Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / The Spielworxx Bulletin-The Spiel des Jahres Episode
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the most informed boardgame news show on the Internet with the beating heart
- 0:04of the German ballgame industry. Uly Bleeman and Sam Blowke found slammed outside of
- 0:09a pub in a pool of his own offerings, Ben Meadows, this is
- 0:13the Spielworks, So ladies and gentlemen welcome. Here. We are to the
- 0:22best podcast with an English and German in the world. It is the Spearworks
- 0:27Bulletin. And my guest of honor, who's my guest every month is only
- 0:32Bledeman. Uly welcome. Yeah, I'm welcome. Thanks for having me,
- 0:36Ben, and I think some half sentence has to be added. The best
- 0:40podcast was English and German in the Tabletop Hobby, and that may be more
- 0:47accorate. No, no, absolutely, with an English and German in the
- 0:51world. All the rest of them are complete disasters. I agree. Now
- 0:56I know a seed. So before we get onto what what game you want
- 1:00to talk about at the beginning of the show? So how long? How
- 1:03long until you how long until you stop doing this podcast because you've become a
- 1:07Twitch celebrity. I think I'm already a Twitch celebrity. For several years when
- 1:14I did my Spielworks chat, there were so many groupies here at bill back
- 1:19at Billaboo here knocking at the door, so we had to relocate. It
- 1:25was awful and I stopped. That was that is the actual reason why I
- 1:29stopped the Speelworks Chat. And now I'm slowly maybe restarting. Do you do
- 1:36you remember doing the having me on the Spielworks Chat and then the very next
- 1:41week having Isaac Shalev on the spire Works Chat and then saying, I quote,
- 1:46this is the best interview I've ever had on the Spielworks Chat. Yeah,
- 1:49one percent, of course, because that is the truth. And you
- 1:56and you see that the difference, especially well when your former guests was so
- 2:02so, and then you see and then you have a real celebrity like like
- 2:07Isaac, and you see the difference. It was fantastic. All right,
- 2:10let's move on. Let's move on then slagging me off. So we're talking
- 2:15about games we played over the last month, and it'll be unsurprising to the
- 2:21listeners to know that you've chosen a GMT game, so only take it away.
- 2:24Yeah it is Prime Minister, But actually I had another GMT game in
- 2:30our former episode Barracks Emperors, and this one is also not a game where
- 2:38you'd say, well, this is typical GMT. But we touched on this
- 2:42briefly last time. I think it's very difficult now to say GMT is only
- 2:47doing that kind of game or that kind of gaming genre. They are basically
- 2:53doing everything. And Prime Minister is a one to four player game, although
- 2:59we just played formed. I think it is a four player game. Although
- 3:02some people are saying the solo mode is wonderful, I'm not a solo player.
- 3:07So, and what is the game about. It's we are in the
- 3:10nineteenth century, so queen Victorian times, and we want to end the game
- 3:17being prime minister, so having a certain amount of victory points. But you
- 3:23can only win if you are prime minister at that time. And four player
- 3:29means one player as a prime minister, one is the government backbencher, another
- 3:35player the third player as Opposition leader, and the fourth player is the opposition
- 3:38backbencher. And this alone makes for some terrific combinations because I was once in
- 3:50this game. So I started in our game as opposition leader. Then I
- 3:53was Prime Minister for a certain amount of time, and you feel the pressure
- 3:59being in the government. You have to get your bills through, So that
- 4:03is it's difficult to deal with the opposition, but you're it's even worse having
- 4:10a back bencher that wants your position too, So your standing has to be
- 4:15pretty high. If you are failing with some things, your your backbencher will
- 4:19take your position. And this alone is really a wonderful concept and I think
- 4:27it has been executed in a in a great way by GMT. Who design
- 4:30this. I forgot. I think it's a it's a new b designer.
- 4:39Let me Paul whatever, So sorry, sorry, Paul, sorry the designer
- 4:44that I'm not that I haven't remembered your your name and Paul, hell yeah,
- 4:49okay, so yeah, probably a new newcomer designer, but well designed.
- 4:57And does it share any similarities to other other familiar games or it does
- 5:01it feel completely original? It feels pretty original. Of course, it has
- 5:06tracking of victory points, tracking of vote projections, but everything, in my
- 5:12opinion, is done in a pretty original way. And don't be scared if
- 5:16you are getting the package like me. When I got the package a couple
- 5:19of months ago, i opened it. On the top there was a multiplayer
- 5:25roots booklet and I'm grabbing it. Looked at the backside. Sixty h pages
- 5:30and I thought, oh wow, let's put it back. I had no
- 5:35inclination to start playing it. But the actual rules, and this is somewhat
- 5:40strange. They end at page twenty two and it's just two columns per page
- 5:46and with description of the components. So it's a pretty easy game to get
- 5:50into. What is interesting there is the example of play in this booklet is
- 5:57more than thirty pages long. So and it's not a simple game, and
- 6:04probably you'll play for two to three hours, especially in your first game when
- 6:10you have to check a couple of rules. But I was very positively surprised
- 6:15by the game. So I want to talk about a game, but I
- 6:17don't really want to talk about the game. I want to talk about a
- 6:20concept rather than the game. Right, and the game I'm going to use
- 6:25because we've talked about Me and Steve have talked a lot about this on our
- 6:29battle reports, and this is so. The game is Key Harvest from Richard
- 6:33Brees, and so Steve is obsessed with collecting key games and then occasionally he
- 6:43suggests we play them, and then we play them and then inevitably they're brilliant.
