Latest / Surrounded / Why Are Vegans So Annoying? | Jack Symes Surrounded Follow-up
Transcript
- 0:00How many cows dying is as bad as someone getting gassed in Auschwitz.
- 0:03The pain of the cow is worth just as much as the pain of the human being.
- 0:08In terms of pain,
- 0:09it's one for one.
- 0:10I think quitting meat's a lot harder,
- 0:12a lot easier
- 0:13than like
- 0:14not consuming pornography or not smoking.
- 0:17I think
- 0:17not consuming meat is way easier than those things and people just need to go like,
- 0:21right,
- 0:21I'll stop.
- 0:22That that's kind of crazy to me,
- 0:23but.
- 0:24Doctor Jack Symes,
- 0:26welcome back to uh
- 0:28Jubilee er for the surrounded follow-up.
- 0:31How are you feeling after your episode?
- 0:33Feeling great,
- 0:33I really enjoyed it.
- 0:34It was good fun.
- 0:35I
- 0:36always love chatting about veganism,
- 0:38er the first time I've done like
- 0:40a debate probably of that length in that style.
- 0:43But I was chef with it and er it was good to see you on the opposite chair as well.
- 0:48defending,
- 0:49defending meat eating or at least posing some questions,
- 0:51so there were some first times for everything and and uh I really enjoyed it.
- 0:55Yeah,
- 0:56no,
- 0:56it,
- 0:56it was,
- 0:57I really enjoyed that episode.
- 0:59For whatever reason,
- 1:00veganism is a topic that
- 1:03sparks a lot of
- 1:05uh fire and fury on the internet,
- 1:07uh,
- 1:07from my experience.
- 1:09Uh,
- 1:09do you,
- 1:11as you know,
- 1:11an advocate for the cause,
- 1:12does that ring true to you?
- 1:15Yeah,
- 1:15people don't like to be told that what they've been doing
- 1:17for their whole lives is wrong and why would they?
- 1:20Right,
- 1:20I think it taps into like
- 1:22an evolutionary thing.
- 1:24If me and you were out hunting and you were chasing one boar and me the other.
- 1:27If I said to you,
- 1:28why are you chasing that boar,
- 1:29you best have a good reason for it.
- 1:31I don't want to be out hunting with somebody who just does whatever
- 1:34you know the body feels.
- 1:35I want someone to act on reasons to be sensible.
- 1:38So you offer this justification out of the fact,
- 1:40and so I think veganism's really interesting because it captures so many of like.
- 1:45Different philosophical problems with people
- 1:47knowing what they should do and then doing otherwise,
- 1:50uh,
- 1:51because everyone sort of agrees on,
- 1:52on,
- 1:52on
- 1:53the big main point which is
- 1:55let's stop factory farming
- 1:56and,
- 1:57um,
- 1:57you know I struggle to find anybody
- 1:59who says no,
- 2:00I,
- 2:00I love factory farming.
- 2:02I think you should carry on,
- 2:03but just it's a view I never encounter.
- 2:06Um,
- 2:06so yeah,
- 2:06people don't like being told,
- 2:08um,
- 2:08that they've been doing something wrong forever,
- 2:10uh,
- 2:10but
- 2:11I think that just brings out a,
- 2:12a certain emotion and um.
- 2:14Exciting debate.
- 2:16Yeah.
- 2:17All right,
- 2:18so I'm gonna pull up the first clip.
- 2:19Are you ready to react?
- 2:20And I,
- 2:20I think you would,
- 2:21I got my uh
- 2:23Cow mug.
- 2:24I thought it was appropriate.
- 2:27I thought this was appropriate.
- 2:28Yeah,
- 2:28it's cute.
- 2:29I like it.
- 2:31Um,
- 2:31OK,
- 2:32so the first clip,
- 2:33this is gonna be with you and Nicole,
- 2:36and so.
- 2:39I think this was,
- 2:40I couldn't tell if you were enjoying this,
- 2:42but this is you and Nicole,
- 2:43and she's kind of,
- 2:44uh,
- 2:45she's poking
- 2:46fun at,
- 2:46at,
- 2:47uh,
- 2:48the debate.
- 2:49I,
- 2:50I think so.
- 2:51Killing plants is murder though.
- 2:53Oh dude,
- 2:53don't do that.
- 2:55Come on,
- 2:55you're joking.
- 2:56You're ripping it from the ground,
- 2:58you're ripping it from its mother.
- 3:00It's murder,
- 3:01and I enjoy the trivial pleasure of doing what the lions,
- 3:05what the hyenas,
- 3:06what the tigers have done for history.
- 3:09So you think plants can feel pain?
- 3:10Yes,
- 3:10they can.
- 3:11So you want to reduce that pain.
- 3:13You know why?
- 3:14Because I have an azalea and when I.
- 3:15Don't give it enough light,
- 3:17that thing dies,
- 3:18so it fills it.
- 3:19Yeah,
- 3:19I think plants have feelings too.
- 3:21Right.
- 3:22Do you think we should reduce the amount of pain that plants are experiencing?
- 3:25Yes,
- 3:25we should.
- 3:25Plants matter.
- 3:26# plants matter.
- 3:28OK,
- 3:29so according to Hannah Ritchie 2022,
- 3:31you get a 75% reduction
- 3:33in all of the land that you need for farming.
- 3:35So if Given the fact you're getting 40 to 1 in your calories
- 3:39and 30 to 1 in your protein from plants to animals then slaughtered,
- 3:42you get a 75% decrease in the plants that
- 3:45you're gonna kill if you go vegan for history,
- 3:48and I have to say this,
- 3:49when I go and don't give my fern enough light,
- 3:52it feels.
- 3:53OK,
- 3:54when I don't give it any water,
- 3:55it feels right.
- 3:57OK.
- 4:00No,
- 4:01that,
- 4:01that was,
- 4:02that was Nicole.
- 4:03Um,
- 4:04I felt like you were being pretty patient.
- 4:05It seemed like you were trying to argue.
- 4:07She was coming in with a bit,
- 4:09but
- 4:10my,
- 4:11my interpretation of that bit is.
- 4:14You know,
- 4:16The,
- 4:16the,
- 4:16the argument for veganism is,
- 4:19is sort of
- 4:21too precious.
- 4:21Like if we overempathize or
- 4:25with anything we can kind of find cause for concern.
- 4:28And so she was sort of,
- 4:30you know,
- 4:30poking fun,
- 4:31like
- 4:32caring too much about animals' feelings is,
- 4:34is the same as caring about plants' feelings.
- 4:38I,
- 4:38I'm curious,
- 4:39is that how it landed for you?
- 4:42I don't think,
- 4:43I don't think she really like
- 4:45believed it
- 4:46er
- 4:46sincerely.
- 4:47It's hard to know what Nicole actually believes.
- 4:50It was great though,
- 4:51I'd,
- 4:51I'd,
- 4:51I thought um
- 4:52it certainly brought something different to
- 4:54to the debate.
- 4:56I,
- 4:56I suppose in,
- 4:57in hindsight,
- 4:58when someone's
- 5:00doing that,
- 5:01maybe it's just better just to,
- 5:02to play along with the bit than it is
- 5:04to sort of give serious philosophical points and responses,
- 5:07um,
- 5:08but my brain just sort of goes straight into like.
- 5:11There might be people who sincerely have this objection,
- 5:14um,
- 5:15really,
- 5:16do,
- 5:16do they,
- 5:16I think it seems to be more of a reduction absurdum argument,
- 5:19right,
- 5:19that people are given
- 5:21that they're going,
- 5:22well,
- 5:22suppose you think that reducing suffering and pain in
- 5:24all instances is what you ought to do,
- 5:26uh,
- 5:27if
- 5:28fans feel pain and suffer,
- 5:29then you ought to reduce that as well,
- 5:31and that's the argument,
- 5:32um,
- 5:33and for the reasons I sort of gave him the tried to give him that
- 5:36aspect of the debate.
- 5:37Um,
- 5:38I don't use any evidence to suggest that
- 5:40plants can feel pain or suffer,
- 5:42and.
- 5:43Uh,
- 5:44I think that,
- 5:44as I said,
- 5:45the Hannah Ritchie study
- 5:46said that you get a 75% reduction in
- 5:49all of,
- 5:50uh,
- 5:50agricultural land
- 5:51if you switch to plant-based and so you
- 5:54consume significant 75% less or significantly less,
- 5:58uh,
- 5:58plants on veganism than you do on meat eating because it takes a lot to,
- 6:02to feed these animals.
- 6:03So if you actually care somebody truly cares.
- 6:07And that's because animals eat the plants that we're raising
- 6:13and.
- 6:14Yeah,
- 6:15and I don't,
- 6:15I agree with you.
- 6:16I don't think she actually cares about the plants.
- 6:19If you rewind in your own life,
- 6:21um,
- 6:22because I assume you,
- 6:23you weren't raised vegan,
- 6:24so at some point this was a conscious decision.
- 6:27Do you remember a time where
- 6:30Caring about animal suffering
- 6:32felt,
- 6:33uh,
- 6:34kind of absurd to you.
- 6:36Do you remember that mental
- 6:37construct?
- 6:39What was that like?
- 6:39And,
- 6:40and how did,
- 6:41what broke that for you?
- 6:43Well,
- 6:43meat eaters are the worst,
- 6:44aren't they,
- 6:45and I consider myself when I was a meat eater to be in that category.
- 6:48Like I,
- 6:49I mean that in the sense like
- 6:50you will just
- 6:51be nasty and lash out and sort of make take make fun of people
- 6:57who do otherwise and um
- 6:59you know everyone's
- 7:00sort of done the dumb like I'll eat more meat just to make up for it or just say
- 7:04or try to give a health argument when they
- 7:06didn't have a clue about the actual health benefits.
- 7:08So my little sister
- 7:09and my older sister were both vegetarian growing up.
- 7:12And it,
- 7:13you know,
- 7:13it just baffled me and and my little brother,
- 7:15uh and so me and my brother ate
- 7:17meat and they were both vegetarian and you know we
- 7:20teased them or we weren't that bad but we certainly
- 7:23couldn't
- 7:24understand why you possibly do it.
- 7:26And now me and my brother are both vegans and the girls are still veggies
- 7:29and um we're we're all in the same camp.
- 7:32I suppose,
- 7:34yeah,
- 7:34just
- 7:35it seems to be
- 7:37like you you can feel that pull just to give the justification.
- 7:40Um,
- 7:41what brought
- 7:41me round to it though,
- 7:42it wasn't like
- 7:43seeing an animal or seeing a documentary or anything like that.
- 7:46It was just the,
- 7:47it was just the argument
- 7:48for,
- 7:49for not doing it.
- 7:50Like,
- 7:51one,
- 7:51gratuitous suffering is bad,
- 7:52two,
- 7:53animal farming causes gratuitous suffering,
- 7:56uh,
- 7:56animal farming is bad,
- 7:57right?
- 7:57And if it's bad it should be avoided.
- 8:00It was just the philosophical framing or the ethical framing itself,
- 8:04yeah,
- 8:04um.
- 8:06No,
- 8:06it,
- 8:06it,
- 8:07in this episode more than others,
- 8:09like I felt a lot of people were kind of uh
- 8:12playing gesture with you,
- 8:14um,
- 8:15and,
- 8:15and we'll see some more clips come up,
- 8:17but it,
- 8:17it,
- 8:18there's just something really interesting about what this brings up,
- 8:21and I wonder if it's also because like food is tied to emotion so much,
- 8:26so like we all
- 8:27You know,
- 8:27have memories.
- 8:28I mean,
- 8:29I,
- 8:29I honestly,
- 8:30one of the earliest memories I have is like my dad
- 8:33making bacon in the kitchen just because it's such a,
- 8:37the smell,
- 8:37a,
- 8:38yeah,
- 8:38the smell,
- 8:39and it's just a very visceral experience and so.
