Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #90🎙️|Public Inquiry Break – Before We Go Back In|
Transcript
- 0:02Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Curranalt public
- 0:12inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:22number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be
- 0:33following the evidence and the arguments, and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscape of
- 0:42The Sperrins. Well, this wasn't actually a podcast I had planned for this Friday, but sometimes plans change, and perhaps that's no bad thing, because we are in
- 0:56one of those strange little gaps in the public inquiry. We go back again on the first of September, and before we do, I thought it might be useful just
- 1:07to stop and think about where we actually are. So here it is: five months in with three months to go. Yet to come are some of the most controversial and
- 1:18important topics, such as the filtered tailings, mine waste facility, water, ecology, landscape, and climate change. Quite a lot to get through with
- 1:31third parties needing to parachute in as much expertise as we can find to help us to respond to whatever surprises come from the applicant's side
- 1:39of the house. Have to say, I'm not looking forward to it at all. But collectively, we've been preparing while simultaneously reaffirming our
- 1:49commitment to exposing the profound risk this mining project poses to the place we call home. It still surprises us today how this campaign
- 2:00continues to attract in and retain an ever-expanding army of supporters, helpers, and volunteers, particularly as the campaign has gone on for over 12
- 2:12years, one would imagine that by now people would have given up and gone away. Not the case. Our numbers continue to grow, and it's heartening to experience
- 2:23and to see so many people working on all fronts, bringing their skills, knowledge, and technical ability to the campaign in the arena that they
- 2:33are most comfortable with. From a small core, the ripples spread ever outwards. First, it is the people on the ground who live near Cournal, and they turn up
- 2:44in their droves as and when needed. Then, widening out from the circle are people like myself who live in and around about The Sperrins, bringing our
- 2:54collective life experiences, skills, and talents to the campaign. Radiating out from there, we have supportive groups from all across Ireland and
- 3:04Northern Ireland, ranging from academics, legal brains, direct action groups, NGOs, artists, musicians, dancers, other mining groups, religious groups,
- 3:18theatre groups, and everyone in between. Going still further, we have supportive groups in the USA constantly working on our behalf, as well as global
- 3:29connection to other communities across the world, who are also experiencing mining in their own communities. Working closely with them all, we swap
- 3:40expertise, information, and updates on mining companies. We support them as they support us, leading to some surprising alliances. Beyond that, our
- 3:52social media presence continues to grow and grow. Daily, we have people signing up to our newsletter, and our podcast has been downloaded 17,000 times in
- 4:0280 countries around the world. Our website also is fast becoming an important archive for the future, and it takes all of these committed people who
- 4:13together weave a web of support, expertise, energy, tenacity, and strength, and most importantly, love, providing vital support when needed, bound together in a
- 4:26common concern for the air we breathe, the water we drink, and the good health of us all now and for generations to come. Over the last few months, it has
- 4:37become increasingly clear that there is much in the realm of what we don't know, we don't know. Whilst we've done our best to write statements of case in
- 4:46rebuttals and respond to every challenge that has come our way, all the way through the process, we are acutely aware of the lack of evidence and information
- 4:55being presented by the applicant. Often hidden in the. Phrase of bespoke modelling being used instead of industry modelling, and therefore we have
- 5:06no clue if industry standards are being met, and neither does the Planning Appeals Commission.
- 5:14This obfuscation often hides details in complex jargon, vague phrasing, long-winded talk to hide a simple truth or avoid a direct answer, and this has
- 5:26occurred again and again in every topic we have covered since April, and I'm sure will continue to be the case until the end of the public inquiry.
- 5:35In a way, it makes nonsense of the whole public inquiry process, and there's nothing anyone can do about it, leaving the PAC with the paradox that
- 5:47they can only rule on the evidence presented in front of them. If it is not present, they cannot include it, and leaving us, the Earth protectors, with a
- 5:56sense of unease and real anxiety about the process. The other alarming fact is the complete lack of leadership by our departments, the civil service,
- 6:08the folk who are employed by the people to serve the people. And I looked up the Northern Ireland Code for the Civil Service Code of Ethics, and where it says
- 6:20that civil servants must perform their duties based on four main values, and I idly wonder how they would score themselves on the following: integrity, put
- 6:32public service duties above personal interests; honesty, remain truthful and open; objectivity, base decisions and advice on strict evidence
- 6:44analysis, impartiality, act on the merits of each case and serve different political administrations equally well. I have a feeling that scoring
- 6:55would be abysmal. On the other hand, I recently came across a discussion about the breakdown of trust between government, the civil service, and the public,
- 7:06and much of it is driven by perceived failures in public service delivery and lack of transparency. Observing these same civil service in action for
- 7:16the past five months, I find that if I apply their civil service code of ethics, to what we have witnessed in the room, I would be sorely disappointed in
- 7:26them. To change focus slightly, after the summer that we have had, where a third of North America is on fire, and much the same story in Europe, countries
- 7:38across the globe are drought-stricken, not least the UK, and even here, Ireland, they have once again extended the hose pipe ban, August 2026,
- 7:49during a summer where the collective climate emergency everywhere across the world has finally doused the old argument that more evidence is needed.
- 7:59Surely now is the time for some of you public servants to stand up and speak, to step into your own leadership, to take great personal risk and put your
- 8:09public service duty ahead of your personal interest. Might you be the person to try to halt the climate wrecking ball swinging through time? Might you
- 8:20be the person when lying on your deathbed and your grandchildren ask you what did you do? Will you be the hero of your own life? Here is a short excerpt
- 8:34from a poem by Drew Dillinger. What did you do once you knew? What did you do once you knew it's 323 in the morning, and I'm awake because my great great
- 8:48grandchildren won't let me sleep. My great great grandchildren ask me in dreams, what did you do while the planet was plundered? What did you do
- 8:58when the earth was unravelling? Surely you did something when the seasons started falling. Surely you did something as the mammals, reptiles, and birds
- 9:08were all dying. Surely you did something. Did you fill the streets with protests when democracy was stolen? What did you do once you knew? And then,
- 9:22as for us Earth protectors, we will continue to present robust evidence showing that this toxic industry threatens our pristine water systems, fragile ecology,
- 9:33and irreplaceable landscape, and will contribute to ever more global warming. We remain entirely resolved to prevent the long-term pollution of our
- 9:43environment, ensuring our children and grandchildren inherit a safe, unpolluted landscape, and that The Sperrins are preserved, not exploited.
- 9:55This public inquiry represents a vital opportunity to safeguard The Sperrins for future. And over the coming weeks, our community will be out in force
- 10:05as local residents stand together to show solidarity and defend their homeland from industrial exploitation. And I'll finish this evening with a
- 10:15quote. Ron Garan, astronaut, began questioning humanity's priorities after 178 days in space, he said, on Earth, economic growth is often treated
- 10:31as the ultimate goal. From space, that hierarchy collapses.
- 10:38He argues that the correct order should be planet first, society second, economy last, because without a healthy planet, neither society nor economy can
- 10:51exist, as shown by the summer we have experienced this year. Thanks very much for listening, and we see you all again soon. You've been listening to the
- 11:03Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social
- 11:13media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a
- 11:23moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to
- 11:31hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for
- 11:41listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.