Latest / Roaming Returns / 151 - Minimum Balance Fees: How Banks Quietly Drain You
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to Roaming Returns, a podcast about generating
- 0:12a passive income with dividend stocks so you
- 0:15can secure your finances and liberate your life.
- 0:18This episode started because we got absolutely
- 0:20hooked by bank fees and it sent Tim down a rabbit
- 0:24hole. What was supposed to be a quick close the
- 0:26Wells Fargo accounts errand turned into a full
- 0:29-on breakdown of how minimum balance rules quietly
- 0:32drain people over time, why it's legal, and how
- 0:35banks move the goalposts without most people
- 0:37noticing. We'll share our story, the research,
- 0:40the math, and the practical alternatives so you
- 0:42can stop suffering death by a thousand cuts from
- 0:44banking fees. After having massive burn from
- 0:49bank fees. Tim went down a rabbit hole. Well,
- 0:53no, first, like, we had to tell the story. The
- 0:54story basically starts, I was, we were trying
- 0:57to close our Wells Fargo bank accounts. And I
- 0:59was like, oh, I was in there looking at the business
- 1:01account. And I said, what the hell is a money
- 1:03market? I didn't know we had a money market.
- 1:04I didn't either, honestly. So then I clicked
- 1:06into it and I saw, like, when you first click
- 1:08into Wells Fargo, it shows you, like, your recent
- 1:10transactions. And I saw a $5 service fee. I was
- 1:13like, what the hell is that about? So then I
- 1:15backtracked it. We had a service fee from 2020.
- 1:20Four. Three. 2023 on. So at one point, our account
- 1:26in the business had $300, and I moved $50 into
- 1:31one of my accounts, and that put it below, I
- 1:33guess, the $300 threshold. So we went from $233
- 1:37down to $44 over the last couple of years in
- 1:40service fees. They just keep chipping away every
- 1:42month. It's a $5 service fee. The thing that
- 1:44pisses me off is I don't even know how I didn't
- 1:46notice it was going down incrementally. I don't
- 1:48know why I had my brain set on that it was at
- 1:50$40. But we were planning to close the checking
- 1:53account anyway because I just closed that business.
- 1:55And I guess Wells Fargo bumped up their minimum
- 1:58limit for the checking account from $500 to $1
- 2:02,500 or $2 ,000. I think it's 2000. And so I
- 2:05got hit with a $15 service fee that I did notice.
- 2:08And then we were going to get hit with a second
- 2:10one. But because we were in the middle of the
- 2:12forest for Tim's bike race, got down to the wire.
- 2:16The one in Silver City was closed on Saturdays,
- 2:18which actually is one of the main reasons I didn't
- 2:20get to close it. And then the day that we were
- 2:22going to be able to do it right before the end
- 2:24of the month, the cat decided to sit in some
- 2:26rocks and he needed to go in town. So one of
- 2:29us had to stay. It was totally screwed up. Yeah.
- 2:32So I got hit with a second late fee or whatever.
- 2:35Insufficient funds fee. Insufficient funds? No.
- 2:39Minimum balance. Minimum balance fee. So anyway,
- 2:42we lost how much money? We lost $30 in the checking.
- 2:46$195? $195 -ish, yeah. $195 on a $200 balance.
- 2:53$233 balance. So that's $195. Yeah, so $195 divided
- 2:57by 200. What did you say? $400? $233. 80%. She
- 3:01goes, we lost 80 % of our principal in the business
- 3:04money market account due to minimum balance fees.
- 3:07So even those little fees, if you put them in
- 3:11a percent, it's a lot of percent, and that's
- 3:13just not okay. So that's the backstory to this
- 3:15podcast. Right. So then Tim just started doing
- 3:18some digging. I went down a rabbit hole once
- 3:20I saw the minimum balance thing, and I wanted
- 3:22to find out the historical. What am I trying
- 3:25to say? The history of why the hell there's fees.
- 3:29Well, I wanted to get the historical accuracy
- 3:32because it's very difficult to find because not
- 3:35one bank actually did it. It was basically, okay,
- 3:39I'm going to date myself. When I was young, the
- 3:41banks didn't charge you fees for a minimum balance
- 3:44fee. They literally were just like, here's a
- 3:47checking account. Here's a phone for opening
- 3:49a checking account. And that's what it was. There
- 3:53was no fees. There was no minimum balance requirements.
- 3:56They were basically free, and banks actually
- 3:59competed with each other by offering gifts like
- 4:01a phone or blenders or whatever. And they gave
- 4:05you a pretty decent interest rate. It was like
- 4:103 % or 4%. So basically you were being rewarded.
- 4:14You put money in a bank, and they would reward
- 4:15you for putting money in there. And they'd give
- 4:17you a couple percent because they were making
- 4:19more. do making their money forever that's how
- 4:23like how it works you put money in a bank the
- 4:25bank takes your money and lends it out at a higher
- 4:27interest rate than what they're giving you and
- 4:30nowadays the interest rate is minimal yeah like
- 4:33they give you 0 .01 0 .1 like or 0 .1 in some
- 4:36cases and you're like oh i'm making 10 10 times
- 4:38more than i am at this other bank so i'll do
- 4:40that but I mean, honestly, it kind of makes sense
- 4:42because back in the day, most people did cash.
- 4:43So they were trying to highly incentivize people
- 4:46to actually put money into their banks so that
- 4:48they could lend money out to make more money.
- 4:50Whereas now everything's basically digital. So
- 4:53I can see there's like. Okay. Well, like what
- 4:55I was able to find out was in 1980, there was
- 4:58something called the Depository Institutions
- 5:01Deregulation and Monetary Control Act. You really
- 5:04need to stop finding these things with ridiculous
- 5:06names that you can't pronounce. Depository Institutions
- 5:09Deregulation and Monetary Control Act. You stuttered
- 5:13on that twice. I keep going. It's hilarious.