- 8:43I'm not,
- 8:44I don't think that's an argument against what you're saying,
- 8:46like the ethical argument,
- 8:48but I think it's,
- 8:49there's something about the
- 8:51The the ritual of eating
- 8:53and and the fact that so many of us eat it that it's like,
- 8:56it's attacking
- 8:58all of that
- 8:58uh
- 8:59in our minds.
- 9:00Yeah,
- 9:01I think that's beautifully put
- 9:02like
- 9:03they lash out at you.
- 9:04Yeah,
- 9:05it's maybe there's
- 9:06like
- 9:07I guess hunting taps into that evolutionary part of your brain as
- 9:10we spoke about on the show where it just makes you,
- 9:12it feels good just as having sex,
- 9:14staying warm feels good,
- 9:16like hunting for food might feel good.
- 9:18And there is like so much of our aesthetic cultural experience tied to meat eating.
- 9:22Like the idea of like the idea
- 9:25of being
- 9:26on a lake with my old man fishing genuinely sounds like a great day,
- 9:30right?
- 9:30It sounds wholesome,
- 9:31it's it's like it's the sort of stuff from storybooks,
- 9:34um.
- 9:35But at the same time it's obviously that suffering,
- 9:37but I can see the the appeal,
- 9:39right,
- 9:39if you didn't
- 9:40know about the nature of uh fish and their capacity to feel pain,
- 9:44um,
- 9:45yeah,
- 9:45so I I can see why people
- 9:47sort of do it and,
- 9:48and the motivations aren't unclear to me.
- 9:50I just don't think they're strong enough motivations to do it.
- 9:53Yeah,
- 9:55OK,
- 9:55I'm gonna pull up the next clip.
- 9:57This is gonna be,
- 9:59now this is gonna be a little bit more of an argument.
- 10:01Nathan was a med student.
- 10:02He's trained to become a physician,
- 10:04and I wanna just kind of dig into the,
- 10:07the supplements and,
- 10:08you know,
- 10:08uh,
- 10:10vitamin deficiency concerns.
- 10:1295% of people in the 95% of people in the US
- 10:16are
- 10:16vitamin D deficient.
- 10:17Yes,
- 10:18that is fair,
- 10:19and you some we do uh prescribe that,
- 10:21but the thing is unique to vegan as I've
- 10:23seen patients as I've been rotating through different things,
- 10:25you rank the diets in terms of healthiest,
- 10:26would you go pescatarian,
- 10:27vegan?
- 10:28I'd go Mediterranean first and then pescatarian and then vegan.
- 10:31OK,
- 10:32so here's the important thing for me too far away from each other.
- 10:35We're not too far away,
- 10:35but here's the thing is that I think about my patients and I think about
- 10:38what is it achievable for them,
- 10:40and the problem with,
- 10:42and I think a lot of people with what's affordable,
- 10:44so affordable,
- 10:45but also,
- 10:46but listen,
- 10:46can I,
- 10:47can I.
- 10:48The other thing is
- 10:50I've seen
- 10:51medication non-compliance.
- 10:52Like I myself take a medication for blood pressure and I suck at it.
- 10:56And a lot of other people,
- 10:58one of the,
- 10:58one of the biggest things in America is that some people,
- 11:01just,
- 11:02a lot of people actually
- 11:03are just not compliant with their medications.
- 11:04So they don't take it,
- 11:06they don't take it.
- 11:06So
- 11:07it's either
- 11:08we have them
- 11:09high BMI,
- 11:10take a bunch of medications,
- 11:11we do a vegan diet.
- 11:12We give them a lot of supplements,
- 11:13like 5 or 6 actually that you would need,
- 11:16or you can have the you have the Mediterranean diet
- 11:19where you can just have a good diet without those supplements or added things in it.
- 11:23So you're,
- 11:24you're pushing back,
- 11:25you're saying you don't need those supplements,
- 11:26you only need.
- 11:29What are you saying you only need B12,
- 11:30is that the only one you think?
- 11:32Uh,
- 11:33take B12 and maybe,
- 11:34uh,
- 11:35keep an eye on your iron.
- 11:36Um,
- 11:37there's just like there's a few
- 11:39like little just nutrition shots you can take each day like,
- 11:42um,
- 11:43and that will give you everything,
- 11:44um,
- 11:45but typically,
- 11:45you know,
- 11:45I've just been taking B12 for
- 11:48uh ever since I've been vegan and I'll be absolutely fine,
- 11:50so
- 11:50I think some people seem to keep
- 11:52an eye on eye on their iron.
- 11:54Um,
- 11:55but yeah,
- 11:55so you don't need to stay.
- 11:56I think he,
- 11:56did he say 6 or 7 there?
- 11:57I don't know where he's getting that from.
- 11:59Yeah,
- 12:00well,
- 12:00I chat,
- 12:01I mean,
- 12:01chat GPT is not the end all be all,
- 12:03but,
- 12:04you know,
- 12:04um,
- 12:05if
- 12:05we just did a quick,
- 12:07uh,
- 12:09You know,
- 12:09question with them.
- 12:10They said vitamin B12,
- 12:12vitamin D,
- 12:13omega 3,
- 12:15and then it said
- 12:17those were kind of the big ones.
- 12:18And then the,
- 12:19the lesser ones,
- 12:20but
- 12:21something to keep an eye on were calcium,
- 12:23iron,
- 12:23and iodine,
- 12:24um.
- 12:26But,
- 12:27you know,
- 12:27what do you think about his argument,
- 12:28just like,
- 12:29hey,
- 12:30if we're asking
- 12:31millions of people to do this,
- 12:32we're introducing a,
- 12:33a large risk of,
- 12:35of vitamin deficiencies to a,
- 12:36a,
- 12:36a huge group of people.
- 12:39Yeah,
- 12:39uh,
- 12:40I think
- 12:41before
- 12:42when I first started going vegan,
- 12:43I thought perhaps this would be one of the,
- 12:45the best arguments.
- 12:46And even then I thought it wasn't,
- 12:48it didn't.
- 12:49Outweigh the sort of suffering and pain and and environmental damage that
- 12:53um it caused,
- 12:54so I was motivated thinking like,
- 12:56suppose like it did have some
- 12:58negative effects on our health,
- 12:59well I still think it would be better to go vegan
- 13:02on the whole,
- 13:03like take an example,
- 13:04you can imagine someone being like,
- 13:05say you had a local vampire,
- 13:07right,
- 13:07and someone had to,
- 13:09uh they had to eat people to survive,
- 13:11um.
- 13:13You'd uh
- 13:13you'd encourage them to,
- 13:14you know,
- 13:15to start
- 13:16eating things that were,
- 13:17I don't know,
- 13:18nearly,
- 13:18nearly about to die,
- 13:19right,
- 13:19and say their blood wasn't quite as good when they're about to die,
- 13:22then it gives them some knockoff,
- 13:23but it's better than going around killing like little kids and,
- 13:26and local people and we'd hunt this person down
- 13:28properly and kill them if they were doing it.
- 13:29It makes me think of let the right one in.
- 13:32I've let the right one in.
- 13:34It's a,
- 13:35it's a vampire movie but it's the plot is vaguely similar to what you're saying.
- 13:40I'm being forced to watch er
- 13:42the Twilight films at the moment,
- 13:43hence why I'm I'm using that for an example
- 13:45and um
- 13:46I also I'm I'm confessing that as well.
- 13:49Different experience,
- 13:50but anyway,
- 13:50uh
- 13:51keep going with your vampire.
- 13:53So they're taking a hit cos they're eating the old blood.
- 13:55Yeah yeah.
- 13:55I think,
- 13:56I think that's fair enough but we and we want um
- 13:58the puppy example I always give as well,
- 14:00right,
- 14:00say you had
- 14:01um
- 14:02you know a shed in your garden.
- 14:03And you had loads of little puppies in there and you grew them
- 14:06fat quickly,
- 14:07their organs fail,
- 14:08their legs break,
- 14:08you slit in their throats,
- 14:10and you eat them and,
- 14:11and you,
- 14:12I said to you,
- 14:12John,
- 14:12why the hell are you doing that,
- 14:13like
- 14:14you're a monster,
- 14:14like that is monstrous behavior,
- 14:16and you went,
- 14:16oh,
- 14:17but it helps me get my vitamin D and and my omega 3.
- 14:20And then suppose I went,
- 14:22you could take a tablet for that,
- 14:23and you went,
- 14:23oh no,
- 14:24but I like getting it from the puppies,
- 14:26and I'd be like,
- 14:27what?
- 14:28That seems,
- 14:28that seems wild.
- 14:29But even then,
- 14:31the
- 14:31um.
- 14:32The studies that I've seen
- 14:34have said that you can
- 14:35absorb the vitamins better if it's in the form of
- 14:39a supplement because it's already detached from the fibers.
- 14:42Um,
- 14:43with vitamin D,
- 14:44as I said to him,
- 14:45like,
- 14:45nearly everybody in the US is vitamin D deficient,
- 14:48so I'm not addressing like
- 14:50arguments where it doesn't
- 14:51track across them.
- 14:53Um,
- 14:54and when it comes to,
- 14:54and let me,
- 14:55let me actually break that down just so that I
- 14:58understand it and anyone listening could better understand it.
- 15:00So what you're saying is,
- 15:01yes,
- 15:03veganism may have some risks of deficiencies,
- 15:06but those risks are no greater and would be no
- 15:09more
- 15:10frequent
- 15:11than.
- 15:12The deficiencies that exist in Americans' diets
- 15:15or people's diets on average currently.
- 15:17Yeah,
- 15:19100% that,
- 15:20but it goes further because the health benefits are greater.
- 15:23When we look,
- 15:23we want to look at overall health outcomes.
- 15:26And as I said a bunch of times throughout this debate,
- 15:29when you look at the
- 15:30uh Oxford Epic survey looking at
- 15:33half a million people and the Adventist
- 15:35Christian one looking at about 70,000 people.
- 15:38The Christian one's great,
- 15:39the Adventist Christian one in the US because you've got 70,000 people
- 15:42who are all got the same sort of background,
- 15:44they're all doing the same stuff,
- 15:45they drink a little,
- 15:46they smoke a little.
- 15:47And the overall health outcomes for vegans are way better.
- 15:49Uh,
- 15:50they're less likely to be prone to disease,
- 15:52cancer,
- 15:52they live longer,
- 15:54uh,
- 15:54they're less likely to be obese by 4 or 5 BMI points,
- 15:57so it drops them from
- 15:58obese right down to a healthier BMI.
- 16:01And so those are the sorts of overall health outcomes that are huge.
- 16:04Um,
- 16:04when it comes to like,
- 16:06Vitamin D and B12 and omega 3,
- 16:08you can get your omega 3 from nuts or you can get a stray from the algae.
- 16:11You don't need the fish in between.
- 16:13People think you just,
- 16:14omega 3 comes from fish,
- 16:15it comes from the algae that the fish eat,
- 16:16so
- 16:17cut out the middle fish.
- 16:18Um,
- 16:18with,
- 16:19with,
- 16:19with,
- 16:20uh,
- 16:20just take your B12 and make sure you've got a balanced diet.
- 16:23Yeah,
- 16:23I like your reference to chachi BT though,
- 16:25right,
- 16:25because it,
- 16:25it might have been difficult
- 16:271520 years ago to do
- 16:29veganism.
- 16:30But
- 16:31you can literally put into chat GPC like this is normally what I,
- 16:34I might eat,
- 16:34like help me out
- 16:35and it will give you a really good guide to it.
- 16:37I'm not saying I get live,
- 16:39live your entire life and diet from it,
- 16:41but
- 16:41you wanna know where to get this stuff.
- 16:44Um,
- 16:45it's,
- 16:45it's pretty obvious,
- 16:46but
- 16:46I don't.
