Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 13. Just because you make more money doesn't mean you make all the decisions: Dave Kramer uncut
Transcript
- 0:00And also to remember that just because I make the most money doesn't mean I make all the decisions.
- 0:06It should always be shared decision-making in a romantic relationship.
- 0:10Whatever happens in your organizations with your pay packet and your decision-making is completely separate to your relationship and your decision-making in that romantic partnership.
- 0:19So I would say regardless of that, because with you out there working 12 days on, five days off in a mine...
- 0:28It's, your partner is at home taking care of the children and the life and the house and everything else that's going on at home.
- 0:35That's a shared partnership both of you are doing.
- 0:38If they weren't doing that, then potentially you wouldn't be able to take all that time at the mine or in the job that you're doing.
- 0:45So it's important to remember that this is always shared.
- 0:47The whole partnership is shared.
- 0:48So the decision should be shared.
- 0:52I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick, I'm a former senior bank executive now working with companies, governments and regulators to change the way financial products are designed.
- 1:01This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask, before you share your money, your accounts or your digital life with someone you love.
- 1:13So before you say yes to sharing your financial life, listen to this.
- 1:20Yeah, my name's Dave Kramer.
- 1:21I'm a facilitator of conversations around respect and respect for relationships in school, in high school.
- 1:27And I also am an advocate for safer men within society.
- 1:31And I do that because I believe that all men and all boys can play a role in contributing to a safer culture for all people.
- 1:37And how did you come to do this work?
- 1:39I came to do this work because I was studying psychology back in 2018.
- 1:44And then midway through the degree, my best friend, Hannah Clark, and her three children were all murdered by Hans' ex-partner and the children's father.
- 1:52And I also knew the man who took their lives.
- 1:55And I reflected a lot on my relationship to that man and the role I could have played in preventing what happened.
- 2:01While I take no responsibility for what happened, I take a lot of responsibility for the lessons I've learned, especially through understanding behavioral science and psychology and understanding, you know, the role that has largely been absent for a lot of men in society who think we're doing good things.
- 2:15There's a lot more we can do, and I just try to call forward more good men to do better things.
- 2:21First of all, I'm really sorry for your loss, and I thank you for all the work that you do and bringing your
- 2:29your professional capabilities and your personal experiences to advocate for this work and I really like to dive in how you're doing that and the conversations that you're having and your reflections on what's going on for young men and boys and older men as well when you're talking to men and boys about relationships and about money what do you see?
- 2:54Yeah, it's an interesting spectrum of experiences and beliefs, attitudes that come up when it comes to it.
- 3:01If I think about men who I work with, what I see a lot is genuinely a sense of pride in being able to be a provider, being able to provide for their family.
- 3:08I spend a lot of time in mining construction or in defense or in places like that where they're like, you know, I'm working a hard job and I'm bringing home money for my family and surviving in an economy that is…
- 3:18trickling downwards.
- 3:20And so they're genuinely very proud of that.
- 3:23But I also see this kind of belief that comes with it that because I make the money, I'm in charge, and I should make all the decisions that revolve around it.
- 3:30And interestingly, with young men or with boys, I see a really...
- 3:36kind of being sucked into the old school beliefs around, gendered beliefs around money, right?
- 3:43As a man, like if I ask them what is the role that a man should play in the home to a group of high school students, they'll say provider straight away.
- 3:51And if I dig deeper on what that means, they'll say make money.
- 3:54It's not provide a safe home.
- 3:56It's not provide emotional stability.
- 3:57It's not provide a space for people to talk about problems.
- 4:00It's provide money, and that's kind of it.
- 4:02And then you talk more about the role they should play in the relationship, and they'll say decision-maker, dominant, in charge.
- 4:09And it's not necessarily saying that all these boys are going, that's the path I'm going to walk, but that's all the stuff that they're seeing.
- 4:14It's what they're being told they should be, and it's kind of –
- 4:17what they're starting to see, this is what's going to make me a good man.
- 4:21Because that's their goal.
- 4:22They want to be a good man one day and they want to be a good provider and a good person.
- 4:26Unfortunately, though, sometimes particular algorithms can corrupt what that looks like.
- 4:31And then they find themselves in really challenging spaces.
- 4:33So the conversations we have is how do we navigate that space together so we can have equal partnerships and fair relationships while still being able to live up to someone who can provide and support their family in a range of different ways.
- 4:44Yeah, I'm sure no one grows up and says, I'm going to just have all this weight all over me that I need to be a good person that is under so much stress.
- 4:57It must put a lot of stress on people if they're thinking it's all on me.
- 5:03Yeah, it does.
- 5:03It does.
- 5:04Because I talk about this because they often...
- 5:07Like, it sounds good, right, to be a provider and a protector, make lots of money, drive a big and fast car, have a mansion.
