Latest / Building The North / How AI changes the future of work with VanHack CEO Ilya Brotzky | Building The North ep 004
Transcript
- 0:00Yeah, I think the whole AI taking our jobs narrative is completely false.
- 0:03I think there's just this, like, missing narrative where these tech companies that are laying people off because they've over-hired during COVID, to your point- Mm-hmm...
- 0:10they're right-sizing their workforce, but they're attributing their layoffs to AI.
- 0:15At the same time that things are changing, all the knowledge in human history is available to you just, you know, on your phone, and it's your responsibility now to go out and learn it, apply it, and figure it out.
- 0:24I would say the last few years, it's definitely declined in the amount of willingness as well as ability for people to move here. Just there's a lot of things that have become worse in Canada, I believe.
- 0:35Like, if we bring in 10,000 people making $100,000 salary a year, that's a billion dollars in GDP that's added to our economy, just from 10,000 people.
- 0:42Honestly, the biggest thing would probably be, be careful who you hire, or be really smart about hiring. It's, it's kind of ironic as a, a recruiting company.
- 0:49So I remember seeing something with Zuckerberg waking up every morning and getting, like, millions of messages or thoughts and messages about all these problems around the world, and it's like that's how...
- 0:58The level of success you are kind of is almost, like, parallel to the l- l- the type of challenges that you're, you get to solve, so. Ilya Brotsky is the founder and CEO of VanHack.
- 1:06In the last eight years, his team has made 50,000 introductions and helped thousands of engineers from all over the world get hired by some of the largest tech companies in North America.
- 1:14We joined Ilya in Vancouver to talk about immigration, what brought him back to Canada, and how AI is gonna change jobs for the better.
- 1:21Every episode of Building the North is an interview with a founder, CEO, or politician making a real impact. This is Building the North with Ilya Brotsky. [upbeat music] We did.
- 1:34And so we built Victoria Builds, which is, like, a, a community for young founders who are all building things, and- Cool... we handed that off, uh, to a, a group that's running it now, and- It's been great.
- 1:45They've been, they've been doing good things. Yeah. No, it's been, it's been a good stuff. It's been a, been a good time. What about you? Do you have, do you have co-founders?
- 1:51[clicks tongue] Uh, well, I did, and then I let them all go the first year. And, uh, yeah, not, not anymore. Although, basically, my wife's, like, my de facto co-founder. What's that like? Good.
- 2:05There are some challenges, but I don't know, it's kinda like you're life co-founders first and then work co-founders second. So, like, if there's anything that's, like... I say, I had someone say this, uh, to me before.
- 2:17It was good advice. Like, you usually have many companies, and hopefully you only have one spouse. So typically, like, if there's [laughs]... Yeah.
- 2:25The best thing is that she can kinda, like, call me out on my shit, you know?
- 2:27If I'm not seeing something, or maybe I'm in denial, like, "Oh, yeah, things are fine," or like, "Oh, no, that person's not the, you know, they're not that bad," and she's like, "No."
- 2:35And then pretty much every time she's right, so [laughs] Life partners first, before- Yes. Yeah, we got married in, started dating in 2013, got married in 2014, and then around that time, VanHack kinda started as well.
- 2:47Yeah. And were you, were you in Brazil when you met? What was that process like? 'Cause I know you've lived, like, everywhere in the world. [laughs] And then you've kept coming back to Canada. What was Brazil like?
- 2:56Did you meet her there? Yeah, we met at a bar in Brazil at the beginning of 2020- 2012. Um, and then I was, uh, we kind of kept in touch for a year and then started dating a year after.
- 3:07Um, and then moved back here Canada Day 2014, actually 12 years ago of, like, just now, couple, like, last week.
- 3:15Uh, and then when I moved back home from Brazil, I had met a lot of developers down there who I kept in touch on Facebook. This is how long [laughs] ago this was, Facebook was still a thing.
- 3:24Um, [laughs] and, and they would DM me or message me or comment on my pictures, uh, seeing that I was in Vancouver, asking me for tips about how to move here. Wow. And so that's kinda how VanHack started.
- 3:33I knew her before VanHack, but kinda she saw the full journey, or at least, yeah, well, yeah, the full journey. Why keep coming back to Canada? Um, well, I mean, it's home. So I moved here when I was five.
- 3:45Um, grew up here, kinda lived here for a while. Lived in the US and then Brazil for a while, uh, three years in the US for university, and then four years in Brazil. Moved back here, and it's always been home for me.
- 3:58You know, I have my parents here, my grandma, my brother. And it's not even just Canada, like it's Vancouver. I just really love the city. Feels like, I don't know, I...
- 4:07It's funny, I, I was telling you guys before we started recording, I was, I actually had, I was thinking about moving to San Francisco recently, and sp- after spending a week down there, I just realized, no, I, I don't, [laughs] I don't wanna do that.
- 4:15Not that it's not great, it just, maybe it's the stage of my life, uh, you know, married, two kids, um, that it feels like a really big change and push.
- 4:26But at the same time, I went to a bunch of meetups, and it was just, like, a bunch of w- almost wantrepreneurs there. And not that...
- 4:33I mean, obviously, there's a great place, and there's a lot of people who are just early, like, starting their companies there, but it just felt like maybe tech bros is a better [laughs] way to say it.
- 4:40[laughs] And then I went to Toronto actually for Tech Week, like, literally the next week, and it just felt like a much more vibrant ecosystem.
- 4:47Um, and it's maybe 'cause, like, I have a better network up here, so it's kind of easier, rather than starting basically from scratch down there.
- 4:54But, uh, yeah, I, I just feel like for personal reasons and also professionally, just comfortable in setting up my roots, and it's also nice to earn in USD and spend in CAD. Um, [laughs] For sure. That's good too.
- 5:06Um, but yeah, I, I guess, um, there's just something special about this place. And at the same time, um, what we're trying to do is actually live between both here and Brazil.
- 5:16So we wanna have, like, the winters down in Brazil, 'cause it's the summer there. So be able to, uh, snowbird down there, um, 'cause we're gonna work remotely. Um, so it's still, that's still a work in progress.
- 5:28We're, we're still kinda figuring out the setup there, but- Where in Brazil would you live? Um, so Giselle's from Belo Horizonte.
- 5:33Uh, it's als- like a suburb of Belo Horizonte, uh, which is, like, an hour flight outside, uh, like, from Rio. I, I, I tell people it's like the Alberta of Brazil- [laughs]... kind of like where the cowboys and- Sure...
- 5:43farms. Um, yeah, it's kinda really nice kinda countryside. Yeah, I was in, um, I was in the Amazon and, and Rio in like, in April and, and loved it. Nice. I'm going back again in the fall. Um- Okay. Let's chat.
- 5:55My mom's doing, like, a- Mm-hmm. Yeah, my mom was doing, like, a, a teaching thing down there and, and- Oh, wow... really enjoyed it, so we went down and visited. And we were like, I was working from the Amazon.
- 6:03We closed a couple deals- [laughs]... from there, which was a, a fun concept. But no, to your point- Starlink. [laughs] Yeah. Thank you, Starlink. I, like, the Wi-Fi at my resort was- Yeah...
- 6:11like, better than the Wi-Fi that I have in Toronto. Um- But I think to your point, like you can work remotely, you can work from anywhere, so why not live wherever you can?
- 6:21But at the same time, you're building this business around bringing people into Canada, bringing people into other countries. What do you think is it that should keep Canada as a place that people wanna keep coming to?
- 6:31How do we keep it? Well, I would say the last few years it's definitely declined in the amount of willingness as well as ability for people to move here.
- 6:40Just there's a lot of things that have become worse in Canada, I believe, uh, much more expensive, crime increasing, um, harder to find a place to live. Yeah, just a lot of challenges.
- 6:51Um, also it's been harder to sponsor visa, so the demand for, uh, employers to sponsor people has gone down, which, you know, I- I'm biased 'cause it's our business to bring people here, but I also feel like it's, uh, too much the other way.
