Latest / Newcomer Pod / Newcomer Turns Four
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Eric Newcomer. And I am Madeline Rinbarger.
- 0:04And this is the newcomer podcast.
- 0:10Each week, Eric and I discuss the VC deals and the drama that
- 0:14went down. Let's do it.
- 0:16Here we go. Let's dive in.
- 0:19You You took a long weekend. Was this part of your American
- 0:22concert tour? Yes, this is this is part of the
- 0:25the Madeline's American concert tour.
- 0:27I was in I was in Denver to see Charlie XCX and Troy on the
- 0:30sweat tour and then made it to the Sabrina Carpenter Short and
- 0:33sweet tour this past weekend on the East Coast.
- 0:35So, you know, wow, you never. In in the zeitgeist, which which
- 0:40did you prefer? Oh, great question.
- 0:42They're very different. I feel like the the the Charlie
- 0:47show, Charlie and Troy Sivan easily hire energy.
- 0:50It was, you know, just it was they sold out an arena tour.
- 0:54It was huge. It's.
- 0:55Like a party based, it's a. Party it's it's and it's all
- 0:58dance music. So you're just you're up the
- 0:59whole time just dancing. And then Sabrina obviously very
- 1:03dancy as well, pop music, but you know, you get some slow
- 1:06songs, you get some kind of typical you get the flashlights
- 1:09out, you got a wave, you know, to the ballads, but and she's an
- 1:13edible vocalist. I I was really blown away.
- 1:16So you know. We're both like pop pop girlies,
- 1:20I guess, because I I've seen Taylor Swift in Stockholm and
- 1:25Boston. So I'm I'm more specifically a
- 1:27Taylor Swift fan, but. Yeah, Eric is our resident
- 1:31Swifty on the pod. But how?
- 1:34Wait, so you went to the Era's tour twice?
- 1:36Yes, yeah. Which date?
- 1:38Which date was better? Boston was like a nightmare.
- 1:41We made a last minute decision to arrive and we hit traffic and
- 1:45it was. No stuff over.
- 1:47Nightmares. So Stockholm, we were like, we'd
- 1:49been in Paris for a couple weeks working abroad and then yeah,
- 1:53that was great. So definitely Stockholm was we
- 1:57also like spent all day waiting in line and we're like the
- 2:00second row. Basically, that's amazing, yeah.
- 2:02It's great so. Cool.
- 2:03Yeah. So you got to go international
- 2:04for your concert tours? Yeah.
- 2:06I know, yeah. Anyway, we this is going to be a
- 2:09fun episode overall because it's a lot of talking about
- 2:11ourselves. So we get to reflect on
- 2:13Newcomers 4 year anniversary. It's true.
- 2:17This is This week marks the four year anniversary of the
- 2:20newsletter. Yeah, you've been here for one
- 2:22year of it. Just about just shy.
- 2:25Yeah, I think when I joined, we were around, you know, just over
- 2:291,000,000 in revenue and now we've more than doubled that.
- 2:33Congratulations. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:35Congrats to all of us. Yeah, I, I sort of announced
- 2:39somewhat impulsively on stage at a media conference called the
- 2:43Amo Summit that we'd hit. We're on track to hit $2,000,000
- 2:47in revenue this year. We're going to cross that
- 2:50between revenue we've already recorded and the committed
- 2:53contracts we have for Cerebral Valley.
- 2:56So very exciting. And we're gonna post post new
- 2:59job openings and yeah. Stay tuned.
- 3:02It's crazy. You know, I'm always in denial
- 3:04that Newcomer is a company, even though it's like, oh, we have
- 3:08many, several employees this time and lots, if you start
- 3:11counting up all the people who, you know, work for us in some
- 3:14capacity is getting bigger and bigger.
- 3:16Certifiably company. I mean, the moment we moved to
- 3:18Slack, you know that that felt. More a real I know, a sad day.
- 3:23But also exciting day. I mean, yeah, I'm, I'm curious.
- 3:27I mean, we've, I know we've talked about it a bit, but what
- 3:30is what's the story behind founding newcomer?
