Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Ruby Franke & Jodi Hildebrandt (Chapter 3)
Transcript
- 0:00Hayters our listeners. I thought I would do a follow up series of episodes
- 0:04to the news story about Ruby Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt. I have learned new
- 0:11things. I should tell everyone that I'm recording this right now, September twenty
- 0:15nine. So this is part six in my series on this very difficult news
- 0:21story. Let's watch. So comment number one is I've gone to multiple different
- 0:26therapists, and what seems to happen is that it initially fills okay, but
- 0:31as I keep going, I just get worse and worse until things are so
- 0:34bad I can't keep going. I've never gotten anything out of therapy that I
- 0:38couldn't get from just talking to people on the internet, which actually has been
- 0:42more productive for me. Okay, So I want to remind people that I'm
- 0:46watching this clip on the Mormon Stories podcast. They are talking with a number
- 0:51of therapists about ethics and the Mormon Church, and they are reviewing different clips
- 0:58that Jody Hallebrandt and and Ruby Frankie put out. And so in this clip,
- 1:03Ruby Frankie's reading a comment on Instagram of someone who was saying that I've
- 1:07been to a lot of therapy and it feels better at first, but then
- 1:11it always gets worse. And I've never been helped by a therapist anymore than
- 1:18it would be as if I were just talking with people online. And yeah,
- 1:22that individual's experience isn't necessarily that uncommon. It's hard to find a good
- 1:27fit. It's hard to find a good therapist that matches with you. It's
- 1:32hard to even know what sort of therapists to look for for most people,
- 1:34it's really hard to You know, when you have a toothache, you go
- 1:37to a dentist, But when you have some difficulty in your life, like
- 1:42your relationships aren't going well, or maybe you have some suicidal thoughts, you
- 1:45don't necessarily know exactly what sort of therapists you should go to. And a
- 1:49lot of therapists don't know who they should be accepting. They think that they're
- 1:53competent with all sorts of things that they might not necessarily be competent. And
- 1:57so is it possible for an due vial to have gone to therapy and have
- 2:00it not only not help them, but to harm them, and to conclude
- 2:05maybe all therapy is bad? You know, I could see that happening to
- 2:07someone I've heard of people going through that, and their accounts sound credible,
- 2:13like it wasn't just them being resistant in therapy, for example, but to
- 2:16conclude that all therapy is bad, and what they're talking about is that you
- 2:23should avoid going to therapists. And because they use some phrase like they use
- 2:30the theory of man or something or the doctrine of Man, I think,
- 2:36meaning that by contrast, they have a theory of the Mormon Church that's behind
- 2:40them. And so they're basically saying therapists who are outside the Mormon Church I
- 2:46believe are bad. And yeah, so they're trying to indoctrinate their people into
- 2:53their culture. Hopefully they're talking to people in truth. Yeah so, yeah,
- 2:58so I hear that. And what I'm hearing is this person is desiring
- 3:04to feel some foundation under their feet, like feel some stability under their feet,
- 3:09and they've gone to different therapists and I don't know exactly what they're looking
- 3:15for, and they're walking away saying I'm not finding what I'm looking for.
- 3:20Well, let me tell you those of you who and what they're doing right
- 3:23now is not unique. There are many chrismatic therapists that have nothing to do
- 3:30with the Mormon Church who have this method of trying to convince people that they
- 3:36are the only one who can help them. If you watch my channel,
- 3:38I hope you never hear me even imply that, because I don't believe it,
- 3:45Like I never say I'm the only person on the planet that can help
- 3:47you. Everyone else is stupid. My model of therapy is better than others.
- 3:53I know I've never said those things, but I would hope you would
- 3:55never think I even implied it, because it just simply and true. If
- 4:00you have been following me for a bit and you get some sort of sense
- 4:03of the way I see the world and also the way that I treat clients
- 4:06that might appeal to you, I hope you know that all the things that
- 4:11I know and I am as a therapist, I didn't invent these things.
- 4:15I stand on the shoulders of giants. They all the researchers and the philosophers
- 4:19who came before me, from John Bowlby to Sigmund Freud, to Karen Horney
- 4:25to Melanie Klein, Mary main Ainsworth, who else, Harry Stack, Sullivan,
- 4:31Kohut, Kerrenberg, Virginia Steer. I could rattle off. I'm just
- 4:39a product of all of their genius. That's all that I am, and
- 4:43many other therapists around the world have been influenced by the same individuals and might
- 4:50even have a better model of therapy than I use. I don't know.
- 4:54So if there's a little tip that I can provide is whenever anyone says I
- 5:00have the answers and everyone else doesn't, whether it's a therapist or a physician
- 5:04or a climate scientist, for example, if they say I have the answers
- 5:10and everyone else is an idiot, you should immediately be skeptical of them,
- 5:14if not write them off entirely, just because they're saying that. Because they
- 5:18get so mad that they can't control what's going on, they turn right around
- 5:24and go give us a one star review. Now, we've made it really
- 5:28easy for them to do that, because we've been trying to make it really
- 5:30easy for you to give us a five star review. We've put the link
- 5:35on the bottom of every single post, so all you have to do is
- 5:40click the link and give us a five star review. That's as simple as
- 5:44it is. But you guys aren't doing it. I think we've had five
- 5:47people from the last time I asked, which is probably a month ago five
- 5:53out of almost nine five. This is obviously unseemly for any sort of of
- 6:00service provider or content provider to say you better like my video. It's gross,
- 6:05it's embarrassing. I'm embarrassed for her. Also, I worry that her
- 6:12followers would actually be influenced by this or intimidated into leaving a five star review.
- 6:17So not only that that's just societal cultural values or judgment, but it
- 6:25is actually against our ethical codes as clinicians. It's explicitly written in our ethical
- 6:30codes that you cannot pressure your clients to not only leave you a five star
- 6:36review, but leave you a review at all. And the vast majority of
- 6:42therapists anecdotally that I work with, including myself, we don't even suggest it
- 6:46to our even that is considered, you know, to have it on a
- 6:50form or to verbally say hey, if you want to leave me a nice
- 6:54review on Google or Yelp or something. I don't know a single therapist who
- 6:59does that, and every therapist I know would go no. I would never
- 7:02do that to a client. That's way too over the line. That's to
- 7:06pressure a client to no. I would never do that. That's completely anathetical
- 7:13to the way that I am, and it is considered unethical. It's an
- 7:15ethical violation. There's not a lot of things that are considered hard and fast
- 7:20ethical violations. There's a lot of wiggle room to look at the particular circumstances,
- 7:27and this also is one of those. There are situations in which one
- 7:30could suggest, Hey, if you want to leave a review, you know,
- 7:33there's a way to do it without pressuring people. But everyone that I
- 7:38know they wouldn't even do that because it puts yourself first, which is anathetical
- 7:43to being a You don't want to say I'm here to help you, but
- 7:46really this is about me, and you need to reciprocate with me. You
- 7:48need to give me a good review on Google or else. I'm not going
- 7:53to treat you well or I'm not going to think you're a good person that
- 7:57sort of thing. I'm going to get angry at you. I'm going to
- 7:59tim you, I'm going to attack you publicly. People give us a review
- 8:05that's five, and we've had probably fifty to seventy five people give us one
- 8:09star reviews, so we started with a five. So I think I'm catching
- 8:16what she's saying that of the sixty reviews she has, there's five five star
- 8:22and there's there's fifty one star reviews. Yeah, I mean it doesn't surprise
- 8:31me. In three months, we're down to like a two Russian and evil
- 8:35has dominated our world because there's too many of us that want to live in
- 8:39truth that are not standing up. So what I think is happening is I'm
- 8:43watching the Mormon Stories podcast YouTube channel and they are watching someone else's YouTube channel
- 8:48that I can't see the little logo at the bottom, and that other YouTube
- 8:52channel is watching TikTok or an Instagram thing of Jody Hildebrandt is like inside with
- 9:01bo Burnham, of like reacting to reacting to reacting. So I take this
- 9:03with a grain of salt because I'm watching something, watching something, watching something.