- 7:05Um, there was kind of this really big, especially during the, the previous election or leading up to the previous election, kind of backlash against, uh, immigrants, and I think like skilled and unskilled immigrants kind of got put in the same bucket.
- 7:18I definitely think that there was a lot of abuse, um, or maybe like, I'm not sure the right word to say, but misuse of the student program, um, and just general like low-skilled l- or labor.
- 7:31Um, you know, you don't need to have foreign workers working at Tim Horton's kind of thing. But in terms of like senior tech talent, AI engineers, this kind of talent, there's a huge gap here, and it's become harder.
- 7:43Um, so what I would do is kind of maybe go back to how it was before. There's a few policy things I can get into.
- 7:49Uh, and then generally we just need to invest, I think, in the energy sector in the country to be able to unlock, and housing as well, to just be able to bring in more revenue, more jobs, and, you know, more housing for people.
- 8:00So yeah, um, there, there's a lot of ideas I have. Uh, one of them is bringing or maybe having something where if someone moves to a smaller town, um, that could incentivize immigration.
- 8:12You can't really force people to live in specific locations, I know, but, um, there, there could be some kind of mechanism to help tech, tech talent relocate here, especially tech talent we found that already has jobs.
- 8:25So one of the programs that Canada, I, I actually recommended, and they created it, but they didn't do it as well as I would like to, is a digital nomad visa.
- 8:32Uh, it essentially has turned into a, a glorified visitor visa, like a tourist visa, where there's no real path to permanent residency and actually having someone live here long term.
- 8:40That's actually a whole 'nother problem. It's really hard to get your PR right now, so immigrants are not wanting to move.
- 8:45Um, anyway, uh, it-- there's a lot of engineers who are making sixty or yeah, sixty thousand, seventy thousand US dollars or more, a hundred thousand US dollars working for American companies that could be bringing, that could be coming here and then spending that money, instead of spending it in Brazil or wherever they live, spending it in Canada.
- 9:02Anyway, I have a lot of ideas [chuckles] around what could be improved.
- 9:04But yeah, Canada, I think still is the preferred destination, I would say, for tech talent globally, as well as, you know, the US and maybe countries like Germany and other parts of Western Europe, Australia.
- 9:16But I would say three, four years have been harder, um, to bring people here. So yeah, I still think we have a lot of work to do.
- 9:24We've seen the, like the Trudeau, Trudeau government, to your point, the Trudeau government was a little bit more lenient on immigration. Carney's government so far has kind of taken a bit of an opposite perspective.
- 9:34Do you think Canada's overcorrected on immigration so far? Yeah, especially on the skilled labor side. Um, there's... they're a lot more stringent as to which companies can hire engineers from abroad.
- 9:45I'll give you a specific example. One of our clients, um, Fintech from Toronto, raised around eleven million dollars in funding. They almost got a refusal.
- 9:53We had to do a lot of, you know, asking politely and, uh, pleading our case for with the officer, but they almost got a, a LMA refused, uh, for a senior engineer, hundred and forty thousand dollar a year salary, Ruby on Rails developer, ten years experience.
- 10:07Uh, instead of giving them a, him a three-year work permit, they gave him only eight months. So he's moved with to Toronto with his four kids, and now he has, I think, six months left.
- 10:17They need to check on what to do next, uh, on, on the LMIA, on his, or sorry, on his work permit. So, um, and then we've had other cases where it just got flat out refused, um, because the company's not profitable.
- 10:28So this is the, the Carney government's now policy in place where if a startup or a tech, any company is not profitable or at least has, does have a specific amount of profit, uh, in the previous fiscal year as the amount of the salary, so if the person has a hundred thousand dollar a year salary, you need to have at least a hundred K in profit last year.
- 10:43Um, which is not how business works. Like companies tend to like not be profitable on purpose, especially startups to get investment. So that's really caused a lot of friction.
- 10:51And before you used to be able to get a letter of attestation from a CPA, which is just a letter from your accountant saying, "Yeah, this company's in good financial standing."
- 10:58Uh, if there was any kind of questions that, that they would just take that at face value. They've now asked banks to give that letter, but no bank is giving the letter because they don't want to take the risk.
- 11:07'Cause the, the letter essentially says that, "I certify that this engineer or the company has the salary to pay this engineer for the next three years." What if they don't? You know, you can't control that.
- 11:15So, um, yeah, uh, that little thing has made a big headache for a lot of our customers. And, um, another thing that they've done is really increase the Labor Market Benefit Plan.
- 11:26Um, stop me if I'm getting into like too detail here, but, uh, the Labor Market Benefit Plan, which I believe just shouldn't exist at all, is basically part of the, um...
- 11:35Uh, in order to bring foreign tech talent to Canada, you use a program called the Global Talent Stream, which was actually introduced by Trudeau on June 12th, 2017.
- 11:40It was a very good day, um, [chuckles] uh, because, uh, yeah, uh, it, it allowed these tech workers to come here and it, it was, it, it was a great policy.
- 11:49The only thing that I didn't like was the Labor Market Benefit Plan, 'cause it basically created this almost like make-work project where companies have to do things to benefit the local labor market.
- 12:01It's just adding more work to their plate in order to hire from abroad, and it's always kind of a, um, a quid pro quo. So if you wanna hire 10 people from abroad, you also have to hire 10 people locally or, um...
- 12:10And I get the fact that you don't wanna have an over ba- a misbalance, but companies don't need, don't... are, are having to commit to these benefits that...
- 12:19it's just a distraction for their business rather than something that actually a- adds value. So in other countries, like I mentioned Germany and Netherlands, they don't have anything like this.
- 12:27They say, "Okay, you're a foreign worker making over a certain amount of money. You got a job offer as a software engineer, approved."
- 12:33And, um, you know, you, you'll still wanna have a, a amount of, of talent that you can bring in. You don't wanna just have one company hiring hundreds or thousands of foreign workers and no Canadians.
- 12:44But, uh, yeah, the Labor Market Benefit Plan, I think, is, is something that just shouldn't be, um, shouldn't be around.
- 12:51So my point there is that before it wasn't so much, but now they're asking more benefits, um, than before. So things like that is, is causing the program, uh, not to work as well as it, it has before. Yeah.
- 13:02What other countries do you operate in that you've seen do it well or do it better that we should be looking at or, or mimicking or, or getting some inspiration from? Yeah. I, um... So in 2017, we spent, uh...
- 13:14Well, 2017, 2018. Basically, yeah, 2017 to 2019, we spent living in Europe. Um, so we did Techstars in Berlin in Germany, and then we did a startup program in Luxembourg.
- 13:24Um, and we went to a lot of different parts of, uh, Western Europe. I would say Germany, the Netherlands, Ireland are probably the top three countries that do a really good job of skilled w- immigration.
- 13:36Um, I would say especially the Netherlands, they even have a tax break. So if you're a foreign worker who comes to the country, you pay less in taxes for the first eight years.
- 13:44So companies like Booking.com, Adyen, you know, these huge tech companies, um, that... And the Netherlands is such a small country, they just, they don't have n- enough tech, tech workers there.
- 13:54Um, so they, they do a, a really good job of recruiting that talent and, you know, if you are between two job offers, one in... Actually, we had this case.
- 14:02One guy had a job offer [chuckles] in the Netherlands and Germany, and he chose the Netherlands because of the tax dollars.
- 14:07And there's this huge misconception that, you know, you bring in these, these, uh, foreigners, these immigrants, and of course, there's many different kinds of immigrants just 'cause like, like there's many different kinds of people.
- 14:16Uh, so I can see why immigration in general can have a bad rep. But these, these people that come in, um, they add jobs.
- 14:24Like, that's, you know, these usually mid-30s, probably ha- are, are married, usually have ki- uh, um, gonna have kids or wanna have kids, set up tr- lo- long-term roots, pay taxes for the rest of their life.
- 14:35Like, what's the, what are the biggest expenses in your life? You have your house and taxes pretty much. Uh, and then, you know, just general day-to-day food. All that is determined by where you live.
