Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Did the Old Testament Endorse Slavery? (with Dr. Joshua Bowen)
Transcript
- 0:02Three, The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the
- 0:19truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand
- 0:23on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feelself much more. Happiness, truth,
- 0:32beauty, and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question
- 0:38everything, and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Said
- 0:47Andrews. There is video of this conversation. The YouTube bank is in the
- 0:59discreet option box of the show. How many times have we been engaged with
- 1:06an apologist speaking in defense of the Bible and we go right to Old Testament
- 1:11slavery? Right, slavery is wrong. This seems rudimentary, and yet the
- 1:18apologists, I don't know, the tap dance they do is just bizarre.
- 1:22So I just finished narrating the audible audiobook of did the Old Testament Indoors Slavery?
- 1:30Written by doctor Joshua Bowen. Doctor josh is with me, hey brother,
- 1:34second edition, that's what we're calling it right. Yeah, that's right,
- 1:38because your first version came out three four years ago, is that right?
- 1:42Yeah? And it was about two hundred pages. I think in the
- 1:45end, this one I think tapped out at seven or two. So,
- 1:49Josh, I mean, this seems rudimentary, slavery bad, slavery bad,
- 1:56and yet especially online, I mean, what kind of stuff are you hearing?
- 2:00What kind of stuff are you what kind of things are you hearing out
- 2:05there? Yeah, It's one of these things that I thought back in twenty
- 2:09eighteen, when I first started kind of talking about this topic, I thought
- 2:14it would be something that would be fairly short lived, right, you'd you
- 2:17know, I'd go and I'd say, okay, look I get it.
- 2:21These Hebrew words that kind of complicated, or you know, it might be
- 2:23unclear with some of these passages. Mean, but look, let me just
- 2:27show you what the text says. Let me show you the engine are Eastern
- 2:30background. And now you realize Christian apologists that it's like the real slavery.
- 2:35It's not some kind of gentle slavery. And the apologist would then say,
- 2:40oh my gosh, well that's that's terrible, right, we shouldn't be doing
- 2:45that. We shouldn't be defending that, and instead what I'm getting is,
- 2:52well, huh, maybe slavery is not immoral, then sort of a strange
- 2:59way to go with that. Well, what I hear a lot of is
- 3:01it's indentured servitude. These were volunteers. They owed somebody some money or a
- 3:08favor, and so they just thought, well, I will sell myself to
- 3:14someone else, and then it's kind of a deal where I can hop out
- 3:17of that arrangement at any time. You hear a lot of that, right,
- 3:21John, Yes, definitely, definitely, And certainly you know that there
- 3:25is in the ancient world, including the Hebrew Vibal, there is indentured servitude.
- 3:30It's definitely not something that you can just hop out of whenever you like.
- 3:36You know this, this is the real kind of slavery. So even
- 3:38if from the standpoint of the law, someone did voluntarily enter into a slave
- 3:45contract, you know, two weeks into it, you can't then say,
- 3:49well, that was fun, but I'm going to go try my hand at
- 3:53something else. The biggest thing that I get pushed back for, you know,
- 3:57if somebody isn't coming back at me with well, that verse doesn't mean
- 4:00that or this passage you're misunderstanding that which you know. Generally speaking, I
- 4:05don't get a lot of direct pushback like that which you know is better.
- 4:10It used to be that way. Now what I get is, well,
- 4:12Josh, how do you even know that slavery is immoral? Like? What
- 4:16is your ultimate foundation for morality to even say that slavery is immoral? And
- 4:23it's just such a weird thing, you know. I think when we get
- 4:27to that point, if I'm having to try to convince you that owning another
- 4:30person's property is bad, like I feel like it's close to the same place
- 4:34as me having to convince you that rape is bad or murder is bad.
- 4:39If we're there, I don't know. In a lot of ways in this
- 4:42argument, I feel like I've won. Well, it's a shoot the messenger
- 4:46thing. It's the objective moral standard. If you don't believe in the standard
- 4:48bearer, then how do you know slavery would be wrong? You should?
- 4:54You should at least not care about slavery. They don't realize how insulting the
- 5:00claim really is. If you don't believe in my God, then you probably
- 5:04are a slavery, murder and rape endorser. I mean, it just comes
- 5:08off like that then. Yeah, and with those types of people, I
- 5:12you know, ultimately what follows hand in hand is this idea that if if
- 5:19they didn't have God, this you know, this will this will come out
- 5:21along run with them. If they didn't have God, if they didn't believe
- 5:26in God, boy, they'd be a terribly a moral person, to which
- 5:29I say, like, well, keep believing, please, right, because
- 5:33if you need God to be a moral person and hang on to that belief,
- 5:39because the boy, I don't want to live in a society where you
- 5:44know, you don't believe anymore. Because I saw an apologist on the debate
- 5:47stage in my own home state do that very thing. He's like, you
- 5:50know, I'm so thankful for my relationship with Jesus Christ, because man,
- 5:55if I didn't know God, I'd be out there doing all kinds of harm.
- 5:59I'd be a domestic abuser, and I'd probably be stealing from people.
