Latest / Blue Leader Nation Podcast / Episode 22: When Leaders Go Silent
Transcript
- Ed Pallas: A supervisor walks out of the command staff meeting. Nobody knows what happens, but everyone can tell something happened. The supervisor is quiet, short answers, no eye contact, walks a little faster than usual, doesn't stop to talk, and does not explain anything. And within about 10 minutes, the squad starts writing its own story. Did someone complain? Is somebody getting transferred? Is the command staff mad at us? Is this about that call from last week? Nobody knows. But that doesn't stop the story from growing because when leaders go silent, people write their own story. And under pressure, that story is usually worse than the truth, especially with cops. We don't fill in the gaps with sunshine and rainbows and unicorns. We fill in the gap with cheating and adultery and violence. Today we're going to talk about one of the most underrated leadership skills there is: clarity. Not having every answer, not pretending to know more than you know, not talking just the talk, clarity. Because in leadership, silence is not always neutral. Sometimes silence creates anxiety. But sometimes silence creates rumor. Often it creates distrust. And sometimes the most calming thing a leader can do is say simply, hey, here's what we know, here's what we don't know, and here's what we're going to do next. Welcome back to Blue Leader Nation, real talk for the next generation of law enforcement leaders. I'm your host, Ed Palace. Thanks for spending part of your day with me. Gonna enjoy a little coffee out of my new Penn State mug, sporting my new, well, old Penn State shirt. That's right. Our youngest, we're gonna be moving her into Penn State shortly. For all you Penn State alum, we are. For everybody else, just have a little sympathy for me for the tuition bills, because that's now two kids. Are going to or have graduated Penn State. All right, let's get into this. Over the last few solo episodes, we've been building a leadership conversation around pressure. We talked about the tactical pause. We talked about setting the emotional weather. We talked about stress contagion and the emotional footprint leaders leave behind. Today I want to take the next step because if leaders transmit emotions, leaders also transmit meaning. Your people are not only reading your mood. They're trying to understand what your mood means. They're trying to figure out what changed. They're asking themselves, what does this mean for me, for the team, for tomorrow? For my schedule? How about the immediate future? If you do not help people understand what something means, they're going to create their own meaning. And this is where rumors begin. This is where trust starts to take a hit. So today's episode is called When Leaders Go Silent, People Write Their Own Story. And the big idea is simple. You don't need to have every answer to lead well. But you do need to communicate with honesty, consistency, and clarity. Silence is not always neutral. Now, there are times when silence is wise. There are times when you should wait until facts are confirmed. And there are times when you cannot share certain information because it involves personnel issues or an investigation or even a legal matter. So I'm not saying leaders need to announce everything the moment they hear it. That's not leadership. That's group text with rank. And nobody needs that. But what I am saying is unexplained silence creates space. And that space is going to get filled. Sometimes with truth, but more often with rumor. And almost always with emotion. Police officers especially do not like uncertainty because the job teaches you to scan for risk. Officers are trained observers, they notice tone and pacing. They notice when a supervisor is suddenly acting different. They notice when someone says, we'll talk about that later, and then later never comes. And once people notice change, they start trying to explain it. That's human nature. The problem is when there's no clear explanation, people build their own. And under stress, the story people build rarely stays calm and reasonable. One person says, I heard there might be staffing changes. The next person says, I heard they're moving people. And then the next person says, I heard they already made the list. And then by the end of the shift, someone is mentally packing up their locker. all because there was an information vacuum. And leadership left it open too long. Here's the mechanism underneath that. Your brain is constantly trying to predict what comes next. That's one of the ways it keeps you safe. It compares today to yesterday, notices what changed, and tries to answer the question: what does this mean? When information is missing, the brain does not politely wait for confirmed facts. It starts filling in the blanks. And under stress, those blanks usually get filled in with threat. Are you getting the message? That's why a vague email from a boss can ruin someone's morning. Stop by my office when you get a chance, has raised more heart rates than most workouts. The boss probably just wants to ask you about a report, but the employee is already reviewing every mistake they've made since 2009. And in calls for service, court, staffing shortages, public scrutiny, and unclear leadership, communication becomes one more thing officers have to manage on top of everything else. That's mental bandwidth they don't have for the mission, for decision making, or for each other. That's why clarity is not a soft skill. Clarity is an operational skill. Now, clarity does not require certainty. Here's where leaders sometimes get stuck because they think I can't say anything because I don't have all the answers. I understand that. There are moments when you cannot give the final answer. When the decision hasn't been made, where information is sensitive, but clarity does not require certainty. There are these different things. Certainty says, I know exactly what's going to