Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Breaking Down the AT Guidance and NETP: Bridging Digital Divides
Transcript
- 2:02Today. We're going to go ahead and dive into a discussion surrounding the AT
- 2:06guidance that was released alongside the NETP.
- 2:09So super excited to have you all today.
- 2:11Great to be here. Thanks for having me. Very excited. To set the scene back
- 2:16in March, we co-hosted a webinar with Jisoo from the OET and a few others who
- 2:22contributed to the development of the NETP.
- 2:25And he really gave us some great background on the NETP and the three digital
- 2:30divides, use, access, and design.
- 2:33Zach, I was hoping if you can give some background on how the AT guidance relates to the NETP.
- 2:40Sure. I'd love to. The NETP is, and always has been since its first release
- 2:45in 1996, a vision document for the country.
- 2:48The federal government has a unique perspective on being able to kind of survey
- 2:52the entirety of the country.
- 2:54And so its release in January was saying there's a bit of a reset for the vision of ed tech.
- 2:59We also know that with that new vision come a lot of questions.
- 3:03And so this AT guidance, we feel, is a really good fit for folks who read and
- 3:09see the call for accessibility for UDL and for a more thoughtful procurement
- 3:15process around assistive technology.
- 3:17This guidance is a natural fit to help folks say, we see that vision in the
- 3:21NETP, and this can help them move into some practical applications of that vision.
- 3:29Awesome. Yeah, thank you so much for that. You can definitely see how alongside
- 3:33the two kind of concoct the perfect set of guidance for educators.
- 3:38That's the hope, at least. Yeah, yeah, definitely. So, you know,
- 3:42on that, I'd love to know a little bit more about how this guidance is being
- 3:47communicated to teachers, service providers, and caregivers. givers?
- 3:52Definitely. So we here at the U.S. Department of Education have worked with
- 3:57various stakeholders and partners to disseminate this guidance broadly.
- 4:01We've been specifically targeting state, district, and school leaders,
- 4:06as well as educators, specialists,
- 4:09people working in educator prep programs, and families, as well as students
- 4:14as the people that we want to make sure are aware of this guidance and the valuable
- 4:19information that it includes.
- 4:21We are very fortunate in that many organizations who represent these stakeholders
- 4:26have worked with us to not only share this information broadly,
- 4:31but also to adjust their existing resources and planned resources,
- 4:36so any materials that they've developed, or to develop new materials and provide
- 4:41training that support the information further.
- 4:45And I could just add to that, Jackie, that at CITES, this is Christine,
- 4:49at CITES, we have been excited to be able to support over time.
- 4:54This is our second round of funding from OSEP, the Office of Special Education
- 4:57Programs, inclusive technology systems.
- 5:00So this AT guidance really complements that work where our primary audience
- 5:06are district leaders, but across the spectrum.
- 5:09So from ed tech and IT to assistive technology and special education,
- 5:13coming from the ed tech and IT background and for the bulk of my career,
- 5:18this guidance is so critical for the audience that's not in the special education realm,
- 5:24especially because there are terms that we're sharing in very concrete ways
- 5:28and truly dismissing those myths that seem to be barriers and opening up the audience.
- 5:35And so CITES has created a variety of resources for different audiences that
- 5:40we're pushing out across the country.
- 5:42That is very helpful information. Thank you so much. You're teeing up my next question here.
- 5:48Is there anyone, you know, who might not be aware of this guidance that should be?
- 5:53So somebody not in that, you know, group that I named teachers,
- 5:56caregivers, kind of outside that realm of direct interaction with students?
- 6:00Well, I would like to add to what Christine talked about, right?
- 6:03So kind of the primary group that we wanted to make sure was aware of it were
- 6:07educators and specifically general educators, because they're not always part
- 6:13of the decision-making process when it comes to assistive technology for children with disabilities.
- 6:18Disabilities but with that
- 6:21we also want to make sure that family members and the
- 6:23children themselves the students themselves are aware
- 6:27not only the requirement around assistive technology within the individuals
- 6:31with disabilities education act or IDEA but the opportunity to have these conversations
- 6:37on at least an annual basis as part of an IEP or an IFSP for our children who
- 6:44are birth through three.
- 6:46What I think is really important, though,
- 6:49is this partnership that we've developed that is between OSERS and the Office
- 6:56of EdTech to really look at how is it that we can work together to layer the
- 7:02resources and the guidance that benefit all children.
