Latest / Following Leads / How the Idaho Murders Shattered a Safe College Town
Transcript
- 00:00:00 Amanda Rowley: Two things. When Kaylee Goncalves, her dad, took that podium and turned it around to face Kohberger, I go, oh, it was. That to me was like, we have something to say and we want you to hear it. And and then Kaylee's sister, her comments sit up straight. Look at me when I'm talking to you. And and she she spoke from the heart. She spoke from the rage, from all the emotion that her and her family had been feeling this whole time. And it was hard not to get emotional watching that. I get emotional thinking about it. 00:00:45 Laura Hettiger: Our country loves a mystery. Millions of us are captivated by true crime. We hang on to every headline, every breaking news update, any tidbit we can get our hands on. But eventually the news cycle moves on and so do we, oftentimes forgetting the very real human impact of true crime. But there are some stories that we just can't move on from. And one of those stories happened one Awful Night in Idaho, that awful night where these four college students Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and Maddie Mogen went to sleep at a home just steps from their university campus, and were brutally murdered in the early morning hours. That one awful night led to weeks of fear and nationwide manhunt and the eventual arrest of Bryan Kohberger. That one awful night forever changed four families, countless friends, and rocked an entire community. And today, a full year after Bryan Kohberger stood in that courtroom and admitted to killing these four college students, There's still so many questions left unanswered. Most importantly, why? Our guest today has followed this story from that one awful night in Idaho through the manhunt, the arrest, and then the plea deal. And today, she's helping us understand not only what happened, but what questions may never be answered. I am grateful to get the perspective of Amanda Rowley. Amanda, thank you for being here. 00:02:31 Amanda Rowley: Hi, Laura. 00:02:32 Laura Hettiger: Let's set the stage. Please take me back to November of twenty twenty two. What do you remember about getting the call after these four young lives were taken from them? 00:02:45 Amanda Rowley: I actually got the call. Uh, it was it was a weekend, I believe. And I had heard, hey, there's some commotion in Moscow. And that's, that's shocking to me to hear something like that in Moscow, Idaho, because it's it's a quaint small town just like my college town just across the border in Pullman. Nothing big happens there. So when I hear commotion in Moscow, my immediate thought was, oh, it's a big fire, right? It's it's it's something of that nature. Uh, it didn't turn out to be that way. It was a big, big commotion. Um, we sent a crew down that same day only because we thought, okay, let's check it out. It it was rumored to be a gas leak. Some some kids had died because of a gas leak in a rented home. That's that's the initial rumor mill that was surrounding that story. Then that as things developed, uh, we learned that it was for University of Idaho students and then the police department who's usually, you know, they're always very forthcoming. They're always, you know, working with media. They were very tight lipped on this situation. And all they would tell us is four students were found dead. We didn't know why. We didn't know the timeline. And that that started to send flags. I mean, we we started okay, what what could this mean? Um, the days, the weeks after were really tiring, emotional and the hardest story I've ever covered as a reporter. And, and it struck home for me personally because of how close it was to the town that I called home for four years. I mean, nothing like this happens in this area. 00:04:31 Laura Hettiger: You say tiring and emotional, but yet also full of fear because as we did learn more, it wasn't a gas leak. It was a horrific homicide where there was no killer that we could quickly point to. What do you remember about the intense fear that took over that community for weeks? 00:04:56 Amanda Rowley: It was unlike any type of fear I've ever experienced. This community has ever experienced. I mean, there was just this blanket of darkness. You could feel it. You could hear it in the people that you talked to. We spent time speaking with restaurant owners and, uh, you know, the neighbors nearby. And usually when I've gone to that area, it's, it's light. It's, oh, well, you know, the, the mayor's not listening to us. It's, you know, it's lighter, but they're just felt like this deep sense of sadness and, and worry because at that point, before we knew who was behind this, who did this crime, that was the fear. It's it's the monster that you don't know. Mhm. Right. And, and that was the sense that just kind of kept everybody on guard. Usually you could just walk around at any time and, and feel safe. I mean, that was that's the type of town it is. And that immediately got squashed after this. This story developed. 00:05:53 Laura Hettiger: Because it's a college town. And when a parent sends their eighteen, nineteen, twenty, twenty one year old to college, they do think it's safe. And as a college kid, you feel absolutely invincible. What do you remember going back to those early days where you realize this now just isn't a story you're covering? 00:06:19 Amanda Rowley: It happened right away, Laura. Like once we realized there's someone behind this tragedy and and it struck these kids from, you know, from Idaho, from this wonderful town. It it hit right away. I mean, my first question was, how could this happen here? How could this happen here that it doesn't happen here. This is a this is a, a nice area. So it, it didn't take long. And I think for me as a reporter, I, it was hard to keep those emotions in check because the gravity of it really did weigh on every conversation, every editorial meeting. Um, you want to be sensitive to how the community, the families are processing what's happening while also, you know, giving the most up to date information because there was that hunger not just locally, but it turned into internationally what happened, right? 