Latest / NEURO MOTION LAB / Mini Season Relationship and Enviroment EPISODE 2 You are not loving that person. You are loving the prediction your brain makes of them
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to Neuro Motion Lab, where we explore the fascinating
- 0:14intersection of neuroscience and athletic performance.
- 0:17I'm Fabio Gida, Physical Therapist, trainer, mental
- 0:21performance coach and I'm passionate about helping
- 0:24athletes like you to reach your full potential.
- 0:46I'm going to say something right at the start of this episode
- 0:50that will probably make you resist.
- 0:53Feel the resistance, please, and stay Anyway, I promise to be
- 0:58polemic today. What I'm going to say that is
- 1:03there is a real chance you have never loved anyone, real chance
- 1:09that you loved with the whole body, with your years of life,
- 1:14with the best. You have just a model, a
- 1:18construction, a high precision prediction, your brain build of
- 1:22another person and that you confuse the whole time with that
- 1:28person. And that this the person on the
- 1:32other side was doing the same with you, loving the prediction
- 1:36of you so that between you 2 of ears, you held a love story
- 1:43among four, the two real people who barely saw each other and
- 1:48the two models who love each other's perfectly.
- 1:52Welcome to narrow motion live podcast.
- 1:54I'm Fabian La Nesta Gida today, second episode of this mini
- 1:59season. Relationship and environment.
- 2:02We touch the most subterm taboo there is, the most protective
- 2:07one, the one culture amoral with centuries of poetry, songs,
- 2:14movies, promises. We're going to talk about
- 2:17romantic love and we are going to take love apart, not to
- 2:22destroy the thing, but to see what reminds once we strip the
- 2:28mythology away. Because the neuroscience of
- 2:33predictive processing, the theory of constructed emotion,
- 2:37and searching contemporary philosophy are converging on a
- 2:40conclusion that nobody wants to heard on Valentine's Day.
- 2:45What you call love is in large part a construction of your own
- 2:50brain, not a perception of the other, a fabrication of yours
- 2:55projected onto the other that makes you fall in love.
- 3:01Do not panic yet, because by the end of this episode, the same
- 3:06idea, the coldest one in the world apparently, will open a
- 3:11door toward a way of loving for more honest and maybe for for
- 3:16deeper than the one culture sold you.
- 3:20But to reach that door first we have to walk through the fire.
- 3:26The underlying question today is this.
- 3:30Are you loving the person beside you or the model of them that
- 3:34lies inside your head? Let me return to something we
- 3:40touched before on this channel. Because the idea is the base of
- 3:44everything that follows. The human brain has no way to
- 3:48percept the word directly. The brain predicts the word.
- 3:52The brains generate each moment I guess about what come next,
- 3:59and only corrects when the reality fails to match the
- 4:02guess. The gap between what the brain
- 4:06predicted and what actually happened is calling prediction
- 4:10error. And prediction error is
- 4:13neurochemically one of the most powerful things there is because
- 4:20the gap release dopamine. Now apply this to the moment you
- 4:24meet someone who moves the ground under you.
- 4:27At the start, your brain has no model of that person.
- 4:32Your brain cannot tell how they will react, what they like, what
- 4:38they think, what they will say tomorrow.
- 4:41Everything is uncertainty. Everything is a new information.
- 4:46And so every gesture, every message, everything you discover
- 4:50lands as a pure prediction error.
- 4:53Constant novelty, dopamine firing again and again.
- 4:59That is why falling in love feels the way that falling in
- 5:04love feels. The obsession, the intensity,
- 5:07the way the other fills your whole head, the way you check
- 5:12the phone every 5 minutes, the way you cannot focus on
- 5:16anything. The cause is no some special
- 5:20magic the person has and others lack.
- 5:23The cause is that your brain is building a new model, a high
- 5:28speed and building that model. Model is literally addictive.
- 5:33Carl Fristan de Neurosay, Scientists who formalize the
- 5:36predictive brain will put the matter this way.