- 7:05So how do we really address those divides and look at equitable access and the use of technology,
- 7:13technology including assistive technology for children with disabilities to
- 7:17show them how to learn how to engage and learn and how to demonstrate their
- 7:22learning in the most effective and efficient way possible.
- 7:26Thank you. Can you speak a little bit more to the impetus for issuing this guidance?
- 7:32You know, what were you seeing in the field that made this resource necessary?
- 7:35What was the real need and thought process behind?
- 7:39Why now? Well, I mean, why now is because the NETP was being revised,
- 7:46and we really saw that as a great opportunity to proactively look and address
- 7:52the needs of diverse students on the front end,
- 7:55right, as we were developing the tools and the resources.
- 7:58But I also think that the AT myths and facts speak specifically to what we're
- 8:05seeing and the questions that we're hearing from educators and families.
- 8:09So while the AT requirements have been within the IDEA for decades,
- 8:15and I mean literally decades.
- 8:17The rapid pace and availability of technology has shifted how we view it as
- 8:22well as the availability and the accessibility.
- 8:25Disability, and those tools have made it more adaptable to meet a variety of needs.
- 8:31So that revision and the update of the National Ed Tech Plan,
- 8:35which included the needs of children and students with disabilities on the front
- 8:40end, provided us that great opportunity to work together across the department
- 8:45on behalf of all students.
- 8:47So while the AT guidance, the myths and and facts document is specific to the
- 8:52requirements of IDEA, that doesn't mean that people are prohibited from using
- 8:57that guidance to benefit more students than students with disabilities,
- 9:02or using the built-in accessibility features and tools of technology to support
- 9:09the learning of all students.
- 9:10We really see these as going hand-in-hand to benefit everyone.
- 9:15I couldn't agree more. I think, you know, accessibility for one really is accessibility
- 9:21for all. So thank you for that.
- 9:24What would you say, and anyone can feel free to jump in here,
- 9:28what would you say is the biggest roadblock for ensuring students with disabilities
- 9:31have access to technology and two-parter, and how can we leverage our organizations
- 9:38to support students through these challenges.
- 9:41We have a lot of nonprofit organizations that listen in to our podcasts,
- 9:46and I'm sure we'll be pulling some information away from this.
- 9:50I'm going to say a couple of pieces, and we've kind of danced around it a little bit here.
- 9:54But one of the things that is a barrier is the thinking that this is a document
- 9:58that should be read by an individual.
- 10:01This document is prep work for folks who are about to go into a faculty meeting.
- 10:08This isn't a document that is for your gen ed teacher or your special education
- 10:11teacher or your assistive technology coordinator.
- 10:14This is one to say, hey, we all need to know about this. I might be the only
- 10:18one in this conversation whose background is just in a general education program, right?
- 10:23And so I had my one class on special education as part of my program, and that was it.
- 10:28So as we were drafting these documents and as I was going through,
- 10:30there was a lot of learning that was going on.
- 10:32We were modeling the removal of those silo barriers between our two offices.
- 10:36And I think that's, that's the piece, right? Is the, it isn't just one person reading this thing.
- 10:42It is everyone reading this document and then having the conversation for what
- 10:47that, what that means for themselves and what that can look like practically.
- 10:51And what those organizations can do is start to build some guidance around what
- 10:55it means to, to make sure a system is only buying things that meet a minimum
- 11:00expectation of accessibility ability and assistive tech, right?
- 11:05So how are we making sure that it isn't just the classroom teacher that is having
- 11:08this conversation, the special education teacher or the gen ed teacher,
- 11:12not the classroom teacher, or that this isn't just a piece for the procurement
- 11:16office, but that all of these folks are working together,
- 11:19right? And so that kind of guidance is new.
- 11:21It really is saying we all have a hand in making sure this is happening.
- 11:25I know Christine could probably give a bunch of examples of folks in the districts
- 11:29that CITES is working with where they have moved that assistive technology piece
- 11:34into procurement and they have set baseline standards for what can be brought in.
- 11:38And so I think that's the big piece. So making sure that this is everybody's,
- 11:43everybody's reading it and then having a conversation about what the implication
- 11:47is and then solving that barrier to say,
- 11:50we can't keep losing time for kids and teachers because we didn't think about
- 11:55this as we were buying things.
