Latest / The Horsehuman Connection Matrix / How much do cattlde understand? What is their social structure?
Transcript
- 0:03This is the Horse Human Connection, a captivating podcast where we extend into the world of equine assisted learning, horse training.
- 0:12and gentleness in working with these magnificent creatures.
- 0:18Captivating stories from the leading professionals and ordinary people alike unravel novel ideas in being with horses.
- 0:26The Horse Human Connection is an idea, a place, and a voice.
- 0:32The idea is to support the quiet revolution and recognize the intelligence and true nature of the horse.
- 0:40The place is a destination farm near the Umpqua Forest and River that slows down visitors and patrons enough to experience the shift.
- 0:49The Voice is this podcast.
- 0:52Welcome to today's episode.
- 1:04Samson Q2U Microphone-4: Welcome to the horse human connection podcast.
- 1:09Samson Q2U Microphone-4: This next episode is about cows, not horses.
- 1:14Samson Q2U Microphone-4: But before I realized what horses were all about.
- 1:17Samson Q2U Microphone-4: I realized it because I realized about the cows.
- 1:21Samson Q2U Microphone-4: And having this herd of mixed cows that later were bred with black Angus bulls.
- 1:27Samson Q2U Microphone-4: To produce a black Angus herd was one of the most incredible experiences of my life.
- 1:32Samson Q2U Microphone-4: It happened over about a six year period.
- 1:35Samson Q2U Microphone-4: And the cows taught me what was to come with the horses.
- 1:39Samson Q2U Microphone-4: So I hope you will enjoy this.
- 1:43MacBook Air Microphone: I lived on a ranch mostly by myself.
- 1:46MacBook Air Microphone: It was 206 acres.
- 1:48MacBook Air Microphone: In about the middle of Southern Oregon.
- 1:51MacBook Air Microphone: Somehow I decided to raise black Angus cattle kind of on purpose and kind of by accident.
- 1:57MacBook Air Microphone: When you have a ranch with that much grass, something's got to eat it.
- 2:01MacBook Air Microphone: Could be the deer and the elk, but it made sense to get some cows.
- 2:06MacBook Air Microphone: So I ended up buying some cows from a neighbor out there and he gave me a piece of advice.
- 2:12MacBook Air Microphone: He said, talk to your cows when you feed them, walk amongst them and talk to them.
- 2:16MacBook Air Microphone: So they know your voice so you can call them in.
- 2:19MacBook Air Microphone: That was the beginning.
- 2:21MacBook Air Microphone: That was the best advice I could have gotten from the old doctor liquidating the herd of 16 mixed cattle.
- 2:29MacBook Air Microphone: So I'd had a cower too before with my ex-husband on the 10 acres that we'd had.
- 2:35MacBook Air Microphone: And now I had 16 cows on 206 acres, and there was plenty of feed.
- 2:39MacBook Air Microphone: I wasn't going to have to buy any feed.
- 2:41MacBook Air Microphone: There was plenty of water.
- 2:43MacBook Air Microphone: And as I look back on it, the way I describe it, as I became a Taoist cattle rancher.
- 2:48MacBook Air Microphone: Now I'd had horses before, but I'd never done any roping or, or any cowboy things that go with cattle.
- 2:56MacBook Air Microphone: And I didn't have any horses currently.
- 2:59MacBook Air Microphone: So my method of.
- 3:02MacBook Air Microphone: getting in these cows to cooperate with me was largely my voice in a bucket of grain.
- 3:08MacBook Air Microphone: And I got pretty good with the voice and I, I took the doctor's advice and when I did feed them, I walked among them.
- 3:15MacBook Air Microphone: I tried to touch them black Angus cattle.
- 3:17MacBook Air Microphone: Don't really like to be touched.
- 3:18MacBook Air Microphone: So they're not warm, fuzzy.
- 3:20MacBook Air Microphone: Going to be your friend kind of animals.
- 3:23MacBook Air Microphone: Because I know you're going to eat them one day.
- 3:26MacBook Air Microphone: But I did walk among them and I did get to know them.
- 3:30MacBook Air Microphone: And.
- 3:32MacBook Air Microphone: I would lay down when there were calves so that they wouldn't be afraid and they'd come investigate me.
- 3:36MacBook Air Microphone: And sometimes they'd lick my long sleeve black or sniff about my legs and my feet.
- 3:42MacBook Air Microphone: And they were really a joy to me.
