Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics With Paul #34: US Voting Policy Reforms Part 3 - Potential Future Changes
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:04I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:07Today is the final piece to our series on US voting policy reforms.
- 0:13The first episode was about how the voting process has changed over time, and the second
- 0:19episode was about how voting access has changed over the years.
- 0:23Now it only makes sense to look toward the future.
- 0:27What possible changes are we going to see when it comes to voting policy?
- 0:31What major shifts happen in terms of who we vote for, when we vote, how we vote, and how
- 0:38accessible voting is?
- 0:40Those are pretty wide ranging questions that can encompass a ton of different policy
- 0:45debates.
- 0:45So we're gonna boil them down into a handful of areas within those spheres, try to hit some of
- 0:51the major points, some of the considerations of these debates, common arguments we hear.
- 0:56So here we go.
- 0:59Future changes to who we vote for.
- 1:02First episode, we talked a lot about offices some offices being elected and some offices
- 1:09being appointed.
- 1:10So which of those offices should be elected and which should be appointed?
- 1:15Well, part of the answer of that lies in how exactly the election and appointment methods
- 1:20would function.
- 1:22If it's elected, should it should this office, whatever it is, be partisan or nonpartisan?
- 1:29Should when would the elections be?
- 1:32What kind of primary would you have?
- 1:34Would it be open, closed, semi closed?
- 1:37We're gonna talk a little bit about primaries shortly.
- 1:42Would there be ranked choice voting at the end?
- 1:47Bunch of different things to consider.
- 1:48If it is appointed, who is making the appointment?
- 1:51Is it a governor?
- 1:52Is it a panel of people?
- 1:54Is it the president?
- 1:56How do we confirm nominees?
- 1:58What would appointees eventually face a retention election by voters, and therefore, do
- 2:03have some say over who those are.
- 2:06You see that for a lot of judges both at the state and local level across the nation.
- 2:12And it also partly depends on what level of government we're discussing.
- 2:16Is this a federal level office?
- 2:18Is it state?
- 2:19Is it local?
- 2:21But without getting too deep into the weeds on the mechanics of elections or appointments,
- 2:27let's look at some of the fundamental arguments behind the two camps.
- 2:32So when we talk about the capability slash knowledge of voters, what offices can we
- 2:40reasonably expect voters to be able to research and have an informed opinion on?
- 2:45Now probably all would agree on governor being one of those.
- 2:50Although there were a few states that early on had their state legislatures, elect the
- 2:55governor or, I guess, technically appoint the governor.
- 2:59But when you get beyond that, attorney general, insurance commissioner, labor commissioner,
- 3:06treasurer, controller, whole bunch of other state executives to consider which one of those
- 3:13should be elected, which one of those should be appointed.
- 3:15So when it comes to the capability and knowledge of voters, the elected camp would one
- 3:20of the common arguments you'd hear is that if you make these officials run for office, that
- 3:25makes them more able to be researched.
- 3:27They're not so or makes them less esoteric, and citizens have a responsibility and a right to
- 3:34pick these people after all these people are having a direct impact on what or on these
- 3:40voters' day to day lives.
- 3:42But people who would say that who whichever official should be appointed, they might say
- 3:49that citizens often make ill informed choices and are influenced by partisan and special
- 3:55interests.
- 3:55So ex official or whichever official you're talking about should be appointed instead.
- 4:03How much responsibility should voters have in picking government officials?
- 4:09How many effect elected officials are too many elected officials?
- 4:13We can't just pick every single person that has an impact on our lives in government.
- 4:19But at the same time, if you don't get to pick anybody, then there's you know, what's the
- 4:25point of voting?
- 4:26But for people when it comes to that question, the elected camp, as in people who believe that
- 4:34more officials should be elected, they might say that voters should be as involved as
- 4:39possible with choosing government officials so they are more accountable to the people.
- 4:44And people who fall more into the appointment camp might say voters should not be expected to
- 4:49bear the brunt of responsibility for choosing a ton of government officials, especially when it
- 4:55comes to state executives like governor, attorney general, labor commissioner, insurance
- 5:00commissioner, controller, treasurer, commissioner of education, or something
- 5:05similarly named secretary of state.
- 5:10How how you know, which one of those should voters be able to vote on and how much is too
- 5:19much.
- 5:21So elected camp will gen or people who believe that elect we should have more elected
- 5:28officials will say that we have more of a responsibility that we should have in picking
- 5:33them.
- 5:34How easily can the duties of these government officials be scrutinized?
- 5:40Undoubtedly, some government officials have more esoteric or specialized fields that
- 5:50they're involved in.
- 5:51Something like insurance is gonna be more complicated than a more generalized official
- 5:58like governor, or even maybe even compared to, an attorney general.
- 6:04And how easily we can scrutinize these officials kind of related to the last two
- 6:07questions of how capable and knowledgeable are voters about these officials and how much
- 6:13responsibility should they have in picking these officials.
- 6:17And you can strongly believe that whichever official here should be elected and then
- 6:22believe that this other official should be appointed for exact opposite reasons.