00:07:15 Laura Hettiger: Yes. And that hunger was something that was coming from all sides. Of course, you have the internet sleuths that sometimes come up with clues that that maybe other people didn't see, but it was nonstop. And as a news consumer, we want every update, every update. And sometimes people forget about those for grieving families. 00:07:44 Amanda Rowley: Yeah, yeah. They're living the worst days and years of their entire life. And, and that to me was really important to keep in mind when we were standing outside the home where it happened every day. I mean, as a local news reporter, you're, you know, always keeping your eyes out for the latest updates while also balancing the emotions and that the family seeing these updates all the time, and they're being inundated with media, news, media and as well as influencers that are, you know, you know, coming to the scene, um, asking questions, tell us what you think. And it's a lot, it's a lot to take on and balancing that is that was, I think that was a big struggle for a lot. But I mean, it got all this attention, uh, which was new for me, all this attention from not just your traditional news media. I mean, we were seeing people that were out there filming with selfie sticks. And that's, that's where it got Erkki. For me, it was like, man, this is yes, everyone's hungry for the latest update, but how do you how do you balance that respect? 00:08:48 Laura Hettiger: Yes. With sensitivity. Right. Because as soon as we found out there was a suspect right after Christmas of twenty twenty two, the focus was Bryan Kohberger, Bryan Kohberger, Bryan Kohberger. But yet the focus should have always stayed on Kaylee, Ethan, Xana, and Maddie, when you saw their families even at a distance or interacted with them, what did you witness about the families that maybe the rest of us did not see? 00:09:21 Amanda Rowley: About the families that we didn't see. 00:09:23 Laura Hettiger: And the friends two of these four beautiful souls? 00:09:29 Amanda Rowley: I mean, what we did see was, was the definite heartbreak. Um, but we didn't see, I think I touched on this is. It was, it was hard seeing the world descend on this town and trying to be sensitive in that coverage. I mean, it was, it was almost like a news mine. Right. And, and so I think what, what most people didn't see and occasionally I would. I would pull the camera back right when we were waiting outside the courthouse, even, uh, for co-workers arrival to be booked. Took a step back and just showed people this is this is the scale of the attention this story is getting. Look at the lineup that I'm seeing here in Moscow. Usually it's me and two other two other folks that are there. And so I showed that to our viewers in the sense to just, uh, put a spotlight on just how big of a scale this is and how important it is, even, I think outside the community. Um, that was really hard to capture again, because you're trying to be sensitive, right? Yeah. 00:10:49 Laura Hettiger: Because you're a human being. Mhm. Before you're a reporter. Yes. Yes. It was very hard to watch and to learn more about Bryan Kohberger, just as a news consumer. And I think for everyone watching and listening to, because we did have so many questions. Take me back to last summer. There were so many things breaking from the court system. When's it going to trial? Oh, it's delayed again. What's happening now? And then right around the Fourth of July, the news started breaking that there was not going to be a trial, that there was going to be a plea deal. Yeah. What do you remember about that time? 00:11:31 Amanda Rowley: Laura, that was the biggest shock that a plea deal is something we never saw coming. I mean, from the first day he was in court, he didn't even enter a plea. He didn't say guilty or not guilty. The judge had to enter it for him. And he stood by this. You know, judge entered not guilty plea the entire time. Didn't say a word. And so for this big bomb to drop. I mean, it was just kind of so even keel. And I don't mean that in the sense that, you know, it was calm. It was just he he maintained just a silent persona and and, and just stood by his. I'm I'm, I'm not guilty. So to come out with a plea deal, it just. I couldn't believe it. I thought it was a joke. At first I thought, no, no, no, no, no, we need a check. We need to double check this. I was up in the mountains camping and came down and raced, raced into cell phone connection, called my news director and said, okay, I'm going to Boise. I'm going to Boise. Mhm. Uh, who can I, who can I take with me? And that day was, I mean, again, just the amount of the scale of media presence there was incredible. And again, it speaks to just that hunger for what's going to happen next, what's going to happen next, right. 