- 14:44So if you bring a t- a tech worker to, to that country, you know, employ them, they're gonna now be mentoring the next generation and creating products that will help the company grow.
- 14:53So, um, yeah, I would say those countries, uh, do a really good job of, of recruiting tech talent. Um, one country that I thought is also really good is Finland.
- 15:02Uh, they have this program, uh, where it was, uh, kinda Helsinki-as-a-Service. So we actually...
- 15:07They flew in, um, senior engineers from around the world to spend one week living in, in, uh, Helsinki and having, um, kind of the experience of what it's like to live there.
- 15:16So, um, yeah, there's a lot of kind of countries where they have to fight to get kind of global recognition in the tech, uh, talent war.
- 15:25And, um, yeah, they kind of are using these kind of creative ways of, of attracting talent, so.
- 15:31And if Canada could steal just one of these policies, whether it be the tax credit from the Netherlands, this, uh, Helsinki-as-a-Service, which I love, by the way.
- 15:39[laughs] It's a great name, um, from Finland, like what, what do you think Canada should steal- Um-... if there was one policy that... Or something else that you think they should, they should put into place or repeal?
- 15:47I would remove the Labor Market Benefit Plan. I, um... And then remove the letter of attestation from the bank. It's more just going back to how it was before. 'Cause the way it was before was working really well.
- 16:01When I say before, I mean, uh, pre-COVID really. Um, or, um, that, that things were smooth, processing times were good. Um, yeah, I, I would just move it, go back to that.
- 16:14Uh, and then if I would a- had to add one thing, uh, probably would be, uh, the digital nomad visa.
- 16:21So a lot of countries, um, have these digital nomad visas if you're making at least, let's say, $5,000, whatever the number is. Uh, a lot of countries in the Caribbean have it, like Spain.
- 16:31Uh, Estonia, I think, was the first one to, to, to create it. Um, but have like a proper digital nomad visa, 'cause it's all just incremental revenue to your, to the government.
- 16:40So let's say, and Canada can, can a- put the salary super high 'cause a lot of people wanna move here. So maybe a $150,000 Canadian dollar salary.
- 16:47If you're making at least that and you can prove it, you have a letter, you have bank statements, you know, obviously it has to be legit, um, give that person, uh, let's say, a three-year work permit, and then give them a path to permanent residency.
- 16:58That's actually probably the biggest ch- challenge right now is we have thousands of people, and I hear this almost every day from engineers who have moved here in the last few years.
- 17:06They're stuck on work permits, and they can't get their permanent residency because, uh, basically in order to get PR right now through Express Entry, which is kind of the federal program that invites, uh, every month a certain amount of people to, to get a p- uh, their, their PR, you have to be under 30, speak French, and have a PhD, [chuckles] uh, basically, um, which is very rare, right?
- 17:25So the, that, that's something as well that's, um, made it hard 'cause people move here or they wanna move here, but then, "Okay, I'm gonna... Am I gonna be on a work permit for the rest of my life?"
- 17:34And then you're kinda looking at the same problem that the US has with their Green Card holders or H-1B visas, uh, holders who can never get their Green Cards. Um, so yeah, there's a lot of things, but, uh, [laughs]
- 17:44uh, I would say, yeah, the d- if we can implement some kind of functioning digital nomad program, that would just add...
- 17:50Like, if we bring in 10,000 people making $100,000 salary a year, that's a billion dollars in GDP that's added to our economy just from 10,000 people. Um, so there's a lot of money out there that's getting paid.
- 18:01And, and especially right now with the whole, you know, US, Canada ri- rivalry that's happening, we can basically steal US dollars.
- 18:10I'm guessing roughly half a million tech workers working for US companies abro- from abroad right now.
- 18:15And if we could bring, yeah, 5,000, 10,000 of those people here, that's half a billion, a billion dollars annual GDP that's being paid out of the US into Canada.
- 18:25Um, not, not to mention, you know, all the knowledge that's now being
- 18:29Because these people may- maybe they'll start businesses, maybe they'll hire Canadian people, maybe they'll, you know, end up joining a, a tech company directly.
- 18:36And then, uh, so that's a lot of, you know, human capital and just capital that will be added to our economy.
- 18:42Under this, like, latest administration in the US, we've seen, I feel like, a rise in more protectionist policies where they're less willing to bring in certain types of immigrants.
- 18:50And again, I think to your point, like, we have to get back to this reminding, or we have to get back to reminding ourselves that there are different kinds of immigrants.
- 18:57We need to think differently about skilled immigrants versus unskilled immigrants, and the role that immigration in general plays in growing our economy.
- 19:03Curious for your thoughts on, like, how that protectionist policy kind of creates opportunity for Canada, especially, like, the green cards and H-1B visas and the ways that the US has thought about, considered, and actually changed the way that those programs have worked over the last couple of years.
- 19:17We've seen a lot of conversation around the way that that could create opportunity for Canada. How does that land with you? How does that resonate with you? Yeah, definitely. Um,
- 19:27I think a big reason why US companies don't onshore that tech talent that's working for them remotely, uh, in other countries is because there is no straightforward path for tech talent to move to the US.
- 19:39Um, even before the $100,000 ca- uh, fee per, uh, H-1B, this was still an issue.
- 19:45Um, so I'm guessing one day, who knows, in the future, uh, the US will wake up and reform immigration and create something that's a similar pathway to what we have in other countries, kinda in the Western world have.
- 19:56But until then, um, I feel like Canada has this huge opportunity to onshore this talent that either would've gone to the US for a job directly or, you know, just moved to Canada instead of the US because they, they can.
- 20:09So yeah, I think also there's a, a huge amount of American companies that have offices in Canada, and it's a really big part of our, um, you know, a really big part of our, our economy.
- 20:20You know, you see here in Vancouver, Amazon's the biggest employer, downtown Vancouver. Microsoft probably number two. I don't have the exact stats, but, um...
- 20:26And then, and then I saw a post that Eleven Labs opened an office in Toronto today. Um, I mean, I, I don't have the list in front of me, but there's- Rumored OpenAI office in Toronto coming. Okay. Yeah. Hypothetically.
- 20:38Hypothetically. I mean, I wouldn't be surprised.
- 20:39And a lot of those offices are opened, A, because yeah, we have great talent here, but B, because we have a really straightforward immigration system, at least compared to the US, that we can bring in the talent from anywhere in the world.
- 20:49Um, so I, I feel like that's a huge opportunity that we are capitalizing on to some extent, but there could be just so much more done if we were to simplify immigration into Canada. What does that look like in practice?
- 21:00I mean, you've talked about the Digital Nomad Visa. Do you think that the Digital Nomad Visa is that solution for bringing, like, higher tech talent in, or is there a different- It's one of the solutions.
- 21:09I think it-- that's more of a GDP play because it would bring someone who's working for an American company into Canada. It doesn't have to be an American company.
- 21:15They can be working for a Swiss company or c- you know, country, any other country. Um, but m- m- most people we see are working, you know, especially, you know, LatAm talent.
- 21:24There's a huge wave now of LatAm talent working for the US, uh, for US comp- companies, and they're making $60,000, $70,000 US, which is a great salary for them there, but you know, they could live in pretty well here on that salary.
- 21:35So there's that, the digital, digital nomad, and then, and then the Global Talent Stream, which is kinda the core way that tech talent moves to Canada.
- 21:42Um, just simplifying that, I would say, is, is the next logical step, in my opinion.
- 21:47Um, one f- small kind of example is when a company opens up in Canada, uh, let's say th- one of these US companies, Eleven Labs, for example, and Eleven Labs isn't able to sponsor visas for tech talent, um, unless they show a profit in Canada.
- 22:02Well, when is that ever gonna happen? Are those Eleven Labs ever gonna show a profit in Canada?
- 22:05No, because they're making their m- I mean, they're probably not gonna show a profit for years 'cause they're VC-backed and burning on purpose. So that would be a huge way.
- 22:12I would say if, as long as you have, um, like, allowing companies to use their international s- subsidiaries or, uh, parent companies as proof that it's a legitimate business, um, would be something else.
