Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / The Kingdom That Tried to Be Roman
Transcript
- 0:00The last Roman wasn't Roman. We picture the fall.
- 0:04As an invasion, Gothic warriors burning marble, civilization
- 0:09shattered in a single night. That's the myth.
- 0:13But here are the mechanics. The fault line is.
- 0:16Power, Theodoric, the Austro Gothic.
- 0:19King took Italy in 493. He kept the Senate.
- 0:23Kept the laws. Kept Roman administrators in
- 0:26power. For 30 years, a Gothic.
- 0:29King governed Rome more competently than the last six
- 0:32emperors combined three things that had no.
- 0:35Right to survive. A Roman senator wrote the West's
- 0:39most important philosophical text inside a Gothic.
- 0:42Prison waiting to be executed. Orts and Ravenna still read
- 0:47Cicero, while Rome itself sat silent.
- 0:50A Gothic treasury. Roman denominations when the
- 0:54system finally. Executed both theists for
- 0:56loyalty. That was power consuming.
- 0:59Itself, that was a pattern. And that pattern is running
- 1:04right now. Welcome back to the Roman
- 1:24Pattern. I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan
- 1:27Slate, and every episode in this series is really a forensic look
- 1:31at the actual mechanics of why Rome failed, the structural
- 1:35reasons underneath the dramatic version that everybody already
- 1:39knows. And the thing you start to
- 1:41notice once you've done a few of these is that the fault lines
- 1:45keep coming back to the same handful.
- 1:47Of pressures. It comes down to money, borders,
- 1:50and power. And today those 3 lines all
- 1:53intersect in a story most people have never heard.
- 1:57It's a. Story about a gothic.
- 1:58King who kept the Senate running, a Roman philosopher who
- 2:01kept civilization alive from inside a prison cell and an
- 2:05empire, then ended up destroying more of Rome, retaking it than
- 2:09the Barbarians ever did, and taking it in the first.
- 2:11Place. So let's get into it to
- 2:14understand. Theodoric, you have to.
- 2:16Understand what he walked into and to understand that.
- 2:19You have to go back. To 476.
- 2:22That's the date, everybody. Knows the fall of the Western
- 2:26Roman Empire. But here's what actually.
- 2:28Happened that. Year there was a. 17 year old
- 2:31boy on the Western throne named Romulus Augustalus.
- 2:36And he'd been. Put there by his father.
- 2:38A general named Orestes. Who held the real power?
- 2:42Romulus had been emperor for 10 months, and that time he'd never
- 2:46commanded an army or governed A province.
- 2:49He was a title more than anything, a symbol sitting there
- 2:52where an emperor. Was supposed to sit.
- 2:54Then a Gothic general named. Ottawaker LED a.
- 2:57Mutiny of Italian Garrison troops and marched on Ravenna.
- 3:01Orestes was killed. And Romulus was removed from
- 3:04power. But Ottawaker didn't kill him.
- 3:07He sent him off to a villa in Campagna with a pension, and
- 3:11then he sent a letter to Constantinople.
- 3:13That letter carried the imperial Insignia eastward.
- 3:17And the message to Emperor Zeno was basically that the West
- 3:20didn't need a separate emperor anymore.
- 3:23One emperor was enough and Italy would be governed from
- 3:26Constantinople. That letter is the thing most
- 3:29people are pointing at when they say that Rome.
- 3:31Fell, but here's what the. Textbooks tend to skip.
- 3:34Right over Otowaca. Ran Italy for 17 years.
- 3:37After that and. Across those 17 years, almost
- 3:40nothing actually changed. This is the point Peter Heather
- 3:44keeps hammering in The Fall of the Roman Empire, 470. 6 was
- 3:48less a rupture. Than a change in the
- 3:51bookkeeping. No walls came down that year,
- 3:54the administration just kept running.
- 3:56The Senate still met in Rome, Roman law still applied to Roman
- 4:00citizens, and the consuls were still being appointed every.
- 4:04Year. A ceremony that reached back.
- 4:06To the Republic. Close to 1000 years deep at that
- 4:10point, the grain still came in from.
- 4:12Sicily, the aqueducts still. Ran and the roads, well, they
- 4:16were still maintained. Odewacher collected taxes.
- 4:19Using the same Roman administrative machinery paid
- 4:22his. Soldiers out of it.
- 4:24And kept the whole bureaucracy employed.
- 4:26So what he was really. Doing was administering the
- 4:29place, keeping it functioning because he understood something
- 4:33the last Western emperors had forgotten.
- 4:36The machine only works if you keep it running.
- 4:39The moment you stop maintaining the infrastructure for a single
- 4:42season, you lose a decade of function.
- 4:45And Odewacher wasn't willing to lose that.
- 4:48He even minted his coins in the Senate's name rather than his
- 4:51own, because he understood that his legitimacy was borrowed from
- 4:55Roman institutions. He needed them far more than
- 4:58they needed him. And that idea, this notion of
- 5:01borrowed legitimacy, is the key to everything that comes next.
- 5:06Then in 488, Constantinople made a decision and a man named
- 5:11Theodoric crossed the Alps. To really get Theodoric, you
- 5:15have to. Start at the beginning.
