Latest / Resilient Kid: Therapy and tips for raising strong kids and teens / The Gap Between Education and Emotional Wellbeing
Transcript
- 0:00The gap between education and emotional well-being.
- 0:05Why resilience support isn't optional anymore.
- 0:08So hello and welcome back to Resilient Kid podcast with me,
- 0:12Ashley Costello. This week feels really
- 0:16reflective for me. As you know, if you're on the
- 0:19newsletter, my youngest turned 16 at last year of school.
- 0:24He's 6.2, thoughtful, handsome and on the edge of becoming a
- 0:28man and we had his friend stay over big family party.
- 0:33It's been a quieter week at home and since the weekend, since the
- 0:38craziness of the weekend and I was watching him and he was, you
- 0:44know, he's been making dinner, it's half term is helping clean
- 0:48up. He's popping next door to see
- 0:50his Nana, the whole thing. And, you know, it really made me
- 0:54think, who are we building the education systems for because,
- 1:01well, are we building a system that nurtures young people and
- 1:05who they're trying to become or are we asking them to constantly
- 1:10adapt under pressure? Now, before I go any further, I
- 1:14want to be very clear. Schools, I want to say schools
- 1:19are not failing. I want to say that they are
- 1:25stretched. I'm not sure that I can say both
- 1:29of those. I do absolutely think schools,
- 1:32the budgets, the teachers are stretched beyond belief.
- 1:37Are they failing in the most part?
- 1:41Some yes are. I think they don't do that.
- 1:45They do it intentionally, no. And I think that distinction is
- 1:49really important because what I'm seeing when I go into
- 1:53schools, the schools that we train in, the families that we
- 1:56support, the young people that we work with isn't a failure of
- 2:01care. It's a capacity issue.
- 2:04It's the pressure. It's the that pressure that the
- 2:08teachers that the kids are under, that the system under is
- 2:12creating a gap. The reality schools are facing,
- 2:18and we kind of see this all the time through the CPD work that
- 2:21we do, the resilient school training that we do, is rising
- 2:26anxiety in primary age kids, emotional dysregulation and that
- 2:31presents as behaviour often staff carrying huge emotional
- 2:37containment demands, increased neurodiversion identification
- 2:43and those kids masking hugely and then performance pressure
- 2:50filtering down from staff to teens and just going younger and
- 2:56younger. So teachers are not just
- 2:57teaching, they are regulating nervous systems, they are
- 3:01mediating social conflicts, they are observing emotion,
- 3:05observing, absorbing the emotion that is pent up in that
- 3:09classroom. And they are often the only safe
- 3:13adult in that room of what can be up to 3030 or kids.
- 3:18And they're tired. And I think by this time of
- 3:22year, half term, February, half term, you can feel it.
- 3:25Children are tired, staff are tired and we as parents are
- 3:29tired. And for me, the system is
- 3:33structured. It's structured around
- 3:34academics, assessment, safeguarding, performance.
- 3:38But where's the emotional regulation?
- 3:40Where's the preventative resilience work?
- 3:43Where's that shared language between home and school?
- 3:47And that's why for me, a lot of our job is to be the advocate
- 3:53for the child or the teen in that school setting, to be the
- 3:59advocate because there's a gap. There's just that gap.
- 4:03And, and what we're doing is we're not seeing the kids, we're
- 4:06not seeing or meeting them where they're at.
- 4:10We're not listening to the kids. That's for sure.
- 4:12You know, for me, that emotional well-being gap, we know we have
- 4:16behavioural policies in school curriculum frameworks, Ofsted
- 4:20standards, safeguarding protocols, I could go on all
- 4:22day. But what we haven't embedded is
- 4:26the emotional scaffolding that these kids need.
- 4:31I feel like I'm banging the same drum that I was when I did my
- 4:35TEDx talk in 2019 in the fact that, you know, yes, we're using
- 4:42computers, yes, we can use technology.
- 4:46Why is it then we are still learning information by rote
- 4:53when we can look it up in 0.5 seconds?
- 4:56Why are we not teaching these kids emotional regulation tools?
