Latest / Humanise The Numbers - for ambitious accountants in practice / Caroline Carter of Carter Clear Accounting
Transcript
- 0:05Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the Humanize the Numbers podcast series.
- 0:08Paul Shrimpling: Leaders, managers, and owners of ambitious accounting firms sharing insights, successes, and issues that will challenge you and connect you and your firm to the ways and means of transforming your firm's results.
- 0:22Caroline Carter: So we're running this business, it was a massive food, but with the three and a half thousand Sunday dinners on a Sunday, we had you know 35 members of staff, it was huge.
- 0:31Caroline Carter: But we had an accountant.
- 0:33Caroline Carter: The accountant never wanted to speak to us.
- 0:36Caroline Carter: If we rang them, you know, they were too busy to take the call.
- 0:39Caroline Carter: You might eventually get a call back two or three weeks later, didn't understand VAT, didn't understand bookkeeping, didn't understand, and they were so expensive.
- 0:48Caroline Carter: But now looking back, I'm like, actually, we got a really good deal for what they were giving us.
- 0:54Caroline Carter: But as a small business owner, you think, wow, it's super expensive, and you don't see the value.
- 0:59Douglas Aitken: How does a formal diagnosis of ADHD and OCD affect your ability to run an accounting firm?
- 1:08Douglas Aitken: In this podcast with Caroline Carter of Carter Clear, you'll hear how that diagnosis allowed her to make sense of the world.
- 1:17Douglas Aitken: Let's go with that podcast now.
- 1:19Caroline Carter: Morning to I'm Caroline from Carter Clear Accounting.
- 1:23Caroline Carter: Um I run a very small accountancy practice based up in Warrington in Cheshire.
- 1:28Caroline Carter: We focus on helping small businesses.
- 1:31Caroline Carter: Most of our clients have a turnover of less than two million.
- 1:36Caroline Carter: We do work with some large kind of corporate bodies like the NHS and huge logistics company on a contract basis, but that's more of a kind of skill set where I go out on day and I do a bit of project work with them.
- 1:50Caroline Carter: Um it's kind of legacy hangover from my career days when I was employed.
- 1:55Caroline Carter: Um, but yeah, that's we're a very small team, very small practice.
- 2:00Douglas Aitken: Fab.
- 2:00Douglas Aitken: Give us an idea, uh, some numbers, Caroline, if you can.
- 2:03Douglas Aitken: How many people do you have?
- 2:05Caroline Carter: Um the we have five members on the team, um, including myself.
- 2:10Caroline Carter: Um we have two trainee bookkeepers, um, a qualified bookkeeper, and then myself and another qualified accountant.
- 2:19Douglas Aitken: Fab.
- 2:20Douglas Aitken: Okay.
- 2:21Douglas Aitken: Um and when did you set up the business?
- 2:26Caroline Carter: Oh I've been licensed since 2014.
- 2:30Caroline Carter: Um, but I used to always do it on the side.
- 2:33Caroline Carter: It's kind of just alongside my day job.
- 2:36Caroline Carter: Uh-huh.
- 2:37Caroline Carter: Which was?
- 2:38Caroline Carter: Yeah, well I I worked in management accounting.
- 2:41Caroline Carter: I've had a massive and hugely varied career.
- 2:44Caroline Carter: I didn't really start working in accounts until tw 2011.
- 2:49Douglas Aitken: Okay.
- 2:50Caroline Carter: Um just because mainly because I couldn't get anybody to give me the opportunity to to try.
- 2:54Caroline Carter: Um I think they see single mum and they they worry about the time constraints that you're gonna have.
- 3:00Caroline Carter: Um and that's really important to me now in Carter Clear that we've got mums who work for us who have a really flexible, I mean hugely flexible flexible approach to work.
- 3:11Caroline Carter: Um but yeah, no, it was always along the side.
- 3:13Caroline Carter: I had my license along the side of my day job.
- 3:16Caroline Carter: Um and then it was during COVID in 2020, uh, all over Facebook.
- 3:23Caroline Carter: At the time I was an accountant electorer.
- 3:25Caroline Carter: Um and all over Facebook, people like, oh my gosh, I don't know what to do.
- 3:30Caroline Carter: Um, what do I do with this S-E-I-S-S?
- 3:33Caroline Carter: What's what's furlough?
- 3:34Caroline Carter: Um so I was running like a Facebook live once or twice a week.
- 3:38Caroline Carter: We're just helping people.
- 3:40Caroline Carter: Um, and at that stage, June 2020, I had 13 clients and a full-time job.
- 3:45Caroline Carter: Um and yeah, we've just grown from there.
- 3:48Caroline Carter: I incorporated the business in March 2021.
- 3:52Caroline Carter: So yeah, we've been going for 11 years in total.
- 3:56Caroline Carter: Been licensed for 11 years, fab.
- 3:59Caroline Carter: But only limited for four.
- 4:02Douglas Aitken: Good stuff.
- 4:03Douglas Aitken: Okay, I'll dive into your career um a little bit more in a moment, Caroline.
- 4:08Douglas Aitken: But we always ask our podcast guests early on about our core purpose, which is to humanize the numbers.
- 4:14Douglas Aitken: Um, just give me a feel for what you get from that.
- 4:18Douglas Aitken: What does that mean to you?
- 4:19Douglas Aitken: Humanize the numbers.
- 4:22Caroline Carter: Numbers are how I make sense of the world.
- 4:26Caroline Carter: Um, they tend to bring me like this this clearness, this focus, um, and numbers don't judge you, numbers don't have an opinion, they don't have a, you know, there are obviously obviously an outcome, a numerical outcome, but they don't have they don't judge you.