- 5:16Back in 461, a Gothic king named Theodomir cut a deal with the
- 5:22Eastern Emperor. His people, the Ostrogoths.
- 5:25Had been settled inside imperial territory on the Pannonian
- 5:29frontier, which is modern day Hungary and Serbia, and to
- 5:33guarantee the peace, Theodomir handed something over to
- 5:36Constantinople. He handed over his son.
- 5:39The boy was. Seven years old and his name was
- 5:42Theodoric. This was completely standard
- 5:44practice in the ancient. World a royal hostage.
- 5:47Guaranteed good behavior. So if the Goths raided.
- 5:51The boy paid the price for it. But Theodoric wasn't sitting in
- 5:54a dungeon somewhere. He was raised inside the
- 5:57imperial court, educated alongside the sons of the Roman.
- 6:00Aristocracy. He studied Latin.
- 6:03He studied Roman law and he studied administration.
- 6:06The actual nuts and bolts of how provinces were governed and tax
- 6:10records were kept and how armies got supplied.
- 6:13He spent about 10 years watching Roman political culture from the
- 6:17inside. He came back to his people at
- 6:1918, and here's what set him apart from basically every other
- 6:23Gothic. Leader.
- 6:24Of his generation, he had seen the machine up close.
- 6:28He knew how it worked, so he didn't look at Roman
- 6:30civilization as some alien thing to be looted.
- 6:34He looked at. It as a working system you could
- 6:36operate. And that one distinction shaped
- 6:38the next 50 years of Italian history.
- 6:41Once he was back he became Co king of the Ostrogoths alongside
- 6:46his father around 471 and then the sole king after Theodomir
- 6:50died. A few years later.
- 6:52For the next 17 years. Or so he was.
- 6:54Fighting against rivals, against the Eastern Empire, and against
- 6:58neighboring peoples, he understood logistics and supply
- 7:01lines and strategic patience in a way that most contemporaries
- 7:06didn't. He also wasn't volatile.
- 7:09At one point he had a rival. Gothic leader.
- 7:11Killed to consolidate his own. Power, which was a preview of
- 7:14what he'd do later. In person to Odawaker, power
- 7:18tends to run in patterns. Just like that by. 488 The
- 7:21Emperor Zeno had himself a problem.
- 7:25Theodoric and his Ostrogoths were strong enough to be
- 7:28genuinely dangerous inside imperial territory, strong
- 7:31enough to raid, strong enough to threaten, but not strong enough
- 7:35to take Constantinople. So Zeno did the math and made a
- 7:39calculated move. He commissioned.
- 7:41Theodoric to go take Italy. Remove Otawaker.
- 7:44Govern Italy as an imperial viceroy and in theory under
- 7:49Constantinople's authority, but in practice with full
- 7:52operational independence. This is how empires tend to
- 7:56outsource the problems that they can't solve directly.
- 7:59You find somebody. Who both has capacity?
- 8:01And ambition. You hand the mission of a coat
- 8:04of legitimacy, and then you accept whatever result comes
- 8:07back. Zeno gave Theodoric the legal
- 8:10cover to conquer Italy. Theodoric gave Zeno a.
- 8:13Way out of his Ostrogothic. Problem and both men understood.
- 8:16Perfectly. Well, what they were trading in
- 8:19488, Theodoric LED his entire nation into Italy, not just an
- 8:24army. Every Ostrogoth who followed
- 8:27him? Something like 100,000.
- 8:29People. The Warriors.
- 8:31The women and the children and the elderly, along with the
- 8:34livestock and the wagons and everything they owned.
- 8:37It was a migration and a military campaign happening at
- 8:41the same time. Which is the borders.
- 8:43Fault line operating at full scale, and it created a tension
- 8:46that would define his entire reign.
- 8:49You can't settle 100,000 people inside an established
- 8:52civilization without serious disruption, and you can't govern
- 8:56an existing population that's frightened of the newcomers
- 8:59without constant political. Work.
- 9:02He spent 33 years holding that tension in place.
- 9:05And for most of those? Years he'd actually pulled it
- 9:08off. The campaign against Ottawaker
- 9:10ran four years and came down to three major engagements.
- 9:14And Theodoric, well, he won every one of them.
- 9:17After that, Ottawaker pulled back.
- 9:19Behind the walls of Ravenna, the most defensible city in Italy,
- 9:23it was ringed by marshes and. Supplied by sea.
- 9:26The Siege. Dragged on for almost.
- 9:28Three years. Until Ottawaker's supply lines
- 9:31finally gave out, negotiations started and a settlement got
- 9:35reached, and the deal was the two of them would govern Italy
- 9:39jointly. So in March of 493, Theodoric
- 9:43invited Ottawaker to a banquet to celebrate the agreement.
- 9:46And then he killed him personally.
- 9:49Right there at the table. The accounts differ on exactly.
- 9:52How? Though the contemporary.
- 9:53Source We call. The anonymous Valcenius.
- 9:57Says that Theodoric drew his. Sword and run Ottawaker through
- 10:00the collarbone with his own hand either.
- 10:03Way. They agree on the results, and
- 10:05it's worth sitting with that with for a second because the
- 10:08method tells you something about how power.
- 10:11Actually behaves the Otterick. Didn't need to kill.
