Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Anchoring Bias in Office Negotiations
Transcript
- Lucas: So you walk into a salary negotiation, and the hiring manager says, 'We're thinking around seventy-five thousand for this role.' Just like that, your mental range snaps to seventy-five. You might have been hoping for ninety, but now seventy-five feels like the centre of the table. Luna: And you leave thinking you did okay if you get seventy-eight. That's the anchoring bias in action. Lucas: Exactly. The first number that gets thrown out—whether it's a salary, a project budget, a timeline—it anchors the entire conversation. Research by Kahneman and Tversky showed that even random anchors, like a number from a spinning wheel, influence people's estimates. In negotiation, that effect can shift the final outcome by fifteen to twenty percent. Luna: So if you're the one who sets the anchor, you're basically drawing the playing field. But what if you're the one walking into someone else's anchor? Lucas: That's the tricky part. Let's say you're negotiating a contract with a supplier. They open with, 'Our standard rate is fifty dollars per unit.' Now every counter you make is in reference to fifty dollars. You're fighting uphill. But there's a move called the counter-anchor—you come back with your own number, backed by data. Luna: Give me a real case. Lucas: I talked to a procurement manager at a mid-sized logistics firm—let's call her Sarah. She was negotiating a three-year deal for warehouse shelving. The vendor opened at forty-two dollars per shelf unit. Sarah had done her homework: she knew the market average was thirty-five, and that a competitor had recently signed at thirty-two. So instead of haggling down from forty-two, she said, 'Based on comparable contracts, we're looking at a range of thirty to thirty-four dollars. Can you work with that?' She effectively reset the anchor. Luna: And what happened? Lucas: They settled at thirty-three fifty. That's twenty percent below the opening offer. If she had just tried to negotiate down from forty-two, she might have gotten to thirty-eight at best. The key was she didn't challenge the number—she replaced it with a new anchor. Luna: So the counter-anchor needs to be credible. You can't just throw out a lowball number because you feel like it. Lucas: Right. Credibility is everything. If Sarah had said twenty dollars, the vendor would have laughed and anchored back to forty-two. The counter-anchor has to be within a plausible range, ideally supported by market data, competitor quotes, or industry benchmarks. That's what gives it weight. Luna: And for low-power negotiators—say you're a junior employee negotiating a raise—you might not have that kind of leverage. What's the move? Lucas: You pre-load your anchor. Before the conversation, you do research on salary ranges for your role, your experience level, your region. Then when your manager says, 'We're budgeting a three percent increase,' you can respond with, 'I've looked at data from Glassdoor and the Bureau of Labor Statistics, and the median for this role is actually eighty-five thousand, which is about eight percent above my current salary. Could we align with that?' You're not attacking their number—you're offering a different reference point. Luna: That's smart. It's also less confrontational because you're citing external data, not just your own opinion. Lucas: Exactly. And here's a nuance: anchoring works even when the other person knows it's happening. In one study, real estate agents were given a list price for a house—some saw a high anchor, some a low anchor. Even though they were experts, their appraisals were still influenced by the anchor they saw. So don't assume that because you're dealing with a savvy negotiator, anchors don't stick. Luna: But there's a danger, right? If you anchor too high or too low, you might kill the deal. Lucas: Big risk. If you're selling a service and you quote a price that's way above market, the client might just walk. Anchoring requires calibration. You want to be ambitious but within the realm of reason. A good rule of thumb: set your anchor about fifteen to twenty percent above your target, assuming you have data to justify it. Luna: Let me ask you this—does anchoring work in non-monetary negotiations too? Like deadlines or scope? Lucas: Absolutely. Imagine your boss says, 'I need this report by Friday.' That's a deadline anchor. If you think you need two weeks, you can counter-anchor: 'Given the complexity, I think a more realistic timeline is two weeks from today. That would allow me to include the Q3 data and get a thorough review.' You're not saying no—you're resetting the timeline anchor. Luna: And if you're the one setting the deadline, you want to set it tight but not impossible. Lucas: Right. You want the anchor to be a stretch, not a fantasy. There's a great example from a product team at a tech company. They were launching a new feature, and the CEO said, 'Can we ship by end of quarter?' That was the anchor. The product lead knew they needed at least six more weeks. So she said, 'We could ship a beta by end of quarter, but the full release with all features would be stronger in mid-November. Which would you prefer?' She gave a choice that kept the anchor but offered a more realistic option. Luna: That's a nice move—it's not a direct counter, it's a reframe. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a softer version of counter-anchoring. It preserves the relationship while still shifting the range. Luna: Before we go further, I want to touch on something you mentioned earlier—ethics. Anchoring can feel manipulative. Where's the line? Lucas: The line is honesty. If your anchor is based on real data or a genuine rationale, it's fair game. If you're making up numbers or exaggerating, that's deception. The goal isn't to trick someone—it's to frame the conversation in a way that's favorable but truthful. For example, in salary negotiation, you might say, 'I have another offer at ninety-five thousand,' even if it's just a verbal offer. That's a legitimate anchor. But if you fabricate an offer, you're crossing a line. Luna: And once you're caught lying, you lose all credibility. Lucas: Exactly. Anchoring is a tool, not a weapon. Used well, it can help both parties reach a better deal faster because it narrows the range of discussion. Used poorly, it backfires. Luna: I want to circle back to something you said about low-power negotiators. Because I think a lot of our listeners are in that position—they're not the ones with the leverage. Are there any specific phrases or scripts they can use? Lucas: Yeah, one that works well is, 'I understand your perspective, but my research suggests a different range. Can I share what I've found?' That signals respect while introducing a new anchor. Another is, 'What if we looked at this from a different angle?' Then you present your data. The key is to depersonalize it—make the anchor about the market, not about your wants. Luna: And if the other person resists? They say, 'That's not how we do things here.' Lucas: Then you might need to anchor incrementally. Instead of one big counter, you chip away. For example, in a project timeline negotiation, you could say, 'I can't do Friday, but I can do Tuesday of the following week. Would that work?' That's still an anchor—just a smaller shift. Over multiple rounds, you can move the anchor significantly. Luna: It's like the boiling frog, but in reverse. Lucas: Exactly. Slow and steady. Luna: You know, this whole conversation reminds me why we keep these episodes ad-free. We want people to get practical, actionable advice without any noise. If you find value in that, and you'd like to support the show staying that way, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just if it helps. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small way to keep the lights on and the content free. Appreciate anyone who chips in. Luna: Alright, back to anchoring. One last thing—how do you defend against being anchored yourself? Lucas: First, recognize it's happening. If someone opens with a number, pause and say, 'Let me think about that.' That gives you a moment to detach. Then, before you respond, do your own research. If you have a pre-set anchor based on data, you're less likely to be swayed. Another tactic is to ignore the anchor entirely and state your own range: 'I'm not sure that's the right framework. Let me share what I had in mind.' Luna: So the defense is essentially to counter-anchor. Lucas: Exactly. The best defense is a good offense. Luna: I love that. Any final takeaway for our listeners? Lucas: Just this: in your next negotiation, whether it's about money, time, or resources, think about who sets the first number. If it's you, you've already won half the battle. If it's not, don't just react—reset.