- 16:47But a last thing says my suspicion is the actual
- 16:49health arguments aren't the reasons why people do it,
- 16:52um,
- 16:53cos the,
- 16:53the,
- 16:54the studies sort of show with wise in health outcomes.
- 16:56I think people are just used to it.
- 16:58It tastes,
- 16:58they think it tastes better
- 17:00and,
- 17:00um,
- 17:01and they're
- 17:02creatures of habit.
- 17:04Yeah.
- 17:05Building on the technology thing,
- 17:07something that.
- 17:09It was interesting to me.
- 17:10So when um plant-based meats came out that really blew my mind
- 17:15when Beyond and Impossibles like what was that about 10 years ago,
- 17:202016,
- 17:22um,
- 17:22I actually bought a little bit of stock in those
- 17:24companies because the argument in my mind at the time was
- 17:29Oh,
- 17:29this is,
- 17:30this is a no brainer.
- 17:31If we can make meat.
- 17:33Uh,
- 17:34artificially,
- 17:35no one's gonna opt in for,
- 17:37uh,
- 17:40real meat because it's just,
- 17:40you know,
- 17:41the comparison's gonna be so obvious.
- 17:43Those investments have gone down
- 17:49to zero.
- 17:49And so I mean that's something I'm interested in you is like you make the case like,
- 17:53hey,
- 17:53chat GPT is going to make this easier.
- 17:55There's gonna be information.
- 17:56We are having technological breakthroughs that make a
- 18:02An animal-free diet more and more
- 18:05accessible,
- 18:06but why,
- 18:06you know,
- 18:07if anything,
- 18:08I've seen meat almost become
- 18:10more
- 18:11prevalent in our culture,
- 18:13like with kind of the RFK Junior,
- 18:16um,
- 18:16cultural sphere and this sort of like,
- 18:19you know,
- 18:19I,
- 18:20Jordan Peterson's daughter,
- 18:22you know,
- 18:22advocates for,
- 18:23and I would love to get you and her in a conversation someday.
- 18:27She advocates for this meat-only diet,
- 18:29and so it,
- 18:30you know,
- 18:30it really is blowing my mind because it seems counterintuitive.
- 18:33The technology has,
- 18:34has made it feel like it's within reach,
- 18:36but then the
- 18:37culture seems to be steering the other way.
- 18:39What's going on?
- 18:40Yeah,
- 18:42I,
- 18:42uh,
- 18:42you put that nicely.
- 18:43I'm supposed to have a conversation with Michaela at some point.
- 18:45Um,
- 18:46I,
- 18:47I hope it,
- 18:47I hope we do get around to it cause I think she's a really interesting
- 18:50case and offers some of probably the better arguments,
- 18:53um,
- 18:53against veganism.
- 18:55Um,
- 18:56the,
- 18:56the first thing is,
- 18:57uh,
- 18:58agricultural lobby,
- 18:59meat lobby in the US in particular.
- 19:01Uh,
- 19:01you've got
- 19:02appalling animal welfare standards in the US,
- 19:05and,
- 19:05and that's the,
- 19:06that's,
- 19:07uh,
- 19:07in comparison to,
- 19:08to Europe and.
- 19:10And um
- 19:11it it's still very far behind and
- 19:13hundreds of millions are spent.
- 19:15Um,
- 19:16making sure that they're free to produce animals as quickly and as efficiently
- 19:20and economically beneficial to the farmers as possible.
- 19:23That's one reason.
- 19:24Um,
- 19:25but then
- 19:26that's not new,
- 19:26right?
- 19:26That's been happening for a long time and it,
- 19:29they've upped the ante in the wake of some of these,
- 19:31uh,
- 19:32plant-based alternatives.
- 19:33Um,
- 19:34I,
- 19:34I think you,
- 19:35there's a lot of problems with lobbying and it's not unique to.
- 19:38Animal agriculture.
- 19:40And
- 19:40the thing you mentioned.
- 19:43The one thing that rings to me is that meat eating can be
- 19:46very tied to masculinity and we're seeing lots
- 19:49of stuff on the manosphere and you know it's
- 19:51sort of like it's becoming cliche to sort of speak about in the last few weeks,
- 19:55yeah,
- 19:55yeah,
- 19:55just like
- 19:56having a big steak and having a cigar and driving like a,
- 20:00a flash car or something,
- 20:01there's a sort of image to it and to be fair,
- 20:03when you study people and when you look at the surveys,
- 20:05um,
- 20:06people,
- 20:07Um,
- 20:07they do report
- 20:08like tough meat eating and being tied to the concept of masculinity,
- 20:12and that doesn't surprise us,
- 20:13right?
- 20:13We,
- 20:14there's
- 20:15cliches we hear in
- 20:16everyday life that speak to the same.
- 20:18Um,
- 20:19and there's,
- 20:19and there's that growth of that,
- 20:21um,
- 20:21there's growth of that conservatism,
- 20:24there's a growth of
- 20:25return to tradition,
- 20:27um,
- 20:27veganism can get thrown in with like wokeism and liberal values and stuff,
- 20:32and,
- 20:32uh,
- 20:32the liberals and the woke,
- 20:34uh,
- 20:34if no one's keeping up,
- 20:36lost the culture war,
- 20:37uh,
- 20:37a couple of years ago in my view.
- 20:39So
- 20:40we're,
- 20:40um,
- 20:41unfortunately get tied in with that,
- 20:42but.
- 20:43It's not unique to liberalism or wokeism,
- 20:46you know,
- 20:46there,
- 20:46there are heaps of when I've spoken to Jordan Peterson
- 20:49about animal rights,
- 20:50when I've spoken to Joe Rogan about animal rights,
- 20:52when I've spoken to,
- 20:53it sounds like I'm flexing now.
- 20:54Sorry,
- 20:55I'm just naming people,
- 20:56uh,
- 20:56or when I've seen Ben Shapiro for example.
- 20:59Example,
- 20:59probably one of your leading conservatives here in the US
- 21:02speak
- 21:02like he's very much like,
- 21:04oh no,
- 21:04like the,
- 21:04the case is extremely strong.
- 21:06Like
- 21:07this is
- 21:08very close to just going,
- 21:09yeah,
- 21:09you ought to be vegan.
- 21:10He might have said that,
- 21:11but he certainly came
- 21:13very,
- 21:13very close to it,
- 21:14um,
- 21:14and that's despite the pressure from his sort of
- 21:17audience as well.
- 21:18Um,
- 21:18so it goes across the board,
- 21:20and I know that there are,
- 21:21you know,
- 21:21that you've,
- 21:22you've even got some.
- 21:23Um,
- 21:23neo-Nazis who will remain nameless,
- 21:25um,
- 21:26in the US as well,
- 21:27who are podcasters who,
- 21:28uh,
- 21:29defend vegetarianism and veganism too.
- 21:31So it's not unique from the Nazi to the,
- 21:33to the woke liberal,
- 21:34uh,
- 21:34veganism is the.
- 21:37He's the view of the day.
- 21:38I guess you gotta,
- 21:38you gotta take,
- 21:39uh,
- 21:39what you could get.
- 21:42Um,
- 21:43OK,
- 21:43so this brings up,
- 21:44uh,
- 21:45the next clip I'm gonna
- 21:46pull up.
- 21:47So this is
- 21:50This is your argument with Fe,
- 21:52and he,
- 21:54I,
- 21:54I,
- 21:54I actually kind of want to hear what you think he's trying to argue because,
- 21:58you know,
- 21:58like other people,
- 21:59he got kind of,
- 22:00it got kind of personally
- 22:02testy a little bit,
- 22:03but I think he was being a little more playful.
- 22:05It's quite concerning,
- 22:07and I had to get a bit serious about this.
- 22:09You come from a place,
- 22:10I believe you're British,
- 22:11correct?
- 22:12A place that's very greenery,
- 22:13and I come from a,
- 22:15yes,
- 22:15meaning there's a lot of Uh,
- 22:18plant based
- 22:19in that region,
- 22:20isn't there a bunch of trees,
- 22:21so on and so forth?
- 22:22I might be wrong,
- 22:23just as much as the US,
- 22:25True,
- 22:26but again,
- 22:26let me finish my point.
- 22:27Let me,
- 22:29come on,
- 22:30I come from a continent that has a place called the
- 22:33Sahara Desert that a lot of people depend on me.
- 22:36And you're saying that everybody should aim to be,
- 22:40aim to be,
- 22:40that's important.
- 22:41Yes,
- 22:42yes,
- 22:42again,
- 22:42let me finish my guy,
- 22:44aim to be
- 22:45vegan,
- 22:46I think it's very unrealistic.
- 22:49In a sense,
- 22:50that's the realistic part,
- 22:51should aim to be,
- 22:52not that everyone has to be.
- 22:53Vegan
- 22:53and there is no circumstances when you can't kill an animal,
- 22:56it's the most sensible claim you can hear.
- 22:57Everyone should aim to be.
- 22:58Yes,
- 22:58but if they can,
- 22:59there's something called somebody just reading a book continuously
- 23:02and having fantasies and the world we live in.
- 23:04Are you saying I just read a book and have fantasies.
- 23:06You come off as that.
- 23:08I've worked on farms.
- 23:10Great,
- 23:11but have you lived in a place that people
- 23:13depend on meat?
- 23:15Have I lived in a place where people depend on me?
- 23:17Yes,
- 23:18have you seen a,
- 23:19that's my point.
- 23:20What do you think Fode's trying to communicate to you there?
- 23:24Uh,
- 23:24there's some places
- 23:26where plant-based alternatives just aren't an option.
- 23:29Fair enough,
- 23:29do you know what I mean,
- 23:30that's where the claims,
- 23:30uh,
- 23:31should aim to be.
- 23:32Mhm
- 23:34I think there's,
- 23:35there's sort of,
- 23:36uh,
- 23:37and this is me reading between the lines,
- 23:39I think he was kind of trying to make a little bit of the privileged argument as well,
- 23:43which is like.
- 23:45You're,
- 23:46you're a white British dude.
- 23:47You come from a place where
- 23:50it's,
- 23:50it's a wealthy nation.
- 23:51Maybe there's an abundance of,
- 23:53of vegetation.
- 23:55That's not the case for everywhere in the world.
- 23:57How,
- 23:58how do you typically push back on,
- 24:00on that argument
- 24:01where it's like,
- 24:03You know,
- 24:03I'm not just,
- 24:04I'm not just,
- 24:04this isn't a luxury belief,
- 24:06which I think some people say veganism is.
- 24:09Yeah,
- 24:10uh,
- 24:10this.
- 24:12A couple of things to say.
- 24:13The first is there was this
- 24:15huge study
- 24:16study at the University of Oxford
- 24:18where they looked at 175 different countries
- 24:21and they looked at the cost of
- 24:23food there and looked at a well-balanced diet
- 24:26and they found that across Europe and in the US it's cheaper.
- 24:30Um,
- 24:31I think it's about 30%
- 24:32to be about 30% or 20% cheaper to be
- 24:36vegan,
- 24:36uh,
- 24:37than to have a meat-based diet.
- 24:39Um,
- 24:39having visited
- 24:40LA a few times,
- 24:41like
- 24:42you,
- 24:42you just,
- 24:43just before Jubilee,
- 24:43walking around the shops,
- 24:45you sort of see the price of meat and everything else,
- 24:47like it's huge.
- 24:48Everything's so expensive there anyway,
- 24:50and so
- 24:50cost of groceries
- 24:52is a great place to save yourself 20,
- 24:5330%
- 24:54of your annual,
- 24:55um,
- 24:56expenditure.
- 24:56You know,
- 24:57like if you're spending $100,000 as a household,
- 24:58you know,
- 24:59you're getting 2 or 3000 back,
- 25:00uh,
- 25:00if you go vegan.