- 5:14Like, all that sounds really cool until you realize, oh, man, that's hard.
- 5:17There's a lot of pressure on me to be able to do that.
- 5:19And then the message they get underneath it is if you struggle, you're on your own.
- 5:24No one cares, especially for men and boys.
- 5:26They are getting – and this isn't coming from –
- 5:29people who advocate for equality.
- 5:30This is not coming from people who believe in men's rights.
- 5:35This is coming from people who have looked at a system that says, this system tells men to shut up and deal with it.
- 5:40And we're going to use that to make them feel inadequate.
- 5:42So they buy my product or my service or whatever it is so that ultimately this influencer or whoever it is can get rich.
- 5:48So boys are getting messages that say, if you struggle with this whole get rich and provide one day,
- 5:54shut up.
- 5:55And then they're kind of deflecting all of that emotional insecurity or that struggle with what they're going through onto other people.
- 6:04They're not looking at their mates and going, hey, man, you're struggling with something.
- 6:07Are you okay?
- 6:08They're looking at maybe women or girls and saying, hey, I'm struggling.
- 6:12This is your fault.
- 6:13Because that's basically what these people are trying to tell them.
- 6:16Yeah, that's an awful environment to be living in.
- 6:21You know, I'm a mum.
- 6:22I've got two children, a girl and a boy, who are both young adults now.
- 6:30And I've watched them, particularly during COVID, being involved in this system and
- 6:35and then trying to find their own way in the world with all of this shouting at them.
- 6:41And have had lots of conversations and one of them, one with my son, is really what brought me to do this work myself and then also this podcast that I want to talk about.
- 6:52Before you say yes, have a think, pause, and how are you thinking about consent?
- 6:58How are you thinking about money and relationships?
- 7:01Yes.
- 7:02What are you teaching people in that approach about if you've got all of these different messages coming at you all the time,
- 7:14Where do you start the reflection?
- 7:16I think it's a good point because as I'm sitting here, I was just reflecting as I was speaking about that.
- 7:21Young people are incredible advocates for themselves and they can see the nonsense online.
- 7:26They're not morons.
- 7:28They're very, very clever, great advocates for themselves.
- 7:30So when they see all these messages, it's not like they're just saying they're going, oh, yeah, for sure.
- 7:34That's what I'm going to do.
- 7:35Or I have to believe this.
- 7:36They're kind of testing it and pushing boundaries and then going, you know, I don't really like this and trying to move away from it.
- 7:42But then when you're in a culture or maybe in a school where lots of people are trying to push those same beliefs or you have relationships where someone might be trying to enforce those beliefs, that's when it becomes really tricky and challenging.
- 7:53So the conversations I have is how do we advocate for each other when we notice that this stuff is happening, right?
- 7:58When we come to a school...
- 8:00or we're going to school and we notice that someone might be talking about how they've got to buy their girlfriend something because she said something about him not buying her nice things or something like that.
- 8:14Or potentially a conversation where a mate might be saying,
- 8:18oh yeah, she's out there, she thinks she's so good because she's got this job, she makes all this money, but maybe that's coming from a place where he's feeling insecure about the fact that he's been told he's supposed to provide, he's been told he's supposed to make more money, but she does.
- 8:32So it's how do they have that conversation around, I guess, the emotion and the challenge they're having with that emotion underneath and then get support.
- 8:39I think when we're working with high school students or young people,
- 8:44I don't want to give them all the responsibility of fixing and being that emotional support and constant support of someone who might be struggling who's young.
- 8:53I mean, we go through stuff for the first time a lot in high school.
- 8:56Everything is almost for the first time.
- 8:58So I can't really support someone who's going through something I've either never been through or I've only been through once.
- 9:04So I'd rather go seek support from my school guidance counselor, maybe pastoral care workers, whoever there is in my school who can have that conversation, help me navigate it better.
- 9:13Yeah, and you also work in workplaces as well.
- 9:17Can you tell me about what that looks like?
- 9:20Yeah, I think it's the same thing because I guess with my role, it's to go in and start the conversations, start the critical reflection.
- 9:28I speak from a prevention of discrimination, harassment, abuse from a workplace cultural perspective.
- 9:37So it's very much in the beginning of the line where we might hear comments in the workplace.
- 9:41So it's when I recognize those types of comments, if they're generalized about women, women are gold diggers and all this stuff.
- 9:47How do I hold my mates accountable there and say, hey, fellas, we shouldn't be saying that sort of stuff.
- 9:51Or come on, we're better than that.
- 9:52We don't believe that about women.
- 9:54Or come on, man, you respect women.
- 9:55That's not something you would say about someone you respect.
- 9:58And then if we notice those things continuing, then who can we seek for support?