- 10:13ODA Walker at that particular. Banquet.
- 10:17He'd already won the. War he could have.
- 10:19Exiled the man. You could have locked him up,
- 10:21but he chose to make a statement instead.
- 10:24A statement about what happens to.
- 10:26The old source of authority. When a new one moves in, who
- 10:29claims to legitimacy can't sit in the same room, Even a
- 10:32defanged ODA. Walker.
- 10:34Alive and pensioned off and irrelevant was still an
- 10:37alternative, still a rallying point, still a living question
- 10:41mark hanging over. Theodoric's rule.
- 10:43And the murder closed that question for.
- 10:45Good. This is the power.
- 10:47Fault line at its most stripped down, and it runs on legitimacy
- 10:51a lot more than ideology. So now Theodoric is master of
- 10:56Italy, and what he builds over the following years is 1 of the
- 10:59strongest political experiments in late Roman history.
- 11:03But here's what he kept intact the Roman Senate, still meeting,
- 11:07still deliberating, still the symbolic center of Roman public
- 11:10life. The consulship was appointed
- 11:13every year, a ceremony that was already 1000 years old and
- 11:17reached back to five O 9 BC Roman law applied to Roman
- 11:21citizens through Roman courts, with Roman judges the whole.
- 11:25Imperial bureaucracy. The tax collectors.
- 11:28And the record keepers and the grain administrators and the
- 11:31postal system. He even kept the aqueducts 11
- 11:35separate systems feeding Rome, although them maintained and
- 11:39repaired on his orders. But here's what was new.
- 11:42The army was Gothic, the top military commanders were.
- 11:45Also Gothic. And a third of Italian estates
- 11:48got formally reassigned to Ostro Gothic settlers.
- 11:52That was the price of conquest. So you had two parallel.
- 11:55Systems running at the exact same time.
- 11:58The Roman civilian apparatus administered everything.
- 12:01The Gothic military class protected it, and one of them
- 12:04governed and one of them fought, and Theodoric stood in the gap
- 12:08between. Both of them even gave the
- 12:10arrangement a name. Civilitas.
- 12:13Civilized order. A Roman.
- 12:15Order. He used the.
- 12:16Word in official correspondence, in legal decrees, in his
- 12:20diplomacy. And he wasn't just describing
- 12:23his government when he did it, he was making a political claim.
- 12:26The claim was that he was the continuation of what Rome had
- 12:29been, not the end of it. This is where Mary Beard's
- 12:32reading of Rome in SPQR actually helps, because her argument is
- 12:37that Rome's real genius was never the marble.
- 12:40It was institutional. It was citizenship and law and
- 12:44an administration that could outlast any single ruler.
- 12:47And Theodoric was betting his whole reign on that being true,
- 12:51betting that Rome was. Portable that you could.
- 12:53Run it without having being born into it.
- 12:55The coins reinforced the same message.
- 12:58He minted them in Rome's name, with his own face on one side
- 13:02and Roman symbols on the other, with the Senate's approval
- 13:05required from the mint itself, Gothic treasury, Roman
- 13:09denominations. Every merchant who handled one
- 13:13of those coins was being quietly told that the system was intact,
- 13:18which made the coinage. A piece of political.
- 13:20Communication operating at an enormous scale.
- 13:24The man who made all of this coherent on paper was a Roman
- 13:28aristocrat named Cassia Doris, a senator, a scholar and an
- 13:32administrator, and. Theodoric's effective chief of.
- 13:35Staff for much of his reign, every royal edict, every
- 13:39diplomatic letter, and every piece of official correspondence
- 13:43between Ravenna and the outside. World.
- 13:46Well, Cassiodorus wrote it. And he gathered 12 volumes of
- 13:49that correspondence into a collection, which is called The
- 13:52Very Eye and still survives today.
- 13:55We can read it, and reading it tells you something pretty
- 13:58remarkable. Because it doesn't.
- 14:00Read like the paperwork. Of a barbarian Kingdom at all.
- 14:04It reads like the. Correspondence of a Roman
- 14:06administration that's just happens to have a Gothic king
- 14:10sitting at the top. The Latin is polished, the legal
- 14:13reasoning is careful, and the same concern shows up over and
- 14:17over, which is to maintain the Roman system, maintain the.
- 14:21Roads. The courts.
- 14:23And keep the food supply moving. Cassiodorus also.
- 14:27Wrote a history of the. Gothic people, which is mostly
- 14:30lost now, but you can tell what it was doing from the pieces.
- 14:33That actually survive. He was.
- 14:35Arguing that the Goths. Had ancient ties to Roman
- 14:38civilization. He was building a narrative
- 14:40where Gothic rule wasn't an occupation but an inheritance.
- 14:44It was propaganda, but it was sophisticated propaganda,
- 14:48because Theodoric didn't only want to rule Rome, he wanted to
- 14:51be. Adopted as.
- 14:52Roman, and that distinction really does matter, because a
- 14:56conqueror takes while the successor inherits.
- 15:00And Theodoric was. Trying to inherit.
