Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Corporate Evasion and the Breakdown of Discovery with Adam Levitt, Diandra "Fu" Debrosse, Brian O'Mara
Transcript
- 0:06I'm Lori Crimp -Martin, certified family law
- 0:08specialist. I'm also the vice chair of BHBA's
- 0:12litigation section. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:14today's speakers, Adam Levitt, Deandra Fu -DeBrasse,
- 0:18and Amy Keller. Adam Levitt is a partner at Decelio
- 0:22Levitt LLP and one of the nation's leading advocates
- 0:26for plaintiffs in complex class action and multi
- 0:29-district litigation. He has secured over $25
- 0:32billion in client recoveries across a wide range
- 0:35of industries and played key roles in landmark
- 0:38biotechnology, environmental, and public client
- 0:42cases. Known for his innovative strategies and
- 0:44leadership, Adam has been entrusted with some
- 0:47of the most high profile. and impactful litigations
- 0:50in recent history. D 'Andrea Fueh de Bruyce is
- 0:53a partner at Decelio 11 LLP and managing partner
- 0:57of the firm's Birmingham office, where she leads
- 1:00high impact mass tort, civil rights, and product
- 1:03liability litigation. Nationally recognized for
- 1:06her advocacy on behalf of individuals and public
- 1:09entities, Foo has recovered nearly 1 billion
- 1:12for clients harmed by corporate misconduct, discrimination,
- 1:16and defective products. She holds key leadership
- 1:19roles in major multi -district litigation, including
- 1:23actions against infrared formula, hair relaxer,
- 1:26herbicide, and social media companies. Our third
- 1:31panelist today is Amy Keller, who's the managing
- 1:34director of the firm's Chicago office and the
- 1:38privacy, technology, and cyber Security Practice
- 1:41Chair. Amy has held leadership positions in a
- 1:44variety of complex litigations across the nation
- 1:47where she successfully litigated high profile
- 1:50and costly data security and consumer privacy
- 1:54cases. Amy has represented consumers against
- 1:57industry titans such as Apple, Marriott, and
- 2:02BMW, securing victories against each. She has
- 2:05been appointed to the leadership positions in
- 2:08more multi -district litigations than any other
- 2:10woman in the last eight years, with each case
- 2:14requiring sophistication and not only understanding
- 2:16complex legal theories, but also presenting multifaceted
- 2:22strategies and damage modeling to ensure favorable
- 2:26results for her clients. And now let's get started.
- 2:29Thanks very much, everybody. is Adam Levitt.
- 2:32And as I say to people, each time I speak in
- 2:35front of them for the very first time, I occasionally
- 2:40stutter when I speak. It's not a problem for
- 2:42me. It shouldn't be for you. If anything I say
- 2:45isn't 100 % clear, please let me know and I'll
- 2:49go right back over it. Our partner, Fu DeBros,
- 2:53is running a little bit late. We apologize for
- 2:56that. She's actually in a hair relaxer deposition
- 3:00prep session that's running a little bit long.
- 3:02And she'll be on as... Oh, she's on now. Look
- 3:05at that. And Fu is evidently on. But anyway,
- 3:11before anything, most important thing with all
- 3:13of this is that we hope that you and... your
- 3:17family members in Los Angeles are safe in these
- 3:21incredibly trying times. And we hope that everything
- 3:24works out there because obviously what's happening
- 3:26there is pretty much unprecedented in our history.
- 3:31We're not living through it, but you all are.
- 3:35So we hope everyone's okay. So as was said in
- 3:41the introduction before we get into some of the
- 3:44other issues is that our firm, Dicello Levitt,
- 3:47is an 85 lawyer firm in eight cities around the
- 3:51United States, with we also have affiliated offices
- 3:57in the EU, the United Kingdom, and in South America.
- 4:04We do a wide range of complex issues and trial
- 4:08work. And as a result of that, a lot of the things
- 4:11that we're going to be talking about this morning
- 4:14are things that we're dealing with and I'm sure
- 4:17you're dealing with every day. But let me turn
- 4:21it over real quick to both Amy and Fu before
- 4:24we get started with the actual substance. Thank
- 4:29you, Adam. I'll go next, just in alphabetical
- 4:32order. My name is Amy Keller, and I'm pleased
- 4:37to join you all today. Adam and Phu asked me
- 4:41to join based upon some of the issues that I've
- 4:44been encountering a lot in my cases lately related
- 4:47to discovery and certain discovery disputes we've
- 4:51had at the corporate level, especially as I litigate
- 4:55against a bunch of technology companies. and
- 4:59the struggles that we face related to not only
- 5:03where the information can be found with technology
- 5:06companies, but also the asymmetry of information
- 5:09between plaintiffs and defendants and discovery
- 5:12disputes. So I look forward to having a robust
- 5:15discussion with all of you today. Hi, my name
- 5:19is Deondra DeBros and I'm Adam and Amy's partner
- 5:22and I am co -chair of the Mass Tort Practice
- 5:26and I work on public entity work as well. I think
- 5:30that discovery makes us all want to scream and
- 5:33that's the truth of it and it's frustrating and
- 5:36I think sometimes definitely when we were younger
- 5:38lawyers it felt kind of pointless. Of course
- 5:41as we developed cases and try to prosecute cases
- 5:45on behalf of our clients, we realize that it's
- 5:48not procedure, right? It's substantive. And if
- 5:50we can't get to what the defendants have, we
- 5:54really can't represent our clients. And I think
- 5:56we've all seen in our career a real negative
- 5:59trend towards just... fighting us at every stage,
- 6:04I believe, affirmatively ignoring the rules of
- 6:08civil procedure on the federal level, on the
- 6:11state level, gamesmanship, not responding to
- 6:14discovery. And that has real ramifications for
- 6:17our ability to prosecute the cases. And I think
- 6:20it just has real ramifications in terms of the
- 6:23integrity of our justice system across the board.
- 6:27So it's something, a topic we're very... passionate
- 6:29about individually and as a firm and that we
- 6:32published about extensively and that I complain
- 6:35about at least on a daily basis. Great. Thank
- 6:39you, Phu. And also a lot of the things that we're
- 6:42talking about this morning relate to or they
- 6:45arise out of three columns that I wrote. I have
- 6:49a monthly column in the National Law Journal
- 6:52called Arguing Class Actions. And so it's three
- 6:57of them that came out. last fall and a couple
- 7:00of them this spring relating to some of the experiences
- 7:05we've had. But if we can go to slide three, I
- 7:10would ask Fu to kick off about the purposes and
- 7:14principles of discovery. Sure. I mean, when we,
- 7:19obviously all of us on the plaintiff side anyway,
- 7:23advance the case and prepare our complaint, we
- 7:25have a good faith basis to make those allegations.
