Latest / Quantum Potential / Finding Meaning in Music with Musicologist Melanie Lowe
Transcript
- 0:01Cybele: Welcome to "Quantum Potential," a podcast dedicated to curiosity, discovery and the bold new ideas shaping our future.
- 0:09Cybele: I'm Cybele Raver, provost of Vanderbilt University.
- 0:19Cybele: I'm thrilled today to welcome Professor Melanie Lowe, associate professor of musicology here at Vanderbilt Blair School of Music.
- 0:27Cybele: Lowe received her Ph.D. and her MFA in musicology from Princeton University after having attended Smith College as an undergraduate.
- 0:35Cybele: Melanie's research focuses on constructions of musical meaning, spanning close analysis of classical music in late 18th century to the ways that we understand and make use of classical music now to pop music currently in the 21st century.
- 0:49Cybele: So cool, Melanie. She's just been named editor in chief for the"Journal of Musicology Pedagogy," really signaling how much she thinks about and contributes to the ways in which we teach music theory, music history and the playing of music.
- 1:07Cybele: Melanie, your work spans so many layers of musical life— how listeners make meaning, how composers are signaling meaning through composition, but also through marketing their music, both in the 18th century and today, and how culture shapes what we hear.
- 1:20Cybele: You've written about everything from, as I mentioned, late 18th century symphonies to the way that classical music is deployed in 21st century media.
- 1:28Cybele: I think a lot about, you know, um, uh, the arias from, uh, "Queen of the Night" in, uh, "The Magic Flute" where you hear that, you know, regularly in weird ways, or music from "Carmen." Um, but then in a totally different direction, tou've examined teen pop, tween, girlhood, ironic masculinity and the gendered performance of fandom, which I just love.
- 1:49Cybele: Um, when you're thinking about your scholarship as a whole, how do you describe yourself?
- 1:53Cybele: Who are you?
- 1:54Cybele: Are you a cultural historian?
- 1:56Cybele: Are you a musicologist?
- 1:57Cybele: Are you a critic of media and gender?
- 2:00Cybele: How do you think about yourself?
- 2:02Melanie: Uh, I think I'm all of those things, but not all of them at the same time is how I would answer that.
- 2:08Melanie: Uh, I think the, the question that has guided all of my work, uh, is really the question of musical meaning.
- 2:15Melanie: What does it mean?
- 2:16Melanie: Can it mean, should it mean?
- 2:18Melanie: And if it does, how does that actually happen?
- 2:21Melanie: And so if I'm working on 18th century symphonic music, I might go deep into a score.
- 2:27Melanie: And if I'm thinking about the way that, let's say tween pop is, uh, holding meaning or expressing whatever it has to say to 12-year-old girls, I'm not gonna really show them a chart.
- 2:40Melanie: I'm gonna go talk to them.
- 2:42Melanie: Hear what they have to say.
- 2:43Melanie: So I do all of those things depending on the particular context that I'm involved in at the moment.
- 2:50Cybele: It's so great when you use the word "go deep." It immediately made me think of, um, some of your writing that talks about canon and canyon.
- 2:58Cybele: Um, and I love that you play with that word and this idea that you teach the canon.
- 3:03Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 3:04Cybele: Um, and I think of the canon as a fixed body of work that we all recognize has value.
- 3:10Cybele: Um, I think you used the phrase"high art," but you also play with that in this idea of canyon.
- 3:15Cybele: Um, can you tell us a little bit about that?
- 3:17Melanie: Sure.
- 3:18Melanie: Uh, so.
- 3:19Melanie: Canon, of course, this, uh, you know, accepted body of work, whether it's literature or music that we hold up and celebrate and say, these are, you know, the most illustrious examples of human creation. And how they got there is not because that's where they belong.
- 3:38Melanie: They were, they got to that position because somebody put them there.
- 3:42Melanie: People kept rehearsing that location, and so I play with this idea of the canon and the canyon and also the canon, which is a musical technique where you have overlapping melodic lines that can just kind of over and over repeat each other, one after the other.
- 4:00Melanie: They're identical, actually.
- 4:02Melanie: And over time, like just like the canyon, if you think of the Grand Canyon, it's just because that current just keeps flowing. And as it flows it definitely reinforces the canon, but also exposes all of the layers that you can see in the meanings that the canon has has taken, um, over time.
- 4:21Melanie: And it's not the same now as it was 200 years ago.
- 4:24Melanie: And I love the idea that you can see all of the sort of meaning sediments or sedimentary meanings, I guess, as you think about a canon moving through time.
- 4:35Cybele: That's so beautiful.
- 4:37Cybele: And, um, the quick example that I think of from your writing is that you have this lovely piece about what Suzuki method prioritizes as the first three partitas that all students have to learn, right?
- 4:50Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 4:50Cybele: Suzuki method, as I understand it, is when you get, you know, incredibly tiny children, like 3-year-olds, to be learning classical music.
- 4:58Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 4:59Cybele: Um, and tuning their brains and their fingers and their passion to play music early, which is such a great idea.
- 5:06Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 5:07Cybele: Um, and you do this amazing thing where you go back and look historically at the origins of those partitas, um, and specifically that one isn't written by Bach.
- 5:18Cybele: And you just have this amazing way of, um, looking at the sediment in the rock.
- 5:23Cybele: Can you tell a little bit about that story of those musical notebooks?
- 5:26Cybele: It's just lovely.
- 5:28Melanie: Sure.
