Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Electric Sting of the Scorpion: Abarth 500e—Pure Fun, Zero Sense
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the deep dive. Today we are strapping ourselves
- 0:13into something. Well, something that's loud,
- 0:15tiny, and honestly, just wonderfully ridiculous.
- 0:18The new Abarth 500 E. And it really is ridiculous
- 0:22because if you think about the formula for a small city EV.
- 0:25Right. It's supposed to be quiet
- 0:27efficient, you know, maximize its range.
- 0:29Exactly. Those are the logical, sensible
- 0:32pillars the whole market is built on.
- 0:34But the Abarth 500 E it doesn't just ignore them, it actively
- 0:39demolishes them. It's a self-described pocket
- 0:41rocket, and it's built for, and I'm quoting here, cure distilled
- 0:45and hardcore fun. And that single minded pursuit
- 0:48of fun leads to some truly bizarre, I mean really
- 0:51counterintuitive design choices it.
- 0:53Feels like a car that rejects the whole spreadsheet logic of
- 0:562024 and just dives head first into emotional excess.
- 1:00Which sets up the central question for this deep dive,
- 1:02right? Yeah.
- 1:02Why take a perfectly rational car like the Fiat 500 E and
- 1:06deliberately engineer it into something so irrational?
- 1:08OK, so let's unpack that. What was the core mission here?
- 1:11Well, it wasn't about range. Fiat and Abarth boss Olivier
- 1:15Francois was pretty clear. He said performance made us do
- 1:18it. Better acceleration, better
- 1:21handling, more fun. So the whole point was just to
- 1:24be more thrilling than the old gas powered.
- 1:26One, that was the entire justification.
- 1:28But isn't sacrificing range in a small EVI mean isn't that just a
- 1:32massive risk? Most buyers care about that more
- 1:35than anything. They do, but Abarth reframed
- 1:38what performance means. They just threw the long
- 1:40distance handbook out the window.
- 1:42And decided to build a sprinter, not a marathon runner.
- 1:45Exactly. They prioritized immediate
- 1:47responsiveness to get up and go. So what does that look like on
- 1:51paper? How much faster is it?
- 1:52Well. They upgraded the motor to 113
- 1:54kilowatts, so the headline figure is pretty good.
- 1:56Zero to 62 in seven seconds flat.
- 1:59That's a full 2 seconds quicker than the standard Fiat 500 EA.
- 2:03Real edge off the line. But here's where it gets really
- 2:05interesting, isn't it? Because this speed isn't about
- 2:08setting highway records, no. Not at all.
- 2:10This car is explicitly tuned for the city for traffic.
- 2:15And that's where you see the biggest difference compared to
- 2:17the petrol version, right at low speeds.
- 2:19This is where the EV platform just shines.
- 2:22The instant torque is devastatingly effective.
- 2:25It's a full second faster from 12 to 25 mph than the old petrol
- 2:31Albarth 695. Which is exactly the kind of
- 2:34burst you need in a dense city. Oh, and listen to this To go
- 2:38from 25 to 38 mph, it takes just 1 1/2 seconds.
- 2:42Wow, that's over a second quicker than its fossil fueled
- 2:45sibling. So they absolutely succeeded.
- 2:48They engineered the most exhilarating short burst City
- 2:50car in the segment. But when you focus so hard on
- 2:53one thing, you create trade-offs.
- 2:55Extreme trade-offs. And that brings us to the two
- 2:58big controversies with this car, the ride and the sound.
- 3:03Let's start with the ride. OK, so the goal was to get what
- 3:06they called a genuine cart like feel.
- 3:08Which meant they had to completely transform the chassis
- 3:10from the comfortable, easygoing Fiat 500.
- 3:13They really went all in, longer wheelbase, wider track and much
- 3:17much stiffer springs all for stability.
- 3:20So it's great in the corners, I assume flat, predictable.
- 3:23Superb. But here's the downside.
- 3:25The daily driver compromises. Huge.
- 3:28The sources all said the ride is just too stiff as a daily.
- 3:31It is, and there was 1 observation that really stood
- 3:34out. It's not just uncomfortable, it
- 3:36actually disrupts your driving. This is the part where it
- 3:39bounces so hard your foot comes off the accelerator.
- 3:41Exactly that. It's such a specific and frankly
- 3:44an alarming piece of feedback. It's like the car is warning
- 3:48you. I am not a comfort car.
- 3:50It's for enthusiasts who will accept physical jolts for that
- 3:53perfect handling response. No question.
- 3:56OK, so moving from the stiff bounce to the loud roar, we have
- 4:00to talk about the sacrilege of a silent Abarth.
- 4:03It was an existential crisis for them.
- 4:05The brand's DNA is that famous and unmistakable.
- 4:08Abarth Roar. Silence just wasn't an option.
- 4:11So they decided to solve the problem of silence.
- 4:14And they invested in incredible, almost unbelievable amount of
- 4:17time into it. We're talking 6000 hours. 6000
- 4:21hours to engineer an optional feature they call the sound
- 4:24generator. The cost of those engineering
- 4:26hours alone it just absurd. For manufactured noise.
- 4:30It tells you everything about how much they value that
- 4:32heritage. The result is an external
- 4:35speaker that plays a synthesized version of the old petrol
- 4:38exhaust note. And it even greets you with a
- 4:41guitar noise when you turn it on.
- 4:42It's a very intentional attempt to, you know, digitally recreate
- 4:47the soul that the physics of an EV took away.
- 4:50But does it actually work? Does it feel real?