00:12:47 Laura Hettiger: And the hunger for the casual news observer was y y. Yes. Yeah. 00:12:56 Amanda Rowley: I wanted to know why after a couple years of, you know, I mean, the first month it was standing every day outside that house waiting for an update. And my heart and my journalistic mindset was invested in the why. The community wanted to know why and the families. The families want to know why, and I think that is what I mean. They said it on the day of the the plea deal when when they came to listen to that, that hearing. We want to know why. We want to know what happened, what what caused this man to do something so horrific to our loved ones. And unfortunately, we I don't think we're ever going to know why. And the judge said in, in the sentencing, that final moment where everything just closed, he said, I don't even think we'll get the truth. If if for some reason he comes forward and says, here's what went through my mind. He's like, don't, don't believe it. I don't think we're even going to get the truth out of him. 00:13:55 Laura Hettiger: I think we all learned a lot about the judicial system through this case. And I'm thinking back to where I was when I listened to the hours of the victim impact statements. What do you remember about that time? Being in the courtroom, hearing the brothers, the sisters, the friends, the parents? Yeah. 00:14:21 Amanda Rowley: I want to be transparent. I sat right outside the courthouse. My team that we were coordinating with sat in the courtroom on the day of the sentencing. Uh, I was watching the feed right outside. What stood out to me that day were two things. When Kaylee Goncalves, her dad, took that podium and turned it around to face Kohberger, I go, oh, it was that to me was like, we have something to say and we want you to hear it. And and then Kaylee's sister, her comments sit up straight. Look at me when I'm talking to you. And and she she spoke from the heart. She spoke from the rage, from all the emotion that her and her family had been feeling this whole time. And it was hard not to get emotional watching that. I get emotional thinking about it. Um, and as a crime and courts reporter, typically that's not the type of, uh, victim impact statement the judges allow, right? They typically keep it very, um, there's very, there's a process to it and victim impact statements. You're supposed to address the judge, which is why that's why I brought up the podium move. Right. The judge allowed the dad to turn that podium and address kohberger. And the things that Kaylee's sister said, they, you know, she swore a few times. Right. And usually a judge would squash these type of comments. This judge I this is my opinion. I think he totally understood the gravity of this case, what the families have been going through. He didn't say a peep. He never paused and said, okay, let's return to order. And I. I thought that was really powerful. He in that moment gave the family their time to speak, because I don't think they really, truly felt like they had a say in any of this. And this was their moment to do that. And that's, that's what stood out to me. And I and I mean, I'll carry those words forever. And even thinking about the roommates, their, their testimony, I mean, hearing their account of what happened and the guilt that they still carry. I, I don't think I'll ever forget those words spoken and how just how vulnerable they were because you're literally on a national international stage. It was live streamed, right. And they, they put it all on the floor. 00:16:50 Laura Hettiger: It's now been a year. You have since moved to Saint Louis. You have left that community. I have to imagine this situation. Those four college students, they haven't left you and they won't. How has this story changed you? 00:17:12 Amanda Rowley: Laura, you're hitting the heart strings. Well, we were sitting here and I'm looking at these photos. I haven't, um, I haven't looked at them since I left Spokane. Oh, man. Mhm. Um, it's not gonna leave me. Um. Sorry. Um, I said earlier, I, um, I went to school in Pullman, and that is truly my second home. Uh, I always felt safe there, and. Uh, for the first time ever in my life. I never thought I'd go to my second home and not feel safe and dread it. Um, because of that, that dark cloud that, that hung over this. But what truly like turned it around for me is seeing the families come forward and in their grief continue to be so strong and, um, and the community truly just going to bat for each other, like it was just a whole other level of love that I'd never seen before. And it just gave me hope that like, we're, we're gonna move on from this, right? We're gonna, we're gonna remember it, but we're going to be stronger together. That's the only way to do it. And, um, so moving to Saint Louis, um, I have plans to go back to Pullman, and that is top of mind for me. Um, going back to the area and just remembering the heartbreak that was there, but also trying to find the light. There are, there are, um, memorials, um, in the area. Uh, the, one of the families is, uh, from the North Idaho, um, community there in Coeur d'Alene. There's a bench in honor of Kaylee and Maddie. Um, I used to walk there with my husband on the weekends, and I would take a moment and just honor that. Um, yeah, I wasn't expecting to get that emotional, but it it does mean a lot, uh, that I had the honor to. Be a journalist and report on the crucial steps in this story because it's important to understand like the, the process and, and make sure that there isn't this misinformation out there because it was swirling. There were there were rumors up the wazoo. And it was an honor for me to help try to navigate that and give people the best information possible. And, and in some way, I tried to honor the family in that sense. 00:20:08 Laura Hettiger: Um, I think you absolutely have. Thank you. Amanda, thank you for your openness, your transparency, And your love and heart that went into covering this for three and a half years. Thank you. 00:20:26 (Following Leads Narration): On the next episode of Following Leads. 00:20:29 Laura Hettiger: February first, twenty twenty six. Many of us start getting alerts sent to our phone all over the country, saying that the mother of Today show host Savannah Guthrie was missing. What do you remember about those initial reports? Where is Nancy? The abduction of today show host Savannah Guthrie's mom, Nancy Guthrie, not only shocked the nation and devastated the Guthrie family, it had a huge impact on the Tucson community. So many people now looking over their shoulders, neighbors questioning neighbors, and everyone asking, how did this happen and how did this happen here?