- 6:48Right, and Key Harvest is two thousand and seven something like this,
- 6:54and the concept I want to talk about, so Key Harvest is this,
- 6:59so so Richard Brees desis these wonderfully nasty little eurogames that are super easy to
- 7:05grow, that you can learn how to play the game in a turn,
- 7:09and then you realize just how mean and challenging the mechanisms are. If you've
- 7:13ever played Key Flower, it is a bastard of a game, but it's
- 7:16wonderful. And every time I play a Richard Brees game, we always talk
- 7:24about how hard it is to get hold of them. And I want to
- 7:27talk about the concept. So you're kind of like this, but you're not
- 7:30like this. So it's the concept of the gentleman designer, right, So
- 7:34it's the board game designer who really doesn't do it for money per se.
- 7:42They have a normal job. Tony Boydell falls into this category as well.
- 7:46But they're incredibly good designers and every game you play from them, whether it's
- 7:53some twenty five years ago or from last year, end up being absolutely fantastic.
- 7:58And I end up getting really frustrated this because if someone like so,
- 8:03you're familiar with Capstone, right you've worked with it. I think Capstone currently
- 8:09at the moment might be the best company for reprinting older games with a modern
- 8:16sheen that aren't outrageous. If you look at the games that they publish.
- 8:22When they do a reprint of something, it looks brilliant, it looks modern,
- 8:26but it's not like the two hundred and fifty quid reprint of Castle's a
- 8:30Burgundy, Right. I mean, even though saying this when I first got
- 8:35into gaming, the idea that an eighty to ninety euro game is kind of
- 8:39quite cheap is bizarre. But still, and you look at their you look
- 8:41at their reprint of Bus, right, their reprint of Bus is astonishing.
- 8:48They haven't messed with the game at all. But what they've done is turned
- 8:52what is a really unappealing package, I would say, with the original copy
- 8:56of Bus, into something that looks modern and sleek and brilliant. And I
- 9:00look at someone like Richard Brees and I wish that he would take his catalog
- 9:05over to a publisher like Capstone, because all of his games are brilliant and
- 9:11they could give them that sort of modern sheen, sell them at a reasonable
- 9:16price, and open up this I think probably maybe the most underrated board game
- 9:22designer, certainly in the eurosphere and open it up to a new audience.
- 9:30Because if you play Reef Encounter once, or you play you play Keedom.
- 9:35I think it is we played recently, Key Harvest, Key Flower, all
- 9:37of these they're just astonishing games and fundamentally what they are. I think a
- 9:45lot of the reasons why modern eurogames feel a bit disposable is because almost all
- 9:50of them now are multiplayer solitaire games. Quite a few at least, yes,
- 9:56And the thing about the Key games is the player interaction is off the
- 10:03chance, and yet the learning of the games is so easy because he's such
- 10:07an efficient and brilliant and clever game designer. And I guess so the concept
- 10:11I'm talking about is the gentleman game designer that frustrates the hell out of me
- 10:16because I want them to be a bit more business like so you can actually
- 10:18get hold of their games, you know what I mean? Yeah, sure,
- 10:22but I do not know. Of course I talked to Richard before.
- 10:28I do not know him well. But probably this is something that he is
- 10:33simply not interested in. Sure it could be, but this is just speculation,
- 10:39you now, So no substance, as always, and this just a
- 10:43speculation that maybe he wants some control about it, and maybe it is total
- 10:50control. He doesn't want to to bump back in a schedule because there's another
- 10:56important project at the publisher. It could be the But I know what you're
- 11:01you're saying then, so it's that kind of thing that it's great. So
- 11:05if he wants total control over his work and he wants to continue to be
- 11:07a boutique publisher with small print runs, I mean, that's fine. It's
- 11:13it's up to him, right, I just think, and it's not about
- 11:16it's not about that thing of he would make loads of money. It's not
- 11:20that it's that thing of His games are so bloody good and he is so
- 11:26unrecognized. I think when people talk about the great designers, when they talk
- 11:31about Chefan Feldubey Rosenberg, Brunokaitala, Richard Breese is never in that conversation,
- 11:35right, And I have never played a game by him that. I've never
- 11:41played a game by him that I thought was bad. But not only that,
- 11:45I've never played a game by him that I didn't think was great.
- 11:50I mean, if you played Reef Encounter, I played it many years ago
- 11:54when it was you, and actually it didn't grab me because I not only
- 12:00anymore. So I can't even tell you why because it's too long ago.
