't do it in that regard or I do it slightly differently, I'd still go, but then James, yeah. probably that was probably reasonable. think it's you know experience is something that we gain. Often, you one of the things that I, you people say, you know, one of the biggest drivers for me is around being an advocate for the patient, being an advocate for the service user. And it's about going, okay, let's do the very best. And this was the thing that I think I said right at the beginning in terms of my, the thing, the biggest thing I took from the... that initial law module I did as part of my top of degree was actually I can have confidence in my practice and I can try things. can go, okay, I'm going to try this new community referral path. I'm going to try this. And ultimately I was doing that because I believed it was the right thing for the patient at the time. And actually that whole, you know, being a patient advocate is so important. The one thing that I think that has improved demonstrably is my written documentation because the amount of hours and years of my life that I've spent now through this work reviewing clinical documentation where I'm just there and I'm just like... What is going on? I say, the really awful thing is when it doesn't say anything. It's often, it's not that it's incriminating or damning or you know, my goodness, often it's just a barren of detail. That often is the thing that I'm... and often my opinion is based on the well actually there's limited information here so I then have to spend the majority of my time going well if this happened then... and then if this happened and then if this... I have to do lots of that hypothetical because ultimately I'm not given a lot of the... know often the detail is want. markjnicol: Yeah. So I speak to obviously a lot of experts that in the medical profession, a lot of them work for the NHS. And one of things that, you know, that they would all kind of agree on, I hope, a lot of them have told me this, is that by being an expert witness has made them a better clinician. James Brogan: Absolutely. markjnicol: So for you, has it changed your approach with your students and how you're teaching them and what you're teaching them about the profession? James Brogan: Yes, no, certainly has. And I think being an educator as well, you one of the things that, you know, I'm often asked is, James, you you bang on about being passionate and being a patient advocate and all this other stuff, but actually the majority of your time now is in a non-patient facing role, in an academic role, or in a strategic leadership role, you know, advising. governments and inputting into policy and why and you know why is that and you know and the short answer is well you know I go back to submit you know my my dad would often cite which would be you know fish from a man feeding for a day teach a man to fish feed him for a lifetime yeah and Actually, taking that one half a step back in terms of not just fully looking at clinical practice has allowed me to really stop, reflect, view other people's practice. Teaching people how to do stuff is a really great way of really understanding a subject yourself. But actually doing the expert witness stuff is really complementary to that as well because it's going, actually, I am seeing lots and lots of... cases and the question here is around, you know, on the face of it you might go, gosh this is really looks really awful and bad and whatever, but when you really dig into it and you go, well yeah, ultimately the end outcome wasn't great, but how did the clinician arrive at that decision? And providing I can go, well I can see how they got there or ballpark how they got there and I go, given all of that, yeah that's probably reasonable, then that is reasonable. And actually, you know, actually, did they make some mistakes or did they go, you know, I think it is this condition and they've got it completely wrong? Yes. But could they reasonably have held that belief? Well, absolutely. You know, that's the thing I think that is most, the thing that I take the most in terms of that, you know, the question of reasonableness and, you know, having understood and gone through the process with lots of different cases across all different jurisdictions. I travel around and I'm versed in the different jurisdictions and the different requirements and stuff. Yeah, I think it really has. I'd like to think so. I'd like to think that I take stuff from that and then share that because there is no point in holding on to it. If you've got a good idea, there is no point in holding onto knowledge. We need to share it with people. We need to share our understandings and we need to share our viewpoints of the world. Because ultimately, all that can do is improve the care that we give to our patients. markjnicol: So how do you switch off at the end of the day? mean, are you capable of switching off at the end of the day? James Brogan: Erm, yeah, mean, it depends what you define as switching off I suppose really. Erm, I... My younger James would look at James today and be like, God, you're so boring. When did you become almost sort cascaded? I remember, there's this thing, isn't it? like, at what point did you find excitement by chatting to your friends about where you can get free parking after six or what's the APR on their mortgage rate? It's like, I jest, obviously. No, I... I try to, I'm one of these people, unfortunately, I'm one of these really annoying people. I'll go, yeah, yeah, yeah, I'm going to have a really chilled out day today. And then by about half past 10 in the morning, I'm crawling the walls again. Come on, let's go. I'm going to go for a walk. I'm going go for a walk. I'm going to do that. Or I'm going to listen to a podcast or I'm going to, you know, for me, life is about learning, you know, and I just want to learn so much more about the world. and I'm branching out now more into more of the social sciences and I take pleasure in watching nature documentaries, I like listening to music, normally whilst I'm doing something, but yeah, love reading, I love reading, I love walking. tends to be fairly active stuff so my idea of a relaxing day is taking my paddleboard out down to the beach and you know going out for a paddle around the coast you know that that's so so my switching off is still being active if that makes sense I yeah I feel like I've got I've got a ball of energy that often I just need to I just need to keep releasing it at steady intervals so yeah markjnicol: So what's still left to achieve for you? James Brogan: the world's my oyster. mean, gosh, where do you want to start? You know, I don't know. think so. I need to get my study finished. And for me now, it's not so much around and it always has been, you what I'm trying to do now is craft a career. that has a great, that goes back to the core values that I said at the beginning, it's about a life of service. And whereas service historically looked like serving in an ambulance service, going to one patient at a time, you don't do that sort of, now service to me is, you know, sitting on the board of a journal, you know. promoting that journal and encouraging other people to put their papers in that we can then publish so that we're spreading new knowledge and you know the developing evidence base. That's that is service to the profession but also service to our patients. know whether that is you know I do it I have I'm now back involved with St John there was a time so I moved from England to Scotland and and unless St John ambulance in England I'm volunteering again for St John. Scotland but in a clinical oversight capacity which is great because I feel like I've come home a little bit because it's it's all part of the international order of St John which is which is great which is really nice it feels very homely whether that is through whether through I'm a fellow of the Royal Society of Arts whether through my membership of the Faculty of Remote Rural and Humanitarian Healthcare, whether it's through being with the Academy of Medical Educators, just trying to now disseminate. I've had lots of people that have given me opportunities and now I'm trying to turn that to go, how can I influence national policy? How can we do that? But also it's that piece around, I want to raise the tide so that all of our boats lift at the same time. that's now the opportunities that I'm seeking and the expert stuff is great because Again, I have impact with specific people and clients and cases, but also, hopefully, that is also part of that service in terms of being able to provide that expert opinion to the court that requires that when they're having to make a determination around whether that is a tribunal hearing from a professional regulatory point of view, whether that is a civil action, a criminal action, coronial fatal accident investigation. I've done all of these things and continue to do that. It's about actually giving back. That's the bit I get the most satisfaction from is that service piece. markjnicol: Yeah, that's brilliant. James, thank you so much for today. Taking up a James Brogan: You're welcome. markjnicol: huge chunk of your time this morning. But James Brogan: That's fine. Thank you. markjnicol: I really appreciate the talk and obviously finding out a lot more about you and what you do. So yeah, thank you. James Brogan: Thank you, it's been fab.