Latest / ThisWeekInGeek / Future Imperfect - Star Trek Picard Season 3 Final Roundtable Discussion (Part 2 Of 2)
Transcript
- 0:08Captain de Bridge, spark here and these signs of life negative? Have you
- 0:12tried all healing frequencies? Affirmative? No answer from the cube? Have the
- 0:16department heads meet me on the bridge, already standing by life sciences? Same
- 0:25report? So are we gonna just let it hold us here? We've got
- 0:29phase of weapons. I vote we blasted. I'll keep that in mind,
- 0:32mister Bailey. Unless becomes a democracy, you realize that the aim will,
- 0:38of course be very crude. I don't care if you hit the broadside of
- 0:43a barn. Just hurry, please, Captain, Why should I aim at
- 0:48such a structure? Mind spot? Just get on with the job. Hey,
- 0:58guys, what's going on? You are listening to this? We can
- 1:00keep dot Net's Future imperfect. I am your Lieutenant, Commander, Mike the
- 1:03Burman. But I'm not alone. As I trek across the scars into the
- 1:08swan song of Piccard's Season three, I'm joined by the intrepid crew of the
- 1:14USS Future Imperfect. I'm joined by my best friend, my compatriot, the
- 1:17guy who makes things keep running anywhere and everywhere on this plane of existence,
- 1:23Alex the Producer, and whenever I have a question about Star Trek life,
- 1:26the universe and everything, and especially be movies. I have my friend from
- 1:30the great Land of Lansing mission because it feels so nice to be back on
- 1:34this show guys to talk about Star Trek and it's nice to talk about something
- 1:38positive for a change. Yeah, we are talking about the back half of
- 1:44Piccards season three, which finished up a couple of months ago, and the
- 1:49news in the Star Trek fandom right now has been tumultuous, to say the
- 1:53least. But hey, we can all agree that Piccards season three was fantastic.
- 2:00So um, let's kind of jump right into this. I wouldn't say
- 2:04fantastic. I really liked, like, this is what I wanted. I
- 2:09would say this is what we would have wanted from season one. And yes,
- 2:15it's not fantastic, but it was really good in parts, Like,
- 2:20yeah, it was okay. This is the first Picard season that was solid.
- 2:24Yes, okay. So I would say, like completely, I would
- 2:27say the first half of the season was good, the second half was okay,
- 2:32but that's overall probably final. I will say this the final episode.
- 2:37I hm, I had problems with parts of it, but I liked it.
- 2:44Uh, maybe that's your blind love of Star Wars because it was basically
- 2:51Star Wars. But we'll get to that. Yeah, yeah, there are
- 2:54definitely elements where they're taking more of the Star Wars ass paced how things are
- 3:01very there's the Millennium Falcon and We're gonna come in and save you moment.
- 3:06But it was very very Skyhook slash Death Star to uh. It's it's like
- 3:14and again, we'll get into it later. But like I like MYCE,
- 3:20I like my Star Trek hard as an hard sci fi And if I want
- 3:27to watch something that is Star Wars EA fantasy, or if I don't want
- 3:31space fantasy, if I want lighter sci fi, I watch something like like
- 3:37yeah or Firefly, where it's still a fantastic show, but it's not it's
- 3:43not hard sci fi. This this would be like like like a know,
- 3:46Aaron's a big fan. This would be like what if the Expanse had u,
- 3:51you know, a Star Wars episode. Yeah, it would be like
- 3:54no, no, or what if we what if we were watching all Mankind?
- 4:00And then at some point little green alien men start walking around green alien
- 4:03men with laser guns and yeah, just yes, Andy gravity and and they
- 4:09started and they started screaming and they started vaporizing everybody like in Mars Attack.
- 4:14Yeah no, see, I really do feel that the last half was okay.
- 4:18It brought down a fairly strong start to the season. Um, and
- 4:24I have to to couch this in like the idea that I like fan service,
- 4:30but a little goes a long way, and we had more than a
- 4:33has to be done, more than a little fan service, so it kind
- 4:39of got aggravating. It's still light, but yeah, like like, yeah,
- 4:46so, if I remember correctly, I think we did there. We
- 4:49did coverage of the first or I think four of the ten or was it
- 4:56was it ten episodes? It was ten episodes. That sounds right, but
- 5:00I have my ratings up there, that's right. Okay, so we did
- 5:02the first Yeah, we did. We did the first four of the ten,
- 5:05and I think when we left we left on a oh my god,
- 5:09this is really really really good and then we just didn't get a chance to
- 5:13cover the rest of the Yeah. Yeah, and I think I think episode
- 5:17so it was actually bighest rated episode that I had for the entire season.
- 5:24That was the was that Ensign Row. No, that was before that was
- 5:29one episode before ens and Row. That's when Ensign Row shows up in the
- 5:31end, I think, right, yeah, uh, and I think maybe
- 5:36Erin give us a recap of what your ratings were for the first four of
- 5:41your part scale. They ranged between five and seven and a half. So
- 5:46the way I kind of ranked things, it's a really steep bell curve.
