Latest / Politics with Paul / Why Do We Vote? Why SHOULD We Vote? | Politics with Paul #113
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today, we're going to answer the questions, why do we vote, and why should we vote?
- 0:15For many voters, the questions seem like they have obvious answers.
- 0:19And for many irregular voters or even nonvoters, the questions seem like they have
- 0:24unsatisfactory answers.
- 0:26But I think a large swath of voters don't really understand why they vote, and many
- 0:32nonvoters don't really understand why they should participate more often in the first
- 0:38place.
- 0:40Because at first glance, the act of voting might seem pointless and inefficient.
- 0:46Why spend all this time and effort researching what's on the ballots with all these convoluted
- 0:52issues and a cacophony of conflicting signals from candidates and parties and interest
- 0:58groups.
- 0:59Then go travel to a polling place to wait for your ballot that you have to then sit and fill
- 1:04out.
- 1:04Also, you can be one of thousands, if not millions of votes, and therefore make little
- 1:11mathematical difference in the outcome.
- 1:13But even in a world where bottom line numbers seem to be all that matters in many people's
- 1:19eyes, from corporate executives and shareholders fixating on profits to social
- 1:24media influencers obsessing over impressions and likes.
- 1:28Maybe overly focusing on just how many voters there are out there and our lack of
- 1:33mathematical impact is the wrong approach.
- 1:36Maybe it's missing the forest for the trees.
- 1:38But at the same time, maybe we should have a convincing reason for why we vote so that we
- 1:43never become so discouraged that we lose our sight of our why, and so we could persuade more
- 1:49people as to why they should also vote.
- 1:52So why do we vote, and why should other people vote too?
- 1:57Well, we have to first talk about whether voting is a rational act.
- 2:03Because for some people, a lot of people, it's not a rational act, and that's why they don't
- 2:09vote.
- 2:09Rationally, we expect people to do things that maximize expected utility.
- 2:14That is to say, they derive the most benefit from it compared to doing something else.
- 2:21The whole process of voting from researching candidates to actually going to a place to vote
- 2:27if you don't request an absentee ballot.
- 2:32Then going through the whole rigmarole of actually going to fill out the ballot and then
- 2:36put it in the machine so that it's counted.
- 2:39The whole process takes time, effort, and sometimes money, and going to vote is easier
- 2:46for some people than it is for others.
- 2:49And all these things could be spent doing something else.
- 2:52You could be working.
- 2:53You could be going to get more money.
- 2:55You could be doing something leisurely, like going to a movie or playing sports or playing
- 3:02video games or reading a book.
- 3:04Could be doing all sorts of other things.
- 3:07And that kind of leads to this paradox of voting that was described by the late American
- 3:14economist Anthony Downs, which is this idea that the expected costs of voting will exceed
- 3:20the expected benefits of voting.
- 3:22So it's surprising that anyone votes.
- 3:24But whether voting is rational depends on what you're trying to do with that vote.
- 3:31If there's a specific goal in mind that you have with that vote, it may be rational.
- 3:35But if it's another goal, it might not be so rational.
- 3:38So are you trying to change the outcome of an election?
- 3:41Most elections make that mathematically unlikely because of thousands, if not millions
- 3:47of votes.
- 3:48So if you're trying to actually change the outcome of an election, it's probably not
- 3:55rational for you to vote.
- 3:57But sometimes even big elections will be decided by only a handful of votes or maybe
- 4:02even just one.
- 4:03Every once in a while, you do see votes that are decided by one vote or they are actually
- 4:07tied.
- 4:09Back in 2016, 2014, 2018, it's something like that.
- 4:14There was a Virginia state house race that was decided by a coin flip because it was a tied
- 4:18vote?
- 4:19Or are you trying to change the, quote, unquote, mandate of an election?
- 4:23So that is the idea that how much the winner thinks they are given a mandate from the voters
- 4:29do all things they wanna do.
- 4:31Because a lot of election winners, typically presidents and governors, they come up with
- 4:35this ridiculous notion that because they won, the voters have given them basically all this
- 4:40leeway to do all the things they want.
- 4:42Like, oh, the vote...
- 4:43Then sometimes they will specifically say, I have a mandate from the voters.
- 4:48No.
- 4:48You don't.
