Latest / GeekWire / Google I/O takeaways: AI is changing the way we read, write, and work
Transcript
- 0:01Todd Bishop: Check, check, check, check. Okay, perfect.
- 0:03John Cook: All right. We're going to make this a one take wonder.
- 0:05Todd Bishop: One take wonder.
- 0:06John Cook: That's the goal.
- 0:06Todd Bishop: Zero edits. Zero edits this week.
- 0:08John Cook: Zero edits.
- 0:08Todd Bishop: Wait-
- 0:08John Cook: That's the goal.
- 0:10Todd Bishop: ... is this the real John or is this robot
- 0:13Todd Bishop: John? Because I think robot John could probably do this
- 0:15Todd Bishop: in one take.
- 0:16John Cook: Yes, robot John could do this in one take.
- 0:22Todd Bishop: Its so weird because the problem now is people are
- 0:24Todd Bishop: going to be like, " Wait, is that really him or
- 0:27Todd Bishop: is it the robot?" Hi, and welcome to GeekWire. I'm
- 0:34Todd Bishop: GeekWire co- founder, Todd Bishop.
- 0:36John Cook: And I'm GeekWire co- founder John Cook.
- 0:38Todd Bishop: John, we got a lot to talk about today. And this
- 0:40Todd Bishop: week I'm in California, and I can share with you
- 0:43Todd Bishop: some of the details from Google I/ O, which I
- 0:45Todd Bishop: got to attend for the first time this week, and
- 0:48Todd Bishop: I was also at Expedia, and lots of interesting news
- 0:50Todd Bishop: to cover. But I feel like we need to start
- 0:53Todd Bishop: with where we ended last week, which was this experiment
- 0:57Todd Bishop: we did where we had these voice clones of you
- 1:00Todd Bishop: and me read this AI generated script. The reaction that
- 1:06Todd Bishop: we got to that was fascinating. And one of the
- 1:09Todd Bishop: people who reacted was your brother? Who-
- 1:12John Cook: Well, both brothers-
- 1:13Todd Bishop: Both brothers.
- 1:14John Cook: ... actually, I haven't shared the other brother's comments. Yeah,
- 1:18John Cook: what (inaudible) -
- 1:19Todd Bishop: So Dave and Dan both reacted, and these are two
- 1:22Todd Bishop: people who know you better than anybody, better than me,
- 1:25Todd Bishop: frankly. What did they think of the voice clone of
- 1:29Todd Bishop: John Cook?
- 1:30John Cook: Well, I think they thought it was pretty close. My
- 1:33John Cook: brother Dave texted and said, " Listened to your AI podcast.
- 1:38John Cook: Crazy, amazing, scary, exciting, all rolled into one.
- 1:43Todd Bishop: Wow. That is the embodiment of the era that we're
- 1:47Todd Bishop: in right now. What did he say? " Crazy, amazing, exciting,
- 1:52Todd Bishop: and scary all rolled into one."
- 1:54John Cook: Yes. Yes. That was it. So..
- 1:57Todd Bishop: Completely. Yeah, and-
- 1:59John Cook: It is all those things, right?
- 2:00Todd Bishop: It is. It's totally all those things. And I got
- 2:03Todd Bishop: a lot of feedback from listeners and readers. Some people
- 2:07Todd Bishop: just did not understand, initially, I didn't set it up
- 2:10Todd Bishop: well enough to make it clear that it was robots
- 2:13Todd Bishop: that we're reading. But the thing that is fascinating to
- 2:16Todd Bishop: a lot of people is the fact that it's not
- 2:19Todd Bishop: just our voice clones. And again, yours was much better
- 2:23Todd Bishop: as a clone than mine was, but it's also the
- 2:27Todd Bishop: fact that it was an AI generated script. I know
- 2:29Todd Bishop: a lot of journalists have been doing the voice clones
- 2:31Todd Bishop: and testing it, but the fact that we took it
- 2:33Todd Bishop: one step further I think was very interesting to a
- 2:36Todd Bishop: lot of people. So if you haven't heard that episode,
- 2:38Todd Bishop: I'd very much recommend going back and doing it. I
- 2:41Todd Bishop: think that there's some potential there to do something interesting
- 2:45Todd Bishop: in a transparent way long term, in terms of using
- 2:49Todd Bishop: AI end- to- end. And I just keep thinking what
- 2:53Todd Bishop: happens to human creativity in all this? Where can we
- 2:56Todd Bishop: add value? I don't know the answers to any of
- 2:58Todd Bishop: this, but I think we've got to be trying things
- 3:01Todd Bishop: like this. I think that's the key right now. And
- 3:04Todd Bishop: frankly, that's a lot of what I saw at Google I/
- 3:07Todd Bishop: O. This is Google's developer conference. It's down in Mountain
- 3:11Todd Bishop: View, California every year, and they're back in person now
- 3:14Todd Bishop: at Shoreline Amphitheater. Which John is funny, I was thinking,
- 3:18Todd Bishop: my brother took me to some Grateful Dead concerts at Shoreline
- 3:22Todd Bishop: Amphitheater back in the day.
- 3:23John Cook: Oh. So it took you back to your roots, huh?