- 15:02You can still see the physical evidence of that ambition
- 15:05standing today. He built in Bervena, his
- 15:08capital, putting up churches and palaces and administrative
- 15:11buildings, all of it in Roman style, with Roman materials and
- 15:16Roman and Byzantine Craftsman and an iconographic program, the
- 15:20mosaics and the architectural vocabulary that was thoroughly
- 15:23Roman. He was constructing his argument
- 15:26in stone, the argument that he belonged inside Roman tradition.
- 15:30For 30 years. For the most part, the argument
- 15:34held Italy under Theodoric was more stable than it had been in
- 15:38decades. The invasions of the 5th century
- 15:40had shattered any sense of confidence and continuity.
- 15:44The Visigoths under Alaric back in 410, the Huns under Attila in
- 15:48the four 50's. The endless run of military
- 15:50coups. And Theodorex, Italy.
- 15:53Had none of that. The harvest got recorded.
- 15:56The roads got maintained. The grain moved from Sicily to
- 15:59Rome right on Schedule 1. Contemporary.
- 16:01Source describes the whole period as a stretch of peace.
- 16:05That older generations simply hadn't lived through and the.
- 16:08Material Record backs that up with.
- 16:10Archaeological evidence of continual occupation and
- 16:14maintained infrastructure and trade networks that were still
- 16:17functioning Rome's population. Or Theodoric was still.
- 16:21Being counted in the hundreds of thousands.
- 16:23And that number is going to matter because by the end of the
- 16:27Gothic. Wars 50 years later.
- 16:29It would be counted in the 10s of thousands.
- 16:31Instead, the city the Romans wrecked, retaking it, had been
- 16:35better preserved under the Goths.
- 16:37And that's the central irony running through this entire
- 16:40period. Now I want to.
- 16:42Stop here for a second, because this is exactly.
- 16:45Where most. Histories of this period go.
- 16:46Wrong. They treat Theodoric's reign as
- 16:49a kind of pause, a ( a brief interval of stability.
- 16:53Before the real story. The Byzantine conquest gets
- 16:56going, but it wasn't a parenthesis.
- 16:59At all. It was an experiment and the
- 17:02question the experiment was testing was whether Roman system
- 17:06could function without a Roman. At the top for 30 years, the
- 17:10answer was yes. And the conditions under which
- 17:13it stopped being yes will tell you almost everything about the
- 17:16power fault line. There was always a deeper.
- 17:19Fracture sitting under the surface, and it wasn't military
- 17:23and it wasn't economic. It was religious, the
- 17:26Ostrogoths. Were Aryan Christians and
- 17:28Arianism held that Christ had been created?
- 17:30By God. Subordinate to the father,
- 17:33rather than Co equal with him. The Catholic Church had declared
- 17:36that a heresy all the way. Back at the Council of Nicaea in
- 17:39320. 5 which is. Around 170.
- 17:42Years before Theodoric took over.
- 17:44Italy, and for that entire stretch, Arianism had been a
- 17:47theological and political wedge driven through every
- 17:51relationship between barbarian rulers and their Roman subjects.
- 17:55The divide wasn't really about. Doctrine.
- 17:56In the end it was about identity.
- 17:59Catholic Romans looked at their Aryan Gothic rulers and saw
- 18:02foreigners not. Just politically.
- 18:05They were foreign in a theological sense too.
- 18:08Men who worshipped Christ differently, who built their own
- 18:11separate churches, who wouldn't take communion alongside their
- 18:15Roman. Subjects.
- 18:16So the Gothic. Army and the Roman population
- 18:19shared the same territory and the same institutions, but they
- 18:23never shared an altar. Theodoric's policy was formal
- 18:26tolerance, and for a long time that held He didn't interfere
- 18:31with the Catholic Church appointments, he didn't
- 18:33confiscate church property, and when Catholic mobs went after
- 18:37Jewish communities in northern Italy, he stepped in and
- 18:40protected. Jewish property.
- 18:41Rights against the Christian violence.
- 18:44He pointed Catholics to the highest civilian post in his
- 18:47government. As his chief philosopher.
- 18:50His most trusted intellectual was himself Catholic.
- 18:53That man was Botheus Initius Manlius Severinius Botheus.
- 18:59The name carries the full weight of the old Roman aristocracy.
- 19:02A patrician family, a deep philosophical education,
- 19:07devoutly Christian and thoroughly Roman, he had spent
- 19:10his life doing something almost nobody else in the West was
- 19:13doing, which was translating Greek philosophy into Latin.
- 19:17Aristotle's logical works. Porphyries.
- 19:20Isagoje Ptolemy on music, Elucid on mathematics, and this matters
- 19:26more than it might sound. Because by the early 6th.
- 19:29Century educated Romans were losing their access to Greek the
- 19:33Eastern Empire. Still spoke it.
- 19:36But the Western world increasingly didn't, which meant
- 19:38the intellectual inheritance of Athens, Plato and Aristotle and
- 19:43the whole. Structure of Greek logical
- 19:45thought. Was slipping out of reach.
- 19:47Both theists understood what that meant for Rome if nobody
- 19:50translated it now. It would be lost.
- 19:53It wouldn't be destroyed, exactly, it would just become
- 19:56unreachable, lost simply because nobody left could.
- 19:59Read it. So he worked at it.