- 3:44MacBook Air Microphone: Cows have a very.
- 3:46MacBook Air Microphone: Distinct social order.
- 3:48MacBook Air Microphone: They have a lead cow who's in charge.
- 3:51MacBook Air Microphone: And they have conversations with each other.
- 3:54MacBook Air Microphone: And I am 100% convinced that they communicate with pictures in their minds.
- 3:59MacBook Air Microphone: And there are a couple of doctors.
- 4:01MacBook Air Microphone: Who study herd animals who agree with me?
- 4:04MacBook Air Microphone: But I realized this long before I read what those doctors.
- 4:09MacBook Air Microphone: Had to say.
- 4:11MacBook Air Microphone: So, what are the cows stories is I had some help.
- 4:15MacBook Air Microphone: Trying to rope and band and vaccinate some of the calves.
- 4:21MacBook Air Microphone: I had teenagers at the time boys and they had friends and so they got together and one of them knew how to rope and somehow, or another, we got these cattle on the ground and got the little machine with the band and, and the vaccines.
- 4:33MacBook Air Microphone: And I was able to do that part.
- 4:37MacBook Air Microphone: We had the calves caught up in about a hundred by a hundred foot fenced pen.
- 4:42MacBook Air Microphone: And the mamas were on the outside.
- 4:45MacBook Air Microphone: And one of the mamas was a first time mom.
- 4:48MacBook Air Microphone: And her calf was in there and she was throwing a fit.
- 4:54MacBook Air Microphone: Her calf got separated when we let the others loose and it was stuck in there by itself.
- 5:00MacBook Air Microphone: And it took some time to get that calf out of there.
- 5:04Samson Q2U Microphone-2: I used a technique that I learned from reading and watching.
- 5:08Samson Q2U Microphone-2: A horse trainer named Monty Roberts.
- 5:11Samson Q2U Microphone-2: He's the one that's credited with the language of Equis.
- 5:16Samson Q2U Microphone-2: And he learned that by watching wild Mustangs in Nevada.
- 5:20Samson Q2U Microphone-2: Oh, When he was a very young man.
- 5:23Samson Q2U Microphone-2: He learned a lot about horse behavior.
- 5:25MacBook Air Microphone: Licking and chewing is part of what Monte Roberts uses to.
- 5:31MacBook Air Microphone: Train animals.
- 5:32MacBook Air Microphone: It's a sign he looks for.
- 5:34MacBook Air Microphone: So I use this looking and chewing.
- 5:36MacBook Air Microphone: Imitating an animal.
- 5:39MacBook Air Microphone: Who is a Grazer by looking at shoeing and moving my jaw side to side instead of up and down.
- 5:44MacBook Air Microphone: And I must've looked quite crazy doing it.
- 5:47MacBook Air Microphone: But the minute I started doing this, not looking at the little calf.
- 5:51MacBook Air Microphone: I'm using my body language to not square off to him, but my shoulders to the side.
- 5:56MacBook Air Microphone: And looking and licking and looking down.
- 5:59MacBook Air Microphone: When I did this, that calf trusted me suddenly.
- 6:01MacBook Air Microphone: I was not a predator.
- 6:03MacBook Air Microphone: I was another herd animal and he trusted me and I was able to get him out the gate and reunited with the mom.
- 6:09MacBook Air Microphone: Meanwhile on the outside of the fence.
- 6:12MacBook Air Microphone: This mama, this new mom has been having this very loud conversation with the lead cow.
- 6:17MacBook Air Microphone: And in my imagination, the conversation was something like this.
- 6:22MacBook Air Microphone: How could you possibly let that happen to our babies?
- 6:24MacBook Air Microphone: Let them by the humans, without us there to protect them.
- 6:27MacBook Air Microphone: I will never trust you again.
- 6:31MacBook Air Microphone: And I think that this is the conversation that they had and I.
- 6:35MacBook Air Microphone: You know, give me some leeway here with imagination because.
- 6:39MacBook Air Microphone: Although I may be a little clairvoyant at times.
- 6:42MacBook Air Microphone: I don't know for sure that that's what I was reading, but here's what happened afterwards to make me think that.
- 6:48MacBook Air Microphone: That mama did not let that calf out of her sight, away from her side until it was over a year old.
- 6:57MacBook Air Microphone: I know this because I would follow the cows around sometimes because I did daily meditations with them in their wanderings.