- 3:26Todd Bishop: I was chatting with Ina Fried from Axios right before
- 3:29Todd Bishop: it started, and I said, " Yeah, I think this is
- 3:32Todd Bishop: sort of the first time I've been completely sober inside
- 3:34Todd Bishop: Shoreline." And she said, Ina's point was, " You really don't
- 3:38Todd Bishop: need anything mind- altering for a concert. You can have
- 3:41Todd Bishop: fun at a concert. Where you would probably need the
- 3:43Todd Bishop: substances like that would be for a Google event. It
- 3:46Todd Bishop: would be much more interesting to be at a Google
- 3:48Todd Bishop: event, to be in that state of mind."
- 3:51John Cook: Well, not to sidetrack, but who was the DJ/ musician
- 3:54John Cook: they had on stage with the duck out there? I
- 3:56John Cook: mean, it did get-
- 3:57Todd Bishop: Oh my God.
- 3:57John Cook: ... a little surreal, right? Like you were on some
- 4:00John Cook: sort of LSD trip.
- 4:02Todd Bishop: He was amazing. That was Dan Deacon. He was a
- 4:04Todd Bishop: composer and a musician. I loved him. I want to
- 4:07Todd Bishop: see one of his concerts. He came out and was
- 4:09Todd Bishop: sort of the pre- show entertainment, and I got to
- 4:11Todd Bishop: say, I've been to AWS re: Invent and Microsoft Build
- 4:15Todd Bishop: and all these conferences tend to have the musical entertainment
- 4:18Todd Bishop: to warm you up. This was by far the best.
- 4:22Todd Bishop: He led the group through a guided meditation. He had
- 4:26Todd Bishop: his AI generated songs that he had worked on the
- 4:28Todd Bishop: Google team with in advance, and it was just, you
- 4:32Todd Bishop: kind of had to see it. I'll link to the
- 4:33Todd Bishop: video from the show notes, but I loved his approach.
- 4:37Todd Bishop: Dan Deacon was his name, and I thought he was
- 4:40Todd Bishop: fantastic. And I think he deserves his own show.
- 4:44John Cook: Okay, well, that was a side note.
- 4:47Todd Bishop: Yes.
- 4:47John Cook: What was the main news coming out of Google I/
- 4:50John Cook: O? What did you learn? What did you see that
- 4:52John Cook: was interesting?
- 4:52Todd Bishop: So it was AI, AI, AI. It was fascinating. A
- 4:56Todd Bishop: lot of the preview posts that different sites did focused
- 5:00Todd Bishop: a lot on Pixel, Pixel phone and hardware, which is
- 5:03Todd Bishop: kind of at this point, the old paradigm. Google came
- 5:07Todd Bishop: out and yes, they eventually got to the phones and
- 5:09Todd Bishop: their Pixel Fold and their new Pixel tablet that docks
- 5:13Todd Bishop: with Smart Dock that is basically going to rival the
- 5:16Todd Bishop: Echo Show. But for 80 solid minutes at the beginning,
- 5:22Todd Bishop: Google CEO, Sundar Pichai, and all of the other executives
- 5:26Todd Bishop: focused 100% on artificial intelligence. They showed a variety of
- 5:31Todd Bishop: new generative AI features for Google Search. They showed some
- 5:36Todd Bishop: new features in Bard, which is the ChatGPT alternative. But
- 5:41Todd Bishop: to me, the most fascinating project that I saw was
- 5:44Todd Bishop: something called Project Tailwind. It wasn't even one of the
- 5:49Todd Bishop: main announcements that they were planning there, John, but to
- 5:53Todd Bishop: me, it embodied, it illustrated everything that AI could be
- 5:58Todd Bishop: in just a small little project. And I'm going to
- 6:02Todd Bishop: make that a teaser, because we're going to take our
- 6:04Todd Bishop: first break right here. We're going to talk about that
- 6:07Todd Bishop: when we come back. You're listening to GeekWire, and we
- 6:10Todd Bishop: will be right back. Welcome back. It's Todd Bishop with
- 6:16Todd Bishop: John Cook. I'm sharing some of the details this week
- 6:19Todd Bishop: from a couple of the conferences that I've been at,
- 6:21Todd Bishop: and one of them was Google I/ O in California.
- 6:24Todd Bishop: I was just talking about Project Tailwind. John, this is
- 6:28Todd Bishop: just a side project essentially that five Google engineers put
- 6:33Todd Bishop: together, it sounds like in their spare time.
- 6:36John Cook: Well, Google still has the program that allows engineers to
- 6:40John Cook: go off and spend a percentage of their time working
- 6:43John Cook: on crazy outlandish offbeat ideas. Is that where this (inaudible) -
- 6:48Todd Bishop: I assume they do.
- 6:48John Cook: Are they still doing that?
- 6:49Todd Bishop: I don't know. It's an interesting question.
- 6:51John Cook: It's part of their culture.
