Latest / FlavorScience from FlavorSum / Seasonal Flavors: Beyond the Calendar to Cultural Moments
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Flavor Science from FlavorSum, where
- 0:02we explore the decisions and real -world challenges
- 0:05shaping food and beverage development. I'm your
- 0:08host, Lisa Jackson. Today, we're examining how
- 0:11seasonal flavors are expanding beyond traditional
- 0:14calendar dates to cultural moments. Joining me
- 0:17to discuss what's changing is Phil a'Beckett,
- 0:20Senior Consumer Insights Manager at FlavorSum.
- 0:23Phil, thanks for returning to the show. Absolutely
- 0:25happy to be here and happy to be discussing something
- 0:28that's near and dear to my heart, seasonal flavors.
- 0:31They are a lot of fun, aren't they? They are.
- 0:33I want us to start by talking a little bit about
- 0:36why seasonal flavors continue to be an effective
- 0:39strategy. And what comes to mind is, of course,
- 0:41pumpkin spice. It is practically its own season.
- 0:44And peppermint is another tried and true that
- 0:47really signals the holidays. So from your perspective,
- 0:50why do brands continue to offer these? Put simply,
- 0:54they see success with them. Seasonal flavors
- 0:56are one of the most reliable ways to encourage
- 0:58trial, support repeat purchase. And then there's
- 1:02a bit of refreshing of shelf offers that comes
- 1:06into play. So a lot of people look forward to
- 1:10pumpkin spice season, as you mentioned it. And
- 1:13what we've discovered, not just here at FlavorSum,
- 1:16but just industry wide, is that seasonal flavors,
- 1:19seasonal offerings, LTOs, these type of products
- 1:24still influence shoppers. According to research
- 1:27from INOVA, one in five North Americans agree
- 1:30that seasonal or LTO offerings influence their
- 1:34food and drink choices. So when you have 20 %
- 1:36of the population saying, this is something that
- 1:38I'm looking forward to, it is a big driver within
- 1:43food and beverage. That's quite an incremental
- 1:45lift in any given month or season. Makes sense.
- 1:49But seasonal flavors They also help us mark time,
- 1:52don't they? Like apple cider signals the arrival
- 1:55of fall, much like pumpkin spice. And then s'mores
- 1:58is versatile. Sometimes it's a spring or maybe
- 2:01a summer evening around a campfire. Is there
- 2:04something that's particularly appealing about
- 2:06these familiar flavor traditions? Oh, yeah, absolutely.
- 2:10At the core of it, these types of flavors, whether
- 2:12it's apple cider for fall, s'mores for spring
- 2:14or summer, these really are temporal landmarks.
- 2:20Without thinking about it, people know that pumpkin
- 2:24spice equals fall. If they have it in the spring,
- 2:28if they choose to have it in the spring, that's
- 2:29one thing. But if they're forced to have it in
- 2:31the spring, that would be a big disconnect with
- 2:34what they've come to expect and what those flavors
- 2:37cue up in their minds. There's also a bit of
- 2:40ritual and belonging that comes into play. Pumpkin
- 2:43spice, we're going to keep harping on pumpkin
- 2:45spice. That's OK. There's a bit of ritual and
- 2:48belonging okay it's it's October it's September's
- 2:50October's November, we're all having pumpkin spice
- 2:53it's sort of a shared experience uh that oh my
- 2:56gosh it's it's it's here or the McDonald's um
- 3:00oh the shamrock shake yes yeah the shamrock shake
- 3:02around Saint Patrick's Day, you mentioned mint
- 3:05earlier, peppermint earlier. That's a perfect example
- 3:08of it doesn't really fit with the season but
- 3:11it fits with the holiday So there is the shared
- 3:16sort of tradition. And then the final thing is
- 3:20a little more psychological, but it induces artificial
- 3:23scarcity and fear of missing out. If I don't
- 3:26get this now, I'm going to have to wait an entire
- 3:28year to have this. So I better get it while it's
- 3:31available. That limited time offer, yes. And
- 3:35it seems like nostalgia also plays into the appeal
- 3:38of seasonal flavors. So you've got the angle