- 7:29And in theory, we have a good faith basis for
- 7:33the factual underpinnings. But the role of discovery
- 7:36is To find the truth. I mean, that's why the
- 7:39rule is a bit liberal. It can lead to admissible
- 7:43evidence. It's related to your claims. And the
- 7:46reason it's a liberal discovery is often the
- 7:49person from whom we're seeking justice has access
- 7:52to a lot of information and the documents and
- 7:55the history that we need to establish that something
- 7:59bad happened in the past. And, you know, how
- 8:01I often explain it to our younger lawyers is,
- 8:04you know, we have a bizarre job, all of us. plaintiff
- 8:07side, defense side have to reconstruct the past,
- 8:10what happened. And often for individual plaintiffs,
- 8:14they are not privy to all of the documents and
- 8:17policies and procedures and personnel and people
- 8:20who were ultimately involved in whatever terrible
- 8:24things occurred to them. And that's the purpose.
- 8:27We're looking for facts and we're trying to understand
- 8:30what happened in the past. And we're also trying
- 8:33to balance the burden on plaintiffs who don't
- 8:37have access to information, while also balancing
- 8:41the burden, which is often overstated, on behalf
- 8:45of entities that have that information. Yes.
- 8:50And I think also along those lines, as we said
- 8:52in the PowerPoint slide, the Seattle Times case.
- 8:57the US Supreme Court said very clearly, the sole
- 9:00purpose of discovery is to assist in the preparation
- 9:04and trial or the settlement of litigated disputes.
- 9:08Now, obviously, and some of the things we'll
- 9:10be talking about over the next 45 minutes or
- 9:12so relate to the fact that what's been happening
- 9:16and what you all experience, what we all experience
- 9:19day to day seems to move very far field from
- 9:23that very simple function and purpose. And so
- 9:31I think it's important, though, that in terms
- 9:33of, and Fu, if you wanted to talk about the importance
- 9:36of early preparation as well so that we know
- 9:39what the rules of the game are, I think that
- 9:41would be helpful. Sure. And I think for Adam,
- 9:45Amy, and I and our other partner, Brian, who
- 9:48couldn't be on today, especially I think whether
- 9:52you practice in one jurisdiction or not and understanding
- 9:55of standing orders in that courthouse, you might
- 9:59have a complex or consolidated case that has
- 10:02multiple standing orders by the time you entered
- 10:04the case. And especially for us across different
- 10:07jurisdictions, it's necessary for us to understand
- 10:11What are the local rules vis -a -vis discovery?
- 10:14What are the standing orders? Something that
- 10:16we often do as well is pull the orders of that
- 10:20judge in other cases. Discovery is funny. Judges
- 10:24have a lot of latitude in terms of what they
- 10:28find to be a problem, what they don't, whether
- 10:31or not they appoint a discovery special master.
- 10:34What are their preferences? What have they ruled
- 10:37on regarding paper documents? find that to be
- 10:41a real fight. A company's been around 100 years.
- 10:44What happened to those paper documents? How do
- 10:47you get to them? Will the court require that
- 10:49you review them on site? So I think there are
- 10:53often a lot of questions that we can answer by
- 10:57doing a little due diligence on the front end
- 11:00and finding out how has this judge or magistrate
- 11:04ruled previously. And often, I think if you're
- 11:08pairing with other lawyers who practice more
- 11:11in the jurisdiction, spending time speaking to
- 11:13other lawyers and understanding how the discovery
- 11:16process went in their particular case. Amy, do
- 11:20you have some thoughts? Absolutely. Of course,
- 11:24all this is balanced against some of the newer
- 11:28arguments that we're seeing more and more as
- 11:31part of this meet and confer process. Something
- 11:34that is new to federal rule of civil procedure
- 11:3826B1 is this concept of proportionality. Now
- 11:42proportionality has always been part of the federal
- 11:45rules of civil procedure, but now it is an argument
- 11:48that we see more and more as a way to restrict
- 11:51discovery. on the other side. And some of the
- 11:54things that you have to think about when you're
- 11:56seeking information are the importance of the
- 12:00issues at stake in the action, the amount of
- 12:03controversy, the party's relative access to information,
- 12:06this is what we're calling the asymmetry of information,
- 12:10the resources of the parties, the importance
- 12:13of the discovery. to what you are trying to resolve
- 12:17and the issues in your litigation and the burdens
- 12:20or expense of the proposed discovery. So as you're
- 12:24preparing and you're reading the rules and the
- 12:27standing orders and you're understanding all
- 12:28the deadlines, you should also have in mind what
- 12:32are the arguments going to be against getting
- 12:35the fulsome discovery that you need to prove
- 12:38your case. If you're on the plaintiff's side
- 12:40and then of course on the defense side, thinking
- 12:43about, you know, whatever the... arguments related
- 12:45to proportionality, what are the limitations
- 12:47that can be in place as you're moving forward.
- 12:51This is something that comes up again and again
- 12:54and again in litigation talking about what does
- 12:58proportionality mean and what are the limitations
- 13:00of it. So far, what we've seen is that proportionality,
- 13:06nothing has really changed so much in terms of
- 13:10the rulings that come down related to what is
- 13:14and is not appropriate to discovery and what
- 13:16is and is not too expansive. But instead, it's
- 13:20more front loading the issue so that it's resolved
- 13:24at the outset when you have these discovery requests
- 13:27and when you have these 30 v 6 deposition topics,
- 13:31the parties dig into these issues much sooner
- 13:33than they would have before. Thank you. Let's
- 13:38go to the next slide. So I think one of the things
- 13:46that we've all seen and we've all experienced,
- 13:50and obviously we understand that our audience
- 13:53here is not all people on our side of the fence.
- 13:57So for those of you on the defense side here,
- 14:01feel free to consider this an admonition of sorts.
- 14:06But anyway, this is all arising out of the experience
- 14:10that we've had. And I think that a lot of the
- 14:14corporate evasion tactics in discovery really
- 14:19fall into a series of clear patterns. And Fu,
- 14:24if you want to speak to extending the first day
- 14:27order negotiations, I think that would be helpful.