- 22:23I actually was in touch with, um, I don't know if I can say the name, but a really large, uh, fintech from Brazil, um, starts with an N, if people can guess.
- 22:32Um, uh, you know, $10 billion or more fintech, so quite capital backed. Um, yeah, [chuckles] you can probably figure it out. Um, that, uh, is opening or was considering opening up a Toronto office.
- 22:44Um, but they aren't gonna do that now because they have to pay tax globally if they open up a Toronto office, and also they can't sponsor visa f- through that Toronto office 'cause they're vis- again, the same situation as the Eleven Labs example.
- 22:57They don't have the profit in Canada. Meanwhile, they have probably thousands of employees. We actually poached a lot of [chuckles] their employees to go work at Neo Financial in Calgary.
- 23:06Um, but yeah, I-- there's a l- a, a lot of examples like that. So I would say making it so parent companies or, uh, Canadian subs could be used their parent company's financials, uh, that'd be one thing. And then, um,
- 23:19yeah, uh, just make simplifying the Global Talent Stream process quite a bit through the points I've mentioned pr- previously. We've talked a lot about policy and that making it difficult to bring immigrants in.
- 23:30I'm curious more on the AI side. You work a lot with software engineers, and bringing them to, to Canada in general is difficult because of policy and others that we've just discussed.
- 23:40But how do we see that af- how do we see AI affecting that same group of individuals? Is that making it more difficult? Are there less software engineers that want to be able to, to travel?
- 23:49Are there less software engineering jobs? Where, where do we see the next couple of years heading? Yeah. I think the whole AI taking our jobs narrative is completely false. Um, I don't think I know. I see it in the data.
- 23:59Uh, AI has actually been the wave that has kinda restarted the tech industry after the ZIRB bubble burst.
- 24:04So in end of 2022, the huge massive layoff wave happened after interest rates started going up, um, basically led to a pretty much nuclear winter through 2023 and, and, um, most of 2024.
- 24:17Uh, kinda end of 2024, we started seeing things pick up again in terms of hiring, which is roughly around when AI started getting adopted a little bit more or a lot more.
- 24:25Um, I know it came out at the end of '22, but it took some time.
- 24:28Um, so what we're seeing is that there's less kind of, "Okay, we're gonna throw as many bodies as possible at the problem and hire as many engineers as we can because we need to."
- 24:36It's more about doing, you know, being efficient with the hires you have But the hires you make can do so much more, and so the value of adding one extra engineer is in- increasing.
- 24:45So we're seeing a lot more hiring in general. Smart hiring, though. It's not like, um, after s- after COVID where everyone was just hiring like crazy.
- 24:54It's much more tempered, I would say, and, and, um, uh, reasonable, planned out, I'd say sustainable.
- 25:00But yeah, the-- there still g- needs to be someone to know if the AI's doing a good job, to answer your question of whether AI engineers are gonna be around or not.
- 25:08So actually, uh, when I was down in the Bay Area, I was sitting-- I g- got a chance to go work, uh, out of, uh, one of our customer's office, the YC company, uh, Truss, uh, Payments.
- 25:17It's a fintech for construction industry. And actually, uh, they hired someone from Calgary, and she was sit- uh, she came down for kinda onboarding and purpose, uh, uh, in person.
- 25:26Uh, so and her and I got to sit next to each other. I had never had that experience before, actually seeing the work that, of that hacker's doing after they got hired.
- 25:32Um, and all day she was just reviewing like cloud code and seeing if it was doing a good job or not, you know, testing and prompting it. So the software engineer is almost kinda like a QA software architect.
- 25:43Um, and just like, you know, in marketing, content creation, you're not gonna trust, uh, AI fully. Maybe one day, but I don't know.
- 25:51Even e- ever 'cause just a little bit of a hint of an AI, AI slop in your marketing communication, you lose credibility. Same thing, you don't wanna have buggy code.
- 25:58So yeah, uh, we're seeing, uh, kind of a resurgence of, of software engineers and, um, maybe a change in the roles, but definitely not, not going away.
- 26:07How do you see that extending out to talent that isn't necessarily software engineers? Um, well, I think there's just always been a natural evolution of jobs in general.
- 26:17Um, you know, there's a lot of jobs these days that didn't exist before and a lot of jobs previously that don't exist now.
- 26:25Um, I always give the example of a, a computer what used to be a human who would just compute, you know? That movie Hidden Figures, I'm not sure if you guys saw that one.
- 26:33Yeah, so people will evolve, change, and, and have to, I guess, uh, adapt if their jobs are being, being taken away. I also think that the time horizon is a lot longer. For example, self-driving cars.
- 26:44Um, you know, everyone's saying, "Okay, Waymo's gonna be everywhere, Tesla Robotaxi." I don't know how long that'll take, and it's probably gonna be more of a regulatory thing than actual technology.
- 26:52Um, so yeah, uh, for example, YouTubers, content creators, that wasn't a job maybe five or 10 years ago, and now it's huge.
- 26:59So things are always changing and evolving, and I think, uh, like that's the one thing about, uh, us as a species, is that we're very adaptable.
- 27:05I, I'd agree, and I, I mean, I think we've, we've seen this messaging almost like take hold. We talk a lot about students who are booing at graduations. Yeah.
- 27:13People who are walking off the stage or walking out of their commencements as a result of speakers mentioning AI. We have- Yeah, the data center protests. Yeah, data centers.
- 27:21Even in Vancouver where we are right now- Yeah. [laughs]... with tons of data center protests. And I, I think there's just this like missing narrative where
- 27:28there are these tech companies that are laying people off because they've overhired during COVID. To your point- Mm-hmm...
- 27:33they're rightsizing their workforce, but they're attributing their layoffs to AI because it, that's what makes sense.
- 27:39They're like, "Well, we're making these incredible gains with AI, therefore, we're able to lay off talent," and that's-- I, I think that's a harmful narrative. That's not the, that's not the truth.
- 27:47That's not what-- I mean, we work with companies, and we, we see that really consistently, that AI's not taking people's jobs.
- 27:53It's in-- it's making them more powerful, and as we dive, dive deeper into the future, I mean, maybe some jobs will be replaced by AI.
- 27:59But to your point, content creators, YouTubers, things that didn't exist or weren't considered work 10 years ago.
- 28:05I mean, you look at 100 years ago, 200 years ago, the concept of-- Like we're, we're literally moving numbers on a screen. We're clicking boxes on screens. That's our job.
- 28:15That's what has become work for people, and if you have introduced that to someone 100 years ago, 200 years ago- Right. Yeah, yeah... they'd be like: What is this person doing? There's-- This isn't work.
- 28:24You're not- Mm-hmm... doing something... Uh, this isn't agrarian. This isn't industrial. This is a little bit of a different concept.
- 28:29So I, again, I feel like the concept of employment, it always continues to change, and I, I think we'll see that with, with AI too. But if you're doing data entry, you're in trouble.
- 28:37[laughs] Yeah, and, and then that's where adaptability, training, thinking about new s- something new...
- 28:44But I also think like coming into the technological revolution of the internet, we had about a, like human, humans in general had about 100 years from start to finish to like fully adopt it and, and like get into what's happening
- 28:59with technology, and I, I think that is starting to collapse, right? Like with AI, it's so quick. Are people gonna be able to upskill themselves fast enough to keep up with a new job or a new way of working?
- 29:11It's a good question. Uh, I think it depends on the type of person and the type of job, so it's hard to say yes or no.
- 29:17But I feel like if you don't know what to do these days, you could just ask the AI to help you learn, and then-- Like it's never been easier to learn at the same time that things are changing.
- 29:29You know, you-- All the knowledge in human history is available to you, uh, just, you know, on your phone, and it's your responsibility now to go out and learn it, apply it, and figure it out.
- 29:39Whereas, again, like you were saying, 100 years ago, there's no way that you could just, you know, look at a magical black box and know the answer to whatever question.
