Latest / The Afterwife Hours / Why Your Kids Side With Him
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, welcome back to the Afterwife Hours.
- 0:03I'm Kerrie your host, and let's get started.
- 0:06Today we're gonna talk about why it is that your kids side with the awful co-parent, the awful spouse that you have, the insecure man who continues to berade your family, and yet
- 0:20you're always the nice one, and somehow you're the one who's always the villain.
- 0:26Why does this happen?
- 0:29Your daughter rolls her eyes at you.
- 0:30Then he walks in for breakfast and she sits up straight and says, Good morning, Dad.
- 0:36Your son tells you you're too emotional, and you've heard that line before, not just from a twelve-year-old, oddly enough, your husband.
- 0:44If you're wondering why your kids seem to side with the parent who hurts the family, the one who yells, controls, punishes, this episode is for you.
- 0:52But here's what I need you to hear first.
- 0:54They don't side with him because they love him more, they side with him because they fear him more.
- 1:01So here's the setup.
- 1:02It starts with a story that he tells about you.
- 1:06He says things like, Yeah, your mom, you know, she's too strict.
- 1:09You know how she is, she's sensitive and she's dramatic.
- 1:12Your mom is the reason we fight.
- 1:14Don't you know?
- 1:16~ and just so you know, if you think that these statements are bad, wait for the comments to intensify during the divorce proceedings and post divorce.
- 1:26And here's the thing, he doesn't have to say it every day.
- 1:28He doesn't have to make these comments every day.
- 1:30He just has to say it enough.
- 1:32And he says it as the calm one, the fun one.
- 1:35The one who seems to be in charge, and over time the narrative is built, and the longer you stay, the more ingrained the narrative becomes.
- 1:44Lundy Bancroft is a male author who spent years working with abusive men.
- 1:51And he wrote this article that's called The Batterer as the Parent.
- 1:55One of the most common patterns he saw was the abusive parent undermining the mother's authority.
- 2:01Not by grabbing the kids, by slowly teaching them she's not the one who matters.
- 2:05It begins with the quiet dismissals of disrespect.
- 2:09By eating a meal without her while she cleans up the kitchen, or better yet, while she is eating, making comments about her weight, as he does most nights.
- 2:19Like, are you really gonna eat that second helping a pasta?
- 2:22But he says it under his breath, and you know all the kids at the table are hearing it.
- 2:26And he also does this subtle disrespect by not asking the kids if mom wants to go to the store with you and the kids, and says things like, she's being too sensitive, let's just
- 2:37leave her alone, let's just give her some time to herself.
- 2:40Little do the kids know that the antecedent, the incident that happened just prior to you and the kids getting in the car to go to the store, is that
- 2:51you got in a fight with him over an argument that you just had as you were trying to reassert yourself by saying, Hey, next time do you think when we eat together as a family
- 3:02you can stop making comments about my weight.
- 3:04It really hurts my feelings and the kids don't need to hear that.
- 3:07That was followed by him saying, Well, I need to point these things out to you because obviously you're incapable of making the right food choices.
- 3:14So this is what happened before.
- 3:16And then he got in the car with the kids, and he looks like the fun parent.
- 3:21And then disrespects you.
- 3:24without you even knowing and says, yeah, mom's just really sensitive tonight.
- 3:27Let's just leave her alone and have time to herself.
- 3:30Kids are small, but they're smart.
- 3:32They're doing one thing all day long.
- 3:34They're figuring out who has the power and how to stay close as they can to the parent who holds it.
- 3:40They are constantly watching and adjusting.
- 3:43Pleasing.
- 3:45And here's the hard part.
- 3:46They've watched what happens to you when you push back.
- 3:49The silent treatment, the punishment.
- 3:51So in their little minds, siding with you feels dangerous and siding with him feels safe.
- 3:57That's not loyalty, that's survival.
- 3:59And if this sounds familiar, I'm gonna tell you something that might hit hard, but that's fine, it should.
- 4:05This survival is the same thing you've done to get through an emotionally abusive marriage.