- 5:03We often left reacting to crisis rather than building a capacity,
- 5:11building a school that is safe for the staff, safe for the
- 5:15kids. And when I mean safe, I mean
- 5:18psychologically safe. You know, and we delivered some
- 5:21training last week in a school and I said psychological safety
- 5:26and one of the SLT went, oh, that sounds really harsh.
- 5:29And actually, you know, what do we mean by that?
- 5:32What do we mean by psychologically safe is where
- 5:34people have someone to turn to. They have a key person.
- 5:39You think we we pluck these kids out of primary where they have
- 5:43the same teacher all year. If they fall and cut their knee,
- 5:47they know who to go to. If they hurt themselves, they
- 5:50know who to go to. If they're if somebody else has
- 5:52hurt them, if they are upset about something, if they've lost
- 5:55something, if they don't know how to do something, they have
- 5:58got that safe adult. They know exactly who to go to.
- 6:01And everybody in that school knows their name.
- 6:04Everybody in that school knows their family.
- 6:07And then yet what we do is we put them into this senior slash
- 6:12high school setting where they have gone from 1 of 200 and odd
- 6:16kids to there's that many in their year group and now there's
- 6:201500 kids in the high school. They are mixing with various
- 6:25different ages. A lot of them that they don't
- 6:28know, a lot of the teachers don't know them until they start
- 6:33moving up through the years. And it's in a noisy environment
- 6:39that is often narrow, low ceilings, bright lights.
- 6:45Everybody goes to lunch at the same time.
- 6:48They might all have various designated areas to hang about
- 6:53in at lunch on outbreak, but do you know that I would
- 6:58guesstimate 75% of our kids don't sit down to eat their
- 7:02lunch? And I've just paused there
- 7:04because actually that's hit me just as much and I'm in a school
- 7:08every day. We are often encouraged to sit
- 7:11down and eat with our families. Sit down with your kids, chat
- 7:15over the day. Don't do that at school.
- 7:19Absolutely. We don't do that at school.
- 7:21They go, they grab and go their lunch.
- 7:23It's a wrap, it's a plastic container.
- 7:26They're eating fish and chips. They're eating, you know, wrap,
- 7:29salad bar, jacket. Whatever it is, it's in the
- 7:31hand. There is very few of our kids
- 7:34actually sitting down with their friends and eating together.
- 7:36There is no adults that I know of that sit down with those kids
- 7:40and eat in a school setting. That to me, those kind of things
- 7:46we're asking our kids to put up with.
- 7:52I was going to use a different phrase then, but put up with is
- 7:54exactly right. Those kids are putting up with
- 7:57this. We're making them adapt to what
- 7:59we need. And actually, it's not fair and
- 8:02it's not right. You know, we're having to
- 8:07support children where they're already overwhelmed with the day
- 8:11we refer when things are already escalated.
- 8:16What if we weren't reactive? What if we built in resilience?
- 8:22What if it was preventative? Because this is what we know
- 8:26from research during the teenage years, that part of the brain
- 8:30that seeks excitement and intensity and it develops
- 8:33faster, you know, than the part responsible for impulse control
- 8:39or long term thinking. So we have these big feelings,
- 8:43big reactions, big risks and without fully developed breaks.
- 8:49Now let's add on. Let's look at the layers to this
- 8:55accident pressure, social comparison, online exposure.
- 9:00And just as a side note, there is a big campaign led by lots of
- 9:04people, Esther Grey, friend of friend of Brazilian kid Jo
- 9:09Frost, Lots and lots of people are calling for a social media
- 9:12ban until the 16. OK, it's not just about
- 9:17exposure. We need to be looking at what
- 9:20our little ones, the technology that they're using too.
- 9:24I'll get back reduced creativity outlets when we're when we're
- 9:30little and we have those creative outlets.
- 9:34It is amazing. And what it does for the brain,
- 9:36how it why is it how it fires? It is absolutely fantastic.
- 9:41And actually, that's all reduced once they're going to school.
- 9:44And there is a huge fear around failure as well because we
- 9:49compare, you know, we constantly get the kids to compare to each
- 9:52other. So it's not surprising we're
- 9:54seeing burnout younger and younger.
- 9:57And it's not, you know, burnout used to be a word that we would
- 10:01talk about corporate adults. Not anymore.
- 10:04We're seeing this in year 6. And it's terrifying.