- 5:15It's an entertainment factor for me. So anyway,
- 5:17so what that was, that's when the minimum balance
- 5:22thing came about. The first wave was the late
- 5:241970s to the early 1980s. No single bank can
- 5:28be blamed for inventing the minimum balance.
- 5:30Rather, it was a collective industry pivot. So
- 5:33they went from giving you... Like actively competing
- 5:36to get your business and giving you a decent
- 5:38interest rate. They went from that into now we
- 5:42want your money and you're going to have minimums
- 5:45to actually keep your money here, which is ludicrous.
- 5:48Why was this happening? The Deregulation Act
- 5:51phased out capped interest rates banks could
- 5:53pay. Suddenly, banks had to pay higher interest
- 5:56rates to savers to keep their money. To offset
- 5:58this massive new expense, large commercial banks
- 6:01collectively realized they could monetize checking
- 6:04accounts. Sneaky, sneaky. So that's what I'm
- 6:07saying. I'm dating myself because we went from,
- 6:09like, we want your business, here's a phone,
- 6:12to we want your business, but we have to pay
- 6:15a higher interest rate, like 3 % or 4%. to fund
- 6:19that we're going to start charging fees yes we're
- 6:21going to pass some of the costs down to you kind
- 6:23of like tariffs yes that's what it sounds like
- 6:26to me so and then then if you look back at the
- 6:29history it took less than 10 years for the industry
- 6:31all the industry to adapt in 1984 the average
- 6:34monthly maintenance fee was $2 .70 by the late
- 6:381980s nearly every major bank legacy banks I
- 6:44mean, we're not going to do a history of banking,
- 6:46but the predecessors to Chase, Citi, and Wells
- 6:48Fargo were the legacy banks. By the late 1980s,
- 6:51all these legacy banks, which became the ones
- 6:54we all know today, had codified minimum balance
- 6:56rules into their standard consumer disclosures.
- 6:59Disclosures. So it took like six years. It took
- 7:03less than a decade for them to go from no fees
- 7:05to ass amount of fees. Then you fast forward
- 7:09to 2010 when all hell broke loose in 2008 from
- 7:12the financial crisis. That's when free checking
- 7:15suffered its final blow after the 2008 financial
- 7:18crisis. The government passed the Dodd -Frank
- 7:21Act. It capped interchange fees that banks could
- 7:26charge merchants whenever you swiped your debit
- 7:29card. So prior to 2008, when you swiped your
- 7:33card, it was like the Wild West. Sometimes they
- 7:35would charge $0 .05, sometimes it's $0 .25, whatever
- 7:38the case may be. I don't remember this, but okay.
- 7:41But prior to 2008, it was the Wild West. And
- 7:44after 2008, they put a cap on how much a bank
- 7:47could actually charge whenever you swiped your
- 7:48debit card. So because they lost billions of
- 7:51dollars in revenue, they hiked minimum balance
- 7:54requirements and monthly fees because of that.
- 7:59to make up the difference between, I guess they
- 8:01were making billions of dollars in the debit
- 8:02card swipes. Oh, I bet. Well, it's kind of like
- 8:05when you go to certain places and they mark up,
- 8:08like auto repair places a lot of times mark up
- 8:11their actual parts 100 % to make a profit off
- 8:16sourcing because they usually get a discount.
- 8:18And even if you go and buy it, quote unquote,
- 8:21it would be more expensive. I don't know if that's
- 8:23still the case anymore, but it's the same concept,
- 8:25right? They like pad some... No, like they lost
- 8:30billions of dollars from the debit card swiping,
- 8:32so they had to make up the - But they were padding,
- 8:34is what I'm saying. They had to make up money
- 8:35somewhere else, so they decided, hey, let's go
- 8:37back to what we were doing in the 80s with the
- 8:39minimum balance things and the fees that go with
- 8:41it. Oh, so they actually went away with the checking
- 8:43fees and then they - No, they just kind of went
- 8:45to the background. People just like, because
- 8:46they weren't too egregious. They were like a
- 8:49couple dollars. Okay. A couple dollars. I think
- 8:52federal credit unions are exempt from that. A
- 8:53couple dollars a year. A couple of dollars a
- 8:55year, not a couple of dollars a month. So that's
- 8:57what, let me rephrase that. Right. So then after
- 9:00I did like the, the boring back, the back backstory
- 9:03about all this, and I said, well, how many banks
- 9:05actually charge the fees? And right now the best
- 9:08I can find out is like 68 to 70 % of banks charge,
- 9:12uh, they have minimum. balance rules and fees
- 9:17associated with checking accounts. Only about
- 9:1932 % of traditional checking accounts are truly
- 9:22free, meaning there's no monthly maintenance
- 9:25fee regardless of your balance or activity. That's
- 9:28where a lot of them get you. I know with Wells
- 9:32Fargo, you had to have $1 ,500 in your bank account
- 9:36or you had to have $1 ,500 worth of bank activity.
- 9:39Or, yeah. direct deposits like their direct deposits
- 9:43and withdrawals and stuff like this a lot of
- 9:44people don't actually uh encounter the fees that
- 9:46we did because it would be just because that
- 9:48account was stagnant for so long we just overlooked
- 9:51it but i mean that can't we can't be the only
- 9:54ones that's no fees well you'll see here in the
- 9:56statistics it isn't that's a lot of people actually
- 9:59That's just for individual checking accounts.
- 10:02For business checking accounts, that number actually
- 10:07climbs higher to 90 % as opposed to 68 % to 70%.
- 10:11Traditional banks almost universally expect business
- 10:15owners to maintain a baseline tier of capital
- 10:17to justify the accounts overhead so they have
- 10:20a higher threshold. There's more banks that actually
- 10:23impose that threshold. I will actually argue
- 10:25that because my Wells Fargo one, Personal was
- 10:28$1 ,500 is the minimum, but the checking was
- 10:30only $500. And then it just jumped to $2 ,000.
