Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #77🎙️ |Public Inquiry week in review 18th June 2026|
Transcript
- 0:02Unknown: The this week at the public inquiry was one of those
- 0:07weeks where the issues being discussed in the room were
- 0:10almost overshadowed by the events unfolding around them on
- 0:14paper. This week was about noise, decibels, modelling,
- 0:18predictions, mitigation measures, and technical
- 0:20assessments, but as is often the case at this inquiry, the
- 0:25conversation taking place beneath the surface proved just
- 0:28as revealing as the evidence itself. The week began with a
- 0:32development that many of us found deeply demoralising. The
- 0:35timetable grew yet again. A further 33 days were added to
- 0:40the inquiry schedule, extending a process that has already
- 0:44consumed months of people's lives. For third parties, every
- 0:49additional day means more preparation, more reading, more
- 0:53time away from family, work, and other responsibilities. Most of
- 0:59us arriving expecting to continue with the evidence,
- 1:02instead we found ourselves confronting a different problem
- 1:06altogether. The internet in the section of the room used by
- 1:11third parties was down at first, that might sound like a minor
- 1:17inconvenience. In reality, it was anything, but modern public
- 1:24inquiries depend heavily on digital documents. Evidence is
- 1:29stored online, reports are accessed online, planning
- 1:34documents, submissions, maps, and technical assessments are
- 1:40all increasingly digital, without internet access, many of
- 1:44us were effectively cut off from the material we needed to
- 1:47participate properly. What made matters worse was the applicant
- 1:51and the statutory bodies continued to have access, their
- 1:57connection was working, ours were not. The proceedings
- 2:01continued regardless for the earth protectors that raised an
- 2:05obvious question about fairness. If one side can access
- 2:10documents, evidence and information in real time while
- 2:13the other cannot, are both sides really participating on equal
- 2:16terms? The discussions that morning focus heavily on noise
- 2:23impacts one of the most important and technically
- 2:27complicated complex areas of evidence. Yet the third parties
- 2:34seeking to challenge that evidence were attempting to do
- 2:37so without access to the documents that they needed as
- 2:42the hours passed. Frustration in the room became increasingly
- 2:46visible. People waited for opportunities to speak.
- 2:51Questions were prepared and re-prepared. Conversations
- 2:56taking place in whispered voices around the room. Eventually,
- 3:01after lunch, internet access was restored, and third parties were
- 3:06finally able to engage more fully once more. Noise remained
- 3:13the dominant topic throughout the remainder of the week. There
- 3:17were lengthy discussions about noise modelling, predicted
- 3:20impacts, and the assumptions underpinning the applicant's
- 3:24assessments. As always, the art protectors continued to
- 3:29scrutinise the evidence very closely indeed. One of the
- 3:34recurring themes of the inquiry has been the extent to which
- 3:38ordinary members of the public have identified errors,
- 3:42omissions, and weaknesses within highly technical submissions,
- 3:48and this week was no different. Time and again, points were
- 3:51raised, assumptions were challenged, and details were
- 3:55questioned. Large plan applications are not improved by
- 4:00unquestioning acceptance, they are improved when evidence is
- 4:04tested rigorously from every angle. Questions arose about
- 4:10whether individuals who have spent decades living beside
- 4:13mining operations should be regarded as expert witnesses
- 4:16when discussing the impacts of mining noise. It's an
- 4:20interesting question, if somebody has spent 30 or 40
- 4:24years living with blasting traffic, dust, and industrial
- 4:28noise, does their evidence carry any less weight than a
- 4:33consultant who has studied the subject professionally? The
- 4:38debate highlights a tension that appears repeatedly through the
- 4:42inquiry, the tension between so-called professional expertise
- 4:47and the lived reality. Towards the end of the week, attention
- 4:51shifted to an issue that has generated considerable
- 4:54discussion both inside and outside the inquiry room. The
- 4:59exclusion. Of longstanding anti-gold mining campaigner
- 5:02Cormac McAleer, and many listeners will be familiar with
- 5:05the events earlier in the week that led to his exclusion. Mary
- 5:11Brawley submitted an application seeking his readmission. Her
- 5:15argument was straightforward. She suggested that a blanket
- 5:20exclusion was disproportionate, and that it deprived the inquiry
- 5:25of a knowledgeable and experienced voice who had spent
- 5:27years engaging with the issues under discussion. Whether people
- 5:32agree with Cormac or disagree with him, there can be little
- 5:35argument that he possesses a deep understanding of both the
- 5:39project and the wider issues surrounding mining in the
- 5:42sperms.
- 5:43The commissioners heard the application and reserved their
- 5:47decision. They indicated that they would consider the matter
- 5:51during the break before announcing their ruling when the
- 5:54inquiry resumes. So that is where we leave things for now.
- 6:00Another week completed, another 33 days added to the schedule.
- 6:05Another reminder of how demanding this process has
- 6:07become for everyone involved. As always, thank you for listening.
- 6:12Thank you for your continued support. And I'll be back with
- 6:15another update when the inquiry resumes.