- 6:28So maybe I think the attorney general or who whichever person you wanna make up in your
- 6:33head, that person believes that the attorney general should be elected because because they
- 6:39they think that's the chief legal officer, legal mind of the state needs to be direct more
- 6:47directly accountable to people, but maybe they think the insurance commissioner is is too
- 6:50esoteric, and that's not something that you can expect voters to make a well informed decision
- 6:56on.
- 6:56Who knows?
- 6:59Well, when you when you think about changing which of these officials are elected, which
- 7:06ones are appointed.
- 7:07So if you're gonna change an elected official to an appointed official or an appointed
- 7:11official to an elected official, you need to think about what laws need to change.
- 7:16You can't just decide, okay.
- 7:18We're gonna just write this law and and change, who exactly gets elected, who exactly gets
- 7:25appointed.
- 7:26It's it's a little bit more involved than that.
- 7:28When it comes to federal officials, especially because the the only federal officials we vote
- 7:34on are president, US house, and US senate.
- 7:38We don't vote on cabinet officials.
- 7:40We don't vote on the US supreme court.
- 7:43And if we were to vote on any of those, we need to change the US constitution, which is a an
- 7:51extraordinarily difficult task to do, whether, you know, whether it's something we should or
- 7:57shouldn't do.
- 7:58It's very, very tough to change the US constitution.
- 8:02There's only been 27 amendments over the course of just over two hundred thirty years, almost
- 8:08two hundred forty years at this point.
- 8:11For state officials, definitely much easier, but the difficulty will vary depending on state
- 8:17because some states' constitutions when voters vote on ballot measures, some states have a
- 8:24higher threshold.
- 8:25You might need 55%, or in the case of, like, Florida, you need 60%.
- 8:30Some states require just a simple majority of voters to pass constitutional measures, and
- 8:36then you have the whole rigmarole of getting constitutional or ballot measures onto the
- 8:42ballot for people to vote on.
- 8:44So for state officials, if you were to change, make an attorney general elected that's right
- 8:51now appointed or they're appointed right now and you're gonna make them elected in your
- 8:56state, you would need to change your respective state constitution.
- 9:00Local officials, if you have a local attorney that you vote on or a local judge you vote on,
- 9:08you're probably gonna need to change local charters.
- 9:10Or you might even need to change certain state laws too because some states have a little bit
- 9:15more involvement in dictating local government elections than in some other states do because
- 9:25you have a difference in home rule.
- 9:28Some states have more involvement in what that local government does than some other states
- 9:34because of home rule laws.
- 9:35Well, actually, you know what?
- 9:36That's a good podcast topic to tackle sometime, maybe sooner than you might think.
- 9:43I don't know of any current particular legislation or ballot measures going on right
- 9:49now that regard changing who we vote for, whether it's at the state level or local level,
- 9:56but you may wanna look at places that have very few or a lot of these state executives that are
- 10:02elected.
- 10:03So if you have a place like Alaska and New Jersey, I believe they I I believe both of them
- 10:09only elect their governor and lieutenant governor.
- 10:14So you might see people try to make their attorney generals or attorneys general.
- 10:20It's actually how you're supposed to say it in a plural fashion.
- 10:23They might try to make that a an elected position or or various commissioners, like, for
- 10:35education or insurance or labor or their equivalents.
- 10:39So or some place like in North Carolina where there's a lot of state executives to vote on.
- 10:46You might see people try to change or make more of those appointed because they maybe think
- 10:55that that's too much of a burden on voters to elect that many state executives.
- 11:00I don't I don't know that for certain, but some people might believe that.
- 11:03So look at states that have either a lot of state executives or that are elected or that
- 11:09are few of them that are elected.
- 11:12Future changes to when we vote.
- 11:15So the normal time to vote in general elections is, as we talked about in, the first episode of
- 11:23this series, is the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November.
- 11:29But should every election be at that time?
- 11:32Because we have some what we call off cycle elections, and those those are usually defined
- 11:38as any general elections that are not held in concurrence with normally scheduled federal
- 11:44elections.
- 11:45So if and and you're talking about general elections.
- 11:47Primaries are a whole other can of worms.
- 11:50But if their general election is not at the same time as presidential elections or the
- 11:56midterm elections for congress, most people would consider that off cycle.
- 12:01Might have different some people might have a different definition of off cycle, but that's
- 12:08that's what we're calling, calling off cycle here.
- 12:11So it's not the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November in even years.
- 12:18If it's not on that if the general election's not on that date, it's an off cycle election.
- 12:24You don't see or or at the state level, there's not a whole lot of those.
- 12:29Talked about some states where their state legislatures or their governor or other state
- 12:34executives will be elected at different times, but the vast majority of off cycle elections
- 12:41are for local governments.
- 12:43One of my earliest episodes of the podcast actually concerned election timing and its
- 12:48effects.
- 12:50Sarah doctor Sarah Anzia.
- 12:51Hang on a second.
- 12:57Really should've, really should've had this ready, at the beginning, but that one right
- 13:05there.
- 13:07Timing and turnouts, how off cycle elections favor organized groups by doctor Sarah Anzia.
