Latest / Democracy in Color with Steve Phillips / Part 2 - The History and Science of Inequality
Transcript
- 0:16In the United States, white men make
- 0:18up 29% of the population,
- 0:20but they hold the majority of
- 0:22positions of power in government,
- 0:25in business, in media,
- 0:27in academia.
- 0:29So how did this happen?
- 0:31Was it merit?
- 0:32Was it coincidence?
- 0:33Or was it something else,
- 0:35something built deliberately
- 0:37over time?
- 0:39This is episode two, How
- 0:41We Got Here.
- 0:42Hi, this is Charlene Chang.
- 0:44In the first episode of this
- 0:46series, We asked the question posed
- 0:48by the title of Steve's new book,
- 0:50are white men smarter than everybody
- 0:51else? And we established that
- 0:53there are really only two possible
- 0:55answers.
- 0:56Either A, white men
- 0:58are in fact more talented,
- 1:00more capable and more deserving
- 1:02than everyone else.
- 1:04And this country's systems of
- 1:06hiring, promoting and allocating
- 1:08opportunity and leadership positions
- 1:10simply reflect that superior merit.
- 1:12Or be the profound
- 1:14over-representation of white men.
- 1:16In nearly every position of
- 1:18power and influence in this country
- 1:19is the outcome of centuries of
- 1:21deliberately designed structures,
- 1:23laws, policies, institutions
- 1:25and stories built to
- 1:27produce and reproduce and reinforce
- 1:29the same outcome.
- 1:31In episode one, we named the
- 1:33question. In this episode, we're
- 1:34going to answer it.
- 1:36We're also going to explain the why
- 1:37and how behind the answer.
- 1:39We're gonna go all the way back,
- 1:42back to the history, the
- 1:44arguments, the laws, and the people�
- 1:46who built and defended a system of
- 1:48inequality in this country.
- 1:50And then we're going to follow the
- 1:52science that explains how.
- 1:54How that system embeds itself
- 1:56into our very brains and
- 1:58into the policies that shape our
- 1:59lives.
- 2:00Because, spoiler alert,
- 2:03the over-representation of white men
- 2:04in positions of power of influence
- 2:06didn't happen by accident.
- 2:08And it was engineered and
- 2:11continues to this day.
- 2:13And understanding how it was
- 2:15engineered and how we got here is
- 2:17the first step towards dismantling
- 2:19it.
- 2:37Steve, there are several main
- 2:38arguments many people, including
- 2:40politicians, business people,
- 2:42and yes, some journalists and
- 2:44some intellectuals have made and
- 2:46continue to make today to explain
- 2:48and justify the status
- 2:50quo, namely why most
- 2:52positions of power and influence
- 2:53across every sector in the U.S.
- 2:56Are held by white men.
- 2:57What are some of the top arguments?
- 2:59Yeah, so there's a suite of
- 3:00arguments that people use.
- 3:02And so the first
- 3:04argument is individual
- 3:06choice.
- 3:07The over-representation of white men
- 3:09this school of thought holds is
- 3:10simply the result of different
- 3:12members of different groups making
- 3:14different choices about what fields
- 3:16to pursue, what risks to take, what
- 3:18careers to enter, and what positions
- 3:20to pursue.
- 3:21According to this view, when you
- 3:23look at who shows up at the top of
- 3:25finance, technology, government, in
- 3:26academia.
- 3:27You're looking at the aggregate
- 3:29result of millions of individual
- 3:31voluntary decisions.
- 3:33This is an especially common
- 3:34argument about why women are
- 3:36concentrated in certain fields and
- 3:37not in others.
- 3:38So according to that argument, those
- 3:41white men in positions of power
- 3:42influence are there because
- 3:44they chose to be there.
- 3:46That's right, and so this is the
- 3:47argument by being in default.
- 3:49It's more because other people,
- 3:51especially women, gravitate to other
- 3:53fields and sectors.
- 3:54That just happens to leave the CEO
- 3:56roles and such to men.
- 3:58The second argument is about
- 4:00cultural, biological, and
- 4:02psychological traits.
- 4:04Some critics of DEI, diversity,
- 4:06equity, and inclusion, go
- 4:08further.
- 4:09Pointing to research suggesting that
- 4:11men, white men specifically,
- 4:13score higher on average in
- 4:15traits like risk tolerance,
- 4:17confidence, and competitiveness.
- 4:19And so then in hyper competitive
- 4:20fields and positions, this argument
- 4:22goes, those traits predict
- 4:24outcomes.
- 4:25That gap in representation therefore
- 4:28reflects a gap in these underlying
- 4:30traits, not discrimination
- 4:32as that theory holds.
- 4:33So this argument basically goes men
- 4:36and white men in particular are
- 4:37innately, which implies biologically
- 4:40more suited to go
- 4:42after and secure those
- 4:44positions of influence and power.
- 4:46Yeah, so the third argument is
- 4:48about what kinds of things people
- 4:49are interested in.
- 4:51There's a body of research around
- 4:52what's sometimes called the gender
- 4:54equality paradox.
- 4:55The observation that in more
- 4:56affluent and egalitarian countries,
- 4:59men and women tend to choose
- 5:00different fields at higher rates
- 5:02than in less egalitarian ones.
- 5:05The argument is that when freed from
- 5:06economic pressure, people naturally
- 5:09gravitate towards their innate
- 5:10interests. And that organic sorting,
- 5:13not bias, this argument claims.
- 5:15Explains who ends up where.
- 5:17And the fourth argument, the one
- 5:19that animates much of the current
- 5:20political moment is about merit.
- 5:22That any institution not
- 5:24reflecting this nation's demographic
- 5:26proportions at the leadership level
- 5:28isn't because of discrimination,
- 5:31it's simply the logical outcome
- 5:32of merit.
- 5:34And by extension, the
- 5:35lack of merit among the
- 5:37population sectors not in positions
- 5:39of power.
