Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / No-Fault ICBC Insurance Under Fire
Transcript
- 0:00SPEAKER_03: We start with the fight over no fault model insurance.
- 0:03SPEAKER_03: This has erupted into a major provincial election issue now.
- 0:08SPEAKER_03: The BC conservatives promising to replace the current system, no fault insurance, with a hybrid model.
- 0:14SPEAKER_03: You'd have the joys to hire a lawyer again in and sue for compensation if you're seriously injured in a crash.
- 0:21SPEAKER_03: The conservatives are also saying we're gonna look at private auto insurance competition in British Columbia.
- 0:27SPEAKER_03: Michael Mulligan standing by to discuss this.
- 0:29SPEAKER_03: First, let's have a listen to Dirksen here.
- 0:31SPEAKER_03: Here he is speaking yesterday.
- 0:33SPEAKER_02: I am absolutely committed and I promise that we will bring a hybrid solution for it.
- 0:39SPEAKER_02: We will have limits around what litigation will look like and the cost of uh what a lawyer will be able to charge.
- 0:47SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 0:47SPEAKER_03: Mike Farnworth, though, he was on the show yesterday, the former NDP Solicitor General running for re-election.
- 0:54SPEAKER_03: He says if the conservatives win and they do this, you better get set to pay through the nose for your auto insurance.
- 1:00SPEAKER_03: Have a listen.
- 1:01SPEAKER_01: British Columbians will pay almost double for their car insurance.
- 1:06SPEAKER_01: That's what it that's what this means.
- 1:08SPEAKER_01: We know that in Alberta and Ontario, they're paying the highest insurance rates in the entire country.
- 1:14SPEAKER_01: Okay, what we want here back in BC, do we want the dumpster fire back here in BC that we had?
- 1:19SPEAKER_03: All right, let's discuss.
- 1:20SPEAKER_03: With my guest now, Michael Mulligan, criminal defense lawyer, Mulligan Defense Lawyers in Victoria.
- 1:26SPEAKER_03: Always grateful to him.
- 1:27SPEAKER_03: Michael, thank you very much for coming on this morning.
- 1:29SPEAKER_00: Hey, good morning.
- 1:29SPEAKER_00: Always great to be here.
- 1:30SPEAKER_03: Okay, likewise, Michael.
- 1:31SPEAKER_03: Let's start with the fundamental question here.
- 1:34SPEAKER_03: What is wrong with no fault insurance?
- 1:36SPEAKER_03: It's definitely cheaper than the old insurance system we had, right?
- 1:40SPEAKER_00: That's true.
- 1:41SPEAKER_00: Uh, but uh, like with most things in life, you get what you pay for.
- 1:45SPEAKER_00: Uh, and to be honest, for minor uh injuries, uh, it works fine.
- 1:51SPEAKER_00: Uh the uh, I mean, there may be philosophical questions about uh whether people should be at fault for what they do, but if you're dealing with uh fender bender and somebody's off work for a day or two or they've got a cast or something, it's not the end of the world.
- 2:04SPEAKER_00: And frankly, we had under the uh prior system a hybrid system as well.
- 2:09SPEAKER_00: It was called part seven benefits, which would pay for like your cast and your you know a little bit of lost work, that kind of thing.
- 2:16SPEAKER_00: But the problem with no fault arises for very serious injuries.
- 2:20SPEAKER_00: Like if somebody becomes a quadriplegic, they can't work for the rest of their life, there are a number of circumstances where it just produces profoundly unfair results.
- 2:30SPEAKER_00: Uh they include things like, for example, no fault takes no account of what might happen in somebody's future.
- 2:36SPEAKER_00: And so if you had somebody who was a third-year medical student who works at Starbucks on the weekend to pay for their education, uh, and they get seriously injured and are never able to work again, they get paid a portion of their Starbucks income for the rest of their life with no consideration about what would happen to them.
- 2:53SPEAKER_00: And so that's a serious problem.
- 2:55SPEAKER_00: The other problem with it is it's a monopoly.
- 2:58SPEAKER_00: And there are two things that control the conduct of large companies, including insurance companies, right?
- 3:03SPEAKER_00: One would be competition, and the other is the possibility of like an independent review of what you do.
- 3:09SPEAKER_00: That would be the judiciary could previously review what ICBC was doing if you're unfair, or it's gonna go to court.
- 3:15SPEAKER_00: That's taken away, and so you're left with a company that can essentially act with impunity.
- 3:19SPEAKER_00: And so combining those things, it produces very unfair results in serious cases.
- 3:24SPEAKER_03: Okay, let's have a listen to Mike Farnworth again.
- 3:26SPEAKER_03: So this is Farnworth on the show yesterday running for re-election for the NDP.
- 3:31SPEAKER_03: He says that no fault auto insurance is just fine, even if you are seriously injured in a car crash, don't worry about it.
- 3:38SPEAKER_03: ICBC is going to take care of you.
- 3:40SPEAKER_03: It's working great.
- 3:41SPEAKER_03: Here's what he had to say, then I'll get your thoughts.
- 3:44SPEAKER_01: Under the uh tort system, the legal system, uh, the amount of money that one would get in a catastrophic industry was based on uh what you have as your insurance.
- 3:52SPEAKER_01: So if you had three million dollars insurance, uh that would be what you would get, minus, of course, the 30% of the legal fees.
- 3:59SPEAKER_01: Uh under uh enhanced care, if those costs run up to$10 million uh over the course of your life, that's what you get.
- 4:06SPEAKER_03: Oh, okay.
- 4:07SPEAKER_03: So he says if you're seriously injured in a crash, you get like$10 million.