- 10:02Again, it could be the EAP or the external assistance provider, or it could be HR, or it could be someone who can help this person deal with that sort of thing.
- 10:10So a lot of the conversations I have are about the language we hear that might indicate that this person has particular beliefs or attitudes about either their relationship or about a group of people in general, and then how do we hold them accountable to that?
- 10:23then seek support if we need further support.
- 10:26You have talked about, you know, hearing something that might make you feel a bit uncomfortable, but maybe letting it slide a little bit and then what that might lead to, because it can become a bit of permission for somebody.
- 10:41Can you tell me a little bit about that and what that looks like?
- 10:45Yeah, often what we speak about is violence on a continuum rather than violence just happening one day out of the blue that no one expected.
- 10:53And usually that's how it's portrayed.
- 10:56We see a lot of behaviors that happen first, and that might start with sexist language and jokes, rigid gender beliefs about what men should be or what women should be.
- 11:05Then that might move towards something like objectification of someone saying that they're, you know, they're too unintelligent to manage money.
- 11:13They're just an object.
- 11:16a side piece or whatever it is, whatever language they want to use, then there might be some victim blaming involved in that, like he's out spending money or he's saying that she's spending this and it's all her fault that they're having challenges.
- 11:32And then we look at things like sexual harassment, sexual assault, domestic violence, and murder, which will write down the other end of the continuum.
- 11:38What we often see as men hanging out with other men in a workplace that is dominated by men is language that comes up.
- 11:48Like, she's a bitch for spending X or she's a gold digger or those types of comments.
- 11:53And that's why I talk about if we can hold people accountable at that point,
- 11:57And it doesn't necessarily mean saying to someone, hey, you're an idiot, you shouldn't say stuff like that, but to have a check-in conversation as well.
- 12:03Hold them accountable for sure.
- 12:04Hey, man, that's not okay.
- 12:05But also you could add to that, what's going on for you?
- 12:08Just to have that check-in conversation and seek that and see that this person gets support to prevent them from taking further steps along that continuum towards the end of the line.
- 12:16If we don't do the work there,
- 12:18then it's complicit.
- 12:20It's saying to this person, that belief is okay.
- 12:22And often what we see, in fact, is people colluding.
- 12:26She's a bitch because she spent money on X and Y. Yeah, man, that must be tough.
- 12:30That sucks.
- 12:30Yeah, she is a bitch.
- 12:32Rather than saying, oof, watch the language, man.
- 12:34And it sounds like you've got a bit of struggle at home with the money.
- 12:37Do you want to talk about it?
- 12:38Or do you want to go seek help from the EAP, the financial counselor, something like that?
- 12:42Yeah.
- 12:42So what would hold people back, though, from having that conversation?
- 12:47If you're in a big group and everyone's part of it, it's really hard to be the one who steps in.
- 12:53Yeah, I mean that's across age groups as well.
- 12:56It's a challenge, right?
- 12:57And everyone else, we sit there in silence because we feel uncomfortable with the comment that this person has made, but no one else is saying anything, so we then blame ourselves.
- 13:07We sit there and go, well, I must be the only one who has a problem with this.
- 13:09I might have missed the punchline, I might have missed the joke, or maybe this is really hard for that person and I just think I'm too woke or whatever it might be that I'm the one who has the problem.
- 13:20Rather than being,
- 13:22Curious about it.
- 13:23You know, is this okay?
- 13:25Is this the way we normally speak around about our partners when we're at lunch?
- 13:29Like just being curious about that situation and then people might, you know, say something or do something that moment.
- 13:34There's a lot of stuff that comes up.
- 13:36I think sometimes a lot of these behaviors that they're seeing are pretty normalized, right?
- 13:39People call it just complaining about my partner.
- 13:42And sometimes it is genuine complaints like they're like struggling with money.
- 13:46I mean, the world isn't that easy at the moment and finances are tough and struggles happen.
- 13:51And sometimes, you know, we have disruptions in our relationship and even healthy relationships have disagreements and arguments and sleeping in separate bedrooms and all those types of things.
- 14:02And sometimes because of that, we just excuse whatever's going on.
- 14:05Oh, they're going through a tough time.
- 14:07That's fine.
- 14:07I'll just leave them go through it.
- 14:08Rather than going, oh, they're going through a tough time.
- 14:10Maybe I'll check in on them, have a private conversation after this and see if they're okay.
- 14:14And if they continue maybe to degrade their partner or say negative things about them, I can hold them accountable to that.
- 14:19But I really want to make sure they get the support they need to navigate this tough time they're going through.
- 14:23Yeah, I love the way you're talking about it doesn't have to be all on me either to solve the problem.
- 14:29How do I step in and maybe be a bit of a circuit breaker or encourage people to think a little bit differently and then get them to other support if they need it as well, that referral?