- 13:12She had a really deep dive into how off cycle elections affect turnout and and just the
- 13:22general business of politics, I guess you could say.
- 13:26So right so for for this, we're just talking about the timing of general elections, not
- 13:33primaries because, again, that makes things a little bit too complicated.
- 13:37So some of the arguments you hear regarding off cycle elections so people who support they're
- 13:47not necessarily gonna support, like, making a whole bunch of elections off cycle.
- 13:51But if for whatever election is being talked about here, if they support having it off
- 13:57cycle, one of the some of the common arguments you hear are, one, it decreases nationalization
- 14:05of state and local politics to keep focus on local issues away from federal issues because
- 14:11if it's not happening at the same time as federal elections, then you're not gonna have
- 14:16that federal level climate effect what's going on at the state and local level, and you do see
- 14:24an increasing nationalization of of politics in general.
- 14:30Two, more invested and knowledgeable voters are the ones participating.
- 14:34They're the ones who know that this election's going on, so they are the ones who make a point
- 14:38of going at this weird time.
- 14:42Three, voting officials stay updated on election protocols because of the frequency of
- 14:46elections.
- 14:47So because they're doing it more and more often, they they're not sitting there for two
- 14:53years, and then they get back to doing or helping administer elections, and then they
- 15:00find out, oh, wait.
- 15:01There's also this change you have to deal with.
- 15:03So that's the idea there.
- 15:05And then four, it's less overwhelming for voters because there's fewer elections
- 15:09happening at the same time, so they don't feel like they have to research a whole bunch more
- 15:15stuff.
- 15:17People who are against off cycle elections generally are against off cycle elections for
- 15:26every kind of office, including local.
- 15:29So arguments you often hear against off cycle elections are, one, voters have to go to the
- 15:35polls more often and does have to spend more time traveling and researching.
- 15:39Those are very real costs, so you have to actually go out to the polling place, which is
- 15:44a lot easier for some people.
- 15:45And then for others, they might not have a car or or even a bike.
- 15:50They might have to wait for a bus to take them, and then they have to research multiple times
- 15:58in a given year to go and vote.
- 16:02Two, election results are not representative of the electorate because fewer people are
- 16:08participating.
- 16:08There's fewer people participating because they tend to not know that these oddly timed
- 16:14elections are happening.
- 16:16They mostly just know, hey.
- 16:19We vote in November of even numbered years.
- 16:21They don't necessarily know that other elections go on at different times.
- 16:27Three, there's more cost to holding elections since you are doing it more often and straining
- 16:32voter voting officials' time and energies.
- 16:34The local governments bear the brunt of election administration costs.
- 16:39So they have to put the election together in normal time, November of even numbered years,
- 16:45and then for the primaries.
- 16:46But then, oh, you have a mayoral election that's that happens in May.
- 16:50Now they've got to spend the time and money to have this election happen at a different time.
- 16:57And four, voters have to spread out time for research instead of doing it all at the same
- 17:01time.
- 17:03So few of those arguments you hear are a little bit back and forth.
- 17:07You know?
- 17:07Is it better for voters to have to spread out the amount of research that they do or to just
- 17:12do it all at once?
- 17:14For example, there's not really a comprehensive database of what local governments are moving
- 17:20toward or away from off cycle elections, but Los Angeles is a prominent example.
- 17:27They recently shifted from odd to even year, elections.
- 17:34There's another there are a couple other big cities that have done that, and I I'm I'm
- 17:39blanking on who on which ones they are right now.
- 17:42So you might, you know, look for some of those big cities because a lot of those you're either
- 17:48gonna find some smaller towns that also change around the the timing of their elections, but
- 17:53because they're smaller towns, there's a lot less coverage, and it's a lot harder to find
- 17:57information on them unless you live in those small towns.
- 18:01Whereas those bigger cities, you'll probably see more information about them.
- 18:05So look for some more, cities and towns in the coming years to align with federal elections.
- 18:12I don't know if there's necessarily a trend towards having more on cycle elections, but you
- 18:18do see it with, several of the big cities recently.
- 18:24So might see more of those, cities do that in the coming years.
- 18:31Future changes to primaries.
- 18:33So there's little, if any, argument against having primaries in general.
- 18:37It's rather what kind of primary we should have.
- 18:40Primaries are basically a given these days.
- 18:44You know, a hundred years ago, not so much, but now primaries are for pretty much almost every
- 18:51office has primaries.
- 18:53But what kind of primary should we have?
- 18:55So some of the recent changes we've seen to primaries include Alaska moving to a top four
- 19:01primary.
- 19:02So in 2020, Alaska voter Alaskan voters approved a ballot measure where the top four
- 19:08vote getters in the primary moved on to the general election, and the general elections
- 19:14actually ranked choice voting or RCV for short.
- 19:18And in 2024, a ballot measure to to repeal that top four primary was voted on, and Alaskan
- 19:26voters narrowly voted against that measure.
- 19:29So they almost went right back to what they had prior to the top four primary.