- 5:49It's very difficult to get outside of four to six range. So like even
- 5:54if something's four out of ten, to me, it's still okay. But
- 5:58I didn't like it more than I liked it, So having something that's like
- 6:02seven and a half so it is pretty good. So like like a four
- 6:09would be like for you see minus okay, and then like a seven like
- 6:15a plus, yeah, okay. It's really hard to get like to nine
- 6:21or one, though it can be done. So I'm thinking, Mike,
- 6:30you you watched it most recently, right, yeah, Um, I'm just
- 6:34looking over episodes summaries basically once you get past episode four, when you start
- 6:42getting into them going after like the Roe Laron stuff was awesome. Like Michelle
- 6:47Forbes, I really wish she had come back to the thing a lot,
- 6:51a lot sooner, but I'm glad they got to wrap up that storyline when
- 6:57they did the data base that goes on and they randomly brought back Moriarty that
- 7:04seemed a little fan servicing for no real reason. I get them bringing back
- 7:09Data, but that it's weird to say. I like it, yet I
- 7:15don't at the same time, because that's a story they kept. They just
- 7:19keep bringing back Brent Spiner for whatever reason, and wonderful actor, wonderful character,
- 7:25but it kind of undercuts the sacrifice in season one of Picard where he's
- 7:30like, I just want to go and experience that mortal Yeah, basically the
- 7:38entire ending of Nemesis. Yeah, like it's one of those things. I
- 7:45mean, yeah, bringing them back's cool, and now he has to fight
- 7:47against uh, you know, Lore in his mind, which I there are
- 7:51parts of that I really like from a creative standpoint, like especially where he's
- 7:58like, I'm gonna give you the one thing you never had, and that
- 8:01was love, and then Laura gets essentially tricked by Data, but they both
- 8:05say goodbye, brother, I love you, and that I thought was a
- 8:09really tender moment, which really I think did Brent Spiner a wonderful service to
- 8:16this character. But there were other parts of the episodes where I'm thinking the
- 8:20whole Changeling Borg alliance kind of came acrost me is a little strange. You
- 8:26guys, go on, well can I can? I say, We'll do
- 8:30episode five just very quickly. That's the roll there, and we touched upon
- 8:35it's the conspiracy episode where Roe realizes that there's, uh, there's been an
- 8:41infiltration within Starfleet. To me, it was like, hey, it's kind
- 8:45of like the season one conspiracy if they you know, we're able to make
- 8:50it in modern times where it's a real spy conspiracy, YadA YadA, YadA,
- 8:54Like Okay, that's cool. That was sort of the pivotal shifting point
- 8:58after that episode though, like you said, to a little more fan service.
- 9:01But this Bounty episode, which is episode six, I want to say
- 9:05one thing before Aaron gets in, and that's, uh, they keep mentioning
- 9:09in the beginning parts of the season that it's it's data before Lal and Lore
- 9:13before and Lal don't appear even once in the personalities they just mentioned were there
- 9:20there, So what was the point of mentioning how? I mean, it
- 9:24doesn't make sense to me exactly why do they mention it though? Just because
- 9:33fan service? Yeah, so I get why they did it for that,
- 9:41And I also get like if they were going to force Brent Spiner to be
- 9:46in person in it, the reasoning behind having an older, flabbier body or
- 9:54should have him because I mean the dudes in his seventies, right, Like
- 9:58the reason for it is like, oh, we want to make him like
- 10:01with a human body that can degrade and allays be like okay, uh I
- 10:05personally think if you were to have brought him back um, because you know,
- 10:09he technically had a separated it should have just been B four with B
- 10:15four his memories and he should have not even had a corporate from He should
- 10:18have been brought onto the ship to run the emergency data hologram. Yeah yeah,
- 10:26like like like like he's literally you know, not maybe not controlling the
- 10:31ship, but we're talking like they go into the ready room and they can
- 10:35pull up data he's on. He's on a partition of the ship to store
- 10:39it. Like that's the only way they like they could store his consciousness.
- 10:43It's in the ship, and he's okay with it exactly. And then you
- 10:48could have had you know, a holographic representation using old footage or picture of
- 10:52him, or just had his voice and that would have been fine. And
- 10:56he probably would have been fine getting paid full money to not have to be
- 11:00then they wouldn't have likely had reused Majel Barrett's voice for the computer in that
- 11:05like last episode, and out of all the fan service stuff in this in
- 11:11this season, that probably actually hit it was the best fan service. Um
- 11:18that because that actually got me to have a tier now, but you know
- 11:22that's me. That's fair. But yeah, so this episode, episode six,
- 11:31the Bounty, Um, I can see Michael what you were saying.
- 11:35This is where you're like, Okay, too much fan service. Yeah,
- 11:41I mean, like it was a cool idea, but like Aaron was saying,
- 11:46if you put too much in, you're gonna spoil it. A little
- 11:48goes a long way, And yeah, it's cool to see Data and Jordy
- 11:54befriends again. It's wonderful they get to pick up that friendship they thought they
- 11:58lost. But part of life is lost and you only part of you grows
- 12:03by experiencing that loss and moving on from it. That was a moment and
- 12:09I'm, like I said, I'm very glad they got to have that very
- 12:11genuine I'm so glad to see you again, my friend. But I don't
- 12:16know, well, did you and also like the museum was an excuse or
- 12:22the like the Holding Center was an excuse for it to be like hey,
- 12:26Central Eastern Central, it's like and like the Triple No, it's James Kirk's
- 12:31body. James Kirk. Yeah, you just the display it actually had bio
- 12:37readings on it, so he's alive. Yeah. No, No, they
- 12:43just pulled his body off Brittian too and like brought him back to life and
- 12:48then threw him into like, you know, a stasis pod. Yeah,
- 12:56because because Wink wink Shatterer's like ninety, we got to be. But that's
- 13:03what I what that says to me. That said to me, like,
- 13:07we don't know how we're gonna get Shatner into something, but maybe we can
- 13:11use his body's corpse. How about you make Shatner you know have be like,
- 13:16oh you know, we we we've built a data based like how many
- 13:20times did Jane Way talk to like Da Vinci, you know, on like
- 13:24holiday? Why don't you just make a holiday character that is Captain Kirk if
- 13:28he had lived longer. That's how you do it. You don't need to
- 13:33have his body pulled out and reanimated like Frankenstein's corpse um there's that like the
- 13:41triple one was like, that's a nod, But it was kind of funny
- 13:43because like, you know, they look at it and it's like it looks
- 13:48way scarier than it should have, and I'm like, okay, it's scary
- 13:52to to to you know, clings. It would have been more funny in
- 13:56my mind if they had to put it in there, if the umans walk
- 14:00by and they looked at it and like, you know, it's cycling through
- 14:03pictures of what a triple looks like and it's just like normal looking, fluffy,
- 14:07trible. But then you know, if you or for any clingon walks
- 14:09by, it's or as they walked away, which is to another picture and
- 14:13it shows it with like a brazilion teeth like it did, and I'd be
- 14:16like, oh so that so like so like even the humans did yeah's like
- 14:22oh that's what the cling Yeah, yeah, exactly exactly. If they had
- 14:31done that, I would have been like, Okay, that's an okay,
- 14:33if you're gonna have some fans service to do it like that so that the
- 14:37humans don't still don't notice how dangerous they really are. Um but yeah,
- 14:43like it's like I said, like this episode. This episode made us go,
- 14:48oh, please don't do this. Yeah, and I will say I
- 14:52know we had problems like talking like was this the episode where we saw its
- 15:00start the because this is where they take cloaking device from HMS Bounty, twenty
- 15:05third century cloaking device that runs on duatronic computer systems, installed it into a
- 15:11twenty fifth century Federation starship that uses ice linear systems. It's a completely different
- 15:16starship, I mean, and they're as rather than like ease. This is
- 15:24a completely foreign piece of technology that by treaty, the Federation can't even have.