- 11:57Yes, I will piggyback to that, Zach. And it reminds me of a tagline for CAST
- 12:01podcast, which is accessibility is everyone's responsibility.
- 12:05So that kind of ties in sites as a framework for bringing inclusive practices,
- 12:10as I mentioned at the beginning.
- 12:12And as part of the dissemination support, we have been creating resources that
- 12:17I think one group we haven't talked about is the suppliers, right,
- 12:21the K-12 companies that are supporting districts.
- 12:24I think they, you know, there's an important factor to educate all of them and
- 12:29share the myths and facts so they understand not only the law,
- 12:33but the why and how everyone should be included.
- 12:37So some of the resources that we developed include graphics,
- 12:41really simple graphics, one myth and fact, they're organized by topic.
- 12:46And we're going to publish in the coming weeks, principal version.
- 12:50So to Zach's point about a faculty meeting, let's have cards around the table.
- 12:54Let's really talk about this.
- 12:55And then a digital version of, you know, for a game as well,
- 12:59because it is a lot of information and different parts are more pertinent to
- 13:05certain individuals, but the whole system really needs to understand.
- 13:08So we're doing everything we can to get the word out across different audiences.
- 13:13And another thing I wanted to add when you talk about the organizations coming
- 13:16from a background of working in other nonprofit membership organizations is
- 13:21the organizations should be modeling accessibility.
- 13:24And I think that's a journey that they're taking now that they're just not always aware of.
- 13:29So organizations themselves publishing accessible documents,
- 13:33making sure their webinars and podcasts are accessible is another way that they
- 13:38can walk the walk as they're sharing with their members or constituents.
- 13:43And building on that, Christine, and a piece that maybe isn't exactly what we're
- 13:48talking about here, but I think is an important offshoot is when they do that,
- 13:51the teaching force becomes more accessible, right?
- 13:55Then we are inviting more people into teaching who maybe thought that Because
- 13:59of these inaccessible barriers and boundaries that have been built into our
- 14:02tech expectations, the threshold for becoming a teacher was too difficult.
- 14:09But when we think about accessibility and assistive technology as everyone's
- 14:13job and important to helping everyone,
- 14:17we set up the career and the profession to be a stronger place and how important
- 14:23that is for our students with identified disabilities. I think we all know.
- 14:27Yeah, I think those are such great points. And I totally agree with the dissemination
- 14:32of the resources amongst all faculty, because so often districts do silo themselves
- 14:37as a means of efficiency.
- 14:39And, you know, before they know it, everyone is kind of operating in separate
- 14:46worlds where really everyone should be operating together.
- 14:49And I think that that's a really valuable point.
- 14:51And also your point too, about making entering the teacher workforce more accessible.
- 14:57Zach, that's a really valuable point that you just made.
- 15:01And then also going off of what Christine was saying, you know,
- 15:05ELA really tries our best to make our content accessible for folks.
- 15:11And one of our pieces of bread and butter, if you will, is our accessible tech
- 15:16tool library, library where we house over 145 accessible ed tech tools.
- 15:21You know, it's our hope that one day all districts will move to 100% accessible
- 15:26tools, which is kind of the conversation that we've all been having right here, right?
- 15:30Being proactive in your procurement process.
- 15:33And I know a lot of folks right now with ESSER is kind of running out.
- 15:38Folks are rethinking a lot of the tools that they have.
- 15:40So I would like to pose the question of where would you folks like to see digital
- 15:45equity and accessibility in schools, you know, five or even 10 years from now.
- 15:51I think the piece that is, we did just touch on, right, is this standard of born accessible.
- 15:57So setting some baseline expectations for accessibility and availability of
- 16:02assistive tech as a part of planning your curriculum, as a part of saying,
- 16:08what does a biology class mean?
- 16:10But I would also say that to head back to the NETP, right?
- 16:16And again, this is how this assistive technology document fits so nicely.
- 16:20And one of the main recommendations is setting and designing a profile of a learning environment.
- 16:27Right. And so knowing where we need to go, what are the expectations of the
- 16:30digital and physical spaces in which we expect students and adults to be learning and teaching?
- 16:35And so then saying, all right, if this is the profile, then what does that require
- 16:39the things that we are designing and putting in front of our learners?
- 16:43So I'd say that in the five to 10 year space, every district,
- 16:47every state having an expectation of accessibility and assistive technology
- 16:52built in to procurement and curriculum adoption standards to say,
- 16:56you know, what can you do?
