Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Microorganisms: The invisible architects of life
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, illuminating the human
- 0:06side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and we'll discuss their
- 0:16meanings from different perspectives and fields
- 0:18of research. Disclaimer, this is a translated
- 0:23version using AI voice for the guest. Welcome
- 0:28to Science Behind the Glass, illuminating the
- 0:30human side. the podcast that explores the people
- 0:32behind research in the macro and micro universe
- 0:35of science. Today, we travel to the invisible
- 0:39world beneath our feet with Dr. César Marín,
- 0:43professor of ecology and evolution at Santo Tomás
- 0:46University in Chile. His passion is understanding
- 0:50how fungi wave the networks that sustain life
- 0:54on Earth, from forests to deserts. Cesar reveals
- 0:59the surprising life that occurs in the soil and
- 1:02how these tiny organisms sustain entire ecosystems.
- 1:06Joining him, Dr. Bernardo Aguilar Salgado, researcher
- 1:10at the UNAM Mexico, invites us to discover how
- 1:13relationships between plants, soils, and microorganisms
- 1:17can inspire new ways of caring for the planet.
- 1:21Joining him, Dr. Bernardo Aguila Salgado, researcher
- 1:24at Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, invites
- 1:27us to discover how relationships between plants,
- 1:31soils, and microorganisms can inspire new ways
- 1:34of caring for the planet. Additionally, he's
- 1:37a personal friend of this podcast as he produced
- 1:39the music we used for it. Today, we'll meet these
- 1:43two experts, their stories, and learn about fungi
- 1:45and their amazing connections. Additionally,
- 1:48he's a personal friend of this podcast as he
- 1:51produced the music we use for the podcast. Today,
- 1:54we will meet these two experts, their stories,
- 1:58and learn about Fungi and their amazing connection.
- 2:02Welcome, thank you so much for being here, thank
- 2:05you Bernardo, thank you César for accepting the
- 2:07invitation and we hope you enjoy this interview.
- 2:10To start, we'll begin with something basic. Since
- 2:12you both work on topics related to microorganisms,
- 2:16how would you explain what the microbial world
- 2:18is? And on a personal note, what draws you to
- 2:21study microorganisms? Well, if I can start, because
- 2:25just these days I'm writing a book chapter that
- 2:28tries to answer that question of what the microbial
- 2:30world is, and in which I describe that basically
- 2:32the world is such as microbial. Microorganisms
- 2:35make up about 20 % of the biomass of all organisms,
- 2:38but also evolutionarily, phylogenetically, microorganisms
- 2:42are the majority. It turns out that since the
- 2:4421st century, we've come to understand that microorganisms
- 2:47are also very prevalent in all organisms, forming
- 2:49a holobiont. So, what I describe in this chapter
- 2:53is this microbial blindness we've had as humanity
- 2:55and as biologists, as scientists, because many
- 2:58of our concepts and our way of thinking about
- 2:59life has been based on microorganisms on what
- 3:01we can see. However, microorganisms are the majority.
- 3:05They're responsible for nutrient cycles, both
- 3:07in the ocean and in the soil, and that's what
- 3:10led me to study them, their complexity, their
- 3:11enormous numbers. In the soils I study, in one
- 3:15gram of soil, there can easily be a billion bacteria
- 3:17and thousands upon thousands of species. So that
- 3:21complexity has always fascinated me. That's what
- 3:23drew me to microorganisms. And that was something
- 3:27that you developed since you were a kid? How
- 3:30did you get interested as a biologist among so
- 3:33many topics? Why did you decide to choose microorganisms?
- 3:38No, it was later. In fact, older. It was when
- 3:40I began my doctoral studies. It was by accident,
- 3:42actually. I was trying to understand what the
- 3:45relationship is between biodiversity and ecosystem
- 3:47services or functions. It's been a topic that
- 3:50has always interested me. I arrived in Valdivia,
- 3:52Chile in February 2014. I had no idea they were
- 3:56on vacation. There was only one professor who
- 3:59told me about a project that focused on understanding
- 4:01how biodiversity, certain methods of quantifying
- 4:03biodiversity, and the resulting explanations
- 4:05of ecosystem services and functions. And I think
- 4:08microorganisms are perfect for studying that
- 4:10question. And you, Bernardo? Well, similar. I
- 4:14mean, it's very similar. For me, microorganisms
- 4:17represent the past to the future. In the sense
- 4:20that they're the ancestors. It's how life originates.
- 4:24And we know, as Caesar said, that we are a holobiont.
- 4:28We really don't exist as individuals. We're a
- 4:31collection of many individuals, including microorganisms
- 4:34that have gigantic impacts on the Earth. i'd
- 4:37even dare to say that even without humans the
- 4:40future lies with microorganisms many experiments
- 4:43are currently underway for example attempting
- 4:45to colonize mars with cyanobacteria among others
- 4:48you can find them under a rock they're everywhere
- 4:52and they have so much mystery because there are
- 4:54so many of them I just came from a conference
- 4:57about fungi, where they discussed how there are
- 5:00families of fungi that aren't completely understood,
- 5:02including those that we encounter every day,
- 5:05but have never been genetically described. And
- 5:08it's crazy how these microorganisms do so many
- 5:11things, yet often go unnoticed. They're things
- 5:13that are transparent to us, to the human eye.
- 5:16But that's what's mysterious. As the doctor who
- 5:19wrote the book Microbial Love also said a very
- 5:22good book which precisely discusses how microorganisms
- 5:25are present in everything, including love, right?
- 5:28We leave traces everywhere. Everyone has their
- 5:31own microbiome profile. However, I agree with
- 5:33Caesar. It's a fascinating world, and what attracted
- 5:36me most, historically, I read a book I think
- 5:38I read in high school called Microbe Hunters.
- 5:42It explains the history of microbiology, and
- 5:44it's fascinating. Well, I was hooked with the
- 5:47stories of Robert Koch and everything the book
- 5:49explains in a very simple way. However, I initially
- 5:52wanted to study microbiology, but the program
- 5:54didn't exist at UAQ at the time I was studying,
- 5:57so I pursued biotechnology instead. But a year
- 6:00later the microbiology program opened, and I
- 6:02couldn't switch anymore. However, I have always
- 6:05been drawn to studying microbes or microorganisms.