- 3:42of nostalgia with something I look forward to
- 3:44every year. But then I've also seen recently
- 3:46some brands are doing a seasonal item that seems
- 3:49entirely new. So how much of the appeal of a
- 3:53seasonal item comes from the familiarity versus
- 3:55this idea of novelty? Yeah, that pulls that
- 3:59touches on something that I like to call flavor
- 4:02risk mitigation, very scientific sounding. Really
- 4:06what this means is combining something familiar,
- 4:09whether it's a seasonal or just something that's
- 4:11nostalgic from your childhood, but that familiarity
- 4:14with something unique. So it reduces the risk
- 4:18that I'm not going to like this unique thing,
- 4:20because I know I like caramel. I'll try the miso
- 4:23caramel sauce or syrup in my coffee. So it sort
- 4:29of is that risk mitigation. I know I like this
- 4:32caramel. I'll try this miso. If I don't like it,
- 4:34it's a low cost barrier to entry in order to
- 4:38try something new. I'm not buying a 12 pack of
- 4:40this necessarily. I might be buying a single
- 4:42can or a single small coffee at a coffee shop
- 4:46that has this syrup. So that's how you can sort
- 4:48of combine that nostalgic with that novelty.
- 4:53I've seen food service really get behind that.
- 4:55So I was thinking... particularly with this idea
- 4:57of lemonade. You see mango lemonade and kiwi
- 5:00lemonade. So I know lemonade and now it's got
- 5:03a familiar twist on it. And then I've also noticed
- 5:08that sometimes social media can influence the
- 5:11balance. So can you talk a little bit about that
- 5:13effect? Yeah, absolutely. The Instagram effect.
- 5:17Food and drink that is meant to be photographed
- 5:19before it's meant to be consumed. That is definitely
- 5:22a core strategy that a lot of brands, even if
- 5:28they don't actively pursue it, they expect that,
- 5:30you know, this is going to happen. I'm thinking
- 5:33of the Starbucks unicorn. Oh, yeah, that was
- 5:35a big one from, I don't know, was it eight, nine
- 5:37years ago with all the colors and the swirls.
- 5:40And I do know that all of the baristas hated
- 5:42making it because it was very complicated. I
- 5:44saw a lot of posts. But it drove a lot of trial
- 5:48into the stores and maybe people buy the unicorn
- 5:50once, but then they're back into the I'm going
- 5:53there several times a week to get my regular
- 5:56coffee. Yeah, definitely heightened brand awareness.
- 5:58And so we know that these seasonal offerings
- 6:00clearly generate attention, trial. But for product
- 6:05developers, there could be another potential
- 6:07benefit. So maybe identifying flavors with staying
- 6:10power. Have you seen anything like that? Oh,
- 6:13for sure. So LTOs and seasonal offerings, while
- 6:17they are a big lift for brands, especially if
- 6:20they're going national, it's a lot of work to
- 6:22get something out for three or four months out
- 6:23of the year. What it can do is really identify
- 6:27flavors that become portfolio mainstays. So it's
- 6:30really a good effective test bed, where in the
- 6:34scheme of things, it's relatively low cost. Even
- 6:36though it's high effort to put out a seasonal,
- 6:38you might discover, oh my gosh, we never really
- 6:41thought this flavor combination would take off.
- 6:43But suddenly, swicy is our new brand identity.
- 6:47One that I'm thinking of right off the bat is
- 6:50it was Red Bull's winter edition last year, maybe
- 6:54two years ago, it was the Fuji apple and ginger
- 6:57that did extraordinarily well. And from what
- 7:00I've read, they've made that just a standard
- 7:02core flavor now. So it's no longer winter. It's
- 7:05now just available year round. Well, you go through
- 7:08all that effort. You do your little test market
- 7:09as a seasonal and then you have predictable performance
- 7:14potentially. Absolutely. I think this is more
- 7:17common in retail versus food service. I'm thinking
- 7:21of Chick -fil -A has their hot honey, pimento,
- 7:25chicken sandwich. That drives a lot of excitement.