- 4:42Caroline Carter: So I've managed my life in numbers for over a decade.
- 4:45Caroline Carter: Um so I was diagnosed with ADHD and OCD um many, many years ago.
- 4:51Caroline Carter: Um, and as part of managing that diagnosis, I started tracking numbers.
- 4:56Caroline Carter: I've got, I can tell you what my step count is for every day going back to March 2014.
- 5:02Caroline Carter: Um, how many calories I've eaten on most of the days.
- 5:06Caroline Carter: I'm not as rigid as I once was.
- 5:08Caroline Carter: Um, I used to be big into running ultramarathons, I've done long distance swimming, triathlons, all of that's on spreadsheets.
- 5:15Caroline Carter: I can tell you my pace, my heart rate, the distance.
- 5:18Caroline Carter: Um, so I've got 11 years of data going back to 2014, and even on the bad days, knowing you've overeaten, you'd be like, You've hit three and a half thousand calories, and you're like, whoops.
- 5:28Caroline Carter: Um, or I've skipped a training run, I still log it.
- 5:31Caroline Carter: So for me, numbers don't lie, they kind of show the truth, um, and they don't judge you.
- 5:37Caroline Carter: And I think once you track the numbers, you can kind of remove the the shame.
- 5:42Caroline Carter: Um, all my personal findances are run on a cash book version of zero, and so I can tell you what mine and my husband's net equity net equity is.
- 5:51Caroline Carter: Um and it might sound unusual, um, but for me it's how I understand the world.
- 5:56Caroline Carter: And part of that comes from that lady HD and OCD.
- 6:00Caroline Carter: Um, but numbers give me um structure and control when I need it most.
- 6:04Caroline Carter: So when things are veering off track in life, I if I kind of revert back to those tracking numbers measures that I've put in place to control my life, um, it kind of brings it back round.
- 6:17Caroline Carter: Numbers don't control me as much as they once did, and step away now.
- 6:22Caroline Carter: If I don't fill in my calories for three months, I I'm not that fussed.
- 6:26Caroline Carter: Um whereas there was a stage where it would be, you know, if I'd missed it for a week or two, I'd be it would be the disaster and like the worst thing that could happen.
- 6:36Caroline Carter: Um but I've managed I've managed that.
- 6:38Caroline Carter: Um I'd still have around myself.
- 6:42Douglas Aitken: Yeah, but how did it show up before pre-diagnosis, Caroline?
- 6:52Caroline Carter: I do I like I run things a million things at once.
- 6:57Caroline Carter: Um so I'm very task-oriented.
- 7:00Caroline Carter: Um and inside the business we have loads of processes and workflows and everything has like steps and videos and instructions and it's probably too much.
- 7:10Caroline Carter: It's uh if for somebody coming into the business who's already qualified, it would be overkill.
- 7:15Caroline Carter: But for somebody who's learning, it's great.
- 7:18Caroline Carter: But that's it's just um I have like this, it's almost like a paralysis.
- 7:23Caroline Carter: There's so many tasks to do.
- 7:25Caroline Carter: I just can't get started on any of them.
- 7:28Caroline Carter: Um so if I put them into like a logical order, I do it with my finances as well.
- 7:34Caroline Carter: I will grade them.
- 7:35Caroline Carter: So if we've got a little bit of debt to pay off, I'll give them like a I'll put them into a grading system.
- 7:40Caroline Carter: Um, so like this is a priority one debt, or this is a priority one task.
- 7:46Caroline Carter: Um, so I my everything in my life is graded with numbers, and then it helps me to go, right?
- 7:51Caroline Carter: I need to focus on number one.
- 7:53Caroline Carter: What's the number one priority for today?
- 7:55Caroline Carter: And then it just removes that.
- 7:57Caroline Carter: So initially it was that I was uh struggling really, really bad just to manage life, um, and I was a single parent with two kids, um, which is hard enough in itself.
- 8:09Caroline Carter: Um but yeah.
- 8:11Caroline Carter: Long time ago.
- 8:15Douglas Aitken: And I I'm interested in um how you felt post-diagnosis.
- 8:22Douglas Aitken: Was there a sense of relief that you could start to make sense of it or how how did you feel?
- 8:29Caroline Carter: I always knew.
- 8:30Caroline Carter: Um so I grew up in a household where when when I was younger, uh my mum was diagnosed with schizophrenia when I was 11.
- 8:38Speaker 4: Right.
- 8:39Caroline Carter: And she was sectioned.
- 8:40Caroline Carter: So there's a very much a kind of stigma about having any kind of neurological issue.
- 8:45Caroline Carter: Um, and when I was a kid, nobody really talked about my mum's diagnosis.
- 8:50Caroline Carter: It was very much kept in the closet and you weren't allowed to talk about it at school, you couldn't tell your friends.
- 8:55Caroline Carter: Um it's kind of we were encouraged, both me and I've got two younger brothers, uh, to keep it close and not really tell anyone.
- 9:02Caroline Carter: So I think there was I think it's a lot more open now.
- 9:05Caroline Carter: When I was diagnosed, you didn't really tell anybody about it.
- 9:09Caroline Carter: Um you know, you don't want people to look at you differently, especially in a professional capacity.
- 9:16Caroline Carter: Um but now I think it's the reason why I'm doing what I'm doing today is because of that.
- 9:23Caroline Carter: That's yeah, it's led me to where I am today.
- 9:28Caroline Carter: So you can only be thankful, really.
- 9:30Douglas Aitken: Yeah, yeah.
- 9:31Douglas Aitken: That's the way I see it.
- 9:32Douglas Aitken: So earlier on you hinted about uh a varied career.