- 7:05MacBook Air Microphone: I know that the hierarchy of the herd and the social structure included a babysitter like.
- 7:12MacBook Air Microphone: Th this is what most, most cattle will do.
- 7:14MacBook Air Microphone: Is they'll pick a babysitter to stay an adult cow, to stay with the babies while the mamas can, can make a wider circle and expand out a little bit to get better grass and to graze while the babies are all in one place.
- 7:29MacBook Air Microphone: Well, with my particular herd, I had one, it was a very mixed herd to begin with.
- 7:33MacBook Air Microphone: And there was one cow with horns.
- 7:35MacBook Air Microphone: And yeah, if you don't know anything about cattle, a lot of people think that bulls or mail cattle are the only ones with horns, but actually it's a breed thing.
- 7:44MacBook Air Microphone: And so within a breed, both the males and females will have horns and less genetically they don't.
- 7:49MacBook Air Microphone: And that's called polled in that gets real complicated.
- 7:51MacBook Air Microphone: But anyways, the cow with the horns is the one.
- 7:55MacBook Air Microphone: That was in charge of the babysitting.
- 7:57MacBook Air Microphone: When they were like zero to a month old when they were most vulnerable, the lead cow put the.
- 8:03MacBook Air Microphone: The cow best equipped to protect the babies with the horns to be the babysitter.
- 8:08MacBook Air Microphone: And and then it would switch off as I got older.
- 8:14MacBook Air Microphone: So.
- 8:16MacBook Air Microphone: That's how I know.
- 8:18MacBook Air Microphone: That this new mama.
- 8:20MacBook Air Microphone: Was having that type of conversation with the lead cow because she never allowed her calf to go with the babysit group.
- 8:26MacBook Air Microphone: She took that calf, With her all the time.
- 8:29MacBook Air Microphone: And the interesting thing about calves is when they are told to sit still.
- 8:35MacBook Air Microphone: To stay in one place.
- 8:36MacBook Air Microphone: They listen so much better than at least my human children did.
- 8:40MacBook Air Microphone: You stay there and they stay.
- 8:43MacBook Air Microphone: And that was demonstrated in another one of my cows stories, where I had this neighbor who used to help me run them through his shoot.
- 8:51MacBook Air Microphone: He had one of those fancy round shoots designed by Temple Grandin.
- 8:54MacBook Air Microphone: And you know what the blind.
- 8:55MacBook Air Microphone: Shoot at the very end in the circle.
- 8:57MacBook Air Microphone: And if you don't know about Temple Grandin and cattle, it's a fascinating story.
- 9:02MacBook Air Microphone: She's one of the doctors that talks about herd animals.
- 9:06MacBook Air Microphone: Communicating in pictures.
- 9:08MacBook Air Microphone: Anyway.
- 9:09MacBook Air Microphone: There's a great movie about her as, as a side note there, but this other cow story.
- 9:14MacBook Air Microphone: So we were running the mamas through we managed to get half of them through the gate on the side of the cattle guard.
- 9:21MacBook Air Microphone: And somehow the baby's turned around and we lost him and we eventually got the rest of the herd through.
- 9:29MacBook Air Microphone: Without the babies.
- 9:30MacBook Air Microphone: So the babies were told to stay upon this little Knoll, not too far from the cattle guard.
- 9:35MacBook Air Microphone: And the rest of the cattle were sent over to the neighbors, which I moved them with.
- 9:41MacBook Air Microphone: Whoops.
- 9:41MacBook Air Microphone: And yell ups and actually kind of this belly dance call that I think comes from maybe Morocco, where you.
- 9:49MacBook Air Microphone: I don't even know what it's called, but it's like, ah, And that's the noise that I would use to move my cattle, to scare bears and coyotes away and whatever else I needed to do that was loud on this 200 acre ranch.
- 10:05MacBook Air Microphone: So, yeah, I was probably known as the crazy yodeling cow lady out there by myself, but I learned a lot.
- 10:13MacBook Air Microphone: And I feel like what I learned was important.
- 10:16MacBook Air Microphone: And it's important enough to be telling you a story about it.
- 10:19MacBook Air Microphone: Anyhow.
- 10:20MacBook Air Microphone: So the cattle got run through the shoot.
- 10:23MacBook Air Microphone: Designed by temple Grandin and operated by my nice neighbor.
- 10:28MacBook Air Microphone: and I came back first.