- 29:48So yeah, I, I guess maybe there's some people who are kinda gonna be left behind or out of touch or whatever it might be, but I think people are more resilient than, than we think.
- 29:59And, and I think a lot of the media narrative is just, you know, driven by these huge, uh, AI labs that need to tell their investors that they're gonna be taking all the, you know,
- 30:10the, the, the, the capital, uh, the talent, uh, the money that people are s- or companies are spending on talent are now gonna be spending on, on AI. So, um, yeah, I, I think that's a lot of it.
- 30:21Like I remember seeing this Sam Altman video a few weeks ago where he's like: My job is literally to remove everyone's job. Like that's just trying to-- like them playing, you know, playing up what they're doing.
- 30:30I don't, don't think it's real. No, no, I agree.
- 30:33I mean, I think that's where we have to get back to messaging and communicating the fact that, A, people's jobs are not at risk, and not everyone's jobs are going to get replaced by AI.
- 30:43Maybe some people's will, to your point, data entry, some things for sure. Um, but when that happens... retraining will take care of those people who, who lose their jobs, right? Like, there are ways to kind of
- 30:56mitigate that shift and make sure that we, we handle that in a, in a thoughtful way.
- 30:59And I, I think that there's been communication that, that, to your point, that when, when you're talking about Sam, I think he also said something about, um, we're going to put intelligence on a meter, like a utility- Mm-hmm...
- 31:10and we'll, we'll meter it out, or you'll pay for access to intelligence, and I, I think that's a challenging narrative. Um- Yeah, especially with open source models. Yeah.
- 31:18And I, I mean, we're, we're seeing that a lot too, where, um, companies are sort of questioning the impact of really expensive frontier models and kind of diving deeper into, okay, how do we look at this and navigate this long term, where
- 31:32maybe we don't wanna be spending this much money on tokens, but we still want access to near frontier-level intelligence? Or even- Yeah...
- 31:38with the way that Fable and Sol and these new models are being kind of, um, regulated a little bit before they hit the consumer.
- 31:46I mean, we, we talk a lot about how we expect in the future there to be export controls or restrictions or things where maybe the consumer doesn't have access to the best model, and maybe open source models are a step behind, but they're still a little bit...
- 31:59They're good enough. Yeah. It's like, this is maybe a silly example, but, uh, um, like performance athletes, right?
- 32:06Like, they have all the best-- Like, if you're an NBA player, NHL player, you have, like, all the best, uh, equipment and training and med school staff and everything dialed in. But if you're just, like, you know,
- 32:18I- I don't know, average Joe or just someone who likes to be a- athletic, um, but you're not, you know, a professional athlete, you're, you're gonna be okay with maybe not having all the best, latest and greatest te- technology and tools to just, you know, be able to do a triathlon or whatever you wanna do.
- 32:32So, um, for us, for example, pr- practically, to bring it back to what we do, uh, we installed OpenClaw at the beginning of this year into prod, and now we have a agent in our, in our Slack that we talk to.
- 32:43Um, and we also have running our own infrastructure. We're paying 2K a month for it, and it's great. Um, we don't have to, you know, pay any of the Frontier labs for it.
- 32:50We just have it all on our, on our own servers and, um, basically have limitless intelligence that we need to use or that, you know, that we're able to use to match talent, to perform different tasks, and to give our ac- our candidates, or sorry, our customers basically an AI recruiter that we built in- into their Slack instances.
- 33:07And, um, so that, it's been... Like, I feel like I'm running a different company than I was in the beginning of the year 'cause, um, yeah, we have an internal joke, like, "If you don't know something, just ask Vanna."
- 33:16It's our a- agent's name. Um, uh, yeah, so that, and that's just made it so we can do a lot more with less and, you know, be more efficient, grow the business faster.
- 33:26But I think that's where companies are going, is having on-prem intelligence that they own and have access to as they want to.
- 33:33And we're seeing more and more, especially on the larger company enterprise side, where they're paying for Anthropic subscriptions on their enterprise tier, and they're spending so much more on tokens that they, than they otherwise would.
- 33:45And we're starting to see that pushback where they're like, "This is too much for what we're getting in return."
- 33:51Whereas if you're sitting on an, as an individual or as a small team on a Teams plan, it's like you can get so much value out of this monthly subscription, but the second you start paying for tokens as a large organization, all of a sudden they're spending so much more money.
- 34:03And this continues to, to bring me to the idea of sovereign intelligence, sovereign AI as a country, not only as the organization but also as a country, because to your point about the US government shutting down, uh, models that came out of both OpenAI and Anthropic recently, what happens when foreign nations control the intelligence that we pay for and use on a daily, weekly basis?
- 34:26Yeah. That's a great question. Uh, it could be used as a, uh, I guess a, a weapon, like to remove it- Of course... or not, and then the access of what, what, what do they do with the data that they have, right?
- 34:36Um, yeah, I think that's a really big issue. So yeah, I, I also, to your point, I think saw that Tesla recently maxed, uh, or put a limit on $200 of, of a week or a month for a token spend.
- 34:47And it's not about just spending tokens for tokens' sake. You just wanna be efficient to be able to build the product you're looking for. Totally.
- 34:54Well, I wanna talk about that evolution of your company and about how VanHack has changed over the years- Sure. Yeah...
- 35:00with the AI recruiting platform that you've kind of come out with recently by going all the way back to the start in its infancy when it was just more of like an education platform. Yeah.
- 35:08And can you talk about, like, that process and where, how it's evolved over the year? I mean, you mentioned you felt like you've been running a completely different company since the start of this year. But- Mm-hmm...
- 35:17looking back to the very beginning. Yeah. Those are always fun, uh, memory lane, uh, conversations. Uh, definitely makes me, I would say, grateful to, to where we are now.
- 35:28Just, I say that because I got started as kind of a, yet another side project that I didn't think would go anywhere. Um, so for context, uh, where I was in my life, I was, I believe, 25 or just turned 26.
- 35:41Um, got let go from my job in Brazil, moved back to Brazil with my girlfriend, my then girlfriend, now wife. L- w- moved in with my parents, was pretty much broke.
- 35:52You know, had a f- a little bit of money, but, you know, nothing crazy.
- 35:55[chuckles] And, um, and yeah, I was kind of in this grind moment where I didn't really know what the next step was, and I started going to all these meetups down, uh, here in Vancouver looking for a job, and I would a- you know, start saying, talking to people, and they would ask me if I'm a developer.
- 36:10I literally had this happen. One guy, I started talking to him, and he's like, "Hey, so are you a software engineer?" And I said, "No." And he just said, "Okay," and he turned around and walked away.
- 36:17It's like I'm just a lowly sales guy. Um, so I kinda realized that there was this need for software talent here in Vancouver.
- 36:23And then, like I mentioned earlier in the conversation, I had this network of software developer friends who I just, you know, met in, in, you know, when I was down in Brazil in the tech ecosystem, just networking at different events.
- 36:33And I also had worked at a startup ecos- uh, accelerator down there, um, and met a lot of developers there too. So I, I kinda thought, hey, like there's these developers that wanna move here.
- 36:43There's a lot of jobs Maybe I can start an, uh, English school for developers, and that was the f- the original idea. I had no idea how recruitment worked, actually.
- 36:50I didn't know you can get paid to make introductions and how, uh, you know, lucrative it could be. But I was in...
- 36:55I had an ed tech background, so I started really just simply put up a very basic and actually very poorly written, uh, landing page.
- 37:02This was, uh, before Google Translate was really a thing, and, uh, so it was all in Portuguese. And I was just thinking I could help Brazilians move to Vancouver.
- 37:10Um, it was on Unbounce, who, um, actually proud to say has become a customer or b- they, they were a customer fr- uh, of ours.
- 37:15Um, threw it up on Facebook Groups and, uh, in about a day or two, we had 100 or so people sign up. Um, and so I was like, "Okay, this is, this is crazy," and I started doing calls with all of them.
- 37:26Every single person, I tried to book a call, do a lot of customer discovery. I'm a big fan of Steve Blank, you know, Eric Ries, "Lean Startup." Um, and just started asking them, you know, "What are your pr- pain points?
