Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 3)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, des Urban listeners. This is chapter three in our deep dive on
- 0:04the Dugger family with my best friend and co host on the podcast, amberto
- 0:09Castaneta, who has a great shirt on psychology in Seattle. So welcome to
- 0:14the podcast. Let's get into it. What do you say, Berto,
- 0:16Let's do it. This is the psychology and style of podcast Dame your host
- 0:19doctor Kirkana. I'm a therapist and a professor. My name is and I
- 0:23train in the ways of the jedde So timeline. This is the chapter for
- 0:28the timeline. Let's begin at the beginning. Nineteen eighty four, Jim,
- 0:32Bob and Michelle are married just weeks after Michelle's high school graduation. Not a
- 0:38crime, Plenty of people get married. My parents got married when they were
- 0:41nineteen, but you know, notable, notable on some level. Nineteen eighty
- 0:46eight, skipping ahead of four years, Josh was born, the first child
- 0:50of nineteen eventual children, not counting miscarriages. Michelle was on the pill prior
- 0:57to this, went off the pill to get pregnant with Josh. After Josh
- 1:02was born, she went back on the pill. So pretty common American story
- 1:06there. You have a couple that is managing their family, you know,
- 1:11family planning. And she became pregnant again though while she was on the pill,
- 1:17which happens sometimes. Sometimes it's because of just the way hormones work and
- 1:22you can't guarantee things, or you didn't take the pill correctly or something,
- 1:26you know, who knows. But she got pregnant again, and one of
- 1:30the things in my notes, so I'm like, do you think Jim Bob
- 1:32might have messed with the pill, And because you know, you can change
- 1:34the placebo at or something, I don't think so. Yeah, it's just
- 1:38the accidents will happen. Yeah. So she miscarried though, which was a
- 1:44very difficult moment. First. So let's let's talk about miscarriage trauma. Berto.
- 1:51You know, for those of you who have been with me a long
- 1:53time, you know that I have an unfinished manuscript on grief. I've been
- 1:57writing this book on grief, and a good portion of is on what we
- 2:01call disenfranchised grief, which is this term meaning that there are certain losses in
- 2:07life that we feel natural grief around, and it could be just as difficult
- 2:13as any other loss, but the culture doesn't acknowledge it or doesn't allow individuals
- 2:20to process it. Normally, generally all losses are disenfranchised, but some are,
- 2:25particularly one being those who go through miscarriage. And it's not just the
- 2:32pregnant person going through every you know, it's potentially the spouse and everyone else
- 2:38in the family. So you know, it's hard. And not only is
- 2:42it losing a child, because you as soon as you learn that you're pregnant
- 2:46and you're planning having the child, you start thinking of the future and you
- 2:50start having a connection with that, with that creature. So not only is
- 2:55that loss just horrific, right, just the experience of losing a child.
- 3:00I mean everyone understands that if, for example, you got a five year
- 3:04old who had leukemia and died, that that is devastating. Well, it
- 3:07can be very similar to having an unborn child die. It can be really
- 3:13yea and things. So no one talks about this, like, no one
- 3:16says, hey, you might have a miscarriage, Like that's not a thing
- 3:20anyone ever mentions. So, you know, you go through it and you
- 3:25think, I'm just gonna have a baby here, and then if a miscarriage
- 3:29happens, it's like did I do something wrong? Why are we? Oh?
- 3:32We messed up, like, where did we mess up? We gotta
- 3:36go and review everything we've done because this isn't supposed to happen, right,
- 3:38Or is there something wrong with my body? You know? Yeah? Did
- 3:43I do something wrong? Did I exercise too much? Did I not eat
- 3:46the right way? And it's an absolute loss? Yeah, And I think
- 3:50that might specifically even play a role with Michelle. I don't know. But
- 3:53but so, not only is it a loss of a child, which is
- 3:57horrific, right and difficult, but also sometimes the physical experience of having a
- 4:02miscarriage can be very difficult, right. There can be a lot of you
- 4:06know, we don't go into details on the different experiences, but very traumatic.
- 4:11But yeah, I mean it can be. Well, you don't have
- 4:15to think too hard about what it could be like to have a miscarriage to
- 4:17know that it can be physically extremely difficult. Not only obviously painful and scary,
- 4:23but it can be traumatizing, graphic in terms of how it plays out.
- 4:29And it's been estimated that fifty percent of all women have experienced a miscarriage
- 4:34at some point in their life. Right, So this isn't a rare thing,
- 4:39even though it's never talked about, right, yeah, And I think
- 4:43I think part of it is that it's like you don't want to jinx it
- 4:46or it's taboo or whatever. It's like you're doing the opposite then, because
- 4:49if you don't talk about it, if you don't prepare people for it,
- 4:51then it it's that much more devastating and secret and you don't want to talk
- 4:56about That's the other thing. Like if you hadn't announced the pregnancy and it
- 4:59happens, it's bad. If you'd announced the pregnancy and it happens, it's
- 5:01bad. If it's the first time you're trying to have a child, you
- 5:04might think you'll never be able to have a child. Yeah, if it's
- 5:08you know it, imagine if we extended this beyond birth right that well,
- 5:13I don't want to tell anyone that I have a child because what if the
- 5:15child develops some sort of early life terminal illness and they die. So I'm
- 5:21gonna not tell anyone that I have a young child at home going to school
- 5:26at times? Because now, why do people that, Well, it's because
- 5:29our society is so weird about death and anything other than the happy stories.
- 5:35The outcomes are fine, we don't discuss the alternatives. Yeah, you'll you'll
- 5:41experience people will get upset at you. If you talk about a difficult you
- 5:45know, you go to a dinner party and you bring up your miscarriage that
- 5:48happened recently or five years ago, people would be I would imagine most people
- 5:53would be like, that's rude that they brought that up. You can't bring
- 5:57up sad stories. By the way, this is one of the reasons since
- 6:00we can't have a reasonable rational conversation around abortion, for example, because the
- 6:04expectations like no happy outcomes, that's the only thing we'll tolerate here, right,
- 6:10But sometimes they're not happy outcomes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So
- 6:15if half of all women, according to one study, have experienced a miscarriage
- 6:18at some point in their life, which is surprising, I'm guessing to a
- 6:23lot of people, you'd think, oh, it's pretty rare. No,
- 6:26it happens frequently all the time. Yeah, And I think this study was
- 6:29actually looking at miscarriages that people noticed, because there's also a whole set of
- 6:32miscarriages that are pre even someone knowing that they're they're pregnant. Right. Well,
- 6:39one interesting thing is like if you rewind the clock one hundred years or
- 6:42maybe even only sixty years or something. Losing kids that were young was very
- 6:46common, and it was of course traumatic, but it was a thing.