- 10:09We're seeing highly functioning anxiety in teens who look fine
- 10:15on paper because academically they're doing OK, but they're
- 10:20absolutely exhausted. And this isn't about blaming
- 10:23schools, like teachers are doing the best that they can in a
- 10:28system that is simply broken and not fit for purpose.
- 10:32But we have to acknowledge the weight of the young nervous
- 10:36systems that we're carrying, You know, and I think I just spoke a
- 10:41little bit about creativity. We know Sir Ken Robinson talked
- 10:47about this all the time. You know, I don't think schools
- 10:51set out to suppress creativity intentionally.
- 10:55But when performance becomes more visible than curiosity,
- 10:59when testing becomes more urgent than exploring, when time
- 11:03pressure reduces play and risk taking, then something gets
- 11:07squeezed. And creativity requires feeling
- 11:11safe. It requires room to experiment,
- 11:15tolerance of mistakes and space. And actually, the classrooms
- 11:19getting smaller and smaller and there's more and more kids
- 11:21getting in them. So, you know, under constant
- 11:26evaluation of kids, creativity narrows very, very quickly.
- 11:31We know in high schools used to have DT, you know, designer
- 11:35technology would work for those of my age.
- 11:38You know, we used to do home economics where you would do
- 11:41cooking, used to do music and drama, and they all used to run
- 11:48alongside each other. Now you should get six weeks of
- 11:511, then you change six weeks of another and six weeks.
- 11:55You know that. And it's not because teachers
- 11:57don't value it, but because our systems reward measurable
- 12:01outcomes. And so we have young people
- 12:04adapting beautifully for the most part to a structure until
- 12:09they don't. And then they lose connection to
- 12:12who they are, to that curious part of themselves, to the part
- 12:16that. And that's the part that
- 12:18concerns me most, because when identity becomes performance
- 12:22based, mental health becomes very, very fragile for our young
- 12:27people. Very fragile.
- 12:30Why is it, do we think then just some young people disengage from
- 12:35school? Well, it's rarely because they
- 12:38don't care. It's more often than not because
- 12:41they feel misunderstood, because they feel not academic, because
- 12:45there's not an outlet for those kids who are not scoring the big
- 12:49numbers in exams. They feel chronically
- 12:53overwhelmed. They don't feel see, they don't
- 12:57feel heard. And in honesty, in my
- 13:01experience, talking to these young people, listening to these
- 13:04young people, they feel like they're the problem in school.
- 13:09And when belonging feels threatened, that's when the
- 13:13behaviour shifts and that's when you get those kids who can't go
- 13:18to school, right. We talk about school refusal.
- 13:21I think it's rarely refusing to go to school is they can't go to
- 13:26school. They don't feel safe enough to
- 13:28go to school, you know, and school is a place that we should
- 13:34feel like we belong. Like everything in US is pulling
- 13:38away from parents and identifying with that peer
- 13:40group, identifying that this is this is my drive.
- 13:45Belongings, not a reward. It's a nervous system need.
- 13:49It's a, it's a DNA need that we have.
- 13:53And if that need isn't met consistently, that's where
- 13:58anxiety rises. They get defensive, they avoid.
- 14:03Its avoidance is a stress response.
- 14:08It's an absolute stress response.
- 14:09And that gap widens. Now, you know, there's part of
- 14:14me who says we don't need to dismantle this system.
- 14:18We don't need to tear it down. And there's part of me that
- 14:20goes, Oh, my God, we've got to start from scratch.
- 14:24But what I know is that we have got to strengthen that emotional
- 14:27scaffolding around it. We need a shared language
- 14:32between home and school. We need staff that are trained
- 14:38in emotional containment. We need to like think about
- 14:44preventative measures, preventative resilience,
- 14:48teaching practical tools they can use everyday, the teachers
- 14:53and the kids and not just a theory around this and support
- 14:59for the adults just as much as the children.
- 15:03So when I was in a school in Abu Dhabi, I had I was very lucky
- 15:10that my immediate boss that my line manager had a background in
- 15:14psychology. Hi Nicola, if you're listening
- 15:17and she was really forward thinking, the principal not so
- 15:23much, but she would give me kind of carte blanche into taking
- 15:29programmes into the younger years.
