Latest / Pete and Hannah’s Watchlist: / AFI Top 100 Movie 100 Ben-Hur
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Pete and Hannah's watch lists and we're presenting the AFI Top 100.
- 0:06I'm here with my great co-host Hannah.
- 0:09Sup.
- 0:10Hannah, we are doing the AFI Top 100 where we watch, re-watch all the 100 movies of the
- 0:17American Film Industry 10th anniversary.
- 0:20So that's five times really fast.
- 0:23And we give our usual reviews and we talk about the film and why it's on the list.
- 0:28Why are we doing the American Film Institute?
- 0:31Well it's a curated list of 100 movies so that's cool.
- 0:36But also it's just, we also love movies and especially American film.
- 0:41In fact it's everywhere.
- 0:45And this is basically saying this is what humanity's got to offer.
- 0:50Like aliens are going to see this, this is our top 100.
- 0:52And we kind of just want to see are they any worthwhile?
- 0:56Like are they actually good?
- 0:57Another thing is like you weren't into movies like heavily until COVID.
- 1:02Yeah, I would also say the thing is like I have, you know.
- 1:07A lot of these you haven't seen.
- 1:08The greats.
- 1:09Yeah.
- 1:10This considered great way before my time.
- 1:11So during COVID when we, everyone was locked down, we started watching television shows
- 1:17and we started watching movies.
- 1:19We first started, we watched West Wing.
- 1:21So you've been indoctrinated into that, which I loved as a kid.
- 1:25And then now love as an adult watching it every year and now you're all.
- 1:29And we also started watching, rewatching movies.
- 1:32And then we started this channel and then we thought, okay, we need something to, let's
- 1:38go back to what we were doing during COVID and watch a movie every week from an old movie.
- 1:42And then you picked the top 100 movies from the American Film Institute and the 10th anniversary
- 1:49revisited, which no one's really talked about much.
- 1:52They talked about the first job in 1997, but the 2007, how much discourse about it?
- 1:58I would like to see, like, cause to revisit and update the films on that list is an interesting
- 2:03thing.
- 2:04Like it hasn't been updated since.
- 2:07It probably will eventually.
- 2:08It definitely will be.
- 2:09And then not only that, it's the, going through this list, it's very interesting to see like,
- 2:14again, it's the American Film Institute.
- 2:16So they choose a lot of American films and stuff.
- 2:19So it'd be interesting to see later on down the years if they actually add.
- 2:22Another thing is like, there's a lot of movies that have been added to this list that weren't
- 2:27new movies.
- 2:28They were, they found 1930s movies and they added to this.
- 2:33So it is quite amazing that the list changed so much.
- 2:36And also it's an update of values too, cause there's like, there's some films on there
- 2:40that, honestly that I consider classics by just any means, but now it's like, oh yeah,
- 2:46of course they're important to film, not just as a good film, but as they're an important
- 2:52part of history.
- 2:53Well, we're starting with a huge one today.
- 2:55The hundredth movie on the list of American Film Institute is one of the best movies of
- 3:01all time.
- 3:03It's won countless Academy Awards.
- 3:07It was nominated for 13, won 111.
- 3:10It's actually a record because there's some wins that Gone With The Wind had that were
- 3:18just automatically given to them.
- 3:19This is actually categories that were fought.
- 3:21And there's also categories in Avatar, Titanic, that weren't actually existed back in when
- 3:29Ben Hur.
- 3:30So Ben Hur won categories, a better strike rate basically.
- 3:35So it's Ben Hur, it's a 1959 remake of the 25 movie.
- 3:41So basically how we'll do this is we rewatch the movie and then we put the movie into categories
- 3:47which we'll learn.
- 3:49We'll add names, funny names to each category.
- 3:52And then we'll just put it through the usual Pete and Hannah's review show, a ringer with
- 3:57the elevator pitch, reasons to, reasons not to.
- 4:00And then we'll talk about where it sits on the list.
- 4:03And then we'll finally ask the real question that everyone wants to know, would we watch
- 4:07it again?
- 4:09And should it be on the list anyway?
- 4:11From people not part of the film.
- 4:14Okay so let's start.
- 4:15It's number 100.
- 4:18It's Ben Hur 1959.
- 4:21Had you seen it before?
- 4:23Nope.
- 4:24I saw this one when I was a kid.
- 4:25So it was big on rotation in Australia when Footy, so our footy in Queensland where we're
- 4:33from is Rugby League.
- 4:35And so when on Sundays it was huge, they'd play a big biblical movie.