- 6:51It's like, oh yeah, like I remember my grandma lost a child,
- 6:56you know, like almost everyone I knew from that generation. And I'm not
- 7:00talking about a miscarriage. I'm talking about like, oh yeah, they were
- 7:01two, they were five. There was because there was more disease, there
- 7:04was more childhood illness. Once that I was reading about the Victorian age in
- 7:10England is that they frequently cite that the average mortality age was like forty but
- 7:15that's only because they include all the deaths prior to five years old. If
- 7:19you survived after five, you actually had a good chance to get to your
- 7:23seventies midst Right. It's a huge myth that I grew up thinking that the
- 7:29typical lifespan was forty years. But that's because of this stat right. But
- 7:33but you were actually pretty likely to die within the first five years. But
- 7:38nowadays we're not familiar with that, right, And I think we sort of
- 7:42like took it to this other extreme, like, I mean, it still
- 7:44happens and it's still total disenfranchised or ignored or so we kind of took it
- 7:47to this other extreme, which is like oh having Yeah, you get pregnant,
- 7:50you have a baby. It just works, right, and never mind
- 7:54the shame and disenfranchisement of people having the experience of having a hard time getting
- 7:59pregnant. Right, although that's getting a little better. Yeah, I know,
- 8:03I know several couples that are friends of mine who have to go through
- 8:07the therapy stuff, the all the signs stuff to make it happen, right,
- 8:11you know. Yeah, so uh, and then all the internalized shame.
- 8:16This is like I'm not a real woman or I'm not a real man,
- 8:18or I'm not a real human because my body isn't working the way that
- 8:24it's depicted in culture. So uh. Specifically, though, what will happen,
- 8:28according to research, is that many parents report that friends and family will
- 8:33say after a miscarriage, if the individual feels safe enough to disclose it,
- 8:37that people will say, well, yeah, well you know, you can
- 8:39have another you can have another kid. So just imagine that that your five
- 8:43year old child dies and people are like, oh, yeah, well you
- 8:46know you can have another one renner at al In two thousand, your two
- 8:50thousand study participants read vignettes of a miscarriage, And there's a lot of findings,
- 8:56but one of them was that eighty seven percent of the responses were by
- 9:01the participants. They were asked like, how would you respond to this friend
- 9:03or family member telling you that they went through a miscarriage. Eighty seven percent,
- 9:07So, you know, a vast majority of the responses were included an
- 9:11attempt to minimize the importance of the loss, such as I would you know,
- 9:16someone says, I would tell her that she can try again, and
- 9:20it's this attempt at trying to help. But because there's no sophistication around the
- 9:26understanding of the experience, people have difficulty with true empathy because they don't really
- 9:31understand what's happening because it's never talked about. You know, when someone says,
- 9:35well, you know, you can try again, it'll be very hurtful
- 9:39potentially, right, But it's not because people are inherently It's sort of like
- 9:43when you have a death in your family, like your one of your parents
- 9:46dies and people are just like, well, you know, thoughts and prayers.
- 9:50It's not because people don't care. It's because there's no protocol. You
- 9:54know, everything in our culture is protocolized. When you go to the restaurant
- 9:58and a waitress comes up to your comes up to your table. In the
- 10:00United States, there's a whole procedure. Everyone understands. There's a you know,
- 10:03they bring out the water and then they say how you doing and can
- 10:07I get you a drink? And they're bringing the menus. You know,
- 10:09there's a whole system there. Well, when it comes to grief, if
- 10:13you have a system, then people know where to slot in. They know
- 10:18their role. Like I'm really closest person. That means that I'm able to
- 10:22do this. I don't know if that's what I can do, but I
- 10:24can test that out. Well, I'm sort of mid tier closeness, So
- 10:26that means that I should offer this, and not because I should, but
- 10:30because I know what I want and I also know what is typical and I
- 10:35know what's expected, and I know what the person probably wants me to do.
- 10:39Whereas when you have no protocol, then everyone runs for the hills.
- 10:41Dude, that's right. We only learn again the happy positive outcome protocols.
- 10:46Someone comes to you and says, Dude, I just passed my bar exam,
- 10:50or I just closed on the house I was trying to buy. We
- 10:54have a protocol. Oh yeah, that's awesome, high five, Let's have
- 10:56a drink, let's go celebrate. It's well. And also with the house,
- 11:00for example, let me see pictures totally. And when we having our
- 11:03houseworking party, and then when you have the house swarrying party, you bring
- 11:05a little thing and you go, oh my god, those draperies, draperies,
- 11:11those drapes are great, or this is a really nice you know what
- 11:15things to say that there's so much light in this room. Like, but
- 11:18we're well trained. When it's like we lost the house, what do you
- 11:20say, Oh, that's I'm sorry to hear. You can get another one.
- 11:24You can always get another house. Well, that's rude that you're bringing
- 11:26a fat app bum er up geez morbid or something, you know, And
- 11:30that's just like, you know, the tip of the iceberg. Like certainly,
- 11:33I actually try to force myself when someone posts something really sad or tragic
- 11:37on Facebook, I force myself to if I'm gonna write something like I try
- 11:43to write something that I can pass to them or something. So as an
- 11:48example, I usually I usually try to talk about like moments that we need
- 11:52to enjoy because that's the only thing we have, Like so moments of like
- 11:56remembering special moments that we had, you know, like I'll write something special
- 12:01if I had a memory with them. Of course, all because I've always
- 12:03felt that like either I shouldn't say anything because just like, oh, that's
- 12:07horrible to hear it. It depends, you know, it depends. Like
- 12:11for me, I don't like That's part of why I don't. I never
- 12:13post news, let's say, news on Facebook because responses like that would do
- 12:18nothing for me, you know, in fact, it would almost only add
- 12:22noise to my life, like yeah, whereas whereas like if if I actually
- 12:26and we talked about this, like That's part of the reason why I think
- 12:28I never used to tell people, even my closest friends, when I had
- 12:33health emergencies, right or when I had really bad problems, because not only
- 12:37am I not trained without what to do when someone tells me that, but
- 12:41I don't know what to do when I'm in it and I and someone's gonna
- 12:43respond to it, right, no one knows what to do, so everyone
- 12:46just appoints, and meanwhile everyone suffers, particularly the person going through the loss,
- 12:50because they're not able to you know, grief for most of the time,
- 12:56for most of us. Is a social experience, a social emotional experience.
- 13:00There's a there's a process to it. You inform people that you had
- 13:05this tragedy. They console you, they show empathy. You feel validated,
- 13:09you feel held. People might even do favors for you, like do your
- 13:16errands for you or something. They reminisce with you. They also are suffering
- 13:20too, is a thing, you know, so everyone is is, you
- 13:24know. That's why we have these traditions like the processional through the streets and
- 13:28then the burial and the crying and the wearing of the black You know,
- 13:33particular cultures will do this kind of thing. Those aren't traditions just because someone
- 13:37just made it up for no reason. It develops out of a culture,
- 13:39you know, for a reason, because it serves a very important social emotional
- 13:43experience. Anyway, So another thing from my manuscript. I actually looked at
- 13:50my manuscript and the bit on miscarriage a disenfranchised grief. I was reminded of
- 13:58a story of a friend mind lost a child just before birth, like like
- 14:01literally a day before or the day of, and she wanted to hold the
- 14:09child. The child was deceased, but she asked the hospital medical providers if
- 14:15she could hold the child, right, And so they said, of course.