- 5:41This school of thought latches onto
- 5:42cultural and family practices
- 5:44and values, and then
- 5:46perversely, frankly, tries to
- 5:49use the stereotypes
- 5:51about Asians to justify
- 5:53over-representation of whites, and
- 5:55that they talk about this
- 5:57Asian tiger mom example
- 5:59being a model of
- 6:01discipline that results in
- 6:03better results for Asians and
- 6:04whatnot. And they cite that example
- 6:06to reference and justify
- 6:09status quo where white men are
- 6:11in charge.
- 6:12And so one of the main people who
- 6:13does this is Heather McDonald, and
- 6:14she's a scholar at the Manhattan
- 6:15Institute and one of most
- 6:17prolific defenders of the
- 6:19status quo in trying to bring
- 6:21intellectual justification
- 6:23and passion behind this
- 6:25point of view.
- 6:26And so she has summarized this quite
- 6:28directly and unapologetically,
- 6:30frankly, saying that the
- 6:32absence of proportional
- 6:33representation is not proof of
- 6:35discrimination.
- 6:36But reflective of different
- 6:37capacities, cultures, skills,
- 6:39and behaviors across groups.
- 6:41And so she says that if institutions
- 6:43focus on merit, disparities
- 6:45aren't inevitable and acceptable
- 6:47outcome.
- 6:47And so boiling it down, she likes to
- 6:49cite things like, quote, broken
- 6:51homes and lack of role models
- 6:53for black folks as the culprit for
- 6:55their absence from positions of
- 6:56power.
- 6:57I wanted to share Merriam-Webster's
- 6:59dictionary's definition of the word
- 7:01merit. The definition of merit is
- 7:03a praiseworthy quality,
- 7:05a virtue, a character or
- 7:07conduct deserving of reward,
- 7:09a person's qualities and actions,
- 7:11et cetera, regarded as
- 7:13indicating what the person
- 7:16deserves to receive.
- 7:17So Steve, there are probably people
- 7:20who are saying,
- 7:21so what's wrong with those argument.
- 7:23Right. Well, some of them sound on
- 7:25the surface reasonable and
- 7:26even somewhat scientific, and they
- 7:28do try to invoke research.
- 7:30And frankly, they cherry pick
- 7:31research and they cite data.
- 7:33They present themselves as simply
- 7:35following the evidence.
- 7:36They claim they cite data.
- 7:38They say, oh, if you look at the
- 7:39AIDS example, their culture
- 7:41and their families our better,
- 7:43basically, is what Heather McDonald
- 7:44says, than the Black families.
- 7:45And that's why they have better
- 7:46results. But if you're really
- 7:47looking at data, it's still white
- 7:49men who control all the positions.
- 7:51If Asian culture was so much
- 7:52greater, why aren't Asians
- 7:54dominating the CEO ranks
- 7:56and the presidents of the United
- 7:57States and the members of Congress?
- 7:59So they claim to want data, but they
- 8:01only cite certain data that
- 8:03reinforces their very narrow and
- 8:05incorrect argument.
- 8:06Fundamentally, all of these
- 8:08different defenders of the as well.
- 8:09Lack historical context,
- 8:12and they lack behavioral science
- 8:13knowledge. And just in terms of the
- 8:15historical piece, it really would be
- 8:16like asking, in 1850,
- 8:18what's wrong with black families,
- 8:20that more young people aren't going
- 8:21to college, and ignoring
- 8:23entirely that the country had
- 8:25legalized slavery?
- 8:26That's why. It's not that our
- 8:28families weren't together or we
- 8:29weren't whatever, it's that we are
- 8:31living in a system that reinforced
- 8:33this inequality and did it with the
- 8:35power of the government and with the
- 8:36laws and the full force of that
- 8:38operation. Also, they're not new
- 8:40arguments, that while over
- 8:42time the specific language has
- 8:44changed, the footnotes have changed,
- 8:46but the structure of the argument,
- 8:48that inequality reflects natural
- 8:49differences, not designed systems,
- 8:52that integration or equality cannot
- 8:54be legislated because they must
- 8:56emerge from natural affinities,
- 8:58that whatever the explanation is,
- 8:59it's certainly not the system's
- 9:01fault or any kind of intentional
- 9:02activity.
- 9:03That argument is very, very
- 9:06old. It's as old as the United
- 9:07States of America.
- 9:08And in fact, it was written into a
- 9:10Supreme Court opinion more than
- 9:12100 years ago.
- 9:13The court opinion you're referring
- 9:15to and that you get into in
- 9:17your new book is Plessy
- 9:18versus Ferguson.
- 9:20And for those who are unfamiliar
- 9:21with the case, this is a case that
- 9:23in 1896,
- 9:25the Supreme Court of the United
- 9:26States decided Plessie versus
- 9:28Ferguson that enshrined separate
- 9:30but equal as the law of
- 9:31the land for the next 60 years.
- 9:34The majority opinion, which was
- 9:36written by Justice Henry Billings
- 9:37Brown. Contains a passage
- 9:39that as you just mentioned, sounds
- 9:41familiar. In 1896,
- 9:43in Plessy versus Ferguson, the
- 9:45court argued that law could
- 9:47not eliminate social prejudices,
- 9:50insisting instead that if
- 9:52the two races are to
- 9:54meet upon terms of social equality,
- 9:56it must be the result of
- 9:58natural affinities and
- 10:00a voluntary consent
- 10:02of individuals.
- 10:04Exactly.
- 10:04And then first of all, it's not the
- 10:06Supreme Court's job to wade in this
- 10:07business about trying to be social
- 10:09science experts.
- 10:10They're supposed to be interpreting
- 10:11what's constitutional and what's
- 10:12not. And we have passed
- 10:13anti-discrimination laws after the
- 10:15Civil War and the Reconstruction
- 10:17Amendments.