- 6:02He just said it like that, and as Interlocketer said, well, in
- 6:06your case, I'm kind of glad you believe in God, right, because
- 6:10otherwise you would be you'd be a nightmare, right, Yeah, no doubt.
- 6:14And this is what's so frightening though, I think about the slavery component
- 6:19to this discussion, because quite the opposite seems to be the case. Right.
- 6:25It seems like if a fundamentalist evangelical didn't hold to those sort of core
- 6:30tenants a fundamentalism, then when I, when I show them in the Bible
- 6:34that this is actual, real slavery, they would be free to say,
- 6:40well, gosh, I must be you know, I must be misunderstanding how
- 6:45to read this text, because certainly this interpretive framework that I have, I
- 6:51shouldn't be walking away from these passages saying slavery is okay. So it seems
- 6:57like it's actually that fundamental framework that's causing them to say, well, if
- 7:02it is the real kind of slavery, then maybe slavery is not bad in
- 7:08and of itself. Maybe owning people is okay. Maybe it's you know,
- 7:12doctor Joshua Bowen, I know, I jumped right into the deep end with
- 7:15you real fast. For those just now being introduced, can you give me
- 7:18sort of your credentials, for lack of a better word, tell everybody what
- 7:24it is that you do and what you bring to the discussion about slavery in
- 7:28the Bible. Please. Yeah. So you know, I went and got
- 7:31a bachelor's degree years ago in religion from the very conservative university, Liberty University,
- 7:41and I was a fundamentalist evangelical for twenty six years. And so when
- 7:45I finished my bachelor's degree, I then went on to get a master's in
- 7:48theology, which is like twenty six semester hour graduate degree from again another very
- 7:57conservative fundamentalist school called Capital Bible. But I really focused in on Hebrew and
- 8:03the Old Testament, and I learned Aramaic and a Kadian and Syriac and Agritic
- 8:09and all these other Semitic languages. And so because of that, I went
- 8:13and applied to get into the program at Johns Hopkins University to study the broader
- 8:18ancient Near East. So that's what's called the Syriology program, just studying the
- 8:24languages and cultures of ancient to Rock. And because of my background, I
- 8:28minored in Hebrew Bible, and so I have a PhD in Ancient Christian Studies,
- 8:35majoring in the Syriologies, marrying a Kadian, those types of languages,
- 8:39but then minoring and the Old Testament and Revival and so you know, because
- 8:45of that, what I do I do sort of public facing work online and
- 8:52try to make the Old Testament, the wider ancient Near East easier to understand,
- 8:58more publicly accessible, too interested in non specialists. That's sort of one
- 9:03of the sort of snarky responses I've had when I told people that I had
- 9:09narrated your audio book. I think this is number three that I've done for
- 9:13you. And for those claiming that I am completely operating with self interest here,
- 9:18okay, yeah, whatever, I mean. I want people to be
- 9:22a part of the conversation, and I'm proud of the work. I think
- 9:26it came out to be about nine hours of recorded audiobook, But a lot
- 9:28of people when I post a link, they're like that it take you nine
- 9:31hours to say, yes, the Old Testament doesendar slavery, which is kind
- 9:37of a I get it. I get that on the surface, but it
- 9:41doesn't address the larger question of why and how right? Why and how does
- 9:48it operate? What do the ancient laws say, how do they inform the
- 9:54writing of the Old Testament and the command structures, how do they echo other
- 10:00Near Eastern laws? You know, these are tools in the toolbox if we're
- 10:03going to engage the apologists. So I just think snarking, well, of
- 10:07course, it is lavery, and then you just sort of, you know,
- 10:11go off and congratulate yourself for being so clever. That bugs me a
- 10:15little bit because it ignores really the nuts and bolts of slavery. Are you
- 10:20seeing that some people are like, why would you write a whole book the
- 10:22answers, yes, right, oh, yeah, no doubt. And you
- 10:26know, for certain people, I think that's probably okay. But these are
- 10:31people that I think that are not going to have maybe the patience, and
- 10:35that's okay, but you know, they're not going to be actively engaging with
- 10:41people, either in their family or online, you know, in the details
- 10:48of the discussion. Again, I think that's okay. Certain people just you
- 10:50know, that's not their thing, and I think that's fine. But if
- 10:54you are interested in having a conversation where you say more than just well yeah,
- 11:00obviously did, let's move on. This is the type of this is
- 11:05the type of material that's useful. I was out with Megan last night and
- 11:11we were watching the Barbie movie and I got a message on the app Clubhouse
- 11:18from a friend of mine, Tom Rabbit, and he asked me, Hey,
- 11:24what's the best argument against this? Exodus twenty one, sixteen it's illegal
- 11:28to kidnap someone and reduce them to slavery. You know, I've got this
- 11:33apologist that's sitting here telling me, well, here, look, Extra twenty
- 11:35one sixteen says you can't kidnap people and reduce them to slavery. Doesn't this
- 11:39mean that there isn't a slavery? Well, you know, that's a that's
- 11:43something that if you just say, well, obviously it endorses it, you're
- 11:48not gonna be able to answer that question. And that's sort of what the
- 11:52book is designed to do. It's designed to take you know, apologetic arguments
- 11:58that get down in, as you say, like the nuts and bolts,
- 12:01the specific passages, and to say, look, here's a passage that says
- 12:05slaves can run away and you can't return them. How do you address that?