- 9:07But according to that other YouTuber, a one star review said, they
- 9:11will ruin your family. Jody Hildebrandt will ruin your family through mind control.
- 9:16They don't want you to think for yourself and critically think, they want to
- 9:20shelter you. They are an actual cult. They also assaulted me, so
- 9:26I'm suing wow wow wow. Yeah, I mean, I guess we knew
- 9:35that this was happening, right, But I guess it's just astonishing to think
- 9:41about how many people Jody harmed and how long Jody was allowed to practice as
- 9:48a licensed clinician, and how long Jody was able to practice or just be
- 9:54a human being not in prison. It's just astonishing. And when you have
- 10:00a high control group that props up certain professionals because they fit neatly within your
- 10:07cult, this is what you get, right, Yeah, you just wonder
- 10:11what's the scope of this? And of course Jody Hildebrandt is not the only
- 10:15one that's doing this. There are probably thousands of clinicians who are around our
- 10:20country that are doing this kind of stuff and are getting away with it.
- 10:24It's you know, it upsets me when I hear about a mediocre therapist who
- 10:31is just phoning it in, or doesn't really know what they're doing, doesn't
- 10:37have a good training under their belt, doesn't have good supervision or consultation,
- 10:41or just isn't really suited to be a therapist. That will really grind my
- 10:46gears. This, you know, this breaks all the gears and a mom,
- 10:52please, I don't understand why you won't do it. Go on to
- 10:58Mom's of truth. There is link underneath every single video that says, give
- 11:03us a review, click it and give us a five star. Mah god,
- 11:09it's so gross. How could you possibly follow a person like this?
- 11:15What would be going through your mind? I mean, even if you thought
- 11:18she gave good advice. Okay, so this says something about her personality,
- 11:26right that It's one you know, of course, if you get a bad
- 11:33you know on iTunes. You know, I used to really obsess about that.
- 11:37I would look, you know, in the beginning fifteen years ago.
- 11:39I would have maybe one review, and I would just be, like I
- 11:45did, read that review over and over again, kind of a thing.
- 11:48I haven't looked at it in a while, but I have looked at some
- 11:50of the one star reviews, and you know, it hurts my feelings.
- 11:54So I know how that feels. I know the feelings she's coming from.
- 11:58I know the pain and the hurt and maybe the anxiety about oh, I'm
- 12:03trying to market something here. What if people are turned off by a one
- 12:07star review? You know, I get all that, but there's a huge
- 12:11leap between that feeling and those feelings of hurt and anxiety, which I think
- 12:16are normal too. And now I'm going to publicly intimidate and demand that people
- 12:24leave me a five star review that is likely a result of a character logical
- 12:28personality disorder, not a global disorder, but a particular disorder. I'll just
- 12:35say it fits neatly within at least one of them. It's not diagnosable given
- 12:41this data point. But as someone who specializes in personal disorders, I am
- 12:46often assessing people over a span of time and really trying to find those leaps,
- 12:54because when you have those, then those are pretty solid data points that
- 13:00you can start to accrue to have a much better conceptualization of what is going
- 13:05on underneath because this behavior, it's coming from somewhere. It's like smoke leads
- 13:11to fire, right, and this leads to something. There's something going on
- 13:15underneath her that is causing her to forego her better judgment. I'm sure she
- 13:20knows that this could look bad, but something is eclipsing that because of a
- 13:26desperate need to establish something. There's something she's running away from desperately that results
- 13:33in this sort of thing. Oh, it's a temper tantrum and it's actually
- 13:37unethical. We as therapists, are not supposed to ask for reviews nor testimonials.
- 13:43It's in pretty much every single one of our code of ethics. Yeah,
- 13:46exactly, I wonderful. A lot of my reactions are similar to the
- 13:50professionals on the Mormon Stories podcast, and the first one we're going to share
- 13:54is Jody commenting on PTSD or post traumatic stress disorder. What you're telling me
- 14:01is that you have not gotten into the truth. Or maybe you don't want
- 14:05to tell yourself the truth. Maybe you have told yourself the truth, but
- 14:07you really don't want to be in the truth. Maybe you like being a
- 14:11victim, maybe you like the attention you get from being a victim. I
- 14:15don't know what you were particular. Oh my god, I don't obviously,
- 14:20I don't need to say anything. Y'all know how not only just stupid and
- 14:26unscientific and outside the standard of practice that is, but how harmful that is
- 14:31and how common that point of view is. It's like she's just a sure,
- 14:35she's a licensed therapist of some sort and she's a practicing therapist, but
- 14:41she's this, she's this disgusting manifestation of our culture. It's like our the
- 14:46hatred and the misinformation and all of what's bad in our culture. It just
- 14:54you know, what was that what was that TV show American Gods, where
- 14:58there are there are certain gods manifest through culture and movements within society. And
- 15:05you know, of course there were these old gods that were roaming around in
- 15:11human form in the United States. But then because technology was this new thing
- 15:15and the worship of technology and cell phones, the Internet, that a new
- 15:20god emerged, this God of the Internet. And she's like this avatar of
- 15:26bigotry and misinformation and anti science and anti psychiatry, anti psychology because she's not
- 15:35saying anything new. Lots of people believe this, but just not clinicians.
- 15:39Maybe you like being a victim, Maybe you like the attention you get from
- 15:43being a victim. I don't know what your particular cases. But the question
- 15:48was, if I have PTSD and I keep getting triggered, is that of
- 15:52destroyed fear? And the answer is yes. If I have PTSD and I
- 15:56keep getting triggered, is what someone is asking her? And person asks her,
- 16:00is that a distortion or the truth? The fact that I'm being triggered?
- 16:06What? Because you know, let's guess, So this person says I
- 16:10have PTSD. Okay, So if the person legit has PTSD, then yes,
- 16:15when you're triggered, You're going to have distress. It's a biological reality.