- 4:09You've also read his mood.
- 4:11You've also kept the peace.
- 4:12You've agreed when you didn't agree because it was easier than the follow-up.
- 4:16Your kids aren't betraying you.
- 4:18They've learned to survive in the same house you did.
- 4:21I'm gonna say that again because it's very impactful.
- 4:24They've learned to survive in the same house you did.
- 4:27How it shows up a decade later depends a lot on the age.
- 4:31So let me give you two names for what I see.
- 4:37So usually under 10, something that I have helped other clients see in my coaching program is something that I call the weather watcher.
- 4:50And I'm going to explain to you why this usually shows up under the age of 10 and why this exercise is usually ~ does really well with younger kids.
- 5:00So the weather watcher.
- 5:01They read his face the second he walks in the door.
- 5:04Is it a gloomy day?
- 5:06a bad day or is it a good day, a sunny day?
- 5:11They know from how he sets down his keys and how he paces into the other room to go find your mom.
- 5:17They adjust all the time.
- 5:18They get quieter.
- 5:20They get funnier to help lighten the mood.
- 5:22They become more helpful so that dad isn't so stressed because mom is making him stressed.
- 5:26They clean up before he asks.
- 5:28They don't bring up the field trip for him because tonight isn't the night.
- 5:31But in a house like this, when is it ever the night?
- 5:35So the form never gets signed and the question never gets asked.
- 5:38And they learn that the most dangerous lesson of all, that if it's not safe to ask a question, questions don't get asked.
- 5:46And what I need, it'll just wait.
- 5:51There is something in the clinical field called the fawn response.
- 5:55And this is exactly what's happening.
- 5:57When fighting or running isn't an option, a child learns to please.
- 6:01To keep the most powerful person in the house happy because that keeps everyone safe.
- 6:07So when your seven-year-old is a perfect angel for him and then falls apart with you, it isn't because she likes him better, okay?
- 6:13Think about school.
- 6:15Remember when your kids were young and they held it together all day, they raised their hand, they wait their turn, they keep their voice down, then they wait.
- 6:21walk in the door and you have five freaking meltdowns before bedtime.
- 6:26It's not because school is safe and home is bad.
- 6:28It's the other way around.
- 6:30They held it together where they had to and they let go where they could.
- 6:34That's exactly what's happening here.
- 6:36Your child is spending all of their energy holding it together for him and she's falling apart with you because you are where it's safe to fall apart.
- 6:45The meltdown is in some ways a compliment.
- 6:50So the next exercise I want to review with you is something that I usually go over with my coaching clients for children who are about ages ten and up.
- 6:58And what I call it is the understudy.
- 7:01So as kids get older, it often shifts.
- 7:04Watching him turns into becoming him, mirroring him.
- 7:09And this is like
- 7:11What I would say is probably the scary part because they've watched and they've mirrored him and now they're actually going to emulate him even more and become him even more.
- 7:21So I call this the understudy.
- 7:23They have watched the lead actor for years and now they know what his lines are.
- 7:28They talk to you the way he does.
- 7:30Same tone, same eye roll, same words.
- 7:32You're being dramatic.
- 7:33You're always overreacting.
- 7:36And if you are in a divorce litigation or you've told your spouse that you want to leave, what you'll see is this disrespect come out even more.
- 7:47So if you haven't seen it yet, this is when you usually do.
- 7:50And if you've already seen ~ glimpses of it, it will just intensify.
- 7:56There is a person named Anna Freud who in 1936 named this identification with the aggressor because when a child can't escape a threat, one way to feel less powerful is to
- 8:07become like the person who holds the power.
- 8:11They eventually learned that if I'm not like him, I'm the one getting hurt.
- 8:15So your teacher mirroring him isn't proof you lost them.
- 8:18It's proof of how much power he held in your house.
- 8:22They picked the safer seat at the table.
- 8:25Can you blame them?
- 8:27And notice who I aim that at.
- 8:28Not him, you, because kids push hardest on the wall they know won't fall.