- 10:18And so they basically tried
- 10:20to narrow those laws,
- 10:22those constitutional amendments down
- 10:23by inserting their own sociological
- 10:26prejudices in this regard,
- 10:28natural affinities, voluntary
- 10:29consent.
- 10:30The law cannot override what is
- 10:32natural.
- 10:33Equality must emerge organically,
- 10:34not from policy or legislation.
- 10:36So the court went even further than
- 10:38that, right? I mean, it went on to
- 10:39claim that, quote, legislation is
- 10:41powerless to eradicate racial
- 10:43instincts, and the attempt to
- 10:45do so could only result in
- 10:46accentuating the difficulties of the
- 10:48present situation.
- 10:49If I just have to shake my head
- 10:50around how far afield from what
- 10:52courts are supposed to be doing.
- 10:55But the Plessy Court wasn't the only
- 10:56one. It essentially defended
- 10:58inequality.
- 10:59Like, throughout American history,
- 11:00the defense of inequalities had many
- 11:02champions.
- 11:03People of great renown, reputation,
- 11:05standing, accomplishment, most of
- 11:07whom are white men, who use
- 11:09their platforms to argue that the
- 11:11existing order where white men
- 11:13happen to be in charge was simply
- 11:15right and simply natural.
- 11:17So consider Leland Stanford,
- 11:19the founder of Stanford University,
- 11:20my alma mater, the alma mater of
- 11:22Cory Booker, Diane Feinstein, Google
- 11:24founder, Larry Page, and others.
- 11:26Founded in 1885, Stanford's one
- 11:27of the most prestigious, powerful,
- 11:29and well-resourced universities in
- 11:30the world.
- 11:31So it's at the heart of Silicon
- 11:32Valley.
- 11:33Stanford graduates populate the
- 11:35C-suites and halls of government.
- 11:37Many of the most well-known startup
- 11:38companies in the world come from
- 11:40there.
- 11:41This endowment is tens of billions
- 11:42of dollars,
- 11:44and Leland Stanford was also one
- 11:46of the chief unapologetic
- 11:49proponents of these points of view.
- 11:51I always am struck
- 11:53by how as famous as
- 11:55Stanford University is that
- 11:57when I first learned about this,
- 11:59it made me realize that I just don't
- 12:00think a lot of people know about
- 12:02Leland Stanford, the founders views.
- 12:05And I thought I would share one
- 12:07quote here as just some
- 12:09insight in a speech for
- 12:11the Republican nomination for
- 12:13governor of California in 1859.
- 12:16He described the
- 12:18cause he served as
- 12:20quote the cause of the white
- 12:22man, declaring, quote, I
- 12:24prefer the white man to
- 12:26the Negro as an inhabitant
- 12:28of our country.
- 12:30He argued then the nation's
- 12:31greatest good came from
- 12:33being, quote settled by free
- 12:35white men, unquote.
- 12:37And there's a chant for students,
- 12:39Leland, Stanford, Junior,
- 12:41University, right?
- 12:43So that's the – they leave out
- 12:45that quote in terms of this.
- 12:46Yeah.
- 12:46Yeah, I bet they do.
- 12:48And as we know, I mean,
- 12:50we're kind of picking on Stanford.
- 12:53We know a lot about the history,
- 12:54you're an alum, but we also
- 12:56know Stanford is by, you know, he
- 12:58and institutions founded
- 13:01by people like him are not
- 13:03the only one.
- 13:03Right, I mean, yeah, he was a
- 13:05political leader, but there was
- 13:06another political leader who became
- 13:07president of the United States,
- 13:08right? And so Andrew Johnson,
- 13:10who only became president because
- 13:12a white supremacist murdered Abraham
- 13:14Lincoln, Andrew Johnson
- 13:17very much had that same
- 13:19view, and he unapologetically also
- 13:21laid this point of view out.
- 13:22I mean he was opposed the
- 13:24civil rights laws of the time,
- 13:27the post-Civil War era, and
- 13:30he declared.
- 13:31Quite forcefully.
- 13:32He says, this is a country for white
- 13:33men.
- 13:34And as long as I am president, it
- 13:36shall be a government for white man.
- 13:38And then later, Johnson warned that
- 13:40legislation like the Civil Rights
- 13:41Act of that era would create,
- 13:43quote, a distinction of race and
- 13:45color in favor of the colored
- 13:47and against the white race.
- 13:49So you can take that language and
- 13:52hear it echoing from the
- 13:54White House today.
- 13:55That's right.
- 13:56And so we'll just fast forward to
- 13:58today. And there are countless
- 14:00examples that we could cite.
- 14:02And I just thought I would quote, we
- 14:03mentioned her earlier, Heather
- 14:05McDonald of the Manhattan Institute
- 14:07and intellect and somebody
- 14:09who commands a lot of attention.
- 14:11A lot of people listen to her.
- 14:12I thought we would just share a
- 14:14clip as she explains how efforts
- 14:16to address inequality are
- 14:18themselves a form of discrimination
- 14:21against white people.
- 14:23You know, it is academic
- 14:25effort, it is family culture,
- 14:28you cannot learn if
- 14:30you're not in school.
- 14:32The black truancy rate is very high.
- 14:34Nobody can actually,
- 14:36at this point,
- 14:38learning to read, the student has
- 14:40to do it himself.
- 14:43And racializing this does not help.
- 14:44The effort has to come from within.
- 14:46And if effort is made,
- 14:48we are an open society.
- 14:50We are waiting with welcome,
- 14:52open arms.
- 14:54I guess I'm having to focus
- 14:57on
- 14:59the charge that racial
- 15:01disparities in institutions is per
- 15:03se a sign of racism
- 15:05somewhere.
- 15:06You know, it's very hard, at
- 15:08this point, systemic racism is like
- 15:10phlogiston.
- 15:11It's like this vaporous thing
- 15:13that we just have to believe is out
- 15:15there, and nobody can really point
- 15:16to where it is exactly.