- 5:28Melanie: It's actually one of my most favorite pieces I've ever written, uh, because I think it, it speaks to musicologists, but it also speaks to moms that are playing that violin with their, their 3-year-old.
- 5:41Melanie: So the, the three minuets in the Suzuki repertoire, pretty much every young musician is going to play these pieces, whether you're a trombonist or a violinist or a pianist. They are in the Suzuki repertoire, and most of our young musicians, certainly string players, this is how we train them.
- 5:59Melanie: Now, the Suzuki method is based on the idea of, of using musical commonplaces that are in the air that are in your ear.
- 6:09Melanie: So everything from little tunes to popular melodies to little tunes that Suzuki composed, and they're all assembled in these books.
- 6:18Melanie: And the three minuets, only one of them is actually by Bach, who for a long time got credit for all of them.
- 6:25Melanie: And the original source is actually Bach's second wife's personal musical notebook.
- 6:34Melanie: And she copied out most of the entries in that notebook.
- 6:38Melanie: And she copied them because she was using it to teach her own children.
- 6:43Melanie: And Bach famously had 20 children.
- 6:46Melanie: Uh, 13 of them were hers.
- 6:48Melanie: And her job was not just to, uh, run the household, but to teach the children music lessons.
- 6:56Cybele: Amazing.
- 6:56Cybele: And also to transcribe his composition.
- 6:58Melanie: And, yes, she was an excellent musician.
- 7:00Melanie: She was a professional musician before marrying him.
- 7:03Melanie: And so when she became, uh, the head of that household, she retained her identity as a musician and a, and a, and a singer and a copyist, but also became what I like to think of as the world's most celebrated musical mother.
- 7:17Melanie: And then the idea that we have this collection of pieces that Anna Magdalena Bach used to teach her children.
- 7:25Melanie: And here at the Blair School of Music, you, if you come into the Blair School in the afternoon, you're gonna see all of these kids with their instruments and they're playing those little pieces and they're keeping company with the same kind of assortment of pieces intended for instruction of the world's youngest musicians.
- 7:43Cybele: So fascinating.
- 7:44Cybele: And I love what you do there with time, right?
- 7:47Cybele: That in telling that story, you bring us back in time to the, what was it, 1780s?
- 7:53Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 7:53Melanie: Or seven...
- 7:54Melanie: ...that notebook is 1725.
- 7:56Cybele: 25.
- 7:56Cybele: Oh, there you go.
- 7:56Melanie: Yeah.
- 7:57Cybele: So what is that?
- 7:58Cybele: 300,
- 7:59Melanie: 300 years, years ago, right?
- 8:02Cybele: You know that you're taking us into a moment, um, where we imagine this woman who has a professional life, I think you mentioned that she's one of the highest-paid, um, you know, vocalists of her time.
- 8:13Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 8:13Melanie: She's a court singer.
- 8:14Melanie: Right.
- 8:15Cybele: Right.
- 8:15Cybele: She's also the parent of somewhere between 13 and 20 children, and she's also, um, navigating this really beautiful moment of teaching her own children how to play.
- 8:26Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 8:26Cybele: And that you do that as an historian and as a musicologist, but also as a person committed to thinking about how we teach music.
- 8:34Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 8:34Cybele: Um, it's really cool.
- 8:35Melanie: I'll just, I'll add one other footnote to that if I might.
- 8:37Cybele: Sure.
- 8:37Melanie: I also come to that piece as a musical mother myself.
- 8:41Cybele: Oh, great.
- 8:41Melanie: I had a daughter who studied piano through the Suzuki method and played that little minuet, and I remember myself as a child pianist playing that little minuet.
- 8:50Cybele: Wow.
- 8:50Melanie: And so there's this incredible history of that piece.
- 8:53Melanie: And any person who studied music lessons probably knows this little minuet.
- 9:06Cybele: That's a vocabulary I don't know.
- 9:09Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 9:09Cybele: Um, and so I'm, I'm really impressed and interested to think about a world of people walking around with that vocabulary.
- 9:17Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 9:17Cybele: Um, and then when you think about that leap that you make in terms of your book, "Pleasure and Meaning in the Classical Symphony"—how to understand music composed in that time, by those greats, by Mozart, by Haydn, by Beethoven.
- 9:30Cybele: You explore how audiences of that era understood musical gestures.
- 9:35Cybele: Can you tell us what you mean by the idea of musical gestures?
- 9:37Melanie: Sure, sure.
- 9:39Melanie: Um, musical topics is the language that I use for, I think what you're, what you're talking about with, with gestures.
- 9:45Melanie: And musical topics are ... they're the materials of musical meaning and communication from this particular musical soundscape.
- 9:57Melanie: So the everyday sounds of everyday life in 18th-century Vienna where this music was composed—you would be walking down the street and you would hear street songs.
- 10:07Melanie: You would hear the fanfares at the court.
- 10:10Melanie: You might hear dance music coming out of the dance halls.
- 10:12Melanie: You'd, you would hear music, um, people playing, coming out of the windows.
- 10:17Melanie: So there's all of this music around, and what the composers at that time are doing is using the materials of these everyday commonplace music ... musical moments ... and they show up in a symphony or in a piano sonata or a string quartet.
- 10:33Melanie: And when, let's say a fanfare or a dance is imported into a piano sonata, it's going to carry with it the meanings and associations that that gesture, that topic has taken on in a context completely external to where it shows up now.
