Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 350:1-351:1

Transcript

Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 350:1-351:1 · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

0:00
Good morning. We are starting Shannon.
0:02
Just yesterday. If I mentioned that a notion is,
0:06
it was just the robin. Then I was a mistake.
0:08
I meant to say caramel is my issue was water water.
0:12
You could find water in Arusha serabian, like in a puddle or a
0:16
little short ditch and you could have water in my computer
0:22
Carmela sources, theocracy the water could be found anywhere.
0:25
Okay, whatever that was worth. Also, just came out, we saw from
0:30
yesterday that we shouted cock. We do see a way that if someone
0:33
gets stuck, and they have to carry something or or a baby or
0:39
a child one is passing between many people or even perhaps just
0:45
to people less than dollar Thomas and just doing like a
0:48
passing, it in between them like a hot potato.
0:51
That would be a, that would be a permissible way of transporting.
0:57
Okay. Shin None again, Olive.
1:01
Well, this is dinamo. See Roche overrule go near shoot
1:05
her shoot. So we touched upon some of the
1:07
principles yesterday in the beginning of sat sheer.
1:11
So it'll follow from here. Let's see.
1:14
Olive Omitted on beer, shoot a hit, the person is standing
1:20
indoors. Note the other Amish, Lira shoot
1:23
her Robin and he sticks out his hand.
1:26
Outside the red or through a window.
1:29
He's indoors and his hand is outdoors.
1:32
Let's say it's leading right into a Russia serabian for
1:35
example. Lumet Alto-Shaam, how fancy you
1:38
can move things outside. Move it a couple feet this way,
1:43
couple feet away, right? Just less Shane, mm streak in
1:48
love and my comes to Ahmed, we're talking about items that
1:53
you don't need them indoors, okay?
1:56
So you're moving items that are outside, doesn't really matter
2:01
if you need them or not on a derisive level, that's exert
2:04
their abundant. So again You're inside the
2:07
objects are outside in your lot of move them outside because
2:11
you're not moving them as long as you keep them outside and
2:14
don't move them indoors. Shh notes on my car.
2:18
No money honey. Can you pick him up here?
2:20
And put them down there without shallow area of your Mr. Obama's
2:23
as long as you're within dollar Thomas of the object, doesn't
2:27
get moved doll. It almost no problem.
2:30
Hello, Kai Xin and shamea. VMS a low and we're not worried
2:35
that you're going to be moving them, there's no gazzara that
2:37
were afraid. You're going to be moving the
2:39
more than dollar almost are bringing them into the register
2:41
yakit. He launched a time.
2:43
Three themes Obama comes through on that jump, since you do Don't
2:46
really need them in your. We're indoors where you are.
2:50
He'll cock. So therefore muta Alamo beer
2:53
shooter Robin you gotta stand outside little Mafia
2:57
specialist:yeah action if you're outdoors and was just to Rob him
3:01
and the key is indoors and you want to open up indoors so as
3:06
long as the key stays indoors your ladder reach in and turn
3:10
the key, turn the door, whatever the crane M RC ocular sister
3:14
Robin in either direction. Doesn't matter.
3:17
It's in the scenario if you're in or out as long as you're not
3:20
taking an item and crossing the barrier from in to out.
3:23
As long as you're sure, it's okay for you to be moving it
3:26
around where it is, and not transporting it from one wrist,
3:32
wrist to another or dollar dramas.
3:35
Except when we said there's Xavier, when you might want to
3:37
bring it indoors. And this is a and it with all
3:41
objects, you're allowed to do it.
3:43
We're going to see a case where it makes a difference.
3:45
But basically, We is long. As it's, we're not afraid,
3:47
you're going to bring it indoors.
3:49
It doesn't matter. Silver cheap, not cheap,
3:52
whatever expensive. It doesn't make a difference.
3:54
What the items are you allowed to move them?
3:56
Where they are of our lawyer? I'm ambitious, Yakov 0 shoulder.
4:00
She was robbed in the East a sham.
4:03
However, here this is an ester, Darrell Bonner, you can't be
4:07
standing outside. Well, Stan.
4:11
Well, the first case is standing inside, sticking your head, out
4:14
the window, or out the door and drinking with a cup.
4:19
Usually is a situation, but I don't think it matters either
4:23
way. You can't stick your head out
4:25
and drink, okay? Even when it goes into your
4:28
mouth or you're lifting up the cup, it's day that all the is
4:31
staying in that Rush us. There's a matter if your feet
4:34
are indoors. Let's say your mouth is outdoors
4:37
and you're putting the liquid into your mouth.