- 7:28I don't see it in the stores anymore. Of course,
- 7:31then it's in their bag of tricks. They can always
- 7:34pull it back out a few years later. McDonald's
- 7:37does this very well with the McRib. I also saw
- 7:39that McDonald's was considering keeping the mango
- 7:42refresher as a full -time item. I don't know
- 7:44if that's going to come to fruition, but I thought
- 7:46I read an article about that. I wouldn't be surprised.
- 7:49That is very, very popular, especially with younger
- 7:51generations. So as they're trying to bring in
- 7:55a new generation to now that they're making money,
- 7:59they have careers. They're no longer begging
- 8:03mom and dad to go get a Happy Meal. It's something
- 8:06for them to go in and say, this is a little more
- 8:07adult. This is no longer just me as a kid with
- 8:11my chicken nuggets and my Happy Meal toy. But
- 8:13this is a very delicious beverage that I can
- 8:16carry around for an hour and just sip on. OK,
- 8:19makes sense. So we've been talking about seasonal
- 8:22flavors associated with fall, winter, spring,
- 8:25summer, but as we've been kind of segueing the
- 8:28conversation, it seems like the occasion might
- 8:30matter more than the calendar. When did seasonal
- 8:33start meaning more than a season? I'm going to
- 8:37say that the seasonal means more than just a
- 8:40season really started to ramp up with the increase
- 8:43in social media, where brands no longer had to
- 8:48do traditional advertising, so it became much
- 8:50less expensive to promote this item. And what
- 8:56we've seen that evolve into is that seasonality
- 8:58is no longer attached to these seasons, but they're
- 9:01attached to cultural seasons or cultural events.
- 9:06A big one this year was America 250, prime example.
- 9:11We all know rocket pops or bomb pops, the red,
- 9:13white and blue popsicle type products. I can't
- 9:17tell you how many items I saw that were rocket
- 9:20pop flavored that were totally in congruence
- 9:23with the flavor, but it seemed to work. It drew
- 9:26in the attention that brands were seeking. Well,
- 9:30and to your point earlier, it kind of made that
- 9:32subconscious link for people. We're talking about
- 9:34America 250, red, white and blue, right? There
- 9:36was that immediate connection to have it make
- 9:40sense to them. Absolutely. And I can't say that
- 9:44I saw a yogurt that was rocket pop, but I can
- 9:46imagine a mom or a dad saying to their son or
- 9:50daughter, but the yogurt, it's the rocket pop.
- 9:54It's red, white, and blue for 4th of July. And
- 9:56then the kids would go, oh, you're right, and
- 9:58happily eat yogurt, even if they don't typically
- 10:00eat yogurt. Right. And in America, it actually
- 10:02extends from Memorial Day to 4th of July, because
- 10:05you've got that red, white, and blue curtain
- 10:06that runs across several months. Correct. As
- 10:09brands are becoming more intentional about this
- 10:12connection between flavor and cultural moments,
- 10:16I guess give us some other examples of where
- 10:18that's happening, because it does seem to be
- 10:20happening more frequently. Yeah, so this is where
- 10:23you sort of expand a little bit beyond necessarily
- 10:25just cultural events, but also cross -industry
- 10:28tie -ins and collaborations. So this is still
- 10:32a cultural event, but the World Cup this year
- 10:34impacted a lot of flavors. potato chips from
- 10:39Lay's, different Powerade drinks that had sort
- 10:41of an international flair. Connecting to movies,
- 10:45so a cultural event could be a big movie release.
