Latest / The Make More Placements Show for Recruitment & Search Business Owners | More Placements | Higher Fees | Less Work | Fewer Headaches | / # 402 The Cost Of Staying The Same
Transcript
- Drew Edwards: Today's subject is the cost of staying the same. Your fees are never an expensive number. The client is just comparing the wrong number. And your job is to change the number to compare it to. So look, let's just recap what we covered. ⁓ three weeks ago, Mike covered about raising your standards, ⁓ about raising standards and mastering your mastering your state. We talked about ⁓ no longer selling and what to do instead, changing how your clients think. And this week is about that pays off in money. You change one number in the client, the the one number the client uses a judge your fee. Right, every time a client tells you this, ⁓ your fees are too high, they're comparing it to one of two numbers. And both of them are wrong. And that's what we're gonna fix today. When a client says your fee's too high, they're measuring it against the cost of doing nothing or a cheaper, cheap, cheaper agency elsewhere. So when I when a when a client says your your fees are too high, I'm gonna repeat that. ⁓ the measuring against two things. ⁓ the cost of doing nothing or the cheaper to agency of i.e. going elsewhere. And if you're in that situation, most recruiters lose on both. Either let the client believe that doing nothing is free, or they sit there defending the fee against some recruiter that's cheaper. If you're doing that, it's a losing game. Just to recap, guys, if you can turn your mics off, please. ⁓ a few of you got your mics off, you can turn your mics off. I think it's deaf, you turn your mic off. Yep, apologies for that. you'll never ever win by trying to defend your number. You will win by changing the number that compare it to. The expensive thing is not your fee. The expensive thing is the wrong outcome. That that job will go unfulfilled and the whole job ⁓ and what that's costing the business. When a client pushes back on your fee. So in the last month when the client pushed back on your fee, which number were they really comparing it to? Z doing a think or a cheaper cheaper agency? Because the move is different for each one. So the whole idea of this is one idea, two leaks. The cost of staying the same is always bigger than your fee, whether the client's doing the thing or buying cheap. So you're not in the business of filling roles. You're in the business of stopping leaps. And there are two links, leaks rather. The leak one is the empty, the vacancy, the empty seat, and leak two is the cheap gamble. And often the hiring manager's got those two options. Same principle and use both. But let's start with, ⁓ do you know what, Mike? What you say is true, and we do need to find an executive for this role. ⁓ but let me just sit think about it. I think And when I say that, just I want you to think of a dripping tap. One drip is nothing. You walk past it, you do not call the trumpet plumber for one drip. So it keeps dripping day after day after day. And at the and the bill at the end of the quarter, it's enormous. And the vacancy is exactly like that. Each day, it looks survivable. The team covers, the manager picks up the slack, deal sits through, but nobody panics. No single day feels like a crisis, so nobody fixes it. That's the trap. Your fee is the plumber's invoice. It looks like a cost, but it's actually stopping that that leak. Now the second leak leak and the one that most recruiters lose out onto, when the client says, ⁓ done, that's great, but you're a lot more expensive than the agency down the road. And then you if you then try and defend that, you're agreeing that you're comparing light to light. But you're not selling the same thing. Because the cheapest would should win. The client is being completely rational if it's exactly the same thing, but it often isn't. So the guidance to you is refuse to do that comparison. What you want to do is break the idea that you and the chief agency are saying the same thing because you're not. A cheap contingent recruiter working on that role with five other recruiters is being paid to be fast, not to be right. They send volume CVs resumes through and hope that one of them sticks. They carry no risk when it fails. You work it exclusively and you're accountable for who actually gets fired. Fee level buys behaviour. A low contingency buys a race to send the quickest CBL stroke resume. A higher retain a higher a higher retained fee guys, focus, exclusivity. If it's retained, you're gonna do the research to find those candidates that are not actually looking ⁓ looking for their next role, but would probably respond favourably to a phone call from a head hunter. And most importantly, the client's looking the client is working with a recruiter who's got some some got some risks involved in in getting this right. The client is not choosing between fees, they're choosing between results and chance. Wanna repeat that? The client is not choosing between fees, they are choosing between results and chance. Gonna give you a practical