- 6:52Todd Bishop: It is definitely baked into their culture. I don't know
- 6:55Todd Bishop: if this resulted from that. I don't know if they
- 6:57Todd Bishop: still have it, but what Project Tailwind does is it
- 7:01Todd Bishop: takes your own notes, your own reference materials, articles that
- 7:06Todd Bishop: you might want this data set to include. In my
- 7:11Todd Bishop: vision for how I would use it, I would include
- 7:14Todd Bishop: interview transcripts, just as another example. It allows you to
- 7:17Todd Bishop: query that artificial intelligence model that's essentially been created on
- 7:21Todd Bishop: the fly. So they pitched this as something for students,
- 7:25Todd Bishop: for example, where you could put in your notes and
- 7:29Todd Bishop: your reading materials and the assignments from the professor, and
- 7:32Todd Bishop: then from there you could say, " Hey, create a summary,
- 7:34Todd Bishop: create a glossary, make this something that I can use
- 7:38Todd Bishop: as a study aid." But for me, from a journalist's
- 7:42Todd Bishop: perspective, this is the Holy Grail. I could take my
- 7:47Todd Bishop: notes, the five background stories that I want the large
- 7:52Todd Bishop: language model to take into account. I could take the
- 7:55Todd Bishop: latest interview that I did. I could write a one
- 7:58Todd Bishop: paragraph lead and a headline, and I could say, " Please
- 8:02Todd Bishop: summarize the rest of these materials with context from all
- 8:05Todd Bishop: of the information that I've just given you and only
- 8:09Todd Bishop: the information that I've just given you." And that to
- 8:11Todd Bishop: me is the key. I've actually talked to people at
- 8:14Todd Bishop: Microsoft in the past about how I could create something
- 8:17Todd Bishop: like this using some of the OpenAI frameworks that they
- 8:21Todd Bishop: had access to last year. I was thinking along these
- 8:23Todd Bishop: lines from a journalism perspective. And this to me is the
- 8:27Todd Bishop: fascinating part about this era of AI. This might not
- 8:31Todd Bishop: light you up in the way it lights me up.
- 8:33Todd Bishop: It might not make folks in our audience go, " Oh
- 8:35Todd Bishop: yes, that's the killer app of AI," but we're seeing
- 8:38Todd Bishop: this level of experimentation and trial that I think is
- 8:45Todd Bishop: going to lead to some fascinating breakthroughs, some real meaningful
- 8:50Todd Bishop: breakthroughs in the future in terms of our own personal
- 8:53Todd Bishop: productivity and the ways that AI can assist us.
- 8:57John Cook: So could you use Project Tailwind right now and use
- 9:01John Cook: it to help create a story?
- 9:03Todd Bishop: Yes, if I could get access to it, that is
- 9:06Todd Bishop: one challenge. Right now, there's a wait list to get
- 9:09Todd Bishop: access. I tried to connect with the Project Tailwind people
- 9:12Todd Bishop: when I was down there. I asked to talk to
- 9:16Todd Bishop: the folks who were behind it. I didn't have any
- 9:19Todd Bishop: luck, but I'm hoping-
- 9:21John Cook: Well, maybe this is your plea to Google PR right here to-
- 9:25Todd Bishop: I guess.
- 9:25John Cook: ... get you to the top of the line.
- 9:27Todd Bishop: ... it was five engineers. Wouldn't one of them listen
- 9:31Todd Bishop: to the GeekWire podcast? There's a big Google engineering center
- 9:34Todd Bishop: in Fremont, just down the street from us in Seattle.
- 9:37Todd Bishop: I would hope that maybe somebody would listen and just, "
- 9:39Todd Bishop: Hey, get me up on that invite list." But I'm
- 9:41Todd Bishop: not asking for special treatment.
- 9:42John Cook: I'll walk down the street, Todd, and put a note
- 9:44John Cook: on their door to get you access.
- 9:47Todd Bishop: Project Tailwind, todd@ geekwire. com. Please get in touch. Yes.
- 9:51Todd Bishop: So that's the thing that got me excited the most,
- 9:54Todd Bishop: just in terms of my own personal use. To me,
- 9:57Todd Bishop: the idea of AI being that true assistant and doing
- 10:03Todd Bishop: some of that drudgery. Now, I want to be clear,
- 10:05Todd Bishop: in my ideal world, I would still read all of
- 10:08Todd Bishop: those materials. I'm not asking the AI to do the
- 10:10Todd Bishop: work. I'm not asking the AI to do all of
- 10:13Todd Bishop: the heavy lifting. But wouldn't it be great to just
- 10:15Todd Bishop: be able to sit back and read and absorb and say, "
- 10:17Todd Bishop: Okay, summarize this now and do it in a way
- 10:20Todd Bishop: that I can adapt the material easily for a story
- 10:24Todd Bishop: that I'm writing?"
- 10:25John Cook: Well, it seems like the next step on that is
- 10:27John Cook: just writing the story then, right? And that's the worry, like,
- 10:30John Cook: gosh, if it can synthesize the information and put that
- 10:34John Cook: context around it, which is a big part of what
- 10:37John Cook: your job is as a reporter and journalist, then it
- 10:40John Cook: seems like, gosh, the writing of it is a second
- 10:45John Cook: step that would naturally come out of that.
- 10:49Todd Bishop: Wow, that's such a downer, John. That's such a downer. I guess
- 10:54Todd Bishop: it's a matter of degrees and shades of gray. I
- 10:57Todd Bishop: hear what you're saying. I personally get so much fulfillment
- 11:02Todd Bishop: out of the process of learning and finishing a story
- 11:06Todd Bishop: that I would help in the middle. I'd like help
- 11:09Todd Bishop: in that difficult middle part, the part between absorbing and
- 11:14Todd Bishop: the part between publishing. I'm not asking for a machine
- 11:18Todd Bishop: to do all of the work in between, but to
- 11:21Todd Bishop: the point of the name of the project, which I
- 11:23Todd Bishop: think is apt, I'd like a little bit of a
- 11:25Todd Bishop: tailwind and a little bit of help. I get what
- 11:29Todd Bishop: you're saying, and I agree that it could be a
- 11:31Todd Bishop: slippery slope, and especially in cases where people actually don't
- 11:35Todd Bishop: want to do any of the work, which I think is
- 11:39Todd Bishop: the case in a lot of situations.