happen. Clarity says, here's what I know, here's what I don't know, here's what matters right now, and here's what we're going to do next. People can handle uncertainty better when the leader is clear about the uncertainty. You don't have to pretend. You don't have to overpromise. You can simply say, I don't have the full answer yet, but here's what I can tell you. That decision has not been made. Or for now, nothing changes. Or I'll update you by the end of the next shift. If you hear something that doesn't sound right, bring it to me instead of letting it grow in the hallway. That kind of communication tells people the leader is paying attention. And it tells them they're not being ignored. It tells them they didn't have to invent a story because someone is willing to provide the frame. And that's leadership. Poor communication is expensive, not always in dollars, but in trust and credibility and energy. Every time your people have to guess what matters, you're spending that trust. Every time they hear important information from the rumor mill. Before they hear it from leadership, you're spending credibility. And once credibility gets spent, it takes time to earn it back. That's why some leaders struggle, even when their decisions are technically correct. The decision might be fine, the communication around the decision is what creates the damage. A schedule change may be necessary, a transfer may be necessary. But if people feel surprised, dismissed, or left in the dark. The emotional response becomes bigger than the actual issue. Now the leader has two problems the original decision and the distrust created by poor communication that came with it. The second problem is avoidable. People do not agree. They don't need to agree with every decision, but they need to know what matters, what's expected, when more information is coming. Once people believe information is being managed to protect leadership while leaving the team guessing, trust drops fast. And when trust drops, correction gets harder, change gets harder. Even simple directions can get filtered through suspicion. And that's a tough way to lead. So let's make this practical. If silence creates stories, leaders need a simple way to communicate under pressure, not a complicated model, just a quick framework you can use before a briefing, before a difficult update, before any moment where people need clarity. I call it the CLEAR Briefing. C L E A R. Because you know I like acronyms. CLEAR. C. Control the tempo. Before you give the message, regulate the room. And before you regulate the room, regulate yourself. If you rush in, talk too fast, or sound irritated. People will read that. Trust me, I've done it. Way more than I care to admit. Communication begins before words. Slow down, stand still, use a steady voice. Do not let urgency become panic. Urgency says, this matters, and we are moving. Panic says, I'm not in control of myself, and now everyone else should be nervous too. Leaders need urgency, but without panic. Before you communicate, ask yourself what emotional pace am I setting? Because your pace gives people information. So that was C. L, label what is known and unknown. This is where leaders build credibility. Say what you know. Say what you don't know. Don't fake certainty. Do not fill in space with guesses. Just because people are pressuring you for the answer doesn't mean you should make something up. A good leader can say, here's what we know right now, here's what we do not know yet, and here's what hasn't been decided. Also, here's what I can and can't discuss. People usually can handle I don't know yet. What they struggle with is vague, slippery, half-communication that sounds like leadership is trying to avoid the question. There's a difference between confidentiality and evasiveness. Good leaders learn how to be careful and clear at the same time. All right, the E in clear is establish the priority. When people are uncertain, they need to know what matters most right now. Not everything, the priority. A leader brings the team back with this is what matters today. This is what I need you to focus on. This is not something you need to act on yet. The last one is important. Sometimes clarity is telling people what not to focus on. Not every rumor deserves oxygen. Not every future possibility needs to become today's anxiety. Help people put their attention where it belongs. Alright, C L E A, assign the next action. Clarity becomes calm when people know what to do next. If all you do is explain the problem, people may still leave anxious. But if you explain the problem and give the next action, you create movement. Continue with your current assignments or document everything related to this issue. Or send questions to your chain of command. Or Hold any schedule questions until Friday when we have an updated plan. Direction lowers anxiety. People may not love the situation, but at least they know what to do. Officers are action-oriented. They do better when they understand the mission, the boundaries, and the next step. All right, the last one in the clear model is R. Return with updates. This is the step leaders forget. They communicate once, they move on. But the team is still living with the uncertainty. If you say you're going to update your people by Friday, update your people by Friday. Even if the update is, I told you I would update you today, and I do not have a final answer yet, but I haven't forgotten. Here's where things stand. A no updates yet update is still an update, if that makes sense. It tells people you remembered and that they don't have to chase you for information. Consistency is calming, not because every update is good news, but because people know leadership will come back. Let's make this real. First, an internal investigation rumor. A supervisor might say, I know there are rumors going around. I'm not going to discuss personnel issues, and I'm not going to speculate. What I can tell you is this is not a squad wide issue. Keep doing your