- 6:08But, well, I don't regret it, and here we are.
- 6:11And now that we are talking about microorganisms,
- 6:14this is a huge topic, right? Microorganisms include
- 6:17an incredible variety of tiny living forms. Could
- 6:20you explain which specific microorganism you
- 6:23focus on and what roles they play? Why are they
- 6:27so important? You had mentioned they are really
- 6:30essential for life on Earth, that without them,
- 6:33nothing could really develop. Could you tell
- 6:36us more about why they are so fundamental and
- 6:39give some examples of microorganisms? Well, I
- 6:42study different types of microorganisms, but
- 6:44the truth is, the last 10 years I've specialized
- 6:46in mycorrhizal fungi. The term mycorrhiza means
- 6:49myco, which comes from fungus, and rhiza from
- 6:51root. It consists of a symbiotic association
- 6:54between approximately 86 % of all terrestrial
- 6:56plants and soil fungi and their roots. So, in
- 6:59this association, there's an exchange. There's
- 7:01a transfer of photosynthesis products, mainly
- 7:03carbon, from the plant to the fungus. The fungus,
- 7:06obviously, all organisms need carbon, right?
- 7:08And the fungus transfers nutrients like nitrogen
- 7:10and phosphorus and cations to the plant in addition
- 7:13to water and protection against certain biotic
- 7:15and abiotic stresses. This symbiosis is universal.
- 7:18It emerged approximately 406 million years ago.
- 7:21It's everywhere in the world and has essentially
- 7:23helped forests, shrubs, and grasses develop in
- 7:25the way we currently see them. So, it's a symbiosis
- 7:28that was fundamental to the current planet as
- 7:30we know it. In terms of functions, its main function
- 7:33is plant nutrition under certain environmental
- 7:35conditions, not in all environmental or contextual
- 7:37conditions. Ecology is a relational science,
- 7:41and in certain conditions this symbiosis isn't
- 7:43so beneficial, but in many others it is. And
- 7:47also on a global scale, it's been elucidated
- 7:49that it definitely regulates the cycles of some
- 7:51nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus. So certain
- 7:54steps of these cycles depend a lot on both these
- 7:56fungi and bacteria that associate with these
- 7:58fungi. And what's been changing my mindset a
- 8:01bit in recent years is that, well, I'm not a
- 8:03microbiologist, but we all have some microbiology
- 8:05training where you separate the type of organism
- 8:07a lot. With mycorrhizae, what's been known since
- 8:10about 2016 -2017 is that in the hyphae of these
- 8:13fungi lie certain bacteria. This is known as
- 8:17the hyphospere, and these bacteria are the ones
- 8:19mineralizing degrading the nitrogen and phosphorus
- 8:21that they pass first to the fungus, and the fungus
- 8:23passes it to the plant. So, it becomes a relationship
- 8:27of three, but it can also be a relationship of
- 8:29thousands or millions. I'm increasingly thinking
- 8:32of microbiology as a system science because it
- 8:34involves the complete system that needs to be
- 8:36investigated. And these Haifa you mentioned,
- 8:38the ones that have this symbiotic or cooperative
- 8:40relationship with plants and fungi, could you
- 8:43explain a bit more what Haifa actually are? We
- 8:48can't see them, right? So how does this interaction
- 8:53happen? Sure. Just as a plant has thick roots
- 8:56and then fine roots and then ultra -fine roots,
- 8:58a fungus, a mushroom, when you see a mushroom,
- 8:59the mushroom is like the tip of the iceberg.
- 9:01Under that mushroom, in the soil, there's an
- 9:03enormous network of these hyphae that are very,
- 9:06very, very thin. They're very thin because they
- 9:09have to enter the root, and they also have to
- 9:11explore the soil. So being so thin and so small,
- 9:13in fact, they can explore regions of the soil
- 9:15that the plant alone cannot. It's been calculated
- 9:18that in pine, when the pine is associated with
- 9:21these hyphae of these fungi, the volume of soil
- 9:23it explores can be 20 times greater than when
- 9:25the pine is alone, when it's without these fungi,
- 9:28because they're so, so, so, so thin that in a
- 9:31teaspoon, in a gram of soil, there can be 200
- 9:33meters of these hyphae if you laid them out end
- 9:35to end. It's a very complex network that goes
- 9:37in all directions, and in that network is transported,
- 9:40on one hand, the carbon that goes from plants
- 9:42to fungi, and also the nutrients that go the
- 9:44rest of the nutrients that go from fungi to the
- 9:46plant. And what can you tell us about what you're
- 9:48doing, Bernardo? And that network that mobilizes
- 9:51nutrients, that minerals, it's the mobilization
- 9:54issue, right? We were seeing, for example, a
- 9:57case where when you inoculate a small pine with
- 10:00leucaria, a little fungus, it has a higher probability
- 10:03of surviving when planted, right? And it's precisely
- 10:06because they help each other. It's a mutualism.
- 10:09So that's one of the functions, as Cesar says.
- 10:11It's an impressive complexity, a network of networks
- 10:14that communicates, and, as he said, they're not
- 10:16bipartite, tripartite interactions. They go into
- 10:19infinity types of interactions. And, well, we
- 10:22also know that when there are positive interactions,
- 10:25negative ones, that is, when there's competition
- 10:27or when there are mutualisms, there's also how
- 10:30it behaves, or, well, let's say how there are
- 10:32certain behaviors when comparing. For example,
- 10:34if the environment changes, there can be parasitism
- 10:37at the beginning, and there's a whole gradient
- 10:38up to almost a mutualism. So this is a function
- 10:42of what the environment is like, if it has many
- 10:44available resources, or if it's a very hostile
- 10:47place, very dynamic, with many changes over time.