- 10:31MacBook Air Microphone: Without the cows, we left them over there for some reason, for a little while I came back.
- 10:37MacBook Air Microphone: With the babies.
- 10:38MacBook Air Microphone: Oh, I know I had a helper and they were bringing, the cattle back.
- 10:40MacBook Air Microphone: So I went back to find the babies and I sat with, I call them babies, the calves.
- 10:45MacBook Air Microphone: I sat with the calves on this Knoll.
- 10:47MacBook Air Microphone: They didn't let me get real close.
- 10:48MacBook Air Microphone: Like I said, black Angus cattle are not real touchy, feely critters.
- 10:52MacBook Air Microphone: But I sat with them.
- 10:55MacBook Air Microphone: And they got to know me and I chewed sideways and made a point of not looking them in the eye.
- 11:01MacBook Air Microphone: And pretty soon the other cattle came back directly to their calves where they had left them, where they knew they would be because when a mama cow tells her baby to stay, it does.
- 11:10MacBook Air Microphone: And when they found me there, they stopped.
- 11:13MacBook Air Microphone: They stopped in their tracks and they looked at me and they looked at the calves.
- 11:17MacBook Air Microphone: And I will tell you from that moment on, I was in, I was part of that herd.
- 11:22MacBook Air Microphone: I was an honorary member.
- 11:25MacBook Air Microphone: Have a black Angus cattle herd.
- 11:30MacBook Air Microphone: That led to some other things.
- 11:32MacBook Air Microphone: There was another incident where There was a baby calf who was wedged in this drainage canal to the Creek.
- 11:39MacBook Air Microphone: The property had some Hills.
- 11:41MacBook Air Microphone: And on a south slope, there were several places where there were Springs along the south slope and they would come down and they would form canals as they got closer to the Creek.
- 11:48MacBook Air Microphone: And this particular little canal was maybe Maybe 20 inches wide.
- 11:53MacBook Air Microphone: And about three feet deep, two and a half, three foot deep.
- 11:58MacBook Air Microphone: And it was surrounded by that bunch grass that grows in wetlands.
- 12:02MacBook Air Microphone: It's actually a reed, I think.
- 12:04MacBook Air Microphone: Anyway, it can get really thick.
- 12:07MacBook Air Microphone: And this calf was stuck and we were up on the hill building something and somebody come down a couple of times for tools and materials and kept telling me, oh, there's a calf down there.
- 12:15MacBook Air Microphone: I heard it balling, but I just thought it couldn't find it small.
- 12:19MacBook Air Microphone: And I wasn't paying a lot of attention.
- 12:21MacBook Air Microphone: Finally, she went down there.
- 12:21MacBook Air Microphone: She said, you know, I think.
- 12:23MacBook Air Microphone: I think something's wrong.
- 12:25MacBook Air Microphone: And she described the situation to me.
- 12:26MacBook Air Microphone: She said, there's this mama cow and a and a bull.
- 12:30MacBook Air Microphone: So the bull was like he was like a little more than a yearling and he had been the offspring of that particular cow that was waiting there with the calf.
- 12:38MacBook Air Microphone: And it was, that was the mom of the calf, as well as the calf was wedged.
- 12:42MacBook Air Microphone: In this area so that its head was barely ground level.
- 12:48MacBook Air Microphone: And I came upon them.
- 12:51MacBook Air Microphone: And the rest of the herd had moved off and it was just the mom and the brother that were there.
- 12:56MacBook Air Microphone: And I came upon them and I was like, oh, what am I gonna, how am I going to get this calf out?
- 12:59MacBook Air Microphone: You know, I looked at the situation and.
- 13:02MacBook Air Microphone: I had a Bobcat and I thought, why come over here with the Bobcat and dig it out?
- 13:06MacBook Air Microphone: But that would just terrify the poor creature.
- 13:09MacBook Air Microphone: So I investigated a little bit more carefully.
- 13:12MacBook Air Microphone: And I was able to get in there on my hands and knees and move some of the brash and touch the calf.
- 13:18MacBook Air Microphone: As soon as I touched the calf.
- 13:20MacBook Air Microphone: The mother and brother walked off to join the herd.
- 13:23MacBook Air Microphone: It was as if they were saying she's got this.
- 13:25MacBook Air Microphone: we got her attention.
- 13:26MacBook Air Microphone: She'll handle it.
- 13:27MacBook Air Microphone: We trust her.
- 13:28MacBook Air Microphone: We can go now.