job, stay professional, and if anything affects your work, I will tell you directly. Doesn't violate confidentiality. It does not lead to rumor. It gives people a frame. Second, after a critical incident, here's what we know. Here's what we do not know. Here's what I need from each of you right now. Don't speculate. Don't freelance information. Refer questions to the designated point of contact, whoever that would be. We will update as facts are confirmed. One of the best examples I saw of this was probably 2009. I was in Athens, Clark County, Georgia, teaching a leadership class. And Chief Lumpkin came into the class and said, Hey, Ed, can I interrupt you for a second? I said, Of course, Chief, it's your class. There had been an officer involved shooting the night before at a trailer park. And Chief Lumpkin came in, pulled up a chair right in the middle of the group, said, Hey, this is what we know. And he gave information on the facts of the shooting. Here's what we don't know. There are still things to be investigated. And that he would update them each day I can't recall all the details, but I do recall by him doing that, he essentially squashed the entire rumor mill. Without saying it, he said it was a good shooting. Without saying it, he said the officer was going to be fine. And without saying it, he said. Don't make this anything more than it really is. I thought it was a great example of leadership. That kind of communication steadies people. It protects the investigation, the agency, the officers, and the truth. Because in the absence of truth, speculation starts doing push ups. And speculation is annoyingly fit. Like what I did there? That was yeah. Okay. Hey, before we continue, a quick note for anyone who's listening who's preparing for a promotion process. If your exam, oral board, or assessment center is coming up within the next four months, I'm putting together a police promotion challenge. It's a short, focused coaching experience built to help you stop studying everything and start preparing with a plan. This isn't a course or a webinar, it's a private set of coaching sessions. Just you and me. Working through your specific process. We'll organize your prep, work on how to think like the next rank, and build how you answer promotion questions with structure and confidence. This one's really for someone whose process is close, If that's you, check the link in the show notes or reach out to me directly. Also, it's time for your dad joke of the episode. You know, for years. They've been talking about getting rid of the US penny. And they finally did. I guess some people are just afraid of change. All right, now back to the episode. One mistake worth naming here, over-explaining. Some leaders try to reduce anxiety by giving every detail, but too many details can create more confusion. People need the frame first. What happened? What does it mean? What matters now? And what do we do next? Details can come later. The other mistake is communicating once and then disappearing. That's the return with updates piece again. If the issue continues, the communication needs to continue. Your team shouldn't have to wonder whether leadership forgot about the thing everyone else is still talking about. Think about the leaders you trusted most. They probably were not perfect communicators. I mean, nobody is, but I bet you knew where you stood with them. I bet you knew they would come back with updates. Now think about the leaders who created anxiety. Sometimes it wasn't because they were bad people, it was because you never knew what they were thinking or whether silence meant nothing. Or everything, and that wears people down. Leadership silence can become emotional noise. The room may be quiet, but people's minds are blowing up. They're interpreting, guessing, defending, wondering. A clear leader quiets that noise, not by having every answer, but by giving people enough truth to stand on. Let's bring this down to one minute, the pressure-proof minute. Before your next briefing or difficult update, pause and ask yourself five questions. What do people need to know right now? What do they not know yet? What fear or rumor might fill the silence? What is the next clear action? When will I update them again? That's the pressure proof minute. Five questions, a clearer message, a calmer team. Now the weekly challenge. Here's my challenge for you this week. Pay attention to where silence may be creating stories. Ask yourself, where have I left people guessing? What updates have I delayed because I don't have the full answer? Then close one information gap. Just one. Have the conversation. Send the update. Tell people when they can expect more. Silence is not qualified. It has no training, no rank, and it is a terrible follow-up strategy. Close the gap. All right, let's close this out. When leaders go silent, people write their own story. That doesn't mean you have to talk constantly or share things you shouldn't or have every answer, but it does mean you have a responsibility to communicate clearly when people are looking to you for meaning. Your silence may feel careful to you. It may feel confusing to them. The next time something happens and you're tempted to go quiet, ask yourself what story people might write if I didn't help them understand that moment. Then give them what you can what we know, what we don't know, what matters now, what happens next, and when they'll hear from you again. That's leadership. Thanks for spending part of your day with me on Blue Leader Nation. If this episode was helpful, share it with another leader. Especially someone who's leading through uncertainty right now. And if you're a supervisor listening to this, remember your people don't need you to know everything. They need you to be honest and steady. They need you to be clear. Until next time, keep leading with integrity, keep investing in your people, and don't let silence write the story for you. I'll see you next time on Blue Leader Nation. Stay safe.