- 10:50That makes those interactions change. They're
- 10:53not interactions that are always fixed, but there
- 10:55can be competition sometimes, and that same node,
- 10:58that same microorganism, can have other competition
- 11:00with an environmental change, right? So it's
- 11:04very, very complex to try to predict what connection
- 11:07will give what response. We study it in microbial
- 11:11ecology. It's known as the emergent properties
- 11:13of ecosystems. All of this, let's say, ecosystem
- 11:17services, ecosystem health. And it's due, as
- 11:21we know, to this impressive diversity of interactions
- 11:24that exist especially in the soil, in the oceans.
- 11:27It's everywhere, but it's precisely that, the
- 11:30functional part, is what keeps our planet alive.
- 11:33To complete biogeochemical cycles, all the members
- 11:36are needed. So yes, it's impressive and wonderful,
- 11:39all that repertoire that exists, invisible, but
- 11:42that's there, that functional repertoire. What
- 11:45you're saying is really interesting, because
- 11:47when we talk about interactions, we usually think
- 11:49only in extremes. It's either competition or
- 11:52mutualism, and that's where it tends to stop.
- 11:56But as you mentioned, there's a whole gradient
- 11:58and a dynamic process that changes over time
- 12:01depending on the resources these microorganisms
- 12:04have. Building on that idea of interactions and
- 12:07functionality, could you tell us how fungi and
- 12:10their relationships are important for sustainability
- 12:13and human health in general for our future? How
- 12:16is this knowledge being applied? I'd say there's
- 12:19enough very high -quality research showing that
- 12:21certain types of agriculture, like intensive
- 12:23tilling, excess pesticides, everything you intuitively
- 12:26believe is harmful, really is harmful to these
- 12:28types of mycorrhizal fungi. 95 % of the crops
- 12:31most consumed in the world depend highly on these
- 12:34mycorrhizal fungi. So, for example, intensive
- 12:36tilling completely destroys these networks. The
- 12:39same with pesticides, they also have harmful
- 12:41effects. So I'd say you have to maintain what
- 12:43in plant ecology is known as a positive plant
- 12:46soil feedback, and this means that the effects
- 12:48of the plant on the following generations or
- 12:50on its own future, the leaf litter a plant drops,
- 12:52the acids that roots excrete positively affect
- 12:54the same plant and the plants that come after.
- 12:56That's positive feedback, and for that positive
- 12:58feedback, these fungi are fundamental to achieving
- 13:01it and maintaining it. Positive feedback, we
- 13:04also know that conventional agriculture generates
- 13:06negative feedback, in fact, so I'd say in that
- 13:08way these fungi are fundamental, looking at it
- 13:10from the agricultural sense. Then there's another
- 13:13topic I don't handle, but that, obviously, is
- 13:15very relevant, and it's more like the culture
- 13:17and gastronomy around fungi. Without a doubt,
- 13:19they're a very important food source for many
- 13:21cultures around the world. An alternative, healthy,
- 13:24economical source. Also, for example, you mentioned
- 13:27interactions with bacteria and plants, and there
- 13:30are lichens too. I'm not sure if you work much
- 13:34with lichens, but we often see them growing on
- 13:38the trunks or the trees. They depend a lot on
- 13:42environmental conditions and exposure. If the
- 13:45air quality is good, these lichens can survive.
- 13:48Could you tell us a bit more about that whole
- 13:51network you mentioned, how it is all connected
- 13:54and how this depends on the environment? For
- 13:59example, those lichens that most people have
- 14:02seen on the trees, they often die when there's
- 14:05a lot of pollution. How does that interaction
- 14:07among plant and bacteria and fungus work? Is
- 14:11there a kind of balance maintained among... Among
- 14:14the three, is it a form of symbiosis or collaboration
- 14:18between them or how does it actually work? Yes,
- 14:22it would really be like something applied, for
- 14:24example, also continuing with what Cesar said
- 14:27about if you know what group of microorganisms,
- 14:29for example, certain bacteria that are used for
- 14:31bioremediation, contaminated soils, for example,
- 14:34there are certain strains that are more efficient
- 14:36at degrading certain compounds than others, so
- 14:39that's already biotechnology, but there are also
- 14:41microorganisms applied to a relationship in which
- 14:43you know that microorganism needs a certain metal
- 14:46or certain nutrient, and you can use it to your
- 14:48advantage to clean a place of residues. it also
- 14:51occurs to me for example everything that's done
- 14:53with what we do a little in our laboratory which
- 14:56has to do with biodiversity to know the health
- 14:58status of natural systems and compare them against
- 15:01systems as you are mentioning now contaminated
- 15:03for example we currently have a case study of
- 15:06contaminated rivers where samples are taken upstream
- 15:09when the river is still relatively clean and
- 15:11a gradient is created as waste is dumped into
- 15:13the river obviously the microbial communities
- 15:17of freshwater fungi undergo significant changes
- 15:20and well this is precisely to evaluate the types
- 15:24of microorganisms present especially to prevent
- 15:26diseases for example also in the case of agroecology
- 15:31we know that certain pests and pathogens are
- 15:33present even though they may not be causing pathogenic
- 15:35action We are aware of their presence, even if
- 15:39they do not have a pathogenic effect. So, it's
- 15:42also something applied toward disease prevention,
- 15:44right? Everything done in microbial ecology has
- 15:47numerous applications, and this is especially
- 15:50true with the latest techniques. Cesar won't
- 15:53let me lie in recent years. With new technologies,
- 15:56it's increasingly simpler to sequence, for example,
- 15:59soil samples, water samples, and be able to know
- 16:02what microorganisms inhabit there. That is, start
- 16:05to understand a bit more all this invisible world.
- 16:08Also, when we talk about soil profiles or sequencing,
- 16:11identifying what microorganisms are present,
- 16:14for instance, in soils used for monocultures,
- 16:18the profile really changes, right? These soils
- 16:21lose nutrients, and that's often why so many
- 16:25pesticides are used. So through a soil profile,
- 16:29as you mentioned, We can understand the composition
- 16:33of microorganisms and assess how healthy or degraded
- 16:37the soil is. How could this kind of applied knowledge
- 16:43help, for example, a farmer with their crops?