- 12:05But I agree that the key games are all wonderful, brilliant, and I
- 12:11look at and I always talk about this when I talk about I've been talking
- 12:13about this a lot recently. And when I think of Tony Boudell, right,
- 12:18you know, he's always got if you follow his blog, he's always
- 12:22got five or six games in the process of being designed, and yet none
- 12:26of them get bloody published. And it's very frustrating because I want more games
- 12:31to be published. And it is that concept of people who kind of if
- 12:35you say someone does something for a hobby, right, that sounds like they're
- 12:39amateur and they're not very good. But that's not the case here. These
- 12:43are two people, for example, who are excellent at the top of their
- 12:46field, but because they don't have the financial impetus to go out and do
- 12:52more work, they don't do more work, right, right, absolutely,
- 12:56And I agree one. And you know, I'm coming from wargaming and from
- 13:03the eighties, and most wargame designers at that time in the US they were
- 13:07amateur designers. And sometimes you could see it and you could feel it,
- 13:11and the work wasn't really good, but some of their work, and some
- 13:15of these so called amateur hobby designers were brilliant and they advanced the state of
- 13:20the art for sure. Yeah, well, it's fascinating. I think I
- 13:24got into gaming sort of around twenty eleven, twenty twelve, which is just
- 13:28as Kickstarter was kicking off in hobby games right and outside of Germany, I
- 13:35would say, because Germany is a kind of different deal, I think you
- 13:39could pretty much count on one hand the professional game designers in the industry right
- 13:46yea and now. And I think it's by and larger great thing that the
- 13:50industry has expanded to such a degree that there is room for more and more,
- 13:56not just professionalism, but professionals. And if you can have your life
- 14:01as a professional within an industry such as board gaming, I think that's a
- 14:05wonderful thing. I think that's a net good for society, right. And
- 14:11yeah, it's just frustrating that what frustrated to me. We were playing Key
- 14:18Harvest with this guy means to with another guy, and he just said,
- 14:22if I looked at this game on the shelf, I'd never bloody play it.
- 14:28And it's and people are like that and It's such a shame that someone
- 14:33as good as Richard Brees isn't being recognized for factors that are nothing to do
- 14:39with the game, right, I mean the art. I don't mind the
- 14:43art on a key game, but but I get why people think it doesn't
- 14:46look modern and it looks a bit amateurish, you know. Yeah, you
- 14:50could think it's a game from twenty years ago, and some of these games
- 14:54are now fifteen, sixteen, seventeen years all of course. But I don't
- 15:01mind the art at all too so I think it's it's fine. It's not
- 15:05in the way like some modern graphics or if you if you see Castles of
- 15:11Burgundy, a new edition, I think the the new buildings are in the
- 15:16way of they are not functional. They are not they are not they are
- 15:20even in hindrance to play the game. Yeah, all right, well that
- 15:26was interesting. Let's move on to in act cross self promotion. Uli Bleets
- 15:31of the German board game industry will tell you what's happening in all right,
- 15:41Ooley, your opportunity now, I mean, you've been doing nothing but marketing,
- 15:46marketing, marketing for the last week, but do some more marketing.
- 15:50Indeed, I'm looking forward to it. But let's go back to Bus for
- 15:54a second. Because Spielworks will have a limited number of English language Bus copies
- 16:02at the Speedworks booth at Essen. So Clay Capstone isn't having a booth again
- 16:07at Essen for reasons. I can totally understand. It's so difficult to rent
- 16:14a booths overseas, bring your games, sell them, have a stuff over
- 16:18their hotel rooms for these people. But I'll have a limited number of bus
- 16:22copies at the Spielworks booths at Asen. I do not know the price yet.
- 16:27I do not know how to handle this, but there will be news
- 16:30in September on the website, so there will be And it's not that there
- 16:36are just ten or twenty copies, so it is limited, but still people
- 16:41should be happy if you're interested. No, not at all at this moment,
- 16:47not at all. But it will be reasonable, I hope. So
- 16:49this is up to Clay. What you're saying is, if you want gut
- 16:52roth chardonnay whiskey that makes you blind for a copy of Bus, go to
- 16:59the sh Bilwig's boothedessent. Yes, actually the whiskey is fine in my opinion.
- 17:06The shadow nay is interesting and of course there's also that Prosecco, which
- 17:15is also interesting. Interesting, So carry on, what else have we gone?
- 17:19Yeah? So and this is news from today, so very new.
- 17:25Spielworks will do its fourth printing of the German edition of Paspamer. So it's
- 17:32limited, but Whirligigs or Drew got in touch and told me there is again
- 17:37enough demand to have a multi language reprint of the game. So German edition
- 17:45will go to Spielworks. Should be in Germany. November is time, I
- 17:49guess, but there will be a pre order. It's a Spielworks website soon
- 17:55because the numbers are really limited, and I will have some coins. If
- 18:00you are into metal coins, I will have some coins as well. So
- 18:04that's Pakspamer. Then a game that is already out for some time is now
- 18:10Elborro German and English edition. I have very few copies remaining, so if
- 18:15you're interested in Otis and Mike's new game, sorry Elborro a la Grange game,
- 18:23please go to our website and check the game out. And then the
- 18:29game the name I already mentioned again because I'm working on this game all the
- 18:34time is IPOs again, this game by Chefan Ristas, and yes the game
- 18:40should go to Game Fountain Spilish Media late next month, so late June.
- 18:45And it is wonderful. It's coming together very nicely, but it's a ton
- 18:52of work. It's really a ton of work. If you're interested, you
- 18:56could check out my Twitch channel or twitch speedworks. But the videos there stay
- 19:03only for a week, so they will disappear. That's why I'm moving all
- 19:07these videos to my YouTube page. If you check for Uli Bleman, so
- 19:11my last name Blenhaman, then you'll find the videos. They give you a
- 19:17first introduction to the game. And if you look at the commens section and
- 19:22all the intro section of the videos, you see there are two pages so
- 19:27you can follow the game at game found and there is a pre sale page
- 19:33for IPOs as well. So hired a incredibly good looking voiceover artist, yes,
- 19:41some videos for Yes, I hired a wonderful person. I'm not sure
- 19:48good looking, but he's called I think ben is Ace. Yes, that's
- 19:55right, that's right, that's what's name, although quite a few people are
- 20:00mentioning him under his Italian name any such. So, can you tell us
- 20:06anything about EPOSS in terms of the interesting stuff, which is how much it's
- 20:11going to cost? Ah, yeah, it will cost more than one hundred
- 20:15for sure, because it's a huge game. It weighs more than three and
- 20:18a half kilos, and it has the base game plus eight scenarios, and
- 20:26all the scenarios have limited numbers of additional components, and then there is also
- 20:32the campaign game, which adds another bits. And all the wooden pieces are
- 20:37no, sorry, quite a large number of the wooden pieces are screen printed,
- 20:42and we are having I think four hundred forty seven wooden pieces in the
- 20:48game, although you'd think, now, oh wonderful, Yeah, you are
- 20:56getting also I think one hundred and twenty wooden cubes dug them. Then you
- 21:00have some wooden discs, but there are each player screenprinted population tokens, and
- 21:10ships and high priests and all this, and of course there are more than
- 21:18two hundred game cards, so that's also a large amount. But it's a
- 21:22beautiful game, brilliantly, I must really say, brilliantly designed by Chefan Ristos.