- 10:33So now it is higher, but it was not before. You
- 10:35can argue it all you want. Well, I'm just saying.
- 10:37It was a thing. Now, again, this is our experience.
- 10:41We have Wells Fargo. We have a credit union.
- 10:45um in pennsylvania we have sofi and we have what
- 10:48do you have you have another credit card so we
- 10:50only have we only have another one too but i
- 10:52just closed the one that the condo was under
- 10:53we only have a handful of bank account like bank
- 10:55bank accounts so we don't can't like speak on
- 10:57all the banks so i was doing the research and
- 11:01so i can speak on the banks we know about there's
- 11:03other banks that i don't know about like pnc
- 11:05i have no idea or um city bank i have no idea
- 11:10you'll know if you have one okay anyway so then
- 11:13that went from How many banks are doing it to
- 11:17how much they make. These numbers are crazy.
- 11:19Pay attention here. This is batshit. That's the
- 11:21next thing. According to reports tracked by the
- 11:24Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, financial
- 11:26institutions pull in roughly $1 billion annually
- 11:29strictly from account maintenance minimum balance
- 11:31fees. $1 billion. $1 billion. Continue. Okay,
- 11:37but whenever you combine the minimum balance
- 11:40penalties with the other stuff that they have,
- 11:42like overdraft fees and insufficient fund penalties,
- 11:45stuff like that, banks actually rake in $7 billion
- 11:47to $12 billion each year in fees. So they're
- 11:51making $6 to $11 billion in overdraft. Wait,
- 11:55when you say you bundle minimum, so that actually
- 11:56includes that $1 billion in it, does it not?
- 11:58Yeah, so I said they're making $6 to $11. $6
- 12:00to $11 billion every year. On insufficient funds
- 12:03and overdraft fees. So that even in itself? Because
- 12:05we were talking, like, the morality of this.
- 12:08I feel like if you go negative on your balance,
- 12:10that's probably a justified fee. You know, overdraft,
- 12:13insufficient funds type deal. Like, that seems
- 12:15like a sufficient, like, penalty. So that one
- 12:17makes sense to me. Right. But minimum balance
- 12:18does not. Minimum balance does not. And if they're
- 12:20only making $1 billion from that, and they're
- 12:22making $6 to $11 from the other one, why the
- 12:24hell do they have minimum balances? That's crazy.
- 12:26But, like, if you look at... It's insane. We
- 12:29do investing stuff, and, like, some of the investing
- 12:31we do is financial stuff. And, like, they're
- 12:33only making... three to five billion dollars
- 12:36for the year so like dude they're making like
- 12:3860 percent of their their total revenue for the
- 12:41year is coming from like fees that's insane uh
- 12:43-huh that's not even what they're investing in
- 12:46making a profit that is insane and they're the
- 12:49back -end fees banks like what banks are doing
- 12:51they're sneaky sons of bitches they actually
- 12:52will artificially lower the barriers to entry
- 12:55to get you to sign up knowing that once you sign
- 12:58up they got you Yeah, because they're going to
- 12:59have this monthly low fee. They're going to recoup
- 13:01the cost on the back end whenever your cash flow
- 13:05naturally fluctuates. And sometimes you're going
- 13:08to overdraw. And sometimes it just happens and
- 13:11they know they're going to make money from it.
- 13:13I had a recent overdraft fee and I was pissed
- 13:16because it's like $40. It's ridiculous. So that's
- 13:19what the banks are making from it. So then I
- 13:21went into like the individual customers, like
- 13:23what are the customers paying? And according
- 13:26to the latest money rates checking account survey
- 13:29in 2026, it's just, I mean, again, we're not
- 13:32like doing the validity of the actual study,
- 13:34but this is just a survey they put online. The
- 13:37average monthly maintenance fee that. people
- 13:40are paying for the banks is between $13 .51 and
- 13:43$13 .95. Obviously, that's an average because
- 13:46$15 is Wells Fargo's checking, but the savings
- 13:50one was $5 a month. I've seen some that are $10.
- 13:54There's people that don't pay any, so it's the
- 13:56median of all the people surveyed. 100 % accurate,
- 14:00probably not, but it's just like an illustration
- 14:02of it's a pretty lucrative business. Right. And
- 14:05that stuff adds up. So that might not seem like
- 14:07a big expense in one month. That means the average
- 14:09consumer or business owner who fails to meet
- 14:11the minimum balance guidelines is losing $162
- 14:14to $167 per year, which is a lot. That is a lot.
- 14:19A couple of bills, a couple of months worth of
- 14:21certain bills. Like before Netflix went up again,
- 14:24that could have paid your Netflix. So then it
- 14:26came into the paradox. Like to avoid a $15 fee,
- 14:29a bank might demand that you keep a constant
- 14:33$2 ,000 in your checking account. But what happens
- 14:38is by holding that money there, they're getting
- 14:40a 0 % interest loan. So you're effectively giving
- 14:42the bank an interest -free loan so they can invest
- 14:44your capital and pocket the difference. And then
- 14:46they charge you whenever you don't have enough
- 14:47money in there for them to do that. Yeah. That
- 14:49is the freaking super fucked up part about that
- 14:52whole thing. That's crazy. Yeah. Okay. So the
- 14:55legal loophole. How is this legal? How is this
- 14:59legal? How is it legal that you put money in
- 15:02a bank - And you get raped. And you take your
- 15:04money and they make money off your money, but
- 15:06then they penalize you for not having enough
- 15:07of your money in there for them to use. How is
- 15:09that legal? Should we do the analogy? Because
- 15:12I feel like the analogy is the better understanding
- 15:14of that whole thing. Okay. Well, the analogy.