- 16:46How could they use this information in practice?
- 16:49Very good question. Very, very good question.
- 16:51And yes, I think it concerns me quite a bit because
- 16:53I'm somewhat or quite involved with FAO, precisely
- 16:55defining soil biodiversity indicators. Always,
- 16:58all your life, defining a biodiversity and soil
- 17:01health indicator is a very complex topic. We,
- 17:04with several colleagues, published an article
- 17:05in Science in the year 2021 on this topic called
- 17:08Essential Soil Biodiversity Variables, and there
- 17:11we had about 13 variables, root characteristics,
- 17:13population abundance, genetic diversity, microbial
- 17:16biomass, respiration and enzymatic activity,
- 17:19and, well, some others I don't remember. That's
- 17:21like a baseline we launched in science, and now
- 17:23from FAO we're making a system of, what's this
- 17:25called, categories, like a tier system that has
- 17:27category 1, 2, and 3, that we recommend to all
- 17:30the countries of the world. So this type of declaration
- 17:32is always voluntary. Countries voluntarily subscribe
- 17:35to monitor or not monitor soil biodiversity through
- 17:38these variables we recommend. Those that belong
- 17:40to category 1 are soil organic carbon, microbial
- 17:43biomass, respiration, and enzymatic activity.
- 17:45If I remember correctly, those four, whether
- 17:48they're the most representative or not, has to
- 17:49do with discussion. But it also has a lot to
- 17:51do with discussion simply what people can access
- 17:53to measure. And those four are much more feasible
- 17:56than metabarcoding, which, for example, Bernardo
- 17:58mentioned before, which for many countries continues
- 18:00to be something costly, although now the costs
- 18:02are much cheaper than 10 years ago. But sure,
- 18:05I'd say I like those. Soil organic carbon, microbial
- 18:08biomass, respiration, and enzymatic activity.
- 18:10Those four I think are okay. I think they can
- 18:13give a good indication of how a soil is, in addition
- 18:16to the classic chemical variables. Carbon, nitrogen,
- 18:19phosphorus, cations, pH. But it's always a very
- 18:22difficult topic. You can measure a hundred things
- 18:25easily on a soil, and you'd never finish describing
- 18:27the complexity of a soil. Yes, it is super interesting
- 18:31and super complex, really. Of course, what one
- 18:35seeks is to try to make everything as synthesizable
- 18:38as possible so people can use it. And well, we
- 18:41talk about things like food security, contamination
- 18:44and that. But how do you think the study of all
- 18:47this microbial world connect also with conservation,
- 18:51with mitigation or adaptation to climate change,
- 18:55which are all other pressing problems right now?
- 18:58well equally a very interesting topic because
- 19:01something that's been attempted as a national
- 19:02effort at mexico is the soil biodiversity atlas
- 19:05in which natural sites are being monitored and
- 19:08they want to see monitoring over time which is
- 19:10precisely one of the variables almost never measured
- 19:12over time that is the dynamism of systems and
- 19:17it's very interesting well and also relevant
- 19:19for food security all this is part of conservation
- 19:22In fact, if we can't compare what a conserved
- 19:25system is from a disturbed system, if we don't
- 19:28know the difference... In academia, you can view
- 19:31it from a taxonomic perspective, where researchers
- 19:34aim to describe new species up to more applied
- 19:36endeavors, such as reforestation. For example,
- 19:40integrating interactions with small fungi can
- 19:42improve seedling survival. So, there are also
- 19:45gradients of possibilities. all of conservation
- 19:49is the foundation in fact well for us in the
- 19:51biodiversity atlas it was the foundation they're
- 19:55the first points that were done which is precisely
- 19:57to see how conservation sites are and how well
- 19:59they are prospering in order to take actions
- 20:01in public policy above all generate information
- 20:05that's useful to decision -makers in government
- 20:07because one thing is what we want as taxonomists
- 20:11or as biologists another thing is really what
- 20:13people in the field need to make decisions for
- 20:16example you could decide if we need more fertilizer
- 20:19in this place or if you have already rhizobia
- 20:21this won't be necessary because when this rhizobia
- 20:23is present in the roots it will be moving so
- 20:25much nitrogen around and you can save up to fifty
- 20:28per cent of chemical fertilizer when you know
- 20:30very well how your agroecological system works
- 20:32that's a little example conservation for me is
- 20:35the foundation and we have to keep fighting for
- 20:38it What you mentioned is very important, because
- 20:42in reforestation projects, for example, people
- 20:45rarely consider the condition of the soil before
- 20:47planting. They usually just focus on the tree
- 20:51species, even after... Events like floods, fires,
- 20:55years of deforestation or extractive activities
- 20:57occur. So yes, it is crucial to take the soil
- 21:01into account in conservation efforts. Resources
- 21:04are often invested without first addressing what
- 21:07truly needs to be done with the soil. And then,
- 21:10when the trees don't grow or die, people say
- 21:13the deforestation failed. What you were explaining
- 21:17about what makes a healthy soil profile. what
- 21:21compounds, nutrients, and biodiversity it should
- 21:26have is essential. Knowing which nutrients are
- 21:30available for certain species to grow and what
- 21:33kind of organisms live in their soil, not just
- 21:36what kind of tree to plant, is key to restoring
- 21:40ecosystems effectively. Yes, I think it's a very
- 21:43exciting time to be a soil ecologist. It's a
- 21:45very beautiful career. In fact, Edward Wilson,
- 21:48in his last book, said that if he could, like,
- 21:50have a scientific career again, he'd be a soil
- 21:53ecologist because in the last 10 or 15 years,
- 21:55a large number of papers have appeared, many,
- 21:57many papers on soil macroecology, which are partly
- 21:59what have inspired things like these soil biodiversity
- 22:01atlases, both global and national. And one of
- 22:05them I remember is by Aaron Cameron from 2019,
- 22:08a nature ecology and evolution paper, showing
- 22:10there's a mismatch. There's no concordance between
- 22:12hotspots of biodiversity above ground and biodiversity
- 22:14below ground. In many regions of the world they
- 22:17coincide, but in many other regions they don't
- 22:19coincide. Here in Chile, it's the case that the
- 22:21area with the most plant diversity, or above
- 22:23ground diversity, is located in the coastal range,
- 22:26around latitude 37 degrees south more or less.