- 14:30Sure, so I think in a lot of our cases, obviously
- 14:33dependent on the nature of the cases, there are
- 14:36protective orders that have to be negotiated
- 14:39and put in place. Often there may be early discussions
- 14:42about ESI and a number of fourth, first day orders
- 14:46that help organize the litigation, assist the
- 14:49judge and help us get off to a great start, to
- 14:52the extent you could get off to a great start
- 14:54when you're litigating. And what we see more
- 14:57and more is rather than conceding, you know,
- 15:01common issues, whether it's giving plaintiffs
- 15:03and their experts access to a site for initial
- 15:07inspections, it becomes, as Amy said earlier,
- 15:11a meet and confirm morass. There are 10 emails
- 15:15and letters about a meeting to have a meeting
- 15:18to talk about the ninth draft of the first day
- 15:20order rather than just really acting in the spirit
- 15:23of getting some protective orders and necessary
- 15:26pleadings and orders in place so we can move
- 15:29forward with the litigation. And so in our a
- 15:32lot of those types of orders could be negotiated
- 15:35in 60 days, sometimes 30 days, and instead they
- 15:39could just drag on for months. I think we would
- 15:42like to believe it's not intentional, but in
- 15:45that it has become a pattern and used as a tool
- 15:49of negotiation. It seems to have become a way
- 15:53to slow down the process. And often, I mean,
- 15:56to be fair, I think it lays in the judge's hands
- 15:59often as well to say, I have no idea why. you
- 16:01all are taking so long to enter a protective
- 16:04order, what kind of games and ship is going on.
- 16:07But sometimes you don't have a court that's focused
- 16:10on that. I mean, judges have hundreds of cases.
- 16:13And so we have found in our practice that it's
- 16:16something that could just drag on for months
- 16:18when that's really not necessary. Amy, do you
- 16:22have any views on that? Yeah, I would definitely
- 16:26recommend from the outset for both sides of the
- 16:28aisle to maybe work with the judge and see if
- 16:32you can get hard and fast deadlines in place
- 16:34to either propose competing provisions of your
- 16:39protocols and draft orders or the orders. themselves.
- 16:44One of the things that has significantly helped
- 16:47me and opposing counsel as well whenever we are
- 16:51negotiating these orders is asking the judges,
- 16:54hey, can you help us set some deadlines here?
- 16:56And they are hard deadlines. And it helps the
- 16:59parties cut through some of the mean confirm
- 17:03morass that my colleague Fu was referring to
- 17:07where you're kind of exchanging a draft of a
- 17:10draft and your final position. are really there.
- 17:14And you still have a lot of leeway for negotiation,
- 17:18but you're kind of starting from, you know, your
- 17:21furthest point away from the middle. Sometimes
- 17:24having these hard and fast deadlines in place,
- 17:26you cut to the issues that are actually very
- 17:28important right away. And sometimes just presenting
- 17:32these issues to the judge, you're competing provisions
- 17:34in those orders. And really what your... you're
- 17:38wanting and trying to get at cuts through some
- 17:40of this stuff at the end of the day. So finding
- 17:44a judge that is friendly enough to help you work
- 17:47through those issues is great. And then once
- 17:49you have an order in place that has worked in
- 17:53prior litigation, helping to get to the meat
- 17:57of all of the issues, sometimes proposing that
- 17:59order again and citing to the previous case where
- 18:03it worked is a really great way to present the
- 18:06issue to the judge. Absolutely. And I think also,
- 18:12I think we could all say this on both sides of
- 18:14the fence, hopefully, that getting this stuff
- 18:18squared away quickly is vitally important. I
- 18:22think one of the things that I was actually speaking
- 18:24on this in court about three weeks ago, we were
- 18:28in the midst of a hearing where the other side
- 18:30said, all the plaintiffs want to do is engage
- 18:33in a fishing expedition. Bottom line is that
- 18:39we're on a contingency. The last thing we want
- 18:42to do is waste our time. We want to get to the
- 18:45point, get the information we need, work it up,
- 18:50and go to trial if we can. And that's really
- 18:53what this is about. We aren't interested in wasting
- 18:57time. We're not interested in going down non
- 19:02-fruitful paths. or rabbit holes. And it's one
- 19:06of those things that we're dealing with every
- 19:08day. So the second point on this PowerPoint slide
- 19:12relates to improper privilege assertions. And
- 19:16what happens, what we've been experiencing more
- 19:19and more over the years is lots of over designations
- 19:24on privilege logs and so much so it's been written
- 19:27about from the Google ruling in 2024, Judge Chabra
- 19:34in San Francisco issued a very pointed ruling,
- 19:39which I talk about at some length in my April
- 19:447th, 2025 column entitled, that's not how any
- 19:47of this works. But I think the key thing on a
- 19:52lot of this. It's a combination of over -designation
- 19:56on the one hand, while on the other hand also
- 19:59the deletion or withholding of relevant documents.
- 20:03And there was an article earlier this year where
- 20:07the former chief operating officer of Metta,
- 20:11Sheryl Sandberg, was sanctioned in an investor
- 20:14lawsuit for getting rid of emails. And that's
- 20:19a real problem. But I guess The key point is
- 20:23that a lot of this, and we'll talk more about
- 20:26this in the ensuing slides, is that a lot of
- 20:31corporate defendants and their counsel engage
- 20:35in discovery evasion as a litigation tool and
- 20:38as a cost of doing business. And that's just
- 20:42one of those things where I think, and again,
- 20:44we'll talk about what to do in terms of expanding
- 20:47sanctions, as we suggest down the road. few slides
- 20:51from now as to why we have to shift this paradigm
- 20:56from simply saying this is all okay or sanctioning
- 21:03someone in a certain way relating to their conduct
- 21:05in this case and getting out of the idea that
- 21:09this is a proper way of doing things. If you
- 21:14want to speak to the AI copyright case, I think
- 21:17it would be helpful, Amy. in terms of 18 ,000
- 21:21documents. Sure, yes. I'm happy to do so. So
- 21:27one of the things that we've seen more and more
- 21:31in some of our litigation against large technology
- 21:35companies is just sort of the delay in the production
- 21:38of those documents. In addition to the improper
- 21:41assertion of privilege, right, we finally, when
- 21:44we get past the privilege dispute, or we have
- 21:47sort of an in -camera review of certain documents
- 21:51to see if there is an over breadth of privilege
- 21:55assertions, then it comes time for a rolling
- 21:59production of documents. And a rolling production
- 22:02of documents, while it sounds great in practice,
- 22:06sometimes results in the documents coming very
- 22:11slowly in a very, you know, disorganized fashion,
- 22:18seemingly unconnected to the order in which you've
- 22:21negotiated your search terms. And so some of
- 22:25the things that we've been dealing with are these
- 22:27delays in productions. And then finally, when
- 22:31the productions are given to us, they're incomplete.