- 12:09Well, I mean, if you're just saying to somebody, know it
- 12:11does, and you don't know anymore, you're not going to be able to
- 12:13address that. And the chances are that if you actually do talk to somebody
- 12:16about it, that passage is going to catch you sort of flat footed and
- 12:24it might seem like something that's hard to answer on the fly. So I
- 12:28think it's an important you know, thing to sort of be armed. I
- 12:31think one of the challenges though, as we say yes it existed in the
- 12:35Bible, and the apologist says Noah didn't. Yes it did, No,
- 12:39it didn't. I mean, there's no real dialogue happening there. I also
- 12:43think that some of the tactics of apologists are trapping you, and the nature
- 12:50of these types of debates is not hang on just a second, that's an
- 12:54interesting claim that you've made. Can we take a moment and research that if
- 12:58you want to pause and you want to go do a deeper dive and research
- 13:03the claim that is made. The style over substance vibe of some of these
- 13:09debates makes you look unprepared and weak. It's I don't know, it's one
- 13:13of those weird things about debating, right if if you are thoughtful and you
- 13:16take a pause and say, well, let's find out, you tend to
- 13:20look unprepared for the discussion, right, Yeah, And that's really you know,
- 13:26I know, we always talk about like how things are and how they
- 13:31should be. Certainly that is a way that things are, and we wish
- 13:35that they were different, right. We wish that interlocutors would come honestly to
- 13:39these discussions and say we want to get actually to the truth, but that's
- 13:43that's not the reality. Right, And and even even not in a formal
- 13:46debate, right, even sitting at the dining room table over Thanksgiving with that
- 13:52fundamentalists, you know, cousin that you have, you know, any pause
- 13:58that you have there, any question that you have, even in that case,
- 14:03I think going to be seen as say, well I got him,
- 14:07I got her. And that's what the stuff that I write it's specifically designed
- 14:16to equip someone to have those conversations. So the other two books that you
- 14:22that you did, the audio versions of atheist handbooks to the Old Testament volumes
- 14:28wanted two, Like, that's that's what they do, right, They go
- 14:31through specific topics and say like here, this is how you talk to somebody
- 14:35about did most write the Pentituch or you know, is their violence and genocide
- 14:39and the Old Testament those types of things. But here with the slavery discussion,
- 14:45there really are certain passages that everybody wants to go to. Right,
- 14:48everybody that's an atheist, urn agnostic, or skeptic, they want to say
- 14:52Leviticus twenty five forty four to forty six XOS twenty one twenty to twenty one,
- 14:56like they want to come out with those and that's good, think they
- 15:00should. The problem is the apologist is going to go, yeah, yeah,
- 15:03yeah, yeah, but and then instead of engaging with those verses,
- 15:07what they're going to do is throw a different verse at you. They're going
- 15:11to say, yeah, but look, let's just assume slavery is really bad
- 15:15in the sex or this livitic is twenty five passage here in Deuteronomy twenty three.
- 15:18It says, if a slave runs a way, you can't return them,
- 15:20So it doesn't matter how bad it is. Right, because of the
- 15:24slave runs a way, you can't return them. So all they had to
- 15:26do is lead, right, And at that point, if you don't if
- 15:28you don't know that verse, if you're not aware of what it says,
- 15:33boy, it's it's tough. You know, it's tough to engage with that.
- 15:37And there are certain passages, there are certain arguments that come up over
- 15:41and over and over again. That again, if you're not ready for it,
- 15:46if you haven't thought about it, if you haven't you read something or
- 15:50listen to something about it, it can be very difficult in the moment to
- 15:54engage with those verses in a beautiful way. Max, I want to talk
- 15:58about Old Testament New Testament. What's the difference and does the New Testament condemn
- 16:04slavery? We're going to find out next. My patrons get the broadcast early
- 16:15and totally commercial free or your support and patronage. You have my thanks Patreon
- 16:22dot com slash Seth Andrews talking with doctor Joshua Bowen, author of the new
- 16:27book Did the Old Testament Indorse Slavery? Second Edition? One of the responses
- 16:34is, well, have you read the New Testament? Have you read the
- 16:37New Covenant? Of course, you know, even if there was slavery,
- 16:41it was God's attempt to work within the system that was in place these primitives,
- 16:48and they did slavery, and so God was kind of trying to speak
- 16:51in their primitive language. It's that bigotry of lowered expectations. And then they
- 16:57bump into the New Testament and say, but the New Covenant hates slavery.
