Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #81🎙️ |Public Inquiry Public Health Week Beginning 29th June 2026 Day 3 |
Transcript
- 0:05Unknown: For countless generations I have sustained
- 0:07life. I have gathered the rain, stored the waters, sheltered the
- 0:13salmon of knowledge, the mountain hare, the freshwater
- 0:17pearl mussel, and the curlew shaped the peoples of the
- 0:21sperms. I am not merely land, I am not merely property, I am not
- 0:28a resource to be consumed. I am a living entity. Every day at
- 0:32the public inquiry, people speak about the spurns, consultants
- 0:37speak, barristers speak, experts speak, campaigners speak,
- 0:44government departments speak, but the mountains themselves
- 0:48never get to speak. Perhaps this is one way of letting them have
- 0:54a voice. So, on to today's events. Topic-wise, we're still
- 1:00firmly in the territory of blasting radon, norm, public
- 1:04health, and EMF. Now, for those who, for some extraordinary
- 1:10reason, may be completely unfamiliar with these terms, and
- 1:15why on earth would you be, unless you were forced to become
- 1:17acquainted with them, because of the prospect of a toxic gold
- 1:21mine opening on your doorstep. Here's a quick guide: blasting,
- 1:26whether blasting could release dust contaminants or affect
- 1:31groundwater. Not much explanation needed there. Most
- 1:36of us are already rather more familiar with blasting than we'd
- 1:40ever have wished, given our post-conflict history. Radon,
- 1:47the naturally occurring radioactive gas that can be
- 1:50released from certain rocks and soils. Again, radon isn't
- 1:56exactly a new concept around here. In fact, most new houses
- 2:00in Tyrone have to be fitted with radon barriers, because the
- 2:03naturally high levels found in parts of the country norm
- 2:09naturally occurring radioactive material, in other words, the
- 2:14radioactive minerals that are naturally present within the
- 2:18rock itself, and whether mining, processing, waste rock or
- 2:23tailings could concentrate or expose them. Now, this one was
- 2:29completely new to me. I suspect it will be to most people as
- 2:33well. It's one of those terms that sounds like it should
- 2:37describe something perfectly ordinary, normal, even, but in
- 2:41reality it's anything but. And then, of course, we come to
- 2:46public health, the potential health implications arising from
- 2:51all the above, including air quality, dust, water
- 2:56contamination, and radiation exposure. And finally, to
- 3:01complete the collection, there's EMF, electromagnetic fields,
- 3:07largely associated with the power lines and electrical
- 3:10infrastructure needed to support the proposed mine. Mix all of
- 3:15those ingredients together, and lo and behold, you have the menu
- 3:18for our final day before the inquiry broke for its summer
- 3:22recess, it certainly felt like a bit like the last day at school
- 3:27as we filed out of the hearing room that afternoon, except
- 3:31somehow discussions around such topics as these added a slightly
- 3:36sobering overtone to any sense of relief. Of particular note
- 3:41today was the number of expert witnesses representing Save Our
- 3:45Spurns. We heard from retired GP Dr. Alan Evans, mr. Michael
- 3:52Mullen, consultant surgeon, and Leona Quigg, paediatric
- 3:56neurodevelopment and neurology expert. Joining them were some
- 4:00of our regular frequent fliers who travelled considerable
- 4:05distances time and again to support us. They included Linda
- 4:09Sullivan and Dr. Louise Taylor. Alongside them, of course, were
- 4:14all the usual suspects, the familiar faces who continued to
- 4:18turn up day after day, week after week, quietly
- 4:21demonstrating the remarkable commitment that has sustained
- 4:25this campaign for so long. Have I mentioned before that we do
- 4:31love a good acronym at the public inquiry? In fact, we love
- 4:35them so much that after a while it becomes something of a
- 4:38mystery what anyone is actually talking about, but that's all
- 4:42right, so long as you nod knowingly and give the
- 4:44impression you understand perfectly. Today's prize acronym
- 4:48has to go to Ichnerp, I c n i r p. Everyone in the room appeared
- 4:55to know exactly what it meant, everyone that is, except me, not
- 4:59to keep you. And suspense stands for the International Commission
- 5:03on Non ionising Radiation Protection. What a mouthful.
- 5:09Ichnerp is an independent scientific body that publishes
- 5:13internationally recognised guidelines on safe exposure
- 5:16limits for non ionising radiation, that is
- 5:21electromagnetic fields, EMFs, produced by things such as high
- 5:26voltage power lines, electricity substations, mobile phone masks,
- 5:31Wi-Fi, etc. The guidelines are designed to protect against
- 5:35established health effects such as tissue heating and nerve
- 5:39stimulation caused by strong electromagnetic fields, so have
- 5:46you got all of that now?