- 14:40You've talked about calling people out and calling people in.
- 14:47What does that mean?
- 14:48How do you call someone in rather than call them out?
- 14:51Yeah, I find it interesting with these little things.
- 14:53They sound so cliche, but I think it's a good way to think about it.
- 14:58Often calling out looks like calling someone a name or putting them down or something like that.
- 15:04Calling them in is just being curious.
- 15:06It's just asking them what's going on.
- 15:08Rather than, the big difference is that there's a sense of curiosity when it comes to calling someone in.
- 15:14When we're calling them out, we don't care.
- 15:15We're judging, we're putting them down, that sort of thing.
- 15:17So it would look like, like I said before, if we've noticed they've made a negative comment or a degrading comment about their partner and it somehow relates to finances or something like that, we can say, oh, man, that must really suck.
- 15:28That must be really hard.
- 15:29Is everything going okay at home?
- 15:30Are you managing your money okay?
- 15:32Are you having any struggles?
- 15:34Asking questions about what's going on for this person.
- 15:36If we have no curiosity, then we know that we're stepping very far away from calling in and we're moving towards calling out.
- 15:43Yeah.
- 15:43Yeah.
- 15:44So tell me a bit about we were chatting before we started the cameras rolling just about your behavioral science background as well and how you and your professional capabilities in that area, expertise.
- 16:00I'm really interested in how that applies in the context of the work that you're doing.
- 16:05And because that's all about trying to make it really easy for people to do something that's good for them generally.
- 16:13How does that work in the work that you do?
- 16:17Yeah, it's interesting, hey, because there's so many theories on behavior change, and it's hard to pick which ones are going to work and when.
- 16:25But we can focus on a couple of, a lot of the things I look at are beliefs and attitudes and how that then either enforces or reinforces the plan to do a behavior and then potentially the behavior itself.
- 16:38And what I've noticed in my experience is that that can predict some behavior, but it doesn't always work.
- 16:45And what is more predictive of someone, I guess, someone moving towards an unsafe behavior is...
- 16:56them becoming resistant of what they believe in.
- 16:58So like when we talked about calling out versus calling in, if I call someone out, it's likely that they're gonna resist what I'm saying and they're going to shut me out and they're going to double down on whatever it is that they're doing, because I believe I should be able to do this.
- 17:11And I think the biggest challenge I see is when people don't acknowledge someone else's pain or someone else's experience, right?
- 17:17I think for men and boys, we largely as a collective will benefit from the system that we uphold in our culture.
- 17:26But as individuals, we suffer when we're told we have to provide, we have to protect, we have to work the hard jobs, we have to hold on to whatever it is that we feel and pretend like it's not bothering us at all.
- 17:35Like all of these things cause individual suffering.
- 17:39But when we say we have to provide and protect and all that sort of stuff, we get the higher paying jobs, we're paid more for the same job, we have better opportunities, we're more expected to be the leader of the organisation.
- 17:48So there are benefits that come to us off the back of that, but the individual suffering is hard.
- 17:53So what I try to do is acknowledge that individual suffering and then bring it to the collective.
- 17:57And then what we see is men starting to acknowledge each other's challenges and then show up for each other, which is the most important thing that we recognise that as men we can carry some emotional labour of each other.
- 18:08We can hold each other accountable to standards that are better, not only for us, but for our families and for other people who we work with.
- 18:14And that's really the goal of it.
- 18:15Acknowledge the individual suffering and then move them towards collective work that supports all people.
- 18:21So what's it like, say, if you're doing a program or education, when you know someone's, the penny's dropped for somebody or there's something that's happened and shifted in the room, what does that look like?
- 18:37Sometimes what it looks like is just someone, as I explained that continuum earlier, someone just saying, you think all of this stuff is nonsense until you know someone who's taken those steps and then you start to realize it's time to make some changes.
- 18:51And they say that, I've had that in a mining group and this guy stood up at the end of the session and said that.
- 18:57And then you just see everyone else.
- 18:59because he was acknowledging the work that we were doing, myself and my colleague from the front of the room, as one of them, as saying, you know, we could all do a little bit better.
- 19:06And that, you could just see the mood in the room change right at the end of that session, that everyone was like, okay, maybe it's worth thinking about this sort of stuff, rather than just being like, oh, forget it.
- 19:17Sometimes it's like, especially in schools, like boys will walk out of the room and they'll say to their mates, hey man, we can do better than that.
- 19:23Like sometimes we're laughing throughout that conversation about respect for relationships and that's really important stuff.
- 19:28We shouldn't be laughing.
- 19:29Like a 15, 16 year old boy in front of six of his mates saying, hey, we can do better.
- 19:34That's a big step.
- 19:35That's a lot of reflection.
- 19:36That's a lot of acknowledgement we just spoke about before.