- 17:03That's bullshit right in a word, yes, And this is one of the
- 17:08things that's new in the in the second edition is going into what I call
- 17:15the aftermath, and that's looking at what does the New Testament say about the
- 17:21topic of slavery? What is what is the early Church? What do they
- 17:26think about the topic of slavery? How did they understand what the the Old
- 17:30Testament? And you know, of course Jesus and Paul and other New Testament
- 17:34writers what did they interpret that to me? And then ultimately we get into
- 17:38the Antelope South. But I mean, as far as the New Testament's concerned,
- 17:42like, you know, the Old Testament is setting out laws, right,
- 17:48This is how most of the passages that that people engage with are in
- 17:52the legal collections that you find in the Penitude in the New Testament. You
- 17:57know, the situation culturally is different, right, you know, the Chosen
- 18:03people are not being presented as being in power. Right, it's not coming
- 18:07from a top down approach where they can set laws. Instead, when you
- 18:11read Paul or when you read Jesus, it's very much from a bottom up
- 18:15approach. They're you know, they're under the thumb of Rome, right,
- 18:18or they're under the thumb of people that are above them. And and so
- 18:22you would expect in that case maybe a little bit, you know, us
- 18:26to be a little more relaxed about it. They're just kind of maybe that's
- 18:30a place where they're kind of engaging with that. The problem is that Jesus
- 18:33makes some very still definitive statements things about like divorce. He's very clear Matthew
- 18:41nineteen what he thinks about divorce, flying in the face of what it says
- 18:45in the in the law in the Old Testament. And so it doesn't seem
- 18:48like Jesus has a problem saying, yeah, you guys, you have this
- 18:53in the law. But really, from the beginning, it wasn't like this.
- 18:56It wasn't God's intent, right, he knows is just working with you
- 19:00here. He's he's cool to say that about things like divorce. But when
- 19:04it comes to slavery, not only do we not see condemnation of it,
- 19:11but we actually see things like Jesus using hypothetical scenarios analogies where slavery is a
- 19:19given right and he's saying, you know, which, which one of you,
- 19:25having a slave to his apostles, Which one of you having a slave,
- 19:29would would allow him to do this? No, of course you wouldn't.
- 19:32You would make him go do the hard work. And so it's it's
- 19:36it's very difficult, I think for an apologist to find a place in the
- 19:40New Testament where certainly that it condemned slavery. I know of nothing that condemned
- 19:47slavery. But it's even hard to find something that seems to suggest that it's
- 19:52it's it's not a given right, it's not something that is understood to sort
- 19:56of be the way you know that maybe that it should be. Was there
- 20:02some pushback in the Old Testament time human rights advocates against slavery. That's a
- 20:10tough question. I don't know that they would have pushed back on it necessarily
- 20:15from a moral standpoint. Instead, what they were I think trying to do
- 20:21was say slaves in and of themselves have humanity right, that these are humans.
- 20:29And generally speaking, this was more focused on people that were debt slaves,
- 20:36people that had come into this position of enslavement through having you know,
- 20:45some type of a debt or alone, or they've been pledged and in such
- 20:48a way that it was assumed ultimately that once the debt was paid off,
- 20:56they would return to their free status, you know, free status, which
- 21:00is tricky in of itself, and and so I think often based on the
- 21:06humanity of the slave, there were certain regulations that were always put in place
- 21:11in the engineers, including the Hebrew Bible, to mitigate things like slave abuse,
- 21:18certainly killing a slave, and and so those types of things are very
- 21:23common to the engineers to in law collections. And again they show up in
- 21:26the Hebrew Bibles as we would expect. And and the other thing that you
- 21:32see is that there does seem to be across the board preferential treatment for you
- 21:37know, for lack of a better term, citizens, Right, so if
- 21:41you have a law collection for a particular country, or you know, for
- 21:45a particular nation, you know, laws tend to be better for citizens than
- 21:52for foreigners for the same type of things. So you know, certainly in
- 21:57the Hebrew Bible, for example, you can see things like you can charge
- 22:02interest on the loan to a foreigner, but you can't do that to a
- 22:04fellow Israelite. And you know, if you if you take a Hebrew slave,
- 22:11you have to release them after six years they're they're freedom the seventh and
- 22:18in the course the little is twenty five. This changes a little bit even
- 22:22in this regard where ultimately you know, they weren't allowed to keep Israelites slaves,
- 22:30Israelites as slaves any longer you had to you had to keep them,
- 22:33to keep them as hired workers, but not to jump in quickly Josh forgetting
- 22:37interruption. The fact that they would differentiate between the treatment of in group slaves
- 22:45and out group slaves. That's a moral referendum, right, I mean,
- 22:48that's a moral judgment. They're like, well, I don't want you to
- 22:51treat our people the way you would treat other people. That's Is that a
- 22:56good way to saying Yeah, I mean I'm always I'm always reticent to make
- 23:02those types of moral I guess claims about a text, primarily because I don't
- 23:08work in ethics. Yeah, but I mean, if you're talking about the
- 23:11Israelites, right, we don't want to do this. We're not going to
- 23:15do that to the israel Lites. We're not going to hold them to this
- 23:18strict of a standard. That to me, I mean, it's I know
- 23:22we're inferring, but it seems like they kind of knew that the tougher rules
- 23:26applying to the odd group kind of sucked for them, right, Yes,
- 23:30and definitely. And I think maybe the way that I would want to nuance
- 23:33it is I don't because this is something apologists want to want to point out.