- 15:15We'll do the analogy. Go ahead. Where is the
- 15:17analogy? You just went past it. Did I? Imagine
- 15:19you lend your... Oh, okay. So, like, the analogy
- 15:21of this is imagining you're going to lend your
- 15:23neighbor a lawnmower. And not only do they use
- 15:26it to mow their own lawn, but they make money
- 15:27mowing other lawns in the neighborhood. But they
- 15:30charge you a storage fee because the lawnmower
- 15:32is physically at their property. Like, that doesn't
- 15:34make any sense. The whole thing makes no sense.
- 15:37But that's how it's legal. It's actually, in
- 15:39financial terms, it's called bailment. When you
- 15:43deposit money into a bank account, you're not
- 15:44legally placing your money in a storage locker.
- 15:46Legally, you are loaning that money to the bank.
- 15:48The bank, this is all in the world, like all
- 15:51of the - In that 40 -page disclosure crap. 60
- 15:53-page disclosure shit that they give you whenever
- 15:55you sign up. The bank becomes the debtor and
- 15:57you become the creditor because the U .S. operates
- 15:59on a system of contractual freedom. A bank has
- 16:01a legal right to set the terms of that loan.
- 16:03They can state, we will accept your loan, but
- 16:05if that loan drops below $1 ,000, we will charge
- 16:08you a rental fee for the digital lender space
- 16:10we provided. So basically how we've all been
- 16:15instructed how banking works is not actually
- 16:19how it works. Because I thought I'm putting my
- 16:21money into the bank for them to hold it so when
- 16:23I need it, I have access to it. And that's not
- 16:25how it is. They actually rephrased it so when
- 16:28I give my money to a bank, I'm actually giving
- 16:31the bank a loan that they can make money off
- 16:33of. But I can't break the terms of the loan or
- 16:35they will charge me a fee. It's insane. It is
- 16:41ridiculous. The second part that makes this all
- 16:43legal is the Truth in Savings Act. This was passed
- 16:45in 1991. The Truth in Savings Act does not cap
- 16:50bank fees or ban minimum balance requirements.
- 16:52Instead, it only mandates disclosure. Under this
- 16:55law, as long as a bank prints the fee structure
- 16:57in a dense 40 -page terms and conditions booklet.
- 17:00When you sign up, they have fulfilled their legal
- 17:02obligation. The law assumes that you, the consumer,
- 17:05or in this case, the lender, read the booklet
- 17:08and you've consented to the penalty by choosing
- 17:10to keep your money there. This is a complete
- 17:14sidebar, but that's one of the downfalls of humanity
- 17:16is everything where people cover their ass is
- 17:19put at the end of stuff. Massive disclaimers.
- 17:21It's like 60 to 100 pages long. Who reads that?
- 17:24Nobody. Nobody. And they know you're not going
- 17:26to read it. Although. I will say now with AI,
- 17:29you can take that 40 -page thing, copy and paste
- 17:31it, and stick it in a GBT and ask it what the
- 17:33heck you need to know. So there is things coming.
- 17:36I bet you there's going to be revolts and rebellions
- 17:37left and right over this. So suppose the banks
- 17:40piss off the wrong person. The wrong person actually
- 17:42goes to the government and says, hey, these banks
- 17:46are screwing me. If that happens, banks actually
- 17:49defend their minimums by claiming that maintaining
- 17:52an account carries fixed operational overhead.
- 17:54They actually will cite the cost of compliance,
- 17:57fraud monitoring, customer service, and physical
- 17:59branches. They then argue that if your balance
- 18:01drops too low, your money isn't generating enough
- 18:04lendable spread to cover those costs, thereby
- 18:06justifying the penalty fee. Hypocrisy. And yes,
- 18:09yes, they make $6 to $11 billion off of the overdraft
- 18:14fees. So I call bullshit on that one. Okay. But
- 18:18that's legalese, right? Yeah. So where my brain
- 18:22went was it's blatant hypocrisy. When a small
- 18:25business owner takes a loan from a bank, the
- 18:27bank charges interest, origination fees, and
- 18:30enforces strict underwriting. But when the same
- 18:32business owner loans their money to the bank
- 18:35via a checking account, the bank pays 0 % interest,
- 18:38invests that capital to make massive profits,
- 18:40and then fines the business owner if the loan
- 18:42isn't large enough. yeah wrap your head around
- 18:45that for a hot second it's nonsense like the
- 18:47financial system is fucked up right it benefits
- 18:50businesses not people and the reason that it
- 18:53actually works even though everybody like once
- 18:55you break it down and look into it you understand
- 18:57it's a completely lopsided argument because the
- 18:59bank has all the perks and the consumer or the
- 19:02lender or the saver whatever you want to call
- 19:04it has none um the Banks get away with it because
- 19:07they know that most people find switching to
- 19:09banks to be too much of a hassle. Now, this was
- 19:11the part that blew my mind a little bit because
- 19:12I'm the kind of person that if I get burned,
- 19:14like right now I'm leaving this freaking bank.
- 19:15Fuck them. They got me once, twice for $15. I
- 19:18did not see the five. If I had seen that sooner,
- 19:20I would have been out and gone way, way, way
- 19:22sooner. For the average person to actually close
- 19:26a bank and go to one that's like a free banking,
- 19:30they know that you like that. The big banks know
- 19:33that you have to make changes to your direct
- 19:34deposits. You have to switch up your automated
- 19:36software billing. You have to wait for outstanding
- 19:38checks to clear. So the bank knows that you're
- 19:41going to tolerate a $15 fee just to avoid three
- 19:43hours of administrative hassle. And it does take
- 19:46a long time to transfer that stuff over. I've
- 19:48done it twice now because I shifted my stuff
- 19:50around. It is annoying. But to me, it is well
- 19:53worth it because that how much dollars? So if
- 19:55it was $15 a month. $162 to $167. No, that was
- 19:59for $13, wasn't it? That's $180 for the year.
- 20:02If you take 180 divided by that three hours,
- 20:05that's $60 an hour. Is that really worth $60
- 20:07an hour to move your stuff? I personally think
- 20:10it is. It is, but again, that's just an estimate.