- 22:37You know, we see situations where You know, we
- 22:42may have a parent document, but we don't have
- 22:44the children documents or the related documents
- 22:47or the attachments, which can sometimes lead
- 22:51to a whole new privilege dispute about, OK, well,
- 22:54the email itself wasn't privileged, but somehow
- 22:58the attachment is, which can be incredibly frustrating.
- 23:02One of the things that we've been having to do
- 23:04more and more lately is follow up every single
- 23:07meet and confer discussion with a letter. that
- 23:10has the topic points that were discussed, the
- 23:15decision points that we came to, which side is
- 23:18doing what in terms of follow -up, and what the
- 23:21plaintiffs or the defendants have said their
- 23:23next steps will be just to document everything,
- 23:26which in of itself is a very good practice because
- 23:30inevitably, you're going to need some guidance
- 23:33from the court to help you get to a resolution
- 23:35on some of these issues. And so when you have
- 23:38incomplete productions, when you have delayed
- 23:41productions, the moral of the story is do not
- 23:44wait till the end of discovery to get assistance
- 23:47from the court or the special master or the magistrate
- 23:50judge. Instead, what you should be doing is making
- 23:54moves. continuously toward the end of discovery
- 23:58and also making sure you alert the court sooner
- 24:01rather than later. Now we've discussed this before
- 24:04sometimes it gets a little tricky because you
- 24:07have these seemingly endless meeting confers.
- 24:10Well there is that you need to decide, you know,
- 24:14OK, we've had enough meet and confers. We're
- 24:16going to the court now. You know, we've engaged
- 24:19in a rolling production of discovery, but two
- 24:22documents per week isn't going to cut it. I'm
- 24:25going to the court for assistance now. And when
- 24:28you have, you know, intermediate deadlines, like,
- 24:30say, for example, you have a deposition coming
- 24:33up of someone or a 30 B6. If you don't have the
- 24:36entire production, there's no way you can adequately
- 24:40prepare to actually take that. deposition, right?
- 24:43So you have to inform the court frequently throughout
- 24:47the discovery process how you're doing. You have
- 24:50to go to the court on emotion to compel if things
- 24:53are moving slowly. Another thing that happens
- 24:57that you should consider doing is scheduling
- 25:00regular check -ins with the court or the magistrate
- 25:03judge or the special master to inform them how
- 25:05the discovery process is rolling along. Because
- 25:07the last thing they want to hear is when you're
- 25:10getting toward the end of discovery, the plaintiff's
- 25:13now complaining, we don't have a fulsome production.
- 25:17Same thing for the defendants, complaining we
- 25:19don't have a fulsome production. discovery is
- 25:22going to end in a week, why didn't you tell me
- 25:24sooner? So continuously inform the court, make
- 25:27sure you have those touch points, and move to
- 25:30compel if the meet and confer process is not
- 25:32resulting in any significant change from the
- 25:35other side. And I think even if, you know, I
- 25:38think one of the challenges, and I was going
- 25:42to say something about the extending first day
- 25:43order negotiations in the context of all of this,
- 25:46I will... Use the legal term bad behavior is
- 25:49we all risk you know very much upsetting the
- 25:52judge and what i've come to realize is a up judge
- 25:55upset judge helps no one you know if. If you
- 25:59begin with the judge saying i can't believe you
- 26:01guys have been messing around for months about
- 26:03first day orders are i'm looking at insane privilege
- 26:07log and i'm gonna you know in camera get you
- 26:09guys i wanna take a sample and this is ridiculous
- 26:12there's nothing privileged about this document
- 26:14you know i found that like. We may like to hee
- 26:17-hee when one of us gets in trouble, but I found
- 26:19more than not that the courts get very irritated
- 26:23with both sides if we just become mired in what
- 26:27should be just moving forward. That's the purpose
- 26:30of the rules, is to help us get through the process.
- 26:34And I think that both sides end up compromised
- 26:37when you have a judge who, quite frankly, becomes
- 26:39sick of you. And I think we've all been subject
- 26:42to that. I think also to the extent that the
- 26:47privilege assertions are, which are often totally
- 26:50overbroad, under informed in the sense that I've
- 26:54had defense counsel say, well, there's a lawyer
- 26:57on the email that in and of itself does not make
- 27:00it privileged unless that lawyer is representing
- 27:02you and providing advice in that capacity. And
- 27:06there are occasions where there's a fraud allegation.
- 27:09If there's an allegation that lawyer is engaged
- 27:11in wrongful conduct, then there's arguments that
- 27:14it is not So there are a lot of contours to privilege,
- 27:18and I say that to say that to the extent that
- 27:21it's not intentional, oftentimes in the midst
- 27:24of these very large litigations, folks have doc
- 27:28reviewers and young associates, and they're sitting
- 27:31there in their pajamas at home scrolling through
- 27:35Everlaw and clicking privilege, and then you've
- 27:38got a problem. You have a privilege log that
- 27:40I've seen, some that are quite silly. And so
- 27:44I think there's an obligation, I think, to have
- 27:47a seasoned lawyer who understands privilege,
- 27:51which is quite complex, to make sure that, A,
- 27:54you're providing a privilege log, because sometimes
- 27:56we have to fight over the provision of a privilege
- 27:59log, and that it is truly a privilege log. Because
- 28:03we have our own teammates who are gifted at challenging
- 28:06privilege, and that becomes another sequence
- 28:10of months engaged solely in privilege litigation,
- 28:14and argument, and in front of a special master
- 28:16or the judge, and it costs everyone time. It
- 28:19costs that company time and money. And often
- 28:22on our side, because I do a lot of health and
- 28:25life work, we have our clients who die while
- 28:28we are playing around in discovery for two, three
- 28:31years when it's not necessary. And I think with
- 28:35regard to deletion or withholding of relevant
- 28:37documents to the extent that it's not intentional,
- 28:40I think part of the problem is the Discipline
- 28:43and rigor with with which defendants issue litigation
- 28:47hold letters and speak. I'm going to say something
- 28:49unpopular. Talk to your employees, you know,
- 28:53we're in the world of emails and letters and
- 28:55you send some obscure litigation letter out in
- 28:59email form to you know 1520 chairs of your departments.
- 29:05They probably haven't seen it or paid attention
- 29:07to it. If you are facing major litigation, you
- 29:10need to call them. You need to have a meeting.
- 29:13You need to talk to your IT and say stop Purge
- 29:15Protocols. You need to ask yourself internally
- 29:18whether or not your folks use their cell phone
- 29:21for work. You need to actually think through
- 29:24who has the documents because... I know my partners
- 29:28and myself and our firm, we're going down there.