- 21:30To put together such a huge design project, and in the first stage
- 21:37doing this all for yourself is amazing, simply amazing. And when are you
- 21:45going to announce that you're going to publish my game? You just keep you
- 21:49keep I keep sending you emails and I don't get any response. I followed
- 21:53them to Ignazi because Ignazi said, well, if you are getting an email
- 22:00about Ben, and I want to have first look at it, right,
- 22:03Okay, I think in your contract with Portless that he has now writes a
- 22:07first refusal on all your designs. Yeah, so I have to do this.
- 22:14I'm contractually obliged, obliged to do this. All right, Well,
- 22:18let's move on to do you like informed opinions on board game topics that are
- 22:22important to you? Then don't listen to Ben. It's our topic of the
- 22:27week. Okay, So this is going to be this section is going to
- 22:33be wonderful because basically we're just going to listen to you moan for thirty minutes.
- 22:38So someone on the discord and if you want to join the five Games
- 22:41for Doomsday discord, you can get a five g fd dot com click on
- 22:45the pin post and you can join the discord over there. And someone suggested
- 22:48that they'd like to hear Oui speak about one of his favorite topics, and
- 22:53that is the Spielders Yrus because the nominations are going to come out soon,
- 22:59and rather than talk about who OUI thinks is going to be nominated. I'd
- 23:03rather ask him more about his views on it in general. And I and
- 23:12I think this is an area in which I don't think we necessarily agree entirely,
- 23:15so this will be interesting. So firstly, you've spoken to me a
- 23:19lot about the SDJ. What is your sort of central thesis on the prize
- 23:26as a whole. It's very difficult, so it also it depends on my
- 23:32mood. And I'm now in this business for about one hundred years, so
- 23:37of course my view on the SDG award has changed two or it is changing.
- 23:45It is fluctuating, and I have to say my first If I'm thinking
- 23:52about Spielisias and the awards, my first thing, my first thought is very
- 23:59positive. That may surprise a few people, but I think each industry,
- 24:07no matter how large or small it is, need some light tower, some
- 24:11award that everybody is looking towards. And that ishbield is siaus. It's not
- 24:18the Origins Awards or some other awards because nobody cares about them. It's like,
- 24:26it's really like the Oscars for movies. And to achieve this and to
- 24:32make this happen in a pretty short time. Is an amazing achievement because what
- 24:38the original or what they founders made very well is not to have fifty categories.
- 24:45In my opinion, that is key. Or look at the War Game
- 24:48Awards, Charles as Roberts Awards. I think now there are more than twenty
- 24:52five categories, and nobody remembers why you have worn something. It has no
- 24:56meaning at all. Under the reign of Tom Felbar about ten years ago.
- 25:04What they did well is to open the award internationally. They attend gen Con,
- 25:11they attend other conventions, so now even the Americans they are looking for
- 25:18spield is the hoars nominations for the Spiel of the Game of the Year award.
- 25:23And I think that is an astonishing achievement for such a small group of
- 25:30people. And so I've been talking a lot about this on podcasts and also
- 25:36in drunken rounds in pubs over the last couple of weeks because it's always this
- 25:41is always my most disappointing time of the year, because I realized no one
- 25:44listens to my podcast because I don't win the Golden geeg Awards. But and
- 25:48I was talking about this on a show and the Golden Geek frustrates me because
- 25:53I don't think the Golden Geek is about the quality of podcasts. It's necessarily
- 26:00because it's a it's a crowdsource to ward. The spielders yrs resolutely isn't a
- 26:06crowdsourced toward. What do you think about the relative merits and so of having
- 26:11a jury decide or having the crowds decide. Do you think that people take
- 26:17jury awards more seriously? I think so. I think so, and ultimately
- 26:22I think it's a good thing that jury picks the games. So I think
- 26:27that is better than a popular award. And these popular crowdsourced towards, they
- 26:40tend to be influenced by the hardcore gamers because most families, why should they
- 26:48vote for such a thing. You can see it even in the you know
- 26:52what's a Dodger Spieder? Price is the price? By the way, I
- 26:56think you can right now wait vote for the prize. But you see that
- 27:00a lot of the high placed games are gamers games. So I just want
- 27:07to say clarify for the listeners. I'm sure most people know this, but
- 27:11just in case. There are two basic prizes in Germany for games. There's
- 27:15the Spielders Yarras and the Deutsche Spieler Prize, which I'm sure you know but
- 27:21anyway translates to the German Game Award and the Schpilders Yarras is the big famous
- 27:26one run by the Spielders Jarras and the deutsch Spieler Prize is a smaller though
- 27:30though quite big awards. The ceremony is great as long as you don't go
- 27:34with early that is run by Essen, that gets awarded at Essen, and
- 27:41this is a crowd sourced award if I'm correct, it is absolutely correct,
- 27:45and you're also correct that don't go with me to the ceremony so because you
- 27:51end up getting nearly arrested. No, this is Essen time and it's right
- 27:57before the start of the show, so I'm stress, I'm really stressed.