- 9:36Douglas Aitken: Um give us some snapshots from it, Carlin.
- 9:39Douglas Aitken: Or or in linear order if you prefer.
- 9:43Caroline Carter: Uh yeah, linear order will make more sense to me.
- 9:47Caroline Carter: Um but yeah, I know I started off when I was younger.
- 9:50Caroline Carter: Um I did one of my first jobs was a bookkeeping job for a construction company.
- 9:55Caroline Carter: Um it didn't last very long.
- 9:57Caroline Carter: I had a very misspent youth.
- 9:58Caroline Carter: Um and then I had my daughter when I was very young as well.
- 10:02Caroline Carter: Um, but once I was on the wrong path when I before I had my daughter, and then I had my daughter and it was like that light bulb moment in life where you were like, wow, this is it, this is what, you know, this isn't about me anymore.
- 10:16Caroline Carter: This is about what I want her to achieve and what I want her to have in life, what opportunities I want her to have.
- 10:22Caroline Carter: Um so I got a job.
- 10:24Caroline Carter: I used to work in call centres.
- 10:26Caroline Carter: And um the only way, because I was so young, all my friends were I was 19 when I had my daughter, all my friends were off partying and you know I was at home with a with a young child.
- 10:38Caroline Carter: Um so yeah, it's um I just wanted to give her a good example.
- 10:44Caroline Carter: Um, but my social life was my brother, when I was 19, he was 16.
- 10:49Caroline Carter: He used to babysit my daughter.
- 10:51Caroline Carter: Um my social life was working in a pub.
- 10:54Caroline Carter: Um and that's how I met my son's dad.
- 10:57Caroline Carter: Um but yeah, and then we were running the pub, um, and then the the company who managed the pub sold the pub from under us, so we bought the lease.
- 11:07Caroline Carter: And that was my first business at I was 23.
- 11:12Caroline Carter: But um yeah.
- 11:16Douglas Aitken: And how long did you have that?
- 11:18Caroline Carter: Uh we bought I'm trying to think.
- 11:21Caroline Carter: It was it wasn't long.
- 11:22Caroline Carter: We owned the business for three years before that we'd managed the site for for a while as well.
- 11:28Caroline Carter: Um, but it was like my first foray into accounting.
- 11:33Caroline Carter: Um, so we're running this business, it was a massive food pub with the three and a half thousand Sunday dinners on a Sunday.
- 11:39Caroline Carter: We had you know 35 members of staff, it was huge.
- 11:42Caroline Carter: Um, but we had an accountant.
- 11:46Caroline Carter: Um, the accountant never wanted to speak to us.
- 11:49Caroline Carter: Uh if we rang them, you know, they were too busy to take the call.
- 11:52Caroline Carter: You might eventually get a call back two or three weeks later.
- 11:56Caroline Carter: Didn't understand VAT, didn't understand bookkeeping, didn't understand, and they were so expensive.
- 12:02Caroline Carter: But now looking back, I'm like, actually, we got a really good deal for what they were giving us.
- 12:07Caroline Carter: But as a small business owner, you think, wow, it's super expensive, and you don't see the value.
- 12:12Caroline Carter: Um, so I did um my first foray into accounting, I did a CIPP payroll qualification because I'm not the person to wing stuff.
- 12:21Caroline Carter: Um, I need to I need to know every facet of something before I can jump into it.
- 12:26Caroline Carter: So I started, we brought the payroll in-house.
- 12:29Caroline Carter: So I did my CIPP qualification, and in the end the cost of the CIPP qualification outweighed the savings that we made with the accountant anyway.
- 12:38Caroline Carter: Um and then I started doing bookkeeping qualifications to bring the bookkeeping in-house and the accounting in-house.
- 12:45Caroline Carter: And when we left the pub in 2007, um, you know, I'd I'd already started my journey towards an AAT qualification.
- 12:55Caroline Carter: Um, I was already CIPP qualified.
- 12:58Caroline Carter: Um so yeah.
- 13:02Douglas Aitken: Okay.
- 13:02Douglas Aitken: So after the pub, what what came after that?
- 13:07Caroline Carter: Um I did relief management for two years.
- 13:10Caroline Carter: So when we left the pub in 2007, um my partner at the time, Oliver, my son's dad.
- 13:16Caroline Carter: Um, we're still very good friends these days.
- 13:18Caroline Carter: People think it's really weird.
- 13:20Caroline Carter: Me and my husband went to his wedding.
- 13:21Caroline Carter: But yeah, um, but we the only thing that we had in common was the pub.
- 13:28Caroline Carter: So when the pub was gone, it was kind of we were more friends and so we kind of separated and went our own ways.
- 13:34Caroline Carter: And obviously I had the children.
- 13:37Caroline Carter: Um so I couldn't continue to do relief management in pubs anymore.
- 13:43Caroline Carter: Um and my mum was really poorly as well.
- 13:46Caroline Carter: Um, so I spent 2009 to 2011.
- 13:51Caroline Carter: I was caring for my mum and the children, kind of out of work, but I was still studying accountancy at college.
- 13:57Caroline Carter: Um and as a consequence of me studying accountancy at college, um, I met a really good friend, um, Rihanna.
- 14:05Caroline Carter: She was in my one of my college classes for AAT.
- 14:09Caroline Carter: And I was telling her, I was really struggling to get a job.
- 14:12Caroline Carter: I must have sent hundreds and hundreds of applications and to various accountancy practices, you know, across across the town, in other towns.
- 14:21Caroline Carter: And I just couldn't get anyone to give me a chance.
- 14:24Caroline Carter: I think I d I do think the minute that you they see that you're a you know a single parent with two young children, that you're just not gonna have the time or the dedication or yeah.