- 4:40So you'd get either Ben Hur or you'd get 10 Commandments.
- 4:44You get like a long movie.
- 4:46So it covers all the day.
- 4:48It always used to be on Channel 9 for some reason, which is the main station over here.
- 4:53And it was before the cricket started.
- 4:55So I think there was three seasons when it came to television in Australia growing up.
- 5:01There was Rugby League, then there was epic movies, and then it went into cricket.
- 5:08So that's my three loves of life.
- 5:10So that's what you chose a little bit about me.
- 5:13Elevator pitch.
- 5:14So Ben Hur is betrayed and he seeks revenge through chariot racing.
- 5:20Now who's Ben Hur?
- 5:22So he's a Jewish person that's living in Judea under Roman occupation.
- 5:32The first year of existence.
- 5:34So one BC.
- 5:35Yeah.
- 5:36One, one after Common Era.
- 5:37Yeah.
- 5:38Yeah.
- 5:39After.
- 5:40So you can mix it with all the after death speed.
- 5:43Yeah.
- 5:44Especially because this movie ties in.
- 5:47Yeah.
- 5:48It ties in with religious angle.
- 5:49There's some, some Jesus stuff in here.
- 5:52So the maker studio was MGM Grant.
- 5:54So one of your favourite studios.
- 5:56Well, yeah, they love throwing money in like really big movies.
- 5:59Well Hannah, when you say that they were going broke at this stage in 1959.
- 6:03They were in big trouble.
- 6:05And so they took a big part on this movie.
- 6:07Now the original budget for this was $7 million.
- 6:11But that pulled out to $15 million.
- 6:12Now that doesn't sound like much now, but it quite, it quite into our money.
- 6:18That's $150 million.
- 6:19Now for a business that's nearly going broke.
- 6:21Yeah.
- 6:22Can you believe that?
- 6:23I will say MGM have a habit of, you know, putting money into a movie and then the movie
- 6:28exceeding that limit.
- 6:29Yeah.
- 6:30Things like Gone with the Wind and Wizard of Oz have done that in the past.
- 6:33So the bet paid off.
- 6:34It was one of the highest grossing movies of the fifties.
- 6:39It was just behind Gone with the Wind and Ten Commandments.
- 6:45If it were equated to today's money, it would have cost $150 million.
- 6:49Inquited in today's money, it would have made over $1.5 billion.
- 6:54Oh wow.
- 6:55Yeah.
- 6:56Okay.
- 6:57Yeah.
- 6:58So it hits money back.
- 6:59$75 million are made.
- 7:00So it had a huge theatrical run as well.
- 7:02So back in those days, there was only one or two movies that made it a cinema, especially
- 7:06in Australia and that played for a year.
- 7:09So now if a movie like look at Marvel's that came out recently that lasted a couple of
- 7:15weeks, you know, we're getting movies that last one or two weeks in the cinemas and then
- 7:18it goes on to a streaming service.
- 7:20It's harrowing.
- 7:21But you go back to like a movie like say Back to the Future, right?
- 7:24Yeah, that was in the same.
- 7:25That was in cinemas for 18 months and it had a run where it was number one and then six
- 7:31months later it was number one again.
- 7:33Like it'll never happen here.
- 7:35It never happened here.
- 7:36It wouldn't happen again with movies like that.
- 7:39No.
- 7:40So the story behind this movie, it was originally a book written in the 1800s.
- 7:46It got turned into a movie in 1925.
- 7:48It was much story when it came out in 1925.
- 7:51People had been trying to remake it for years and years and years.
- 7:55The biblical Pixar had been huge hits like Ten Commandments was a huge movie starring
- 8:00Charles M. Heston.
- 8:03And so they looked at Lee Wallace's book and it was a spawning epic.
- 8:09And when they tried to remake it, it was going to be a four hour movie.
- 8:13So they brought this director on William Wyler.
- 8:17Now this guy is he makes bangers after bangers.
- 8:20Roman a Holiday.
- 8:21Oh, funny girl.
- 8:22Oh, you know what?
- 8:23This guy is amazing.
- 8:24Yeah.
- 8:25Yeah.
- 8:26So he also directed Wuthering Heights as well.
- 8:30Oh, wow.
- 8:31Yeah.
- 8:32Okay.
- 8:33So he did everything great.
- 8:34He he he he didn't want to do it at the start.
- 8:38He really didn't want to do it.
- 8:40Because he was Jewish.
- 8:41And so this movie is heavily Christianity.