- 15:17Um, but...
- 15:20I guess rather than
- 15:22just saying, well, we
- 15:24will have disparities, get over
- 15:26it, I feel like
- 15:28my engagement at this
- 15:30point is to explain
- 15:32those disparities.
- 15:35And then it's a slightly
- 15:37different argument.
- 15:39In one sense, we're making the same
- 15:40argument, which in light of the
- 15:42academic skills gaps
- 15:43and the behavior gaps in crime,
- 15:46yes, of course, we are going to have
- 15:47lack of proportionality.
- 15:51So the assumption that
- 15:53there would be equal
- 15:55outcomes
- 15:57is only valid if
- 16:01cultures at this point
- 16:03were different. But I can tell you
- 16:06the Asian culture,
- 16:08the tiger mom culture puts
- 16:11everything else to shame.
- 16:12And if you juxtapose that to the
- 16:14inner city culture, the behavioral
- 16:16disparities are so great, It
- 16:17astounds me that.
- 16:20Apparently, my good
- 16:22friends on the left actually believe
- 16:24that the best explanation
- 16:26for the
- 16:28lack of disparities is racism and
- 16:30not what is quite
- 16:32empirically provable
- 16:34about how the home cultures differ.
- 16:54When Ben Carson was running for
- 16:56president and it goes 2016,
- 16:58black doctor.
- 16:59And he would say, so it's, well, my
- 17:00mom was poor,
- 17:02but she didn't have these bad habits
- 17:04and whatnot.
- 17:05And I always wanted to say,
- 17:07why was your mom poor?
- 17:09How did she get poor?
- 17:11What was that? So we don't have any
- 17:12kind of historical context.
- 17:14And so that's why in
- 17:16my first book, Brown is Doing White,
- 17:17I had this section called, why do
- 17:19white people have all the money?
- 17:20And the answer, when you look at it
- 17:21honestly, isn't complicated.
- 17:23America's early wealth came from
- 17:25stolen land worked by stolen
- 17:27people. English studies arrived in
- 17:281607 as part of a privately financed
- 17:31profit seeking venture.
- 17:33Then launched a tax on the original
- 17:35inhabitants of the land,
- 17:37forcibly took control of the fertile
- 17:38soil and shipped in
- 17:40enslaved Africans to pick crops
- 17:42that generated tremendous amounts
- 17:44of cash.
- 17:46That pretty much sums up the entire
- 17:48story of how America
- 17:49became wealthy early on.
- 17:52And the pattern did not stop in the
- 17:541600s.
- 17:55It continued to the rise of slavery
- 17:57as a global economic engine.
- 17:59The betrayal of post-Civil War
- 18:01reconstruction, which was designed
- 18:02to provide compensation to formerly
- 18:04enslaved people, and
- 18:06up through the resurgence of
- 18:07sharecropping and the rise of Jim
- 18:09Crow segregation in the 20th
- 18:10century. That is a large part
- 18:12of the origin of the inequality
- 18:14that these DEI measures
- 18:16that are now under attack,
- 18:18that's why they were created and
- 18:20what they're trying to address.
- 18:21Talk briefly about what you see as
- 18:22one of the main flaws of the attacks
- 18:24against DEI right now.
- 18:26Well, it's more than just a flaw.
- 18:27It's also important to bear in mind
- 18:29that all of these attacks in
- 18:31the more recent period are
- 18:33coming fairly recently from a
- 18:34historical standpoint after the
- 18:36racial reckoning after the murder of
- 18:37George Floyd in 2020.
- 18:39And so all these people were saying
- 18:40they cared about inequality, they
- 18:42cared systemic racism, wanted to do
- 18:44something about it.
- 18:45And so DEI was one of the measures
- 18:47designed to
- 18:49remedy inequality and
- 18:51injustice.
- 18:52And so what we're having now is
- 18:54that people are attacking the
- 18:56remedies without addressing
- 18:58the underlying disease and
- 19:00problem that the remedies were
- 19:01designed to bring about.
- 19:03And the irony of this inequality
- 19:04itself isn't a front to the founding
- 19:06ideals of the United States of
- 19:08America.
- 19:09Declaration of Independence
- 19:10proclaimed that all men
- 19:11are created equal.
- 19:12And we think most people interpret
- 19:14that as all are created equally.
- 19:17Lincoln and Gettysburg.
- 19:18Reaffirmed the founding notion that
- 19:20this dedicated the proposition that
- 19:22all are created equal and during the
- 19:24height of the civil rights movement
- 19:251965 Lyndon Johnson
- 19:26stood before a joint session of
- 19:28Congress on national television
- 19:30audience and embraced the anthem of
- 19:31the Civil Rights movement and
- 19:32declared We shall overcome
- 19:34and then as I mentioned most
- 19:36recently in summer of 2020 after
- 19:37George Floyd was killed everybody
- 19:39It seemed was talking about
- 19:41how anti-racist
- 19:43they were. They gave away from
- 19:45Walmart to the National Football
- 19:47League, Fortune 500 corporations,
- 19:49all proclaiming that black lives do
- 19:50in fact matter and that
- 19:52anti-black systemic racism is
- 19:55in fact a problem and a wrong and
- 19:56something that needs to be
- 19:57addressed.
- 19:59And, but now today,
- 20:01the inequality persists in
- 20:03worsens and as it persists and
- 20:04worsens, these enemies of equality
- 20:06are gleefully taking a wrecking
- 20:08ball to the remedies.
- 20:10DEI, Affirmative Action, other
- 20:12initiatives designed to address this
- 20:14gap. And people are scrubbing the
- 20:16words gender from their website.
- 20:18All of it is under attack.
- 20:19And so what all these critics are
- 20:21doing is they're trying to focus on
- 20:23the shortcomings and any kind
- 20:25of inadequacies
- 20:27of those who are trying to overcome
- 20:29inequality and are thinking to
- 20:31gain equality.