- 19:36New Mexico, just a few days ago as of this recording, so March 2025, the New Mexico state
- 19:44legislature just passed a bill to allow third party and nonparty or as New Mexico calls them
- 19:50declined to state DTS voters to participate in democratic and republican primaries, so making
- 19:57them open primaries.
- 20:00The governor, Michelle Grisham, she still has to sign the bill to make it law.
- 20:09I'm not sure if there's necessarily a a suspicion or a assumption one way or another as
- 20:17to whether she'll sign it or not.
- 20:19But in any case, she has to sign the bill for it to become law.
- 20:23Or if she decided to veto it, then the legislature would have to override her.
- 20:29And I'm not sure exactly what the threshold they need for overriding that is.
- 20:33But, but you've seen some, several unsuccessful attempts at primary changes in several states
- 20:41from the twenty twenty four election.
- 20:43There were some ballot measure to ballot measures to try to implement open primaries
- 20:48that did not pass.
- 20:50And I can't think of the states off the top of my head.
- 20:53I won't but was New York one of them?
- 20:57I can't remember.
- 20:58But there were several that tried to change states so that they were open primaries, and
- 21:05they were not successful.
- 21:07So there's various arguments for each different kind of primary.
- 21:11But just to make things easier, we're just going to focus on closed primaries and what
- 21:18people argue for and against regarding those.
- 21:21So arguments made foreclosed primaries that you commonly hear.
- 21:27One, parties have a right to only allow members to select their nominees, and they cite the
- 21:32First Amendment right to assembly and say, if if you let other voters in here, it violates
- 21:39their the party's right to association.
- 21:44Number two, they say closed primaries prevent sabotage and reflect the will of the party's
- 21:51voters.
- 21:51So their the idea is that independence and if if we're talking about a democratic primary,
- 21:59for example, you won't have independence and republicans try to come in and purposely sway
- 22:06the Democratic primary's vote.
- 22:07Or if it's the Republican primary, you won't have Democrats and independents come try to
- 22:11sway the vote.
- 22:13At least that's how the argument goes.
- 22:15Number three, they say it does not produce more ideologically extreme nominees.
- 22:21It's a common argument against closed primaries, but closed primary advocates say,
- 22:26no.
- 22:26That's not what happens.
- 22:28Number four, closed primaries are essential government functions that merit public funding.
- 22:35So it's kind of going back again to the party's right to assembly that comes from the First
- 22:42Amendment, our right to assembly.
- 22:44It's one of the lesser known First Amendment rights.
- 22:48So that's what people who advocate for closed primary say.
- 22:54Now for the arguments against closed primaries, they might what kind of primary they want might
- 23:01be a little bit different than others.
- 23:02Some might want a just fully open primary.
- 23:05Some of them might want a top two primary or top four primary.
- 23:09But generally speaking, arguments against closed primaries.
- 23:13Number one, they say that primary should be open to all registered voters since they are
- 23:17publicly funded because regardless of what party affiliation you are, if you have no party
- 23:23affiliation, you pay taxes and taxes go towards administering elections.
- 23:29So they're saying, we're paying for these elections.
- 23:31We should be able to participate.
- 23:33Number two, they say that closed primaries do produce more ideologically extreme candidates
- 23:40because the idea is that the people participating in primaries are usually more
- 23:46polarized.
- 23:46There are a lot more hardcore partisan and ideologues, so the idea is that they'll
- 23:52probably be more ideologically extreme.
- 23:55Now closed primary advocates say that's not the case.
- 23:59People who are against closed primary say that is the case.
- 24:03Number three, some elections are already decided in the primaries because that district
- 24:09or state is so lopsidedly in favor of one party.
- 24:13So if you're in a really democratic district in California or a really republican district in
- 24:22Florida, you'd be the general election might basically not matter because there are so many
- 24:29democrats in that California district or so many republicans in that Florida district that
- 24:35there's nothing that can actually be done to stop that majority party from winning.
- 24:40So independents say, well, if we can't even participate in the election, then we're we're
- 24:47base we basically have no say.
- 24:50And then number four, they say that nonmembers of that party for that closed primary rarely
- 24:57try to sabotage the nominating process.
- 24:59They say that the idea that Republicans are gonna just file into the Democratic primary or
- 25:06that Democrats are gonna file into the Republican primary, basically, that those
- 25:10concerns are overblown.
- 25:12So as for changes that we might see in regards to primaries, be on the lookout for more
- 25:20attempts at implementing open primaries in states like Florida, New York, Nevada,
- 25:26Pennsylvania.
- 25:28Just saw a couple of let me see here on Ballipedia because Ballipedia has a legislation
- 25:37tracker.
- 25:38There is a Arizona and Connecticut and Delaware couple examples of potential changes to,
- 25:51primary elections and how and what they look like.
- 25:55So we'll we'll see exactly how that goes.
- 26:00There's also some that are about oh, yeah.
- 26:03There's an Arizona one here that's about repealing open primaries.
- 26:08So we'll see that one's right now, that's only just been introduced on February 13, it looks
- 26:16like.
- 26:16So that might be a case where you see some movement in regards to whether the primary
- 26:24changes there.