- 13:30MacBook Air Microphone: And that's what they did.
- 13:31MacBook Air Microphone: They went off and joined the herd and left me to deal with the problem.
- 13:34MacBook Air Microphone: Well, luckily.
- 13:35MacBook Air Microphone: The wedge was mostly created by this bunch grass.
- 13:39MacBook Air Microphone: And so by pulling the grass back, And kind of giving the calf a little bit of a motivation to move forward.
- 13:47MacBook Air Microphone: He was able to move forward and then jump out on his own.
- 13:51MacBook Air Microphone: But it was quite an interesting experience to be.
- 13:54MacBook Air Microphone: I called upon to help.
- 13:57MacBook Air Microphone: And trusted to that degree.
- 14:00MacBook Air Microphone: As soon as I made contact with the calf.
- 14:04MacBook Air Microphone: There's another story that comes to mind.
- 14:07MacBook Air Microphone: I didn't always live at the ranch when the cattle were there.
- 14:09MacBook Air Microphone: Sometimes I would visit once a month with grain and the grain was mostly to say, hello.
- 14:14MacBook Air Microphone: It's not like they needed the food.
- 14:15MacBook Air Microphone: And one bag split between anywhere between 16 and at one point 34 head of cattle is what I had.
- 14:21MacBook Air Microphone: You know, isn't really a supplemental feed.
- 14:23MacBook Air Microphone: It's a treat.
- 14:25MacBook Air Microphone: But it was enough that they knew when they heard my car to come running from wherever they were on the 200 acres.
- 14:30MacBook Air Microphone: And that's the kind of cows I had.
- 14:34MacBook Air Microphone: So this one day I had arrived and I was going to do some hiking and I set up off the hill where the trail was and the mama cow, the lead cow.
- 14:44MacBook Air Microphone: Came after me balling.
- 14:46MacBook Air Microphone: Oh, she was making such a fuss and this is not normal.
- 14:48MacBook Air Microphone: Behavior was just her.
- 14:49MacBook Air Microphone: It wasn't anybody else.
- 14:51MacBook Air Microphone: And she got in front of me a couple of times as if to block my way up there.
- 14:55MacBook Air Microphone: And when I kept kind of going around her and make her way up the hill, she followed me for a while.
- 15:00MacBook Air Microphone: Balling the whole time.
- 15:02MacBook Air Microphone: Finally, she gave up.
- 15:04MacBook Air Microphone: And went back.
- 15:06MacBook Air Microphone: So my destination was a Knoll at the top of the property with a lot of Oak trees.
- 15:11MacBook Air Microphone: And it's quite steep at the top.
- 15:13MacBook Air Microphone: When I.
- 15:15MacBook Air Microphone: Got almost to the top.
- 15:17MacBook Air Microphone: Something made me stop.
- 15:18MacBook Air Microphone: I heard something wrestling in the bushes and I thought it was deer.
- 15:22MacBook Air Microphone: I thought they were just some deer up there.
- 15:24MacBook Air Microphone: So I stopped and approached more cautiously, more slowly, more quietly.
- 15:29MacBook Air Microphone: And and then I saw what was happening.
- 15:32MacBook Air Microphone: One of the cows was giving birth up there.
- 15:36MacBook Air Microphone: And the mama cow had been asking me to leave them alone.
- 15:39MacBook Air Microphone: So I did that as soon as I saw what was happening, I turned and I went back down.
- 15:46MacBook Air Microphone: But if anybody thinks that cows don't communicate, if cows don't have an advanced social structure, if cows don't know.
- 15:53MacBook Air Microphone: What's in your mind and your heart, I'm telling you they're wrong.
- 15:57MacBook Air Microphone: And I know this is really upsetting.
- 16:00MacBook Air Microphone: For cattle ranchers.
- 16:02MacBook Air Microphone: People don't want to think this.
- 16:03MacBook Air Microphone: They don't want to know this.
- 16:04MacBook Air Microphone: We don't want to think that our food.
- 16:07MacBook Air Microphone: Has that kind of consciousness.
- 16:09MacBook Air Microphone: But it does.
- 16:13MacBook Air Microphone: It certainly does.
- 16:15MacBook Air Microphone: In fact, there was a moment with this neighbor.
- 16:18MacBook Air Microphone: Where he was helping me with the cows and he had some helpers and we had all my cows in a big pen.
- 16:24MacBook Air Microphone: That had the ability to be split into two.