- 23:38Well, look it says here in little bit like it's twenty five thirty
- 23:41nine, as you can't keep the Israelites to slaves anymore. So that means
- 23:45that they knew this slavery was immoral. And I don't think that's what's going
- 23:48on. I think what they think is slavery for Israelites is immoral, not
- 23:57the institution itself. It was very important for them to distinguish between this people
- 24:03group and that people group. And this actually, I think sort of address
- 24:08as one of these big apologetic arguments, because so often one of the first
- 24:12things that comes out from an apologist's mouth is, well, well, you
- 24:15know, slavery wasn't race based, race based in the Hebrew Bible or in
- 24:21the Old Testament as it was in the antevelom South, and and it's it's
- 24:25like, yeah, I mean, so what so what if it wasn't so
- 24:30what if race wasn't the distinguishing feature? Would it be okay? If like
- 24:33hair color was the distinguishing feature, we can we can enslave people with blonde
- 24:37hair, but now with brown hair? I guess is that really okay?
- 24:41And I mean, because what you're having to say is, well, I
- 24:44guess it's Okay, if you know in Leviticus twenty five year enslave foreigners,
- 24:48that's okay, but just not Israelites. Does that make it better for the
- 24:52apologist? That's that's what I failed to understand there when they bring up the
- 24:55race kind of a tribalistic model, isn't it. It's awesome them. It's
- 25:00okay to enslave them, or at least hold us to a higher standard,
- 25:03to relax the rules. A little bit of speaking here with the seriologist doctor
- 25:07Josh Bowen. He is author of several books, including the second edition.
- 25:12Did the Old Testament Endorse slavery? Ancient Near Eastern laws? The Old Testaments
- 25:21a lot of parallels. You've spoken about how it's not really stealing whenever.
- 25:29The Old Testament sort of emulates stuff that came before because cultural borrowing was normal.
- 25:36We addressed that in your book before this as we got into the atheist
- 25:41ten book for the Old Testament, and people said, well, they stole
- 25:44Noah's ark from Gilgamesh, and you were revealing that actually, culturally it was
- 25:48normal or myths to be borrowed and built upon and altered. Was the Old
- 25:56Testament like the previous sneer Eastern laws, they just borrow some and they enhanced
- 26:00and altered. Would that be a wedge, Sam, Yeah. One of
- 26:04the things, as you're just pointing out, that is so important is to
- 26:10utilizing older material. I mean, we do this today right when it's seems
- 26:17like it's very rare for completely new Christmas carols to come out. And I
- 26:21haven't like run numbers on that, but I feel like every year we kind
- 26:25of have the same Christmas carols, so the same Christmas songs. They might
- 26:30get reworked, you know, like a remix version or something, but but
- 26:34really we're utilizing old material. And because it's because people value in certain contexts
- 26:41and certain genres that this older material that it's it's it's revered. And this
- 26:48is I think a good parallel to what we see in the ancient Near East.
- 26:52And so with mythologies, they would utilize earlier mythologies and rework them and
- 26:57polemicize them quite often in order to make new theological points. And the same
- 27:03was true with the legal collections. So we have lots of examples and we
- 27:08go through them in the Book of Older Legal Collections. Law collections going back
- 27:14into the third millennium BC and you know, those law collections have striking parallels
- 27:23with what we see in certain parts of the Hebrew Bible, particularly places like
- 27:27Exodus twenty one and the Covenant Code and the sections about slavery. They parallel
- 27:34the laws of Hammurabi actually quite closely. And so one of the important things
- 27:38to do, and what we did in this second edition, is to do
- 27:45a lot of comparative analysis. So let's look at all of the ancient hears
- 27:51to law collections and what they say about slavery, and then look at what
- 27:56the Hebrew Bible says in its law collections. And what you end up seeing
- 28:00is that there are not only parallels, but the reality is that so little
- 28:10is changed relatively speaking. In other words, when you look at mythologies,
- 28:15you know, like you brought up the flood tradition, the flood tradition is
- 28:18very specifically reworked in order to make a theological statement about Yahweh. But the
- 28:25law collections, you know, while you might have some reworking and some intertextuality
- 28:33in that sense to bring about something new, for the most part, the
- 28:37law is in the Old Testament are just on par particularly about slavery, with
- 28:42what we see in the wider ancient Near East, and we have an entire
- 28:45chapter where I just we go through that and look at all the I'm reading
- 28:51it. Right, it's like the laws of Hammurabi and the laws of lipid
- 28:55Ishtar and the laws of ish New Noah blah blah blah, and these pre
- 28:57dates Old Testament are or they contemporary two Old Testaments. They certainly they emulate
- 29:06or originate so much of what we read in Exodus, Limticus, Deuteronomy,
- 29:10et cetera. Right, Yeah, So, like the earliest law collection that
- 29:14we have, that that that we dealt with in the book comes from the
- 29:18late third millenniums, around twenty one hundred BC. And you know most of
- 29:25the other law collections come from the second millennium. But you know, you're
- 29:27talking about a thousand to fifteen hundred years before to the local texts, and
- 29:33so yes, much earlier. And uh and this is it's it's really fascinating.