- 20:33And then they're try to turn this
- 20:34argument to blame those individuals
- 20:36for, quote, complaining about the
- 20:37obstacles placed in their past.
- 20:40Rather than trying to focus on
- 20:41getting the obstacles out of there
- 20:42in the first place.
- 20:44And it really is a situation of
- 20:45criticizing people for having
- 20:47shackles on their legs and not going
- 20:49faster, rather than how do you
- 20:50actually remove the shackles so
- 20:52that everybody can move at an equal
- 20:54standpoint.
- 21:09Steve, let's talk about merit.
- 21:10As just one example, defenders
- 21:12of this status quo
- 21:14where white men are
- 21:15over-represented, they'll often
- 21:17point to institutions like
- 21:19Harvard, Yale and Stanford
- 21:21as proof of meritocracy
- 21:23at work.
- 21:23That these are the best
- 21:24universities, the argument goes,
- 21:26and they admit the highest achieving
- 21:28students and therefore the system
- 21:30is working. In doing research for
- 21:32your new book, you came across some
- 21:34interesting history related
- 21:36to merit and academia.
- 21:37Can you share that with us?
- 21:38In terms of the history of this
- 21:40country on this very question of
- 21:42merit and particularly merit in
- 21:43relationship to higher education
- 21:45admissions, which is particularly
- 21:47important, given that it's the
- 21:49Supreme Court in their
- 21:50case due to affirmative action
- 21:51against Harvard and they
- 21:53were going after affirmative action
- 21:55and trying to eliminate affirmative
- 21:56action, which sent the signal that
- 21:58opened the door for all these other
- 22:00attacks on measures to
- 22:02address inequality.
- 22:03And so what this professor,
- 22:05sociologist Jerome Carrabelle,
- 22:07and he has this landmark book, The
- 22:08Chosen, he shows that it's
- 22:10actually the literal opposite.
- 22:13As people are running around saying
- 22:14like, well, we can't have these
- 22:16special rules or
- 22:18affirmative action and for a lack
- 22:20of merit to let these other people
- 22:22in, we have to have strong
- 22:24standards.
- 22:25But it's the opposite that has
- 22:26actually happened in history.
- 22:27And so he really breaks this down
- 22:29in his book and that really in
- 22:31the late 19th and early 20th
- 22:33centuries. Admissions at Harvard,
- 22:35Princeton, and Yale were very
- 22:36straightforward, objective.
- 22:37They had a test.
- 22:38If you could pass the test, you
- 22:40would admit it. Very simple, very
- 22:41clear, very objective.
- 22:43But then something happened.
- 22:44In the 20s, as immigration from
- 22:47southern and eastern Europe, the
- 22:48less desirable whites, surged,
- 22:51the leaders of those institutions
- 22:53found that the student bodies were
- 22:54changing the ways they didn't like,
- 22:55in particular in terms of having a
- 22:56lot more Jewish students, more
- 22:58immigrant students, students from
- 22:59the wrong backgrounds.
- 23:00They were passing the exams and were
- 23:02being admitted. And then as a
- 23:03result, they were changing the
- 23:05composition of those institutions.
- 23:08And so what they decided to
- 23:10do was to change the definition of
- 23:12merit. The response of Harvard,
- 23:14Princeton, and Yale's leadership was
- 23:16really the opposite of meritocracy,
- 23:18and they literally rewrote
- 23:21what.
- 23:21Merit-wise and how do you define
- 23:23merit?
- 23:23Let's hear a bit from Carabelle as
- 23:25he explains this in The Chosen.
- 23:28I asked, what difference did
- 23:30it make that Southerners had this
- 23:32power and control in the Democratic
- 23:34Party?
- 23:35Answer, in
- 23:37key areas of public policy,
- 23:40social security, which passed
- 23:42in 1935,
- 23:44the Wagner Act, which gave
- 23:46unions protection
- 23:49to organize, 1935.
- 23:531937-38, the passage
- 23:55in 38 of the
- 23:57Fair Labor Standards Act,
- 23:59which gave us minimum wages
- 24:01and maximum work hours
- 24:03of 40 hour a week.
- 24:06The character of the American
- 24:07military during the Second
- 24:09World War and
- 24:11the GI Bill that passed
- 24:13for veterans after the war.
- 24:16All of these elements,
- 24:18all of them,
- 24:20social policy,
- 24:23labor policy,
- 24:25military policy,
- 24:27veterans policies.
- 24:28All of them passed through a
- 24:30Congress in
- 24:32which Southern members had
- 24:34disproportionate power.
- 24:36And I call this unevenness
- 24:39of benefits, whether
- 24:41for social security or
- 24:43for the GI Bill,
- 24:45the period when affirmative action
- 24:47was white because
- 24:49the government was using its
- 24:51policy power.
- 24:53To create benefits and
- 24:55advantages for white
- 24:57veterans that were not
- 24:59available on equal terms to
- 25:01black veterans.
- 25:02So that's when affirmative action
- 25:04was white.
- 25:05And that helped open up
- 25:07huge gaps between white
- 25:09and black Americans in
- 25:11terms of income and wealth,
- 25:13which persists alas to this
- 25:15day.
- 25:16Right, and so what Carable lays
- 25:18out, right, is that this, you have
- 25:20this new, highly subjective
- 25:22definition of merit being
- 25:23introduced.
- 25:24One emphasizing character,
- 25:26leadership, personality,
- 25:27extracurricular activities.
- 25:29Definition that, as Carable put it,
- 25:31reflected the power of the existing,
- 25:33largely Protestant elite to impose
- 25:35a definition that would serve its
- 25:37interests.
- 25:38And it's fascinating just looking at
- 25:39this. This is exactly what they're
- 25:40trying to accuse proponents
- 25:42of affirmative action of doing.