- 3:32I mean, when did you make the decision to to leave and go
- 3:35independent? Yeah, so I, I launched it in
- 3:40October 2020 during the pandemic and covered startups and venture
- 3:44capital. And here I see finally a trend
- 3:46that applies to me, right Sub stacks, you know, coming up,
- 3:50it's an opportunity to start your own business.
- 3:53So that was really exciting to me.
- 3:55I think I launched like I can't, it was right around the New York
- 3:58Times trend story. So I was either right before,
- 4:01right on top of Yeah, I think you were.
- 4:04I was ahead. You were ahead of the curve.
- 4:07Please give. Yourself some credit.
- 4:11And the other piece of it was that, you know, when I left the
- 4:15information, the two places I was thinking about going were
- 4:20Gawker and Bloomberg, you know, Valley Wag.
- 4:23And, you know, I went with Bloomberg and, you know, it was
- 4:26just like a pretty conservative direction.
- 4:28And I definitely wanted, well, not to be like, mean and snarky,
- 4:32like Valley Wag. I wanted, you know, some of the,
- 4:35like, voicey, sort of first person writing, you know, I'd
- 4:38really come up through traditional newspaper
- 4:41internships and wanted some, you know, more bloggy, I guess, type
- 4:46experience. And I was very jealous of, you
- 4:50know, Ben Smith's column in The New York Times at the time where
- 4:52he was really doing great reporting but writing with his
- 4:56perspective. And that's really what I tried
- 4:58to emulate when I started Newcomer.
- 5:00How do you feel like the media environment's changed since
- 5:03starting Newcomer? I mean, I feel like this sort of
- 5:06voicy perspective is much more popular and you were a
- 5:09trendsetter in this, but how has it changed?
- 5:12What have you seen? Yeah, I mean, I clearly, you
- 5:17know, well, you know, big advocate of the collision
- 5:20between the influencer and the journalist and journalists are
- 5:24clearly realizing that they have to compete with influencers.
- 5:29I think, you know, even at Bloomberg, after I left, Mark
- 5:31Gurman, their Apple reporter has been allowed to have a much
- 5:36freer reign to sort of give his own personal opinions about
- 5:39devices and everything. So even sort of my old employer
- 5:43I think has chilled out a little bit.
- 5:46It seems like our. Competition is not as much, you
- 5:48know, other publications themselves as it is also, you
- 5:51know, like TikTok and personalities and hosts on these
- 5:54kind of social platforms too. Right.
- 5:55I mean, tech Twitter and yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 5:58It's not clear that if they're not reading, you know, I think a
- 6:01lot of our readers are fit us into what, I don't know, reading
- 6:05pirate wires and cobbling together information from
- 6:09Andreessen Horowitz podcasts and sort of a mix of alternative
- 6:13media. Leaving an established
- 6:15publication, I mean, even, you know, nowadays, but especially
- 6:18four years ago, was a pretty big risk in the media world.
- 6:22I mean, what made you want to take that leap?
- 6:26Well, yeah, literally the day I had to tell my editor that I was
- 6:29quitting, I like, chickened out on the first call and my now
- 6:32wife had to be like, do it, you know?
- 6:34So, I mean, at least you can always be like, oh, I need a
- 6:37better plan. I haven't decided what day I'm
- 6:39going to launch, you know, whatever.
- 6:42I mean, my my, you know, wife and friends were extremely
- 6:46supportive. So I think that helps.
- 6:49I mean, I do credit sub stack for making it sort of much
- 6:52easier to see a path to doing this thing.
- 6:55They did not offer me the pro program.
- 6:58They offered me like a tiny advance that I thought wasn't
- 7:02worth it. So, so, yeah, I mean, it was
- 7:06just sort of felt like I wanted to take the leap.
- 7:10I do think it helped that it was the pandemic.
- 7:12So the cult of the workplace was, you know, much diminished.
- 7:16You're not going in to an office.
- 7:19And I was really hungry just to write for our audience, you
- 7:24know, and to write directly for startups and VCs.
- 7:26I mean, I always, I think often about covering the Zenefits saga
- 7:31where Parker Conrad was ousted and just how like, you know, I
- 7:36sort of wanted to write the counter narrative to the zenfit
- 7:39story. But as a reporter for a big
- 7:42outlet, you know, you sort of have to write, I don't know, the
- 7:451st order story. Anyway.
