Latest / The Feminine Manifesto / #14 Australia Day: Changing the date is not the solution with Kurt Mahlburg
Transcript
- 0:17Who are concerned about the lack of truth being spoken in our culture.
- 0:21This podcast was born out of a desire to free women from the lies they are being fed from the world.
- 0:26We are not here to be controversial intentionally, but to seek to point women
- 0:30to the truth that can be found in Christ.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy coming along this journey with us.
- 0:38Hello, Kurt, and welcome to the Feminine Manifesto podcast. Hey,
- 0:42Heather. It's awesome to join you. Thanks for having me on today.
- 0:45Oh, thanks so much for coming. It's a privilege to have this chat with you.
- 0:49So today, after reading one of Kurt's articles on the Australia Day debate,
- 0:53I wanted to have an interview with him to have a chat through some of his thoughts,
- 0:57which I found really helpful.
- 0:59So before we get into that, firstly, Kurt, can you just give us a little bit
- 1:03of background and understanding of who you are, what your work looks like,
- 1:07your writing work looks like as well.
- 1:09Yeah, thanks. So, I'm an Adelaide Hills dweller.
- 1:12Grew up here, live here, married, two kids, and I've kind of been in all sorts
- 1:18of different, I guess, pursuits over the years.
- 1:20I originally studied architecture at university.
- 1:22Then I went into school teaching when the GFC took the bottom out of that industry.
- 1:26I was in teaching for several years. Then I was in youth and young adults ministry.
- 1:31So, So I worked for five years at my local church in that capacity as a pastor.
- 1:36And since 2018, I think it was, I've been working with the Canberra Declaration,
- 1:40which is a pro-life, religious freedom, marriage and family Christian institute.
- 1:45And we've also launched a new site called the Daily Declaration,
- 1:48which has grown quite significantly over recent years.
- 1:51So that's obviously where you came across my piece about Australia Day.
- 1:54Yeah. Yes. Yep. As I was preparing for this, I was thinking,
- 1:58oh, Daily Wire. No, it's not the Daily Wire. It's the Daily Declaration.
- 2:01All right. That's the one. Maybe the equivalent.
- 2:05So in your article, you've talked about Australia Day. We're coming up to celebrate Australia Day.
- 2:13And there's so much I find to celebrate about being Australian today.
- 2:17Why do you personally like to celebrate Australia Day?
- 2:20Yeah, well, I guess I love history and I love looking back at the past,
- 2:25you know, how our country came to be.
- 2:27We began as, you know, essentially a prison colony. Obviously,
- 2:31there were free settlements too, South Australia being one of those.
- 2:34But when you look at where we came from, essentially just a bunch of ragtag
- 2:38Brits that got dumped here, you know, a couple of hundred years ago,
- 2:42and the amazing, prosperous, incredibly blessed nation that we are today.
- 2:47I think that's something to be extremely proud of and very, very grateful for.
- 2:51So I guess when I think about Australia and I think about Australia Day, it's in that context.
- 2:55It's looking back over the passage of time and just seeing where we came from
- 3:00and just how amazingly blessed we are. And I think that's something really to celebrate.
- 3:03Yeah, for sure. Yeah, completely agree.
- 3:06So in your article, you mentioned that the majority of Australians,
- 3:0976% actually, want to still celebrate Australia on the 26th of January Day.
- 3:14Sorry, celebrate Australia Day on the 26th of January.
- 3:17Which is really a great statistic because I feel like you look at the political
- 3:21landscape and the news and it
- 3:24doesn't seem like this. So what's your thoughts? Why do you think that is?
- 3:27Yeah, well, I guess to talk about that statistic first, it comes from the IPA,
- 3:32the Institute of Public Affairs.
- 3:34Obviously, people might criticize that group because they are sort of center right, I suppose.
- 3:38But they've tracked this question over time. And not only is it substantial
- 3:4276%, but it's also grown over recent years.
- 3:45So I think last year, it was 69% favorability or support. So that's gone up
- 3:50by another seven percentage points.
- 3:52But also, it's not just the IPA. There are other groups that ask similar questions.