- 10:51Melanie: And so the reason that I got interested in this is I'm particularly interested in the meanings that people who are not trained in music hear—today, and then. Like this music was performed in public concert halls, and only the landed nobility, uh, and upper, upper middle classes and above would have known how to read music or think about music.
- 11:15Melanie: And yet people enjoy this music.
- 11:18Melanie: They heard something in it that made sense to them.
- 11:20Melanie: It was intelligible. And this musical surface that's coming out of the sounds of their everyday world are the primary means of ... of understanding and expressing for that particular audience.
- 11:34Cybele: So fascinating.
- 11:35Cybele: I mean, I think in that early chapter you talk about the popularity of that music.
- 11:40Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 11:41Cybele: Um, that it was not just popular in Vienna, not just popular in Paris, but popular in the United States.
- 11:47Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 11:47Cybele: Popular...
- 11:47Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 11:49Cybele: ...really in many different locations for many different classes of people.
- 11:54Cybele: How do we now see that, right?
- 11:57Cybele: It's not so popular to listen to classical music.
- 12:00Cybele: It's right the case that, you know, Carnegie Hall is willing to give you a big discount if you're a younger listener to try to build a younger listening audience.
- 12:10Cybele: How do we sort of mentally make sense of the idea of popularity, of the music having meaning now...
- 12:17Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 12:17Cybele: ...or having meaning then.
- 12:18Melanie: Yeah.
- 12:18Melanie: That's actually one of the biggest questions that I've been working on answering. And I, I have one way of answering it in, in the book that we're, we're talking about. And I think the biggest disconnect is the way that that music was able to communicate with its original audience is lost to us because, of course, we don't have 18th century ears.
- 12:37Cybele: Yeah, we don't...
- 12:37Cybele: there's no sea shanty singing in the streets today.
- 12:40Melanie: Right.
- 12:40Melanie: We don't walk down West End and hear fanfares.
- 12:42Cybele: Right.
- 12:42Melanie: And or, you know, minuets coming out of the student dorms.
- 12:45Melanie: I mean, it's an entirely different soundscape.
- 12:48Melanie: So the, the real problem is that we don't have the sounds in our, in our brains to make that kind of immediate association.
- 12:58Melanie: And then the other difficulty is, I think ultimately the great irony that classical music has now become a topic in our own musical experiences.
- 13:08Melanie: So if you, I mean, how many television commercials trying to sell you a, a high-end product are gonna accompany it with, you know, a top 20 classical music hit. You're gonna hear Vivaldi while you try to, the hand model caresses gold coins.
- 13:21Melanie: I mean,
- 13:22Cybele: Right. There's like a piece out of Carmen that I hear every time a...
- 13:25Melanie: Right.
- 13:25Cybele: ...you know, a triumphant athlete comes onto screen.
- 13:29Melanie: Yeah.
- 13:29Melanie: Yeah.
- 13:29Melanie: So that, that is...
- 13:31Melanie: that is topical expression.
- 13:32Cybele: Yeah.
- 13:32Melanie: That is topical meaning. So you only need to hear a little bit of that triumphant sound to know what that music is telling you.
- 13:39Melanie: But now the entire repertoire of late 18th century instrumental music, just is "classical music." Even though there's incredible variety in it, we hear "classical music" and it has a very specific meaning to us.
- 13:54Melanie: And ultimately I find that fascinating.
- 13:57Melanie: First I was sad.
- 13:59Cybele: Yeah.
- 13:59Melanie: Because this is music that I love.
- 14:01Melanie: And then I realized, wait a minute, I don't have 18th century ears either.
- 14:04Melanie: So why am I able to enjoy this and so many people are not?
- 14:09Melanie: And that's what settled me on the idea of trying to listen, not just to the, what I call lay listeners or people who are not musically educated in the 18th century, but also today.
- 14:19Melanie: You know, literally, what are you hearing?
- 14:20Melanie: What does this mean to you?
- 14:22Melanie: And ultimately the, the idea that this music can't mean something if you are not musically trained is a really alienating idea that comes out of the 19th century movement— music can only mean pure musical things.
- 14:38Cybele: Yeah.
- 14:38Cybele: Sort of segregated to high art category.
- 14:42Melanie: Yeah.
- 14:42Melanie: The meaning of music is purely musical. And then that goes into the 20th century—"Musical meaning resides in its structures, in its forms. And if you don't have access to that, you can't understand it." But there's this whole other story going on on the surface
- 14:57Cybele: And is that there was some stripping away of the legitimacy of how the music made you feel?
- 15:03Melanie: Oh, absolutely.
- 15:04Cybele: Yeah.
- 15:04Cybele: That was a sentimentalist sort of vibe that we should not fall prey to.
- 15:08Melanie: Yes.
- 15:09Melanie: The 19th century romantic gushing criticism made people profoundly embarrassed.
- 15:15Cybele: Got it.
- 15:15Melanie: The 20th century...
- 15:16Cybele: Yeah.
- 15:16Melanie: which was this turn towards objectivity.
- 15:20Melanie: And I wanna reclaim the listener's subjectivity, the way that we can actually own and create and take great pleasure in our own control over the meanings of whatever the music is that we are listening to.
- 15:45Cybele: I love that you insert that pleasure is, um, is so key, and that it's about control over the narrative that's going on in our heads, rather than being told that it's good music or it's being told that it's difficult music.
- 15:59Melanie: Right.
- 16:00Melanie: That's exactly what's happened.