- 7:47I, I, and I had like, you know, I, I wrote my unauthorized
- 7:53story, The Unauthorized History of Andreessen Horowitz.
- 7:56Or some I forgot. What I Yeah, the.
- 7:58Unauthorized history. Of Andrews and Horowitz, yeah.
- 8:00You know, I, I had these pieces sort of that I was hungry to
- 8:04write that I felt like, you know, Bloomberg doesn't love
- 8:07like the sort of media self absorption, which obviously I
- 8:10lean into here. And so, yeah, I felt free to do
- 8:15the meta story. And, you know, it was just
- 8:16exciting. And I felt like, you know, I'd
- 8:19be able to get another job if it all blew up in flames.
- 8:22You know, we talked about, you know, influencer journalism and
- 8:24the rise of this trend, right? But it seems like, you know,
- 8:27there's this kind of fascinating thing going on in the media
- 8:30environment where the the very biggest are succeeding, like New
- 8:33York Times size publications and then the very smallest seem to
- 8:39be succeeding. You know, there's there's us,
- 8:41there's platformer, you know, Taylor Lorenz just launched her
- 8:44own sub stack user mag. But then there's kind of the the
- 8:48messy middle right where that seems to be where the biggest
- 8:51fallout in the media industry has been coming from.
- 8:54And I'm curious, just how have you been thinking about that?
- 8:57As you know, we am I. Growing the same mistake many
- 9:01companies have made before. I think it's a great question.
- 9:05To me, the issue with a lot of companies is they lose sight of
- 9:11who their customer is. When I launched, you know, one
- 9:15of the refrains I always has, I don't want to explain who like
- 9:18Bill Gurley is anymore. You know, it just felt like
- 9:20every Bloomberg article, there would be sort of a sort of
- 9:23parenthetical phrase, you know, early Uber, investor, whatever.
- 9:26When I was a Business Insider, it was always like we had to
- 9:29write out LP parentheses. Limited partner, which does.
- 9:32This, you know yeah, exactly exactly that so I we wonder we
- 9:37want to write for the insider and I have absolutely no
- 9:40intention of moving away from that.
- 9:42Really what I'm saying is the customer that I saw when I
- 9:45launched we still like are under penetrated in that market and
- 9:49then there's much more we can do to serve them with events or
- 9:53whatever. So it's less like, oh, now that
- 9:56I have a foothold with one audience, I'm going to go go go
- 9:59to a broader audience. I think that would be a big
- 10:01mistake. Like I think what I want to do
- 10:03is have every VCV obsessed with newcomer and subscribed and
- 10:08have, you know, great stories that they care about an event
- 10:10that they can go to. And then I don't know, maybe
- 10:13someday data or something else, but I'm extremely focused on the
- 10:16same customers. I think there's obviously an
- 10:19opportunity to continue monetizing them.
- 10:22And I think the mistake would be if I drifted to a broader
- 10:26audience and started chasing clicks or something like that,
- 10:30that that would then end up hurting me with my, my core
- 10:33audience. And so I think what a lot of
- 10:35these publications do is they lose sight, You know, they just,
- 10:38they get big enough that they're like, oh, we need to go after
- 10:40more people. And I, I would not want to get
- 10:43so big that I would ever think, oh, start up founders and
- 10:47venture capitalists aren't enough for us.
- 10:49And so I think as long as there's plenty, plenty of money
- 10:52and attention to to be gobbled up in that area, then we can
- 10:56hire more people. Knowing your customer always a
- 10:59good strategy. I mean, I know it's the Amazon
- 11:01customer obsession, you know, customer obsession.
- 11:03And I think the thing I've continued to learn is like,
- 11:07actually, you know, what good reporters do is they talk to
- 11:10their sources. They're in our, you know, our
- 11:12sources are our customers. So I'm talking to our customers.
- 11:16That means that, you know, I can get them to speak at events or
- 11:19sponsor events. And, you know, it's relationship
- 11:22building and understanding the world we inhabit.
- 11:25And so I think those things are actually much more symbiotic
- 11:30than, you know, I didn't go to journalism school.
- 11:32I knew I wanted to be a journalist, but then my
- 11:34perception of journalism school would be like, ah, separate, you
- 11:38know, the business and the media arm.