4:39
Well. Mouthing now is in was just her
4:42
Robin so there's no issue. The ricer going on whatsoever.
4:46
So it cut or you're standing outdoors and you're leaning
4:49
indoors. You want to get a drink from
4:51
your friend, you're outside playing ball and you're thirsty.
4:55
You reach into your friends window and you drink, you stick
4:58
your head inside and you drink inside his house.
5:03
Through the window. So as you have to go inside his
5:05
house to drink, you can stay outside and drink indoors.
5:09
It's well, I'd say, it's a gender of Honor, I'll let you in
5:12
Kenya can use Rochelle's, arugula, makka, moo shu Showtek
5:17
must be that you have most of your body, right?
5:20
And Lena, and I don't know, but but at least one full leg in be
5:24
most of your body in and you have your head inside or
5:29
whatever were you drinking and then you can drink their the
5:32
cave. A bunch of its article 81 my
5:34
machine on camera V mL of because once these are items
5:38
that you need for yourself, so we're afraid you're going to end
5:42
up moving them and you might by mistake carry them from one
5:46
resource to another where you are, okay?
5:50
All right, that's all akka. And okay.
6:02
What's the number? I just points out.
6:03
I think it's obvious. Even when we said before, you're
6:06
not allowed to carry it. More than dollar damos.
6:11
That means, even if you lift it up, you carry it or you move it
6:16
above tens, Fox him and then you put it down on the ground.
6:19
That's also going to be uh, sir because you didn't like Kira and
6:24
a Hanukkah of doll it almost so it doesn't matter if while it's
6:30
in the air. It's also through a computer,
6:33
it's still a sir. Okay, let's keep reading.
6:41
Well, muhtar Obama versus the Yaki, the brushes are album,
6:44
releases be caramelized. Now this is only a problem in a
6:49
case of Russia, so Yahoo into a register Robin.
6:53
But if it's true, the caramel has, if either one of the
6:57
locations are a Karma lists and very likely, that's the case of
7:03
my son, your situation. Obviously, it depends on the
7:06
city, depends where you are. So then if it's a caramel
7:09
assits, There's no Xavier, their abundant will kind of like eggs
7:14
are Alexandra creation of a farce you.
7:17
Now, this next station fire stream is not the hello, but it
7:21
is another obviously valid opinion from the rezoning but
7:25
it's not a lock or the mice and most situations.
7:30
So what is it? It's a little bit more make you.
7:33
You can see the only time it was goes there.
7:35
This opinion is, if it's with expensive or nice, Kayla, Lee.
7:41
But if it's something like a plastic disposable cup, then
7:46
there's no bugs, are that you might bring it inside.
7:49
Okay, let's let's just read it inside.
7:53
But he'll uncle and myself, it's anytime you're making.
7:57
Or any time you're eating or giving you could perhaps even be
8:01
clothing depending on the situation there.
8:05
Then there would be the zero that we you might bring it in
8:08
the a schmelff are seeing that half at symmetry him though.
8:11
I know killing. I am shoot sorry Clem.
8:13
Some say there's only time there's an Xterra is if I nice
8:17
scaling, I don't know. Silver, maybe glass about a name
8:21
Calum Shane. Mm nayeem.
8:23
But if they're not nice and with Charlie shut him off of each
8:25
load zero sugar, abolish, oh shoot several avoid.
8:28
Even if you just look at your neck you can drink.
8:31
There's no gazzara Usha Arts, yell to him who had symmastia
8:34
feel, okay, Liam, Naima toilet out and everything else is also
8:38
motor is just just nice cups for water.
8:42
That's the only thing. We're worried about she'll Gazoo
8:44
Elevate Kelly and I'm Shota by hand only time there's this this
8:48
this era is by nice scaling. Nice cups when you're drinking.
8:53
To whom the carve on a. That's when we're more worried
8:55
about you, bringing it indoors by mistake and crossing the
8:59
lines and being over in this direction.
9:02
Okay. Bet Lillian would add a new
9:06
Terror beam via 1600, yurok pursue sahid, a person cannot
9:14
should be a derisive even person cannot stand in one rushes like
9:19
a register, Robin and and urinate or the spit bearish
9:25
shoot area fit into a different result.
9:27
Just crossing the barrier because you're in one reshoot
9:31
that goes to another Shirt, and it doesn't matter.