- 11:41John Cook: Well, another product they talked about was right in line with
- 11:46John Cook: what we're discussing here right now, which was called Help
- 11:50John Cook: Me Write.
- 11:51Todd Bishop: Oh, yes.
- 11:51John Cook: So talk about that, which is essentially, it's a product
- 11:56John Cook: for Gmail that will craft an entire message for you
- 12:00John Cook: and make it in such a way that hopefully it's
- 12:04John Cook: more convincing to whomever you're writing to, so you can
- 12:07John Cook: get your point across or make a sale or get
- 12:10John Cook: your money back or whatever.
- 12:13Todd Bishop: I loved this.
- 12:13John Cook: So it really is crafting an entire email for you.
- 12:17Todd Bishop: So this was so mind- expanding in a lot of
- 12:20Todd Bishop: different ways. This is a feature that's currently in testing
- 12:23Todd Bishop: for Google Workspace. So John, this will be available to
- 12:26Todd Bishop: us as Gmail and Google Workspace users eventually, actually pretty
- 12:30Todd Bishop: soon. And the example that they showed, as you just
- 12:35Todd Bishop: mentioned, was a customer service reply with a canceled flight.
- 12:39Todd Bishop: Sundar Pichai showed this on stage, where it initially drafted
- 12:45Todd Bishop: the request for a refund for the flight, and then
- 12:48Todd Bishop: knowing that a more expansive plea might have a better
- 12:53Todd Bishop: chance of success, underscoring, for example, how long you've been
- 12:57Todd Bishop: a customer, some of the details of the flight, which
- 13:00Todd Bishop: it pulls in automatically.
- 13:02John Cook: Your anger level.
- 13:03Todd Bishop: Yes, yes. But-
- 13:07John Cook: "I'm mad as hell."
- 13:07Todd Bishop: ... in a reasoned, rational way that's likely to get
- 13:10Todd Bishop: a response. You can just hit expand and it does
- 13:13Todd Bishop: that for you. It's funny, I was just trying to
- 13:15Todd Bishop: get a refund before we jumped on, John. My mom
- 13:18Todd Bishop: got a real lemon of an iPhone, and I'm trying
- 13:21Todd Bishop: to get a refund from Verizon. So I'm on customer
- 13:23Todd Bishop: chat sitting there almost thinking like a robot based on
- 13:27Todd Bishop: this example that I saw, and it worked. The person said, "
- 13:30Todd Bishop: Okay, here's how you can get a $ 700 refund." It's like, "
- 13:33Todd Bishop: Okay," even though I'm outside of the 30- day window.
- 13:36John Cook: You were probably communicating with a bot.
- 13:39Todd Bishop: They said it was real.
- 13:40John Cook: Okay, I'm just saying. That's where this gets interesting.
- 13:44Todd Bishop: Yes.
- 13:44John Cook: One bot against the other, right?
- 13:45Todd Bishop: Exactly.
- 13:46John Cook: And who's going to win the battle?
- 13:48Todd Bishop: Exactly. Because on the other hand, I'm sitting there thinking,
- 13:52Todd Bishop: my main problem as the recipient of emails, not people
- 13:57Todd Bishop: asking for refunds necessarily, but just the recipient of emails
- 14:01Todd Bishop: in general is just being flooded with information. So if
- 14:04Todd Bishop: you think about this in the abstract, on the one
- 14:07Todd Bishop: hand, we're making it much easier for systems to just
- 14:10Todd Bishop: spam people with things that look like human text. And
- 14:15Todd Bishop: on the other hand, you've got people using email prioritization
- 14:21Todd Bishop: programs and different types of productivity tools to combat that.
- 14:24Todd Bishop: So your point is very true, John. You're going to
- 14:27Todd Bishop: have a machine against a machine.
- 14:29John Cook: Yeah, it's like the cybersecurity wars-
- 14:34Todd Bishop: Yes.
- 14:34John Cook: ... in some ways.
- 14:35Todd Bishop: So that was really interesting. I got to say, I
- 14:38Todd Bishop: got into kind of feature request mode, which happens sometimes
- 14:42Todd Bishop: when I go in and talk to people who run
- 14:44Todd Bishop: products that we use very heavily in our daily work
- 14:47Todd Bishop: at GeekWire. So I spoke with one of the top
- 14:50Todd Bishop: executives on the Google Workspace team, and for part of
- 14:54Todd Bishop: it just basically said, " Hey, here's what I want as
- 14:56Todd Bishop: a user." And they actually appreciate it, to a point.
- 15:00Todd Bishop: They do want to hear from a user. I got the
- 15:02Todd Bishop: sense, I might have gone a little bit overboard on
- 15:04Todd Bishop: it. But one of the things, John, great example, when
- 15:07Todd Bishop: we have a new employee start at GeekWire, it's about,
- 15:11Todd Bishop: oh, half hour, 45 minute process, sometimes more, setting that
- 15:16Todd Bishop: person up on email, setting them up in the different aliases
- 15:21Todd Bishop: that we want based on the job profile that we
- 15:23Todd Bishop: have. There is no reason that I shouldn't be able
- 15:27Todd Bishop: to go in and type a paragraph and say, we
- 15:29Todd Bishop: have a new employee named this. This person is reporting
- 15:33Todd Bishop: to this person. Please set this new employee up with
- 15:37Todd Bishop: the appropriate email address. Let them know. Just have it
- 15:42Todd Bishop: in a few basic natural language commands be done. And
- 15:47Todd Bishop: it's interesting when you watch the person's reaction on the
- 15:49Todd Bishop: other side, the Google Workspace VP, she kind of looked
- 15:53Todd Bishop: at me with a little bit of a gleam in
- 15:54Todd Bishop: her eye. You can tell that they're working on it.