- 14:35Caroline Carter: But yeah, she gave me my first opportunity to land a job in a county.
- 14:40Douglas Aitken: So yeah.
- 14:42Caroline Carter: She starts work for me next month.
- 14:44Douglas Aitken: Oh wow.
- 14:45Douglas Aitken: Can't wait.
- 14:46Caroline Carter: I can't wait.
- 14:46Caroline Carter: It's come full circle.
- 14:47Caroline Carter: We worked together for yeah, about five years.
- 14:51Caroline Carter: Um, but she was that person, she was like, actually there's a you know, there's a job going at our place.
- 14:55Caroline Carter: Do you want me to kind of mention your name?
- 14:57Caroline Carter: And I was like, Oh, absolutely, yeah.
- 14:59Caroline Carter: That'd be wonderful, thank you.
- 15:01Caroline Carter: And that was my first opportunity in accounting, that was 2011.
- 15:05Caroline Carter: Um, I worked there for four or five years.
- 15:10Caroline Carter: So it's a big big pharmacy company.
- 15:14Douglas Aitken: Yeah.
- 15:15Douglas Aitken: And uh did you know straight away that this was for you?
- 15:19Douglas Aitken: Yes.
- 15:21Caroline Carter: Immediately.
- 15:22Caroline Carter: It brings that sense of order, doesn't it?
- 15:24Caroline Carter: I remember at the time they were using uh, you know, everything coming on paper, um, and they were using folio references and files and um everything was scanned and um so some of it was digital um, but predominantly all the paperwork was in big files.
- 15:40Caroline Carter: They used to get massive statements from the some of the big pharmaceuticals players because they were obviously ordering stock for the various pharmacies that we looked after.
- 15:49Caroline Carter: And the statements were like huge, they were like 56 pages.
- 15:53Caroline Carter: It's like reading a book, um, some of the statements.
- 15:57Caroline Carter: But yeah, I loved it.
- 15:58Caroline Carter: So it was that's yeah, you just know, don't you?
- 16:03Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 16:04Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 16:05Caroline Carter: So I progressed in that business.
- 16:06Caroline Carter: I went from um just doing bookkeeping um and then I went to doing management accounts and all that kind of stuff.
- 16:14Caroline Carter: So and then I moved into practice from there.
- 16:19Douglas Aitken: So how did that decision come about to move into practice?
- 16:23Caroline Carter: There was no opportunity for me to go any further where I was.
- 16:26Caroline Carter: I love the company.
- 16:28Caroline Carter: Um one of the best jobs I've ever had.
- 16:31Caroline Carter: And in hindsight, I'm like probably maybe I should have just stayed.
- 16:34Caroline Carter: Um because they were lovely.
- 16:36Caroline Carter: Um and my mum passed away whilst I was working there and they just looked after me.
- 16:41Caroline Carter: Um the whole team at the office looked after me and it was just if I'd been anywhere else, I wouldn't have got the same level of care.
- 16:49Caroline Carter: But yeah, no, it was um there was just nowhere else to go.
- 16:53Caroline Carter: The positions above me in the finance team were filled by really competent people and so I thought I need a new fresh opportunity.
- 17:01Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 17:02Caroline Carter: And so I moved into practice and hated it.
- 17:05Caroline Carter: Yeah.
- 17:09Douglas Aitken: So what type of firm was that with?
- 17:12Caroline Carter: Um, it was a contractor accountants.
- 17:15Caroline Carter: Um the less said the better maybe.
- 17:20Douglas Aitken: Yes.
- 17:21Douglas Aitken: I suspect I know the one that you're talking about actually.
- 17:23Douglas Aitken: So yeah.
- 17:24Douglas Aitken: Okay.
- 17:24Douglas Aitken: So you you weren't long there?
- 17:28Caroline Carter: Uh no, not long, and then I moved into literally to get out of that job um that I kind of felt trapped in.
- 17:35Caroline Carter: Um my dad lived around the corner from their offices and I used to go around at lunchtime and just cry.
- 17:41Caroline Carter: Like I really hate this job.
- 17:43Caroline Carter: Um, and I just took an agency job just to get out.
- 17:47Caroline Carter: Um and um yeah, and then I worked for the NHS.
- 17:52Douglas Aitken: Okay.
- 17:53Caroline Carter: Um so I used to work for a trust that no longer exists um in the NHS.
- 17:58Caroline Carter: And yeah.
- 18:00Caroline Carter: Yeah.
- 18:02Caroline Carter: Just moved about a bit.
- 18:06Douglas Aitken: So I'm interested in your experience of the accountant, but going back to the pub, the accountant that you never heard from.
- 18:14Douglas Aitken: How how is that informed how you deal with clients in in your firm now?
- 18:20Caroline Carter: We try not to leave um emails and phone calls and voicemails and WhatsApp messages were answered.
- 18:28Caroline Carter: Um, even if we haven't got an answer at the moment.
- 18:30Caroline Carter: Um just getting back to them to say, absolutely, we're aware you've sent this message.
- 18:35Caroline Carter: You know, we've got a task in our system and all of them know me well enough to go, wow, if it's in the system, it's definitely gonna happen.
- 18:42Caroline Carter: Um but yeah, um they yeah, it's just making sure they're communicated to and then explaining it to them in terms that they'll understand.
- 18:55Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 18:55Caroline Carter: And so trying to relate it to maybe something in their business or something that they could correlate this with in the in the real world.
- 19:05Caroline Carter: Um you know.
- 19:06Caroline Carter: I've been known to tie weird accounting concepts back to all kinds of all kinds of weird and wonderful things.