- 10:48Takis, you know, the really hot, spicy tortilla
- 10:51chips that stain everything red. They had a lot
- 10:56of Wicked for Good themed varieties. A couple
- 10:59of these, there's Emerald Heat, which was habanero
- 11:02cucumber, and then Spellbindingly Sweet, which
- 11:06was cinnamon sugar. So going outside, some of
- 11:10these are going outside of their core sort of
- 11:12flavor profiles where Takis are associated with
- 11:14heat, but then a cinnamon sugar, and it really
- 11:17just pushes the bounds of what this format can
- 11:19do. The other one I can think of is Mountain
- 11:22Dew has been very, very successful leveraging
- 11:26partnerships with big video game releases or
- 11:28the e -sports world, targeting gamers and that
- 11:31younger generation. I think, too, you were talking
- 11:34about movies. Barbie was another one that we
- 11:36saw. Yes. A lot of tie -ins with that Barbie
- 11:38movie. But some of these seem pretty far removed
- 11:41from what we've been talking about in terms of
- 11:43traditional seasonal flavor development. So what
- 11:46makes the cultural or entertainment partnership
- 11:49feel authentic rather than just a promotion?
- 11:52Does the flavor need to connect or is the association
- 11:55enough to generate interest? Yeah, this is where
- 11:58we start to blur the lines between seasonal you
- 12:01know, strict seasonal and then strict LTOs or
- 12:04limited time offers. And so there is, as we've
- 12:07seen across food and beverage, a lot of blurring
- 12:09of the lines, whether it's category or what we
- 12:12call something or flavor blends. In order to
- 12:17make a partnership feel authentic rather than
- 12:20promotional or forced, it needs to make sense.
- 12:24So Toy Story 5 came out last, was it this year?
- 12:27I think it was this year. Yeah. And so if you
- 12:31had kids products that were Toy Story themed,
- 12:33it makes perfect sense. If you had a ready to
- 12:39drink alcohol cocktail that had Buzz Lightyear
- 12:41on it, that would be a massive disconnect. That
- 12:43sounds a little fun, but I get your point. I'm
- 12:46sure the flavor profile would be great, you know,
- 12:50Buzz Lightyear's Lychee galaxy, whatever it
- 12:53might be. But it would not. It would be very
- 12:55weird to have that children's character on an
- 12:58adult beverage. OK, so you really need to align
- 13:01to the audience that you're that you're targeting.
- 13:04The other thing, too, is really understanding
- 13:09whether this is going to be culturally relevant.
- 13:11So I'm just going to stick with movies. If there's
- 13:15an indie movie coming out, what was the big one
- 13:19that came out this year? There's Back Rooms and
- 13:22Obsession, sort of horror type movies. There's
- 13:25not a franchise. You don't know if they're going
- 13:27to be culturally relevant or not. So maybe don't
- 13:30license that. But then you get something like
- 13:33Toy Story 5. It's a known entity. You know it's
- 13:36going to be big. And so there's a lot of licensing
- 13:39opportunities there to cross collaborate, create
- 13:42LTO flavors to really sort of draw in the attention
- 13:46of people. OK. So that idea of relevance also
- 13:50gets you into the concept of magnitude. So there
- 13:53may be people that were really fans of some of
- 13:56those genres, but they're a niche. And so doing
- 13:59an LTO is really going to be nonproductive. OK.
- 14:02All right. And maybe less authentic. Yeah. And
- 14:05of course, that does open the door for some smaller
- 14:07brands or there's more niche brands to then to
- 14:11maybe take that risk. You know, thinking of Obsession,
- 14:14maybe Liquid Death would have been a great just
- 14:17because of the brand name and sort of what they're
- 14:19cultivating would have been a perfect tie in.
- 14:21But you wouldn't you didn't know that it was
- 14:23going to be that big of a hit at theaters. So
- 14:26I don't think you would have, I don't think anybody
- 14:29would have said we're going to do this necessarily,
- 14:32but it would have been a home run, you know.
- 14:35It would have actually absolutely been a grand
- 14:37slam. It has relevance. I gotcha. So it sounds
- 14:39like there's a lot more opportunities to create
- 14:41limited time offer offerings. But is there a
- 14:45risk that brands could dilute the excitement?