- 16:58And then I think it's also important to say on the other side,
- 17:00we've seen a rise of third party validation of some of these accessibility of
- 17:05neurodiversity, of user experience, of interoperability, of privacy,
- 17:09all of those kinds of things.
- 17:10So hopefully seeing that vendors are bringing those to the forefront and developers
- 17:16are bringing those to the forefront to say, listen, we've done our homework.
- 17:19You don't have to worry about kicking the tires on these functionality components
- 17:23because we know that this matters to all students.
- 17:26So asking, but also providing on both sides of that. I would agree with that.
- 17:32I think the concept of being able to be seamless.
- 17:36So we're not even really talking about this, right? We're not wondering if anything is accessible.
- 17:41It's just a standard practice. And also then no student is signaled out, right?
- 17:46Because, oh, you're using a screen reader and none of us can or will because
- 17:51they feel that comfortable because everyone has access to those tools,
- 17:55those that, you know, through their IEP and whatever needs they have, have it in our hands.
- 18:00Using those and other students are using them just as many of us do on a regular
- 18:04basis without even thinking about it. Just within the classroom,
- 18:07it's not always as seamless.
- 18:08So I think that is very critical when it's just part of the process from the
- 18:13build, the procurement, to the implementation.
- 18:16In addition to what my colleagues have all so shared,
- 18:20I think that I would like to see Universal Design for Learning or UDL fully
- 18:25implemented that framework of looking at add accessibility and different ways
- 18:30for students to demonstrate their learning and to engage in that learning process.
- 18:36I would like to see that fully developed and implemented throughout schools.
- 18:41Yeah, I think what each of you have shared is definitely something that,
- 18:45you know, districts should be keeping in mind as technology and the world is advancing.
- 18:51I'd like to, you know, take a minute as we wrap things up for each of you to
- 18:56spotlight some of the work you're doing and how folks can stay involved and
- 19:02stay informed about that, the work.
- 19:05Great. Well, all started off, but here at OSURS and specifically with the work
- 19:10that's happening with the Office of Special Education Programs, or OSEP.
- 19:14We have multiple OSEP-funded technical assistance centers, such as CITES,
- 19:20an example that we've heard about today.
- 19:23Those, I think, are a great way of really staying up to date with the work that's
- 19:28happening, the latest research, the latest evidence-based, as well as free opportunities
- 19:34for professional learning and to learn more about these tools.
- 19:38There are a variety of professional organizations that also partner with Ed
- 19:43and partner with the TA centers.
- 19:45And so connecting with some of those professional organizations that work on
- 19:50behalf of families, who work on behalf of advocates or educators or school leaders
- 19:56are another opportunity to really stay involved and connected.
- 20:00We do put out a monthly newsletter from OSEP, And you can sign up on the Department
- 20:07of Ed webpage under OSEP.
- 20:10And then I think that one of the things that we do not talk about and we do
- 20:14not give enough credit is that as part of the AT Act,
- 20:18which is administered through Health and Human Services, so not Department of
- 20:23Ed, there is an AT3 center in every state that also helps support assistive
- 20:29technology evaluations.
- 20:31A lot of times they have lending libraries and professional development opportunities there.
- 20:37Thank you so much, Gwena. I did not know about that. And I would really love
- 20:40to grab that resource link after this call and include that in our resource
- 20:46library. So thank you for sharing that. Yeah.
- 20:49As one of those centers, I can just piggyback on to what Glenna said.
- 20:53The site does host a community of practice.
- 20:56Any educator is welcome to participate, whether it's a district leader or a classroom teacher.
- 21:01We meet bimonthly and it's truly an opportunity for dialogue.
- 21:04We spend a lot of time the last several, we have meetings bimonthly,
- 21:08folks talking about the myths and facts and how they're leveraging them,
- 21:11who they're working with.
- 21:12In addition, CAST hosts the National AIM Center, and that podcast,
- 21:18the Accessible Learning Experience, has a lot of great, easy-listening podcasts
- 21:23with educators and administrators and authors and researchers from across the
- 21:28country sharing monthly details on accessibility and folks'
- 21:32journeys to accessibility throughout their careers. Thank you, Christine.
- 21:37And Zach, how can we stay up to date with what you're doing over at the Office
- 21:41of Education Technology?
- 21:42Sure. You can come over to our site, tech.ed.gov, and take a look at all the great.
- 22:08Music.