- 5:40The system is minimizing uncertainty about a new object
- 5:44of very high relevance, and while that uncertainty stays
- 5:48high, activity stays as the maximum.
- 5:53You are, in calm terms, solving that person the way you solve a
- 5:58fascinating puzzle. But here is what the mythology
- 6:03of love hides. If falling in love is the face
- 6:08of building the model, then falling in love comes with an
- 6:14expiration date built in. Know from failure, from design,
- 6:18because every model eventually finish building.
- 6:23And when the model finishes building, something's happened
- 6:27that most every couple in the world lives, suffer and misread.
- 6:33Let's talk about neurological structures.
- 6:34So let me go to the structures, because here is the core of the
- 6:39mechanisms when you meet someone.
- 6:42The mentalizing network, the one we saw in the first episode, the
- 6:46middle prefrontal cortex, the temporal particle junctions,
- 6:51works at full power. The network is actively
- 6:54computing the other What they think, what they feel, what they
- 6:58want. Intense cognitive work.
- 7:01You are all the time modeling another mind you barely know.
- 7:06Yet with time, as the model grows more precise, something
- 7:12happens that Frinceton predicts clearly and that carries A
- 7:17brutal consequence for love. The brain stopped activating,
- 7:22processing, whatever the brain can already predict.
- 7:26This is neural economy. The brain is wildly expensive
- 7:32organ in terms of energy, and the brain's governing principle
- 7:37is to spend the minimum. Everything that becomes
- 7:41predictable gets automated and drop it from active computation.
- 7:47That is why you fail to feel the clothing on your skin until I
- 7:52name the clothing. Only now you fold the fabric
- 7:56because your brain had marked the sensation as predictable and
- 8:00stopped processing this signal. That is why you fail to see the
- 8:05furniture in your home you walk in.
- 8:08Your brain assumes the furnishes sits where the furnishes always
- 8:11sits, and spend no resource looking.
- 8:16Your brain runs the exact same operation on people you know
- 8:20best. When the model of your partner's
- 8:23growth persists enough, your brain has stopped computing
- 8:26them. Your brain assumes them.
- 8:29Your brain predicts them with no need to look.
- 8:34You know what they will say before they say the words.
- 8:38And the moment the prediction becomes nearly perfect, you stop
- 8:42perceiving the real person and you start relating to your model
- 8:47of them. What cultures calls the spark
- 8:51went out is narrow. Biologically, this a model that
- 8:58reaches such precision that the model stopped generating
- 9:01prediction error and therefore stop generating the dopamine of
- 9:06novelty. You did not get bored for the
- 9:10person, you stopped seeing them. You replace them without
- 9:15noticing with the prediction of them in your head.
- 9:19And here is the finest cruelty of the matter.
- 9:23You treat the person you love most with the same neural
- 9:28economy you use on the back wall of A room.
- 9:33The known becomes invisible. Not for lack of love for
- 9:38architecture. That is why so many couples say
- 9:42the other no longer sees me. I'm unlike one more piece of
- 9:47furniture in the house. That metaphor, my friends, which
- 9:51sounds poetic, is neurologically literally.
- 9:56You become predictable, and the predictable for the brain is
- 10:02invisible. Let's talk about neurochemistry.
- 10:06And here I want to bring in Lisa Feldman Barrett because she adds
- 10:11a layer that frisson alone cannot reach, and that makes all
- 10:16of this even more verticious. The intuition of all of us sure
- 10:21is that emotion and reaction. Something happened outside and
- 10:26you react with an emotion. You see the person you love and
- 10:31you feel love as if love were an automatic response to their
- 10:36presence. Barrett, after three decades of
- 10:39research, holds something radical.
- 10:41Different emotions are not triggered.
- 10:44Emotions are constructed. Your brain fabricates each
- 10:49emotion in the moment, combining 2 things.
- 10:53The physical sensation rising from your body, heart rate,
- 10:58temperature, activation, and the cultural concept you learned
- 11:03about what those sensation means, apply it to love.
- 11:08What this mean is devastating. When you feel love for someone,
- 11:14you are not detecting a property of the person.
