Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: Trump on the Ballot & Michigan Mother Convicted
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: Insurrection is a broad term, and if there's some debate
- 0:14Speaker 2: about it, I suppose that will go into the decision.
- 0:17Speaker 2: And then eventually what we would be deciding whether there
- 0:21Speaker 2: was an insurrection when one president did something as opposed
- 0:24Speaker 2: to when somebody else did something else.
- 0:26Speaker 3: And what do we do?
- 0:26Speaker 2: Do we wait until near the time of counting the
- 0:31Speaker 2: ballots and sort of go through which states are valid
- 0:34Speaker 2: and which states aren't.
- 0:35Speaker 1: Chief Justice John Roberts expressed the concern that seemed to
- 0:39Speaker 1: underlie the oral arguments over Colorado kicking Donald Trump off
- 0:44Speaker 1: the ballot for engaging in an insurrection. The Supreme Court
- 0:47Speaker 1: doesn't want to be in the business of deciding every
- 0:50Speaker 1: challenge over ballot access of presidential candidates. With the consequent
- 0:55Speaker 1: political ramifications, there seemed to be little doubt that the
- 0:59Speaker 1: Court will vote to keep Trump on the ballot, As
- 1:02Speaker 1: both liberal and conservative justices questioned whether a state can
- 1:06Speaker 1: enforce Section three of the Fourteenth Amendment, a provision barring
- 1:10Speaker 1: those who engaged in insurrection from holding office. Here's Justice
- 1:14Speaker 1: Elena Kagan.
- 1:15Speaker 3: I think that the question that you have to confront
- 1:18Speaker 3: is why a single state should decide who gets to
- 1:21Speaker 3: be president of the United States. In other words, you know,
- 1:24Speaker 3: this question of whether a former president is disqualified for
- 1:27Speaker 3: insurrection to be president again is just say it. It
- 1:33Speaker 3: sounds awfully national.
- 1:34Speaker 1: As for the question of whether Trump had engaged in
- 1:37Speaker 1: an insurrection, in two hours of oral arguments, only one
- 1:42Speaker 1: Justice Katanji Brown Jackson asked that question of Trump's attorney
- 1:46Speaker 1: Jonathan Mitchell.
- 1:47Speaker 2: For an insurrection, there needs to be an organized, concerted
- 1:50Speaker 2: effort to overthrow the government of the United States through violence.
- 1:54Speaker 1: And this point is that a chaotic effort to overthrow
- 1:57Speaker 1: the government is not an insurrection.
- 1:59Speaker 4: Well, we didn't see that it's an effort to overthrow
- 2:00Speaker 4: the government.
- 2:01Speaker 5: Either of Justice Jackson.
- 2:02Speaker 1: My guest is election law expert Derek Muller, a professor
- 2:05Speaker 1: at Notre Dame Law School. Broad question. First, does it
- 2:09Speaker 1: appear that the justices are going to rule that Colorado
- 2:13Speaker 1: can't disqualify Trump from the ballot, perhaps even unanimously.
- 2:18Speaker 4: Yeah, I think it's going to be an unanimous or
- 2:20Speaker 4: near unanimous decision reversing the Colorado Supreme Court. Here, the
- 2:24Speaker 4: justices across the ideological spectrum seemed concerned about the notion
- 2:28Speaker 4: that one state could have such an outsized influence and
- 2:31Speaker 4: a presidential election to have such an influence on the
- 2:34Speaker 4: rest of the process, and to do so without any
- 2:38Speaker 4: guidance from Congress. The presidency's unique office. It's not just
- 2:42Speaker 4: an office out of one state, but an office that
- 2:45Speaker 4: comes from the choices of many states making the decision.
- 2:47Speaker 4: I think the notion that the Supreme Court would be
- 2:50Speaker 4: expected to clean up those messes if different states reached
- 2:53Speaker 4: different resolutions, or that every time there was a challenge
- 2:55Speaker 4: it would end up a the Supreme Court store was
- 2:57Speaker 4: certainly unattractive to them. So I think there's a lot
- 2:59Speaker 4: of consensus that Trump's name will appear.
- 3:01Speaker 5: On the ballot.
- 3:02Speaker 1: Let's discuss some of the arguments that Trump raised. He'd
- 3:06Speaker 1: argue that the president isn't covered by the Insurrection clause
- 3:10Speaker 1: because the president is not an officer of the United
- 3:13Speaker 1: States as defined in that clause. And there was a
- 3:16Speaker 1: lot of discussion of what is an officer does a
- 3:19Speaker 1: president qualify? And Justice Neil Gorsich basically gave a history
- 3:23Speaker 1: lesson at one point don the term officer versus office.
- 3:26Speaker 4: Yeah, I mean, I think Justice Gorsuch was worried about
- 3:28Speaker 4: some of what I described as pedantic originalism. We're worried
- 3:32Speaker 4: about parsing these terms of such fine precision. Now that
- 3:35Speaker 4: said Justice Jackson spent a significant amount of time at argument,
- 3:39Speaker 4: suggests that the history at the time shows that the
- 3:43Speaker 4: Reconstruction Congress was really worried about state offices and about
- 3:48Speaker 4: state factions of ex Confederates gathering together and retaking parts
- 3:53Speaker 4: of the government. And if that's the case, the fact
- 3:55Speaker 4: that the word president is not listed among those offices
- 3:59Speaker 4: suggest that the Framers were not terribly worried about the
- 4:03Speaker 4: presidency at all. And if that's the case, the inference
- 4:06Speaker 4: should be the presidency was just not of their concern
- 4:08Speaker 4: and therefore not one of those offices covered. So while
- 4:11Speaker 4: she spoke up about that proposition, it's not clear how
- 4:13Speaker 4: many other justices would agree with her.
- 4:14Speaker 1: What about kicking this over to Congress and saying that
- 4:18Speaker 1: Congress has to enforce Section three.
- 4:21Speaker 4: Yeah, there were versions of the congressional enforcement question that
- 4:24Speaker 4: came up. Justice Kavanaugh seemed to lean most strongly into
- 4:28Speaker 4: an eighteen sixty nine decision called Griffin's Case, which involved
- 4:32Speaker 4: then Chief Justice Chase, who was riding circuit at the
- 4:36Speaker 4: lower court, issuing a decision effectively saying Congress needs to
- 4:40Speaker 4: do this, and nobody else can do this without congressional involvement.