- 11:39And I think what we've discovered is that as long as
- 11:42you're sort of honest and transparent, you know, and
- 11:47thinking about your customer, both in your coverage decisions
- 11:51and how you monetize makes makes a lot of sense.
- 11:54And so we're going to continue to lean into that.
- 11:56I, I got into reporting because, you know, I want to learn a lot
- 12:00about the world. It's sort of like fast way to
- 12:02sort of insist that people answer your questions.
- 12:05I think one thing that sort of surprised me is that building a
- 12:08business is sort of another way of learning about how the world
- 12:12works because you're sort of like, oh, why do business,
- 12:15especially when you cover business, you're like, oh, why
- 12:17do business people do XY and Z? And, and so, yeah, it's fun.
- 12:20It's fun to learn about the world this way too.
- 12:24And you know, I want to keep doing doing both.
- 12:27What do you see for the next year going forward with
- 12:30Newcomer? First and foremost, you know our
- 12:32North Star will always be great writing and reporting in the
- 12:36newsletter. I do think that is sort of the
- 12:38heart of everything we do. And I think part of that is
- 12:41hiring another reporter who can help us get scoops and keep
- 12:46things fresh. And then, yeah, I think for the
- 12:49business, it's really a matter of, you know, we have two great
- 12:53Cerebral Valley events. We had a banking summit in March
- 12:57that was good, but not great. I'd say.
- 12:59I I think good in terms of who we got there.
- 13:02But we didn't have as much of a story for sponsors, which is I'm
- 13:06learning to build an events business.
- 13:07It's like sponsors are a big customer.
- 13:12And so I think we'll find two more sort of anchor events that
- 13:17that really sort of resonate in Silicon Valley.
- 13:20And I think that will be a big piece of their business.
- 13:23And there's lots, you know, I, you know.
- 13:25Yeah, yeah, I was. Going to.
- 13:26Say I mean. Do you have any?
- 13:27Do you have any topics that you're thinking about for those?
- 13:29Summits. Oh, yeah.
- 13:29Well, and I won't be able to weigh in.
- 13:31I mean, we surveyed subscribers. I mean we're, we're thinking
- 13:33fintech is making a comeback and given we did banking, there's
- 13:37definitely a logic there. We're considering Frontier to
- 13:40wrap in sort of defense and space and some of those
- 13:44companies I have toyed with a VCLP focused event, but that has
- 13:51a little bit, you know like I feel like a Frontier event or
- 13:55Fintech has a similar story for AI, whereas VCLP is sort of a
- 14:01different strategy. So I'm trying to get my head
- 14:03around whether that will make sense or not.
- 14:05So we did our first event, the first Rupal Valley we planned in
- 14:10six weeks. So we're definitely willing to
- 14:12sort of, I don't know, blitz these things once we have a
- 14:15great idea, but trying to do a little bit more big company, big
- 14:20company, you know, big company trying to do a little bit more
- 14:23planning. But so yeah, we're thinking
- 14:24about it and would love, love input from anybody.
- 14:27If there's there are things where you think there's a real
- 14:31gap in the market right now. You've started the newsletter,
- 14:33it the kind of the the beginnings of the boom times of
- 14:37venture capital. So what you how has it changed
- 14:40over the last four years? What have you?
- 14:42What have you seen? Yeah, who who knew that the
- 14:46pandemic would turn out to be like this.
- 14:48Great. The best period for start of
- 14:51investing lots of manic behaviors.
- 14:53So that was super enjoyable to cover.
- 14:57You know, now we've had a couple years seemingly of a downturn,
- 15:01of course, that's been covered up by these big AI rounds.
- 15:05I'd say. I mean, the boom is fun to write
- 15:09about because there are deals to cover.
- 15:11Like if you think about getting scoops, it's like things
- 15:14happening is easier than things scoops.
- 15:16Left and I. Mean to cover and scoop a.
- 15:19Day, You know, every time there's a new deal that closes
- 15:21you. Can and you know, I, I wrote
- 15:23like a bear case on Rivian and like, it's fun.
- 15:26You can still be sort of skeptical of things even in the
- 15:28boom times. You know, now we have the sort
- 15:31of tale of two worlds or what do we keep calling it?