- 15:35It's made for a ship that's tiny, and Titan is supposed to be
- 15:39big. Yeah, supposed to be big because the behind the scenes production stuff
- 15:43says it's it's kind of like it's kind of like the sovereign size, but
- 15:48all the special effects shots that you see of it, it's literally the same
- 15:52size as a constitution. Look, because we get to say from the one
- 16:03point that comes up, I think that's like what episode eight, So you
- 16:08can see how big the decks are and you go, okay, well,
- 16:12production and the start. The person who designed the starship says that it's X
- 16:17long X tall it has this many decks, but you can literally see isn't
- 16:22the special effect shot, So it's it's confusing if you know any of the
- 16:26behind the scenes stuff, But if you're just watching it from perspective of your
- 16:30average viewer, it's a very small ship. Sorr. If you're babbling about
- 16:37that, I still like the time. I think it's actually very cool.
- 16:42Oh no, it's the details, like you know, this is why you're
- 16:48here, buddy, because I would look at it and go, it's all
- 16:52special effects shots. All the exterior shots of it make it basically the same
- 16:59size as a constant tuition class, maybe even a little smaller withinter volume.
- 17:07And I almost wonder if that was I don't know if they did it on
- 17:11purpose or if it's an unconscious choice to do it for composition of like the
- 17:17Competially, it's just because they they designed it originally to be just like a
- 17:23constitution, using the same kind of window patterns and everything like that, but
- 17:26no one ever scaled it up. Oh okay, so it just might be
- 17:37a scale thing when they were when they were designing their shots, they just
- 17:41never scaled the windows a little to window side for the decks for on camera
- 17:49oh oh, I see what you mean. Okay, yeah, yeah,
- 17:52so this you know that was episodes episodes seven, Episode seven. That's what
- 18:06was that about? Toronto blank on it. According to the official Wikipedia summary,
- 18:11which I will just read very quickly, Pcard surmises the changelings want to
- 18:15create a perfect replica of himself to target Starfleet's upcoming celebrations for the two hundred
- 18:19and Fiftiest Frontier Day. Geordie attempts to maintain Data's control over the synthetic body
- 18:25as it overcomes the devious Laura. Piccard devises and an act of plan to
- 18:27trap Vatic on her and her crew on the Titan with force fields, using
- 18:32Jack, who is developing telepathy, and Sydney as bait. Piccard and Beverly
- 18:36interrogate Vatic, and she reveals she's hunting Jack for someone else. She also
- 18:40explains that she was one of ten Changings whom Starfleet doctors experimented on to develop
- 18:44a breed of superspies. Upon their escape, she swore revenge formed a roach
- 18:48changeling fashion, taking her tortuous form. Beverly confirms these facts as Piccard decides
- 18:53he has to kill Vatic. However, Jordy fails to revive data in time
- 18:56to stop Laura from taking over the Titans computers and disabling the force fields,
- 19:00allowing vatic In her underlings to escape. They capture seven Shaw and the rest
- 19:04of the bridge crew. Vat It invites Jack to the bridge and she says
- 19:07she knows his true nature. Oh is this episode where you flash back to
- 19:14and I have a feeling going to be very Starfleet? They specifically say,
- 19:21yeah, this was so confuses Section thirty one with Starfleet in the Federal Okay,
- 19:27Section thirty one is an illegal organization. It is not a part of
- 19:32Starfleet. Is an underground organization that is there to basically do the Federation's dirty
- 19:38deeds. It's also basically, um, there for lazy writers to make the
- 19:45Federation bad guys. Basically what it is. I hate Section thirty one with
- 19:51a passion because there were used very well in Deep Space nine, very well,
- 19:57um, and they have not been used well at all since there's no
- 20:10reason to believe they will be with that movie or whatever it is coming up.
- 20:17Uh. But yes, so this was the torture episode where I was
- 20:22watching I'm like, I don't want to watch people. I was watching to
- 20:23go and wait a minute, oh no, no, yeah, not in
- 20:30Star Trek like I can if if if if your whole Like, okay,
- 20:37I can see it happening in like Battlestar galact Together, the remake show that
- 20:41happened like something that is much more visceral and and dark, and the whole
- 20:48time you're dealing with you're not even dealing with like shades of gray. It's
- 20:51it's very Galactica had a very yeah, and and they were dealing with horrible
- 21:00shit, and there's like they deal with like war crimes and all this sort
- 21:04of stuff. It's like, okay, I get it. For that Ron
- 21:07Wars, you know, reimagining of that was you know, really good for
- 21:11the time. Uh. But there's a reason that when he did that show,
- 21:15it wasn't Star Trek right, you know, like like you wouldn't have
- 21:21seen like as much as he wrote, you know, complex and darker storylines
- 21:25and stuff into Deep Space nine. There's a reason that that he didn't just
- 21:30make another Star Trek show and make it like that, and he went and
- 21:33did Galactic instead and made that show that dark. Right, there's certain there
- 21:37are certain principles that you shouldn't Cross with Star Trek, and I felt like
- 21:42I was like, oh no, I don't want to I don't Yeah,
- 21:49good reason, Yeah, because yeah, yeah, that's the first time character
- 21:57Roe died in a way where I was like, one of like new track.
- 22:02Yeah, say since since it came back with Discovery where their death actually
- 22:04felt meaningful and a part of their character's arc. Yeah, And and was
- 22:15their choice, you know, through their through their like even though she was
- 22:21gonna it was through her actions. It was not hey, here's torture porn,
- 22:29which tends to happen in a new track. For whatever reason, Um,
- 22:33so yes, I oh yeah, no, I'm watching this. I
- 22:36was like, okay, and take away I might some tails in each one
- 22:40of their episodes. The fact is that every time there's character moments in this
- 22:47entire season, character moments where there's characters sitting at a table talking to each
- 22:51other or interacting having a heartfelt conversation. Is Chef's kiss, Yes is incredible?