- 25:01So I don't think,
- 25:02I don't buy that it's
- 25:03a,
- 25:04um,
- 25:05a luxury.
- 25:05I think it's a luxury to be able to spend the time and think about it.
- 25:08You mean,
- 25:08I'm a philosopher,
- 25:09I'm not saying like,
- 25:10hey,
- 25:10I don't have the privilege of being able to think about things and
- 25:13and spend my time researching and running around doing jubilee debates,
- 25:17like that's a privilege,
- 25:18that's a,
- 25:18it's an amazing thing to be able to do for a
- 25:20for a job,
- 25:20so I accept the fact that
- 25:22um
- 25:22like my life now is uh is of a certain privilege,
- 25:25of course.
- 25:26Um,
- 25:26elsewhere,
- 25:27and he's talking about,
- 25:28um,
- 25:29especially in Africa.
- 25:31Um,
- 25:31with
- 25:33the one of the leading problems there,
- 25:35Doctor Richard Oppenlander makes this case that,
- 25:37um,
- 25:37in 82,
- 25:3983% of cases of child starvation,
- 25:43um,
- 25:43they're going,
- 25:44they're coming from countries where the overwhelming majority of the
- 25:48plant-based agriculture is fed to non-human animals,
- 25:50which is then slaughtered and sold to more affluent countries in the West,
- 25:53uh,
- 25:54Gambia,
- 25:55um,
- 25:56South Sudan,
- 25:57uh,
- 25:57Ethiopia.
- 25:59Uh,
- 25:59I think in Ethiopia,
- 26:00Ethiopia might be the leading
- 26:02like in terms of having uh the most
- 26:04animal products produced and
- 26:0780% is all sent to places like Saudi Arabia.
- 26:11Uh,
- 26:11which isn't a surprise,
- 26:12right?
- 26:12We've got a poor country
- 26:13and we've got farmers that own all the livestock and
- 26:16they wanna make the best money they can from it,
- 26:17so they sell it elsewhere.
- 26:19Um,
- 26:20so,
- 26:21you know,
- 26:21it's not.
- 26:22I don't think meat eating is a luxury,
- 26:25er no sorry,
- 26:25I think meat eating is the luxury
- 26:28because it depends on
- 26:29uh you having more money
- 26:31and you being able to exploit other people to be able to eat that
- 26:34and taking food out of their mouths,
- 26:35putting it in a cow and then eating the cow instead.
- 26:38Um,
- 26:38but yeah,
- 26:39there's gonna be some cases,
- 26:40but it's,
- 26:41it should
- 26:41be
- 26:42someone
- 26:42who's living on the frigging North Pole,
- 26:45like someone who's,
- 26:45uh,
- 26:46is trapped on a desert island with a pig,
- 26:48you know,
- 26:48I'm not saying these people should be vegan.
- 26:51You should be,
- 26:51but
- 26:52I think there are times when you can kill a person.
- 26:54Um,
- 26:54someone's about to commit a terrorist attack,
- 26:56kill the person.
- 26:56I'm not a pacifist.
- 26:58If you're,
- 26:58if you're gonna die and the pigs,
- 26:59uh,
- 27:00it's between you and the pig,
- 27:01you know,
- 27:02all power to you,
- 27:03you can kill the pig.
- 27:04Um,
- 27:04the vegan community is,
- 27:05is,
- 27:06is one of the most divisive there is,
- 27:08and there'll be a lot of vegans who are unhappy with that,
- 27:10but,
- 27:10uh,
- 27:11you know,
- 27:11they can,
- 27:11uh,
- 27:12they can try and kill me over it,
- 27:13and I wouldn't mind.
- 27:15Yeah.
- 27:17OK,
- 27:17so that actually brings up kind of the,
- 27:19the calculus around how you value
- 27:23life.
- 27:24Um,
- 27:25and this was actually
- 27:26probably my favorite part.
- 27:27So you and Gerard kind of dig into this.
- 27:31Um,
- 27:31he brings up
- 27:32the Holocaust.
- 27:34I'm,
- 27:34I'm gonna just play this clip for you,
- 27:36but it's basically like,
- 27:37how do you do
- 27:38the math,
- 27:39and I wanna
- 27:41see,
- 27:41hear your reaction to this clip,
- 27:42and then we can,
- 27:43we can go further.
- 27:44First,
- 27:44you started with the numbers of deaths of animals,
- 27:46right?
- 27:46Like that's a relevant metric for you.
- 27:47How many deaths of cows is equal to the death of one Jewish person in Auschwitz?
- 27:52Give me the number.
- 27:53How many cows for one because you said,
- 27:54I asked you why it was bad,
- 27:55and you said because the number of cows that are slaughtered every year.
- 27:58So I'm asking you,
- 27:59what's your ratio?
- 28:00Like how many cows dying is as bad as someone getting gassed in Auschwitz?
- 28:04Well,
- 28:04can we,
- 28:04can we extract
- 28:06the Jewish version Auschwitz?
- 28:08I'm just using,
- 28:08I'm using the word I don't like to I can think of.
- 28:10Well,
- 28:10I don't like to play into the answer.
- 28:11Are you.
- 28:12How about the Armenian.
- 28:12Genocide,
- 28:13can we talk about that one?
- 28:14How many cows are worth a human being?
- 28:15I think,
- 28:16I think a,
- 28:16I think a human being is significantly more valuable than a cow.
- 28:20How much?
- 28:20Why?
- 28:21Because a cow lives for 20 years
- 28:23and a human being will live for 70 or 80 years.
- 28:25So 4,
- 28:26so a cow is 4 cows is roughly a.
- 28:28I'll give you a number,
- 28:28I'll say 1000 cows.
- 28:291000 cows is the worth of a human being,
- 28:31is all human beings.
- 28:32It's just arbitrary number.
- 28:34OK,
- 28:341000 cows.
- 28:36We got there.
- 28:37The Armenian genocide,
- 28:39the Holocaust.
- 28:41Can you see ultimately what this,
- 28:42you see why I didn't want to tell him like
- 28:44why,
- 28:44why,
- 28:45if,
- 28:45if someone asked you how much is a Jewish
- 28:47person's life in Auschwitz compared to a cow,
- 28:49like it'd be,
- 28:51it'd be dystopia if I gave a number.
- 28:55Yeah,
- 28:55well,
- 28:55I,
- 28:56I'm glad Gerard,
- 28:57I mean,
- 28:58I thought it was riveting,
- 28:59riveting the way he framed it,
- 29:01but I,
- 29:02I,
- 29:02I see what you're doing.
- 29:03Like,
- 29:03let's,
- 29:03let's detangle some of the political stickiness here because
- 29:07ultimately this just boils down to a human life
- 29:10versus an animal life and what,
- 29:13what is this,
- 29:14this math you offered the number 1000 cows roughly
- 29:18is,
- 29:18is kind of the equivalency.
- 29:20How
- 29:21can you expand on that framework?
- 29:22Like,
- 29:23I think earlier in the episode you mentioned like a hierarchy.
- 29:26You see there being kind of a hierarchy.
- 29:28How does that work for you?
- 29:30Um,
- 29:30I think there are a philosophical language,
- 29:32there are intrinsic
- 29:33values.
- 29:34There are things that are valuable about
- 29:36being a thing in the world.
- 29:37Being conscious is good,
- 29:38having a life is good.
- 29:40Having powers,
- 29:40knowledge,
- 29:41um,
- 29:42being able,
- 29:43having a capacity for,
- 29:44uh,
- 29:44pleasure and happiness.
- 29:45I think they're all valuable things,
- 29:47and I think we can
- 29:48judge things,
- 29:50the value of things based on that scale.
- 29:52So the more
- 29:53power,
- 29:53knowledge,
- 29:53goodness,
- 29:54consciousness,
- 29:54etc.
- 29:55you're capable of,
- 29:56the,
- 29:56the more valuable you are.
- 29:57I think that's,
- 29:58uh,
- 29:58I think that's true.
- 29:59Um,
- 30:00again,
- 30:00controversial in the vegan community,
- 30:02uh,
- 30:02cos it's often used against animals,
- 30:03but I think it actually works for them.
- 30:05Why 1000 cals?
- 30:06I thought I said like 5000 in the thing.
- 30:09Um,
- 30:09it's,
- 30:09it's so fast paced.
- 30:11Uh,
- 30:11I'm,
- 30:11I'm happy with 1000.
- 30:12The point
- 30:13is
- 30:14that the 1000 or the 5000 would be a ceiling on it.
- 30:17It wouldn't be like
- 30:18the amount that it would be.
- 30:20I'm saying like the very worst case scenario.
- 30:22Um,
- 30:23in philosophy,
- 30:24we wanna do
- 30:24all of the things being equal.
- 30:26So we're not talking like
- 30:27is the person
- 30:28Hitler or Alexander Fleming,
- 30:30right,
- 30:31because if it was Hitler,
- 30:31obviously a human.
- 30:33Yeah,
- 30:33but Hiller would be worth,
- 30:34you know,
- 30:35no,
- 30:35a killing regardless of killing the cow.
- 30:37Um,
- 30:37and then Fleming might be worth,
- 30:39Fleming might be worth thousands upon tens of thousands
- 30:41of cows cause he saves millions of lives.
- 30:44It's really difficult to say
- 30:46What things you're measuring it by in terms of like
- 30:49how you,
- 30:49how you expand things out because.
- 30:51In terms of the pain,
- 30:53and in his
- 30:54the thing people might find controversial,
- 30:56the pain of the cow is worth just as much as the pain of the human being.
- 31:00In terms of pain,
- 31:01it's one for one.
- 31:02So if you slit my throat or kick,
- 31:04it'll slit the cow's throat because of the sensitive
- 31:06tissue underneath,
- 31:08uh,
- 31:08underneath your skin,
- 31:09because of the nerve endings on the surface,
- 31:11you're,
- 31:12uh,
- 31:12it's gonna be excruciatingly painful for both of us.
- 31:15And I think in terms of pain,
- 31:16it's exactly the same.
- 31:18And then you want to go,
- 31:18well,
- 31:19this is actually just a pause there.
- 31:21This is a question I have
- 31:23because I hear you.
- 31:24Like,
- 31:24I don't doubt that animals experience pain,
- 31:27um,
- 31:28but I do wonder if,
- 31:30uh,
- 31:31consciousness,
- 31:32because I think humans have an especially loud
- 31:35narrative quality to their consciousness which may not,
- 31:37does that amplify pain,
- 31:39um.
- 31:41In a sense of like.
- 31:43You,
- 31:43you know what I'm saying,
- 31:44and so that,
- 31:45that makes me,
- 31:46that gives me pause on like,
- 31:48is the suffering
- 31:49because like I would make the argument like
- 31:51the suffering of a chicken or a fish
- 31:54feels somewhat negligible to me,
- 31:56um,
- 31:57the suffering of an ant.
- 31:59Feels very negligible to me.
- 32:02Now those are just that's just sort of like baked in
- 32:06intuition I have you get to like dogs,
- 32:07mammals,
- 32:14cows,
- 32:14I start to,
- 32:14I see where you're kind of that,
- 32:15um,
- 32:15but for whatever reason,
- 32:16human suffering because I know the depth of the conscious experience,
- 32:21it seems like it still has a premium like a premium for me
- 32:24like I can't,
- 32:25I can't quite see it as one for one.
- 32:28No,
- 32:28I,
- 32:28I,
- 32:28I think a lot of people share that intuition.
- 32:30I think you articulated it really well.
- 32:32Um,
- 32:32I held that intuition,
- 32:33uh,
- 32:34for a while too,
- 32:34and I,
- 32:35but I was hosting an event,
- 32:36a debate,
- 32:37um,
- 32:37with the
- 32:38British biologists,
- 32:40evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins,
- 32:42and
- 32:43in the debate,
- 32:44uh,
- 32:44he said something that really stuck out to me.