- 37:36What are your challenges? What, what, what could I do to help?"
- 37:38Uh, a few of them were actually here in town, so I got to meet them in person, have coffee, and then really kind of interact on a, uh, on a one-to-one basis.
- 37:45And I started realizing they need help with, you know, resumes, cover letters, LinkedIn profiles, and English speaking.
- 37:50So they're really good coders and good at, you know, just programming, but their spoken English especially was, was tough.
- 37:56So they maybe had an accent or they went on too long, as I feel like I'm doing right now in this answer.
- 38:01Um, a- and you know, they can't answer basic questions like, "Tell me about yourself," or "Where do you see yourself in five years?"
- 38:07Things that, you know, I had just, uh, not just graduated from university, but you know, a few years I graduated from university and did a lot of career prep to get my, my jobs af- after graduation.
- 38:16So I kind of had a little bit of that knowledge. And yeah, I remember the first payment we got was someone I think spent, sent us, me $45 to correct his resume.
- 38:24Um, so it's kind of okay, there's some- something here, and just kind of kept pulling at that string.
- 38:29And for the first year, it was really just building a community of Brazilian software developers who wanted to move to Vancouver. It was super, super, super niche, um, and it was all in Portuguese.
- 38:38Uh, and it was just all about the education side of things. And then we would used to go to, um, [clears throat] career fairs, um, and I would actually do a webinar and bring a laptop. So I had a, a laptop.
- 38:49I felt kind of like a, a cameraman, you know? I, I had a, I had a, I had a laptop, uh, with about 100 or 200, uh, developers, VanHackers on, on the, on the webinar, uh, who wanted to move here.
- 39:00So I would go to every booth and say, "Hey, um, you know, tell me about like Micr- why should p-people want to m- work at Microsoft or, or whatever tech company."
- 39:09And then I would say, "Look, there's all these, you know, developers," and people would see the chat and say, "Oh, that's kind of cool."
- 39:13Um, and then one of the companies, uh, Isai Games, um, Josh from Isai Games, uh, him and I were walking out of, uh, one of the, the career fairs, and he's like, "Ilya, how, how much would it cost to hire an, an engineer from you?
- 39:24Uh, you know, I want to hire a Unity developer." And I had no idea, so I came up with a random price. I think it was like 500 bucks. Um, [chuckles] and, uh, and then he said, "Okay, yeah, let's give it a shot."
- 39:36So that was our first customer, and then from there we got, you know, a few more, and I started realizing we're undercharging. Started charging, you know, uh, 20% of the salary, just kind of market rate.
- 39:46Um, and I remember making our first hire at that full salary, and it was more revenue than we would in, in one month of English school just from one hire and one introduction.
- 39:56So that really kind of opened my eyes as to, okay, there's actually this other business on the side, on the, on the, on the other side of the market, uh, and there's actually a marketplace where we can connect talent.
- 40:04And I've been always kind of that guy who likes to make introductions, so, um, just being a salesperson and I, you know, had a, kind of knew a lot of people and, uh, uh, and, and very s- was very social in college and just like early career.
- 40:17Um, [clears throat] so I love sending those emails, you know, John, you know, with the little brackets, [chuckles] me James, and then seeing what happens.
- 40:24Um, and then I realized I can get paid for that, so I was like, "Okay, let's, let's, let's go." So, um, yeah, I'll pause there, but that's kind of the early days.
- 40:31Knowing what you know now from that entire journey and all the things you learned along the way, what do you wish you had the opportunity to tell your 25-year-old self when he was first starting?
- 40:41[laughs] Uh, save more money. Um, yeah, that'd be one thing.
- 40:46Um, so we always kind of ran it on a just kind of like m- invest more, invest more, keep investing in growth, and I kind of wish I had just like, let's just save 5%, 10% of revenue and put that in a, for a rainy day, 'cause those come.
- 41:00So that'd be one thing.
- 41:02This is a silly one, but we used to have a profitable Facebook ads funnel where we would run Facebook ads, uh, and the money we would make from the English school, 'cause we, we had, we were still charging candidates for the English school.
- 41:14We had to stop that business for regulatory 'cause some li- like we had to get recruiting license, and so they said, "If you're charging candidates and employers, you can't get a recruiting license."
- 41:21So we had to shut it down. But before, um, w- we had a profitable Facebook ads funnel. I wish I had maxed that out more so we had more candidates.
- 41:29Um, honestly, the biggest thing would probably be be careful who you hire or be really smart about hiring. It's, and it's kind of ironic as a, a recruiting company.
- 41:37In the early days of VanHack, I was like, "Hey, do you have a pulse? Like, you're hired." [chuckles] That was really it.
- 41:43Um, didn't have contracts, uh, didn't do references, um, didn't really do like actual interview processes. It was more like, "Wow, I can't believe you actually wanna help my project." Um, and I had, um...
- 41:55When we started the company, uh, again, I, I thought this would just be yet another failed side project that I, I was, I was running. I was like in not a very, you know, positive place and not optimistic.
- 42:04So I actually, um, had, uh, three other co-founders in the beginning, and I wish I didn't have any, or at least one that like was like my l- like a legit co-founder that I knew and like really trusted.
- 42:15It caused a lot of stress. Like I, I remember the first person I ever fired was one of the co-founders, like two weeks in, wasn't a fit. The second person, he moved,
- 42:23uh, and basically disappeared for three months, and I had to let him go.
- 42:27The third person was tough, uh, 'cause we actually had a contract by that point, and I had to buy him out, basically our full like 20 k- K of our seed fam- seed round, which was a lot, I mean, still a lot of money, but it was a lot of money back then.
- 42:37We had to pay him to, to leave the business. Uh, so yeah, be careful who you hire and partner with, um, 'cause there was a lot of other mistakes that happened.
- 42:45Actually, in 20 s- 17, uh, one of my, my mentors, uh, ended up joining the business as a sales consultant and then, and, uh, ended up, uh, s- like basically stealing money and, uh, starting a competitor.
- 42:56So yeah, there's a lot of, [chuckles] a lot of scars. And even, even now it's hard.
- 43:00Hiring's hard, but like, yeah, that, that ironically is something that I still feel like I'm not that good at and can always be better at. So yeah, tho- those would be the, the lessons. What do you think...
- 43:09Do you think there was something that you learned from... hiring or was there, like, a common denominator?
- 43:14Like, if there was something you could go back and say, "Oh, I, I saw this one thing from this set of candidates that turned out to not be a great fit." I think it's just
- 43:24generally, it's not even about them or the ca- the, the other person, it's about m- me or the whoever the company hiring is [clears throat]
- 43:33not being thorough enough in, in the interview process, wishing that things would work out when clearly they're not gonna work out. So the whole hire slow, slow fire fast motto, it's, it's a cliche 'cause it's true.
- 43:45Um, we definitely took too long to fire people and kind of, "Oh yeah, let's put them on a PIP," you know, performance improvement plan, or l- "May- maybe next, next month they'll be better," or yeah.
- 43:55Um, so that, that's always, that's something that, yeah, I've made that mistake many times, kind of wishful thinking that hopefully this person will be better, e- even though, like, pretty much right away you know they're not a fit.
- 44:06Um, yeah.
- 44:07So I think it's not something necessarily anything about them because, listen, it's like, like, I've been fired I think three or four times [chuckles] in my life, and every time it's devastating, but then it always works out better.
- 44:18I think, like, n- being scared to fire someone, uh, uh, 'cause it's scary, like, it's to have that conversation, uh, has cost me a l- a lot of headaches and money. Um, so I would just say, like,
- 44:30do a thor- more thorough job in hiring, and there's a lot of, like, great processes out there. Like, I'm not that big a fan of top grading. I think that's actually overkill.
- 44:38But just generally, like, running a thorough process, having multiple teams involved, um,
- 44:44you know, getting a second opinion, conducting backdoor reference checks where they don't know you're asking, but, you know, maybe you wanna, uh, get, get an opinion or asking for, like, 10 references rather than asking for three.