- 4:50But even as ridiculous as that is, some of these election winners justify it in their
- 4:56heads even though voters rarely are ever saying they want you to do every single thing that you
- 5:04wanna do.
- 5:04But somebody who wins by a smaller margin of victory may be inclined to be more careful
- 5:12about what they do in office because they know that they have a small margin of error with the
- 5:17voters.
- 5:18So a voter may have that idea in mind and say, well, you know what?
- 5:23I wanna make sure that this person realize that they don't have the mandate they think they do.
- 5:29Now, again, that still is mathematically speaking, probably not gonna make a huge
- 5:34difference.
- 5:35But if you have enough people that think that way, they are gonna make a difference.
- 5:39And if enough people think that, well, I'm just one voter, I'm not gonna make a difference.
- 5:43Eventually, that's gonna lead to a whole bunch of people that decide that, and then suddenly
- 5:48that will make a big difference.
- 5:51But if you're...
- 5:52As a voter, are you simply just trying to make a difference?
- 5:56That's a pretty vague phrase that could just mean whatever you want it to mean.
- 6:00It could mean a difference in the outcome of the election or the difference in a mandate.
- 6:05Or if you're simply just whatever you want that difference to be, you can argue that you're
- 6:13doing it.
- 6:14Or are you just simply trying to express your views?
- 6:16You're easily doing that with your vote.
- 6:18And so in that way, it is very rational to go vote.
- 6:22But because of the shortcomings of rational choice in explaining why people vote, we are
- 6:28often better served looking further at the internal impetuses, these motives, these
- 6:33impulses for why people vote instead.
- 6:38So I wanna look at five common motives for voting.
- 6:42Not necessarily the only ones, but they are very common ones that are cited.
- 6:48Now, obviously, we theoretically want to vote for the people who we think are the best
- 6:53choices for their respective office.
- 6:56But that's not really the ultimate reason we vote for these people.
- 6:59But as we talked about a couple episodes ago, people who don't wanna quote unquote waste
- 7:03votes, some of these people aren't voting for who they think is the best candidate, but who
- 7:09is their most preferred out of who they perceive as the most likely to win.
- 7:14So we're gonna look at five common motives for voting, not necessarily the only ones that are
- 7:20studied in political science and brought up in voting surveys.
- 7:23Altruism, which is the concern for others leads you to vote for what you think will benefit
- 7:29others even at a personal cost, a sense of duty, belief that there is some moral
- 7:35imperative for you to vote, Self interest in this, vote for what or...
- 7:41And who you think will most likely implement what you want.
- 7:45In some cases, people might call it selfishness.
- 7:49Belonging, which is the want to be a part of a social action, and social approval, which is
- 7:55desire for others to think positively of you for voting.
- 8:02And these aren't mutually exclusive, and people can be motivated by multiple motives here.
- 8:09And there are some other motives that generalists hear, like self expression.
- 8:14You simply wish to make your voice heard.
- 8:16Although that's most likely going to...
- 8:19There's most likely going to be much more to why you vote than simply just wanting to make
- 8:23your opinion clear.
- 8:25So we're mostly gonna focus on these five common psychological motives we've already
- 8:30listed.
- 8:30There's also the desire for accountability, wanting to punish somebody you felt was doing a
- 8:36bad job in office either directly or against other people in their party.
- 8:42There's also preemption.
- 8:44You're wanting to keep somebody out of office in the first place, but I wanna focus on the
- 8:49aforementioned five altruism, sense of duty, self interestedness, belonging, and social
- 8:54approval because they are probably the most common ones and are the primary subjects of the
- 8:59study that we will be talking about here.
- 9:01And when you're talking about evaluating the motives for voting, you mostly have to rely on
- 9:05self reported motives here because it's it's kind of hard to not kind of hard.
- 9:11It's it's pretty impossible to just open somebody's head and look at their brain and
- 9:16say, okay.
- 9:16That's their motive for voting.
- 9:18No.
- 9:18You have to go by whatever they say.
- 9:20So there's a 2020 study that looks at the five motives of selfishness or self interestedness.
- 9:27They call it selfishness, but I also use self interestedness, and I'll talk about that in a
- 9:33minute.
- 9:34Altruism, duty, belonging, and social approval.
- 9:38And he looks at it across two surveys.