- 26:28Future changes to early and absentee voting.
- 26:32So just a quick recap of the early voting and absentee voting states.
- 26:37Nearly every state, 47 of them, allows for early in person voting.
- 26:42Every state allows for absentee voting of some kind, but 14 states require an excuse for doing
- 26:48so.
- 26:48So whatever they consider a valid excuse for needing a an absentee ballot, you need to put
- 26:56that in writing, and then they might grant you the absentee ballot.
- 26:59And then eight states have automatic mail voting of some sort where they just send out
- 27:05absentee ballots regardless.
- 27:09In regards to early voting arguments for and against, so people who argue for more early
- 27:18voting or early voting in general, some people don't some people might think that early voting
- 27:24should be curbed a little bit, but not necessarily eliminated.
- 27:27Some people might say we should outright eliminate early voting.
- 27:31So some of the early voting arguments, people who support early voting, they'll say that it
- 27:37increases voter turnout amidst among certain demo demographics that have inflexible
- 27:43schedules.
- 27:44So people who are working class, students, single parents, The idea is you give them more
- 27:50opportunities to come out to vote.
- 27:54Number two, gives voters more flexibility and shortens wait times at the polls.
- 27:58So instead of having giant lines on election day, you kinda spread those people out on other
- 28:04days.
- 28:06Number three, it's also easy to implement and accommodates more voters because also,
- 28:12typically I I don't know if I I can't necessarily say that this is the case
- 28:16everywhere.
- 28:17It's at least the case where I am.
- 28:19On election day, you have a specific precinct and a specific place you have to go to to go
- 28:26vote.
- 28:27Early voting, you have several different options of where you can go.
- 28:33So the idea there is that it's more accommodating to voters.
- 28:37Maybe on election day, it's a lot harder for you to get to where you are designated to go
- 28:42vote, but early voting, maybe there's a place that's closer to you.
- 28:47People who are against early voting or at least want to limit it more than it already is, they
- 28:55often argue that there's ill informed voting because there's less time spent engaging and
- 29:00researching.
- 29:00So if you vote two, three weeks before the election and and you're allowed to vote and and
- 29:07it is a case where you're allowed to vote two or three weeks before the election, they might
- 29:12say, well, you there's still a couple more weeks that you could have spent engaging with
- 29:16the campaigns and researching them, but you're not using up that time and then you're voting
- 29:23and then you can't obviously you can't vote again.
- 29:27Well, some places maybe you can vote again.
- 29:29No, I'm kidding.
- 29:30I'm kidding.
- 29:32Number two, there's logistical concerns and fraud risks because ballots could languish in
- 29:37storage.
- 29:38And even if there's no reason to be suspicious about it, it generates suspicion.
- 29:43So they can't necessarily count.
- 29:46They can't count the votes from the ballots beforehand.
- 29:49And then if they and they certainly can't release that information because then that
- 29:54kinda tips off the campaigns to say, oh, wow.
- 29:57There's a whole bunch more people that voted for that republican or there's a whole bunch
- 30:00more people that voted for that democrat, then you got then they suddenly changed their
- 30:05tactics, and that kinda taints the election.
- 30:08Although you do sometimes see data as to how many voter republican and democratic voters and
- 30:17independent voters turned into an absentee ballot.
- 30:20There's there are some places that have that data and kinda does the same thing that we were
- 30:25just talking about as because most the vast majority of Republicans are gonna vote
- 30:31Republican or and the vast majority of Democrats are gonna vote Democrat.
- 30:37So you kind of still get a sense of who's in the lead in that regard.
- 30:42Now independence, not you won't necessarily get a feeling one way.
- 30:47But in any case, there's there's concerns that it taints the electoral process.
- 30:53And then three, it prevents voters from changing their minds if they accumulate new
- 30:57info closer to election day.
- 30:59So maybe two weeks before the election, they were very gung ho about, oh, I like so and so.
- 31:06I like Joe Schmo.
- 31:07He he's he's got a good head on his shoulders, and then some serious scandal, comes out a week
- 31:15after that and a week before the election.
- 31:18And that voter who was very gunk ho about him, whatever that scandal was, they cannot abide by
- 31:23it.
- 31:24They say, this guy is terrible, but you can't change your vote at this point.
- 31:27You've already put your vote there.
- 31:29So some of the arguments you hear for and against early voting.
- 31:34Now when it comes to absentee voting, nobody really argues against absentee voting as a
- 31:40whole.
- 31:40Pretty much everybody agrees we should have some form of absentee voting, but the the issue
- 31:46is whether it should require an excuse to to request a ballot and what kinds of people
- 31:52should be allowed to collect them.
- 31:54So I'm gonna focus a little bit more on the expanding of no excuse or regarding having no
- 32:02excuse absentee voting and expanding absentee voting in general.
- 32:07Not as much about the who can collect them because this is already getting kind long.
- 32:14And that's that's a whole other can of worms.
- 32:17But people who argue for no excuse voting or expanding as any voting, one, they say
- 32:22increases accessibility, as people don't have to worry about having the request be
- 32:28potentially denied even if it is a legitimate request.