- 4:43Speaker 4: It's not clear there was a lot of support for that.
- 4:45Speaker 4: Justice set of my own particular pushed back on that argument,
- 4:48Speaker 4: but there was broad consensus on a different dimension, and
- 4:51Speaker 4: several justices expressed concern that one state could enforce this
- 4:55Speaker 4: in a presidential election without some kind of federal guidance
- 4:59Speaker 4: or federal ar oversight. That not necessarily clear what that
- 5:01Speaker 4: would look like, but I think the concern that states
- 5:04Speaker 4: could go about this on their own in a presidential
- 5:06Speaker 4: election to keep a candidate off and again have an
- 5:09Speaker 4: effective exclusion that could carry over to other states was
- 5:13Speaker 4: problematic and a reason why the uniquely national office the
- 5:16Speaker 4: presidency required perhaps unique congressional legislation to implement it in
- 5:20Speaker 4: such a case.
- 5:21Speaker 1: Just as Kavanaugh gave what i'll call a little speech
- 5:25Speaker 1: about democracy and the importance of not disenfranchising voters, do
- 5:31Speaker 1: you think that underlies all this? And it's really more
- 5:35Speaker 1: a political consideration that the Court doesn't want to be
- 5:38Speaker 1: the one to say no, this person can't be on
- 5:42Speaker 1: the ballot.
- 5:43Speaker 4: Yeah, I mean there are some radiations of this to
- 5:45Speaker 4: think about. There's one level, which is, in the case
- 5:48Speaker 4: of ambiguity or uncertainty, how confident do we have to
- 5:52Speaker 4: be about this result before we're going to exclude somebody's
- 5:55Speaker 4: course such and some others. Yeah, did question a little
- 5:57Speaker 4: bit more broadly about the consequence of this decision, And
- 6:01Speaker 4: I think the consequences could be viewed in those terms
- 6:04Speaker 4: of the people making a decision that people voting, but
- 6:07Speaker 4: also in terms of very real concerns about the Court's
- 6:10Speaker 4: involvement in the case. And while it wasn't as overt
- 6:13Speaker 4: in these terms, I think there is a concern from
- 6:16Speaker 4: the Court that if it's asked on a regular basis
- 6:19Speaker 4: to adjudicate the qualifications and candidacies of presidential candidates, it
- 6:23Speaker 4: puts itself in a very difficult spot and it finds
- 6:25Speaker 4: its healthy arbiter of decisions that we typically think are
- 6:27Speaker 4: left to the political process. So there was an undercurrent
- 6:31Speaker 4: of allowing the political process to play out. But I
- 6:34Speaker 4: think part of that was more skepticism that these states
- 6:37Speaker 4: had done the right thing, or that the Supreme Court
- 6:40Speaker 4: was the right place to do it, rather than maybe
- 6:42Speaker 4: just some affirmation that states should be able to do
- 6:44Speaker 4: what they want.
- 6:45Speaker 1: Do you think there's a fear sort of like echoes
- 6:48Speaker 1: of Bush v. Gore, we don't want to be in
- 6:50Speaker 1: that position.
- 6:51Speaker 4: Yeah, I think there are echoes of that. I think
- 6:53Speaker 4: to be sure, I think the Court, since Bush Versus,
- 6:55Speaker 4: was certainly acutely aware of the consequences of being an
- 7:00Speaker 4: involved in decisions like this. Now Colorado Supreme Court's decision
- 7:04Speaker 4: puts the United States Supreme Court in a difficult place.
- 7:06Speaker 4: Right if it acts or if it doesn't act, it
- 7:10Speaker 4: finds itself on one side of a political question or another.
- 7:13Speaker 4: So that's why I think I was somewhat heartened to
- 7:15Speaker 4: see the Supreme Court justices coalescing around arguments with one
- 7:18Speaker 4: another and supporting a sort of singular output. So I
- 7:22Speaker 4: think there's going to be a lot of effort to
- 7:24Speaker 4: coalace around a clear decision from the Court the percurium,
- 7:28Speaker 4: ideally unanimous decision that resolves the issue at least for
- 7:31Speaker 4: presidential candidates or some set of federal candidates, and moves
- 7:35Speaker 4: on to say that the political process needs to resolve it.
- 7:38Speaker 4: And that might be unsatisfying to some, but I think
- 7:40Speaker 4: at the top level I think the Court is aware
- 7:42Speaker 4: that it doesn't want to be viewed as overtly partisan,
- 7:45Speaker 4: and whatever it can do to mitigate that, it will
- 7:47Speaker 4: definitely try to do.
- 7:48Speaker 1: So do you have any idea what path they'll choose
- 7:51Speaker 1: to get there?
- 7:52Speaker 4: Yeah, I think the goal will probably be something along
- 7:55Speaker 4: the lines of this notion that the presidency is a
- 7:59Speaker 4: unique national office. The Court has its precedence saying that
- 8:03Speaker 4: states have less of an interest in patrolling the ballot
- 8:06Speaker 4: for those kinds of candidacies because it is a unique
- 8:09Speaker 4: national office. That there are concerns about how states administer
- 8:14Speaker 4: this inconsistently, or that if there's one state that moves first,
- 8:18Speaker 4: how does that affect other states? And those practical consequences
- 8:22Speaker 4: are significant enough to suggest that Congress needs to be
- 8:25Speaker 4: the one to provide guidance and rules in this context.
- 8:28Speaker 5: At least it.
- 8:29Speaker 4: Comes to Section three of the fourteenth Amendment. So it
- 8:31Speaker 4: will be I think something that is a little bit
- 8:34Speaker 4: more election law heavy than Section three heavy, but something
- 8:37Speaker 4: that reflects these concerns that presidential elections are unique and
- 8:41Speaker 4: require some kind of federal guidance before they can be
- 8:44Speaker 4: regulated in the way that Colorado tried to do.
- 8:46Speaker 1: Here, there was only one question about what's at the
- 8:49Speaker 1: heart of this Colorado case? Did Donald Trump engage in
- 8:54Speaker 1: an insurrection? And after an hour Justice Katanji Brown Jackson
- 8:59Speaker 1: pose that question, and then it sort of disappeared, never.
- 9:02Speaker 6: More to be heard.