- 19:13Caroline Carter: Running being a big one.
- 19:15Douglas Aitken: Yeah, yeah.
- 19:17Douglas Aitken: How and how financially literate are most of your clients?
- 19:21Douglas Aitken: Do you know uh how do you how do you vet who you take on?
- 19:25Caroline Carter: There's a varying scale.
- 19:27Caroline Carter: And I think we've got clients who've been with us for five, six years before I went limited, and you can see their progression over time.
- 19:36Caroline Carter: So they've started and they've came on board with us, and they're there's zero understanding.
- 19:40Caroline Carter: Um they just know what what money's in the bank.
- 19:43Caroline Carter: They'll occasionally know how much money they're owed from from their customers, um, and that's it.
- 19:50Caroline Carter: And then they're once a year, you know, what's my tax bill?
- 19:53Caroline Carter: And there's no preparation, no planning.
- 19:55Caroline Carter: Then we've got some of them now, and it's that regular discussion with them where they've got a monthly report, we've made some suggestions, we know we're chatting about, they'll come back and they'll go, What if we declare an interim dividend?
- 20:07Caroline Carter: You know, the the language has changed, their understanding has developed over time.
- 20:13Caroline Carter: Um, so yeah.
- 20:14Caroline Carter: One of my longest time standing clients actually met on a running race in the middle of the mountains in Wales.
- 20:21Caroline Carter: We're running and just chatting about our respective businesses as you do on a 10K uphill.
- 20:27Caroline Carter: Um yeah, and she came a couple of weeks later, and yeah.
- 20:32Caroline Carter: That financial understanding develops over time.
- 20:36Douglas Aitken: But because you invest the time.
- 20:38Douglas Aitken: I suspect you're understating the impact that you're having on your clients here.
- 20:43Caroline Carter: Probably.
- 20:44Caroline Carter: Yeah.
- 20:44Caroline Carter: Well that we we'll go out and meet clients and you know, once a year we try and catch up with them for a a coffee and cake, and you know, we'll if they want to book meetings in we don't actually this is gonna devalue my time now.
- 20:59Caroline Carter: Um but we don't charge for if they want to jump on a quick Zoom for 15 minutes, we don't we we deem that to be included in their package of service.
- 21:08Caroline Carter: If as part of that meeting we identify that they need the addition of another another line of service, then we'll explain that to them and and kind of upsell it.
- 21:18Caroline Carter: But that regular contact with clients gives us the opportunity to do that.
- 21:22Caroline Carter: Um we know what's going on in their life, you know, we know what their spouse is doing, we we know what their kids are doing, um, because we speak to them all the time.
- 21:32Caroline Carter: Yeah.
- 21:33Douglas Aitken: What what would you say roughly your average fee is, Caroline?
- 21:36Douglas Aitken: Just approximately.
- 21:38Douglas Aitken: Average fee, annual or monthly?
- 21:41Douglas Aitken: Either.
- 21:43Caroline Carter: Yeah.
- 21:44Caroline Carter: Average annual fee is about 1700.
- 21:47Douglas Aitken: Okay.
- 21:48Caroline Carter: On average.
- 21:48Caroline Carter: Um, but we have the bankers' cell traders and stuff who obviously pay a little bit less than the bigger, bigger companies.
- 21:55Caroline Carter: Yeah.
- 21:55Caroline Carter: Yeah.
- 21:55Caroline Carter: But the average annual fees is currently sat at 1764.
- 22:01Douglas Aitken: Exactly.
- 22:02Caroline Carter: Exactly.
- 22:03Douglas Aitken: Why am I not surprised you know that?
- 22:05Douglas Aitken: Yeah, it's uh one of those KPIs.
- 22:09Douglas Aitken: Please forgive this brief interruption.
- 22:12Douglas Aitken: You secure the future profitability and future growth of your firm when your clients become more loyal, buy more from you, are happy to pay more, and also recommend you more.
- 22:25Douglas Aitken: These four important outcomes depend entirely on the behaviour and mindset of one group of people, your client managers.
- 22:34Douglas Aitken: When your client managers improve their skills and mindset, your firm results naturally improve too.
- 22:40Douglas Aitken: If you think that you could do more to build your client manager's capabilities, please click the Remarkable Client Manager link in the show notes.
- 22:50Douglas Aitken: When you do, you'll be able to complete the client manager diagnostic.
- 22:55Douglas Aitken: It won't cost you anything, and you'll discover the six elements that can help your managers unlock greater success in your firm.
- 23:03Douglas Aitken: What I'm interested in, Caroline, I guess, is in having spoken to other guests about this too, I'm interested generally in smaller businesses who aren't financially literate.
- 23:15Douglas Aitken: Like often accountants in our work with them will say things like, um, oh my clients don't don't want that type of service.
- 23:23Douglas Aitken: Advisory type service, as I would call it.
- 23:26Douglas Aitken: Um and they'll often say, No, clients don't want that.
- 23:29Douglas Aitken: But I'm often torn between, well, how do they know?
- 23:32Douglas Aitken: Because if they've never had it, then how do they know if they don't want it?
- 23:37Douglas Aitken: And you know, often we get difference in estimates of how many um or what percentage of the small business client base needs that type of service.
- 23:48Douglas Aitken: Now, I would say it's relatively high, accountants would say it's relatively low, and I suspect the truth is somewhere in between.
- 23:56Douglas Aitken: Um but I I I'm getting a sense here that you gently do that education and gently cross-sell.
- 24:04Douglas Aitken: You know, do you want to talk a little bit more about that?
- 24:07Douglas Aitken: How you go about it?
- 24:10Caroline Carter: Think about uh when you sign up for a software, and accountants love software, don't they?