- 15:56Todd Bishop: I mean, clearly they're working on it, even though she
- 15:58Todd Bishop: can't say, and it's a natural, logical thing to do.
- 16:02Todd Bishop: And it was frankly just one of the many feature
- 16:06Todd Bishop: requests that I have. Really, in terms of big picture
- 16:09Todd Bishop: stuff, what I want is a personal assistant to read
- 16:14Todd Bishop: every single one of my messages, all of the social
- 16:19Todd Bishop: media, inbound, direct messages. I don't want to have to go to LinkedIn,
- 16:22Todd Bishop: Twitter, Facebook, whatever. I want to be able to go
- 16:25Todd Bishop: to one interface and have it be like I'm walking
- 16:29Todd Bishop: into the office in the morning. " Mr. Bishop, here are
- 16:32Todd Bishop: your messages." The person who would hand me all those post-
- 16:36Todd Bishop: it notes and say, " Here's what you need to do
- 16:38Todd Bishop: the first 10 minutes of your day."
- 16:39John Cook: Who was the person, was it Trump? It was a
- 16:42John Cook: former president or somebody who used to have emails-
- 16:47Todd Bishop: Printed out.
- 16:48John Cook: Printed out for them.
- 16:49Todd Bishop: I think it might have been.
- 16:50John Cook: So that's what you want, somebody-
- 16:51Todd Bishop: No.
- 16:51John Cook: ... who does the equivalent of that.
- 16:55Todd Bishop: I want the AI virtual equivalent of that. And frankly,
- 16:59Todd Bishop: would be more than 10 minutes. It would probably be
- 17:01Todd Bishop: the first hour, but it would save so much time.
- 17:04Todd Bishop: And there are ingredients of that right now, and I
- 17:07Todd Bishop: wrote a little bit about that in my post about
- 17:10Todd Bishop: Google I/ O. We're seeing ingredients of that right now,
- 17:12Todd Bishop: but nobody's really come up with that overarching AI killer
- 17:15Todd Bishop: app. And it's just so obvious that it needs to
- 17:18Todd Bishop: be done, and I hope somebody ends up doing it.
- 17:20Todd Bishop: So that was Google I/ O. I will link from
- 17:23Todd Bishop: the show notes to my coverage from there. Definitely recommend
- 17:27Todd Bishop: checking out what they announced there. And in just a
- 17:30Todd Bishop: couple weeks now, John, we've got Microsoft Build coming up.
- 17:33Todd Bishop: It is developer conference season, and something actually happened this
- 17:37Todd Bishop: week as I was planning for Microsoft Build that plays
- 17:41Todd Bishop: into a larger trend that I wanted to share in
- 17:45Todd Bishop: terms of the balance of power between tech, media, and
- 17:50Todd Bishop: everybody else. We're going to talk about that when we
- 17:53Todd Bishop: come back. You're listening to GeekWire. Welcome back. It's Todd
- 18:00Todd Bishop: Bishop with John Cook. You can tell I've been energized
- 18:03Todd Bishop: this week. I'm on a trip to California. I got
- 18:05Todd Bishop: to go to Google I/ O. Earlier in the week
- 18:07Todd Bishop: I was at Expedia EXPLORE. I got to listen to
- 18:11Todd Bishop: Barry Diller and other Expedia executives talk about their plans
- 18:15Todd Bishop: for AI and other aspects of travel. And then looking
- 18:18Todd Bishop: ahead, John, in a couple weeks, Microsoft Build is coming
- 18:22Todd Bishop: up. This is Microsoft's big developer conference that they do
- 18:25Todd Bishop: every year. They are back in- person on a limited
- 18:29Todd Bishop: basis, at least, with some developers in Seattle attending this
- 18:33Todd Bishop: conference. It's a hybrid conference. It'll be online, but it's
- 18:37Todd Bishop: in our neck of the woods. It's in Seattle, right
- 18:38Todd Bishop: downtown in the new convention center, the expanded Seattle Convention
- 18:42Todd Bishop: Center, which I haven't really been in yet. I'd love
- 18:44Todd Bishop: to experience.
- 18:45John Cook: It's beautiful.
- 18:45Todd Bishop: Yeah. My thought was, I should go to this thing.
- 18:49John Cook: Yeah, why not? That's part of why we have GeekWire
- 18:52John Cook: based in Seattle, so you can pop into these types
- 18:54John Cook: of events, right?
- 18:55Todd Bishop: Yeah. What happens here matters everywhere, as the bots say.
- 18:58John Cook: There you go.
- 19:01Todd Bishop: I asked for a press pass. And granted, that's a
- 19:05Todd Bishop: privileged thing-
- 19:06John Cook: Which I presume they've provided in years past.
- 19:09Todd Bishop: Absolutely.
- 19:10John Cook: Not just to you, but to other members of the media.