- 8:43Yes, heavily.
- 8:44It's like Christianity.
- 8:46But then he later said that he you know, you bring a Jew on to make a real Christian movie.
- 8:54So he was he had a little bit of humor about this guy.
- 8:56But he said he only wanted to do it if it was going to be a three hour movie and not
- 9:03a four hour movie.
- 9:04Okay.
- 9:05Oh, okay.
- 9:06He also said that he didn't want to skip on budget.
- 9:08So he said, well, the producer was Steven Zeppeles.
- 9:14He said, well, it's going to be seven million dollar budget.
- 9:15He goes, well, I think it's going to need to be more than that.
- 9:18And so it ended up being 15 million dollars.
- 9:22Yeah.
- 9:25He had a lot of choices to for actors and the Judah Ben Her role.
- 9:29Okay.
- 9:30So he he ended up going with The Great Child in the Heston who was in The Ten Commandments.
- 9:34A lot of actors he was he went off to Paul Newman.
- 9:38Paul Newman.
- 9:39Paul Newman said, no, I wouldn't look good in a skirt.
- 9:44Kirk Douglas really wanted this role, but he was too old because he really wanted to
- 9:48play it because he's Jewish.
- 9:49Yeah.
- 9:50He ended up making Spartacus work and he became Spartacus.
- 9:54Wow.
- 9:55Yeah.
- 9:56That's it.
- 9:58A lot of the other actors.
- 9:59So the actor that played Ben Her's mom, it was only actually three years older than Charlton
- 10:04Heston.
- 10:05And earlier, earlier he she had played a young mom of the baby Moses in The Ten Commandments.
- 10:13So it's a big turnaround that she's playing the old, the mature lady.
- 10:21So the reaction of the film at the time, critics went wild for it.
- 10:26Of course.
- 10:27Of course.
- 10:28It was a huge, highest grossing.
- 10:32It won heaps of awards.
- 10:35It was just, it swept the Oscars.
- 10:37It won best director.
- 10:38It won best picture.
- 10:39It won best actor.
- 10:41It won best supporting actor.
- 10:42Now that's...
- 10:43This is where we could argue one of the things that don't make sense in the past.
- 10:49The role of the sheik was played by a Welsh actor.
- 10:59Now not the greatest thing you've ever seen, hey.
- 11:02No.
- 11:04You could say they're better ideas.
- 11:07Let's be honest.
- 11:08There was Blackface.
- 11:09Yeah.
- 11:10No.
- 11:11And it's when you get to these older films, they weren't really looking for people that
- 11:16looked like the people they're supposed to play.
- 11:18They just worked around a metaphorical bush and just was like, oh, you know what?
- 11:23You're pretty good.
- 11:24Let's just throw something on and have a day.
- 11:28So I was played by Hugh Griffin and he won the best supporting actor.
- 11:32He didn't accept it at the Oscars as well.
- 11:37He played Mutiny.
- 11:38It was in The Mutiny and The Bounty.
- 11:40It was How to Steal a Me and he was in heaps of movies.
- 11:43And he was also in Oliver.
- 11:44Oh yeah.
- 11:45Yeah, so he storied actor, won an Oscar, but yeah, he did.
- 11:51He didn't want to accept it.
- 11:54Someone accepted on behalf.
- 11:55Yeah.
- 11:56William Wallace accepted on his behalf.
- 11:59Yeah.
- 12:00It's an interesting choice for best supporting because I feel like there are some other greater
- 12:08best supporting.
- 12:09Well, there's another probably better supporting actor in it than I would say the sheik.
- 12:14He only plays like a really a minor role.
- 12:17Yeah.
- 12:18Well, you're talking about the Masala who played Masala who was played by Steven Grubb.
- 12:26He a lot of people wanted to play that role.
- 12:32He there was a bit more meat on that bowl.
- 12:35Do let's talk a little bit more about the movie and we'll come back to that.
- 12:39We'll come back to the theme that you want to talk about majority of this award.
- 12:47How I like to enjoy the movie.
- 12:49Yeah, it's wow.
- 12:54So Hugh Griffin was up against Arthur Connelly in Anatomy of Murder.
- 12:59George C. Scott, they probably cross each other out.
- 13:03Robert Vaughan in The Young Philadelphians who just died recently.
- 13:07Edwin and Dario the Frank.
- 13:08So I've seen I've seen the Anatomy of Murder and I've seen Young Philadelphians.
- 13:13I'll surprise that Hugh Griffin actually won after watching this movie.