- 8:34And I know this feels unfair because you shouldn't be treated this way, but I tell you this because you are the safe parent.
- 8:41And like I said, if you try to leave or if there is any fear of abandonment ~ from the narcissist and the narcissist is sensing this, it will begin to get louder before it gets
- 8:51quieter.
- 8:52Because now he has a story and it's a good one.
- 8:54Yeah, you know your mom, she broke up the family.
- 8:57She's the one responsible for this.
- 8:59Your mom left us.
- 9:00I wanted to make it work, she didn't, and here I sit.
- 9:02He gets to play the wounded role and the one who was abandoned.
- 9:05And your kids only see one person who made the change.
- 9:09You.
- 9:09You're the one who moved them.
- 9:11You're the one who split the holidays.
- 9:12You're the one who made them pack the bag every other Friday.
- 9:16They don't see the years that led up to it because maybe you tried to cover up for it.
- 9:22you tried to mask it or maybe they see it the day that it ended.
- 9:29So now you hear it out loud.
- 9:30You've ruined my life.
- 9:32You're the reason everything is like this.
- 9:33I hate living at your house.
- 9:36Sound familiar?
- 9:37Have your kids said anything like this?
- 9:38But here's really what's going on.
- 9:41They can't be angry at him.
- 9:42That's too dangerous.
- 9:43He's the one who might punish them, pull away, or make them pay for it at his house.
- 9:48So all that fear, all that grief about the family breaking has to go somewhere.
- 9:53It has to go to the safe parent, so it goes to you.
- 9:57You've ruined my life usually means this.
- 9:59My life feels out of control, and you're the only one I'm allowed to say that to.
- 10:03So if your child says something like this, say, I hear you, I understand that this feels like something you can't control, but I want you to know that I do love you, and this was
- 10:14a very, very hard choice to make.
- 10:17Please know that if you have any questions, now bearing in mind you know, the age-appropriate nature of this question, right?
- 10:27for kids that are teenagers or young adults, things like if you have any questions, please just talk to me about them, but by saying, you know, I understand that this doesn't feel
- 10:37like it's in your control, but I want you to know that I do love you unconditionally.
- 10:44So when your kid says you've ruined my life, again, don't defend the divorce, don't explain the years, don't tell them what your dad did.
- 10:51That's an adult conversation.
- 10:53And for really young kids, what I say to moms is, hey, you know what, that is between your dad and I, that is adult stuff, and we're going to leave that up to the adults to figure
- 11:04out.
- 11:05Because what your kids are saying is that they're hurting.
- 11:06So you name the feeling and you hold the line in the same breath.
- 11:10You're really angry.
- 11:11You're allowed to be.
- 11:12I know that you feel like you can't control this, but you're not allowed to talk to me like that.
- 11:17That's it.
- 11:18Feeling yes, disrespect no.
- 11:20Here's what I tell the women in my program.
- 11:22The day you decided that disrespect stops, it didn't just stop with him.
- 11:26it stops in your house.
- 11:28Period.
- 11:29You didn't walk away from being talked down to by the one person just to take it from someone else.
- 11:34Even someone you love more than anything.
- 11:37That's not punishing your kids, that's showing them what you've finally learned.
- 11:41Love and respect are supposed to come together.
- 11:43So what does that look like?
- 11:45You say it once, calm and short.
- 11:47If they violate the ~ ask for respect, you say to them, I'll talk to you when you can speak to me with respect, and then you walk away.
- 11:56No lecture, no crying in front of them, no yelling.
- 11:59You're showing them a grown-up who doesn't flinch and doesn't explode.
- 12:03And then you have to follow through every time.
- 12:06If the phone goes away when they're cruel, the phone goes away.
- 12:11His house may run on moods, but yours runs on rules.
- 12:15That predictability is what makes you safe.
- 12:17don't make it about him.
- 12:19Never.
- 12:19You sound just like your father, even when they do.
