Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Secondment Without Losing Your Current Role
Transcript
- Lucas: So we got a question this week from a listener named Priya. She's a senior analyst at one of the big global banks, and she's been in her role for about four years. She's good at her job — her manager tells her she's 'too valuable to lose.' But she wants to spend six months in the bank's ESG division to build a different skill set. The problem: she's terrified to ask. She thinks her manager will see it as disloyalty or a sign she's about to quit. Luna: And to be fair, that fear is real. A lot of managers do hear 'I want a temporary assignment' as 'I'm looking for the exit.' So how do you ask for a secondment without triggering that? Lucas: Right. And first — if you've ever found yourself in a similar spot, wondering how to ask for something like this without putting your current role at risk, honestly, if today's episode was worth a coffee to you, you can find that link at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's what keeps this show ad-free and independent. Totally optional, but appreciated. Luna: Yeah, and we mean that. It's a small way to say this helped. Lucas: Okay, back to Priya. The key insight is that a secondment is fundamentally a negotiation about risk — specifically, your manager's risk. They worry about coverage, continuity, and whether you'll come back. So your ask has to address all three before they even raise them. Luna: So you're saying you need to pre-solve their objections? Lucas: Exactly. I had a conversation with an HR executive at a Fortune 500 firm a few years ago, and she told me the single biggest reason secondment requests get denied is that the employee doesn't offer a plan for what happens to their current workload. They just say 'I want this opportunity.' The manager hears 'I want you to figure out how to cover my desk.' Luna: So what did Priya do? Did she have a plan? Lucas: She came to me before she made the ask, so we workshopped a three-part framing. Part one: the career development case. She didn't say 'I'm bored' or 'I want a break.' She tied the ESG stint directly to the bank's strategic priorities. The firm had just announced a net-zero commitment, and her team in corporate banking was starting to get client questions about ESG metrics. She framed it as 'I can bring back expertise that makes our team more competitive.' Luna: That's smart — it's not about her, it's about the team. But what about the coverage piece? Lucas: Part two: she drafted a coverage plan. She identified a junior analyst on her team who was ready for more responsibility, and she proposed that this person would backfill her during the six months, with Priya doing a two-week full handover before she left. She also offered to be available for one hour a week for urgent questions — and she said that if something critical came up, she'd come back for a day. That last part was key. Luna: Because it shows she's not abandoning ship. She's still committed. Lucas: Exactly. Part three: the opt-out terms. She proposed a six-month secondment with a mutual review at month four. If either side — her manager or the ESG team — felt it wasn't working, she'd return to her original role with no penalty. That gave her manager an off-ramp. They weren't locked into a bad decision. Luna: I love that. It's essentially a 'no-fault divorce' clause. And did her manager go for it? Lucas: He did, but not right away. He asked for a week to think it over. That's normal. The thing is, he came back and said yes, but he also asked her to commit to staying in the role for at least one year after she returned. She agreed. That's a reasonable trade-off. Luna: So she got the secondment, but she also gave a retention promise. That seems fair. But I think a lot of listeners might be in a situation where their manager is less reasonable. What if the manager just says no outright? Lucas: That's when you have to decide whether to escalate. If the manager says no without engaging with your plan, you can ask to loop in HR or the internal mobility team. Most large companies have a formal secondment policy, even if managers don't always advertise it. You can frame it as 'I'd like to understand the company's process for this.' Luna: And if there's no policy? Smaller company, no HR infrastructure? Lucas: Then you have a tougher conversation. But even then, you can ask for a 'project assignment' instead of a formal secondment. Same idea — you work on something cross-functional for a set period — but you call it a project to make it feel less permanent. I've seen that work at startups where titles are loose. Luna: There's also a data point I came across from a Gartner survey published in 2025. They found that 73% of employees who successfully requested a secondment received a promotion or an expanded role within 18 months of returning. That's a huge incentive. Lucas: That's striking. And it makes sense — you come back with broader context, new relationships, and demonstrated flexibility. It's hard for a manager to argue you're not ready for more responsibility when you just proved you could handle two different roles in a year. Luna: So for Priya, the secondment actually became a springboard. She's now being considered for a VP role in the ESG division, but her original manager is also trying to keep her. Either way, she wins. Lucas: Right. And the lesson for anyone listening is: don't lead with what you want. Lead with what the company gets. Have a plan. Address the risk. And give them an out if it doesn't work. That's how you ask for a secondment without losing your current role. Luna: One last thing — what about timing? Is there a bad time to ask? Lucas: Absolutely. Don't ask during a major project deadline, during budget season, or in the middle of a restructuring. You want your manager to have mental bandwidth. Priya asked right after her team closed a big quarter — she waited for a moment of calm. That matters. Luna: Good advice. And if you have a question for us, you can always send it in. We read every one. Lucas: We do. And thanks for listening. That's all for today.