- 3:57I just saw, I think it was a Roy Morgan poll yesterday that came out and I don't
- 4:04know what their leaning is, but it's a separate data point.
- 4:07And I think it was something like 60% of Australians want to retain the 26th
- 4:11of January as Australia Day.
- 4:13So it's not just the IPA, it's not some right-wing thing.
- 4:16There's actually pretty good evidence out there that there's very strong support
- 4:20for celebrating Australia Day as we currently do.
- 4:23But as to your question about why is there, I guess, a disconnect between what
- 4:28the public seems to want and what the media is portraying, honestly,
- 4:33I see that misalignment in, it's sort of manifested in countless ways in the media.
- 4:39We, you know, the views that are portrayed on the nightly news and in the newspapers
- 4:43and, you know, by these big media organizations and the views of everyday Australians
- 4:48just don't align on just about any topic that you can imagine.
- 4:52Maybe that's not true of every topic, but so many topics. And I don't know,
- 4:56there's a whole bunch of...
- 4:58There's a huge background to that, of course, but I think in many ways,
- 5:03you know, the media has its own interests.
- 5:05Often there are people at the top who have certain agendas and generally journalists
- 5:10come from a more of an elitist, highly educated background,
- 5:14insulated from the concerns and the difficulties of everyday Australians or
- 5:19everyday Americans, whoever it might be.
- 5:21This is a phenomenon seen across the Western world. and there just isn't a clear
- 5:25understanding of what life is like for just ordinary people.
- 5:29I think there's sort of an elite bubble that has been created in the media.
- 5:32There's also ideological, historical developments as well. We could talk about neo-Marxism.
- 5:39How deep down the rabbit hole do you want to go? But I think it's not just on
- 5:43this topic of Australia Day.
- 5:45I think it's almost any culture, culture war topic that you could imagine the
- 5:50views of common everyday Australians and the views of journalists and the media
- 5:54kind of crew is vastly different in so many cases.
- 5:59Yeah, for sure. And I think because of the way they put this forward through
- 6:04the media, people would be fearful of expressing their views because it's so politically charged.
- 6:11Absolutely. Yeah. And sadly, I think that's kind of the environment that's been
- 6:15created in many Western countries, Australia in particular, is people feel quite
- 6:21afraid to voice what they really think.
- 6:23And the irony is that maybe the majority of people that we work alongside or
- 6:27study alongside or just do life alongside actually share our views,
- 6:31but we've all kind of learned how to self-censor. We've become fearful of expressing
- 6:35what should just be normal opinions.
- 6:37So I think that's very sad. And so it is important to be able to talk openly
- 6:41about this like we're doing today.
- 6:43For sure. Yeah, I really appreciate your thoughts on how long it is until a
- 6:48people become Indigenous to their own country.
- 6:50So like you, I've lived in Australia my entire life. My whole family history
- 6:54has been here for over six generations, both coming out as free settlers from
- 6:59Scotland to South Australia, actually.
- 7:01So that takes us to at least the mid-1800s.
- 7:05But I'm not considered Indigenous. You're not considered Indigenous.
- 7:09To say that is probably quite offensive even in our culture now.
- 7:14So can you take us through your thoughts here about.
- 7:17Yeah, I mean, you've hit on an important point that it probably is seen as offensive
- 7:21to even suggest the possibility of a Caucasian Australian being Indigenous to Australia.
- 7:26I guess that it might be seen by some as trying to take the identity of Indigenous Australians.
- 7:33That's not my intention, but I think the concept of indigeneity is just a really fascinating one.
- 7:38In the article, I wrote about the Pemerank people. So that's the tribe that
- 7:43originally lived on the land, the Adelaide Hills, where I live today.
- 7:47And what I explained is they likely took it by conquest from tribes before them,
- 7:52who likely took it by conquest from tribes before them.
- 7:55And that's based on what we understand about the history of pre-colonial Australia.
- 7:59There was warfare, inter-tribal warfare.
- 8:01There was violence. There was land acquisition.
- 8:04So that's well known. We don't know the specifics about the Pemerank,
- 8:07but generally speaking, that was the case in Australian history.