- 4:53That's what's so fascinating. The reaction was completely
- 4:55divided. Reviewers called it an acquired
- 4:58taste. That's putting it mildly, I
- 5:00think. One reviewer just said it
- 5:01bluntly. It's not sporty and does nothing
- 5:04to enhance the driving experience whatsoever.
- 5:06So it's a digital ghost. An impressive technical
- 5:09achievement, maybe, but a spiritual failure?
- 5:11For many, yes. Thankfully, you can turn it off
- 5:14for your own sanity and probably your neighbors.
- 5:16A very necessary feature. And if you connect this
- 5:18obsession with heritage and these extreme trade-offs to the
- 5:21bigger picture, you realize this car is carrying a ton of
- 5:25historical baggage. The legacy of Fiat itself?
- 5:28Exactly. This isn't just a machine, it's
- 5:31tied into Italy's national story.
- 5:33Absolutely. The original Fiat 500 was a
- 5:35symbol of Italy's post war rebirth.
- 5:38It put the country back on wheels.
- 5:40The sources call it a vessel for memory.
- 5:43And that deep national connection created some deep
- 5:45structural problems for the company down the line.
- 5:49For years, Fiat was under immense pressure from the
- 5:51government not to layoff workers.
- 5:54So it was almost part of the state's welfare system.
- 5:57In a way, yes. And that really limited their
- 5:59agility. While competitors in Germany and
- 6:01Japan were streamlining, Fiat was carrying thousands of extra
- 6:05workers. Which brings us to today.
- 6:08Why is manufacturing in Italy so challenging that it leads to
- 6:12this this eye watering price tag on the Abarth?
- 6:16Well, the legacy labor costs are part of it, but the bigger issue
- 6:19now is energy. Italy has some of the highest
- 6:21industrial electricity prices in all of Europe.
- 6:24Why so high? They don't have many domestic
- 6:26fuel sources. They're heavily reliant on
- 6:28imported natural gas, which makes their factories incredibly
- 6:31vulnerable to price shocks. So moving production abroad
- 6:34wasn't a choice, it was a necessity for survival.
- 6:37It was a cold, hard necessity. So this little Abarth 5 Hundredy
- 6:41arrives carrying all of that the need to be modern, the need to
- 6:45cling to a noisy heritage and a price tag that reflects decades
- 6:49of industrial challenges. Precisely.
- 6:52And that's why when you look at it logically, the analysis is
- 6:55brutal. OK, so let's do it.
- 6:57Let's evaluate it with that spreadsheet driven mindset.
- 7:00First up, price. Universally described as eye
- 7:03watering. And the number in the.
- 7:05UK it starts at over £34,000. It goes all the way up to 41,000
- 7:09for the convertible. For a tiny City car with huge
- 7:12compromises, OK, next range. The official WLTP number is
- 7:17between 158 and 164 miles. Which already isn't great and in
- 7:22the real world. On the motorway, you're looking
- 7:23at a paltry 120 miles. That's that's performance from
- 7:27five years ago. And what about practicality?
- 7:29Barely exists. The boot is a tiny 185 liters
- 7:33and the back seats useless for anyone as one source put it
- 7:36older than about 10 and. To top it all off, a subpar
- 7:39warranty the. Three-year warranty.
- 7:40It just isn't cricket, as they say for a premium car in 2024.
- 7:44So what does this all mean? The list of flaws is huge.
- 7:48It's long if you use your head. If you look at the numbers, you
- 7:52simply should not buy this car. And yet critics love it.
- 7:55They do because it was never meant to be rational.
- 7:58It's only purpose is entertainment.
- 8:00It's the ultimate emotional purchase.
- 8:02That's the whole story. The emotional capture is total.
- 8:05One review put it perfectly. To concentrate on its many flaws
- 8:10is to misunderstand its main purpose, to entertain and put a
- 8:14smile on your face. And on that front, it delivers.
- 8:16It delivers more smiles per mile than anything else in the
- 8:19sector. It's a car bought with the
- 8:21heart, not the head. What a fascinating bundle of
- 8:24contradictions. It's a perfect vehicle for this
- 8:26uncertain electric future, isn't it?
- 8:29Blending silent instant torque with this desperate cling to a
- 8:32noisy past. It really is.
- 8:34But let's look forward for a second.
- 8:35We talked about all that industrial baggage, especially
- 8:37the high energy costs. Is there any way out of that for
- 8:40Italy? There is, and this is the real
- 8:42source of optimism in the story. It's the development of
- 8:45photovoltaics, solar power a. Potential game changer.
- 8:49A huge one. If Italy can transition its
- 8:52industry to domestically generated solar, it solves that
- 8:56decades old problem of high energy costs.
- 8:58And that would make Italian manufacturing competitive again.
- 9:01It would be like a 21st century version of the post war rebirth
- 9:05the original 500 represented. Exactly, and the Barth 500 E,
- 9:09for all its flaws and its digital roar, proves that the
- 9:12Italian spirit of fun and style and passion can endure.
- 9:16It's just that smiles per mile might just be the most important
- 9:19metric after all. I think it might be.
- 9:22That's a wonderful thought to end on.
- 9:24You now know everything about the bizarre, brilliant and
- 9:27deeply flawed Abarth 500. Thank you for diving deep into
- 9:31the sources with us today. It was a pleasure to unpack this
- 9:34one. Such a complicated story of
- 9:35engineering and emotion. If you enjoyed this journey, be
- 9:38sure to follow the channel so you don't miss the next
- 9:40fascinating story we unpacked together, Grazi para vecchi del
- 9:44Tempo.