- 29:32We're going to ask that CEO and your staff and
- 29:36the 30B sixth opponent, what about this? Where
- 29:39is this? What did you do to preserve this? Why
- 29:42didn't you preserve it? I mean, we will go there.
- 29:45And I think if you get the wrong judge, it can
- 29:49be very public, and you could be facing sanctions.
- 29:53Now, under a lot of rules, we can't receive copies
- 29:57of those litigation hold letters unless we have
- 29:59reason to believe at that point that you are
- 30:02in violation, that you did not preserve. But
- 30:05there are different rules in different states,
- 30:07and that's not everywhere. So I think it just,
- 30:10you know, advice for the defense bar, just, you
- 30:12know. actually talk to your client and figure
- 30:15out, where is this stuff? We've all been there
- 30:19and we're all normal people who happen to be
- 30:21lawyers and you're fighting with defense counsel.
- 30:24No, I think you have paper. Your client's been
- 30:27around for 80 years and you're just fighting
- 30:29to fight. And then you end up in front of a judge
- 30:31and the judge yells, do you have paper or not?
- 30:34And then that lawyer is like, okay, let me go
- 30:37back and speak with my clients. So I guess my
- 30:39legal advice is let's just be people. If you
- 30:42spoke to your clients six months before, knew
- 30:44you had paper, had the discussion with us, that
- 30:47would save everybody a lot of time and a lot
- 30:50of heartache and help the litigation move forward.
- 30:53Thank you. Can we go to the next slide, please?
- 31:00and deposition mayhem. So if you can beat off
- 31:03on that one, then I believe you have a conflict
- 31:05and you're going to need to finish up your deposition
- 31:08prep. But if you can simply speak to this in
- 31:11the first instance, I'd appreciate it. Sure.
- 31:13So I think, and again, I'm going to stay on the
- 31:16side of it's not intentional. Although sometimes
- 31:19I know it is. But we do on the plaintiff side
- 31:23spend a lot of time. determining the topics for
- 31:2730B6 testimony. And we often serve with it, Supina
- 31:32Dukas take them to make sure if you have not
- 31:34produced those documents, that document comes
- 31:36with the witness. And as you all know, and you
- 31:39all do, there will be different types of 30B6.
- 31:42And I'm going to ask Adam and Amy their percentage,
- 31:46but I would say more than 50 % of the time. I
- 31:51walk that 30B6 deponent through the 30B6 deposition
- 31:55notice, and sometimes they haven't seen it, and
- 31:58they definitely are not prepared to testify to
- 32:01all of it, and they have not done what they're
- 32:04supposed to do under the rules, which is if it's
- 32:06not in their personal knowledge to take due diligence
- 32:08to find the answers to those questions prior
- 32:12to sitting for deposition. So A, colossal waste
- 32:16of time, B, violation of the rule, C, causes
- 32:22chaos in that deposition, because now I'm peeved,
- 32:25defense counsel is peeved, you're asking, you
- 32:29know, it depends on the defense lawyer, you're
- 32:30asking them, did you prepare for this? No. Did
- 32:32you prepare for this? No. And to build a record
- 32:35sometimes, we just have to ask them the questions.
- 32:37that they already testified in the first 25 minutes
- 32:40when we went through the deposition notice that
- 32:42they don't know. So we could build a record that
- 32:47you all were not prepared and take it to the
- 32:49judge. And I guess my common sense says, why
- 32:52are we doing this? Why are we doing this? And
- 32:56then it's a fight about keeping the deposition
- 32:58open and whether or not the person provided the
- 33:01documents. And so it's a really a significant
- 33:07issue because those are representations on behalf
- 33:09of the corporation and we are entitled to that
- 33:12under the rule and defense counsel is required
- 33:16to prepare that person to the extent that they
- 33:19can. So I think it's a huge issue. I think it's
- 33:24common for 30B6 deponents to appear and not be
- 33:27prepared. I'll tell you, I think we've just all
- 33:31gotten used to people not following the rules.
- 33:34And that's not OK. There's a reason we have 30B6
- 33:37deposition. Yeah. And one of the things in terms
- 33:41of following the rules, too, the amendments to
- 33:46rule 30B6 in December of 2020 now injects this
- 33:49mandatory meet and confer requirement about the
- 33:51topics, right? And one frustrating thing from
- 33:58My angle is that will send a rule thirty b six
- 34:02notice with topics set the set the deposition
- 34:07date set the deposition time on the other side
- 34:11the other side will say who the department will
- 34:13be and. Will say great when should we meet and
- 34:17confer about the topics and i'll follow up. Continually.
- 34:22When should we meet and confer? When should we
- 34:23meet and confer? Until it's, you know, two days
- 34:26before the deposition. And we'll just get an
- 34:29objection to all of the 30b6 topics. And then
- 34:33what? So, you know, if we're having a discussion
- 34:36amongst mixed company. Um, you know, I know that
- 34:40whenever I've been in a 30 v six deposition and
- 34:43I've called up the magistrate judge and I said,
- 34:45um, you know, either we instruct the witness
- 34:47to answer the questions related to this topic
- 34:50or we hold the deposition open. The magistrate
- 34:52judge is going to let me hold it open so that
- 34:55you can prepare the witness to testify about
- 34:58this topic because you waited till the 11th hour
- 35:01to object to the topics, and I've been the one
- 35:05asking to meet and confer throughout this entire
- 35:10process. So if the other side, if defendants
- 35:14have an issue with the topics, and plaintiffs
- 35:18are asking to meet and confer, then the defendants
- 35:20also have to, in good faith, meet and confer,
- 35:24rather than holding objections until the night
- 35:27before, like things used to be done, and then
- 35:30debating the whether or not the topics are proper
- 35:35later on. This whole thing was meant to get around
- 35:39the process of having these disputes during the
- 35:42deposition and having topics that are supposedly
- 35:46overbroad. I can tell you that Foo, Adam, and
- 35:49I, along with what Adam said previously, we don't
- 35:52have time to engage in a fishing expedition,
- 35:53so we don't like overbroad topics. We're trying
- 35:56to get to the heart of the matter. But to the
- 35:59extent there is an argument that they are overbroad,
- 36:02they actually engage the meeting confer process
- 36:03rather than holding the objections to the night
- 36:05before, because it's just a giant waste of client
- 36:07time. Absolutely. Thank you. Can we go to the
- 36:12next slide, please? I think this one, deposition
- 36:15mayhem. Do you mean the next topic? Oh, no. If
- 36:18you want to stay there, let's go back one. I'm
- 36:20sorry. Well, no, no. I would put speaking objections
- 36:24and coaching along with witness non -responsiveness.