- 22:29But where there's the most below -ground diversity
- 22:30is in the southern region, and it's globally
- 22:32recorded that there's a mismatch in biodiversity
- 22:34hotspots. Of course, to declare a new protected
- 22:38area, even today, the vast majority of legislation
- 22:41and norms are based on above -ground diversity.
- 22:44So, efforts like what Bernardo is doing with
- 22:46the Biodiversity Atlas of Mexico, I would hope
- 22:48to change that discourse a bit and that logic
- 22:50in making decisions. I know one successful case
- 22:53in Estonia, but because in Estonia there are
- 22:55all these people who work a lot with what we
- 22:57do, and they did manage to declare a small protected
- 22:59area. It's a tiny country based on fungal diversity,
- 23:02for example. It's the only case I'm aware of.
- 23:05And what you're saying about reforestation is
- 23:07super important, because precisely with another
- 23:09atlas we produced this year, which I have the
- 23:11fortune of being a co -author of, is one in the
- 23:13journal Nature. We also show that only 10 % of
- 23:17mycorrhizal biodiversity hotspots globally, of
- 23:19mycorrhizal fungi, are found under a protected
- 23:21area of less than 10%, while it's 30 % for macroorganisms.
- 23:25This leads to a whole discussion on how to choose
- 23:27a protected area and a biological corridor, based
- 23:30on what metrics. I saw some of this at the last
- 23:32COP in Cali with the EO. Wilson Foundation. They've
- 23:36produced some super good maps for all countries,
- 23:38but these maps continue to be based on the numbers
- 23:40of endemic species of macroorganisms. So, the
- 23:43next step they have to do those maps, they produce
- 23:45them for all countries to say, well, if you protect
- 23:48all these zones, you reach your goal of 30 by
- 23:5030, that is, declare 30 % protected by the year
- 23:522030, but they continue ignoring soil diversity.
- 23:56Precisely talking about how there isn't so much
- 23:58regulation in the soil, I mean, there's a lot
- 24:00of regulation in the country. In Mexico, there
- 24:02is regulation regarding air quality and water.
- 24:05Well, the law is something that's written right,
- 24:08but it's another thing whether they apply it.
- 24:10But there's nothing related to soil. Nothing,
- 24:13nothing. And yes, this case of Estonia is very
- 24:16interesting, right? We'll have to see. Well,
- 24:18as they say, it's a very small place. That's
- 24:21where the experts in fungal ecology are. But
- 24:24yes, it would be something. Well, a decision
- 24:26in our favor. Information we can use in favor
- 24:29of remediating a zone or doing good reforestation.
- 24:32Basically applied knowledge. Yes, that's true.
- 24:35And something I want to bring up is if you had
- 24:38a farmer in front of you and could offer them
- 24:41tools to improve their soil or change their techniques
- 24:44beyond using pesticides, what tools or strategies
- 24:49would you suggest? And on the other hand, if
- 24:52you were advising scientists working in conservation,
- 24:55for example, in designating protective areas,
- 24:59what kinds of tools or approaches would you recommend
- 25:02to them? I've seen that things that are intuitive,
- 25:05like crop rotation, cover crops. Recently, they
- 25:07invited me to a cattle rancher's congress and
- 25:09asked me to help them understand soil management.
- 25:11They had done soil analyses. They have this rotational
- 25:14regenerative ranching. I think, for example,
- 25:17things like that work, and I liked that they're
- 25:19ranchers. They're people with many resources,
- 25:21but who have already understood this discourse
- 25:23a bit and have understood the importance of the
- 25:25soil and its biodiversity a bit. And of course,
- 25:28the central message I gave them is the same thing
- 25:30I just said a few minutes ago, to characterize
- 25:32a soil that's not one or two variables, there
- 25:34are many variables, because sometimes, especially
- 25:36if people come from classic agronomy schools,
- 25:39they stick with measuring phosphorus, measuring
- 25:41whether there is little or high phosphorus, but
- 25:43it's not that simple. So, I think that message
- 25:45was clear to them. They're doing monitoring.
- 25:48That's what's important, because many times these
- 25:50techniques appear that promise to save the world
- 25:52and suddenly you see they put a lot of money
- 25:54into, I don't know, into regenerative agriculture,
- 25:56regenerative ranching or whatever. But it works
- 25:59for a few years, but there's no long -term monitoring.
- 26:01It's the same criticism I have against carbon
- 26:03credits. It works for a decade. What happens
- 26:06in 20 years? What happens in 30 years with that
- 26:09supposedly captured carbon? So, thinking in those
- 26:12long terms, thinking for our children or our
- 26:14grandchildren still costs us as humans. But yes,
- 26:18all the intuitive techniques, being mainly crop
- 26:20rotation, is very good for any soil, living fences,
- 26:23cover crops, polycultures work. Well, there are
- 26:26two Colombians here, and I think in Mexico it's
- 26:28very similar. There are many things our grandparents
- 26:30did. My grandfather did these things. Now when
- 26:32you research it, scientifically make a lot of
- 26:34sense. When coffee is grown, in the middle of
- 26:36the coffee they put yucca, they put plantain,
- 26:38they put corn, they put beans, they put a lot
- 26:40of things. And that's how it is all the time
- 26:43most small -scale coffee in Colombia has been
- 26:44that way because coffee takes two years. So,
- 26:47you have to do something with that land in the
- 26:49meantime, and people did that for survival, not
- 26:51for any environmental discourse, but it worked
- 26:53super well. And also in the Colombian countryside,
- 26:57chicken manure is used, coffee husks are reused.