- 16:18We could even frame it, not even necessarily in psychology. You could
- 16:22just frame it in terms of the brain and the nervous system. It's well
- 16:26established science. And so the person, because they're indoctrinated into her cult,
- 16:32the person's like, so, when I'm being triggered, is that a distortion
- 16:36or is that the truth? And then she says yes, Jody Hildebrant says,
- 16:40yes, it absolutely is a distortion. It's not the truth, which
- 16:42I'm guessing implies that the individual is not right with God or doesn't have enough
- 16:49strength to live in the truth to overpower their PTSD. Just the fact that
- 16:55she talked about playing a victim in the same sentence where we're talking about post
- 17:00traumatic stress disorder is extremely angering to me. Yeah, I mean, just
- 17:06think about all the people under her care who came to her having been recommended
- 17:11by the Mormon Church, by the community, and propped her up. And
- 17:17even when a few people might complain or want to complain because of the high
- 17:21control group, they can't complain. Just think about all the people that went
- 17:23to or over decades to Jody for help. And you know so many people
- 17:29go to therapy with PTSD, whether they know it or not, and that
- 17:34she, Jody Hildebrandt, has this point of view that if you're triggered or
- 17:38you're suffering in some way, that you're playing the victim. Yeah, I'll
- 17:52I'll flip my wig when I hear just a layperson say that shit a fucking
- 17:56clinician. Yeah. So I want to get to the comment that lehu or
- 18:06Aliyah left in full. The comment was, I can't stand that Jody was
- 18:14acting in her capacity as a therapist while proadly saying such unethical things and experiencing
- 18:19no consequences. As of two days ago, her license had been suspended pending
- 18:25the outcome of her case. I don't understand that, meaning that why is
- 18:30it just suspended? Why hasn't it just been revoked? Are the ideas that
- 18:33Jody is professing not grounds for revocation of her license? What about the standard
- 18:40of care? She literally, not figuratively, is telling us in her videos
- 18:45that she doesn't follow the standard of care, and the government Department of Licensing
- 18:49apparently could care less about these statements made by Jody. It is just infuriating
- 18:55and of comment. Yeah, So what I'll say to that, there's a
- 18:57lot that I could talk about, but very briefly, is that the government
- 19:03agencies that oversee the licensure of professionals they tend to underreact. You might have
- 19:11watched my videos on Jordan Pearson, and in those videos, what he was
- 19:15saying was they were overreacting to him, and a lot of his followers and
- 19:18even people who aren't his followers were saying that the agency was overreacting. And
- 19:23generally speaking, in my experience, these agencies underreact. They get a lot
- 19:30of complaints that are pretty obviously investigatable and worthy of providing sanctions to the licensee,
- 19:37to the clinician, and they don't do it, or the sanctions that
- 19:41they impose are minor. Like, for example, I did a whole episode
- 19:45a listener contacted me years ago about a case that she was in and it
- 19:51was legit. I actually looked into the case. And if you want to
- 19:53listen to those episodes, I think they're called a therapist kisses his client or
- 19:57something like that. Long story short. Over a number of sessions, this
- 20:03male therapist with a female client started with hugging and then with hand on her
- 20:11knee and then with like cuddling and then kissing her on the forehead, and
- 20:15then long session long hugging sessions while he would lay on top of her,
- 20:22and she, according to her account, was actually falling in love with him.
- 20:27Later she would realize that it wasn't love love, it was some form
- 20:33of cult and doctrination experience. But she complained and there was an investigation,
- 20:37and what the Department of Licensing did in this case was they suspended his license
- 20:45or put them on probation or something along those lines, and made him go
- 20:49to a bunch of trainings, and also he had to be overseen by a
- 20:52supervisor for a number of years. But eventually a year or two later,
- 20:57his license was reinsta and he was practicing again. To me, those individuals
- 21:03who exhibit that kind of judgment should just be excluded from the profession entirely.
- 21:07We just don't take the chance there's something wrong with the person that led them
- 21:12to the thousands of choices that led to that behavior. And you can't guarantee
- 21:18that you can negate whatever's wrong with that person's personality or the way that they
- 21:22think or something. It's hard to imagine that some trainings and some supervision would
- 21:27take that away. You know supervision, like if you're a supervisor at a
- 21:30McDonald's, you can watch someone as they're working. Supervisors in my field,
- 21:36we typically aren't there ninety nine point nine percent of time. As you know,
- 21:41I have supervis's, I'm not in the office with them. I depend
- 21:45on them reporting to me, the therapist that my supervis I depend on them
- 21:49telling me what happened in their week. And occasionally they will record their sessions
- 21:56video and I will watch them. But I don't have time to watch every
- 22:00single session every minute. I only watch snippets here and there. And So
- 22:03to have a therapist that did this sort of thing and then a year or
- 22:07two later they're under supervision, that unethical therapist, how do we know that
- 22:14they're not doing it again or doing something similar. So typically Department of Licensing
- 22:19underreacts. So the fact that they actually reacted to Jordan Peterson, it says
- 22:25something. And you could argue that they did too little. All they were
- 22:29saying was you need to attend a social media training, which I don't know
- 22:33what that meant, but it could have meant. It could have meant just
- 22:36like three hours or one hour or five hours or something. I mean,
- 22:40do we believe given everything that Jordan Peterson has done unprofessionally regarding his bigotry and
- 22:45I don't use that word lightly regarding trans people regarding you could argue women,
- 22:49and you could argue his attack on plus size women like on the swimsuit edition
- 22:56of Sports Illustrated. He didn't just talk about society. He attacked the actual
- 23:00bottle and said you are disgusting. You know, no, you're not beautiful.
- 23:04It's basically what he said in the tweet. Do we believe that a
- 23:08five hour training would have fixed the problem that is Jordan Peterson? No,
- 23:15we don't think so. If anything, the public should be saying, now,
- 23:21finally you're doing something, and it's only that that's the only thing all
- 23:25he had to do anyway, So yeah, le whu slash Aliyah. It's
- 23:30infuriating when you hear about a case like Jodiy Hildebrant because you don't have to
- 23:33look very deep within just what Jody has posted to say, yeah, let's
- 23:41revoke the license at the very least, because sometimes they'll revoke and reinstate right,
- 23:45they can always sometimes they'll work that into it, sometimes they won't.
- 23:49But given everything that's happened, and even independent of the criminal case, because
- 23:55you don't really know what's happening. People are innocent until proven guilty. But
- 23:57in terms of what Jody has said herself, I'm going to take a guess
- 24:02and say there's more than enough to say yeah, no license and never again.
- 24:06But in my experience, they tend to underreact. If anything, If
- 24:11you watched the movie or the series The Shrink next Door with Will Ferrell and
- 24:15Paul Rudd, it's about a true story. I actually did an episode reacting
- 24:21to the story a number of years ago before the TV series came out,
- 24:25and in that case, long story short, there were many complaints about a
- 24:30very unethical therapist in a different way than Jody Hildebrandt, and the New York
- 24:34Department of Licensing did nothing, did nothing, did nothing until this big podcast
- 24:40came out called The Shrink next Door, and then there was all this news
- 24:45coverage of it and questions about the Department of Licensing, and miraculously, that's
- 24:49when the Department of Licensing just decided to to do something. Now, I
- 24:53don't know exactly what's going through their minds. I don't know if they just
- 24:56have a bias, or they're underf you know, these organizations typically don't have
- 25:03a lot of funds, thus they don't have a lot of time to look
- 25:07into things, or if there are politicians that prevent them. I don't know.
- 25:11I don't know what's going on there, but they tend to do too
- 25:15little. So I'm not surprised that Jodie Hildebrandt has just had a suspended license
- 25:21according to Leyhu, and hasn't had it revoked. It's a problem. Do
- 25:26I think that eventually it'll be revoked. Yeah, I think that's likely because
- 25:30the truth is in this case, in this culture, it's the Mormon Church
- 25:36that sets up the rules, and the rules are for decades, if not
- 25:40centuries, well at least for fifty years. The Mormon Church typically has discouraged
- 25:48its members from seeking license mental health professionals. Okay, so we are watching
- 25:53the Mormon Stories podcast, which has been producing excellent content regarding this story and
- 26:02others, and I want to give a huge thank you to a YouTube commenter
- 26:07by the name of lay Who. Their real name is Aliyah, and they
- 26:12provided a lot of clips that I could watch, you know, because this
- 26:17interview is three hours long. But lay Who slash Aliyah provided very specific clips
- 26:23that I'm going to watch and comment on. So right here, what they're
- 26:27talking about is Jody Hildebrandt having been for decades a practicing therapist even though there
- 26:36were signs and allegations and accounts of her abusing children and promoting abuse of children,
- 26:44and how could that happen? Right? So, there's going to be
- 26:48a lot of discussion along those lines, and I have a lot of experience
- 26:52within different areas within this discussion as to whether or not Jody Hildebrandt should have
- 26:56had her license taken away because I been a therapist myself for twenty seven years.