- 16:27MacBook Air Microphone: Cause that's helpful for that sort of thing.
- 16:30MacBook Air Microphone: And his helpers were in there, like kind of prodding my cattle with electric cattle prods.
- 16:35MacBook Air Microphone: And I was like, what are you doing stops?
- 16:37MacBook Air Microphone: Do you don't need to do that?
- 16:38MacBook Air Microphone: Stop that.
- 16:38MacBook Air Microphone: What are you trying to do here?
- 16:40MacBook Air Microphone: And he said, well, what do you want to do?
- 16:41MacBook Air Microphone: And I said, well, let's separate them and run the moms through first.
- 16:46MacBook Air Microphone: So I jokingly, like this was about midway through some of the Cal stories that I just told.
- 16:52MacBook Air Microphone: So I didn't feel like.
- 16:54MacBook Air Microphone: My perceptions about my relationship with the cows was really cemented.
- 17:01MacBook Air Microphone: But it was good enough.
- 17:02MacBook Air Microphone: And I did this as a joke.
- 17:05MacBook Air Microphone: At first, but I got up there.
- 17:08MacBook Air Microphone: And I did my my thing to get their attention, which was to move like a cow.
- 17:12MacBook Air Microphone: I did that a lot.
- 17:13MacBook Air Microphone: I did a lot of imitating animals, and so I imitated this moon.
- 17:17MacBook Air Microphone: Got their attention.
- 17:18MacBook Air Microphone: They all stopped was when you put them in a pen, they do two things.
- 17:21MacBook Air Microphone: They mill in circles.
- 17:23MacBook Air Microphone: Which is what temple Grandin's like circle thing is based on.
- 17:27MacBook Air Microphone: And they make a lot of noise cause they don't know what's happening and why they're caught.
- 17:31MacBook Air Microphone: So when I got up on this fence and I mood.
- 17:34MacBook Air Microphone: They all stopped and looked at me.
- 17:37MacBook Air Microphone: And that was probably enough to make the neighbor and his hands.
- 17:41MacBook Air Microphone: Drop their jaws.
- 17:44MacBook Air Microphone: The thing I did next.
- 17:46MacBook Air Microphone: And again, I say I was half joking when I did it.
- 17:48MacBook Air Microphone: I didn't expect it to happen.
- 17:50MacBook Air Microphone: I said mama's over here and baby's over there and motioned to the two opposite ends of this rectangular pen.
- 18:01MacBook Air Microphone: And they did it.
- 18:03MacBook Air Microphone: And these men looked at me like I was a witch and they started calling me the cow whisper.
- 18:11MacBook Air Microphone: The fact that.
- 18:13MacBook Air Microphone: I had exposed cattle to be intelligent.
- 18:17MacBook Air Microphone: Loving interactive creatures.
- 18:20MacBook Air Microphone: Was probably too much for their world of raising them for
- 18:23Samson Q2U Microphone-3: Come to the horse human connection.
- 18:27Samson Q2U Microphone-3: This podcast is mostly about horses.
- 18:29Samson Q2U Microphone-3: So though it's about asking questions and answering questions, and I have to include the stories about the cows because before there were horses, there were cows.
- 18:40Samson Q2U Microphone-3: And that's where my awareness of herd animals began.
- 18:46Samson Q2U Microphone-3: So onward with the cows stories.
- 18:51MacBook Air Microphone-4: So this podcast is about.
- 18:56MacBook Air Microphone-4: Horses.
- 18:59MacBook Air Microphone-4: And more than horses, but it.
- 19:04MacBook Air Microphone: beef
- 19:07MacBook Air Microphone-2: When our belief systems become challenged.
- 19:14MacBook Air Microphone-1: Especially the belief systems that drive our behavior or our financial livelihood..
- 19:19MacBook Air Microphone-1: Either.
- 19:20MacBook Air Microphone-1: We have to make a shift.
- 19:21MacBook Air Microphone-1: We have to acknowledge new truths.
- 19:24MacBook Air Microphone-1: Or.
- 19:27MacBook Air Microphone-1: We just can't hear it.
- 19:29MacBook Air Microphone-1: And I think what happened is they had so much invested.
- 19:32MacBook Air Microphone-1: They just couldn't hear it.
- 19:34MacBook Air Microphone-1: And so eventually I became the bad guy.
- 19:38MacBook Air Microphone-1: The messenger.