- 20:13I'm pretty sure it's more than three hours. Once
- 20:17you do it the first time, it actually doesn't.
- 20:18But if you don't have all your stuff, like if
- 20:20you don't know what all you have is auto payments,
- 20:22that's where you run into issues. And I actually
- 20:24kept my account open on the one a little longer
- 20:27than I would have. And most people I think actually
- 20:29don't have the float to transfer. Because if
- 20:32you need to stay at a minimum on the one and
- 20:33a minimum on the other one, most people don't
- 20:35have the extra paycheck to be able to start moving
- 20:37payments under the one and like moving the other
- 20:39one to the other one while keeping the old stuff.
- 20:41Because then you have like quarterly payouts
- 20:43that come for like sewer or your registration
- 20:45or things. That was actually where I got hit
- 20:47was my yearly domain renewals. I was like, whoa,
- 20:49hold on a second. It is a pain. It's a pain.
- 20:54But so now we did mention that we just actually
- 20:57went through this. And I know that most people
- 20:59are thinking, is my bank actually doing this?
- 21:01Yes. Yes. I didn't have, like, you can just tell
- 21:03me. Any of the big ones with physical branches.
- 21:05Yes. Mainly if you hit, there's a physical branch,
- 21:07the probability is pretty high that, yes, they're
- 21:10doing it. Again, though, federal credit unions
- 21:12fall under different criteria, so they're not,
- 21:14they're usually non -fee. So let's look at Wells
- 21:17Fargo real quick. Here we go. So in early 2026,
- 21:22Wells Fargo updated the terms for their initiate,
- 21:25how do you say that? Initiate business checking
- 21:28account. Okay. Fee increase. They basically raise
- 21:31their monthly service for you from $10 to $15
- 21:33if you went below the minimum balance in your
- 21:36business account. Now, I'm sure certain accounts
- 21:39may be grandfathered in because we were only
- 21:41paying five. No, that was the savings account,
- 21:44not the checking account. Checking was $15. Okay.
- 21:46So what they did, notice how they just went from
- 21:50$10 to $15. That's not too bad. People are not
- 21:52going to get their panties up in a twist about
- 21:55that. But what they did, at the same time, they
- 21:58simultaneously quadrupled the minimum daily balance
- 22:01required to waive that fee. It went from $500
- 22:03to $2 ,000. Now that is a huge difference. But
- 22:08here's where it gets sneaky. Because they also
- 22:11completely removed the alternative. alternative
- 22:15waiver option of maintaining a $1 ,000 average
- 22:18ledger balance. If you're a business owner who
- 22:21normally keeps $1 ,000 in your checking and you
- 22:22went from safely hitting the waiver threshold
- 22:24to suddenly being penalized $15 every month,
- 22:27Because it happened through a dense fine print
- 22:28email update. It will quietly drain your checking
- 22:31account. But do you see what they did there?
- 22:33The fee itself was small. It didn't raise any
- 22:37red flags. The actual stuff where you get penalized,
- 22:40the amount you have to keep in there, was huge.
- 22:43That's like 400 % as opposed to whatever that
- 22:46was, $5, 50%. Right. Now, where it gets super
- 22:50sketchy is the reason they do that or they might
- 22:52not up their fee at all, but they up those balances
- 22:54because the people who are already paying fees
- 22:56don't just the number of people who are now paying
- 23:00fees goes up. But it's not the people who were
- 23:03already paying these. It's just like the difference
- 23:05of people who weren't before. I'm not explaining
- 23:07this well. Dude. Basically, when they raise it
- 23:10from $500 to $2 ,000, like they're basically
- 23:13they're going to massively increase the pool
- 23:16of people that are paying a fee. Right. But the
- 23:17people who were already paying the fee are going
- 23:19to continue to pay the fee. They're not going
- 23:21to notice any difference. They're going to be
- 23:23under $2 ,000. Obviously, they're under $500.
- 23:25Right. But the sneaky thing under the radar is
- 23:27the fact that they actually have less complaints
- 23:29because they're not hitting as many people, but
- 23:31they're increasing the number of people they
- 23:33have paying fees, which dramatically increases
- 23:35the amount of money that they're making. It's
- 23:37vastly more profitable. Basically, it dodges
- 23:39the outrage metric, like basically where people
- 23:42get all pissed off about on social media or they
- 23:45cry or they scream or whatever they do. Like
- 23:47if it would have went from 15 to 30, people would
- 23:49have freaked the hell out on across the entire
- 23:51populace of whoever was banking. So consumers
- 23:53and like even the people that. But like the watchdogs
- 23:55of banks, if there's such a thing, I mean, I
- 23:57guess they're supposed to be. Basically, they
- 23:59monitor fees closely. So if a bank raises a monthly
- 24:02fee to $30 from like $5, it'll automatically
- 24:05trigger negative press, social media backlash,
- 24:09and scrutiny from the Consumer Financial Protection
- 24:12Bureau. However, if they leave the fee relatively
- 24:14low while moving the goalpost, the minimum balance
- 24:18line, that basically allows the bank to achieve
- 24:20the exact same financial windfall, probably more
- 24:22with a fraction of the public. public relations
- 24:25damage that's why they do that sneaky shit with
- 24:27the 500 to the 2000 as opposed to they didn't
- 24:30go from 10 to they didn't go from 10 to 40 which
- 24:33would have been the same four times thing right
- 24:35and i was asking tim like if there were statistics
- 24:37on people who actually do leave when these things
- 24:39get increased and he said it's i don't know if
- 24:42you found numbers but you said it's probably
- 24:43minimal the minimal yeah because of the fact
- 24:45that people don't want to do the effort to change
- 24:47like fix it Now, here's where the math gets wicked.