- 15:31She would, you know, help me help the staff and their
- 15:37well-being. There was 2000 of us in this
- 15:41huge, huge school, 200 staff, 1800 kids from 2 1/2 up to 21.
- 15:47And you know, it was just as important that the staff had
- 15:51access to me as a psychotherapist as it was the
- 15:56kids. Now you think 2000, how do you
- 15:59fit them all in? Well, we did a lot of
- 16:00preventative work in the younger years.
- 16:03We did a lot of preventative work so that as they grew, they
- 16:10weren't needing us, but actually the staff well-being meant that
- 16:16their first port of call was to go to teachers or teaching
- 16:19assistants, not come directly to me.
- 16:22So it meant that preventative work was really good, but it
- 16:26also meant we looked after the staff so they could help the
- 16:30kids as well. You know, and I will credit my
- 16:35work in that school is why I created the Resilient Kid
- 16:39framework, because I could see how it worked on every age group
- 16:46and, and how we supported how we, you know, how we met the
- 16:51kids, where they were at, how we supported the staff in the role
- 16:54that they did, You know, and, and I think, I wish, I wish we
- 17:00didn't need a service like ours or I wish this service was for
- 17:04everyone, you know, but I wish there wasn't a need.
- 17:08We're not here to replace schools.
- 17:10We're not here to criticise schools.
- 17:13You know, we're here to fill that gap.
- 17:16We're here to partner with those schools.
- 17:18I'd say the biggest part of my jar is advocating for those kids
- 17:22in school, without a doubt educating the parents and yeah,
- 17:26working with the kids, you know, and, and that's the, that's the
- 17:30fun part for us. That's the to see their change,
- 17:33to see, you know, to, to sit down with a young person,
- 17:36irrespective of age and really see them is, is a privilege, you
- 17:41know, but for me, I want to give the schools the practical tools
- 17:44for regulation, for belonging, for confidence, for resilience,
- 17:49you know, help parents understand what's happening
- 17:52developmentally and to support the kids before they get into
- 17:57crisis, irrespective of age. And this is where for me, it
- 18:01gets interesting because if you're listening to this and you
- 18:06work in education or therapy or coaching or youth support, and
- 18:10you've had that feeling, that sense of we could be doing more,
- 18:15you're not imagining it because there is a gap.
- 18:18There is an absolute gap and gaps create opportunity, not
- 18:22opportunistic, you know, opportunity in a leadership
- 18:27sense, opportunity to build emotional infrastructure around
- 18:31education, opportunity to create that consistency within that gap
- 18:37and to change outcomes long term because that's what we're doing
- 18:41and we're growing because the need is growing.
- 18:43And what I would say to you is if you're listening to this as a
- 18:47teacher, as a head, as ATA, as a family support worker, you'll
- 18:54know what I'm talking about. You're in the system, work in
- 18:58the system, and you see those gaps all the time.
- 19:01And we see you, we see that hard work.
- 19:04So to finish off, as I watch my son this week 16 steady becoming
- 19:11himself, I realised something. It didn't become this version of
- 19:15himself because of pressure. He became this version of
- 19:19himself, which will change because of this part around him,
- 19:23because of the people that turned up for his party, because
- 19:27of his friends, his tribe that he belongs to, because of
- 19:31conversations that he's had, because boundaries that have
- 19:35been held with connection. You know, I often get that call.
- 19:39Your kids are really well behaved.
- 19:40Oh, no, no, not always. But actually, it takes hard
- 19:43work. But what I would say to you is
- 19:46this system matters, but the scaffolding around that matters
- 19:52so much more. And if we want confident,
- 19:56emotionally intelligent young people, resilience can't be an
- 20:00afterthought. It has to be intentional, and it
- 20:04has to be preventative. So thank you for this short
- 20:08sharp episode for listening. Whether you're a parent, a
- 20:12teacher, or a professional, I'd love to carry on this
- 20:14conversation. So please get in touch.
- 20:18Drop me a message, Ashley at the Resilient kid.co.uk or comment
- 20:23underneath. But we'd absolutely love to
- 20:26continue this conversation. And if you fancy, if you are in
- 20:29the system, working in the system and you want to be part
- 20:33of the conversation, drop us a message.
- 20:35Come on the podcast, we'd love to have you.