- 20:01Systematically planning to translate the entire
- 20:04Aristotelian corpus, every major work and he got.
- 20:08Through the logical works before his arrest.
- 20:11Those translations went on to become the intellectual
- 20:14foundation of the medieval European philosophy for 600
- 20:18years from Bothius. Right up to recovery of
- 20:21Aristotle through Arabic sources.
- 20:24In the 12th century, Western philosophers worked mainly from
- 20:27his Latin versions. That whole chain of transmission
- 20:31ran through one man's desk in Ravenna, under a Gothic King's
- 20:34roof. In 522, Theodoric appointed him
- 20:38Magister Oficiorum, the Master. Of offices, the highest.
- 20:42Civilian administrative post in his Kingdom Boethius run the
- 20:46palace administration, coordinated the communications
- 20:49between Ravenna and Constantinople, and handled the
- 20:52schedules and appointments and official correspondence of the
- 20:57entire central government. It was, in practical terms, the
- 21:02most powerful Roman in Italy. And for a year or so it worked.
- 21:07The Roman philosopher and the Gothic king, the civilian brain
- 21:11and the military commander, the civilatas operating at its
- 21:14absolute best. Then around 5:23.
- 21:17Boatheus was arrested. The charge was treason.
- 21:22And specifically, it was secret correspondence with
- 21:25Constantinople. The allegation was that he'd
- 21:27been communicating with the Eastern Imperial Court and
- 21:30working to undermine Theodoric passing along information.
- 21:35Was it true? We honestly don't know, Boethius
- 21:38denied it. He argued that the.
- 21:40Evidence had been fabricated and he named the accusers the men
- 21:44who had their political reasons to want him gone.
- 21:47None of it helped him to understand what Theodoric was.
- 21:50So afraid of. You have to understand what
- 21:52Constantinople was doing at that moment in 5/19.
- 21:56A new Eastern emperor named Justinian the First had ended
- 22:00the Acacian schism. A theological split.
- 22:03Between Rome and Constantinople that had run about. 35 years.
- 22:07And just. Like that, the Catholic.
- 22:09And Orthodox churches were reconciled.
- 22:12For Western Aryan rulers, that reconciliation read as a
- 22:15warning. Constantinople was positioning
- 22:17itself as the defender of Catholic Orthodoxy and an
- 22:21Orthodox emperor with a unified Church behind him.
- 22:24Had a perfectly plausible pretext.
- 22:27To intervene anywhere Aryans happened to be ruling.
- 22:29Over Catholics. Which meant Italy, which meant
- 22:33Theodoric. And Theodoric was in his 70s by
- 22:36now, and no male heir, and his health was disappearing.
- 22:39His Kingdom had been built on a delicate balance of Gothic
- 22:43military power and Roman civilian administration, and
- 22:47there was no. Obvious successor capable of.
- 22:49Holding that balance together, the tolerance he'd.
- 22:51Practiced for 30 years. Had been a personal achievement,
- 22:55an act of political will sustained by one man's
- 22:58judgement. And one man's judgement gets
- 23:00worse with age and fear, as well as paranoia.
- 23:04So in that climate, the suggestion that Boathius was
- 23:07corresponding with Constantinople was explosive.
- 23:11Whether he was a genuine conspirator or just a convenient
- 23:14target, the accusation fit the. Fear.
- 23:17And the fear in a declining system is stronger than any
- 23:20evidence. This is the power fault.
- 23:23Line at its most recognizable, and we've watched it run through
- 23:26this series. Before.
- 23:28Silico, the half fandile general.
- 23:30Who effectively held the? Western Empire.
- 23:31Together for over a decade. Was executed in a four O 8 by
- 23:35the very emperor he'd been serving on a charge of secret
- 23:39dealings with the enemy. The reality?
- 23:41Was that the most? Capable man in the system, and a
- 23:44system in decline can't tolerate that kind of capability without
- 23:48becoming afraid of it. And now you've got Boathius, the
- 23:51most capable Roman administrator in Gothic Italy, facing the same
- 23:54accusation, the same fear, the same outcome.
- 23:58It's the same pattern playing out again.
- 24:00Boathius got sent to prison in Pavia and he was there.
- 24:04For about a year. And in that whole.
- 24:06Year he wrote the book he wrote. Was the consolation of
- 24:10philosophy. It's a dialogue.
- 24:12Between Boathius and a. Figure he calls Lady Philosophy.
- 24:16Who appears to him in his cell, tall and ageless, her robes
- 24:20embroidered with the Greek letters π and Theta.
- 24:23Standing for practice and theory.
- 24:25She asks him why he's grieving. And what follows is one of the
- 24:29most sustained meditations on fortune and justice and the
- 24:33nature of good in all of Western literature.
- 24:36And notice what he doesn't write.
- 24:38He doesn't curse Theodoric. He doesn't write a.
- 24:40Political treatise. He doesn't even write Christian
- 24:43theology, even though he's a Christian and he's sitting there
- 24:47waiting to die. What he writes is philosophy.
- 24:51In the tradition of Cicero and of Plato, a Roman senator in a
- 24:54Gothic prison, writing like the Rome of 500 years earlier, the
- 24:59Rome of the Republic, the Rome that hadn't get cracked under
- 25:03the weight of the emperors and debase, coinage and barbarian
- 25:07generals. The choice tells you exactly.