- 25:44It's like, oh, you have these other
- 25:45non-objective characteristics
- 25:47and whatnot.
- 25:48But the people who actually did it,
- 25:50who created the current inequality,
- 25:52they did exactly what now they're
- 25:53trying to claim that we're actually
- 25:55doing.
- 25:56And so we know from this, for many
- 25:57of the examples, that merit is not a
- 25:59fixed objective standard
- 26:01and that talent manifests itself
- 26:03in different ways and doesn't
- 26:04necessarily have all of the
- 26:06traditional standards
- 26:08attached to it.
- 26:09Right, some of the top, you see this
- 26:11even in Silicon Valley and some of
- 26:12these top white guys dropped out of
- 26:13college. And went to pursue their
- 26:15company, and they became super
- 26:16successful.
- 26:17So are they not, do they not have
- 26:19merit because they don't have a
- 26:20college degree?
- 26:22So it's just something that's far
- 26:23more malleable in terms
- 26:25of how we think about this, that
- 26:26we've been looking at the particular
- 26:28point of view at a moment in
- 26:30time. We have a really much more
- 26:32of a fluid narrative around
- 26:33this, and that has how we've
- 26:35been approaching merit as a
- 26:37determining factor for access to
- 26:39positions of power and influence.
- 26:41The reality is it's historically
- 26:43been engineered, often at
- 26:44moments of institutional threat,
- 26:47to protect the incumbent
- 26:48establishment and the status
- 26:50quo.
- 26:51Steve, now let's talk about bias.
- 26:53We've talked about how history is a
- 26:55big part of how we got here and
- 26:57how it contributes to this ongoing
- 26:59reality of inequality and
- 27:01to this on-going reality of
- 27:03white men being overrepresented in
- 27:05positions of power and leadership.
- 27:08But a big of how got
- 27:10here is actually
- 27:11science, the science of
- 27:13human behavior.
- 27:15And many scholars and academics have
- 27:16spent their entire careers studying
- 27:18how that bias actually works.
- 27:21Two of the leading researchers in
- 27:22this field are Stanford's Dr.
- 27:24Jennifer Iberhart and UC
- 27:26Berkeley's John Powell.
- 27:28Dr. Iberhard is a professor of
- 27:30psychology at Stanford and a
- 27:322014 MacArthur Genius
- 27:34Grant recipient.
- 27:36In her book, Biased Uncovering
- 27:38the Hidden Prejudice that Shapes
- 27:40What We See, Think and
- 27:42Do, she articulates
- 27:43the mechanics of how the brain
- 27:45produces bias.
- 27:47Let's hear a little bit from
- 27:48Dr.Iberhard from an interview.
- 27:50Explaining how the human brain
- 27:52categorizes and forms beliefs.
- 27:56Yeah, so it's almost like the brain
- 27:58can't handle everything that
- 28:00it's exposed to,
- 28:02and so there are these sort
- 28:04of techniques that
- 28:06our brains use to deal
- 28:08with all that information.
- 28:11So categorization is one of those
- 28:13things, and we don't just categorize
- 28:14people. We categorize animals,
- 28:17other animals, we categorize
- 28:19furniture, we catagorize
- 28:21plants, You know, all sorts of
- 28:23things. But that
- 28:25categorization allows us to
- 28:27engage in the world,
- 28:29and the world becomes more coherent
- 28:31because of that categorisation.
- 28:34But it's also something that
- 28:36we do with people, right?
- 28:37So it's not just plants and
- 28:39other animals.
- 28:40It's social groups.
- 28:42And when we categorize those social
- 28:43groups, we develop
- 28:45beliefs about people who are in
- 28:47that category.
- 28:48We develop feelings about
- 28:50people who are in that category.
- 28:52And those beliefs are called
- 28:54stereotypes, and then the feelings
- 28:55are called prejudice.
- 28:57And together, that's called bias.
- 29:00So it's all really very interesting.
- 29:02Actually, I know Jennifer, and she's
- 29:04an incredible scholar on
- 29:06these different fields.
- 29:07And another person who has really
- 29:09been a real leader in this whole
- 29:10realm is John Powell at
- 29:13UC Berkeley.
- 29:13And he's now the director of the
- 29:15Otheringham Belonging Institute at
- 29:17UC Berkley.
- 29:18And then he has a whole institute as
- 29:20well as a whole lifetime career
- 29:22of research and study
- 29:24looking at and
- 29:26understanding from a scientific
- 29:28basis.
- 29:29What bias is and how it works.
- 29:38Can we talk a little about the
- 29:40neuroscience aspect of it all?
- 29:42Because I think that's something people
- 29:43don't really appreciate.
- 29:45Because most people think that we
- 29:46know what we think or how we make,
- 29:48we arrive at decisions.
- 29:49But your research really challenges
- 29:51that pretty fundamentally.
- 29:52So what has the scientific
- 29:54literature shown about how bias
- 29:55actually operates in our brains and
- 29:57behavior?
- 29:57Well, it's interesting, Steve.
- 29:59I mean, one of the things I
- 30:01sometimes say is we're biased
- 30:02against bias.
- 30:03Bias is actually a fundamental part
- 30:05of intelligence.
- 30:06We don't actually have direct
- 30:08contact with the world.
- 30:09This is counter-intuitive.
- 30:10We have all kinds of filters and
- 30:12then there's different parts of the
- 30:13brain. The newest part of the, brain
- 30:15is called the prefrontal cortex.
- 30:17The older part of brain is the
- 30:18amygdala, which helps
- 30:20regulate emotions and fear and
- 30:22stuff like that. And so much of the
- 30:24brain function happens
- 30:26below consciousness or
- 30:28outside of consciousness.
- 30:30Call it the unconscious, we call it
- 30:31implicit.
- 30:32Some people think that the conscious
- 30:34is a fraud because all the work
- 30:36is being done at the unconscious
- 30:37level and the unconscious
- 30:39communicates to the conscious.