- 28:02And it's not the best type for ceremony. But it's free drinks and food,
- 28:07so what more can used to be it used to be so right,
- 28:11so and doutscha Spila. Price is important in my opinion for Esen. So
- 28:21if you win this award and it's as in time, you can of course
- 28:26have it at your booze. You can advertise it and quite a few people
- 28:30not hardcore gamers, but quite a few people are confused by these two awards.
- 28:34But after after the show, it's Spielisias and Spielisias and Shpilisias Spila.
- 28:41Price isn't important anymore. So I think the jury is actually a good thing.
- 28:48What I am now going to the first negative part in my opinion is
- 28:53who is a good jury? Who makes a good jury? And I know,
- 29:00I think almost all people may be all some better than others, and
- 29:07these are all nice people. I'm still not one other percent sure if they
- 29:11are all qualified to be in the jury for Game of the Year. So
- 29:17so what would what would you suggest is because I know a couple of people,
- 29:19they're all very nice, what would you suggest is the qualification people need?
- 29:25I think, or please keep this in mind and ask me again in
- 29:32a couple of seconds, because I think one thing that is in a way
- 29:37dangerous is how few people are in the jury. So if you see the
- 29:42oscars, and this is not really something that you should mirror because the oscars
- 29:51have so many problems and it's it's not really a transparent thing. But what
- 29:56the one thing is great that there are more than one thousand people voting on
- 30:02the various categories. And here you are having a handful of people or two
- 30:07handfuls of people. So that is dangerous because of course these people are talking
- 30:11and you have your opinion leaders, and it's very easy to get a majority.
- 30:21And I don't like this, and your question going back to this qualification,
- 30:27I think it's not good enough to be a podcaster or yeah, of
- 30:33course you could be in the jury, not a podcaster or a hardcore gamer
- 30:42who plays one game per day. It's not good enough. You need to
- 30:48know something about game theory. You should have read some books about this,
- 30:56and maybe now everybody in the jury is upset and telling me I've read that,
- 31:02and I've read that, and then I can only apologize, but I
- 31:04doubt it. So here's our first point of disagreement. And so in theory,
- 31:11I don't think you're wrong, but I think what you're doing there is
- 31:18misinterpreting the purpose of the spielders yaas, especially the spielders yars Award. Kennispiel
- 31:25put that off to the side for the moment. The point is the purpose
- 31:27of the spielders yaas is too. It's too it's twofold. I think it's
- 31:33to give a boost to the industry. Wow, well, because the spielders
- 31:42yours I think. I think the idea of the Spielders Yours is to make
- 31:47the industry more profitable, more successful, to put it more foremost in the
- 31:52minds of the of the German public, but the public of the world.
- 31:56And secondly, if you look at the Spielders Yaris award, it's there for
- 32:02family game. Do you want the people who buy the Spiel disjaas to be
- 32:07able to play the game and say this is brilliant. It doesn't matter how
- 32:10many times you've read Homo Ludins. If you're someone who knows about games,
- 32:15you know what is going to appeal to that demographic right within a certain amount
- 32:21of I disagree vehementally here, So yeah, I think. So. It
- 32:32is called Spiel Desias, which means the game of the year, So it
- 32:38should be the best game of the year. Should if it's for the industry
- 32:44or to boost the industry, it should be the best game where the industry
- 32:47makes the most money with in the next couple of months. I think sometimes
- 32:52I have the I'm under the impression that it's really that purpose, and I
- 32:58don't think it's the job of the jury to decide this or to boost the
- 33:05industry. Everything is fine if they are trying to bring with the money they
- 33:10are getting from the publishers that they bring in new people. And they have
- 33:15these various various programs where some designers get some money some organizations and I love
- 33:27this, and let's face it, the jury, the Spieldersias organization has lots
- 33:32of money, so they should do this. But I don't think it's there.
- 33:40What is the best It's not their job maybe to have a more general
- 33:45term to bring in or try to bring in more gamers. And yes,
- 33:52a family game if it's family game of the year, so now the general
- 33:57Spielsias it should be easy to get into. So if it has sixteen pages
- 34:01of rules, that's of course way too many. But I still I'm here
- 34:07in disagreement. And if you see in books the best games in the year,
- 34:14there's the Deutsche Book Prize, that is not a book that has just
- 34:20eighty pages of texts and in large print. It is a book that is
- 34:28outstanding and the short list and the long list as well, and I'm not
- 34:32seeing this in the spielders yas. So I think it's yeah. In last
- 34:37sense, maybe the mission is strangely presented, but yeah, So firstly,
- 34:49I think you agree with me right that the Spielders JAUS has a very specific
- 34:53purpose, and the purpose I've outlined is what they consider their job to be.
- 34:58Right. Otherwise, otherwise you wouldn't it wouldn't the spielders generist nominees wouldn't
- 35:04be games of a certain difficulty value, right, you'd be any kind of
- 35:07game. Also, I think what is fundamentally different about games and books?