- 14:18And so she's holding the child for a long time, and she asked
- 14:22her family to take a picture of her with the child, because she knew
- 14:28she would after handing over the child, she would probably never see the child
- 14:33again, right, And so she had a picture taken, and later she
- 14:37sent the picture to a few select friends. And I think I had this
- 14:41right. I'm not quite sure, but from my memory, she said that
- 14:45others thought it was uncouth in some way, that it was weird or something
- 14:50morbid or but you could absolutely imagine people thinking that, right. Yeah,
- 14:54well, like, for example, you know that trend that like a hundred
- 14:58years ago or whatever was take pictures of the kids and that and it was
- 15:03a thing to remember them or whatever. Yeah, people was it seems kind
- 15:07of gorrier horrific or horrific. People equate it with like your Jeffrey Dahmer or
- 15:11something, and you know, each of their own. If that's not what
- 15:16you want to do, but if that's what's going to help some people,
- 15:20then that's what's gonna help. You know. There are cultures who literally will
- 15:22dig up the bones of their lost loved one a year later and will do
- 15:28stuff with the bones. If you do that in United States people, it
- 15:31probably it's probably against the law. It's probably literally against the law. Yeah,
- 15:35And so in our culture in particular, we were just so phobic and
- 15:39backward about these ideas that it really disenfranchises people. So for Michelle Dugger who
- 15:48goes through this difficult experience, just it's difficult as is. But also and
- 15:54I don't I couldn't find any accounts of like how along she was, not
- 15:58that that necessarily matters, but you know, it does provide some context.
- 16:00But anyway, so it's a difficult thing. It could have been very physically
- 16:04difficult. It could have also been very physically painful or some who knows.
- 16:08But also just the emotional and the fact that it's so disenfranchised. I don't
- 16:12know. She didn't really talk about it. But you notice what ends up
- 16:15happening is they blame themselves, right, They're like Michelle and Jimbo, Right,
- 16:21what did we do wrong? Right? We must have done something wrong.
- 16:23We need to find the answer so this never happens again, right,
- 16:29Which was basically the I see whatever the religion, the system, the well,
- 16:37the pill, well the pill was the but but you can see I
- 16:41mean, but it was like the belief system wouldn't have You wouldn't have been
- 16:45on the pill if you would have been in the belief system, right,
- 16:47So if you go on the IBLP, yeah, then that of course there's
- 16:52no pill. Definitely don't want you barely have any No, you don't have
- 16:55contrasus. And I think that this just occurred to me. There's a pretty
- 17:00good possibility that a sizeable chunk of people that are attracted to IBLP or end
- 17:04up in it have a similar motivation to some people that end up in the
- 17:07military. There's it's not everyone, of course, but if you grew up
- 17:11with abuse, there's a lot of different ways to cope with it. And
- 17:12one of the ways is to tell yourself that you deserved it or and or
- 17:18even to participate in things that are self sabotaging or even self harming, right,
- 17:23not necessarily non suicidal self injury, but like putting yourself in harm's way
- 17:29because it's like, well, if you can't, if you can't beat them,
- 17:30join them kind of. And you develop this mindset when you're three,
- 17:34by the way, and so it benefests older so you can imagine for them
- 17:40and other people because I've seen this happen. I've treated clients who did this
- 17:42with the military. Again, not everyone in the military is like this,
- 17:45but somewhere where they go through that abuse and they give into it in terms
- 17:48of the schema, they surrender to that idea, and then as they start
- 17:53to think about a career or their adult life, they're thinking, you know,
- 17:57they're at this this why in the road where they can finally be free
- 18:02from authoritarianism and from harm. Right, But there's a part of this as
- 18:07well, but I'm worthless, I need someone to keep me in line.
- 18:10That's not a conscious thought necessarily. And so they are attracted to the military
- 18:15because they predict that it will abuse them in a sense or control them or
- 18:21take away their freedoms and so and I guess some people might even commit crimes.
- 18:25So that because some people are literally attracted to prison, they they they
- 18:27they want to go there consciously or subconsciously because of the path, the stability,
- 18:36you know, the routine. Anyway, So for some people, they
- 18:38might be attracted to IBLP in this way. And for Jim Bob Michelle,
- 18:42who knows there's there's no data along the designs, but you can imagine how
- 18:47they might shame themselves for the miscarriage or something wrong with me. That's very
- 18:51common, right, and I need to fix this, I need to punish
- 18:56myself. Well, I get both if I had joined and I stopped taking
- 19:02the pill, right right. Well, so I did know several people,
- 19:07I guess I've known several people throughout the years in uh, these kind of
- 19:11extreme religious environments who came to that religion after having some very very hard life
- 19:18problems like addiction, uh, having been abused, or having had you know,
- 19:25really hard knocks and things, because they found solace in the you know,
- 19:30like one of my relatives, for example, was living definitely a pretty
- 19:34hard life, pretty uh deviating from the norm, let's say, uh,
- 19:40and nowadays he's the most devout, reborn Christian you could possibly find. Yeah,
- 19:45it's a very common story where someone will grow up with trauma. Then
- 19:49they enter into addiction, which can be its own routine and its own cult,
- 19:55if you will, even if it's just you by yourself, there's a
- 19:57there's a system there. You're under someone else's control. You have a prescripted
- 20:02set of behaviors that you have to engage in. And then when these individuals,
- 20:07not all, but some when they get clean. I have seen a
- 20:08pattern anecdotally, and I think it might bear out in the research that they
- 20:14might go into the military. Like I said, they might join a cult
- 20:18like organization without really knowing it, or they might join they might engage in
- 20:22extreme sports. I have ever seen this before, Yeah, like where they
- 20:26become decathlon or iron man. Yeah, because it's a spiritual pursuit as well.
- 20:32Yeah, right, you know, it gives its structures healthy. But
- 20:36actually I have another friend, sorry, I'm another friend who in college was
- 20:41one of the most debauchroous party animals, etc. And then became an extreme
- 20:47ironman competitor, and his life became the most regimented thing, to the point
- 20:52where we are no longer friends because he never had time for friendships anymore.
- 20:56Yeah, right now, it could be healthy. It could be It could
- 21:02be slightly unhealthy, but much better than the addiction. Right. It keeps
- 21:06them at bay, keeps their addiction at bay, right because they have a
- 21:08routine, they know what they're doing, and they with that regiment sometimes like
- 21:14you can't even think about certain kinds of foods. Right, So I candid
- 21:17at McDonald's because I'm training. I'm training, and I definitely can't use drugs
- 21:22and drink and that kind of thing. So it could be healthy overall,
- 21:25but it could also be unhealthy. It could just be another manifestation of the
- 21:29compulsion to beat oneself up or you know, there's obsessive comust person ice order.