- 25:09What Boethius believed civilization actually was.
- 25:13To him, it wasn't an army or an institution or a bloodline.
- 25:17It was a set. Of intellectual habits preserved
- 25:20through reading, passed on through writing, kept alive by
- 25:23individuals who. Decide the ideas are worth.
- 25:25Carrying forward and he was doing precisely that in his
- 25:29cell, knowing he was going to die.
- 25:32The consolation went on to become one of the most copied
- 25:34and translated and. Widely read books.
- 25:37In all of medieval Europe, King Alfred translated it into Old
- 25:41English. Chaucer translated it.
- 25:43Queen Elizabeth the First translated it.
- 25:46It was read in monasteries, courts and schools across 1000
- 25:51years of European history. It outlasted the Gothic.
- 25:54Kingdom by 14 centuries, and it's still in print today.
- 25:58Boatheus wrote the most important Roman book of the 6th
- 26:01century. He wrote it in a prison cell.
- 26:04And he was. Executed by a goth, that's what.
- 26:07Civilizational continuity actually looks like.
- 26:10When you get close to it. It comes down to individuals
- 26:13deciding the ideas are worth passing on one person at a time.
- 26:18It is in the triumph, and it has.
- 26:19Very little to do with the powerful.
- 26:22Preserving anything from the top, the container was Gothic,
- 26:26the content was Roman, and the content what survived in 520. 4
- 26:30Theodoric had Boethius executed. The method was.
- 26:34Brutal with the sources. Describing him bound and beaten
- 26:37to death, some of them saying Accord was tightened around his.
- 26:40Skull first. And he also had Symicus executed
- 26:44Boethius's father-in-law, the head of the Roman Senate and one
- 26:48of the most respected men in Italy, two of the most committed
- 26:52defenders of Roman civilization under Gothic.
- 26:54Rule. Eliminated within roughly the
- 26:57same. Stretch after that.
- 26:59The Senate went silent. It wasn't abolished, it just
- 27:03went. Quiet the civiletas kept.
- 27:05Functioning on paper. The decrees were still.
- 27:07Issued and the court still. Sat.
- 27:09But the trust had made the whole thing run.
- 27:12The willingness of Roman aristocrats to genuinely serve a
- 27:15Gothic king, well, that was broken.
- 27:17You can't execute the two most prominent Romans in your own
- 27:20administration and expect their. Successors to serve with.
- 27:23The same conviction. What you get instead is a
- 27:26compliance men doing the bare minimum required.
- 27:29To stay out of trouble. And that's not the same thing as
- 27:32governance. And it tends to go in a
- 27:34sequence. First the system starts to feel
- 27:37threatened, and then it turns on.
- 27:39The most capable servants starts mistaking their loyalty.
- 27:42For a threat. And then removes.
- 27:44The very people who keep. It running.
- 27:46After that, it's coasting on compliance rather than
- 27:49commitment, and eventually it collapses.
- 27:52Not right away, and often not for years, but the real damage
- 27:57is already done. The executions of Boathius and
- 28:00Symmecus didn't end Theodoric's Kingdom that day.
- 28:04What it ended was the kingdom's ability to regenerate itself.
- 28:08Theodoric died in 526 in his mid 70s, having ruled.
- 28:13Italy for 33 years. Which, by the standards of late
- 28:16antiquity, was an extraordinary run.
- 28:19The grain still came in, the aqueducts still ran, the roads
- 28:23were still maintained, and the Senate still met.
- 28:25But he died without a male heir, so his daughter Amalfa Suntha
- 28:30took power as a Regent for her young son.
- 28:34Athalaric. And by every surviving count,
- 28:37she was extraordinary. She spoke Latin and Greek and
- 28:41Gothic. She'd been educated in the Roman
- 28:43tradition, and as she wanted to carry on her father's policy of
- 28:47Roman Gothic integration, he appointed Roman administrators.
- 28:51She worked Constantinople diplomatically, and she
- 28:54understood that the kingdom's survival depended on keeping her
- 28:58father's system intact. But the Gothic.
- 29:00Military aristocracy rejected her.
- 29:03Because they didn't want their sons raised as Roman scholars.
- 29:07They wanted warriors to them. A.
- 29:09Gothic boy who read Cicero. And spoke fluent Latin.
- 29:13Was a gothic boy being stolen there was a cultural.
- 29:16Fracture. Running right through the Austro
- 29:18Gothic Ruling Class 1. Theodoric held together by
- 29:21sheer. Force of personality by his
- 29:24authority and his. 33 year track record.
- 29:27Amaltha Suntha had none of those buffers, so the military faction
- 29:32forced her to raise an authoric in Tradition instead, and he
- 29:35died young, somewhere around 17 or 18.
- 29:39His death blamed on drink and dissipation, though account
- 29:43comes to us mainly through. Pocopius, who is a hostile.
- 29:46Byzantine source on the Goths? After that, Amalthasuntha was
- 29:50pushed into a power sharing arrangement with a Gothic noble
- 29:54named Theodahad, who had promptly had her imprisoned on
- 29:58an island in Lake Balsanina and then had her strangled.