- 32:46He was,
- 32:46he said
- 32:47he was arguing with a,
- 32:48a,
- 32:49a Christian philosopher.
- 32:51And we're talking about pain and suffering in animals,
- 32:53and he said
- 32:54that presumption
- 32:55that you have that the,
- 32:57the lower down the chain of being you are,
- 32:59the more primitive of an animal you are,
- 33:01um,
- 33:01for lack of a better phrase,
- 33:02is a
- 33:03um is an ungrounded assumption.
- 33:06And why?
- 33:07He said,
- 33:07well,
- 33:07if I put my hand on the hot stove.
- 33:10Because
- 33:10I've got this,
- 33:10as you,
- 33:11you know,
- 33:11there's more complex integrated consciousness,
- 33:14I can
- 33:15feel the pain,
- 33:15I can go,
- 33:15I shouldn't do that again,
- 33:17and I could
- 33:17bake that into my memory.
- 33:19I can tell myself not to do it again,
- 33:20I can even stick something on the stove saying like don't do that again.
- 33:24Um,
- 33:24but when it comes to a really
- 33:26simple
- 33:27sort of biological organism,
- 33:29um,
- 33:29Dawkins said it may be that they just have a very strong feeling of pain
- 33:33to make sure they never do it again,
- 33:36right,
- 33:36to make sure they keep,
- 33:37stay away from it because they can't do the same thing,
- 33:39thinking about it,
- 33:40making sure it
- 33:42it building in a behavioristic,
- 33:43um,
- 33:44or even,
- 33:45uh,
- 33:45you know,
- 33:46having a mental map of things they should go towards and avoid.
- 33:49They they need the strongest red flag.
- 33:51It's a big red flag,
- 33:52stay away from the pain.
- 33:53Um,
- 33:54that's an argument to the other side.
- 33:56I'm,
- 33:56I'm not convinced by this argument.
- 33:58I'm not convinced by the sort of argument that that you articulated either.
- 34:01I think we should be agnostic as to
- 34:03the,
- 34:04the overall,
- 34:05uh,
- 34:05capacity for pain for,
- 34:06for either of these beings,
- 34:08um.
- 34:09And just say,
- 34:10you know,
- 34:10give it,
- 34:11we in philosophy we do credences,
- 34:13i.e. probability.
- 34:14Given the fact I think there's a strong
- 34:16probability that these creatures are gonna feel pain
- 34:18and it's stronger than not,
- 34:20and giving medicine necessary,
- 34:21then we should avoid it.
- 34:23Mhm.
- 34:24Yeah,
- 34:24thanks for breaking that down,
- 34:26but I interrupted you,
- 34:27were you gonna break down kind of the,
- 34:29the hierarchy a little further?
- 34:31Yeah,
- 34:31I think so take a cow,
- 34:33it's a 20 year old cow,
- 34:3470 year old human,
- 34:35like,
- 34:36why take the pain,
- 34:37that's fine.
- 34:38Let's say it's one for one,
- 34:39all of the things being equal,
- 34:41or,
- 34:41you know,
- 34:42our best guess is one for one.
- 34:44What,
- 34:44what about the life of the human,
- 34:45where you sort of
- 34:46you in your
- 34:48response you sort of said we have this complex louder consciousness,
- 34:51you also have this narrative self,
- 34:52you know things that matter to you
- 34:54and you're able to appreciate
- 34:56um I I I haven't got a taste for it,
- 34:58uh like classical music or the theater
- 35:00um
- 35:01as well as,
- 35:02you know,
- 35:02eating food,
- 35:03right,
- 35:03so my dog can eat food,
- 35:04he gets dead excited when he's eating food,
- 35:06but I have this higher pleasure of going to the theater.
- 35:09Um,
- 35:09so that's one argument you might give.
- 35:11I don't think that's a
- 35:12particularly good one
- 35:14because,
- 35:14you know,
- 35:15the football fan,
- 35:16middle class football fan compared to the theatergoer,
- 35:19if,
- 35:19um,
- 35:20if there were such things as higher pleasures,
- 35:22then we think that
- 35:23it's better to go to the theater and go to the football,
- 35:25but I think that's just arrogance and pompousness
- 35:28and should be taken seriously.
- 35:29I think when the dog eats its food,
- 35:31Pushbin's as good as poetry as Bentham said.
- 35:33When
- 35:34the dog eats its food,
- 35:34it's just as good as me,
- 35:36um,
- 35:36watching the football or eating food myself.
- 35:39Um,
- 35:40I think,
- 35:40I think the easiest way to go is
- 35:42how long's their life,
- 35:43that's one thing.
- 35:45And
- 35:46humans importantly also have instrumental values,
- 35:48i.e. they're able to change the world for the better as well.
- 35:52So I think if you're a human being and you take more things away from the world,
- 35:55you know,
- 35:55you start wars,
- 35:57you're nasty to the people around you,
- 35:58you're an abuser,
- 35:59you're a selfish person who takes from the system
- 36:02more than you uh try and put into it.
- 36:04I think you have less value
- 36:05and I think if you,
- 36:06but if you're,
- 36:07you know,
- 36:07like Fleming or another moral saint,
- 36:09then you,
- 36:10you have
- 36:11higher value.
- 36:12Um,
- 36:13so again,
- 36:14because we're doing all the things being equal,
- 36:15it's hard to say.
- 36:17You know how
- 36:18what that greatness consists of,
- 36:20um,
- 36:21but let's say
- 36:22the,
- 36:22you know,
- 36:23a typical human
- 36:24with lots of
- 36:25people that matter to them and can make a generally
- 36:29good contribution to the world
- 36:31and has a long
- 36:33healthy life
- 36:34compared to the cow.
- 36:35I think 1000 is the ceiling.
- 36:38Uh,
- 36:38I,
- 36:38I,
- 36:39I thought I said 5000.
- 36:40I thought that's way too many.
- 36:41If it was 1000,
- 36:42that would probably be around the ceiling.
- 36:44Um,
- 36:44the last thing I'll say is.
- 36:46Why is it difficult?
- 36:47Cause there's gonna be a threshold,
- 36:49right,
- 36:49it's hard to say when it's gonna happen.
- 36:51It's like a pile of leaves,
- 36:52I,
- 36:52I put a few leaves down.
- 36:54Is it a pile yet?
- 36:55Is it a pile yet?
- 36:56And then all of a sudden there's enough leaves and I can call it a pile
- 36:59or water droplets.
- 37:00I put them together.
- 37:01When do the water droplets become a cloud?
- 37:03And I think the same
- 37:05way we can sort of
- 37:06do this with how many cows or human animals worth a human's life.
- 37:10You go 1 cow,
- 37:11no,
- 37:12234,
- 37:12not quite there yet.
- 37:14I can't pinpoint it exactly.
- 37:16But there will be a threshold,
- 37:17and I think that's crossed when I say like,
- 37:19if I said 10 trillion cows for a human's life,
- 37:22I think that's,
- 37:23uh,
- 37:23I think that's evil through and through,
- 37:25and
- 37:25the threshold's been crossed.
- 37:27Um,
- 37:28so merely because we can't identify the actual
- 37:30number doesn't mean that there isn't a threshold,
- 37:33and that's why I hesitate to give the number because it it
- 37:35takes a little while to explain sort of the threshold argument.
- 37:38And,
- 37:39and that's why I said to him
- 37:401000,
- 37:41why not,
- 37:42it's trivial.
- 37:42And by trivial I mean
- 37:44call it 999,
- 37:46call it 1000.
- 37:46I don't think the 999
- 37:48uh would change my mind,
- 37:50right?
- 37:50I'm talking like
- 37:51vague boundaries and that's fine,
- 37:53we've got vague boundaries for lots of things.
- 37:56Yeah,
- 37:57no,
- 37:57I,
- 37:57that makes sense
- 37:58for me.
- 37:59The number seems maybe like a little higher than 1000,
- 38:02but I,
- 38:03I hear what you're saying like that would give it.
- 38:05I mean,
- 38:06I was honestly thinking something like 5000,
- 38:10um,
- 38:10like I know that's high.
- 38:12I know that's high,
- 38:13but it's like
- 38:14that
- 38:15that's where I can,
- 38:16I start to feel that intuition that you're saying where it's like,
- 38:18OK,
- 38:18that starts to feel like a pile to me,
- 38:21um.
- 38:23It's interesting kind of building on this narrative element is,
- 38:27you know,
- 38:27I think Gerard was being really clever
- 38:30in building that narrative around the human
- 38:33because
- 38:34that amplifies
- 38:36the
- 38:37sense of suffering
- 38:38because if if you were to kind of concede,
- 38:41yeah,
- 38:41yeah,
- 38:42like I think one Jewish person
- 38:44suffering in Auschwitz equals.
- 38:473000 cows,
- 38:49it,
- 38:49you know,
- 38:50it
- 38:50that amplifies this idea that you're diminishing that suffering,
- 38:54um,
- 38:55because we,
- 38:55we,
- 38:56we tie so much tragic weight to that,
- 38:59that anecdote,
- 39:00um.
- 39:02OK,
- 39:02so
- 39:03the last clip I want to pull up.
- 39:05And then I,
- 39:06we can kind of just.
- 39:08I,
- 39:08I want to talk about my own journey a little bit with you because I do find this,
- 39:12this very compelling.
- 39:13So
- 39:15you asked,
- 39:16um,
- 39:16I think his name is Vidur back to the center,
- 39:19um,
- 39:19at the very end,
- 39:21and he was the closest person.
- 39:23He had tried being vegan previously.
- 39:25He wasn't successful at sticking with it,
- 39:27and you really just kind of put him on the spot at the very end.
- 39:30Like,
- 39:30come back,
- 39:31and it's this really interesting moment.
- 39:33I like the way he responds to you though,
- 39:36um,
- 39:36so let's just watch this.
- 39:37I'm not gonna go vegan,
- 39:38but I don't wanna leave you hanging.
- 39:39Come on,
- 39:40you can't leave me hanging.
- 39:40You'll try to go vegan.
- 39:42I just don't wanna say that I'll turn vegan in front of you and
- 39:44then not do it cos I'm not a hypocrite asking you to turn vegan,
- 39:47I'm asking you to try.
- 39:48I,
- 39:49I have tried in the past,
- 39:50and I am,
- 39:50I'm promising you that I will be trying to reduce.
- 39:54In conversation,
- 39:54like you,
- 39:55you accept all of the reasons
- 39:56and you think that you should do it.
- 39:58Yeah,
- 39:58Doctor Jack,
- 39:59I will,
- 40:00I promise you that I will try to limit the amount of meat I eat,
- 40:03but I can't promise you that I will be vegan right,
- 40:05like right away.
- 40:06Try it for a week.
- 40:07Give me
- 40:07me me me a week,
- 40:08Mimi a week.
- 40:09I don't think I will be able to do that.
- 40:10Try,
- 40:11try me a week.
- 40:11I don't think I would be able to do that.
- 40:13I apologize,
- 40:13I'm a weaker man than you,
- 40:15but I won't be able to do that.
- 40:16Disappointed me,
- 40:17dude.
- 40:18Hey,
- 40:19it's lovely to speak to you though.
- 40:20Thank you to speak to you.
- 40:21I appreciate it.
- 40:22Oh
- 40:23dude,
- 40:24I'm so disappointed man.
- 40:26You,
- 40:26you were close,
- 40:27but,
- 40:27but not quite.