- 9:03Speaker 4: Yes, I think there was very little appetite on the
- 9:06Speaker 4: court to be talking about engaging in insurrection. About the
- 9:09Speaker 4: First Amendment issues, There was almost no discussion about those topics.
- 9:13Speaker 4: There was some brief discussions about what insurrection was. Trump's
- 9:17Speaker 4: attorney did mention that, you know, it was enous act
- 9:20Speaker 4: from an the l acts committed that day, so some
- 9:22Speaker 4: condemnation there. And so the court did avoid some of
- 9:25Speaker 4: those really thorny in the weeds, fact intensive or disputed questions,
- 9:30Speaker 4: focusing instead on a variety of other topics that they
- 9:33Speaker 4: could coalesce around. And so while it might have surprised
- 9:36Speaker 4: people that they think a lot more attention, it was
- 9:38Speaker 4: not terribly surprising to me. I think that was the
- 9:40Speaker 4: issue that they wanted to avoid the most of all
- 9:42Speaker 4: messy facts with deep political consequences. If they can decide
- 9:46Speaker 4: on pure law, all the better for them.
- 9:48Speaker 1: There was sort of a warning from the attorney for
- 9:51Speaker 1: the Colorado voters. He said, if Colorado loses this case,
- 9:55Speaker 1: the issue could come back with a vengeance. If Trump
- 9:58Speaker 1: was elected president and then members of Congress have to
- 10:01Speaker 1: decide whether to let him take office, do you think
- 10:04Speaker 1: the Supreme Court is going to leave that question open?
- 10:07Speaker 4: It seems like they might, you know, the question of
- 10:09Speaker 4: whether or not Congress on January sixth, twenty twenty five
- 10:11Speaker 4: will count electoral votes or try to object to them
- 10:14Speaker 4: and refuse to count them is certainly an open one.
- 10:16Speaker 4: And then there's the separate question about what happens after
- 10:19Speaker 4: Trump takes office. Will there'll be lawsuits to challenge his
- 10:22Speaker 4: official action? And if so, what did those challenges look like?
- 10:25Speaker 4: So if the court moves in the direction that we
- 10:28Speaker 4: anticipate it's moving, it seems that it's more a valid
- 10:31Speaker 4: access issue and less an issue of disqualification Intersection three.
- 10:35Speaker 4: But it does leave the door open for another day
- 10:38Speaker 4: the resolve these questions.
- 10:39Speaker 1: After this argument, and how the justices seem to be
- 10:43Speaker 1: fleeing for the exits.
- 10:45Speaker 5: In my opinion, do you.
- 10:47Speaker 1: Think that when Trump makes a request for sirchiari from
- 10:51Speaker 1: the DC Circuit Court decision rejecting his claims of presidential immunity.
- 10:56Speaker 1: Do you think that they'll refuse to take that case
- 10:59Speaker 1: or they'll be four hardy souls who want to address
- 11:02Speaker 1: that issue.
- 11:03Speaker 4: Yeah, I don't know. You know if I'm thinking what
- 11:06Speaker 4: the court might do here, and maybe I'm wrong, But
- 11:08Speaker 4: you issue a decision in a couple of weeks on
- 11:11Speaker 4: this case saying Trump can appear on the ballot, and
- 11:13Speaker 4: the same day you deny sircerari in the immunity case
- 11:16Speaker 4: and essentially say the DC Circuit opinion stands and he
- 11:19Speaker 4: can be subject to criminal prosecution. So in both cases,
- 11:23Speaker 4: the Court would be letting the political and legal process
- 11:26Speaker 4: play out without needing to step in.
- 11:28Speaker 6: Now.
- 11:28Speaker 4: I don't know if they're going to do that. There
- 11:30Speaker 4: might be some interest in addressing the immunity issues at
- 11:33Speaker 4: some level from some justices in the court, but that
- 11:36Speaker 4: is kind of a wait and see approach. We don't
- 11:38Speaker 4: quite know how these two cases might relate to one another,
- 11:40Speaker 4: but there definitely seem to be linked to some degree.
- 11:43Speaker 1: At least we won't have too long to wait and
- 11:45Speaker 1: see what the Supreme Court does with this. Thanks so
- 11:48Speaker 1: much for the conversation, Derek. That's Professor Derek Muller of
- 11:51Speaker 1: Notre Dame Law School. Coming up. One apparent victory, one defeat.
- 11:56Speaker 1: We'll take a look at why Trump lost his presidential
- 11:58Speaker 1: immunity arguments the DC Appellate Court. I'm June Grosso and
- 12:02Speaker 1: you're listening to Bloomberg and they.
- 12:04Speaker 7: Talked about threat to democracy. That's your real threat to democracy.
- 12:10Speaker 7: And I feel that as a president you have to
- 12:12Speaker 7: have immunity, very simple, and if you doubt, as an example,
- 12:16Speaker 7: if this case, we're lost on an immunity and I
- 12:20Speaker 7: did nothing wrong, absolutely nothing wrong. I'm working for the country.
- 12:24Speaker 1: But the DC's Circuit Court of Appeals definitively rejected former
- 12:29Speaker 1: President Donald Trump's claims that the office of the presidency
- 12:33Speaker 1: shields him from criminal prosecution. In a unanimous ruling, the
- 12:37Speaker 1: three judge panel found that quote, for the purpose of
- 12:40Speaker 1: this criminal case, former President Trump has become citizen Trump,
- 12:45Speaker 1: moving him one step closer to standing trial for trying
- 12:49Speaker 1: to overturn the twenty twenty election. The judges made their
- 12:52Speaker 1: skepticism of Trump's immunity claims clear during the oral arguments
- 12:56Speaker 1: last month. Here's Judge Karen Lacraft Henderson.
- 13:00Speaker 8: I think it's paradoxical to say that his constitutional duty
- 13:06Speaker 8: to take care that the laws be faithfully executed allows
- 13:10Speaker 8: him to violate criminal laws.
- 13:15Speaker 1: And in their opinion, the judges repeatedly used Trump's former
- 13:19Speaker 1: words and positions against him, for example, pointing out that
- 13:23Speaker 1: during his impeachment, Trump had argued that he could still
- 13:26Speaker 1: be criminally charged, something Judge Florence Pan brought out during
- 13:30Speaker 1: the oral arguments.