- 35:15You use books as an example, and people often compare the two. Books
- 35:22are an art form with a four hundred year history of being considered an artful.
- 35:28Games are old, don't get me wrong. But this idea that we
- 35:31criticize them in the way that we criticize literature or cinema is very new.
- 35:37Yes, twenty years at most, and so and so, and whether I
- 35:44agree with this or not, it's kind of inconsequential, I think. But
- 35:46the idea that what you're trying to do is have an award that isn't that
- 35:53is focused on broadening the appeal of games to people, so then wider ranges
- 36:01of people can come in and have that discussion about the cultural relevance of games
- 36:06is the purpose of the Spielders yars. I really don't think that the purpose
- 36:10of the Spielders Yrus is to pick the best game. I think it's to
- 36:14pick the broadest game. Now you are you can tell me that you think
- 36:19that is unacceptable, and then there's a discussion to have. But I think
- 36:22it's clear to me that the Spielders Yrus is not about necessarily finding the best
- 36:29game. It's finding the best game within a certain appeal, right just for
- 36:36us gamers. I think it is misleading because if the standard German people are
- 36:45going to a store in November to pick up for Christmas the game of the
- 36:49year, they are looking for that logo and this has to be the best
- 36:54game. They are not interested in a discussion now. They want to just
- 37:00a broaden the hobby or bring in new people. They want to buy the
- 37:05best game of the year. And maybe it's just the title is misleading.
- 37:10Maybe the mission is not clearly pointed out. Of course they are doing this
- 37:15on the website, but who cares when they are in a store and when
- 37:22they are pretty much uninformed. So again I'm not against this mission. I
- 37:27just think in the context of the award. This is a wrong thing,
- 37:32and I don't like it at all, that is. But yeah, so
- 37:38what I would say, because I think it's clear to me that their purpose
- 37:44is to spread gaming. It's an evangelical it's an evangelical idea. And what
- 37:49I would say is, while every year I look at the nominees and I
- 37:52think maybe they aren't for me, or maybe you know, even if they
- 37:58are, because I've played some Schilder's Hours game that are absolutely amazing. Camel
- 38:01Up is the best in the last ten years, and it's still a game
- 38:05I love and I play a lot. I don't think they get it massively
- 38:08wrong though. I don't think if you're a non gamer looking to get into
- 38:14games and looking to something that is an easy introduction, that if you buy
- 38:19that year spield as Yarrus, you're gonna buy a dud. I don't think,
- 38:22you know, I think you're going to buy a good game that is
- 38:23going to appeal to that certain demographic. But the point is, right,
- 38:28you're a war gamer of five hundred years standing, I'm you know, I'm
- 38:32a nerd as well. Spield Is Yours isn't for us, right, right,
- 38:37But I think there's still quite a few people we are hardcore gamers,
- 38:42but quite a few people do not know better. But I agree. I
- 38:45think in general terms, most games that have be won this price so I
- 38:51have been nominated are good, too great, So no problem here. It's
- 38:55just that I think the jury is too small, not enough people, and
- 39:02their mission statement I think is questionable. And another thing that next me is
- 39:10that they also want to see the game to be nominated in general distribution in
- 39:19Germany. And I think that is also a very strange thing because it hinders
- 39:25creativity and it's not a good cultural thing or to promote culture because some of
- 39:34these small publishers like Spielworks, if I had a game in this category,
- 39:39I have no chance to be nominated. And again going back to why is
- 39:45that? Because you have to be in general distribution in German stores. So
- 39:50can you explain to the listeners what that means, what general distribution means?
- 39:53Yeah, so at least in the larger stores, or you need a first
- 40:00is you need a larger print run, and then you should not or you
- 40:02cannot just sell the game via your website. So you have to be in
- 40:07stores or online stores. The game has to be widely available in stores,
- 40:14which I totally get. If there is a spielder is the artist and nobody
- 40:17can purchase it, that's a really bad thing. But the same thing with
- 40:22again going back to books and here, if there is a minor publisher nominated
- 40:31for on the long list or on the short list, there are immediately other
- 40:37publishers stepping in. You need a short term loan, we can help you
- 40:40with all this. And this would be the same thing with here the gaming
- 40:50gaming industry. So let's say there is this game from tiny publisher, from
- 40:55a tiny publisher, and it will be nominated even four Game of the Year
- 41:01award ceremony, which is six weeks afterwards, there are deals to make sure
- 41:09that the game will be available. So yeah, and I know that this
- 41:15point is discussed inside the jury and some members try to change it, but
- 41:23so far it hasn't happened. And right now when I'm explaining it to us
- 41:29publishers who are asking me, can my game be nominated for a Game of
- 41:34the Year in Germany, first I say no, you need a German edition.