- 30:41The thing that's interesting in this
- 30:42is that the
- 30:44unconscious is constantly looking
- 30:45for shortcuts.
- 30:46And so that's one of the ways that
- 30:48bias comes in.
- 30:48Bias is actually a heuristic
- 30:51mode that the brain
- 30:53used to sort of pare down all this
- 30:55information so it's usable
- 30:57by the conscious By
- 30:59some accounts, we process 43
- 31:01bits of information a
- 31:03second consciously.
- 31:06During that same second, we
- 31:08processed 11 million bits of
- 31:10information unconsciously.
- 31:12And the unconscious operates very
- 31:13differently than the conscious.
- 31:16So if things happen
- 31:19over and over again in close
- 31:21proximity, we draw a neural
- 31:22connection. An example would be
- 31:24Pablo's dog.
- 31:25You ring a bell, you feed the dog.
- 31:27You ring the bell, you feed a dog.
- 31:28Ring the bell.
- 31:29The dog starts salivating.
- 31:31Why? Because the dog has
- 31:33associated the bell with food.
- 31:35Literally in the brain of the dog,
- 31:36there's been a neural network
- 31:38connecting the sound of
- 31:40the bell and food.
- 31:41We do the same thing with race, the
- 31:43same things with gender, the same
- 31:44with color.
- 31:45It's like we have these
- 31:46associations.
- 31:47And when you think about it, the
- 31:49associations are largely reflecting
- 31:51the outside world.
- 31:52So an example, there was a study
- 31:54looking at black and poverty.
- 31:56And in a mega study on literature,
- 31:59the association was quite strong.
- 32:01Whenever you saw the word black.
- 32:02Where poverty was close to hand.
- 32:04So now the brain is
- 32:06learning that there is a
- 32:08connection between poverty and
- 32:10blackness.
- 32:11Whether it is or not, it's not
- 32:12factual.
- 32:13It's just repetition,
- 32:15proximity, and frequency.
- 32:18So that's how these particular
- 32:19social biases are created.
- 32:21And so can you talk a little bit
- 32:22about how that plays out
- 32:24in terms of hiring,
- 32:27promotion, who gets invested
- 32:29in, et cetera?
- 32:30There's that famous study, right,
- 32:31from a number of years ago, are
- 32:32Emily and Greg more employable than
- 32:34Latisha and Jamal.
- 32:35How does this unconscious
- 32:38processing manifest
- 32:40itself in terms decisions that get
- 32:41made?
- 32:43So there's a lot of studies showing
- 32:45that women would not get selected to
- 32:47be in the orchestra.
- 32:48And so they start having blind
- 32:50testing. They're saying, again,
- 32:52you see a man, you associate a
- 32:54man with being an orchestra.
- 32:55You see a woman, you don't associate
- 32:57her being an an orchestra,
- 32:59and then that affects your decision
- 33:00and your behavior.
- 33:02They call it confirmation bias.
- 33:03The once you have a bias, once you
- 33:05expect to see something, you're
- 33:07likely to see it.
- 33:08So what they did is they said, let's
- 33:09have blind tests.
- 33:10Let's actually create a curtain so
- 33:12we can't see who's playing for
- 33:14the audition.
- 33:15And then it proved.
- 33:17The selection of women.
- 33:18When they couldn't see the woman,
- 33:20they just heard the music, all of a
- 33:22sudden the woman could play better.
- 33:23But it wasn't anywhere close to
- 33:25even. So somebody said, okay, now
- 33:27we've eliminated the bias.
- 33:29Now the remaining selection process
- 33:31is only based on how
- 33:33well someone plays.
- 33:35And someone said, well, I don't
- 33:35think that's quite right.
- 33:37The still is highly distorted, men
- 33:38being selected a lot more.
- 33:41And so then someone figured out
- 33:43that when a person
- 33:45walked out on the stage behind
- 33:47the curtain to play music,
- 33:49the unconscious could detect if
- 33:51the steps were that of a woman or
- 33:53a man. And then it
- 33:55actually fed the bias.
- 33:57A man is coming out on stage, the
- 33:59music sounds better.
- 34:00The unconscious is incredibly
- 34:02subtle. Going to a hospital and
- 34:04all the doctors are men, all the
- 34:05nurses are women.
- 34:06What assumption do we make?
- 34:07Men are smarter.
- 34:08Men work harder.
- 34:10They're supposed to be doctors.
- 34:12Women are supposed to serve men.
- 34:14That confirms the bias we
- 34:16already have.
- 34:17Let's talk a little bit about public
- 34:18policy, because people don't,
- 34:21again, they think things are all
- 34:22neutral, that we have
- 34:24arrived at this level of inequality
- 34:25just for whatever reason.
- 34:27One of my favorite because I spend
- 34:29way too much time on airplanes.
- 34:31Luggage racks, an airplane.
- 34:33Where are they?
- 34:34They're overhead.
- 34:35That means some populations are
- 34:37disadvantaged by that.
- 34:39So what population as a
- 34:40group is shorter than other
- 34:42populations?
- 34:44Well, women are shorter than men as
- 34:45a group.
- 34:46And as a GROUP, women
- 34:48has left less upper body
- 34:50strength than men.
- 34:51So even a woman who's as tall as a
- 34:52man, on average, will have
- 34:54less upper body strength that a man.
- 34:56And, as a Group, women aren't more
- 34:58likely to luggage than they are.
- 35:00So you know what women do?
- 35:02Women as a group are more likely
- 35:04to check their luggage,
- 35:06which means they have to be at the
- 35:07airport 45 minutes earlier
- 35:09than their male counterpart.
- 35:11And when they leave,
- 35:13they have to wait for their luggage
- 35:14and sometimes it's not there.
- 35:15So they are paying a tax for
- 35:18that arrangement.