9:34
Okay, so these cases both these examples will be a sir, the
9:38
caramel eat, or would be a strong leader abundant to do
9:41
this, in a caramel 8, if cut right in other words, either
9:45
direction from Russia serabian treasure stockier, vice versa
9:48
that will be the right side and one of them to a car - or
9:51
caramel has to the other one would be an ester terrabona
9:54
number of points out. Also, if a person is standing in
9:59
a Russia serabian or in a Carmelite, Eat it.
10:02
Be us are also to spit or urinate more than dollars
10:08
fucking sofa person here. Which number of points out the
10:17
beer. Allah.
10:19
That now what happens? If, so we just said the simple
10:22
case of you aim, and you spit or whatever you're doing doll, it
10:27
almost straight into the air. That would be an
10:30
extraterrestrial right order. Abundant depends, mr.
10:32
Serabian caramelized. What about?
10:36
It's out on. You have a, it's a little bit of
10:37
a slope, the grounds, on a little bit of a slope, and you
10:41
spit or urinate right next to you.
10:43
But then since it's it's a sloped and it's it's rolling
10:49
there it's it's continuing going down the hill.
10:53
So he says it's if it was just her Robin it would be uh sir but
10:57
by a caramel estate would be murder.
11:00
We're going to see it again. Another example but there's a
11:02
concept shall look us Zuko hope the caramel eat.
11:05
They weren't goes there by a caramel eat if it's like the
11:10
rolling running down situation on a slope.
11:13
Nope. So therefore if a person is in
11:16
camping on Shabbos, or he's at a park and he needs to do it, it
11:20
needs to do to relieve himself. He has to be careful to not aim
11:24
it so that it goes a distance of dollars almost and as far as
11:29
running on a slope. So that's the case of depends if
11:33
it's mr. Serabian, or if it's terrabona,
11:36
this is the last part. I feel even Haute.
11:39
See, peeve vomit. Oh, look, who's now a Even if a
11:44
person is standing, let's say endorse, but he puts out his
11:50
mouth. So is the mouth is outside
11:53
through the window or the door or if a person puts out his, his
11:58
Aver, his Alma, and it's sticking out, and from there you
12:00
spit, or from there, you urinate solo, cuts, and you doing it
12:04
outside in Russia, Robin. So that's, uh, sir to do.
12:07
That's actually a case in the gemara.
12:09
That's a Suffolk and soffit a coup.
12:13
And the question is that I Locker is the show up and ask
12:17
questions the camera that the halaqa is if your your body is
12:22
indoors, but the orifice that it leaves, your body is outdoors.
12:27
So the gemara wants to know, do we go after the body?
12:30
Because that's really where the source of the liquid is
12:34
certainly by the bladder and said you go after that and you
12:37
just consider the Ava is just being like a pipe that just
12:41
passing right through or do you. You say no, you go after the
12:44
mouth and the end of the Aver though, the orifice, and that's
12:48
where the Akira happened. So it's actually a Suffolk in
12:52
the gemara and that's so there's only a so when it comes to
12:57
leaving your body, that's when there's the Suffolk because
13:00
maybe it goes after the origination which is inside the
13:03
body. But if you're just going to
13:05
throw it into someone's mouth, then there's no Suffolk wherever
13:08
the mouth is. That's where the, that's where
13:12
the item. Is right?
13:13
That's why you glad it stick out your heads or Raisa and drink
13:16
and its inertia serabian. Even though your feet are
13:19
indoors, no problem because the mouth is we don't say the water
13:23
that you're drinking lens inside.
13:24
Just that your body. We say it lands inside your
13:27
mouth or if someone throws it into your mouth.
13:28
So my dear It's okay. Now, what about Carmela's?
13:42
So from the show Connecticut's much money that it would be, uh,
13:48
sir. Although it's that is not clear
13:51
if you have half your body and have your body out, but the
13:53
mission number and the grass, they, you can buy a car milus.
13:58
If your body is in and your mouth is out, then it's not a
14:02
problem with the car. - because I hold in, is this stuff away
14:05
from the gemara, it's enough that our summer and by a
14:08
Carmelita it's would be more of a Suffolk they're abundant
14:12
nakula and so he says therefore by a Carmela sits It's okay.
14:21
Mature. Yeah.
14:21
Okay. That's it.
14:22
That's only if I had half your bodies, your body's in and you
14:26
have in your and just your mouth or your favor is outside in your
14:29
spitting, you're spitting, okay? But if you're outside completely
14:35
and you want to spit doll, it almost away.
14:38
That's for sure to be an ester their abundant by it caramelize.
14:41
Guillermo rogozhin need Lush Biff peeve who mooc on mazurka.
14:46
So now a person they created spit in your mouth.
14:50
It's waiting for them or mucus and you're ready to spit.