- 13:32Speaker 9: You took the position or your client did, during the
- 13:35Speaker 9: impeachment proceedings that there would be an option for criminal
- 13:40Speaker 9: prosecution later, and it's in the congressional record. And I
- 13:43Speaker 9: guess the question is what has changed or why have
- 13:46Speaker 9: you changed your position.
- 13:47Speaker 1: The Court put the ruling on hold so that Trump
- 13:50Speaker 1: can appeal to the Supreme Court, but they gave him
- 13:52Speaker 1: a tight deadline, only giving him until Monday to file
- 13:56Speaker 1: the appeal, joining me his former federal prosecutor, just A. Wrath,
- 14:00Speaker 1: a professor at Cardozo Law School. The court said, our
- 14:04Speaker 1: analysis is guided by the Constitution, federal statutes, and history,
- 14:08Speaker 1: as well as concerns of public policy. What's your impression
- 14:12Speaker 1: broadly of the opinion.
- 14:15Speaker 10: My opinion is that it is a resounding rejection of
- 14:18Speaker 10: Trump's claim of immunity from criminal prosecution. And that it's
- 14:22Speaker 10: an extremely thorough well written and well reasoned opinion that
- 14:26Speaker 10: is unanimous, issued on behalf of a panel that included
- 14:29Speaker 10: one judge appointed by a Republican president, all speaking in
- 14:33Speaker 10: one calm but clear voice, holding that a former president
- 14:36Speaker 10: is not above the law.
- 14:38Speaker 1: They address all of Trump's arguments for immunity and shoot
- 14:42Speaker 1: them down one by one, starting with his argument that
- 14:46Speaker 1: separation of powers immunizes him.
- 14:49Speaker 10: The court took that argument seriously and addressed it thoroughly,
- 14:53Speaker 10: but found that there was no problem in separation of
- 14:57Speaker 10: powers concerns with a form president being held criminally responsible
- 15:03Speaker 10: for actions taken while in office that were in violation
- 15:06Speaker 10: of federal criminal laws passed by the United States Congress.
- 15:11Speaker 10: And it cited precedents in which presidential actions had been
- 15:14Speaker 10: subject to judicial review, including former President truman seizure of
- 15:19Speaker 10: the steel mills, and the Court said it did not
- 15:21Speaker 10: find that separation of powers concerns prevented the Court from
- 15:26Speaker 10: exercising oversight through the adjudication of the criminal laws over
- 15:30Speaker 10: acts committed by a former president while in office that
- 15:33Speaker 10: in fact were violations of criminal law.
- 15:36Speaker 1: As you mentioned, there was a measured tone, but I
- 15:38Speaker 1: thought that the tone was a little less measured when
- 15:41Speaker 1: they had concerns about quote at bottom, former President Trump's
- 15:46Speaker 1: stance would collapse our system of separated powers by placing
- 15:50Speaker 1: the president beyond the reach of all three branches. At
- 15:54Speaker 1: different points, I just thought that they raised some heightened concerns.
- 15:58Speaker 10: They certainly concerns, and there were a number of really
- 16:02Speaker 10: striking portions of the opinion that in a sense, in
- 16:06Speaker 10: a very measured way, I thought, expressed a sense of
- 16:09Speaker 10: outrage over the implications of the former president's arguments. So
- 16:13Speaker 10: you just read one portion of it. There's another portion
- 16:16Speaker 10: where the court said it would be a striking paradox
- 16:19Speaker 10: if the president, who alone is vested with the constitutional
- 16:22Speaker 10: duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed,
- 16:25Speaker 10: were the sole officer capable of defying those laws with impunity.
- 16:30Speaker 10: So there are a number of statements like that that
- 16:32Speaker 10: are just really strong rejections of the notion that a
- 16:36Speaker 10: former president would be immune from prosecution and from his
- 16:41Speaker 10: actions being reviewed by the court.
- 16:43Speaker 1: They also took on policy considerations that he'd raised. Trump's
- 16:48Speaker 1: lawyer had said, and Trump himself has said this that
- 16:52Speaker 1: if presidents didn't have immunity, it would risk chilling their actions,
- 16:57Speaker 1: and that presidents would be routinely indicted after they left office.
- 17:01Speaker 10: Yes, the court did take into account those policy considerations
- 17:06Speaker 10: and said that not only was there no historical precedent
- 17:11Speaker 10: for immunity from criminal prosecution of the kind that former
- 17:16Speaker 10: President Trump thought, but that these policy considerations did not
- 17:21Speaker 10: weigh in favor of recognizing such immunity for the first
- 17:25Speaker 10: time in this case. They said that it has always
- 17:29Speaker 10: been understood that former presidents could be subject to criminal
- 17:33Speaker 10: prosecution when they left office. For example, that's why former
- 17:37Speaker 10: President Ford pardoned former President Nixon. They cited the example
- 17:41Speaker 10: of former President Bill Clinton, who entered into an agreement
- 17:44Speaker 10: with the Special Council who had been investigating him with
- 17:47Speaker 10: various sanctions, including forfeiting his law license, in part to
- 17:51Speaker 10: settle the prospect of a future criminal prosecution. And then,
- 17:54Speaker 10: most importantly, they cited statements by attorneys for former President
- 17:59Speaker 10: Trump during his impeachment trial his second impeachment trial, where
- 18:03Speaker 10: they argued that impeachment was not the proper remedy, but
- 18:06Speaker 10: rather the possibility of a criminal prosecution would be the
- 18:10Speaker 10: proper remedy. And so they said these examples that point
- 18:14Speaker 10: toward an understanding that former presidents could be subject to
- 18:18Speaker 10: criminal prosecution when they left office for acts taken while president,
- 18:23Speaker 10: and that there was no suggestion in the historical record
- 18:26Speaker 10: that that prospect had chilled presidents while they were in
- 18:30Speaker 10: office from exercising their duties without too much concern. And
- 18:36Speaker 10: in fact, there was a quote from the District court
- 18:37Speaker 10: opinion that I just thought was very telling. The District
- 18:40Speaker 10: Court had said, every president will face difficult decisions, whether
- 18:44Speaker 10: to intentionally commit a federal crime should not be one
- 18:47Speaker 10: of them. And the DC Circuit quoted that language saying, basically,
- 18:51Speaker 10: they don't think that they're holding that there is no
- 18:54Speaker 10: immunity from criminal prosecution is going to actually chill presidents
- 18:58Speaker 10: in the exercise of their due.