- 4:11SPEAKER_03: Like what are what are people complaining about?
- 4:13SPEAKER_03: Your thoughts, Michael?
- 4:16SPEAKER_00: That's the only way I can put it.
- 4:18SPEAKER_00: Uh the uh under the system where you could sue somebody, what you could sue them for is not limited by your insurance.
- 4:24SPEAKER_00: That's sort of the whole point.
- 4:26SPEAKER_00: What's also fascinating, and it explains why the NDP is sort of uh putting out these just completely misleading announcements, saying that there was some kind of a secret letter or secret deal, which is has no basis in reality.
- 4:40SPEAKER_00: It comes from, and it was fascinating, I listened carefully to your interview with Mr.
- 4:43SPEAKER_00: Farnsworth.
- 4:44SPEAKER_00: And it was possible to tell what he was reading from, what was in front of him when he was reading.
- 4:48SPEAKER_00: Uh, and it was a press release issued by a union called Move Up, and that's the COP local that is the Union for ICBC employees.
- 4:57SPEAKER_00: And the reason that was completely clear, not only from what you just mentioned, but during your interview with him yesterday, he was reading from uh examples in that union's press release that they just put out this week.
- 5:10SPEAKER_00: He gave an example of a 30-year-old male with a F-350, and he gave an example of an 18-year-old male with a Honda Civic.
- 5:17SPEAKER_00: Both of those are from this ICBC union called Move Up, uh, that has been intensely campaigning for a long time in favor of no fault.
- 5:25SPEAKER_00: Uh, in fact, looking at what was going on this week, it caused me to look up what this union had been doing, and it goes back to why the NDP introduced no fault.
- 5:35SPEAKER_00: Uh, that union, that uh move up union, which is a part of a larger union called CLTE, uh, during a uh I guess they thought they were doing it uh internally.
- 5:44SPEAKER_00: There was a conference they held in 2022, and that move up union uh reported on in the conference uh how they had run a campaign called Driving Public Campaign, uh, where their 5,000 members who worked for ICBC got funding from the national COPE union and ran a campaign in favor of uh Monopoly No Fault with ICBC, and they described it as a campaign to save our union.
- 6:11SPEAKER_00: And they thanked them for their significant financial support to run this advertising campaign.
- 6:16SPEAKER_00: That occurred back in 2019 when again there was discussion about the possibility of competition for ICBC.
- 6:23SPEAKER_03: So do you think do you think okay, Michael?
- 6:25SPEAKER_03: That's very interesting.
- 6:26SPEAKER_03: Do you think that that's a major factor here that a lot of this is being driven by the union at ICBC uh trying to keep out private sector competition?
- 6:35SPEAKER_00: There is no question about it.
- 6:37SPEAKER_00: They've said so clearly.
- 6:38SPEAKER_00: I've got the report on it, and you have this you have uh Mike Farnsworth, the NDP, reading from the move up uh union press release, uh saying various misleading things uh in an effort to try to justify uh a uh no fault scheme that otherwise we know works serious injustice to people who were badly injured.
- 6:59SPEAKER_03: Michael Mullengan is my guest.
- 7:01SPEAKER_03: We're talking about the fight over no fault to auto insurance.
- 7:03SPEAKER_03: Let me ask you about private sector competition here, because right now, when it comes to basic auto insurance, that's the basic insurance you're required by law to buy.
- 7:11SPEAKER_03: ICBC has a monopoly on that.
- 7:13SPEAKER_03: They're the only outfit you can buy from.
- 7:16SPEAKER_03: Now, what's wrong with some private sector competition?
- 7:19SPEAKER_03: Like if ICBC is so great, why not allow them, why not allow private sector companies to compete against them?
- 7:25SPEAKER_03: And if people love ICBC, they'll keep buying their insurance from ICBC.
- 7:28SPEAKER_03: If they get a better deal from the private sector, then maybe they can shop around.
- 7:33SPEAKER_03: I'm not sure what the problem is with that.
- 7:35SPEAKER_03: Now, let me play a clip here for you, Michael, for your thoughts.
- 7:37SPEAKER_03: Mike Farnworth, again, on the show yesterday saying, look, you don't do this, don't monkey around with this system because it's working great and it's low cost.
- 7:46SPEAKER_03: Let's listen.
- 7:48SPEAKER_01: The model that works that they have in uh Manitoba and Saskatchewan under both conservative and NDP governments, it's a model that has delivered the lowest insurance costs for for motors.
- 7:59SPEAKER_01: We have the lowest in the in in in the country here in BC.
- 8:03SPEAKER_03: Okay, so he says we got the lowest insurance costs in in Canada here with public insurance.
- 8:08SPEAKER_03: Your thoughts.
- 8:09SPEAKER_00: Uh well, first of all, in answer to your question, there is nothing wrong with competition unless, of course, your primary goal is to preserve your 5,000 union positions and you're the union called move up, right?
- 8:21SPEAKER_00: It's devastating if you have to face competition.
- 8:23SPEAKER_00: And you're quite right.
- 8:24SPEAKER_00: What's wrong with it?
- 8:25SPEAKER_00: If the ICBC insurance is so great and so inexpensive and everything's wonderful about it, people can choose that.
- 8:32SPEAKER_00: Uh, what's being talked about is should you force them to choose that?
- 8:35SPEAKER_00: Should you give them no options?
- 8:36SPEAKER_00: Should you force people to purchase insurance which uh has no competition and where they can act with impunity?
- 8:43SPEAKER_00: Uh, the answer to that, in my judgment, is is no.
- 8:46SPEAKER_03: Michael, thank you for coming on with your thoughts on this today.
- 8:48SPEAKER_00: Thank you so much for having me.