14:54
It's in your mouth. So, again, that's another
14:55
Suffolk in the gemara. So what do you do?
14:58
Can you carry Dalai Lama's? Ye Shi Misha.
15:01
All marichal oily are baramos miserable.
15:04
Ahmad Shah Rukh. So the lava is one is not
15:06
allowed to walk doll it almost in a Richard Serra beam while
15:10
he's carrying spit or mucus and his mouth as a dinner of so that
15:15
that's remarkable and that one. But what about a car milus?
15:20
He's so most rishonim most acronym that I've seen, Miss
15:24
Newberg has chosen the Pentagon. They all say, it's amateur by a
15:27
Carnales. If you're in a car milus, you're
15:30
allowed to have spit in your mouth and still walk dollar.
15:33
Dom us Now, if a person went outside, let's say already is
15:41
inertia serabian and he carried spit and or a candy in his mouth
15:48
doll, it almost or our food whatever or you moved from
15:53
indoors to outdoors and while it's in your mouth, right?
15:59
So you base so you did so since indoors or wherever your
16:03
starting point is when you moved your And started walking, you
16:07
did the Akira, right? You lifted it up.
16:10
So then what has long as you haven't stopped and you have
16:15
until, you know something else. But let's say you're crossing
16:17
the street, be careful. Because sometimes when you cross
16:19
the street, you stop before you cross, or there's a red light or
16:22
whatever it is, you look both ways.
16:24
And then you go, whatever it is. As long as you haven't stopped,
16:27
you have not stopped. So they, so the postgame say,
16:30
you should go back because you never did a Hanukkah, you never
16:34
stopped. So go back to where you were and
16:37
put it back and then therefore, you only did a Hanukkah and you
16:40
never did Anna Karenina class. You never over.
16:44
Okay, if it's too late and you already did and a Hanukkah and
16:49
you continue to walk in and you can't go back anymore.
16:52
So then there is not, it doesn't help to go back anymore, but if
16:55
you can try and spit it out, or put something down, if you're
17:00
holding the same thing, as if you're carrying something by
17:02
accident in your pocket, so try and put it down into a Malcolm A
17:06
tour wherever you're going into a Muslim picture or at least.
17:11
The caramel is versus a richesse to Robin.
17:15
Okay. I think we'll go on.
17:20
Give you finish Kim. All right.
17:25
Okay. Shaylen Olive almost together.
17:28
Lets you know, vicious rob you mr.
17:29
The person will see the Quasi the case inside with basically.
17:34
The case is an example of a case is a gutter.
17:38
You have water collecting for could be from a roof and a
17:43
collects along the gutter, some kind of a tube and you could
17:48
drink from it. Or just use the water from it.
17:51
Most of us probably won't drink from it, but we potentially
17:55
could use the water from it. At least.
17:56
That's the case. Probably more common in those
17:59
days than nowadays, because we have easy running water from a
18:02
sink all over the place. Okay, RF William, Adama shooter,
18:08
Ibaka burrito llamas, Gila one, cannot stand in Russia serabian.
18:12
That's the case. We're talking European, you're
18:15
standing in Rochester album and you put your hand mouth or a
18:19
clean. Right up to the muscular so it's
18:23
touching it. Your hand clear.
18:25
Em out that we sent I sent out a couple pictures from Lazada and
18:28
your shoe. Basically, you have like a
18:30
little tune or a little Gutter and you put your hand right up
18:36
to it, right? It's connecting.
18:38
So then shoot senior Acuna florica God or you have right?
18:43
What's a muscular? It's a garden.
18:45
Some kind of a pipe that's along the roof but talk slow.
18:48
Shit's Whack Him, some milk for God.
18:50
God and it, but the case is it's within three to four claim to
18:54
the Gog or the opening where you're collecting from is within
18:59
three talking to the to the roof and we'll acaba La Miami Manner.
19:04
And so this this this gutter collects the water from the
19:08
roof. And now the water is pouring out
19:11
after it rains and now you want to get that water.
19:14
Shake a bunch who buttocks Lucia.
19:16
Samoa for God. Classroom kid.
19:18
God we are. So as long as Within three as
19:21
long as this pipe, this gutter is within 312 him of the god.
19:27
It has the same halacha of the god, right?
19:29
That's this part is called me. Didn't allow hood and we're
19:34
assuming the God is on top of a house and the house has walls.
19:39
So the house, the roof is considered a Russia sake.
19:43
So since the roofs considered was just the Yaki that the this
19:47
muscular the gutter is a Russia's yucky.