- 15:35It's the best of times in AI and the worst of times everywhere
- 15:38else. And so that's that's sort of
- 15:41created this mix mix storyline of the moment.
- 15:44I mean, you just got to, I guess, move away from reflecting
- 15:50on the glory that is newcomer. You got some data on the venture
- 15:55market today. What?
- 15:56Yeah. How would you describe where we
- 15:58are today? Yeah.
- 16:00We mean we're really seeing a consolidation around, I would
- 16:03say the the mega funds, you know, the Lightspeed A16Z index
- 16:08being able to still raise even though they're sometimes cutting
- 16:11their targets back, but other times meeting them, but raising
- 16:13these multi billion dollar funds.
- 16:15And then for everyone else, it's kind of a different world.
- 16:18And the same goes in the startup world, right?
- 16:19Like you see Anthropic Ilya's safe super intelligence raise a
- 16:24billion dollar round and then you see startups shutting down
- 16:28or quietly, you know, merging, if they can possibly find an
- 16:31exit at all. So it's really what I think is
- 16:35the most fascinating point that we found in the data last week
- 16:38was the number of unique venture investors in US startups has
- 16:42fallen just really dramatically since the boom times.
- 16:45Obviously there were a ton of these tourist investors that
- 16:47came in, people, you know, got excited, thought they could
- 16:50start their own fund, did start their fund, but then, you know,
- 16:53have failed to raise a fund too. And it's, we've seen this
- 16:57consolidation of funding to really just come from the big
- 17:00firms and then kind of everyone else is sort of left out in the
- 17:04lurch unless you have a super, you know, specific value add or
- 17:07you can really market yourself as doing something different.
- 17:10But the bar for that is just getting higher and higher like a
- 17:13lot of these. Merchants yeah, we put the chart
- 17:15in our Friday newsletter. We'll probably include it with
- 17:17this podcast post, but it is quite dramatic to watch the fall
- 17:22off and a little a little sad. I mean, it's it would I I liked
- 17:28all the new managers and like, you know, there's always some of
- 17:31the best funds are early funds of new promising VCs.
- 17:34But we've clearly the downturn is sort of enabled this pivot
- 17:38to, I don't know, venture capital becoming a lot more like
- 17:42private equity and big firms ruling the day.
- 17:46And so, yeah, it's been good news for Andreessen Horowitz and
- 17:50Lightspeed and a few others, and not good for the anonymous
- 17:55manager who isn't gonna raise their second or third fund.
- 17:59Yeah. I mean, obviously we did get to
- 18:01touch on some positives, a couple notable exceptions.
- 18:04You know, a Crew Capital announced that they closed 700
- 18:06million in new funding last week.
- 18:08And then also last week a friend of the pod, Harry Stabbings
- 18:13closed, you know, his third fund at 400 million to invest in
- 18:18early stage startups and you know, everywhere, but also
- 18:21especially in Europe since he's based there.
- 18:23Really exciting, got to catch up with him about that.
- 18:26And he's, you know, also doing, he's leaning into his podcaster
- 18:30angle and his media company as a cell to LP's about access around
- 18:33deals that he has which. Is we're not doing that right
- 18:35now. We're not doing that.
- 18:37I, I have no judgement anymore. I feel like I used to.
- 18:40There was a day where I would have been such a purist, but we
- 18:44are very focused on the media business events.
- 18:48Yeah, I, I stirred on LinkedIn that I'd done like 2 sort of,
- 18:52I've done 3 investments sub Stack, which obviously I talked
- 18:56about in the newsletter was effectively marketing for sub
- 18:58Stack. I invested in Volley who I Co
- 19:01Cerebral Valley with. So they're like a part of, you
- 19:05know, and then protege, my friend Bobby Samuels.
- 19:08But it was like, that was just sort of like the friend who, if
- 19:10they ever served a company, I wanted to.
- 19:14Your friend, your friend that if you know whatever you'll do,
- 19:16I'll back you. I got you.
- 19:18Yeah, exactly. You know, I feel like that
- 19:20anyway. I don't, I, I want, I just want
- 19:22to be transparent, but it's just inevitable.
- 19:25I feel like the savvy person, you know, you hear?