- 44:53Maybe 10 too much, but those kind of things you can do to really, like, dig deep into the person.
- 44:58And then yeah, uh, maybe not, like, at the first sign of trouble, but, like, if there's a, in the first especially month, if something's not going well.
- 45:05For example, like, n- uh, recently we had to let go of someone, and then in the first I think two or three weeks, they sent me a message saying, like, "I'm overwhelmed," and, like, complaining they have too much work to do.
- 45:17And I was just like, "Y- you haven't even started."
- 45:19[laughs] Um, so yeah, maybe it's misalignment on us expecting too much but at the same time, like, if someone's saying that when they're not producing any results and they're already overwhelmed, it's, you know, not a good fit.
- 45:29That's, like, a small kinda antidote. Um, but yeah, it's a challenging thing because it's relationships, it's human, and there's no real black and white, like, yes or no, this person's great or not.
- 45:39There's so many different factors and, um, yeah, I feel like that's definitely the, the hardest part.
- 45:45I mean, other than obviously customers, you know, getting customers and sales, um, recruiting is, is, is for us, it's been hard.
- 45:51What do you think about incentivizing the employee to leave within the first 30 days with cash? Um, I mean, it's a nice gimmick. Um, yeah, I, I haven't tried it, so it's hard for me to give a specific opinion.
- 46:05It does feel, like, like I said, gimmicky. Um, but maybe just, like, doesn't even have to be about incentivizing them to leave. Like, it should be your... The, like, if you don't see them as a fit, then just let them go.
- 46:17Um, but yeah, I think having, like, a more stringent check-in of, like, these are the specific deliverables I want you to have.
- 46:25Um, for example, with sales, like, we have a very black and white, if for the first three months you haven't brought any revenue or, like, you're not very close to bringing revenue, you're gonna get let go.
- 46:34And I've broken that rule myself. And that, I think that's where you get it 'cause you kinda get it. You know, you become not friends, but, like, you grow fond of people, or you think you see the promise of them.
- 46:42You say, "Oh no, they're doing a good job." Eh, so yeah, that's I think more the- How do you vet people in the VanHack ecosystem, and have clients had bad experiences or have they- Yeah...
- 46:53gone through that process themselves? Yeah, definitely. Um, so we, we recently ran some stats, and I think we've made, like, 50,000 intros in the last, you know, 10 years, and, uh, 2,300 hires.
- 47:06So, um, not everyone gets hired. [chuckles] And then after people get hired, um, yeah, things don't work out.
- 47:15Most, I'm proud to say, like, probably 95% of the time it works out really well, and there's just, you know, some cases where, um, things don't work out. I haven't heard any super terrible horror stories.
- 47:26Um, but- I feel like that's a testament to your ability to create a good network 'cause you'd think there'd be, like, bound to be some bad horror stories with that many intros and that many hires. Yeah.
- 47:38Yeah, no, there definitely have been bad hires that have been made, for sure. Um, you know, people don't work out, people don't show up, for example, um, change their mind last minute. Um, yeah, people...
- 47:49It's, it's funny, like, it's the only product you can sell that has self, has, you know, self-will, right? So if I sell you this cup, the cup can't just say that they don't wanna go [chuckles] to the...
- 47:57You know, if you buy a new car, the car doesn't decide whether they don't like the owner or not, so... And obviously, you're not selling the person, but you're selling their services and, and skills. Um, [laughs]
- 48:06uh, but it's, it's kind of both the, the, the g- the, the good and the bad, right? 'Cause n- on the positive side, you see the impact that it makes, and sometimes people pleasantly surprise you.
- 48:15Like, you didn't really expect that to happen. But actually just got a text this morning. It wasn't a hire we made, but just an intro I made after a coffee meeting I had.
- 48:21It was more just, um, someone needed someone with experience with blockchain engi- engineering. And, um, I made an intro. Didn't actually... I totally forgot about it.
- 48:29And then six months later, I got a text saying, "Oh, we're, you know, working together. It's good." So that's cool. Um, so you get pleasantly surprised. But, um, yeah, to, to get you back to your question about vetting.
- 48:39So, um, one thing that we created early on was an English vetting system. Uh, all our candidates have intro videos. Uh, so, uh, you can watch their intro video.
- 48:47And then we've actually been using AI for quite a while now, since 2019, to vet their English, uh, without humans having to watch the video.
- 48:54Um, we b- we were able to get a data set of about 40,000 videos that were created by a, a ESL school that we were partnered with before, um, that was graded manually, and then we used that to train the model to be able to say, "Okay, this person actually has good English or not."
- 49:08So the English is the first thing. The second thing is coding tests.
- 49:10So we've used a lot of different providers over the years, but- Basically, finding how to measure if someone's a good engineer or not is a really, it's a really hard problem, um, uh, 'cause a lot of these kinda like take-home tests don't really work.
- 49:22Um, but then at the same time you don't wanna do like an hour interview with a human 'cause that also doesn't scale, so that's been a challenge. Um, but we've been u- using those kinda third-party platforms.
- 49:33Uh, and then sometimes we don't always have to do it 'cause you can usually get enough data from just like reading the profile, but we also like to have a call with the person and actually have a conversation.
- 49:41And that, you know, that's where our recruiters come in and, and talk to the candidate for about 10, 15 minutes and just, um, you know, answer any questions they might have and, and really kinda dig into the details, um, that you sometimes can't get from just a profile.
- 49:53Uh, so yeah, that would be the three-step process we use. And what's that, like what does it look like to work with bigger and bigger companies? I mean, you guys have worked with some massive companies in the tech space.
- 50:04Do you feel like there's pressure involved as you start to work with bigger and bigger companies to deliver or do you- Mm... do you find that you kind of, that rolls off of you- Yeah... 'cause you've done so many intros?
- 50:14Um, actually, I prefer the mid-size companies. Um, so it's cool to say you've made hires at like, I won't say any specific names. You can-- People can go to our website and see the logos. Uh, um, [clears throat]
- 50:25but enterprise clients are, you know, fun to say 'cause people recognize the name. But they're usually really slow, they don't pay that well, and, um, they don't hire that mi- that much.
- 50:36So our best customers have been kinda mid-size companies that don't have a really big talent brand, or at least when we start working with them, don't have really huge talent brands.
- 50:46People don't know them as like a great place to work, at least not yet.
- 50:50Um, and maybe they're in cities like Winnipeg, Calgary, um, Kitchener-Waterloo, where you don't have a lot of people in general, and let alone software engineers. Um, Halifax, for example.
- 51:02We had some really great clients out in, in Halifax over the years. So yeah, I, I feel like that's, uh, those are kind of my favorite.
- 51:09And, uh, I used to get really impressed, like, "Oh man, we got this really big client that everyone knows," but then, you know, after going through like procurement to try and get y- your invoice paid for three months, it's just, okay, I, I don't really wanna work with this company anymore.
- 51:21[laughs] And we've experienced the same thing in AI too.
- 51:23It's like those enterprise big logos and names are great for the website, they're great to be able to bring up in prospect conversations, but in terms of like the tangible direct correlation to the work that needs to happen in these small and mid-size companies, it's like it starts to blur a little bit, right?
- 51:38It's like these are cool on paper, but here's actually a whole bunch of use cases in other small businesses like yours that you don't wanna hear about, but are actually useful to you. Yeah.
- 51:48And I also feel like they're easier to work with. They're more grateful for like when you actually, you know, deliver. Um, they have budget 'cause they're not just like, you know, a random small company.
- 51:57They're, they have, uh, say, um, you know, Series A, Series B kinda funding. [clears throat] Um, and then also you can grow with them, which is cool too. Yeah. I'm, I'm curious.
- 52:08I, I wanna get back to the, the Canada piece. We talked a lot about immigration and, and the way that you thought about that.
- 52:14But again, coming, like you've lived all over the world, came back, decided to build a business here.
- 52:19Why was Canada the place that you chose to build this business, and how do you think we can incentivize others to build businesses here in the future? Mm. Yeah. I think it's... So kinda personally, um, I grew up here.