- 16:01Melanie: We have been told, um, from so many sources that classical music is elitist, it's boring, it's, you know, not anything that you want to hear unless you're forced to go to the concert.
- 16:11Melanie: Which is not at all how this music originally functioned.
- 16:16Cybele: So fascinating.
- 16:18Cybele: Um, I think that would make a great segue for me to ask you to talk a little bit about teaching music, um, specifically to undergrads here at Vanderbilt.
- 16:28Cybele: You have this wonderful set of exercises and, um, this wonderful essay, um, that I found extraordinarily funny, um, because you admit the difficulty of teaching the canon—teaching the whole, you know, the whole shebang, and that you can't possibly get that done in 13 weeks.
- 16:45Cybele: I think for any of us who teaches, that's always a feeling of sort of halfway between despair and, you know, um, sort of like, okay, I'm just gonna teach my favorites.
- 16:56Cybele: You do this really brilliant thing of asking students to break down what they think of as high art or what counts as reasonable to include in the canon—which is kind of cool because you're bringing students into the creation, essentially, of what you're gonna study.
- 17:14Cybele: Um, I thought maybe you could read, um, this piece of, uh, your text that I've, uh, gone ahead and put some highlights on.
- 17:22Melanie: Sure, sure.
- 17:23Cybele: So you asked the students a couple of questions and I started with there.
- 17:26Melanie: Right.
- 17:27Melanie: Can something that is accessible or goes down easy be high art.
- 17:32Melanie: Can something that is produced for money, marketed and sold for profit be high art?
- 17:37Melanie: Can something that is entertaining be high art?
- 17:40Melanie: Can something that is merely entertaining be high art?
- 17:43Melanie: What do we mean by high art, anyway?
- 17:47Melanie: Um, do you want me to talk about the class discussions?
- 17:49Cybele: Yeah.
- 17:49Cybele: There's a great class discussion.
- 17:50Melanie: And in the many years that I've been at Vanderbilt, this is one of my absolute favorite teaching moments ever.
- 17:57Melanie: So I'm really happy to read this.
- 17:58Cybele: Yeah, that's great.
- 17:59Cybele: It was great.
- 18:01Melanie: Um, so the students are, are talking about these questions.
- 18:04Melanie: And, uh, as I've written it up, these class discussions are always quite lively. As the students reveal more of their perspectives and debate the questions, I become less of a discussion leader and more of a traffic cop.
- 18:16Melanie: When the class approaches intellectual road rage, which usually happens around 40 minutes, I know we're truly getting to the heart of the matter, which of course is nothing short of the definition, meaning and purpose of art. In a most revealing moment in one of these discussions, a composition major stood up, waved his arms and shouted at his classmates,"Art is structure! Art is form!" He was very passionate, and the moment was terribly funny.
- 18:45Melanie: But for a student, so in touch with his inner Hanslick (this is a, a, a conservative, romantic critic who was all about form), so for a student, so in touch with his inner Hanslick, the more progressive ideas of some of his classmates were truly threatening.
- 19:01Melanie: These were the people on whom he relied to perform his music and transmit his ideas— musical and otherwise—to his audience.
- 19:09Melanie: And that moment, he also recognized that these students, his peers, were his audience.
- 19:16Melanie: He was genuinely rattled by the realization that at the end of the day, he had absolutely no control over the ultimate meanings of his music.
- 19:27Cybele: It's just so great.
- 19:29Melanie: It was hilarious.
- 19:30Melanie: He was very upset.
- 19:32Cybele: Yeah.
- 19:32Melanie: Um.
- 19:33Melanie: But you know, we learned from those moments where his entire sense of what he was doing was horribly shattered.
- 19:41Cybele: Yes.
- 19:41Cybele: And also I think, um, in that moment, it captures exactly what we want through initiatives like Dialogue Vanderbilt and our commitment to civil discourse.
- 19:51Cybele: This idea that totally, totally different viewpoints can exist in the same classroom, in the same conversation, in the same symphony, in the same, you know, conversation between the audience and the composer.
- 20:05Cybele: You know, what the composer is intending, um, and what the audience is wishing to hear is so clearly possibly at odds.
- 20:15Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 20:15Melanie: Absolutely.
- 20:16Melanie: And even when we have, let's say, documentary evidence that a composer says, "This is my intention." My question is, how do we know they're telling us the truth?
- 20:26Melanie: Why should we believe them?
- 20:28Melanie: Is everything you write in your diary truly true and honest?
- 20:32Melanie: So even, even when we think we know the intention, we, it's ultimately unknowable.
- 20:38Cybele: Yeah.
- 20:38Cybele: Just one layer of the sediment in that canyon, right?
- 20:40Melanie: Exactly.
- 20:41Melanie: Maybe the first, and then you see ultimately where the meaning...
- 20:45Melanie: the meaning is much, much further away from that surface creation.
- 20:50Cybele: And how do you navigate, um, such different opinions in the classroom, right?
- 20:54Cybele: That, you know, you may have your own viewpoint, but just as, um, one of my other "Quantum Potential" interviewees, um, Josh Clinton doesn't share his political views, as he calls the national presidential election, right?
- 21:08Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 21:08Cybele: I would imagine you're in this really interesting position of authority, um, but you're navigating totally different opinions.
- 21:14Cybele: How do you handle that?
- 21:16Melanie: Well, I can share an example from last night, actually, very briefly.
- 21:20Melanie: I was teaching a course called Music in the Environment, and it's a course for non-majors.