- 14:48We talked about pumpkin spice early in the conversation,
- 14:50but I saw something there's actually pumpkin
- 14:52spice kitty litter. I think that could be a different
- 14:55story. We're not in the fragrance business, but
- 15:00I can only imagine that might not turn out too
- 15:02well. I don't think the cat would appreciate
- 15:04it. So I guess talk a little bit about that idea
- 15:07of dilution. Yeah, this is and pumpkin spice
- 15:12is sort of the perfect example. It's been around
- 15:14for 20 plus years. We have a term for pumpkin
- 15:16spice season. It's ubiquitous at this point.
- 15:19So if you come out with a pumpkin spice tortilla
- 15:22chip, it's not going to generate the buzz that
- 15:26it might have 18 years ago. So there is this
- 15:31idea of saturation. And saturation is not necessarily,
- 15:35oh, everybody's doing seasonal. We shouldn't.
- 15:38It's you need to be unique and do something that
- 15:41stands out. So you're not just, you know, a face
- 15:45amongst the crowd with pumpkin spice as we keep
- 15:49going back to it. Well, because there's flavor
- 15:50fatigue at some point, right? People get tired
- 15:53of seeing every type of food or drink that they
- 15:55have. Yeah. Yeah. And then and then to your point,
- 15:59it doesn't really fit with tortilla chips, does
- 16:01it? I wouldn't think so. I'm also not a Pumpkin
- 16:05Spice fan, personally. I much prefer carrot cake
- 16:08or gingerbread, which are very similar profiles,
- 16:10which is a way a brand could go to differentiate
- 16:13themselves from Pumpkin Spice, is to find a similar
- 16:15profile that has the same connotations to that
- 16:18season, but is different enough where people
- 16:21go, oh, finally, not the same old thing. Right,
- 16:25right. And going down the path that you just
- 16:27mentioned, apple cider, gingerbread, that link
- 16:32between the season and the flavor is more likely
- 16:35to induce repeat purchase when it fits the category.
- 16:40So if I buy, the easy one is, you know, a gingerbread
- 16:44donut, then I might go back and hope that I get
- 16:48it before it runs out because I'm going to try.
- 16:50I liked it. It made sense versus say, oh, it
- 16:53would be, I don't know, a gingerbread flavored
- 16:56water. That might be a stretch. I might try it
- 17:00once, but maybe not twice. Many many years ago
- 17:04I had a gingerbread beer in July. It was so incongruous
- 17:08to my brain. I couldn't, I couldn't, I had two
- 17:10sips of the beer and said I can't have any more
- 17:12of this. Yep, yep, I understand. So as brands
- 17:16look ahead to 2027, thinking about everything
- 17:21we've talked about this morning, what should
- 17:22they consider when they're deciding which cultural
- 17:26moments deserve a place in the seasonal innovation
- 17:29plan? There's two tacks to take on this. One
- 17:34is follow the success. McDonald's with their
- 17:38McFlurry, they sort of own St. Patrick's Day
- 17:41and that. But is there something you can do as
- 17:44a brand to leverage that excitement? And so you're
- 17:47sort of on the coattails a little bit. The other
- 17:51way to go is what's a holiday that nobody uses?
- 17:56This one's a little riskier. and most holidays
- 18:00do have something around them, but I'm thinking
- 18:02like Flag Day. Nobody really does much for Flag
- 18:05Day. It's a perfect lead into between, it's between
- 18:09Memorial Day and Fourth of July. It's right in
- 18:12that season, so that's probably why nobody does
- 18:13something for Flag Day. But Labor Day, you know,
- 18:17it's always a three -day weekend. The furniture
- 18:20stores certainly do quite a bit of sales. They
- 18:23do. But there's not a lot of food around it.
- 18:26And I don't have an answer of how you might do
- 18:28that, but just look for some of those other holidays
- 18:31that aren't associated with seasonal food, seasonal
- 18:36beverage, and maybe leverage something from there.