- 19:00Speaker 1: During the oral arguments, Trump's lawyer spent seemed like most
- 19:05Speaker 1: of the time on the impeachment clause and this argument
- 19:09Speaker 1: that Donald Trump would first have to have been convicted
- 19:14Speaker 1: by the Senate in order to then be tried criminally
- 19:19Speaker 1: after he left office. And they took that on and
- 19:23Speaker 1: they said, the strongest evidence against Trump's claim of immunity
- 19:27Speaker 1: is found in the words of the Constitution's impeachment clause.
- 19:31Speaker 10: They did treat thoroughly this argument that he could not
- 19:34Speaker 10: be prosecuted criminally because he had not been convicted in
- 19:38Speaker 10: the Senate relying on the impeachment clause. They addressed it
- 19:41Speaker 10: thoroughly and said that they rejected it, that they thought
- 19:45Speaker 10: it was a strained reading of the clause that he offered,
- 19:48Speaker 10: and that although the clause makes clear that a president
- 19:53Speaker 10: can be criminally prosecuted after being impeached and convicted, that
- 19:58Speaker 10: the negative implication that Trump was arguing from that clause
- 20:01Speaker 10: that he could only be crivitally prosecuted if he had
- 20:03Speaker 10: been convicted in the Senate following impeachment simply did not follow.
- 20:08Speaker 1: So in the opinion, you had the legal arguments based
- 20:12Speaker 1: on precedent and history and the Constitution, and then there
- 20:17Speaker 1: were this sort of logical, sensible arguments, and one here
- 20:21Speaker 1: was that, you know, the founders knew how to grant
- 20:24Speaker 1: immunity if they wanted to, and they didn't want to.
- 20:27Speaker 10: Hear, Yes, absolutely, they cited to other portions of the
- 20:30Speaker 10: Constitution that were explicit about granted immunity, for example, with
- 20:34Speaker 10: respect to the speach and Debate clause and making clear
- 20:37Speaker 10: that there would be immunity there for actions in the
- 20:40Speaker 10: course of speech and debate by members of Congress. And
- 20:42Speaker 10: so if the framers knew how to be explicit about
- 20:45Speaker 10: grants of immunity, it follows that if they didn't explicitly
- 20:48Speaker 10: grant it to presidents in this context, that it doesn't exist.
- 20:51Speaker 1: The Court put the ruling on holds so that Trump
- 20:54Speaker 1: could appeal to the Supreme Court, but they put him
- 20:57Speaker 1: on a really tight deadline, giving him only six days
- 21:00Speaker 1: to do that. Do you think they were looking at
- 21:03Speaker 1: his strategy of delayed delay delay.
- 21:06Speaker 10: I can't speak to what was in the judge's vines
- 21:09Speaker 10: in their decision about the timing here, it is notable
- 21:13Speaker 10: that they gave him a short time frame in which
- 21:15Speaker 10: to appeal to the US Supreme Court before they would
- 21:18Speaker 10: issue the mandate. I think it speaks to the urgency
- 21:22Speaker 10: of the matters involved in this case when you see
- 21:25Speaker 10: that sense of the significance of this case throughout the
- 21:29Speaker 10: Court's opinion, when it talks about how the alleged conduct
- 21:33Speaker 10: was an effort to overturn the results of a democratic
- 21:38Speaker 10: election and the public's interest in the enforcement of criminal laws.
- 21:42Speaker 10: So I think that those substantive aspects of the case
- 21:46Speaker 10: may carry over to the court sense of what is
- 21:48Speaker 10: an appropriate time frame in which to allow resort to
- 21:53Speaker 10: further appellate review before the case goes forward in the
- 21:56Speaker 10: district court.
- 21:57Speaker 1: No one knows whether the Supreme Court will take the
- 21:59Speaker 1: case or not, but they already have a couple of
- 22:02Speaker 1: Trump cases on the docket, including the case over Colorado
- 22:07Speaker 1: Barringham from the ballot. What would be your guess as
- 22:10Speaker 1: to whether they'll take the case or not.
- 22:12Speaker 10: This is such a well reasoned and thoughtful opinion that
- 22:17Speaker 10: I think they are very compelling reasons why the Court
- 22:20Speaker 10: wouldn't take this case up. There's no circuit split on
- 22:24Speaker 10: this issue, and they certainly have their plateful with other
- 22:28Speaker 10: really important the cases that they need to decide, including
- 22:31Speaker 10: the ballot access question. On the other hand, this is
- 22:35Speaker 10: an enormously significant issue whether a former president is entitled
- 22:39Speaker 10: to immunity from criminal prosecution. One could imagine that Justice
- 22:43Speaker 10: is saying this is an issue on which we should opine.
- 22:46Speaker 10: But on the other hand, unless there are enough justices
- 22:50Speaker 10: who think that the DC's circuit opinion is wrong, then
- 22:53Speaker 10: I could also see them letting the DC opinion be
- 22:56Speaker 10: the final word on this subject.
- 22:57Speaker 1: So Timing is everything here, because the federal election case
- 23:03Speaker 1: was on from March fourth, but then the judge had
- 23:05Speaker 1: to take it off the calendar because of this appeal
- 23:08Speaker 1: on the immunity issue. If the Supreme Court decides not
- 23:12Speaker 1: to take the case, how fast could the trial be
- 23:14Speaker 1: put back on the calendar and move forward.
- 23:18Speaker 10: Well, the Trial court has indicated that she will give
- 23:21Speaker 10: the former president additional time to respond to motions that
- 23:26Speaker 10: were filed by the Special Council. To file any additional
- 23:29Speaker 10: motions on his own behalf time that but for the
- 23:34Speaker 10: stay of the trial court proceedings, he would have had
- 23:37Speaker 10: to work on these motions in this last month or so,
- 23:41Speaker 10: So she's going to give him that time. That means
- 23:44Speaker 10: we're probably looking at some time at the earliest in
- 23:47Speaker 10: late summer, perhaps late July, early August, for a trial date.