example. About 18 months ago, I went to get a car, get a new car, and the dealership were keen to talk to me about buying an EV, and I had no intention of buying mine. Why would I do that? I then started complaining about, yeah, I've heard all about. What they call it, sorry just a meant to talk. You have this fear that you won't have enough charge on your battery to get home. There's a proper name for it, ⁓ but I can't think what it is now. And he said, but you're comparing a petrol through EV. It isn't the same. I said, yes, it is. He said, no. He said, think about it. Whatever car you drive, most of the time you're not in the car. Most of the time you're not driving it. So you've got plenty of time to charge it. He said, but people aren't comparing light for like. And I thought, that's a fair point, actually. Eventually I ended up buying ⁓ electric vehicle, though I had no intention at the time. But what he did is he got me to stop comparing the light for like. An EV with a petrol isn't a light for light. And you don't make the comparison. A cheaper recruiter to you isn't a light for like. So and and I want to share with you how to sort of make the cost real. Cost of the I'm gonna use the term empty seats or the cost of the of the vacancy. What does that person produce or pro or protect? Put a weekly number on that. Lost spillings, a manager doing the their manager doing two jobs, the project not moving. I I mentioned before I worked in IT, so recruiting. So I would talk to the IT director about the impact of this project, not having the right team in place to ensure these IT projects are delivered on time to a budget. The cost of the wrong hire. The fee gap between you and the cheaper and the cheaper agency is is probably not a great deal of money in the higher in the scheme of things. But a bad hire costs three times the salary to unwind, plus the lost time, because you've got to start all over again. These are the questions you should be asking the hire manager. What's the cost of a failed cheap process? If a cheap gamble did not work, that weekly leak leak Keeps running while they start from zero. The saving on the fee evaporates in a fortnight because they went for the cheapest. Then get them to talk about the numbers out loud. So what what's what's it costing you per week for this vacancy being open? What's the downside of the wrong hire? What if you do hire with one of the cheaper recruiters so you get the C B or resume really quick, but it doesn't work out because you went for speed rather than quality? Almost every single time your fee is smaller than the number. In terms of the f the ⁓ of the in in that room. So it's different now. Think of one live role on your desk right now. Do you actually know what it's cost that client every week it stays empty? Do you know how much it's costing that client every week? It stays empty. If you don't know, would it be worth asking that question, the next job order you pick up? Some of you here, Mike and ⁓ Don, I know you were you remember a lady we used to work with called Jenny in the UK. ⁓ so we worked with her about four or five years ago, good operator. Well, two stories about Jenny. Before she joined us, she sent out an email. This is just, I think it was just after COVID, Matt, saying that she would undercut any other recruiter out there. One of the reasons she joined us, because she sent out this email to her list of prospects saying she will undercut any recruiter out there. And I think two hiring managers came back and said, If you're operating purely on price, I don't want nothing to do with you. And that forced her to contact us because she said, I don't know what to do. I thought everybody bought on price, but they don't. ⁓ but she learned that she learned the lesson that people don't buy on price. But she shared a story with us. She had this brilliant candidate for a finance role at a family run manufacturing company. I think their turnover is about four million. But the client client stalled and stalled and kept saying to Jenny, we're not in a rush. Let's see who else is coming through. And then out of blues, she got a text message saying, Jenny, another agency's quote us half your fee. So we're leaning that way. And and Jenny sent me a message the next day saying, I don't know what to do, Derry. I thought people don't buy on price. Because my my reaction now is to drop my fees down to fifteen percent and beg for this business. But I said, look, just let's just talk it through. And do these two things in another. First, refuse to be compared to the other person, to the other recruiter. She did not defend her fee at all. She simply said, You're right. I am not the cheapest. And if this other recruiter puts account the same candidate through for the role, then you must use them. But I'm curious. How many agencies are working on this role and trying to fill it? And it turned out there were four other companies working on it. Contingent, no exclusivity. And then Jenny said, So you're they're being paid to be fast, not right. Have I got that right? And they goes, Well, no, not right. She goes, but you're