- 11:18You are constructing an emotion in your brain combining
- 11:23combining a bodily state of activation with the cultural
- 11:27concept of love you absorb across your whole life, from
- 11:31movies, from songs, from what you saw at homes, from what
- 11:37people told you love should feel like.
- 11:41Your brain takes a bodily sensation and applies a label.
- 11:45You learner, and that construction is what you live
- 11:50as. I'm in love with this person.
- 11:53Put the two together. Frisson tells you you predict
- 11:57the person instead of seeing them.
- 11:59Barra tells you that you also construct every emotion about
- 12:05the love with them. So you don't only love a model
- 12:10of the other, you love that model with an emotion you also
- 12:14fabricate using concepts that are not yours either.
- 12:19That culture handled you. There is activation, of course,
- 12:24the oxytocin of attachment, the dopamine of desire.
- 12:28All chemistry is there real. I'm not going to deny any of the
- 12:33chemistry, but the chemistry is only raw material.
- 12:39What you're experienced as love for this specific person is a
- 12:44high level constructure your brain assembled over prediction
- 12:49of who the other is with an emotional fabricate for learned
- 12:54concept. And I know that it's hard to
- 12:58hear that. And here the question start to
- 13:01hurt. If the emotion is built by you
- 13:05with your concept over your model of the other, how much of
- 13:11the real other ever entered the equation?
- 13:17There is a contemporary philosopher, Bun Chu Han, who
- 13:20wrote about this from a place completely different than
- 13:24neuroscience, and who arrives surprisingly at the same
- 13:28conclusion. Han argues that contemporary
- 13:32culture is killing love, nor from too much freedom, nor from
- 13:37lack of commitment, the way conservative speeches claim.
- 13:43Culture is killing love from something deeper, and it's
- 13:47killing because culture no longer tolerates the other as a
- 13:51truly other. For real love to exist, there
- 13:56has to be an another for sure, someone generally different from
- 14:01you, a mystery, a difference you cannot reduce, cannot predict,
- 14:07cannot consume, cannot turn into of a reflection of yourself.
- 14:13Desire of the root is the pull toward what is not me, toward
- 14:19what I don't control, toward what access me.
- 14:25And what consumer culture trying to ask to do is to stop
- 14:28tolerating that difference to 1 the other made to measure, to
- 14:33consume the other the way we consume a product.
- 14:37Give me what I'm expect, confirm what I'm ready.
- 14:40I am. Do not upset me.
- 14:44Stay predictable, manageable, comfortable.
- 14:48We turn the other into a mirror of our own needs.
- 14:52And a mural is not an other. A mural is the self handed back.
- 15:00You see the connection with what we say from neuroscience, what
- 15:04hence call reducing the other to a consumable reflection is in
- 15:09for instant terms, replacing the real person with your
- 15:13predictable model of them. Philosophy and neuroscience from
- 15:19two different methods saying the same thing.
- 15:22We love our construction of the other, and in the process we
- 15:28make the real other disappear. We generally kill them gently,
- 15:34with no violence. With the best of our intention,
- 15:38we turn them into what we needed to them to be, and we call that
- 15:44knowing them well. I know you like nobody else, we
- 15:48say, and maybe the truth runs the other way.
- 15:53Maybe I know you like nobody else real means I reduce you to
- 16:00a model so persist that I no longer need to look at you.
- 16:06The question that all of this opened is, is the person you
- 16:11love still for you a misery? Or have you already turned them
- 16:16into something you believe you fully know and they're forced to
- 16:21stop watching? I would like to share a story.
- 16:25Maybe you know a couple like this.
- 16:27Maybe the couple is yours. David and James have been
- 16:32together for 22 years. They made young, but when begin
- 16:36together costs more than today, when there was less to explain
- 16:41and more to defend. They build a life, a home, a
- 16:46routine, a way of loving each other that with the ears grew as
- 16:51familiar as path from the bed to the bathroom in the dark.
- 16:56And for a while now, both of them feel the same thing,
- 17:01thought neither says the worst to the other.