- 19:40The one out of the seven who thinks a bit different, that can feel like risk, but they're willing to do it.
- 19:46So that's what it looks like in action.
- 19:48Yeah.
- 19:48And it's really, it is a bit of seeing the unseen, isn't it?
- 19:53Laying things out a little bit differently so that when you do see it differently, maybe you can come to it in a different way as well.
- 20:00Yeah.
- 20:01So I want to go into a little bit about how you, a bit of practical advice that you might have or the way that you would approach it.
- 20:13If the work you're talking about is the pressure on men and young people to provide services,
- 20:23How would you go about having a healthy money relationship?
- 20:27What would that look like in terms of having the conversation with your partner and then literally starting to manage money in a more equitable way, even when you might have some of these other pressures on you?
- 20:42Yeah, that's a tough one.
- 20:43I think for young people, it's a very different context.
- 20:46They're probably not going into shared incomes and shared assets and all those sorts of things, so it might be a little bit different.
- 20:53But it's just for them when we talk about it, we're just talking about acknowledging those things
- 20:58things that are coming in that saying he should provide and she should be dependent when she wants to be independent and he is not, he's probably contributing to something at home and all that.
- 21:07So to understand each other's pressures and what they're dealing with and then to connect on an emotional level and not worry so much about that financial level, ultimately that's what they want and they know that and that's what they work towards.
- 21:18It's when they struggle that they start saying, oh, you're not making money or you are making too much money and that's when it becomes a problem.
- 21:24So if they connect on an emotional level
- 21:27they can keep things safe.
- 21:29I think in adult or even young adult relationships, having financial independence and understanding of your own, I think so many people just take it for granted.
- 21:39And I mean, we could probably do more work in schools and helping young people understand what it looks like to be financially independent.
- 21:46So people take for granted what that actually means and then they start making money and they start spending money and then they start having bills and the bills keep going up and then, you know, eventually maybe they move out of home and there's even more bills and then someone moves in with them and then there's shared assets and shared, shared bills.
- 22:00So I think what a healthy conversation looks like is when two people have their own incomes or they contribute to a relationship.
- 22:09There's no sense of because I make more, I make more decisions as well.
- 22:14Because I make more money, I make more decisions as well.
- 22:16It's just we contribute to this partnership.
- 22:19For some people, what it looks like is having independent incomes and then where there's maybe shared bills, there's a shared account or a shared credit card or a shared mortgage, whatever it is, and they still have their independent incomes.
- 22:34Yeah.
- 22:34The other thing that's really important is when we set goals as a couple for saving, saving for a house, whatever it might be, they're realistic and they're achievable for both people.
- 22:46What we see sometimes in financial abuse is this setting of targets that are unattainable and unachievable.
- 22:52And a woman shared with me, and she's given permission for me to share this as well, that she would set a target to save goals.
- 23:0280% of her casual income by the end of the month, whilst also looking after school stuff, kids stuff, groceries, bills, all that sort of stuff.
- 23:11And he made more money, so he said, no, I'll contribute more to the savings, but you have to contribute X amount.
- 23:17And by the end of the month, she got nowhere near it because it was impossible.
- 23:20And then he said, well, you can't manage your money.
- 23:22I'll get all the money from now on.
- 23:24I'll be in charge, and then I'll just give you what you need.
- 23:26Even though she got the same amount of money every single week, he was giving it to her either in an envelope or transferring it to her.
- 23:33And now she has no autonomy over her money.
- 23:35So when we set goals, they're achievable for both parties.
- 23:38They are reasonable for both people.
- 23:43And there's no sense of because I make more money, I make more decisions.
- 23:49It's just equal shared decisions across the board because we both contribute to this relationship.
- 23:53Yeah, I think that last point is really important because, and we were talking about this, that actually that's part of a society.
- 24:03If you make a lot more money, you tend to be the decision maker and we look up to you as the person who the buck stops with you.
- 24:09Tell me how to fix that one.
- 24:10Yeah, it's tough, eh?
- 24:12Because like, I mean, you look at an organization, the person with the biggest pay packet makes the biggest decision or has the final decision at the end of the day.
- 24:19Kids who are going to school, they know who's making more money and that person is usually more in charge.
- 24:25And so, and at home, potentially they live in a home where one parent makes more money and that person makes more decisions as well.
- 24:31Not always, but that does happen.
- 24:34And so it's hard when you're looking at all of this sort of stuff and thinking, well, that seems to make sense.
- 24:39So I guess for me it's about talking about what does safe feel like in a relationship?
- 24:44Does it feel like I get no autonomy over my own decisions?
- 24:47Does it feel like that no matter how much money I make, if it's less than you, you're in control and in charge of me?