- 13:16Yeah, I think he doesn't he doesn't play in nowadays.
- 13:22His role one you wouldn't have it because yeah, of course, but his my he doesn't really
- 13:28add anything to this like to the plot.
- 13:32It doesn't mean I wouldn't say he he does a good job acting but I wouldn't say he's
- 13:37you know, putting on a performance that supports I guess the main actor in it anyway.
- 13:42So we're not a huge fan of like sites of critics and stuff like that.
- 13:47So we as people who have watched our show before we don't really give like a score we
- 13:54give like a sort of funny rating and sort of like we're not like and we like to also
- 13:58showcase what we liked and what we disliked about it.
- 14:01Yeah, because we we know there's things to like about it even if it's you know, considered
- 14:08film lovers not film critics.
- 14:09So so just to go through some of the metrics, it's 85% of Rotten Tomatoes was 8.1 on IMDB.
- 14:18Like yeah for that for what it is.
- 14:20That's high that's high praise, you know, so yeah, especially a movie to you know, it's
- 14:24been a long time to still gonna praise even to this day.
- 14:30Does it does it does it deserve a price?
- 14:35Does it deserve all the price it got?
- 14:37Now I think at the time, everything about it is so amazingly well done.
- 14:43At the time.
- 14:44Yeah, definitely when you look at it now compared to some you look on it and some of the sets
- 14:49you're like that looks like a set or they had to recently they retouched they did a
- 14:55remaster not long ago and so everything's got a little bit you know, sometimes the siege
- 15:00they like drawn pipe drops and they just added some textures and stuff and I'll give you
- 15:06a little bit of background.
- 15:07So the battle scenes were filmed but with miniatures which is the job of the time.
- 15:12I miniatures when miniatures are used I think that when they're done really well, you'll
- 15:17never notice that and it's brilliant.
- 15:19Well Oppenheimer recently yes, Nolan is a huge lover of his he did it with the dark
- 15:25knight trilogy like any like when you see behind the scenes Batman begins like the whole
- 15:30train thing was miniatures like that's incredible.
- 15:34So they tried to film in Libya but when they found out this movie was about Judaism and
- 15:41Christianity not a thing.
- 15:44So they started filming in 1957 it was a long shoot nearly six months.
- 15:51The chariot scene the famous chariot scene was six weeks alone.
- 15:56Horses died no one died as in people.
- 15:59Oh no one died?
- 16:01Yeah it was near fatal but no one died.
- 16:04But horses did.
- 16:06So animals were harmed during the making of this film which deserves to be said in a taste
- 16:12of time but that chariot scene alone and like you could even though again horrifying it
- 16:18is a impressive thing they were able to achieve even though we could definitely argue that
- 16:23sometimes those laps were long and sometimes they were very short for some reason.
- 16:28So yeah he so what he did was William Wilder he did one big crane shot of when they came
- 16:36at the start now that wasn't from the book and that wasn't historical when they came
- 16:40in all together like that the chariot as they all came in but he wanted to do that for a
- 16:45reason to give it scope because most of the shots were really close when you're going
- 16:50around corners.
- 16:51No yeah this I think some of the really like unique shots he likes to do he really wanted
- 16:56to scale this movie that's the whole.
- 16:58So filmed in Rome Spain like it just goes to show like they were filming back into locations
- 17:07back then why can't we do it now?
- 17:09I know right even when some of them look a little bit off.
- 17:12Yeah the sets weren't like the sets probably were great for back then but they weren't
- 17:18great.
- 17:19But he definitely like there were shots in Rome where like you when you go to Rome and
- 17:23it really he likes to draw you out like yeah as it almost has this moment where he where
- 17:30Judo has saved someone's life and they're accepting something and it's almost like this
- 17:35is like that Star Wars moment when they accept the medals like it harkens.
- 17:39A lot of directors have seen this movie and I wouldn't be surprised.
- 17:43On Letterboxx like it's a lot of famous actors and famous directors favorite movie.
- 17:47Yeah because it's just it is a pretty epic scaled movie that yeah I think.
- 17:53Do you want to go into our usual review?
- 17:56Yeah I think let's start with that because I'm ready to talk about.
- 18:02Reasons to see him.
- 18:04Reasons to see it it's pretty epically well done this movie.
- 18:08In a sense that it's amazing it's like a really great idea of using revenge and faith in
- 18:16one movie which is you know never really like faith and revenge don't really go hand in
- 18:21hand with each other but in this movie it's a big part.
