Latest / The Sky This Week / Tiny Whirlpools on the Sun
Transcript
- 0:08Along the edge of a bright patch on the sun,
- 0:11a little curl develops. Nearby, another takes
- 0:13shape. The pattern resembles a row of waves beginning
- 0:16to break, except the shoreline is made of hot
- 0:19solar material, and the smallest details are
- 0:21only about 20 kilometers across. Small, in this
- 0:25story, is a word that needs a little room. These
- 0:27are real telescope observations released with
- 0:30a study in August of 2026. They give us a new
- 0:33view of activity hidden inside the familiar face
- 0:36of our nearest star. I'm TM Ng, and this is a
- 0:39short special from Under the Same Sky. Today,
- 0:41we're following those tiny curls to a much larger
- 0:43question. How does motion on the sun help rearrange
- 0:46its magnetic field? We're going to explore the
- 0:49observatory's published pictures. But please
- 0:51don't look at the sun or point a camera, binoculars,
- 0:54or telescope toward it to follow along. This
- 0:56one's an episode for the screen and the imagination.
- 1:04First, we're going to need to find our footing.
- 1:06Although there's nowhere here to stand. The sun
- 1:09has no solid surface. The bright layer we usually
- 1:12call its surface is the photosphere. That's the
- 1:14part that supplies most of its visible light.
- 1:16The sun is made of plasma, which is extremely
- 1:18hot material containing electrically charged
- 1:21particles. Those charges matter because the material
- 1:24and the sun's magnetic field can influence one
- 1:26another. Close views of the photosphere reveal
- 1:29a crowded pattern of cells called granules. Hot
- 1:32material rises, spreads out, cools, and sinks
- 1:35again. The cells are roughly 500 -2000 kilometers
- 1:38across. What looks like a texture in a photograph
- 1:41is the visible result of material continuously
- 1:44moving heat outward. Now follow a granule to
- 1:47an edge beside a concentration of a magnetic
- 1:49field? That boundary is where the new observations
- 1:52become especially interesting. Structures that
- 1:54once blurred all together resolve into delicate
- 1:57curls and ridges. I'm going to apologize in advance
- 2:00because I always screw names up even after I
- 2:02research how to pronounce them. Cut me some slack
- 2:04here. The telescope responsible is the National
- 2:07Science Foundation's Daniel K. Inui Solar Telescope.
- 2:11That's on the Hawaiian island of Maui. Its 4
- 2:14-meter aperture makes it the world's largest
- 2:16solar telescope. A big telescope still has to
- 2:20contend with our own atmosphere. Moving air bends
- 2:22the incoming light and smears fine detail. Inui
- 2:25uses adaptive optics, a system that rapidly adjusts
- 2:29a mirror's shape to counter that distortion.
- 2:31Careful image reconstruction helps recover the
- 2:34detail afterward. For this study, observations
- 2:36made on April 14, 2025 resolved features about
- 2:4019 kilometers across in a small region near a
- 2:43sunspot. It took that combination of scale and
- 2:46sharpness to make the little curls available
- 2:48for study. But recognizing a shape is only the
- 2:51beginning. What makes it curl? There's a clue
- 2:56to this much closer to home. Occasionally, clouds
- 2:59form a row of curling crests that look uncannily
- 3:01like waves drawn by an illustrator. These are
- 3:04called Kelvin -Helmholtz clouds. They can form
- 3:07when one layer of air moves faster than a neighboring
- 3:09layer. The difference in speed creates shear.
- 3:13A small disturbance at the boundary can grow
- 3:15and roll over into a curl. The important ingredient
- 3:18is that difference in motion. Two layers don't
- 3:21have to race in opposite directions. Moving in
- 3:24the same direction at different speeds can provide
- 3:26shear too. The broader process is called the
- 3:29Kelvin -Helmholtz instability. That's named after
- 3:31the scientists associated with its early description.
- 3:34An instability is a situation in which a small
- 3:37disturbance can grow instead of fading away.
- 3:40That gives the solar pictures an intriguing possibility.
- 3:43Perhaps those curled boundaries are revealing
- 3:45the same family of fluid behavior in a very different
- 3:48setting. The sun adds intense heat and magnetic
- 3:51fields to the problem. So a resemblance to clouds
- 3:54cannot settle the question by itself. Researchers
- 3:56compared the observations with a physics -based
- 3:58computer simulation of the solar surface. The
- 4:01simulation produced similar structures and supplied
- 4:03something the images did not directly measure,
- 4:05the sideways flow of plasma along the boundaries.
- 4:08That distinction matters. The telescope recorded
- 4:11changing brightness patterns. The simulated flows
- 4:14helped explain how those patterns could develop.
- 4:16Agreement between the two strengthens the identification,
- 4:19while each still tells us a different part of
- 4:22the story. Their behavior also agreed with what
- 4:24instability theory predicts. This was the first
- 4:27identification of this instability in the photosphere.
- 4:31Related behavior had already been studied higher
- 4:33in the solar atmosphere. The discovery brings
- 4:36a familiar piece of physics into view in a place
- 4:38where it had been difficult to test. A feature
- 4:4320 kilometers across would be quite an event
- 4:45in our neighborhood. Beside a star, it almost
- 4:48disappears. Why should motion on such small scales
- 4:51matter? Because a magnetic field can store energy.