- 27:00There's a logic there that comes from much earlier
- 27:02that now if they study it at UCLA or at Stanford,
- 27:04because I've seen people from Stanford who study
- 27:06these topics. Okay, but many people, many of
- 27:10our ancestors were doing it, have done it all
- 27:11their lives. So, I like to always give those
- 27:14examples because, especially in an industry like
- 27:17Colombian coffee, where the majority continues
- 27:18to be small coffee growers and it's done nationally
- 27:21coordinated, I think it works quite well. I've
- 27:23published some studies where we calculated that
- 27:25precisely the carbon captured in coffee polycultures
- 27:28with Guama, the genus of Guama is Inga, and they
- 27:30capture almost as much as a native forest. So,
- 27:33it works very well. And what could you recommend
- 27:35to a scientist working in conservation? Lots
- 27:38of courage. Above all, perseverance. Here in
- 27:41Mexico, it's impressive there is a large amount
- 27:43of conflict of interest over land use. In fact,
- 27:46it's a whole issue, this conservation thing.
- 27:49There's something they coined as narco -conservation,
- 27:52which are those zones where nobody can enter,
- 27:54and precisely because it's so unsafe there, the
- 27:56natural system is very well conserved. And there
- 28:00are biologists who still dare to go to these
- 28:02places and say, conservation is increasing in
- 28:05these hot spots. That was in 2016, I think. around
- 28:09there they did a study where they precisely saw
- 28:11how michoacan started to see a lot of conservation
- 28:13again in zones where there was strong beeforestation
- 28:16but precisely because of the insecurity so yes
- 28:20it's a very ugly issue that actually has to do
- 28:22with a conflict of interest not only in the country
- 28:24but from outside due to the extractivism itself
- 28:27that you were saying so yes it is a complex issue
- 28:31and in fact the soil biodiversity atlas so much
- 28:34so that the points we're missing we have almost
- 28:36four hundred sites now and the points we're missing
- 28:38are the most dangerous zones the narco conserved
- 28:41zones as you could say conservation is also worth
- 28:44while especially for those who are biologists
- 28:46in the protection part of their favorite organism
- 28:48the macro -organisms are very beautiful the axolotl
- 28:52and all that part But for someone who studies
- 28:54microbes, they have to be very enamored with
- 28:57their microbes. What I'd recommend above all
- 28:59is a lot, a lot of strength, a lot of courage.
- 29:02Yes, especially in Latin America, it can become
- 29:05something not so pleasant to dedicate yourself
- 29:07to conservation. In the doctorate where I teach
- 29:10here at Santo Tomas University in Chile, the
- 29:12dean herself personally teaches a course called
- 29:14Fundraising for Conservation. That's something
- 29:16I don't know how to do. I've depended on state
- 29:19money all my life. I don't know how to knock
- 29:21on a private entity's door and have them give
- 29:22me money to do conservation. I don't know how.
- 29:25So, for new people entering this world, I'd recommend
- 29:27that they develop all those soft skills I don't
- 29:29have. I know how to compete scientifically, but
- 29:31those soft skills, no, I don't have them. And
- 29:34the truth is, with how uncertain our politicians
- 29:36and our science ministries in our countries are
- 29:38well, also in the United States, of course you
- 29:40have to look at sources other than the state,
- 29:41and that's super important to learn from the
- 29:43beginning. Exactly. We were heading in that direction
- 29:46with our next question. How has your experience
- 29:48been working in science in Latin America in general?
- 29:51Considering that this podcast is listened not
- 29:54only here in Latin America, but also in places
- 29:56like Australia and elsewhere. Could you share
- 29:58what that experience has been like for you? And
- 30:01how would you compare it with the experiences
- 30:03or collaborations you've had with research groups
- 30:07in other parts of the world? I always have an
- 30:09ambivalent or bittersweet answer to that type
- 30:11of question. I'm very happy with what I've done,
- 30:13with what I've achieved. I'm very happy, very
- 30:16satisfied was my scientific career, that I have
- 30:18no doubt about. But I also know that if I were
- 30:21somewhere else, perhaps I could do more, like
- 30:23I could cover more, could have more students,
- 30:25do more things, so I always have that ambivalence.
- 30:27But the truth is, what I've done up to now has
- 30:29been very satisfying. It's been difficult, but
- 30:32it's been very satisfying. Chile, at least the
- 30:3511 years I've been here, has been stable in its
- 30:37funding, whether there's a right -wing government
- 30:39or a left -wing government, it's been stable.
- 30:42Now, slowly, I've been getting into the internal
- 30:44workings of science. I have to evaluate projects.