- 32:31Just because you do what the government says you have to do to get something, in this case,
- 32:38a ballot, it does not mean that that absentee vote or ballot is going to be granted to you
- 32:44because who who knows?
- 32:46Maybe actually processing the paperwork takes a while for some reason or your for some reason,
- 32:54your signature just is a little bit different than what they have on file, and they reject
- 32:59the request.
- 33:00Who knows?
- 33:01Number two, having no excuse voting and absentee voting in general does not
- 33:05significantly benefit either Democrats or Republicans, so they say you don't have to
- 33:10worry about partisan considerations.
- 33:12And number three, prevent fraud.
- 33:14No excuse voting when done well can prevent fraud and improve reliability, and increases in
- 33:24voting mail voting have not seen a serious increase in voter fraud.
- 33:30It stayed very small.
- 33:33People who are against no ex excuse absentee voting and don't wanna see it absentee voting
- 33:41in general expanded.
- 33:43One, they say it increases the risk of fraud because it's harder to ensure that mailed in
- 33:47votes are legitimate than than when an excuse is required.
- 33:55Because if it's no excuse, then you don't have to give a reason.
- 33:57Whereas if you have an excuse, they at least have to say what the reason is for, and the
- 34:03idea is that you can verify whether that excuse is legit.
- 34:06Two, it, having these absentee ballots delays election results as wait times for ballots
- 34:13trickling in late.
- 34:15You you have to wait for these ballots to trickle in sometimes depending on where they're
- 34:19coming from, especially if they're overseas from military, and it makes the results less
- 34:24accurate.
- 34:26And number three, that ballots are too important to send through the mail and thus
- 34:31more susceptible to partisan machinations.
- 34:35Some early voting legislation.
- 34:38There's there's some going on in Alaska as to not necessarily whether to implement these
- 34:46these this legislation is not necessarily whether to implement it or to remove it, but
- 34:52whether to expand the duration of early voting days or to constrict it.
- 34:57So maybe somebody wants it from nine days before the election to sixteen days before the
- 35:04election, or they wanna change it from sixteen days to nine days.
- 35:09They wanna go in the other direction.
- 35:11Alaska's got some stuff going on there.
- 35:14Alabama, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas.
- 35:22What exactly they're doing, you know, it it varies.
- 35:25Haven't had a chance to dive into all those bills, but so you might see some changes there
- 35:31for early voting.
- 35:32As for absentee voting, there's a bunch of states there like Colorado, Hawaii, Iowa,
- 35:39Kentucky, Massachusetts, Maryland.
- 35:41So a bunch of different states there that are considering some sort of change to early voting
- 35:48and absentee voting to for in in terms of state legislation.
- 35:57Voter identification laws.
- 35:59So as of November 2024, we didn't really get into voter identification laws in the first
- 36:08couple of episodes because kinda wanted to deal with it more in this episode.
- 36:14But as of '20 November 2024, '30 '5 states require some form of voter identification.
- 36:2223 require a photo ID, and then 12 do not require a photo ID.
- 36:28So you need an ID of some sort, but it does not need a photo.
- 36:32But there are a few states that don't normally require an ID at all, but they may require it
- 36:37in some way the first time you vote.
- 36:40Now what kinds of IDs are valid can differ a fair amount between states, even between photo
- 36:47required states and between non photo required states.
- 36:51So photo required states might not all be the same kinds of of identification measures that
- 37:02other photo required states need and same case for between non photo required states.
- 37:12But some of the common IDs or maybe not necessarily common, but some of the ones you
- 37:18will see include driver's license.
- 37:20I I can't think of a single state that would not at least allow that, but that mean that is
- 37:30probably the most common one.
- 37:31US passport, military ID, student ID, government employee ID of some sort, whether
- 37:38you're federal, state, local, concealed weapon permit, retirement center ID, neighborhood
- 37:43association ID, tribal ID, so on and so forth.
- 37:46And some of these, again, might not be valid in other states that have ID requirements.
- 37:51So at the heart of this debate is largely arguments regarding voter fraud and voter
- 37:59suppression.
- 38:00Now if you dig hard enough, you will find that both of these things do happen, but do they
- 38:05happen as much as either side says?
- 38:09The arguments about voter fraud, that's typically a an argument from Republicans slash
- 38:15conservatives.
- 38:16Hence, they tend to be more supportive of voter ID laws, whereas voter suppression typically is
- 38:23a Democrat slash liberal argument.
- 38:26And so you tend to see less support for voter ID laws from them.
- 38:30So because of those concerns from their respective sides, states that are considered
- 38:35more republican tend to have tighter voter ID laws, and states that are considered more
- 38:40democrat tend to have looser voter ID laws.
- 38:43That's not always the case, and there's no clean spectrum of voter ID law strictness or
- 38:49looseness that accordingly follows partisanship, but there is some level of
- 38:56correlation between the two.
- 38:59Now common arguments you hear for looser voter ID laws.
- 39:03One, they say the ID laws are suppressive because they are a burden for many voters
- 39:07because of travel and costs associated with getting IDs.