- 29:41Let scholars say and how they write about how that may have transmitted down
- 29:45to the writers of the Heb Rebibal. But I mean, for our purposes,
- 29:49it's it's terribly relevant. It's just the fact that we know that the
- 29:55writers of the heb Rebible are utilizing broad this genre of law collections and writing
- 30:03claw collections, but in some cases very specifically drawing on much earlier material,
- 30:08which is part of the point the idea that Yahweh originated these ideas. Right,
- 30:15He's the one who came up with the specific rules and laws for this
- 30:19culture. And then the next question is, well, did he also tell
- 30:25Amabi? You know, did he held the other cultures to do the same
- 30:29thing? And then he had the Old Testament written? You know, I
- 30:32think it's one of the great counter apologetics out there as people talk about how
- 30:37inspired the Old Testament is. Okay, after the break, doctor Joshua Bowen
- 30:45and I are going to get into some even darker shades of Old Testament slavery,
- 30:49some hard realities that a lot of apologists do not want to talk about.
- 30:55We continue next speaking here with doctor Joshua Bowen. He is at a
- 31:04seriologist, Old Testament scholar and his author of the new book Did the Old
- 31:11Testament Endorse Slavery? Second Edition? Let's get into a difficult but necessary conversation
- 31:19about sex slavery. The indentured servitude argument simply falls apart against the reality that
- 31:30women were sold into sex slavery in the Old Testaments. Can you elaborate,
- 31:37Yeah, you know, this is something that I think often gets passed over,
- 31:44gets sugarcoated, it's slightly reinterpreted in such a way that we can move
- 31:48past it and not not have to really deal with the reality of what these
- 31:52passages say. And again, the idea here is not to condemnation culture,
- 32:00but it's to realize what it is that these texts actually are saying. Because
- 32:04people that are looking back to the Old Testament to say this is what we
- 32:08should base our moral you know, our moral system, our ethical system on
- 32:16this is these are problematic passages. So in Exodus twenty one Versus seven through
- 32:21eleven, he kind of get your first example. There's a man who is
- 32:25falling into debt, and the law says that he can sell his daughter as
- 32:30a slave to a man to compensate to pay all fact debt, and that
- 32:35man has the right that the purchaser has the right to either take her as
- 32:40a concubine for himself or he can give her to his son. In other
- 32:49words, he has the authority to say you're gonna marry me, or you're
- 32:51gonna marry or you're gonna become a concubine of me or of my son.
- 32:57And the law, you know, sets in play some protections for her in
- 33:01that situation, and those are the things, by the way, that apologists
- 33:06will tend to really focus in and will look, the law is seeking to
- 33:10protect her right. And the problem is they class over the fact that she's
- 33:15being sold. And so we talk about in the book what's being like,
- 33:22what's happening here is there is no consent on her part. It's irrelevant she
- 33:28is being sold. She is she is passive in this transaction, and what
- 33:31she's being sold into is her use sexually right, the use of her sexual
- 33:42capabilities. So either being sold as at best like a slave wife, but
- 33:50probably more likely just concubine it because the text says that take another for himself.
- 33:55And so like this, when we talk about sexual slavery, like they
- 34:01would not have considered it sexual slavery in the ancient world like as we would
- 34:07today. But sexual slavery is someone whose sexual capabilities can be utilized by force
- 34:14by someone, and that's what's happening here. And you see this even earlier
- 34:19in the passage. But it's the woman is a more even more passive in
- 34:23Verses two to six and Exodus twenty one. It talks about a male debt
- 34:27slave who comes into servitude single and his master gives him a wife. This
- 34:35woman is a chattel slave, and it's not that she has the option,
- 34:39all right, you know, do you want to marry this guy? No,
- 34:42the master is is utilizing both her and the male slave for their sexual
- 34:49capabilities, so the man to aid in the production of more slaves. And
- 34:54so when that woman gives birth to a child, that that child is the
- 35:00property off the master comes a slave him or himself. And so like this
- 35:05is by our definition strictly chidel slavery that is sexual in nature. And again
- 35:15it's sexual slavery as you see in versus seventh or eleven, and one more
- 35:20very briefly, because again it's you know, it's something that gets glossed over
- 35:25quite commonly. Is up in Deuteronomy chapter twenty one. This is the passage
- 35:30about women who are captives from war, and an Israelite man could see a
- 35:37beautiful woman among the captives and say I want to take her as a wife.
- 35:42There is no consent here on the part of them. She's a captive
- 35:45right, and so of course by their standards, they would not have thought
- 35:51this was sexual slavery, but indeed it is. And when we read the
- 35:58verses, Josh, it's so insidious because it's not just the kidnapping of females
- 36:04for sex slavery, but they bring them in and essentially change their identity,
- 36:07right, change their clothes and cut their hair. And I think it says
- 36:10cut their fingernails, and then I'll give them four weeks to mourn the family
- 36:15that's been slaughtered. And then now you've got a woman. And I think
- 36:21if you and I had quoted this story and attributed it to the Quran in
- 36:27front of someone who was not well versed in the Christian Old Testament. And
- 36:30I do this from time to time. I'll go in and be like,
- 36:31did you hear about the woman being forced to drink the bitter water to see
- 36:37if she was an adulteress and then the fetus would flush out of her body
- 36:39and you know all those types of stories. But I attribute it to another
- 36:44religion, and there are people are aghast. Christians are like, that's just
- 36:47barbaric. It's people need to reject these horrible stories. It's so evil.