- 22:59Yeah? Very good dialogue? Yeah, like, there's some really good
- 23:03dialogue. Well. And and for out of all three seasons, for whatever
- 23:10reason, this season, Patrick Stewart actually acted as Piccard and not just gave
- 23:15a shit. He well The problem with season one and two is even if
- 23:18you know, I know he had influenced in season two a lot that was
- 23:22reported that that was actually one of the major issues with the writing of it
- 23:26because he kept interfering. Was he seemed to only be acting as eighty year
- 23:32old Patrick Stewart in those first two seasons and not actually as eighty or whatever.
- 23:38You know, he wasn't acting his age as Piccard. He was acting
- 23:41his age as himself and just used Star Trek as an outlet to express his
- 23:47own personality. And it's like, that doesn't work. You can do that.
- 23:53He's a good actor and he could do that on his own, but
- 23:56it doesn't work when you have like thirty five years of a legacy character.
- 24:00So it was like a light switch was flipped in this season. And actually
- 24:03as the season went on, I noticed he seemed to appear more comfortable in
- 24:08playing Piccard. Yes, definitely more at ease the emotional tense moments like there's
- 24:15one in some of the last dialogue he had with like ensign Row in the
- 24:21last episode when they're both expressing you broke my heart, I trusted you.
- 24:26That was really, really, really good, and that was Patrick Stewart and
- 24:30Michelle Forbes obviously two different actors of different calibers, and they were meeting at
- 24:36such a good way, where like, this is what I've wanted, This
- 24:38is good dialogue, these are good character moments. And think about this from
- 24:41earlier in the season, people went from hating Captain Shaw fucking loving that guy,
- 24:48like two episodes, like the online discourse on that character changed immediately,
- 24:53and you know what it was. People were terrified that he was going to
- 24:57be just like all the their new characters that they introduced. Oh great,
- 25:03another asshole who's not going to behave like a Star Trek character would behave And
- 25:07within two episodes, what, oh no, he can actually actually remember what
- 25:11I said, would behave? He's just an asshole? Would go ahead,
- 25:15looks, I'm sorry, not just not just an asshole, like sorry,
- 25:25yeah, it was he was behaving like an asshole should within Star Trek,
- 25:29whereas all the other asshole characters, Yeah, I've been behaving. Well,
- 25:33I was gonna say, I don't remember exactly what I said in our first
- 25:36half review in previous but I can say, at least from my perspective now
- 25:42looking back, I know I hated Shaw as a captain, but liked him
- 25:47as a character general at the beginning because I'm like, this guy's a dick.
- 25:52Can't really be this kind of dick and be a Starfleet captain because people
- 25:56aren't going to respect you, they're not going to like you, and how
- 26:00did you get promoted? But as the season goes on, my opinion really
- 26:04didn't change about Shaw. That he was still an asshole. He was still
- 26:08a dick, but you realize that he did have these moments where people around
- 26:12him could see the good that he used to be, if you know what
- 26:17I mean, before his trauma and that scene where he sits down and explains
- 26:22his trauma to Piccard and it is dark but entirely appropriate for Star Trek,
- 26:30and I had chills. And the fact is is that when he's done and
- 26:34he's like glaring at Picard, Piccard just says, I understand. He doesn't
- 26:38try to apologize because there's nothing Picard can do to apologize. There's nothing to
- 26:44apologize for. He wasn't Piccard at the time, you know, he was
- 26:47licutest. He's like, Okay, I understand where you're coming from. And
- 26:52Card was the stand in for the audience at that point, we as the
- 26:56audience should have said, Okay, you're an asshole, you're an ass from
- 27:00Chicago, but we understand where you're coming from. Excellent writing well, and
- 27:11you get the feeling that when he when he does jump back into like engineer
- 27:15mode, you're you start to think, wait a minute, had he not
- 27:19experienced that trauma, gone through that post traumatic stress, and and not had
- 27:26such horror, horrific survivor's guilt, would his you know, alcohol addiction have
- 27:30happened. Would and you start to go, wait a minute, what he's
- 27:34able to you know, uh, rig up, you know, last minute,
- 27:38just thinking on his feet. He is very intelligent, he's very resourceful.
- 27:41Could he have been like another job? I think I think it drove
- 27:47further. I think that's such a drove mind have achieved otherwise because yeah,
- 27:56it's yeah, yeah, okay. So the way he was explaining it is
- 28:03that he didn't understand why he lived and all of his friends died and it
- 28:07was just whatever lieutenant you get on the escape pod, not that that lieutenant
- 28:11came on with him, because remember the way he describes it, it was
- 28:15him in the escape pod, right, even like one other person. But
- 28:26yeah, yeah, like they they weren't even drugs. They were just pointing
- 28:32at people saying, you go there, you go there, you go there.
- 28:33And from random, he's the one that lived. All of his friends
- 28:37died and left there with Darlene watched that episode with me and she was like,
- 28:45holy crap, I get it. I get why this guy was an
- 28:48asshole in the first couple episodes. I get the kind of anger that he
- 28:53would have at himself and like disrespect towards himself because now he's not having to
- 29:00live just for himself, he's having to live for all the other people that
- 29:03never made it. And you feel like he's still a good captain or good
- 29:17sorry, he might be good at running his ship, and then the second
- 29:19he sees who's coming on board his ship, it amplifies all of his anxieties
- 29:26to the point, yeah, to the point where you know he might have
- 29:30had bad days quote unquote with the crew and that that's why they're not You
- 29:34know, you can see that they all respect him, they all do their
- 29:37job, but they would know, oh, Captain's having one of his bad
- 29:40days. Well, the second he sees who's coming on his ship. Every
- 29:44day now becomes a bad day. His trouble and death always follow the card
- 29:48no matter where he goes, Like, yeah, Like, I really like
- 29:53the way that they handled Shaw, Like, I don't know if they Aaron
- 30:00Alex, You've probably seen a lot more Star Trek than me, although I'm
- 30:02going to correct that problem this summer. How well does the franchise deal with
- 30:06Survivor's Guild? Like, this is one of those things where I think it's
- 30:08it's a really good example of it. Deep Space nine is basically Survivor's Guild.