- 24:52do you want to be in control and in charge of me like it or do you just struggle with some things sometimes and think that control is the only way to deal with whatever that struggle is and is there another way to deal with that struggle right and there is there always is there's communication there's counseling there's financial counseling there's lots of ways we can manage this this sort of stuff so for me it's like recognize that a lot of these
- 25:16uh, influences that tell us that making money mean making more money means making more decisions.
- 25:22While it might be relevant for organizations, um, to have particular people, you know, make particular decisions and therefore make money fine.
- 25:30But when it comes to a romantic partnership or relationship, that doesn't have to be the case just because it is over there.
- 25:36It doesn't mean it has to be over here.
- 25:37Yeah, it's so interesting.
- 25:39I know when I started doing this work over a decade ago and I met Rosie Batty and over many years we've had a really great conversation and she's taught me so much.
- 25:53But I still remember her saying, you know, when she was able to manage her own money, she might have made some choices that were probably not great choices with the way she spent her money.
- 26:06Mm-hmm.
- 26:07but they were hers to make.
- 26:09And that's always really stuck with me that you don't have to control somebody else through their access to money.
- 26:16And this podcast comes about because of the work that I do and what I've learnt around financial abuse.
- 26:27But it's not solely the reason I'm doing it.
- 26:30It's because I really want to get underneath what's going on and why would you think that I have this pressure and that I do get to make all the decisions because I'm the main breadwinner?
- 26:43There's probably other people who do it because that is the way they're going to coerce somebody.
- 26:48But maybe there's a group of people who are so inculcated with this pressure that that's just the way they come to money management.
- 26:59I don't know if that's a question to you, Dave.
- 27:02It's just musing out loud a little bit, but I do.
- 27:05I've been thinking so deeply about this for a long time.
- 27:09And also after reading Chanel Contos' book where she talked about a group of people that she said were entitled opportunists, and I'm
- 27:17I'm like wondering how does that apply in a relationship and in the money relationship?
- 27:23What are your thoughts on that relationship?
- 27:25I think you raised a really good point that there's certainly people out there with real intentions behind their behaviours in terms of coercively controlling, financially controlling someone.
- 27:35And the financial control might be another contribution to the way they control this other person, not necessarily the whole thing.
- 27:41Sometimes it is.
- 27:42But there are also people I would acknowledge in our society who struggle with the pressure to make money and the pressure to –
- 27:52provide and therefore then choose.
- 27:54And this is not one causing the other, but they do choose to also then control the other person, the way they spend and even the money they earn.
- 28:03So it's really hard to hold that conversation in two things, right?
- 28:07Because two things are happening.
- 28:09This person is experiencing pressure and it may be self-perceived pressure.
- 28:13It may be very real pressure to provide and to earn money.
- 28:18And they're also choosing to say to the other person, their partner, you can't spend that money or you can't go to that place or you can't see those people through a sense of like, I'm entitled to make this decision because I make the money.
- 28:30So it's like there is a relationship there, but one is not causing the other.
- 28:34So if we can acknowledge that first thing, though, as you said, there may be this group of people who are feeling the pressure and the pinch, especially in today's economy, of making money and trying to provide for their family and then choosing to.
- 28:46to control further.
- 28:47And I talk a lot about this with young people.
- 28:50Sometimes their experiences of control, they're not coming from a place of, genuinely coming from a place of like, I want to control this person.
- 28:58They might be coming from a place that they call love, but is actually fear.
- 29:03It probably feels the same.
- 29:05Love and fear can be confusing.
- 29:06And maybe this person, this man who is reaching for control in this household,
- 29:12or this particular group of men who are reaching for control in this household, maybe they're afraid that that extra dollar could break the bank and therefore they are an inadequate father, they are an inadequate provider, they are not good enough for their family, she might leave him for someone else who's made more money, all of this type of stuff might be going on there.
- 29:28So for me, as an outsider, again, acknowledging that there are people with real intention, there are also potentially people who are struggling and then choosing to control.
- 29:39For those people who are struggling, as I said very early on, they need support.
- 29:43They need help to manage that belief system they hold, and this is where the behavioral science thing, I think, comes in.
- 29:49They hold particular beliefs about what money means to them and their role as a provider, and it's helping them manage those beliefs that will then probably do a lot to soothe those emotions, and this may happen over a course of a very long time.
- 30:02And that may help them to make different decisions or even include the other person in the decisions that are made around money and their financial future.
- 30:11I don't know if that was...
- 30:13I think, yeah, absolutely.
- 30:15I think this is a, it's a conversation because I think it's a really tricky one to navigate and not many people understand what financial abuse is, even if they're in it.
- 30:26But your words that you chose then, when you said choice, it's always a choice about the way you behave, even if it doesn't feel like it's a choice.
- 30:35I still remember when I went back to work after having the kids and I was like, oh,
- 30:40how am I doing this?