- 27:02I have been a trainer of therapist, a professor, and a supervisor
- 27:07not only within the university, but also therapists that are working in the field.
- 27:11I have taught ethics and legal matters to my students and supervise that I
- 27:18have had the opportunity to talk on this YouTube channel often about it. It
- 27:21gives me a chance to look into all these legal cases. I have been
- 27:26asked to be an expert witness or provide consultation for people who are being accused
- 27:33of an ethical violation or clients who are accusing their therapist of an ethical violation.
- 27:37And I have colleagues who work in courts regarding that, so you know,
- 27:42I have a fair amount of expertise on this. So what they're talking
- 27:47about on the Mormon Stories podcasts, as alerted to me by Lehu slash Aliyah,
- 27:52is that what they're talking about right now is what systems allowed Jody Hildebrandt
- 27:57to be able to practic for so long without any sort of meaningful, helpful
- 28:03oversight, is what they're getting into, and instead has just encourage people to
- 28:08pray and fast and read their scriptures and maybe talk to your bishop. Right,
- 28:15So what he's saying is that in the more traditionally and when we talk
- 28:21about Mormons or the Mormon Church or Latter day Saints, we're talking about millions
- 28:26and millions of people that span the globe in hundreds of different cultures and languages.
- 28:33So it's hard to generalize. And I have had a lot of people
- 28:37in my life and clients who were Mormon, and I've heard varying accounts.
- 28:41I've heard on one end of the spectrum, Mormons who seemingly are not in
- 28:47occult and it's a very positive thing in their life. They have the freedom
- 28:51to leave perhaps or to question that the faith. So you have people in
- 28:56that end of the spectrum that I have known in my life. I grew
- 29:00up with a fair amount of Mormons. I don't know exactly why. East
- 29:03of Seattle is where I grew up, Bellevue, Sequah, that kind of
- 29:06region, and there's a fair amount of Mormons out there, I don't know.
- 29:10But anyway, so on that in the spectrum, and then on the
- 29:11other end of the spectrum, I've absolutely worked with clients and heard accounts from
- 29:17people who within the Mormon faith were absolutely in a high control group and were
- 29:22abused in a variety of ways. Families just completely split apart because one member
- 29:26just decides that they want to question the Mormon doctrine. And there's a lot
- 29:33of patriarchy and racism within the traditions of the Mormon Church. So, you
- 29:37know, I just want to say that upfront, But what he's saying is
- 29:41that traditionally, often within the Mormon Church, they will discourage their members from
- 29:45going into see a therapist outside of the church because it's such an intimate relationship
- 29:52with the therapist and there's a lot of potential influence and at least, it's
- 29:57a stereotype that therapists are not necessarily religious. They might even be considered by
- 30:03religious people like Mormon individuals. They might consider us to be of the devil
- 30:08because we don't talk about religion, or we give people the freedom, or
- 30:14there might even be this notion that because we follow science and we talk about
- 30:18the freedom to choose and those kinds of things that were actually anti religion,
- 30:25not only just neutral about religion, but anti. And what I'll say is
- 30:27that there's a wide variety of therapists. There are Mormon therapists who are ethical.
- 30:33They are Mormon therapists who are un ethical. There are secular therapists that
- 30:37are ethical and their secular therapists are unethical. It's kind of it varies.
- 30:41But the problem is is that when you have a high control group, a
- 30:44cult that denies its members the ability to seek outside advice, then you,
- 30:51as a cult, have total control over the narrative. When you do that,
- 30:56you're privileging a set of therapists, not because they're better, but because
- 31:00they adhere to your point of view of religion, because you're afraid of the
- 31:06outside world. That's what cults do. They make everyone afraid of the outside
- 31:11group. They're very concerned about the outgroup, and they're very concerned about the
- 31:15in group. There aren't those normal checks and balances, and so when you
- 31:18have that insular culture, it raises the risk a lot for a bad actor
- 31:23to be able to abuse all sorts of people. Now we know through the
- 31:32research that people from all religious backgrounds do prefer a therapist that comes from their
- 31:37own religious background. Usually. There's been a long history between the field of
- 31:41psychotherapy and religion being somewhat controversial and somewhat conflictual. And that makes sense because
- 31:48a lot of the principles that have to do with psychology are about self determination
- 31:52and a lot of the principles that have to do with religion have to do
- 31:56with community and external authority. It's weird sort of a both and in that
- 32:01in my anecdotal experience in my neck of the woods, I have seen almost
- 32:07an over emphasis of religion being within psychotherapy. For example, in the Seattle
- 32:14area, off the top of my head, most of the training programs,
- 32:17the universities, the colleges that train therapists are religious, are Christian. You
- 32:22have Seattle Pacific, which is considered to be I guess evangelical or contemporary Christian
- 32:30south of Seattle and Tacoma. I believe there's a Lutheran UNI university that trains
- 32:35therapists, or at least they used to. With Seattle Pacific, there was
- 32:37a controversy that the school, the university, was forcing the professors to sign
- 32:43a pledge that they were that they believed being gay was a sin or something
- 32:47like that. So imagine that that you're being trained as a therapist in Seattle,
- 32:52one of the most liberal places and frankly one of the most non religious
- 32:55places. Not that religion is bad, imagine that in Seattle that you have
- 33:01a university that is well respected and training a lot of clinicians that the professors
- 33:07have to sign a pledge saying that they I don't know the exact pledge,
- 33:10but it was seen by people that were criticizing it as basically a homophobic pledge.
- 33:16In today's day and age, it's just abhorrent. We understand that homophobia
- 33:22exists, but in a university one and two in a Seattle university, and
- 33:27three in a university at trains therapists, it's pretty awful. And I also
- 33:30want to say, as I've said before, I have worked alongside of even
- 33:35supervised therapists who consider themselves to be Christian counselors or Christian therapists, and we
- 33:42talked a lot about how they could integrate Christianity into their practice in an ethical
- 33:46way, and how they can advertise themselves as such, and how they can
- 33:52still honor the autonomy of the client. So there's a lot of variety,
- 33:55is the point. So on one hand, religion has always been very much
- 34:00overlapping with psychotherapy and psychology. But on the other hand, as she is
- 34:06getting at, I believe her name is Natasha Helfer, that it has been
- 34:10an opposition for some obvious reasons. What she's identifying is interesting. I don't
- 34:15think I've heard it that way, but it makes sense that in therapy and
- 34:19in psychology we tend to value individual autonomy to make your own life, to
- 34:25decide who you are, to make your own choices, and to decide for
- 34:30yourself what sort of moral values that you want to follow, and traditionally within
- 34:36religion it's the opposite, right, So those things are in opposition, but
- 34:42to me they don't have to be. And the Christian counselors that I supervised,
- 34:45they certainly didn't impose some sort of notion on their clients regarding that.
- 34:50These nineteen sixties, we had plenty of ecclesiastical leaders, including those from the
- 34:54LDS Church, that basically said psychiatry was evil. It was an evil thing.