- 30:14Yeah, I've only seen like the first two seasons of it, so
- 30:15I'm gonna have seen it. I've seen obviously season one, and I've seen
- 30:19probably fifty percent of the episodes sporadically throughout. I just haven't done a full
- 30:25watch through. But I mean the episode opens, like the whole reason the
- 30:33reason Cisco is there, it exists is it's because yeah, yeah, and
- 30:37and it's like his his dislike a picard and and disillusionment and everything. That's
- 30:42why they become basically frontiersman. They're just like they don't want to. It's
- 30:48easier for him to not be there than it is to deal with it.
- 30:52And then ings go on and because it'll be interesting to watch, but that
- 30:57is his guilt basine. Basically, iSER Deep Space nine does it very well.
- 31:04Um. The other series don't do it very well. Um. And
- 31:11the reason I say that is that while there is a ship's counselor in TNNG,
- 31:17we have Troy Um Troy, they basically criminally misuse Troy as a character
- 31:23most of the time, and they do so in the final episode of Hard
- 31:30season three as well. Like they they really undermine her as a therapist in
- 31:37the last the last episode, And I don't know if you remember that,
- 31:41but it actually really upset me because I wrote this large section for Star Trek
- 31:45Adventures about counselors and dealing with trauma and how star Fleet would have to have,
- 31:52you know, very passionate, very caring counselors to have just help crew
- 31:59process us through these really traumatic experiences. But what does Troy do In the
- 32:02last episode, She's looking at freaking um vacation vacation spots, just kind of
- 32:08going mm hmm to Data as he's like pouring his heart out to her.
- 32:14It was like, wow, wow, yeah, he would well, And
- 32:27not to mention you'd have more than one on a ship, but it always
- 32:30seems like there's one, there's one you mean like and in that, yeah,
- 32:35she would thinking about class and then also doing other stuff like like you
- 32:51have a chief medical officer on a ship, but you have more than one
- 32:52doctor and nurse. You you would have always the one ship counselor. It's
- 32:57like you have a single ship counselor and you have like families living on the
- 33:00ship. But uh but yeah, uh but yeah, so I mean episode.
- 33:10I know we're not really talking deep into each episode, but like,
- 33:14uh, I thought it was interesting how they killed off that. I think
- 33:17that was that was kind of hilarious and I did laugh. It was I
- 33:22laughed because I was also, we don't want to pay you anymore for being
- 33:24in this, so we're gonna turn you into in the next episode because the
- 33:28changing, um, we're gonna go down the easy route with villains for Star
- 33:34Trek and now it's the board and then it becomes the last three episodes become
- 33:50Star Wars Wars. Yes, very very much. And that's where that's where
- 33:52some people were like, you know what the shop the season was like soaring
- 34:00at about an eight out of a ten for me, and then I went
- 34:02down to about a seven as far as entertainment. I'm not talking on like
- 34:06a value of how great of trek it was, as far as how enjoyable
- 34:09it was. I and I'm sitting there watching it with my brother every week.
- 34:13He was coming over and he's not the big truck fan. He's watching
- 34:15this and he he turns to me part way through the you know, the
- 34:20last two episodes, he goes, this is just Star Wars, but not
- 34:24as good. And I went, oh, you just yeah, you just
- 34:30hurt my soul and every single person that ever watched Next Gen by saying that,
- 34:35because I heard it and I went in actually right, the interpersonal scenes
- 34:37between the characters, because when they're like characters dialogue the Star Wars if every
- 34:42single cast member was overweight trying to understand themselves and the problem. Overall,
- 34:46it's great. The dialogue is amazing. People are giving it. They're all
- 34:51they're not phoning in performances. This is credit where credits due to the actors
- 34:55and actresses involved. Seriously well well done. But the overall plot is just
- 35:06yeah, yeah, it's Star Wars. Not literally like it's not like New
- 35:10Hope. You know what I'm saying. It's action overthought. It is spectacle
- 35:15over. Yeah, it felt like a movie. Yeah, it's it's modern
- 35:25Star Wars movies, not the not the Mandalorian. Mandalorian's a great show.
- 35:29We're talking like the Modern trilogy, and it's like the spectacle for the sake
- 35:34of it without making any sense. Hey, hey, for my military fan
- 35:38friends here, what did you think about Starfleet deciding to have every single ship.
- 35:44It's clear that that for no reason, Wow, you're leaving vast parts
- 35:51of the Federation undefended. And if anybody was a Star Trek fan watching that,
- 35:55they would go, that's not all because clearly it takes audience. Every
- 36:01sources is going to be there. No, that would be like, yeah,
- 36:15if they had said every like and they were trying to say it was
- 36:17like everything in the Alpha Quadran. If they had said everything, you know,
- 36:22we're having every every every uh, you know, h every basically important
- 36:29ship within a you know, five sector radius or something, or you know,
- 36:32if they had given a distance that we're having them come in and then
- 36:36we're going to broadcast it to everybody, sure, because you know, that
- 36:39would be like you know somewhere, that would be like us doing a Memorial
- 36:44Day thing here and having you know, most of the military from Ontario there,
- 36:47you're not going to call the military and from you know, British Columbia
- 36:51for no reason, you know what I mean, Like you might have a
- 36:52representative or two, but you're not going to call everybody in. That would
- 36:55be like America being like, hey, we're gonna have Fourth of July celebration.
- 37:00And by the way, we're calling all of our our navy vessels in
- 37:04that uh that you know, patrol international waters and keep China in check.
- 37:10We're just gonna pull them all in because we want to have a fireworks show.
- 37:15And when I saw that, I was like, my brain is melting.
- 37:17What are you doing? Also they're just like the I was like,
- 37:22did you learn nothing, dude, Battlestar Galactica. You're going to So that
- 37:30should be to have had issue command show that that's like in incredibly bad idea.
- 37:39And Fleet Admiral Elizabeth Shelby, the person who is literally stood against the
- 37:44Borg every time we've seen her on screen, they're announcing we have Borg enhanced
- 37:49starships to tighten all together. Then she gets killed because she's the legacy.