- 17:05That's something cooled, that they no longer see each other
- 17:11the way they used to, that they become efficient partners in
- 17:15shared enterprise, the bills, the house, the plans, the family
- 17:20they built. But that the thing from the
- 17:25start, the fire, that attention, that look at each other, faded
- 17:30slowly, with no exact date, with no fight to explain the fading.
- 17:37What happened is that each one built across 22 years a model of
- 17:43the other so persists that each one stopped looking.
- 17:48David's brain predict James with no need to see him.
- 17:52James brain predicts David with no need to look.
- 17:57Each one lives for years, not with the real person beside him,
- 18:02but with a model of that person that froze at some point along
- 18:07the way. And update less and less and
- 18:11less. And meanwhile, the two real
- 18:14people, the real David, the real James, keep changing in silence,
- 18:19with no model of the other registering the change, because
- 18:24the model was already closet, Because for the brain the
- 18:28predictable goes and watch it, we cannot know everything.
- 18:33Each one of them keep inside these ears.
- 18:36Maybe James develops new fears, he never name it.
- 18:40Maybe David health desires he could not name it either.
- 18:45Maybe both of them grew in direction, the other never
- 18:49noticed because the other already believed he knew.
- 18:54Now the scientists describe the mechanism what they actually
- 18:57leave, only they know if they dare to ask each other.
- 19:02And one ordinary night, maybe through a conversation that is
- 19:05started by accident, maybe through a question they had no
- 19:09ask at each other other in years.
- 19:13James say something that David did not expect, something
- 19:17outside the model, an idea, a fear, a desire, a memory David
- 19:22had no file for. And for one second, Davy fails
- 19:27to see James, the usual one, the one I already know.
- 19:33For one second, Davy sees a person, real, present, with an
- 19:39inner life that had grown invisible to him.
- 19:43A stranger again after 22 years. And there only there, my
- 19:50friends, something returns. A crack of the prediction error,
- 19:55a surprise, a flash of what was there at the start.
- 20:02Not because James turned into someone else, Because David for
- 20:07one instant stopped looking at this model and look it at the
- 20:12person again. The question David and James
- 20:15leave, and maybe leave for you, is not how do I keep love from
- 20:21cooling? The question is another one,
- 20:26more uncomfortable and more hopeful at once.
- 20:32How many times did the person you believe you fully know try
- 20:37to show something new and you fail to see because your model
- 20:43have already decide who they were?
- 20:47As a customary on this channel, I will leave you with three
- 20:51tools, but today with a clarification that matters.
- 20:55These tools would not give you back the falling in love of the
- 20:59start that face, the building of the model with no return and no
- 21:06returning is fine. It's just fine.
- 21:09Trust me. What these tools can offer is
- 21:12something deeper than falling in love.
- 21:16Help to see again the real person that in some way you stop
- 21:23it. Looking at tool #1 break the
- 21:27prediction on purpose. The brain stop watching what the
- 21:31brain predicts. So we have to make the person
- 21:35unpredictable on purpose. This is a good strategy.
- 21:39Do things with the person you love that fall outside the
- 21:43script no to rekindle the frame the way that the magazine says.
- 21:49So the pass on Instagram says do something more concrete to
- 21:55generate prediction error, which is the only thing that ranges
- 22:01the brain. Attention new places
- 22:04conversation. You never have question you
- 22:07believe were already answered. When you break the predictable
- 22:12context, your brain has to compute the person again to look
- 22:16at 10 and new, because the old model no longer suffice.
- 22:23Well tool #2 the question that assume is you do not know.
- 22:28Once a week ask the person you love a genuine question from the
- 22:33assumption that you have no idea what the answer will be.
- 22:38No, how was your day that that one you know already has a model
- 22:43answer something real? Try with something very honest
- 22:48and real like. Is there something you have been
- 22:52thinking about lately that you have not told me?
- 22:57Has anything changed in what you want this past while?
- 23:03What part of you do you feel I no longer see?
- 23:08And then the hard part. The hard part for you is this.