- 21:25Melanie: And our last exercise was a 42- minute listening indulgence to John Luther Adams' "Become Ocean," which is a, an orchestral piece that it just has to kind of wash over you.
- 21:36Melanie: It's a really amazing experience, but you have to commit to it.
- 21:39Cybele: Yeah.
- 21:39Melanie: And it's not everybody's cup of tea.
- 21:42Melanie: But this is what we do on the last meeting of our, our three- hour class in the evening.
- 21:47Melanie: And so I have, um, students lying on the floor listening, others with their heads down.
- 21:52Melanie: That's perfectly fine.
- 21:53Melanie: And at the end, they have to reflect on their listening experience.
- 21:58Melanie: What was it like for you to listen to this 42-minute piece of music in the dark?
- 22:02Melanie: And, and you know, and this isn't maybe your choice of music.
- 22:06Cybele: Yeah.
- 22:06Cybele: No cell phones, I'm assuming.
- 22:07Melanie: Right, right.
- 22:07Melanie: No cell phones, no talking.
- 22:09Melanie: I mean, it is, it is a listening indulgence...
- 22:11Cybele: Yeah.
- 22:11Melanie: ...as, as I tell them.
- 22:12Melanie: And their first thing they have to do is just reflect. Brain dump.
- 22:15Melanie: What was that experience like?
- 22:16Melanie: And I tell them, "I personally love this composition.
- 22:20Melanie: I've listened to it so many times, and every time I come out feeling different at the end of it. That said, you might've thought it was the worst 42 minutes of your semester, and you would love to have those 42 minutes back."
- 22:32Cybele: Yeah.
- 22:32Melanie: "And if you absolutely hated every second of this, great.
- 22:36Melanie: Tell me about it, and tell me why.
- 22:38Melanie: That's what I wanna hear." And so I really, you know, share, I do share my enthusiasm for a piece of music.
- 22:45Melanie: And at times, even my dislike for a piece of music.
- 22:49Melanie: And also, I'm unabashed that this is my opinion, and I love a, a good argument about it.
- 22:55Cybele: Yeah.
- 22:55Melanie: And I can't wait to hear what... especially people who don't know anything about this music— it, it taps into my fascination with what, again, what I think of as the lay listener, people who are not trained in music are musically initiated.
- 23:10Melanie: What do you hear?
- 23:19Cybele: On the next "Quantum Potential," AI's power to correct hearing loss and the future of AI-enhanced medical devices. We'll talk with Jack Noble, an assistant professor of electrical and computer engineering who combines his expertise in computer science, biomedical engineering, and hearing and speech sciences to revolutionize the efficacy of cochlear implants.
- 23:40Cybele: But first, let's get back to my conversation with Melanie.
- 23:47Cybele: I mean, I think it's also, uh, incredibly democratizing in, in that way, right?
- 23:51Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 23:51Cybele: Not only is it that you have, um, you, you're not required to have a vocabulary to be able to engage in thinking about this music, but you're not required to have liking of it be the ticket of entry...
- 24:05Melanie: Right.
- 24:05Cybele: ...um, to have a conversation about it.
- 24:07Melanie: Right.
- 24:07Melanie: And, and one of my other favorite moments from this, this past semester is on the very early in the semester, I play a really big orchestral piece by a composer named Joan Tower.
- 24:16Melanie: It's called "Sequoia," and it's, it's her musical portrait of the sequoias.
- 24:20Melanie: And I had a bunch of guys, uh, that were just lying on their backpacks on the floor, listening to it and afterwards just went, "That was awesome!" It just shocked me.
- 24:32Cybele: Unbridled.
- 24:33Cybele: Great.
- 24:33Melanie: Not at all what I expected.
- 24:35Melanie: I expected what I think people think they're gonna hear in an orchestra concert, which is ho-hum.
- 24:42And that these guys... Cybele: I wish I had that those minutes back, right?
- 24:45Melanie: Yeah.
- 24:46Melanie: No, these guys were really into it.
- 24:47Cybele: Totally into it.
- 24:48Melanie: They were, they were stunned that they were so into it.
- 24:51That was... Cybele: Great.
- 24:51Melanie: ...really affirming.
- 24:52Melanie: That was wonderful.
- 24:53Melanie: They might want their 42 minutes back from last night.
- 24:55Melanie: I don't know.
- 24:56Cybele: No, but I think that way in which, how to sharpen one's viewpoint so that you feel like you can not only participate, but shape others' views, have your own views change, right?
- 25:09Cybele: That I'm sure over the course of the semester, students initially walk into with their own priors about the material that, that you're gonna introduce them to changes.
- 25:19Cybele: And, um, at least that's what we would hope in a university setting, right?
- 25:23Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 25:23Cybele: That it's not just, oh, I learned to appreciate, but I now have much more fully formed viewpoint and opinion...
- 25:31Melanie: Right.
- 25:31Cybele: ...than I did.
- 25:32Melanie: I think teaching non-majors music is, is largely about the experience.
- 25:37Melanie: You know, this is music.
- 25:38Melanie: So when I set them up for this 42 minute listen, I say,"This is an experience that you are likely never going to have again and you likely would not have had if you didn't take this class.
- 25:48Melanie: So I want you to fully commit to it."
- 25:50Cybele: That's great.
- 25:51Melanie: Let's do it.
- 25:51Melanie: Let's, we're gonna do
- 25:53Cybele: it.
- 25:53Cybele: Experience this.
- 25:53Cybele: Let's really do it.