- 41:37I could do a German edition small printer, and I'm saying not good
- 41:40enough, and they do not understand that concept. They simply do not understand
- 41:46it. So I went to the ceremony last year, which if I'd recommend
- 41:52to anyone if you can get there, it's great. It's free food and
- 41:54booze. And there was a speech beforehand, and it was really it really
- 42:01struck me that the rhetoric for which Germans, the rhetoric that Germans use for
- 42:08games is very different to the way British people talk about games and American people
- 42:15talk about games. The speech was an academic style speech in which he called
- 42:22and I can't think of a decent translation, he said that games were called
- 42:25toure gut, which were products of culture. So two questions, firstly,
- 42:34how true do you think that is? And secondly, if the speaker of
- 42:38the Spieldersiarus is saying, you know, we are here to promote games as
- 42:44cultural artifacts, how well do you think the spielders Juris serves that end with
- 42:52the initial part, I have problems, and I suggest our games in Germany
- 42:59should culture good. That we do a complete episode on this, because I
- 43:05think this is a fascinating topic. I have my views on it, but
- 43:09it's way too difficult for me to have them in two minutes and I totally
- 43:17understand why the spieldesias jury and more importantly, the publishers try to have games
- 43:28as culture good as cultural achievements, because in Germany video games they are a
- 43:35culture good and tabletop analog games aren't, which is somewhat strange, and some
- 43:43other things in Germany of course are also culture good. I have a fear,
- 43:49but that maybe is then enough for today on culture good that publishers are
- 43:55just interested to get the reduced VAT rate because it will drop from nineteen percent
- 44:02to seven percent like in books which are cool to a good, and I
- 44:07doubt that the additional money is going that's suddenly the prices of the games will
- 44:13be reduced. It's going to the pockets of the publishers, and so I
- 44:20have my doubts about this. If this is a good, I want to
- 44:23see some things around tabletop gaming. I want to have some programs. I
- 44:30want to show why it is. But again this should be a future episode.
- 44:36But I have to be more prepared for this because I think it's a
- 44:39fascinating topic. I like it, and there are so many different aspects here
- 44:47to consider. So just as a last question, then do you think the
- 44:52spielders Yarra serves its purpose, no, yes or no. So schpield Desias.
- 45:02For me again, if I look at Spieldersias, and I know that
- 45:06this is the same thing as car of the year. If you have this
- 45:10Auto Desias in Germany, it's not the best car of the year. It
- 45:15was a price. But for me, Schield Desars should be an outstanding achievement.
- 45:20And so far it is good games in this category, sometimes excellent games.
- 45:24And look at some classics as Ticket to Write, as Carcasson and Katan.
- 45:30They formed our industry, these games, and they are classics. They
- 45:37are still selling like hotcakes. And without such an award that promoted these games
- 45:44at that time, probably the industry would be different. So, as I
- 45:46said initially, high praise for what the Schpielersiaras organization did achieve in a short
- 45:54time. But Schpieldisias. Am I really happy about it? No, because
- 46:00one thing that we didn't touch upon is when I'm getting pitches for games,
- 46:09and some people do not know schpiel works too well. So they are entering
- 46:15a discussion at a convention or at some place, or when we are skyping
- 46:20or zooming or whatever, they are saying, well, no problem. It
- 46:23is just four pages of rules, it's forty five minutes tops, it plays
- 46:28in thirty I can explain it in two minutes. And I'm saying I'm not
- 46:30interested in this, but they want to be within the framework of game of
- 46:37the year. And again this is in my opinion, also killing creativity.
- 46:44So I'm not totally happy. And again I like most of the people.
- 46:49I love some of the people in the jury. I wish it could be
- 46:53just a little bit different. But I'm old, I'm a complainer, and
- 47:00I could now have my first cheap shot of me. So with Uhli about
- 47:07to turn to the bottle, we'll move on to now the big toe of
- 47:10the German board gaming industry. Uli Bledemm will regale you with industry. All
- 47:21right, So you wanted to talk in this Tales of the Industry section about
- 47:24from what I what I gathered from your notes, the the internationalization of gaming
- 47:31and how interesting that is. So first off, tell us when you founded
- 47:37Spearworks all those years ago, when we were I mean pre the Wheel,
- 47:42I think it was spi Works. I wanted to have in the logo wheel
- 47:49but then I thought, well, it hasn't been invented invented yet, so
- 47:52what am I going to do so has to change? So how international was
- 48:00Speedworks when you started? And what has been the change in the sort of
- 48:07internationalization of the industry that you've seen. Yeah, but so Speedworks was founded
- 48:13as a company to localize US games. So it wasn't my original intention to
- 48:20have global rights to games and sell them in as many languages as possible.
- 48:25But I would move back in time, so to prehistoric times. Even so,
- 48:32when I started in the hobby as a gamer, as you said,
- 48:37I was a wargamer, and I'm still a wargamer. And all these games,
- 48:40including some games like The Fantastic Civilization by Francis Treasure, these games were
- 48:50process orientated, so you had your rigid phases. So basically in Civilization you
- 48:55start at the top of the page, there's that phase, then is movement,
- 49:00then there are training calamity. If you're at the end of the process
- 49:05you started, you in the next game, turn at the start. So
- 49:08all of that was fine, but very rigid. And then suddenly modern German
- 49:16type eurotype games, but at that time they were called German type games.