- 18:24Yeah he's learning a lesson through it.
- 18:27He's a lot yeah he's learning a lesson it's an interesting tale about it and.
- 18:30Well he starts off as like a huge big deal.
- 18:33Yeah he's like a.
- 18:34And then he gets wrong for something he didn't commit.
- 18:37Yeah and he gets punished and then he comes back to try and take punishment onto the person
- 18:42that punished him.
- 18:43Yeah he's seeking revenge he just wants.
- 18:45And then he sees a lot.
- 18:46He has to go through so many like different trials and stuff and there it's an epic scale
- 18:52and scope.
- 18:53Talk about the real reason you think to watch this.
- 18:55Okay so Charles Heston has great chemistry with anything he's on screen with.
- 19:01For some reason he's got chemistry with the horses he's got chemistry he just like immediately
- 19:06when he likes a woman he's just sizing her up and you're like wow this guy is already
- 19:10on.
- 19:11But um um what's his name?
- 19:16Steven Borde.
- 19:17Steven.
- 19:18Massella.
- 19:19Massella.
- 19:20He's the villain but originally these two were friends.
- 19:24And the moment they meet they're like bonding they're in love with each other.
- 19:28So I'll give you a great story behind the scenes.
- 19:31And so this was rewritten to make it a little bit shorter by Gourvardel.
- 19:38And Gourvardel noted Rochonter.
- 19:44He's told the Stephen Borde character to play it homo erotica because he was he was he said
- 19:56he was a childhood friend he would have been um kicked back by Charlton Heston was a little
- 20:03bit more popular.
- 20:04That's the reason why he saved his life as a child.
- 20:07And you need to play it like this and Charlton Heston had no idea why he was playing it like
- 20:11that.
- 20:12Now so why you picked up on that thing that this is well known.
- 20:16Now you know that there's fan fiction out there.
- 20:18Yeah I literally wanted to look it up.
- 20:21It's small but it's there and I bet I could find more of a.
- 20:23It's a great reason to see but he didn't just have chemistry with Stephen Boyd and Marcella.
- 20:30He had he had chemistry with the horses.
- 20:31There's these four white horses that he deals with.
- 20:33He like lovingly pats and he's like hey and they're like they're like these horses are
- 20:38like nipping at him and stuff and he's just like hey you know.
- 20:41He has more chemistry with Marcella and the horses than he does any woman in this movie.
- 20:47Yeah I would say but he like size them up to start and then eventually he's just like
- 20:51yeah but I'm in love with my horses.
- 20:54But the fact that Stephen Boyd was told to play it like that.
- 20:57I yeah I was so enthralled because they were they were tight and then once they he used
- 21:03him as a basically just you know to condemn him.
- 21:06It was like an interesting it added so much tension to this plot.
- 21:10I was just like enthralled with what was going to happen next.
- 21:14Reasons not to look I think the start of the movie is a bit slow.
- 21:21Then when you get into the battle on the boats amazing.
- 21:25Boats.
- 21:26The rowing there's like 10 minutes of just rowing.
- 21:28There's so many moments where he's just doing one action simply and it's just many different
- 21:33shots.
- 21:34Was Channels just trying to get in shape?
- 21:35Yeah I was like I was like he's trying to show off here.
- 21:38It's actually great it's entertaining.
- 21:41The fact is I'm on the edge I'm like really enthralled.
- 21:43I'm like what is gonna happen here.
- 21:46I would say yeah and then the last 30 minutes.
- 21:49He was like in his 30s when he made this movie.
- 21:52I think he was just trying to get in shape.
- 21:53Like he knew he was gonna have to play an astronaut on a planet of eight so he needed
- 21:58to get in shape.
- 21:59You know even though it was eight years later.
- 22:01What a career Charlton Heston had.
- 22:02Like Ten Commandments he had this.
- 22:06He had a Planet of the Apes.
- 22:09Like he had the Ometa strain.
- 22:11Like he had the movie with Citizen Kane director Orson Welles Touch of Evil.
- 22:21Just amazing.
- 22:22What an absolute banging career and then he finished it with being the head of the NRA.
- 22:28No political talk here.
- 22:32Another reason not to see it.
- 22:33Like it builds everything up to the chariot scene.
- 22:35So they talk about the chariot scene when he's in Rome.
- 22:38Like he's like a great chariot racer.
- 22:40And they tease their absolute hell out of it.
- 22:42I'd say that yes.
- 22:44Which by the way.
- 22:45Because in the trailer you see the chariot scene in the trailer.