- 12:22Because what you'll say and what they'll hear is you're becoming the bad guy, and that's a weight no kid should ever have to carry.
- 12:30And lastly, you need to come back to them.
- 12:32So you say to them later at night when everything's calm, you peek your head in the door of their bedroom and you say, I know this is hard.
- 12:38I'm not going anywhere.
- 12:39I love you.
- 12:41And I will, however, keep expecting respect because you deserve to learn what that looks like.
- 12:47And I'll say it again because it's very impactful.
- 12:50I know this is hard.
- 12:51I'm not going anywhere.
- 12:52I love you.
- 12:53And I'll keep expecting respect because you deserve.
- 12:58to learn what that looks like.
- 13:01Here's what happens over time.
- 13:02They will test the wall over and over.
- 13:04And if it doesn't fall, they will stop testing.
- 13:07Not because you won, because they finally believe you're the person who won't change the weather.
- 13:13You stop accepting it from him and now you're teaching them that they never have to accept it from anyone and that they never get to hand it out either.
- 13:21That's how you stop the cycle before they're old enough to start their own families.
- 13:25Because here's what I want you to do.
- 13:27I want you to picture something.
- 13:29It's 20 years from now.
- 13:31You're at a Saturday barbecue at your son's house.
- 13:33You've got burgers on the grill.
- 13:34It's a beautiful Sunday morning.
- 13:36The grandkids are running through the sprinkler, and here comes your daughter-in-law.
- 13:39She finds you alone in the kitchen.
- 13:41She's quiet and her eyes are a little red, and she asks you, Why does he treat me this way?
- 13:46And you know exactly what she's talking about because you just saw the interaction between her and your son.
- 13:52Outside, and it was the same interaction that he, your son, witnessed in his childhood.
- 13:57He's acting like his dad.
- 13:59So she says, Why does he treat me this way?
- 14:02What do you want to be able to say to them?
- 14:05What do you want to be able to say to them?
- 14:07Do you want to say, yeah, you know, that's just how families are?
- 14:10No, you don't.
- 14:12You are not that woman.
- 14:15Or do you want to say, I know exactly what that feels like?
- 14:18I saw it start and I spent years trying to show him another way.
- 14:23Or better yet, what happens if you never hear that question at all?
- 14:28Because if you stayed in this type of marriage, you may not.
- 14:31Because what happened in your child's upbringing is likely just continuing, the cycle continues, and what isn't
- 14:43given light likely won't stop, right?
- 14:46So if it remains in the dark, it will stay in the dark.
- 14:50That's what this is about.
- 14:51It's not winning this week.
- 14:53It's not getting your teenager to apologize tonight.
- 14:55It's about who your son becomes as a husband, who your daughter lets herself marry, what they think love is supposed to look like.
- 15:04They're learning it right now in your kitchen from you.
- 15:08What this is not, okay, I want I want to be really clear about this.
- 15:11This is not parenting failure, and I know a lot of moms feel like they are failing.
- 15:16It's what happens to kids raised in a power imbalance.
- 15:20And there's one more thing I want you to know because it matters in court.
- 15:23When kids reject the safe parent, the abusive parent will often call it alienation and point the finger right back at you.
- 15:30Researchers have written about how complicated it is
- 15:33To tell why a child is rejecting a parent.
- 15:36Sometimes the child is pulling away from the parent, hurt them.
- 15:39Sometimes the child is aligning with the parent who scares them.
- 15:43You do need help showing it, which means this: solid documentation, a good attorney, and ideally a child therapist or a coach who understands high conflict.
- 15:54And yes, this is something I can help you with.
- 15:57I help moms determine what's really going on in their high conflict homes, how to respond without making it worse, how to document it so it holds up in court, and how to walk into
- 16:06a GAL interview or a mediation calm and prepared instead of looking like the emotional reactive parent he's been describing for years.
- 16:16When it does happen and if this is something that resonates with you and you're like, man, my kids are going through this, please know that I do work with children too.
- 16:25You do not have to sort out what alienation is and what fear is on your own.