- 24:15Caroline Carter: Um you get a free trial for 14 days or 30 days.
- 24:20Caroline Carter: That's what we do with clients.
- 24:21Caroline Carter: Um so we'll kind of prep a set of management accounts um and send it to them for free for two to three months.
- 24:29Douglas Aitken: Okay.
- 24:30Caroline Carter: It's that then the next month they don't they don't get that.
- 24:33Caroline Carter: We explain to them that we're kind of gonna trial it and see if it adds value to their business.
- 24:38Caroline Carter: Um, do they find it you know informative?
- 24:40Caroline Carter: Is it helping them?
- 24:42Caroline Carter: Can we tweak it and we get their feedback?
- 24:44Caroline Carter: And then they make that decision then whether they want to kind of take up that service or not.
- 24:51Caroline Carter: Probably half of them will.
- 24:53Caroline Carter: Um we do like a varying array of of management accounts.
- 24:58Caroline Carter: And I hate the term management accounts, traditional management accounts are awful, aren't they?
- 25:03Caroline Carter: They don't really they're they're still looking at the the past um and not really helping them to plan for the future.
- 25:10Caroline Carter: Um but it's look it's the small things like how putting a corporation tax estimate into the accounts, making sure all the depreciations run, um, looking at their capital allowances periodically rather than just at the year end, so that that tax estimate is a little bit more accurate.
- 25:29Caroline Carter: Um and that that's where it adds the value.
- 25:33Caroline Carter: So they know we we've got some clients who are tracking, you know, they've they've got these modern bank accounts and they've got pots, and in their pot they'll use the figure off our simple management report for a corporation tax estimate to make sure they've got that much money in that bank account.
- 25:47Caroline Carter: They literally top it up so it matches what we've what we've estimated estimated it to be.
- 25:53Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 25:53Caroline Carter: Um and then when they've got used to that value, which is why we do it for two to three months, um they they can't really live without it.
- 26:03Caroline Carter: And and that's the idea, isn't it?
- 26:05Caroline Carter: It's kinda yeah, you need to have s provide them with with a service that they can't really walk away from.
- 26:12Caroline Carter: It becomes they become reliant on it.
- 26:14Speaker 3: Yeah, it does.
- 26:15Caroline Carter: I think there are some other greater accountants who probably do it better than we do.
- 26:19Caroline Carter: Um and but I think that's that's the key, isn't it?
- 26:23Caroline Carter: Being part of their business and part of their their lives on a on a weekly basis or yeah.
- 26:29Caroline Carter: We have we have touchy awards.
- 26:31Caroline Carter: We try to touch our clients.
- 26:33Caroline Carter: Um and the person who's touched the most clients in the month, it sounds awful, doesn't it?
- 26:38Caroline Carter: Um we'll we'll get to like a touchy award.
- 26:43Douglas Aitken: I love that idea.
- 26:45Douglas Aitken: Do you actually measure your your touches?
- 26:50Caroline Carter: We use contact points in the practice management software.
- 26:53Caroline Carter: So we'll look at emails and WhatsApps and and have like a little bit of a tally.
- 26:58Caroline Carter: Um again, it's one of those data things that I've fallen behind with, but it's it's not killing me at the moment.
- 27:05Caroline Carter: Um but give it another couple of weeks and I'll be like, yeah, I need to bring that back around.
- 27:09Caroline Carter: It doesn't take long.
- 27:10Caroline Carter: Well all the data's in the system, you just need to extract it into a way that makes sense for the team.
- 27:18Douglas Aitken: Yeah.
- 27:18Douglas Aitken: Yeah.
- 27:19Douglas Aitken: Um the the data's at the root of everything, isn't it?
- 27:22Douglas Aitken: What you what you can measure, um, you can manage what tends to get managed, tends to get better.
- 27:28Douglas Aitken: Um an oft-quoted phrase, and uh but it's true.
- 27:33Douglas Aitken: I was with a manufacturing company over in Northern Ireland yesterday and uh they measure quality, which you'd expect in manufacturing, but I've I've come back really challenged by what are the analogies or the similarities with accounting.
- 27:49Douglas Aitken: And I actually posted about it today on LinkedIn challenging accountants to how do you measure quality?
- 27:55Douglas Aitken: Um and or do you measure quality at all even?
- 28:00Douglas Aitken: And I know for a fact that the majority of firms don't.
- 28:03Douglas Aitken: They they just don't.
- 28:05Douglas Aitken: They assume that they're putting out a a high quality product, but um who's the arbiter of that?
- 28:12Douglas Aitken: And and then you've got the the other conundrum around um what does the client actually value?
- 28:19Douglas Aitken: They do value a good quality product, of course, but do they value the relationship more where there are these touches um and where there is that education around the finances and where there's a direct link between what they're trying to achieve and you know the the focus of your meetings and whatnot.
- 28:39Douglas Aitken: Um so there's there's a lot wrapped up in that.
- 28:42Douglas Aitken: Tell tell me about what interactions do you tend to have with clients throughout the year, before let's say before the year-end meeting.
- 28:53Caroline Carter: All the time.
- 28:54Caroline Carter: Um I'm trying to think.
- 28:55Caroline Carter: We've we've had one client who crashed his van and he he rang us before he rang his spouse.
- 29:01Caroline Carter: Um it crashed his workpad, he wanted to know what what he needed.
- 29:05Caroline Carter: I was like, Well, are you okay?
- 29:07Caroline Carter: And he was like, Yeah, I'm fine.
- 29:08Caroline Carter: I was like, well, okay, we went and sort of the finance stuff later.
- 29:12Caroline Carter: Um it's that level of um support.