- 35:00Do not go to a psychiatrist, because really the field of psychiatry you
- 35:02came before, this field of psychology as far as like the literature and all
- 35:07of that. Yeah, it's a very common thing, not only within religious
- 35:13groups, but just in the general public. There's a suspicion or anxiety about
- 35:17having medications infect your brain, which, yeah, we should be careful and
- 35:22we should not over diagnose or over depend on medications when other treatments might be
- 35:30safer and more effective long term. But to just write off the entire field
- 35:37of psychiatry is just mind boggling. It's similar when people say, you know,
- 35:42it's like a flat earth or that climate change isn't real. It's like,
- 35:46so, you have, it's a very robust discipline within biology and science
- 35:53and medicine that has been going strong and doing a lot of really great work
- 35:58for one hundred years plus. And to just say, yeah, the whole
- 36:01thing and so you know, you remember seeing this with Tom Cruise and scientology.
- 36:07Yeah, there's just something scary to cultish organizations that it's like, Ooh,
- 36:15there's this powerful group who could influence our members. We don't want that.
- 36:20And also I think it challenges their doctrine often that well, God can
- 36:25fix you. You don't need any other thing. God has all the answers,
- 36:30or our system has all the answers, and since we can't prescribe medications,
- 36:37we can't provide that service to you. It must not be valid or
- 36:40it is a competitor for your allegiance. You know, it's weird to think
- 36:46that they would think that if you have allegiance to psychiatry that somehow that would
- 36:52diminish the allegiance to the religion. I mean, the two can absolutely coexist.
- 36:57Were the types of things that would get a more Thing therapist off the
- 37:00LDS Family Services List? Well, for me, it was the blog post
- 37:05that I did in twenty twelve where I talked about masturbation being normative sexual behavior.
- 37:10It's different to have values against masturbation, but to also know that it's
- 37:15considered clinically normative behavior. That's very well put the way that she puts it.
- 37:21That scientifically, there's nothing wrong with masturbation. As long as it's not
- 37:25harmful to people, as long as it's not part of a compulsion or an
- 37:30addiction, then it's fine. There's a lot of positives that come from it.
- 37:35You don't have to do it, but if you are doing it,
- 37:37it's fine. But it's also fine if as a part of your religion that
- 37:42you believe that it's a sin or wrong or it's not good for your marriage.
- 37:46You can have that point of view for yourself. It's not wrong to
- 37:52not masturbate. It's not immoral to not masturbate. It's just a personal choice
- 37:58that you make. But for or the Mormon Church apparently it was wrong,
- 38:04not only for their members, but it's just wrong. The whole thing is
- 38:07wrong, and any therapists who suggests otherwise will be labeled as someone that is
- 38:13unsafe or not good or not worthy of us sending clients to. You should,
- 38:17as a therapist be able to hold those two realities. Many therapists cannot,
- 38:23and that's what gets us in trouble. We've all been through the same
- 38:25trainings every single program out there, whatever program Jodie Hildemrant went to to become
- 38:30a licensed therapist, she had to take ethics, and all of us have
- 38:35to take ethical training three hours every three years for the rest of our careers.
- 38:40That's all of us. Yeah, every state I believe has its own
- 38:45requirement. In Washington, it's actually more than that, but it's not enough.
- 38:52I've had a lot of classes and continuing education on ethics, and they
- 38:57certainly have helped these courses, but to really understand ethics and the law,
- 39:02I have had to spend a lot of time really on this podcast. People
- 39:07will ask me questions, and because I have the privilege of people being members,
- 39:13paying members, I can actually spend my work week actually investigating personally,
- 39:20just to kind of get my head around these things so I can talk about
- 39:22it with competence when I am speaking publicly, and in that process of many,
- 39:29many hours and talking with legal experts and all sorts of people. It's
- 39:34started to click rather recently, maybe in the last seven years or something.
- 39:39And this is after I had had two masters and a doctorate with all sorts
- 39:44of ethics, and I was teaching ethics at least I was teaching ethical concepts
- 39:47to my students, and it was sort of late in the game. It's
- 39:51hard, it's complicated, and the way that we teach ethics is in my
- 39:55opinion, not optimal. So there's a better way to accelerate that, in
- 40:00my opinion. And so you know what she's saying is we all come from
- 40:07the same system. Jody Hildebrandt got her degree in a regular accredited program.
- 40:13In all likelihoods, I'm just going to take your guests and say that that
- 40:15happened. It wouldn't be the reason to believe that didn't happen. And yet,
- 40:20even though we have that training, not everyone follows it or understands it,
- 40:23and one of their positions would get someone off the list. Well,
- 40:29the reasons I got excommunicated from the church was I supported gay marriage. The
- 40:32other reason is because affirming Well I haven't necessarily seen that necessarily explicitly stated as
- 40:43being off the list, But that's going to flag you, And what does
- 40:45that mean? It's just incredible. We're not talking about Westboro Baptist Church.
- 40:52If you're not familiar, it's a tiny little cult that is super homophobic,
- 40:57I mean just over the top. I think the congregation has you know,
- 41:01a few dozen people, maybe more, but it's this tiny little group of
- 41:06people that have a very loud voice. We're not talking about that. We're
- 41:08talking about millions and millions of people who are integrated within our society. They're
- 41:13living right next door to us, and they believe that masturbation or being bisexual
- 41:24or trans is wrong, immoral, a sin against God. It's just incredible,
- 41:34and they do so much to try to push us back into the Stone
- 41:39Age about this. I don't want to denegrate the Stone Age. They probably
- 41:43weren't as homophobic as these people are today. You know, they want to
- 41:46I don't know what they what they're trying to do. They're just hateful bigots
- 41:52who have this completely illogical I just don't understand it in twenty twenty three that
- 41:58you could still have this point of view in the United States. I just
- 42:00with the internet, with everything that is available to you. You know,
- 42:05thirty years ago you didn't have the internet. You could you didn't have a
- 42:08lot of contact with things. You know, gay people weren't necessarily on television
- 42:12very much as characters. I remember there was a gay character played by Billy
- 42:16Crystal in soap as a kid. I remember that was revolutionary in like the
- 42:22late seventies. I don't know if that holds up today, But point is
- 42:24is that back then there weren't a lot of opportunities to stretch your mind.
- 42:29Today. I mean, I just wish we could force all these folks like
- 42:35in Clockwork Orange, you know, you hold their eyelids open and you force
- 42:38them to watch just like three episodes of Queer Eye, and it just shoots
- 42:44them in the foot. It makes them irrelevant. You know, if they
- 42:47just adjusted like a lot of other churches do, they wouldn't be in such
- 42:52opposition with reality and the rest of the society. But of course the reason
- 42:58for this, in my stimation, is because they need to establish an in
- 43:01group and an outgroup, and this is one of the ways that they can
- 43:05do that. If they fear monger, right, and they just say,
- 43:07you know, they're trying to have sex with all of our kids, and
- 43:09they have all that mentality and that paranoia, then it just makes them more
- 43:15insular, and it makes the chrismatic leaders more powerful because they have more control
- 43:20over the members. It could have been anything. There just has to be
- 43:22some something that demarkets between us and them, and that detail that idea of
- 43:30being pro gay marriage or anti gay marriage is I guess what they decided to
- 43:36land on right, And it's just it's mind boggling. And like I said,
- 43:43if it was a small little group and I'm waking up. I knew
- 43:46that these elements were in my country, but I did not know the how
- 43:52prevalent it was. Religion is going down, but fundamentalism is going up.