- 36:52And then you flip the switch and you say this is the Bible, and
- 36:58they wink out, right, but it's insidious, change their identity. Let
- 37:01him mourn for a few weeks like it's no big deal, and then she's
- 37:06all yours, right, And the reality here is that that month of mourning
- 37:12very likely is you know, put put in the text to sort of soften
- 37:16it. But probably what's happening here is this is to ensure that she's not
- 37:22pregnant, right, because part of what was going on here was, you
- 37:28know, a man is setting up a situation where you can have a legal
- 37:31air. This is part of the rationale here is if you want to have
- 37:38a legitimate, legal wife with whom you can produce an air, this is
- 37:44how you do it. And so this month to more and it's very likely
- 37:47to see if she's going to have a period, right to ensure that she's
- 37:52that she's not pregnant. And so yeah, I mean again, what apologists
- 37:58will do with this very very frequent say oh well, I mean sure it
- 38:01sounds bad to our ears, but I mean, like, what else was
- 38:05the guy supposed to do? Right, leave or out there on the battlefield
- 38:08to die, or you know, let her become a slave. You know
- 38:14this Honestly, in many cases, I think this is just coming from a
- 38:19often a male perspective that just doesn't understand the severity of what would happen and
- 38:29what a woman would experience in this context. But I mean, even more
- 38:31broadly, it's just trying to, as you say, sort of wink at
- 38:37some of the atrocious, more atrocious and in citious implications. Yeah, we
- 38:43get into numbers thirty one, right, I mean, God's army goes in
- 38:45slaughters everybody, but kidnaps the virgin girls. And the apologists are like,
- 38:50well, it doesn't say that they became wives or concubines or that they were
- 38:53abused sexually. I mean, for all we know, God's army was doing
- 38:59them a favor, right, their lives were spared. What a beautiful story.
- 39:04And I'm like, all right, you just slaughtered your mom and dad
- 39:07and siblings and you know friends, you just slaughtered everybody in their life,
- 39:14and then you kidnap them into your home and you're doing them a favor.
- 39:20I mean it's it's really offensive. And and to sort of top it off,
- 39:24if if anybody listening ever does talk to someone about a passage like numbers
- 39:30thirty one take them where the women that are captured, these virgin girls that
- 39:35are captured are numbered along with the other spoils of war. So you know,
- 39:42so many thousand cattle, you know, so many thousand you know,
- 39:47you know other types of property, so many thousand women, and they're divided
- 39:52up as spoil. So really, I mean, it's very difficult, I
- 39:58think, to read through that path stage and in good conscience walk away saying
- 40:04no, this was a really good thing that you were doing for them.
- 40:08The context argument is always a pain in the ass, right, Well,
- 40:13you know you're taking it out of context. Well, let's say all of
- 40:16us have misunderstood the whole concept of owning other people, including sex slaves,
- 40:24its property. Why would a benevolent an omni benevolent yahweh not come and give
- 40:31us the context we would need to properly understand these verses. I mean,
- 40:37I've got all of these experts and they've written books to explain the Book,
- 40:40which I do not get. I mean, the Bible is not enough,
- 40:43so now I need someone else. And then the expert books disagree with each
- 40:46other in its thunderdome out there. But if God really gave a shit,
- 40:52he would come down and say, this is exactly what I meant, This
- 40:57is exactly what I mean today that seems I don't know, obvious to me,
- 41:02right, And this is really the more I don't won't say comical,
- 41:08because it's certainly not funny, but odd aspects of this of this topic to
- 41:15me, because the scholars that are working in the field in something like slavery,
- 41:22they don't all disagree. Right. This is part of the reason that
- 41:27I wrote the first edition of the book and obviously now the more expanded second
- 41:30edition. But the whole point was to just tell everybody, Hey, look,
- 41:35people that work in the field on this topic, they all agree on
- 41:37this, right, They're all saying it's the bad kind of slavery. There's
- 41:42debt and chadels slavery, and so it's really only in these online discussions or
- 41:49you know, discussions amongst you know, family members, in other words,
- 41:53people that are outside of the field. This is really the only place that
- 41:57you have this topic question because go pick up an evangelical scholar or you know,
- 42:04a quote unquote liberal scholar, and all of them are going to say,
- 42:07yeah, I mean sure, the Old Testament endorsed that in chattel slavery.
- 42:12It's it's like what it did right, or it sanctioned it, whatever
- 42:15you know word that they want to use to talk about how the text says
- 42:17you may do this right in the law. Yeah, but let me jump
- 42:22in, jo, how did the theologians justify that? Because, as you
- 42:24have said, actual scholars in the field agree almost universally. It's the online
- 42:31apologists that are, you know, trying to do the tap dance. But
- 42:35if you're a theologian who is a Christian, how do you get around that?
- 42:38If you believe that chattel debt and sex slavery did happen in the Old
- 42:44Testament? And this is I think that's a really good example of this is
- 42:50in the endevelopment South right. And I'm certainly not an expert of that historical
- 42:54period, but you know, anti slavery. The Elogians they were, you
- 43:04know, primarily, as I understand it, the progressive Christians, right,
- 43:08they were the ones that that said, well, gosh, these passages.