- 30:43This is really hard.
- 30:45My kids were really young.
- 30:46I was trying to do this full-time work and juggle everything.
- 30:50And I still remember someone saying to me, you know what?
- 30:53You feel like you don't have a choice at the moment, but actually you've made a really important choice.
- 31:01And that is to have a family.
- 31:04And once I started just, once she said that to me, I just all of a sudden felt this relief about, oh, yeah, that's the most important choice I've made.
- 31:14So how am I going to think about things very differently now?
- 31:17And I don't know that I changed a whole lot.
- 31:19It was still a really hard juggle.
- 31:21But...
- 31:22my mindset was different and I chose to behave differently.
- 31:27So that was just that one little flick of the switch over 20 years ago, you know, so I do think that point about choice is really critical.
- 31:38So I want to just, we're probably going to wrap up shortly and there's two sort of final questions for you, Dave, which is,
- 31:49If someone listening to this series takes one thing away into their life, and particularly men and boys, what would that be?
- 32:04What would you want them to take responsibility for?
- 32:08Each other, mostly.
- 32:09I think that's a big thing.
- 32:11We tend to excuse each other's behaviors and emotions because we think as men we don't know how to deal with them.
- 32:17So we just say, oh, he'll find someone who you can talk about that with.
- 32:21But we acknowledge those things as we spoke about throughout where he might be expressing some emotional distress, but he's talking about it from a perspective of control of finances or she's doing X and Y and it's not good.
- 32:31or degrading her, we take responsibility for each other.
- 32:35And we say, hey, mate, I've heard some things.
- 32:37I don't like the way you're speaking about her.
- 32:38And also, do you need some support?
- 32:41Again, that's the choice to do both, to engage in both the belief around control and then the decisions they make off the back of that.
- 32:50And I think understanding that just because I make money does not mean I make all the decisions.
- 32:58Like regardless of what the workplace says around that sort of thing, a relationship, a romantic relationship is very different.
- 33:04It's an equal shared partnership.
- 33:06And maybe one person does earn the money and the other person is at home cooking, cleaning, nurturing the children to school and back and doing all the other stuff.
- 33:15If they're not doing that, then that means that you can't work full time.
- 33:19You have to do some of that work, right?
- 33:21So it's shared.
- 33:22So everything should be shared.
- 33:23Decisions should be shared and there should be particular.
- 33:26Fair enough, there'll be someone in the relationship who knows more about money and someone who probably manages spreadsheets better than the other person, for sure.
- 33:32But that doesn't mean that all the decisions are controlled by that person.
- 33:36It just means that they may have more of an understanding of how these budgets will work.
- 33:41and they can be well explained, and then we can support each other.
- 33:44And if – sorry, this is so long – if we both struggle with that or if we're struggling to come to agreements, then seek external support.
- 33:51Look for a financial counsellor or someone who can help to navigate those decisions together as a couple.
- 33:56One of the things that I talk about is that how can you have a conversation which is what's mine, what's yours, what's ours, and then how does that work?
- 34:04But this point about just because you earn –
- 34:07the money or the most money doesn't mean that you get all the say.
- 34:10I think it's really critical.
- 34:12I think it's key for men.
- 34:14Yeah.
- 34:14It's automatic.
- 34:15Yeah.
- 34:15Like even for boys, it's automatic.
- 34:17It's like I will provide and therefore I'll be the decision maker.
- 34:20Yeah.
- 34:21It does strike.
- 34:22I still remember having a conversation with two of my mates and their wives had just, the three of us were out for dinner and their wives were both...
- 34:35Stay-at-home mums, but we're starting their own businesses.
- 34:39why people start their own businesses as a new start-up and doing this is so hard, right?
- 34:45And both of them, I still remember them saying, well, what she's choosing to just like not work and do this, now we're getting all this more expensive stuff because we've got to have childcare and now they're starting these businesses and, you know, I've got to keep working really hard to do this.
- 35:00So this conversation we're having is really resonating and reminding me of that.
- 35:05But we also, it was such a good conversation to have with the two of them.
- 35:09and me as a woman who they, who was, we were equals because we'd all been colleagues together and just, it's just, I think I shifted them a tiny bit, but it was so good to see the way they, they then were trying to work it out as well.
- 35:27What would you say to people who are listening to this series about the thing that they might want to take into their life and particularly to men about what's their responsibility?
- 35:39Yeah, I think with this one, one of the big responsibilities we can take is for each other.
- 35:43You know, we spend a lot of time together and if we're working long hours all day and not spending as much time at home as what we are at work, then we spend a lot of time listening to each other and hearing each other's experiences and potentially complaints and whatever else it might be.
- 35:58So to take some responsibility for that emotional labor that our mate's struggling with and to say, hey mate, are you okay?