- 19:13Todd Bishop: Right, recognized media, which we're getting into all sorts of
- 19:17Todd Bishop: gray areas here, but it's the standard thing. And was told, "
- 19:21Todd Bishop: Thank you for your request. We do not have a
- 19:25Todd Bishop: press program this year." I went, " Oh, okay." So I
- 19:29Todd Bishop: thought to myself, I understand the polite brush- off. I'm
- 19:33Todd Bishop: going to ignore it and try again. So I said, "
- 19:37Todd Bishop: Got it, no problem. I don't need a program for
- 19:41Todd Bishop: the press to attend. I'd just like to attend in-
- 19:44Todd Bishop: person. For me, there's real benefits." I'm thinking in the
- 19:47Todd Bishop: back of my mind. " You get to bump into developers,
- 19:51Todd Bishop: overhear conversations, see people you wouldn't otherwise see if you
- 19:55Todd Bishop: were just attending online. You get to go into sessions."
- 19:58Todd Bishop: There's all sorts of serendipitous stuff that happens when you
- 20:02Todd Bishop: actually go in- person, just like working from the office.
- 20:05Todd Bishop: And I was told in response that there would be
- 20:09Todd Bishop: no press passes this year that I was welcome to
- 20:11Todd Bishop: buy a conference pass and go if I wanted.
- 20:14John Cook: Or you can tune in virtually, I presume. Yes.
- 20:16Todd Bishop: Now, I talked with some people at Microsoft about this.
- 20:19Todd Bishop: I understand their perspective. They're saying, essentially, that there are
- 20:25Todd Bishop: certain people who cannot attend these events in the press
- 20:28Todd Bishop: because of issues related to underlying medical conditions. And COVID
- 20:33Todd Bishop: has brought a lot of these things out. Hey, I'm
- 20:36Todd Bishop: going to give them the benefit of the doubt. I
- 20:37Todd Bishop: can see the skepticism on your face, John, go ahead.
- 20:41John Cook: Okay.
- 20:41Todd Bishop: They're saying that, " The cost of making an equitable experience
- 20:46Todd Bishop: between those members of the press attending online and those
- 20:49Todd Bishop: attending in person would be too great for them." That
- 20:52Todd Bishop: is what they say. I'm going to take them at
- 20:55Todd Bishop: their word. But to me, it's an example of how
- 21:02Todd Bishop: companies, whether purposefully or not, are using this post pandemic
- 21:09Todd Bishop: period to maintain a level of separation and sanitization that
- 21:18Todd Bishop: did not exist prior to the pandemic, because of in-
- 21:21Todd Bishop: person, real human interactions. And I had another experience like
- 21:26Todd Bishop: this on a press conference with Tableau earlier in the
- 21:30Todd Bishop: week. This was a Zoom press conference, and the way
- 21:35Todd Bishop: they did the questions was they allowed you to submit
- 21:38Todd Bishop: chat. So I asked the question of the new Tableau
- 21:42Todd Bishop: CEO, something along the lines of, " How do you respond
- 21:47Todd Bishop: to concerns that Tableau is losing its identity and autonomy
- 21:53Todd Bishop: and important aspects of its brand under Salesforce?" Which of
- 21:58Todd Bishop: course acquired Tableau a few years ago. So obviously, that
- 22:03Todd Bishop: was the way I phrased the question. It had an
- 22:06Todd Bishop: assumption behind it. The question was read by a Tableau
- 22:13Todd Bishop: PR person to the CEO as, effectively, " How does Tableau
- 22:20Todd Bishop: make sure that it retains its autonomy and identity under
- 22:23Todd Bishop: Salesforce?" Not really the same question, kind of the same
- 22:27Todd Bishop: question, but really not. And I made my feelings known
- 22:32Todd Bishop: to the Tableau people afterward about how that struck me.
- 22:37Todd Bishop: That to me is shades of 1984. And now maybe
- 22:45Todd Bishop: that's too dramatic, but if you're going to have an
- 22:49Todd Bishop: independent press, shouldn't they be allowed to directly question the
- 22:52Todd Bishop: people that they're writing about? And at the very least,
- 22:54Todd Bishop: shouldn't their questions be relayed verbatim and rant? What do
- 22:59Todd Bishop: you think?
- 23:00John Cook: This is a good rant. I love when you go
- 23:02John Cook: off on your tangents. I mean, of course, I agree.
- 23:06John Cook: I mean, what is it you're asking?
- 23:06Todd Bishop: Well, but you're on my side.
- 23:08John Cook: Yeah, I mean, it's troubling. I think it's bad for
- 23:13John Cook: society, bad for democracy. I think you're seeing it not
- 23:17John Cook: just in the business world, but certainly in the political
- 23:20John Cook: world. I mean, look what the big news was this
- 23:23John Cook: week in terms of the CNN Town Hall-
- 23:26Todd Bishop: Oh, wow.
- 23:26John Cook: ... with Donald Trump, and boy talk about controlling a
- 23:30John Cook: message and stacking the deck with the audience that they
- 23:33John Cook: placed in that town hall. It's completely unfair. And I
- 23:37John Cook: guess CNN probably looks at it and says, " Well, we're
- 23:41John Cook: getting an interview with the former president," that's probably newsworthy.
- 23:45John Cook: You'd want to take that. But then there's a negotiation
- 23:48John Cook: behind the scenes in terms of what the format's going
- 23:50John Cook: to be like, who's going to be in the audience?