- 35:19So we've talked about the science of
- 35:21bias, and we've talk about
- 35:22the history of inequality, but
- 35:24we haven't yet exactly connected
- 35:27the dots between bias
- 35:29and why white men are
- 35:30overrepresented in positions of
- 35:32leadership and power and influence
- 35:35throughout our history, and
- 35:37continues to be the situation today.
- 35:39I was struck by Professor
- 35:41Powell's mention of confirmation
- 35:43bias, really interesting
- 35:45confirmation bias and how
- 35:47he said, Once you have a bias,
- 35:49once you expect to see something,
- 35:52you're likely to see it.
- 35:53Yeah, and I think the most simplest
- 35:56manifestation of that
- 35:58is who gets to hold positions of
- 35:59leadership. Who do we think
- 36:01consciously and subconsciously
- 36:02should hold positions for
- 36:03leadership? We have never
- 36:05had a woman as
- 36:07the president of the United States
- 36:08of America.
- 36:09And so is that a question of talent
- 36:11or is that question of who
- 36:13the country psychologically
- 36:15thinks should have that leadership
- 36:16position?
- 36:17There's never been a black woman as
- 36:19a governor of a state in this
- 36:21country. And is that a question of?
- 36:23Or is that a question of what roles
- 36:25that psychology wants
- 36:28and assigns people to?
- 36:30And so there's really been nobody
- 36:32more articulate
- 36:34about this than Isabel Wilkerson.
- 36:36And in her landmark book,
- 36:38Caste, she talks about this and she
- 36:40really articulates it in
- 36:42a very compelling way that when
- 36:44you – if you see someone who
- 36:46looks a particular way in the same
- 36:48roles often enough, you begin to
- 36:50think that that's what those roles
- 36:52are supposed to be and that that's
- 36:54who should be holding those kinds of
- 36:55roles.
- 36:57It's a great book, and I know you've
- 36:58cited her in at least
- 37:00two of your books, and there's a
- 37:02passage that I just love,
- 37:04and it really captures what you're
- 37:06talking about and this notion of
- 37:08confirmation bias.
- 37:09It goes like this.
- 37:10Day after day, the curtain
- 37:12rises on a stage of epic
- 37:14proportions, one that has been
- 37:16running for centuries.
- 37:18The actors wear the costumes of
- 37:19their predecessors and inhabit
- 37:21the roles assigned to them.
- 37:23The people in these roles are not
- 37:25the characters as they play.
- 37:27But they have played the roles long
- 37:29enough to incorporate the roles into
- 37:31their very being to merge
- 37:33the assignment with their inner
- 37:34selves and how they are seen in
- 37:36the world.
- 37:37The costumes were handed out at
- 37:39birth and can never be removed.
- 37:41The costumes cue everyone in the
- 37:43cast to the roles each character
- 37:45is to play and to each
- 37:47character's place on the stage.
- 37:49Over the run of the show, the cast
- 37:51has grown accustomed to who
- 37:53plays which part.
- 37:55For generations, Everyone
- 37:56has known who is center stage in
- 37:58the lead.
- 38:00Everyone knows who the hero
- 38:02is, who the supporting characters
- 38:04are, who is the sidekick
- 38:06good for laughs and who
- 38:08is in the shadow.
- 38:10Stay in the roles long enough and
- 38:12everyone begins to believe that
- 38:14the roles are preordained,
- 38:17that each cast member is best
- 38:19suited by talent and temperament
- 38:21for their assigned role
- 38:23and maybe only that role.
- 38:26Yeah, that's probably preordained,
- 38:29right? And that word is doing
- 38:31a tremendous amount of work in how
- 38:32we think about inequality in this
- 38:34country and how we're thinking about who's
- 38:35supposed to have white roles.
- 38:36As listening to you read that made
- 38:38me think about James Bond.
- 38:40James Bond was a fictional
- 38:41character. He was a very popular
- 38:43fictional character, but there
- 38:45was a attempt or discussion
- 38:47about should Idris Elba, the black
- 38:48actor.
- 38:50Play the James Bond role.
- 38:51And people were up in arms, like,
- 38:52no, James Bond is a white guy.
- 38:54James Bond's a fictional character,
- 38:56right? But the mindset around who
- 38:58is supposed to play of this, you
- 38:59know, suave, commanding,
- 39:01in control, is
- 39:03very, very deep.
- 39:04And I thought that Wilkeston did
- 39:05such a great job of
- 39:07articulating that. And it does
- 39:09manifest itself as to reinforcing
- 39:11this current situation of inequality
- 39:12in the country, right, that,
- 39:14you now, so when white men run
- 39:16everything for long enough, in this
- 39:18country's case.
- 39:19Since the beginning, it begins
- 39:21to feel natural and inevitable
- 39:23and right.
- 39:24And people begin to believe that
- 39:26it's the result of talent and
- 39:28temperament and merit
- 39:29and not of assignment and design.
- 39:32And so that feeling is not
- 39:34an accident, but it's not the truth.
- 39:36So where do we go from
- 39:38here? How do we write a new story
- 39:40and create a new reality?
- 39:43One that celebrates and elevates
- 39:44all people that is rooted
- 39:46in human flourishing for everyone
- 39:48from every background.
- 39:50That promotes a society with
- 39:52preferences for none and
- 39:54justice for all.
- 39:55How do we make manifest the founding
- 39:57vision of a country that
- 39:59truly believes and works toward
- 40:01the idea that all
- 40:03are created equal?
- 40:05That's going to be the topic of our
- 40:06next and final episode.
- 40:09Stay tuned.
- 40:12This is our White Men Smarter
- 40:14Than Everybody Else, the
- 40:16podcast.
- 40:18This special series podcast
- 40:20is a democracy in color production
- 40:22written by Steve Phillips and
- 40:24Charlene Chang.
- 40:25Produced by Olivia Parker,
- 40:28Fola Onifade is our associate
- 40:30producer.