- 8:11And then, of course, if you go back beyond that, we know that Australia wasn't
- 8:15always inhabited by anyone.
- 8:17The Pemerankh were descended from groups of migrants that came through Southeast Asia,
- 8:22through the Asian subcontinent, back to the Middle East, and depending on what
- 8:27your views of origins are, perhaps Africa or as a Christian,
- 8:31I believe, from the Tower of Babel, God created the whole human family and then
- 8:35we spread out from there.
- 8:36So it's not as though Australia was always inhabited. And there's also the possibility
- 8:41that there were people that lived here before the Aboriginal Australians came.
- 8:46So the point being, the concept of indigeneity is very subjective and it's very time bound.
- 8:53So if the Pemarank could be understood to be indigenous to this land,
- 8:59but they weren't always here.
- 9:00Well, I wasn't always here, but my ancestors have been for generations.
- 9:05So how long do we have to wait until I'm considered indigenous?
- 9:09That's essentially the question I was asking. So I'm not claiming to be indigenous.
- 9:13I'm simply challenging the idea, the very idea of indigeneity.
- 9:17And the reason I think it needs to be challenged is because.
- 9:21Perhaps initially, there were good intentions behind these categories of indigenous
- 9:25and non-indigenous in terms of Australian discourse.
- 9:28But in all honesty, I think over recent years, I have seen that those divisions
- 9:33have actually created division in Australian culture.
- 9:36Rather than creating healing, they've actually created more and more division.
- 9:39And it's not like I'm saying this and I'm a white Australian and all Aboriginal
- 9:46Australians disagree with me.
- 9:47That's not the case at all. there are activists who
- 9:50would disagree with me of both you know indigenous and
- 9:53non-indigenous heritage but likewise there are
- 9:56indigenous and non-indigenous australians who would agree
- 9:59with me too so the the ideological lines are
- 10:02actually not race they're wokeness they're ideological there are plenty of really
- 10:08well respected aboriginal australians who would take my view of this who really
- 10:12don't like the categories of indigeneity and non-indigeneity so yeah as i say
- 10:17this is an ideological division, it's not a racial one.
- 10:20Yes, for sure. And there's so much in that to unpack.
- 10:23But I think just focusing on that, questioning what is indigeneity and how long
- 10:29that takes is really helpful just to think about, as you've mentioned.
- 10:33And as you said, we're beginning to see that the problem here,
- 10:37it's not actually the date. So it's an ideological problem.
- 10:41And the fact that Australia exists, as you've pointed out in the article.
- 10:46And this came out quite clearly in that picture by the popular feminist artist Charlotte Allingham,
- 10:51depicting an Aboriginal girl standing on a white man, spearing him quite gruesomely
- 10:56with the Australia flag being burnt and Abolish Australia written on it.
- 11:01That was really confronting to see.
- 11:03And you've written on that too, which I found really helpful.
- 11:06And I'll link that in the show notes for anyone who wants to have a look.
- 11:10So what, I mean, you've already touched on it, that it is an ideological debate.
- 11:15But do you think that changing the date is going to have any influence on helping us move forward here?
- 11:22Yeah, it's a great question. I guess the reality is there's a spectrum of views
- 11:26on Australia Day and on changing the date.
- 11:29And so I don't want to lump everyone in the one category and assume they all think the same.
- 11:33I'm a Christian and I know that there are Christians who would want to change
- 11:36the date and there are Christians who think it's great as it is, as I do.
- 11:40But, you know, whether Christian or non-Christian, there really is a spectrum of views.
- 11:44There are some people who are very soft on this issue who would say,
- 11:47yeah, like, let's change the day.
- 11:49Let's try to appease, all these issues that are being talked about each year
- 11:54when Australia Day approaches in the hopes that that will settle the question.
- 11:58And for some people, I guess that will settle the question.