- 40:28But I,
- 40:29I really appreciate his intellectual honesty,
- 40:31you know,
- 40:31he's like,
- 40:32I'm not,
- 40:33cause a lot of times what we have is
- 40:36People come on this show
- 40:37and they're just super performative and they're just trying to,
- 40:40you know,
- 40:41dunk on somebody
- 40:42so that millions of people will,
- 40:44will,
- 40:44will see it and
- 40:46he's doing the,
- 40:47the exact opposite,
- 40:48you know,
- 40:48he has this moment to sort of
- 40:51Project his values and virtue signal
- 40:53and yet he's saying,
- 40:54hey,
- 40:55you know,
- 40:56I,
- 40:56I just got to be honest with you,
- 40:57I don't see myself fully committing to going 100% vegan
- 41:02and
- 41:03I can relate to that because I feel in a very similar place to him where
- 41:06it's like
- 41:08I,
- 41:09the,
- 41:09the argument feels sound,
- 41:11um.
- 41:13I can
- 41:14Acknowledge the suffering of animals.
- 41:16I can acknowledge the immorality
- 41:18of
- 41:19the way the meat industry
- 41:22has,
- 41:22you know,
- 41:23transformed and how egregiously.
- 41:26horrific it is
- 41:28in its current state.
- 41:29And so all of that rings clear,
- 41:31but then there's just this,
- 41:33there's this inertia,
- 41:34like,
- 41:34hey,
- 41:34there's so many things going on in the world.
- 41:36I'm worried about the climate or I'm worried about politics or I'm worried about.
- 41:41Screen addiction or how our electronics are made,
- 41:44like how do you choose which moral alley
- 41:47to fully commit down when there's so many directions.
- 41:51To be concerned.
- 41:53Um,
- 41:54so why,
- 41:55for you,
- 41:55you know,
- 41:55there I
- 41:56earlier you were drinking a Red Bull and you're like,
- 41:58I know that's unhealthy.
- 42:00But you know it's,
- 42:01it's something I gotta do.
- 42:03Now,
- 42:04obviously animals probably aren't dying for Red Bull,
- 42:06but I don't know,
- 42:06maybe they are.
- 42:07But like how,
- 42:09why is
- 42:11Why is veganism,
- 42:12you know,
- 42:13you,
- 42:14you're like this argument is sound.
- 42:15I'm planting my flag and committing to this
- 42:18when there's,
- 42:19it feels like there's so many.
- 42:21Directions to get pulled.
- 42:24Yeah,
- 42:25uh,
- 42:25I think it,
- 42:26I,
- 42:26I find it really
- 42:27depressing.
- 42:28I find it hard not to,
- 42:29uh,
- 42:30you know,
- 42:30feel a little bit upset when I think about it,
- 42:32to be honest,
- 42:32like
- 42:33it's,
- 42:33um,
- 42:34it,
- 42:34it,
- 42:35it's,
- 42:36you think of historical examples of people
- 42:38going,
- 42:38yeah,
- 42:39like I had this plantation and I've got these
- 42:41slaves and you know I believe in human dignity
- 42:44and the equality of people,
- 42:45but.
- 42:46You know,
- 42:46I just can't,
- 42:47you know,
- 42:47I've got so many other things to focus on or I just can't do it for these reasons,
- 42:52um,
- 42:52and it feels sort of like that with
- 42:54uh non-human animals and factory farming especially.
- 42:57Um
- 42:59It,
- 42:59it's hard to sit there
- 43:01and sort of someone goes,
- 43:02hey,
- 43:02you know,
- 43:02I believe it,
- 43:03I think I should do it.
- 43:04Like the producer of my own podcast,
- 43:06uh,
- 43:07my friend Paul,
- 43:07who we've been friends for
- 43:09nearly 10 years,
- 43:10and he's bought the vegan argument for ages,
- 43:12uh,
- 43:12and they're like,
- 43:13we'll do a show,
- 43:13you know,
- 43:15whatever it is,
- 43:15and we're,
- 43:16we're in,
- 43:16uh,
- 43:17Boston today.
- 43:18We just did a show yesterday and then it was,
- 43:20we sat down for dinner and he's,
- 43:21he's eating pepperoni and stuff,
- 43:23and it's just like,
- 43:24but he believes it,
- 43:25he,
- 43:25he buys the argument
- 43:26and he thinks you should do it.
- 43:28Which just doesn't do otherwise.
- 43:30Um,
- 43:30and that's,
- 43:31it,
- 43:31I just,
- 43:32I,
- 43:32I,
- 43:32I think I was trying to say,
- 43:33uh,
- 43:34during the debate there as well,
- 43:35like just,
- 43:35just do it,
- 43:36like just,
- 43:38just make the commitment.
- 43:39Like people think they don't have this power over
- 43:42themselves that they can't just make a new habit,
- 43:44that they can't just flip the switch,
- 43:45but once you've tried a week and then you go a little bit,
- 43:47you just try one week and then it goes to 2 and then all of a sudden like
- 43:51you've got the habit and it's there
- 43:53and you commit to it and you don't break it.
- 43:56Um,
- 43:56I understand that.
- 43:58You know people
- 43:59in the same way of like it might be porn addiction
- 44:02or uh it might be like smoking or or whatever it is like these things,
- 44:05there are things harder than others to sort of quit.
- 44:08I think quitting meat's a lot harder,
- 44:09a lot easier
- 44:11than like
- 44:12not consuming pornography or not smoking.
- 44:15I think
- 44:15not consuming meat is way easier than those things,
- 44:17and people just need to go like,
- 44:18right,
- 44:19I'll stop.
- 44:19That's kind of crazy to me,
- 44:21but
- 44:22no,
- 44:22no,
- 44:22no,
- 44:23that
- 44:24quitting it's sounds so much harder.
- 44:26You think,
- 44:27you think quitting smoking,
- 44:28you think quitting meat's harder than quitting smoking?
- 44:31Uh,
- 44:32yeah,
- 44:32I mean,
- 44:33I never was addicted to smoking.
- 44:37But I,
- 44:37it depends what you were smoking,
- 44:38I suppose.
- 44:40Well,
- 44:40I mean,
- 44:41what are we talking about?
- 44:42OK.
- 44:43I've,
- 44:43I've had my fair share of,
- 44:45of smoking.
- 44:45All I'm saying is
- 44:47I actually porn was the one that stuck out to me more,
- 44:50so yeah,
- 44:51people to quit porn.
- 44:53If,
- 44:53if you told me right now like
- 44:55quit porn.
- 44:57Forever or quit,
- 44:59um,
- 45:00eating meat.
- 45:02Not watching porn seems
- 45:03much more doable.
- 45:05I think
- 45:06I do
- 45:07when I think of meat,
- 45:07it's like,
- 45:08OK,
- 45:08so like.
- 45:10It's,
- 45:10I'm gonna have dinner with my family this weekend or,
- 45:14you know,
- 45:14um,
- 45:15I'm not going to eat eggs anymore.
- 45:17Uh,
- 45:18what's,
- 45:19what's the substitute like there's so much inertia there
- 45:23and then like I brought up in the debate,
- 45:24you know,
- 45:24your kids,
- 45:25it's like,
- 45:25OK,
- 45:26I,
- 45:27I gotta kind of reinvent this.
- 45:30I mean,
- 45:30it's so hard to get your kids to eat
- 45:33anything that they specifically
- 45:35should,
- 45:37um,
- 45:37and so that's where it starts to feel.
- 45:40Like,
- 45:40oh my God,
- 45:40I don't,
- 45:41I don't know how to untie that knot.
- 45:44Yeah,
- 45:45OK,
- 45:45fair enough.
- 45:46Oh well,
- 45:46maybe I don't wanna
- 45:47pin my colors to the flag and say that
- 45:49I guess it's an unnecessary claim which is made that,
- 45:52um,
- 45:53having,
- 45:53um,
- 45:54uh,
- 45:54that meat eating's easier to quit than than other things.
- 45:58Uh,
- 45:58like you say,
- 45:58for some people it is really baked into their
- 46:00into their lives,
- 46:01uh,
- 46:02especially when you've got kids and stuff,
- 46:03yeah.
- 46:03Um,
- 46:04I don't think it
- 46:05I don't think it's
- 46:06I don't think it's as difficult as people
- 46:08think it is or people say that it is.
- 46:11Um,
- 46:11yeah,
- 46:11you know,
- 46:11you,
- 46:12you just switch your eggs to like,
- 46:13you know,
- 46:14you get,
- 46:14uh,
- 46:14the tofu which is already like
- 46:16egg-based and it's got more protein and more,
- 46:18uh,
- 46:18more nutrients than your eggs,
- 46:20and you know you're doing something good for your kids there,
- 46:22you're doing something good for your body.
- 46:23You know,
- 46:24typically when we're going,
- 46:24we're walking around the supermarket,
- 46:26we will pick up new products,
- 46:27you know,
- 46:27just from looking at them and I think just starting
- 46:29by picking up some vegan products as you're walking around
- 46:32is a good point to go.
- 46:33What you'll realize when you're eating it is,
- 46:35you start to have that and you're exposed to more things in the same sections and.
- 46:39You sort of go from there.
- 46:40The easy thing to do is like stop the meat,
- 46:42just go to the meat free section and pick up the plant-based burgers,
- 46:46pick up the plant-based chicken and switch your eggs for tofu,
- 46:49get oat milk instead of regular milk or any other milk.
- 46:52Like it's not
- 46:53when you're looking at the massive range of milks they've got,
- 46:55it's not like your arm's forced to pick up the other milk,
- 46:58like and that that's why I think maybe it's easier in that sense,
- 47:01right,
- 47:01to stop smoking it.
- 47:02I,
- 47:02I found stopping smoking difficult when I was in my early twenties.
- 47:06Um,
- 47:06it's way easier for me to pick up the other milk,
- 47:08just,
- 47:09you know,
- 47:09it's than the other one in the supermarket.
- 47:11Um,
- 47:11but you said something really interesting as well,
- 47:13which was there are so many
- 47:14massive problems for us to deal with,
- 47:16like why veganism,
- 47:17why pick that one?
- 47:18I think
- 47:19because the vegan.
- 47:21Has so many impacts beyond uh just the
- 47:23animals who are suffering for child starvation,
- 47:27uh,
- 47:27global food,
- 47:28uh,
- 47:28inequality and access,
- 47:30uh,
- 47:31climate destruction,
- 47:32it being the third or maybe in some people's views,
- 47:35uh,
- 47:35the first
- 47:36leading cause of,
- 47:37of,
- 47:37of climate change.
- 47:38I don't think you're a real environmentalist if you're,
- 47:40if you're,
- 47:41um,
- 47:42eating,
- 47:42um,
- 47:42if you're eating meat,
- 47:44um,
- 47:44in,
- 47:44in Europe or in or in the United States.
- 47:47I think,
- 47:47um,
- 47:48and I don't buy the argument that.
- 47:50Uh,
- 47:50we have to wait for government reforms of fossil fuel industries to,
- 47:55to make that impact.
- 47:55If,
- 47:56if we stopped using all of these,
- 47:57um,
- 47:58fossil fuels tomorrow,
- 47:59um,
- 48:00it wouldn't make a difference in terms of the climate catastrophe.
- 48:02We will still be on our way,
- 48:04um,
- 48:05to,
- 48:05um,
- 48:0523 degrees by 2100
- 48:08merely by,
- 48:09um,
- 48:09our meat consumption,
- 48:11uh,
- 48:11and the animal agriculture industry.
- 48:13So I think if you care about the environment,
- 48:14if you care about starving children,
- 48:16if you care about non-human animal suffering,
- 48:18if you care about your own health.
- 48:20You know there are so many reasons
- 48:21um just to just to do it.
- 48:23It probably is the best thing in my view that
- 48:25you can just sort of do today straight away to
- 48:28make yourself and the world a better place.
- 48:30Cause I,
- 48:30cause I looked at some studies afterwards and saw that
- 48:32a lot of the,
- 48:33cos I was interested in your point.