- 21:33You can vacillate at higher levels of the disorder between binging and restricting.
- 21:40Right, Essentially, it's just like I'm all drugs and the yeah yeah,
- 21:45And it's either or instead of recovering from the trauma so that you don't need
- 21:48to engage in that rubber banding. But anyway, so Jimbob and Michelle,
- 21:52who knows, maybe there's some data out there. I doubt that there is,
- 21:56but we could imagine one possible story where they both maybe particularly Michelle,
- 22:03but really maybe both really went through something significant emotionally after the miscarriage that tapped
- 22:08into also some other traumas in their life. I'm guessing they weren't trauma free
- 22:12up until that point, and that really either solidified or even just completely pushed
- 22:18them into into this lifestyle. And by the way, so like, have
- 22:22you ever been to one of these big stadium Christian events. No, okay,
- 22:29I will say these things. I can totally understand why they're powerful for
- 22:33people. I remember I went to a few in high school, and it
- 22:40is there's so many people, all of them expressing, even though their life
- 22:45might be in total problems and shambles, expressing this outward like complete joy and
- 22:53super welcoming love bombing. Everyone's love bombing everyone, and they're telling stories and
- 23:02everyone goes through some mystical experience and if they get up on stage, there's
- 23:06some miracle that actually happens and it's and singing, and it's just so powerful
- 23:11that I can totally understand how people are transfixed by that and feel, well,
- 23:15this is the answer. So I can imagine. Let's say you have
- 23:18been through something like that and you go to one of these events with Bill
- 23:21Gothard or whatever, you know, tens of thousands of people and they're all
- 23:23happy and finding meaning and a solution to life, and do this and you
- 23:29won't have miscarriages anywhere. Like It's like wow, you know, it's powerful,
- 23:34yeah, and gives new meaning to that common thing that people would hear
- 23:38after a miscarriage of well you can have another right, because that's exactly.
- 23:44You could argue what IBLP offered on a platter, which is you will be
- 23:48having another yeah, and you will make up for the mistake because you will
- 23:53never take the pill again. And not only are you going to have another
- 23:57child to make up for the death that you caused, and who knows,
- 24:03but you're gonna have all sort You're gonna make up for it eighteenfold or however
- 24:07many. But anyway, so let's take a break, we get back,
- 24:10let's continue at the timeline. What do you say, brow back from the
- 24:17break. So that is what happened in nineteen eighty eight with this young couple
- 24:23that is married there in their twenties, Jimbaba Michelle, and they went on
- 24:29to have many, many more babies after this, on average a birth every
- 24:33eighteen months, by the way, for nineteen children. I was thinking about
- 24:38this, and I know that this used to be more common. It's just
- 24:41so incredible to me to think my body is going through to be giving birth
- 24:47to any human every year and a half. So therefore, the in between
- 24:52times I'm pregnant and going through that and post birth, I'm my body is
- 24:57still recovering, and I'm breastfeeding and suffering from sleep deprivation and it's shuts.
- 25:04It's overwhelming to think about, let alone go through it. Yeah, someone
- 25:10online speculated, and I don't know how accurate this is, but they were
- 25:14saying that if they weren't connected with TLC and the money and everything, she
- 25:18would have died at some point given what she was going through, you know,
- 25:22and she almost did die one time on the show Scare There. Yeah.
- 25:29But yeah, but also, like affording that many kids seems like a
- 25:33problem. Now, there's nothing morally wrong with having nineteen kids or being pregnant
- 25:38and giving birth every eighteen months, you know. And it's certainly a city
- 25:44folk thing to ridicule, but you know, there's nothing wrong with it.
- 25:48I will say though, that there is some research indicating that the and it
- 25:51stands to reason that the more kids you have, the less love and attunement
- 25:56you can spread out among the children. And that just seems so intuitive to
- 26:00me. Yeah, which makes sense because I have two kids. Balancing the
- 26:06time between two kids is hard for me to give each of them the attention
- 26:11that I want to give them and fine tune my style and like help them.
- 26:15And that's two kids. Yeah, I mean, I will say that
- 26:19there's some style differences that are of typical Seattle parents a day that aren't necessarily
- 26:29like if you had to give up part of that parenting style that you have,
- 26:33which I think is great. It's very attuned, it's very personal,
- 26:37there's a lot of time spent, quality time spent, and of course you
- 26:41can't go wrong with that. But research shows that kids born in other circumstances
- 26:48maybe there's six you know, imagine you had six kids and thus you had
- 26:52to split up your time even more. You'd be a little bit more stressed
- 26:56out and frazzled. But if the system is working well then and things can
- 27:00kind of there's pros and cons. So, so the con is is that
- 27:04each child gets less daddy time. The pro is that each kid gets more
- 27:10sibling time. And the model of parenting or raising children usually has a lot
- 27:17of extended family involved as well. Right, And that's one of the reasons
- 27:21why they believe people humans live so long post being able to have children anymore,
- 27:25because the evolutionary advantage of that is that they can make up for the
- 27:29deficits that the parents have or even like even again, even just with two
- 27:33children, I obviously had to compromise the amount of time and activities I can
- 27:37do with each of them. So for for example, when I had one
- 27:40child, like all the attentions on that child, all the learning is on
- 27:44that child, the tweaking of like what we're okay. When we have the
- 27:48second child, immediately the attention on the on the first child goes down dramatically,
- 27:52even if we're trying, especially for those first couple of years, because
- 27:56like it's a baby, like they need attention twenty four seven. Yeah,
- 28:00and that's a loss for the older child, a loss, and then for
- 28:02the new child. There's a lot of things I used to be able to
- 28:04do with with my single child that I actually can't do with the other one,
- 28:07or at least not that frequently. So they're missing out on that too.
- 28:11Now Again, I'm not saying that therefore their lives are ruined or something.
- 28:14It's great. We do what we can't. Could I make it with
- 28:15three, I'm sure we can. Many people do it with six, But
- 28:18I'm noticing that difference with two. Right, So imagine nineteen. I think
- 28:22it just gets really hard unless you have a really robust, extended family and
- 28:30you've also raised the older kids not to abuse the younger kids. Well,
- 28:33right, because you're not able to supervise your kids as they play together as
- 28:38often. Right, So my seven year old still needs sometimes quite often actually
- 28:45to come sit on my lep kind of crawl all over me like a cat.
- 28:48My twelve year old doesn't need. In fact, my sadness with my
- 28:52twelve year old is I'm like, am I not required anymore? Right?