- 22:47I would also say so it's presumed.
- 22:51Could we fast forward once he gets to Rome it cuts to a couple like months ahead.
- 22:55And he's apparently been like.
- 22:57He's killing it.
- 22:58He's the best driver in the world.
- 22:59Yeah.
- 23:00He's the Lewis Hamilton Max Verstappen of chariot racing.
- 23:04If you put this movie in the 80s we would have gotten like a 20 minute montage of him
- 23:10learning the ropes.
- 23:12Not the 80s now.
- 23:13We would have got 100%.
- 23:14There is a little bit with the horses when he's trying to train to take on.
- 23:18Yeah.
- 23:19No.
- 23:20But I meant a full long one.
- 23:21I would say it's building up to that chariot race because it's also the moment where he
- 23:26claims his vengeance.
- 23:28Do you know the underrated thing is the scene where.
- 23:34The scene where they're putting the bet on.
- 23:38Yeah.
- 23:40Hugh Griffith trying to draw Masala out and trying to.
- 23:43Probably this is where he got his escape from.
- 23:46So you had that bet that he was having in today's terms with the four to one odds of
- 23:52the thousand scarabs.
- 23:53Yeah.
- 23:54That would have been worth eight billion gold.
- 23:55Eight billion gold.
- 23:56That's ridiculous.
- 23:57Eight billion gold.
- 23:58Can you believe that?
- 23:59That's why they.
- 24:00Which makes a lot of sense why they were so shocked.
- 24:04Now spoiler alert here for those who haven't seen the movie.
- 24:08Yeah.
- 24:09Yeah.
- 24:10Yeah.
- 24:11Well, you've got to spoil it.
- 24:12OK.
- 24:13Well, Masala dies in the chariot race.
- 24:14Yeah.
- 24:15Well, not in the chariot race.
- 24:16Well, he dies because of the chariot race.
- 24:19Does he pay up?
- 24:20Does he pay up?
- 24:21I don't think he did.
- 24:22I don't think he did.
- 24:23Where's that eight billion dollars worth of gold?
- 24:24I don't think anyone cares.
- 24:25I would.
- 24:26I love all these little factoids about this movie.
- 24:27I think it's interesting because it has been a long time and people just pick up different
- 24:34things.
- 24:35Again, I think a lot of people get recommended this movie because of, you know, just film
- 24:40critics and everything.
- 24:41And so different people who watch movies for different reasons will pick up completely
- 24:46nonsensical things like me going those two should get together.
- 24:50Bound to the bow.
- 24:51Wow.
- 24:52Yes.
- 24:53A lot of people picked up on it.
- 24:54The only one that didn't pick up on it was Charlton Heston.
- 24:57But he was like, hmm.
- 25:00What's happening there?
- 25:02So the real reason not to is like once a chariot scene is done, it's just such a life deal.
- 25:07It's 30 to 40 minutes of just, of about, it's purely about the Christianity.
- 25:13It's purely about the faith.
- 25:15Yeah.
- 25:16Purely about like we're watching, you watch, you watch Jesus get put to the cross.
- 25:20Not to put it back to it.
- 25:22Not to keep putting it back to a recent movie about Oppenheimer.
- 25:26When you had the Trinity test, you still got Emily Blunt cooking.
- 25:32I would still got Robert Downey Jr cooking like this.
- 25:34It was very slow burn.
- 25:36I would argue that we spent way too much time in a leprechaunal any that I, you know, like
- 25:41Oppenheimer, I would go that that last hour is more entertaining than me watching the
- 25:47Trinity test.
- 25:48Like, like we're our background is Christianity.
- 25:51So we sort of know the story.
- 25:53But for those who aren't probably, probably don't really, it's not one of the real things
- 25:58to sell the movie on is it?
- 25:59If your knowledge of, of is from Simpsons, then you've learned all you needed to.
- 26:05Let's talk about, so that's one of the reasons not to see it.
- 26:08So one of the reasons not to see is.
- 26:10Spoke some Christianity.
- 26:11Yeah.
- 26:12It's aged poorly with some of the moments.
- 26:14Just like if you go into the history of the movie or something, I would also go just reasons
- 26:19not to.
- 26:20Actually, yeah.
- 26:21Reasons not to it is long and if you don't love movies about faith and vengeance, having
- 26:25a parent like, you know, connecting too much.
- 26:29Yeah.
- 26:30And yeah, the leprechaunal is like, yeah, like it is just ridiculous.
- 26:34It is insane.