- 18:39But then also, of course, cultural events. We
- 18:43have the Olympics in 2028. Everybody is spinning
- 18:46up for the Olympics. So I don't pretend to believe
- 18:52that there won't be a lot of Olympic -themed
- 18:55Seasonals and LTOs coming out. But what other
- 18:58cultural events? Big movie releases? Big video
- 19:02games? Everybody's talking about GTA 6 is coming
- 19:04out in a few weeks. I have yet to see any GTA
- 19:086 themed products. It's probably way too late
- 19:11to put that out. But what other big video games
- 19:14are coming out that could be licensed or leveraged?
- 19:19OK. You mentioned events and I remember seeing
- 19:22an article in the paper where I don't know the
- 19:25beverage brand - see, I didn't make that brand connection,
- 19:27but it was at the the tennis the tennis championships
- 19:32in New York. There was some sort of very bright
- 19:35green drink that came with something that almost
- 19:37looked like a tennis ball and all around
- 19:39the area the of the venue event you saw all
- 19:43these people with green drinks and that immediately
- 19:45led people to say where did you get that? I want
- 19:47to try that. You know I don't know that they'll
- 19:50bring it back, but they probably sold quite a
- 19:52few of them. Yeah, and that's a perfect example
- 19:57of, it has to taste good, but it's also designed
- 19:59for the visual. It has to look good. So when
- 20:01you see it on TV, you see it in people's photos,
- 20:04you see it on their Instagram stories. They go,
- 20:08whoa, is that a tennis racket filled with...
- 20:11a drink or whatever it looked like. Yeah, right.
- 20:14That makes sense. But from our discussion, it
- 20:16seems like a key takeaway is that traditional
- 20:18seasonal flavors are not going away. Is that
- 20:22a fair statement? That is a very fair statement.
- 20:25They do everything we've discussed. They still
- 20:29operate on human psychology pretty much the same
- 20:31way. OK, so it does, though, from our commentary,
- 20:35seems like it's OK to think beyond it, but don't
- 20:37completely abandon it. Yes, yes. And like we
- 20:42mentioned earlier, sort of that flavor risk mitigation,
- 20:45what can you do? A gingerbread cheesecake for
- 20:48the holiday season? So it's still that flavor,
- 20:51but it's in a slightly different format. Maybe
- 20:54people don't like gingerbread because they think
- 20:56it's too dry. Put it into a cheesecake, suddenly
- 20:58you open up a new audience. Makes sense. Well,
- 21:01Phil, thanks very much for sharing your insights
- 21:03today. And for our listeners, please watch for
- 21:06FlavorSum's upcoming 2027 Seasonal Flavor Guide.
- 21:10That's where we examine the flavors shaping seasonal
- 21:13innovation in the year ahead. Do you want to
- 21:15talk a little bit more about that, Phil? Sure.
- 21:18This will be, I believe it's our fifth annual
- 21:20Seasonal Flavor Guide. What it does, it looks
- 21:23at the past five years of launch data and associates
- 21:26flavors with spring and summer or fall and winter.
- 21:30and we rank them and identify new flavors that
- 21:34have entered into the seasonal launch calendar.
- 21:38So a lot of the flavors might seem familiar,
- 21:40but you'll see the prioritization in how brands
- 21:44are shifting towards some new seasonal flavors.
- 21:47We also look at social listening to identify
- 21:49some up and coming flavors. And over the past
- 21:54four or five years, we've actually identified,
- 21:56I'm going to say, about 25 flavors that were
- 21:59not in the top 10 seasonal flavors that have
- 22:01now moved into that launch calendar. So this
- 22:05becomes a predictive tool as well as one that
- 22:08gives an idea of what's currently happening.
- 22:10Yes, I will say predictive tool and not crystal
- 22:13ball. Oh, yeah, no, we don't have those. Well,
- 22:15again, thank you. And to our listeners, look
- 22:19for our next podcast to come out in early November.
- 22:23There we'll be talking about the cultural shifts
- 22:27that are happening in North America and the extent
- 22:29to which flavor can help create experiences that
- 22:32will connect and address some of those needs.
- 22:35So thanks again. Thank you everybody.