- 28:56Like? But if I had my seven year old and a four year old
- 28:59and a two year old and a newborn baby, I can't, like often
- 29:03when that seven year old comes to one, I sit on daddy's lap and
- 29:07sorry, I can't. I've got like two other kids on my lap let
- 29:10alone, like, and I can't have them because I got to go attend
- 29:11to the baby. Well, and you probably have to work three jobs just
- 29:15to pay alone, yea son, Yeah, I mean, I'm curious about
- 29:18this research, but I've always had the hypothesis that if you have a lot
- 29:23of kids, you know another factor that I would actually see more often as
- 29:27a clinician, as a family therapist in at the beginning of my career,
- 29:30the first ten years, I about half my clients were families, particularly teens
- 29:36and their and their parents. But I would find that families in Seattle would
- 29:41add a lot of dogs to their family. So you might have three or
- 29:45four kids, two three or four kids, but you also have like seven
- 29:48dogs. And I would see that that would interfere with a lot of things,
- 29:53and you know, the chaos, the sleep deprivation, the and so
- 30:00I would actually learn over years to actually with some families because I would do
- 30:06in home therapy and I would observe these things. So I would talk with
- 30:10the parents in private and say, let's have a conversation about moving forward.
- 30:15I'm not saying let's get rid of the dogs now, as a dog lover
- 30:19myself, but let's make some smart choices about the phase of life your family
- 30:23is in, and how maybe because you're a bleeding heart and you want to
- 30:30rescue all the dogs or whatever, let's think. Let's think, you know,
- 30:33rationally about what is good for you and your children and maybe for the
- 30:37dogs anyway. So that is that, all right, nineteen nineties. So
- 30:44we're down there, late twenties, early thirties at or something. And at
- 30:49some point in this time span, and I couldn't really figure out that the
- 30:53timeline they become fundamentalist Christians. They might have already had inklings in the direction,
- 30:57but at some point around here they become fundamentals Christians. So the father
- 31:03what's his name, Jim, Jim Bob, he grew up way it sounds
- 31:08like way more on the on that side of the fence, right, uh
- 31:12than she did. Yeah, but yeah, at some point it sounds like
- 31:15they both really but he was allowed to date and marry whoever he wanted to.
- 31:21Obviously he was okay with her taking the pill, you know. So
- 31:23now that's another part of story that we'll probably never know, was the decision
- 31:29for her to go off the pill because Jim Bob was saying you, I'd
- 31:33always told you to not take the pill? Or was it was it just
- 31:37Miselle's decision? Who knows, but you know, it's just impossible and though
- 31:41but anyway, at some point they become fundamentals Christians as I would call them
- 31:45specifically the quiver full movements. Yeah, so what did you learn in all
- 31:49your deep dive around the quiver full movements? Quiver as in a quiver of
- 31:55arrow, quiver of arrows. The more arrows you have in your quiver,
- 31:56the better for what? For what? Quiver meaning children. But yeah,
- 32:01it's for the battle. Honestly, it's for the battle that's coming. It's
- 32:07literally, uh, you know, the end of the world is coming.
- 32:09We need to be on the side of Christ and good and uh, and
- 32:15we need the more people we have on that side the better. Yeah,
- 32:17and or the good people are under attack, we need more ammunition. I
- 32:22mean, you know, there's a lot of metaphors you could come up with,
- 32:25aside from arrows and a bow, right, you could say basket full
- 32:30of strawberries or something. You know, we need the the basket full,
- 32:36but quiver full. Yeah, you know, it's it's not like having an
- 32:43AR fifteen clip full of bullets, you know what I mean. But you
- 32:45know it's ammunitions ammunition. So you know. Well, and so one thing
- 32:50they didn't go into this much in any of the documentaries I've seen, and
- 32:53maybe because this family in particular didn't give off this vibe and maybe the IBLP
- 32:59didn't either. But another group that is very concerned with the number of children
- 33:04that is being had are white white Christian nationalists because they're concerned that they're being
- 33:08replaced, and so they they have this big movement too, Like you have
- 33:14to be having lots of children. We need to essentially fight back against this.
- 33:19And I got that same vein out of all this. Oh yeah,
- 33:22oh yeah. I mean, it wasn't explicit, but it might have been,
- 33:25and we just didn't come across it. Plus, I'm sure there were
- 33:29people in the IBLP movement who already came to the table with that or eventually
- 33:36adopted it or something. You know, maybe not a majority, who knows,
- 33:38but but yeah, absolutely so specifically, the beliefs included that God commands
- 33:45parents, but particularly women, to be constantly pregnant. They wouldn't say that
- 33:50that that way, but you're supposed to a no contraception period zero yea too,
- 33:54if you're gonna have sex, it should be when you're ovulating to get
- 33:58pregnant. Yeah, I mean, there was some talk about family planning essentially
- 34:01just not having sex right but the way, And they depicted this pretty well
- 34:06in the documentary that it was highly elevated at these conferences. The families that
- 34:12had a lot of kids, including the the Duggers, these were considered to
- 34:15be the ideal and you were blessed, you know, and so quiver ful.
- 34:21Bl blah blah blah, so basically the message was women need to be
- 34:24constantly pregnant and yet ironically an obsession with not having sex other than that because
- 34:30that's bad. Sex is bad unless you're doing this. Yeah. Yeah,
- 34:35we'll get in the whole thing in a later chapter. I mean it's so
- 34:38bizarre. Of course, a lot of the problems. Yeah, and the
- 34:45problem is that most of the world probably adheres to these notions, you know,
- 34:50a lot of the independent of Christianity. And it's not just Christianity,
- 34:53there's there's yeah, these same themes of uh, misogyny and troll and sex
- 35:00is bad. That's very prevalent in many parts covering women's bodies. Yeah,
- 35:06so the beliefs are, in my words, God commands women to be constantly
- 35:10pregnant. Of course, no birth control. There's a rigid hierarchy of sexism,
- 35:15and that's based on sexism, and feminism is definitely evil. Maybe not
- 35:21in those words, but essentially that and homeschooling also, because why do you
- 35:25think the quiver full movement, So this is independent of IBLP. It's over
- 35:30there's a lot of overlap there. But that was another fascinating thing about this
- 35:34steep dive. It's just learning about all these little it's sort of I don't
- 35:37know what it'd be like. It's like these little movements when within the larger
- 35:42movement of evangelicals or something. Yeah, it's like thinking about going to some
- 35:49sort of comic con experience and you know, you have the Marvel people and
- 35:52the DC people and you have you might have yeah, like you might have
- 35:55Star Wars fans, right, but the Star Wars fans are subdivided. There's
- 35:59a Star Wars fans that know all the comics stuff, and there's a Star
- 36:01Wars fans. It's just no, it's the three original movies. That's what
- 36:05we do, and then they're all Star Wars. But then there's the millennials.
- 36:07You actually like the prequels, and so it felt like that. It's
- 36:14like, oh, it's interesting, But why would homeschooling be part of it?