- 48:35I looked at some studies about the kids and saw that it
- 48:37was the same as sort of what we're saying in the debate
- 48:39that
- 48:40kids who have vegan diets,
- 48:42you need to make sure they're getting the B12,
- 48:44you need to make sure they're getting their iron,
- 48:46and that was flagged too,
- 48:47um.
- 48:48But then the health benefits and compared to them being
- 48:51overweight,
- 48:52developing heart diseases and stuff like that was,
- 48:54uh,
- 48:54you know,
- 48:55across the,
- 48:56across the board it seemed to be
- 48:57just as healthy if not more healthy.
- 49:00Um,
- 49:00it,
- 49:01it,
- 49:01it seems a bit more
- 49:02difficult because there are there are far fewer studies on kids,
- 49:05um,
- 49:06but it looks,
- 49:06you know,
- 49:07if I,
- 49:07if I was.
- 49:08If the
- 49:09in philosophy we do the truth demon,
- 49:10so a demon comes down and says to you,
- 49:12give me what you think's the right answer or you go to hell forever,
- 49:15you have to get it right.
- 49:16I'd probably say it's roughly just about as healthy.
- 49:18I wouldn't claim that it's significantly healthier for kids.
- 49:22Yeah
- 49:23Makes me think I'm Monty Python.
- 49:24He's like,
- 49:26what's your favorite color?
- 49:28Blue,
- 49:28no green
- 49:32Anyway,
- 49:33um,
- 49:33OK,
- 49:34so I,
- 49:34I'm in a similar place as,
- 49:36as the last guy.
- 49:37I can tell you,
- 49:38you know,
- 49:38I,
- 49:38I don't wanna lie to you,
- 49:39but I,
- 49:40I can say like.
- 49:42This argument really rings true to me and so I,
- 49:45I really do want to commit to,
- 49:47to taking big steps towards being,
- 49:49being vegan and you know,
- 49:50I've actually,
- 49:51I had an impossible.
- 49:53Me
- 49:5522 days this week and I had chickpeas last night.
- 49:58So
- 49:59making steps,
- 50:00um,
- 50:01so yeah,
- 50:01I'm,
- 50:02I'm gonna give it,
- 50:03uh,
- 50:03as good of a shot as I can,
- 50:04but you know,
- 50:05I,
- 50:05I,
- 50:06I can't,
- 50:07I know there's gonna be falters.
- 50:09So,
- 50:10you know,
- 50:10I guess I can tell you
- 50:12I can commit to aim,
- 50:13aiming to be like 90% vegan.
- 50:17And why don't we touch base?
- 50:19Why don't we touch base.
- 50:21It's it,
- 50:21is this off the back of uh like when did you,
- 50:24you felt the arguments before and this is sort of just triggered the,
- 50:27the thought.
- 50:28I have friends,
- 50:29yeah,
- 50:29I,
- 50:29I've had friends and and uh who are vegan and,
- 50:33um,
- 50:34you know,
- 50:34for me I just.
- 50:36I feel like I've heard Sam Harris talk about it before.
- 50:38It's just,
- 50:39uh,
- 50:39it is an obvious.
- 50:42Moral.
- 50:44Failing
- 50:45the,
- 50:45the state of things,
- 50:47um,
- 50:48and yeah,
- 50:48you know,
- 50:49I,
- 50:49my dog died last year,
- 50:51um,
- 50:51or no,
- 50:52not last year,
- 50:52it was like 2 years ago,
- 50:54but,
- 50:54um.
- 50:56I had never had a pet before and uh
- 50:59we had to euthanize him,
- 51:01you know,
- 51:01because he was really
- 51:03in bad shape
- 51:04and that was a really profound
- 51:08experience,
- 51:08the witnessing of a life ending,
- 51:11even,
- 51:11you know,
- 51:11like a life of a
- 51:14A dog with severe dementia.
- 51:16Um,
- 51:17and
- 51:19yeah,
- 51:19that was impactful,
- 51:20and I,
- 51:20I,
- 51:21even before then,
- 51:21I've always kind of thought that.
- 51:24It just makes so much sense.
- 51:25So
- 51:26yeah,
- 51:26the thoughts.
- 51:28I'm,
- 51:29I'm really sorry.
- 51:29Like it,
- 51:30it,
- 51:30you know,
- 51:30it's heartbreaking,
- 51:31uh,
- 51:32putting a dog,
- 51:32putting your dog down,
- 51:33any pet.
- 51:34What's,
- 51:34um,
- 51:35do you mind me asking like what sort of thoughts like,
- 51:37cause I remember
- 51:38I,
- 51:38I put my dog down about a year and a half ago as well,
- 51:41um,
- 51:41and I sort of,
- 51:42I remember having some thoughts similar.
- 51:44I wonder what was going through your head when,
- 51:46when you were doing it in terms of like how that translated to
- 51:48animal like our treatment towards them.
- 51:52Yeah,
- 51:52well,
- 51:52I'm,
- 51:52I'm sorry for your loss as well.
- 51:55Um.
- 51:56I don't know.
- 51:57It was,
- 51:57I think it was just profound,
- 51:59the level of grief I experienced.
- 52:00I didn't expect my,
- 52:02I didn't anticipate myself,
- 52:04um,
- 52:05grieving as hard as I did,
- 52:07and that was sort of the emotional indicator that there was more,
- 52:13um,
- 52:15weight to that life than maybe I had previously thought.
- 52:18And because I had not grown up with pets,
- 52:19I had sort of dismissed pets as kind of,
- 52:22or maybe abstracted them as sort of like um.
- 52:25More complex appliances like I,
- 52:27you know,
- 52:28not to,
- 52:29to sound too coldhearted,
- 52:29but it just.
- 52:31The reality of their life hadn't really
- 52:33hit me.
- 52:34And then when I,
- 52:35there was an underwater like an aquatic documentary I watched in college,
- 52:40and I just remember hearing the recordings of dolphins,
- 52:43and this is something I'm actually really excited
- 52:48for AI to maybe open up is
- 52:50it
- 52:50it was so undeniable.
- 52:51It was like the realization that alien life existed.
- 52:57But it just exists underwater,
- 52:59you know,
- 52:59where it's like,
- 52:59wow,
- 53:00they're speaking,
- 53:02there's so much obvious complexity in the languages that we're hearing.
- 53:08And so it'd be great to see a moment where humans maybe start to
- 53:11decode a little bit of that language and it might even
- 53:13open up the interiority of some animals that we coexist with.
- 53:19I think that could be a big reframe
- 53:22for how we think about life.
- 53:23Yeah,
- 53:24it's really
- 53:25It's,
- 53:26I guess it's incredibly profound,
- 53:27like,
- 53:28I suppose the
- 53:29um.
- 53:30The thought,
- 53:31the,
- 53:31the grief,
- 53:31yeah,
- 53:32when you put down a dog is,
- 53:33is massive,
- 53:34the first thing to say.
- 53:35Um,
- 53:35I,
- 53:35I feel,
- 53:36I feel
- 53:37my grief comes like in the form of anger and injustice.
- 53:40I sort of
- 53:41that when a family
- 53:42member or um,
- 53:44or I put down an animal,
- 53:45like my,
- 53:46my first response is just anger and upset like
- 53:48I feel like some some wrong's been done to
- 53:51them
- 53:52and um I feel like it's unjust and
- 53:54I think that I may,
- 53:55I don't know how common that is,
- 53:56I don't know much about the.
- 53:58Phenomenology of of grief for it to give it a wanky phrase,
- 54:02um,
- 54:02but like I just,
- 54:03I get,
- 54:04I get the anger,
- 54:05and the anger sort of I remember the thought I was like,
- 54:08and how dare
- 54:09people or how dare I think it was OK to sort of,
- 54:13put this creature down
- 54:14and then
- 54:15eat its flesh,
- 54:16right,
- 54:16even though,
- 54:17even if.
- 54:19Even I think this is the
- 54:21the one of the most difficult arguments is
- 54:22like roadkill or animals that are already dead
- 54:25or things that are going to waste,
- 54:27and I think that is,
- 54:28that's where some of the biggest objections to veganism lie
- 54:31and
- 54:32to,
- 54:32to be honest,
- 54:33I've,
- 54:33I struggle to sort of pinpoint what it is that's wrong about that thing.
- 54:36Um,
- 54:37but it's the same sort of thing which would be
- 54:39wrong in chewing our family member's corpse after they die.
- 54:43Right,
- 54:43it,
- 54:43it,
- 54:43it,
- 54:43it's sort of the same
- 54:45thing that they're not there to feel the harm,
- 54:47but how dare somebody sort of eat these creatures after they've,
- 54:50after they've killed them
- 54:51is the
- 54:51is the sort of thought.
- 54:53We're animal lovers as well.
- 54:54Like here are our dogs and then they sit down and serve meat
- 54:57and he's start and that's how his uh
- 54:59how his uh bestselling book starts.
- 55:01Um,
- 55:02and we're all,
- 55:03it captures some of.
- 55:04Incredibly true of all of human history that we're all animal lovers,
- 55:08we are animals,
- 55:09uh,
- 55:10but
- 55:10only a very small percentage of people sort of take that Swiss logical conclusion,
- 55:15mainly because
- 55:16things are packaged up and you don't have to look the animal in the face and,
- 55:19uh,
- 55:20live with the animal before you eat it.
- 55:22Well,
- 55:22in Catholic school,
- 55:24there was actually.
- 55:25It was there was like a venial soul,
- 55:28I think,
- 55:28and a mortal soul.
- 55:30So there was actually a real categorization between wildlife and
- 55:34humans and that kind of created the moral hierarchy
- 55:37that was cemented in me for a long time and then my wife was like,
- 55:41no animals are.
- 55:45Suffering.
- 55:45I was like,
- 55:46uh,
- 55:46oh,
- 55:46she,
- 55:46you know,
- 55:49no,
- 55:49she's not,
- 55:49but I've been talking to her because after we recorded your episode I was like,
- 55:52hey,
- 55:53what do you think about steering more towards veganism,
- 55:56and she's like,
- 55:56yeah,
- 55:57whatever.
- 55:57I,
- 55:57I'm down.
- 55:59And her and I have,
- 55:59um,
- 56:00you know,
- 56:01we,
- 56:01we,
- 56:02we always made it a point to eat,
- 56:03um,
- 56:04meat-free meals,
- 56:05uh,
- 56:05a few nights a week.
- 56:07I actually made.
- 56:08This is
- 56:09TMI.
- 56:09They'll probably cut this out,
- 56:10but,
- 56:10uh,
- 56:11I made vegan chili for a chili contest last year.
- 56:14Oh nice,
- 56:14I heard that it goes up.
- 56:16It was actually really good.
- 56:17I,
- 56:18I,
- 56:18I am drawn to even just the,
- 56:21the creative challenge of making savory food with these kind of new,
- 56:27new things that we have like tofu and you know,
- 56:29um.
- 56:31What is it,
- 56:31the,
- 56:31the yeast,
- 56:32you know,
- 56:33that you can add to it to nutritional yeast.
- 56:35I like just like the,
- 56:36like the vegan mince or something.
- 56:38I,
- 56:38I've just got,
- 56:39when I went vegan I just got hooked on spicy food.
- 56:42Like couldn't have much spice and now there's like
- 56:44I just
- 56:45the hottest curries or the hot,
- 56:46hottest Mexican food,
- 56:47I just went down a hole of just
- 56:49hot sauce and just sort of all that stuff,
- 56:51which maybe maybe that doesn't serve the vegan cause as well,
- 56:53it makes it sound like normal food's bland,
- 56:55but I just got hooked down that er
- 56:58down that line.
- 56:59No,
- 56:59yeah,
- 57:00Indian food.
- 57:00I mean their dolls,
- 57:02you know,
- 57:02the lentil-based food's incredibly flavorful,
- 57:06um,
- 57:07and,
- 57:07and a lot of that is,
- 57:08is vegan.