- 23:52Speaker 10: But we really don't know what's going to happen. I mean,
- 23:55Speaker 10: if the US Supreme Court were to take the case
- 23:57Speaker 10: in grant to stay, that would mean that things would
- 24:00Speaker 10: remain frozen. We really don't know, But we do see
- 24:04Speaker 10: coming from the Trial Court in DC, Judge Chutkin every
- 24:07Speaker 10: effort to move the case along as expeditiously as possible,
- 24:10Speaker 10: So I think we may have a better sense by
- 24:12Speaker 10: next week, by Monday, when and if Trump files an
- 24:16Speaker 10: application in the US Supreme Court for a stay, whether
- 24:19Speaker 10: that's going to happen, I expect it will, and then
- 24:21Speaker 10: I would imagine within a week or so after that,
- 24:24Speaker 10: perhaps we would have some indication from the US Supreme
- 24:26Speaker 10: Court about how quickly they're going to move, and if
- 24:28Speaker 10: they're not going to take the case at all, then
- 24:30Speaker 10: things may start proceeding even more quickly in the trial court.
- 24:33Speaker 1: I think everyone is anticipating that Trump will file in
- 24:36Speaker 1: the Supreme Court, but we'll know definitively on Monday. Thanks
- 24:40Speaker 1: so much, Jessica. That's Professor Jessica Roth of Cardozo Law School.
- 24:44Speaker 1: Coming up next, the landmark conviction of a Michigan mother
- 24:48Speaker 1: for murderers committed by her son. I'm June Grosso and
- 24:51Speaker 1: you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 24:53Speaker 6: We find the defendant guilty of involuntary manslaughter, Guilty of
- 24:57Speaker 6: in manslaughter, guilty of involuntary mans guilty of involuntary manslaughter.
- 25:02Speaker 1: Jennifer Crumbley found guilty of four counts of involuntary manslaughter,
- 25:07Speaker 1: one for each of the students her teenage son murdered
- 25:10Speaker 1: in a shooting rampage at a Michigan high school in
- 25:13Speaker 1: twenty twenty one, a historic verdict the first parent ever
- 25:17Speaker 1: held criminally responsible for a school shooting carried out by
- 25:20Speaker 1: her child.
- 25:21Speaker 11: Jennifer Crumbley didn't pull the sugar of it, but she
- 25:24Speaker 11: is responsible for those debts.
- 25:27Speaker 1: Prosecutors Mark Keast and Karen MacDonald argued that Crumbly was
- 25:31Speaker 1: responsible because she and her husband ignored her son Ethan's
- 25:35Speaker 1: mental health struggles, bought him the handgun used in the shootings,
- 25:39Speaker 1: and disregarded the concerns of school counselors about his behavior.
- 25:43Speaker 1: Just hours before the attacks, she walked to.
- 25:46Speaker 12: Law school when just the smallest, smallest of things could
- 25:52Speaker 12: have said, couldn't have helped Hannah and Tate and Madison
- 25:58Speaker 12: and Justin.
- 25:59Speaker 1: Crumbley took the stand in her own defense and testified
- 26:02Speaker 1: that she didn't see herself as a failure as a parent.
- 26:06Speaker 13: I trusted him and I felt like I had an
- 26:09Speaker 13: open door and he can come to me about anything.
- 26:12Speaker 13: I mean, I fell as a family where three of
- 26:15Speaker 13: us were really close. Of course, I look back after
- 26:19Speaker 13: this all happened, and I've asked myself if I would
- 26:23Speaker 13: do anything differently, and I wouldn't have.
- 26:25Speaker 1: And the cross examination seemed to reinforce the prosecution's case.
- 26:30Speaker 11: When your son texted you that he was seeing demons
- 26:34Speaker 11: in bulls flying off the shelves, that was in the
- 26:39Speaker 11: spring of two thousand and twenty twenty. When you recall
- 26:42Speaker 11: it evidence right, correct, You don't dispute that that was
- 26:44Speaker 11: on your phone. No, you don't dispute that at some
- 26:47Speaker 11: point you read those messages.
- 26:50Speaker 7: No.
- 26:51Speaker 1: After eleven hours of deliberations, the jury found Crumbly guilty
- 26:55Speaker 1: of involuntary manslaughter. Craig Shilling, who's seventeen year old son
- 26:59Speaker 1: Justin was killed in the shooting, said Crumbly would not
- 27:02Speaker 1: be sitting in prison if she had done her job
- 27:05Speaker 1: as a parent.
- 27:06Speaker 14: And this is your twice to have a child, and
- 27:11Speaker 14: you cannot choose to not take care of your child.
- 27:13Speaker 14: You cannot choose and not nurture your child. You cannot
- 27:15Speaker 14: choose to take your own interests over your child, especially
- 27:21Speaker 14: when it comes to mental health.
- 27:24Speaker 1: Joining me is Echo Yanka, a professor at the University
- 27:26Speaker 1: of Michigan Law School. In a real sense, was it
- 27:30Speaker 1: Jennifer Crumbly's parenting that was on trial here.
- 27:34Speaker 5: I think the prosecution painted a picture of her as
- 27:36Speaker 5: an indifferent, callous parent, one who is more interested in
- 27:41Speaker 5: her forces and hobbies, her extramarital affairs than getting her
- 27:46Speaker 5: child to help that he explicitly seemed to be seeking.
- 27:49Speaker 5: But of course the prosecution knews that being a bad
- 27:52Speaker 5: parent is not by self illegal, and having that be
- 27:55Speaker 5: the only line of argument would be not just legally insufficient,
- 28:00Speaker 5: probably unpalatable, And so they really made a point that
- 28:03Speaker 5: it's not just that she is a bad parent, it's
- 28:05Speaker 5: that she had opportunity after opportunity to do something to
- 28:09Speaker 5: avoid these killings, and that even given a million little
- 28:13Speaker 5: moments where she could have saved those lives, she did nothing.
- 28:17Speaker 1: The prosecution had so much evidence against Crumbly, from her
- 28:21Speaker 1: son's text, that she didn't answer, to journal entries, to
- 28:25Speaker 1: videos of her at the shooting range with her son.
- 28:28Speaker 1: What was the best evidence? In your mind?
- 28:31Speaker 5: I think you put your finger exactly on it that.