- 36:17Because you would think it would be easier to have more arrows if the
- 36:22kids are at school, so you know you can have a break. So
- 36:24why would they have to home school in berto? And this is where we
- 36:28could certainly get into the cult discussion. But even besides that, it's uh,
- 36:31yeah, no, you gotta control the messaging. You have to control
- 36:35the messaging. The world is corrupt. The world is trying to corrupt me
- 36:38and mine. So and what you're gonna learn at school, it's a lot
- 36:44of stuff that doesn't go to the heart of the matter. The heart of
- 36:46the matters. You gotta be producing more of us, and so we're gonna
- 36:51certainly schools for that. Schools. Certainly schools don't teach that. And they,
- 36:57according to them, would teach a lot of counter They would talk about
- 37:00birth control. Yeah, you know, and they do in all honesty.
- 37:04If you're in this thing and you send your child to school, there's a
- 37:07good chance they'll get out of your movement right right, There won't be arrows
- 37:10anymore, especially if they go to university. It's like you're spilling arrows all
- 37:15or arrows are turning into just regular sticks exactly. So you want your arrows
- 37:20to actually still be fireable. Hence, control the messaging. Control the messaging,
- 37:24especially as we get into the IBOP stuff like now, the messaging gets
- 37:29very specific and there's a hierarchy. You're sending kids to a different hierarchy when
- 37:32you're sending them to school, right, that's not our hierarchy, right where
- 37:37the principle of your elementary school might be a woman, oh God, or
- 37:40a lesbian. Yeah. So Berto, when you think about your experiences recently
- 37:47and in the past, what have you seen people like this around you personally?
- 37:55Anecdotally? This kind of so okay? So, first off, when
- 37:59I was growing up Columbia, I didn't I'm sure that there were, you
- 38:02know, but I didn't come across because everyone that the average vanilla flavor was
- 38:07Catholicism, and so I'd go to school it was a Catholic school. My
- 38:10dad did not allow me to go to church because he's an atheist and he
- 38:14did not allow it, but he would allow for me to watch the Mass
- 38:20at home on TV, which I wanted to do because my grandma would go
- 38:24to Mass. And my grandma was a huge influence in my life, and
- 38:30she was Catholic and she would talk to me about God and all these things.
- 38:34So, you know what you were saying, a lot of your experiences
- 38:36were positive me too, Like, my grandma never ever used the religious angle.
- 38:43I don't remember a single time where she said something to me that was
- 38:46like that. In retrospect, I'm like, oh, that wasn't good,
- 38:49but it was couched in religion. No, it was always positive, good
- 38:52things, be good to others, like all the things that I wish would
- 38:55still be the main conversation when people are talking about what we should be doing
- 39:00for Christians. That's what I got from my grandma, and so I wanted
- 39:04I did. I sat there at home on Sunday morning with the TV doing
- 39:07the Mass and I hold you ten twelve. I don't you know. I
- 39:12was doing it because I felt like that's but my dad didn't allow for me
- 39:15to actually go to the church and that school it was a Catholic school,
- 39:19so I learned all of the Bible stuff. So would you do the kneeling
- 39:22and the chanting? Okay, yeah, anyway, so that was my thing
- 39:27and I had positive things. Now, there were some things at school where
- 39:30I remember, not all the teachers, but some of the teachers would say
- 39:35weird things, and there was a little weirdness around sexuality, but it was
- 39:37nothing, not extreme. But what I did notice growing up for sure,
- 39:43was how like religion was part of the government and it was part of the
- 39:45culture, and it was the hierarchy was definitely there, but I didn't think
- 39:50much of it. I just noticed it was there. Some inherent sexism that
- 39:53you were internalizing. Oh, I definitely. I was not aware of it,
- 39:57but of course, because like you know, the hierarchy was men.
- 40:00I then left and I came up here, and then things changed. My
- 40:04mom took started taking me to church. I was in a youth group.
- 40:07I got baptized because I was never baptized before that. Then I went through
- 40:10confirmation. Oh it was a Catholic church up here. Yeah, and I
- 40:15was. And I was very involved with the youth group. I went on
- 40:17all the little retreats and the conferences and the things. I went on a
- 40:21mission trip to Mexico to build a house in a kitchen, and we went
- 40:24to Disneyland. I did all that. It was great, you know,
- 40:29so again positive, nothing bad. I wasn't abused, nothing bad. It
- 40:31was all positive. But I also had these friends that were from high school
- 40:37and who were reborn Christians. Some of them were great. In fact,
- 40:42like I said, one of my best friends was at and he never was
- 40:45pushy about it with me. He invited me to his church a few times,
- 40:49and they all seemed very nice. There was also this other wing of
- 40:52friends that I had that weren't close friends, but they were acquaintances as we'd
- 40:55be at parties and things, and I certainly talked to them a lot,
- 40:59and some of them were close friends of friends of mine that were very very
- 41:05about being a reborn Christian. So, like I said, this guy that
- 41:07was one of my best friends was, but he was never And I think,
- 41:12by the way, for maybe people who aren't familiar with that term.
- 41:15To me, reborn Christians can mean a lot of things, but I think
- 41:20it also was what we might call conservative Christians or or well fundamentalists, like
- 41:25they believed in the fundamentalists like the Bible's real, everything's real. I think
- 41:30it depends, I know, and I'm saying the ones I knew, yeah,
- 41:32yeah, So just so people understand the context, because they had.
- 41:37First of all, you had to go through this reborn thing where you had
- 41:39to be rebaptized. But it doesn't matter what you were before you had to
- 41:44be rebaptized. It had to be fully dunking in water all these things.
- 41:47And then and like I'm saying, it's not everyone. Like my friend,
- 41:51we always had great times conversations about everything, and he was a reborn Christian
- 41:57and he invited me to his church, and actually a lot of people at
- 41:59his church were lovely, but again there was this other faction. They were
- 42:01the ones who were always judging everything. Like I said, there was music
- 42:06you weren't allowed to listen to, movies you should definitely not watch, shows
- 42:08you should definitely not watch. They were the ones talking about the demon and
- 42:13angel warfare. They were the ones like constantly noticing sins in you and everyone
- 42:19else. And that was there. And when I was invited to those events
- 42:22and churches, I always felt so out of place, judged and horrible.
- 42:29I mean, did you know there was something screwing with these people or not?