- 26:36So you talked about the Simpsons.
- 26:38Go a little bit more into that.
- 26:39I would go.
- 26:40So Ben Hurd's definitely infected pop culture.
- 26:44Like you can't argue it.
- 26:46It hasn't.
- 26:47You know, directors and actors and everyone loves it.
- 26:51But the Simpsons for me, that's where I'm like, that's all I knew.
- 26:55Like I knew Ben Hurd from.
- 26:57Knew like a lot of like things that popped up.
- 27:00Yeah.
- 27:01And there was, there's just a moment I thought that would happen where Jesus gives Ben Hurd
- 27:08some water to drink.
- 27:10And in the Simpsons, there's a lovely episode called and where Simpsons, the Springfield
- 27:18is hosting like a short film festival and Mr. Burns hires a Spanish knockoff of Stephen
- 27:27Spielberg, Senor Spielberg, and makes himself out to be Jesus and he gives childless Ben
- 27:36Hurd, drink up Judah, Ben Hurd.
- 27:40And say it.
- 27:41And Burns, you are truly the king of kings.
- 27:45You truly are the king of kings.
- 27:47We were saying that in the entire film.
- 27:48I almost felt like everyone was going to say it at one point and I realised and then it
- 27:54comes to a realisation, oh no, that was made up to insinuate that's Ben Hurd.
- 27:59So the movie was remade as well in 2016 and it was not.
- 28:06I don't think anyone's liked the remake.
- 28:08And it was like way too short and yeah.
- 28:11I wouldn't suspect anyone because I think for the movie, at its time, it's a piece of
- 28:19history for its time.
- 28:20And also it is like an artwork, whereas when you try to recreate it and just, you know,
- 28:26try to chop it into pieces and make it flushed out and new, people don't, there's no creativity
- 28:32there.
- 28:33You know, this one, this movie has identity to itself.
- 28:37Is it too crass to say should you watch or should you miss Ben Hurd?
- 28:43I would, I don't know.
- 28:46It is a pretty long movie and if you don't like these themes, I would give it a miss.
- 28:54So this AFI top 100 list, when it steals down to it, I've seen most of these movies, probably
- 28:59a handful I haven't seen.
- 29:00And every question is going to go back to you.
- 29:03Should you watch or miss?
- 29:04You're the new generation.
- 29:05I personally would, I've watched this.
- 29:08Like if this was on TV, I would sit down and watch it.
- 29:12But I know for a fact, a general audience of anyone in my demographic would be like
- 29:17miss.
- 29:18Unless you're a film junkie, they do not care.
- 29:23It's hard to say so early, but does it deserve to be on this list?
- 29:27Does it deserve to be?
- 29:28I mean, it's really hard to say because you know, there's so many.
- 29:32What about for the Oscars alone?
- 29:33I could totally lose it.
- 29:35100%.
- 29:36There are some Oscars, if you go through Oscar history, there are some Oscars of undeserving,
- 29:40incredible.
- 29:41This was up against some good movies like Dio, Van Franky is a great movie.
- 29:45Young Philadelphians is a great movie.
- 29:46And Anatomy of a Murder is a great movie.
- 29:47No, but I'm talking about previous ones.
- 29:48Like why did Gigi, that's about seducing young girls.
- 29:49That one is Oscar.
- 29:50That's a take.
- 29:51It's not a take, it's the whole movie.
- 29:52It's not a take.
- 29:53It's not a take.
- 29:54It's not a take.
- 29:55It's not a take.
- 29:56It's not a take.
- 29:57It's not a take.
- 29:58It's not a take.
- 29:59It's not a take.
- 30:00It's not a take.
- 30:01It's not a take, it's the whole movie.
- 30:04Doesn't deserve to be higher.
- 30:05So before you say doesn't deserve to be higher, in the original list, it was 28 places higher.
- 30:11Oh, interesting.
- 30:12And it got dropped down to 100.
- 30:13I can see why it's in 100.
- 30:14I could see 100% why it's here on the end.
- 30:17Yeah.
- 30:18Because one, it's like the start of like, oh, look, you know, this is where we start.
- 30:22I think for any director, they'll probably put this in their top 10 or top 20.
- 30:29Yeah.
- 30:30But in reality, to films nowadays, we've evolved a lot more from just like, you know, just
- 30:38nice, you know, pretty shots of chariot races.
- 30:41Hannah, would you buy this on Blu-ray?
- 30:44Now it's not available on any streaming services.
- 30:48We rented this on Apple TV.