- 4:54When the field's arrangement changes through
- 4:56a process called magnetic reconnection, some
- 4:58of that energy can heat plasma and accelerate
- 5:00it. That process is important in solar eruptions.
- 5:04Scientists often draw a magnetic field as lines.
- 5:06The lines show its direction and structure. They
- 5:09aren't physical strings lying across the sun.
- 5:11Moving plasma can help distort the field, changing
- 5:14the energy stored in it. The newly observed vortices
- 5:16offer a possible way to stir and deform magnetic
- 5:19regions on very small scales. Researchers are
- 5:22investigating whether such motions help build
- 5:24up magnetic energy and mix material across those
- 5:27boundaries. One reason that possibly attracts
- 5:30attention is the sun's outer atmosphere, the
- 5:32corona. The photosphere is around 5 ,500 degrees
- 5:35Celsius. The corona reaches temperatures of a
- 5:38million degrees or more. How energy reaches and
- 5:41heats that outer atmosphere remains a major solar
- 5:44physics question. These images do not show that
- 5:47the tiny vortices supply all that heat. They
- 5:50reveal a process that could contribute to the
- 5:52larger chain of events. Now there's still work
- 5:54to be done on following the energy through that
- 5:56chain. and measuring how much arrives where.
- 5:59There is also a limit built into the observation
- 6:01itself. The study followed one small patch for
- 6:04about three minutes. Many curls in that patch
- 6:07make a compelling result, but they are not a
- 6:09count of every swirl across the entire sun. That
- 6:13leaves an excellent question. How common is this
- 6:15behavior in different solar environments? And
- 6:18how much does it matter there? A telescope has
- 6:20made the question more precise. Now researchers
- 6:22have something they can look for, compare, and
- 6:25test. This is the part of the episode where I
- 6:36want to show some appreciation and gratitude.
- 6:39I need to thank each and every one of you for
- 6:41taking time out of your busy day to listen to
- 6:44The Sky This Week or the Under the Same Sky episodes.
- 6:47Without you, this would not be possible. I mean,
- 6:50if I'm the only one listening to my podcast,
- 6:52it's kind of pointless, right? If you would like
- 6:54to support the podcast directly, head on over
- 6:56to Patreon and become a friend of the show. You
- 6:58can listen completely ad -free and it's only
- 7:00$3 a month. The link is in the show notes. I
- 7:03have a ton of content on the way, so saddle up.
- 7:06Otherwise, you can feel free to leave me a voicemail.
- 7:08That link will be in the show notes as well.
- 7:10Let me know your thoughts on any of the topics
- 7:12I've discussed, make some topic suggestions,
- 7:14or just tell me how boring I am. Whatever the
- 7:17case, I would love to hear from you. Now let's
- 7:19get back to the show. For Through the Lens today,
- 7:25we're going to be borrowing the observatory's
- 7:26view. These tiny structures are beyond an ordinary
- 7:29camera. There's no reason to turn this story
- 7:31into a risky attempt to photograph the sun. For
- 7:34any solar observing on another occasion, get
- 7:36expert guidance and use equipment specifically
- 7:38designed and correctly filtered for the job.
- 7:41Eclipse glasses do not make it safe to look through
- 7:43an unfiltered camera, telescope, or binoculars.
- 7:47Concentrated sunlight can damage the glass and
- 7:49seriously injure your eyes. For this micro assignment,
- 7:52open the official observation movie linked in
- 7:54the episode notes. Choose one small boundary
- 7:56and watch how its shape changes. Pause, return
- 7:59to the beginning, and follow that same boundary
- 8:01again. Can you keep track of one curl as it develops,
- 8:05or does it become difficult to distinguish from
- 8:07its neighbors? You don't need to calculate a
- 8:09speed. The useful experience is discovering how
- 8:12much care it takes to follow even one feature.
- 8:14A still picture gives you a shape. A sequence
- 8:17is going to ask you to decide whether you're
- 8:19following the same shape through time. Then watch
- 8:22the companion comparison with the simulation.
- 8:24Check the labels so you know which view is observed
- 8:27and which was calculated. Pick one similarity
- 8:30you can describe, and one thing the simulation
- 8:32shows that the telescope image alone cannot tell
- 8:35you. If you have no screen handy, that's perfectly
- 8:37fine. Just keep this question for later. What
- 8:40would I need to measure before I could say how
- 8:42that little curl works? The sun has been lighting
- 8:45our days all along, and now, at the edge of a
- 8:48patch in a remarkably sharp picture, we can follow
- 8:51a few more of its movements. And a boundary that
- 8:53used to blur into the background has become a
- 8:55place worth watching. Thank you for watching
- 8:58this feature short. I'm Tia Ming, and this has
- 9:00been Under the Same Sky. Stay curious, my friends,
- 9:03and remember, this planet is one sky above two
- 9:06hemispheres with endless opportunities to photograph.
- 9:09Until next week, keep looking up, my fellow stargazers.