- 43:58And I don't don't think I saw that. I knew religion was going down,
- 44:02but I thought that fundamentalism would also be going down. But it's the
- 44:06opposite. More. There are much more fundamentalists Christians the United States than there
- 44:10ever have been. And that's terrifying that we live in a group that we
- 44:16and I live in a country that's supposedly about freedom and progressing forward and social
- 44:22justice. That is what we were founded upon and what we've continued to bend
- 44:27the arc of justice towards. And yet we have this rise of this very
- 44:32powerful, very frothing at the mouth group of people that are insane. They
- 44:40just they don't know what they're talking about. And they're all just echo chambering
- 44:45each other and to this frenzy, and it's terrifying. It just it's will
- 44:52it ever go down? Or will it continue to get worse. And when
- 44:54we have that, then we have cases like the Jodie Hildebrant and Ruby Fra
- 45:00where they, in my estimation, were allowed not only to proliferate, because
- 45:06there are many more. You make no doubt about it. I have heard
- 45:08so many accounts and read so many news stories. Jody Hildebrandt and Ruby Frankie
- 45:14are one of tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of Chrismatic leaders and parents
- 45:19who are in this camp of promoting the abuse of children. It's a point
- 45:24of pride to them. It's a cult within a cult that comprises of many
- 45:29cults. It's not just Mormons, but it's the IBLP and the Evangelicals and
- 45:34maybe even other religions. I don't know. But it's this movement to abuse
- 45:38children and to make parenting great again, and it's happening all the time,
- 45:44and it's we need to do something about it. And a part of that
- 45:49is that our regulating bodies not only of child mistreatment and child welfare like Child
- 45:55Protective Services, but also the licensing board, like when the Licening Board goes
- 46:00after Jordan Peterson. These organizations need to be stronger, not weaker, They
- 46:07need more tax dollars, they need more leeway to monitor and do things.
- 46:12That's the answer that I think. Okay, let's go ahead and switch to
- 46:15parenting now, and let's hear what Ruby has to say about parenting. And
- 46:21I want to remind everyone that I am watching the Mormon Stories podcast YouTube channel.
- 46:27They have been following this story very thoroughly. How do you know if
- 46:32you are a controlling parent? What is it that you're going to look at?
- 46:38So we have this idea that controlling parents are parents who make their kids
- 46:43do something that the kids don't want to do. Did you know that a
- 46:46controlling parent is also a parent who doesn't expect anything from their children and allows
- 46:53the child to do whatever they want. That's also a controlling parent. Uh
- 47:02yeah, I mean so if I didn't know Ruby Frankie and I saw this,
- 47:07I'd be like, huh. But given that we know where she's coming
- 47:09from, she is probably reacting or trying to get out ahead of accusations that
- 47:16she's a controlling parent, and so she's just in this very silly way flipping
- 47:24it. So I said, it's like, no, I'm not you are
- 47:27kind of a thing. I'm not controlling a parent, you are, And
- 47:30so she's said, I'm just wondering how she's gonna twist this to make sense
- 47:35to herself. Being a parent is a position of power. You have a
- 47:39responsibility, and you have an obligation and a duty to show up being wise,
- 47:49being a guide, being an instructor for your child. Yeah, that's
- 47:55all true, But what about that initial statement of controlling parent. What is
- 48:00there such a thing as a controlling parent. I'm guessing to her there isn't,
- 48:05or I'm guessing that threshold is way too far in the direction of harm
- 48:08to children, And so this is her response to that. And cult leaders
- 48:14and chrismatic leaders and harmful people will have this format of rhetoric where they start
- 48:20with a legitimate question or a question that might be relatable, or a fact
- 48:23that might be relatable, and then they progress into their nonsense. And if
- 48:30you don't have the ability to decipher what they're doing, and you don't have
- 48:35a lot of education in this area, then it's very easy to be convinced
- 48:39because it's sort of a bait and switch thing where they start with something that
- 48:43is reasonable and that gets you into this mode of oh, I'm listening to
- 48:47something that's reasonable, and then then they proceed to slowly transition or sometimes quickly
- 48:52transition into their brainwashing of you. Essentially, politicians bad act and politics will
- 49:00do this as well. They'll say, like, you know, hey,
- 49:02you've heard a lot about climate change lately, and yes, it's possible that
- 49:08CO two emissions are going up and global averages of temperature are going up,
- 49:15but we really just have to ask ourselves what is the agenda of those people
- 49:21who are talking about this, and let's look at this, you know.
- 49:25Then they identify some actual news story of a disingenuous scientist who made up some
- 49:31data, and then they say, and then let's look at this tweet from
- 49:36this liberal who wants to take down the entire entire oil industry, or this
- 49:42terrorist who attacked this power station, and let's really look at what's you know,
- 49:46So you start with something that a lot of people can relate to.
- 49:50It's like, oh, yeah, I've heard of climate change, and then
- 49:52you start to feed the information and then before by the end, you've basically
- 49:58said climate change is silly and the liberals are idiots and terrorists, and I
- 50:04am now going to feed you the information that I want you to adhere to,
- 50:07which is that oil companies are awesome, and I want you to vote
- 50:12for me because the oil companies are paying me. I mean, it literally
- 50:15is what we're going through around the world right now. So for Ruby Finkey
- 50:19Reantws, she's like controlling parent, But controlling is also this other thing.
- 50:23And you're thinking, oh, really, controlling is also being passive, and
- 50:28you have a responsibility. It's all reasonable, right, And then what would
- 50:31follow this This statement is the most reasonable thing she said this far. It's
- 50:35like, yeah, you do have a responsibility as parent, absolutely, and
- 50:38what do we mean by controlling? But for her, we know what that
- 50:42means. She is abusively controlling. You know. Yeah, you have responsibilities
- 50:46to impose limits or to guide the child, to help the child understand where
- 50:52their rights and and other people's rights begin kind of a thing. Yeah,
- 50:57you need to do all those things, but you also have a responsibility to
- 51:00love your children and to teach them in a way in which they learn lessons
- 51:07that can actually be adhere to. When you just control children and you punish
- 51:12them constantly, then they're basically just acting out of fear. They're not making
- 51:15their lunch in the morning because they've learned some lessons about responsibility or about how
- 51:21to make lunch in the morning. They're making their lunch in the morning because
- 51:23they're terrified that they're going to be hungry and humiliated in front of all the
- 51:28other class mates and the teachers and on the internet. You know, they're
- 51:32acting out of fear. And yeah, you've taught them a lesson to be
- 51:37afraid of you and to fear your retribution, like you're Ramsey Bolton. You
- 51:42know, do we really think that theon Gray Joy learns some sort of good
- 51:45life lesson by being tortured by Ramsey Bolton. No, your children are showing
- 51:51up saying I won't do that. No, I don't want to. If
- 51:53you're in a position of power and you turn your power and give it over
- 51:57to the kids. That is everything she's saying, verbatim is I can get
- 52:04behind. I wouldn't word it that way, but some parents are harming their
- 52:09children by not having any sort of structure, by just letting their kids do
- 52:15whatever they want. I for a beginning, in the beginning of my career,
- 52:19did a fair amount of work with kids and teens and parents. I
- 52:23don't anymore, but I did back then, and as a part of that
- 52:27work, I would go into homes a lot of the times and I would
- 52:30just see how the family operated. It was very interesting because it was a
- 52:34big contrast with clients that would come into the office where they're all sort of
- 52:37buttoned up and on their best behavior, especially in the beginning. But when
- 52:42I would just show up at their house and knock on the door, a
- 52:45lot of the times, the parents would have forgotten that they paid the appointment.
- 52:49They'd be like, oh, yeah, that's right, you're here.
- 52:50And you know, the animals meeting the pets and the dogs we run around,
- 52:53and the cats and which I love, by the way, but it
- 52:58just adds to the to the charm slash chaos. The kids are running around
- 53:04and the toys and you know, just all the just regular life right.