- 38:00Yeah, yeah, because that's a great idea. Yeah, yes, And
- 38:07by the way. Uh, we're going to take away what makes the start
- 38:12not to start for what makes the Federation the enduring Beacon. Uh, you
- 38:17know, we're going to take away all the individuality and the ingenuity of the
- 38:22crew by making it all computerized. It's beyond bath, no reason to have
- 38:27any staff. The problem is even further and when you're going to take away
- 38:30what makes the Federation the Federation happened? Okay, So basically, the the
- 38:36plot of the last couple episodes is that the Borg of Borg with the Changeling's
- 38:42help, have basically put this code into the transporter systems that inserts genetic code
- 38:49into everyone that goes through it. That makes sense so far. Absolutely it
- 38:52does that then allows them to become a part of the collective when they're activated
- 38:58through magic telepathy from Picard's kid um. This means that when when it gets
- 39:07activated, this literally should mean its game over because it's everybody that's gone through
- 39:12the transporter system under a certain age like twenty something, So that means everybody
- 39:23on Earth. Yeah, everybody on Earth now under is controlled by everyone on
- 39:30or under twenty five or whatever. Right, so it's like all all kids,
- 39:37what would what would have stopped anybody from doing that to civilian transporters.
- 39:42Well, it's it's anybody that's used a transporter onto a starfleet military absolutely nothing.
- 39:49But like you you think about it, all the people that were beaming
- 39:51to and from earth Dock there big as earth Dock was. The writer has
- 39:55a crew of like three hundred thousand people. How nothing happened on Earthdoc.
- 40:09Yeah, so you've you've got that. And I went, oh god,
- 40:20they did the same thing that they do, and all the new Trek seasons
- 40:22is have a really stupid ending that doesn't make any sends except for somebody in
- 40:28the writer's room went wouldn't this be cool? And then nobody said no because
- 40:34they were going so well. And yet again all the character stuff's great.
- 40:38I mean, how you know, how teared up or did you feel when
- 40:44they you know, finally went on the Enterprise d and lit it up.
- 40:45Uh, Like I thought they went a little long and overboard with that.
- 40:50But I'll tell you one thing, I started laughing audibly out loud as when
- 40:57they went on the ship and started lighting up that the lighting for the whole
- 41:01became flat bright lighting, not as bright as was uh you know in next
- 41:07ship when it was airing on TV. But it had the same lighting and
- 41:10even took screenshots. You actually see what was going on as first the first
- 41:15time set as the movie did twenty five years ago. And yeah, exactly,
- 41:34And I went, oh, you mean that? You know, I
- 41:36can walk in the room and see what's happening, and I don't have to
- 41:37be, you know, squinting at every time to see what the actors are
- 41:40doing at a telltale sign. I don't know if you guys saw they all
- 41:45the actors were doing except for Picard, we're doing uh podcast appearances some things,
- 41:50uh and uh. Gates showed up on. I think it was the
- 41:57what's the shuttle one? The one that's run by the doe from uh from
- 42:00Enterprise they run a video podcast with Trip and uh, uh what's his name?
- 42:08The British guy, I forget his name now, But but they had
- 42:13her on and she's talking and I almost feel like, oh, did she
- 42:15kind of let it slip talking about how hard it was to film the show
- 42:21because they could barely see the other actors when they were filming their scenes together.
- 42:25Said that she goes, Oh, it's it's part of modern filmmaking now.
- 42:29Apparently, because you know, again she does all stuff behind the scenes
- 42:31usually now mostly just doing choreography. But she's like that the with the cameras,
- 42:37they pick up so little light that that they darkened. We had a
- 42:40hard time knowing when it was our time to talk because we couldn't see the
- 42:44other actor's faces. I'm like, you were four feet away and you couldn't
- 42:47see the other actor. So a lot of the lighting was done right,
- 42:53Yeah, And then she said that, uh, Patrick Stewart had trouble remembering
- 42:58when it was his time to do his lines and they had to give him
- 43:00a visual indicator because he couldn't see the other actors because a lot of these
- 43:05actors have reading glasses right or are they they have contacts whatever now and they
- 43:08can't see like and she said that they mentioned, well what about when they
- 43:12you know, lit up the set and everything. Oh, then it was
- 43:15great and it's like, exactly, if the actors can't see each other,
- 43:20we can't fucking see them, what's going on? Like unless they artificially brighten
- 43:24you know, after the fact and post and then it looks like shit,
- 43:28So like that's there's a reason, like that's brighter, and then we know
- 43:30that strange New Worlds is already brighter, but not this bright. But like
- 43:35when we saw that, and then basically for the last you know, episode
- 43:38or two, whenever they showed them in the set, it was like,
- 43:40this looks and feels right. Why couldn't it have been this since two thousand
- 43:45and seventeen or whatever when they started bringing back the shows. Oh? Yes,
- 43:50that's my final thoughts on this season. Are I enjoyed it? Uh?
- 43:54There's really dumb moments like we just mentioned, But I think overall,
- 43:59this was, you know, the best of the three seasons and the most
- 44:02like I would honestly say, if you're if you're a fan or if you're
- 44:06getting into it, you know, and you watch the t and and everything,
- 44:10he skips seasons one and two entirely, and you could just watch this
- 44:14one. I would honestly, if you're gonna skip seasons one and two,
- 44:17just watch a quick video synopsis that just kind of brings you up the date
- 44:22with certain characters. One of the things I will say as we begin to
- 44:25finish out here, I did find some of the newer characters were less annoying
- 44:30as this season went on, because I know we've I haven't cared for Raffy
- 44:36almost this entire time, And I know in the beginning of this season she
- 44:39was like, look at me, I'm all strung out and whatever. As
- 44:45this season went on, she became less and les annoying. But it's also
- 44:46because she became less and less prominent. But they did provide her a little
- 44:52rap in a bow. Although I guess one thing to talk about, guys
- 44:55before we wrap this up, they're clearly setting up something else. What do
- 45:00we think about that? I think, I think do not make do not
- 45:07do that. I think that we're great but only returning carrot from the card
- 45:13season three. No, I don't want to see Jack Crusher. I don't
- 45:15want to see Raffie. Um okay, well maybe maybe Sydney Sydney Forge,
- 45:22That's that's fine. She can be held the helms person, that's that's fine.
- 45:27But those two, yeah, yeah, I'm not sure why I don't.