- 30:02Constantinople used her murder. As a pretext.
- 30:06The emperor Justinian had been looking for an opening.
- 30:08A way to. Retake the western provinces,
- 30:11and since Amalthasuntha had been a diplomatic contact with him,
- 30:15her death became the trigger. In 535, Justinian sent his
- 30:20general. Belisarius to Sicily.
- 30:22And the Gothic Wars began. What followed was 20 years of
- 30:26devastation. And I want to be specific here
- 30:29because the standard narrative presents the Gothic Wars as
- 30:32Rome's recovery, the Eastern Empire proclaiming its rightful
- 30:36territory, civilization restored.
- 30:39But the evidence shows something very different.
- 30:42And the man who gives us most of that evidence is Precopious, who
- 30:45served on Belisarius own staff and watched those campaigns
- 30:49first hand. He's our witness, and he's the
- 30:53one who tells us much of what got broken in the process.
- 30:58Belisarius campaigns destroyed the infrastructure that
- 31:00Theodoric had spent three decades keeping alive.
- 31:04Gothic defenders cut the aqueducts to deny water to
- 31:06besieging armies. Crops were burned to deny them.
- 31:10Food Cities were sacked. And the Italian peninsula became
- 31:13a military theatre for 20 years straight.
- 31:16Rome itself changed hands five times over the.
- 31:19Course of the war the city Theodoric had kept.
- 31:22Several 100,000 people collapsed, and by the time the
- 31:26Gothic Wars ended in 554, the estimates put Rome's population
- 31:31somewhere between 30 and 50,000, from hundreds of thousands down
- 31:35to 10s of thousands in 20 years. And the thing that did that to
- 31:39the city was the Roman conquest itself, rolling through like.
- 31:43Fire through dry grass. The Barbarians didn't.
- 31:46'Cause that collapse. The Senate effectively stopped
- 31:49functioning. It wasn't formally abolished.
- 31:52It just quietly stopped. Existing as anything that
- 31:55mattered. The last.
- 31:57Recorded meeting of the Senate, the body that had governed Rome
- 32:00since the early centuries. Of the city was.
- 32:02Somewhere around 580 AD, more than 1000 years of continuous
- 32:07operation. And it didn't end under ODA
- 32:09Walker. Or under Theodoric.
- 32:12It ended in the wreckage left behind by the Byzantine
- 32:15reconquest, then in 568, barely 14 years after the Gothic.
- 32:20Wars wrapped up the. Lombards came down from the
- 32:22north and Italy had nothing left to defend itself with the Gothic
- 32:26military. Class that had.
- 32:28Protected. The peninsula for 70 years was
- 32:30gone, and the Byzantine Garrison was spread too thin and funded
- 32:34too poorly to hold the whole country.
- 32:37So the Lombards took most of northern and central Italy
- 32:40within a few years, and they were a different kind of ruler
- 32:43entirely. They weren't Romanized, they
- 32:46didn't use Latin as a political language, they didn't keep the
- 32:49Senate, and they didn't preserve Roman law for their subjects,
- 32:53the whole arrangement. Theodoric had built Gothic
- 32:57power. Riding on top of Roman
- 32:58institutions came apart completely.
- 33:01So let me. Walk you through the fault lines
- 33:03right now. Because this is where the three
- 33:05threads. Finally, converge start with
- 33:07money. Theodoric's Kingdom have kept
- 33:10the fiscal infrastructure intact.
- 33:13The tax system worked. Revenue moved from the provinces
- 33:16to the center, the bureaucracy got paid and the army got
- 33:19funded. The Gothic Wars wrecked.
- 33:21All of it. Now the armies had to be paid
- 33:24out of a countryside that was being actively destroyed.
- 33:27The Italian tax. Base evaporated as the
- 33:30agricultural. Economy collapsed and Justinians
- 33:33Italy just started requiring constant subsidy from
- 33:36Constantinople. It became a fiscal drain from
- 33:39the moment the reconquest began. So the system Theodorica kept
- 33:43solvent turned into a wound in the Eastern Empire's finances
- 33:47that nobody could close. Then the.
- 33:49Borders the Ostrogoths had. Creating something genuinely
- 33:53unusual, A working coexistence where Gothic and Roman land
- 33:57holders share the same legal and fiscal system.
- 34:01Not perfectly, and not without friction.
- 34:03But that third of the. Estate that had been handed to
- 34:06Gothic. Settlers had stabilized over a
- 34:08generation, the Gothic soldiers. Protecting the Italian
- 34:11population now had a real stake in its prosperity, so they
- 34:15weren't simply occupiers anymore.
- 34:17They were invested. The Gothic Wars undid all of
- 34:20that, erasing 50 years of settlement, and the Lombards who
- 34:24came afterward had no such investment.
- 34:26They were conquerors without the institutional inheritance.
- 34:30Theodoric had worked so hard to build so the whole.
- 34:33Question of what it meant to be governed and protected and part
- 34:36of a system in Italy. Got reset to 0.
- 34:40And then the power Justinian's reconquest was strategically.
- 34:44Catastrophic because he stretched.
- 34:47Byzantine resources across three major campaigns at the same
- 34:50time. North Africa taken back from the
- 34:53Vandals. Italy taken back from the Goths.