- 53:07And one of the things that I would find sometimes pretty quickly was that the
- 53:13parent, for a variety of reasons, had almost no structure or very little
- 53:16structure. The parents or parent might almost be like just another kid in the
- 53:22house, and the kids just have total leeway to do whatever they want.
- 53:27They could be violent with their siblings, they could run across the street,
- 53:30they run into the kitchen and eat whatever they want. They don't do any
- 53:35chores. They don't clean their room, they don't do their homework, they
- 53:39don't go to ben on time. They eat a lot of junk food,
- 53:44They watch R rated movies when they're seven years old. They you know,
- 53:49just things that can and often do harm children, not only in putting them
- 53:54in danger by running cross the street or diet wise, but also they don't
- 54:00learn that there need to be limits. You know, there's a lesson learned
- 54:04every time you establish some sort of limit for a child, the child is
- 54:07given an opportunity to learn some sort of lesson. Hopefully, like they have
- 54:12an impulse to hit their sibling, but by helping them with their emotions and
- 54:16by having a limit like no, there's no hitting in this house, that
- 54:20they have to learn how to refrain from hitting, and they have to get
- 54:23to and if you're there helping them with their anger or whatever emotion they're having,
- 54:27then at the end of that whole process, they learn a lesson of
- 54:30regulation, of how to use their words, how to notice when they have
- 54:36those impulses. You know, yes, there's a lot of things that you
- 54:40need to do as a parent to help in parents that don't do that are
- 54:45harming their children. Absolutely, But what she is saying is, you know
- 54:50that example of a neglectful, harmful parent justifies being abusive to children. It's
- 54:57this huge leap, right, It's not like there's a middle zone between what
- 55:01Ruby does and what a neglecting parent does. Just said other than we do
- 55:10have a term that's called permissive parenting. So again she's kind of coming up
- 55:15with her own terms. Of course, we're supposed to be guides. Of
- 55:19course we're supposed to show up with wisdom. Of Course there's going to be
- 55:22some level of consequence or parenting styles, and they can differ as far as
- 55:28how you're going to you know, reward or have consequences or all of those
- 55:32things. But again it's a flowery presentation that basically ended in severe child abuse.
- 55:39Yeah, she should have her own YouTube channel. Natasha Helfer should have
- 55:45her own YouTube channel. She's much more concise than I am. So yeah,
- 55:52yeah, absolutely. Let's go and go to the next clip about parenting
- 55:54where Jodie talks about children acting out so many of us parents it's like,
- 56:00I don't want to have to track them down. I don't want to have
- 56:04to just, you know, like take everything away from them. And it's
- 56:06like you're not taking things away from them. What you're doing is you've handed
- 56:10them things that they're not managing, and so it's your job to make sure
- 56:16that the first thing they manage is themselves. I've seen this clip before of
- 56:22Jody Hildebrant, and I'm pretty sure what she's getting at is that she would
- 56:27be recommending to parents in her program that when the child misbehaves, according to
- 56:32her, that the parents take away things like take away their phone or their
- 56:38computer, or their toys, or their privileges or whatever, and maybe even
- 56:45take away their room like with Ruby, Frankie took away her son's entire bedroom.
- 56:51He had to sleep in the living room for a number of months on
- 56:54the floor according to him. And then so Jody would recommend that probably and
- 57:00then her clients would either react in the moment or later on and say,
- 57:04like, it feels like I'm just constantly taking stuff away from the children,
- 57:08that it doesn't feel good. Is this the right thing? That because the
- 57:12child's not doing so well that they're getting angry at me, And then Jody's
- 57:15saying, hey, you know, here's how you look at it. You
- 57:17look at it as I gave children these things, but it was temporary.
- 57:22It's not their things. You know. Their cell phone isn't theirs. I'm
- 57:25just letting them use it for a while, and I'm just taking things back
- 57:30so that they can know that they have to control them they you know,
- 57:32if they don't have control over their cell phones, if they don't have control
- 57:36over their privileges, we're going to take those away and they have to get
- 57:38control themselves. There's a lot of things I could say about this. There's
- 57:43a lot of different parenting practices. Can a parent who has an overall good
- 57:46approach to parenting, can a particular parent take away privileges, take away the
- 57:52phone, take away the computer. Yeah. Absolutely, you can integrate that
- 57:57into an overall parenting plan that we're for children. You can go too far
- 58:00with it, of course, but it is one of the things that you
- 58:04can do. You know, if a child, a fourteen year old child
- 58:07is getting bad grades and you notice that they're constantly on Snapchat or whatever kids
- 58:13are doing today, and you even see them late at night, at one
- 58:16in the morning, two in the morning under the covers on their phone,
- 58:21might you consider talking with them about you know, regulating that and possibly if
- 58:25they can't control it that for their own good, you're going to take it
- 58:28away or as a disciplinary measure. Yeah, absolutely, that's not bad parenting
- 58:32necessarily. There's a lot of other options, but you can absolutely do that.
- 58:37But what I think she's getting at is that it goes, of course,
- 58:40way beyond that, because of course the allegation and what seems to be
- 58:45in the evidence is that eventually she's taken away so many things and taken away
- 58:52so many privileges that you have very young children, elementary school children being tied
- 58:58up and duct taped and you know, not given any food, not given
- 59:01any water. So we know how far she takes this, and it sounds
- 59:07like she has a way of trying to convince parents to continue to go down
- 59:13those roads and maybe even convince herself that it's okay to do this sort of
- 59:15thing. Is video. We are going to be talking all about words.
- 59:20Now. Words are literally letters that are strung together that make a sound.
- 59:25How do I know that that's actually what that word means? Well, I
- 59:30would go to the source of truth. I would go to God to know
- 59:34what is the meaning of this word? And I so, if you don't
- 59:37want to have a baby, then do not use your agency to engage in
- 59:44sexual contact. Now, I know that nobody talks about that anymore, Like
- 59:50nobody, nobody, I don't hear that from anyone, like abstinence, abstinence
- 59:57that used to be around when I was a kid, obstinatece But nobody says
- 1:00:01that anymore because everybody feels like they have a right to just do whatever they
- 1:00:06want, and then they have these these consequences, these outcomes of STDs or
- 1:00:14pregnancy or you know, rape, and they they they don't want to take
- 1:00:22any responsibility for their participation in it. Oh my god. I mean I
- 1:00:28was already irritated by what she was saying at first, but that last bit,
- 1:00:34she's saying that if you are raped, it's your fault because you chose
- 1:00:38to be sexually active. I think what she's saying is if you engage in
- 1:00:43consensual sex, then you're opening the door to being raped. And it's actually
- 1:00:49quite the opposite, Jody. If you were following the standard of care,
- 1:00:53and we're up to date on the research, then you would know that what
- 1:00:59did Luke Skywark has everything you said there was wrong, So we start from
- 1:01:02the beginning that she says that, you know, people don't talk about absence
- 1:01:06anymore. Well, yeah, in the past, they might have talked about
- 1:01:09abstinence, but they weren't abstaining. You can talk about abstinence, but people
- 1:01:15don't abstain. It's like telling people not to drink water. It's a basic
- 1:01:19human need to have intimacy and sex. Not everyone needs it, but most
- 1:01:24people do, and it's a compulsion that we can't control, and you shouldn't
- 1:01:30try to. You should try to cultivate relationships in which you can meet your
- 1:01:34needs sexually, romance, intimacy, conversation. It'd be like saying to someone
- 1:01:39you can never talk to anybody. You need to abstain from talking to people.