- 25:53Melanie: Yeah.
- 25:54Cybele: Yeah.
- 25:54Cybele: It's very, very cool.
- 25:56Cybele: And then how does that translate to teaching, um, about popular music?
- 26:00Cybele: Is it that those classes are just extraordinarily high in their enrollment, and students come in totally excited that they get to think about Taylor Swift and tweens loving music?
- 26:12Cybele: Like how, what, what's the, is there a polar difference between how students come into your classrooms in terms of their anticipation and expectations around classical music versus popular music?
- 26:22Melanie: Yeah.
- 26:23Melanie: Um, I'm probably not gonna be able to answer that particularly well for today because I actually haven't taught those big classes on popular music for a while.
- 26:32Melanie: But I do teach a class that has a mixture of classical and popular music, largely for music majors.
- 26:38Melanie: And so when we get to Beyonce, for example, they loosen up.
- 26:42Cybele: Interesting.
- 26:43Melanie: And I don't know whether it's because it's sort of their music more than my music, or that's what they think anyway, and that might not entirely be accurate.
- 26:50Melanie: But yeah, they, they're, they're a little more relaxed.
- 26:52Melanie: Um, they take a little more ownership of it.
- 26:55Melanie: And they also, I think, uh, know that I might not be the expert on that, that they are.
- 26:59Cybele: So interesting.
- 27:00Melanie: So, and that's fine.
- 27:01Cybele: Yeah.
- 27:02Cybele: Expertise matters walking into the classroom.
- 27:04Melanie: Yeah.
- 27:05Melanie: Yeah.
- 27:05Melanie: And also I'm, I'm really upfront about, especially when we get into music that is not music that I'm an expert on, but I'm teaching anyway because it has a pedagogical purpose in that moment.
- 27:15Melanie: So, yeah, I, I tell them I wanna learn from you.
- 27:19Melanie: And they have a lot to say.
- 27:21Melanie: They a lot to share.
- 27:22Cybele: I bet. That's great.
- 27:22Melanie: Yeah.
- 27:23Cybele: In terms of thinking about listening, particularly early experiences of fandom for girls and how girls experience a sense of desire or empowerment in listening to music, tell us a little bit about your work in that area.
- 27:36Melanie: Okay.
- 27:36Melanie: That, that's interesting 'cause it is also connected to what I'm doing in classical music.
- 27:41Melanie: It's ultimately the same question.
- 27:43Melanie: How does this music mean something to the listener? and what we think it's meaning if we're on the outside.
- 27:50Melanie: We're not the actual listening subject.
- 27:52Melanie: The person who thinks they know what this music means, that is likely not what the listening subject is actually experiencing.
- 27:59Melanie: And so this is kind of going way back, but I, I did this, this work, uh, when Britney Spears had come out as this very young-looking 16-year-old-looking girl in her school uniform, and was obviously sort of a very sexual, sexualized portrayal.
- 28:19Melanie: A lot of moms getting a little upset about the music and the imagery that their, their young daughters are consuming— 9-, 10-, 11-, 12-year-olds idolizing this singer.
- 28:29Cybele: Right.
- 28:29Cybele: I remember the parent advisory stickers.
- 28:31Melanie: Oh yeah.
- 28:31Cybele: I was that generation.
- 28:33Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 28:33Melanie: You know, her image on all the magazines and...
- 28:36Melanie: But I actually talked to the girls themselves. And I did some focus group, uh, work and just played some music and we talked and we, we, I listened to what they had to say. And at the end of that, they are really savvy media critics.
- 28:52Melanie: So on the one hand, they are completely aware of what the media is doing to the image.
- 28:58Melanie: They know, oh, she might be like that or she might not, but this is how she's being made to look.
- 29:04Melanie: So they're, they understand that.
- 29:06Melanie: So on the one hand, they, they understand that, on the other they don't like it.
- 29:11Melanie: They are perfectly, a 10-year-old is perfectly capable of calling that out and saying, yeah, she's being objectified.
- 29:17Melanie: She might not use that exact word, but that's what she's saying.
- 29:20Cybele: Yeah.
- 29:21Melanie: But then the really interesting thing is when those girls get behind closed doors and the parents aren't there, and their brothers aren't there, and it's just a couple of, let's say 10-year-old girls, lip syncing, playing the music, singing along with it, dressing in clothes, and moving their bodies in that way.
- 29:40Melanie: The way I read it is they are actually practicing their own, kind of, nascent sexuality in a very safe space, which is their own private bedrooms.
- 29:52Cybele: Right.
- 29:52Cybele: There's just something really awesome about music happening in, in private spaces.
- 29:57Melanie: Yeah.
- 29:57Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 29:57Cybele: Whether it's your earphones or in the car or in your bedroom as a teenager.
- 30:01Cybele: Really an interesting observation, right?
- 30:03Cybele: It's, um, very different than if you go to a concert publicly.
- 30:07Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 30:08Melanie: Right.
- 30:09Melanie: And, and that music meant different things to them at different moments...
- 30:12Cybele: Yeah.
- 30:13Melanie: ...um, depending on where they were or how old they were or what the ...
- 30:16Melanie: you know, and this would get back, this gets back to the idea of the listener's control over meaning. That's the pleasure in this music, the girls ...
- 30:24Melanie: took a lot of pleasure in this music, especially when they were controlling its meanings.
- 30:29Cybele: You know, and I can think about yacht rock or music that appeals to, you know, older listeners who just wanna be able to go back in time in their own heads...