- 23:14Listen to the answer without completing the answer in your
- 23:19head before the person finish it.
- 23:22Your brain will want to predict what they will say.
- 23:26Refuse the prediction, stop it, hold the tension.
- 23:30Wait for the real person, no for the model of them.
- 23:36Tool #3 see it like it's new. Even after 1000 times, once a
- 23:43day, look at the person you love for a few seconds as if you
- 23:47didn't know them, as if you have just see them suspended for the
- 23:52instant everything you believe you know about them.
- 23:56This is an exercise of perception, no, of feeling.
- 24:00You are forcing your brain out of the model.
- 24:03I already know what it is and back into the model.
- 24:07I'm seeing someone new. You will discover some of the
- 24:13time details you had no registering years.
- 24:17An expression, a gesture, something that the mother had
- 24:21cover and you cannot see anymore.
- 24:25What you see in those seconds, that is the real person.
- 24:28The rest, the everyday version, is in large part your
- 24:33prediction. I want to close this episode
- 24:37with honesty because I opened this episode with a hard claim
- 24:41and I don't want to leave you in the cold.
- 24:45The hard claim is true in large part.
- 24:48You love your model of the other.
- 24:50You build a person, you predict them, You fabricate the emotion
- 24:55you love them with and across the ears.
- 24:58You make them so predictable that you stop seeing them.
- 25:03This is real and uncomfortable, and neuroscience and philosophy
- 25:06agree on the point. But here is the other side, the
- 25:11side that matters, That love begins a construction carried no
- 25:16implication, that love stays trapped there.
- 25:20The point is something else. Mature love is not the love that
- 25:24feels the egg stronger. Mature love is the love that
- 25:28chooses to see. The falling in love of the start
- 25:32was easy. That was what your brain builded
- 25:37a model at high speed, free dopamine, no merit in the
- 25:40process. The hard love, the real love, is
- 25:44the love that appears afterward, when the model is already
- 25:48complete. When stopping, the looking will
- 25:51be saved. Too easy, and you still choose
- 25:55every day to see the real person behind your prediction of them.
- 25:59Han will say that loving for the real is restoring the other's
- 26:03condition as a mystery, letting the others stay other,
- 26:09different, surprising, never fully know, instead of reducing
- 26:14them to the comfort of reflection of what you need them
- 26:19to be. The cure for the agony of love
- 26:23is no to feel more. The cure is to look better.
- 26:27The cure is to tolerate that person you have slept beside for
- 26:3222 years remain in some corner, someone who have no finish it
- 26:38knowing. And that farm from cold is the
- 26:42highest front of respect. There is to keep seeing the
- 26:48other as a universe that no model of yours will ever
- 26:52exhaust. The question I'll leave you with
- 26:56today are three and their question.
- 26:59Carrie, wait, who are you actually loving?
- 27:03The person beside you or the model of them you assembled a
- 27:07year ago and stopped updating? How many times did the person
- 27:13you claim to fully know try to show you that they had changed
- 27:19it and you failed to see because your prediction have already
- 27:22decides who they were? And are you willing to do the
- 27:27hardest things? Love us not to feel more, but
- 27:31stop looking at your model long enough to see for the real the
- 27:36person in front of you. Well, well, well.
- 27:40We're deep today my friends. If this episode made you
- 27:44uncomfortable and then left your a door open, share this episode
- 27:48with someone who is loving a model and missing a person.
- 27:53Maybe, maybe the information helps them to look again.
- 28:00If you are not subscribed yet, please subscribe to Neuromotion
- 28:03Live Podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcast or Amazon Podcast.
- 28:08And you help me to produce more episodes.
- 28:12OK, well this was narrow motion Lab podcast.
- 28:17My name is Fabian Ernesto Gida and remember, maybe you never
- 28:22loved the person you love it the model your brain build of them
- 28:27and the real love is no doubt model.
- 28:30The real love is what happens the day you dare to let the
- 28:35model go and you see for the first time in years, the person
- 28:41beside you see you in the next episode.
- 28:44Bye.