- 12:01But if you look a little bit deeper down the rabbit hole, this is not just a
- 12:05question of the day. There's a whole ideological problem,
- 12:09background to this which is essentially decolonialization
- 12:13if you're you know if you and your listeners are familiar with that
- 12:16i guess ideological framework the idea
- 12:19is we need to decolonize australia australia was colonized by the british and
- 12:24and still has british caucasian largely christian influences in all of our institutions
- 12:30obviously that's faded a lot over recent decades but you know needless to say
- 12:34it's still there we have the rule of law we've got democratic institutions.
- 12:38You know, marriage is still upheld, though it's changed a lot.
- 12:41But, you know, that's all, essentially, that's all baggage from colonization.
- 12:44And the idea of the decolonization movement is to unsettle the idea that all
- 12:49of that is the right way to do things, that, you know, that Australia as it
- 12:53currently stands is invalid and needs to be totally remade in the image of,
- 12:59I don't know, Marxism or just the decolonization narrative.
- 13:04Yes. Okay. Yeah. So for some, Australia Day is a wedge issue and they're hoping
- 13:10that if we change the day, that will actually open the door to everything else
- 13:15that they want to achieve,
- 13:16which in many cases is just totally remaking Australia.
- 13:20And again, that's another very deep rabbit hole, but you don't have to go very
- 13:24far online if you Google Australia and decolonization to see what some of these
- 13:29people are hoping to achieve.
- 13:30We saw some of that in the voice debate as well. Yes.
- 13:34Yeah, okay. That is helpful to think through the spectrum of people who are
- 13:40speaking out on this issue.
- 13:42I think there would be a lot of Christians, we're both Christians,
- 13:46and coming from a perspective of,
- 13:49forgiveness and wanting to restore people, wanting to show love,
- 13:54and would think, okay, let's just change the date so that we can share this
- 13:58with the Indigenous people and make a path step forward towards that.
- 14:03However, seeing this from the perspective of there's a decolonization movement
- 14:10out there who wants to abolish everything that Australia has created, that's a real problem.
- 14:16It is, yes. And I guess as a Christian, I'm sensitive to that very,
- 14:21I would say, gracious attitude, which is, let's concede just this one issue
- 14:27and hope that it can foster reconciliation.
- 14:29I think a lot of Christians have good motives in thinking that way.
- 14:34But I also try to take a bit of a historical lens on this.
- 14:37And when you look at all of the dates that have actually already been added
- 14:41to our calendar, not all of them are national holidays, but many of them are
- 14:44marked by significant celebrations.
- 14:46They're talked about on the news, the ABC, you know, churches even are getting
- 14:50on board with a lot of them, whether it's NAIDOC week or National Sorry Day.
- 14:54There's actually a list, and I provided this in the article that we're discussing,
- 14:57maybe it's a dozen dates on the national calendar every year that are really
- 15:01centered on grieving, what happened to Indigenous Australians,
- 15:05essentially apologizing for colonization in various forms.
- 15:08And so I guess I'm also not convinced that if we've already added all of these
- 15:13dates into the calendar,
- 15:14each year we're marking these and using them as opportunities to mourn colonization
- 15:20and what happened to indigenous people,
- 15:23the idea that we can change the date of Australia Day and that somehow will
- 15:27achieve what all of those other changes have not achieved, I'm very doubtful
- 15:30about that, to be honest.
- 15:32Yes. Yes, that was helpful, you putting down all those dates that were already
- 15:37celebrated within Australia.
- 15:40Yeah, just thinking through that. Yeah, I don't necessarily contest that we
- 15:44shouldn't be marking those days. I think obviously there are things to grieve,
- 15:48there are things to mourn. Yeah, for sure.
- 15:49But yeah, I really am doubtful that by changing one more day,
- 15:53that somehow that's going to fix things that all of those other changes have not already fixed.
- 15:58Yeah, for sure. And I think making room for this debate to actually take into
- 16:04account how can we move forward and grieve actually what has happened because
- 16:09there have been grievances that have happened and horrible things that have
- 16:11happened throughout history.
- 16:13However, the current debate and the current push from this side is –.
- 16:18It's not helpful. Yeah, yeah. And I'd also say that it's fairly unbalanced in
- 16:24the sense that we are called to grieve and mourn colonization and what happened
- 16:29to Indigenous Australians, and for good reason in many cases.