- 30:38Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 30:39Cybele: ...right?
- 30:39Cybele: In the sense of the pleasure of having control over that feeling.
- 30:44Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 30:44Cybele: It's a, it's a great, uh, kind of connection that you've made between, um, sort of a more affective, emotional way of thinking and a more cognitively analytic frame.
- 30:55Cybele: I just, it's very fascinating to me.
- 30:57Melanie: Thank you.
- 30:58Melanie: Thank you.
- 30:58Cybele: Um, and then tell me a little bit about ironic masculinity.
- 31:01Cybele: I'm totally captivated.
- 31:04Melanie: Oh, ironic masculinity.
- 31:06Melanie: Um, this actually came from listening to a bunch of synth pop and, uh, hearing electric guitars and realizing that those electric guitars were performing a kind of ironic masculinity.
- 31:21Melanie: If we think about the...
- 31:23Melanie: the usual signification of an electric guitar.
- 31:26Melanie: It's um, I mean it's basically a phallic object, right?
- 31:29Melanie: And we've got the power chords and we have the kind of wall of sound.
- 31:33Melanie: I mean, it is, it is a very powerful masculine musical symbol.
- 31:39Melanie: And here we have these synth pop, I mean, defiantly not masculine male performers...
- 31:46Cybele: Totally.
- 31:47Melanie: ...uh, embracing the sound of the electric guitar in a way to throw shade on its usual meaning.
- 31:55Cybele: Yeah.
- 31:55Melanie: And so using it in a, not always campy, but sometimes, but definitely or embracing it with earnest, you know, just being really serious about this electric guitar, which ultimately shows the hollowness of, of, of the symbol.
- 32:10Cybele: The whole meaning of shredding, right?
- 32:11Melanie: Yes.
- 32:11Cybele: And if a woman shreds on an electric guitar, what does that mean?
- 32:14Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 32:15Cybele: And if a guy shreds on an electric guitar, what does that mean?
- 32:18Melanie: Yep.
- 32:19Cybele: And a guy with a woolen beanie stands with his, you know, five o'clock shadow and does not shred emphatically.
- 32:27Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 32:28Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 32:28Cybele: What does that mean?
- 32:29Cybele: I think it's just a great,
- 32:30Melanie: or a performer in like full stage makeup and really flamboyant costumes, but has, you know, the symbol, you know, but he's shredding.
- 32:38Cybele: Right?
- 32:38Melanie: And it, it's really incongruous, which is ultimately to me, the, the ironic masculinity and ultimately reclaiming that masculinity is multifaceted.
- 32:49Cybele: Right.
- 32:50Cybele: Just to say, right?
- 32:51Melanie: Right.
- 32:51Melanie: Exactly.
- 32:52Melanie: Just because you choose not to play music with electric guitars and it's all synth, does that mean that it's feminine or not masculine?
- 33:01Melanie: So I think at the end of the day, it's really expanding our sense of what is masculine...
- 33:06Cybele: It's great.
- 33:07Melanie: ...and masculinity in music.
- 33:09Cybele: I mean, it's certainly, I think a huge question that constantly comes up now, and particularly I think in, I would say in cinema studies and gender studies.
- 33:20Cybele: And I'm curious about the ways in which you collaborate across um, campus in, in terms of faculty and other departments. Is that a conversation that they recognize is true in music and musicology as we might in, um, thinking about media studies or cinema studies or other fields?
- 33:39Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 33:40Melanie: I think that's a, um, an area of collaboration that really needs more development.
- 33:44Melanie: Um, and there's, there is a sense because, um, music requires a certain kind of education.
- 33:50Melanie: You know, you need to be able to read music or you know, that that's the very traditional training.
- 33:55Melanie: And so, and it's been a kind of perennial problem that music and musicology and the academic study of music is somehow separate from the study of other art expressions, you know, literature, painting.
- 34:10Melanie: And for that reason I think there is always a little bit of a gap that needs to be closed in terms of what musicologists do and what other people in the humanities working on artistic topics.
- 34:24Melanie: Um, so I would say there's a lot of potential for collaboration that personally I have not really engaged very much in.
- 34:43Cybele: I'm really curious, for example, about the way in which algorithms, uh, used by Spotify and other platforms shape musical taste right? And the ways in which what we again, um, per your point earlier about what we listen to in terms of classical music, what we get exposed to, or how we make meaning of music in the future. For what I would draw from what you're saying is that it's gonna be affected dramatically by what we're exposed to, what we perceive as sort of the standards of our day.
- 35:12Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 35:13Melanie: I think we're kind of being told what we like by the algorithm.
- 35:17Melanie: And if we sort of take my idea of the listener's control over meaning and the pleasure that we take in that this, it's a similar kind of path.
- 35:27Melanie: When we were be ... became told what, let's say, 18th century symphonic music meant to us—it meant dull, it meant old, it meant boring, it meant elite.
- 35:36Melanie: If we kind of farm out too much of our control over our choices, or what we decide something means or how we interpret it, I worry that the actual expression will be vastly diminished.
- 35:50Cybele: Yeah.
- 35:50Melanie: And the pleasure, certainly.
- 35:52Cybele: It makes total sense to me, especially based on the sort of themes that you've outlined.
- 35:57Cybele: And the other theme that immediately comes to mind is the theme of making time.
- 36:02Cybele: You've talked a lot about that in the article about teaching— that you just need enough time for students to be able to really, really immerse themselves in that music.