- 52:33I feel really comfortable in the city. Um, it's a really great place to live, uh, just from quality of life point of view. Um, family's here. And then I guess you kinda have
- 52:47this access to the American market, um, and really the global market, but, um, the, the, the American market, which is the largest economy in the world, but you don't have to, um, live there [laughs] if that makes sense.
- 53:00Yeah. Um, not that, you know, I, I went to school there. I'm really a big fan of the US in general.
- 53:05Um, I think actually we kinda need to get a- away from this kinda us versus them narrative of like, okay, moving to San Francisco or New York is bad. Like do, do, do what you need to do for your career. Um, uh, so yeah.
- 53:18Um, but I, I just generally, um, kind of feel like myself when I'm here, and therefore I can focus on my work more than otherwise.
- 53:29We've talked a lot about what Canada needs to do from both an immigration perspective, also from an AI perspective. We talked about sovereign AI, sovereign data inside of the country.
- 53:38Walk us through what that bear and bull case looks like for Canada if we go down the path of implementing all of these things that we've talked about as a nation versus going the opposite direction, which is maybe not having sovereign AI or letting in a whole bunch of immigrants that aren't properly skilled or, or even the other way, where it's we're letting in, uh, or we're stopping the borders and stopping immigrants from coming into the country altogether.
- 54:01What does that best case scenario look like, and what does the worst case scenario look like for Canada in, in five years? Yeah. I think we could be like the Switzerland or Norway of North America.
- 54:10Um, relatively small population, incredible natural resources and land mass. Um, and I think we could be, you know, using that to our benefit rather than being drowned in all the bureaucracy that we are currently in.
- 54:23Um, like I keep coming back to energy, which I think is the fundamental kind of building block of everything. Like when you compute, uh, electricity is the biggest bottleneck right now in terms of innovation.
- 54:34Um, why can't Canada be the, the world's leading producer of electricity and exporter of energy globally, right? Like we have so many projects, so many natural resources. Uh, and it doesn't have to be just oil and gas.
- 54:45You know, hydro, solar, um, uh, what's the one undergr- uh, I know this, this is gas, but like LNG, liquefied natural gas. Um, so there's, there's just... Yeah, I think like if we can get that
- 54:57sorted, um, that, that, that's, that would be a really big thing. And have like, yeah, um, lower taxes, more housing, and kinda...
- 55:09I remember, you know, the Canada I grew, I grew up in as a kid, um, say is like a safe place where you could raise a family and, you know- I, I don't know.
- 55:17Maybe it's hard to say, like, things were all great back then, 'cause obviously they weren't. But, um, I think we've kinda gone a l- a, a, away from that.
- 55:23Um, and then on the talent side, like if we bring in some of the world's best or a lot of the world's best tech talent or, you know, AI researchers, et cetera, um, I think that'll fuel a huge amount of innovation and create a lot of businesses that, um, you know, will be Ca- Canada-owned and, um, you know, serving the world's market.
- 55:40So, uh, yeah, I'm pretty optimistic we can... I mean, I don't know if we c- we'll get there, but, uh, like we have the potential for that, for sure.
- 55:48And I think there's such a clear link between bringing in high-quality talent in these critical fields and success in those fields, building more businesses.
- 55:58Like we believe that with AI, we're gonna have more businesses, smaller businesses. Oh, for sure. It's gonna enable entrepreneurship at a scale that we've never seen before.
- 56:06Um, and in doing so, we'll create the next generation of companies and kind of bring J- Canada back to a kind of a culture of builders, and we're excited by that. So it's gonna be- Yeah... gonna be good. Yeah, I agree.
- 56:18I think that, that c- uh, concept of more companies, um, and maybe less people per company, but more kinda mid-size, small businesses, I, I, I'm seeing that as well.
- 56:26We ask in every one of our conversations a guest to leave a question- Yeah... for the next guest- Yeah... without knowing who they are. Uh, the question that was left for you was, when you're thinking, when you're...
- 56:37The question that's been left for you is, in quiet moments, when you're taking a pause from running your business or you're not in the everyday busyness of it,
- 56:46what's the quiet voice in your head telling you to do, or what's it telling you in general? [lips smack] Well,
- 56:52a lot of time I spent freaking out about the future and [clears throat] worrying about where things are going, so, you know, potential problems, issues, how to solve that. It just kinda always in my mind is a way of,
- 57:07you know, prev- preventing those things from happening. Um, so the thing that I tell myself is to be present in the moment, uh, in order to,
- 57:16like, not create these doomsday scenarios or way-too-positive scenarios in my head, 'cause, uh, that's, that's something, uh, that I've, I've always struggled with, um, as, as well as looking in the past and saying, "Oh," like, you know, "the good old days back then," or, you know, "Things were way better before."
- 57:31So I feel like, um, as much as I can, I'm trying to remind myself just to be in this moment here and, um, you know, let the future come, and obviously you wanna prepare and stuff, but don't worry unnecessarily for what, uh, probably won't even happen.
- 57:47I feel like that's a good message for entrepreneurs in general. I know, like from our experience, this being like both of our second companies, um, it feels like you're on a rollercoaster every day.
- 57:57You're just always, can be the best day of your life, the worst day of your life, and you're always thinking.
- 58:01I remember you saying to me like two years ago, before we were co-founders, that you think about, like you just lie awake in bed at night thinking about like all the things that you could do, all the things that are happening, and it's like, I like the perspective of trying to just be more present.
- 58:18But also the thing as entrepreneurs, we tie our feelings and ego on a daily basis, like our purpose and how we feel about
- 58:28our outlook on life is so tied to the performance of how well things are going in the business on a daily basis. And you have to take that step back of being like,
- 58:37center yourself in gratitude and be like, "This is incredible that we're even in this moment to be able to experience this issue or challenge that we're going through."
- 58:46And it's less about, "This is a reflection on me personally," and more that this is something that we get to experience and go through and come out on the other side being, being stronger and have, have gone through a, a struggle like that.
- 59:00Yeah, definitely. Um, and also I feel like you usually don't get challenges that you're not able to overcome. So, um,
- 59:09like whenever a challenging moment happens, which happens more often [chuckles] than I'd like, um, you kind of have to be like, "Oh, wow," like that's some- like it's almost take it as a compliment in a way.
- 59:21It's like, oh, like, uh, 'cause look at the challenges that, you know, the s- most successful people solve.
- 59:26They're way bigger than the ones that you and I solve, like just, you know, 'cause the nature of where they're at.
- 59:30So like I remember seeing something with, um, Z- Zuckerberg waking up every morning and getting like millions of messages or, you know, thoughts of messages about all these problems around the world and it's like that's how, like the, the, the level of success you are kind of is almost like, um, parallel to the l- the, the type of challenges that you're, you get to solve.
- 59:49So, uh, one thing, that's kinda way I flip it, uh, to, to be like grateful for the challenge, and that's hard to... easy to say, hard to do.
- 59:56[laughs] 'Cause yeah, like even right now we're going through some stuff and I'm like, "Oh, goddamn." [chuckles] I have to like, um, figure out ways to solve it.
- 1:00:03But typically, um, yeah, I find like it, it tends, tends to work out. Yeah. No, I agree. I think like my perspective has been, if you, you, you get the experience of, like you get to go through
- 1:00:18and build up the thicker skin, build up the resiliency of having like not fun things happen to you, and the better you get at navigating it, the easier it'll get in the future. Well, curious to- Yeah...
- 1:00:28to hear what, what your question would be for our next guest. Huh. Not knowing who they are. Um, well, I really like the 25-year-old question, so I'll s- I'll steal, I'll steal that one.
- 1:00:37[laughs] Uh, what would you tell yourself maybe 10 years before? Awesome. Well, thank you. We appreciate the time. Cool. Yeah. Yeah. This has been awesome. Thanks for having, having me here. This was fun. Cool.
- 1:00:45Well, thanks for joining us. Yeah. [upbeat music]