- 16:31That's my job, and that is what I can help you with.
- 16:35So speaking of documentation.
- 16:39You can get a glimpse of this in terms of what is supported in court when you work with me in my coaching program, because most moms can write it like a diary, but courts need it
- 16:51like a police report.
- 16:52Facts, neutral language, and that are non-accusatory.
- 16:56And I'm going to point out the difference, okay?
- 16:58Weak language would look like this.
- 17:00He was horrible to the kids tonight.
- 17:02He's such a narcissist.
- 17:03I'm so done.
- 17:04Okay?
- 17:05Means nothing.
- 17:06But here is a strong piece of documentation.
- 17:10Tuesday, October 7th, 6:15, kitchen.
- 17:13Emma 11 spilled milk.
- 17:15He yelled within five feet.
- 17:17What is wrong with you?
- 17:18You're useless, just like your mother.
- 17:20Emma looked up, cried, and went into her room.
- 17:24Jack 8 was at the table in the same physical distance as Emma.
- 17:31and witness this as well.
- 17:33See the difference?
- 17:34There's no labels, facts and data.
- 17:36Every entry gets the same five things.
- 17:39When?
- 17:40Date, time, and what happened, what was said word for word, in quotes, not he insulted her, the actual words.
- 17:46What he did.
- 17:47slammed a door, took her phone, left her practice, behavior, not opinions.
- 17:52Who saw it?
- 17:52Which kids?
- 17:53Which adults?
- 17:54How far away were they?
- 17:56What happened afterward?
- 17:57She cried, she wouldn't eat, she asked if she was in trouble.
- 17:59And document what your kids say word for word.
- 18:03Another example of this something that would be weak.
- 18:06Jack is scared of his dad.
- 18:08As opposed to strong language, such as Saturday, October eleventh, in the car after pickup, Jack, unprompted, asked
- 18:17Jack Unprompted said, Daddy said if I tell you something, he'll take my switch.
- 18:26Nintendo Switch for those that may not know what the switch means.
- 18:30That word unprompted matters.
- 18:32It tells a GAL you didn't plant it.
- 18:34And keep track of the boring stuff too, because that's where most moms come short.
- 18:40Something like Monday, I drove both kids to school, packed lunches, did homework at four, took Emma to the dentist at 5 30 and he got home at 8.
- 18:47When he asks for fifty fifty parenting or more, that boring list actually shows who's been doing the parenting all along.
- 18:53Where to keep this documentation, somewhere he can't reach.
- 18:56Not the family iPad, not a shared Google account, a private email, you send notes to yourself, a notes app with a passcode or a co-parenting app journal.
- 19:06One warning though, don't secretly record him or the kids until you've talked to your attorney.
- 19:10Recording laws are different in every state.
- 19:13And a recording that seemed like proof can end up actually hurting your case.
- 19:17So what can you do about this?
- 19:18Three things.
- 19:19One, don't compete.
- 19:21You will never outfun, outbuy, or outpower him, so don't try.
- 19:26Your job is to win them back.
- 19:28It's to be the same person every single day.
- 19:31I said this to a client a couple days ago.
- 19:33I said, just keep being mom.
- 19:36Just keep being you.
- 19:38Same rules, same warmth, same bedtime, same mom.
- 19:42Boring is a gift to a scared kid.
- 19:44Two, don't correct him through them.
- 19:47Your son looks at you and says, You didn't even try to work on the marriage.
- 19:50Dad agrees with me.
- 19:52Everything in you wants to hold the record straight, right?
- 19:55The counseling you begged for, the years you held it together, the nights you cried in the bathroom so they went here.
- 20:00But do not
- 20:03Defend yourself.
- 20:04Don't say your father is lying.
- 20:06Try this instead.
- 20:07I can tell you've been thinking about it a lot, and it makes sense you'd want to know why.
- 20:11Some of what happened between your dad and I is grown-up stuff, and it isn't fair to put that on you, but I want you to know I will always tell you the truth and I will never ask
- 20:18you to pick a side.