- 36:12Cybele: And you've talked about that today, this idea that it's an indulgence.
- 36:16Cybele: How do you think about students committing to listening to an album in analog form or listening to, you know, 42 minutes by a single composer?
- 36:27Cybele: Do you have, um, a, a sense of hope or a sense of concern around the ways in which we have time and time stretches versus we don't have time and time compresses when we listen.
- 36:38Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 36:39Melanie: Uh, one of the things I talk about a lot in my teaching is how we are temporal beings and music is a temporal art. And the music on the page is actually just a reification of something that doesn't exist in that medium.
- 36:55Melanie: So the music, the actual sheet of music, is a spatial object, and it's simply a set of instructions for realizing a temporal experience.
- 37:06Melanie: So I have really kind of mixed feelings about it.
- 37:08Melanie: Um, it's wonderful that our students are listening to music all the time.
- 37:11Melanie: If you can't walk across campus, every single person you pass has earbuds in.
- 37:16Cybele: Yeah.
- 37:16Melanie: And they're in their own private musical space or podcast space or whatever it is they're listening to.
- 37:21Melanie: So they're listening more and more and more.
- 37:23Melanie: I'm not entirely sure that they are listening attentively as much as perhaps certainly a music instructor would like them to.
- 37:32Cybele: Yeah.
- 37:33Cybele: I mean, for me it's like a film score, right?
- 37:34Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 37:35Cybele: If I'm walking through campus or um, doing something and I have earphones in, I, my life is being scored.
- 37:41Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 37:42Cybele: Um, I have a soundtrack.
- 37:43Cybele: That's, that's, and I think you're absolutely right.
- 37:45Cybele: I'm not necessarily attending in the same way as if I were in your class, lying on the floor listening, um, and that's the only thing I was doing.
- 37:54Melanie: Right.
- 37:54Cybele: Were doing at the time.
- 37:55Melanie: And, and of course that's fine.
- 37:56Melanie: I mean, there's different reasons we listen to music.
- 37:58Melanie: There's different listening modalities.
- 38:00Melanie: I would really like to hope that, uh, we haven't lost the pleasure to just sit and listen to music and really do nothing else.
- 38:09Melanie: That is an indulgence, and I think our, our lives are so cluttered and noisy and busy, and we think we can listen AND run.
- 38:17Melanie: We can listen AND cook.
- 38:19Melanie: We can listen AND do homework.
- 38:22Melanie: You know, we can listen AND walk to class, but when are we just listening to ourselves listen?
- 38:28Cybele: Totally, totally.
- 38:29Cybele: The listening room.
- 38:31Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 38:31Cybele: The listening hour.
- 38:32Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 38:33Cybele: I love that idea.
- 38:34Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 38:35Cybele: Thank you so much, Melanie.
- 38:37Cybele: I was really just thinking as you were speaking about, um, what gives you hope, thinking going forward?
- 38:43Cybele: I've been asking this question, um, in my interviews just because I think it's useful to, um, frame what we do in the university as having impact in the world and in many cases having solutions.
- 38:56Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 38:57Melanie: I think what gives me hope, at least in the, the, the realm of the university that I hang out in, which is the Blair School of Music, um, our students are genuinely curious about the music of the world—not just the music that's in their studio or the music that they've grown up playing.
- 39:17Melanie: And I think the more that we can inspire students that are here, largely to study classical music, to understand that the music that they are committing to learning and studying and performing is in a constant dialogue with the music of the world in a way that it never has been before because they have pretty much the world's recorded music, or at least access to it, in their pockets.
- 39:43Cybele: Yeah.
- 39:43Cybele: Incredible.
- 39:44Melanie: And we have never had a moment like that before.
- 39:46Cybele: Yeah.
- 39:48Cybele: That is amazing— the level of globalization and fluency in world culture.
- 39:53Melanie: Mm-hmm.
- 39:53Cybele: Fascinating.
- 39:55Cybele: And if there's one thing that you wanted to advise our listeners or, or tell our listeners, uh, something to leave them with, what would that be?
- 40:03Melanie: Do the musical indulgence.
- 40:05Melanie: Listen and listen to yourself listen. And don't do anything else at least once a day, even if it's just a two-minute pop song.
- 40:14Cybele: Wonderful.
- 40:15Melanie: Just listen and stop doing anything else.
- 40:19Cybele: I love that.
- 40:20Cybele: Thank you for that gift.
- 40:21Cybele: Thanks so much, Melanie, for joining us today.
- 40:23Melanie: It was my pleasure.
- 40:23Melanie: Thanks for having me.
- 40:24Cybele: Yeah.
- 40:37Cybele: The "Quantum Potential" podcast comes from Vanderbilt University.
- 40:41Cybele: I'm your host, Cybele Raver, provost, and vice chancellor for academic affairs with Vanderbilt University.
- 40:48Cybele: Thank you to our guest, Melanie Lowe, associate professor of music at the Blair School of Music.
- 40:54Cybele: This episode was edited and mixed by the team at Sound On Sound Off.
- 40:58Cybele: You can learn more about their work at SoundonSoundoff.com.
- 41:03Cybele: For more information about"Quantum Potential," go to vanderbilt.edu/quantumpotential.
- 41:09Cybele: Thank you for joining us today for the "Quantum Potential" podcast.
- 41:13Cybele: Stay tuned for more conversations with the thinkers and innovators reshaping our world.
- 41:18Cybele: I'm Cybele Raver, and this has been "Quantum Potential."