- 24:50If a bank forces 1 million business owners to
- 24:52hold an extra $1 ,500 in their accounts to avoid
- 24:54a fee, the bank instantly nets $1 .5 billion
- 24:57in cheap, stable liquidity. Yeah. Under the rules
- 25:02of a rig game, because it is a rig game, the
- 25:04bank can then take that free $1 .5 billion from
- 25:06the consumers, park it in risk -free government
- 25:09bonds or overnight Fed deposits or whatever the
- 25:11hell they put their money, and they can actually
- 25:12effortlessly pocket a massive 4 % to 5 % return
- 25:15on your money. then it's a win -win for the bank
- 25:19because if the customer complies, the bank gets
- 25:22free capital to lend. If the customer fails to
- 25:24comply, the bank will then pull a highly profitable
- 25:26pure margin cash penalty straight out of the
- 25:28account. So they're getting money either way.
- 25:29They're making more if they could take your money
- 25:32and lend it out for 4 % to 5%, obviously, but
- 25:34they're still making money if they can't take
- 25:36your money because you don't have enough in there
- 25:37and they'll just ding you for $15. Actually,
- 25:39are they making more? $1 ,500. No, they're making
- 25:42more. They actually make more if you don't have
- 25:44the minimum balance in there. $6 .25 a month
- 25:47if you had $1 ,500, just the bare minimum threshold.
- 25:49But if you had more. $2 ,000? Do you want me
- 25:52to do? If you're going to be a nerd. Nerd, be
- 25:54a nerd. Be an accurate nerd. Three. So they're
- 25:58actually making more money from you paying the
- 26:00penalty than they actually are by taking it and
- 26:02lending it out. If you're at the minimum balance.
- 26:04If you have the minimum of $2 ,000. So they're
- 26:06making $8 .33 a month on that money. If you have
- 26:09more in there, they're making more. So if this
- 26:12is the minimum, no. But if they're making $15,
- 26:14they're actually making double if you're paying
- 26:15the fee. That is some slimy shit right there.
- 26:20Another benefit that I actually had to think
- 26:23about and then I had to put it into the interweb
- 26:25to see was the undesirable customer. What is
- 26:29that? So in the eyes of a banking executive,
- 26:33accounts with low balances that don't generate
- 26:35high lending power are viewed as operational
- 26:36liabilities. So if they raise the minimum balance
- 26:39threshold. It's a deliberate filtering mechanism.
- 26:42It basically, they automatically figure out who
- 26:45the undesirable customers are, the ones that
- 26:47don't have enough money in there. So basically
- 26:49it pressures low liquidity startups, freelancers,
- 26:52and lower income individuals to either put more
- 26:54money into the bank that they may or may not
- 26:56have or to leave that bank entirely. Yeah. And
- 26:59we leave. Well, we leave. I don't know about
- 27:02other people. So then there was other interesting
- 27:03things that they brought up. I found one of them
- 27:06is called the zombie account trap. When a customer
- 27:08or a small business abandons an account because
- 27:11the balance hits zero, they don't close it. They
- 27:13just don't use it. The bank doesn't close it.
- 27:16They don't always close it. Well, it's not that
- 27:18they don't close it. They don't exempt you from
- 27:21the penalties. And the overdraft. So yeah, they
- 27:24keep charging that $15 monthly fee into the negative.
- 27:27Then they hit the account with an overdraft or
- 27:28extended overdraft fees, eventually sending a
- 27:31$0 count into a collection agency for $150 balance.
- 27:35Now, I will actually say this happened to me
- 27:38in my federal credit union because there was
- 27:40actually a activity fee that it went inactive
- 27:44for six months or something. So they hit me with
- 27:45a fee. And because I only had like $5 in there
- 27:48to keep it open, it went under that. And then
- 27:50I got hit with that minimum. overdraft thing
- 27:53and then it oh man i was pissed and then you
- 27:55can't close the account until you pay off the
- 27:57balance and if you don't pay off the balance
- 27:59then they freaking go into this next thing here
- 28:01where they go into collections yeah so most people
- 28:04don't know that there is a secret credit bureau
- 28:06just for banking called the check systems If
- 28:09you get hit by minimum balance fees, refuse to
- 28:11pay them, and abandon the account, the bank will
- 28:13report you to the check systems. And this can
- 28:16effectively blackball you from opening a bank
- 28:18account anywhere else for up to five years. So
- 28:20they basically have, like, the mafia there. Like,
- 28:22oh, so -and -so doesn't do this. Right. I won't
- 28:25let them have a bank account for five years.
- 28:28But then you'll go into collections. Like, they
- 28:29actually have a collection agency coming after
- 28:31you, plus you get blackballed in this system.
- 28:33Like, oh, my gosh, so ridiculous. So you basically,
- 28:36if you're going to do that. open an account before
- 28:38you, somewhere else before you let it go. So
- 28:42then there's the last part that I want to bring
- 28:44up is the tactical friction that banks use to
- 28:46keep you from living. They make you change your
- 28:47direct deposits, switch your automated billing,
- 28:50wait for the outstanding checks to clear. The
- 28:52banks knows you're going to tolerate that. Again,
- 28:53I'm going to reiterate there. And they know you're
- 28:55going to tolerate the $15 fee. Just avoid that.
- 28:57They know you're going to. No, I will not. But
- 29:00most people, I know I'm an outlier. I'm telling
- 29:02you like 90%, maybe 95 % of people are willing
- 29:04to pay $15 just to not have to deal with But
- 29:07I actually did make that decision when we were
- 29:09in the forest when we had the cat issue. I was
- 29:10like, all right, I will eat that $15 fee for
- 29:12literally the day that I can't go because I waited
- 29:14to the last minute because of his bike race.
- 29:17And that was worth it to make sure the cats didn't
- 29:19disappear and die and whatever. So that $15 was
- 29:22justified there, but I could not do that every
- 29:24month. That would piss me off. Something fierce.
- 29:26What can we do? Tired of the big bank hypocrisy.