- 30:47I'm part of the Chilean Academy of Sciences,
- 30:49and of course, you start to understand things
- 30:51you didn't understand before, and you also start
- 30:53to understand the problems, the problems that
- 30:55exist, which are many. Bureaucracy is one, for
- 30:58example. The bureaucracy here is insane. It's
- 31:01something I think I know many examples of. In
- 31:04fact, a Colombian who was my professor in the
- 31:06PhD, he left for New Zealand because here in
- 31:08Chile, the bureaucracy got to him. So, I think
- 31:11that's one of the detriments, and it happens
- 31:12because our governments don't have confidence
- 31:14in scientists. When you report on a project here,
- 31:18at least, I don't know how it is in Mexico, but
- 31:20here you have to keep every little paper, every
- 31:22invoice, every receipt, every single thing, absolutely
- 31:25everything. So, you spend your time, your energy,
- 31:29your resources on all this administrative and
- 31:31bureaucratic work. In other countries, it's not
- 31:34like that. I've worked with NGOs. With Spoon,
- 31:36it's super easy, so I think that's a big, big
- 31:38detriment. But in the middle of all that, I tend
- 31:41to see the positive side, and the truth is, it's
- 31:44been quite satisfying, despite being the last
- 31:46country in science investment like 0 .4%. So
- 31:49obviously everything is lacking. A lot is lacking,
- 31:52yes. And you, Bernardo? Well, very similar. In
- 31:56fact, we're very similar. Really, I also feel
- 31:59I've done well. I've been lucky, but I know that
- 32:01sadly in our country, not everyone has the same
- 32:03opportunities. There is quite a bit of inequality,
- 32:06and in science, in academia, in the academic
- 32:09part, well, I understand it has its good parts,
- 32:11its murky parts too, but the part, let's say,
- 32:14that always attracted me, the one I feel comfortable
- 32:16with, is discovering new things and trying to
- 32:18devise new solutions. I've always seen it from
- 32:21an applied point of view, so I feel we're fortunate
- 32:23because not many people have the time to be thinking
- 32:25like a scientist. There are many people who simply
- 32:29have to work 24 -7, and we who have the time
- 32:32and can try to entangle this network we call
- 32:34reality, and give it an explanation for a benefit,
- 32:36well, let's say, of our society, I see it from
- 32:39that side, like putting my grain of sand toward
- 32:42knowledge. So it's always been something that
- 32:45has guided me. It's that part of knowledge. I
- 32:48feel very comfortable with that part. i feel
- 32:50what i'm doing right now is making certain breakthroughs
- 32:53in the knowledge that exists like we're discovering
- 32:56new things that hadn't been discovered and that's
- 32:58for the benefit for example of application to
- 33:01agroecology for example i mentioned the little
- 33:04fungus that's already being implemented for reforestation
- 33:06allowing plants to survive well it's something
- 33:09that's already being done there's already very
- 33:12good work many people involved in that work are
- 33:14very good i've had the experience of collaborating
- 33:17with very good people and especially young people
- 33:20i don't want you to think i've really liked seeing
- 33:23in mexico lately these generations that are know
- 33:25-it -alls from the start and are very good at
- 33:27the scientific part they make very good insights
- 33:30and i think i'll stick with that that's really
- 33:33what i like about science and i suppose also
- 33:36in academia i have to give like precisely the
- 33:39tudor part teaching well how things are done
- 33:41explaining the theory seeing it from an applied
- 33:44point of view too explaining to students why
- 33:47this information is important for the farmer
- 33:50from a multidisciplinary point of view especially
- 33:52because we already had a stage in our country
- 33:54where a lot of science was done like it's not
- 33:57bad to ask about the immortality of the crab
- 33:59as we say doing very specific studies of something
- 34:02that well it's frontier knowledge it's excellent
- 34:04very good but given the economic situation our
- 34:07country was in i feel there had to be a more
- 34:09applied turn so that knowledge wouldn't also
- 34:12become extractivism because you also saw this
- 34:14brain drain Many brilliant minds in our country
- 34:18left, and now a reverse phenomenon is happening.
- 34:20All the people who were at other universities
- 34:22are returning, and I feel that's also something
- 34:25very good, that I'm very interested in everything
- 34:27that's happening. It's a good initiative. All
- 34:30these collaborators were making these new networks.
- 34:33I feel we are well. Obviously, we have many complaints.
- 34:37We all always complain about bureaucracy in science
- 34:40everywhere, actually. In Mexico, bureaucracy
- 34:42is everywhere, not just in science. and that's
- 34:45precisely it seeing it from the point of view
- 34:48that we're going to do things well and do the
- 34:50best possible with the information we have to
- 34:52do something good for society information for
- 34:55decision makers so they can make the best choice
- 34:57using science in our favor it's very idealistic
- 35:00but there we go yes yes because it's also complicated
- 35:04exactly i completely agree bureaucracy and in
- 35:08some cases corruption in how funds are managed
- 35:11at least speaking from Colombia's perspective,
- 35:14are definitely issues that hold things back.
- 35:17And as you said, there's often no real collaboration
- 35:20or open dialogue between scientists and the government.
- 35:24You have to prove everything, absolutely everything.
- 35:28And on top of that, there's little continuity
- 35:31in projects. I would add that as well, maintaining
- 35:36long -term projects is very difficult. But it's
- 35:40not just a problem in Latin America. I have also
- 35:44seen it in Australia, at least to some extent.
- 35:48Still, what you have done is fantastic. It's
- 35:51fascinating to look into this world of microorganisms,
- 35:54this micro -universe we rarely think about and
- 35:58realize that so much of what sustains us, like
- 36:01food, antibiotics and medicines, actually comes
- 36:05from there. We often take it for granted. as
- 36:09if these things just appear from nowhere. But
- 36:12if we don't take care of our soils, those microorganisms,
- 36:16the entire microcosm, we might end up without
- 36:20anything to eat at all. I love that we are keeping
- 36:23things on a positive note. But following up on
- 36:27that last point, what do you think are the main
- 36:30problems or weakness within the academic systems
- 36:33where most scientific work takes place? And how
- 36:37do you think young researchers could help improve
- 36:39or change these issues? Good question. There
- 36:42are many problems in academia. One that's universal,
- 36:45that's global, is how we're evaluated. In the
- 36:48recent Nobel Prizes, someone was saying on Twitter
- 36:50that the person who won the Nobel Prize in Medicine
- 36:52had an age index of 21. I have 21 and I never
- 36:56appeared in the Stanford ranking she has 35,
- 36:5840 publications. So she's someone who, under
- 37:02the current logic that manages the academic system,
- 37:04they wouldn't even consider her because she publishes
- 37:06little, is little cited, but wins a Nobel. So,
- 37:09there's a very perverse logic in how we're evaluating
- 37:12ourselves and what we consider success. And what
- 37:15does the number of publications translate to?
- 37:17That's universal and, well, that triggers many
- 37:19other problems. Journals that are very bad, there
- 37:22are journals where I get invitations that I don't
- 37:24even review. So yes, there's an incentive system
- 37:26that's a bit poorly designed. And on the other
- 37:28hand, a fear that generates a bit for me, at
- 37:30least in Latin America, in Colombia, I know they've
- 37:32already stopped funding all basic science, and
- 37:34that would be problematic because here in Chile,
- 37:36our politicians constantly talk to us about this
- 37:38issue of stopping funding basic science. All
- 37:41of us who dedicate ourselves to biodiversity
- 37:43can say goodbye. So, I also see that as a bit
- 37:46problematic. In the middle of everything, there
- 37:49are things science is still based on merit, but
- 37:51I think they're becoming fewer, unfortunately.