- 36:28I think witness non -responsiveness can be a
- 36:32tricky phrase in that sometimes on our side,
- 36:36our clients are testifying or witnesses are testifying,
- 36:40but the examiner does not like the responses.
- 36:44I want to be clear that that is not. what I am
- 36:46speaking about where a deponent is answering
- 36:50to the best of their ability and the best of
- 36:52their knowledge in the weirdness that is being
- 36:55subject to a deposition. I mean, that's not normally
- 36:57how we speak to one another. I'm speaking about
- 36:59the, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know,
- 37:02that's category number one, that's ridiculous,
- 37:05even though it's things that they clearly know
- 37:08or things that they provided with a verified
- 37:11response in response to the interrogatories or
- 37:14things that are just like common sense, like
- 37:16what's your address or what do you think about
- 37:18this? So that's the first one. The second bucket
- 37:21of non -responsiveness, and we have been subject
- 37:24to this more and more as I get older, are where
- 37:27no matter what question you ask the deponent,
- 37:30They go to a script. They go to the exact same
- 37:35three or four sentences and they actually do
- 37:38not respond to the question or they do not speak
- 37:41to the document. And why I'm speaking about speaking
- 37:45objections and coaching is because often that
- 37:47is paired with, and it's different in all jurisdictions,
- 37:51whether or not you just object to form, whether
- 37:53or not you have speaking objections. Often there
- 37:56is a deposition protocol in place, but that non
- 37:59-responsive of this is just wrong. You're supposed
- 38:02to prepare your witness, of course, or your client,
- 38:07but under the rules, you are not to instruct
- 38:09them to not respond or to repeat the same themes
- 38:14or same words over and over again. And it's gonna
- 38:17make me sound like a Girl Scout, but we are also
- 38:20officers of the court. and encouraging your client
- 38:24to lie, to misrepresent, to refuse to answer
- 38:30the question. I believe is very contrary to an
- 38:34oath a lot of us took a long time ago So I have
- 38:37a real beef with the non responsiveness and I
- 38:40would also say you know to the defense bar We
- 38:43use it. Well, we cut those clips for trial 55
- 38:47times. I don't know. I don't know I don't know
- 38:49and the witness has three degrees from Harvard
- 38:52and two from MIT and they've worked in the field
- 38:54for 50 years That's no bueno doesn't help anybody
- 38:59doesn't look good for your client, doesn't get
- 39:02the answers we need. And again, it's something
- 39:05that I believe we've all gotten used to that
- 39:08is not appropriate, is not helpful, and it leads
- 39:13to a real fight in the deposition, during the
- 39:17deposition, calling the judge. keeping the deposition
- 39:21open, and just subjects your witnesses to plaintiff
- 39:24lawyers who will keep fighting until they get
- 39:27that response, or will use that testimony to
- 39:30their advantage in continuing to prosecute the
- 39:32case. That's my soapbox. OK, let's go to slide
- 39:41six, please. And I think we've been talking about
- 39:45a lot of this as part of the points we've been
- 39:48making in the earlier slides. But I think that
- 39:52there are very clear ways to stop this or to
- 39:57try to stop this. I mean, we have an internal
- 40:00rule at the firm that on the discovery response,
- 40:05a meet and confer letter has to go out in 48
- 40:07hours. A meet and confer has to happen within
- 40:10that week. And we're going to get to court as
- 40:13fast as we reasonably can, because one of the
- 40:16points I know we keep on coming back to, wasting
- 40:19time is not something we're interested in. So
- 40:22I think that, as we were talking about earlier,
- 40:25early and aggressive record building is really
- 40:28important. As Amy, I believe, was pointing out,
- 40:30keep going back. Keep on clarifying that this
- 40:34is something. There is no moral equivalence here.
- 40:37That we are trying to get meaningful and compliant
- 40:43discovery responses and we aren't getting them.
- 40:46And I think that that is vitally important. And
- 40:50I think the same way as I was saying, we think
- 40:53it's very important to get in front of the court
- 40:56as quickly as reasonably possible. Obviously,
- 40:59one of the last things any judge or frankly,
- 41:02any magistrate even hates is lawyers who are
- 41:05fighting on discovery. And I think that the fact
- 41:09that, or if we're able to spin it as a necessary
- 41:15evil, we gotta get this done. We need clarity.
- 41:18I think that as we move our cases closer to trial,
- 41:23getting that clarity and sort of having all of
- 41:26the other noise fall away, I think, is vitally
- 41:30important. Fu -Amy, what do you think? Sure,
- 41:33and I think, and I'm sorry, I'll have to jump
- 41:35off after this, and I apologize to everyone.
- 41:38but lawyering calls, sorry. But I also think
- 41:42on our side, and it's not a judgment on lawyers
- 41:45because especially on the plaintiff side, we
- 41:48balance so many clients and so many obligations,
- 41:51is this is going to sound silly. You have to
- 41:54look at the discovery. What does the discovery
- 41:57do? Did they respond? And I think that is the
- 42:01number one threshold issue in terms of combating
- 42:05evasion and ensuring that defendants respond.
- 42:08We're all slammed. Have you sat down and read
- 42:10your interrogatories and read the answers? Have
- 42:12they responded? I think part of a pretty consistent
- 42:15and newer last decade violation of the rule is
- 42:18simply not answering, just putting in three,
- 42:20four paragraphs of objection. That's not proper.
- 42:24You're only not to respond if it's privilege.
- 42:27Otherwise, you risk you. preserve all your objections,
- 42:30you respond, and then we duke it out. And I think
- 42:33sometimes, you know, the plaintiff barges being
- 42:36inundated with clients may not look at all of
- 42:39those interrogatory responses or documents in
- 42:42response to requests for production until maybe
- 42:45like 30 days before a deposition or close to
- 42:48the discovery deadline. And they realize, holy
- 42:51cow, you know, there really aren't responses
- 42:54or production. Or to Amy's point earlier, there
- 42:56are massive gaps. in production, or metadata
- 43:00shows information's missing. And so I think part
- 43:03of the strategy is to be disciplined and have
- 43:07your litigation management software in a place
- 43:10where you have that alert, defendant's responses
- 43:13are due, and then you have your own alert. It's
- 43:16time for me to review the responses, where you're
- 43:19timing it out so you have time to see what have
- 43:22they not produced, so you can get that. You can
- 43:25get in a fight over the items you need. before,
- 43:28as Amy discussed, you just go take a deposition
- 43:30and you don't have all the information that you
- 43:33need. So I think as a threshold matter, it's
- 43:36really making sure that you're on top of your
- 43:39discovery and that you are making sure that all
- 43:43ROGs and RFPs and RFAs have been responded to.