- 45:37I don't know if I can, I can speculate what. Yeah,
- 45:40well, you know, I don't. Or actresses except for RAFFI no,
- 45:47like they're not even mentioned, like what happens with Lara's. I just think
- 45:59they were given bad stuff to work with. I thinkst deal and season Yeah,
- 46:07there's not anything there for her because like there was like they don't even
- 46:14yeah yeah, yeah, nothing for her and the other characters that were more
- 46:24made like they don't even mention them, like at all. And they only
- 46:31mentioned of any previous season of this other than uh when they you know mentioned
- 46:38you know, data, they mentioned it what happened to him? Uh,
- 46:42and he's like, oh, that was not me, that was another me
- 46:45basically, you know, because he was split. Uh. The only mention
- 46:50is when Captain Shaw makes fun of the season two by saying, I'm not
- 46:57talking about you know, Layard, those those those those those pocket dimension Borg,
- 47:02I'm talking about the real Borg. Yeah, and he's like, the
- 47:06real scary Borg are still out there. Yeah. It's like basically saying that
- 47:10everything you showed was bullshit in season one and two. Yeah, Like and
- 47:16then the thing that annoyed me and I wish they just cut this scene out.
- 47:22This series finale did not need a post crediting to me bringing Q back
- 47:30at the various But does that undercome season two in being what happened between him
- 47:36and that plot? Now it's Q dying kind of meaningless because Q would always
- 47:40come back regardless, because so, yeah, like the only explanation I worked
- 48:00out in my head with Q doing that was different wasn't it wasn't dying is
- 48:05that he was trying to believe that it was hard, that cards like that
- 48:08that's him at the end of his life, and that everything else can inspire
- 48:13him to snap. It comes back, you know in a series, you
- 48:16know, fifty years from now. Yeah, it's just que from before he
- 48:20was dying. It's okay, m hm, yeah, yeah that because he's,
- 48:37like he said, he's outside of time. He's not aging linearly with
- 48:39us. He came back to die at a different point in time, so
- 48:43he's technically existing in multiple times at once. He's doctor who It's well it's
- 48:47like yeah, like like he's still living and doing his own thing. Like
- 48:52it's just that that particular queue or at that point in time, that's when
- 48:55he chose to die. Okay, fair enough, fair enough? Um,
- 49:00Yeah, Like I'd like to see a new Star Trek show, you know,
- 49:05no more psychic powers unless it's like a random one off episode. Please,
- 49:08I don't want What is with Okay, what is with the red motif?
- 49:14Why is everybody Trek have this thing with a you know, a red
- 49:20red matter, red angel, red Matter, red Angel, red door.
- 49:23Everything is this red mcguffin. What is it some weird obsession that they've got
- 49:30with it. I don't I don't understand why it's always something red. Visually
- 49:34it stands out, I mean from a film perspective. I mean also like
- 49:38I'm speaking purely as a set dresser, it's very visually striking. But I
- 49:43totally feel you though, like, yes, it's becoming very obvious that it's
- 49:49like, oh, if anything red shows up, that's the mcguffin for the
- 49:52end of the whole season. And like Star Trek tends to rely very heavily
- 50:00on certain primary colors. Green, you know, it's alien, like you
- 50:04always assume it's Borg or something. Blue is always Starfleet. Red as always
- 50:08big spooky aliens or Clingon's Yeah, but yeah, I mean it was it
- 50:15was nice seeing cling On makeup look right again. Yeah, Like, I
- 50:21don't know, I think Star Trek stands at a weird thing because I know
- 50:25there was an interview, uh Patrick Stewart said the other day there should be
- 50:30one more TNG film, one last great adventure. What do you guys think
- 50:37about that? I'd say if there would there's enough gas for the TNG crew
- 50:39to do It's one thing only if uh, if either run More or Ira
- 50:47Baird comes and writes it. You have to get you have to get somebody
- 50:57that's not a film like a film script writer. Uh. You have to
- 51:01get somebody that was part of the writer's rooms in the nineties to do it.
- 51:07Mhmm. I don't, like, I don't. I wouldn't trust anybody,
- 51:13like even a superfan might. The problem with a superfan writing it is
- 51:16they might get they might get ninety percent of it right and then put too
- 51:20much fan service and not realizing it. Yeah. Like, basically we don't
- 51:23want the force awakens with the enterprise. I don't think. I mean,
- 51:30I'm not one hundred percent sure, but I don't think most of the writers
- 51:34from the TNG era, like of TNG itself, are still actively writing shows.
- 51:40Um. I don't know. An I think, well, almost all
- 51:46the DS nine people are still around in their their show writers. Um.
- 51:52And I mean I keep saying it, but like Ronald D. Moore,
- 51:54if you got him to come in and write it, even though yeah he
- 51:57was a writer on on TG, he was the main dude behind DS nine,
- 52:00But like if you had him, yeah, you would him and his
- 52:04crew that's writing all the ship for for for all mankind. Have that writer's
- 52:09room make it, and have that writer's room make it and watch us cry
- 52:13when we have the hear the announcement that they're making it. Right, So
- 52:21yeah, exactly, they'd be like, and who's directing it? And they'd
- 52:24be like, I don't know what they like. As much as Frakes is
- 52:29decent, but when it comes to like the movies he directed, he directed
- 52:34one good but right, and a lot of that was star momentum of the
- 52:38show. I would want to get somebody that would be would you want to
- 52:42get specifically Start Trek? I think so yeah, h and and not the
- 53:02no no no. I mean ideally you get Deneville Neuve, the guy that's
- 53:07doing do Yeah, that'd be cool. And he'd and like he somehow made
- 53:13a Blade Runner sequel that was good. Right, you have him come in?
- 53:19Yeah, you have Denevillnuve do it done, slow, methodical, Star
- 53:22Trek done, and and he's making a crap ton of money for Warners,
- 53:28so you know, Paramount would want that kind of money too, and they've
- 53:30he's proven that you can make a slow, methodical movie and still make hundreds
- 53:35of millions of dollars. Yeah, and it doesn't need to have some special
- 53:38effect spectacle bad guy, because now we don't have the Borg. The Klingons
- 53:44are working with us again, the Romulans are not a threat anymore. So
- 53:49you could tackle different issues with that director and actually have it be a more
- 53:54of a space well movie that makes you think, I have to go to
- 54:00one of two directions. I would say they'd have to go in and if
- 54:01you had a really good director and writing team, you could do it.
