Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Late-Stage Tech Companies Are Buying Back Employee Shares Before IPO
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this quiet thing happening in late-stage tech that most people don't notice until they're inside one of these companies. Private startups — think Stripe, Databricks, even SpaceX — are spending hundreds of millions, sometimes billions, buying back shares from their own employees before the IPO ever happens. Luna: And that's different from the old model where employees had to wait until lockup expiration, right? Lucas: Completely different. The traditional playbook was: you join a startup, get stock options, work for years, the company goes public, and then you wait six months for the lockup to expire before you can sell a single share. Now, companies are offering tender offers — basically, 'we'll buy your shares now, at a price we set, before we even file the S-1.' Luna: Why would they do that? It costs them cash they could otherwise keep for growth. Lucas: A few reasons. First, retention. If employees have a massive paper gain tied up in private stock, they get antsy. They want liquidity. If the company doesn't offer it, they might leave and join a competitor who does — or they push for an IPO before the company is ready. Second, it lets the company control the narrative around valuation. When Stripe did its latest tender offer earlier this year — a $2 billion buyback at a $70 billion valuation — it effectively set a floor for what the stock is worth. That signals to future IPO investors: look, insiders just transacted here. Luna: So it's like a mini price discovery event before the real one. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just Stripe. Databricks has done multiple tender offers. SpaceX does them regularly. The pattern is spreading because companies are staying private longer — the average time from founding to IPO is now over eleven years, up from about four in the late nineties. Employees can't wait a decade to cash out even a little. Luna: But isn't there a risk? If a company buys back shares at a high valuation and then the IPO prices lower, employees could feel like they got the short end. Lucas: That is the tension. Look, we've seen it happen. Take Rivian — they went public at seventy-eight dollars in 2021, and today it's trading around eighteen. If you participated in a pre ipo tender at a higher price, you took a loss relative to what you could have waited for. But the counterargument is: you had cash earlier. You diversified. Many employees are overconcentrated in a single stock — their paycheck and their net worth are tied to the same company. Luna: So it's a liquidity tool disguised as a benefit. Lucas: Right. And companies are getting more sophisticated about the mechanics. They often use third-party administrators to run the tender, set a window, and let employees decide what percentage of their vested shares to sell. Some limit the total dollar amount per employee to avoid concentration risk for the company's cash position. Luna: What about the signal to the public market? If a company is buying back shares pre ipo, does that make the eventual IPO more credible or less? Lucas: I think more credible, generally. It shows the company has confidence in its own valuation — they're putting real money behind it. Compare that to a company that never offers liquidity and then goes public at a price that surprises everyone. The buyback creates a known reference point. When Airbnb went public in 2020, they had done a tender offer earlier that year at around thirty dollars — the IPO priced at sixty-eight, but the tender gave long-term employees a chance to take money off the table. Luna: So it's not just for the company's benefit — it's actually a retention tool that aligns incentives. Lucas: Exactly. If you're an early engineer at a company that's been private for eight years, and you have options worth a couple million on paper, but you can't touch any of it, you're going to feel trapped. The tender offer turns paper into cash. And studies show that employees who sell some shares in a tender are actually more likely to stay — they feel rewarded and less anxious about the company's future. Luna: That's counterintuitive but makes sense. You give them some cash, they're less likely to bolt for a higher salary elsewhere. Lucas: And the company avoids a mass exodus right before the IPO roadshow, which would be a disaster. So the buyback is a retention expense, not just a capital allocation decision. Now, the scale is getting bigger. Stripe's $2 billion buyback is the largest I've seen for a private company. Other unicorns are following suit. Luna: Which brings up the question: how do they fund these buybacks? They're not public, so they can't issue debt easily. Lucas: They use cash from operations, or they raise a new round that includes a secondary component — where investors buy shares directly from employees rather than the company. That's become common in late-stage rounds. For example, when a company does a Series F, the round might include a hundred million for the company and fifty million for employee liquidity. That way, the company isn't depleting its own cash. Luna: So the investors are effectively