- 43:48in the complete manner in which you think it's
- 43:51appropriate or you've fought for that and the
- 43:54judge has made a determination and you're at
- 43:56the end of the ability to force responses to
- 44:00your discovery request. Thank you. I know we're
- 44:06getting a little short on time and I know there's
- 44:09three specific topics we wanted to raise on the
- 44:13next three slides before taking any questions.
- 44:17But thank you, Phil. So let's go to the next
- 44:20one, slide seven, please. And this goes to the
- 44:24issue of the meet and confer abuses and using
- 44:30them as a defense strategy. As Amy pointed out
- 44:34earlier, the original intent of the meet and
- 44:37confer requirement that went into effect in 2006
- 44:42was to really streamline and clarify any any
- 44:48discovery disputes, now it's gone way past that.
- 44:53And I think that this has now become, unfortunately,
- 44:57another way for our opponents to run out the
- 45:00clock. It becomes, as Amy pointed out and Fu
- 45:03pointed out, another avenue to raise fights.
- 45:07throw out the anchors, saying things like, we'll
- 45:11take it back to our client, which it's one of
- 45:14those things, whenever you hear something like
- 45:15that, whenever I hear something like that, it's
- 45:18the same as when any of us have been sitting
- 45:21on an airplane and the pilot comes on and says,
- 45:27well folks, and then whatever he says after the
- 45:31word folks is never something good. It's never
- 45:34folks, we're gonna be early. It's folks, we're
- 45:36actually, we're circling over Omaha. So here,
- 45:40the exact same way, saying we'll take it back
- 45:43to our clients really falls into three, as I
- 45:49pointed out in my November 4th, 2024 column,
- 45:53which actually specifically focuses on meet and
- 45:56confer abuses as litigation strategy. There's
- 46:00a three -part dance, so to speak, on the slow
- 46:07walk, lack of availability, lack of authority,
- 46:11and lack of impasse. And I think of the three,
- 46:15and then I'll turn it over to you, Amy. I think
- 46:17that of those, the lack of impasse and keeping
- 46:21something open forever in an effort to stop getting
- 46:25in front of the court may be the most frustrating
- 46:28part of all. But if you want to speak to that,
- 46:31Amy? Sure. And when you say, I think of it as
- 46:35a pilot saying, folks, You know, I think of when
- 46:40I'm on a customer service phone call and the
- 46:43representative promises me that they'll escalate
- 46:46my request, which means that I'm never hearing
- 46:48back. But, you know, one of the things when I
- 46:53have younger associates prepping for their first
- 46:56meet and confer, I often tell them, your job
- 47:01is not to convince the other side that you're
- 47:03right and your job ultimately at the end of the
- 47:07day is not to get anything else because we've
- 47:11already, through all the letter writing campaigns
- 47:14that we've engaged in leading up to the meet
- 47:17and confer, we've already put out our arguments.
- 47:20Your job at a meet and confer, a live meet and
- 47:24confer, is to get the parties to say, this is
- 47:27my final position. This is my position. This
- 47:30is what I'm comfortable going to the court with.
- 47:32The worst thing that could happen and I mean
- 47:34confer either side is for the parties to say,
- 47:37you know what? Yeah, we'll think on that. We'll
- 47:41bring it back to the client because usually the
- 47:44client has already said what their position is.
- 47:46And if you're a good lawyer, which all of you
- 47:49attending this CLE are, you've already gamed
- 47:52out with your clients. all of the things that
- 47:55might potentially happen on the mean conferrer
- 47:57and all of the authority that you have to negotiate
- 48:01what your position might be. So, you know, whenever
- 48:04I hear we'll take it back to our client, I just
- 48:07know you've already talked about this with your
- 48:09client. And whenever I say, I'll go back to my
- 48:13team about this and we'll think about if we're
- 48:16going to, you know, give you the plaintiff's
- 48:19full social security number or something like
- 48:21that, even though we wouldn't. You know, I know
- 48:24full well, like I'm going to talk to my team
- 48:26and the answer is no. So really, the meet and
- 48:29confer, you know, absent really crazy circumstances,
- 48:33you should come away from that call knowing what
- 48:37your positions are. Because if you don't and
- 48:40you don't have full authority to actually have
- 48:43these discussions, you're just wasting everybody's
- 48:46time at the end of the day. So, you know, my
- 48:48what I instruct people to do is. get the position
- 48:51of the other side, understand what it is. If
- 48:55the other side has to go back and talk to their
- 48:57client, put a very short timeline on it. I need
- 49:00an answer in two days. And either way, we're
- 49:03getting ready to move for what we need. Yes.
- 49:07I agree. All right. Let's move on because we
- 49:14are running out of time. Slide eight. relating
- 49:17to sanctions and judicial responses. And as we
- 49:22began to talk about earlier, the current sanction
- 49:26regime is wildly insufficient, especially when
- 49:31you're dealing with a wealthy opponent like Facebook
- 49:35or Google or any of the automotive companies,
- 49:40sticking them with a million dollar sanction.
- 49:45isn't going to actually change anything. And
- 49:49I think one of the issues that we talked about
- 49:51here with the case study of in -rate Facebook
- 49:54incorporated consumer privacy user profile litigation,
- 49:58I think that we saw there the limits on discovery
- 50:02sanctions. I think one of the things that would
- 50:05be really important as we talked about is rather
- 50:09than a judge simply looking to a defendant's
- 50:14misconduct in the context of that single case
- 50:18that you have. I think it's vitally important
- 50:21for a judge to actually look and understand what
- 50:25a defendant's conduct is across other cases on
- 50:29these exact issues. And I think that if we're
- 50:33able to show that this type of recidivism has
- 50:37been happening as a matter of of course, and
- 50:40the judge in our case fashions a sanction that's
- 50:47actually commensurate with a recidivist abuser
- 50:51rather than one or two times in the context of
- 50:54this one case. I think it really opens up the
- 50:58possibility of a much heavier hammer. If you
- 51:02want to speak to that, Amy. Absolutely. And I
- 51:05completely agree that monetary sanctions aren't
- 51:09really deterrent, especially when you talk about
- 51:11the amount of money on the line for some of these
- 51:13defendants related to these lawsuits. If you're
- 51:17talking about a lawsuit that's going to resolve
- 51:20at trial for over a billion dollars, spending
- 51:24a million dollars on sanctions to hide some of
- 51:27the most egregious documents seems like a bargain
- 51:31at twice the price. One of the things I've been
- 51:33talking about with my colleagues, including some
- 51:36of the attorneys who worked on that case, you
- 51:39have a double pronged approach. Adam already
- 51:41talked about the defendant's conduct and a pattern
- 51:44or practice of this kind of contact. conduct
- 51:48across cases, one of the things that the plaintiff's
- 51:51bar has been talking about is actually challenging
- 51:53the pro -Hakfiche applications of the attorneys
- 51:56who are involved in these things. It only takes
- 52:01a couple of times of discovery, abuse, and misconduct
- 52:04before you start scratching your head and thinking,
- 52:07is this sort of a badge of honor? If you have
- 52:10a client that you're really willing to go to
- 52:13the mat for and it looks like a close call, but
- 52:18you are thinking, well, you know, it's a close
- 52:21call on these documents. My client really has
- 52:24some, you know, good views on this kind of stuff.