- 23:52John Cook: And that was not the best moment for CNN
- 23:57Todd Bishop: I caught only a bit of it, but I got
- 23:59Todd Bishop: to say, Kaitlan Collins, the CNN reporter who did the
- 24:03Todd Bishop: moderation, I'm sure she's being criticized roundly by people on
- 24:08Todd Bishop: different sides of the political spectrum, but in terms of
- 24:11Todd Bishop: just journalistic, oh, what's the word, John?
- 24:15John Cook: Rigor, journalistic rigor and professionalism and smarts. I thought she
- 24:20John Cook: did a great job.
- 24:21Todd Bishop: Totally agreed.
- 24:22John Cook: And great job in a impossible situation, which is what
- 24:26John Cook: a lot of people have been saying. I listened to
- 24:30John Cook: Scott Galloway and Kara Swisher on their pivot podcast, and
- 24:33John Cook: they were doing a breakdown and an analysis of it.
- 24:36John Cook: And hearing Kara talk about the interview style. She was
- 24:40John Cook: a little more critical, but it was just not a
- 24:46John Cook: good situation to throw a reporter into. But yeah, I
- 24:50John Cook: think this gets to the point you're making that there's
- 24:53John Cook: a lot of control, a lot of sanitation. There's no
- 24:55John Cook: more freewheeling, and it's not just Trump. I mean, Biden
- 24:58John Cook: has done fewer press conferences than the last 20 presidents,
- 25:05John Cook: or a number of presidents prior to him, and I
- 25:08John Cook: think we should be hearing more from him with more
- 25:11John Cook: direct questions from an independent press.
- 25:15Todd Bishop: I'm glad you brought that up.
- 25:15John Cook: But the press has been beaten down and battered for
- 25:20John Cook: years now, and it has such a negative perception. And
- 25:25John Cook: some of it's brought upon by the industry themselves, where
- 25:29John Cook: you have very splintered and political press. I mean, it
- 25:35John Cook: is hard for people that are more centrist to exist
- 25:39John Cook: in this world. So it's a challenge, but it's not
- 25:43John Cook: going to matter whether we're all AI generated images on
- 25:48John Cook: TV and news stories written. So then it's all going
- 25:51John Cook: to come from one bot. Maybe that'll take us back
- 25:54John Cook: to the Walter Cronkite days, because all the information people
- 25:56John Cook: will be getting will just be funneled through two or
- 25:59John Cook: three bots, and it'll be like ABC News, NBC News, and
- 26:04John Cook: CBS News. It'll be the Google bot, the Microsoft bot,
- 26:07John Cook: the Amazon or Apple bot, and that's how you'll get
- 26:10John Cook: your information.
- 26:11Todd Bishop: Just circling back to Google I/ O, I think it's
- 26:13Todd Bishop: important to recognize that tech companies as well have played
- 26:16Todd Bishop: a role in this through undermining, on a large scale,
- 26:20Todd Bishop: a lot of the business models that many media companies
- 26:23Todd Bishop: have relied on. That came up a little bit at
- 26:26Todd Bishop: Google I/ O this week. In interacting with some of
- 26:29Todd Bishop: the other reporters, I was fascinated by how much they
- 26:34Todd Bishop: were focused on policy and societal issues in the middle
- 26:39Todd Bishop: of this tech conference. 5, 6, 7 years ago, it
- 26:43Todd Bishop: would not have been that way, at least in my
- 26:44Todd Bishop: experience. And the end result was, I think in some
- 26:51Todd Bishop: ways, maybe you could criticize me for this, but in
- 26:54Todd Bishop: some ways, some of the awe and the wonder about
- 27:00Todd Bishop: what we're seeing right now with generative AI has gone
- 27:04Todd Bishop: away from the perspective of these reporters. And I think
- 27:10Todd Bishop: you can go too far in one direction or the
- 27:13Todd Bishop: other. You can go too far in terms of the
- 27:16Todd Bishop: potential downsides of AI and all of the advances that
- 27:22Todd Bishop: we're seeing. And you can go too far on the
- 27:24Todd Bishop: side of being amazed by it and not thinking about
- 27:28Todd Bishop: all of the potential pitfalls. It would be nice to
- 27:30Todd Bishop: be somewhere in between. I kept going back and forth,
- 27:33Todd Bishop: but I got to say, just looking at the kind
- 27:37Todd Bishop: of stuff that's shown on stage, I have a hard
- 27:40Todd Bishop: time, my default, maybe this is why I'm just a
- 27:42Todd Bishop: natural geek, I sit there and go, " Holy cow, what
- 27:47Todd Bishop: can I do with this stuff? This is amazing." That
- 27:49Todd Bishop: is my first reaction. And then I go, " Oh, yeah,
- 27:52Todd Bishop: what about the downside?" And maybe that's my ultimate failing
- 27:56Todd Bishop: as a tech reporter in some ways, is that I'm
- 27:58Todd Bishop: not thinking first about the negatives. I'm thinking first about
- 28:03Todd Bishop: the potential.
- 28:04John Cook: I don't think that's a negative. I think going in
- 28:07John Cook: with some sort of interest and curiosity about how it's
- 28:10John Cook: going to work will lead to better journalism at the end of the day. So-
- 28:15Todd Bishop: It's got to be tempered though. It's got to be
- 28:17Todd Bishop: tempered. And I always have to remind myself of that.