- 5:49So we now know that Ichnerp is the body that sets the exposure
- 5:53limits for the electromagnetic fields, and as you might
- 5:58imagine, the applicant argues that its infrastructure complies
- 6:02with ICNERP, effectively saying the predicted EMF levels fall
- 6:07within the internationally accepted safety guidelines.
- 6:11Interestingly, Derry and Straban Environmental Health did not
- 6:17have any concerns, saying that the proposed development
- 6:21complies with the guidelines, but whether those guidelines are
- 6:25sufficiently precautionary is a separate question. And Fidelmo
- 6:30Cain was very quick to point out that reliance on guidelines is
- 6:33highly selective and offers no regulatory protection over a
- 6:37multi decade timeline that the EIA, another acronym,
- 6:43Environmental Impact Statement, relies on computer simulation,
- 6:47and that third parties would have liked to have seen a
- 6:50worst-case scenario rather than smoothed out averages, and that
- 6:54the studies are about adults and are not suitable for developing
- 6:58children. Dr. Evans explained how there had been a twofold
- 7:04increase in loot in childhood leukaemia, and that it is still
- 7:07a risk, even though it falls within the guidelines. Dr.
- 7:12Cromie, speaking on behalf of public health, said that they do
- 7:16accept the guidelines as being adequate to protect public
- 7:19health. Orbanson counsel for NIE said that there wasn't any
- 7:25evidence that the existing 100 power lines that crisscross the
- 7:30AONB have had any impact and that there would be no impact
- 7:37from our power line which are 33 kilovolts. Later on, another
- 7:44third party wondered how many of the lines that were
- 7:47crisscrossing the AOMB were 33 kilovolts, which I think is
- 7:54carries a huge power supply. Niall McAleer pointed out that
- 8:00there was a well-known cancer cluster in the mid-orlist for
- 8:03area, which Dr. Conmee from PHA was cut to refute. Commissioner
- 8:09McCary then went on to ask a series of questions to Elvin
- 8:13Barrister for DFI as to who was responsible for considering
- 8:18arsenic and lead within the application. DFI did not know,
- 8:23followed by another question, Who was responsible for
- 8:26radiology? DFI did not know. Later that morning, we heard
- 8:33from Leona Quigg, paediatric neurodevelopment and neurology
- 8:38expert, who spoke movingly about the rising rates of autism
- 8:42spectrum disorder, ASD, in Northern Ireland, and the
- 8:45growing body of research examining associations between
- 8:49exposure to air pollution during pregnancy and early childhood,
- 8:53and an increased prevalence of ASD, as well as greater severity
- 8:58of symptoms. Her evidence was that these exposures do not
- 9:03occur in isolation, rather they combine at critical stages of a
- 9:09child's development, creating what she described as a perfect
- 9:13storm of multiple environmental exposures. She referred to
- 9:18research from Denmark, which she suggested provided a useful
- 9:21comparison with Northern Ireland. One of the figures that
- 9:24really caught my attention was the prevalence of autism here.
- 9:28Northern Ireland is often quoted as having a rate of around one
- 9:32in 16 children, compared with the global average of around a
- 9:36one in 100 She also noted that once children still waiting for
- 9:42an assessment are taking into account the true figure here may
- 9:46be closer to one in 10. She suggested that this may indicate
- 9:51a population with a particular genetic susceptibility, meaning
- 9:57environmental factors could have. An even greater
- 10:01significance, and that the economic impact is enormous too.
- 10:06She cited estimates that the lifetime health care costs for
- 10:10one autistic individual is around 1.5 million pounds, and
- 10:14argued that taken together these costs exceed those associated
- 10:19with stroke, cancer, and heart disease. Importantly, she
- 10:24stressed that the discussion should not be confined to autism
- 10:27alone. She said there is similarly compelling evidence
- 10:31linking air pollution with a range of other conditions,
- 10:34including cancer, respiratory diseases, and metabolic
- 10:38disorders. Her closing message was simple, but powerful. We are
- 10:44already in the midst of a childhood crisis, so would a
- 10:47development like this improve the situation or make it worse?
- 10:52In her view, the evidence needed to help answer that question
- 10:56already exists, and it is the evidence we should be paying
- 10:59attention to, and I'm going to leave it here for this evening,
- 11:04because we've only managed to make it as far as 1130 this
- 11:09morning. I'll pick it up again on Saturday evening, when I'll
- 11:13finish today's proceedings and round up the week with an end of
- 11:16week review. Thanks very much for listening, and we'll see you
- 11:20all again soon.