- 42:32At first? But I started realizing it, so I started backing away
- 42:38from all that because like what happens is they first tried to suck you in,
- 42:42but if if you are not playing along, they actually like will get
- 42:45aggressive. And but one of my main girlfriends in high school was did they
- 42:49let you be friends with Did they let your friends be friends with you when
- 42:53you were noticed as a as an enemy of the church or something. The
- 42:59church they were in not the same church as this friend of mine, So
- 43:01that didn't come to pass, but it might have happened because I actually know,
- 43:05yes, because I actually know someone else that that happened to as a
- 43:08girl who lost a friend because of that. But one of my main girlfriends
- 43:12in high school was part of this group, of this set of this church,
- 43:17and oh my gosh, that was it was so crazy, like the
- 43:22drama and the trauma and everything was dialed to eleven. So my experience with
- 43:28it was, Wow, there's these flavors. Like you're saying, it's true,
- 43:31it's not that reborn Christian means this. It's just that there was this
- 43:34flavor of it that was extremely overly hyped on every aspect of it. Again,
- 43:39fundamentalist believes about the Bible, like everything's real. Angels and demons are
- 43:45real, they're here, they're now, they're fighting for us as we speak.
- 43:46You're always sinning. You definitely don't want to consume any of these things
- 43:51here. You want to only sit and constant and their whole day, every
- 43:53conversations about it. That's where I was like, oh, and when I
- 43:58went to those events, those were the ones you see in the movies and
- 44:00stuff. That's like this really slick preacher who performs the miracles. They were
- 44:05doing it in this huge stadium. They were healing people left and right,
- 44:08and That's where I started going, Oh, and they were talking in tongues,
- 44:12they were doing the lab and I was like, Okay, I don't
- 44:16I don't think I belong here. And I really started backing away from that
- 44:21world. And yeah, well again, we'll get into this morning another chapter
- 44:23when we talk about the religion at length, it might even take a few
- 44:28chapters. But to be clear, belief systems can be benign. They could
- 44:32be positive. But when you look at the pattern as a whole, and
- 44:36particularly certain practices around fear mongering and us versus theming, then we start getting
- 44:42into cult and high control, brainwashing and harm not only to the members,
- 44:47but also to the people connected to the members or the people who come across
- 44:52the members. You know, having a belief in angels and demons could be
- 44:58benign. You know, you could just be like, yeah, there's a
- 45:00angels and demons, but how does it play out in your life? How
- 45:02does it control your life? How does it control your relationships? But if
- 45:07you're it's a part of a larger pattern where you're constantly being told you need
- 45:10to be hyper vigilant and anyone who is not of us has a demon inside
- 45:15of them or is worshiping a demon or whatever. And then you start getting
- 45:21those individuals in political office like the vice presidency, which we'll get into at
- 45:24some point. Then you start having actual oppression and harm to not only just
- 45:30people in general, but also the identified others, like the queer people and
- 45:35the foreigners, you know, the dirty people from the other side of the
- 45:37border. You know, it becomes one of the most destructive forces on our
- 45:42planet. What freaked me out was because I had been on my youth group
- 45:45side. I've been to some big events actually also in stadiums with lots of
- 45:49people, these big jamborees where like lots of kids all over and they're huge.
- 45:53But those events, I'm not saying there can't be bad for in these
- 45:58cases, it's like, yeah, you are saying I believe all these things,
- 46:01and you're saying I'm going to be a better person and stuff. But
- 46:05what I wasn't getting from those was these weird vibes of like, I think
- 46:08I'm being asked to believe magic things because I'm being asked to believe them right
- 46:14now. And of course it's a fine line because you're like, well,
- 46:17if you're telling if you're being asked to believe in a god and things.
- 46:21Maybe, but but again there was this difference for me, where in these
- 46:23other events there is this highly charismatic figure performing miracles, where they're healing people
- 46:30on stage, there are people speaking in tongues, there are constant angel and
- 46:35demons battles, so like, the level of suspension of disbelief needed is so
- 46:39much higher, and then the reaction when you don't play along is so aggressive
- 46:45and you and me, being a Catholic, I'm so offensive to this unless
- 46:51I submit and go through the thing. That's why I was like, oh
- 46:53no, this is Yeah, it doesn't feel right at your age and experience
- 46:59level, and pre internet you're kind of just bewildered Itself's like later you would
- 47:05learn more specifically. Have you experienced people today in today's contemporary times that I
- 47:13have family members in Colombia that are that believe that the end is nigh.
- 47:19They are and we'll send me messages saying, hey, don't forget, like
- 47:23the world's about to end, and like literally like like I was telling them
- 47:28about something and it's like, well, in the end, don't don't forget,
- 47:31like the world's about to end. But then that translates into like COVID
- 47:37denialism, thinking everything's a conspiracy and therefore they need to go form a commune,
- 47:45which I've heard they want to go and join and stuff. Because again,
- 47:49I mean, it's kind of weird because of course, intuitively those things
- 47:53go hand in hand, but logically they don't. Believing the world is going
- 47:58to end doesn't nessitate that you throw out all of science, you know what
- 48:01I mean? Also, what was the other thing that you mentioned? Well,
- 48:07so, yeah, like the COVID a nihilism, but also all the
- 48:09conspiracy theories, right, yeah, you believe that the world is coming to
- 48:14an end. Okay, that's weird, but okay, but why do so
- 48:19many of those people also believe in the conspiracy theories at the same time.
- 48:22And I don't know if they're correlated, but yeah, but in this case,
- 48:24so and there are people I love that are fundamental to who I am.
- 48:30So now you know, maybe it doesn't cause any harm. Doesn't cause
- 48:32any harm so to me personally, because I don't live there, not directly,
- 48:37not much. I have had some very stressful conversations when I've been down
- 48:42there with some of them, but fine. What I have heard though from
- 48:45other family members is a lot of stressful chaos of people accusing other people of
- 48:52being witches, of people accusing someone of having put a hex on someone,
- 48:57and that's why they're suffering. Why would they accuse of being a which is
- 49:00random, or because they were displeased with someone in the family. Well,
- 49:04in one case there was a I don't I don't actually I don't want to
- 49:07go into too much detail because it's my family. But what I'll say is
- 49:10basically, uh, part of this belief system is again which is are real
- 49:15and around us, and they're trying to bring demons into our life, so
- 49:20that's reals. And so then when they see bad stuff happening, that's a
- 49:22witch. And they don't mean it as a metaphor they literally mean it.
- 49:27So I've never I mean, is our witches specifically of this religion and the
- 49:32teaching, because I don't know what kind of maybe maybe it's a flavor of
- 49:37Latin America. But what I what I know is like to them, all
- 49:40the things of the Salem Trials, all that stuff like, that's real,
- 49:45meaning they probably should have burnt those people because witches are real and they do
- 49:51corrupt. Is this some sort of legacy because your ancestors are from Spain,
- 49:58conquisa. Is this some sort of legacy of the Spanish Inquisition because oh well
- 50:01no, so no, certainly, as we know, like obviously the Catholic
- 50:06part of the country is all because of Spain, and the hierarchy is all
- 50:08because of Spain. The Spanish hierarchy was like it started with with the Catholic
- 50:14Church, right, and like the king and Queen were Catholic Church representatives essentially,
- 50:17So that's all there. Superstitious belief from Europe. I'm sure you know
- 50:22that carried over here too. Think of like, you know, people coming
- 50:24from England with all the witch beliefs and all the things. What I just
- 50:29I just don't know, like you know, where the lines are drawn between
- 50:31this and other flavors of it. All I know is that they are,
- 50:35uh you know, they believe they're fundamentalist Christians, so therefore they believe a
- 50:38lot of it. But more importantly, they really believe in the magic part
- 50:43of it now currently manifesting itself all around them. Yeah, and it cuses
- 50:47harm and it's harmed to them in the family, yeah and everyone else.