- 52:29I'm going to read this order in a way that's
- 52:32barely appropriate, but still, you know, allows
- 52:37me to keep my law license. If you're doing things
- 52:40like that over and over again, the plaintiff's
- 52:44bar very quickly is going to start opposing your
- 52:46pro hoc VHA application. Because that seems to
- 52:50be really the only way from our perspective,
- 52:53you know, in addition to challenging the defendant's
- 52:56conduct from other cases, to really call into
- 52:58question the behavior of some of these attorneys
- 53:00who are engaging in this process, you know, encouraging
- 53:04of your client to always copy a lawyer on communications,
- 53:11even if it's not for legal advice, to shield
- 53:13it with privileges, some part of communicate
- 53:16with care program. When you start doing these
- 53:20things over and over and over again, it is completely
- 53:25improper. And it's something that we're going
- 53:28to start doing if we continue to see this practice
- 53:30happening. Along those lines, let me just say
- 53:33the one thing that I've experienced across a
- 53:37number of cases, normally automotive cases, very
- 53:41often the large automotive manufacturers will
- 53:45hire, in addition to their primary litigation
- 53:48counsel, outside discovery counsel. The problem
- 53:52with that, and I'm just going to say what it
- 53:55is, if your whole job And your whole possibility
- 54:01of getting hired on future cases is to hold the
- 54:05line in discovery in every case. That firm has
- 54:10the incentive to actually lie. That firm has
- 54:14the incentive to hide things. That firm has the
- 54:16incentive to be as obstructionist as possible
- 54:21because after all, that's what they believe they
- 54:24were hired to actually do. So I think in a lot
- 54:27of ways, what brings a lot of this full circle
- 54:30is when the incentives for defendants outside
- 54:37counsel are so great to cheat in discovery and
- 54:42obstruct the entire process, that's really a
- 54:46fundamental flaw with what we have here that
- 54:48needs to be dealt with pretty harshly, I believe.
- 54:55I agree. Yes, thank you. So we would open it
- 55:00up for any questions. The last PowerPoint slide
- 55:03that we have of substance really isn't something
- 55:05that we should spend a lot of time on. But one
- 55:07thing that we've done, if you can go to number
- 55:10nine, please. One of the things that we've seen
- 55:13really in the social media MDL, which is pending
- 55:17right now in Northern California, Judge Gonzalez
- 55:23Rogers has it. In that, In that case, the defendants
- 55:27opened a new front that is based on either an
- 55:31intentional or general misapprehension of how
- 55:36state attorneys general offices work relative
- 55:40to the other agencies in the state. And as a
- 55:44firm that handles an awful lot of public entity
- 55:47work, seeing what was happening there, showed
- 55:50what happened was the magistrate issued an order
- 55:53that the Article 3 judge ultimately adopted that
- 55:59effectively comprehended or misapprehended the
- 56:08relationship between the sovereign, the state
- 56:12attorney general and the underlying agencies
- 56:14in that what they missed was the underlying agencies
- 56:19are clients of the state attorney general's office.
- 56:22They are not simply within the possession, custody,
- 56:27or control of the state attorney general. That's
- 56:32an issue we've been dealing with across the board.
- 56:34It's one of those few situations where the red
- 56:38states and blue states really, they agreed on
- 56:44this one with various state AGs ultimately leaving
- 56:50that case. So I think what's going to happen
- 56:52there going on if that's not stopped. And we're
- 56:55working with the various state AG offices and
- 56:58the FJC and others in an effort to clarify what
- 57:03this really means because this type of misapprehension
- 57:07is highly problematic. So we would open it up
- 57:14to any questions if you'd like. Okay, so it looks
- 57:25like we have one question from Michael here.
- 57:28Can judges use adverse inferences as a response
- 57:32to discovery abuse? Seems like the most important
- 57:34hammer as increases the likelihood of a poor
- 57:37result of trial making the witness, making the
- 57:40willingness to get hit with sanctions not useful.
- 57:43What are your thoughts? We firmly agree, actually,
- 57:49on slide eight. I think that the idea of using
- 57:53adverse inferences or default judgment or something
- 57:56else that would ultimately result in shaping
- 58:01the case as it gets closer to trial, I think
- 58:04is a very effective sanction that in some ways,
- 58:08in most ways, is far more effective as a deterrent
- 58:14than simply hitting a company for whatever, half
- 58:18a million dollars. a million dollars or whatever
- 58:21it is, an adverse inference would be something
- 58:24really helpful, I think. Amy? Yeah, absolutely.
- 58:28And I think, you know, we actually engaged in
- 58:32sort of briefing related to an adverse inference
- 58:34in one of my cases. And one of the things that
- 58:37you have to help the court with is what would
- 58:41the discovery had? What would the discovery that
- 58:45has been lost or delayed or you know protected
- 58:49under privilege you know what didn't it prevent
- 58:53you from finding out. And so that, if it goes
- 58:58to some sort of legal issue that you were trying
- 59:00to get to, the adverse inference then would relate
- 59:03to that very specific legal issue. So the adverse
- 59:06inference is carefully tailored to the discovery
- 59:09that you're missing out on, essentially, which
- 59:12is a very clean way and a rifle shot, so to speak,
- 59:16at resolving the issue, and one which we've definitely
- 59:18employed before. Any other questions? OK. I guess
- 59:27that's it. Well, thank you very much, everybody.
- 59:30We appreciate you taking the time on Monday morning
- 59:34to hear from us about these really important
- 59:37issues. And if you have any questions, we're
- 59:39obviously easily reachable. Our information is
- 59:42on the screen and in the materials. And we look
- 59:46forward to speaking with a number of you in the
- 59:48future. So thank you. Thanks, everyone. You may
- 59:53be eligible for CLE credit in your state. Visit
- 59:56bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.