- 29:16Caroline Carter: And I think the first thing that goes through somebody's mind when they have a big expensive disaster is how is this going to impact my finances?
- 29:24Caroline Carter: Yeah.
- 29:25Caroline Carter: Um it's it's like a pain point for people, isn't it?
- 29:28Caroline Carter: Have I got enough money?
- 29:29Caroline Carter: Um, can I cover this expense?
- 29:32Caroline Carter: So yeah, we talk to people frequently.
- 29:35Caroline Carter: It does sometimes drive me a bit by because we do get Facebook messages, um, text messages, WhatsApp, emails.
- 29:46Caroline Carter: Um we get people who chat to us via their software.
- 29:50Caroline Carter: Um so if they're on zero, they'll leave you know discussion points on the on the bank reconciliation.
- 29:56Caroline Carter: So there's just all these methods of communication.
- 29:59Caroline Carter: that are bombarding it.
- 30:02Caroline Carter: But it works for the client.
- 30:04Caroline Carter: So if we know that that that client has this preferred method of communication.
- 30:09Caroline Carter: And we work with an external bookkeeper.
- 30:12Caroline Carter: And she does all the bookkeeping for one of our larger Soul Trader clients and she prefers Facebook Messenger.
- 30:18Caroline Carter: So she's probably we communicate with her on Facebook Messenger.
- 30:23Caroline Carter: But we'll do like you know if she wants to catch up or she's looking at tiding up the books for the year end we'll jump on a on a Teams call or a Zoom call with her.
- 30:32Caroline Carter: And again I'm doing myself out of money again.
- 30:36Caroline Carter: We wouldn't charge her for that.
- 30:38Caroline Carter: So yeah.
- 30:39Caroline Carter: It's about support isn't it about supporting people.
- 30:42Douglas Aitken: Yeah and I guess it's also personalised as well that people just expect I was going to ask you about client expectations um Caroline.
- 30:51Douglas Aitken: How do you feel client expectations have changed over the last few years say I think they are now looking for a more modern solution to the provision of services.
- 31:06Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 31:07Caroline Carter: We've we've done loads of migrations where people are coming off very old dated software and therefore they're leaving their previous account because their previous account will only deal with this software that they've they've been used to for a long time.
- 31:23Caroline Carter: They want something a little bit more modern.
- 31:25Caroline Carter: We're actually moving a client at the moment off quicken.
- 31:28Caroline Carter: Right, wow quicken I mean I haven't used quicken for they've been on quicken for yonks like donkeys years as they say um but yeah no I think that the expectation it's like Amazon isn't it you order something off Amazon and it arrives the next day and I think that's what that's what they're looking for with the provision of accounts and services and advice.
- 31:56Caroline Carter: They want somebody to be at the end of the phone somebody that they can drop a quick WhatsApp to them and just say well you know I've just crashed my van what what here are my two options for financing the new one what what's your advice on this and then we can go away and prep what our advice would be um based on their individual circumstances because it's not one size fits all is it?
- 32:19Douglas Aitken: That's right.
- 32:20Douglas Aitken: Yeah I often use the analogy about um Spotify or Netflix.
- 32:25Douglas Aitken: If Spotify or Netflix doesn't give me good recommendations based on what I've watched or listened to you know I'd be pretty grumpy about that but they don't because it learns of course what what genres you like and what music you like and whatnot.
- 32:40Douglas Aitken: And and so that's where that it feels like that drives a lot of client expectations.
- 32:48Douglas Aitken: They really want a personalised thing and you know that that of course goes for employees too.
- 32:53Douglas Aitken: They too expect a personalised experience.
- 32:57Douglas Aitken: Tell me about your team you know what what's what's the next stage for them and for you as well you know what are your aspirations for growth?
- 33:07Caroline Carter: I think we need to balance out.
- 33:09Caroline Carter: I think we need a couple of maybe till the end of our next financial year to just steady the ship.
- 33:16Caroline Carter: So yeah that's kind of where we're at the moment and we're not looking to grow the client base at the moment.
- 33:25Caroline Carter: I mean we will if if somebody comes along that's too good to to turn away um we would take them on board as I think most accounts would but um we're not actively looking to do any marketing activity at the moment our website has been down for a couple of weeks um it's being rebuilt so it's like a little project piece on the side and I'm I'm not that bothered that it's down at the moment because it gives us that that time to settle.
- 33:54Caroline Carter: So I've grown I I've made hiring mistakes in the past um but the first employee who is took on who is still here is is Emma.
- 34:06Caroline Carter: She's on maternity leave at the moment and she's back in November.
- 34:10Caroline Carter: But with my uh background in a in apprenticeships I used to work in apprenticeship um provision um in accounting and I sent both of uh Emma and Dave who work for me have both done apprenticeships through um the training provider that I used to work for.
- 34:28Caroline Carter: So Emma's finished her level three um Dave's finished his level four.
- 34:34Caroline Carter: And yeah it's about it's about offering them that that next step isn't it so I know that Emma is interested in maybe looking at um some social media stuff and you know the local um chamber of commerce the local growth hub they've run training courses where I can you know send her on that.
- 34:55Caroline Carter: Before she went on a maternity we were doing some payroll training so it's about having that bespoke training for each individual person and what what they need that not only fits the business requirements but actually interests them.
- 35:10Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 35:11Caroline Carter: I mean that most accounting's pretty boring in it.
- 35:13Caroline Carter: So but you know running an AGM for a rock band is probably a little bit more interesting.
- 35:21Douglas Aitken: Yeah.
- 35:21Douglas Aitken: Tell me about um um your biggest success with a client you know maybe maybe it's someone that literally knew nothing about finance at all because they hadn't been supported by their previous accountant um you know tell me about your your biggest success story.