- 29:30Well, for business owners and freelancers, there
- 29:32are options. There's the Blue Vine business checking.
- 29:36which is a totally free business checking with
- 29:38no minimum balance requirements, no overdraft
- 29:41fees, and it actually pays a higher interest
- 29:42yield on balance up to a certain threshold. So
- 29:45they have no minimum fees and they actually pay
- 29:46you a higher yield than you're going to get at
- 29:49a brick and mortar. Now, I'm pretty sure most
- 29:52of these are online. So if you have the safety
- 29:55and security thing where you need to actually
- 29:57walk into a physical location, there are a couple
- 30:00maybe, but for the most part, like the ones that
- 30:03you're going to find that actually have no minimum
- 30:04balance. They're going to be online and they're
- 30:06probably going to be tied to something else.
- 30:09Credit cards, for example. Yeah, big banks. And
- 30:11I would say, too, that that's like a convenience
- 30:12fee, in my opinion, to be able to walk in. The
- 30:15next one's Novo Business Checking. N -O -V -O,
- 30:18Novo. It's built perfectly for small business
- 30:20owners and freelancers. It features zero monthly
- 30:22fees, no minimum balance, and integrates natively
- 30:26with Stripe, Shopify, and QuickBooks. So that's
- 30:29a really good one for businesses. The third one
- 30:32is Found Banking. It's a zero -fee banking app
- 30:34designed specifically for self -employed individuals
- 30:36and independent contractors. It features built
- 30:38-in bookkeeping and tax tracking. The fourth
- 30:41one is Mercury. I know this one has a credit
- 30:44card associated because I used to have a Mercury
- 30:45credit card. It's a popular choice for startups
- 30:47and tech forward businesses. It requires a zero
- 30:49minimum opening deposit, has no monthly fees,
- 30:52and allows free domestic and international USD
- 30:55wire transfers. So that's if you're going overseas.
- 30:57That's pretty hardcore for wire transfers. Usually
- 30:59they're like $30, I think. And then the last
- 31:02one that, I mean, there's obviously going to
- 31:03be more. I mean, I just picked a few of them.
- 31:05A few of the ones that seemed most interesting.
- 31:06There's the Capital One Spark Business Basic.
- 31:09It's one of the very few brick and mortar. They're
- 31:12brick and mortar. Yeah, major national banking
- 31:13choices that offer a no monthly fee business
- 31:15checking product with unlimited transactions.
- 31:18But my guess, well, unlimited transactions is
- 31:20pretty clutch if you have a high transaction
- 31:23business. Capital One credit card, I imagine
- 31:27that's how they're able to be able to afford
- 31:29that. I'm saying most of them are tied because
- 31:30Mercury has a credit card, so they're tied to
- 31:32it. So they're making money off the credit card
- 31:33interest and late fees and all that stuff so
- 31:36they actually can afford the - And I think that's
- 31:39pretty smart. I personally really like - No minimum
- 31:41bank accounts because most of the time you'll
- 31:44actually get a credit card with them and they
- 31:45probably make, again, we did the back -end transactions.
- 31:48They're probably going to make money on the back
- 31:50-end transaction with the majority of people
- 31:51on the credit card. That's basically paying for
- 31:54their no minimum balance. And I actually really
- 31:56like my Capital One account. So for personal
- 31:58checking, there's Ally Bank. It's a pioneer in
- 32:01the online banking space with zero monthly maintenance
- 32:04fees on checking or savings and no minimum balance
- 32:06hoops to jump through. If I didn't have SoFi,
- 32:09I'd probably have Ally. I actually opened an
- 32:11Ally account. If you do anything with crypto,
- 32:13they are a no -go. They cockblock you hard. So
- 32:18don't do crypto. I'm just saying. That's something
- 32:20everybody needs to know if you're into that thing.
- 32:22Capital One is actually one that allows a crypto
- 32:25discoverer. Capital One 360 is the next one.
- 32:29Capital One 360 checking. It's completely free
- 32:31personal checking with fee -free access to massive
- 32:33top -tier ATM network. They actually pay you.
- 32:36And you can do cash deposits at random places.
- 32:39There's a thing on the app, which is nice about
- 32:41the Capital One. And I went with Capital One
- 32:42over Discover as well because it actually does
- 32:45pay you an interest on your checking. It's very
- 32:48minimal, but... Discover Bank offers a cashback
- 32:50debit account with no monthly fees, no minimum
- 32:52balance requirements, and it rewards you on everyday
- 32:55debit card purchases. And I don't quite understand
- 32:57this, considering Discover and Capital One merged,
- 32:59why they're still separate. So that's a few.
- 33:02That's a couple options. What else you can do?
- 33:05There's other options. Obviously, you have to
- 33:07monitor your bank account, and you have to know
- 33:10the fine print. You have to know what the minimums
- 33:13are. I mean, I'm sure you'd be able to just do
- 33:15a cursory AI thing with I'm currently with such
- 33:18and such bank. What are the minimum fees, minimum
- 33:21requirements? Or you can dump the full disclosure
- 33:24into the AI and just have it analyze it for you
- 33:26for what you need to know as a consumer. But
- 33:28I do think that probably one of the easiest ways
- 33:31to get your account to switch would probably
- 33:34be. Everybody should have an emergency fund.
- 33:37We talk about this all the time. But if you utilize
- 33:39that emergency fund to do that transfer over
- 33:41to get away from these fees that are going to
- 33:43keep racking up, like you're going to save so
- 33:44much money in the long run because if you keep
- 33:46paying those fees over time, you're bleeding.
- 33:50I mean. So much money. It's 180. A year. We did
- 33:54the math for you. But it's still. That's a lot.