- 9:40And what the study did was it used descriptive prompts without naming what they were, and
- 9:46respondents allocated percentage points to each of them to add up to 100.
- 9:50So they would add...
- 9:51You could say, they put 15 percentage points to selfishness and then 20% to altruism, and then
- 10:00they split up the last remaining percentage points across personal duty, belonging, and
- 10:06social approval so that they all added up to a 100.
- 10:08And so, for example, the selfishness prompt said that I vote to increase my income or
- 10:14reduce my expensive...
- 10:16Expenses.
- 10:17For example, I vote because there is a potential economic benefit such as reducing
- 10:21taxes or increasing government benefits.
- 10:24Or the belonging prompt, I vote because it makes me feel like I am participating in
- 10:29something larger than myself.
- 10:30It makes me feel like I am part of a community.
- 10:33And so the results of the survey found that altruism had the most percentage points
- 10:39allocated in the two surveys with an average of 4436%.
- 10:46Personal duty came in second with 2328%.
- 10:50Belonging was third with 1818% in both of those surveys.
- 10:55Selfishness was fourth with 1316%, and then last was social approval with 23%.
- 11:01So altruism was the thing that people most gravitated towards, and social approval was the
- 11:07lowest.
- 11:07Personal duty was also a pretty high ranking, but the selfishness prompt was pretty low.
- 11:14But, again, this is self reporting and for only two surveys.
- 11:18So we'd wanna see if these findings were replicated across multiple surveys.
- 11:22And, also, despite the props that people were given, maybe respondents in these surveys
- 11:27weren't as consciously aware of their motives as they may think.
- 11:32Because if you really look at these motives more closely, there's some thin lines between
- 11:42some of them, and I wanna group a few of them for several reasons.
- 11:46I don't wanna group altruism and self interestedness or selfishness together.
- 11:53And before I get to why, altruism is once again the concern for others leads you to vote for
- 11:59what you think will benefit those others even if it personally costs you.
- 12:04And what are those costs?
- 12:05Time, effort, and money spent to research elections and to travel to vote and cast your
- 12:10ballot.
- 12:11And in the context of voting, casting a vote for a party or policy outcome is expected to
- 12:17provide benefits to those citizens that that person cares about.
- 12:23And then self interestedness and selfishness are you vote for what and who you think will
- 12:28most likely implement what you want.
- 12:30It's motivation to enhance your own welfare.
- 12:34Now I group those two together because theoretically, those two motives are complete
- 12:39opposites.
- 12:39How can you be both selfish and altruistic?
- 12:43But is there really that much separation between the two?
- 12:48Is there a fine line between what we think is altruistic and what is really self interested?
- 12:54Is your voting to support people and causes that you care about really altruistic if you're
- 13:00only voting for them because you support those groups so much?
- 13:04Or are you voting for them because these are people and causes that you happen to identify
- 13:10with or are part of the same party with them?
- 13:15If you didn't have any sort of linkage to them whatsoever, would you care about them?
- 13:20Would you be so altruistic?
- 13:21Or on the other hand, is it automatically selfish to vote for something you think will
- 13:26benefit you or benefit a group you care about?
- 13:29Because it's not reasonable to expect people to vote for something they think won't benefit
- 13:34them at least a little bit.
- 13:37And there's nothing inherently wrong with that.
- 13:39We all have some level of self interest going on, and anybody who says otherwise is just
- 13:45lying to themselves.
- 13:46We're human beings.
- 13:49There's nothing wrong with that.
- 13:50It's whether it gets to the point where it's ultimately driving everything you do and where
- 13:55everything has a or most things have an ulterior motive to them.
- 14:01So we may think we're being altruistic, but really, it's something that ultimately benefits
- 14:08us.
- 14:08Or maybe we're just supporting these causes because it makes us feel good to support these
- 14:14causes and these people rather than we're actually trying to do it for their benefit.
- 14:21And that's that might sound very cynical.
- 14:23It's not necessarily meant to be cynical, but we also have to pry deeper into our own
- 14:31motivations to see if we're as altruistic as we think we are.
- 14:34But even if there is self interestedness at play, is it necessarily a problematic level of
- 14:42self interestedness?
- 14:43When does it become selfishness instead of just self interest?