- 16:32But we are actually prevented or very much discouraged from celebrating the
- 16:39good that colonization brought.
- 16:41I mean, the fact that you and I are talking on these devices over thousands
- 16:45of kilometers, you know, modern technology is one of the blessings of colonization in Australia.
- 16:51We wouldn't be able to do this were it not for that. Or we wouldn't be living under rule of law.
- 16:55We wouldn't be living in air-conditioned homes with high-quality clothing.
- 17:01And all these things are blessings of colonization. And we're not allowed generally
- 17:05to talk about the good things.
- 17:07We are only told to mourn the bad things. and I just think that's pretty unbalanced.
- 17:12It's a pretty pessimistic view of history and not a very accurate or honest one. Yeah.
- 17:18So, what do you see as a pathway moving forward so that we can celebrate this
- 17:23great country that we do live in?
- 17:25Yeah, I guess at the end of the day, you're not going to appease certain segments of the population.
- 17:32I think there'll always be a minority that are loud about Australia Day and
- 17:36wanting to push forward the decolonization narrative, abolish Australia,
- 17:41abolish Australia Day, all of that.
- 17:43And look, we live in a democratic country and I appreciate the fact that I can
- 17:47put my views forward and therefore, you know, other people who think differently
- 17:51should also have the right to speak on these issues.
- 17:54So, I'm not sort of suggesting that we should shut, you know,
- 17:56the debate down totally.
- 17:58Yeah, I don't know whether there's a solution as such, I guess, just telling the truth.
- 18:03And ironically, you know, truth telling is something we're told a lot about
- 18:06in, you know, this space of Indigenous activism. Yeah.
- 18:10But there's a lot of truths we're not supposed to talk about that are taboo.
- 18:13But if we do, as I just have as an example,
- 18:17you know, the blessings of colonization, if we're allowed to tell the truth
- 18:20about that and we continue telling the truth about that and trying to get more
- 18:23of a balanced perspective on these things,
- 18:25then I actually think the segment of the Australian population that's pushing
- 18:29to abolish Australia Day will shrink because it's just an untenable position.
- 18:35So yeah, I think more talk about this and not less is probably the best way
- 18:40forward. They say truth is the best disinfectant, right?
- 18:43Yes. Yeah. That's great. That's really helpful. I'm really helpful to think
- 18:46through. You can tell that you've researched a lot on this and have thought
- 18:49through it quite deeply.
- 18:51So thanks for doing that. And thanks for putting these articles out there.
- 18:53It's really helpful for lay people like myself and people reading this.
- 18:58Of course. Yeah. Thanks. Yeah. Thanks so much, Kurt, for joining me today.
- 19:02It's a privilege to be able to chat to you through this topic.
- 19:06Hope you have a great Australia Day. Awesome. Thanks so much,
- 19:09Heather. It's been great to be with you. Happy Australia Day.
- 19:12Thanks. So ultimately, personally, for me, this comes down to a worldview problem.
- 19:17If you believe the world was created by God, that humans were created equally
- 19:21in his image, and that all nations of the earth were dispersed around 5,000
- 19:25years ago from the Tower of Babel, the notion of Aboriginal complete sovereignty doesn't hold up.
- 19:31And additionally, this debate, there's no talk about forgiveness.
- 19:35Forgiveness is a distinctively Christian notion, and without it,
- 19:38we're going to be left in this perpetual sorry state where your ancestry determines
- 19:43whether you are a victim or an oppressor, despite never having committed or
- 19:47faced those injustices.
- 19:49We've all sinned against God and all deserve punishment for that.
- 19:52However, He offers forgiveness to us, to those who will receive it.
- 19:56So come to Jesus and receive the forgiveness that He offers,
- 20:00and then be free to offer that to others so that we can unite as fellow Australians
- 20:04and celebrate this beautiful country that we live in together.
- 20:09Thanks for joining us today. We hope you found this discussion beneficial and
- 20:13it is our prayer that this will cause you to see Christ more clearly within our.