- 33:56That's a lot, especially if you're under that
- 33:58minimum balance, which means that's a pretty
- 33:59high percentage of what. That's 9 % of a $2 ,000
- 34:02minimum. Right. Whereas you could be investing
- 34:05at 9%. Oh, that was the other thing. We did the
- 34:08math. Oh, oh, oh. So if you took the $15 that
- 34:12you're paying in fees and instead took the time
- 34:15to switch over to the zero fee account and took
- 34:18that $15 that you would have been paying and
- 34:20put it into investments. This is crazy. If you
- 34:24took that $15, like I just said, and put it into
- 34:26this THTA at 11 % -ish, and you get paid out
- 34:31and then you reinvest dividends, and you just
- 34:32keep doing that automatically over a 30 -year
- 34:36period, your total contributions of that $15
- 34:39a month thing over 30 years would be $5 ,415.
- 34:44At the end of the 30 -year, though, with the
- 34:45interest compounding, and this is where the magic
- 34:47of interest compounding comes into play here,
- 34:50you'd end up with $42 ,468 .42. So does it make
- 34:56sense to continue to pay those fees that slowly
- 34:59erode your actual investable money? It doesn't.
- 35:04Or you do something like that. Again, that's
- 35:07why I said the solution, honestly, is going to
- 35:09be finding an online bank that you're comfortable
- 35:12with that has no minimum fees. And then figuring
- 35:15out actually how to do that month of transitory
- 35:16period where you actually have checks clear and
- 35:19then new bank accounts. I know with Wells Fargo,
- 35:21we just went through this. You literally have
- 35:23to have everything paid, go through, and then
- 35:26you have to have a zero account in there to close
- 35:28it. So basically, we have to wait for everything
- 35:30to clear, and then we transfer whatever's left
- 35:32into one of our bank accounts, and then we can
- 35:34close it. a cumbersome process. Well, I was going
- 35:36to say that's where I think I would use the emergency
- 35:38fund to actually fund the new account and then
- 35:40start trickling them over and then let the old
- 35:42one eat. And then I'd replenish my emergency
- 35:44fund because there's really no other way that
- 35:46makes sense unless you actually have a bigger
- 35:48buffer in your account. But if you're paycheck
- 35:49to paycheck, you're kind of trapped. But we were
- 35:52talking before with the three hours and that
- 35:55$60 an hour. If you're actually looking at from
- 35:58the future loss percent, that number is like
- 36:00astronomically infinity, in my opinion. Of what
- 36:03you'd lose by not investing that fee as opposed
- 36:06to taking it. And even, honestly, if you probably
- 36:09told somebody in your life that you were planning
- 36:11to get out from under this fee succubus situation,
- 36:14they might lend you a buffer for a month to just
- 36:17give back to them to get out of this situation.
- 36:19I would totally do that for a friend. Just because,
- 36:22like, the rapage pisses me off. But that's me.
- 36:25Yeah, so banks are no better than credit cards
- 36:28is what I've concluded. But the ones with credit
- 36:30cards usually have the zero checking account.
- 36:33And they're criminals. I don't know how it's
- 36:38legal. In my opinion, they're criminals. I personally
- 36:40don't know how it's legal. But that to me says
- 36:42that the government actually is more in favor
- 36:44of businesses than people. And the bigger the
- 36:47business, the more they're in cahoots with. Yeah,
- 36:50that makes it seem like it, doesn't it? They
- 36:52set up a system. We do a lot of system thinking.
- 36:56We've read a couple books on system thinking.
- 36:59The system was created to extract money from
- 37:01you. And now they're changing the rules because
- 37:03they weren't extracting enough. So now the rule
- 37:05used to be $500. Now it's $2 ,000. And then probably
- 37:0810 years from now, it's going to be like $5 ,000.
- 37:10They're going to keep changing the rules to keep
- 37:12extracting from you. That's what the system is
- 37:15built for. And they start small and then they
- 37:16keep pushing up because once you're in, you're
- 37:18trapped. And then they just keep pushing the
- 37:20limit, pushing the limit. pushing the limit but
- 37:22there are companies that do offer so it's like
- 37:25do yourself a favor and not death by a micro
- 37:27cuts because if you allow all aspects of the
- 37:30systems to eat you can go to all cash just keep
- 37:33cash at home there are a lot of places that don't
- 37:35take cash now yeah but you could that's another
- 37:37solution you could literally just take everything
- 37:39in cash and then just have a pile of money in
- 37:41your house but the more um plausible one would
- 37:45be to find like an iu sofi now and so far is
- 37:48actually pretty excellent i actually like it
- 37:50i really like capital one it pays um one percent
- 37:52for my savings and 0 .5 for my checking so it's
- 37:55not as much as it could be if i had direct deposit
- 37:57going in there but still one percent's better
- 37:59than 0 .01 or 0 .1 or whatever it is yeah i think
- 38:03capital one's savings is actually like one of
- 38:08the higher like three percent or something i
- 38:10don't have a savings account in there because
- 38:11we have everything in uh thta and stuff but yeah
- 38:15do yourself a favor and if you're getting eaten
- 38:18by fees like that's money so this was like we
- 38:20didn't initially plan to do this podcast but
- 38:23that's just because of current situations that
- 38:25the podcast came about right the actual podcast
- 38:28that we wanted to do was what was it about if
- 38:30you listen to the other episode that we're posting
- 38:32right around this one about the k -shaped economy
- 38:35That is going to help you get out of that bottom
- 38:37tier. Like all these little things will stack
- 38:39up. This is a prime example of how they keep
- 38:41you in the bottom layer. The bottom leg. Yeah.
- 38:45So don't get off your butt. The three hours thing.
- 38:50Just make it a day. Do it with a whole group
- 38:53of friends. Have you all help save money? Something.
- 38:56It's crazy. That is crazy. But I think it's the
- 38:59paycheck paycheck thing. Paycheck to paycheck
- 39:00thing that keeps people from moving their account.
- 39:03Honestly. Insanity. It is. I still can't fathom
- 39:05how it's legal, but apparently it is. It's what
- 39:09it is. So. All right. We will see you guys at
- 39:12our next episode. Bye -bye.