- 20:20Then stop talking.
- 20:22Let it sit.
- 20:23He might roll his eyes, he might walk away, that's fine.
- 20:25You're planting the seed, not winning a debate.
- 20:28Because one day he'll be older.
- 20:30And he'll remember that one parent
- 20:33made him carry the story and the other parent let him put it down.
- 20:38So for the Weather Watcher, remember we talked about the Weather Watcher earlier?
- 20:43You want to name what you see, not what he did.
- 20:46You worked really hard to keep things calm tonight.
- 20:48You don't have to do that here.
- 20:50Grown-ups are responsible for their feelings, and it's not your job to make them feel better.
- 20:54This is something you would say to someone who's under 10, a kiddo who's under 10, who is the Weather Watcher, as I outlined previously.
- 21:04For the understudy.
- 21:07What you say to your child who is performing in this way, and remember the understudy is the person who is mirroring your spouse now.
- 21:14You say to them, I'm going to talk to you with respect and I do expect the same back.
- 21:19Calm, short, repeat it as many times as it takes.
- 21:22And if they can't give you that respect, don't walk away just yet.
- 21:26Tell them exactly what it looks like because for a lot of kids they don't know what it means when you say I need respect.
- 21:31And so you wanna say being respectful, especially for a kid who
- 21:35has seen a house where disrespect lives, they need it spelled out.
- 21:39So you can say things like, I think we need a little space right now.
- 21:43I love you.
- 21:44I'm not going anywhere.
- 21:45But when you're ready to talk, here's what respect is going to look like.
- 21:48No name calling, no yelling, no talking about me, and saying things like, hey, are you sure that you need to eat another piece of spaghetti tonight?
- 21:59I think you've eaten enough.
- 22:00Things like that.
- 22:02It's really good if you are specific because that draws out the specifics of your ask.
- 22:08You can also say you can be angry, you can disagree with me, you can tell me I'm wrong.
- 22:12You just have to do it without tearing me down.
- 22:14When you can do that, when you can engage with me in that way, my door is open.
- 22:20Then you give them the space, an hour, an evening, whatever it takes.
- 22:23But here's the line you never cross.
- 22:25Space is not the silent treatment.
- 22:28You don't freeze them out.
- 22:29You don't punish them with distance.
- 22:30You still make them dinner.
- 22:31You still get say goodnight.
- 22:32You still check in with them again.
- 22:34And for those of you that have older children and maybe they're not at home, you can still send them messages.
- 22:39You can still say, hey, how was your school assignment?
- 22:42You can still say I love you, right?
- 22:44But what hasn't gone away is your ask.
- 22:47When you re-enter the conversation, when you re-enter the relationship, I expect respect.
- 22:52Because
- 22:53That's the difference they need to see.
- 22:55At his house, distance is punishment.
- 22:57At yours, it's a pause.
- 22:59And the way back in it is clear.
- 23:05Here's what I want you to remember.
- 23:07Kids don't attach to the parent who's the nicest.
- 23:10They attach to the parent who's the safest.
- 23:13Right now, they may be managing him, but they're watching you too.
- 23:16They're learning what a steady adult looks like.
- 23:18They're learning that someone in this family doesn't change with the weather.
- 23:21That's you.
- 23:23It may honestly take years for them to say it out loud.
- 23:26Some of the kids who mirrored the scariest parent grow up and call the steady one the safe one, the person they have the closest relationship with.
- 23:34And they say things like, I get it now.
- 23:37I see it so much clearer.
- 23:40Stay steady, stay the wall.
- 23:43If you're living this now and you don't know what your next move is, book a free call.
- 23:48The link is in my episode link because we will figure it out together.
- 23:52And we will figure it out quietly.
- 23:55Because this, the quietly prepare phase is one of the most useful phases there is when you are deciding to quietly exit and
- 24:03You need to know what your next steps are.
- 24:05I'm Kerrie This is the Afterwife Hours, and I will see you on the next episode.
- 24:09Thank you.