you're whoever gets the C V C the quickest is who you're gonna go with. And she they went, Well, yeah, I guess so. She says, Well, it's speed then rather than anything else. So they're gonna send you a stack of CVs and hope that one sticks. But here's the thing. If you qualify, and note that language by the way, if you qualify to work with me. It will be exclusively. I will not share the top candidates with your direct competitors. And I am accountable for who you hire. See what she's doing? She's not comparing the two fees. She's comparing the chance and the result. And then Jenny asked this question. In this finance role that is empty, who's doing the finance role right now while this while this role is empty? And it turned out that the finance director was doing two jobs, some days working until nine o'clock, and already created two errors that slipped through them last quarter. What Jenny did, she did the mass of the call out loud. She did, your finance director's with about 110,000 and spending half his wheat below his pay grade. That's about eight hundred eight hundred a week of t his time wasted. That's more than two grand a month. Just let that sink in. And the client went quiet. And the client has said this, Jenny, how soon can you help us fill this role? And she won it on the retained. The client went from f ⁓ I think it was fifteen percent to twenty-two percent. Jenny found the candidate in three weeks and the offer was made within six. But she didn't compete on price. She didn't win on the fee. She didn't defend her fee once. She won because she refused to be compared like for like. And then she made the cost of getting it wrong greater than the cost of not working with her. Truth about all this, you're not losing on fee. You're losing because you let the client compare you to the wrong number. And you've never challenged it or corrected it. You let doing nothing look like free, or you sat there justifying your fee against somebody who's cheaper than you, which just confirmed you were both saying the same thing. So the moment you start doing that, you're acknowledging, you're saying at some level, yeah, we're the same. But we're we're we we we ⁓ we're just a bit more expensive. The client who feels the real cost, who understands you're not the same as the cheap agency, doesn't haggle. They just ask you to move faster. So here's the challenge for you. If you can't put a number on what that vacancy is costing the client, and if you cannot say in one sentence while you're not the same as the same as any other is a cheaper recruiter, then you're a commodity and you're going to lose out on price. And again, I want to repeat this. If you cannot put a number on what that vacancy is costing the client, and you cannot say in one sentence, why you're not the same as all the cheaper recruiters out there, then you become a commodity. And you're gonna lose out purely on price. So I want you to make a note of this challenge. On your next role or job order that you get, do not send out a single C V throat resume until you've done two things. One, work out or establish the weekly cost of that vacancy. This is the important bit and get the client to admit it out loud. And and so they understand that you're not saying the same thing as a is a cheap option. In the current roles you've got right now, your clients right now, how many of your clients actually understand the the cost of getting this filling this role incorrectly? Because it's your job to make them understand that. And the way that you get them to understand it, and we talked about this last Thursday, is it's about the questions that you ask. This week, don't and going forward, stop defending your fee. When the fee comes up as a comparison, you change the number they're comparing against. If they're comparing you to nothing, well, we're gonna sit on this for a couple of weeks, a couple of months. You make that you make that look really expensive. How much did it cost if you don't build this for another three months? Example. What's the typical notice period that these candidates are on? ⁓ the problem about a month. Yeah, that's right. So even if you make an offer today, they can't join you until ⁓ the third week of July, is that right? Well yeah. Can you afford to wait that long? What impact's gonna have on you? So they join the third week of July, they probably won't hit the ground running until the middle of August. Can you afford that? They're the questions that you need to be asking. My fee is never the cost. The outcome the wrong outcome is. That's where the cost is. My fee's just the investment. You get this wrong. That's where the cost is. Well the repeats. The best recruiters never argue about fee, they change what the client is measuring again. So look, as we wrap up, here's my message to you. Stop defending your fee. Change the number that they're comparing it to. Make the wrong outcome the only expensive thing in the room. Because that's all that matters. And the moment you're gonna do that, you're gonna get less resistance to your fee. Until next time, folks, take care, take action, be relentless, folks.