19:50
And you're standing in wishes to Robin.
19:52
So if you take it straight from it, you just took from Russia.
19:55
Sarawak it into a Richard Sarabi.
19:58
Now this is there is been in houla, Mala Mia, Sara all amata
20:03
Mia sorrow. Now it doesn't matter if the
20:07
roof is within tens, Fox him or not to the ground because the
20:14
roof is either way in the gutter is either way considered
20:17
carassius, a yaqui. You're standing on the ground.
20:21
So you are considered where sister Robin.
20:23
So it doesn't really matter where the waters pouring from
20:26
the end of the gutter if it's above or below.
20:29
Okay? So it's either way it's a case
20:32
of Russia so Yakitori schiraldi a vol 1 is a mutter just
20:38
muta'ali, Claude mean obviously you're allowed to take it from
20:41
the air. All you have to do is just move
20:44
your hand or the clearly a little bit away, just a little
20:49
bit away. From The Gutter and is no
20:51
problem. It's so easy.
20:54
I feel um, yeah, do takshashila mascara, even if your hand is
20:58
within three talking of the gutter, no problem, there's no
21:02
love food from your hand to a gutter.
21:05
No didn't like that. And so why is it okay?
21:08
Because once it enters the airspace just omashu, then it's
21:14
no longer in a Russia sake, right?
21:17
If you were to have four walls and that's your ishizaki, a
21:21
Masha who outside of that wall is already know.
21:24
Longer and we're supposed to be awkward.
21:26
So if you're in the air right and you move it away from the
21:30
resistor, yeah, he just am a shoe then it's certainly
21:34
horizontally. If your boob it away, there's
21:37
just then it wouldn't be a problem for sure and fine.
21:44
Hi, Thomas, kill a bullet, a social media.
21:46
God. Now, what happens if you have a
21:49
gutter and it extends more than three talking, from the Gog,
21:53
against Thompson or shabbat shalom, And normal scene or is
21:59
it extends Beyond three, talking from a, from the roof.
22:03
So then what? Yeah, Calabria Do, Liam lockable
22:07
of mine. So then since you don't say love
22:10
it. So now this this orifice or the
22:16
end of this gutter is 312 him away.
22:20
So now it has the din of wherever it is, if it's over a
22:24
rash of heroin. If it's less than ten, fuckin
22:28
has a generator serabian if it's above 10, fuck him and his
22:30
Legion of a Mac computer. But either way, it's not.
22:34
If, once it's beyond three, it's definitely not a researcher.
22:37
Robin are we not part of the was just shocked it of the God.
22:42
So therefore, since it's either I'm a competitor or Russia, sir
22:46
Robin, and you're a nourishes, our Robin.
22:48
You can put your hand right up to it.
22:50
No problem who has on Shane behind marble above a hen
22:55
LaMotta, me, I'm sorry. And it should be less than four
22:58
by four below 10, because then you have an issue of it could be
23:03
a caramel has about him, uh, by inaudible are ba, but if it's
23:07
four by four, oh, I feel ain't behan are vulnerable or even if
23:12
it's not for both 4x4, Venom Mala Mia Sara.
23:16
But if it's above 10, it's us are being above 10 which still
23:22
make it a complete orbit. There's eggs, are there a bun on
23:24
if it's 4x4 according to the shock on our social scenarios
23:29
worried about for a platform of 4x4 above 10.
23:33
So Parts, Justice O'Connor says, it's uh, sir make 60 over here
23:38
because he holds you do have a dinner of a Karma list above 10.
23:43
If you have a just to explain the growing others say that you
23:47
can never have a caramel has above 10.
23:49
Let's say you have a flat surface, a 4x4 in the air or a
23:53
roof. That's 4x4.
23:55
We And upon this before, if the surface is above 10, trust him
24:01
from the ground. So the show honora holds, the
24:05
Carmela's could begin, the platform can restart the car,
24:09
Maurice, even if it's above 10 and then the caramel is goes up
24:12
10 talking from the roof for 10-12 km from the platform.
24:17
But then once you hit the air space of time, talking then
24:20
above that, is my computer the ground.
24:23
Other say that no The caramel is, it doesn't matter where the
24:28
roof is. Doesn't matter what the platform
24:29
is? You can never have Carmela's
24:33
above tenth. Welcome from the ground, doesn't
24:37
matter where the roof is a matter where this platform is.
24:40
It doesn't, it's, you know, kind of shocking dark past has its
24:43
you start all over again. Wherever this platform is you
24:45
beget, another 1012, human and higher and that's okay.
24:51
I think what actually stop.