- 30:49Would you buy it on Blu-ray?
- 30:50Would you have physical media?
- 30:51Would I have physical?
- 30:52I think so because I appreciate having, especially older films, I appreciate having them on physical
- 30:59media.
- 31:00But I have, I collect a lot of older films, especially ones that no one's heard of.
- 31:05And they will, they, some of them go out of print.
- 31:08Like I have the last print of something because it's, it's, it's not going to exist anymore.
- 31:12So the two things that will end every podcast with is would you watch this again?
- 31:19And what is the rating for Ben Her?
- 31:22Would I watch this again?
- 31:23I watch most of the movie and I wouldn't watch the whole movie again.
- 31:27I would probably, chariot scene and then the Marcella scene.
- 31:31Like then I'd be calling it a miss.
- 31:32And rating for this movie?
- 31:34I would, I would say give it a, a golf clap.
- 31:40I think it's just, it's definitely what it's trying to achieve.
- 31:43This movie does incredibly well.
- 31:46And that's what I, when we look at these movies, I like to look at what the movie is trying
- 31:50to achieve rather than say put it up against, like I'm not going to put this movie up against
- 31:55speed racer because I have a deep appreciation and love for speed racer and it's an incredible
- 32:01film.
- 32:02If I keep bringing up Pop and Hymen and you keep bringing up speed racer, this is going
- 32:04to be a long podcast.
- 32:05I'm not going to bring up John Wick because John Wick is a completely, well, Vengeance
- 32:11does play a role in John Wick as well.
- 32:13Hannah, that was a really enjoyable conversation that we've had about Ben Her.
- 32:16I really appreciate it.
- 32:17And John Wick, the similarities, Vengeance plays a different role.
- 32:21What's next on the watch list?
- 32:22So tomorrow on Wednesday we'll drop What's Next, a show where we like to figure out what
- 32:31to watch next.
- 32:32And we'll be reviewing Napoleon, Cat Person and Royal Hotel.
- 32:36And then later the week it's Movie News and we're looking forward to the Australian release
- 32:40of Bottoms.
- 32:41Yes.
- 32:42Oh, so excited.
- 32:43I've been wanting to watch this for such a long time.
- 32:45You can also catch Kenny Gets A Movie, also our Blockbuster Showdown where we fight to
- 32:50the death of movie knowledge.
- 32:53Next week, What's Next Week on the AFI Top 100 Podcast.
- 32:56So it's number 99.
- 32:58And for those playing along at home, you can watch beforehand because it's on Disney Plus.
- 33:03And we also have a physical copy of this one.
- 33:05It is Toy Story.
- 33:07And absolutely classic.
- 33:08This is why I think they updated it because movies like this definitely needed to be...
- 33:15We'll go into it next week.
- 33:17We'll talk a lot more about Toy Story, but thanks for everyone for listening today.
- 33:20Such a different Toy Story than her.
- 33:24And this is what the joy of the AFI Top 100.
- 33:27So much.
- 33:28For those listening for the first time, thanks for listening.
- 33:32And for those watching on our usual channels, we really appreciate all the support.
- 33:37I hope you catch up with the Ridley Scott draft.
- 33:39That was great to have Danny there.
- 33:41Voting convinces tomorrow.
- 33:43Hopefully you vote for me or Hannah.
- 33:45We do not want to hear it.
- 33:47Yeah.
- 33:48He kind of cheated and didn't watch.
- 33:51Well, you come in and you start the podcast by saying, is Ridley Scott overrated?
- 33:55I just want to kick him out.
- 33:56And then he said, Black Hawk Down.
- 33:57It's fine.
- 33:58Yeah.
- 33:59And then he gave nothing.
- 34:00He gave absolutely nothing.
- 34:01We then went into like all the British white boys in that and then he was like, yeah, it's
- 34:06fine.
- 34:07It's fine.
- 34:08Yeah.
- 34:09Oh my God.
- 34:10So you do...
- 34:11If you vote for Danny, it's a vote for mediocrity.
- 34:15Yeah.
- 34:16You're just choosing, yeah, I like those movies.
- 34:18Of course you do.
- 34:19Everyone does.
- 34:20Let's like just be...
- 34:21Go for the interesting ones.
- 34:24Well, that's my lovely co-host, Hannah.
- 34:27I'm Peter.
- 34:29Until next week, when we take a trip down memory lane with the AFI top hundred, we'll
- 34:34catch you for a little later podcast during the week.
- 34:38It's bye for now.
- 34:39Bye.