- 39:10So they have to go to a local government or state government office to get that ID, and
- 39:18they might not have the money to get those kinds of IDs.
- 39:23Number two, they say the ID laws disproportionately target minorities, poor,
- 39:27elderly, and disabled voters because they often don't have one of the valid IDs.
- 39:32Again, going back to that cost, they say that a lot of times they can't afford to get those
- 39:39voter IDs.
- 39:41And then number three, that voter fraud is quite rare as there are very few criminal
- 39:46convictions for it and very few people attempt to impersonate another voter.
- 39:53Common arguments for tighter voter ID laws, they say that I ID laws are needed to prevent
- 40:00voter fraud by ensuring a fair and accurate process as IDs are required for many other
- 40:06things.
- 40:06So if you're, you know, going to buy a car or buy a house, they they point to that and say,
- 40:13oh, you you need IDs for that.
- 40:16Number two, I they say ID laws do not suppress minority voter turnout and that minorities were
- 40:21just as likely to vote in states that require photo ID as those that don't.
- 40:27And number three, that requiring voter ID is highly popular with voters, including among
- 40:33Democrats or and independents.
- 40:35So to not do have voter ID laws is, you know, in a sense, according to them, thwarting the
- 40:41will of the people.
- 40:42So you you can pretty much and and and any political debate, you can if you try hard
- 40:49enough, you're gonna find statistics that support your side of the argument.
- 40:53So people that support tighter voter ID laws and say that voter fraud is a problem, they
- 40:59have their data that they point to, voters people who argue for looser voter ID laws and
- 41:08say there's a lot of voter suppression.
- 41:10They have their data that's that supports what they say.
- 41:14Not saying either one of them are right or wrong.
- 41:16I'm just saying that if you try hard enough, you're you're gonna find some sort of data that
- 41:22backs up, your claims.
- 41:25So just something to keep in mind when you hear these claims.
- 41:30But I'm not I'm not gonna say that fraud and or suppression happen as often as they say or it
- 41:36happens more or happens less.
- 41:37That's for you to decide.
- 41:41But some of the states that we see some, state, California, there is a, at least a couple
- 41:51bills.
- 41:53It was they're actually just senate version and then the assembly version or their which is
- 41:57what their house is called.
- 41:58It's called the assembly.
- 42:03They they both have an in person voter ID law that's been introduced.
- 42:09So there there's there's some potential movement there, not necessarily far along, but
- 42:17Arizona has got a voter ID for absentee and mail in ballots.
- 42:24See.
- 42:25Connecticut's got a potential some potential legislation, voter ID for absentee and mail in
- 42:30ballots, in person voter ID, voter ID for low income voters.
- 42:35That that's just a summary of what it deals with, not necessarily what it's actually doing
- 42:41because then you'd have to go into the the bills themselves.
- 42:44And each of these bills might only be just introduced.
- 42:48They might only still be in committee stage.
- 42:50They might not be anywhere close to being passed, but just some of the states that you
- 42:55want to keep in mind seeing some potential changes in regards to voter identification
- 43:01laws.
- 43:02And for our final discussion, we're gonna talk about felons voting rights.
- 43:08Another thing that we didn't quite touch on in the first couple of episodes of this series,
- 43:15but we've expanded the right to vote based on race and gender and property ownership and
- 43:23being 18 to 20 years old, but there is still at least one demographic where there is some
- 43:29debate about their voting rights, those convicted of a felony.
- 43:34So how should we handle the right to vote for current and ex felons?
- 43:40Do they keep the right to vote no matter what?
- 43:42So if they're still in prison, do they get to keep the right to vote?
- 43:46Do they only get it back when they get out of prison?
- 43:49Do they have to go through some sort of post prison process that, like, petitioning the
- 43:54state's governor to get the right to vote back?
- 43:59Do they have to finish their prison sentence and parole and probation as opposed to just a
- 44:05prison sentence.
- 44:07Is there a distinction between violent and nonviolent offenders where violent offenders,
- 44:13have much stricter regulation than a nonviolent offender does even though they're both felons?
- 44:19Is the process for getting voting rights back different for those who commit one felony
- 44:25versus two or more felonies?
- 44:27A lot of different things to consider.
- 44:30As of October 2024, Maine and Vermont are the only states that allow felons to always keep
- 44:37the right to vote.
- 44:37So even when they're in prison, they keep it.
- 44:41Twenty two states restore voting rights automatically after that felon's prison
- 44:46sentence.
- 44:47Connecticut restores the right to vote automatically after prison and parole.
- 44:51So if they get out of prison, they still have to finish parole.
- 44:5715 states restore voting rights automatically after prison, parole, and probation.
- 45:04And then there are 10 states where it's not automatically restored, and they must go
- 45:08through a process that may or may not get their voting rights back.
- 45:14So arguments regarding automatic restoration following the completion of their sentence.
- 45:21So people who support auto restoration of felon voting rights, they say it's the right thing
- 45:26for democracy, and it's unconstitutional to deprive them of the right to vote.