- 19:28Oh, Sir, Harry Stephens is doing this big fun that that is,
- 19:32that's not sort of on our minds at the moment.
- 19:35Yeah, stay tuned or not for that, but they're.
- 19:40Like Eric's whims? No.
- 19:44See. Why do you think he was able to
- 19:46raise now? I mean, honestly, it doesn't
- 19:47feel like the. Yeah, it doesn't feel like this
- 19:50season, I guess, for new funds anyway.
- 19:52I mean, this is his third fund going to 400 million.
- 19:55But yeah. What was your take on why
- 19:57Harry's sort of succeeded where others have failed?
- 20:00Truly, I think I mean, the biggest thing without a doubt is
- 20:03I'm sure the podcast is just an incredible asset for, you know,
- 20:07meeting talent, meeting founders, meeting investors and
- 20:10just, you know, as you meet people, you get clued into the
- 20:12network and you get kind of a, an advantage on what deals you
- 20:17should be tracking if you're, you know, talking to these
- 20:19people all the time and building these networks.
- 20:21But then he's now at this point raised a third fund.
- 20:25The biggest Cliff, I feel like for emerging managers is going
- 20:28from fund one to fund 2. So if you can pass that, you're
- 20:31that's certainly a positive signal.
- 20:34And also in his first fund, he's got these.
- 20:36Uncomfortable then you're too big to fail and your IPS are
- 20:41like, oh, not this fun. You know, it's the classic like
- 20:45we we pulled out and we didn't hit excels fund where they had
- 20:47Facebook. So we can never pull out again.
- 20:50And we'll just, and then and then you become General Catalyst
- 20:53and you buy a hospital. So.
- 20:54That's. That's the journey.
- 20:56But he no, I think he, he really, you know, has some track
- 21:01record. He's invested in some, you know,
- 21:02promising companies, including 11X and the AI startup, you
- 21:07know, really bullish on having an advantage in the European
- 21:09market and especially at the early stage there, there's a lot
- 21:12of good AI talent coming out of there, which he's, you know,
- 21:15clued into. So I think that I think that,
- 21:17you know, focus having a media product as a selling point to
- 21:21differentiate yourself is really important.
- 21:23And now he's also, you know, starting this scout fund.
- 21:26Additional additionally from the 400 million main fund where
- 21:31investors are all, you know, VPS or, you know, chief officers of
- 21:35some kind in other startups that, you know, can pull their
- 21:39network and they get they get to keep all of the carry on their
- 21:42investments. He, you know, can just use it as
- 21:45an incredible funnel. You know, if the scouts make a
- 21:47deal that you like, you can follow on and invest in bigger
- 21:50check, you know, so it's it's pretty savvy, you know, for deal
- 21:53flow to, you know, finding deals.
- 21:56He's he's certainly thinking about venture differently than a
- 21:59lot of people, which is appealing.
- 22:02All right, well, let's the our the bread and butter.
- 22:06Let's wrap up with what what was the most notable recent deal for
- 22:10you? Start us off.
- 22:12For sure, one deal I noticed last week that came to the top
- 22:16of the list was X energy nuclear reactor and energy company.
- 22:20They raised a $500 million round led by Amazon's climate pledge
- 22:24fund. And then Ken Griffin was also on
- 22:27the cap table, among some other strategics.
- 22:29You know, people are just looking for energy, energy
- 22:32resources to power AI moment right now the the AI wave is
- 22:37going to take a lot of power. So seems like people are making
- 22:41the bets on nuclear now. Yeah, mine's, mine's another one
- 22:43on theme where investors are excited.
- 22:45Right now we've got Path Robotics raised $100 million
- 22:49from Matter Venture Partners and Drive Capital, also Tiger
- 22:54Global, an investor. It's interesting to see them
- 22:57back. They're.
- 22:58Not leading and and basis set another firm, a new firm that
- 23:02we're tracking. So we've got sort of old and
- 23:05new, Yeah. But I think, you know, nuclear
- 23:09robotics, two big themes in the world of generative AI and will
- 23:13be interesting to see where they go.
- 23:15Cool. Well, that's this week's
- 23:16episode. Thanks for listening to the
- 23:17Newcomer Podcast. See you next week.