- 14:47And then the other grouping of motives I wanted to talk about were duty, belonging, and social
- 14:53approval.
- 14:54And before I get to why I group those, we'll talk about each of those individually again.
- 15:00So duty is the belief that there is a moral imperative for you to vote, that it's the right
- 15:06thing to do.
- 15:09There's this need for internal validation and seeking our own approval, and that requires
- 15:16consistency with core values and principles.
- 15:19And so your sense of duty might be to your country.
- 15:23It could be to the veterans who fought and died for our freedoms.
- 15:27It might be to our communities, to our social groups, whether it's religious or racial or
- 15:32ethnic.
- 15:33Might be to our party, to our specific set of moral values.
- 15:38Could be a combination of those things.
- 15:41Duty sometimes is also tied to what we are voting for more so than the actual act of
- 15:47voting itself.
- 15:48So, yes, it motivates us to vote, but because we're motivated to vote for a specific thing,
- 15:53not so much that we're motivated to vote, period.
- 15:58And then belonging is you simply wanna be part of a social action.
- 16:02You wanna be part of a social group.
- 16:04You wanna feel connected to other people, causes, and organizations, which could be your
- 16:09family, could be your neighbors, could be local issue groups, could be religious or racial
- 16:16groups.
- 16:17And so much of political mobilization is focused on this group level.
- 16:23And then there's the social approval aspect, which is the desire for others to think
- 16:27positively of you for voting.
- 16:30And that could be society at large.
- 16:32It could be groups or units that are close to you, like neighbors, family, religious
- 16:37affiliation, so...
- 16:39And so on.
- 16:40And it's it's somewhat similar to that social desirability bias that we sometimes see in
- 16:47polls, such as when there's self reporting of voter turnout.
- 16:51There's usually over reporting because people who didn't go out to vote are sometimes
- 16:58inclined to say they went out to vote because they don't want other people to look down upon
- 17:02them.
- 17:03Now why do I group these three things together?
- 17:05Because there is a thin line between all of them.
- 17:07They can all look very much like each other.
- 17:10Is it really a sense of duty that you're bound to, or do you feel that duty because of a
- 17:15pressure for social approval that you believe it's your civic duty to go vote, but really
- 17:20it's because you want other civic minded people around you to think highly of you.
- 17:26Or do you just wanna belong to that group that you have a sense of duty to?
- 17:32It's not like with altruism and self interest where there's seemingly...
- 17:40They're seemingly polar opposites.
- 17:42These three things can look very similar to each other even more so.
- 17:48And so it goes to show how these things are, once again, not mutually exclusive and how in
- 17:55that 2020 study, these respondents assigned percentage points to how much each of these
- 18:01motives resonated with them instead of just choose this one is most resonance with me
- 18:07because most people are gonna have different levels of pull from each of these motives.
- 18:17But regardless of what our motives are, what does all this matter?
- 18:24Why does it matter why we vote?
- 18:28Even if we get past the idea that...
- 18:32Of whether or not it's rational to vote.
- 18:34Why why do we care whether...
- 18:36Why we vote?
- 18:36Isn't it just important that we go and vote?
- 18:39Yes.
- 18:39It's important that we go and vote, but we really should understand why we vote.
- 18:45Not why we vote the way we vote, but why we vote in the first place.
- 18:49Voting is the most basic democratic right that we have, and some people would also call it a
- 18:54responsibility.
- 18:55And to a some extent, I would say that too.
- 18:58Your why for doing anything, though, is just as important as what you do.
- 19:04And I think in a lot of ways, we lose sight of that even beyond voting.
- 19:09Yes.
- 19:10Doing good things...
- 19:13Going outside of voting for a second.
- 19:15Doing good things is is great.
- 19:17Yes.
- 19:18But your motives for doing that should also matter.
- 19:21If you're just doing it just for social clout, that really cheapens what you're doing.
- 19:29Now if we bring it back to voting, I'm not necessarily saying that it cheapens your vote,
- 19:34but you should also know why you vote because it teaches us about ourselves and informs us
- 19:40what's truly important to us at the end of the day.
- 19:44It's not just about the policies we support, but what ultimately drives us.
- 19:49And it leads to a stronger sense of community and understanding of each other.