- 34:57Spain partly taken back from the Visigoths, all of it running
- 35:01simultaneously, and the Eastern Empire's finances?
- 35:04Never. Really recovered.
- 35:06Within a generation, the Byzantine Italy was too weak to
- 35:09defend itself. Too peripheral to be
- 35:12prioritized. And too expensive to be
- 35:15maintained properly. And as a note, we understand
- 35:18it's the Eastern Roman Empire. We're calling it Byzantium here
- 35:21just to differentiate. Power had concentrated up to
- 35:24Constantinople and pulling everything toward the center.
- 35:27Of it destroyed the local. System that actually kept the
- 35:30provinces working. It's the same centralizing
- 35:32failure that brought down the Western Empire in the 5th
- 35:35century, now eating away at the Eastern Empire's ability to hold
- 35:39on to what it had just retaken. And the Pattern didn't seem to
- 35:42care which empire was running it at all.
- 35:44So step back and look at the whole.
- 35:46Ark. Rome falls, but Italy keeps
- 35:49running. A Gothic king takes Italy and
- 35:52keeps the Senate, the law, and the bureaucracy.
- 35:55A Roman philosopher becomes the most powerful civilian in a
- 35:58Gothic Kingdom, and then that. Philosopher gets executed.
- 36:01And the trust inside the system breaks, Theodoric dies, the
- 36:06experiment ends, Rome retakes Italy.
- 36:09The Reconquest finished the job, the Lombards arrived, and Italy
- 36:13won't be a unified country again for 1400 years.
- 36:17The fall was never a single moment.
- 36:19It was a process. And the sharpest irony buried in
- 36:23the. Process is this.
- 36:25The people most committed to preserving Rome at its most
- 36:28fragile moment weren't Roman at all.
- 36:31The Otteric. Cassiodorus Boatheus.
- 36:34Who was Roman by blood but working inside a Gothic?
- 36:37Structure. Even Silico before them, the
- 36:40half Vandal general who held the Western Empire together right up
- 36:44until the emperor he served had him killed.
- 36:47Outsiders, all of them. People who had looked.
- 36:50At Roman civilization from the outside and.
- 36:53Decided it was worth keeping. Meanwhile, the formal heirs, the
- 36:57emperors and the court factions, the military aristocracies, had
- 37:01spent two centuries tearing it apart from the inside.
- 37:05Rome lasted as long as it. Did because the people who.
- 37:07Weren't supposed to be the ones to save it and that tells you
- 37:11something about how civilizations.
- 37:13Actually work. They don't survive.
- 37:15Because of their formal. Institutions.
- 37:17They survive because particular. Individuals.
- 37:20Decide the ideas are worth. Carrying forward as Theodorus.
- 37:24Copying and preserving the administrative tradition in his
- 37:27monastery at Vivarium. Boathius translating Aristotle
- 37:32at a desk in Ravenna and then finishing his last book in a
- 37:35prison cell. A Gothic king who repaired the
- 37:38aqueducts. Barbarians who took Rome didn't
- 37:41destroy Rome, they tried to become it.
- 37:44So the tragedy was never. That outsiders took over the
- 37:47tragedy. Was the system was already so
- 37:50broken by the time they arrived that even the most.
- 37:53Capable outsiders. Could only slow down the
- 37:55collapse, they couldn't stop it. And this is the shape.
- 37:59Of the thing. When a civilization is failing,
- 38:02it doesn't announce the failure. The buildings are still
- 38:05standing, the courts are still in session, The currency is
- 38:08still circulating. The failure isn't the people
- 38:10running the machine, it's when the competent administrators
- 38:14start getting replaced by compliant ones.
- 38:17When loyalty gets valued over function.
- 38:19When the institutions. Exist to protect the people at
- 38:21the top. Instead of serving the people
- 38:24underneath them, when the system starts executing the men who
- 38:27actually make it work, that's when the fall begins, long
- 38:31before the walls ever come down. It's the same pattern, just a
- 38:36different century. So when you see a system
- 38:38swapping out its best administrators for loyal.
- 38:41Ones. When competence start getting
- 38:43treated. As a threat.
- 38:45When the institution still work on paper, while the trust inside
- 38:48them drains quietly away, what you're looking at is Ravenna in
- 38:52524. You're watching the slow
- 38:55execution of the very thing that made the system work.
- 38:58Oatheist gave Fortune a voice in the Consolation, the book he
- 39:02wrote in that cell, and the line is hers.
- 39:05Quote This is my art. This is the game I will never
- 39:10cease to play. I turn the wheel that spins.
- 39:14I delight to see the high come down and the low ascent.
- 39:17End Quote. He was describing how the thing.
- 39:20Actually works. Not good fortune or bad fortune,
- 39:24but the wheel itself, the pattern that grinds on
- 39:27regardless of who happens to be standing on top of it at that
- 39:30time. He was executed within a year.
- 39:33His book survived 15 centuries. The wheel kept turning, and it's
- 39:38still turning now. This has been the Roman pattern.
- 39:41I'm Jeremy Ryan. Slate, please Like this video?
- 39:44Leave us a comment and smash that subscribe button if you
- 39:47want more of the Roman pattern.