- 36:03And also I'm concerned about some of the ways you talk about your partner or some of the ways that you talk about finances if that's...
- 36:09feels like a safe conversation to have potentially in a one-on-one environment, and then seek to help that person get to the support they need to be able to manage whatever it is that's going on there.
- 36:18So I think a big responsibility we can take is for each other.
- 36:21And also to remember that just because...
- 36:24I make the most money doesn't mean I make all the decisions.
- 36:28It should always be shared decision-making in a romantic relationship.
- 36:32Whatever happens in your organizations with your pay packet and your decision-making is completely separate to your relationship and your decision-making in that romantic partnership.
- 36:40So I would say regardless of that, because with you out there working, you know, 12 days on, five days off in a mine,
- 36:49It's, your partner is at home taking care of the children and the life and the house and everything else that's going on at home.
- 36:57That's a shared partnership both of you are doing.
- 36:59If they weren't doing that, then potentially you wouldn't be able to take all that time at the mine or in the job that you're doing.
- 37:06So it's important to remember that this is always shared.
- 37:08The whole partnership is shared, so the decision should be shared.
- 37:11I think it's important to remember that one person might be better at the spreadsheets and the finances and all that sort of stuff, for sure, and that's okay.
- 37:18But when we communicate about how money is spent, what's mine, what's yours, what's ours, or whatever it is that you were speaking about,
- 37:24It's shared decisions and both of us carry the same weight in the decisions that are made about how our finances go as we move forward.
- 37:33Yeah.
- 37:34If you're watching a friend or a family member's relationship and something doesn't feel right, what would be a way to open that conversation?
- 37:46Yeah, I think sometimes it's good just to talk about ourselves a little bit.
- 37:50Sometimes it can be easier just to say, geez, this economy is hitting us hard at home.
- 37:54How do you manage it?
- 37:55And then just to see if anything further comes up in that conversation.
- 37:58I think I might have said this before about staying curious without judgment.
- 38:02I think it's important when maybe they say, oh, yeah, you know, I just don't worry about the money.
- 38:06He handles all of that.
- 38:07That's not my job.
- 38:09We might think, oh, that's controlling or that's not okay or that's unfair.
- 38:12Yeah.
- 38:13But if we can just hold that and then say, oh, that must be really tough.
- 38:16Do you want to make more decisions around the money or is that just something you're comfortable with?
- 38:21And just stay curious and continue to ask questions and continue to keep that space safe.
- 38:26Any judgment we pass on the person we're speaking with or the person they're speaking about will ultimately end that conversation and that person feeling unsafe to share anymore.
- 38:35Even if we're saying, oh, I think that's really bad that that person is doing that to you.
- 38:39They're going to, sometimes what can happen in this situation is someone thinks, oh, you think I'm a horrible person for dating this other person or marrying this other person or whatever it might be.
- 38:48And that resistance might come up.
- 38:50And they also might be feeling really unsafe.
- 38:52And if they're feeling really unsafe, it's unlikely that they're going to talk about this person or it's more likely that they're going to try and defend this person who makes them feel unsafe because their brain is saying that's the only way for them to stay safe.
- 39:06So keep judgment completely out of the situation and just inquire curiously about how are you coping with the economy?
- 39:16We tend to make decisions around money that look like this.
- 39:20How do you make those kinds of decisions?
- 39:24Anything that might help them to open up a little bit more and just be okay with whatever they say because they might not open up at all.
- 39:31You say, okay, well, if you have a need to talk about it, I'm always here.
- 39:33Yeah, yeah.
- 39:34Thank you so much for your time, Dave.
- 39:37I'm asking every guest at the end of our sessions to complete this sentence.
- 39:42I'm keen to hear what you would say before you say yes.
- 39:46Before you say yes, I think it's always important to have a really good friend around you.
- 39:53a person who you know will always tell you what you don't want to hear.
- 40:00I think that person is the one who's going to be most honest with you about some of the decisions you might make where you might be doubting yourself, where you might have been convinced that your ability to manage money is inadequate or you might have been slowly your sense of self or self-esteem has been eroded to the point where you're struggling with understanding what your
- 40:21what your power might be in that decision-making process.
- 40:24You will almost always have a friend who will say, are you okay?
- 40:27And I'm concerned about the decisions that this person is trying to force you to make, or potentially you're, you've got a friend who says, Hey mate, I'm really concerned about some of the decisions you're making and how this is impacting on your partner.
- 40:40So I think having a friend before you say yes, have a friend who is willing to tell you what you don't want to hear.
- 40:47Yeah, I love that.
- 40:48Thank you so much for your time, Dave.
- 40:49Really appreciate it.
- 40:51Thanks so much, Catherine.
- 40:51I appreciate it.