- 19:53When we're not actually understanding why we do what we do, it also prevents us to some extent
- 20:00from learning why other people do what they do.
- 20:05And in this case, knowing why they vote in the first place.
- 20:09We should know why we vote in the first place.
- 20:12And if you also want to convince irregular voters and nonvoters that they should vote,
- 20:17it'll help you understand why they don't vote or why they don't vote often.
- 20:23Because they might actually have similar motivations to you, but it's twisted, for lack
- 20:28of a better term, in a way that persuades them not to vote.
- 20:33Maybe a nonvoter is motivated by altruism, but whereas an altruistic voter is doing it because
- 20:40they want to help others through their vote, maybe the nonvoter feels it's actually
- 20:45altruistic for them to not vote because they are ill informed or they don't even know where
- 20:50to start to become informed.
- 20:52So they think they would actually be doing their fellow citizens an injustice to
- 20:58participate in the political process when they don't know what they're doing.
- 21:02Or maybe a nonvoter wants to belong, but the group that they belong to or that they feel
- 21:08they most belong to also doesn't vote.
- 21:12So it's...
- 21:13If they don't have anybody else to show them the way of how to go about voting or why voting
- 21:19is important, even if they may wanna try to go vote, they may be persuaded because, well, I
- 21:24don't know anybody else who votes, so I guess I'm not gonna go vote either.
- 21:27I don't even know where to begin.
- 21:31As voters, we often take it for granted that we should just go vote.
- 21:35But just like how voting is a habit, so is not voting.
- 21:38So if you want to change that habit, if you want to break that habit, you need to flip that
- 21:43motivation on its head.
- 21:45And even if you do, that's not a guarantee that they're gonna go vote.
- 21:48Make that perfectly clear.
- 21:50But you're gonna have much...
- 21:52A much greater chance to change that behavior if you do that.
- 21:58So if you have that nonvoter who wants to be long, you might wanna offer them a ride to
- 22:04their local polling area so that they can feel like they're part of a voting community.
- 22:08You say, hey.
- 22:09Look.
- 22:10I'll help you research these candidates, and then we can go to the polling place together
- 22:14and cast a ballot.
- 22:16Now you've planted those seeds, and academic studies have shown that going to take a friend
- 22:21to go vote makes them much more likely to go vote and to stay consistent in voting.
- 22:28Or a nonvoter who is motivated by altruism.
- 22:33You might show them how getting involved is actually better for others around them that
- 22:37they care about and say, look.
- 22:38You may think you're doing your friends and your community a service by not participating
- 22:44because you're afraid of making a bad uninformed decision, but it's actually hurting
- 22:50your community, and here's why.
- 22:54That's obviously a lot easier said than done, and I'm certainly not gonna promise that that's
- 22:59gonna work on people.
- 23:00Some people are just not gonna vote no matter what you do, no matter what you say, but you
- 23:05have to meet nonvoters and irregular voters where they are if you want to have any chance
- 23:10of increasing their participation in the political process.
- 23:14So not only understanding your why for why you vote, but understanding why other people vote
- 23:19is important and also understanding why some people don't vote.
- 23:24And you may find a lot more commonalities amongst yourselves than you may initially
- 23:31think.
- 23:31And that is gonna wrap things up for today's episode of politics with Paul.
- 23:35Thank you so much for listening.
- 23:36As you can probably tell from my voice, a little bit under the weather.
- 23:39I'm just getting over COVID, so I've had to make this episode a little bit shorter,
- 23:45unfortunately.
- 23:46So sorry about that, but thank you for tuning in.
- 23:49And and maybe this will work out better.
- 23:51It'll be a lot more condensed and focused.
- 23:53Maybe it'll it'll work out better this way anyways.
- 23:56But links in the show notes, my other works, like my five day educational email course about
- 24:02how we can all be more effective in mitigating political polarization, my book on political
- 24:10independence and why they rarely win elections and how they could become more competitive on
- 24:15Amazon, ebook, and paperback format, my medium.com profile that I write on from time to
- 24:21time, and then my other links, my Facebook page, my LinkedIn profile, my website,
- 24:27paulraider.org, and my email, PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com.
- 24:31And that's where we're gonna wrap it up.
- 24:34So please, again, like, comment, share, subscribe, and thank you for listening, and
- 24:38we'll see you next time.