- 1:01:45That would be hard to do. You would maybe be able to do
- 1:01:47it for a while, especially if you've been brainwashed since you were a child,
- 1:01:52but eventually you're going to slip up and have a conversation with them because
- 1:01:55we have a human need to have a conversation. We have a human need,
- 1:02:00most of us for sex. And when you have a brainwashed group of
- 1:02:05people that believe that having sex is somehow this horrible thing outside of marriage,
- 1:02:09then you get what you get. So she's saying, you know, people
- 1:02:12don't talk about ustading anymore. Well, yeah, I mean people do,
- 1:02:15but at least mainstream science and good public education doesn't, because they certainly do
- 1:02:22talk about I've taught sex said, we talk about abstaining, we talk about
- 1:02:28the reality of abstaining, we talk about the benefits of ubstaining, but we
- 1:02:31also talk about the benefits of having a consensual relationship as well. You know,
- 1:02:37if you want to abstain, go for it, and it is the
- 1:02:39most effective way to avoid all the sdis and the pregnancies and whatnot. But
- 1:02:44to force yourself to abstain when you don't necessarily want to abstain, then you
- 1:02:49get problems. Anyway, point is that the data shows that when you have
- 1:02:53programs sex education, programs that are only talking about abstaining and our abstinence only
- 1:03:01education is what's called. Data shows that. And it's hard to know exactly
- 1:03:05because you know, correlation does an equal causation, but from my memory,
- 1:03:08there's a fair amount of research strongly suggesting a causal element here that when you
- 1:03:14take a community of kids of teenagers and you teach absence only education, you
- 1:03:20see an increase in sdis you see an increase in childhood pregnancies. And the
- 1:03:24theory goes is that you don't give them any tools about how to navigate their
- 1:03:29needs, and so they just suppress and they say, Okay, I will
- 1:03:32abstain, and that's what I'm going to do. And so they just move
- 1:03:36on with their life and say, I'm just never going to have sex.
- 1:03:37I'm a good person, I'm a pure person. And then these needs are
- 1:03:43occurring for them, but they're pushing them out and put a shameful and then
- 1:03:47they find themselves in the backseat of a car with someone that they have a
- 1:03:51crush on, and all the needs just come pouring out and they have no
- 1:03:55ability to manage it because they haven't been told how to manage it. And
- 1:03:59then they don't use protection because they didn't bring any because that's sinful to have
- 1:04:02protection that admits that you're going to have sex. They might not have even
- 1:04:06had access to to, you know, to protection because their school or their
- 1:04:12church, or their community bans that from being exposed to children because that's child
- 1:04:16abuse. You know, to give a seventeen year old a condom. And
- 1:04:20so I'm saying that faceeaciously. I hope you know that. You know,
- 1:04:24it just comes bursting out and then boom, they have an SDI, they're
- 1:04:27pregnant, and then we get what we get. It's not like that doesn't
- 1:04:30happen outside of absence only education, but it seems pretty clear that it is
- 1:04:34a much higher rate of that. So all that is, of course idiocy
- 1:04:41what she is talking about, and has been known to be idiotic for decades.
- 1:04:44By the way, it's just so weird that in twenty twenty three people
- 1:04:47are still talking this shit. It's just so disheartening. You know, when
- 1:04:51I was young and in my twenties, we knew this was stupid, and
- 1:04:56I thought, well, surely by twenty twenty three it'll be over and no
- 1:05:00one will be talking about this anymore. But the politicians who were elected officials
- 1:05:03talking about this shit. It's just so disheartening anyway, So all that's stupid
- 1:05:09what she's saying, And then you know she's rattling sdis pregnancy rape. It's
- 1:05:14one thing to be stupid about the stuff that we've been talking about, another
- 1:05:16thing to say if you were raped, it's because you were not being you
- 1:05:24weren't abstaining from sex. I don't have to explain to you why that is
- 1:05:28not only just stupid, but abhorrent and evil, just evil. It's immoral.
- 1:05:32What she's doing is immoral. It is immoral, It is wrong,
- 1:05:39It is potentially against technically the Mormon religion. I don't know to actually suggest
- 1:05:45that someone who is victimized and harmed in that way that it is their fault
- 1:05:51because they were sexually active in a consensual way prior to that incident. That
- 1:05:59is moral evil statement. And why is it evil? Well, because I'm
- 1:06:04sure she knows, or at least she's been exposed to the data that when
- 1:06:10people, particularly young people, are sexually assaulted, that they will blame themselves
- 1:06:15and society will blame them. And we need to do everything in our power
- 1:06:19as clinicians, Jody, to be able to counter all of that culture and
- 1:06:25all of those internalized voices from culture. That's my fault. I shouldn't have
- 1:06:30a dressed that way, or you know, maybe it's I deserved it,
- 1:06:34or maybe this is a good thing, or whatever, all those brainwashed thoughts.
- 1:06:39We need to do everything in our power to counter that and to participate
- 1:06:44willingly in that oppression, in that harm of victims. Is just disgusting.
- 1:06:50It's truly disgusting. Now when I say rape, what I'm talking about is
- 1:06:56you engage in a sexual relationship and then you may say stop and the person's
- 1:07:00like, I'm not stopping, let me take what I want. I'm not
- 1:07:03talking about like someone attacks you and forces you. Oh she's elaborating, Okay,
- 1:07:11So yeah, just abhorrent, Just abhorrent. It's like if, hey,
- 1:07:17if you're in the backseat of a car and your partner and you are
- 1:07:21kissing, and then they decide to force you to go further than you want
- 1:07:28to, then hey, that's on you. Jesus Christ. H Yeah.
- 1:07:36Yeah. Twenty twenty three, people, twenty twenty three. When I was
- 1:07:43young in the seventies and I thought about, forget about twenty twenty three,
- 1:07:47just think about the year two thousand. I thought we would be so far
- 1:07:51beyond all of the ills of society. You know, I watched Star Trek.
- 1:07:58I just thought, not only would we be on multiple planets across the
- 1:08:01galaxy, but we'd have jet packs and hovering cars, and certainly all this
- 1:08:09nonsense would be gone because science and research and experts and knowledge, all this
- 1:08:18backward shit will be will be flushed down the toilet. Nope, apparently not.
- 1:08:27I'm talking about your participation. And then at some point you say,
- 1:08:30I don't want to do this anymore. She's a licensed therapist. I want
- 1:08:35to remind everybody. I mean, right now, our license has been suspended
- 1:08:41as of the time of recording this. But at this moment she is a
- 1:08:45practicing licensed therapist for decades, and her local religious organization is funneling countless clients
- 1:08:55to her. And these are public statements she's making on the Internet that she's
- 1:08:58not doing this behind closed she is doing this out in the open. It's
- 1:09:05just astonishing, and it's astonishing to me. You know, what she's doing
- 1:09:11is astonishing. But even more disheartening and more astonishing is that many many people
- 1:09:15worshiped her, not just loved her help or her philosophy, but and I
- 1:09:20don't use worship lightly. People thought she was this guru of parenting, that
- 1:09:26she had figured out all the answers, and she was this, you know,
- 1:09:30this oasis in a sea of secular ridiculousness. And yeah, it's just
- 1:09:36that's pretty upsetting because we can put Jody Hildebrant in jail, but what about
- 1:09:42all those parents, they're still out there, all right, Well that doesn't
- 1:09:45for that episode. Everyone please take care of herself because you deserve it,
- 1:09:48You really really do.