- 54:05One. You go for the easy, right, which is you do a
- 54:07callback, you know, like like a Rathicon thing, but not with the
- 54:12Boord. They would have to pick something from, you know, the previous
- 54:15stuff, and they can't do a lot of stuff with the Romulans because of
- 54:21how that's been mined and there's no Romulus and YadA YadA YadA and nero and
- 54:27all. You can't really do that. You'd have to pick another conflict from
- 54:30one of the seasons to go with or two. And this is more challenging
- 54:36but ultimately more rewarding. You use the movie as a means to not introduce
- 54:40a new villain, but you could introduce new factions or new new parts.
- 54:45Like you could have them, you know, boldly going where no one has
- 54:49gone before, and they're going to eight different you know, they're no longer
- 54:52going to the you know, sports base, not like voyage or where they're
- 54:58lost. But like maybe you have of them go beyond anywhere where anybody has
- 55:01gone before and they start encountering completely new types of aliens and that becomes a
- 55:06setup for future Trek TV shows. That'd be cool. I mean, you
- 55:10could even steal an idea from Mass Effect Andromeda. Maybe they found a stable
- 55:15wormhole to the Andromeda galaxy. Yeah, like there's some way, like it's
- 55:21like how did they get out there? You know how they what was it
- 55:23the was it the traveler snapped his fingers or something or or or they put
- 55:28them out yeah yeah, or yeah, and they were sent out where there's
- 55:32like weird like jellyfish and crap in space, but wherever that was. But
- 55:37you have a way, you have a means there's something that happens. Maybe
- 55:40they're traveling to you know, the event they're traveling to is they're traveling to
- 55:44save somebody using a transwarp conduit and something freaking out of it and they get
- 55:49out and they're like, where are we And they're like, there's no star
- 55:53maps. Not that we're you know, within whatever quadrant. There's no star
- 55:59maps because we're not in the Milky Way. And you set it up where
- 56:04it's like okay, and you know, the final voyage of them is they
- 56:07don't come home, they go and travel, and then that starts setting up
- 56:12you know, a series on Paramount Plus where it is you know, not
- 56:16necessarily the founding of the Federation, but it's it's this, it's maybe this
- 56:22crew, or you jump forward and it's multiple generations down the line. People
- 56:27have been living on the Enterprise and they're in this new galaxy becoming you know,
- 56:32the new Federation and trying trying to establish communications with our galaxy. But
- 56:38do you know, bringing the values of the Federation to what could be either
- 56:43lawless or a completely different culture. Yeah, that, you know, and
- 56:49that's just spitballing it, you know for a couple of minutes, Like that's
- 56:52what a really creative team could do to give it options because then you have
- 56:57the options for television shows and movies of things in the current galaxy, current
- 57:01you know where we are here and also having stuff set you know, bam
- 57:06somewhere way the hell away. So like, you give more, I'm tired
- 57:09of things just mining what we already know. Yeah, Like I don't want
- 57:14to hear the words borg anymore. I don't want to hear Romulan. I
- 57:16don't want to hear Klingon. Give me something interesting. Hell, I would
- 57:21love to see the Tholians come back. That'd be cool. Or give me,
- 57:24give me some one off or the corn Give me an anthology series like
- 57:30Twilight Zone, but not like you know, like Twilight's Eleben start tre where
- 57:34each episode maybe is an hour long, but it doesn't have to take place
- 57:37on a you know, a starfling events. Why don't we have an episode
- 57:38where it's it's literally following a Klingon as you know, honor guards that just
- 57:44gets promoted, is on his first ship, and you're seeing events that happened.
- 57:50Maybe it's you know, certain Cold War events or whatever events from the
- 57:53perspective of you know, a young Klingon officer encountering a fight with what we
- 58:00never see the perspective of the other aliens within the Federation or even allies.
- 58:05Are villains like, we could have an episode that's about, you know,
- 58:08how about the Vulcans making first contact with Earth, But it's from the Vulcan
- 58:14perspective, So the whole the whole time, they're they're discussing, you know,
- 58:20logically, what's going on, and then you don't even necessarily know what's
- 58:22happening. They're like, we're making contact, this is this happened? We
- 58:25see this, and then they go down and and it's you know, they
- 58:29see Zephyrm Cochrane's uh, you know, warp flight, and you like,
- 58:35you could go with forty five minutes without realizing that's what it is. And
- 58:37then it ends with them making first contact and they're unsure of what this is
- 58:40going to, what the future holds. Boom. They never do it.
- 58:45It's always from the human perspective, and that's what an anthology series could let
- 58:50you do. Anyway, I'm off my soapbox now. Good times. So
- 58:54anyway, guys, that's gonna do it for this edition of Future Imperfect.
- 58:58You're probably hearing this show. At some point in July. I'll be recording
- 59:01a couple more of these with JT. Ken and Aaron As Alex has taken
- 59:07the month of August off as he goes into hibernation and webmaster only mode.
- 59:12UM. So hopefully you guys are having a safe and happy summer vacation here
- 59:16on twig. Me and Alex are probably playing video games. I'm probably watching
- 59:21a lot of Star Trek and probably some anime. UM. Yeah, so
- 59:24again, guys, thank you for doing this. I'm so glad we got
- 59:28a chance to talk about cards. Definitely check it out. Finding Star Trek
- 59:32on a streaming service is going to be interesting. We'll say that. UM
- 59:37have fun doing that. So I guess until next time, folks, for
- 59:40the future imperfect. We have been Alex the producer, and I'm Mike the
- 59:46Birdman saying, and until the next time, folks, live long and prosper.
- 59:50Computer. This is Captain James Kirk of the USS Enterprise destruc Sequence one
- 1:00:01COLDE one one A computer. Initiate the self destruct sequence authorization Jane Way Pie
- 1:00:08one one zero computer. This is Captain Benjamin Cisco. Initiate autodestruct sequence authorization
- 1:00:16Cisco Alpha one Alpha gain auto destruct sequence authorization Picard for seven Alpha Taco self
- 1:00:23destruct in fifteen minutes. There will be no further audio warning my lord.
- 1:00:30The ship appears to be deserted. How can that be they're hiding, yes,
- 1:00:36sir as the bridge seems will be run by computer. It is the
- 1:00:39only thing speaking speaking, let me hear nine eight seven six five good