- 49:21They entered the hobby, the industry and you could see, well, you
- 49:25could do it much better hardly any downtime. There are now microturns and interactive
- 49:31turns, and some things are interwoven, and different kinds of components are entering
- 49:37the fray. So that was also the most important in my opinion. And
- 49:44although it's now known as an Amerri trash company, Fantasy Flight Games, what
- 49:50they did initially very well that Christian Petersen, a Danish guy who moved from
- 49:58Denmark to the US to work there professionally. He knew European style gaming and
- 50:06he knew US style gaming because he's a science fiction gamer, a war gamer,
- 50:10and they tried to initially to synchronize these two schools of game design,
- 50:20and it worked very well. And suddenly people thought, wow, you can
- 50:23have large games without these. Now it's my movement face. I'm just I'm
- 50:30just allowed to move two of my ships in this science fiction game. And
- 50:36that worked very nicely. And then later there was the French school of sort
- 50:44entered, especially with a colorful, beautiful artwork, which added something to the
- 50:51more let's put it to the more drab German type games going now back and
- 51:00and sorry you're Richard, I don't mean it in a bad way. I
- 51:02like your artwork, but Keyflower looks all the key games, they look really
- 51:07German in my opinion in a way. And this change, and of course
- 51:13in this global market, at a certain point there were suddenly the Japanese and
- 51:17East Asian games entering twenty cards. That's all. We do it, and
- 51:24we can do it and it's still a meaningful, wonderful game. And I
- 51:29think that is something that I found excellent in gaming nowadays. That sometimes globalization
- 51:37and some people hate globalization and for some effects me too, but globalization,
- 51:43in some ways it's really a wonderful thing because you are thinking outside of the
- 51:47box. You're getting new influence from other people from other cultural backgrounds, and
- 51:54it has helped our industry, in my opinion, tremendously. How has it
- 52:00changed spiel works especially, And I guess such a large part of it must
- 52:06be the ubiquity of the internet, not just the Internet, but the ability
- 52:12to communicate with people in foreign countries in real time. Yes, true,
- 52:21it is. I guess you used to use smoke signals, right, We
- 52:23had smoke signals and because we weren't too font of the pigeons doing all the
- 52:30messaging, because you had such a high rate of them not returning and after
- 52:37a while then we had smoke signals and that was a huge improvement. And
- 52:42definitely that was important for speed works as well, because most of my of
- 52:52the pitches that I'm getting are from people overseas, either from East Asia or
- 53:00from the US. And of course twenty years three years ago, this wouldn't
- 53:05have been possible. And especially as you know, we are doing gam ass
- 53:08games and in Germany, for some reason, there aren't that many designers who
- 53:16want to do games that are appealing to spiedeworks. Maybe this is because of
- 53:23spield asiatist organization maybe, And so you've talked about, you know, there's
- 53:35potential negatives to globalization. I think with an industry like board games, it
- 53:39feels it feels like it's almost been a pure good. How has it changed
- 53:47game design? Do you think it is almost a pure good? In my
- 53:52opinion too, I agree one at a percent. How does it have How
- 53:57has it changed game design? I think that people are adding access to to
- 54:00various styles, various games that they wouldn't have acquired earlier. They are in
- 54:08direct touch with other game designers. So if you look at Matias Karma,
- 54:14so he was always an eighteen xx heavy gamer. Always he started before he
- 54:21became a professional. That was his favorite kind of games. So hardcore gamers,
- 54:27hardcore gamer. But in the wargaming world he only designed, or the
- 54:34political historical type of gaming world he only designed after he'd seen the influence from
- 54:40US designers like Mark Herman. He had played Churchill, so ah, I
- 54:45could take the debate track in WIMA from Churchill. Oh, card driven.
- 54:51This is interesting to script your games and to have colorful events so that people
- 54:58know what they are doing, so to make to ease your start in the
- 55:02game. And I think without the Internet, without the influence from the US
- 55:07designers, it would have taken way longer. Maybe maybe there would know wouldn't
- 55:15be a Weima from Matias now. And so just to finally wrap this up,
- 55:20then, how thankful are you about the Internet nationalization of gaming, the
- 55:25the sort of technologicalization of gaming that has resulted in the fact that you met
- 55:34me. Until the last couple of words, this was one of I was.
- 55:42I was very thankful, but there are always downsides. So when I
- 55:46said almost one hundred percent a good thing, there's always the other side of
- 55:52the coin. Excellent. So to wrap up this episode of the bulletin.
- 55:57OI tell us again, where can we find spiel Works and what have you
- 56:00got to flog? Yeah, so you'll find me at It's easiest to drop
- 56:06me a mail by to Uli at Spielworks dot e. That is Uli at
- 56:10Spielworks dot e. You can also find me at Blue Sky or at x
- 56:15Twitter at uliblay u l I ble e and I will respond. You could
- 56:22send me a BGG direct message. I'm not looking into that that often,
- 56:29but I will finally respond. And of course my website, my webshop is
- 56:34at www Spiedworks dot dee and available right now. There's a nice selection of
- 56:40games. Most of them are just German editions, so for example Sparta or
- 56:49Wima, but I have a couple of English German editions like you none the
- 56:57Fantastic Unan by Aron Hak and of course Elbow is also available in an English
- 57:04edition. And speaking of Vima, because it just came to my mind,
- 57:07there will be a second edition should be available this fall, and Spiedworks will
- 57:15also do English copies of this uh of the of that game, because so
- 57:22far and Kepstone has sold out of English and hardly any copies from Kepstone moved
- 57:28to Europe and I will mainly have the English editions for Europe, so this
- 57:31fall if you're looking for an English edition Vima, yeah, it should be
- 57:37available from Spielworks excellent. And just to wrap up, as I said,
- 57:39you can join the five GFD discord and have a chat with the world famous
- 57:44Uli Blenheiman, the Methusela of board games. Just go to five gfd dot
- 57:49com, click on the pinpost and you can go there. You can also
- 57:52support the show if you want to by going to picture on dot com forward
- 57:57slash five GFD and you can back and get loads of free content, well
- 58:02not free content, paid content, but loads of bonus content there. And
- 58:07that's it. I just need to rap up and say, Julie Berman,
- 58:08thank you very much. Yeah, thank you. Ben was a pleasure and
- 58:14everybody should check out the discord of five g four D and should support Ben.
- 58:21So thank you for listening and come back next month for another