- 28:33Speaker 5: As the prosecution tried to hammer home, it just seems
- 28:36Speaker 5: like there were a million moments where she could have
- 28:38Speaker 5: done something given of the help he needs. There's a moment,
- 28:41Speaker 5: for example, when he is caught searching online about ammunition,
- 28:45Speaker 5: and she texts back, you know, I don't care if
- 28:47Speaker 5: you do this, just don't get caught, you know, Lol.
- 28:50Speaker 5: But if you ask me, this single moment, the single
- 28:53Speaker 5: moment that was the most powerful, when I talked to friends,
- 28:56Speaker 5: when I debate with legal colleagues, and frankly just around
- 28:59Speaker 5: the dinner table, I would say the fact that the
- 29:01Speaker 5: school called her in that very day when Ethan is
- 29:05Speaker 5: drawing pictures of violence and death, and they asked the
- 29:08Speaker 5: Crumbleys to take even home, and depending on who you believe,
- 29:12Speaker 5: they either refuse or together they decide not to do it,
- 29:16Speaker 5: but in any case they walk out of there knowing
- 29:18Speaker 5: he had a weapon.
- 29:19Speaker 1: The four person told NBC that she was swayed by
- 29:23Speaker 1: the belief that Crumbley was the last person who had
- 29:26Speaker 1: custody of the gun and that therefore she was responsible
- 29:31Speaker 1: for it. And I'm wondering if that is faulty reasoning.
- 29:35Speaker 1: I mean, can you really draw a conclusion of guilt
- 29:37Speaker 1: from the last information that the prosecution has?
- 29:41Speaker 5: So I feel torn about that. I'll say why. On
- 29:43Speaker 5: the one hand, clearly part of the background of because
- 29:47Speaker 5: part of the overall theory of her involunteer manslaughter rest
- 29:51Speaker 5: on her negligence, and that rests on the idea that
- 29:54Speaker 5: an ordinary person would have known that was going to
- 29:57Speaker 5: do this. An ordinary person should have seen that this
- 30:00Speaker 5: danger existed. And so the fact that the parents knew
- 30:04Speaker 5: that there was a weapon, that the parents didn't tell
- 30:06Speaker 5: the school, that the parents could have, for example, locked
- 30:09Speaker 5: up the gun, all those things are in the mix.
- 30:11Speaker 5: But I do worry about a jury foreman. You know,
- 30:15Speaker 5: if I were a defense were on appeal, you might
- 30:17Speaker 5: think such reasoning assumes evidence not in fact, and it's
- 30:21Speaker 5: not clear that it is a legally relevant standard. So
- 30:24Speaker 5: I think I understand the feeling behind it. But if
- 30:28Speaker 5: that sentence is literally true, you know it's going to
- 30:31Speaker 5: give the defense something to hold on.
- 30:33Speaker 1: Crumbly took the stand in her own defense. As you know,
- 30:36Speaker 1: often when that happens, the whole focus of the jury
- 30:39Speaker 1: is on the credibility of the defendant, and she didn't
- 30:43Speaker 1: come across well on the stand. Listen to what the
- 30:45Speaker 1: jury four person told NBC.
- 30:48Speaker 6: At the time. I tried to take her as she
- 30:51Speaker 6: gave herself, but once we went into deliberation, it became
- 30:56Speaker 6: clear that she wasn't a super really witness in this case.
- 31:02Speaker 5: Look, her testimony was not great. I thought the worst
- 31:06Speaker 5: moment was when she was asked what she would do
- 31:09Speaker 5: differently today, and her answer was nothing.
- 31:12Speaker 13: Right.
- 31:12Speaker 5: I understand the impulse her answers, I just didn't do
- 31:14Speaker 5: anything wrong. But when you're staring at, you know, a
- 31:17Speaker 5: day where four children were killed and seven more were injured,
- 31:21Speaker 5: that answer just feals callous. So I definitely worried about that.
- 31:25Speaker 5: That being said, look, the defense had a great legal
- 31:28Speaker 5: principle on which they were lying, but they had a
- 31:30Speaker 5: really tough task because the prosecution had really tainted her.
- 31:34Speaker 5: Is callous bordering on monstrous, and I think the defense
- 31:37Speaker 5: felt a lot of pressure to humanize her. The only
- 31:41Speaker 5: image that the jurors had in their minds was of
- 31:43Speaker 5: a parent who just didn't care about her son and
- 31:46Speaker 5: her son's danger to others, And so I understand why
- 31:49Speaker 5: they felt strategically like they had to do something to
- 31:52Speaker 5: claw back an image of a human mother who was
- 31:55Speaker 5: doing her best.
- 31:56Speaker 1: He said the defense had a good theory. Tell me
- 31:59Speaker 1: what the theory is.
- 32:00Speaker 5: Well, the defense I think had two prongs. The second
- 32:03Speaker 5: wave just talked about that. Look, I mean, there's a
- 32:05Speaker 5: kind of human instinct. This is a mother doing our best.
- 32:08Speaker 5: And moreover, you're saying a reasonable person could have foreseen this.
- 32:11Speaker 5: You're asking a mother to foresee something that mothers might
- 32:15Speaker 5: think is bordering on unthinkable. You're asking a mom to
- 32:17Speaker 5: foresee that her son will be monstrous, will be a
- 32:21Speaker 5: mass shooter. And so that has a kind of I
- 32:23Speaker 5: wouldn't say it's the very point of the legal theory,
- 32:25Speaker 5: but it has a kind of diffuse tug on a
- 32:28Speaker 5: juror's heart that truly requiring a mother to see that
- 32:31Speaker 5: is a strain. But the core of the defense theory
- 32:34Speaker 5: really is the first year legal principle, the one that
- 32:38Speaker 5: you learn when you're starting law school that you are
- 32:41Speaker 5: just not responsible for the actions of another. That when
- 32:44Speaker 5: somebody who's a responsible agent acts, it severs the causal change.
- 32:48Speaker 5: And I think the defense really thought at the end
- 32:50Speaker 5: of the day that not only as a legal matter,
- 32:54Speaker 5: but as a social and moral matter, that has a
- 32:56Speaker 5: lot of weight in people's minds.
- 32:58Speaker 1: Do you think that this case provides a blueprint to
- 33:01Speaker 1: other prosecutors and we'll see more parents being charged for
- 33:06Speaker 1: the criminal acts of their children.