- 43:14Sure, who seem to say what the slavery? Uh? You know,
- 43:19the people that are pro slavery, Uh, it does seem to support their
- 43:22position we must not be interpreting this correctly, right, we must have to
- 43:29take a more liberal approach, and so we want to focus instead of looking
- 43:34at these passages like the legal collections, we want to look at more broad
- 43:39statements like love your enemies, right, or you know, God came to
- 43:45set the captives free, right. So we want to look at these these
- 43:50these broader, you know, big picture statements and say things like, well
- 43:55it was God as you, as you pointed out earlier, like God's sort
- 44:00of working with the people where they were. But God can do whatever he
- 44:05wants because he determines what's moral. So the Lord giveth, the Lord take
- 44:09it the way. We're the ants in the ant hill, right. So
- 44:13if God wants to burn us all with a magnifying glass, that's his prerogative.
- 44:16I've heard that one before. Yeah, And ultimately in that case,
- 44:20like if everything that God does, you know, is a reflection of his
- 44:25nature and that's where morality comes from them, whatever it is that God does
- 44:30is by definition moral, and it's just a boy. It becomes a terrible,
- 44:37terrible position for someone because then you have to say things like okay,
- 44:43first Samuel fifteen, God commands that everybody down to infants and babies be killed
- 44:50with a sword. H that's moral because God commanded it, right, and
- 44:55that's a boy, that's That's not a position I want to defend a huge
- 44:59doubles standard, right, because they wouldn't take that position with Allah or any
- 45:02other deity anywhere suddenly, any human dictator. I know we're on the clock
- 45:09here, but I want to have you kind of pitch what the book is.
- 45:14Just give everybody the I don't know the rundown of what they're in for.
- 45:19I mentioned it's about nine hours in audio form, and the actual book
- 45:22itself is a great resource because it also has a bunch of appendices and references.
- 45:27It's a deep dive, right, I mean, even as I was
- 45:30narrating, I'm like, I'm I qualifying to read this. I did feel
- 45:34that. But give me the rundown of the book real fast. Yeah.
- 45:37Basically, the book is designed for anybody that is interested in discussing did the
- 45:45Old Testament and ultimately the Bible endorse the practice of slavery? Is it real
- 45:51slavery? Is it like sort of a nice some sort of nicer version of
- 45:53slavers that would be calling it like a set set like inventions servitude or is
- 45:59it really chattel slavery? And what I do not only do I go through
- 46:04all of the specific passages in the Old Testament that deal in the laws with
- 46:10slavery, but it really focuses in on comparing all of those laws to the
- 46:15laws and the wider ancient Near East. And so there's a whole chapter dedicated
- 46:20to what were those laws and the ancient nearies, how they function, what
- 46:23apologetic arguments to do are you know, are made based on those? And
- 46:28then it gives overviews of slavery and the ancient ear East slavery and the Hebrew
- 46:32Bible of the Old Testament, and then it goes through the specific passages about
- 46:37slavery. Then it has a whole chapter on comparative analysis. So you know,
- 46:42when you see an ex of the twenty one sixteen it says it's illegal
- 46:45to kidnap people, Well, gosh, that sounds really bad. We were
- 46:47there other laws and the ancient earies that said you couldn't kidnap people. Spoilers,
- 46:52yes, And so we go through all of them, and then there's
- 46:55a chapter that talks about the New Testament, the Early Church, the Antibell
- 47:00them South, like, what is it in this aftermath of the Old Testament
- 47:02that these texts were utilized? How were they utilized? And then finally there's
- 47:08a chapter that just deals with any other major arguments that apologists and people in
- 47:15social media bring about these texts and about these passages about slavery. And then
- 47:22of course in the print version there's hefty appendices. But I mean, really,
- 47:25I think that the audiobook really capture what most people are going to need
- 47:31it for. You're very kind to say that, Well, it's you know,
- 47:36I think what I love about you and Megan, beyond the fact that
- 47:38your stellar human beings and dear friends, is that you take even though you're
- 47:43kind of a geek egghead type. And I say that as a compliment,
- 47:45Josh, but you let the rest of us play along, all right,
- 47:51those of us who don't have a PhD, who are not a seriologist,
- 47:53who are not Old Testament scholars. You you phrase it in a way that
- 47:59doesn't con to send to us, but it is written in a language that
- 48:02tools us up for these necessary conversations. Links to the book an audiobook in
- 48:08the description box. Thanks for writing it because I'm sick and tired of the
- 48:14apology. Not that they're going to stop, but I'm sick and tired of
- 48:15the apologist trying to tell me that it either didn't happen, that it's out
- 48:20of context, or that it's okay because Yahweh decided slavery. Thank you for
- 48:25writing the book, Doctor Joshua Bowen. You are much appreciated, my friend.
- 48:30Thank you, sir. I appreciate having follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook
- 48:34and Twitter. For a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs
- 48:38and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 48:44and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 48:49The Thinking Atheist dot com