- 45:32They might even point to, for example, the fourteenth amendment.
- 45:37Number two, vote they say that voting bans disproportionately affect racial minorities
- 45:43because of how prison population statistics show up.
- 45:49And number three, it promotes rehabilitation and reduces recidivism.
- 45:56So people who are against auto restoration of felon voting rights, they say ex felons should
- 46:05be required to prove they are reformed and willing to abide by society's laws.
- 46:10Number two, those who break laws shouldn't be allowed input into making laws because if
- 46:15they're if they're breaking laws, why should they even get to say how they're made?
- 46:20At least that's how the argument goes.
- 46:21And number three, they say that disenfranchisement laws are neutral to race.
- 46:27That's regarding automatic restoration following completion of their sentences.
- 46:33Now when it comes to voting rights while incarcerated, you'll have some of the arguments
- 46:39are are similar, but they include also debate about whether someone's debt they are paying to
- 46:46society should also include a temporary or permanent removal of voting rights.
- 46:52So is it well, you committed a crime regardless of what the crime is.
- 46:56Not only do you have to serve in time in prison, maybe a fine, but you should also have
- 47:01your your right to vote revoked for at least a period of time.
- 47:08Some of the recent events that we've seen in regards to felon voting rights, New Mexico in
- 47:132023, they changed it so that before you had your voting rights returned after prison,
- 47:22probation, and parole, they changed it so that it's restored after your prison sentence.
- 47:27So even if you're on parole or probation, you can still vote in New Mexico.
- 47:33Oklahoma in 2024, house bill sixteen twenty nine restored voting rights after re for people
- 47:40after receiving a pardon or commutation because apparently, previously, they were ineligible to
- 47:46register or vote until the completion of prison, parole, and probation under their
- 47:52original conviction.
- 47:52So if they if all that was 15, for example, and their sentence got reduced to five years, they
- 48:03still had to wait those those fifteen years for their right to vote to come back instead of the
- 48:10five.
- 48:11Or if they were just completely pardoned and and and got out of prison, they still had to
- 48:15wait that amount of time.
- 48:17That that bill eventually became law, and then so now they now it's based on if you receive a
- 48:28pardon or commutation, then you get your voting rights back after the completion of the new
- 48:36sentence.
- 48:38And then in Mississippi, there was a it was a bit of a long battle between 2023 and then
- 48:43earlier this year, 2025.
- 48:45In 2023, they had a lifetime voting ban on felons and ex felons that was ruled
- 48:51unconstitutional by the fifth US Circuit Court of Appeals, or by a panel on that circuit
- 48:58court.
- 48:59And in 2024, that ruling was upheld by the full court.
- 49:04And in 2025, the US Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal, and so it left that fifth
- 49:10circuit court decision in place.
- 49:14So there does appear to be a trend of pro auto restoration legislation and court rulings and
- 49:22ballot measures in recent years.
- 49:24So we may see more of these states, the 10 states that do not automatically restore felon
- 49:30voting rights.
- 49:31You might see those become move towards an auto restoration of felon voting rights, possibly.
- 49:42We'll have to see.
- 49:42Alabama has some stuff going on, some legislation going on there.
- 49:47Arizona, California, Connecticut, Missouri, Mississippi, New York, Rhode Island, South
- 49:57Carolina.
- 49:57So, again, can't see exactly what those states are doing right, in regards to that right now,
- 50:05but they are talking about said policies.
- 50:09So that is going to cover that that covers all the, things that we are gonna talk about today.
- 50:18So they're already running, a bit over, but that's I just wanna get, put a little bit of a
- 50:25bookend on this, series about voting policy reforms.
- 50:30Because there's a lot of things that for some of us, it's not things that we really have to
- 50:35think about when it comes to voting.
- 50:37It's just it is what it is.
- 50:39And when we have our voting rights and we, you know, just go along our merry way.
- 50:44But over time, a lot of this stuff has had to change.
- 50:47A lot of people had to fight for the right to vote.
- 50:51Some people today still have to do that now, you know, whether you believe that felons or ex
- 50:58felons should be able to to vote, that's that's that's for you to decide how exactly we should
- 51:04change early in absentee voting regulations or if we should change those, what kinds of
- 51:12primaries we should have, all sorts of of things to consider and to look out for that can
- 51:18potentially directly impact how you're able to vote.
- 51:23So just wanted to at least shine shine some light on on all of those and hopefully have
- 51:31made those things a bit more clear.
- 51:34So but we're gonna wrap things up here.
- 51:37So thank you as always so much for listening.
- 51:40Please like, comment, and subscribe, and share the podcast with all your friends and enemies
- 51:47and people you don't know, and links in the show notes for my Facebook page, LinkedIn, my
- 51:59five day educational email course on mistakes we make in regards to trying to depolarize the
- 52:07political climate that actually unintentionally enhance polarization and how why we make those
- 52:13mistakes and how we can correct those mistakes.
- 52:16My book on Amazon, why independents rarely win elections and how they could become more
- 52:22competitive, and, some a couple of other links as well.
- 52:26So as always, thank you for listening, and until next time, take care.