- 35:38Caroline Carter: It's hard to ch I'm I'm looking at the work in progress board now and I'm trying to decide what's it probably the the well we've got a few and it is it's about that that light bulb moment where they kind of they get it they finally they get it um and then they start chasing you then.
- 35:58Caroline Carter: You kinda oh I've not had this report yet.
- 36:02Caroline Carter: Oh yeah sorry um it doesn't happen very often but they're educated enough to know when it when things are then due and when they should be receiving data and information um and what it means as well.
- 36:16Caroline Carter: So we've um yeah it's difficult to pick one client.
- 36:22Caroline Carter: We've got so many good ones.
- 36:24Caroline Carter: I mean like everyone we've got some that are not not as good and being putting it nicely.
- 36:33Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 36:33Caroline Carter: Um but yeah no predominantly the client base is really good.
- 36:38Caroline Carter: Yeah it's that that that moment that that education piece where they finally they get it.
- 36:44Caroline Carter: Even something as simple as payments on account for self-assessment and they finally get it.
- 36:51Caroline Carter: Like oh right okay I get it now.
- 36:54Douglas Aitken: Yeah yeah and I think that's the best thing you can give to someone isn't it so yeah yeah absolutely to know that you're actually helping and helping move on their business because inevitably it impacts on their personal life too.
- 37:08Douglas Aitken: Um I suspect you're underselling yourself remarkably here Caroline Probably and I just like I like chatting with people so I think you can you just can't shut me up.
- 37:20Caroline Carter: So if the client rings Dave who works for me will say this I'll say to him oh just be I'll just be two minutes I'll just get this call because we plan to do something and then half an hour later I'll come off the phone it's like see it's never five minutes.
- 37:34Douglas Aitken: Yeah yeah because I'm checking in on them you know how's the dog how's the kids yeah absolutely and and that's the human side isn't it absolutely um well I've really enjoyed our discussion here today um Caroline could go on but in closing I just want to pose a a question that I I tend to pose to guests what do you see as the future for accounting?
- 38:00Caroline Carter: How do you see it changing in the next let's say five years or so and and also maybe associated with that what's going to stay the same in you I think you will all know always need people that are technically sound um I often find that the people who kind of have the technical expertise and the and that skill set don't really like to be in the limelight or in the spotlight or hold the relationship with the client and they kind of wanna want to work in the background.
- 38:33Caroline Carter: And I I think those people in in the future the the development is to more client facing, more relationship focused um letting AI to take some of the pressure off with the workload um and yeah you're still going to need people with the the technical expertise but I think a lot of the kind of data entry the dreary stuff um is going to disappear over time.
- 38:59Caroline Carter: Yeah I think we need to jump on board with this A AI revolution.
- 39:03Caroline Carter: Yeah absolutely yeah so yeah I think it'd be more difficult to recruit as well.
- 39:10Caroline Carter: And I always recruit based on um you can teach accounty and I I think that comes from I've spent years teaching accounty so um but you can teach accountancy to most people most people will be able to get a basic understanding of it if you hire based on those other skill sets.
- 39:32Caroline Carter: And so they're able to communicate with people.
- 39:35Caroline Carter: They're not scared of taking a phone call um they want to build relationships with people they're chatty they're friendly they're personable you can't teach that stuff yeah and so we've started hiring to a completely different set of skills good excellent and what does the future hold for Carline I'm not sure I think I I miss teaching um I don't think I would like to go back to a full time teaching job.
- 40:09Caroline Carter: I do still teach occasionally to cover sick leave at colleges and stuff.
- 40:13Caroline Carter: Right but and I think maybe building some kind of educational program um yeah but it it becomes the next shiny object for me.
- 40:26Caroline Carter: And I really need to focus on just um you know building the business and settling the team and and kind of you know delivering the work for a couple of months improving some of the processes and systems before I jump off on the next um the next new shiny thing like a magpie.
- 40:45Caroline Carter: Yes.
- 40:46Caroline Carter: Good self awareness I've already mapped it all out so it's all it's all there in the background for me to jump into but it is the the next shiny project that I need to ignore for a while.
- 40:56Douglas Aitken: Yeah yeah fab.
- 40:58Douglas Aitken: Okay well Carline I've really enjoyed our chat this morning um thanks so much for being a guest on the podcast.
- 41:06Douglas Aitken: Me too thank you thank you.
- 41:09Douglas Aitken: You've just heard Caroline Carter of Carter Clear Accounting talk about how her recruitment has been informed by how she sees the world and how she makes sense of the numbers.
- 41:30Douglas Aitken: These are subjects taught in the Accountants Growth Academy.
- 41:33Douglas Aitken: To find out more go to remarkablepractice dot com or follow the link in the show notes.
- 41:39Speaker: You'll find more valuable discussions with the leaders of ambitious accounting firms at humanize the numbers.online you can also sign up to be notified each time a new podcast is made available this is a short snippet from a podcast with Noel Guilford in which he talks about his definition of advisory if you'd like to hear more go to your usual podcast platform or listen to it on humanizehenumbers.online businesses need somebody from the outside looking at their business and offering suggestions have you thought of this have you thought of that because we're all very close to our own businesses um sometimes it's it's uh you know we can't see the wood for the trees and so having somebody who's who's who's looking uh at your at your business overall and and thinking about the business and how it might be able to grow what possible opportunities are and obviously using the experience of what maybe other clients are doing even though they're not in the same industry I can talk about obviously on an anonymous basis well you know a client of mine is doing so and so and so and so and that's having some success with that is that something that that that you think would be relevant to you