- 28:20John Cook: Yeah. Well, I think we also have reporters on staff
- 28:22John Cook: that are looking at those societal issues. It is interesting
- 28:26John Cook: as you think about the public policy components of this,
- 28:30John Cook: and I wonder, and I'm curious how you think about
- 28:33John Cook: just the impact that social media has had on society
- 28:36John Cook: over the last 10 years, 15 years, and whether we've
- 28:41John Cook: woken up to the fact of how generative AI is
- 28:44John Cook: going to impact society? And do you think there will
- 28:47John Cook: be regulations? Do you think we're going to get ahead
- 28:49John Cook: of this? Because I mean, the move fast and break
- 28:52John Cook: things model of Facebook certainly moved fast and broke some
- 28:56John Cook: things, and now we're all suffering from a lot of
- 28:59John Cook: the consequences of that. I think the same potential is
- 29:03John Cook: there with generative, AI, maybe it's already here, to break
- 29:08John Cook: some stuff, probably even more so than social media. And
- 29:11John Cook: so the question is, are the public policy components going
- 29:16John Cook: to be in place to put the right guardrails around
- 29:20John Cook: this? And my gut says, " Heck no. It's not," because
- 29:23John Cook: we can't even get basic stuff done in this country.
- 29:29John Cook: I mean, it's like, let alone talking about AI. I
- 29:33John Cook: was hopeful in that CNN debate, actually, I wish they
- 29:36John Cook: did talk about generative AI. That would've been a complete
- 29:39John Cook: curveball question. I would've loved to have had Trump try
- 29:42John Cook: to answer that. That would've been interesting, at least. Why
- 29:47John Cook: not throw a curve ball in like that? It's going
- 29:50John Cook: to have a massive, it already is having a massive
- 29:52John Cook: impact. And so I think it's completely fair game. I
- 29:57John Cook: would've liked to have seen that question.
- 29:59Todd Bishop: Well, I don't think you would've gotten a substantive discussion-
- 30:05John Cook: Oh, well, no.
- 30:05Todd Bishop: ... in the general public-
- 30:05John Cook: You don't get-
- 30:05Todd Bishop: ... in the general public. And that gets to the
- 30:08Todd Bishop: broader point we're making right now, which is that then
- 30:11Todd Bishop: is the role of journalists, especially at mainstream media publications.
- 30:15Todd Bishop: It's to put these issues in context so they are
- 30:20Todd Bishop: easily inserted into the conversations like the ones you're referencing now.
- 30:24John Cook: Right. And why questions shouldn't be sanitized or pressed, should
- 30:28John Cook: not be barred from going to events to see... I
- 30:31John Cook: totally agree.
- 30:33Todd Bishop: And to your point, Facebook did move fast and I
- 30:37Todd Bishop: think Facebook broke us. And that is what we're seeing
- 30:42Todd Bishop: with social media. John, I'm still heavily using that Unplug
- 30:47Todd Bishop: app that I've referenced. It stops me two or three
- 30:51Todd Bishop: times a night from going down a YouTube wormhole. And
- 30:54Todd Bishop: it is hard for me to acknowledge, even to myself,
- 30:57Todd Bishop: that I have that issue with the addiction to that
- 31:01Todd Bishop: platform. It's YouTube. YouTube Shorts, I can sit there for
- 31:05Todd Bishop: hours and waste my life. And I just got to
- 31:08Todd Bishop: say, point taken, John. I was excited about Facebook back
- 31:13Todd Bishop: in the day, much like I'm excited by generative AI
- 31:15Todd Bishop: now, and I feel like I've just gone through some
- 31:19Todd Bishop: tech therapy with you, so thank you very much.
- 31:22John Cook: Okay. Well, be excited and explore it, but cast a
- 31:27John Cook: critical eye and think about the consequences.
- 31:30Todd Bishop: All right.
- 31:31John Cook: That's what we should be doing in the reporting.
- 31:33Todd Bishop: I'm going to go into ChatGPT and find out what
- 31:37Todd Bishop: Bing and Bard think about this and put it into
- 31:40Todd Bishop: your voice and... No, no. All right. Well, I did
- 31:48Todd Bishop: not get a chance to talk as much as I
- 31:50Todd Bishop: had hoped about my visit to Expedia this past week.
- 31:53Todd Bishop: They're extraordinary new campus on the Seattle waterfront. Not really
- 31:58Todd Bishop: that new, frankly, but new post pandemic, and some interesting
- 32:03Todd Bishop: comments by Barry Diller, the Expedia Chairman, the media mogul,
- 32:07Todd Bishop: about the value of in- person work and the potential
- 32:10Todd Bishop: and the risks of generative AI. So I will link
- 32:12Todd Bishop: to all of that from the show notes, and really,
- 32:15Todd Bishop: you got to see the pictures of the place. It's
- 32:17Todd Bishop: just a amazing campus and reason to go to work,
- 32:21Todd Bishop: I'm sure, for some of those Expedia employees. All right, John.
- 32:25John Cook: Good seeing you. Enjoy California.
- 32:26Todd Bishop: Thank you. Thanks for listening, everybody. Be sure to subscribe,
- 32:30Todd Bishop: rate, and review the GeekWire Podcast wherever you listen. We'll
- 32:33Todd Bishop: be back with a new episode next week. Until then,
- 32:36Todd Bishop: I'm Todd Bishop.
- 32:38John Cook: And I'm John Cook.
- 32:39Todd Bishop: Thank you for listening to GeekWire.