- 33:08Speaker 5: Yeah, this is a question I've been asked a lot,
- 33:10Speaker 5: and you know, I struggle to answer it. Well. On
- 33:14Speaker 5: the one hand, as we've discussed, this case has such
- 33:16Speaker 5: degregious facts, such heartrending facts where moment after moment, things
- 33:21Speaker 5: were going wrong, and to be honest, perhaps it's just
- 33:25Speaker 5: an extraordinary case with extraordinary facts, you know, as lawyers say,
- 33:28Speaker 5: the kind of case that should be confined to its facts.
- 33:31Speaker 5: On the other hand, you know, the life of the
- 33:33Speaker 5: law's precedent. Lawyers argue by analogy, and prosecutors certainly do too.
- 33:38Speaker 5: And once a prosecutor has this precedent in the world,
- 33:41Speaker 5: it's impossible to imagine they won't use it. And further,
- 33:44Speaker 5: as I've said before, and I think is really important,
- 33:46Speaker 5: prosecutors can use these things in ways that are much
- 33:49Speaker 5: less spectacular and visible than a Krumley case. Right, So,
- 33:53Speaker 5: in the Crumbley case, the whole nation, indeed the whole
- 33:55Speaker 5: world is interesting because the facts are so visceral. But
- 33:58Speaker 5: we won't see the case where the prosecutor has a
- 34:00Speaker 5: parent who thinks they have a legal defense and says, look,
- 34:03Speaker 5: I'm going to offer you three years, but if you
- 34:06Speaker 5: don't accept the fleet bargain, I'm going to prosecute you
- 34:09Speaker 5: for fifteen or twenty and if that person pleads out,
- 34:12Speaker 5: they may be giving up on their legal defenses. They
- 34:15Speaker 5: may serve many years in jail, and it will be
- 34:18Speaker 5: quite invisible, it will be quite under the radar. And
- 34:21Speaker 5: I worry about those cases.
- 34:22Speaker 1: As far as appellate issues, you mentioned one, Do you
- 34:26Speaker 1: see any obvious appellet issues?
- 34:28Speaker 5: There are going to be some, right, I mean, I
- 34:31Speaker 5: do think the format of the jury speaking, you know,
- 34:35Speaker 5: because there's a reason turies deliberate in secret. That statement
- 34:38Speaker 5: that she thought Jennifer Crumbling Will was last to handle
- 34:41Speaker 5: the gun might be worrying. They're always going to be
- 34:44Speaker 5: issues on which the judge ruled, in particular some of
- 34:47Speaker 5: the evidence the judge let in, some of the really
- 34:50Speaker 5: really gut wrenching photographic evidence. Surely some part of the
- 34:53Speaker 5: appeal will be that bad evidence was more prejudicial than broken.
- 34:56Speaker 10: You know.
- 34:57Speaker 5: The argument will be something like everybody knows that Keeping
- 35:00Speaker 5: committed this horrible act. There was no need to see
- 35:04Speaker 5: the result of it, right, There was no real addition
- 35:06Speaker 5: by seeing the pictures. It just emotionally, it's like the jurors.
- 35:09Speaker 5: But I think ultimately the thing on which you appeal
- 35:12Speaker 5: is the legal principle. I mean, if this goes all
- 35:15Speaker 5: the way up to the Michigan Supreme Court asking the
- 35:17Speaker 5: Supreme Court to reinforce the legal norm that one just
- 35:22Speaker 5: can't be responsible for another person's act, you know, the
- 35:25Speaker 5: hypothetically parents who are doing their best but are afraid
- 35:28Speaker 5: that their children are tempted to violence. At some point
- 35:31Speaker 5: they get to say, I've done what I can. His
- 35:34Speaker 5: actions are his.
- 35:35Speaker 1: Now, the father's trial is coming up. Will he learn
- 35:39Speaker 1: from what happened here? Can he use different strategies, you know,
- 35:43Speaker 1: change things up for his trial, or maybe even try
- 35:46Speaker 1: to plead out.
- 35:47Speaker 5: Yeah, it's a great question. You know, my mind is
- 35:50Speaker 5: spinning about that too. Obviously, the parents are the ones
- 35:53Speaker 5: in the most pain, and Jennifer Crumbley was convicted. But
- 35:57Speaker 5: other than those people, nobody had a word today than
- 36:00Speaker 5: James Crumley. Right now, I would say every case is different.
- 36:04Speaker 5: You know, this case was supposed to be tried together
- 36:06Speaker 5: until really almost the last minute where they decided to
- 36:10Speaker 5: separate the cases. And presumably that's because each of them
- 36:13Speaker 5: thinks that or at least one of them thought that
- 36:15Speaker 5: they were more damning facts towards the other right. So
- 36:18Speaker 5: you saw Jennifer argue that it was the father James
- 36:21Speaker 5: who bought the god and he is the one in
- 36:23Speaker 5: charge of blocking it up. And presumably his team will
- 36:25Speaker 5: have arguments about why she's more culpable, and most importantly,
- 36:29Speaker 5: every jury is different, right, But it seems to me
- 36:31Speaker 5: the most obviously that'll happened given a conviction is that
- 36:33Speaker 5: his team will move for a change up venue. They'll
- 36:36Speaker 5: just think this poisons It was already such an emotional
- 36:39Speaker 5: and difficult case, so visible, that the conviction is just
- 36:43Speaker 5: too poisonous for them. And then a part of me
- 36:46Speaker 5: really does wonder if at this late hour, if they
- 36:49Speaker 5: really would reach out for a plea bargain and if
- 36:51Speaker 5: Frank Is the prosecution would think there's anything be gained
- 36:53Speaker 5: after they've already done all the work to take the
- 36:55Speaker 5: case to trial.
- 36:57Speaker 1: Once thanks so much for sharing your insights, Echo Yanka,
- 37:00Speaker 1: a professor at the University of Michigan Law School. Jennifer
- 37:04Speaker 1: Crumbley will be sentenced on April ninth. She faces a
- 37:07Speaker 1: maximum fifteen years in prison. Ethan Crumbley is already serving
- 37:12Speaker 1: a life sentence after pleading guilty in the case, and
- 37:16Speaker 1: that's it. For this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 37:19Speaker 1: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 37:21Speaker 1: subscribing and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 37:25Speaker 1: and at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm
- 37:29Speaker 1: June Grosso, and this is Bloomberg