- 37:53It's increasingly more important to sell something
- 37:55or be very present in the news. That's always
- 37:58caused me a lot of curiosity. What you're doing
- 38:01now with this podcast, this is science communication,
- 38:03and this is what in Chile is called community
- 38:05engagement. This really is that. For our universities,
- 38:09if we take a photo because we had a meeting with
- 38:11the governor, they consider that community engagement.
- 38:13So there's also a logic that's a bit strange,
- 38:16like showing yourself a lot. And I don't know,
- 38:17I don't feel comfortable with that logic. I like
- 38:19these types of scenarios much more. Yes, that's
- 38:22very true. And what you had mentioned is extremely
- 38:25relevant. We actually had Dr. Ana Maria Cheto
- 38:29on the podcast, and she explained the whole business
- 38:32behind scientific publications and everything
- 38:34that's sadly quite dirty in the system. Because
- 38:39the real currency of prestige has become the
- 38:44impact factor and the number of papers published
- 38:47by researchers. As a result, the focus often
- 38:51shifts away from the quality of the science itself.
- 38:55And as you said, it is not only about predatory
- 38:59journals. This whole system encourages the problem
- 39:02to persist. Auditors and universities are being
- 39:06charged absurd amounts of... money to publish.
- 39:09Well, the publishing houses take all the profits,
- 39:13including money from taxpayers, and many times
- 39:16the authors don't even retain the copyright to
- 39:18their own work. It is something that needs to
- 39:21change. And in some places, I think this is slowly
- 39:25starting to. But what you mentioned about sensationalism
- 39:28also has a big impact on science. Certain topics
- 39:34become trendy. And then all the funding flows
- 39:38in that direction, for example, towards space
- 39:44research, while other urgent context -relevant
- 39:48issues are neglected. That's one of the major
- 39:52criticisms we often discuss in science. And what
- 39:56do you think, Bernardo? Yes, well, the same.
- 39:59There are many dark things in academia. starting
- 40:02with reviewers when you want to be a reviewer
- 40:05they don't pay you and you end up doing work
- 40:07that supposedly is only to have that title and
- 40:10also there are so many examples right of the
- 40:13monopoly of certain publishers that in fact there
- 40:15are already articles about that three or four
- 40:18reviews have come out about the monopoly that
- 40:20exists in academia and those who manage it I
- 40:23was actually commenting, I think, to Caesar around
- 40:25this in the book Jurassic Park, in the original
- 40:28by Michael Crichton. There's a reference to Nature
- 40:30magazine precisely talking about that topic.
- 40:33Imagine, that book is from the 90s. I think they
- 40:36call it expensive advertising or something like
- 40:38that, but the point is that already since then
- 40:40they were seeing that critical part, right? Of
- 40:43who they accept articles from, what research
- 40:45group you're in, and if you have a relationship
- 40:47with that group and you know the editor, you
- 40:49made it, right? some examples it shouldn't happen
- 40:52but there are documented cases for example peer
- 40:56review has fallen into excessive commercialism
- 40:59becoming unstoppable it's an evolutionary hypothesis
- 41:02it would be a red queen now everyone is constantly
- 41:07wanting to publish it doesn't matter what's published
- 41:09the quality doesn't matter The point is the number,
- 41:13and since resources depend on that, I think there
- 41:16the question you also asked, but I don't think
- 41:18we need to answer, is what would young people
- 41:20do? The new scientists. It's precisely to try
- 41:24to change that scheme. We already know that's
- 41:26going to increase inequality. Yes, we already
- 41:29saw that's going to suffocate the scientific
- 41:31method we adore so much. Well, almost. We have
- 41:34it there like it's a Bible, but really it's a
- 41:36matter of common sense. these groups that have
- 41:39already formed to control academic research it's
- 41:41very difficult to try to remove them i don't
- 41:44know how we're going to get there There would
- 41:46have to be a revolution of academics internally
- 41:48from below, which is basically what we see with
- 41:51Sci -Hub, this Ukrainian who started putting
- 41:53out free publications precisely because of the
- 41:55academic need in other countries that can't afford
- 41:57to pay those exorbitant prices. Yes, of course.
- 42:00It's part of what can be done. And, well, there
- 42:03are those who dare and manage from those more
- 42:06eastern side of the planet to set up their pirate
- 42:09publication servers. Another issue that comes
- 42:12up recently is copyright in the context of artificial
- 42:15intelligence. Many people are using AI not just
- 42:18as a tool, but for everything. So it becomes
- 42:22difficult to determine or verify who actually
- 42:25wrote what. And that's where it really comes
- 42:29down to the ethics of each scientist or author.
- 42:33But we are more or less heading in that direction.
- 42:37Thank you very much, Bernardo and César. It has
- 42:40been a pleasure having you here on the program.
- 42:43Thanks for sharing all your knowledge and for
- 42:45being here. Thank you very much for doing this.
- 42:47Thank you so much. Pillars of life. And the planet's
- 43:10health depends on them. Beneath our feet exists
- 43:13a universe that breathes, communicates and cooperates.
- 43:16And understanding it is also understanding ourselves.
- 43:20Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating the Human
- 43:22Side is an independent podcast created and hosted
- 43:25by Linda Hernández and Daniel Esguerra with the
- 43:27invaluable support of our dedicated technical
- 43:29director Rafael Giordano and original music by
- 43:32our colleague and today's guest Bernardo Águila.
- 43:35Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, TikTok
- 43:38and visit our website for more stories, updates
- 43:41and resources. Don't forget to subscribe and
- 43:44share this podcast with your friends and communities
- 43:46to amplify these essential narratives together.
- 43:48And if this post podcast inspired you consider
- 43:51supporting us with a contribution through paypal
- 43:54you just have to click the support us button
- 43:56on our website as this contribution helps to
- 43:59continue this project and keep growing