- 50:51Uh. Side note, tangent time in Colombia is there and I think this
- 50:55is important to point out because we will often as Americans, think that we're
- 51:00unique, which isn't necessarily true in a lot of arenas in Colombia. Is
- 51:05there a similar movement or has there been regarding the IBOP fundamentalist Christian thing?
- 51:12Until I saw the documentary, if you had asked me, I'm like,
- 51:15oh, I don't think. Since they're international, probably there's probably IBO people,
- 51:19well not specifically IBOC, but when you're talking about your relatives, they
- 51:23don't sound like IBOP. But it's in the same category for me anyway.
- 51:29Of Basically, they're being correct me if I'm wrong. They didn't come up
- 51:31with this idea at the top of thow. No, of course not.
- 51:34They're being brainwashed by a cult. But it is a different flavor because what
- 51:37you see a lot here and actually, now that I think about it,
- 51:40this makes sense. Here's what wouldn't play well with people in Colombia that don't
- 51:45have a lot of money. They really slick preacher with the big watch in
- 51:49this fancy suit, asking for a lot of money. So although that I'm
- 51:52sure that exists in Columbia as well, for this demographic, it's actually a
- 51:57lot more it's like, no, no, you gotta be humble, and
- 52:00you've got to be helping the poor and the needy, so that that part
- 52:02sounds fantastic. In fact, like all these people that I'm talking about,
- 52:06they spend a lot of their time helping the needy. Like one of these
- 52:08people, he's devoted his life for this. So it's like that's all great.
- 52:15And their congregation stuff, it's all about like these more humble, like
- 52:19no ostentatious, we gotta help the needy, like all that stuff. It's
- 52:22just that they add this other layer of and the world is ending and COVID's
- 52:28a control thing and people are witches and you see what I'm saying. It's
- 52:31like, why can't we have all the good parts? Yeah? Is this
- 52:37a large problem in Colombia. It's a good question. I don't know how
- 52:39large this movement is. I don't know. Yeah, all right, Well,
- 52:44so going on with my with my timeline here, nineteen ninety nine,
- 52:51so we're skipping ahead quite a bit. Jimbob and Michelle have had a lot
- 52:53more kids by this point. He Jimbob serves in the Arkansas House of our
- 53:00Presentatives, so a state House of Representatives, the Federal House of Representatives and
- 53:05their state houses, and so he serves for four years in the Arkansas House
- 53:09of Representatives. The year two thousand. Year, dude, I have a
- 53:13cold. I care two thousand because I don't have a cold. I'm recovering
- 53:17from a cold from a couple of weeks ago. The construction of their seven
- 53:22thousand square foot house began in two thousand, so this is the house that
- 53:25eventually is depicted in the show. And they started working on this before they
- 53:30became famous. So it was. By the way, this always trips me
- 53:35up, because can you imagine buying like a family here like because he's not.
- 53:40He was just working class, right, you imagine a working class here
- 53:44in Seattle buying a seven thousand square foot home. Yeah. Yeah. And
- 53:50it was presumably because they were planning on having a lot of kids, right,
- 53:52But he was building it himself, basically from what I understand. And
- 53:57they ran into several problems and the construct auction site languished apparently, so it
- 54:04might have stayed that way if not for future events. But two thousand and
- 54:07two, Michelle wrote an essay in Parents magazine about her life. So this
- 54:12shows the germination of both of them trying to get the word out for public
- 54:19personas. Yeah, becoming public personas, Yeah, Jim, Jim. And
- 54:23by the way that I think from I learned from the documentary is that the
- 54:28IBOP movement, part of the whole idea was to take over the world,
- 54:32and they didn't see it as a nefarious take over the world. They said,
- 54:35it is like, hey, we believe we're right. We believe this
- 54:37is the right way to live. So the way to make this happen worldwide
- 54:40is we gotta get in positions of power, we gotta have more kids,
- 54:44we gotta spread the word right, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 54:46So who knows the motivation? But I also think it points to a personality
- 54:52trait. You know, you and I started a podcast. Not everyone does
- 54:55that, And I think that there's some narcissism to it, yeah, or
- 55:00whatever label you want to put to it. Just they like to be on
- 55:02stage. Or Jim Bob ran for office again. This time he wanted to
- 55:08become a US senator. Actually say yeah, so he went. Becoming elected
- 55:15is a difficult thing to a state house, but to become a senator a
- 55:20state tear competing against other very ambitious people. Yeah, there's two senators from
- 55:25from each state, and so that's a big deal. But he did run
- 55:30and he lost. But a very important thing happened while he was running.
- 55:34They were voting him and his kids. Their kids weren't voting, but they
- 55:38were walking to the polls apparently, and someone took a picture of him and
- 55:45all of his kids, maybe for a promo or just a snapshot, and
- 55:50the in typical dugg Or fashion, they already had their their stick if you
- 55:53will. The boys are all dressed in blue, the same outfit. The
- 55:58girls are all dressed in red, I believe, the same outfit. Very
- 56:00cute looking kids, and they're all walking in a line. It just looked
- 56:07kind of striking well that picture because of he was because he was running for
- 56:10US Senate, there was enough media attention for that that that picture became were
- 56:17really well known, and that's what started the ball rolling that would eventually lead
- 56:21to them having a TV show. So because it does stand out like what
- 56:27is this? Yeah, and at the time they only had like twelve or
- 56:30right, so presumably someone at TLC sees this and it's just like hmm okay,
- 56:36so patron pause, right, patron pause. So he's doing two past
- 56:42pause with pause it makes sense, of course. So the rest of this
- 56:46episode will just be for patrons of the podcast. We are arguably getting to
- 56:51what everyone wanted us to start getting Kid into from the very beginning, which
- 56:54is basically talking about the full sequence of when the parents discovered that Josh was
- 57:01abusing his younger siblings. There's a lot of detail there and a lot of
- 57:06things to talk about, actually, because I think the public discourse around this
- 57:09whole thing is not very fair. In my book, there are problems,
- 57:15obviously, but there's actually some things that we can point out that the parents
- 57:20and Jim Bob did that I think we're responsible. It didn't work out and
- 57:23it might have been the fairest, but anyway, there's a lot of nuance.
- 57:27There's my point. So if you want to listen to that, become
- 57:29a patron of the podcast. Otherwise, please take care of yourself because you
- 57:34deserve it.