- 57:09One last thing I want to ask you for,
- 57:11um,
- 57:12and let me know if you,
- 57:13if you got a bounce,
- 57:13um.
- 57:15How do you square,
- 57:17I,
- 57:17I think
- 57:18this kind of came up in the first guy that debated you.
- 57:20There's sort of this argument that.
- 57:22There's just a natural,
- 57:24there's a naturalness like
- 57:26nature.
- 57:29deemed it
- 57:30as such that animals,
- 57:32some animals eat each other,
- 57:34and you know,
- 57:35we value the life of
- 57:38a lion,
- 57:39and we would think it a great tragedy if that lion were to leave this planet,
- 57:42but we don't expect the lion.
- 57:45To
- 57:47morally consider the,
- 57:48the,
- 57:50the value of the life of its prey
- 57:52because we kind of see it as its nature,
- 57:54it has to hunt that
- 57:56that animal.
- 57:57Why
- 57:58do you think of the humans kind of differently?
- 58:00Like we have this responsibility to sort of maybe transcend
- 58:04our inherited nature.
- 58:06Yeah,
- 58:07so there's two versions of the argument.
- 58:09One is
- 58:10that.
- 58:11Just
- 58:12lions hunt,
- 58:13lions will kill other animals and therefore it gives us the right to,
- 58:17to kill lions as well,
- 58:18just as they don't have the,
- 58:20um,
- 58:21we can't impose the morality onto them.
- 58:23Um,
- 58:24that argument doesn't track for a,
- 58:25for a whole range of reasons,
- 58:27and the easiest way is maybe just to give a quick example and say,
- 58:30let's say the,
- 58:31um,
- 58:32you know,
- 58:32the,
- 58:33let's say the psychopath,
- 58:34or,
- 58:35let's say,
- 58:35um,
- 58:35let's say the dog
- 58:37during the middle of the night
- 58:38jumps in your bed
- 58:39and starts
- 58:40licking you in places that people would frown upon it licking you.
- 58:44Right,
- 58:44that doesn't give you the right to jump into the dog's bed and do the same to the dog,
- 58:48right?
- 58:49Just because the dog doesn't have a choice in doing it
- 58:51does not mean you can go and do those things,
- 58:53um.
- 58:54So that's to say just because one animal does it to another
- 58:57doesn't mean you can go and do those things to another animal.
- 59:00So that's one version of the argument.
- 59:01But you might be thinking,
- 59:02Jack,
- 59:02you're missing the point.
- 59:04The,
- 59:04the actual argument I'm saying is it's a part of nature,
- 59:06it's baked into nature.
- 59:08We are preordained,
- 59:09given evolution by natural selection or God's laws.
- 59:12God we made it this way.
- 59:13That's what a lot of people would say.
- 59:15Yeah,
- 59:15we,
- 59:15we had the God debate and
- 59:17I think theists are often surprised.
- 59:19I think someone said uh we did Genesis 1:29.
- 59:22I said,
- 59:22so why didn't,
- 59:23why did God create the world with it give us a purely vegan diet?
- 59:26And I think it surprises a lot of
- 59:28Abrahamic believers when they hear that when
- 59:30they know in the Genesis story,
- 59:31God creates the world perfectly or as best as
- 59:33he can and he gives everyone a vegan diet.
- 59:35And at the end of time God will make us
- 59:37vegan again,
- 59:38the lion will lay down with the lamb.
- 59:40Um,
- 59:41and we could,
- 59:42uh,
- 59:42it's a,
- 59:42it's a separate one interpretation.
- 59:44I've never heard that.
- 59:45But if we,
- 59:46let's,
- 59:47let's transcend Christian Christianity though.
- 59:49Yeah,
- 59:50the,
- 59:50the,
- 59:51the evolution or naturalistic argument,
- 59:53there are two things.
- 59:54One is that the methods matter,
- 59:56and two,
- 59:57that
- 59:58explanation isn't justification.
- 1:00:01The means matter.
- 1:00:02It,
- 1:00:02it's the case that we are preordained by natural selection to
- 1:00:07want to do things like engage in sexual reproduction.
- 1:00:10But evolution doesn't tell us to have consensual or non-consensual sex,
- 1:00:13it just says go forth and have sex.
- 1:00:15But we think we should take that drive
- 1:00:17and choose the consensual sex over the non-consensual sex.
- 1:00:20In the same way evolution dictates that we should
- 1:00:22take on a certain amount of protein and nutrients,
- 1:00:25but it's important that we do that in the right way.
- 1:00:27Um,
- 1:00:27we can
- 1:00:28kill and slaughter animals
- 1:00:30or we can,
- 1:00:30um,
- 1:00:31seek that stuff from elsewhere.
- 1:00:33The second thing to say is that
- 1:00:34the.
- 1:00:35It's,
- 1:00:35it's the naturalistic fallacy
- 1:00:37in uh in philosophy
- 1:00:39that an observation isn't a justification.
- 1:00:42So just because the world is a certain way doesn't mean it ought to be that way.
- 1:00:45It's,
- 1:00:46it's crossing that hisor gap to take Hume's language.
- 1:00:48So there are lots of things we do.
- 1:00:50Uh,
- 1:00:50I'll give two quick examples like
- 1:00:51Saint Augustine of Hippo
- 1:00:53in the 6th century,
- 1:00:54Christian
- 1:00:55theologian,
- 1:00:56said that humans.
- 1:00:58We're built in with original sin.
- 1:01:00We want to lie,
- 1:01:01cheat,
- 1:01:01steal,
- 1:01:02be selfish,
- 1:01:03right?
- 1:01:03But he thought just because we are that way doesn't mean we have to be.
- 1:01:06We can transcend that and do otherwise.
- 1:01:08And similarly for the atheistic philosopher Thomas Hobbes,
- 1:01:12English philosopher of the 17th century,
- 1:01:14he said
- 1:01:14it's a mechanistic world,
- 1:01:16probably no God,
- 1:01:17and.
- 1:01:18But
- 1:01:18in a state of nature,
- 1:01:20what are humans like naturally?
- 1:01:22Well,
- 1:01:22humans,
- 1:01:23uh,
- 1:01:23life would be nasty,
- 1:01:24brutus,
- 1:01:24and short.
- 1:01:25It would be a war of every man against
- 1:01:26every man because we just want things for ourselves.
- 1:01:29We,
- 1:01:29we,
- 1:01:30we wanna,
- 1:01:30we engage in countless wars,
- 1:01:32you know,
- 1:01:33there's,
- 1:01:33there's been too many,
- 1:01:34far too many genocides,
- 1:01:35even though one would be enough.
- 1:01:36Uh,
- 1:01:37that's things that humans do by nature.
- 1:01:39But again,
- 1:01:40that just because it's a part of our nature.
- 1:01:42Doesn't mean that it ought to be that way.
- 1:01:44So if you think that lying,
- 1:01:45cheating,
- 1:01:46stealing,
- 1:01:46genocide,
- 1:01:47war and things that are in our natures,
- 1:01:49um,
- 1:01:50but we should transcend them,
- 1:01:51then I don't see why it'd be different when it comes to,
- 1:01:54uh,
- 1:01:55torturing,
- 1:01:56um,
- 1:01:56mutilating and slaughtering animals.
- 1:01:59Mhm,
- 1:02:00yeah,
- 1:02:00no,
- 1:02:00I think that makes sense,
- 1:02:02um,
- 1:02:02to me,
- 1:02:02that idea of like.
- 1:02:05You know,
- 1:02:06once you have this interior compass,
- 1:02:09um,
- 1:02:10exploring morals,
- 1:02:11um,
- 1:02:12there's a responsibility of paired with that.
- 1:02:15What is going on in our brains and why we have that ability is another discussion,
- 1:02:20but I agree,
- 1:02:21I think it's there and,
- 1:02:22and I think it it.
- 1:02:24It points us in certain directions.
- 1:02:26Um,
- 1:02:27well,
- 1:02:27we're out of time.
- 1:02:28Uh,
- 1:02:29I gotta run.
- 1:02:29My daughter's actually,
- 1:02:30uh,
- 1:02:32she's,
- 1:02:32she's home sick,
- 1:02:33so I gotta go get her off the television.
- 1:02:35Um,
- 1:02:38but.
- 1:02:39Oh yeah,
- 1:02:39thank you very much.
- 1:02:40I'm,
- 1:02:40she's having the time of her life,
- 1:02:42uh.
- 1:02:44Unrestricted screen time.
- 1:02:46But uh it was,
- 1:02:47it's sorry,
- 1:02:48just it I just say I'm absolutely delighted that you've went,
- 1:02:51uh,
- 1:02:52that you're reducing your meat intake or going 90% vegan.
- 1:02:54I,
- 1:02:54I,
- 1:02:54I,
- 1:02:55I will admit I was a little bit depressed after the last guy who was on the,
- 1:02:58on the show and he,
- 1:02:59I just couldn't bring him round to
- 1:03:01just to commit to it.
- 1:03:02So you've restored my faith and,
- 1:03:03um,
- 1:03:04and made the whole experience,
- 1:03:05uh,
- 1:03:06uh,
- 1:03:06well,
- 1:03:06it was worth it anyway cos I hopefully it changes some other people's minds,
- 1:03:09but it's nice to.
- 1:03:10Um,
- 1:03:11yeah,
- 1:03:11I'm,
- 1:03:11I'm really glad that it's brought you around,
- 1:03:13uh,
- 1:03:13even a little bit.
- 1:03:15Yeah,
- 1:03:16well,
- 1:03:16I mean,
- 1:03:16I think my hope is,
- 1:03:17I,
- 1:03:17I can understand,
- 1:03:18I,
- 1:03:20the issue itself is very interesting because
- 1:03:22like we discussed,
- 1:03:23it brings up so many feelings,
- 1:03:26but um
- 1:03:27You know,
- 1:03:28witnessing you on the show,
- 1:03:29it just,
- 1:03:30it reignited that kind of like a ha,
- 1:03:33like there's sort of a light bulb,
- 1:03:34and I think generally
- 1:03:36when something
- 1:03:36feels so obvious or it or it sparks rage,
- 1:03:40that's sometimes an indicator that it's kind of an obvious
- 1:03:45truth.
- 1:03:46Um,
- 1:03:47and yeah,
- 1:03:47it is an inconvenient truth,
- 1:03:48but um,
- 1:03:49I appreciate you coming on the show and just sort of like reigniting my interest in,
- 1:03:53in the,
- 1:03:53the issue and the arguments there.
- 1:03:55It was really fun to watch you.
- 1:03:56Um,
- 1:03:57I hope you enjoy the,
- 1:03:58the final video when you see it out in the wild,
- 1:04:01but,
- 1:04:01uh,
- 1:04:01Doctor Simes,
- 1:04:02thanks for coming on the follow-up.
- 1:04:04Thanks for being in surrounded,
- 1:04:06and,
- 1:04:06uh,
- 1:04:06hopefully this won't be the last time we talk.
- 1:04:09Great,
- 1:04:09so,
- 1:04:09cheers,
- 1:04:09John.
- 1:04:10Thank you so much.
- 1:04:10It's been a,
- 1:04:11it's been a pleasure.
- 1:04:12If you want to see more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 1:04:14be sure to like,
- 1:04:15leave us a positive review,
- 1:04:17comment if you're watching the video on YouTube.
- 1:04:20Uh,
- 1:04:20you can subscribe to Tubili,
- 1:04:21Jubilee's second channel.
- 1:04:23You can also subscribe to Jubilee to see full
- 1:04:26Surrounded episodes.
- 1:04:27But however you want to support us,
- 1:04:29just thank you so much for listening.
- 1:04:31Remember,
- 1:04:31you could be wrong,
- 1:04:32so could I.
- 1:04:33Keep your mind open
- 1:04:35until next time.