buying out the employees. That changes the power dynamic — now the VCs own more of the company pre ipo. Lucas: It does. And it can dilute existing shareholders if not structured carefully. But many employees are happy to sell at a known price rather than gamble on the IPO. There's also a tax advantage: if the company buys back shares, employees can pay capital gains tax on the sale, whereas if they exercise options and hold, they might owe alternative minimum tax on the spread. Luna: So it's a win-win in many cases, but there are losers too. What about the IPO underwriters? Do they care about these buybacks? Lucas: They do, because the buyback price becomes a benchmark. If the IPO prices below the tender price, the employees who sold feel smart, but the new investors might feel they overpaid. Underwriters want a clean price discovery process. So they often advise companies not to do tenders too close to the IPO — at least six months gap is typical. Luna: That makes sense. Timing is everything. Lucas: And we're seeing this trend accelerate because of the current market. Look at the ARK Innovation ETF — down three and a half percent over the last five days. The IPO window is not exactly wide open. So companies are using buybacks as a way to keep employees patient while they wait for the right moment to go public. Luna: So the buyback is a substitute for the IPO in some sense — it provides liquidity without the volatility of being a public company. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just the mega-cap private companies. We're seeing this at earlier stages too. Some Series C companies are doing small tender offers for early employees. The concept is spreading down the stack. Luna: Alright, let's take a quick step back here — something I think about often. We do this show every week, deep dives into tech IPOs and capital markets, and it's ad-free. The reason is that a small number of listeners support us through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's literally what makes this sustainable — no sponsors, no pressure to hype anything. Lucas: Yeah, and we love doing it. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or investing in, that's the whole point. And the listener support keeps it independent. Luna: Exactly. So if you've been meaning to chip in, that's the place. Now, back to pre ipo buybacks — let's talk about the legal side. Lucas: Sure. There's a regulatory angle. The SEC has rules about what private companies can disclose during a tender offer. They have to provide some financial information, but not the full prospectus required for an IPO. So it's a lighter touch. However, if a company does a tender and then later files for IPO, the SEC will look at whether the disclosures in the tender were consistent with what's in the S-1. Luna: So there's a consistency risk. If you tell employees one valuation and the public market another, you could have legal exposure. Lucas: Right. Companies have to be careful. That's why many tender offers are priced at a discount to the most recent financing round — it gives a cushion. For example, if the last round was at $100 per share, the tender might be at $85. That way, if the IPO prices at $90, employees who sold aren't upset, and the company looks conservative. Luna: It's a balancing act. Too low and employees won't sell; too high and you risk the IPO pricing below the tender. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the art comes in. Some companies use a Dutch auction format where employees bid how many shares they want to sell at various prices, and the company sets a clearing price. Others just set a fixed price. The trend is toward more transparency — companies are sharing more financial data with employees to help them make informed decisions. Luna: That's a big cultural shift. Traditionally, startups kept financials very close to the chest. Lucas: It is. But when you're asking employees to make a life-changing decision about whether to sell stock, you need to give them information. Some companies now hire financial advisors to counsel employees during tender windows. It's becoming a standard part of the pre ipo process. Luna: So what's next? Do you see this replacing the traditional IPO entirely for some companies? Lucas: No, I don't think so. The IPO still provides a permanent liquidity mechanism and a currency for acquisitions. But the pre ipo buyback is becoming a necessary feature for companies that stay private for a decade. It's like a pressure valve. If you don't offer it, you risk losing talent. So it's here to stay. Luna: And for investors, it's another data point to watch. If a company does a large tender, it tells you something about their confidence and their cash position. Lucas: Right. And it's one more reason why the IPO process is evolving. The old model of 'private until you're ready to go public' is giving way to a hybrid model where companies gradually transition from private to public, with liquidity events along the way. It's healthier for everyone, I think. Luna: Interesting. Thanks, Lucas. That was a great look under the hood. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And thanks to everyone listening. We'll be back next week with another angle on the changing face of tech IPOs.